"Is it necessary for me to know Kannada...?"
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 มี.ค. 2023
- The Kannada-Hindi language debate in a nutshell.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Brut India is the fastest-growing digital video publisher in the country. We're a young, independent platform producing compelling journalism in new formats.
You can also find us here:
Facebook: / brutindia
Instagram: / brut.india
Twitter: / brutindia
Snapchat: Brut India
Snapchat: Brut India Stories
Virat Kohli has been playing for RCB for 15 years now. Does he know how to speak in Kannada?
Atleast he won't say kannad gottilla
He does not reside in Bangalore so he won't know kannada. But he hasn't delivered the ipl cup. Don't know why RCB is not throwing him out?
He doesn't need to like the rest of us 😂 No one needs to learn a dead useless language when we have Hindi and English lol
These kannads forget that India is bigger than their small fragile egos!
Its just a brain less statement
@@Aratiii06if rcb throw virat. Then only banglore support rcb 😂
Because of kohli rcb have huge fan following
And he is expecting us to speak his language 😅😅😂😂😂
And that won't happen 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Never
You can continue with pakistans language !
"If people like me can go through this,imagine a normal man"😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Kanimozhi,an MP from Tamil Nadu,went through the same for not knowing Hindi,in an airport,a long ago.
You are just born,bro.Go have some milk and peace.
😂😂
Completely another case😂😂😂
Who knows if she did staged it..
Well politics and the players😂😂
Out of all the people you chose kanimozhi that too a politician as an example. That's a b***h in women's body
I am from Bangalore, and my mother tongue is Kannada. I think the issue we face in Bangalore regarding these kinds of language crises is almost always through the extreme sides of both the Kannada people and the North Indians (Hindi speaking) who migrate to Bangalore, sure whatever the airport official did to him is simply not acceptable and frankly, the authority should take some serious action on the official for mistreating a person based off of such circumstances. But while I'm at it, I think most people (who haven't been to Bangalore) need to realize that there are certain groups of people who almost "force" Kannada people to speak Hindi, heck, it's happened to me multiple times too. I've had instances where I've been forced to speak Hindi in my own city like I don't belong there, and if I've encountered such situations, I'm confident a lot more Kannada people have gone through the same too, and probably that's the reason why some Kannada people tend to get aggressive on this matter as I've seen on social media.
At the end of the day, I think the language in itself is not such an important barrier as these extremists claim it to be, but at the same time when there's an issue like this, I believe it's important to address both sides of the problem rather than victimizing one and defending the other. Please don't get me wrong about this, I am all for Salman Yusuf's side in this particular situation but what I'm stating is, there are plenty more situations like this where Kannada people have been the victim of language shaming by North Indians, in their own city - Bangalore.
Perhaps the only sensible comment I could find here
Bro he seems to hv been born in bglr, it's not wrong to expect him to know kannada right?? If he was tourist to the city, no1 would ask him to speak in kannada..
@@abhilash4479 He would have born in Karnataka and then his parents might have immediately taken him to Saudi. Then what will he do? Why judge?
@@arunv3961 would he not have visited the place where he's staying since his birth?? I'm sure he would hv visited countless times, the fact tht he's born in bglr.. it's likely tht his parents or his relatives stay in bglr so y not learn the language of the place he & his relatives stay & not just enjoy the lavish lifestyle & money bglr gives
@@abhilash4479 i agree with everything but can’t agree that Bangalore gives a great life to everyone. Everyone works hard in their own way, nothing comes for free.
Hooliganism shouldn't be tolerated, plain and simple. If one doesn't wish to speak Hindi, it is absolutely justified, but one shouldn't be forced to speak any language just because it is common to your place, not everyone is supposed to know it.
Try that in TN.
Keliye brindavan dekhiye debo.
Learning basic kannada is not that difficult. If that auto guy talks in kannada and those north girls dont understand, they won't reach their destination. Its their necessity atleast they have to learn some basic word. These people learn korean for showing off but can't learn regional language.
agreed
@@sowmya6942 even if it is easy... i am not willing to learn it... who the hell r u to force it... dont do moral policing..... such practice of enforcing activities will spread in all aspects of life... later on dont get shocked if u r forced to wear parda or burkha in the name of basic deceny.....
ನಾವು ಎಲ್ಲರೂ ಸೇರಿ ಆ ಮನುಷ್ಯನಿಗೆ ಸನ್ಮಾನ ಮಾಡೋಣ💫 ಏನು ತಪ್ಪಿದೆ ಆ ಮನುಷ್ಯ ಕೇಳಿದ ಪ್ರಶ್ನೆಯಲ್ಲಿ😢 ನಿನ್ನ ಮಾತೃಭಾಷೆ ಕನ್ನಡ ಬರೋದಿಲ್ಲ ಅಂತಾ ಕೇಳಿದ್ ತಪ್ಪಾ .....?ಈ ತರಹದ ಪ್ರಶ್ನೆ ನಾವು ಮಾಡಿಲ್ಲ ಅಂದ್ರೆ ಮುಂದೆ ಯಾರು ಮಾತೃ ಭಾಷಣ ಮಾತಾಡಲ್ಲ in Karnataka we also know Hindi we also know English but we respect our own culture and all languages ಜೈ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕ ಮಾತೆ 💛❤️
SPEAK HINDI FIRST AND THEN SAY ANYTHING
Can you be put on a suspect list for speaking another language?
We don't hate Hindi we hate people like you who force Hindi
It's a good language but so is ours and we want that same respect nothing else
@@dextermore4851we dont speak Pakistani language
Yeah but you kannadigas dont know tulu ,so upgrade yourself and give some respect to.tuluvas too ,dont say karnatakadalli kannadane sarvabouma blah.blah,karnatakadalli tulu language kooda idhe
Forcing kannada guy to speak hindi and english is ok
But you are in karnataka and you are forced to kannada is notok
Well said
source: trust me bro
Forcing is not okay. Whether it's Hindi, English or Kannada. Cultures built out of imposition lose their essence under the unpleasant veil of Fascism.
As a Kannadiga I wouldn't want that to happen. There's beauty in my language. I want to explore it and express it and make people drawn and attracted to it. Not force them into it.
It pushes them further away
Forcing anyone is wrong, period. Let them speak the language they are comfortable with
I despise people who impose languages whether it be Hindi or kannada or Tamil or Telugu etc..
Why do people assume that Hindi is the national language of India.....
Hindi is an official language....
Like Kannada,
Like Telugu
Like Tamil
Like Malayalam....
Along with 21 languages.... Hindi is also an official language....
India has no National language....
Pls also cite the facts where constitution nowhere says one can force their language on others.
Why just talk about Hindi when it's not the non hindi speakers who are getting targeted in north, but hindi speakers in south?
@@ultimexg1419 BECAUSE THEY DISPROPORTIONATELY LEARN HINDI IN NORTHERN STATES AND NORTHERN CITIZENS HAVE A SENSE OF ENTITLEMENT THAT EVERYONE SHOULD KNOW HINDI IN SOUTHERN STATES. Learn the language of the state you reside in.
@@compound118Open Defiance WTF can you do
Hindi is not an official language and should never be
Govt should make hindi as national launguage and we vote them ..
ಕರ್ನಾಟಕದಲ್ಲಿ ಕನ್ನಡವೇ ಪ್ರಧಾನ... 💛❤
proud to be ಕನ್ನಡಿಗ ..🌟
Yavo ev yella
@@kishanl9307 yak pa en ata ning
@@progamer.4657 fake account bro … chill
@@kishanl9307 ನಿಮ್ಮ ಅಮ್ಮನ ತುಲ್ 🎉😂😂
When you are in Infian union you must adjust
I am a Kannadiga and I speak Kannada. After landing in India from Germany, I went to the immigration control check counter like all other arriving passengers and the officer asked some questions to me in Kannada. I answered to him in Kannada. He took 10-15 minutes to check details of each arriving passenger in the system before me. He checked my details atleast 15 times and took 15 minutes. The other officers in parallel queues were taking 2-3 minutes on an average before letting the passengers go further to collect their baggage. Some officers there are more suspicious (or incompetent) than others and need more time. Some are arrogant and some are polite. And ofcourse every person is equal before the officer, celebrity or a common man! Cheers..
