She has the range to hit all the notes perfectly, and so much more - heart, passion, soul, that brings it to life, makes it her own. Tough song to cover, she nailed it and then some.
I am a 300 pound rough and ugly biker and want you to know this performance brought a tear to my cheek. I have loved this song for many years and also want you to know you really did it justice. I'm also a musician. I refer to ALL the people involved in this production when I say, your are to be commended. Great job.
Jim Collinson Wonderful! Have a look to my channel I have more than 1, 300 videos of kids playing rock music. I'm continually amazed at the performances.
Your comment is really cool! I thought they were awesome! I love that they're doing amazing classic rock. Kids listening to and performing Pink Floyd is hope for our future!
Frmr Christian Definitely! Not all the kids are at her level, but that's the nature of the school - a mixture of ages and skill levels (which don't necessarily correlate.)
How many hours did she spend listening, practicing and rehearsing this? She sounds excellent! A few more years and she can probably belt this out as naturally as breathing.
Her voice has a nice depth and clarity -- unlike most professional singers I've heard try this, who just sound strained and raspy and I can't even listen to it. This is very smooth and beautiful. She has a great voice! And so young. I'm sure she has a bright future in singing.
You must of been too stoned at the concert or you're too stoned now. I seen Pink Floyd 3 times in '88 and 3 times in '94 and you don't know what you're talking about.
It was pretty much an average show, until this song happened and I got goosebumps. It's moments like this that are the reason why I spent a decade shooting _School of Rock_ shows.
@@MidWestConcertVideo2 Crikey, I'd have loved to have been there. Were you involved in the School of Rock filming of California Dreamin'? The lead vocalist on that is a one in a generation talent!
@@MidWestConcertVideo2 Ah, thanks for that. Interesting work. Do check that song out though, it's another goosebumps moment! Have a great Xmas wherever you are! :)
Pete Guard There might be hope for Western Civilization if ALL kids today listened to and those who could performed Pink Floyd - but because they don't and they won't, we're all going to go down with the ship.
Becuase pink floyed is integral to the foundations of western thought. Or something like that. Plato, locke, and pink floyed, the holy western trinity. I like pink floyed as mush as the next guy but I feel like you're being just a tad hyperbolic there.
@@ericliu8434 How many top selling albums did Locke or Plato ever release? Pink Floyd is the crowning achievement of western civilization. The moon landing, and the Internet being second and third respectively
This song is cursed. Absolutely mastered by Clare Torry in like 2 takes on Pink Floyd's classic album "The Dark Side of the Moon". This is one of the best vocal covers I've heard of this song, and it takes serious guts to even attempt it. INCREDIBLE JOB GUYS!!!
She sang all afternoon. Then they asked her to open up, let loose, and she thought she already had. Anyway, we got this. Fun Fact: After all these years she's still pissed off that she was paid as a session muso, and didn't receive any royalties. She tried suing, but got nothing.
I never make comment on TH-cam but have been a fan of the Floyd for over 45 years (am 58years young) and play a bit of piano. This performance is truly remarkable - Great Gig in the Sky is a seminal piece of music and nothingness off a seminal album. Clare Torry, Roger, Richard, Nick and the Flioyd crew would have to be speechless by this performance. Amazing talent guys and what a voice - NEVER give it up, love it, nurture it and live music forever - old school, new school, opera, death metal, country, rap, muliticultural - all of it Highwood School of Rock you are amazing - from aApua New Guinea
Anyone commenting here know how difficult it is to play slide if you have never played it before? Let me answer for you, at any age it is extremely difficult. I have been playing in Pink Floyd tributes for well over a decade now and I still wrestle with the slide parts. Too many people think that Pink Floyd music is real simple to play. Floyd has a feel and if all of the musicians are not in sync, it can get away from them. Whenever people listen to Great Gig they always listen for the singer. Why? Because most of the Great Gig videos here have either Floyd themselves playing the music or an accomplished tribute band. These kids tackled what is in reality a very difficult song for every instrument involved. The dynamics in this song are incredibly difficult, so give these kids a break. They picked a song that people always take for granted, but very few people can actually play.
Besides that, Gilmour plays it on a lap steel which I'd imagine is much different than playing slide on a Les Paul. I'd imagine that getting the same sound out of a Les Paul is well above that kid's skill level, so good on him for giving it a try.
