Gah! I know watch geeks are saying the P39 is boring... But man, I LOVE IT! It's exactly what I want in my collection. I love the dimensions, I love how versatile it is, I want a titanium dive watch sooo bad. This video has only made my want one moooore!
This came out right after I got my BB58 blue. I love it! But I love my BB58 blue. I totally would have considered this Pelagos instead, though. And the bracelet is better. I love my BB58 blue…
Tudor listens to their consumers. That's why I have purchased every modern Tudor since the release of the black bay 41. Every watch geek wanted a smaller dive watch in a material that is lighter and less scratch resistant. A better bracelet because they didn't like the look, a better clasp with a extension. Tudor gave the clients all this in this release, but it doesn't matter what they release, every watch geek think they know better and find negatives. I personally think it's an amazing watch. Thanks Teddy for the great review.
@@ShashankD137 THEY dont like to have advanced scratch resistant.coating on titanium, like duratec, dlc, etc. ... to keep THEIR adventure marks, I think.
Can we hear more about the Murph 38? I’d like to know why it’s better than the automatic khaki field, to justify the price, besides that I like the way it looks more than…..😊
Have owned the P39 four months now and I do not want to wear anything else from my collection, great fit and love the dial, very legible and love the white and black contrast.
I imagine it would make for a great 1 watch collection (even though we all know there is no such thing). Not that I'm suggesting 'get one and sell everything else you have'. Just that, if a friend or colleague suddenly became a watch nut and told me their budget was enough to include this as an option, right now, it's the one I would recommend. Especially after comments like this. Thanks.
I am on a waiting list for a Rolex sub and gave up, bought the 42mm Pelagos this year and so far it was the best decision, I am so happy with Tudor I just bough the 1926 two tone in 41mm and same result, I have 2 watches that are totally different look amazing and still cost less than one Rolex
Great decision! Rolex sub also has a crazy msrp nowadays. There are a lot of other options at a similar price level which you can instantly get without a waitling list.
@@key4duty I wanted the Rolex for the brand reputation but to pay the crazy price supper happy with my decision I got 2 watches associated with Rolex and at a lower price than one Rolex. Definitely would recommend Tudor as a brand
They really nailed the design. The dial is perfectly balanced. The square hour markers are fantastic and unique giving it a vintage feel. The snowflake hands suit the hour markers exceptionally well. The understated matte look is utilitarian and functional. Submariner is beefy and shiny where this is like the Rolex Explorer. A classic for times to come.
If they would ever drop the diamond on the hour hand I would be right there with you. As Tudor sits right now, I think they are ugly and turn me away from ever thinking about them. As Mr Wonderful always says, it’s about the dial, and Tudor needs work
@@AndrewJohn4A I agree he isn’t always right, but watches start with the dial, he is not wrong there. And that doesn’t change my opinion on snowflake hand of the Tudor
I recently picked up my P39. So far I am very pleased with this watch. It feels very high quality and has a modern sharp feel to it that I appreciate. I was slightly concerned about the size of the clasp but on my 17 cm wrist the clasp is center nicely and does not feel too large. My watch runs at around +1 sec per day which is very impressive. For this price you'll be hard pressed to find a better diver.
I popped into my AD a few days after launch to enquire about the P39 and they had one in stock to show people the real thing before selling it. I looked at it and was pretty stunned how different it was from the LHD that I've had for some years. It's so much lighter than the 42. I did notice the long clasp but felt it should be OK (the LHD has quite a long clasp as well) so I registered my interest. A couple of weeks later I had the call so went back and picked it up. Some reviewers have commented negatively on the sunburst dial saying a dive watch should have a matt dial but the sunburst finish is very subtle and in most lighting conditions it look a deep black tone. The bezel has a little more pronounced sunburst effect but works great. The lume is brilliant and I think it's super readable. I had mine sized so the clasp was in the middle (with links removed from either side like all my watch bracelets) and have no issues with it. In summary I have no regrets purchasing the watch. If there was a slight negative it does take some wrist time away from my LHD but it's different enough from its larger sibling I can't bring myself to selling my beloved super comfortable LHD. If anyone has reservations about the sunburst parts or the clasp all I would suggest is going to see one if you can. I do understand that this watch is not for everyone.
It might be worth mentioning, that scratches on Titanium Grade II are much less notable as on Titanium Grade V. Plus scratches on Titanium Grade II on the Pelagos can easily be hidden by the blue side of a conventional eraser.
I think this will be the first Tudor in my collection. I really hope they release this in the matte blue of the larger pelagos, maybe even leaving off the sunburst finish, that would be my perfect watch!
