Well, true but also, he led lots of soldiers of the 401st than just a team, but it is also true he is not a Senate Guard, they were not clones, they only wore relatively close armor to what a clone wears.
fox wasn't really that bad cause u forget he never wanted to be part of the guard he wishes he could be fighting on the front with his brothers but to be fair fox was told fives was defective and insane and fox gave 3 warnings after fives pulled a gun on fox and his men so fox chose his squad over what he thought was rouge insane clone who had already attempted to murder the Chancellor
Anthony Virtucio really vulgarity towards someone who just seid that fox didn't really a choice because he had a gun aimed at his head that just proves how many brain cells you have left ps u just got made to look like an idiot by a 15 year old just so u know that saying stuff like that doesn't provide a point or valid argument it just makes u look ignorant
@@cassielov3 Ik I’m hella late but like shut the fuck up please, I hate when people said that I’ll list several reasons why he couldn’t use stun 1: He was most likely ordered by palpatine to kill him and if he didn’t follow those orders he’d probably get court marshal’d 2: Fox held captain red and a akin hostage 3: One of the most important ones he was accused of trying to assassinate palpatine 4: The most important one Fox warned fives not to grab the gun so did Rex 5: before he grabbed the gun fox was listening wit a brief moment and he thought fives was acting a crazy 6: Then fives grabbed the gun and aimed it at fox and his men and then fox shot him to protect himself and his men. I honestly don’t like fox is personality I love his army though I repeat I don’t like fox besides his armor and I’m no personal opinions I just think fox deserves way less hate then he deserves everything I stated is facts there is myths why he killed fives but I don’t want to get to that thanks for reading hopeful this change you view of fox at least a little bit.
Pariah97 actually the corsair guards are the best of the best most Wer taken from other clone legions because they Wer so good at what they do that they were promoted to an elite rank and fox leads them so fox was a extremely high ranking clone and for a reason remember rex was a fan favorite and even he was just a Capitan. fox and Cody both outranked him so no hate for either of them from me
I think Fox was either stressed to shoot Fives because he grabbed a gun so for the safety of his own mans he didn't had the time to... because when your stressed you do mistakes I wouldn't mind if fox shot his the leg, but not in a fatal spot. Or Palpatine told his secret...
CommanderCodyHD how does one shoot someone's lag? I would really like to know because it would make multiplayer games so much better if you could just shoot the lag away. Anyway, Fox was given orders to kill Fives on sight, but he still tried to bring him in alive. If you want to be mad at someone for killing Fives, by mad at that Kaminoan who drugged him to make it seem like the chip actually did control the clones aggressive behavior.
Few things one I read that Fox and many shock troopers were quite bored on Coruscant cause no action. I have never seen evidence of this social diffrence between coruscant gaurd and regs in well anything and lastly Fives pulled a gun on him a real life cop would've done the same.
Paul Harrison because they are elite and shock troopers aren't infantry they are like a military swat and do the same things fox and his men do like at ziros and when bane kidnapped the Senate or all the other times they stormed into enemy territory
I'm talking real life where the name comes from was the elite German units of WW1 my point was why did the creators of starwars call them shock troopers instead of say SWAT troopers.
Company007 I agree because if fives was alive then the Jedi and most clones would know palpatine was a Sith Lord.Then Palpatine would get rEkT by everyone.
Exactly what I thought, no clone is stupid enough to forget to put his gun on stun. In saying that fox did let in suicide droids in the Coruscant power station so...
He also not only let separatist sabotage droids through security, but also gave them direction to the power plant. Granted, this is just sucking at his (ONE) job rather than being a jerk, but still...
Ethan Steffek I meant other than the fact he killed Fives. I only remember him only failing at his job once. I mean, if he didn't kill Fives, then I think Fox is a perfectly fine, if not, great, clone trooper.
+CT_21_0408 YT He failed his job multiple times. While every clone was trying to stun Ahsoka when she was accused of bombing the Jedi Temple, Fox used lethal force. When Separatist bomb droids attempted to bomb the generator room, Fox didn't see how suspicious they were, & even TOLD them where to go. Then the whole Fives incident happened.
Vector Kennedy I just think for the incident with the Separatist suicide-bomber droids, of course people would say he failed, because the episode tells us that they're evil, but Fox wouldn't know, and I don't think a lot of other clones would have realised, either. It was pretty funny, though.
Commander Stone had to be an exception to this, his unit of the guard were elites I think and they escorted diplomatic missions. Like the battle of Scipio, seriously you gotta love Stone after that.
Say what you want, he just did his job :(after Fives grabbed his gun he was a damger for all of them but I dont think that he killed him accidently. Sounds more like an order from Palpetine
They aren't even close to shock troopers. Coruscant guard was the bottom of the barrel. Why do you think when Anakin wiped out the jedi temple he brought the 501st instead of the garrison on coruscant? Fact is when you have competent troopers you don't put them on guard duty, just sayin.
cptTK421 No that comparison is ridiculous. This is a runaway and possibly dangerous soldier, what you're referring to is the slaughter of millions of innocents.
everyone seem to hate on fox for killing five before he told the truth but no one angry at the Jedi or clone for killing the zillo beast or Anakin killing mace windu before they kill\captured palpitine fox who was ordered to kill fives not capture
Looking at he Fives death scene logically, Fox COULD have switched his gun to stun, however was there a reason he didn’t? Maybe Palpatine gave Fox a direct order to shoot to kill. However, aside from that Fox was in a stressful position, because if he was to take the time to turn to stun he may have taken too long and one of his men could’ve been shot by the clearly cornered Fives. When someone is stressed they make mistakes, both Fox and Fives were in this position.
