Talban gave quarbni this why they got reward this all other sect just eated USA money and made property in uae so they were not sincere with their own people.
Occupied wow. As an Afghan I'm sick and tired of the West systematic propaganda. Allahumulillah peace is restored in Afghanistan. That's why France can't get their hands on €2 billions diamonds in panjshir they started to stage even more media war to start war in panjshir dobthat they get the Diamonds once again
@Shafigh Khalili so you can leave Afghanistan and you can go where you want the borders are open. Or you can simply declare your self stateless. As a pashtoon where we have stopped uou from leaving Afghanistan or calling your self something else? Afghanistan map is very clear, whoever lives in its borders are Afghans, if anyone wish to make their state in afghanistan then it's not allowed you have tried for 20 years with super power you couldn't it. What makes you think you will created a different state inside Afghanistan
Bro I know what u mean wellahi.... this medeas are the great fitna of this time... they are liers propagandists.. I know this because am suffering the same fate as the afghanis , am from Ethiopia and the same journalism is happening...
To be honest its better to leave these people to live as they like & as they want.Its not problem of USA or Russia or China or Uk, leave the people to live please.
@@worldview5433 ironically i see a permanent pattern in the invasion of Russia since napoleonic wars until ww2... Now again i see it in the Graveyard of Empires... It doesnt repeat but it rhymes...😌
Situation in Assam got worstened. China is building village in AP, mass poverty is back in India.Your own GDP per capita is below Bangladesh lol. So where is your lord ram, Krishna at? You still have faith in them??
Taliban in 2021 also has diverse fighters. Compare to 1990's, Taliban in 2021 have Uzbek and Tajik fighters. In 1990s, Taliban fighters is focus on Pashtun only
@@magatism Taliban has broken the arrogance of entire western alliance of NATO .Taliban fought and won against the entire world army and still fighting the western economic terrorism. Taliban terminated the Western terrorism, colonialism and imperialism.
@@asifali-kp7zh The Taliban couldn't even beat the US for 20+ years. It literally took the US withdrawal and help from Pakistan to take the country back.
@@EM33700 ??? Do you read Doha Agreement 2020 ? It is basically USA surrender to Taliban. Also, Pakistan never help Taliban much as for people talks about. After all, Pakistan army is helping Uncle Sam (USA) to destroy Taliban. That is why many Gitmo prisoners is capture by Pakistam
@Jordan you're not wrong taliban is just another piece of fragment mujahideens made by US during cold war with uni soviet But these mujahideen being backstabbed by USA and take their land and resource, no wonder these people angry to US Until now they're still resistance because they're only focused their land and build their nation when ISIS-K attack taliban
@@mirwaisayobi118 Various Powers are using Afghanistan for their own interest and it has made the lives of local Afghans hell. So rich in resources but still they have to beg others for food.
@@amolkhobaragade funny thing it mostly Afgans who are dying there and are starving the west just realized it was wasting time trying to civilize cavemen
it's so sad to see the living condition of the people after billions of dollar spent in the last 20 years, the corruption started from Washington Contractors and it ended in very low level of Afghanistan Government position, if you think it was otherwise, we wouldn't have been in this humanitarian crisis across Afghanistan.
Because America was dumb they should have taken the hint from russia when they tried it some 40yrs prior. Hate to say it but the middle east is not like the rest of the world. those countries are not single culture/nationallly unified people. You will never have a situation like germany after ww2 you will never have a south korea or a japan after a war where the nation rebuilds as a unified people and country and rebounds like nothing happened regardless of whatever new government system they adopt. The middle east a war there will always end in some civil war where unification never happens
The mistakes of the U.S. go back decades. We should have skipped the 1991 Gulf war, and withdrew from the Middle East. The 9/11 attacks would not have happened and the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq would not have happened.
Then they would have just created more FALSE FLAG TERRORIST EVENTS perpetrated on their own people as a justification for ZIONIST MINERAL RAIDS on other poor nations. War for profit needs to manufacture scapegoats to justify their illegal invasions and wars.
@@asifali-kp7zh Well since you think the west is so terrible then do not keep asking for the west's money and help. Grow up and learn to take care of yourselves.
@@1suitcasesal @Janet Wells no one need your money just take your dirty nose out of other peoples affair anyway those aid money is not yours but looted resources from other countries.
Yet the Afgahns who lived there said that even in the 1970s, the Taliban could not occupy the Panjshir Valley, because it was difficult to reach the place and is quite well protected due to its natural endowments . There were still armed Afghans a few months ago who said they would not surrender to the Taliban in any way but there seemed to be too few to defend the valley.
@@adilkhan-yt9op the US have been kicked out only be 3 countries. which is Libya, Vietnam and the unconquerable Afghanistan. meanwhile, pakistan still couldn't free kashmir from the cow worshippers from India lol
As a person who lives in Afghanistan, I see no people other than us afghan among them. And if media of other countries are in favor of afghan people than they should call for unfreezing afghan nation asset to take afghan people out from heading catastrophe and economical collapse.
The problem is that money could end up going to the Tali. Maybe the Tali will completely reform itself and stop being radical because of how scared it is and needs other nation's supports, but that's only because other nations won't give support until we know they're not radical. Basically, if Tali de-radicalize because of wanting support, than the US mission would actually be a success, as the Tali would then modernize and de-radicalize, eventually turning into possibly a democracy. It would be nice if they do this, but that's basically what we've been wanting them to do for 20 years so if they do it's also giving us what we've wanted without us needing to intervene to get it done, which is a win-win for all I guess, but the tali needs to let go of its pride for that to work.
@@thelaymenmuslim4603 Not enough did, but some did, as well as the most ambitious highway project in Afghanistan history was spearheaded by the US. A lot of the benefits that the Tali are going to reap by a much more educated populace and better infrastructure were from the US's attempt to nation-build a democracy. The US failed to create a functioning democracy, but it did benefit Afghanistan and its people in some ways. Further, the start of modernizing the highway system has probably paved the way for China and Pakistan to step in, and they'll take all the credit, we'll see though. Either way, I do agree that a lot of the money was spent inefficiently and lost to corruption, which is one of the reasons I want to be extra careful about how we spend our money abroad now and in the future.