Singer does a nice job and kudos to the kid on keyboards. However, the guitarist just plain sucks, he needs to practice more or give it up. He practically ruins the entire song and drags the other musicians down.
Young lady has a remarkable voice. She must also have tremendous confidence to pull that particular tune off so well. BRAVO! And the other young musicians on stage did a fantastic job. Really really wonderful to see and hear this performance. Lucky it came up on my suggestions.
I remember hearing this many many years ago and it gave me chills. The guys can barely play the tune but this brave girl (now fully grown woman) absolutely crushes it !
she's better than the two singers Roger signed for the tour.. I've heard them, they.. just.. don't interprete the song properly.. they just do it, no feelings involved at all :(
I just spent a few hours listening to "reactions" to Pink Floyd and tribute bands such as Brit Floyd and The Australian Pink Floyd Show. Those bands have been practicing Pink Floyd covers for more than twice as long as these kids have lived. And this was great. I am wonderfully impressed. The singer has an amazing voice. You are all going on an amazing journey for the rest of your lives.
where does anyone get the right to criticize these kids !! this is where it all starts, school bands, basements and garages of course the vocals are good we are born with that instrument so she is ahead on the curve ... it isn't perfect, but its fun and we all enjoyed it ... keep practicing and never give up !! Rock'nRoll \m/
This is now my favorite vocalist... Please continue with lessons...this is vital... You could be a star one day...i am such a fan of your tone...dont quit... Get with some older musicians later...and spread your wings...
To say that she nailed it is unfair to Clare Torry, The Great Gig in The Sky is longer having parts that would require more power and control, but let's be fair, Pink Floyd have 3 or more experienced and talented singers in their concerts working together to achieve something close what Clare did in one studio take; Talullah has a jaw dropping and wonderful voice that gives anyone goosebumps and show to the world that true talent is there to be discovered. She has the voice and potential to be among the legends, she is impressive is the minimum that I can say about her. Great job!
NexySaloon all great singers need discipline. It's not all about going on America's Got Talent. Classical singers practice for many years. They start out with Talent then they practice for years
Amazingly beautiful work ... one of my favorite cuts for sure, she nailed it. I love the history and documentaries around this piece of work also. Probably one the most difficult vocal runs ever performed.
You have to know that the lady vocalist of the original song asked for a financial compensation after this song became a huge hit. She was right I think. Your singer lady - Talullah I think - is absolutely very talented -- many thanks all guys.
Excellent performance of young musicians! Greater than many professionals. The vocalist is gorgeous, she has a great potential. I have loved their respectful version of Pink Floyd's masterpiece. I feel grateful to this young people!
This was the Highwood School of Rock's Progressive Rock show. The Oak Park school just did a Best of Pink Floyd one that was just astonishing and I'm putting videos from that one up now. Uploaded Shine On You Crazy Diamond last night.
I'll see what I can do. I usually put up four full songs from each show, trying to include performances from each kid. If I can get a dozen orders, I'll put up the full show. Currently, I'm 11 short. By the way, I put up another excellent Pink Floyd show in full - the Kansas City SoR doing The Dark Side of the Moon - dressed all in white, with The Wizard of Oz being projected on them! th-cam.com/video/UTJ7JFhLoAU/w-d-xo.html
Wow, just wow. One of my favorite songs ever (I'm a 60++ something). Having heard a lot of versions of this song, many of which were just excruuuuuciating, this young gal has done one of the best renditions I've heard. She does the vocals the way Clare Torrey first did them, true to tune and without the self added "flourishes" that can quickly ruin a live performance by a singer - and so often do. Great job kids.
One of my favorite songs. Nailed it. quite the challenge for the young lady to do the vocals on her own. Over the years I have mostly seen 2 or 3 female vocalists sing it, taking turns since its so demanding vocally. Well done. Pink Floyd should be calling her for their next tour.
The singer's name is Talullah Ruff. She is pursuing a career in music, and has her own TH-cam channel.
youtube.com/@TalullahRuff
MidWest Concert Video f
Thanks for the info
This great Vocal
Very good singer like claire torry
She has so much potential in her it will come out later and she will shine
I don’t think people can understand how incredibly difficult this song is to sing .... good to hear youth doing a song from one of the greatest bands
Yea. I was at the concert and was looking around at everyone like do you understand how amazing this is?