Well the coruscant guard is the equivalent to Military police and had such roles it isn't rocket science why they're hated so much. The fact they they have a policing role/corrections and security such as close protection and diplomatic buildings/sites is a police vibe to them and they do maintain the law and set all the other clones straight.
I love how 99% of the comments are basic insults.."he's stupid" "he killed Fives" etc, yet not only, from a law enforcement standpoint, was his shoot of Fives justified, he was a cop, and a military one at that, anyone who served unless you were an MP yourself has had one bad run in with them before yet no one cares to look at it from his perspective or the other side. As for him hunting Ahsoka, we, as the audience, had knowledge he, Fox, did not. with all the evidence in front of him, from the death of the witness to him finding his men down with Ahsoka standing over them, what else was he supposed to think? maybe if people stepped back and studied everything they'd realize what situation he was in and that Fox isn't a bad trooper
and before anyone comments about the stun mode for incapacitating fives, that move alone would have come with undue risk that would have put the lives of Fox, his men, or Captain Rex and Anakin in extreme danger. the stun mode of a blaster is much like a Taser used by modern police, it woukd cause the subject getting hit to react violently in terms of muscle movements, including balling hands into fists, because of this the chance of Fives pulling the trigger on his blaster was VERY high and if that round had hit another trooper, or Anakin or Rex, the blame would be on Fox or the trooper who fired the stun round. as for distance, if you look at the chase scene with Ahsoka the troopers we fitting from about 10-15 meters and the arc of the stun round was losing its velocity at that range, indicating a lack of charge and therefore a lack of effect. Basically, the closer you are, the better the effect, which is why they ran toward Fives instead of hitting him from afar
+TheArmyScoutSniper Actually, the only similarity stun has to tazers is that they both incapacitate the target. Tazers make the target spaz uncontrollably because it's electricity coursing through their body. Stun in SW, as seen used on Ahsoka, safely incapacitates targets & makes them unconscious.
TheArmyScoutSniper Her hands ball up from her movements beforehand. The only movement caused by stun was slight trembling at the most, which is not enough to pull the trigger of a blaster.
Vector Kennedy which depends on the style of tremors. don't forget Ahsoka is not human, Fives is. bodies react differently to different stimuli. Togrutas may be more resistant to stun than humans and this may react differently. i still hold true to the fact that a lethal shot was warranted, and justified
Great video. However, I watched the death scene of Fives again and I noticed something: Fox tried reasoning with Fives before he took the shot. *Fox before shooting Fives.* "Stand down, soldier. Stand down! Get on your knees!" *Fives reaches for blaster.* "Don't do it, soldier. Don't do it!" My guess is since the Coruscant Guard is more of a security force, they meet hostile actions with hostile actions.
Fox was given orders to kill Fives on sight, but he still tried to bring him in alive. If you want to be mad at someone for killing Fives, by mad at that Kaminoan, who drugged him to make it seem like the chip actually did control the clones aggressive behavior.
I still like Fox as much as I like all the other clones which includes Fives, Fox was just following orders, gotta remember the shock troopers don’t know that Palpatine is a Sith lord, all they know is that a clone tried to kill the chancellor, the head of the republic, obviously Fives would be put to death and Fox did tell Fives to stand down, Fox was defending himself when Fives continued to grab the gun. Lots of people seem to forget this and just hate Fox cause he killed one of everyone’s favorite clones (mine included) in a way Fox’s actions are justified from a certain point of view
Fox, Foxes are often used to represent treachery. Palpatine was treacherous. He was also a force user. Either I’m overthinking this, Palpatine used some sort of force trick to make Fox do his bidding, or Fox new all along.
This has no basis in canon? The Guard on Coruscant was used to overlap the duties of the senate guard later in the clone wars, a rapid response swat-like unit, and for diplomatic escort. They also later largely take over the positions of the Coruscant Security Force near the end of the war, becoming the predominant police force on Coruscant. As for killing Fives, Fives was listed as defective. He was acting irrationally, went AWOL - which is nearly unprecedented with clones - and was holding a general and captain hostage. From the information Fox had, it was curious that he didn't put him down on sight. Finally, why would he not chase Ahsoka? Again, with the information he had, she was the prime suspect in a murder in connection with a terrorist plot, and was framed in killing his men. In either case, he didn't have the information the audience had, and his actions were more than justifiable if you have a basic understanding of dramatic irony. This isn't why he was disliked by his brothers, because in canon, Fox is one of the most highly decorated clones in the Grand Army. This is why the Fox is disliked by the fans of the show, and little more.
I think someone said this before and It got a bunch of likes. I think he deleted the comment, probably because it's true that this vid is pure fanfiction and nothing more.
@@GimmieTheJimmie I wouldn't be surprised he clearly hates fox and the coruscant guard in general and makes up lies about them acting like they are facts all because one of them shot and killed one of his favourite character ( in a completely justifiable scenario ).
'Geetsly's' Top 5 Gaming Oh you're fine, I understand lol. I just never expected TH-cam to start advertising Scientology lol. Good video tho, Keep it up
well moneys money xcomicmuffin (on youtubes part not 'Geetsly's' Top 5 Gaming) becous i dont rly know him and he might not wanna take money from Scientology
Vector Kennedy, Most clones actually didn't want to carry out Order 66 and weren't willing to do it. They HAD to because they were literally programmed by the kaminoans to carry it out.
Palpatine ordered Commander Fox to kill Fives , as he knew about order 66 and was threatining to tell the jedi about it. Also , he only shot Fives when he had a gun out , so I' m pretty sure I' d do the same thing.