That was ur choice and the officer's choice and convenience not the rule. There's no such rule or guideline or training which allows officers to do the same.
Ask the immigration officer whether he was recruited based on kannada or was it English?
Plus immigration itself is a national thing based on country to country basis. Nobody can force or assume about regional languages over there.
@@ultimexg1419 read my comment i never blamed the officer. I only said that how a passenger/immigrant is going to be treated depends on the officer's ability (competence) to go thorough and pay attention to detail. Some take less time and some more. It's not convenience like you write, That's a rule! the officer should check the details and arriving passengers should get checked. It's obvious that he spoke to me in Kannada because I was born in Karnataka.
Anybody arriving in Bengaluru, certainly, cannot be taken for granted that they know Kannada. You knew it, and you replied the same way, that's fine. But what if it was somebody else visiting Bengaluru either rarely or for the first time or so?
You are backchoda
@@vijaysrini27 In addition to that people might be going through different problems , and learning a new language is a very challenging thing it takes time, it has very high confidence curve to it. What if people don't want to go through all that .
The auto driver was forced to talk in hindi so he told them this is Karnataka and talk in kannada he was right, if you force us to talk in hindi then we will force you to talk in kannada
RESPECT ALL LANGUAGES ❤
ಸಿರಿಗನ್ನಡಂ ಗೆಲ್ಗೆ, ಸಿರಿಗನ್ನಡಂ ಬಾಳ್ಗೆ
These fools will never know what exactly happened and come here telling Hindi Hindi , hindi is the language 😂
@@rameshkoppad4892 💯
@@rameshkoppad4892 so you are intelligent right please enlighten everyone what happened at the air port you moron . make sure to learn gujarati before visiting gujarat learn hindi before visiting up mp . learn bengali before visiting Kolkata learn japanese before visiting japan french before visiting france etc .
Telling someone that u dont know their language isn't about forcing them to talk in your own language ... grow up
@@pramodpatilvpYour surname is Patil which is a marathi surname 😂
If You are Living in Karnataka Then You Should Learn the Local Language for Communicate
You Have No Right To Impose Your Mother Tongue Language on their State. As a Bengali from North East If I want to Do Job or Business at Hindi Belt Without Knowing Hindi Language Is it Possible?
The point is if you "live" in Karnataka. Go watch the video again. Other than that, it's not mandatory to learn the local language, but it's highly advised to learn the language and culture for better communication and getting a better understanding of people around you. But on an international airport, where people from different ethnicities and nationalities come and go, if their staff isn't adept in the international language English or is trying to make things harder by refusing to communicate in international language, then it's a problem
@@MooMoo10066 Why He Didn't Learn Kannada Language
@@MooMoo10066 If Any Non Kannadiga Goes To Hindi Belt
& oppose To Learn Local Will You People Accept Him /Her
@supersaiyans7845 then that's his choice, other than the communication barrier that person may have. No problem. I'll talk about my state, Punjab. There are so many immigrants from UP and Bihar and other states, they don't speak punjabi we don't have any problem with it.
@@montysaini8602 One Day Your Language Will Die in Your Own State
People need to appreciate that Kannada people are welcoming and go to the extent of switching to Hindi, and some even with broken Hindi to be accommodating. This goes unappreciated as always. What if it was the other way round where people didn’t switch and responded only in Kannada? So the least we expect is some attempt on broken Kannada or real appreciation towards Kannada language, it’s integrity and the people .
But forcing the language is not good, Kannada is a beautiful language but some goons are defaming
Learn and talk in broken kannada. U can mix english.
Hindi is not national language. Kannadigas prefer
Kannada overhindi or english.
FYI
I was in nagpur.most of sign boards were in devanagari
I have been here for just 1 year and I am trying to learn Kannada as well but all my life I spoke one language so it’s going to be difficult. I agree that that language and culture for any state for that matter should be preserved but you shouldn’t force it in a way that is borderline racist. I am literally sacred to go out because I live alone and what if I am bullied one day just because I couldn’t learn a whole new language in one year. I hope you understand this pov and be a little more considerate to your brother sisters from another state but the same country. Let there be peace,love and unity amongst us.
How many kannada are learning gujrati, marwari , hariyanvi, awadhi etc ?
Kannada is regional language and nothing more !
@@rockysikander.8177 Why should we learn your languages in our state? LOL It's a regional language? Then learn it when you enter this region
Learning the local language is the respect you give to the land that's giving you food,water and shelter.
There's no harm in learning and speaking the language.
Wtf 💀🦧....it is helpful for communication that's it ...they can't just create war on us for this 😢..
There is no harm.. however everyone might not be able learn it... you might consider the possibility. Imagine a person asking you or requesting assistance and u turn them down coz u didn't speak my state language
All people have interest to learn local language. But because of rowdisim saying - "LEARN KANNADA OR ELSE LEAVE THE CITY" , nobody wants to learn kannada.
You cannot FORCE anyone and dictate them to learn Kannada.
Even if we learn kannada, then there is complains that "Speak properly kannada".
Too much of Kannada language madness in Bangalore..
@@RameshKumar-ng3nfwe dont force you to speak kannada properly if u are living in our state or setteled in our state u should learn, and it is okay to not learn kannada if you came here for vacation for few days.. We respect and love our culture, we have fear that our own culture is should not be destroyed as it is destroyed in dehli some of them adopted to western culture. That's why we are doing this
@@Vishwa_i Bro, i am staying in Bangalore. I tried learn Kannada and whenever i tried to practice speaking to people, everywhere they started complaining that i am not pronouncing properly , not spelling properly and making fun of me and asking me to stop speaking kannada if i cannot speak properly.
Now you only tell, How will a person speak kannada when your own kannada people are not supportive to learn kannada.
If we learn the language, there is a problem in making fun of us.
If we dont learn the language, there is a problem saying get out of our place or learn.
What shall we do brother ? Its becoming very tuff when people behaving so badly and expecting us to be very clear in kannada right from the beginning. How it is possible ?
I support local language but be friendly and teach people about your language. Assimilate them, one cannot speak kannada from 1st day.
My Mother tongue is Telugu. I lived in Bangalore for 12 Yrs. But cant speak fluent Kannada for so many reasons. Got humiliated so many times. I felt like i was not in India. I respect Bangalore, since i got chance to learn and be a bread earner to family. I Left Bangalore with Family because of these kind of reasons. Tamilnadu also I heard same issues. People should grow up. People should be patriots towards country.
Exactly. People usually fail to understand how much more tolerant and friendly Telangana and Andhra Pradesh are to diversity compared to the other South Indian states, just because they haven't had the level of PR that other states have had!
Patriotic means. How.? Plese elaborate
Telungu and kerala people in south wont have any problem..... Tamil and Karnataka people are making problem always
@@nikhilnambiar1990Because that Kerala and Telagana states get less migrants than Karnataka and TN. Because that both states get less issues of migrants.
Same thing happen with me i also don't speak kannada but people of Bangalore doing discrimination with me, no one talking to me properly and even no one is helping at all.
Bro hasn't just been "born" here....bro has also graduated from NITTE meenakshi clg which means bro has studied here for a minimum of 3 years (depends on the course)....
So that's ample amount of time to learn atleast "manageable" Kannada
I am assuming you have lived well over for two decades in India. So with the same logic, what attempts have you made to learn hindi?
