This is a crisis I knew had to come, destroying the balance I'd kept. Unsettling and doubting and turning around, wondering what will come next. Is this the role that you wanted to live? I was foolish to ask for so much. ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
I dont think its tweaked. I m pretty sure i had this version on tape 30 years ago, and it sounded exactly the same. Very raw recording. I think it was recorded during a concert at 'The Apollo'. All the other songs had that same raw low-paced sound.
To think that Ian’s biggest fear about touring the USA was people mocking him for how he danced. ❤️❤️ sadly he did not get to see how wrong he was. If we had known about the KETO diet back then he would probably be here today .
I don't think Americans could ever really get Joy Division. I can get exactly why Ian freaked at the idea of touring the US and it's why I abandoned touring when I worked in the music industry.
@@PurityVendetta Americans weren’t given a chance to get to know them as they never toured here. They were pre-MTV and music videos were just beginning to become a thing. I knew who they were and loved them ❤️
@@yathome5596 So.... you actually believe you can make an assumption based on what? Your in depth knowledge of british culture and living in the hopeless shitholes of the north of england? No, youo making assumptions about someone you never knew living in a place that you've never been to. This is why I don't make assumptions about am rock bands or country and western 😉 Oh, and the keto diet is just unhealthy quack twaddle. Snake oil for the gullible.
Joy Division, the greatest band of all time. Far better than the weakest band of all time, Nirvana which had nothing to offer to music. Here on this live version, and let's be honest, there's not the polishing of what was done in the studio in which case the studio versions for nearly everything Joy Division put out, ever, is far superior because it was so way above its time, and still is, the lyrics, changed, are much better, leaving a much more decisive blow and make more sense in unison with each refrain than what the studio version was.
now I wasn’t around in the early 90s, so (assuming u maybe were?) they were probably everywhere at that time, so I can see being turned off from them bc of that
@@rgil1998 I was there at the height of the worst genre of all time, namely grunge, in Seattle from 91 to 92 going to college to witness all of it. The absolute crap that Nirvana was, the worst band of all time, without question for anybody who respects and cares about music in which case Nirvana didn't have any respect for music, and what is the second worst band of all time Pearl Jam is still having trouble playing quarter notes and singing within a 3-note range and thus have to yelp beyond it. Nirvana plagiarized at least 6 times. One of them was a lawsuit and that song was plagiarized twice. There was clearly no passion within Nirvana because after all, how could there be within anyone who in Kurt's words was "bored" and "faking it"? Grunge died faster than any other genre except for disco and rightly so. There was no place for it to grow because it was all the same idea loud soft and or soft loud. Any audience gets bored super quick unless there's an outlet for change in which case there was none for grunge. I'm turned off by anyone that doesn't respect music as far as those who are musicians and those who bite into the commercialism popularity issue because that never makes a band or artist good or even great. It usually, though not all the time as there are those who love what they are doing and many have been around for decades and are scarcely noticed, ruins a band or artist because it gets to their heads and not the music which should always come first. Indeed, I have listened to Nirvana, grunge, etc. How could one not in being in Seattle as it was part of the Seattle scene from 91 to 92? So much so that anyone's ears would bleed due to so much repetitiveness of the same old tired simpleton 3-chord twangs. However, there was one helluva lot more going on than grunge as far as the music at that time in Seattle. I've been extremely lucky. Because I lived in Seattle, while I was there I've gotten to see almost every single band and artist I've ever cared to see. A couple more things that have got to be said and please think about this, Nirvana would never be remembered unless Kurt committed suicide. People wonder why anybody could do such a thing and they become entrapped in someone else's depression just as I still am with Joy Division. But Joy Division hid nothing, they were not fake and they did change the face of music in a huge monumental way and so did New Order. Had Kurt survived, he would have gotten out of the music business and "faded away" according to him. Also, every now and then to keep Nirvana's memory alive critics keep bringing them up for whatever reason, many getting it wrong, and once again publicizing them, which was the very last thing Kurt wanted. Is it any blunder why he committed suicide? Yeah, having a lawsuit filed against you for obvious plagiarizing surely contributed. Also, isn't it strange that what was Nirvana's audience generally speaking doesn't keep Nirvana's memory alive? In other words, people grow up, move on, and change.