But if you go to Herat and other cities then you might find terrorist Talibans from other countries and that I can prov it with a video. They can’t speak nor Dari or Pashtu so stop talking about whole Afghanistan while you are just in your own city.
USA gave Afghanistan an opportunity to change and improve. They didn't want to improve. 75% of the Afghanistan economy comes from the west. They say that they do not want foreign involvement in their country , so let them now take care of their problems themselves. I hope no one helps them. Let them learn their lesson.
Panjshir valley was safe haven for the all hypocrites and gaining members and terror’s organizations. It’s big last for the western country’s that don’t have opportunity’s to make their evil plan against other citizens in the country. No more hypocrites roots can’t handle in Afghanistan…
Yes, you figured it out and stopped our evil plan to educate afghan women, and to let them know they don't have to act like slaves. Honestly though, the whole world thinks afganistan is filled with weak men now, since they fear a woman being able to compete with them in life.
But why can't they take care of themselves then? They don't want foreign involvement but they want foreign money and help constantly. 75% of Afghanistan's economy comes from aid from foreign governments. Afghanistan needs to grow up and learn to take care of itself. They don't appreciate when others try to help them, so I hope no one helps them. Pain sometimes helps people and countries grow up.
@Osama Binladen I thought you were dead already. You people hate the west but you turn to us for money. You are like spoiled children who refuse to act right and insist on doing everything your own way but when you fail you turn to others for help. How would you feel if you gave to others and tried to help them only to be hated by them? We are tired of caring about thankless Afghans. The time has come for you to grow up and learn the hard way to take care of yourselves. Stop begging for help from others. Pain can teach many lessons in life, including taking responsibility for yourself and your choices and actions. It's called growing up. It's now time for you to stop begging from others and grow up. I wouldn't give you a dime. You choose to be backward so now go live your backwards lives in your backwards country. That's what you want, so that's what you get.
@Osama Binladen Osama, Afghanistan is one of the most backwards countries in the world. The average income is $45 a month, even for a family. You sell your 9 year old daughters to get cash to live on. More than half the population cannot read or write. Do you call that advanced? 🤔
I see soo many corrupted people in this comment section they are really happy that people lost everything they had from their lands to food and their pride which was a better life
@@shrikantmuthuswamy1 one hundred percent But after everything they did to afghanistan again they still do not leave it alone and are trying to make a terrorist group an official government and recognize it
It's funny how they say they check for drugs, while at the same time they are selling drugs to fund their state. And most of the drugs they sell end up in the US.
Not only Americans but whole Europe combined to over 40 nations how taliban kick them out with no air power no tank no missiles no armour vehicles am surprised,
Lmao they are anything but invincible They had only motorcycles and kalashnikov when the government had apache its just that the afghan government was too corrupt and sold out the cities to the taliban and the afghan officials left the country
People from Panjshir is Hero, dead taliban, People fighting for freedom of Panjshir and all Afghanistan free from taliban. I hope my city Panjshir and all Afghanistan from terrorists taliban, taliban is terrorists, the don't school for girls,
un khabees adam besyar insane kasif was murdar bood..berwayn the revolutionary women of afghanistan .org wa dar unja site nami shan ra bepalayn barayatan wazay maloom mashoawad ki cheraqam insan kasif bood....
Only the capital is being occupied, the rest of Panjshir in its mountains are not controlled, many T ban are dying because of ambushes, IED attacks and sniping, now the t ban are moving their dead through the night, they cut the internet to the valley and they banned the media of reporting the fighting that is happening which only grows as several other fronts are opening in other provinces, also Tajikistan is giving access to a military airport and direct support to the process of transfering the former afghan airforce aircraft from Kasagstan to their new base, the Mi6 and indian intelligence services are getting involved. Basically the US planted the liberty seeds in the population and after the corrupt goverment fell they are finally sprouting
😂🤣😂🤣 you watch to much dramas and movies. There is no such thing other country help nrf. All country around the world nowadays are dealing directly with Taliban
Common denominator= Western interference by either directly occupying or using proxy agents to create civil war, chaos & using penalties/sanctions as a weapon. There.
@Shafigh Khalili There had been no need of any help of aid if there had been no imperialism. Arabs are also victim of same imperialism. U talk like a fool with lack of common sense.
Ask why? Because of your western barbarians that invaded major of the Islamic countries for their own interests... I recommend you to do better research next time
France has lost his gold mind and Emerald. So now it's belong to Afghan of course you will make a negative report. It's not free anymore Emerald for France
@@mangsport3273 You are still living in the days of your pedophile prophet, when he raided other tribes for slaves and shiny bling-bling. No modern country is dependent on useless jewellery. Most emerald is mined in Colombia and Zambia, so quit your fairy-tales
@@karlscher5170 that's a different story for a next time. now we are in Afghanistan. ((divide and rule)) is over in Afghanistan for France and their friends
such a tough life for Afhans. All because of the Taliban. They could have been one of the most flourishing new Democratic society's in which yes there would be corruption but more freedoms and opportunities for the people. Instead, the Taliban will lock them into the stone age.
@@shahsaud2625 98.21( 2019) perecnt indian household have toilets while pak have 78 percent so lol see yourself first you mock us cause we had the guts to accept the problem and we eradicated that problem but you 😭😭😭😭😭
was this not occupied when us and nato were forcely controlling?? just focus how save they are now. thousands of childrens and adults killed in foreign occupation but currently murder
Their life expectancy dropped a few years and they are now running out of food while all the girl's schools closed. The taliban literally stopped all trade with the terrorist takeover so now isis fighters are running free all over the country and over 5 million people fled the country.
