Gaza to Pakistan, political Islam is at its strongest and weakest. Depends how you look at it
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 ม.ค. 2024
- This is not an argument about Islam, the faith. This is about political Islam, where the faith is the state religion, defines a nation and/or maintains its mostly unelected leaders in power. Watch this week’s #NationalInterest with ThePrint Editor-In-Chief Shekhar Gupta
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Politics has never been separated from Islam since its inception
And BJP making Ram Mandir part of its political promises is not political Hinduism? Lol you naive nelly, every religion is political.
True
@@user-gv5mo1rd2p I don't have any disagreement with your comment being a staunch BJP voter
Then get on changing India's constitution. This secularism or democracy pretense has been going on for a while.
so you mean avangelicals that support trump are iligimate or the ortodox jews in likud party
There’s nothing as non political Islam. It’s always been core politics masked as a religion.
Islam means submission, humbling oneself, and obeying commands and heeding prohibitions without objection, sincerely worshipping Allah alone, believing what He tells us and having faith in Him.
@@Talhatahir-wp9rdBut it doesn’t stop there, it goes on to destroy the native civilisation and wipe it out completely, as it has done in Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran, Arabia, Turkey, Egypt and North Africa. Intolerant towards everything non-Abrahamic, because it’s supposed to be the only way.
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd deflecting from a complex sociopolitical discussion to a simpler, more doctrinal one. Good save.
@@Mr.GauravTiwari No, this is the actual definition of Islam. you can read any book of ilm -ul- kalam and you will find this definition.
Political Islam is a misnomer. Islam, in itself, is a political philosophy.
Islam means submission, humbling oneself, and obeying commands and heeding prohibitions without objection, sincerely worshipping Allah alone, believing what He tells us and having faith in Him.
@@majiddd17Phobia is an irrational fear. When it comes to Islam it’s common sense to dislike such an intolerant political ideology. It’s followers have completely wiped out every native culture with brutal violence, justified by verses from Koran and sunnah especially if it’s non-abrahamic. Gone are most of the ancient cultures of lands it has conquered.
@@Talhatahir-wp9rdthat's the cover for the delusion of world domination. Tell me, isn't it your duty to work towards the goal of a world where everyone is a muslim?
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd Islam is dangerous political philosophy. There is no Allah. Mohammad Nabi is imagination character
@@majiddd17phobia means irrational fear. Neither are our points about islam irrational......nor are we scared of the muslims.
You just cannot bifurcate Islam and "Political" Islam, Islam is a religion that threads the fine line between a religion and a political ideology; failing the test of modern/humanistic values on both the "Religious" and "Political" fronts.
Exactly, well said. Islam in itself is a dangerous political ideology , disguised as a religion.
You can argue that. But Jihad or political Islam is not part of the 5 pillars of Islam. At the same time, the majority of Muslims do practise and support political Islam.
@@vinsin328India Should Also ban Political Islamic ideological Tanzeems in India Especially Jamaat-e-Islami & Tabligi jamaat...
Becoz it Was
Jamaat-e-Islami ideology Gave Birth to Jihadi Ideology in Pakistan when General Zia Ul Haq was dictator of Pakistan
& Today its jamaat ideology that has destroyed Pakistan..
Even Saudi Arabia has banned Tabligi jamaat...
Even Aftermath of Pulwama Modi Govt. banned Jamaat-e-Islami Kashmir...
Becoz Jamaat ideology was being used to radicalise Majority of Muslim population..
@@vinsin328 A few act it out, a few of them provide intellectual cover, a few of them provide political backing, sizable number fund through zakat,a lot of them vote and a lot of them support silently by not speaking against it. Its like tip of iceberg ( see the picture of tip of iceberg).
My Grandmother's analysis in most of the topics that SG covers has a very uncanny resemblance to what SG provides and in very sentences and she is only 10th pass. @@vinsin328 i should better start paying attention to her and save my time.
BJP is not against Muslim , this is the only party which opposes pollical ISLAM .
Congress and other parties are doing appeasement politics for vote bank.
Hindus must remove caste system and get united, and we should not again become weaker.
Hindus should remove caste system...so will Brahmin girl marry Dalit boys?? I don't see it happening in large numbers in India...in very rare case it happens.
Will Dalits become Priest? Not happening anywhere
@@IronMan-nu3rbif you don’t know the priest in ram temple ayodhya is appointed from sudhra community . Plz educate urself
@@alwayscreator4006 Exceptions do not disprove the rule.
It is like me claiming there is no suppression of Baloch people in Pakistan since spokesperson of Pakistani MOFA is a Baloch and Pakistani caretaker prime minister is a Baloch too.
Thick head.
