Realistically the Jedi wouldn’t have stayed away from the Republic considering just how vast it was, and it was reaching every corner of the Galaxy, which brought up the question if the Jedi should merge with the Republic to better aid the people of the galaxy, even without the Sith Wars raging on.
That guy was supposed to be the focus of KOTOR 3, before it was turned into an MMO. The Jedi Knight playthrough is one of the more interesting ones for the Republic options.
I'd like to see more stories about the individual Jedi/Sith throughout this era, the overall lore is nice, but it was always the personal struggles, victories and defeats that keep me interested in StarWars.
Well, never going to happen and the lore will be gone if Disney did it... So poorly done personal struggles without the unique and rich Legends lore doesn't seem as popular as Disney thought it would be
I am enjoying the series so far. And while I can't wait for the next part of it, I'm also cautionsly optomistic, as the next part should be focusing on the Jedi during their time as part of the Republic, maybe even getting all the way to the Prequel stories and the Clone Wars, not sure if your going to split that stuff up or not I can't read your mind, and in recent times you've been very critical of the Republic and the Jedi Orders affiliation with it, so I should be on guard and ready to defend them, as I make it no secret I'm a firm supporter of the Galactic Republic and the Jedis affiliation with it, despite the many flaws. In which case I better get my platoon of 36 Clone Troopers, which I only know is how many Clones are in a platoon because of your great videos thank you for that, ready for the defense.
Had multiple states existed within the galaxy like Europe during the late 19th century, will the Jedi Order have their own territory similar to the Teutonic Order used to rule over Prussia and Livonia to function but wit htheir territory functioned somewhat more like Switzerland? You know, as this place where all nations in the galaxy must preserved its neutrality. And in turn, it can be a place where they can come and discuss what needed to be done to maintain peace and balance in the galaxy.
Awesome video, do I want to watch more on this topic? hell yeah. I didn't know about that Dark Age of the Galactic Republic. I bet the Russan battle is what brings the times of Darth Bane and the rule of two, I certainly want to learn more about it.
It's kinda funny that for how bumbling and incompetent the Republic was, the Sith only managed to defeat it a handful of times and even then not for very long. Would you do a video theorycrafting how the Clone Wars would've ended had Palpatine been eliminated prematurely. The Zillo Beast could've eaten him or he could've slipped on some soap in the shower and that would've been it.
I had a dream Disney released a KOTOR movie trailer. It had a scene of Keanu Reeves as Revan hugging Bastila Shan. And then a scene of Revan in a cave, some other weird scenes. It looked so real, I thought this wasn't a dream, but cinematography was cheap and backgrounds were claustrophobic like they shoot everything in the Volume today. I woke up and looked up Revan on TH-cam to see if Disney started massacring his story 😂
If I understand the term of the sale to Disney anything considered Legend still in a way belong to Lucas, so if they use it they have to give him a % of it. Thus why they tried so hard to make new characters which for Disney in almost every case flop big time. This I believe is why they were so desperate to have Rey and the other characters fly off, so they could keep everything in their bank account
@@quantemwensday Right? They screwed it up so badly it’s mostly dead now. When you have life long fans like myself since 1977 not given any f@ck about Star Wars now you just know how much they messed this up.
It's easy to be critical of the decisions made by the Jedi, and there are definitely legitimate criticisms to be made. However, I don't believe it was wrong for them to join the Republic. The main issues seem to be twofold. 1. The Jedi became more focused on governing, rather than the issues facing everyday citizens. 2. The unwillingness of the Jedi to be publicly critical of anything the Republic did, or did not do. I think if the Jedi had remained more connected to the people, and had put more public pressure on the Republic regarding the care of average citizens, it would have been more difficult for Sidious to undermine them. There are other issues, of course, but these are two of the most important, imo.