If you think about it fox is the reason for every single thing that happened if fox never killed fives . Fives would have told everyone about the inhibitor chip and arrested the chansler there would be no empire and the sith would have been destroyed and Galaxy would be saved
Actually, yes he did kill fives! But fives was going to threaten them she putting him and his clones at risk. However when Commander Fox shot Fives, as you forgot to mention, he did seem to regret it and payed his respect to Fives as he took of his helmet and showed sadness with what he did along with the other clones who stood around the unfortunate Trooper 'Fives'
Mostly your points that the clones despised commander fox and the coruscant guard for the reasons you listed and that the coruscant guard thought themselves as superior to their brothers. Ive seen literally nothing on that. Also many of the points you make are not the brightest, including where you make Fox out like an idiot for not switching to stun when a drugged up hothead was pointing a gun at him and his men. From what I've seen, many of the clones on coruscant for most of the war longed for the front line experiences of their brothers, as can be seen in characters like Clone Commander Ponds. Yes, he wasn't a member of the guard but he spent a lot of his time on the war in coruscant and its possible that his sentiments were shared by members of the guard. Also, what you said about the coruscant guard being pawns to Palpatine is also dumb, as all clones were his pawns and followed the Chancellor's orders without question, its what they were born to do. So yeah, basically all of those assumptions you seem to have made.
I don't have anything against him. He might have killed my fav clone but he told him to not take the gun but Fives reached out for it anyways so it's kinda Fives fault. But he could have just used stun.
I like Fox, Ive always liked him. Him and the C. Guard having the easiest sector in the galaxy is Bullshit. Ever heard of the battle of coruscant? Or the Zilo beast? Or have you watched the cartoon 'Clone Wars' from 2002?
Vanders Did you not watch the video? The guard always thought the clones outside of the guard were less then them (Arrogance, Egotistical). Palpatine liked them the best and it was implied in this video that they would do any order for him (probably order 66 without being forced by the chip) and (probably to advance in being favored by the Chancellor unless you can think of some other reason) and didn't care for the Jedi or the rest of the republic (traitorous and greedy)
Michael Brown Firstly, I haven't read anywhere about them thinking themselves better so I don't know where he got that from. So no arrogance or egoism. Secondly, they do what the chancellor says because he is the elected representative of the Republic unlike the Jedi who are just a monastic order within the Republic (not to mention that as far as they and the Republic know, the Jedi are traitors). So no, not traitorous. And lastly, none of what you or the video said is the definition of greed.
+Nashtheenderman ! Not that. He meant the bomb droids. Separatist Bomb droids disguised themselves as cleaning droids, but when the wrong way. Instead of being suspicious of the droids that made an obvious mistake, Fox pointed the Bomb droids to where the Power Plant was, & the droids were able to complete their mission by blowing up the plant & taking out the power. All because Fox was a negligent idiot.
+Vector Kennedy How would you know that a team of cleaning droids would turn into massive transforming, self detonating monstrosities? That makes zero sense. That's the equivalent of a janitor asking where the bathroom was, and you shoot him thinking he's a terrorist.
For those who say he was doing his job, still you don't kill your own brother. He evidently didn't care about his brothers and was so quick to follow orders from Palpatine that he forgot about the important relationship a clone should have with his clone brothers.
Than why did he want to kill ahsoka after she was standing on clone corpses? Even tho he was kind to her before that. Also fives was a mentally unstable deserter who tried to kill the chancellor.
Thorn was an actual badass compared to Fox who is sitting on his ass on the rich suburbs of Coruscant while the clone casualties are tallying up even higher by minute.
Fox did really nothing wrong. He was being used by Palpatine, and there are multiple other reasons he did nothing wrong such as (Some credit given to Blackbird Rose) Attempted assasination of Palpatine, Fives pulling a blaster on Fox and his men and some other reasons. Do not be hard on him.
You could just watch the scene of Commander Thorn dying. His armour kinda looks like Fox's. Poor Thorn. Thorn was one of the best. 'FOR THE REPUBLIC!'. - His last words.
Anthony Rodriguez He f****** killed fives who was on my favorite clones and probably one of the few that if he had survived what is said f*** no to order 66
Daniel Turpin Your point? Did you pay any attention to the situation? Fox had direct order's to kill five's from palpatine himself and he was told that five's was armed dangerous and deranged and yet fox gave five's 3 warnings to surrender up until five's pulled a gun and fox had no choice but to kill him
Daniel Turpin And what does being right have to do with anything Not only does no one(especially fox)have a single reason to believe five's Fox had literally no other options unless you think fox should have gotten himself shot by a raving mad man who is holding Anakin and rex in a ray shield and is pointing a gun at his head
![The Surprisingly Different Moral Perspectives of our Favourite Clone Commanders [Pt.3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/izB1AwId5-0/mqdefault.jpg)
You still gotta admit Thorn is probably one of the best clones
Madman107 thorn was one of the best, but he was a senate guard and went off world a lot to escort senators, so not as stuck up as fox
Madman107 I like Thorn he was a og nigga
He was CG, Senate Guard aren't clones.
Retrun 126 he was a clone and was leader of the team of guards to protect senator amidala.
Well, true but also, he led lots of soldiers of the 401st than just a team, but it is also true he is not a Senate Guard, they were not clones, they only wore relatively close armor to what a clone wears.
fox wasn't really that bad cause u forget he never wanted to be part of the guard he wishes he could be fighting on the front with his brothers but to be fair fox was told fives was defective and insane and fox gave 3 warnings after fives pulled a gun on fox and his men so fox chose his squad over what he thought was rouge insane clone who had already attempted to murder the Chancellor
still could've stunned him
JohnTheGamer he was given orders to kill Fives, but he still tried to take him in alive.