@@jerichoholic5805 who says Hindi is the language of India? India has 22 official languages and we know one of the official languages which is Kannada. If I move to North, I'll definitely speak Hindi. I won't go around whining that people are not speaking kannada there, Especially if I'm born and brought up there.
@@prajwalkundalgurki4084 Right. You are absolutely correct and have your choice to learn/speak Hindi if you move to North.
But the thing is, It should remain a choice only. Not an imposition as shown in this video. The guy speaks english and hindi. He converses english which the airport official understands. What's the point of what he does/says next?
Likewise, the comment here expects him to learn kannada. Why? It is his CHOICE.
That's same as saying to all people living in maharashtra, you must learn marathi, not hindi.
@@jerichoholic5805
Your assumption is wrong....forget living 2 decades in India, I haven't even been for 2 decades in this world itself xD
With the "same logic"...coming to the "attempts" I made to learn Hindi.... i know to speak, write and understand Hindi (though at a not so fast pace)....which is enough (and I would be using it) if I happen to be travelling to any Hindi speaking area....
@@jerichoholic5805your comment isn’t right the guy says he could at least learn manageable Kannada since he’s born in Karnataka and studied here for at least 3 years , just as you’d expect someone travelling or living in the north to speak Hindi he just expects him to speak Kannada . If you have your domicile as Karnataka you are naturally expected to learn kannada . What if ipyou have to communicate with someone while in Karnataka who doesn’t know Hindi and English , at lest a minimum is expected
I am sure this guy can at least speak manageable Kannada. Maybe he is doing this for publicity. It's hard to believe someone born in Karnataka but can't speak Kannada.
By the way, I am not a Kannadiga. I have lived in Bengaluru for some years but now I live in my home state.
He did say he spoke broken kannada but they were still grilling him. Some people are like that
Sarig ugdavre yaro...ennu ugibekithu..😂
@@manasar5550howdu... Kannadigaru ugiyovaaga artha aagokke maatra Kannada kalee beku....
South Indian people cannot elected any PM or Central government
Because a single North Indian State called " Uttar Pradesh " has ( 16% ) of Indian population .
And the Total population of South Indian States are only ( 20% ) of India
From your 16% population, not even 6% stays there. You don't have jobs, you migrate all over India. So you don't even vote during elections because UP people are far off.
the first issue of the immigration officer suspecting: Dude this is not an issue of regionalism, it's an issue of verification of residence. any person born in a particular place, and his/her parents being born there and not knowing the local language would obviously raise suspicions.
the second issue of the auto driver: is a cropped video showing partial truth, where the girls first demanded him to speak/learn Hindi imposing it as the national language. how can you expect an auto driver brought up in his local language to speak Hindi? can you go to a Bengal or tn or Gujarat or Manipur and ask a rickshaw puller to know a completely different vernacular language? at least appreciate him for knowing a bit of English to communicate to earn his living.
Jai Shree Ram. At least there are a few sensible people in this comment section.
FINALLY FOUND A LITTLE SENSIBLE COMMENT
He could speak in English
How would not knowing Kannada in Bangalore raise suspicion? Bangalore is a pretty diverse and metropolitan city, and way too many Bangalorean residents speak little to no Kannada. Surprisingly the security official living in the city didn't know this fact about Bangalore? And when the person said that he was raised in Saudi Arabia and not Bangalore, then what's the fuss?
lol there's no such rule, authority, or guideline given to immigration to do such things.
There are lakhs who r born at a place but may not know the regional language especially in metro cities coz metro cities aren't just about regional ppl. Moreover airports are neutral grounds having ppl from all around.
Do u know how many ppl born in defence societies have different place of birth than the state they are actually from? Ever heard anyone face such things around the world?
Simply there's no ground for suspicion here. The officer don't know shit about background of a person and he cannot make assumptions to force things.
Why is this problem only happening with bangalore? Why not mumbai? Calcutta? Delhi?
then you should stop saying you born in Karnataka,
your right modi don't speak kannada but he always respected and tried to speak native language where ever he visited
Interesting how people go to many lengths to learn a language like German or French when moving to their countries but find it offensive when asked to respect our very own languages. Agreed, we may not know every single word, but at least try. Learn some basics to get by and connect with people. I was Bengaluru for two years and ensured to communicate a little when taking the auto. They appreciated it too. No one should ever be forced to learn a language but at least be respectful and considerate when asked to respect them and their language.
Yeah this Northie bas***rds. I stay in goa and this Northie people even knowing 100% konkani ask weather you can speak Hindi or not, if we replied yes then this people proceed to speak in hindi like we are in their place, even tho my first language is not konkani, it's kannada, but i learnt konkani even not being shy to speak broken during my primary school, at the middle school i became so so fluent that my accent is absolute goan, and no one can get to know that i am non goan.
Because in these u mentioned have 1 language in whole country not like india every state different language..
@@nomadicbharat8642 then learn english
A Hindi Pajeet speaker can even understand German due to English, but not even a single word in Kannada.
Kannada is totally foreign to Hindi Pajeets.
@@VariouscartoontopicPa-jeet is a Punjabi name, not a Hindi name. Try harder!
The immigration officer didn’t ask him questions out of love for Kannada, it was a normal security protocol as there are lot of illegal immigrants in Bangalore/ India with fake documents. The officer didn’t know about Mr.Khan, being a millennial even I didn’t know about him until this happened. Mr. Khan could’ve easily handled it but he created ruckus on social media. By calling the officer uneducated, Mr. Khan made us feel that he himself is not educated properly. Modi thing was unnecessary too.
Its beyond the officer's authority. One who managed to fake documents and passport approval system and office, getting questioned based on language to cut the suspicion? 😂 This is having next to zero probability. And even after the suspicion why was this salman allowed to make the travel? Or suddenly did Salman fire some lines in kannada to get the officer accept it?
Same question the officer could have done in English, the same language which was compulsory for him to get recruited.
Plus immigration is doing nation level work not regional.
Exactly!! Shows his upbringing trying to make nuisance with such a simple issue !
Correct
Try to be peaceful and to your community
@@name_802 😂😂 it is not nuisance
I am saying this because i have faced it. I am staying in Dubai and from gujarat Ahmedabad. Mostly stayed in PGs and hostels . We make sure the other people coming from outside do not feel like an outsider. We try to learn their culture. Make them feel like home. Bring tiffin for them. Because we know how that person already is feeling by coming this far from home. When i came to dubai where lots of south indian people are there... They made me feel like i was in outsider. We all here are far from home. We should have stayed united.. instead people from other countries made me feel better than them.. this was such a bad experience.
We will make Rajput Vistaar! And carve it from Gujarat
Yes these South Indians are not so welcoming.
I am from Indore living in Ahmedabad. Hats off to you guys who never made me feel unwelcomed as a non-gujarati speaker.
I'm Gujarati and you said we try learn their culture do hindi speakers learn our Gujarati culture while living in Gujarat?
@@pranavgohel6710 they enjoy the treatment
bro, ur in karnataka, learn kannada or leave. Dont say why should i learn. Try to make an effort to learn. There is no bangalore without kannada.
As a Bengali from North East Agree with you This Hindi People Want To Rule us By Imposing their Language & Culture Etc
@@supersaiyans7845 then pls leave india and settle to Bangladesh . Whole country only speak Bengali.. and leave india for hindi speaking people .. i will give you ticket price
@@nomadicbharat8642 Is this Country Your Father's Property?
This country is Not Made In the Basis of Language. But The States were Made in the Basis of Languages. Non Hindi States are Part of India.
Not Colony of Hindi People
This is India Not Hindia
Hindi Pajeets should live in Pakistan, that's the right place for them
@@supersaiyans7845 who is Hindi people their is not a single state in India where hindi is mother tongue
If that's the problem man if you come to haryana first learn Haryanvi or rather don't come
this is also not your father country every north state have their own state language still we talk in hindi or eng so that people from other state can understand us
we don't force them to learn any particular lang
There is no harm in learning and speaking kannada in Karnataka (Bangalore) it's such a beautiful language!!!