@@IronMan-nu3rb So many of native temples in TN are non-brahmins. Fact is majority priests in TN are non-brahmins. This propaganda is very old. If dalits are interested in learning the relevant studies, there are 1000s of temples who need priests & will employ them-instead current political discourse is like yours, half truths & lies, making political dalits to make them anti-Hindu
@@IronMan-nu3rbyes it’s happening every where,
Such a funny vlog .... shekhar ji worried about sar tan se juda keeps on giving disclaimers throughout the video that he's not against Islam 😂😂😂
He is being realistic. Nobody wants to lose their head to some hateful stone age idiots
If you can KEEP your head
When all about you are losing theirs.
(SG's attitude is borrowed from R. Kipling's "If")
@@narendersheoran5102 all "about" you. Look it up.
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
@@narendersheoran5102stone age idiots you mean stone worshippers who do mob lynchings
That first liner about not being a critique of Islam was a pleading prayer to Sar tan se juda gang
Shekhar chicha ko apne sir ki bahut parwah hai . Baki gyan to hinduon se chodna hai😆
Lol you lynch people for cows. As if that's better.
Every journalist knows this but cannot say it or its sar tan se juda😅
Harsh but true.
Shekhar is a smart and respectful guy. No Muslim would touch him.
Most of the islamic countries promote ISLAM first . Their constitution are based on ISLAMIC laws.
Je Suis ThePrint (just in case...)
So what is wrong in that . . Don't the Hindus have the Hindu law
yes like Maldives
@@koteswar009 most of the islamic nations do so .
The adjective used is redundant because Islam itself is political.
So is Hinduism. How else do you get 100% Hindu ultra-right-wing BJP govt in India?
@@user-gv5mo1rd2p Because people won't vote for 100% Muslim ultra-left-wing Congress govt. in India.
No they vote for political Hinduism or Hindutva. That's why.
By appeasement & vote bank politics for 60 yrs. Keeping aspiration of majority suppressed @@user-gv5mo1rd2p
@@user-gv5mo1rd2p its a reaction against political islam aka pakistan
Political Islam in Islamic country is at its weakest ( incld gulf and North Africa)
Political Islam is growing stronger in west ( incld North Amer , Turkey and Europe )
Political Islam is in check and static in Asia ( India , Bangladesh ,Indonesia and ASEAN contr )
Politician Islam is radicalized( Iran, Pakistan , Afganistan)
"Political" Islam (or rather how Islam has been practiced for centuries) is in check in India only because of demography. The day the demography changesbeyond a point, India will be the same as Pakistan or Qatar. Even today, Kefirs (Hindus/Atheists/Christians) live like Dhimmis in Muslim majority areas in India. Kashmir is a classic example. Before 1947, Pakistanis were also Indian Muslims.
how about political hindu?
@@yuck4u mewat, old city Hyderabad and Malappuram too.
Couldn't said it better.
Every year 20,000 AMERICANS convert to ISLAM
I like how if it is islam then it is political islam but for hindus it is hindu nationalism or hindutva 😂
Because "double-standards" and "Left-Liberals" are synonyms
Hindu Nationalism is different from Hindutva. Also, majority of Hindus would most like to support Brahmavad.
Can you define "Brahmavad" for the uninitiated please? @@vinsin328
The Print❤ 🙏बहुत दिनों से सोच रहा था की श्री राम 🚩के राम मय🙏 वतावरं मे राम 🚩के अलावा कोई कंटेंट नही 🤏दिख रहा है, और ये लो प्रिंट के अडिग अंतराष्ट्रीय इस्लामी प्रेम और विधवा विलाप तुरंत आ गया🤪 Keep it up The Print💪 Seculat🤠 Bro 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@vinsin328true hindu nationalism is different from hindutva
Globally, is there anything like
1) Political Christianity
2) Political Buddhism
3) Political Hinduism
with the same degree of fanaticism & dogmatism.
1. Christianity has no law. Paul abolished the law.
2. I don't think Budhism is a religion.
3. I don't think Hinduism is a religion.
The only other religion that has an all encompassing law to govern every aspect of life is Judaism.
@@quenky1 And my response is: there is only Judaism that has a poltical character, apart from Islam. So the comparison is invalid.
The only question that can be posed is: does Judaism have the same degree of fanactucism and dogmatism that Islam has?
@@quenky1 It is like questioning, 'is liberalism as totalitarian as communism?'.
The question has a degree of assumption that liberalism has totalitarian aspects. If someone disagrees with the premise of the question itself, he would get in a trap if he tries to answer that question.
Do you understand what I am trying to say?
@@maquacr7014 It's not assumption, it's deducing to arrive at a conclusion.
@@Kanthavel.KV.Chennai.Bharat Except deduction requires reliance on solid premises. In your case, your premises are faulty.
Islam is always political. All its versions including Sufism are political. It has political rules and even tax for non-believers etc. mentioned in the book itself.
They do tax from the muslims you don't read that btw ??😂😂😂 Stop argue with these low level facts
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
@@Voop87900it's called zakat. Which is not mandatory. And it's very less. People got converted because they cannot pay exorbitant jiziya taxes.
