Kangoo vs Berlingo: Which would you choose?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 มี.ค. 2023
- A Renault Kangoo 1.5Dci takes on a Citroen Berlingo M59 1.6 petrol in this battle of the cars that were vans. Which of these practical Euro wagons would you pick?
Video sponsored by Bidding Classics, the Online Marketplace. More here! bit.ly/BiddingClassicsHubNut
Kangoo provided by fullgrown.co.uk - well worth checking out! They grow furniture!
Delightful HubNut goodies can be purchased at hubnut.org
Or, support HubNut at / hubnut or via Channel memberships: / @hubnut
Want to help Hubnut for free? Don't forget to like the video if you like it, and share with your friends if you really like it! Thank you all. - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Classic Hubnut: informed; entertaining; insightful; relevant. Thank you Ian.
Silly bugger
This is also my opinion. That's why I like Ian's videos so much.
This is the kind of stuff we come to HubNut for - joint test of two out of production slightly shabby vans with windows lol
I was thinking surely 5 sunroofs means more chance of leaking, then you opened the rear seat storage 'tank'
Nice one Ian. I must confess I miss some of the simplicity of some cars, These days everything is electronic and probably controlled by some silicon brain. I'm leaning to a van based car as a future consideration for both practicality and maintenance. With all the modern gadgetry including cameras and sensors etc I think we are becoming a tad reliant on them and loosing our skills to do simple things like parking a car. Many thanks for sharing.
Am looking forward to watching this. But before doing that, I'll say Berlingo! We have a 2016 Kangoo with very little mileage (inherited from a late relative about 18 months ago). We should be grateful to have it, but I find it so uncomfortable. Especially riding in the back. Rear seat is hard and so is the suspension - you get thrown about. Rubbish for long trips - up to now the longest trip we've done has been to the Normandy coast, from the south of Paris. That was enough to make me feel that I wouldn't want us to do a longer jaunt. We had use of a 2004 Berlingo about 10 years ago for holidays. It was excellent in comparison.
Not much between either of these, but I'd have the Kangoo as, for me, the dashboard garden edges it.
For me it's a Fiat Doblo (without seeing the video). Such a nice and industrial looking thing, pls do a review!
Cool road test à la française. When I need a transporter, I know now what to choose. Thanks, Ian! 🇫🇷🚗🇫🇷
The ceiling storage in the Kangoo is like the overhead lockers on a plane 😂
The berlingo is clearly better. It has an integrated footbath.
I like the external look of the Mk I kangoo. The interior and doorhandles are also more my style
Looks so spacious inside the Berlingo, looks much larger than you’d expect.
Perfect concise relevant points for anybody wanting to own one of these excellent practical vehicles
I've been eagerly anticipating your review of a Kangoo, seeing how it compares to your Berlingo, but I didn't expect a bonus comparison to yet another but newer petrol Berlingo.
Another great video. Who knew that watching someone review average, old, often bland, often partially broken cars could be so enjoyable 🤘🏼
Absolutely brilliant video Ian ❤️ 👍 it's difficult which to go for both great vans brilliant
Oh I really want to pick the Kangoo for sentimental reasons because wifey had a van version few years back and I loved it. It too was a 1.5dCi and was a little flying machine! However, out of those two I'd have to go for the Berlingo, as that particular example is so much more well appointed than the Kangoo. I also think the petrol engine was more willing than the usually excellent dCi.
As a quick aside, the second rear-view mirror in the Kangoo is exactly for what you said it's for - keeping an eye on those pesky kids. We had flip down one on the Galaxy we used to have and used to call it the "naughty cam"!
We've had our Berlingo for years now, brilliant workhorse with so much storage.. ❤
another great video has always Ian and miss hubnut and hublets and hubmutts 👍
Nice video - as idiosyncratic as ever! I drove several Berlingos and Kangoos on French/Spanish holidays in the noughties. Both excellent family transport but the Berlingo/Partner had more room, and better ride comfort for passengers. Generally a more relaxing drive.
Never driven either but I'd rather have the Berlingo on the looks and interior alone.
