OceanGate sub: Video shows how implosion likely happened | LiveNOW from FOX
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 มิ.ย. 2023
- Video obtained by FOX 5 New York shows how the Titan submersible could have imploded as it was carrying tourists to the wreckage of the Titanic.
Ashlie Rodriguez with FOX 5 New York joined LiveNOW from FOX's Josh Breslow to discuss the new video and the latest on the investigation into the implosion that killed five people onboard.
Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! th-cam.com/users/livenowfox?su...
Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox.com/
Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.
The 19 year old DEFINITELY didn’t die ‘doing what he loves to do’. He died scared to death just to please his dad
Hope they knew Jesus 🤟...
I nominate dad for “Douchebag of the year” award. Posthumously.
They also literally say that in the video Right after. That he was terrified to go. But did it to please his father. They literally said it
The father is a POS - hopefully the son is in heaven. Screw the dad
Well I was going to say it but you did.
What breaks my heart the most is the 19 year old that was scared to go but only went to please his dad. The fact this could have been avoided completely baffles me
Who gives AF
Lmao
@@DreamHarmonyHubclearly you
just say no.
At his age he may have swam to safety inside the Titanic.
The 19 year didn’t die doing what he loved. He died terrified and scared. Rest easy young man.
I know, he's the only one I feel sorry for, submitted himself, to his father's peer pressure to go on this thing, even though he was terrified, and didn't want to go
@@tony--james He even brought his rubix cube along for the ride
@@Silvia.Araujo yes I see that now, there seems to be 2 conflicting stories, one from the Aunt, NBC News Last Thursday and this more recent one,
The sub imploded in 30 milliseconds, it takes a pain signal 150ms to reach the brain. Those people were dead before they even knew anything was wrong.
They died instantly
The saddest part is that the 19 year old was apprehensive and must have had that gut feeling about the dangers involved but his father ignored him.the other 20 year old and his father who declined the offer for the trip actually saved himself and his father due to his intuition. Luckily his father listened to him and withdrew. What a wise decision that was.
Hope they knew Jesus 🤟......
Mr beast was actually offered to go on the submersible
I don't know how true it is that the 19 year old didn't want to do it. An interview with the mother she states she was originally supposed to go with her husband but the son kept asking and she switched with him. Now to say he didn't have apprehension is silly everyone would be nervous going to do this. He opened up to the aunt that gave the interview and she seemed to be doing the interview in the wrong state of mind, spoke out of turn, and for the wrong reasons. I don't know what was going on with her emotionally (rightfully so) I don't know what the reason she gave the interview but she was going through a lot... I don't mean this as a negative I don't think she was looking to gain anything again I don't think she knows why she did it.
@@jonlamontagne what would the aunt gain by making such a serious statement? Nothing at all. The mother on the other hand? Easing her conscious as any mother who feels at fault would react .in my opinion it's a coping mechanism.why did she take so long to give the interview
Titanic sank to such deep depths that deep imploded the submersible instantly
This company should be held accountable and closed down for good.
These people have already signed the death waiver so it's also the passenger's fault for signing a death certificate.
@@MyFirstHandle You don't know what they signed, you weren't there.
It probably will be shut down. The waivers, according to one legal channel, won't be held valid if the investigation finds neglience in its report. Plus the testimony of the engineer(?) That was fired for warning about the too slim safety margins. After that the flood gates of suits plus the bill for the SAR will quickly bankrupt the company.
They already announced they’re shutting down indefinitely
@@hearmenow909 was about to say the same, but the vid does say it.
the passengers did sign waivers saying things could go wrong.
The 19 year old didn't die doing what he loved. I feel like that phrase is often said by people trying to make themselves feel better or less guilty.😢
@@rightwingcollectiveiqYou've just been a bundle of joy during this thing exploiting tragedy for one shitty joke after another. And a fitting name at that.
Not if hes loved spending time with hs dad
@@rightwingcollectiveiqwow you are just a terrible person
How do you know he was forced to go?? I haven’t seen that on any news network. Quit spreading false information.
@@bme6949 because he didn't want to go. The aunt said he didn't want to go but was just making his dad happy
Honestly it’s tragic yes but I truly only feel bad for the kid. Never let anyone guilt or persuade you to do something you don’t want to do. Trust your gut
It’s not really that easy I’m sure. The kid wanted also to hang out with his dad on FATHERS DAY!! The kid was also surrounded by so called experts and he believed in them because that’s who his father believed in. It’s natural for any of us to feel fear. Don’t act like that’s not a natural feeling..