Girl singing is awesome
When the vocalist opened up, I literally got chills. Wow.
This song was my mother´s song, which we played at her funeral 2015 at her special request. Many thanks kids for this beautiful performance !!!!!
So sorry for your loss. I lost my mother more than 20 years ago, but I still feel it.
Anch'io ho sempre pensato che vorrei questa canzone al mio funerale?✝️
This girl needs some real good musicians, she's really amazing. Unbelievable, what a voice.
Fully agree with you
She has the range to hit all the notes perfectly, and so much more - heart, passion, soul, that brings it to life, makes it her own. Tough song to cover, she nailed it and then some.
I am a 300 pound rough and ugly biker and want you to know this performance brought a tear to my cheek. I have loved this song for many years and also want you to know you really did it justice. I'm also a musician. I refer to ALL the people involved in this production when I say, your are to be commended. Great job.
Jim Collinson Wonderful! Have a look to my channel I have more than 1, 300 videos of kids playing rock music. I'm continually amazed at the performances.
Your comment is really cool! I thought they were awesome! I love that they're doing amazing classic rock. Kids listening to and performing Pink Floyd is hope for our future!
Clare Torrey always brings a tear to the eye and so did Talullah Ruff. You are in good company kid.
I concur. this man IS ugly. also, she nailed it. well done.
idk about you man, but you look like Gabe Newell
Whoa!
When the girl started singing, I was blown away! Never thought a kid could pull off the vocals on this track, but I stand corrected!
Frmr Christian Definitely! Not all the kids are at her level, but that's the nature of the school - a mixture of ages and skill levels (which don't necessarily correlate.)
I got goose bumps... she has a set of pipes that is for sure. 10x better than Ariana & Katy,
Frmr Christian Sung well, this song just blasts my tear ducts out.
This girl's jam was like tear duct Drain-o, what fantastic pipes on her.
How many hours did she spend listening, practicing and rehearsing this? She sounds excellent! A few more years and she can probably belt this out as naturally as breathing.
Wow!!!....just Wow !!!
Holy shit, that girl has a mind blowing voice on her. I actually teared up when she started singing! Fantastic job!
I was going to comment the same thing
Her voice has a nice depth and clarity -- unlike most professional singers I've heard try this, who just sound strained and raspy and I can't even listen to it. This is very smooth and beautiful. She has a great voice! And so young. I'm sure she has a bright future in singing.
This is better then most guest singers that have attempted it over the years at Floyd concerts. Awesome job!
You must of been too stoned at the concert or you're too stoned now. I seen Pink Floyd 3 times in '88 and 3 times in '94 and you don't know what you're talking about.
She definitely did her homework.
@@cfaria1894
Yes 22/06/88 Versailles
And 2 times Bercy/Paris in 89
That was awesome
Yea not really but this girl was great for tackling this song
Jesus Christ, I instantly got tears in my eyes when she started singing, can't believe how good she is.
Good grief! I mean seriously. The thought of trying this on stage, live. Absolutely nailed it. Thrilling voice.
It was pretty much an average show, until this song happened and I got goosebumps. It's moments like this that are the reason why I spent a decade shooting _School of Rock_ shows.
@@MidWestConcertVideo2 Crikey, I'd have loved to have been there. Were you involved in the School of Rock filming of California Dreamin'? The lead vocalist on that is a one in a generation talent!
No, all my work is live. Another group does those "in studio" videos.
@@MidWestConcertVideo2 Ah, thanks for that. Interesting work. Do check that song out though, it's another goosebumps moment! Have a great Xmas wherever you are! :)
It's great to see kids today listening to and performing Pink Floyd. There may yet be hope for western civilization.
By long tradition, the first show every new School of Rock location does is The Wall.
Pete Guard There might be hope for Western Civilization if ALL kids today listened to and those who could performed Pink Floyd - but because they don't and they won't, we're all going to go down with the ship.
Becuase pink floyed is integral to the foundations of western thought. Or something like that. Plato, locke, and pink floyed, the holy western trinity. I like pink floyed as mush as the next guy but I feel like you're being just a tad hyperbolic there.