I certainly didn't know that I needed to know, but now I do I am glad that I do. 😊
We have a 17 year old Berlingo from new. We went for the 1.6 Petrol engine not knowing that 17 years later I would be grateful that we did as the petrol is ULEZ compliant where as the diesel
is not so we can keep this near prefect condition car going a bit longer. Although Under pressure from the wife and children to change. Great Video as usual.
Keep it - cars from this era are the perfect balance of reliability and simplicity. Modern stuff with touch screens, electronic driver assists, etc, I'd stay well away from.
They are appreciating assets, believe me
I love my kango van. Just a simple tool. Reliable
I like how simplistic and cv2/R4 like the Kangoo is. Maybe more for shopping and short hauling trips. On longer rides The Berlingo is the one I guess. In Ian's place I'd go for a Picasso or C5, it's more interesting imo.
great comparison review. I must admit when the clutch went on my wives 307 2.0 Hdi we replaced it with a 1.6 petrol engine'd one. I can confirm the simplicity of the engine compared to a diesel is great. for example I'm looking forwards to changing the cambelt rather than dreading it compared to the Hdi derivative. The engine has quite a nice sporty note too. As always a great video.
The K9K Renault/Nissan 1.5 dCi unit evolved a lot over the years, with refinement improving along the way. Later installations were pretty good at isolating NVH.
Thanks for that. I've got a 1.6 petrol kangoo Trekka 4x4. 95hp. Love it.
My Mom had two Kangoos back to back, and she loved them. I think she received a fair bit of ribbing about the style, but as they still took lots of trailer tent trips back then the space was hugely useful.
Berlingo!
Well, I have this generation as a daily, with 4x4 and 1.6 HDI 90, with 270.000km on the clock. Fun to drive on our curvy mountain roads, quite agile and handles like a normal car.
And I can transport my racing motorbike in the trunk, it surprises everybody!
Would you get a honda crf250 in the back ??
@@stephenfoster4255 I think it should work. My S1000RR is 2075mm long and 1200mm high.
The 2024 CRF250 is 2180mm long and 1265mm high.
But if you remove the side mirrors, it seems that the height is about 1200mm, right?
The CRF is 100mm longer, but I think it can work, I have a little margin with mine. Maybe for your case the bike should stay straight in the trunk. Mine parks just on the side stand (with only one strip on each side to tighten it), and takes more space then.
Just note that the bike fits diagonally in the trunk. I load straight, on the trunk floor there is a U-shape rail sliding on it, which can rotate the whole bike to put it diagonally without effort.
@HarikenRed1 cheers bud . Since I done suspension she is super high!! " the bike "
I'm going to get a berlingo. Mega cheap and easy to fix . Getter that the vw overrated shite
@@stephenfoster4255 I was thinking of the VW Caddy before buying the Berlingo too. But the price and the overcomplicated engines/service, and the need of special tools gave me a headache. Globally the phase 1.2 Berlingo is reliable. Just the rear swingarms must be done after some years. But I do it by myself, it's not so complicated.
Hope it will work for you buddy!
From the same group, I had a Fiat Doblo work van and that was a very pleasant drive.
I'm french and i love the way you say berlingo ! It's sounds like some caribbean dance.
"Have a look at your swimming pool!" - that cracked me up! 😂😂
I'd be interested to see you try a Fiat Doblò !!
My mum actually had a Renault Kangoo cargo in the mid-to-late '00s for a florist business she was briefly a part of. It became something of a local icon. For a time it was our only car so I also very nearly learned to drive in it! (though I didn't end up learning to drive as a teenager and I'm only doing it now in my 30s. ^^; ) I believe it was indeed the turbo-diesel like this one too.
Unfortunately the passenger MPV versions of these vehicles have never been all that popular here in Australia; a lot of them straight up weren't even sold here in that spec for the longest time. I know the Volkswagen Caddy California has a following here though, so maybe that could be changing.
For the time me and my family had owned a Berlingo Multispace 1.6 16V, it was one reliable and dependable drive let me tell ya! it was quite nimble for what it was worth, was pretty fun to drive despite it`s outer Diemensions, and on top of that, had held us over 20 years and almost 180.000 miles. Sadly the car was getting weaker, older and sadly more brittle. Sold it for 700€ to an export, it was taken away, with me and my mom having tears in our eyes, as we knew we were going to miss our old friend. One who had carried me since the Childhood.