Conner Hoyt studpid ass niga
but i he was i pursuit of fives then while in pursuit he still could've put the gun on stun
Anthony Virtucio really vulgarity towards someone who just seid that fox didn't really a choice because he had a gun aimed at his head that just proves how many brain cells you have left ps u just got made to look like an idiot by a 15 year old just so u know that saying stuff like that doesn't provide a point or valid argument it just makes u look ignorant
Fox always looked like a badass, I don't hate him, I just dislike him, he may have killed Fives but he was ordered to, I hate Palpatine for that.
What about Nala?
@@CT--my4lf fuck Nala Se
nah he could’ve just stunned him
@@cassielov3 Ik I’m hella late but like shut the fuck up please, I hate when people said that I’ll list several reasons why he couldn’t use stun 1: He was most likely ordered by palpatine to kill him and if he didn’t follow those orders he’d probably get court marshal’d 2: Fox held captain red and a akin hostage 3: One of the most important ones he was accused of trying to assassinate palpatine 4: The most important one Fox warned fives not to grab the gun so did Rex 5: before he grabbed the gun fox was listening wit a brief moment and he thought fives was acting a crazy 6: Then fives grabbed the gun and aimed it at fox and his men and then fox shot him to protect himself and his men. I honestly don’t like fox is personality I love his army though I repeat I don’t like fox besides his armor and I’m no personal opinions I just think fox deserves way less hate then he deserves everything I stated is facts there is myths why he killed fives but I don’t want to get to that thanks for reading hopeful this change you view of fox at least a little bit.
@@colddezumaki1168 not you being mad lmaoo fox still trash 😘😘
I know why he was truly hated by everyone- us and the other clones. Killing Fives... :(
No, Thorn died on Scipio. It was Fox. Either way, Fives is dead, cuz Coruscant guard sucks
tbh i never really liked fives so i still really like Fox
*Alarms blaring* Warning, triggering in process
Mark Leonard gg
Jedi Archives yea he killed fives that's really why no one can stand him
so the Coruscant guard is like the Military Police in Attack on Titan
XD so true
Pariah97 pretty much yea
Pariah97 actually the corsair guards are the best of the best most Wer taken from other clone legions because they Wer so good at what they do that they were promoted to an elite rank and fox leads them so fox was a extremely high ranking clone and for a reason remember rex was a fan favorite and even he was just a Capitan. fox and Cody both outranked him so no hate for either of them from me
Or it's the Military Police period. as in, the real world.
Alex Steil I was gonna say that but you said it better
I think Fox was either stressed to shoot Fives because he grabbed a gun so for the safety of his own mans he didn't had the time to... because when your stressed you do mistakes I wouldn't mind if fox shot his the leg, but not in a fatal spot. Or Palpatine told his secret...
CommanderCodyHD how does one shoot someone's lag? I would really like to know because it would make multiplayer games so much better if you could just shoot the lag away.
Anyway, Fox was given orders to kill Fives on sight, but he still tried to bring him in alive. If you want to be mad at someone for killing Fives, by mad at that Kaminoan who drugged him to make it seem like the chip actually did control the clones aggressive behavior.
goldenhedgehog9 ur off subject mate
CommanderCodyHD + he was making fun of you
how
I ment LEG.
Few things one I read that Fox and many shock troopers were quite bored on Coruscant cause no action. I have never seen evidence of this social diffrence between coruscant gaurd and regs in well anything and lastly Fives pulled a gun on him a real life cop would've done the same.
Ikr. And were hated for being bored on Coruscant?! UGH! Also without us there crime would double and it would be pure anarchy.
I love you Fox, you're my favourite clone! ^^
I don't get why there even called shock troopers which is suppose to be an elite form of infantry charging the front lines
Paul Harrison because they are elite and shock troopers aren't infantry they are like a military swat and do the same things fox and his men do like at ziros and when bane kidnapped the Senate or all the other times they stormed into enemy territory
I'm talking real life where the name comes from was the elite German units of WW1 my point was why did the creators of starwars call them shock troopers instead of say SWAT troopers.
Thanks for watching! Leave your thoughts about Fox below
'Geetsly's' Top 5 Gaming wish croissant had more show time
'Geetsly's' Top 5 Gaming my 2st favorite clone
'Geetsly's' Top 5 Gaming fox should be executed
'Geetsly's' Top 5 Gaming Fox is fucking awesome
OLdSNIPEr K1Ng4 2st? Please don't ever reproduce
fox was cool but when he killed five I hated him
I disliked Fox all along, but that's just me :/
He did have cool armor, but I hated him after that too
'Geetsly's' Top 5 Gaming I can't blame you lol but I think the only reason why I did like him is that he look really cool in phase 2
They did have cool armor, I'll give you that
Marcelo Molina he didn't kill him it was thorn
2:15 He was probably ordered by Palpatine.
Company007 I agree because if fives was alive then the Jedi and most clones would know palpatine was a Sith Lord.Then Palpatine would get rEkT by everyone.
Exactly what I thought, no clone is stupid enough to forget to put his gun on stun. In saying that fox did let in suicide droids in the Coruscant power station so...
'Geetsly's' Top 5 Gaming He probably would have shot Fives even if he didn't grab a gun.
Company007 very much agreed has he was just an over all dick
They were very good disguised
So Fox and the Coruscant Guard are hated by the other Clone Troopers for being parade ground soldiers with a cushy assignment? That makes sense.
ryan macdonald hes hated by fans by killing fives in season 6
Am I the only one who actually kind of likes Fox? His armor looks damn nice.
He's one of my favorites, even after fives. He was just doing his duty.