@@mental9453 who told you zaziya was way higher that they couldn't pay ... Idiot you are literally mental without having any rationality to your clause ...read the rates first then come to me
@@mental9453zakat have a limit and it's for muslims only 2.5 % while jizya can't be lower than zakat 2.5%but can be higher under islam rule in india there have been riots many in gujrat,up,bihar,haryana over jizya because it was most of the time almost 50%
Interesting Fact: If the population exchange in 1947 was complete, the unemployment & cost of living in India would be less than 70% what they're today. If there was no Islamic invasion(i.e., no Kashmir & Pakistan conflicts), the unemployment & cost of living in India would've been less than 50% of what they're today..
How will cost of living be less if the population exchange was complete?
True it doesn't make sense but definitely less birth rate in india and also some population removed from india. Overalll less people and more stable in all regions so india wouldn't waste money on Kashmir war and maintaining the state and the active military And it would have had slightly more secular educated people.
Temple priest don't discuss politics, or dos and don'ts of Hinduism, but Mosques & Churches do exactly opposite to that. They are quite political in nature. They collect a compulsory membership fee that consistbof some percentage of an attendee's income... They talk politics and political parties; to my surprise that they discuss Geopolitics as well. Both have their view on Israel. Jains, Bhuddists, Sikhs and Parsis don't do any of that.
Good observation
There's no fee to go to a mosque. And a mosque, or a church, or a temple: all of these are social institutions too. Quite naive to pretend that a Hindu temple or any other religious place does not influence social life.
@@user-gv5mo1rd2p U being naive... None of the temples of the indic value system talk politics, be it Jain, Gurudwara, or Parsi Fire temple...By membership fee I meant Zakat and tithes. I'm sure, u haven't heard of the word Tithe.
You naive nelly, pandits don't have to make a political statement for endorsing BJP or a Hindu government. Also, zakat or any other thing is never "required* to be given to a mosque. Don't confuse Islam with pagan traditions.
@@user-gv5mo1rd2pTrue
There was need of BJP amd RSS because INDIA was never a practicing secular state that's why they came. Religious appeasement was always there since independence.
@@usual-suspect impression anti hindu
@@usual-suspect I got it but he was 😭
Shekher ji, the Ram Mandir issue is galvanizing me to support Hinduism as a state religion. Although I support a secular republic, the constant attacks by my fellow Muslims and people of the left on the Ram Temple, without understanding the gravity of this issue, are making me sick. As a coping mechanism, it forces me to contemplate the extremes. Thanks for reminding me about what happens when religion is involved in state affairs.
Lol but this whole report only discredit islam as a state religion, only they have such constant fights and cry victim when they're not in majority
Not at all. It is stupid to equate Islam with Hinduism. They can't be more diverse and opposing.
There r many Buddhist countries - Thailand, Cambodia, Laos, Japan. Why don't u compare them with India. Singapore is a modern country. India can be Hindu and be modern at the same time.
@@RKCHUX we are modernizing too... Buddhism in Japan is waning..
Religion ? It was always there in USA ,UK, ITALY ,NETHERLAND ,POLAND, UAE , SAUDI ARABIA , CHINA.
AND THEY ARE a developed nation ,only those states are weak where AMERICA has its proxy.
India is gradually moving toward islamic nation if not stopped now then it will be too late. Popular of muslim have increased in India but at same time HINDUS have reduced in PAKISTAN, BANGLADESH, no BUDDHIST in MALDIVES , IN Nepal MUSLIMs no. are increasing , Iran no more PARSIAN, AFGHANISTAN no more SIKHS or HINDU, KASHMIR , Lakshadweep, KERALA are prime example ,northeastern states were converted by missionaries , only 53 % hindus are there in ASSAM ( thanks to open border and humanity) . In recent caste census in BIHAR data showed that there are more than 2crore people are muslims. It's a threat.
@@RKCHUXAll of the countries you mentioned are secular and liberal.
How cynically Mr Gupta compares growing religiosity among Hindus with Islamism. No Mr. Gupta your are wrong because fundamentals of both religions are different. Therefore fundamentalists will be different as well.
Lol.
Fundamentalists don't look at fundamentals of religions. All fundamentalists have almost same fundamentals... and evil in their hearts feed it. Religions or nationalism just provide divine or patriotic justification
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
Just like leftist say hindutva is political Hinduism same way why don't political islam is simply said as ISLAMISM
I am a proud leftiest..
And i agree with you
@@quenky1Bhai me to left right ki politics ko hi nahi manta I am atheist. Mere bahut vichar leftist se milte hain par islam ko le kar bahut jyada against hu unke.
For me islam is worst ideology currently. Yes worse than communism, worse than Hindutva, worse than evangelical Christianity.
If you are supporting or helping islam you are my enemy full stop.
This is reason even western self proclaimed liberal and atheists have started voting far right.
Islam is flobal problem.
Hinduism is full of problem too.
But see one guy is coming to kill me and other guy doesn't want to touch me. First one is much more dangerous.
@@mountolympus1098 👏👏
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
There is no devotion in Islam. It is all about subjugation of other faiths. Islam is purely political.