Jai Karnataka!!!! Jai Kannada ❤️💛🥺💛
🤮🤢
In North bihar has bhojpuri angika maithli
Uttar pradesh has magdhi panjab has panjabi gujrat has gujrati bangal has bangali assam has assami ( my language ) nagaland has nagamese but we accepted hindi as a common language and that's why we don't face these type of shit when moving from one state to another state in north but in South no one got brain but pride filled ass and that's why if you want to move through southern state your have to learn tamil telgu kannad malyalam
@@sajalsharma249you north hindi people but south and maharastra are not acepted urdu origin hindi
@@sajalsharma249 Karnataka has kannada, tulu, konkani and coorgi as their language. All of them have accepted Kannada as their language.
You know what, this very preachy nature of yours coupled with ignorance and superiority complex is what we South Indians are fed up with. So stop preaching us. 😡
We understand secularism better than you. That is why two generations of the the celebrity in the video was able to survive in karnataka. Can two generations of kannadigas survive in Bihar without learning you language. Aap log Baja doge unn logon ki.
But one thing I can gaurentee you that you not find a single South Indian in Bihar who has not learnt to speak Hindi and continues to live in Bihar.
I have lived in North india. Mujhe maloom hai Hindi na sikhne se wahan kya hoti hai. Jake kahin aur do apna gyan.
@@sajalsharma249 Btw my two pence learn one South Indian language you will be able to manage in entire south India. Not only that you might even eventually end up learning at more than one South Indian language and even understand Sanskrit better
Hindi is not the Mother Tongue of most Indians. This guy got his 15 minutes of publicity.
First of all,Its not at all the language of this land👎🏼
@@manoharindia7774 agreed, its farsi mixed with saurseni.
What happened to him was unfortunate and certainly condemnable especially at an airport, but
1- He calls Bengaluru his city and does not relate to its very core ,
2- He calls hindi the national language our country which isn’t even true .
The irony here is that he calls the staff uneducated when he himself is uneducated about the schedule 8 of the Indian Constitution and that we have no National Language and only have Official languages.
I guess If people can take pride of knowing hindi in most northern states of India, I think its only fair that the people of Karnataka and all southern states have the right to be proud of their respective languages
you are the one who is sounding uneducated does the indian constitution force us to speak the language of the state we live in. in south people expect even the tourist to know their language which makes no sense . a person from south visiting japan as a tourist will he learn japanese 🤣 .
its not wrong to have pride for your language, but its wrong to force someone to learn your language irrespective of even if that person was born in that state
@@vishalshah7043 Yes it is called common sense to learn local language of the place one is living in for years.
@@MK-hb8lo it is also common sense to learn the national language in the country you are living in .
Keep crying. Hindi is the national language. keep crying
Born and raised in bangalore, then you must speak kannada
Born in "Bengaluru", not Bangalore. Raised mostly in Saudi Arabia. Did you not catch that part?
@@SarthakSabharwalMusic then he should return to saudi arabia or north india where they speak simlar north indian language....not Bangalore.
@@martinluther4720 Please show me the law that states that.
@@SarthakSabharwalMusic that's the official common sense law in south india.....
....and you come and force your hindi on kannadiga locals in bangalore, see what wil happen to you
@@martinluther4720 Not speaking a language does not mean forcing another language.
And there's no such thing as a common sense law. Making bs up won't make you win arguments.
Plenty of Marathi, Hindi, Telugu speakers in Bangalore rn who don't speak Kannada. Make it happen to them right now. Don't sleep until it happens. Unless you enforce it yourself, don't act like a fake macho in TH-cam comments lmao.
Now you know how we southerners feel when we visit delhi
You don't know English 😂😂😂
Saar
Plz saar
Dan't knaw heendi saar
@@AnonymousAlien2099bhayya thoda pyas dalo
He could have simply diffused the situation by saying he never had the opportunity to learn Kannada though he was born in Bengaluru as he was raised in Saudi where his family mostly spoke their language instead his response was why should I learn your language which indicates his ignorance and ego.
What i assume he was trying to do was make a big issue out of it. He knows how to play with sentiments of Bengaluru's locals and non- locals which he is exploiting to his benefit.
But why should he learn a language because someone asked him? Learning a new language is a tiresome process.
@@suryakiran3085It's not about learning or not learning.He should have told the immigration officer that he was brought up in Saudi Arabia so he didn't get to learn it
That's all
@@suryakiran3085you are missing the point…again
People who face such situations will know how it feels..
My man called the people uneducated and continued to speak like one
And here you are... a genius to judge him..
@@kartiksharma-bg6kk It is the geniuses like you who dont see the real problem he says he loves bangalore and was loved and brought up here and doesn't speak kannada. Do you think the same can happen in delhi or other northindian states!!!! We are blinded by these social media debates that we don't understand the logic and everyone is on it to get fame. This guy got his fame he calls himself Bangalore boy and doesn't respect the city or the culture enough even after he and his previous generation stayed here. He never bothered to learn kannada! The kannada that he spoke in the video my friends who shifted to Bangalore 6months back have learnt better than him.
AND IT IS NOT ABOUT JUDGING WHEN HAVE YOU EVER SEEN A SOUTHINDIAN IN DELHI TELLING THAT I WONT LEARN HINDI AND MERESE AAP MERI MOTHER TONGUE ME BAAT KARO. MORONS LIKE THESE WHO THINK, JUST STAYING IN THE CITY IS THEIR CONTRIBUTION IS BULLSHIT. "JAISA DESH WAISA BHESH" AAP FOREIGN ME JAAKE DUBAI ME FOLLOW KAROGE BUT TUMHARE KARMA BHOOMI PAR NAHI.
Mr educated, pls state which law, rule, guideline given to immigration officer which itself is a national authority post and not a state based or regional post, allows the officer to suspect based on place of birth and languages? 😅
The officer was stupid to cause inconvenience to the passenger. Immigration has nothing to do with regional drama and languages. That officer himself doesn't get recruited based on regional language but English, and then comes hindi and regional language only for helping the passengers, not messing with them
Mr.Genius came. Such a cheap punk you are to comment on someone.
What wrong did he said ? Tell me please!!
I did my schooling and graduation from an other part of Karnataka where I had no exposure or a necessity to speak any language other than Kannada or English..
But after moving and living in Bengaluru for the past 4 years..
I learnt to speak in Telugu, Hindi and understand bit of Tamil..
I wonder why I did it..? With all due respect.. I would have been just as ignorant as many of my cross border friends (from other States)
Don't blame Kannadigas because.. we have always accepted you...
You (Most of u and)never ever bothered to do the favour in return..
Why don't u appreciate and learn bit of Kannada when u are in Karnataka..?
Guys, Karnataka has got rich culture and a beautiful language kannada to celebrate..
Join and celebrate with us... We do the same when we happened to be at ur place anytime..
It's your right to be the way u are..
But also ur duty to not hurt the locals and their sentiments..
Let's grow together..
Love and Thank you
Very well said......some ignorant people don't even bother to learn the local language and tend to impose Hindi forcefully on the native speakers where they have emigrated to.
Stop, bro. What favour are you expecting to be returned? People are working and receiving pay; they are not sitting idle and getting pay. Karnataka is not just for Kannadigas; it is for all Indians. What fucking article gave you the authority to say Karnataka is only for Kannadigas? It is the people's choice whether or not to speak. Simple!!
There’s no harm in learning Kannada for that matter any language in the world, but if someone doesn’t know a particular are they supposed to be hated, cheated on or shamed!? Faced a lot of this in Bangalore, a metropolitan which should be more accommodating, whereas the people from other parts of Karnataka were much more sweeter and accommodating.