Agreed. I think the Jedi joining with the Republic was the correct move to make, espcially after the New Sith Wars ended, as it allowed the Galaxy to rapidly recover and rebuild. Sure the Republic has problems, a lot of problems, but it did a decent job of running the Galaxy considering it stood for 25000 years and if the Jedi had taken a more active role like you said in trying to improve things it could have been something really great. The Jedi and Republic do work well together, as seen by how peaceful and good things were for many years following the Russan Reformations at the end of the New Sith Wars. And even during the time of the Clone Wars there were still great instances of Jedi and Republic forces(Clones and others) doing some real good, like when they saved the Togruta people from the Zygerrians.
I think the Jedi were always going to be warriors, because martial arts was a part of their lifestyle, as is the case with any monastic order to an extent. Look at the Shaolin, Yamabushi, Sohei, Wing Chun Monks in Southern China, etc. However, they were never meant to act as bodyguards for a chancellor. They're like commisioned officers within an armed force. And THAT, they shouldn't be.
In a way, Exar Kun won. He completely, totally won. He broke the Jedi in a way they never came back from. He made them cruel, cynical, insular, and afraid for the rest of the centuries they existed after that.
You can argue whether they should be warriors or not, but they should never be generals as they suck at it. Leave the war fighting to the professionals please.
I've always considered the number of force users and jedi star wars Just bad And does it make sense That galaxy has a population of a hundred quadrillion So the jedi order should have the number of a few billion or a few trillion At least This is also why the size Of star wars militaries don't make sense or the size of galactic fleets of ships
Technically speaking, every being in the galaxy was Force sensitive to a degree, Though the midiclorian concentration would not be enough to do anything with it. The Jedi accepted only initiates with a certain minimal Force sensitivity, that still allows them to listen to the Will of the Force, which most beings simply didn't have. Adequate Force sensitivity was exceptionally rare and it was only thanks to the interconnection and medical services the Republic provided, that the Jedi had the numbers they had during the Separatist Crisis
@@dorianwiesner4477You know One per cent of a hundred quadrillion is one quadrillion If you want to go smaller one quadrillion And its one percent is 10 trillion and Going Even further back One percent of a trillion is a hundred billion Think how small that is to entire population of a galaxy The number The jedi Have never made sense in the galaxy they Live in Same thing with military and ship of there fleets
It’s Star Wars, it never was suppose to make any sense. Star Wars is just simple fun, huge space battles with crazy sizes ships coupled with small size Jedi vs Sith sabre combat. The stories are just put your brain on neutral and don’t asked too many questions just accept it the way it is. Trying to apply any of facts of scientific reality to Star Wars just defeat what it was made for…fun
Most galaxy spanning scifi franchises are off with their numbers. Anyway, in Star Wars, where the actions of just one Force user can radically reshape the state of the galaxy in a hand full of years, imagine the constant chaos of a galaxy where every Force user at some point in their lives were to decide to shake things up, and we have a few trillion or quadrillion Force users at any one time roaming around. Civilization wouldn’t be the default state of the galaxy, tribalism and isolation would be the default state of things in the few systems in the galaxy where life is still possible.
Realistically the Jedi wouldn’t have stayed away from the Republic considering just how vast it was, and it was reaching every corner of the Galaxy, which brought up the question if the Jedi should merge with the Republic to better aid the people of the galaxy, even without the Sith Wars raging on.
Windu, “We are keepers of the peace. Not soldiers.”
Palpatine, “And yet, you have fallen right into my trap.”
To keep the peace you have to fight to end it
Mace: "says the guy crying like a kid for a teeager to save his life while his face melted due to his own attacks."
Palpatine:
“Ok. Not soldier. Generals and Commanders. Now will you fight for me?”
Mace:
“Where do we sign up?”
@ Anakin was 23. That’s not a teenager
@@ottooctavius9552 before 25 we are all teenagers
I love SWTOR and The Hero Of Tython, he’s so damn powerful.
That guy was supposed to be the focus of KOTOR 3, before it was turned into an MMO. The Jedi Knight playthrough is one of the more interesting ones for the Republic options.