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
No spiritual principles either. It's all transactional religion
Again conflating spiritual side with political. Islam has a huge spritual side and devotion than most of you can imagine with hundreds of millions of people praying 5 times a day even in coldest nights, giving more charity than other religions, practicing extreme fasting for a month and giving up many of world's sins (liquor,adultery, gambling) for the sake of religion.
However, unlike other religions it doesnt limit itself to spritual aspects but extends to political arena which has been taken advantage and get to manipulated by then colonial and now american influence.
Fool
Q) What is Pakistan?
Ans: Many areas in Bharat have transformed from "Secular areas" into "Muslim areas". Pakistan & Bangladesh are two such gigantic areas. West Bengal, Assam & Kerala are next in the line if we look at the current demographic trends..Thankfully Hindus are in 'secular anesthesia' so the process would be smooth.
Cope cow worshipper.
I attended my hometown in Maharashtra and it has 70% peaceful people now. It has 30% about 2 generations ago.
@@highplatform1649 all towns & villages which were around 20% islam in 1950 are now Muslim majority. It's all part of plan.
Pakistan conversion to islam was during ghaznavid mughal. Whatsapp University is bad for you brain. There was no bharat. Mughals unifed india and if weren't for British you all would be muslim
@@desistarktm7270 you are childish it is the people who want islam in their life why dont you accept this fact... why there is so much political islam growing in West and North America and South America see after 100 years same thing will happen in india but don't worry nothing will happen to any non Muslim .they are as good as others except that they are non believers which is okay for muslims
Bangladesh is a country with Islam as a state religion. This is another way of saying it is an Islamic country. The Islamization of Bangladesh is happening at a much faster rate than one can think. Indian Journalists focusing mostly on the western side of India probably cannot fathom the true rate at which Bangladesh is moving towards that direction but as a Bengali we can.
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
In his first statement, SG got scared that now it is his time for Sar tan se juda.
If you can KEEP your head
When all about you are losing theirs.
Excerpt from R. Kipling's "If"
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
😂😂😂
Islam is inherently political considering its strict rules that forbid queer rights, multiculturalism and atheism.
Islam already has those laws ingrained in it's philosophy that BJP is trying to implement for Hindus since Hinduism didn't have them since the beginning (example,punishing blasphemy and conversions)
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
BJP doesnt apply those rules as the constitution gives freedom of individual to follow any belief peacefully. Since ancient times queer, atheism multiculturalism existed peacefully in India. Nastika people were not killed by kings.
India should keep it that way. I'm all for keeping islamism in check, that's absolutely necessary in every society, but to quote Nietzsche "He who fights with monsters might take care lest he thereby become a monster". I think especially at the state level some of the BJP's laws about things like cow protection, bulldozer justice, have parallels in Islam and should be very thoroughly debated. On things like queer rights you don't have to follow the exact path of the west (which has had its own downsides) but its good to find a way to stay true to that ancient philosophical tradition of tolerance and debate which pre-dates even the Western ideas. @@koteswar009
politics and islam are inseparable. Bangladesh while claiming to not be an islamist state has reduced its hindu population from 33% to 7%.
I see this comment in many places by hindus who have only surface level knowledge. Yes, Hindu is decreasing in BD. Because most hindu, who can, move out to India or other hindu zone willfully. Educated hindus move to US and other foreign countries and don't come back.
Those people moved to India... mainly during 1971 war.
How have they reduced? Ethnic cleansing? Why haven’t anyone raised a finger if such a thing had or is taking place
@@IronMan-nu3rbbecause they were killed or about to get killed in the war
@@JordanNoahhHad the bjp been there during 1971 war it would have been discussed
Islam is a complete way of Life and politics is just one part of it..
Stupid cult
Islam is political. There is nothing such as non political Islam. Please read.
Islam has spread through wars and conquests, even in its founding place with many non-muslim tribes wiped out and womenfolk captured. Plotics cannot be separated from it. It is only a matter of time before your examples of Bangladesh, Indonesia and Malaysia join the other islamic countries with islamic politics. They are already so to a degree.
Islam itself is a religion of wars and capturing lands and how to deal with it when land is captured, how to capture new land etc
No... that's your wrong opinion
@@IronMan-nu3rb
What is kafir in islam
What is idol worshipers in islam
@@IronMan-nu3rbthe history of persia, afghanistan, iraq, the whole northern africa is laughing at you.
@@niteshsahani7409 Kafir means Non Muslim. Aren't u Idol worshipper?
@@madanpunekar1406 all religion expand simple if earth is a billion yr old and Hinduism is 5000. That live acouple of million yrs plus islam is 1400yr old and with more the a billion in followers simple put people are free if they want to rejoin you in Hinduism which i doubt go co convince them. I think your anger is a coping mechanism with the reality of being completely Surrounded by muslims.