Just bought one today. Was having trouble deciding between a bb58 and the pelagos, but decided I wanted something that chose function over form. And something that appeared a little less flashy. I hope it lives up to all the great reviews.
Yes, Tudor delivers on what ppl like, do not forget we are a small collecting community so should be happy of them. BB and Pelagos is two interesting ranges that do live in harmony. Good for Tdr and good for us
I love my blue Pelagos 42 that I bought nigh on 3 years ago. I admire it every time I wear it and I do not pamper it either, scratches, whatever, it is a tool watch after all. I even sleep with it on from time to time, the lume is nice to look at. Black bay is for the masses, Pelagos 42 - less so.
I’m loving this watch and with the T fit clasp it fits perfectly, with the Titanium case & bracelet it doesn’t fall off your wrist to the side like a Rolex Sub, its a great timekeeper with great lume. I love the 21mm lug to lug, makes the watch chunkier but I’m with you on the clasp, this is not a dive watch and doesn’t need the dive extension, this is an all round utility/sports watch, apart from the large clasp and maybe a date this watch is just perfect! The other bonus side is you are unlikely to be robbed (especially in UK) as its not a Rolex😉.
Interestesting perspectives. Agree on both your perspectives on scratching and depth ratings. Neither are an issue - it's more about how the watch community perceives the watch and the lifestyle branding is divisive for some.
Great review! I just saw this watch in person today. I hope Tudor comes out with a 41/42mm version of this watch. Don’t need more than 200m and love the black sunray dial and bezel, plus the thinner case. Smaller clasp and date window would be ideal too.
Got mine recently and it is glued to my wrist ! I love it apart from 2 things : that fit clasp, especially for my small wrist and a bit of play with the bezel when you push on one side, say at 6, the other side at 12 lifts. Other than that, the rotation is solid !
I own several Rolex but bought this and it’s awesome Less conspicuous Titanium is toned down I wear on grey waxed canvas strap for comfort No one mentions the floating hands which are spot on too. I’ve also had the Seiko 65mas which was too sunburst and square lugs shape not refined as this
Teddy, I was watching this and realized that we do not know at all what is your collection like. Would be awesome to make a video with your current collection and the 2, 3 pieces you like to wear the most. Take care !
Teddy, thanks for no-bs content. Love your integrity, as well as this new Pelagos. For the moment I will wait until a blue version is released. Cheers!!
Just received a Ginault Silent Service and, while it does not have the heritage of these others it is both hand finished and better in all ways than any of these others I’ve tried-my opinion of course!
I understand that the 39mm will appeal & fit a lot better on those with a smaller wrist but for me the best Pelagos is the 42mm in blue. I can’t see many people who wear the 42mm buying it. Great review I did enjoy watching. 👍👏👏👏
I am waiting on one from my AD. My only concern is the clasp length. I haven't got hands on with one yet but hopefully that won't be an issue for my 6.3" wrist. The new 41mm Sub clasp is just too wide.
Tudor has had a storied dive watch history going back to the snowflake days and the French navy. It's great that Tudor continues that tradition, and is now one of the most desirable Swiss watches on the market.
This new Pelagos 39 is the first Tudor I actively put my name down at ADs expressing interest to buy. I ended up getting another watch so I pull my request to those ADs but still. I think it's a homerun. For me it fixed everything that stopped me from getting the larger Pelagos and/or the BB58.
As a person who wore a Speedy Schumacher 03 for 10+ years, this is super tempting. Honestly, the only thing I do not like about the watch is the Titanium. There is something to be said with a weight of a watch and when you are dealing with something as compact as this, the obvious Submariner from Rolex and the higher grade of Ti, I would say it is the only slight miss in the watch. There are so many grades of stainless to consider as well as various alloys thereof. Maybe it is me, but I like the feel of the weight of the watch I pick. That is not to take away from this watch nor anyone else's choice. When you think about having 2-3 watches in your collection, you really want to make sure it is something that is wearable as both a piece of art, a time piece, and to a lesser degree a subtle nuance to what you are like as a person. Absolutely beautiful time piece. Love the red. Would have liked to see a bit more game in the palladium, rhodium, stainless steel, chromium, cobalt and other alloys. I work in med-tech. Metal selection has a human factor element that is so important. Bring it over Tudor.
Thanks for measuring the clasp length! (46mm.) I spent an embarrassing amount of time on web searches the other day trying to figure that out. It's my one hangup about this watch, and the nearest Tudor AD is over an hour away. Didn't wanna make the trip just to find out whether or not the clasp would swallow my tiny wrist!