My dad got me into it since I was a kid
@@ericliu8434 How many top selling albums did Locke or Plato ever release? Pink Floyd is the crowning achievement of western civilization. The moon landing, and the Internet being second and third respectively
THE LEVEL OF TALENT IN THIS YOUNG LADY IS AMAZING, BLESS YOU KID
This song is cursed. Absolutely mastered by Clare Torry in like 2 takes on Pink Floyd's classic album "The Dark Side of the Moon". This is one of the best vocal covers I've heard of this song, and it takes serious guts to even attempt it. INCREDIBLE JOB GUYS!!!
One take, from what I remember. They told her to go in and act like she was going through a couple different emotions: sadness, shock, horror, etc.
She sang all afternoon. Then they asked her to open up, let loose, and she thought she already had. Anyway, we got this.
Fun Fact: After all these years she's still pissed off that she was paid as a session muso, and didn't receive any royalties. She tried suing, but got nothing.
@@paulieplayspoorly She actually reached an undisclosed out of court settlement in 2005, and all releases since then acknowledge her as co writer.
It was one take made up on the fly.
@@paulieplayspoorly There it is, the music business. (One would have thought that people like Pink Floyd could have sorted that out for her!!)
I never make comment on TH-cam but have been a fan of the Floyd for over 45 years (am 58years young) and play a bit of piano. This performance is truly remarkable - Great Gig in the Sky is a seminal piece of music and nothingness off a seminal album. Clare Torry, Roger, Richard, Nick and the Flioyd crew would have to be speechless by this performance. Amazing talent guys and what a voice - NEVER give it up, love it, nurture it and live music forever - old school, new school, opera, death metal, country, rap, muliticultural - all of it
Highwood School of Rock you are amazing - from aApua New Guinea
This is amazing! They all crushed it! I’m 65 and it thrills me to know classic rock is long loved! Blessings
Anyone commenting here know how difficult it is to play slide if you have never played it before? Let me answer for you, at any age it is extremely difficult. I have been playing in Pink Floyd tributes for well over a decade now and I still wrestle with the slide parts. Too many people think that Pink Floyd music is real simple to play. Floyd has a feel and if all of the musicians are not in sync, it can get away from them. Whenever people listen to Great Gig they always listen for the singer. Why? Because most of the Great Gig videos here have either Floyd themselves playing the music or an accomplished tribute band. These kids tackled what is in reality a very difficult song for every instrument involved. The dynamics in this song are incredibly difficult, so give these kids a break. They picked a song that people always take for granted, but very few people can actually play.
Besides that, Gilmour plays it on a lap steel which I'd imagine is much different than playing slide on a Les Paul. I'd imagine that getting the same sound out of a Les Paul is well above that kid's skill level, so good on him for giving it a try.
You are right and thank you. I was thinking he had need to practice more.
Singer does a nice job and kudos to the kid on keyboards. However, the guitarist just plain sucks, he needs to practice more or give it up. He practically ruins the entire song and drags the other musicians down.
Whoever thought that Pink Floyd would be easy to play?? Idiots, maybe?
Joel - I was commenting on the original post. I didn't even see yours.
Kid on guitar wearing a Quadrophenia shirt playing Pink Floyd. Bravo to his parents. Raising him right!!!
Joey D you made me laugh hard... yeah, his parents raised him right ;)
Lol the shirt looks like some metal band but its a album from the who
@@diegoholguin8019 i know!!!
Jesus Christ what a voice absolutely gobsmacked
The second best singer of TGGiTS I had opportunity to hear in the last 43 years!! Cheers!!!!
THIS GIRL HAS A PURE ROCK KICKASS SOUL. AWESOME.
Frickn awesome...
Oh my what a voice. Hit every note perfect pitch
From italy....greaaaaaaaaaaaaat
Holy shit! When she started singing every hair on my arms stood up on end! Well done!
This entire band did an excellent job, & the young lady was absolutely phenomenal! One of the best vocal covers I"ve ever heard for the song!!!
Nice to see the youth of today actually doing something other than looking at a screen
Young lady has a remarkable voice. She must also have tremendous confidence to pull that particular tune off so well. BRAVO!
And the other young musicians on stage did a fantastic job. Really really wonderful to see and hear this performance. Lucky it came up on my suggestions.
God, I just love it when Pink Floyd transcends generations. So awesome these high school kids are playing this in the 2010s!
I remember hearing this many many years ago and it gave me chills. The guys can barely play the tune but this brave girl (now fully grown woman) absolutely crushes it !
