Just a heads up: this isn't a new release-it's a reupload from 11/14/2020. If you'd like to know what's going on and when _"Sonic: What If?"_ will officially start up again, please see my latest update video: th-cam.com/video/-ZdWZSCw6YI/w-d-xo.html
Other stories like the sequel to this one ,lost Hex Espio ,the Wherehog after generations, & Permanent eggman and knuckles duo from workbench channel Should all be continued? Thanks to both IDW and the new sonic games that would bringing more intrigue as was any Inclusions of others parts of sonic media like the Soul dimension, Stix the Bagder, The prime prism dimensions, or New plans of doctor Starline. Although the Gamma dying story could either conclude there Or Someone else like Doctor Starline, Eggman, or Neo Metal Sonic swoops in to make a deal with Aya in order to save gamma with a little twist of the story continuing on, plus The conflict that just happened in the jungle and ruins might grab the attention of Stix the badger as a third party. Some forethought for your new plans, I like to hear your opinions on this. I've always been a big fan of these custom What if stories with video editing with the detail put into this using Canon Lore, and to see your work coming back after almost 4 years I'm am quite anxious to see: Something New Something Old Something Borrowed Something Blue Returning 💙
I'm still convinced that Ken Penders is the reason this what-if went on hiatus. I mean, one does not simply bring up the Nocturnus clan without him suing for "infringement"
Lets start by the fact that she would still be dead by the events of Adventure 2 Either by old age or by her illness The only thing that would mostly change is that Gerald wouldn't do his revenge plan, and Shadow probably would be turned into a Ultimate weapon by gun And probably everyone would at least know about him in the sonic univer... Oh wow A lot would actually change
With the ending veering into the Twilight Cage, I can picture a new chapter with the name, "Sonic Chronicles: The God of Time" That way, Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood would pick up where God of Time left off
Welcome back Sega Scourge you have been deeply missed, this reupload has now inspired me to re watch all your previous videos to prepare for all your new content and I've decided to include my comment from this video's original upload hope you still like it. "Thank you for not including the Sonic & Elise kiss and Emerl & Gemerl’s merged form Masterl is a real masterpiece (pun intended). And you made a great creative choice at the end of fully incorporating Emerl’s connection to The Nocturnes clan for which you hinted at in the beginning of part 1 that ending bit caught me off guard" Major respect, I’m really looking forward to seeing all your new content.👍🏻
Part 4 is back and better than ever! You have no idea how much I miss this what if and I'm looking forward to your other what if when the time comes! And also. Vox: That f***er is back! Val: Yes~! Vox: It's been two years!
I know that now might not be the best time, considering how busy you are from what I've gathered, but I think I have an idea for a possible plot point in whatever part the Werehog What If takes place during Lost World. In one of your theorist archive videos, you theorized that when the Zeti were absorbing the planet's energy, they were also absorbing the energies of Light and Dark Gaia. Perhaps this could also have an effect on the werehog? Edit: forgot to write this part: I apologize again for it, but I couldn't help myself. The idea was there and I wanted to get it out before I forgot. Welcome back, Scourge!
It's good to see you come back, I Saw your channel a few months ago finding the What if Sonic lost his memory videos. I can't wait to see what happens In Lost world with the Werehog Series.
Good to here from The Scourge himself. It's good that you're coming back. But we know you gone through a lot and we don't know you personal like that, but the views always care. If you got busy just take your time coming back.
Amazing episode! But the question for now is, how can Sonic and his friends venture to the Gizoid's location? Maybe they'll have to travel on new Frontiers to obtain the answers.
I hear a cry that sounds like the true Emerl I sense he is not gone but lies dormant.The true Emerl will return for a soul such as Emerl’s can not WILL NOT be snuffed out that easily.
You don't understand how happy I am to see you again. Hope to see more of your espio what if because that's my favourite even tho all your what ifs are good.
I'm kinda curious, how far back have any new releases been in development? For example, were any too late in production to account for that lore-changing TailsTube?