Is there any free kannada learning centers jn Bengaluru
Students the only language important for us is python html Java and c++
For the guy at the airport, we need to hear the full story. And same for the auto driver incident.
I agree with you.
Yes ..we should respect and third oldest language kannada
Yes I agree
@@KnowledgeBase321desh chunothiyo se nahi c type ke logo se pareshan hai😂😂
Who disrespected?@@Be_happy3010
Narendra Modi doesn't live in Bengaluru.
He shared his pain which unfortunately many normal people had faces living in same Country. What a shame.
Why north hindi people come to south india kannada full support marathi maharastra unity local language kannada marathi telgu tamil is southern part
Please call all your local people back and keep them there. Only Maharashtra and Karnataka do not have local languages, other states do have theirs too so as per them they are in danger as well so keep your people at home. Non Sense.
@@brobotinlaw get lost you panipuri salers
Bro we Telugu people respect other state people
We welcome others
Don't add Andhra Pradesh into this group
We are not racist
I know bro AP accepted hindi and we respecting telugu🙏
Maharashtra is not part of South Indian
That's why I prefer to converse in English, absolutely neutral language.
People would still find a problem with that
dodd bevarsi neenu 😂
That's perfect but still at some places people will harass you because of this too
Pls learn local language where ever you go. Atleast respect the culture and literature which gives food and shelter to you.
@@Truthisbitter1 bro how does not learning a language show disrespect if you go somewhere as a tourist for a week or fortnight will you do a course to learn the local language then get ready to travel does it make any sense?
My parents are from AP, I was born and brought in Bangalore.I know to speak kannada and read kannada.when your in particular state please try to learn local language..
No need I was born brought up in Kerala for college and job I came to Bangalore here no one speak kannada everyone speak English, Hindi, Malayalam college and office also even native kannad boys and girls don't speak kannad 😂😂😂 and out like market local vendors they speak casual English 😂😂😂😂
So basically I get the permission to force my school friend from Kannada to speak Marathi as he lives in Maharashtra,🗿🗿🗿💀💀💀
Lakhs of kannadigas are in maharashtra all know marathi, also lakhs of marathis are in karnataka, they too kannada , incase of mumbai and pune , hindiwalas have already hindized these cities, your own people don't speak Marathi in public there, ask hindiwals to speak marathi first , we kannadigas won't tolerate that hindiwalas bullshit here ! Karnataka belongs to kannadigas , we will not speak hindi, our choice.
Karnataks belongs to Kannadigans??!!! sir, please go form a separate nation then. INDIANS ARE UNITED IN DIVERSITY. THE LAND DOES NOT BELONG TO YOU, YOU HAVENT SHED AN OUNCE OF PENNY FOR THE STATE. SO DARE NOT RULE.
If immigration officer ask him few question, they should sort out.. How does it grant permission to you ? Use brain ..
@@noBiasCandy😂😂ofcourse Karnataka is of kannadigas.... Karnataka MLAs are elected by kannadigas not hindi &hits 😂😂😂......WE LOVE TO HAVE A SEPERATE COUNTRY --- DRAVIDANADU
Separation is starts slowly@@noBiasCandy
BIMARUH superiority complex
😂
Ah u guys are no better , just wait people are seeing ur reality, actually mental bimaru are u guys
Happened to me 5-6 times I was in college nd there local ppl used to shout that u hv to learn nd thn auto driver abounded me on road
But yes thn I learnt the language ... they loved me even when I spoke broken kannada but I did learnt it ... to travel in local areas its needed
@@ZeeJee5 Let me note this, might come in UPSC exam
@@ZeeJee5 The States that produces most of IAS and IPS officer ig
@@ZeeJee5 😅 I got selected and I hv to go study in college.. but misbehaving bcz of language should not happen . Nd I know kannada
@@ZeeJee5 Ohh I wonder... Good information. BTW please elaborate "cow dung State". Maybe your parents belongs to those states. I never heard of them. Searching Geography books... Still nothing 🤔
@@ZeeJee5 that's a bunch of horseshit
This guy was born and brought up in Bengaluru....still doesn't know kannada!!
So you born and brought up in india you should know hindi if he need to know kannad
@@hirenahir76200tuje kaise prove Karu ki muje Hindi aata hai??!!😂
@@hirenahir76200 why ? Why should I know to speak Hindi if I'm Indian ? If I'm not born or raised in the northern states then how can u expect us to know a language we don't even speak here 😂 where's the logic
@@hirenahir76200 Did you get dropped when you were a child?
@@shantanunish955 exactly why why he should know Kannada??stupid
Yeh Saala boltha ki Im a Saudi child bcz he studied in Saudi, but even he born in Bengaluru he cannot assume he is kannadiga...shame on him
Can't even speak English the right way 😂😂😂
@Aryan group then why is he speaking it . atleast he could've done was to attempt to pronounce the words proper
Very good.....!! Sometimes it happens....!! People still think that entire South Language is Tamil... To clear that he might have asked you there is Kannada also .... Go to Hyderabad.... They will ask you whether you know Telugu.... Go to Kerala... He will ask .... Whether you know Malayalam 😂😂😂😂
Telugu is the most spoken language of Dravidian family
Respect for Tamil Nadu to defend their culture. As a North Indian, I hope all South Indian states follow the DMK path
@@kartikrajsingh1895
As a Telugu we will not encourage Tamianadu type worst language politics in our society and this issue is not about language this is about safety concern.
Frankly Kannandiga local folks are not happy with Reddy and other telgu folks saying they have encroached and made it more telgu city.
I am also a proud Marathi Telugu i know both languages
Aai Marathi!
Telugu thalliki!
You are born and brought in Karnataka learning will not cost you nothing dear .....iam not kannadiga but yet when i see people from different background i try to speak in kannada, Malayalam, Tamil and Hindi as well ...my kids will laugh at me 😅but still i never give up learning....dear Salman Yusuf khan dont get offended by those officers you are young educated man politely make them understand....
His up bringing is in Saudi Arabia. Why South Indian working in Dubai and other gulf countries don't learn Arabic?
@DannycageGhostrider language politics will destroy india one day
I’m from Maharashtra And I support Kannada brothers 💛♥️
Thanks buddy. 😊
That person born in Karnataka his dad also born in Karnataka stayed here educated here but don't know kannada, but in Tamil Nadu every people will talk in Tamil. I don't know why people will not talk in regional language if they were born and brought up that place and educated from there,why people don't like to talk in that place language. Whenever we go to work in North India we learn there language we participate there function we give respect. Because we work and give respect to that land .many people other place and they know regional language but they don't talk it because something they fill inferior for communicating languages.
North India doesn't have regional language,so of all 5 states Hindi will do,but in South Indian states every language is different,so newcomers always find tough.
@@ashutoshmishra310 bro first of all see your progress your people will come to work to south india and your north india cm told that he can't build a factory in that state no more development literatacy rate low women safety is also low and many problem is there think about that don't poke your nose in this matter. I told that person because he and is family stayed ear for more than 40 year okay bro thank you.
@@AKASH-cw9ix if he is living more than 40 years and can't speak kannada then it's sad
@@ashutoshmishra310 see man his family is living more than 40 years and asking modi to talk Kannada who didn't born in Karnataka and not leaved in Karnataka. how it is correct you tell me
Love you kannada brothers. Full support from Bengal. ❤
Yessir! Joy bangla
ಕನ್ನಡ that's all
Learning hindi is not compulsory though we try to talk .. you guys are showing attitude ... not learning kannada but earning your livelihood in Karnataka... this is india and not hindia.. you guys need place to earn, eat, sleep etc . But when requested to talk in local language and try learning it.. you guys show pathetic attitude.. you guys cant be called indiana also.. there are lot of freedom fighter from Karnataka who fought for freedom...