It's different when it's a Parent having you do something that you really would rather not do. It's almost impossible for the child to say to actually say no. It's so sad that a wonderful life ended only because someone wanted to have more bragging rights.
@@teresamier9370 bragging rights. You are exactly right!!
They could have done something else. Like go to a movie or something less dangerous. By the sound of it his son doesn't seem to be the adventurous type. Would you agree?
@@BlackCatFilmProductions to a certain degree!!! Hell going to the movie, shopping mall, festival, church, grocery store may be just as deadly. 🤷🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️
Honestly cannot imagine how the 19 year old felt when things rapidly started going wrong. He was apprehensive to even get into the sub. How a man can put his son into this dangerous situation I just do not understand.
We don't know but more than likely nothing was noticeable it was just black they wouldn't of heard a noise but still I'm sure if he was scared before hand he probably still was inside so you're still kinda right
Never mind actually I just seen James Cameron say they dropped the weight belts and were coming up indicating they were having problems and probably hearing the hull cracking which would be terrifying
He wouldn't have even known what was coming it would have happened so quickly like within milliseconds he would have been vaporized
There might've been some creaking or rumbling in the hull for a split second before it ceased to exist.
@@pereirahawk I haven't heard any of that. Might be fake news
Forget about the sub, they should *NEVER* have signed those waivers. If you're ever asked to sign an insane waiver like that, the only correct response is to say "HELL NO!" and walk away.
Those waivers will mean nothing if there was negligence.
Especially if you think it was recreation tourism. If I was desperate I might sign such a waiver, but not for an excursion.
@@daCubanaqtthat’s correct. Full disclosure is necessary.
Well alone the fact that the waver stated death 7 times in a 2 page waver. If a 2 page waver mentioned death 7 times count me out!!!!
Smart advice
A waiver doesn't excuse gross negligence. If the company was put on notice about safety concerns and they brushed them off, a piece of paper won't get them off the hook legally.
Are you sure about that? Many people in Pfizer and CDC still have their jobs.
I agree 100%
i know one thing, it makes a damn good defense in court. im sure defense team will use it against the victim's lawyer
The CEO literally said he cut corners and was tired of people blabbing about safety. So there's that.
It actually 1000% does release them from liability. That's literally the entire purpose of the waiver. If they sign it, then they are not held liable. Also, I'd like to point out that the waivers they signed are almost the same waiver signed for scuba diving.
This should be a sign to leave the Titanic alone. It’s people’s graveyard, and we should respect that. Rip to all those who died on the Titanic & those on the submarine.
For reals but they’ll keep experimenting and eventually they WILL be able.
This is just the beginning.
I think there shouldn't be tours and money involved yes; but researchers who visit it's site down there to check it's conditions and only studying it should be fine, imo.
@@Abcity92 well they don't have too because camera exists
Should we not visit Auschwitz too then?
Maybe its best to not make tourist attraction on areas nearly impossible for humans to get too
I saw an interview with his mom and she said she was supposed to go, but she gave up her seat so her son could go because he really wanted to. He wasn’t “scared to death” or he would’ve just let his mom go. People just say he was scared to add to an already tragic story. They don’t realize that it unfairly paints his dad in a bad light and makes it seem like he pressured his son to go when that is not the case. Just report the truth- it’s sad enough on its own without people spinning extra stories to try and make it worse.
Agreed 100 percent. Fox news is a racist channel. The main intent of his channel is to spread hatered and invite racial tension. I have blocked these dumb channel.
The only reason people say he was scared to go was because his aunt said it.
The 19 year old is who I feel heartbroken for. I can’t imagine his mother and family ❤
I feel for this young man's mother...I couldn't imagine losing my son to such a stupid idea of an adventure. Please ppl don't ever think about going down on something so tiny and risky like that sub.
Would you shoot yourself if your father ask you to? Thats basically what this dumb kid did
Exactly! he had his whole life ahead of him, and just wanted to make his dad happy. That is truly the tragedy!
the fact this man died at 19 in fear if his farther deapite his better judgement knowing the sub was not safe really 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔 heart breaking
@@ericakaupa6245 My mom would have told my dad it’s too dangerous, and he would have listened. Even if he insisted on going, there is NO WAY my mom would let my brother go!! I’m shocked the mother allowed them BOTH to go! Unless it was a super sexist home, where she had no voice. But I would think in most families, the wife would have prevented it. Because women are usually more prone to worry, and more safety conscious. Especially when it comes to protecting her baby!! Anyway, heartbreaking for the mother and sister 💔💔
The 19 year old didn't die doing what he loved doing. He gave in to pressure from his father who should have exercised better judgement in making the decision to go for both of them.