Sir You also forgot the Maldives. Something very hard for Indian to forget recently
For folks who disagree (the naive leftists) that Islam is a political philosophy please listen to Sarah Haider. Also I disagree Malaysia or Bangladesh are exemplary secularism. In well developed, beautiful Malaysia apostasy is prohibited, only Hindus/Christians can convert to Islam and not the other way round - this is a controversial and painful issue in that country. Here is the link to her talk: th-cam.com/video/55x9ndmkUpA/w-d-xo.html
I used to crib about the beginning ad but now that it's gone, I think I miss it.
"Save it for someone else" 🥺
😅
@@BeE_AriyaNI miss that cutie
I really like this piece as My country Nigeria is suffering from this nonsense ideology
Boko Haram is funded by Western countries. And wahabbism is being imported by Saudis.
Nigerians are not vocal online about this.
You should shame western leftists who shout BLM. But only when it suits their agenda.
Speak up
Nigeria should be divided in half muslim and Christians. Since you Christians see yourself as oppressed by us. I'm sure you won't end up like congo.
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
SG sir, Its not right to compare Islam with Hinduism. Islam is a religion with one god, one book, one set of prechings; whereas Hinduism is a way of life. Dont have one God, one book and inclusions is Dharm of Hinduism.
Having said that oucome with rise of Hinduism and Islam is not apple to apple comparison.
Even if people with counter views replace Hinduism with Hindutva in my above paragraphs, of rise of Hidutva will not lead to same consequences, because there is no binding force (of one God, one Book, one Preachings, or one Preacher) in Hindu, Hinduism, or Hindutava. Hence fear mongering is not needed
You guys are playing with Hindutva fascism the same way Pakistan played with Islamism in 70s and 80s. It'll be funny to watch India destroy its religious/cultural pluralism. Keep pretending it's a non-issue, it doesn't affect the majority after all.
@@user-gv5mo1rd2p We got your memo. Stop spamming the comment section. Yes, we want to become a H I N D U Pakistan. So?
see the better answer would be to ask from an average indian Muslim. as i grew up in a hindu society with little to no Muslims in contact apart from my own relatives who live hundred of kms away. sadly i would say the the environment will sooner or later become the same as the radaclised Islamist state in the form of hindu country.
even Islamic set of teaching said treat your neightbour better so they don't think Islam is bad. but none of those radaclised people followed the teachings of Islam and see what they have done with their country.
that's my humble answer.
Mr Gupta, either you have lack of knowledge on this aggresive political militaristic religious ideology or intentionally you are sugarcoating this ideology. This decade long narrative of one sided and flawed version of secularism are awakening increasing number of Hindus and that gave birth to BJP, not the other way around. So when you preach at the end that this increasing religiousness of Hindus in India is not good for India, you are denying the continuous step motherly treatment of Hindus by Indian System since independence. We can understand your heartburn.
Actually he has to appease his masters who give him$$$ but then he can't antagonise his viewers and the present dispensation and also Bharat's pulse and enthusiasm for RamJanmBhoomi so he chooses Islam to drive his point and camouflage his anti Sanatan intentions but its too late had Bharat not been divided on religious grounds his view could have been considered but the people of Bharat have waited too long sucking their thumb in the name of secularism only to find that no milk flows trough the thumb of secularism😂
Je Suis ThePrint. (just in case...)
Hi baldy, why your lyrics has changed?
Did Omadiyar fund for causing unrest in India dried up?
ok but how is this the "national interest" seems more like a "Personal Interest"🤣🤣🤣🤣
Why is there an ad at the beginning of the video? It is stitched into the video itself, thereby bypassing the “no ads” feature of TH-cam premium. Some of us paid to see no ads. How does youtube justify allowing this underhand tactic?
Shekhar - please do not compare Hinduism with Islam. Islam as a state religion will always be destructive.
Whereas Hinduism as state religion will always preach Dharma. There is no comparison between the 2 philosophies
Je Suis ThePrint. (just in case...)
Thanks, Shekhar ji for the wonderful overview and sharp points. The video is very balanced and cuts the clutter about very different interpretations.
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
Thank you, my friend. I'm glad you found this episode insightful. Do keep watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
For those conflating spiritual side with political and completely denying the former. Islam has a huge spritual side and devotion than most of you can imagine with hundreds of millions of people praying 5 times a day even in coldest nights, giving more charity than other religions, practicing extreme fasting for a month and giving up many of world's sins (liquor,adultery, gambling) for the sake of religion.
However, unlike other religions it doesnt limit itself to spritual aspects but extends to political arena which has been taken advantage and get to manipulated by then colonial and now american influence.
Islam itself is the most "peacefull" "blessed" way of political "religion".
Ask SG ,who surrounded Indian express ,Bengaluru office ?
Je Suis ThePrint. (just in case...)
Islam is never apolitical, so is our Shekhar Gupta, doesn't miss a chance to take a stab at Hindutva, how much ever subtle it might be.
So glad to see you back , Shekhar Ji ❤
Remember dear gupta sahib neither political Hinduism nor political Islam can produce any good.Religion and state two different things and we all must accept this.At the end I would request you to look what your country,s politician are doing.Set a good example first then throw ash on other.love for all hatred for none. Mahmood Butt.