He also not only let separatist sabotage droids through security, but also gave them direction to the power plant. Granted, this is just sucking at his (ONE) job rather than being a jerk, but still...
Silvercrusher it's alright
Revan498 yea
Silvercrusher yea
Fox was a good clone trooper, all in all, and I don't see why a lot of people hate him, other than the fact that he killed Fives.
CT_21_0408 YT because fives knew that Palpatine was a Sith Lord
Ethan Steffek I meant other than the fact he killed Fives. I only remember him only failing at his job once. I mean, if he didn't kill Fives, then I think Fox is a perfectly fine, if not, great, clone trooper.
+CT_21_0408 YT
He failed his job multiple times. While every clone was trying to stun Ahsoka when she was accused of bombing the Jedi Temple, Fox used lethal force. When Separatist bomb droids attempted to bomb the generator room, Fox didn't see how suspicious they were, & even TOLD them where to go. Then the whole Fives incident happened.
Vector Kennedy I just think for the incident with the Separatist suicide-bomber droids, of course people would say he failed, because the episode tells us that they're evil, but Fox wouldn't know, and I don't think a lot of other clones would have realised, either. It was pretty funny, though.
CT_21_0408 YT the droids, had they been authentic, would have been programmed to go the right way.
Commander Stone had to be an exception to this, his unit of the guard were elites I think and they escorted diplomatic missions. Like the battle of Scipio, seriously you gotta love Stone after that.
Elites?
WORT WORT WORT
FACE PALM**
That was actually Commander Thorn on Scipio, but yeah, mad respect to him, and Stone.
@Andrew Gidilla only true gamers will get that
I love Fox. His 2008 Lego figure is a prime piece of my collection.
I used to have that one.
Now the Coruscant Guard are my favorite Clonetroopers. I really like Commander Fox now. Thanks for this new info to me.
BECAUSE THAT JERK KILLED FIVES! In other news great video
Kirsten Øgaard Thorn was dead before that.
NOPE IT WAS THORN! *Puts up a poster saying Fives lives matter and runs*
Commander Fox How dare you,YOU have no honor for the troop that got an epic last stand???????
Dominic Garcia umm not really u know if he hadn't removed the inhibitor chip he would have probably helped kill the Jedi so yea
+Commander Fox (Commander Fox) #ClonesLivesMatter
Say what you want, he just did his job :(after Fives grabbed his gun he was a damger for all of them but I dont think that he killed him accidently. Sounds more like an order from Palpetine
I mean to be fair.....he did tell fives to stand down and only shot him when fives tried to grab a gun.
Christopher Salinas020509 Doesn't exactly immobilize 100% of the time. Fives was in the wrong.
YipYipAnimation No he wasnt
Anakin Vader Yes he was lmao. How stupid do you have to be to pull a gun on a group of shock troopers
they have a stun setting for a reason
They aren't even close to shock troopers. Coruscant guard was the bottom of the barrel. Why do you think when Anakin wiped out the jedi temple he brought the 501st instead of the garrison on coruscant? Fact is when you have competent troopers you don't put them on guard duty, just sayin.
Never had a problem with him personally. He just followed orders.
People just get too emotional.
^ What he said. Was just doing his job.
He vaz juzt following orderz.
cptTK421 No that comparison is ridiculous. This is a runaway and possibly dangerous soldier, what you're referring to is the slaughter of millions of innocents.
He could've set for stun... Fives was so close too exposing the truth.
everyone seem to hate on fox for killing five before he told the truth but no one angry at the Jedi or clone for killing the zillo beast or Anakin killing mace windu before they kill\captured palpitine fox who was ordered to kill fives not capture
Looking at he Fives death scene logically, Fox COULD have switched his gun to stun, however was there a reason he didn’t? Maybe Palpatine gave Fox a direct order to shoot to kill. However, aside from that Fox was in a stressful position, because if he was to take the time to turn to stun he may have taken too long and one of his men could’ve been shot by the clearly cornered Fives. When someone is stressed they make mistakes, both Fox and Fives were in this position.
Well the coruscant guard is the equivalent to Military police and had such roles it isn't rocket science why they're hated so much. The fact they they have a policing role/corrections and security such as close protection and diplomatic buildings/sites is a police vibe to them and they do maintain the law and set all the other clones straight.
I love how 99% of the comments are basic insults.."he's stupid" "he killed Fives" etc, yet not only, from a law enforcement standpoint, was his shoot of Fives justified, he was a cop, and a military one at that, anyone who served unless you were an MP yourself has had one bad run in with them before yet no one cares to look at it from his perspective or the other side. As for him hunting Ahsoka, we, as the audience, had knowledge he, Fox, did not. with all the evidence in front of him, from the death of the witness to him finding his men down with Ahsoka standing over them, what else was he supposed to think? maybe if people stepped back and studied everything they'd realize what situation he was in and that Fox isn't a bad trooper
and before anyone comments about the stun mode for incapacitating fives, that move alone would have come with undue risk that would have put the lives of Fox, his men, or Captain Rex and Anakin in extreme danger. the stun mode of a blaster is much like a Taser used by modern police, it woukd cause the subject getting hit to react violently in terms of muscle movements, including balling hands into fists, because of this the chance of Fives pulling the trigger on his blaster was VERY high and if that round had hit another trooper, or Anakin or Rex, the blame would be on Fox or the trooper who fired the stun round. as for distance, if you look at the chase scene with Ahsoka the troopers we fitting from about 10-15 meters and the arc of the stun round was losing its velocity at that range, indicating a lack of charge and therefore a lack of effect. Basically, the closer you are, the better the effect, which is why they ran toward Fives instead of hitting him from afar
+TheArmyScoutSniper
Actually, the only similarity stun has to tazers is that they both incapacitate the target. Tazers make the target spaz uncontrollably because it's electricity coursing through their body. Stun in SW, as seen used on Ahsoka, safely incapacitates targets & makes them unconscious.