What if you swapped characters around like swapping Sonic with Blaze? Blaze the fire throwing high speed fighter for Mobuis and Sonic high speed prince of the Sol dimension. Keeping their personalities similar but changed a little with their new upbringing. Blaze "Uncle Chuck how is it that i'm a cat but you and my parents were hedgehogs?". Amy with Rogue or Whisper in Sonic CD Metal Sonic tries to kidnap Whisper but Whisper just opens fire although she wouldn't have wisps since its before Sonic Colours so its probably a laser blaster. Metal Sonic "Sonic help me she's crazy get me outta here!" He's slowly dragged into the darkness his metallic fingers try to dig into the ground. Shadow with Maria maybe during his time on the arc Dr Gerald Robotnik figured out how to cure Maria but Shadow would have to give his powers to Maria turning Shadow into a normal hedgehog person then all the stuff happens causing Maria to be sent to Earth and shadow dying. Tails "So you had a hedgehog buddy too?" Maria "Yeah...but he's dead now" Tails "...that's rough buddy". What if the idw comic characters like Tangle and whisper was in the games. What if the symbiote from was in Sonic "if you want the badniks gone i'll take the staff job double the rings
Now thinking about it, Emerl's brothers having personalities is not possible. Wasn't Gerald's intervention what gave Emerl his personality? These two were never even seen by Gerald, thus they can't have personalities, and should be more like mindless mechs
All we know is: Gerald gave Emerl a "soul" so to speak, he didn't craft a personality-Emerl's personality came from Sonic and the others. (It's also possible that Emerl's true personality is his power-hungry self when he loses control.) Scylla and Charyb had their personalities in Chronicles, so I can only assume that they also derived theirs from experiences with the Nocturnus. Either that or they were built with them.
@@thesegascourge I understand what you mean, but I would argue the soul and the capability to have a personality are too closely connected to exist one without the other. And the other Gizmos, are totaly blank (or maybe they are not, and just imitating the British royal guard) so these two being special was always wierd to me. But ok, it is Sonic Chronicles, doing these type of stuff, is one of the reasons why they are hard to consider as canon.
I have no idea where else to put this ‘what if’ idea so I’m just gonna put it here What if Blaze couldn’t return to her world after sonic rush? Maybe even the opposite. What if Sonic and Tails got stuck in Blazes dimension. Idk how this would happen but I think its both an interesting idea and a creative outlet if you end up choosing the second, because Blaze’s world hasn’t really been explored all that much. Cant wait for the next installment of sonic what if :)
Just a heads up: this isn't a new release-it's a reupload from 11/14/2020. If you'd like to know what's going on and when _"Sonic: What If?"_ will officially start up again, please see my latest update video: th-cam.com/video/-ZdWZSCw6YI/w-d-xo.html
Welcome back comrade, it’s good to see you again.
Good to see you again. Which what if story is getting an update this time?
Yeah I figured it out from the “last time on-“ segment, but it still makes for a good refresher none the less.
The return of the Ultimate gizod or what some people would like to call him Robo Jesus. Better than Sonic and Eilesa kissing scene though!🤣
Other stories like the sequel to this one ,lost Hex Espio ,the Wherehog after generations, & Permanent eggman and knuckles duo from workbench channel Should all be continued?
Thanks to both IDW and the new sonic games that would bringing more intrigue as was any Inclusions of others parts of sonic media like the Soul dimension, Stix the Bagder, The prime prism dimensions, or New plans of doctor Starline.
Although the Gamma dying story could either conclude there Or Someone else like Doctor Starline, Eggman, or Neo Metal Sonic swoops in to make a deal with Aya in order to save gamma with a little twist of the story continuing on, plus The conflict that just happened in the jungle and ruins might grab the attention of Stix the badger as a third party.
Some forethought for your new plans, I like to hear your opinions on this. I've always been a big fan of these custom What if stories with video editing with the detail put into this using Canon Lore, and to see your work coming back after almost 4 years I'm am quite anxious to see:
Something New
Something Old
Something Borrowed
Something Blue Returning 💙
As agent stone once said,
HE'S BACK!!!