The ultimate goal of spiritual practice is Moksha or Nirvana means liberating knowledge which will set you free from bondage and illusion and help unlock the mystery of universe. For the path and process of this realization Hindus are free without prophet or conversion. There are festivals throughout the year to enjoy and library for lifetime to guide in every aspect of life. It's way of life.
"ದಯವೇ ಧರ್ಮದ ಮೂಲ" Kindness is the essence of a relegion - Sri Basveshwara, 12 century saint and,reformer from Karanataka.
Islam, no matter how inhumane it is, will keep becoming stronger and stronger
why is that ? any reason ?
ISLAM0PH0BIA ❌
'QURAN'0PHOBIA✅
Islam is entirely political in its genesis and organisation! Sooner this is understood the better it is.
Je Suis ThePrint. (just in case...)
Your channel is never so scared to discuss Hindus
Islam can never exist without politics,Islam is itself a politico-religious thought
My humble assessment ......
.......
The Cat (US) gets the rat (Pakistan military establishment) to come to their country. The Cat has assessed how hungry the rat is and knowing very well the rat is unscrupulous but still wants to know how low it can go ! The rat discusses options and rewards with the smaller cat(US Defence). Quite possible the rat would have agreed to empower the militant groups along the border to create trouble for Iran in return for some rewards. Similar strategy by West to engage militant groups in Syria and Iraq to hurt Iran. That is why Iran is attacking these proxies.
For some decades Iran ofcourse has been behaving like a rogue nation empowering its proxies (Hamas, Hezobullah, Houthis et al) who all claim to fight for freedom for their people but ultimately will end up being war mongering dictatorial states like Pakistan should they become independent states.
Many of these Islamic states operate like war lords from the earlier centuries each dreaming up to reclaim muslim dominance they once enjoyed whether it be Iran, Turkey et al.
Saudis will be happy to see US get involved in a war against Iran their arch enemy and weaken them so that there is a regime change via a rebellion. Turkey would like Iran to maintain its status so that the Saudis are kept in check and possibly destabilised and they could become the leader of the Sunni world. Russia is looking for a chance to get out of the Ukraine war without losing face. That is possible only if the US gets involved in a war and thereby stops assistance to Ukraine that would give them an upperhand when peace talks happen. China wants the US to be knee deep in the war so that they will be weakened and they can get back to normal relations as a stronger player.
IT IS A STRANGE WORLD !!!
GuptaJi does have a good sense of humor... Jaish-e-this and jaish-e-that!!
But then, of course, he has to push his agenda at the end!! Sir, with all due respect, Hinduism and Islam are Fundamentally different. High time you left-liberals accept this fact (I say accept, because you KNOW it is true, but refuse to acknowledge it)
Maulana maududi's Jamaat-e-Islami Ideology gave birth to Jihadi Ideology in Pakistan.
When zia ul haq was dictator of Pakistan....
Jamaat ideology is totally based upon political islam.
Maulana Maudidi & his history related to Aurangabad Maharashtra where Aurangzeb Grave is located....
Was big Supporter of Aurangzeb ideology of political Islam...
India should ban Jamaat-e-Islami & its radical ideology otherwise civil War situation like riots between hindus & muslims inside india is inevitable in future....
Just like it banned Jamaat-e-Islami in Kashmir where jamaat was supporting radicalistion in the valley...
half of the opposition parties are just as bad in my opinion
Islam is root. There are thousand of islamic terror organisation. Banning one will not do magic.
Sir,Why are you taking breaks from CTC regularly nowadays?
My apologies. I was away in Davos for the week and was too immersed in the sessions and meetings to be able to sustain CTCs, and that too all by myself. Will make up for it now…thanks for your concern… Shekhar
If your non availability due to WEF can be informed, Print subscribers will be also be more than happy to give CTC a break. Also we will not keep posting "Hope you are fine!, Take Care Shekar" message daily.
What about political Hinduism these days sir....🌹🌹🌹🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂🤣🙏
Its a reaction to Political I S L A M. Remember Newton's 3rd law? Every action has equal and opposite reaction.
Political hindutva is everything other than Hinduism
our nation Bharat is also on a path of becoming Islamic nation. only difference is the religion and god. mejority Islamic state are with intolerance people, authotirian state, week institutions. In our nation, Mejority Hindu hates muslim and in a process of hating muslim, we are also becoming like muslim and in some cases worse than them.
Hinduism sanatan se isko islam se tulna kar chhota mat karo...🙏🙏
True.. Political Hinduism is more Dangerous for Indians and humanity as well.
With the trending topic expecting your show on Ram Ayodya event. It is one in lifetime event for the country irrespective of religion
Dear The Print,
Maybe grow a spine and stop deleting my comments. Thank You.
What an irony, in an 11 min long episode of "National Interest" the internet of the nation gets just a few seconds.
Here goes the " unhyphenated journalism". What a subtle slam on the Ram-Mandir Shekhar ji.