Vector Kennedy watch her hands, same with others that were stunned, you see their fists clench or hands jerk..that's the key
TheArmyScoutSniper
Her hands ball up from her movements beforehand. The only movement caused by stun was slight trembling at the most, which is not enough to pull the trigger of a blaster.
Vector Kennedy which depends on the style of tremors. don't forget Ahsoka is not human, Fives is. bodies react differently to different stimuli. Togrutas may be more resistant to stun than humans and this may react differently. i still hold true to the fact that a lethal shot was warranted, and justified
Great video. However, I watched the death scene of Fives again and I noticed something: Fox tried reasoning with Fives before he took the shot.
*Fox before shooting Fives.*
"Stand down, soldier. Stand down! Get on your knees!"
*Fives reaches for blaster.*
"Don't do it, soldier. Don't do it!"
My guess is since the Coruscant Guard is more of a security force, they meet hostile actions with hostile actions.
I actually loved Commander Fox, he's badass
Commander Fox is my favorite Clone Commander...
If you asked Fox to "Give me five"
He'd break down in tears and try to kill himself for his actions
I found fox always to be my fav commander
no
same
I like his armor that's all I like about him
I accidentally turned on captions, and instead of coruscant guard, It was curse on God. gg.
O.o
iSpecialties / CC-4372 The Caption is ass fuck you TH-cam get your shit straight
Stephen Kline on roblox 666
For me it says croissant god
lmao same
Fox was given orders to kill Fives on sight, but he still tried to bring him in alive. If you want to be mad at someone for killing Fives, by mad at that Kaminoan, who drugged him to make it seem like the chip actually did control the clones aggressive behavior.
I still like Fox as much as I like all the other clones which includes Fives, Fox was just following orders, gotta remember the shock troopers don’t know that Palpatine is a Sith lord, all they know is that a clone tried to kill the chancellor, the head of the republic, obviously Fives would be put to death and Fox did tell Fives to stand down, Fox was defending himself when Fives continued to grab the gun. Lots of people seem to forget this and just hate Fox cause he killed one of everyone’s favorite clones (mine included) in a way Fox’s actions are justified from a certain point of view
I love Fox because he looks so dope as a Gen I clone. He just looked nearly identical when wearing Gen II armor.
Fox, Foxes are often used to represent treachery. Palpatine was treacherous. He was also a force user.
Either I’m overthinking this, Palpatine used some sort of force trick to make Fox do his bidding, or Fox new all along.
So the Coruscant Guard were basically the Star Wars version of the Ultramarines from Warhammer 40k, super loyal and by the book.
Ultrasmurfs*
NinjaOtter bruh come on at least the Smurfs held back the Nids
kingmark210 A fan of If the Emperor had Text To Speech I see
Fuck you no. The Coruscant Guard are more like the Imperial Fists chapter.
@@centurionnicolaum8588 ooooooo someones salty
But I liked Fox...
He was the only clone other than Rex and Cody that I remember getting a name in the movie.
Rex wasn’t in the movies, neither were Fox.
@@CC-1004Gree The Clone Wars movie, dude
No matter how much hate he gets, we can all agree on one thing
His armor looks sick
Commander Fox was my first Star Wars the Clone Wars action figure. Still one of my favourites.
I had no problem with him. He was just doing his job
no
Yes sir
@@cassielov3 well yes. He was always just doing his job.
This has no basis in canon? The Guard on Coruscant was used to overlap the duties of the senate guard later in the clone wars, a rapid response swat-like unit, and for diplomatic escort. They also later largely take over the positions of the Coruscant Security Force near the end of the war, becoming the predominant police force on Coruscant. As for killing Fives, Fives was listed as defective. He was acting irrationally, went AWOL - which is nearly unprecedented with clones - and was holding a general and captain hostage. From the information Fox had, it was curious that he didn't put him down on sight. Finally, why would he not chase Ahsoka? Again, with the information he had, she was the prime suspect in a murder in connection with a terrorist plot, and was framed in killing his men. In either case, he didn't have the information the audience had, and his actions were more than justifiable if you have a basic understanding of dramatic irony. This isn't why he was disliked by his brothers, because in canon, Fox is one of the most highly decorated clones in the Grand Army. This is why the Fox is disliked by the fans of the show, and little more.
I think someone said this before and It got a bunch of likes. I think he deleted the comment, probably because it's true that this vid is pure fanfiction and nothing more.
@@GimmieTheJimmie I wouldn't be surprised he clearly hates fox and the coruscant guard in general and makes up lies about them acting like they are facts all because one of them shot and killed one of his favourite character ( in a completely justifiable scenario ).
Ever since I saw the episode I wanted to know this.
WHY. IS. THERE. A. SCIENTOLOGY. AD. WHY
Wait what? I thought the ads on my channel were all related to games and Star wars. Sorry dude, this one's on youtube.
'Geetsly's' Top 5 Gaming Oh you're fine, I understand lol. I just never expected TH-cam to start advertising Scientology lol. Good video tho, Keep it up
well moneys money xcomicmuffin (on youtubes part not 'Geetsly's' Top 5 Gaming) becous i dont rly know him and he might not wanna take money from Scientology
Why no adblock?
The only Coruscant Guard that I respect is Commander Thorn and his men.
truth
For the Republic!
Dark Gamer and Stone, Deviss and Thire.
Was Thorn not the one who shot Fives? It definitely wasn't Fox.