Holy chills! When the girl hit those notes!
Wow. She's amazing... Points for drummer boy also
Her amazing vocals knocked it out of the park. Fantastic melodical pipes she has indeed.
Young lady you ARE so amazing, what a talented gift you were born with. YOU are already a star! Please continue as an artist, don't ever stop.
Hello Roger Waters, I think we foung the singer you were looking for your Us and Them Tour
she's better than the two singers Roger signed for the tour.. I've heard them, they.. just.. don't interprete the song properly.. they just do it, no feelings involved at all :(
Agree!
Good voice and talent girl
@@Petar269724 Agree, those two singers seem to be in competition one with the other and have no sensuality.
I’m inspired every time I see young people get Pink Floyd’s great song here. May you all grow up to be rich and successful musicians.
To truly be great an artist has to put themselves "out there" and this is one of the most out there songs ever, this young lady is incredible.
Love the voice and appearance, I have followed her but her new music is dark with the pipes she has I exepected more.
I just spent a few hours listening to "reactions" to Pink Floyd and tribute bands such as Brit Floyd and The Australian Pink Floyd Show. Those bands have been practicing Pink Floyd covers for more than twice as long as these kids have lived. And this was great. I am wonderfully impressed. The singer has an amazing voice. You are all going on an amazing journey for the rest of your lives.
About as good a cover of this incredibly difficult song as you will find anywhere. Very well done.
I almost left this post...then she sang!
Great Rendition of Original...my favorite song without words
Is there a LOVE button instead of just a thumbs up?!? Holy hell. Clare Torry would be proud
This beatiuful cover played by young people, make me believe againg in humanity... Congratulations from Mendoza, Argentina!!!
where does anyone get the right to criticize these kids !! this is where it all starts, school bands, basements and garages of course the vocals are good we are born with that instrument so she is ahead on the curve ... it isn't perfect, but its fun and we all enjoyed it ... keep practicing and never give up !! Rock'nRoll \m/
Fantastic!
Vocals are beautiful, I hope she gets to where she dreams to go in life!
Great job. I find it refreshing to see our younger generation appreciating such great music.
holy shite. Young lady can hold her own on stage w Pink Floyd. Band is respectable!!! NICE WORK GUYS!
Nailed it, if I close my eyes I would think it was Clare Torry herself.
Don’t skip. Just wait for a minute ❤️
FABULOUS!!!!! Ive been listening to Dark side of the moon since 1973....the year it came out......this cover is great...
As a Pink Floyd fan since they started (yes, I am that old!), this is one of the better singers, great gig in the sky.
Doris Troy was the only female lead vocalist on any Pink Floyd song. The late Doris Troy would be proud.
WOW. Clare Torry (who sung on the original version) must be really proud of this young lady's performance
I wanted to scream, "LOUDER!"... but that girl sure belted it out at first, and did a great job, thanks for posting this rendition, I LOVE this tune
Wow, I got goose bumps the instant she started singing. Not an easy cover, but she did an amazing job.
Guys, thank you for that clip! You touched the heart and got the spirit of the song!
This is now my favorite vocalist... Please continue with lessons...this is vital... You could be a star one day...i am such a fan of your tone...dont quit... Get with some older musicians later...and spread your wings...
I didn't expect a lot when I clicked on this, but considering the ages and recording equipment I was blown away. Great work guys!
Her first note rose the hair on my neck. Tremendous.
Drop dead gorgeous and an awesome voice, well done young lady. hope to hear more from you.
To say that she nailed it is unfair to Clare Torry, The Great Gig in The Sky is longer having parts that would require more power and control, but let's be fair, Pink Floyd have 3 or more experienced and talented singers in their concerts working together to achieve something close what Clare did in one studio take; Talullah has a jaw dropping and wonderful voice that gives anyone goosebumps and show to the world that true talent is there to be discovered. She has the voice and potential to be among the legends, she is impressive is the minimum that I can say about her. Great job!
You did well all musicians through this most difficult Pink Floyd song! Keep it up. It was a great listen.
SOMEBODY SIGN THAT GIRL, ASAP.
I second the motion, SIGN THAT GIRL!!! What a vocalist!!! What a vocal range!!!
i don't think they do that anymore. the only way to make money now it by playing big arenas but I could be wrong. Amazing voice though.