Israel has state religion it is progressing.
Thailand has state religion it is going fine.
Poland has state religion again working fine.
But sooner or later they will all go down first Thailand then Poland then israel you don't have that sense which I m having give it a note and believe me pass it to your generations they will see it
Surprised and funny to say Islam is not political ideology as its core ideology is to spread its faith and rule the whole world as Dar al Islam. Early Islamic legal theory divided the world into two divisions: "abode of Islam" and "abode of war". The first, called dar al-Islam, sometimes Pax Islamica, consisted of Muslims and non-Muslims living under Islamic sovereignty. The second was dar al-harb, ruled by non-Muslims and specifically infidels.
In fact I just read about the start of Rashidun Calipahte who succeeded their Prophet and how they conquered west Asia, northeast Africa, which is where most Islamic nations exist as the journalist said. Then came the Umayyad and Abassid Caliphates. He said India is excluded because Islam is not state religion. But one must remember the great kings from Kashmir, Rajasthan, Punjab, Gujarat, southern kings from Chalukya and Rashtrakuta who collaborated and defeated these three Calipahtes and they never again tried to attack after mid 800sCE after nearly over 2 centuries since 636 CE when their first naval attack on Thane was a defeat by local Indian king. Ofcourse many decades later Mohammad bin al Qasim conquered Sindh in 715 CE but the Arabs could not conquer India until Qutb ud din Aibak in 1206CE became first Sultan, only because Prithviraj Chauhan forgave Ghori in first battle of Tarain in 1191 CE, and next year Ghori defeated the former.
It's good to see you ❤
Bangladesh does not declare itself to be an Islamic Republic but Article 2A states that ' Islam shall be the state religion'. You know this or should no this but continue to false fake news-I presume the Petrodollar flow has been very good fpr you.
Sorry, Shekhar. I look forward to a CTC session on this subject.
As I see what is happening in the world including the Islamic world is the manifestation of "Survival of the fittest" and towards this end historically some groups are constantly trying to overpower other groups and as an extension, when a particular group becomes strong, sub groups emerge within that and the fight for survival continues.
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
Many religions,cultures, faith, beliefs and even ideas define a nation or a state even if they are at odds with each other. A nation is not a monolith as is evident by the example of a ever hostile neighbour Pakistan. Pakistan was carved out of india to protect the class interests of the Muslim elite in India. They feared loss of representation and political power in an independent and democratic India. But they forgot one thing that their would be space for everyone in india irrespective of their demographic strength. Pakistan's inability to develop as a nation that would be inclusive and accomodate differences has brought that nation to where it is standing today i.e security challenges, political instability, institutional corruption ,economic collpase and loss of geopolitical heft. Punjabi domination combined with Sunni islamism alienated every section of the society and triggered the alarm for minorities. Slowly this discontent is heavily weighing on this nation which is bracing for an impending collapse.
Shekhar Saab please make a video on global financial structure of political Islam the money flow to Islamic tsunami. Thanks for the wonderful video Sir.
Money flow to islamists. Correction in typing
That religion itself is a political ideology dressed up as a religion. Why do I say this? Read the islamic scriptures. God apparently tells to tax Jizya to non muslims instead of accepting and respecting them. God apparently tells the taxation rules and how to spread the only true religion. Every other religion is less than and should not be given equal justice. God apparently promises war booty and tells how to treat women as slaves, instead of talking about freeing them. All the rules are set.
India's Hindutva is also in the same league, Politics and Religion needs to be separate or more problems will be expected.
But where in lies the national interest if India in this context? I think the content of the National interest column of this episode belongs to some CTC episode, isn't appropriate for a national interest column.
@ 9:47 lesson for us for what, Rajat...? The undertone of building your entire narrative from @ 9:47 to 9:55 was to wean away Bharat from the current fervor of 'Ram Temple'... it is evident, and we could see it thru your whole narration... The moot question is - was the country not at a disadvantage when Iftar parties were held in the PM house; Haj Houses were built at fervent pace and subsidies were doled out to outdo each other. To use your favorite sport - Cricket - every side gets it's turn of batting, they batted till 2014 now we are batting - so, stop patronizing or sermonizing - feel the pulse of the country and say Jai Shri Ram...
You are right about what SG is hinting and SG is right about what he is saying
Je Suis ThePrint (just in case...)
Not only Political Islam but also any Religion that is Mixed and controlled by Politics and politicians are weakest and dangerous ......So Be it Political Islam, Political Hindu, Political Christian , Political Sikh, and Political Jews.........................Religious affairs must be handled by Religious people and not the Politicians or Prime Ministers..............
Je Suis ThePrint (just in case...)
The Print❤ 🙏बहुत दिनों से सोच रहा था की श्री राम 🚩के राम मय🙏 वतावरं मे राम 🚩के अलावा कोई कंटेंट नही 🤏दिख रहा है, और ये लो प्रिंट के अडिग अंतराष्ट्रीय इस्लामी प्रेम और विधवा विलाप तुरंत आ गया🤪 Keep it up The Print💪 Seculat🤠 Bro 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Demographic Islam >>>> Any type of Islam.