💔
U don’t know
You don't know that
@@Sweetiedgdhbse Google it. He was TERRIFIED & did it to please his father.
They all gave in to the pressure.
Thank you for this. I kept hearing that an implosion is the opposite of an explosion but I couldn't imagine how that looked. Thank you Brad Perry for making this.
I believe it's the same as holding an empty can of soda or water bottle in the center and squeezing it. Or squeeze an egg. They were crushed and torn apart. Deep sea creatures ate up their remains.
It breaks my heart for these passengers and especially the young man whom already had a premonition something didn’t feel right….. RIP and prayers for the families
Hope they knew Jesus 🤟....
It is horrifyingly haunting to hear that the kid not only didn't want to go, but he was also terrified of going. Makes me both angry and sad, it's so unfair on so many levels. May they all rest in peace.
Do you think the son only went because it was Fathers day or do you think the Father may have threatened his inheritance if he didn't go? Maybe I'm judgemental but I feel like rich people threaten their kids inheritance if they don't do what they say. I also don't know if the mother, aunt, or any relatives know if the 19 year was threatened over his inheritance or not. I do believe that the Father and Son duo were and if there's an after-life still Muslims. Would Muslims just want to please their parents or was it something more like if you don't go you aren't getting your inheritance. I don't know why I'm so stuck up on this but I just feel like rich people have a way at getting their children to do things when they threaten to take money away.
you follow to much fake news he made a tweet saying it would
be scary before he left --- news flash going 12,000 ft under the ocean is scary
@@josephwilson8391Great point!
@@josephwilson8391that’s terrible. You can’t obey their parents on everything. Inheritance money means nothing now. Better earn your own
@@josephwilson8391 stop making up stuff. It was NOT threatening to with hold inheritance!! Maybe just to please his dad since he was the only son in the family. The other kid is a daughter and We are talking about South East Asian culture where boys are valued over girls. I know the dad had 2 sisters too
He didn’t die doing what he loved he was terrified and didn’t want to go
Where are they getting these stories that the kid was terrified to go? His own Mom said he was excited to go, and that he had planned on breaking a worlds record with his rubiks cube underwater. Leave it to the media to try and "spice" things up..😒
Excuse my ignorance, and maybe I shouldn't even mention it, idk, but I'm a tad confused about the 19-year-old and his father because from the beginning the boys' aunt has stated that she remembers him being very nervous and correct me if I'm wrong, but I've even heard her describing him as being "terrified," and that he only went with his father on the trip to please his father because it was father's day. Then, in a recent interview with the mother and wife of the father/son duo, she states that she was originally supposed to be on the Titian, but she gave, "Gave the seat to her son because he really wanted to go." It doesn't really matter at the end of the day, I suppose because she lost two of her loved ones and other families lost their loved ones and it's all just very tragic, but something about the testimony the mother gave doesn't sit well with me for some reason. Anyone else get that vibe? No?
Screw those waivers, Oceangate needs to be accountable for this.
It's called gross negligence and if Ocean Gate is found to have done that in court those waivers are worthless
There are lawyers saying the waivers can be part of a lawsuit because it how thoses with the bad "technology" along with the repeated other problems reported as well can be a lawsuit.
Thats not how it works…..
The issue the owner of the submarine company also was inside when imploded
Hope they knew Jesus 🤟....
David Lochridge, an engineer and submarine pilot, claimed in his counterclaim against OceanGate that he was hired in 2015 by the Everett, Washington, company to ensure the safety of all crew and clients during the submersible and surface operations of the vessel called Titan. But when he expressed concerns about the design and testing of the minisub's hull, he said he was terminated by the company.
sus
In the end, the owner payed the ultimate price. What's sad is he took 4 other people with him.
Hope they knew Jesus 🤟....
All about the Benjamins...fkn greedy people....
@@Shaolin91z you know jesus?
I feel soo heartbroken for the 19 year old. But what’s more sad about this is he didn’t even wanna go but did it for his dad 😢 this whole story is just making it hard to swallow 😔
Life is a journey, my condolences to the 5 families who lost their beloved ones ,may their soul rest in peace
Waivers don’t prevent a lawsuit if gross negligence happens which seems to be the case here the more we discover.
Exactly
Hope they knew Jesus 🤟..☠️
A good lawyer can always argue that the consent was flawed in the first place for gross negligence. But I doubt that Ocean Gate will survive long enough to see a trial. And since the CEO went down with the ship, he can't be charged with manslaughter. That being said, I wonder if the passengers all had personal life insurance. If so, then that's pretty much the only compensation that the estate would receive. This being a commercial operation, Ocean Gate should have insurance covering their employees and clients. But in this case, it's most unlikely. Sometimes, the richest people can make the dumbest mistakes.