The return starts with this…
A gizoid containing the ultimate power!
That's The...Chaos Emeralds!
gizoid*
That's the... Chaos Emerl!
@@bobandmrmecaleb5873So, now I know what’s going on. The Military has come to me to find the likes of you.
@@bobandmrmecaleb5873 That ain't Emerl. That's Masterl, The Ultimate Hero and The Bane of The Sun God!
I sense a great disturbance in the TH-cam thread, as if millions of voices suddenly cried out in excitement and chorused together.
Nwoser: Bwahaha!
Nwoser Jr.: Bwahaha!
That they did my young padawan. That they did
I'm still convinced that Ken Penders is the reason this what-if went on hiatus.
I mean, one does not simply bring up the Nocturnus clan without him suing for "infringement"
After so long of using MasakoX, Salad Saiyan, Smugstick and Damon: What if? To get my What if Fill your finally back
Check check check and check. Me too.
It’s been so long, I started voice acting for one of them.
We twining 🤞
Glad to see this one back up. Take all the time you need preparing for the comeback!
19:26 Wait a minute-
Idea for a future What If:
What if Maria Robotnik survived that fateful day aboard the ARK and escaped with Shadow.
Also welcome back!
Lets start by the fact that she would still be dead by the events of Adventure 2
Either by old age or by her illness
The only thing that would mostly change is that Gerald wouldn't do his revenge plan, and Shadow probably would be turned into a Ultimate weapon by gun
And probably everyone would at least know about him in the sonic univer...
Oh wow
A lot would actually change
Masterl: *Exists*
Solaris: Why do I hear “Brave Heart”?
“HE’S BACK!”
King he's back king what If
Agreed
It is good to be back.
GUYS, SHARE HIS CHANNEL AROUND, THIS MAN NEEDS THOSE VIEWERS BACK!!
I'm fr happy to just have the viewers I _have!_ Those returning to the channel. Couldn't ask for much else.
With the ending veering into the Twilight Cage, I can picture a new chapter with the name, "Sonic Chronicles: The God of Time"
That way, Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood would pick up where God of Time left off
This man’s content was my childhood. Great to see him back! ❤️
37:50 wellp, guess we'll see ya in a few more years lol. Jokes aside I'm really looking forward to the next part!!!
Saaame. Can't wait to pick up the Emerl story again. It's been too long.
THE RETURN OF THE KING
Welcome back Sega Scourge you have been deeply missed, this reupload has now inspired me to re watch all your previous videos to prepare for all your new content and I've decided to include my comment from this video's original upload hope you still like it.
"Thank you for not including the Sonic & Elise kiss and Emerl & Gemerl’s merged form Masterl is a real masterpiece (pun intended). And you made a great creative choice at the end of fully incorporating Emerl’s connection to The Nocturnes clan for which you hinted at in the beginning of part 1 that ending bit caught me off guard"
Major respect, I’m really looking forward to seeing all your new content.👍🏻
Ahhh Christopher, that's so cool that you included your OG comment! And thank you for that love and encouragement. You're seriously awesome.
Glad to see this amazing episode back up. Honestly it just gives me an excuse to re watch all of what if emerl survived and im all for that.
Had to rewatch the whole series first. I'm glad to see it all again since this was actually my favorite scenario thus far
Part 4 is back and better than ever! You have no idea how much I miss this what if and I'm looking forward to your other what if when the time comes!
And also.
Vox: That f***er is back!
Val: Yes~!
Vox: It's been two years!
it's good to have The Sega Scourge back after all this time
It's good to _be_ back. 'Almost' back, anyway.
He’s back……. HE’S BACK!!!!!!!
Awesome to have you back dude!
When the world needed him most, he returned.
Yo I've been missing your content welcome back
This reupload was a nice opportunity to rewatch the whole Emerl series again. Looking forward to see how this continues or concludes in the future.