@@Skman838 Still Religion and state be same, But because you Christian did development after breaking ties, so you think that country can only development when state has no religion, But it is not true.
@@kodvavi150 I’m not Christian and a country needs religion but is should not mix with politics. You need religion but you can’t let it get in the way of politics keep those thing separate .
Where are the Billions in Dollars that almost every Panshiri had a share off??! They stole and sucked almost all huge sums of money from American contractors because they were behaviour was like they owned Afghanistan and panshiris had to have the big slice of everything first. Taliban are being too good to them compared to how they treated Talibs after their downfall in 2001
Does anyone know from a journalistic standpoint the best route to contact them to do a documentary and safely get there? I live in the U.S. and will travel alone there. Any and all help/advice is greatly appreciated.
Travel via Pakistan. Go to Pakistan areas that border Afghanistan. Get some trusted friends. Pakistanis are very hospitable people. Travel legally to Afghanistan via Pakistan. You can go meet the Taliban at their HQ in various cities etc. And you are free to do whatever you want.
Leave them alone. You guys have ruined their lives for 20 years in the name of peace.. trillions spent for distruction only in 20 yrs.. now let them run their business.
anyone can invade a defenseless touristic place whose people have been away from fighting for 25 years but the good news is panjshir hasn't been invaded completely.
Give help to who? Right after the US left the taliban took over, no one did anything. These people apparently prefer to be ruled by the Taliban because they sure as hell don’t seem to want to fight for their country.
@k. u infidel it should not concern you, I’m afghan I go there on holidays I live a better life than you honestly I’m in the UK right now I have businesses and I can buy you if I want to, how much are you worth u inbred?
@@Pyongyang4948 I'm wondering the same thing. Some reports say the NRF got a shipment of sniper rifles. My first question was where was the money coming from to pay for them. Next was that the French were providing them with Black Hawk helicopters. Again my question was how are those helicopters being financed. Here is the thing though: France doesn't fly Black Hawks.
@@bigearl3867 these are all lies of the delusional massoud fans. in Afghanistan, people don't even know them and Twitter statistics show, it's usually always some dudes in India posting stuff about the so-called nrf.
Occupied ?!?! Using that logic, Corsica is occupied by France, many of the banlieues are occupied territories, the Basque regions are occupied. And that’s just Metropolitan France!
Same amount of misery and helplessness can be shown from any part of the world, wether it be france or any other country in europe or usa. The camera and the background narrator can have tailor made effects on viewer minds.
So... Taliban DID capture pansnsjir valley after all. Thought so . All of those resistance guys posing and smiling for cameras were only posers. Goodbye
Massoud Jr is not his father. Massoud Jr does not have war experience. Besides that, Taliban in 2021 is mors powerful than Taliban in 1990's. Taliban 2021 have better weapon and more fighters
@@magatism Media has you roped and on its knees… Go watch Indian news where it is proven that they fake and propagate many news, including “Panjshir resistance”
@@magatism You’re right… You don’t need media… You need pure delusion and pure opium to create assumptions like these. Who’s government did the US back? Why did they overthrow the Taliban govt? With your mindset, there will always be a foreign occupation whether it be the Soviets or the Americans. Tell me… I keep hearing about this “resistance”, but it seems to be in the form of Daesh (ISIS). Tell me… are you a Daesh supporter?
@@adrakss9588 uneducated! Peace come through the Taliban and Humanitarian Crisis come through the champion of Human Rights, Women's Rights and yet champion of peace 'The US' Isn't this the hypocrisy?
so ask french politicians , what have they done in this valley for improving lives or development for people? the answer is 0. ask to your politician. dont create news , use it for better society..
Those people don't threaten anyone in the continent of America. Yankees or Canadians don't need to be in Afghanistan, Afghans should not be here in the continent of America either..
Don't worry , fundamentalist will march to Europe as well. ha ha!! Long live Taliban. Afghanistan is the victory over crusades declared by Bush. Bush said, war in Afghanistan is crusades. But we will not be like crusaders who killed millions of innocent Muslims. This is documented by Western Christian Historian. Saladin has shown the crusaders the meaning of mercy in Jerusalem.
Panjshir Valley after the Taliban takeover: An occupied, impoverished territory"
Let''s not forget the 20 year war waged by the West.
Yeah, these colonial powers love these projections. The title gives the impression Panjshair became impoverished since Taliban took over.
Panjshir is occupied? Really? How low can you get in spreading lies France 24?
Talban gave quarbni this why they got reward this all other sect just eated USA money and made property in uae so they were not sincere with their own people.
Like Paris under president macroni
@@mukhtarb6737 Yeah, it's not like Panshir resisted the Taliban, am I right?
It's not
@k. Yes they are begging but they are not begging for pocket as previous officials used to.
Occupied wow. As an Afghan I'm sick and tired of the West systematic propaganda. Allahumulillah peace is restored in Afghanistan. That's why France can't get their hands on €2 billions diamonds in panjshir they started to stage even more media war to start war in panjshir dobthat they get the Diamonds once again
@Shafigh Khalili so you can leave Afghanistan and you can go where you want the borders are open. Or you can simply declare your self stateless. As a pashtoon where we have stopped uou from leaving Afghanistan or calling your self something else?
Afghanistan map is very clear, whoever lives in its borders are Afghans, if anyone wish to make their state in afghanistan then it's not allowed you have tried for 20 years with super power you couldn't it. What makes you think you will created a different state inside Afghanistan
@UC-YxMH9teYeLE42poOg8_DA you can go to Tajikistan or other countries, no one is stopping you. If you live in Afghanistan you are an Afghan
@Shafigh Khalili
Don't drive Muslims in the name of pashtoon and non padhtoon . You are a racist
@Shafigh Khalili youre indian LOL
You're not Afghan really, across the border?
Panjshir Valley Occupied territory ?? What?? Occupied by whom?? The people of afganistan ?? Great Journalism!