I feel so sad for that 19yr old boy. He had his whole life ahead of him... And unfortunately it was cut short. So Heartbreaking. 💔
But maybe what happened was his 'Whole Life'.
His life imploded from the inside out.
*rimshot*
It's kinda dumb to focus on one life when 5 entire lives were lost.
@@lolitis01 are u dumb? the others wanted to go on their own. The boy was terrified and didn't want to go he only did it to please his father
@@lolitis01 He was the youngest and he was afraid to go. That's why I'm putting the emphasis on him. Everyone else should have known better than to put this young mans life in danger like that.
Is there video footage of the day they started their journey into the Titan?? Why does everything say the son was scared? An interview today with his mom said he was excited to go, and that's why his mom gave her seat to him.
Cant help but notice the day it went missing, the info went straight to how vulnerable the sub was. After 7 years of diving.
The guy openly saying he broke rules on a TV interview is honestly disgusting tbh. You don’t say something like that when it comes to life and death.
What’s been bothering me from the very first day is that they allowed someone under 21 to go on this endeavor. I feel so bad for that 19-year-old and his family. Then to find out that he never wanted to go, it just made me even sadder
@@rightwingcollectiveiq what a terrible thing to say
@@rightwingcollectiveiqHorrible thing to say!!
They didnt care about age they only cared about money. Basically they would have let a 2 year old get on if their parents pay the 250,000 dollars
@@TampaAries fs
What is age of majority in Pakistan? In the US, 18- 20 year olds.....and sometimes 17, can join the military, pledge an Oath to the Constitution and DIE, with their brains and guts hanging out, in Iraq and Afghanistan. What is this hang up all over ADULTS aged 18-20????? You people treat them like china dolls or fragile antique china. They are ADULTS. They can sign contracts, get married, have kids and decide their own destiny without some legislation, saying that they can't.
This is so sad. Rip to the ones that passed. Sending prayers 🙏🙏to the family members of the submarine crew members. 😢💔
I feel the worst for the son.. always go with your gut and dont ever be pressured into doing something you dont want to.. regardless of family or not!!
From the last message sent from the vessel, we know it didn't suddenly implode without warning. He sent a message saying they were dropping weights to resurface, but didn't say what the emergency was. There's alot of unknowns on how carbon fiber reacts when it starts failing at those depths, because nobody has ever been foolish enough to use it for a sub, aside from this guy. It's all speculation and I could be wrong, but I think it either sprung a pinhole leak and started spewing high pressure water, or part of the hull started pressing in at a weak spot. The Brit he fired, said there were stress cracks, so it probably started failing in that spot. He was probably frantically trying to resurface to no avail. If we knew the precise time the navy sensors detected the implosion and the time of the last message, we can at least know how long it took to implode after he started having problems. Then again, my scenario could be wrong. Someone said the thrusters could have gotten stuck, forcing the sub down too fast, which would have imploded it. He was using those cheesy wireless video game controllers, that have a history of failing. Just like in the video games, it's game over if the control messes up.
That's crazy... if the composite shell was cracking and popping that would be the most terrifying experience ever... nowhere you can go and nothing you can do to stop it... yikes
Yeah, I have a bad feeling the 5 people onboard knew something was happening, or at least the pilot did. I do think once it happened it was instantaneous though, but there probably was a few seconds or even minutes of terror as they tried to resurface.
It had manual backup controls
Hope they knew Jesus 🤟...
I think you're right. They sent a distress signal so something definitely happened. They knew they were in trouble. Even a pinhole leak could cut someone in half or quickly evolve into loss of hull integrity and implosion.
Why did they not mention that they dropped their ballast. Which means they Knew they were in trouble, James Cameron mentioned this from the information inside the community that was received. Sure, the death was "instant", however, they knew they were in trouble.
An Implosion would cause the ballast to drop
Because it didn't implode - it's all assumption
@@DracoReptoidsExposedit’s not assumption when they found pieces of it, it very clear what happened
There's a video from a dude in MX from 10-11 months ago of him boarding this sub. They experienced problems down there (comms) and were trying to resurface, but ran into one more problem. Everyone was calm. Nobody cared. P.H. was there.
As they were going up, things were restored and they went back down to see the Titanic. The man also explains how the people before his trip were down there 27 hours.
He then says your time varies. They tell you it's 4 hrs watching the Titanic but that sometimes u never see it bc it's tough to find and/or you can encounter problems and the company aborts mission.
