I own both. WS is overall better because it plays well at any player count and there is a higher control over available cards since there are at least the 3 in the tray which one can see beforehand. Earth plays well up to 3 player max, 4 and 5 is overwhelming because you can’t really control what your opponents are doing being so engaged over your own tableau. Earth is a ok game, but I would pick WS over Earth anytime even at 2 and 3 player count.
We just got Earth and generally enjoy it; still learning and have only 4 games played; but funbun and ethmah both have wins ... and I don't yet ... ouch
Earth hands down, I find wingspan boring and the score cards feel pointless, it felt more strategic with the scoring cards in earth and it has more depth
I haven't played wingspan again since getting Earth and probably won't again, Earth is deeper and more strategic and just more fun for me, wingspan feels a little boring in comparison
This looks cool Tay. I like how the cards feature the binomial nomenclature. One for the nature nerds!
Glad you like it!
I own both. WS is overall better because it plays well at any player count and there is a higher control over available cards since there are at least the 3 in the tray which one can see beforehand. Earth plays well up to 3 player max, 4 and 5 is overwhelming because you can’t really control what your opponents are doing being so engaged over your own tableau. Earth is a ok game, but I would pick WS over Earth anytime even at 2 and 3 player count.
Great insights!
We just got Earth and generally enjoy it; still learning and have only 4 games played; but funbun and ethmah both have wins ... and I don't yet ... ouch
It’s not about winning but more about the quality time spent together right… right…
@@tuckNcache Uhhhh... right?? Though I did pick up a W last night v ethmah and it felt pretty goooooood. LOL
Earth hands down, I find wingspan boring and the score cards feel pointless, it felt more strategic with the scoring cards in earth and it has more depth
Earth feels more puzzle-like than strategy for me. I enjoy both games in general.
Maybe you should choose, wingspan or earth, or both.
Wingspan of course!
I haven't played wingspan again since getting Earth and probably won't again, Earth is deeper and more strategic and just more fun for me, wingspan feels a little boring in comparison
Is this available digitally or is it just a board game Tay?
You can play it for free on Board Game Arena
Both, you can play it digitally on Board Game Arena.
Clearly Harvest Moon: Friends of Mineral Town is the better game
📺