Journalism on a propaganist's journey.
Occupied by isi.. You are a blind batant
@@billubarber1335 ISI?? It's Taliban LoL ! Get some knowledge before teaching others! Dumb 😒
Bro I know what u mean wellahi.... this medeas are the great fitna of this time... they are liers propagandists.. I know this because am suffering the same fate as the afghanis , am from Ethiopia and the same journalism is happening...
@@salahhalas6732 exactly!
To be honest its better to leave these people to live as they like & as they want.Its not problem of USA or Russia or China or Uk, leave the people to live please.
Yes just return what belong to them. Stop blaming taliban failure if their money were taken away. Pay them what belong to them.
Well it will be an issue if Heroin Production increases.
@@Sieffre_Tawr as opposed to when the west was in charge?
@@najlasaleh6503 when exactly was the West in charge?
@@Sieffre_Tawr NATO for the past 20 years
Marseilles looks like occupied territory to me which must be liberated from the racist regime of Macron
Maybe Omicron will eliminate macron
@@c0detearz320 LMAOOO
what you mean "occupied"? they're the government of the country, it's their right to control all the territory
They destroyed the government in an unlawful way. Destroying women rights and other religious minorities.
@@cutieeefiaaa3625 you have deltarune profile picture so your opinion is invalid
THE LOCAL PEOPLE WANTED FREEDOM NOT SCUMBAG TALIBAN. FREE PANSHIER
Your profile picture represent muhmad, quite funny.🤪🤪
@@NBrioDaZueraRules What? You can't do that.
Keep having faith in Allah, the same who has put them in this situation.
I wonder how France feel after U.S.A., Great Britain, and Australia betrayed her... 😗
You're right, world view.
@@ihsanamsal2947 in geopolitics nothing is permanent.
@@worldview5433 ironically i see a permanent pattern in the invasion of Russia since napoleonic wars until ww2... Now again i see it in the Graveyard of Empires... It doesnt repeat but it rhymes...😌
Situation in Assam got worstened. China is building village in AP, mass poverty is back in India.Your own GDP per capita is below Bangladesh lol. So where is your lord ram, Krishna at? You still have faith in them??
Taliban in 2021 also has diverse fighters. Compare to 1990's, Taliban in 2021 have Uzbek and Tajik fighters. In 1990s, Taliban fighters is focus on Pashtun only
@@magatism Taliban has broken the arrogance of entire western alliance of NATO .Taliban fought and won against the entire world army and still fighting the western economic terrorism. Taliban terminated the Western terrorism, colonialism and imperialism.
@@magatism 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@magatism 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@asifali-kp7zh The Taliban couldn't even beat the US for 20+ years. It literally took the US withdrawal and help from Pakistan to take the country back.
@@EM33700 ??? Do you read Doha Agreement 2020 ? It is basically USA surrender to Taliban. Also, Pakistan never help Taliban much as for people talks about. After all, Pakistan army is helping Uncle Sam (USA) to destroy Taliban. That is why many Gitmo prisoners is capture by Pakistam
Go ask Massoud or USA to give money aid back belong to afghan people.
You don’t have money, that’s US and infidel’s money .You don’t have equity, you were living with free US and infidels aid all those time.
Usa the one start to invaded afghan and destroyed the country how come u said so.
@Jordan usa ceated isis its usa fault
@Jordan you're not wrong taliban is just another piece of fragment mujahideens made by US during cold war with uni soviet
But these mujahideen being backstabbed by USA and take their land and resource, no wonder these people angry to US
Until now they're still resistance because they're only focused their land and build their nation when ISIS-K attack taliban
@k. Damn... You're really hate Afghanistan what afghan people did to you, mate?
Respect to Afghanistan - the graveyard of empires.
Graveyard for its own people too.
@@mirwaisayobi118 Various Powers are using Afghanistan for their own interest and it has made the lives of local Afghans hell. So rich in resources but still they have to beg others for food.
Graveyard of WESTERN empires.
@@amolkhobaragade funny thing it mostly Afgans who are dying there and are starving the west just realized it was wasting time trying to civilize cavemen
@@mirwaisayobi118 afghanistan is THE GRAVEYARD OF EMPIRES.... HATE IT OR NOT.
Occupied? This is what happens when English is not your first language.
yes the editor appears biased to the bones
People are commenting here like they're witnessing what is happening in Afghanistan
it's so sad to see the living condition of the people after billions of dollar spent in the last 20 years, the corruption started from Washington Contractors and it ended in very low level of Afghanistan Government position, if you think it was otherwise, we wouldn't have been in this humanitarian crisis across Afghanistan.
Because America was dumb they should have taken the hint from russia when they tried it some 40yrs prior. Hate to say it but the middle east is not like the rest of the world. those countries are not single culture/nationallly unified people. You will never have a situation like germany after ww2 you will never have a south korea or a japan after a war where the nation rebuilds as a unified people and country and rebounds like nothing happened regardless of whatever new government system they adopt. The middle east a war there will always end in some civil war where unification never happens
FAHRT!
There is nothing there to make it great. It is a barren wasteland. Near the rivers is ok but there is so little you have to kill for it.
The locals never saw a dime.
The mistakes of the U.S. go back decades. We should have skipped the 1991 Gulf war, and withdrew from the Middle East. The 9/11 attacks would not have happened and the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq would not have happened.
west wants to impose its sick ideology of satanism, libralism, nudity, adultery, homosexualty, alcohol etc etc. on us muslims.
Then they would have just created more FALSE FLAG TERRORIST EVENTS perpetrated on their own people as a justification for ZIONIST MINERAL RAIDS on other poor nations. War for profit needs to manufacture scapegoats to justify their illegal invasions and wars.
True
@@asifali-kp7zh Well since you think the west is so terrible then do not keep asking for the west's money and help. Grow up and learn to take care of yourselves.