All in all I think it was common to lose comms and to try to resurface. That said, idk if in this last trip they heard the delamination taking place as Cameron stated they might have which probably made the experts nervous...and relayed it to those in the vessel, but idk.
@@TampaAries really? You know what I meant.
I was going to try and open communication with my dad again who has been absent and manipulative majority of my life just to be nice to him since I felt bad that he didn’t have his kids (me and my brother) with him for Father’s Day, but the Titan and that passenger taught me “Why the hell should I do something to please my family member? I don’t like being with him and he clearly does not care.” (This is my own experience, I do not know the relationship he and his father had and will not assume what it was out of respect and human decency) I put the phone down and decided to cut contact for good. This is a lesson for all of us: Don’t do things for other people if you don’t feel comfortable or not up to it. Follow your gut, you don’t owe anybody anything. It’s okay to be “selfish” sometimes and just say no.
Should have sped up the simulation, since I'm guessing a lot of people want to know what it actually looked like and whether they had time to worry. Showing a slow mo version alone is pretty short sighted.
There is so much wrong with this "implosion simulation". The titanium end caps and the fairing (tail end) were shot off which is consistent with the wreckage. What likely happened is that because of cyclical pressure fatigue causing weakening of the carbon fiber pressure vessel and due to dissimilar materials being attached, the carbon fiber laminate cracked, causing the implosion. The crew didn't even know what happened as the implosion was faster than their nervous system reaction (150 to 300 milliseconds). It was a very merciful death compared with being stuck on the bottom and dying from carbon dioxide poisoning or oxygen running out. From a physics and engineering perspective, we can discuss the flexural modulus or resistance to bending of the materials: Titanium is 100 and very resistant while carbon fiber ranges from 20-30+. Additionally, constant pressure cycling from 300+ atmospheres to 1 atmosphere (surface of the ocean) and multiple trips to the Titanic over the last two years caused fatigue: cracks, de-lamination, and other structural damage which culminated in the implosion last Sunday.
I read somewhere that they had some type of syringe 💉 in case something bad happened. Soo they wouldn’t suffer too long!
I love when you talk nerdy to me
Yes what you said and the simulation also showed fire then smoke for a couple seconds during implosion is that even possible under water?
@@kpeezyforsheezy Lol!😄
@@luisgandster420 idiot... I heard it was locked behind a cabinet bolted by 17 bolts. The 18th is inconsequential obviously.
The titanic debris field is a cematary not a tourist attraction.....the hell is wrong with folks....as sad as the situation is...
So is Normandy nothing inherently wrong with that it's a memorial and a grave site
What about the German concentration camps? They are visited everyday. Same with the World Trade center...
I agree with the 2 comments above ☝️
@@CarsCatAliensThey are not 2 miles deep underwater. Making money of visiting death sites is blood lust tourism and feeds people’s fascination on the suffering of others for profit.
Hope they knew Jesus 🤟....
OceanGate should sell tours of the Titan’s debris field
I didn’t expect it to be so violent, at least they didn’t feel anything. R.I.P. to everyone on board.
A tremendous amount of F'ing around resulted in a tremendous amount of finding out.
Reminds me of the Challenger explosion in 1985 with the "o" ring which was an issue before and 'they' knew it was a weak point. I feel for that poor young kid on there. His intuition was strong and told him NOT to get on -- but he gave in to his father's coaxing. We must ALWAYS listen to our gut feeling because that is telling us the truth about something.
Not his father fault, but the 19 old man. He wanted to go in, he went it. If he didn't he wouldn't. Drop the drugs you are intaking, it doesn't suit you.
Rest in piece everybody on board. May there souls forever find peace.
I cant imagine the tourist, loosing communication and seconds bein terrified..
RIP
The thing that bothers me the most with this whole ordeal is hearing the youngest of them all didn't want to go. But he went to please his father. We have to teach our kids how to listen to their own instincts. That young man may still be alive.😢😢
Even with signing waivers, the guy knew he was not doing any real safety/testing with that death trap after each dive. Some text messages of his have been exposed where he comes off as a desperate used car salesman promising things like its safer than crossing the street.. He needed their $$$$ to fund his madness because the trip out there cost over a million in just the fuel/expenses for the mother ship. Without the rich folks he manages to lure into risking their lives he would never be able to use his little toy.
That animation is terrifying, especially considering that happened in a fraction of a second.
This should be a perfect demostration of following your own gut feeling not forced into putting your parents first.
So sad that any dad would put his son in that situation! Prayers for his mom!