James Love I’m not sure if your joking or not but anyway no Thorn was killed off planet but it was Fox who killed 5’s
I used to role playing with my friends when I was a little bit younger, I was always Fox :( I miss those days
Holy shit! A clone willing to kill a jedi??!! That's Nuts!!!
Yeah. Totally whack. Not like there was an Order 66 or anything.
Vector Kennedy,
Most clones actually didn't want to carry out Order 66 and weren't willing to do it. They HAD to because they were literally programmed by the kaminoans to carry it out.
Damien I did kinda like that version better.
Captain Thorne even though his time was short, is one of the best ways a clone has died with honor
Fives death made me want to die and cry.
Thorn along with his brethren that died defending Coruscant are the only Coruscant guards that I respect.
wait isnt that Commander Thorn? 2:47 or was Thorn and Fox same clone...
still great video!!
Oh yes, my mistake! That was Thorn. Definitely not the same clone. Thorn was actually cool compared to Fox
It wasnt Thorn actually Thorn has a Z6 and two wings on his helmet while Fox is almost all red and uses a pistol
Darth Vader Nope,it's Fox.
well now you shuld make a video about commander Thorn
You guys had right it was fox after some reserch my bad...
I cried when Fives died. Saddest scene ever seen on a screen
Ooh, now do one on Alpha from the original Dark Horse Clone Wars comic series.
Palpatine ordered Commander Fox to kill Fives , as he knew about order 66 and was threatining to tell the jedi about it. Also , he only shot Fives when he had a gun out , so I' m pretty sure I' d do the same thing.
Sometimes I wish Thorn survived.
After he killed fives Jesse and Kix beat the crap out of him as the other clones watched and cheered
But we all love commander thorn
I loved fox right until he killed fives but I still refused to believe it was fox until I couldn’t deny it anymore
I think Fox killed Fives because the emperor found out that Fives knew about order 66. What do you guys think?
thats exactly what happened
Zombieslayer 115 Yeah
Zombieslayer 115 the same
Palpatine told him about Order 66, if you watch the scene where Fives is brought to Palpatine you'll see
I really like Fox from the first time I saw him and to the end of the clone wars. And no matter what he'll always be my favorite clone commander.
Would commander thorn and lieutenant hound be considered to be corusant guard or just shock troopers?
Evan Helms I think shock troopers because they actually went out into the battle field
shock trooper = coruscant guard.....its the same
Fox kicked ass. He shot fives to save his other men.
I like fox. yes, he killed fives, but I still like him.
If you think about it fox is the reason for every single thing that happened if fox never killed fives . Fives would have told everyone about the inhibitor chip and arrested the chansler there would be no empire and the sith would have been destroyed and Galaxy would be saved
I love fox even though he killed 5s even though im not sayign 5s is a bad character i likes him to but Fox was my favorite clone :D
Project Breakthrough I guess you like a bitch ass nigga
Tuna stfu I eat your kind for breakfast.
+Commander Fox (Commander Fox)
And you point Separatist Bomb droids to where the power plant is.
Vector Kennedy how would he been able tell alot of droid make mistake
I knew it fox had the chance to stun fives!
What was the name of the clone who had commander Fox's job before he died on corasant (not spelled right srry)
I think it's spelled Coruscant
It was Commander Thorn
SwedishDINO Gaming
Was that the guy who got ambushed with his unit on that banker planet or whatever planet it was.
I'm sure Fox either had the job before him, or they were both commanders simultaneously.
Captain Thorn* Thorn led the 401st before Fox took over
Actually, yes he did kill fives! But fives was going to threaten them she putting him and his clones at risk. However when Commander Fox shot Fives, as you forgot to mention, he did seem to regret it and payed his respect to Fives as he took of his helmet and showed sadness with what he did along with the other clones who stood around the unfortunate Trooper 'Fives'
Double upload? Thanks
Dominic Garcia hey whats up guys its scarce here, today we have another double upload
I would've loved to see the battle of Courscant (ground assault) in the clone wars show it would've been awesome
he was basically ss if the republic was the 3rd reich
SpetsnazHunter true.
Ya know, I hope fox for some reason when the empire started got demoted to sanitary
I guess I'm in the minority that actually liked Fox.
Same
The actual, real cause for Order 66. Thanks a lot. Also Fives is the best clone there is. He killed him. Also Thank you.
This is like pure fanfiction, try harder next time.
You can't present fanfiction as fact lol there is like nothing that supports all of this
Unfortunately for you, there is. Please take the time to read about and watch videos about Commander Fox.
I have many times and I didn't see anything like this, so could you tell me where you got this information from? Thanks
If you tell me what you don't believe is valid in this video, I'll be happy to answer you
Mostly your points that the clones despised commander fox and the coruscant guard for the reasons you listed and that the coruscant guard thought themselves as superior to their brothers. Ive seen literally nothing on that. Also many of the points you make are not the brightest, including where you make Fox out like an idiot for not switching to stun when a drugged up hothead was pointing a gun at him and his men. From what I've seen, many of the clones on coruscant for most of the war longed for the front line experiences of their brothers, as can be seen in characters like Clone Commander Ponds. Yes, he wasn't a member of the guard but he spent a lot of his time on the war in coruscant and its possible that his sentiments were shared by members of the guard. Also, what you said about the coruscant guard being pawns to Palpatine is also dumb, as all clones were his pawns and followed the Chancellor's orders without question, its what they were born to do. So yeah, basically all of those assumptions you seem to have made.
I don't have anything against him. He might have killed my fav clone but he told him to not take the gun but Fives reached out for it anyways so it's kinda Fives fault. But he could have just used stun.
Basically similar to military police in Attack on Titan.