I absolutely love it, everything about it, the only thing is I’d have to see the sunburst bezel insert in the metal as I’ve never seen one like that ever and I’m not sure, as with all things though watches definitely look different in your hand than any video or photos on the web, I do really really love the watch though, 100% my kind of watch, I hope to pull the trigger on one soon, thanks for the excellent video Teddy 👍🏻
Nothing against grade 2 titanium (I have a watch made if this) but a watch in this price range should be grade 5. Also, if the bezel is 40mm, then industry standard is to go with the widest width of either bezel or case for stated dimensions, so this should be called 40mm. Finally, if your wrist size is small, a clasp that long is going to look weird and uncomfortable anytime you rest your hand on anything, like a desk or on your own leg when sitting, and sometimes even when holding your hand up. I went through this with my Omega watches. I started with a 40mm Railmaster that has a long clasp, which for the previously mentioned reasons ruined the fit on my small 6.5 inch wrist. I eventually got rid of that watch and got the Seamaster 57 LE which has a compact clasp and have been happy ever since making the switch. I’m a fan of Tudor watches but I’ll give this one a hard pass. Great review as always. Nobody does it better.
Hmmm when you have a Pelagos LHD..and you try a Pelagos 39..swapping ain’t gonna enter your thoughts..but if you don’t then it’s a great choice..Like almost all Tudors, great watches at good value
Everyone is making a big deal about the clasp but I don't see it as being much of an issue. True, the dive extension is very uncessary especially considering they already lowered the water resistance and removed the helium escape valve. The overall watch is so light though, that the large clasp helps balance it out.
I own a Rolex REF16234 circa 2000….stainless on an oyster bracelet, white gold bezel, rhodium colored face…. I wanted to add a Tudor to my higher end collection and this review has surely helped me to also consider the Pelagos 39…. I also like the Black Bay GMT two tone so come purchase time I’ll have to make a decision. I also own several higher end Seikos, two Tissot PRX Powermatic 80s, a Raymond Weil Parsifal, and many higher end Citzens along with a slew of Casio Gshock and other….. Tudor seems like a nice (and more affordable than Rolex) addition to my collection. Thanks Teddy,
As someone who owns two Black Bay 58s in black and blue, I thought the P39 would be a "can't miss" based on the perfect case dimensions and specs; it went to the top of my short list. But when I tried it on in person, something about it didn't quite click. Couldn't identify what it was, maybe the double sunburst. It felt off though. Sterile. Bottom line: check it out in person and don't just make assumptions based on the specs.
It has no presence - a straight forward tool watch.. I got out from my AD with a BB59 gilt on my wrist for a $1k less than what they asked for the p39 after tax.
This definitely a great watch for smaller wrists. My wrist is right at 7.5", so my blue 42mm Pelagos works just fine, and, well, it's blue... Matte blue, which is a big thing for me.
Really love the P39 but am also considering the BB54 oooor a Seamster 300 in polar or the neovintage 22545000. Besides others;) Great vid btw. Thanks and all the best
This watch is absolutely perfect to me the only thing I can actually think that would make this even more perfect is having a dat calendar but then again there would be barely any face difference from the the old one so I also get it
Pelagos 39 has been on my short list for months while waiting for a call from Rolex that never came. I had all but removed the 39 from that short list because I was worried about the bezel and dial finish based on the close-up views and lighting of some of the review videos. Once I finally saw it in person today, it did not take me long to pull the trigger. The video reviews of this watch really put a microscope on the finish, in a way that it just does not come across to the naked eye. In person, the finish to the bezel and dial is like "eggshell" to use the terminology of latex interior paint. It's not glossy or even semi-glossy; just one step removed from matte. I think because the size is diminished, it has a more subtle wrist presence that Tudor offset by adding just a wee bit of sheen, while preserving a matte look.
I have a week with mine and haven't worn it yet but I hear a loud grinding noise when winding it after about 10-12 turns, I have experienced this with my other Tudor BB steel version, it not good. I will reach out to my AD this morning. I just past seven days which is the return policy and it's awful
If I had to guess why they went with a 21mm lug width, I’d say it’s because a taper to 18mm at the clasp isn’t enough going from 20mm. Or at least, that’s what some would say. But I agree with you, Teddy. I think a 21mm is a swing and a miss. Great video, Teddy. Thanks!
I actually think they made a different size so you can't put a bracelet/strap on from another model... the rubber strap comes with a buckle whereas I would have prefered a clasp like the black bay 54's rubber strap....
I was very excited about this watch. It hit everything I wanted from a diver, but then... no date. I own a BB36 and really like it, but the no date bugs me often when I look down and it's not there. It's a must now. Except on a dress watch which I wear rarely and care more about being slim with clean symmetrical esthetics than anything.