Je Suis ThePrint
(just in case...)
There is an american hand behind recent Iran pakisthan conflict
Wow, people realising injustice and saying killing of innocents is wrong is political now...
Good to see u back.
SG IS CLEARLY TARGETTING RAM MANDIR AND HINDUTVA POLITICS IN NAME OF L
POLITICAL ISLAM. LISTEN TILL END WHEN HE SAYS THERR IS IMPORTANT LESSON FOR US, INDIANS
A great message to carry forward
Islam is completely way of life,
Politics is also the part of life ,
Only portraying one side....
Honestly, this is the first time in many years the muslim countries in question arent using islam as the reason for the clash. Middle east has always been the capital of the crisis. Change in religions never made much difference. Khamenei wants the sassanid empire back and seems to be still following its foreign policy of annoying the hell out of its neighbors minus the constant wars.
Volume is less without ear phones
Apologies. What are you trying to say?
Islam requires obeisances and obedience and submission without question. Thanks to this very "peaceful" political "religion", a staunch beaf-eating alcohol-consuming porn-enjoying athiest like me have become a born again Hindu, after feeling the necessitation to house our culture against this peaceful dogma. Again, thank you, "peacelam".
What you think about political hindutva... Where does it stay in global politics and what is its clout?
SG sir, please consider a cut the clutter on Iran - Pakistan border conflicts.Thank you.
Political or Radical?😅
Today's Arab world are not emodying the political Islam. Look at Umar's kingdom to know what it would look like.
But the oppression of 95% mass people selecting leader through election in Bangladesh, which was interrupted by India will have enormous consequences.Use AI in social media for a survey. Election have become "National Security Issue" in mass people minds.
Shekhar Gupta's enthusiastic insistence on political Islam as monolith is amazing. He does not understand that it has many faces and manifestations. If he means political islam as using religion for politics, what about Modi and BJP's use of Hindu religion for political purposes. what Modi is doing on 22nd of January 2024, is he a shankaracharya? May we call it Hindufication or politcal hinduism?
Modi galat hai yeh 50% Indian maante hain, including me. Shouldn't we also discuss the facts which make me question political Islam, thinking is it indeed a threat to a moderate like me?
This rise is just catalyzed by earlier fissures on east & west lines that existed before the Gaza conflict. If the West's & Russia's relations weren't this bad and if Russia wasn't this preoccupied, Iran wouldn't be punching this much above it's weight.
Iran has been getting stronger since the 80s, clown.
Also, Islamic world was phenomenal in beating communism. It would be phenomenal in determining who comes out on top this time too. You are talking about roughly 1.7 billion people here.
This political Islam has weakened religious Islam back from Abbasi to till now.
SG well said "Any Politics that's determined by RELIGION is today hugely outdated and its also been discredited over the centuries".
According to you
@@Reginald-Dyer
No Sanskari BJP MP Brij Bushan
So final conclusion is you are drawing parallels between terrorists and Hindus 😅
It was clear that you were reading a written script. Makes it difficult to understand your message
Interesting analysis: the only country on your "so-called progressive" list I would agree with is Malaysia; and that too apparently because it has a "House of Rulers" some of whom use the interesting title Raja - denoting significant Hindu influence and therefore general tolerance to other faiths (famous Murugan temple) Good luck to Islamic majority countries in general - I do not give them much.
Malaysia has Islam in their Constitution. True Malays are supposedly Muslim. Indians & Chinese are second class citizens. Only true malays are bhumiputra.
Hinduism is not a religion,it's a way of life , Sad to see SG cannot get the difference 😂😂😂
Islam is also a way of life governing social, political and even economic aspects of life.
@@maquacr7014 good joke , good governance, Libya, Syria, Somalia , Pakistan, Uganda muslim African nation , Iran Afghanistan, etc, ISIS,Al Qaeda, Hamas , Internet ka zamana hai Bhai propaganda ko update Karo , 1400 years ka strategy purana ho gaya hai
@@sandeepshetty237 Almost all of the countries you mentioned were destroyed as a result of Western interference. The terrorist organizations were created as a result of Western interference.
Stop using the few braincells you have. It is not good for your health.
@@maquacr7014 yes, that is the problem. People take religion with god given right. If it starts interfering in social ,political and economic aspects of life, it becomes very problematic, because then humans begin using religion as a weapon for self gain. Humans are very hypocritical animals.
Religion should be restricted to only spiritual aspects of life.
That is is the difference between religion and way of life , In India before Arab invasion there was no violence bases of religion my friend , read the Quran or follow Adam seeker ,
One god in different forms at different times and places, this simple thing is ignored for political reasons. I can not make any simpler then this guys. 😁
If the thing you’re claiming to have analysed can be at its greatest or lowest depending on how you look, it is a nonsensical argument to begin with. End of discussion.