Eitherway, i hope wherever our lil Berlingo is heading now, he will keep on running, and keep being the reliable Family Transport it always was.
Asking the essential questions.
Great vid, you now need a Doblo!!
There's a 12v port AND a cigar lighter in the M59.
I was going to say as well!
Both vehicles have a lot of appeal, but I'd go for the Berlingo due to the Modutop.
Tango in the Night is my favourite Fleetwood Mac album, because Eighties, but I also really like Tusk, because I like weirdness ^^
The petrol TU5 is a great engine, have one in a 206 XSi and it offers decent enough performance but is also great on fuel too. Can get around 40mpg around town and around 48mpg on a long run.
Also have an older berlingo too albeit with the DV6 lump. The comfort and ride on them is excellent and they really are a great vehicle for long distances.
Great video thanks Ian
Thanks Ian, very informative video, I’ve had the opportunity to drive similar examples of the Berlingo 1.6 petrol and Kangoo 1.5 and I think I agree with your comments, the Berlingo is nicer to drive, my ex had a Berlingo 1.6 petrol and it was pleasant to drive and own, plenty of storage capacity and a good all rounder.
I’ve driven the van version 1.5 Kangoo and it was pleasant, the interior I think is a bit lighter and simple which I think I prefer.
The 1.5 dci engine I think is a tad wheezy in anything bigger than a Clio, best going for the bigger Diesel engine or a bigger petrol.
Used a Renault kangoo 1.4 aut. at work.. i liked the room it had.. good workvan.
i have the same model as Jono but with the 1.9 diesel (no turbo)
runs quite well, very much like a 2cv in performance, lots of space, lots of storage, lots of fun 🙂
Liked the look of the Berlingo more. Great review.
Another Great video review from Hubnut.
I love my Berlingo 2.0hdi Desire.
Its a great little vehicle for all occasions, Especially wild camping.
Looking up at the stars through the modutop makes for a great night.
The A/C works efficiently, The Traction control is effective enough to keep out of bother on the skiddy stuff, And the roofrails/ rack are more than sufficient to carry my kayak around, or mount the roofbox upon.
Its so utilitarian and capable of any task its truly the Swiss army knife of motoring.
All in all, It's cheap to run, And loads of fun.
I definately won't be parting with it.
Kangoos are popular here in Tokyo; I rarely see Berlingos these days though. Excellent and classic HubNut review. Thanks, Ian!
Wonder if it is due to Nissan/Renault. Wasn't the Kangoo sold as a Nissan?
Yes, the first generation was badged as a Nissan too.
Berlingo/Partners outsell Kangoos probably 20:1 in Costa Rica, and are frequently used as taxis. The PSA products are better finished, significantly more durable, and better supported in the market.
In the area of France where I live these are absolutely everywhere, although I'd say the Berlingo outnumbers the Kangoo. Country folks definitely value their practicality, and these are roomy inside while being small enough for small country lanes. Perfect !
Is that Dave Bass Man after the fish, the drink or the instrument?
I really enjoy these comparison videos.
I suggest a Sierra compared to a Cavalier next 😉
Great idea (Sierra for me!).
I'd love this if only for nostalgia. As a kid Dad had a Cavalier, grandad had a Sierra.
I like both!
Well Ian I comment regularly and u know I am a 1.6 petrol owner bloody love it wish had modutop tho. It is a 16v with 110 bhp. So light on its toes.
Great review - on two cars that I really like - thanks Ian. I'd be interested to know how the 1.4 petrol Kangoo compares to the 1.6 Berlingo.
the berlingo seats are really nice. I love the different shades of blue. The french are just so good at picking and matching colors. The Kangoo is nicer from the outside though. Thanks for the great video.
I had an early 1.4 petrol Berlingo. Drove it from Denmark to London twice.
Evening Ian. Looks like an interesting comparison.
Berlingo every time for me! I had a nice M49 petrol which lasted me 20 years and was still good when I recently sold it. Now got a B9 1.6 XTR diesel which is really superb (apart from the worst "triangle of doom" you've ever seen!). My friend had a Kangoo but it wasn't built as strong and she had few problems. Great comparison video. Thanks!
what is triangle of doom?