He’s finally returned welcome back Sega scourge
Even though you have not exactly returned, let's just say you're slowly returning.
WELCOME BACK, SCOURGE!
I know that now might not be the best time, considering how busy you are from what I've gathered, but I think I have an idea for a possible plot point in whatever part the Werehog What If takes place during Lost World. In one of your theorist archive videos, you theorized that when the Zeti were absorbing the planet's energy, they were also absorbing the energies of Light and Dark Gaia. Perhaps this could also have an effect on the werehog?
Edit: forgot to write this part: I apologize again for it, but I couldn't help myself. The idea was there and I wanted to get it out before I forgot. Welcome back, Scourge!
It's good to see you come back, I Saw your channel a few months ago finding the What if Sonic lost his memory videos.
I can't wait to see what happens In Lost world with the Werehog Series.
Awesome Video And Welcome Back 😎😎
Nice to see you again
Take your time
Awesome, it's back.
Return of the KING. welcome back
AYE! MY MAN SEGA SCOURGE!!!! Welcome back homie!! Back with the Robert Patterson Batman Shadow voice! 100/10! 😁
It’s enough to make a grown man cry… and that’s okay…
Good to here from The Scourge himself. It's good that you're coming back. But we know you gone through a lot and we don't know you personal like that, but the views always care. If you got busy just take your time coming back.
Hey part 4 is back awesome
Emerl is back in canon, baby!
HELL YEAH!!
Emerl fans finally gettin fed
Even if it's a reupload, it's good to see you back!
The king is back
How is one of my favorite robots of the Sonic franchise
Amazing episode! But the question for now is, how can Sonic and his friends venture to the Gizoid's location? Maybe they'll have to travel on new Frontiers to obtain the answers.
It’s been FOREVER. Holy shit! Even if it is a reupload.
Welcome back my brother
“I am neither Emerl or Gemerl! I’m Masterl! It’s over for, Solaris, I’ve come for you!”
Its been 2 years
Welcome back king
Damn bro, looks like they finally freed u from the gun base. It's been 50 years😂
"Freed me?" Pfft.
@@thesegascourge
Awe u broke out that jam?
Good shit my boi.
@@thesegascourge You can induce Chaos Control?!
a note. chronicles was specifically decanonized in the sonic encyclo-speed-ia in 2021. so its status is officially known now.
I love the new logo
Thanks dude. It was whipped up by my bud Steven: twitter.com/segasteven
what the fuck
seeing you again was a pleasant surprise
Holy crap he’s back
I hear a cry that sounds like the true Emerl I sense he is not gone but lies dormant.The true Emerl will return for a soul such as Emerl’s can not WILL NOT be snuffed out that easily.
You don't understand how happy I am to see you again. Hope to see more of your espio what if because that's my favourite even tho all your what ifs are good.
Well, well, well, it's been a long time. Where's part 4 of the gamma series? I want to see Gamma interact with Sigma
Here's a cool what if: What if Knuckles stayed on Eggman's side?
He’s back...
HE’S BAAAAAAAAAACK!!!
I'm kinda curious, how far back have any new releases been in development? For example, were any too late in production to account for that lore-changing TailsTube?
Little amendments and changes are being made! I always strive for _Sonic: What If?_ to be as canon-compliant and "official-like" as possible.
Good to have you back, man. Can't wait for the next video.
Dude, that Nocturnus integration was crazy!
Hell yeah! Hes back! ❤❤❤
This is so interesting, I can't wait to see what happends with the nocturnas clan and how they'll take over the world
Damn, it's good to hear you voice again.
Much love, Ross-you'll get to hear more soon!
@@thesegascourge I can't wait.
What if you swapped characters around like swapping Sonic with Blaze? Blaze the fire throwing high speed fighter for Mobuis and Sonic high speed prince of the Sol dimension. Keeping their personalities similar but changed a little with their new upbringing. Blaze "Uncle Chuck how is it that i'm a cat but you and my parents were hedgehogs?".