India has a total of 780 languages in the country, while visiting different districts in different states, do you learn the language? do locals tell you to get out of there if you dont know that certain dialect? No right?
I agree with you, if you live in karnataka and earn your livelihood there, you should learn the language. But forcing EVERY SINGLE PERSON to learn kannada to be welcomed there without knowing where they are from and how long they are staying is unjust right? I've faced this exact treatment in bangalore when I was there for my 3 weeks stay multiple times. People in bangalore just see a north indian person and lash out on them and make the language shit seem like an extreme political matter which somehow gives them the right to be abusive and aggressive?
not to mention hindi is the national language of india, if you cannot respect your country you shouldnt be living it it.
And who pays for food residency u do sir ? People pay Karnataka doesn't have them anything for free. U want international companies in ur banglore and still want every migrated people to adapt to their culture.
First please understand the languages of India. If you see in North you have similarities in most of the language. However, as of now most of the languages have been vanished due to implementation of Hindi in northern states.
Hope you know the top 5 oldest Indian languages.
1 sanskrith (7000 years)
2 Tamil (5000 years)
3 kannada (2000 years)
4 Telugu ( 1500 years)
5 malyalam (2000 years)
Similarly you have odisha, odia, bengali etc.. However, Hindi is new compared to these languages. They made Hindi as a language due to some political gains.
We have learnt Hindi even though we are not in North states, You can talk any local auto driver in Bangalore they can easily talk in 5 languages. However, people from north start imposing Hindi here which we won't agree you can't come here and impose your language and tell us also to talk only in Hindi. We respect your language if you can't respect ours you can leave. We don't have any reason to let you stay in our land when you don't respect our language and culture.. In India most of the traditional culture is still surviving in south. North I don't see much.. if you can't respect our tradition culture, language you can't be called Indian.
You can also have the mnc, int airport in your state and start building your life.
If ur mother tongue is hindi y u come to karnataka,, go there ,, must speak Kannada in Karnataka
Bhai kannada learn karna logo ki choice hai tum kisiko force nahi kar sakte ki kannada sikho
*But you are forgetting dying languages like Kodava because of Kannada domination*
I wonder what the "Hind desh ke Niwasi, sabhi jan ek hai" line means now. This issue should be addressed by the Central Govt of India. Political propagandas are targeting our National Language, which is Hindi, whether you want to believe it or not.
In this video he says he is connected to the roots of Bengaluru city, but my question is... how the fuck are you connected without knowning Kannada?
U kannada begger
Language is just a medium to connect each other he contributes for the city for the city he never told about language question is who the airport authority works for hindi,spanish,english whatever' language might a passenger speak the authorities get paid for the job to help them not to mock or give trouble
*But you are forgetting dying languages like Kodava because of Kannada domination*
Legally it is not necessary to know any language. But it pays to have a genuine interest in languages. Here the problem is attitudes of people not any language I believe. Jealousy and hatred are the problems.
Then why we have to learn hindi.
@@pavankannada7358bro when u came out of ur state Karnataka which language u will prefer to speak
@@rajeshkotwal3877Please enlighten me in which language you are typing in the comments here ? If you can understand what I’m typing then what’s the use of learning Hindi.Just make the language in which u are typing as compulsory in all educational institutes in north.
Rightly put
@@rajeshkotwal3877 Your question is hilarious and stupid 😂
If they don't ask him to learn kannada, Bengaluru would become another hindi/urdu city like Hyderabad & Mumbai.
I feel sad for ur IQ bro 😂
Really? Go and sit in the railway station and say to every passenger, speak in kannada or else i won't allow you to enter karnataka.. A*s. Hole
@@AmitSingh-helloWorld
Say the reason before making irrelevant comment & unnecessary emojis.
@@AmitSingh-helloWorld frfr 😂
@@pokemonitishere202quora wasn't enough for you ?
Exactly the way we feel,when we are being told to learn Hindi as its our "official language"
There are 22 official languages of India.
And no body in NORTH INDIA says if you donot know HINDI then we can suspect you .
That's the difference .
A GUJRATI , BENGALI, HIAMCHALI, PUNJABI , ASSAMESE, ARUNCHAL PRADESHI , BIHARI, UTTRAKHANDI, KASHMIRI ...etc can speak their locak language/s but they never spread hate towards HINDI SPEAKERS.
It's ok if you can't communicate to them in their language and they will never hate you on that un like South Indians.
Speak in English
But you learned English very well I don't see ..why people have issue with their own country born langauge but ready to lick foreign born langauge and feel proud of it hypocrisy
@@kpopvoodoo well why don't you learn tamil or Telugu instead of "licking the boots of the colonizers",why should only others speak Hindi,are you mentally not equipped to learn new things or do you think you are entitled to this nonsense.
As a kannadati if I go to Coorg, I will learn kodava tak n their culture,
If I go to Tulunad I will learn Tulu
Uneducated people are better than saudi-radicalised terrorists.
U probably never stepped out of your ghetto and hence u don’t know the language.
Try telling this whole crap in Germany, France who want you to learn their language before going to their country.
Hindi isn’t the National language and honestly it’s been so mixed with too much Persian, replace the Persian with sanskrit first and then maybe people of the south will understand you better.
The Sanskrit vocabulary is known to us, most of us don’t know waqt, ishq etc etc but we know samay, prem etc
*Local language helps* 😇 *Few highly educated folks are bringing regionalism and trying to break the Indian ethos of Peace and Solidarity😮 Welcome to the New India* 🙌🏽
The name India itself is from UK British and Hindu word itself is from Persian.. if Indian politics doesn't speak english why would south Indians who are the government voting these political parties speak hindi.. nice irony right 😂
@@serenemind7654the name India is was used by greeks. It's happens when illiterate people try to behave like literate people. And your sentence does not make any sense
@@DannycageGhostriderindia is british term
Kudo's to the Kannadigas in Bengaluru, don't behave rudely but insist them to learn Kannada.
Don't let Bengaluru became next Mumbai.
That sounds really dumb , in telengana or ap most people can speak Hindi fluently, yet those states didn't turn into the "next Mumbai".
Bhai bengaluru ki aukaat nahi mumbai jaise banne ki bhi
Banglodu is not even a metro city , just wait for some more years and see the downfall, Mumbai is still in the top
I remember I went to Mumbai for a trip but I was surprised almost every person I spoke were Hindi speaking people . One thing I know is Marathi is finished in mumbai
I faced same problem when i had to go to police station in Bangalore. All the paper work was in kannada. Even though I'm from Rajasthan and only know English and Hindi. They talked in front of us only in kannada so that we can't understand anything
So please leave then. We don’t want you here
Because it is karnataka .not rajasthan .go back to your state if you have problem. Karnataka will not become rajasthan specially for you 😂kya logic hai ...they will talk in their own language in their own state why would they talk your language
I'm sorry I'm not privileged like most people. I have to go to places for work. And isn't it duty for police to be helpful. I faced unfair treatment I will tell about it. I'm not asking u to turn Karnataka into rajasthan atleast English is common language they could have used it.
See the audacity 😂 did you expect people from Karnataka to talk to you in Marwadi or Hindi. You people are the reason for hatred against Northies in South India.
ಎಲ್ಲಿಂದ ಬರ್ತೀರೋ ನೀವೆಲ್ಲಾ
He was born in Bangalore and he belongs to Bglore and he can't speak Kannada. 😮
OMFG what an observation, what happens the World ends, your GODS will eat him. You people mind your own business. INdia Is a democracy not a imposition centre
*But you are forgetting dying languages like Kodava because of Kannada domination*
@@aloe704Are you a Kodava?