@@vs6300 An area of the windscreen not wiped fully by the passenger wiper. Usually in the area near or behind the inside mirror.
@@vs6300 th-cam.com/video/xhHF8a8WWc4/w-d-xo.html
@@flatheadV8 Well explained. Appreciated. I recall that the correct sizes for the wiper for M59 was 22 Inch for driver's wide and 18, or was it 16? for the passenger side I didn't have an issue. I had the Partner for 11 years - got totalled in an accident 400k kms later, but I had a blast.
Always fancied a four wheel drive kangoo, great little package.
Man I feel like a right spotter. Had a 57 Partner van, 58 kangoo WAV and now on a 66 Partner Allure. The auto gearbox in the kangoo pooed itself at 26k and the current Partner is better than the vw t6 we had before it. Awesome little vehicles.
Very practical vehicles. I’ve got similar with the Ford Tourneo Connect which is based on the Transit Connect.
You were following a Doblo. I think! Great video, many thanks.
Tango in the night is a bloody masterpiece
I own a partner m59 with the modutop. It's an annoying rattly thing that is known as the cupboards of doom in my family! My dad used to have a berlingo with a full vinyl sliding roof- that was awesome!
I had a Berlingo van, first registered in 2010. After that I would choose the Berlingo, between 2008 and 2018. The Kangoo is also sold as a Mercedes van, with the same engine as well.
Who needs Top Gear? You're videos are much more interesting and informative. Keep up the good work. 👍
You can easily make any car wash the wrong windscreen by mixing up the hoses or electrical connecors when you change the washer pumps. I did that on my mondeo becauseI thought it was done wrong from the factory but it didnt really work well in practice anyway.
Fleetwood Mac oh yes.
Lovely video.
My girlfriend’s 307 has the same engine as the Berlingo. TU5. I must say that it is a very polyvalent engine even having some torque low down. Cruising very easily is okay low down and in higher revs it is happy as well.
The washers issue may be due to an aftermarket washer pump. I changed one on my Ford, and on trying the front wash/wipe had the rear screen washed with the front wipers operating; operating the rear wash/wipe washed the front windscreen with the rear wiper operating. The washer motors are polarity sensitive, and only two wires, so chopping the wires near the pump and reversing them had it all working correctly.
I'd pick the Kangoo. I ran a Megane with that 1.5Dci engine for a couple of years, and its a great engine for high mileage motorway work.
But the modu-top on the Berlingo is cool, even though I'm not sure what I'd actually put in it, and it seemed a bit flimsy.
El kango no és 1500 és 2000 turbo yo tengo una 4x4 que va de lujo i llevo más de 500000 mil kilómetros mismo embrague motor cambio una gozada
"All the stuff my family REALLY wanted and errr... I disappointed them"
What a legend, my current favorite on YT
I’ve had a 1.2 Kangoo for about 6 months. It’s been OK. I find it pleasant enough to drive, it’s very practical (I like the rubber mats and painted metal inside) and there’s plenty of room. It goes round corners well enough and grips OK in the wet. The plastics are a bit flimsy and I have a couple of minor electrical gremlins to sort out, but for a 15 year old car it’s pretty decent. The Kangoo build quality is a big improvement on a R5 that I used to own. Previously I had 2 Skoda Felicia’s which were absolutely bulletproof but I got the Kangoo to make a micro camper!
I've got a mk1 kangoo van she is now just over 21 years old the 1.5dci engine is still going at only 164000 miles it's a great old thing .
I'm on a surf beach in a mapped 150+hp 2.0 hdi Romahome campervan on a Berlingo. It's done 133k and I love it. One of the best diesel engines ever made in my view People here in France absolutely love it and I get so much glory for roughing it and surf touring in it. Living the Berlingo dream. 😂
I myself have a 20 yo Fiat Doblo Malibu 1.6 16v. Very nippy, fairly comfortable and huge inside. I love it. Between those two I would choose the Berlingo.