Its not like he hated his son, he spent 250,000 on him and wanted him to have an experience to bad he didn't listen to his son
@@stratocasterblueThat's the worst kind of love
Son Wanted to go. He even contacted Guinness world records because he wanted to solve a rubix cub down there
Hope they knew Jesus 🤟
I don’t understand the interest in spending so much money to see a gravesite /wreckage with so many obvious life risks. Just Bc you can, doesn’t mean you should. Use common sense. If they died this way, at least it was quick and painless. I’m sorry for the families 😢
Yup. I'd rather see the titanic in VR mode. They can make a ride out of it. Much safer.
Some people have different aspirations in life (exploration/science) and are willing to accept high risk. But deep ocean exploration is probably the most dangerous exploration you could do and Ocean Gate took too many loopholes which made the risk ridiculous (no certification...).
What was unacceptable is that we give idiots a Ocean Quest lot more respect than it deserves.
I disagree. Darwinism at work
There's is nothing wrong with wanting to see the Titanic wreckage....the problem here is that they completely trusted the company that was going to take them there...unaware that there were shortcut taken by the company...James Cameron went deeper than that but did it with the proper vessel
Makes me happy to observe the visual, now i get to imagine
The things being said just brings back warnings on avaition throughout history and also more recent times. It’s not just smaller companies who try these things.
Personally i think the Titanic site should be regarded as a grave site.
Only to be studied by legitimate research teams with the appropriate permission.
Definitely not a "tourist attraction "..
I know the wreck is in international waters...but inlight of this tragedy some legislation needs to be set in motion .
RIP to those explorers ❤😢
United Nations can list it as a protected area -
@@AmyC37217
Ah..thanks for the information.I didn't know that.
I'm guessing that it stops scavengers and relic hunters but not sightseeing tours.
they aren't explorers, they're tourists at best lol.
This is so sad. That poor boy. I pray his soul finds peace
He wont, his soul will always be wondering around the titanic wreckage
His arse hole hanging around Titanic now
@@TampaAriesno! All of them had the doors to the staircase inside Titanic opened and everyone was in there clapping and welcoming them to the Titanic family. Didn’t you see the movie?
Typical Pakistani mentality.where son or family abides to father and husband wish.damn on them
He’s hanging out with Ariel under the sea
Wow, the company and ceo were warned over 5 years ago and chose to ignore the warnings.
However the chunks of wreckage salvaged were in larger pieces so the implosion simulation is not accurate of what actually happened
That is exactly how I thought it happened. The front and tail were made of titanium. The pressure chamber was carbon. The two ends of the sub crushed it you do when you step on an aluminum can.
more importantly then the materials it was made from..the fact is was a cylinder and not a sphere made it a lot weaker
@@hotdog9262that was probably the main cause
I saw a video of it being made it was a titanium too wrapped in carbon fiber
@@hotdog9262 after all the submarine talk an idea came to me I just think a good design for a submersible would be a triangle shape
The titanium end caps are all that's left of the pressure vessel... the cylinder is just gone apparently probably in a million pieces.
The electronics in the fairing outside the pressure vessel seems okay so they might be able to pull data and see how it happened exactly. The hull had stress monitoring system and it likely sounded the alarm as it's now all but confirmed that they dropped ballast, began an emergency ascent and then imploded. They knew it. The hull must have made some ungodly sounds before giving way and then yeah... 30 milliseconds. I thought 10 but they must've run the numbers.
the pressure was so powerful when the vessel imploded, it was like a lightning strike. they didn't even knew what hit them
Wow you're smart
They heard it crumbling from the pressure even if it was a few seconds, death may be quick but they heard the crushing
BUT, they had already communicated they were having problems and had dropped ballast to ascend, so they DID know there was a problem 🙄 😥 then.....💥
Bet there were some WEIRD noises before it failed.......
Either, the tube to end cap bond failed, the tube itself failed, or the door glass failed as reported, one rear end cap is filled with carbon fibre debris,
They made a toy to travel beneath the ocean 🥴
not true. listen to James Cameron, someone who actually knows what he's talking about. He said they would have heard it coming and that's why they dropped the ballasts and tried to ascend.
Praying for the families of these people.
From visiting a tour of history to being actually part of history now😮
Aint no way IN HELL im goin down there not even if u gave me 50 million.
also there is one thing, it should be investigated, I think those tourists were deceived to the moment they saw the sub, how crappy it was, but it was too hard for them to say no, when they were so close to their goal finally, like some kind of a psychological pressure and deception that things are safe, even when there were problems all the time
I can’t believe they had no warning. I hope they didn’t. Such a tragedy.