@@1suitcasesal @Janet Wells no one need your money just take your dirty nose out of other peoples affair anyway those aid money is not yours but looted resources from other countries.
Yet the Afgahns who lived there said that even in the 1970s, the Taliban could not occupy the Panjshir Valley, because it was difficult to reach the place and is quite well protected due to its natural endowments .
There were still armed Afghans a few months ago who said they would not surrender to the Taliban in any way but there seemed to be too few to defend the valley.
They lied to you..
They got sold out like the rest of the country by the scummy president
America has been kicked out of 109 countries and lost all the wars 😂😂😂😂
@@adilkhan-yt9op the US have been kicked out only be 3 countries. which is Libya, Vietnam and the unconquerable Afghanistan. meanwhile, pakistan still couldn't free kashmir from the cow worshippers from India lol
Im from Afghanistan and i can tell you 100% pakistan air force was involved other wise talibans wouldn’t be able to conquer panjshir
As a person who lives in Afghanistan, I see no people other than us afghan among them. And if media of other countries are in favor of afghan people than they should call for unfreezing afghan nation asset to take afghan people out from heading catastrophe and economical collapse.
The problem is that money could end up going to the Tali. Maybe the Tali will completely reform itself and stop being radical because of how scared it is and needs other nation's supports, but that's only because other nations won't give support until we know they're not radical. Basically, if Tali de-radicalize because of wanting support, than the US mission would actually be a success, as the Tali would then modernize and de-radicalize, eventually turning into possibly a democracy. It would be nice if they do this, but that's basically what we've been wanting them to do for 20 years so if they do it's also giving us what we've wanted without us needing to intervene to get it done, which is a win-win for all I guess, but the tali needs to let go of its pride for that to work.
@@b.ballooon9225 and US money get into afghan people when they rule??? Pffftttt
@@thelaymenmuslim4603 Not enough did, but some did, as well as the most ambitious highway project in Afghanistan history was spearheaded by the US. A lot of the benefits that the Tali are going to reap by a much more educated populace and better infrastructure were from the US's attempt to nation-build a democracy. The US failed to create a functioning democracy, but it did benefit Afghanistan and its people in some ways. Further, the start of modernizing the highway system has probably paved the way for China and Pakistan to step in, and they'll take all the credit, we'll see though. Either way, I do agree that a lot of the money was spent inefficiently and lost to corruption, which is one of the reasons I want to be extra careful about how we spend our money abroad now and in the future.
But if you go to Herat and other cities then you might find terrorist Talibans from other countries and that I can prov it with a video. They can’t speak nor Dari or Pashtu so stop talking about whole Afghanistan while you are just in your own city.
@@arrahimi9774 bro half these people aren’t even Afghan they’re Pakistani Taliban supporters.
This how USA left Afghanistan after 20 years of occupation.
Its been like this since the 80s bro.
@@Fummy007 yeah thats why U s british russian left Trulli spiriit.😁😊🦾
More like this is how life has always been under the Taliban.
USA gave Afghanistan an opportunity to change and improve. They didn't want to improve. 75% of the Afghanistan economy comes from the west. They say that they do not want foreign involvement in their country , so let them now take care of their problems themselves. I hope no one helps them. Let them learn their lesson.
@@1suitcasesal imbeciles always speak as if they are experts
Afghans occupying Afghanistan, interesting…
Not all Afghans support the Taliban...
@@Marie-fx2qp yeah, nearly 5% dont Support
@@KABKAKIy_KAPATEJI_DOP higher but sure
@@Marie-fx2qp as an Afghan, stfu, we support them
@@SpeedKing.. your very rude for a Afghan, anyway all I said is not everyone supports them..
Panjshir valley was safe haven for the all hypocrites and gaining members and terror’s organizations.
It’s big last for the western country’s that don’t have opportunity’s to make their evil plan against other citizens in the country.
No more hypocrites roots can’t handle in Afghanistan…
Yes, you figured it out and stopped our evil plan to educate afghan women, and to let them know they don't have to act like slaves. Honestly though, the whole world thinks afganistan is filled with weak men now, since they fear a woman being able to compete with them in life.
It seems that France is paying back for the friendship with Ahmed Masood
Afghanistan don't like foreigner involvement
But why can't they take care of themselves then? They don't want foreign involvement but they want foreign money and help constantly. 75% of Afghanistan's economy comes from aid from foreign governments. Afghanistan needs to grow up and learn to take care of itself. They don't appreciate when others try to help them, so I hope no one helps them. Pain sometimes helps people and countries grow up.
But they want money
@Osama Binladen I thought you were dead already. You people hate the west but you turn to us for money. You are like spoiled children who refuse to act right and insist on doing everything your own way but when you fail you turn to others for help. How would you feel if you gave to others and tried to help them only to be hated by them? We are tired of caring about thankless Afghans. The time has come for you to grow up and learn the hard way to take care of yourselves. Stop begging for help from others. Pain can teach many lessons in life, including taking responsibility for yourself and your choices and actions. It's called growing up. It's now time for you to stop begging from others and grow up. I wouldn't give you a dime. You choose to be backward so now go live your backwards lives in your backwards country. That's what you want, so that's what you get.
@Osama Binladen Osama, Afghanistan is one of the most backwards countries in the world. The average income is $45 a month, even for a family. You sell your 9 year old daughters to get cash to live on. More than half the population cannot read or write. Do you call that advanced? 🤔
It's not just panjshir valley,also the people they love their land and they proud people
I see soo many corrupted people in this comment section they are really happy that people lost everything they had from their lands to food and their pride which was a better life
Pakistan is the reason for Afghan people's misery
@@shrikantmuthuswamy1 not just Pakistan
@@shrikantmuthuswamy1 one hundred percent
But after everything they did to afghanistan again they still do not leave it alone and are trying to make a terrorist group an official government and recognize it
@@Cruelrevolter dude , indian people's prayers are with you 🙏 ❤
@@anujagrawal306 thank you man we and our country loves you ❤
Talibans are Afghans and it was occupied by the west for the past 20 years so don't report nonsense 🙄
I was laughing when they say we can take panjshir in two days ...but they did it
😉
Pakistan army has helped Taliban to takeover panjshir by supplying drones and pakistan airforce has help to takeover panjshir
@@saikrishnasaikrishna9914 lol 😁😁😁
It's not cleared but it's cleared indian army and agencies were backing courroupt ghani government...