KTnarnia with some training she could be very good. I see a lot of potential she obviously has talent.
Wow rare natural talent - yes get this gem into a sound studio - no to training, there are too many clones already.
NexySaloon all great singers need discipline. It's not all about going on America's Got Talent. Classical singers practice for many years. They start out with Talent then they practice for years
Amazingly beautiful work ... one of my favorite cuts for sure, she nailed it. I love the history and documentaries around this piece of work also. Probably one the most difficult vocal runs ever performed.
this girl got a great voice!!
Excellent performance! All of them did an amazing job on a very difficult song. Brava!
That's a great vocal - Clare Torry would enjoy hearing that.
This is incredible. Took me back to the time I first heard this piece and was just astounded. Got that same feeling tonight. Indescribable.....
She's wonderful. The whole performance is really well done, but the singer stands out here moreso than I expected. Bravo!
Nice job kids, You guys all did a great job. Thank you for the video.
Thank you, glad to make it available.
each of the kids is doing a great job - and the girl is launching a rocket, Gilmour and his friends would be very, very proud
Umm...just as there are no lyrics for this song, there are no words to capture what she stunningly pulled off.
You have to know that the lady vocalist of the original song asked for a financial compensation after this song became a huge hit. She was right I think.
Your singer lady - Talullah I think - is absolutely very talented -- many thanks all guys.
Excellent performance of young musicians! Greater than many professionals. The vocalist is gorgeous, she has a great potential. I have loved their respectful version of Pink Floyd's masterpiece. I feel grateful to this young people!
Great emotion from the girl and the piano ... bravo from France ;-)
Best vocal cover of that I've ever heard, that girl can really sing, great range and control - blows most current 'pop' stars out of the water.
Wow THATS beautiful what a voice!!! Flint mi Thank you
Excellent Performance = GREAT Vocals!
This was the Highwood School of Rock's Progressive Rock show. The Oak Park school just did a Best of Pink Floyd one that was just astonishing and I'm putting videos from that one up now. Uploaded Shine On You Crazy Diamond last night.
I know, I saw you there filming! I was the Director this Past Weekend... the kids were Astonishingly good!
Might I request that you post "Time" or "Us and Them" from Last Sunday?
I'll see what I can do. I usually put up four full songs from each show, trying to include performances from each kid. If I can get a dozen orders, I'll put up the full show. Currently, I'm 11 short. By the way, I put up another excellent Pink Floyd show in full - the Kansas City SoR doing The Dark Side of the Moon - dressed all in white, with The Wizard of Oz being projected on them!
th-cam.com/video/UTJ7JFhLoAU/w-d-xo.html
KC Sounding Good!
you will be our next super star rocker -loved it
Omg she sounds amazing it’s probably the best vocal cover I’ve seen recently of this song I hope she got the credit she deserves for this performance
Nice job from such a lovely young lady who took on an impossibly difficult song to sing even from a seasoned pro. Good for her and the group!
SPECTACTULAR VOCALS! Great rendition!
Considering it usually takes 3 singers on vocals these days that was excellent
This is amazing! I haven't even listened yet, but to do this song is legend!
Wow, just wow. One of my favorite songs ever (I'm a 60++ something). Having heard a lot of versions of this song, many of which were just excruuuuuciating, this young gal has done one of the best renditions I've heard. She does the vocals the way Clare Torrey first did them, true to tune and without the self added "flourishes" that can quickly ruin a live performance by a singer - and so often do. Great job kids.
Hauntingly beautiful and so is the singer
Deep track for a young band, very tasteful.
Holy crap...i didn't expect it to be that good.
Vocals start at 1:08. Such a young woman to sing with so much soul.
Wow! You did it so great!! Congratulations for your good work!!
Wow. That kids has some pipes. Nice work.
Great job, so cool to see young kids keeping the fire burning with some of the greatest songs ever written. Job well done by all the kids here!
I've seen a lot of singers trying to sound like Tory but this lady nailed it.
One of my favorite songs. Nailed it. quite the challenge for the young lady to do the vocals on her own. Over the years I have mostly seen 2 or 3 female vocalists sing it, taking turns since its so demanding vocally. Well done. Pink Floyd should be calling her for their next tour.
These kids know great music and also did a great job especially the singer 👍