Yes! Thank you for the video.❤
I love this series you guys are doing! 🙏🏻👍🏼
I'd like to see more stories about the individual Jedi/Sith throughout this era, the overall lore is nice, but it was always the personal struggles, victories and defeats that keep me interested in StarWars.
Well, never going to happen and the lore will be gone if Disney did it... So poorly done personal struggles without the unique and rich Legends lore doesn't seem as popular as Disney thought it would be
Indeed. Thanks for the update.
I am enjoying the series so far. And while I can't wait for the next part of it, I'm also cautionsly optomistic, as the next part should be focusing on the Jedi during their time as part of the Republic, maybe even getting all the way to the Prequel stories and the Clone Wars, not sure if your going to split that stuff up or not I can't read your mind, and in recent times you've been very critical of the Republic and the Jedi Orders affiliation with it, so I should be on guard and ready to defend them, as I make it no secret I'm a firm supporter of the Galactic Republic and the Jedis affiliation with it, despite the many flaws. In which case I better get my platoon of 36 Clone Troopers, which I only know is how many Clones are in a platoon because of your great videos thank you for that, ready for the defense.
All about that Big Beautiful Year
Geetsly, do a video on rahm kota or kotas militia and the possibility of it becoming canon again please❤️
I love that idea actually
Had multiple states existed within the galaxy like Europe during the late 19th century, will the Jedi Order have their own territory similar to the Teutonic Order used to rule over Prussia and Livonia to function but wit htheir territory functioned somewhat more like Switzerland? You know, as this place where all nations in the galaxy must preserved its neutrality. And in turn, it can be a place where they can come and discuss what needed to be done to maintain peace and balance in the galaxy.
Awesome video, do I want to watch more on this topic? hell yeah. I didn't know about that Dark Age of the Galactic Republic. I bet the Russan battle is what brings the times of Darth Bane and the rule of two, I certainly want to learn more about it.
It's kinda funny that for how bumbling and incompetent the Republic was, the Sith only managed to defeat it a handful of times and even then not for very long.
Would you do a video theorycrafting how the Clone Wars would've ended had Palpatine been eliminated prematurely. The Zillo Beast could've eaten him or he could've slipped on some soap in the shower and that would've been it.
The republic wouldive fell anyway
23:35 DARTH JAR-JAR, THE TRUE DARK LORD OF THE SITH
I had a dream Disney released a KOTOR movie trailer. It had a scene of Keanu Reeves as Revan hugging Bastila Shan. And then a scene of Revan in a cave, some other weird scenes. It looked so real, I thought this wasn't a dream, but cinematography was cheap and backgrounds were claustrophobic like they shoot everything in the Volume today. I woke up and looked up Revan on TH-cam to see if Disney started massacring his story 😂
all this content that could've been used to make some movies or anything really
but disney wasted it
So true its up to the fans to do what Disney couldn’t
If I understand the term of the sale to Disney anything considered Legend still in a way belong to Lucas, so if they use it they have to give him a % of it. Thus why they tried so hard to make new characters which for Disney in almost every case flop big time. This I believe is why they were so desperate to have Rey and the other characters fly off, so they could keep everything in their bank account
@@patrickols they tried so hard to screw him
they only ended up screwing themselves instead
@@quantemwensday Right? They screwed it up so badly it’s mostly dead now. When you have life long fans like myself since 1977 not given any f@ck about Star Wars now you just know how much they messed this up.
@patrickols corporations can only think in the short term
they don't know how to really make the most money they can out of something good
It's easy to be critical of the decisions made by the Jedi, and there are definitely legitimate criticisms to be made. However, I don't believe it was wrong for them to join the Republic. The main issues seem to be twofold.