Im confused did it actually shatter into a million pieces ? Cuz they just found wreckage of the titan sub and it looks like they found a huge piece of the vessel all in one piece🤔
1:23 I'm told the kid wasn't doing what he loved.
The 19 year old was terrified to go! R.I.P. to all 5 men and my condolences to the 5 families of the 5 men!!!
Rip to the five people who lost their lives my thoughts are with the families x ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
In another article mom of the 19 year old stated he was very excited to go in. In fact, the mom was supposed to go; however, gave her son the ticket because he really was super happy to go!
Is there any video or photos of them entering the can ? Until those are shown i doubt every word about this.
The fact that Oceansgate privately had know that Sunday that the sub imploded immediately after comms and tracking were both lost simultaneously and shared that fact with the Navy,....yet, while publicly misleading the public for four days is the real tragedy here. The families were hanging on to false hope for days until Thursday when Wood's Hole Oceanographic Institute finally confirmed what was known all along on Sunday by traveling to Titan's last known position and then descending straight to the bottom where Titan's wreckage was found,......exactly where they expected to find it.
Because they wanted to blame their deaths on lack of oxygen.
Prob wanted money for the search
Never waste a good tragedy. That's the news and big businesses motto. 96 hours of energy harvesting
True the mother ship and crew knew from the very beginning and even those who work in oceanography field knew imploding is the main reason when they especially knew the hull was made up of carbon fibers. So extending it to 4 days was really cruel and so tragic. Water pressure is a serious matter to be taken into account first for making a submersible or submarines, they just played it all way to end up like this.
Stockton Crush's arrogance finally caught up to him. He didn't respect the open sea.
So sad ! Especially for that nineteen year old , who didn’t want to go !
17 out of 18 bolts were tightened on the door, Point of failure is obvious.
A new interview with the mother of the child who died told the opposite of what Fox is claiming. She told that he was excited and overwhelmed at the opportunity to go with his father, that it was originally going to be the mother but he wanted to take her place. Please don't spread lies about this poor kids death, its unfair.
Not the 19 year old he was terrified 😢 poor thing 🙏
The reason Mr Cameron that you were not more vocal about it because you didnt want to be sued
The 19 year old gave in to pressure from his dad. And then got demolished by pressure from the sea. Damn
That poor kid didn’t have to go like that. It angers me, because there are plenty of reckless and stupid dads out there who push their kids to live their own selfish power fantasies without any considerations.
Watching the recreation is absolutely chilling. Prayers to all the families of those who perished.
That recreation is cartoonish. The initial implosion would have lasted about one or two frames of the video, possibly accompanied by a flash as any atmospheric gases inside the sub - and _people_ - ignited under a pressure increase of 180 or so million pounds within a few milliseconds. Much of the debris wound up blown inside one of the hemispherical titanium end caps, according to Cameron.
Hope they knew Jesus 🤟....
Wow, so all five were basically crushed into each other forming one lump of mingled remains
My brain can’t handle this image
Pretty much and turned into dust.
@@FlixCreEightR No. Actually, an expert said their remains were first cooked when the implosion superheated the oxygen in the pressure vessel as hot as the surface of the sun for just and instant. This would have instantly softened their remains and the immense pressure would have turned them to liquid where they would have been shot out at immense speed. So basically that’s the same as saying there was nothing left of them. Their bits that are left will feed creatures at the site
like compacting a vibrational jelly’ish’-sea-urchin effect at its core
Does anyone know if that guy next to him didn’t go on either? But also he is so lucky and smart to not go on that submersible I’m so happy he got out!
Goes to show you that parents don't always make the best decisions. You should always think for yourself and put yourself first over anyone else.
Carbon fibre has _tensile_ strength, but the forces from water pressure acting on the Titan were _compressive._ It is likely that the binder alone gave the hull its compressive strength with fibre holding it together to prevent cracking. The junction of the carbon fibre, titanium and the glue that bonded them was a weak point with different rates of expansion and contraction. Glue that is elastic at room temperature is likely brittle at near freezing temperatures. These materials were bound to detach from one another. What is surprising is not that the vessel failed, but that it managed to remain intact for as long as it did.
There is nothing fundamentally wrong with a cylinder design with heme-spherical ends, although in the submersible it was employed in a situation that is the reverse of the gas container concept under which it evolved, exerting pressure outward. That will likely be the shape of future crafts, not spherical designs. Had the hull of this vessel been constructed of a single material, titanium, properly analyzed as to the forces acting upon it, with welded joints, this craft might have successfully completed this and many other trips to the ocean floor.