@@saikrishnasaikrishna9914 major amir liquat helped them
They're proud of Afghanistan so let them starve there if they chose to, its not the problem of anyone else.
It's funny how they say they check for drugs, while at the same time they are selling drugs to fund their state. And most of the drugs they sell end up in the US.
They can sell the weapons they have taken from running US army!
Taliban seems invincible......They defeated Soviet union , America and Lastly Captured panjshir valley......
Not only Americans but whole Europe combined to over 40 nations how taliban kick them out with no air power no tank no missiles no armour vehicles am surprised,
Lmao they are anything but invincible
They had only motorcycles and kalashnikov when the government had apache its just that the afghan government was too corrupt and sold out the cities to the taliban and the afghan officials left the country
Because it s an Ideology
they hid in caves every time
Well the Taliban at least prove it to the world
People from Panjshir is Hero, dead taliban, People fighting for freedom of Panjshir and all Afghanistan free from taliban. I hope my city Panjshir and all Afghanistan from terrorists taliban, taliban is terrorists, the don't school for girls,
That's all you care about in the end? School for girls? Don't you think the country has bigger things to focus on at the moment?
Lol ignorant 😃
Do you even know what the word terrorist means
un khabees adam besyar insane kasif was murdar bood..berwayn the revolutionary women of afghanistan .org wa dar unja site nami shan ra bepalayn barayatan wazay maloom mashoawad ki cheraqam insan kasif bood....
Only the capital is being occupied, the rest of Panjshir in its mountains are not controlled, many T ban are dying because of ambushes, IED attacks and sniping, now the t ban are moving their dead through the night, they cut the internet to the valley and they banned the media of reporting the fighting that is happening which only grows as several other fronts are opening in other provinces, also Tajikistan is giving access to a military airport and direct support to the process of transfering the former afghan airforce aircraft from Kasagstan to their new base, the Mi6 and indian intelligence services are getting involved. Basically the US planted the liberty seeds in the population and after the corrupt goverment fell they are finally sprouting
😂🤣😂🤣 you watch to much dramas and movies. There is no such thing other country help nrf. All country around the world nowadays are dealing directly with Taliban
Hahaha Panjsher has been fallen
Don't worry It is safe my Tajik dude
Only india, who believe panjshir still fighting, and only india believe serena hotel have 5th floor hahaha
Khorasan will have its freedom one day from Pashtun (Afghan) occupation, and Panjshir will lead it
@@sasukeuzumaki3608 😂🤣😂😑😑🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂
Its Liberation, not occupied..
Occupied by ethnic pashto, educated in pakistan men.
@@Fummy007 nope freed
THREE LOCAL RESIDENTS DONT WANT THEM
@@Fummy007 Created by USA themselves.
@@Fummy007 Afghans are mostly pashtun and Afghanistan governors has always been a pashtun.
Humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan, Syria, Yemen, Iraq, Somalia ..... There is something common among all these places. That is the problem.
Common denominator= Western interference by either directly occupying or using proxy agents to create civil war, chaos & using penalties/sanctions as a weapon. There.
@Shafigh Khalili There had been no need of any help of aid if there had been no imperialism. Arabs are also victim of same imperialism. U talk like a fool with lack of common sense.
And it is called pislam
@Shafigh Khalili whitout the west they☠☠and i really do not care for it let them
@@user-pi4su6je8p Exactly. You answered with common sense besides those people that responded with hate to a religion...
Afghanistan was a land of abundant milk and honey before Taliban takeover!
Really? Hahaha. You are so silly.
Shame on u ignorant
Show me one Islam country apart from the oil owners where there is affluence and peace. There are none. Says it all.
Malaysia
indonesia
@@CometZ same for Indonesia
Ask why? Because of your western barbarians that invaded major of the Islamic countries for their own interests... I recommend you to do better research next time
@@khybar17 no bc everey were there is pislam there is war
Indeed,God is Great
@Shafigh Khalili Hindu talking like I eat cowd
@Shafigh Khalili another day another racist indian seen, you guys are ruining the image of indians
@@CometZ he is not a madarsechaap
@@CometZ his name is like the least Indian name I’ve seen lmao. Idk how u concluded he was indian.
France has lost his gold mind and Emerald. So now it's belong to Afghan of course you will make a negative report. It's not free anymore Emerald for France
What are you even babbling?
@@karlscher5170 you know what I'm babbling. Emerald too expensive when you pay for it. when you get it free and it's over. It's really hard
@@mangsport3273 You are still living in the days of your pedophile prophet, when he raided other tribes for slaves and shiny bling-bling. No modern country is dependent on useless jewellery. Most emerald is mined in Colombia and Zambia, so quit your fairy-tales
@@karlscher5170 that's a different story for a next time. now we are in Afghanistan. ((divide and rule)) is over in Afghanistan for France and their friends
@@mangsport3273 Yes and if the afghan people are starving they only can blame themselves or their taliban rulers
some of them have the kindest faces
they are beautiful people
This country is hopeless. Just leave it be.
True and only a miracle can change the destiny of my country 😢
@@arrahimi9774 stay strong man.
@@HR-lm3jh Really hard to do that but I will try and hope the best for the poor people of my country 💔
Is there COVID there ? Doesn’t seem like COVID did anything to this guys lmaooooo
Look at that. The place has become more peaceful now.
As long you take guns
With Gun.....Without food .....