ಬೇರೆಯವರಿಗೆ ನಮ್ಮ ಮನೆಯಲ್ಲಿ ಆಶ್ರಯ ಕೊಟ್ಟ ತಪ್ಪಿಗೆ, ನಾವು ಬೀದಿಗೆ ಬಿದ್ದಿದ್ದಿವಿ, ಇನ್ನೂ ಸ್ವಲ್ಪ ದಿನಗಳಷ್ಟೇ, ಆಮೇಲೆ ಕನ್ನಡನೂ ಇರಲ್ಲ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕ ನೂ ಇರಲ್ಲ, ನಾವೆಲ್ಲ ಹಿಂದಿ ಕಲಿತು ಅವರ ಕಾಲ್ ಕೆಳಗೆ ಇರೋಣ, ಏಕೆಂದರೆ ನಾವೆಲ್ಲ ಸ್ವಾಭಿಮಾನವಿಲ್ಲದ, ಧೈರ್ಯವಿಲ್ಲದ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರು 🤦,
ಕನ್ನಡ ಮಾತೆಗೆ ಅಂತಿಮ ನಮನಗಳು🙏
English is the most globally used language, that doesn't mean you can use English wherever you go like Germany, Chile, Peru, Sri Lanka, Nigeria, etc. Same thing applies to this as well.
The last time someone said "SiriGermanum gelge, SiriGermanum balge", it didn't end well 😂😂😂😂
Sri Lankans and Nigerians speak english very fluently
agree while we are at it we should make the foreigners landing in bengaluru take a test of kannada as a foreign
Language so they can read the Pub signs !
Blaming kannadigas u will never Grow in your life write in your dairy
If i go to south I'll ❤to learn there language as here in north south people speak hindi more good., be respectful and don't mock them to learn hindi,,nehru mindset people
Of these were to happen with a Kannadiga in west Bengal or Guj you guys would be literally burning their houses..
To hell with your language..
Next what learn tulu,and hundred other local Karnataka languages??😂😂😂😂.
Remember Guj ,Bengal,UP Bihar,Punjab accepts all Hindi and non Hindi speakers coz they don't want language barrier like nonsense..
Do you think north has only Hindi??😂😂😂
@@pikachue602can't really explain these bimaru mindset people
@@Lol06987 can't explain sense to poras the self-annoted Jnaanis🤣
The one thing officer said right was knowing the language where u take birth, i agree with that, but the debate should go beyond conversation
No it's unnecessary. If I suppose born in Japan but did whole my education and job in india, then I don't need to learn Japanese.
Not at all. Some of my friends were born in foreign nation.
Like Malaysia, South Africa and Germany.
But they completed their education here in India.
None of them know Malay, Afrikaans or Deutsch.
But they can speak English, Hindi,Gujarati and Marathi.
So it's not necessary that you should know the language of the place you were born in.
@@harsh_n208 well you can't survive without Japanese in Japan because they follow their tradition more than us and you won't see a lot of immigration in Japan
*But you are forgetting dying languages like Kodava because of Kannada domination*
ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರು ಬದಲಾಗುತ್ತಿದ್ದಾರೆ ❤
Hu agtidivi..
I stay in mumbai ..aadhre naanu kannadane maathaduvudu, kannada newspaper oduttene..baashe bagge gaurava irbeku
*But you are forgetting dying languages like Kodava because of Kannada domination*
Honestly we came to bangalore for our livelihood not to learn kannada..we respect kannada just like assamese or rajasthani but that doesn't mean you can force us to learn what you love....this dictatorship attitude should stop...Our brains are already exhausted from leaning English, Hindi, mother tounge, C++, Java, Python etc...Making ridiculous and unreasonable demands would not increase our respect to any language...
🤔If u r exhauated & tiered & get back to ur home town & stay peacefully🤗.. Simple
@manoharindia7774 I would love it.. nobody threatened non locals or me to learn any new language or put sign boards in our home town... there is no dictatorship or cruelty in other town...
@@mnd3607🤗 try & check plese👉🏼..
To all the uneducated people supporting, find where it's written Hindi is the national language. Learn to respect the locality where you stay. Please help him to settle permanently in Saudi as he s done his schooling and all over there only.
Bro don't say like this not every state has ego ....I live in Bengal but belong to up& Bihar belt ....In icse schools Bengali is taught from 3 to 5 so I learnt to read and write Bengali then .... However I am not confident enough to speak Bengali ( being an introvert ).... I understand whatever another person is saying and reply in Hindi ... Never has someone told me that "you live in Bengal but don't speak in Bengali ".........To sum up , I want to say that don't make it a compulsion that if you come to a state you need to learn the language like in northern India most people are uneducated so you need to talk with them in Hindi and in south India most people are educated so one can easily converse with them in English ...
UNEDUCATED? Show us where is it written to necessarily know a language of one's place of birth
@@adityaverma2501 Very well said!
Good....kanadians are better...can i speak Tamil in Delhi.......when Hindi is imposed on us ....what is wrong in telling to speak in kanada...thanks to Modi govt people are knowing there languages.....value
Point...
*But you are forgetting dying languages like Kodava because of Kannada domination*
It's true I've been to banglore
It's a nice City overall
But their is a huge language barrier
And the locals are not at all cooperative
U learn and speak in Kannada.. U will be treated as ur home state..
@ProGamer Rather u should learn and speak Hindi so all the outsiders can feel it as home
@@RajSharma-xd5mg You are coming to Bengaluru. So you should adapt by learning Kannada . Karnataka or Kannadigas will not adapt for you.
@ Sunshine K
If I am only coming for 5-10 days for a small visit then it means I have to go through the whole book of learning kannada
And you guys cant prefer to speak Hindi
That means if you guys come to Maharastra then you should learn Marathi
Or in Gujrat you should learn Gujrati
Ans In Assam you should learn Assamesse
Is it?
No you illiterate piece of shit
Rather you guys should speak in Hindi
Or else this communication barrier will not stand with
Unity in Diversity
And if this is your attitude then Kannadnigas should not go anywhere outside Karnataka
मला कानडी लोकांचा हेवा वाटतो. खरोखर त्यांनी कानडी भाषा बेंगळुर मध्ये जपली आहे. येथे मुंबई मधल्या सोसायटीज मध्ये मराठी लोकांना रहायला पण permission देत नाहीत.
Not really
There are many areas in Bengaluru where there are literally no Kannadigas
When in Karnataka speak Kannada or leave Karnataka
@@aaatd7550 महाराष्ट्रात मराठीच बोला !
Being born in karnataka, grew up here, drinking kaveri water, living in karnataka and doesn't understand kannada.. wow
Are u stupid or what....he has contributed so much to Bengaluru n u r doing discrimination on language.
Bu drinking Kaveri water do you get to learn Kannada by itself? Then I will stop having borewell and have Kaveri from tomorrow.
See, everyone doesn’t get to learn the local language. I live in Karnataka since last 5 years, though I never got a chance to learn the language as all my kannadiga friends speak English in when we all are together so that everyone can understand. We order grocery, medicines, cabs from app. So people like us will never be able to learn Kannada. Please don’t tell me go get classes as those are very bad, I tried once.
@@poulamipanjal3070😂😂😂
Lol😂😊
is it so easy to learn by drinking kaveri water 🤣
Thank God I know Kannada 😂
Good, learn to read it too.. you won't be disappointed.. i mean it
If I’m going to Bangalore, im not going without learning Kannada
Dravidian languages is described as crow language by ancient sanskrit speakers
@@gadinadasobagu EVERY language has its gems, but forcing a person will only spoil that languages reputation.
@@ALOK-pe5fpHindi is said to be the language of Pajeets and cow language by our ancestors and other countries too.
Speak in kannada otherwise you don't have to come to karanataka
Whole Karnataka is not booked by you... You can't say where a person can go or not... This is just india mate... don't spread hate
Don't worry days are not far away when other cities in north central east and west india will challenge your position of an IT hub then only your arrogant mind would realize that how much these immigrants contribute to your economy
5-10 years and watch their ego go down@@sankalpshrivastava1103
Same happening to me in pune for knowing little bit of Marathi in the office
Dude Maharashtra much liberal compared to other states from south, don't create a hype around it..