When I hear the descriptive words “for medium to large wrists” I shy away, I am definitely leaning towards “smaller to medium size wrists” I have a 7 inch wrist and love 38mm with a lug to lug of around 47mm
I've had this watch for a week and love it. Some bezel back play but I'll wear it for a while longer and see if I can get that fixed. Looks way better in person imo.
@@KFen10 oh yeah a little to much back play at this price point imo. Once I'm out of the honeymoon phase I'll bring it in. No rush, the warranty is 5yrs 😊
Not the biggest fan of the snowflake hour hand, but it works so much better compared to the BB due to the square/rectangle indices of the Pelagos imho.
P39 is incredible. Point. For me, it's so good it's boring. It's the look no further, one stop shop where I find myself thinking, this could be the most perfect watch on market. And for those that might not like the 21mm Lug width, You'd most likely not be changing that bracelet anytime soon because it's so so good! Great job as always Teddy :-)
Just got mine today. Wish it had no diver extension and smaller clasp (won’t use anyway like 99% of other owners) got the bb58 bronze with t-fit clasp and it’s a much better size and comfort. So I will probably wear it mostly on the provided rubber strap 😅.
Just my opinion of course. Think I would rather have the Zodiac Super Sea Wolf. Seems to win all categories except power reserve. (not a big deal.. 30 seconds to set and go)
You can get a not dissimilar look with the certina ds action diver 38mm for a fraction of the price.. They are not tudor but the are a lot of watch for the money.
Gah! I know watch geeks are saying the P39 is boring... But man, I LOVE IT! It's exactly what I want in my collection. I love the dimensions, I love how versatile it is, I want a titanium dive watch sooo bad. This video has only made my want one moooore!
Hi mom
Nobody asked for your overrated opinion on anything.
This came out right after I got my BB58 blue. I love it! But I love my BB58 blue. I totally would have considered this Pelagos instead, though. And the bracelet is better.
I love my BB58 blue…
That's because your wrists are SO small you will easily be able to wear it in your tiny little 'Dolls House of Watches' 🤷♂
It is by far my favorite Tudor ! Have also the BB chrono and the Ranger
Tudor listens to their consumers. That's why I have purchased every modern Tudor since the release of the black bay 41. Every watch geek wanted a smaller dive watch in a material that is lighter and less scratch resistant. A better bracelet because they didn't like the look, a better clasp with a extension. Tudor gave the clients all this in this release, but it doesn't matter what they release, every watch geek think they know better and find negatives. I personally think it's an amazing watch. Thanks Teddy for the great review.
Thanks for watching, Richard! Thanks for sharing your perspective as an passionate Tudor buyer!
They wanted a material that was less scratch resistant ? 🤔
@@ShashankD137 THEY dont like to have advanced scratch resistant.coating on titanium, like duratec, dlc, etc. ... to keep THEIR adventure marks, I think.
Can we hear more about the Murph 38? I’d like to know why it’s better than the automatic khaki field, to justify the price, besides that I like the way it looks more than…..😊
I want to know the rest of your watch collection
I haven't worn or purchased a watch since my high school Nixon. This year I bought a Pelagos 39 and wear it everyday.
Grab this watch more times then my Tag and others! It is so nice and fits well!
Is the bracelet (links and clasp) really that sharp that it can cut or scratch something?
Got myself one a month ago. Can't stop wearing it on the rubber strap. Absolutely love it
Have owned the P39 four months now and I do not want to wear anything else from my collection, great fit and love the dial, very legible and love the white and black contrast.
I imagine it would make for a great 1 watch collection (even though we all know there is no such thing).
Not that I'm suggesting 'get one and sell everything else you have'. Just that, if a friend or colleague suddenly became a watch nut and told me their budget was enough to include this as an option, right now, it's the one I would recommend.
Especially after comments like this. Thanks.
I am on a waiting list for a Rolex sub and gave up, bought the 42mm Pelagos this year and so far it was the best decision, I am so happy with Tudor I just bough the 1926 two tone in 41mm and same result, I have 2 watches that are totally different look amazing and still cost less than one Rolex
Excellent choice!
Great decision! Rolex sub also has a crazy msrp nowadays. There are a lot of other options at a similar price level which you can instantly get without a waitling list.
@@key4duty I wanted the Rolex for the brand reputation but to pay the crazy price supper happy with my decision I got 2 watches associated with Rolex and at a lower price than one Rolex. Definitely would recommend Tudor as a brand
They really nailed the design. The dial is perfectly balanced. The square hour markers are fantastic and unique giving it a vintage feel. The snowflake hands suit the hour markers exceptionally well. The understated matte look is utilitarian and functional. Submariner is beefy and shiny where this is like the Rolex Explorer. A classic for times to come.