@@saneeshvr6147 without toilets..oh wait ..that's India
such a tough life for Afhans. All because of the Taliban. They could have been one of the most flourishing new Democratic society's in which yes there would be corruption but more freedoms and opportunities for the people. Instead, the Taliban will lock them into the stone age.
@@shahsaud2625 98.21( 2019) perecnt indian household have toilets while pak have 78 percent so lol see yourself first you mock us cause we had the guts to accept the problem and we eradicated that problem but you 😭😭😭😭😭
Panjshir is not occupied. It is under control of government (Taliban). Plz correct the title
How can you occupy something you own?
They dont
They are illogical.
Alhamdolillah Afghanistan is free.
@@jadendrysdale8864 they own you and the whole of afghanistan. As a matter of fact, they own the whole world
@@Afgballer 😂
@@Afgballer most of you guy's ran away to foreign countries now your sat behind a screen giving it the big spuds about you own the world 🤣
People of Painjshir is not whit TERRORISTS
Yes, They are Hero's, No doubt!
Please also talk about occupied Kashmir next door. Worst human rights abuses going on their right now
was this not occupied when us and nato were forcely controlling?? just focus how save they are now. thousands of childrens and adults killed in foreign occupation but currently murder
Improvished. Just the same as 3 months ago under American occupation
Twenty years and trillions of dollars spent, and nothing accomplished by the U.S. war in Afghanistan.
Their life expectancy dropped a few years and they are now running out of food while all the girl's schools closed. The taliban literally stopped all trade with the terrorist takeover so now isis fighters are running free all over the country and over 5 million people fled the country.
Panjsheer was never an independent country it was an integral part of Afghanistan.
Still Western Media Crieing, ask USA what they did in 20 years.
major spelling mistakes
This is why religion and politics should not mix
If this is wrong, then Why Muslim ruled world for 800 years in past with same Shariah Law?
@@kodvavi150 well I don’t know what to tell you this is a modern society the old ways are not always the answer.
@@Skman838 Still Religion and state be same, But because you Christian did development after breaking ties, so you think that country can only development when state has no religion, But it is not true.
@@kodvavi150 I’m not Christian and a country needs religion but is should not mix with politics. You need religion but you can’t let it get in the way of politics keep those thing separate .
@@kodvavi150 countries can also develop with religion you just need to keep it balanced not more but just balanced
Perfect example how own country people are destroyed own country without any thought.
RUN US RUN 😀😀😀
With india 😂😂😂😂😂
Are we just going to ignore how the west bombed the country?
Where are the Billions in Dollars that almost every Panshiri had a share off??!
They stole and sucked almost all huge sums of money from American contractors because they were behaviour was like they owned Afghanistan and panshiris had to have the big slice of everything first.
Taliban are being too good to them compared to how they treated Talibs after their downfall in 2001
Does anyone know from a journalistic standpoint the best route to contact them to do a documentary and safely get there? I live in the U.S. and will travel alone there. Any and all help/advice is greatly appreciated.
You will probably need backing from a big news network to be deemed as valid to local authorities.
Travel via Pakistan. Go to Pakistan areas that border Afghanistan. Get some trusted friends. Pakistanis are very hospitable people. Travel legally to Afghanistan via Pakistan. You can go meet the Taliban at their HQ in various cities etc. And you are free to do whatever you want.
If your documentary is for positivity, you can easily get to afghanistan via Pakistan
You are welcomed. We can support and guide you. We look forward to being asked for more Information.
It depends.
Do you wish to portray *THE* truth or *THEIR* truth?
These guys seem reasonable; basically traditional Afghan standards. It’s not for outsiders to tell them how to run the country.
Yes true all the love for Afghanistan
Yep, Tajik Panjshir is now occupied by Pashtun Talibs. You are right.
you want to know the real story behind your hero go rawa dot org and search for his name ...
This newscaster needs to learn how to pronounce English words and then be a news broadcaster
Leave them alone. You guys have ruined their lives for 20 years in the name of peace.. trillions spent for distruction only in 20 yrs.. now let them run their business.
The Islam effect - keeping people oppressed whilst resisting the benefits of the progress and the freedom that the rest of us enjoy.
Afghans paid heavy price for the wars and foreign accupation atleast now onwards they live in peace and unity.
Where this story come from
Or Afghanistan- Their own graveyard.
Tell the rest of the world how reverting back to the stone age works for you...
Shut up
@@__-si9ux go bang some rocks together
@@driftjunkie6978 have you ever washed your shiitholess instead of wiping
@@driftjunkie6978 🐂💩🇺🇸
What do you mean by occupied?
The boys of khurasaan it’s time to March for peace and makes people humble.
is this star wars?
anyone can invade a defenseless touristic place whose people have been away from fighting for 25 years but the good news is panjshir hasn't been invaded completely.
Been nice if you protected the lady's identity
why doesn't FRANCE give them help.......because like all countries, no gives a crap.
Give help to who? Right after the US left the taliban took over, no one did anything. These people apparently prefer to be ruled by the Taliban because they sure as hell don’t seem to want to fight for their country.
Afghanistan is occupied by afghani:-typical western media😀
There are different of ethnicities and different believes so yes. Afgans occupying Afghanistan.
yes, they are occupying panjsheer
Dejen a los talibanes tranquilos no los jodan , Asia no necesita de la ONU para resolver sus problemas .
Long live Islamic Emirates of Afghanistan 🏳️
Blane Beijing Xiden
The USA had Afghanistan under control with only 2500 men
so the customer & the shopkeeper said totally opposite things!!
The valley has not fallen mate its not conquered!!
Mate it’s been conquered months ago by the Taliban, where is your puppet massoud? The Taliban crushed the NRF
@k. u infidel it should not concern you, I’m afghan I go there on holidays I live a better life than you honestly I’m in the UK right now I have businesses and I can buy you if I want to, how much are you worth u inbred?
Congrats Taliban, looks everything now in order anf got improvement . Hope got some countries willing to help them in economies.