😂
Good
@@CCCP85lol..
Typical marathi chauvinist attitude ...First go through the same treatment, then we will talk ...😂😂😂
Is it only a Karnataka, kannada thing or does this discrimination happen in Kerala, tamilnadu, Andhra Pradesh? Please share your thoughts, really want to know .
Apparently, this happens all over south. KA, especially Bangalore is highlighted as it the largest city there.
I agree this happens in north as well but the instances of this "imposition" happening in south are much more.
ఎందుకంటే హిందీ మా ప్రాచీన గొప్ప భాషల్ని చంపేస్తుంది కాబట్టి.
Not in Kerala, we are flexible to Hindi , English, Malayalam.
@@mortisdeusYeah!! But still some of our people won't be preferring hindi language......
First of all the person is immigration officer who is appointed by Ministry of Home Affairs of India (Central Government) and not by Karnataka State government.
So he has to show similar behavior to all passengers.
Also should not impose any language on passenger.
If it was BBMP office then it's not a big matter. But such behavior in airport is rude and disrespectful.
Dude, you were like 38 years old and you lived all your life in Bangalore and you haven’t even taken a minute to learn Kannada that is surprising
If u r living in a state or a country first try to respect that place who ever u may be
Our south language kannada, tamil, telugu, malayalam is far more greater history then hindi....
For speak with the world english is ok for us.. Why hindi?... Really fun😁
speak only tulu in karnatak
@Rajnasya wrong. Hindi is a bastardized version of Persian and Turkish imposed on a parakrit script. Infact Telugu, Kannada and Malayalam were way more influenced by Sanskrit as the standard grammar and pronunciation are taken from Sanskrit. Which is why Sanskrit is present in the soul of these languages. Tamil have had influence of Sanskrit but purists are pursuing the desanskritization of Tamil.
@Rajnasya whatever you call descent is what I call bastardization because of Islamic conquests. Hindi's grammar is different from that of Sanskrit and pronunciation goes way different. Compare that with say Telugu, the script is way older than that of Hindi, but the grammar and pronunciation are way closer to Sanskrit. A simple word like Rama is pronounced as Ram in Hindi and as Rama in Sanskrit and Telugu. Standardized formal southern languages have way more vocabulary from Sanskrit.
@Rajnasyajanpats where also tibes 😂 learn history nortie
*ಹೇ ಸಾಡೇ ಹೋಗು ನಿನ್ನ ತಂದೆಯನ್ನೇ ಕೇಳು...ನೀನು ಬೆಂಗಳೂರಿನಲ್ಲಿ ಯಾಕೆ ಜನ್ಮ ಕೊಟ್ಟೆ.... ನಿಮ್ಮ ಆಧಾರ್ನಲ್ಲಿ ತಂದೆಯ ಹೆಸರನ್ನು ಇಡುವುದು ಅಗತ್ಯವೇ?? ನೀವು ನನ್ನ ಹೆಸರನ್ನು ಸಹ ನೀಡಬಹುದು...#NKN DON'T MESS WITH ಕನ್ನಡಿಗ❤️💛🤬
I am a Telugu who studied in Bangalore. I am with you. Way to go.
I have done my schooling in Lucknow. God alone knows the kind of discrimination I had faced.
These North Indians feel as if they are whites of India. They used to call me Madrasi. They would say I smell sambar . Also remarks like , “ Madrasi ho kar tum aur tumhare family wale itne gore kaise ho.
This supremacist attitude is very irritating.
we want a separate country we dont want to be in Hindia anymore jai karnataka jai dravida nadu
Full support from Gujarat
If you have that much power then try brother
THEN U WILL FIGHT AMONGT URSELVES...........SAAAR THESE TELUGU GULITES ARE IMPSOING TLEUGU SAAAR,AS TELUGU IS MOST DOMINANT SOUTH LANGUAGE😂😂,FIRST ATLEAST MAKE ONE COMMON DRAVID LANGUAGE IN 5 SOUTH STATES......................................THEN ASK OTHERS TO LEARN UR LANGUAGE
Who's this guy. Claiming to be from Bangalore and yet doesn't know Kannada? 😂😂😂
Such a shame!!!😅
That's what I am thinking... I feel like this is the biggest threat to kannada😂😂
Guy in the video is uneducated he says Hindi is national language!!
Also he implies indirectly Modi don’t know kannada so all to speak Hindi?
Anti national he is!!
And by the way who is this guy 😂
@@sanjay.pandey 💯
@sanjay.pandey nan shaata
Had same scene today, at Bangalore by one Muslim local he abused my wife too, in fact she is Kannada speaking girl from Udupi. These idiots need to get a tight slap. He was abusing me and my wife for no reason.
The auto driver angry on her because she know kannada but refused to speak
It more looks like she was forcing him to speak in Hindi.
1St stop calling 'apna shehar' if you ever felt that its your city you would have learnt kannada which is official language. You should be ashamed to tell that you don't know the kannada even after born and brought up here.
He grew up in Saudi Arabia. There is no Kannada in Saudi Arabia.
Really appreciate that immigration officer for asking. This was really needed for entering Bengaluru.. Huge respect to that immigration officer...
Obviously no one has right to impose their language on others...
But being a telugaite married to gujarati, living in Bangalore I can see majority of kannadigas are forced to learn hindi, telugu,tamil and malayalam due to immigrants from decades .... in this process they are losing the authenticity of language in daily life, so I can understand their view too... but I'm not okay with imposing languages.
Personally I feel that if I am living in gujarat I will learn gujarati to bond with the localites...afterall learning languages will only help us in gaining knowledge and giving respect to their language is also gaining respect from them.
People who live in Karnataka must talk Kannada
You know Kannada, then you are the King of Karnataka.... 💥🌟
Thanks to WhatsApp University...for this all...😢
What the hell is problem with this guy.... You went to Karnataka and saying you will not try to speak kannada... And he is frustrated about one officer asked him to speak in kannada... He will never understand the trouble south indians go through every day because of hindi... Even in local railways all the announcement are in Hindi... First grow up... It's their land their language and their rules if you don't like you don't go there....
What the hell wrong with you? If you visit any state or any country do you learn their language? How many countries did you visit in Europe have you capability to learn every language? What if you face shity discrimination on the ground of language? Don't impose anything on anyone they love to learn If they love and feel neccessary. Btw learning language is not overnight task.
When guys from South come to our states, we never behave like these hooligans here I'm South, y do these guys do sp then????? We never force them to speak Hindi........
@@YourSqnType in what dream land you are living man... My friend spoke Tamil in Delhi and got slapped(beaten) for not speaking in Hindi... In Tamil Nadu and Karnataka there are lot of migrant workers are there in South India they mostly order us to talk in Hindi... Infact my brother learnt hindi to speak with migrant workers in Bangalore... So please be awake hindi people make it worse than anyone in India....
@@sharankumar5115 never
@@sharankumar5115 wtf do u mean by order 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
*Kannadigas impose Kannada in fear of Kannada erasure, but don't think about Tulu, Kodava, Konkani, Beary erasure.*
A person , just born in a place without being culturally and linguistictically native cant claim its his city unless he become part of natives . Urdu speaking muslims in bengaluru are migrants from upper deccan or northern India . They are aliens here in every sense . They didnt adopt and formed their own gullies . "Migration without assimilation is invasion " .
There is every right for the inspector to suspect as this person has history of living in saudi , which is staunch muslim country under sharia rule , for some time and mention Bengaluru as his local place without knowing native toungue .
One and only kannada
*But you are forgetting dying languages like Kodava because of Kannada domination*