I think the 1st Berlingo got a 1.8 petrol aswell, don't think they sold well so maybe hard to find now, but pretty sure the 1.8 was an 8 valve , so should be quite torquey
My first Berlingo was a Desire model with the modutop and they had a 12 volt socket in the rear lockers for kids to plug in their electronics and keep them quiet on long journeys. Unfortunately the modutops are also prone to leaking and, when new some had to go back to Citroen uk under warranty to be re-sealed as it's not a dealer job!!
Love this. I started off with 2CVs and the Berlingo/Partner seemed the obvious upgrade, now on my second. Definitely a fan of these vehicles. Was that a red Fiat Doblo or Fiorino you were following at one point? A possible third model to add to the comparison.
It’s a tough choice. I would have said Berlingo but I already own one and a lot of things have broken, are leaking or don’t work anymore. However I like the 1.4 petrol engine. It was dual fuel originally but I don’t bother with the LPG anymore. The engine design is very traditional and simple to work on, except for the ECU which controls all sorts of things unnecessarily, like the cooling fan. I like the Renault Kangoo design and the smaller size of it. Looks very use friendly and I wouldn’t mind the engine noise or the lower power. Probably very economical, so it would be the Kangoo for me.
very nice reviews.. a step up from the Express which we still see plenty of in Spain, As you say the HDIs are better the 2.2 s have addictive tourque
1461cc DCI engine powering like a dream even in the Dacia today and whisper it, the Mercedes A class!! A diamond of an engine as long as you look after it. There was an issue with the engine when it was put in the Juke and Qashqai some how they managed to get the drive belt and water pump pulley slightly mis aligned which resulted in many engine failures at 60k or less.
I bought a 1.5 Kangoo years ago as I wanted the simplest, most practical vehicle I could find. I’d still be driving it now but for an unfortunate accident. Totally reliable in 5 years of ownership, moved house in it, went on holiday in it umpteen times, four people and two dogs. Sitting in the back staring at the sea with a cup of tea, wetsuits slung over the rear doors drying in the sunshine. Fantastic down twisty little lanes in Cornwall, we nicknamed it the Mountain Goat. With winter tyres it was unstoppable in the snow due to high ground clearance. All in all a terrific car.
Paddling pools and quick-release cubbies! My mates Mam-Van 3000 (aka 110 diesel Berlingo) was good fun to be fair. I appreciate this is a Bangernomics channel (is James Ruppet still alive?) but the new one looks fab too! Those Nissan Renault alliance engines are good too, although I must declare an interest (like PM’s are supposed too), my brother is SVP for Nissans Technology Centre here in the U.K.!
Interesting test, especially since the Kangoo and Berlingo are potential candidates for replacing my parents' 2009 Golf with something larger if it fails completely. I've never been in a Berlingo but at least two different Kangoo models. My pet peeve with the Kangoo is that despite of the seemingly massive headroom those shelves above the windscreen are low enough for me to hit my head on trying to look into the glovebox or something like that. Might have to try a Berlingo next!
I've owned both for several years and the Berlingo comes out on top, IMO.
The best kangoo was the trek 4x4 version, that was only on the early models it never made it to the face lifted ones, it was really handy, saw loads of them in Bavaria, handy for the mountain roads.
I can confirm they did make a 4x4 facelift
Some of my favourite type of vehicles, family vans!
I have had both, both diesel. Preferred the Renault as the gear change was smoother and the switches better. Once you accept you have a van with a seat in the back their a great practical vehicle. The Kangoo rear seat folds flat into the floor whereas you have to remove the seats in the Berlingo to get the same space.
The Berlingo has so much glass & storage vry well designed
With the amount of space and overhead storage both these cars would be good if you were thinking or indeed being forced to be homeless and living in your car. which a lot of folk are having to do. The overhead lockers are a game changer for this purpose.
Next battles Berlingo vs Fiat Doblo and Berlingo vs Transit Connect Tourneo mk1 shape
I don't know if there was a passenger variant of a Vauxhall Combo but that could also be a contender if it exists
Hi there. I was thinking the same.
In Europe we have opel combo passenger version. Don t know about the uk version.