check out my other youtube channel!! th-cam.com/channels/Gi3zCSF9Lssl5MFd83k3eg.html
link imagen
Incrivela
Another masterpiece by a tortured genius archetype
For all of you youngsters who weren't there? Welcome to Manchester. This sound is what it felt like.
Plenty of places left today that probably aren't far off either.. maybe not in Manchester but nearby.
That guitar pumps shockwaves through me.
Music way ahead of its time in the late 70’s. An inkling of what was to come!
This version is my favourite
Absolutely
Hard & dark.
So beautyfull...Ian, you didn't have anyone at your level...Thankyou for your existence...
My favorite Joy División song.............. greetings of Perú....
Reminds me of the song Dust or Addition by Ataxia.
the guitar melts!
god i have never heard joy division like this
legend
This is a crisis I knew had to come, destroying the balance I'd kept.
Unsettling and doubting and turning around, wondering what will come next.
Is this the role that you wanted to live? I was foolish to ask for so much.
⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
happy passover
Rock Poetry at it's best, sound Ian
Watching the reel as it comes to a close, brutally taking its time.
the lyrics on JD songs were superb
Sounds very good 👍🏼 great stuff from joy division
Back to this masterpiece.. love it
Hey who is that in your profile photograph
(inside the little circle yanno)
my 2nd great grand@@rgil1998
@@rgil1998
th-cam.com/video/uDhh_t5UMNA/w-d-xo.htmlsi=cqqgNtHToJbeA9pk
It's my 2nd Great Grandfather lol around 1860
@@rgil1998
This is life blood
best version lmao
Great band
Closer,in the pinnacle of albums.
Hollow but so beautiful
Добрая музыка !
Chingona!!
thank you!
Some knobs have to have been turned on this bootleg .. nothing sounds like this. Great version 🤘
this is also slowed down a bit which really adds to it
@@daviddockery8962 definitely makes it
I dont think its tweaked. I m pretty sure i had this version on tape 30 years ago, and it sounded exactly the same. Very raw recording. I think it was recorded during a concert at 'The Apollo'. All the other songs had that same raw low-paced sound.
@@rapho8539 I've got to get looking now thank you
@@vannjunkin8041 My ferro tape is long gone. Should have made a backup but copy-paste was not as trivial as now.
Dark af!
..and beautiful 🖤🖤
Thanks for sharing.
There is music this tipe that tipe and original tipe like Joy division of course n1 Atmosfere n2 New dawn fades n3 Insight n4 transmission
Muito top incrivel
Recorded exactly five months before Ian died.
Wow really? I had wondered how close it was to his passing.
JA ARTUR PĘPEK JESTEM TWÓRCĄ ,AUTOREM I WYKONAWCĄ TEJ MUZYKI .1971 -3 - ZAŚWIAT .TO TRZECIA WERSJA .
A ma Pan dowód?
wow
It's been slowed down
WOW
Help! It is not version from Les Bains Douches album! Where is it from?
A very best of moment of noisy music...
From where is the photo?
To think that Ian’s biggest fear about touring the USA was people mocking him for how he danced. ❤️❤️ sadly he did not get to see how wrong he was. If we had known about the KETO diet back then he would probably be here today .
I don't think Americans could ever really get Joy Division. I can get exactly why Ian freaked at the idea of touring the US and it's why I abandoned touring when I worked in the music industry.
@@PurityVendetta Americans weren’t given a chance to get to know them as they never toured here. They were pre-MTV and music videos were just beginning to become a thing. I knew who they were and loved them ❤️
@@yathome5596 So.... you actually believe you can make an assumption based on what? Your in depth knowledge of british culture and living in the hopeless shitholes of the north of england? No, youo making assumptions about someone you never knew living in a place that you've never been to.