1. The Jedi became more focused on governing, rather than the issues facing everyday citizens.
2. The unwillingness of the Jedi to be publicly critical of anything the Republic did, or did not do.
I think if the Jedi had remained more connected to the people, and had put more public pressure on the Republic regarding the care of average citizens, it would have been more difficult for Sidious to undermine them. There are other issues, of course, but these are two of the most important, imo.
Agreed. I think the Jedi joining with the Republic was the correct move to make, espcially after the New Sith Wars ended, as it allowed the Galaxy to rapidly recover and rebuild. Sure the Republic has problems, a lot of problems, but it did a decent job of running the Galaxy considering it stood for 25000 years and if the Jedi had taken a more active role like you said in trying to improve things it could have been something really great. The Jedi and Republic do work well together, as seen by how peaceful and good things were for many years following the Russan Reformations at the end of the New Sith Wars. And even during the time of the Clone Wars there were still great instances of Jedi and Republic forces(Clones and others) doing some real good, like when they saved the Togruta people from the Zygerrians.
I think the Jedi were always going to be warriors, because martial arts was a part of their lifestyle, as is the case with any monastic order to an extent. Look at the Shaolin, Yamabushi, Sohei, Wing Chun Monks in Southern China, etc.
However, they were never meant to act as bodyguards for a chancellor. They're like commisioned officers within an armed force. And THAT, they shouldn't be.
Yup. Champions and advisors, SpecOps.
The corruption of the Jedi, and the Republic is what causes the problems to arise.
Always finishing with the Ruusan Republic.
In a way, Exar Kun won. He completely, totally won. He broke the Jedi in a way they never came back from. He made them cruel, cynical, insular, and afraid for the rest of the centuries they existed after that.
That's a great story so far though
You can argue whether they should be warriors or not, but they should never be generals as they suck at it. Leave the war fighting to the professionals please.
I've always considered the number of force users and jedi star wars Just bad And does it make sense
That galaxy has a population of a hundred quadrillion
So the jedi order should have the number of a few billion or a few trillion At least
This is also why the size Of star wars militaries don't make sense or the size of galactic fleets of ships
Technically speaking, every being in the galaxy was Force sensitive to a degree, Though the midiclorian concentration would not be enough to do anything with it. The Jedi accepted only initiates with a certain minimal Force sensitivity, that still allows them to listen to the Will of the Force, which most beings simply didn't have. Adequate Force sensitivity was exceptionally rare and it was only thanks to the interconnection and medical services the Republic provided, that the Jedi had the numbers they had during the Separatist Crisis
@@dorianwiesner4477You know One per cent of a hundred quadrillion is one quadrillion If you want to go smaller one quadrillion And its one percent is 10 trillion and Going Even further back One percent of a trillion is a hundred billion
Think how small that is to entire population of a galaxy
The number The jedi Have never made sense in the galaxy they Live in
Same thing with military and ship of there fleets
It’s Star Wars, it never was suppose to make any sense. Star Wars is just simple fun, huge space battles with crazy sizes ships coupled with small size Jedi vs Sith sabre combat. The stories are just put your brain on neutral and don’t asked too many questions just accept it the way it is. Trying to apply any of facts of scientific reality to Star Wars just defeat what it was made for…fun
Most galaxy spanning scifi franchises are off with their numbers.
Anyway, in Star Wars, where the actions of just one Force user can radically reshape the state of the galaxy in a hand full of years, imagine the constant chaos of a galaxy where every Force user at some point in their lives were to decide to shake things up, and we have a few trillion or quadrillion Force users at any one time roaming around. Civilization wouldn’t be the default state of the galaxy, tribalism and isolation would be the default state of things in the few systems in the galaxy where life is still possible.
@@djashovel You are talking like 1 is the lowest percentage you can get
GEETSLY'S?!??! IS THAT YOU?!
Yep
Im curious to know if you will continue the legends timeline?
Totally
no one forced the jedi to change they made those choices and in turn bore the consequences of those actions
Of course he did anyway
Re-uploaded content smh
Am I Fr gonna be the first comment on this?
👍
Totally