They just need some dial from GS, it will be an MVP
If they would ever drop the diamond on the hour hand I would be right there with you. As Tudor sits right now, I think they are ugly and turn me away from ever thinking about them. As Mr Wonderful always says, it’s about the dial, and Tudor needs work
@@jimbobsmith2496 he also thinks he’s getting his money back from FTX so maybe Mr wonderful isn’t always right
@@AndrewJohn4A I agree he isn’t always right, but watches start with the dial, he is not wrong there. And that doesn’t change my opinion on snowflake hand of the Tudor
I recently picked up my P39. So far I am very pleased with this watch. It feels very high quality and has a modern sharp feel to it that I appreciate. I was slightly concerned about the size of the clasp but on my 17 cm wrist the clasp is center nicely and does not feel too large. My watch runs at around +1 sec per day which is very impressive. For this price you'll be hard pressed to find a better diver.
I popped into my AD a few days after launch to enquire about the P39 and they had one in stock to show people the real thing before selling it. I looked at it and was pretty stunned how different it was from the LHD that I've had for some years. It's so much lighter than the 42. I did notice the long clasp but felt it should be OK (the LHD has quite a long clasp as well) so I registered my interest. A couple of weeks later I had the call so went back and picked it up. Some reviewers have commented negatively on the sunburst dial saying a dive watch should have a matt dial but the sunburst finish is very subtle and in most lighting conditions it look a deep black tone. The bezel has a little more pronounced sunburst effect but works great. The lume is brilliant and I think it's super readable. I had mine sized so the clasp was in the middle (with links removed from either side like all my watch bracelets) and have no issues with it. In summary I have no regrets purchasing the watch. If there was a slight negative it does take some wrist time away from my LHD but it's different enough from its larger sibling I can't bring myself to selling my beloved super comfortable LHD. If anyone has reservations about the sunburst parts or the clasp all I would suggest is going to see one if you can. I do understand that this watch is not for everyone.
Great comment, thanks for sharing bro
Thanks for this comment - v useful. Can I ask what size your wrist is? (TH-cam comment questions are weird sometimes)
@@HydrogenAlpha My wrist size around 6 3/4" I think.
@@Spit87 you are spot on its a fantastic watch
what's a LHD?
I hope they produce the same gorgeous blue dial on the 39mm, as is available on the 42mm. I will definitely buy one then.
It might be worth mentioning, that scratches on Titanium Grade II are much less notable as on Titanium Grade V. Plus scratches on Titanium Grade II on the Pelagos can easily be hidden by the blue side of a conventional eraser.
I like it, waiting for the blue version to come out as a 39mm. Hope they releases variant color option for this model at that size.
I think this will be the first Tudor in my collection. I really hope they release this in the matte blue of the larger pelagos, maybe even leaving off the sunburst finish, that would be my perfect watch!
I love this watch. Very high on my next watch radar.
Just bought one today. Was having trouble deciding between a bb58 and the pelagos, but decided I wanted something that chose function over form. And something that appeared a little less flashy. I hope it lives up to all the great reviews.
Yes, Tudor delivers on what ppl like, do not forget we are a small collecting community so should be happy of them. BB and Pelagos is two interesting ranges that do live in harmony. Good for Tdr and good for us
Excellent offering from Tudor! Too small for me but excited to see what Tudor has planned for the future!
I love my blue Pelagos 42 that I bought nigh on 3 years ago. I admire it every time I wear it and I do not pamper it either, scratches, whatever, it is a tool watch after all. I even sleep with it on from time to time, the lume is nice to look at. Black bay is for the masses, Pelagos 42 - less so.
I’m loving this watch and with the T fit clasp it fits perfectly, with the Titanium case & bracelet it doesn’t fall off your wrist to the side like a Rolex Sub, its a great timekeeper with great lume. I love the 21mm lug to lug, makes the watch chunkier but I’m with you on the clasp, this is not a dive watch and doesn’t need the dive extension, this is an all round utility/sports watch, apart from the large clasp and maybe a date this watch is just perfect! The other bonus side is you are unlikely to be robbed (especially in UK) as its not a Rolex😉.
I love the Pelagos 39! Since AD's won't let me buy a Submariner, this would be my #1 pick.
I bought this watch a month ago, very striking dial, comfortable to wear. I wish it had a date.
I love my BB58 in Blue and plan to add this to my collection. Titanium, 39mm, and Tudor quality
Interestesting perspectives. Agree on both your perspectives on scratching and depth ratings. Neither are an issue - it's more about how the watch community perceives the watch and the lifestyle branding is divisive for some.