Quang Anh Vu or real life
Quang Anh Vu Or MP in well you know... real life?
I like Coruscant Guard armor,but idk why i hate commander Fox,maybe becuze he is killing Fives(501st Hero)
Yeah, once he killed Fives I lost a lot of respect for Fox.
I like Fox, Ive always liked him. Him and the C. Guard having the easiest sector in the galaxy is Bullshit. Ever heard of the battle of coruscant? Or the Zilo beast? Or have you watched the cartoon 'Clone Wars' from 2002?
Fox is still my favorite clone ever
He is a egotistical greedy unethical arrogant traitorous piece of shit...
He never displayed any of those except maybe being unethical.
Vanders Did you not watch the video? The guard always thought the clones outside of the guard were less then them (Arrogance, Egotistical). Palpatine liked them the best and it was implied in this video that they would do any order for him (probably order 66 without being forced by the chip) and (probably to advance in being favored by the Chancellor unless you can think of some other reason) and didn't care for the Jedi or the rest of the republic (traitorous and greedy)
Michael Brown Firstly, I haven't read anywhere about them thinking themselves better so I don't know where he got that from. So no arrogance or egoism. Secondly, they do what the chancellor says because he is the elected representative of the Republic unlike the Jedi who are just a monastic order within the Republic (not to mention that as far as they and the Republic know, the Jedi are traitors). So no, not traitorous. And lastly, none of what you or the video said is the definition of greed.
Vanders So you think then this video has some biased made up assumptions?
Didn't Rex tell them stun for Fives or was that Asoka
Wouldn't they also hate Fox when he failed to stop the terrorist attack on the power station, just felt like pointing that out.
it's not his fault that Cade Bane placed bombs in the room with the senators and Anakin Skywalker
+Nashtheenderman !
Not that. He meant the bomb droids. Separatist Bomb droids disguised themselves as cleaning droids, but when the wrong way. Instead of being suspicious of the droids that made an obvious mistake, Fox pointed the Bomb droids to where the Power Plant was, & the droids were able to complete their mission by blowing up the plant & taking out the power. All because Fox was a negligent idiot.
Vector Kennedy The Clone Wars would have ended right then and there if Fox was just a little smarter.
Filip Holm
Yup. Tells you how useful Fox is. I wish Thorn was still alive at that time. If it were him, he would've never fucked up.
+Vector Kennedy How would you know that a team of cleaning droids would turn into massive transforming, self detonating monstrosities? That makes zero sense. That's the equivalent of a janitor asking where the bathroom was, and you shoot him thinking he's a terrorist.
Fox is actually my favorite, especially in the clone wars movie in the early 2000s (when Grievous was portrayed best)
I hate Fox because he shot Fives
THATS NOT THE POINT
Exactly
Clash Mine bro Studios why all the vulgarity dude it makes no difference it just makes you look ignorant
Nerf Boy Matt I hate you also.
Alright why didn't you have STUN mode on
I understand the hate, but I think he panicked when fives pulled the blaster because he had to worry about all the men behind him.
For those who say he was doing his job, still you don't kill your own brother. He evidently didn't care about his brothers and was so quick to follow orders from Palpatine that he forgot about the important relationship a clone should have with his clone brothers.
Than why did he want to kill ahsoka after she was standing on clone corpses? Even tho he was kind to her before that. Also fives was a mentally unstable deserter who tried to kill the chancellor.
I like commander fox. but I like all the shock troopers. mostly for their armor
I still like Fox
Thorn was an actual badass compared to Fox who is sitting on his ass on the rich suburbs of Coruscant while the clone casualties are tallying up even higher by minute.
I never knew this
Fox did really nothing wrong. He was being used by Palpatine, and there are multiple other reasons he did nothing wrong such as (Some credit given to Blackbird Rose) Attempted assasination of Palpatine, Fives pulling a blaster on Fox and his men and some other reasons. Do not be hard on him.
Commander Thorn is better.
I'm pretty sure I am better
you are better
Darnit Fox!!! if he had not shot fives, order 66 would have never happened!
I love fox, always have
Perhaps we should sentence Fox to an eternity to listening to Slippy from Star Fox for killing Fives? XD
Still waiting for an animation of fox dying
Nikolas Hipolito how was he the best if he had the easiest job
You could just watch the scene of Commander Thorn dying. His armour kinda looks like Fox's. Poor Thorn. Thorn was one of the best. 'FOR THE REPUBLIC!'. - His last words.
+Nikolas Hipolito Hey, dude, fuck you.
We know that but fox is shit that's why he's in the police force
+Nikolas Hipolito Ha ha ha ha ha, please stop being stupid
Put sub titles on cuz I had no headphones and the 'curse of God' is the coruscant guard
I would love their to be a comic where Fox is killed.
Daniel Turpin why?
Anthony Rodriguez He f****** killed fives who was on my favorite clones and probably one of the few that if he had survived what is said f*** no to order 66
Daniel Turpin
Your point?
Did you pay any attention to the situation?
Fox had direct order's to kill five's from palpatine himself and he was told that five's was armed dangerous and deranged and yet fox gave five's 3 warnings to surrender up until five's pulled a gun and fox had no choice but to kill him
Anthony Rodriguez he might have been arranged but he was 100% right
Daniel Turpin
And what does being right have to do with anything
Not only does no one(especially fox)have a single reason to believe five's
Fox had literally no other options unless you think fox should have gotten himself shot by a raving mad man who is holding Anakin and rex in a ray shield and is pointing a gun at his head
0:44 what's the difference?
Lets not forget how he not only let sabatoge droids through security, but also gave them direction to the power plant.
the title should have been "Why Commander Fox is the most hated character in the entire Star Wars universe"