Very similar to the 03 Berlingo Forte Multispace I drove quite a lot when I was in England back in 05. The only difference was A/C and the HDI motor with 5 speed manual. The Forte had everything yours had otherwise. It wasn’t bad to drive but there was a VW Sharan TDI 6 speed manual on the fleet which was a much better drive.
I drove a 1st gen Partner van round Europe as a wide load escort vehicle back in 97. One of the best and most reliable vehicles I ever drove doing a couple of thousand miles a week! The only annoying thing was the keypad immobiliser which was set at the default of 1111 and served no purpose whatsoever...
Switched from a 1.4 HDi turbo diesel car to a 1.6 16v petrol, although petrols are fun to rev and drive quickly, I do miss having useable torque and power low down the rev range for normal driving. Would make sure if you do get a petrol in a larger vehicle like a Berlingo, need a big enough one to not feel sluggish, although would still choose a diesel one personally if I was thinking of getting one or another PSA product in the future.
Got a 2010 Kangoo 1.5 which had for 10yrs, sore on track rod ends though. They are both OK as MPV.
Nice little vans. We never had much of such offerings here in Canada
There are everywhere in France, even old ones
I would prefer the Berlingo myself. Love all that storage space in the roof and under the floor - and the under floor storage is also a good place to transport your goldfish apparently. ( I once had a Mitsubishi Galant that allowed you to transport goldfish in the boot if you removed the spare wheel) I have never really liked Renault's, probably due to my experiences with them back in the 80's and early 90's. I used to drive a Transit van for work back then, but when it went in for a service we used to get a Renault Traffic as a courtesy van, it was like driving a tin can down the road, sound levels inside were appalling, and the foot pedals were off-set to the left, making for a horrid driving experience. We also had Renault Laguna's on the fleet, they were let down by the pedals again being off-set to the left, and also the fact the pedals were so close together you were forever hitting two pedals at once. And finally we got a Kangoo, the noise level inside was horrible, and the suspension thudded it's way over irregularities in the road. Those experiences put me off Renault's for life, probably unfairly because no doubt some of their later cars were much nicer.
Have driven several kangoos and there's a wide range of power outputs depending on spec from these engine's. Most recent one had ad blue for whatever reason. Cheapest van around that's why we had them😮 you can tell the plastic is cheap and cheerful. Don't crash it as you'll need a sweeping brush to pick up the bits 😏
Can you believe in Argentina is exactly the same versus polemicize ? Renault Kangoo is best selling 'cause it has a cheaper sticker price for acquisition at official dealers . The Berlingo is a quite best buy , infact i work at a Mechanic's parcel area , we saw very often those Renault Kangoo at idle for everything. Mechanic told me that thanks to Renault's his wallet gets fat and is a good profit for him , instead of Citroen's being very healthy vehicles . So amazing your discusion resembles the same discusion in SouthAmerica , true compliments so appreciated mister Hubnut
Having had 2 Kangoos a pre-facelift 2002 Model Year and a 2004 facelift (very similar to the one in the video), both had the 1.2 16V petrol lump. I can vouch that whilst these were no speed machines (albeit cruising at 70 was definitely possible!) I couldn't fault their practically, anything from 3-seat sofas to several 20" framed Mountain bikes, as well as taking 5 people camping and acting as the official transport as I was support for two teams of four during the 2006 Oxfam Trailwalk! The only fly in the ointment was their reliability, frequent trips to the Renault dealership for both to iron out manufacturing faults during the early part of ownership! Wonder if the popularity of the Kangoo might be something to do with the 2nd Generation Kangoo is available with a Merc Benz suit in the Citan!
I'm hoping to move flats later in the year and I may very well consider hiring a van like one of these to assist me. I think Enterprise has some rental Kangoos.
Is the Renault engine is K9K?
If so, you can find it on many Renault, Nissan (as well as the Qashqai you mentioned, I rented such car in Germany in 2016, I had the 1.5DCI K9K with 110HP, drove on autobahn and on cities like Berlin, Frankfurt and Munich, and still got 19-20 km/l) and Dacia as well.
This is a pretty reliable engine with very good fuel consumption, especially on highways.
We had such engine on a Renault Megane estate MK3 with the EDC gearbox, I was managed to get 22 km\l!