This has just got to be the best looking watch ever, the proportions are just perfect.
Great review! I just saw this watch in person today. I hope Tudor comes out with a 41/42mm version of this watch. Don’t need more than 200m and love the black sunray dial and bezel, plus the thinner case. Smaller clasp and date window would be ideal too.
Absolutely beautiful!!! A steel version and a shorter clasp would have been perfect for me.
Got mine recently and it is glued to my wrist ! I love it apart from 2 things : that fit clasp, especially for my small wrist and a bit of play with the bezel when you push on one side, say at 6, the other side at 12 lifts. Other than that, the rotation is solid !
Wtf that is unacceptable though
@@Sandevistan2020 it's really small but I can definitely feel it. A friend of mine tried it at an AD and it was the same with the exposed pelagos
I own several Rolex but bought this and it’s awesome
Less conspicuous
Titanium is toned down
I wear on grey waxed canvas strap for comfort
No one mentions the floating hands which are spot on too.
I’ve also had the Seiko 65mas which was too sunburst and square lugs shape not refined as this
Teddy, I was watching this and realized that we do not know at all what is your collection like. Would be awesome to make a video with your current collection and the 2, 3 pieces you like to wear the most. Take care !
Teddy, thanks for no-bs content. Love your integrity, as well as this new Pelagos. For the moment I will wait until a blue version is released. Cheers!!
Thanks for watching, Eduardo!
Just received a Ginault Silent Service and, while it does not have the heritage of these others it is both hand finished and better in all ways than any of these others I’ve tried-my opinion of course!
I understand that the 39mm will appeal & fit a lot better on those with a smaller wrist but for me the best Pelagos is the 42mm in blue. I can’t see many people who wear the 42mm buying it. Great review I did enjoy watching. 👍👏👏👏
What I would give for this exact design in a 42 mm! Personally, I like this way better than the larger option
I am waiting on one from my AD. My only concern is the clasp length. I haven't got hands on with one yet but hopefully that won't be an issue for my 6.3" wrist. The new 41mm Sub clasp is just too wide.
Ohhh I was waiting sooo long for Teddy to do a video on Pelagos 39😀😀
I just got this for $2700 used but in great condition. Wasn’t my first choice but couldn’t pass on the deal.
Tudor has had a storied dive watch history going back to the snowflake days and the French navy. It's great that Tudor continues that tradition, and is now one of the most desirable Swiss watches on the market.
It is an incredible piece indeed, I have a 16.5 cm wrist and that is really good presence but still stealthy , excellente video thank you Teddy.
It's a great watch, I've tried one on. Really liked it, but for me, I'm waiting for the blue version to come out.
I have the 42mm black version,and I really likes the sunray bezel.I just wanted atool watch with a great bracelet.
This new Pelagos 39 is the first Tudor I actively put my name down at ADs expressing interest to buy. I ended up getting another watch so I pull my request to those ADs but still. I think it's a homerun. For me it fixed everything that stopped me from getting the larger Pelagos and/or the BB58.
As a person who wore a Speedy Schumacher 03 for 10+ years, this is super tempting. Honestly, the only thing I do not like about the watch is the Titanium. There is something to be said with a weight of a watch and when you are dealing with something as compact as this, the obvious Submariner from Rolex and the higher grade of Ti, I would say it is the only slight miss in the watch. There are so many grades of stainless to consider as well as various alloys thereof. Maybe it is me, but I like the feel of the weight of the watch I pick. That is not to take away from this watch nor anyone else's choice. When you think about having 2-3 watches in your collection, you really want to make sure it is something that is wearable as both a piece of art, a time piece, and to a lesser degree a subtle nuance to what you are like as a person. Absolutely beautiful time piece. Love the red. Would have liked to see a bit more game in the palladium, rhodium, stainless steel, chromium, cobalt and other alloys. I work in med-tech. Metal selection has a human factor element that is so important. Bring it over Tudor.
Thanks for measuring the clasp length! (46mm.) I spent an embarrassing amount of time on web searches the other day trying to figure that out. It's my one hangup about this watch, and the nearest Tudor AD is over an hour away. Didn't wanna make the trip just to find out whether or not the clasp would swallow my tiny wrist!
I am waiting for Blue Pelagos 39.
Will be possilbe to come out next year?
Best review on the 39 I have seen. Great review on a great watch, I need one.
Bought the P39 a month ago and love it. All my other watches are jealous!
I am a watch estuthiast! I don’t know when but I will buy one!!! Thank you for the outstanding review! Like always you are the Man!