Always trust your gut, one day i was hiking something strange felt like something was watching me, i felt like heading back to the car, next thing I’ve noticed a mountain lion was getting close to me without realizing it.
Did you shoot it?
This is so sad I’m wondering why didn’t they send robot vessels down there to look for what it is they needed to see? It’s heartbreaking that 5 people lost their life especially after being warned not to go, I don’t know what will happen if anyone else tries to do this I just hope it doesn’t happen again, may the 5 people who lost their life RIP I feel for their families at this very difficult time🙏🏽
Whenever you ignore a waiver, that literally means you are signing off to life. If their is a waiver involved, that ultimately means it isn't safe. That's what have woken me up like how guy that didn't end up going. Crazy to think when they were lowered into the water that was the last time they were going to be above the surface 😞
Look how nature and the world works. Absolutely terrifying. If there are any future expeditions to the titanic; guaranteed there will also be a note to, “this is also where the titan submersible disaster happened”
It must have been scary asf when they got 300 feet from the titanic and saw it coming out the darkness like a ghost ship and then they imploded 😮 Must Have Been So Horrifiying Poor Kid..God Rest his soul he didnt deserve that 😢
"launching an investigation" we hear this so many times.
Because a vacuum is definitive and pressure unlimited, in .31 milliseconds the temperature in the sub was hotter then surface of the sun and all calcium liquefied. It would be like being instantly teleported to the inside of a tank of liquid oxygen and it exploded. There's nothing left..
What about the bodies? Did they just melt?
@markschultz786 Watch the Mythbusters episode about a pig in a diving suit. That was around 135psi. These people were subjected to 5000psi.
@@esport1686shatter into bits
they wuz vaporerized...atomizised and morselizised..
whole thang wuz disorganizised...
I think the French guy wuz comprimizised...
seems very unlikely
Did not want to hire any 50 year old experienced experts.
Those experts were charging way too much. Not very inspirational!
Paying a 50 year old expert to build it the right way, isn’t innovating. That nut thought he could use cheap materials and slap a bunch of different pieces together with some epoxy and bolts. He knew better than the experts and he was going to show them that he could build a submersible for less money that was just as good.
the instead hire a black tranny who just got his GED and that one fat lesbian with green hair who got a gender studies degree
50 yr old white guys
No old white guys, we only want 25 year old surfer dudes running our company
the curse of Titanic still remains
The 19 yr old had more brains than the others put together.
Its super nice of the aunt to tell the media he was scared and only went to please his dad. Im guessing the aunt was on his mothers side.
She was estranged from her brother/relatives (because he/they didn't approve of her using cannabis for a chronic ailment she has) but she was close to her nephew, I heard her say in an interview.
@A.Walker. ahhh yeah I can tell. She definitely seemed to want to stick the boot in. That's how he'll be remembered now
Seeing how it may have imploded and then them saying 30 milliseconds thank goodness it was super quick and probably didnt even know it happened. So tragic. RIP to these guys and my prayers are going out to the families of these victims.
Payne
The implosion would be over faster than their eyes could send a signal to their brain about what was happening
That 2003 video game simulation sure is accurate
"Titanic's UPDATED death toll has risen from 1,517 to 1,522"
People sign these waivers with such little knowledge. If they knew that crush depth decreased with each dive, and how much pressure would be on the craft, along with how many dives this sub had made as well as the actual depth they were diving would they still have signed that waiver and gone on the dive? I bet not.
Surely it’s your responsibility to check and double check you know what your getting into
@@shirleyberry7550 You don't think the company taking your life into their hands shouldn't make an effort to be as transparent as possible? Not everyone knows what questions to ask or what research needs doing. Only after this would I have ever thought of things like crush depth, vessel fatigue, etc... I don't think most people ever thought of these things as it isn't their area of expertise.
And there're those talking about recovering the bodies. Oblivious to what happens when an accident like this takes place
The fish would be almost done eating their flesh by now. In 10 days they will be just bones.
There is no body to recover. If anything was even left. The fish would of eaten it.
There are these awkward moments where reporters ask experts about recovering the remains, and the experts try to find ways not to say what they’re thinking
@@FlixCreEightR there are no fish at that depth.
@@buckmurdock2500 yes, there are fish there. Do some research on the anglerfish
Dreamybull was inside that titanic, his final word after the implosion was: "Ambadebleu raytnaw, *ambadebleuuoooww* "
They would hear the cracks, unfortunately. Would be terrifying.
A quick look at the scoreboard. It now says Titanic: 2 and Rich people: 0