You know there’s been hundered of isis attacks against them hahahaha terror sympathiser
@@connorwilson8078 facts and talibans are still fighting with the NFR
@Osama Binladen What happened to your Al Qaeda brothers Mr Osama?
"Help them in economies" means handing out free money?
@Osama Binladen "We"= muslim states? Ok, nobody is preventing you from giving money to whoever you like.
And yet the NRF has daily reports about victories against the Taliban. Both can't be right.
Not certain if they even exist
@@Pyongyang4948 I'm wondering the same thing. Some reports say the NRF got a shipment of sniper rifles. My first question was where was the money coming from to pay for them.
Next was that the French were providing them with Black Hawk helicopters. Again my question was how are those helicopters being financed.
Here is the thing though:
France doesn't fly Black Hawks.
@@bigearl3867 these are all lies of the delusional massoud fans. in Afghanistan, people don't even know them and Twitter statistics show, it's usually always some dudes in India posting stuff about the so-called nrf.
@@bigearl3867 it’s all false info , If it’s not in the main tv channels then it’s not true
@@Pyongyang4948 bro are you from afghanistan, are you currently living their?
Its a beautiful heaven on earth waiting for world with explorer eyes.
where is ahmed massoud
The president of Afghanistan? That guy just ran away from the country 😂😂
@@GrandGamesReviews no?
@@robertmugabe5727 yes he did.
u better speak of the *occupied paris* with your socalled *yellow vests* :)
France24 you should do your homework panjshir is not occupied it is part of the Afghanistan
Occupied ?!?! Using that logic, Corsica is occupied by France, many of the banlieues are occupied territories, the Basque regions are occupied. And that’s just Metropolitan France!
the white colonist americans occupy the native americans land too !
yes, but panjshir doesn't WANT to be a part of afghanistan. Yes, this is the very definition of occupation
@@jegge5336That's pure nonsense. Panjshir didn't even declare independence.
God has blessed these people with bad judgement.
😛😛😛😛
Haha ha
Stop forcing our people not to wear niqab
wwhat
Question: how do they pay for those high end Toyota trucks?
Same amount of misery and helplessness can be shown from any part of the world, wether it be france or any other country in europe or usa. The camera and the background narrator can have tailor made effects on viewer minds.
How is the old guy saying nothing has changed under one or the other.
Graveyard of empires? Big no! It is graveyard of its own people. It's destiny has been plagued after the fall of Kabul shahi dynasty!
You didn't report Taliban causality in panjshir heights.
So... Taliban DID capture pansnsjir valley after all. Thought so . All of those resistance guys posing and smiling for cameras were only posers. Goodbye
conclusion😂😂🤣 so Taliban are capable of security, that’s all they had to say
Massoud Jr is not his father. Massoud Jr does not have war experience. Besides that, Taliban in 2021 is mors powerful than Taliban in 1990's. Taliban 2021 have better weapon and more fighters
@@magatism They only exist on twitter.
@@magatism Media has you roped and on its knees… Go watch Indian news where it is proven that they fake and propagate many news, including “Panjshir resistance”
@@magatism You’re right… You don’t need media… You need pure delusion and pure opium to create assumptions like these. Who’s government did the US back? Why did they overthrow the Taliban govt? With your mindset, there will always be a foreign occupation whether it be the Soviets or the Americans. Tell me… I keep hearing about this “resistance”, but it seems to be in the form of Daesh (ISIS). Tell me… are you a Daesh supporter?
We are not Afghan we are Tajiks in Afghanistan 60 %Tajiks 17 %Afghan
Brother we Tajik+Pashtun+Usbek+all = Afghan Muslim's.
Now, Please brother, forget the past and start new life.
60% tajik? Can you really count? Afghan is mostly Pashtuns.
It really looks peacefull🥰🥰🥰
It looks peaceful but if economic problems continue unrest will once again brew
Yes its so peaceful that they dont need any help
Yeah surely does, “peaceful and welcoming” as long as you’re a radical extremist, a religious fanatic with no morals and respect for human rights
@@adrakss9588 uneducated! Peace come through the Taliban and Humanitarian Crisis come through the champion of Human Rights, Women's Rights and yet champion of peace 'The US'
Isn't this the hypocrisy?
Nothing positive to report?
How come they let you in?
"Occupied" lol
How can the government of a country be occupying it's own territory???
Good to see Taliban Setup Checkpoints to Stop smuggling of Charas and Cocaine
@Persnikitty If they allow having weapon, then people can use that weapon for killing other human beings when people wanted to take revenge.
نعم افغنيستان بلد جميل جداً و ال نس جميل ايظن.
Sad. Very sad. May God bless Afghanistan🙏🙏🙏
Don't need your wishes.
Was controlled by the French !!???
so ask french politicians , what have they done in this valley for improving lives or development for people? the answer is 0. ask to your politician. dont create news , use it for better society..
Those people don't threaten anyone in the continent of America. Yankees or Canadians don't need to be in Afghanistan, Afghans should not be here in the continent of America either..
Don't worry , fundamentalist will march to Europe as well. ha ha!! Long live Taliban. Afghanistan is the victory over crusades declared by Bush. Bush said, war in Afghanistan is crusades. But we will not be like crusaders who killed millions of innocent Muslims. This is documented by Western Christian Historian. Saladin has shown the crusaders the meaning of mercy in Jerusalem.
Bruh, at that time even all Muslim nation will wage war against you
The problem with these bearded guys is that they only concentrate on Men and forgetting the women..
Love you Taliban you are the best ❤️👍💪
😂
Jihadi 😂😂
@@anujagrawal306 Yes alhamdulillah I'm jihadi ❤️
@@kabiljan1890 nothing to be proud of 😂 you literally kill innocents if you are jihadi
@@anujagrawal306 One word social media
The refugees at our borders cheekbones are not sticking out the way the peoples in this towns are.