I absolutely love it, everything about it, the only thing is I’d have to see the sunburst bezel insert in the metal as I’ve never seen one like that ever and I’m not sure, as with all things though watches definitely look different in your hand than any video or photos on the web, I do really really love the watch though, 100% my kind of watch, I hope to pull the trigger on one soon, thanks for the excellent video Teddy 👍🏻
I have the a blue 42 , 39 is a bit small and light for my taste. But it is a real nice piece for smaller wrist for sure.
I just miss the date and the blue color. Excellent dimensions overall, except for the lug width.
Fantastic review and great talking points! Thank you
Longines listens to their customers too. they made hydroconquest ceramic bezel 39mm too.
Teddy, thank you for the overview. Do you think the 39mm will ever be offered with a date ?? Thank you.
I really love Tudor. Since I got my Black Bay 41 with the upgraded movement I want more Tudor watches. Next for me will be the new Ranger, I guess:)
Great review. I did not notice the clasp size when I visited my AD; mine should arrive any day - looking fwd to rotation w my BB Pro.
This is the best feel watch you have to try it you won't regret it
What a fantastic video, it fully explained everything I needed to know, I’m definitely getting one, it’s perfect 👍🏻
Looks amazing on wrist. Definitely on my list of watches to own.
Nothing against grade 2 titanium (I have a watch made if this) but a watch in this price range should be grade 5. Also, if the bezel is 40mm, then industry standard is to go with the widest width of either bezel or case for stated dimensions, so this should be called 40mm. Finally, if your wrist size is small, a clasp that long is going to look weird and uncomfortable anytime you rest your hand on anything, like a desk or on your own leg when sitting, and sometimes even when holding your hand up. I went through this with my Omega watches. I started with a 40mm Railmaster that has a long clasp, which for the previously mentioned reasons ruined the fit on my small 6.5 inch wrist. I eventually got rid of that watch and got the Seamaster 57 LE which has a compact clasp and have been happy ever since making the switch. I’m a fan of Tudor watches but I’ll give this one a hard pass. Great review as always. Nobody does it better.
Hmmm when you have a Pelagos LHD..and you try a Pelagos 39..swapping ain’t gonna enter your thoughts..but if you don’t then it’s a great choice..Like almost all Tudors, great watches at good value
Everyone is making a big deal about the clasp but I don't see it as being much of an issue. True, the dive extension is very uncessary especially considering they already lowered the water resistance and removed the helium escape valve. The overall watch is so light though, that the large clasp helps balance it out.
I own a Rolex REF16234 circa 2000….stainless on an oyster bracelet, white gold bezel, rhodium colored face…. I wanted to add a Tudor to my higher end collection and this review has surely helped me to also consider the Pelagos 39…. I also like the Black Bay GMT two tone so come purchase time I’ll have to make a decision. I also own several higher end Seikos, two Tissot PRX Powermatic 80s, a Raymond Weil Parsifal, and many higher end Citzens along with a slew of Casio Gshock and other….. Tudor seems like a nice (and more affordable than Rolex) addition to my collection. Thanks Teddy,
As someone who owns two Black Bay 58s in black and blue, I thought the P39 would be a "can't miss" based on the perfect case dimensions and specs; it went to the top of my short list. But when I tried it on in person, something about it didn't quite click. Couldn't identify what it was, maybe the double sunburst. It felt off though. Sterile. Bottom line: check it out in person and don't just make assumptions based on the specs.
It has no presence - a straight forward tool watch.. I got out from my AD with a BB59 gilt on my wrist for a $1k less than what they asked for the p39 after tax.
This definitely a great watch for smaller wrists. My wrist is right at 7.5", so my blue 42mm Pelagos works just fine, and, well, it's blue... Matte blue, which is a big thing for me.
Really love the P39 but am also considering the BB54 oooor a Seamster 300 in polar or the neovintage 22545000. Besides others;) Great vid btw. Thanks and all the best
I'm all in with Tudor now. Sold my Rolex Submariner and replaced with a Pelagos 42 and a Black Bay Chrono reverse panda.
This watch is absolutely perfect to me the only thing I can actually think that would make this even more perfect is having a dat calendar but then again there would be barely any face difference from the the old one so I also get it
I own several vintage Tudor pieces, I love them but I just don't like the snowflake hands on the newer ones.
2 year wait list. You can’t get it unfortunately. Not in Canada anyway. Great review as always.
It’s a great watch I love the flat crystal and bracelet. It’s a bit small for me but other than that I’m impressed.
Was set on a Black bay pro but this has thrown a spanner in the works! What to go with now?!