Amy with Rogue or Whisper in Sonic CD Metal Sonic tries to kidnap Whisper but Whisper just opens fire although she wouldn't have wisps since its before Sonic Colours so its probably a laser blaster. Metal Sonic "Sonic help me she's crazy get me outta here!" He's slowly dragged into the darkness his metallic fingers try to dig into the ground.
Shadow with Maria maybe during his time on the arc Dr Gerald Robotnik figured out how to cure Maria but Shadow would have to give his powers to Maria turning Shadow into a normal hedgehog person then all the stuff happens causing Maria to be sent to Earth and shadow dying. Tails "So you had a hedgehog buddy too?" Maria "Yeah...but he's dead now" Tails "...that's rough buddy".
What if the idw comic characters like Tangle and whisper was in the games.
What if the symbiote from was in Sonic "if you want the badniks gone i'll take the staff job double the rings
Didnt Sega Scourge upload this years ago? I swear I remember seeing this before
We are so back!
Scourge returns, and with him, The Gizoids Beyond The God Of Time!
THE. FUCKING. GOAT. RETURNS!!!!
Good to see this video get re-upload! Now we just have to wait for the next part of this what if to finally come out in due time! Lol
So is Sonic Chronicles the dark brotherhood next, or is it another Sonic game
HE'S ACTUALLY BACK!!!!
The king has reclaimed his crown.
FINALLY! MY BOY EMERL IS BACK!!!
2 what if ideas: what if shadow died
Instead of maria or if shadow and Maria died on the space colony arch
Glad to have you back
THE GOAT RETURNS
Glad to see it back up again 😁
I know it's a reupload but It's always nice to see a new video on the channel 🤩
And Sonic went full Fall Guys with Sonic Rumble on mobile 🦔
I've missed these, awesome as always
I was about to wait 1 or 2 Months for a new Video,but Here it is(i know that this is a reupload but still).
Glad to see you back
Ayyyyy My childhood is backkkk
Will you do a What if Gamma survived Part 4, Gamma is My favorite character
I'm so happy to just see uploads from you
Lotsa happiness on my end, too. Can't wait for more. I appreciate you, SCN.
HE'S BACK
I AM! KINDA! ALMOST!
@@thesegascourge MAYHAPS EVEN
we need more of this!!!!
HES BACK
Now all we need is a video about gamma
He has returned the great King has returned
Idea: what if Sonic stayed in Camelot and abandoned the real world?
Welcome back, my good sir! Tis been a while!
It’s back? ITS BACK!!
HE'S BACK!
Now thinking about it, Emerl's brothers having personalities is not possible. Wasn't Gerald's intervention what gave Emerl his personality? These two were never even seen by Gerald, thus they can't have personalities, and should be more like mindless mechs
All we know is: Gerald gave Emerl a "soul" so to speak, he didn't craft a personality-Emerl's personality came from Sonic and the others. (It's also possible that Emerl's true personality is his power-hungry self when he loses control.)
Scylla and Charyb had their personalities in Chronicles, so I can only assume that they also derived theirs from experiences with the Nocturnus. Either that or they were built with them.
@@thesegascourge I understand what you mean, but I would argue the soul and the capability to have a personality are too closely connected to exist one without the other. And the other Gizmos, are totaly blank (or maybe they are not, and just imitating the British royal guard) so these two being special was always wierd to me. But ok, it is Sonic Chronicles, doing these type of stuff, is one of the reasons why they are hard to consider as canon.
Welcome back, @thesegascourge :)
I have no idea where else to put this ‘what if’ idea so I’m just gonna put it here
What if Blaze couldn’t return to her world after sonic rush? Maybe even the opposite. What if Sonic and Tails got stuck in Blazes dimension.
Idk how this would happen but I think its both an interesting idea and a creative outlet if you end up choosing the second, because Blaze’s world hasn’t really been explored all that much. Cant wait for the next installment of sonic what if :)
YES! YOU’RE BACK
It's back! IT'S BACK! IT'S BAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACCK!
Welcome back you scourge
Senpai has returned