This is why I don't make assumptions about am rock bands or country and western 😉
Oh, and the keto diet is just unhealthy quack twaddle. Snake oil for the gullible.
🔫🔫🔫
Lol what the fuck...
is this of the death album
🙂
It is not Ian's voice. It is in slow motion
That sounds like Ian with some effects added
🤪🤪🤪musica original!!
Uuuuu Nice skull
its okay
Demoniak sound....they kill him at the end
Vrdd
Since as Fk.
A dark art.
C ~ 15 01 24
Joy Division, the greatest band of all time. Far better than the weakest band of all time, Nirvana which had nothing to offer to music. Here on this live version, and let's be honest, there's not the polishing of what was done in the studio in which case the studio versions for nearly everything Joy Division put out, ever, is far superior because it was so way above its time, and still is, the lyrics, changed, are much better, leaving a much more decisive blow and make more sense in unison with each refrain than what the studio version was.
(we all have different tastes ofc, maybe theyre just not for u and thats ok) but I think u should give nirvana another chance sometime
now I wasn’t around in the early 90s, so (assuming u maybe were?) they were probably everywhere at that time, so I can see being turned off from them bc of that
but just…u should listen to in utero front to back one day imo, judging from what u were saying too about this song…I think u might like it
@@rgil1998 I was there at the height of the worst genre of all time, namely grunge, in Seattle from 91 to 92 going to college to witness all of it. The absolute crap that Nirvana was, the worst band of all time, without question for anybody who respects and cares about music in which case Nirvana didn't have any respect for music, and what is the second worst band of all time Pearl Jam is still having trouble playing quarter notes and singing within a 3-note range and thus have to yelp beyond it. Nirvana plagiarized at least 6 times. One of them was a lawsuit and that song was plagiarized twice. There was clearly no passion within Nirvana because after all, how could there be within anyone who in Kurt's words was "bored" and "faking it"? Grunge died faster than any other genre except for disco and rightly so. There was no place for it to grow because it was all the same idea loud soft and or soft loud. Any audience gets bored super quick unless there's an outlet for change in which case there was none for grunge.
I'm turned off by anyone that doesn't respect music as far as those who are musicians and those who bite into the commercialism popularity issue because that never makes a band or artist good or even great. It usually, though not all the time as there are those who love what they are doing and many have been around for decades and are scarcely noticed, ruins a band or artist because it gets to their heads and not the music which should always come first.
Indeed, I have listened to Nirvana, grunge, etc. How could one not in being in Seattle as it was part of the Seattle scene from 91 to 92? So much so that anyone's ears would bleed due to so much repetitiveness of the same old tired simpleton 3-chord twangs. However, there was one helluva lot more going on than grunge as far as the music at that time in Seattle. I've been extremely lucky. Because I lived in Seattle, while I was there I've gotten to see almost every single band and artist I've ever cared to see.
A couple more things that have got to be said and please think about this, Nirvana would never be remembered unless Kurt committed suicide. People wonder why anybody could do such a thing and they become entrapped in someone else's depression just as I still am with Joy Division. But Joy Division hid nothing, they were not fake and they did change the face of music in a huge monumental way and so did New Order. Had Kurt survived, he would have gotten out of the music business and "faded away" according to him. Also, every now and then to keep Nirvana's memory alive critics keep bringing them up for whatever reason, many getting it wrong, and once again publicizing them, which was the very last thing Kurt wanted. Is it any blunder why he committed suicide? Yeah, having a lawsuit filed against you for obvious plagiarizing surely contributed. Also, isn't it strange that what was Nirvana's audience generally speaking doesn't keep Nirvana's memory alive? In other words, people grow up, move on, and change.
@@enterthesubconscious8731 o
what they actually sounded like
Original is better.