Pelagos 39 has been on my short list for months while waiting for a call from Rolex that never came. I had all but removed the 39 from that short list because I was worried about the bezel and dial finish based on the close-up views and lighting of some of the review videos. Once I finally saw it in person today, it did not take me long to pull the trigger. The video reviews of this watch really put a microscope on the finish, in a way that it just does not come across to the naked eye. In person, the finish to the bezel and dial is like "eggshell" to use the terminology of latex interior paint. It's not glossy or even semi-glossy; just one step removed from matte. I think because the size is diminished, it has a more subtle wrist presence that Tudor offset by adding just a wee bit of sheen, while preserving a matte look.
I have a week with mine and haven't worn it yet but I hear a loud grinding noise when winding it after about 10-12 turns, I have experienced this with my other Tudor BB steel version, it not good. I will reach out to my AD this morning. I just past seven days which is the return policy and it's awful
I wished it was slightly bigger 40 would have been spot on for me anyway worth a look
Does the "tail" of the clasp poke out like it did on the older model?
But when is the blue one coming?
If I had to guess why they went with a 21mm lug width, I’d say it’s because a taper to 18mm at the clasp isn’t enough going from 20mm. Or at least, that’s what some would say. But I agree with you, Teddy. I think a 21mm is a swing and a miss. Great video, Teddy. Thanks!
It tapers to 16mm, same as the BB58 which has a 20mm lug width.
I actually think they made a different size so you can't put a bracelet/strap on from another model... the rubber strap comes with a buckle whereas I would have prefered a clasp like the black bay 54's rubber strap....
How about a video covering left-side crown watches? I haven't seen any source that sets out the choices for lefties.
I was very excited about this watch. It hit everything I wanted from a diver, but then... no date. I own a BB36 and really like it, but the no date bugs me often when I look down and it's not there. It's a must now. Except on a dress watch which I wear rarely and care more about being slim with clean symmetrical esthetics than anything.
This watch in blue, with a date, would make a perfect daily driver🤗👌
When I hear the descriptive words “for medium to large wrists” I shy away, I am definitely leaning towards “smaller to medium size wrists” I have a 7 inch wrist and love 38mm with a lug to lug of around 47mm
How much does the 39 weigh?
And its predecessor?
Predecessor is titanium?? Or just some of the predecessors?!
I just ordered one. The closest competitor to my taste is the upcoming Yema Superman Steel 39mm with in-house manufacture movement.
Stunning watch P39..I also own pre ceramic ..Rolex Sub really wear my sub ...says alot
I've had this watch for a week and love it. Some bezel back play but I'll wear it for a while longer and see if I can get that fixed. Looks way better in person imo.
Thanks for sharing your personal ownership story, Alex. That certainly helps others looking to buy.
@@TeddyBaldassarreThis is not something I encounter at all. I have one and the bezel is very crisp in its movement. Worth getting looked at by Tudor.
@@KFen10 oh yeah a little to much back play at this price point imo. Once I'm out of the honeymoon phase I'll bring it in. No rush, the warranty is 5yrs 😊
I'm all in if they release a blue version. Fully blue or black dial with a blue bezel
Love my Pelagos 39. Perfect diver for a guy that doesn’t keep his diver watches
Not the biggest fan of the snowflake hour hand, but it works so much better compared to the BB due to the square/rectangle indices of the Pelagos imho.
Hope they make a matt blue one will be on the list
P39 is incredible. Point. For me, it's so good it's boring. It's the look no further, one stop shop where I find myself thinking, this could be the most perfect watch on market. And for those that might not like the 21mm Lug width, You'd most likely not be changing that bracelet anytime soon because it's so so good! Great job as always Teddy :-)
my only concern is the lume piece, how long it's gonna last and keep bright color, no turn to yellowish!
Just got mine today. Wish it had no diver extension and smaller clasp (won’t use anyway like 99% of other owners) got the bb58 bronze with t-fit clasp and it’s a much better size and comfort. So I will probably wear it mostly on the provided rubber strap 😅.
Fantastic watch, like wearing it more than any of my Rolex’s.
I'm really hoping they do a blue color release at some point
So hard to find this info. Is the bezel engraved and filled or printed on? Thanks
Just my opinion of course. Think I would rather have the Zodiac Super Sea Wolf. Seems to win all categories except power reserve. (not a big deal.. 30 seconds to set and go)
You can get a not dissimilar look with the certina ds action diver 38mm for a fraction of the price.. They are not tudor but the are a lot of watch for the money.
Always comprehensive and interesting. Another good review, Mr. Baldassarre.
Great video Teddy!
Yes mate, am getting one before Xmas, thanks for the video and positive review, no buyers remorse 😂