Bandiyal jo adhi raat ko adalat khol ker patwariyon ko hakomat mein laya, aaj patwari ussi ko galiyan dey rahe hain, ye 'Suwer' patwari Faiz Issa ko bhi nahin chorrain gey hehe.
You are one of the few TH-camrs who are actually trying to do something positive in Pakistan. Keep up the good work Junaid bhai! More power to you from Berlin, DE 🇩🇪
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview. See my other comments for list of errors.
If, Out of 15,57,000 viewers who have seen this video, at least 50% are Pakistanis, the hard work of Junaid Akram and Muzammil Shah is fulfilled. God save Pakistan.
I’m a 73 year old senior indian and after listening to Muzzimil can safely predict that as long as sane and knowledgeable people like you are there in Pakistan everything is not lost. Just want to add that it doesn’t mean that everything is perfect in India but at least we are moving in right direction. Wish you a great future.
From India here. I've heard Syed Bhai in great detail in many of his videos and podcasts. I must say I'm always blown away by his clarity of thoughts and his ability to speak his mind out. A gem of Pakistan. I also believe that the majority of people in Pakistan even despise him but people like these are the ones who need to be heard. More power to you Syed.
I am an Indian and have watched podcasts of many intellectuals from India and West. But have never been astonished by the knowledge level of a person in Politics and Philosophy until I watched this podcast. Mr. Shah is a hidden gem.
Thanks Syd Muzamil for this amazing podcast. Honestly for me Junaid Akram, Syd Muzamil and Wildlens Abrar are the youtubers who are worthy of watching from Pakistan.
It would be great if Pakistani TH-camrs add english subtitle since they're missing a massive Indian audience who don't know Hindi/Urdu(especially from South & East India). It's great to hear history, different view points, economics, etc., which is not a shouting match!!! Hope they add Subtitles to this video as well.
I'm from India 🇮🇳. This is a very long podcast but every minute was worth it. There was so much clarity and logic behind each spoken word. I'm blown away!!! There were so many pointers to take away as learnings that we can incorporate in our personal lives (even if I keep aside Pakistan's current state & political scenario).
ALL the Books mentioned by Syed Muzammil Shah: - Two Treatises of Government (in the Former, The Falfe Principal and Foundation of Sir Robert Filmer) - Leviathan - Thomas Hobbes - The Social Contract - Jean-Jacques Rousseau - Amusing Ourselves To Death (Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business) - Neil Postman - The Origins of Totalitarianism - Hannah Arendt - Madness & Civilization - A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason - Michel Foucault - A Princely Affair The Accession And Integration Of The Princely States Of Pakistan 1947 1955 - Yaqoob Khan Bangash - The Crowd (A Study of the Popular Mind) - Gustave Le Bon - The Communist Manifesto and Das Kapital - Karl Marx - Crime and Punishment - Fyodor Dostoevsky - The Brothers Karamazov - Fyodor Dostoevsky - Blook and Oil (MSB's Ruthless Quest for Global Power) - Bradley Hope & Justin Scheck - The End of History and The Last Man - Francis Fukuyama - The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the World Order - Samuel P. Huntington - Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media - Edward S. Herman and Noam Chomsky - Brave New World - Aldous Huxley Syed Muzammil Shah's list of must-read books: - Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind - Yuval Noah Harari For understanding (introduction to) Philosophy, these three books: - The Pleasures of Philosophy - Will Durant - The Story of Philosophy - Will Durant - A History of Western Philosophy - Bertrand Russell - Beyond Good and Evil - Friedrich Nietzsche - Thus Spoke (Spake) Zarathustra - Friedrich Nietzsche - The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam (Encountering Traditions) - Mohammad Iqbal For Pakistan (these three books are based on objective history) - Magnificient Illusions - Husain Haqqani - Reimagining Pakistan - Husain Haqqani - Pakistan Between Mosque & Military - Husain Haqqani - Yeh Khamoshi Kahan Tak by Lt. Gen. SHahid Aziz - The Murder of History - K.K. Aziz - The Nine Lives of Pakistan - Dispatches from a precarious state - Declan Walsh Religious History: - The Heirs of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) - Barnaby Rogerson Partition: - Freedom at Midnight - Larry Collins and Dominique Lapierre Jinnah: - Jinnah - His Success, Failures and Role in History - Ishtiaq Ahmed - Jinnah of Pakistan - Stanley Wolpert - My Brother - Fatima Jinnah Military: - Military Inc - Inside Pakistan's Military Economy - Ayesha Siddiqa
Books recommended by Sir Muzammil shah 1.Sapians a brief history of humankind 2.The pleasures of philosophy 3.Story of philosophy by Will Durant 4.A history of western philosophy by Bertrand Russell 5.Magnificent delusion by Hussain Haqani 6.Reimagining Pakistan 7.Pakistan between mosque and military 8.The nine lives of Pakistan by Declan Walsh 9.Heirs of prophet Muhammad 10.Jinnah his success, failures and role in history by Ishtiaq Ahmed 11.Jinnah of Pakistan by Stanley Wolpert 12.My brother by Fatima Jinnah 13.Military inside Pakistan's military economy second edition by Ayesha siddiqa 14.Beyond good and evil by Friedrich Nietzsche 15. Murder of the history 16. Freedom At Midnight
I have read Sapiens and it's safe to say it's a populist book written by a populist writer. He has mixed science and fiction a lot to present his ideas.
میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔
Here from 🇮🇳. He is one of the very few educated minds in true sense who thinks rationally and logically. Pakistan should bring forward people like him to discuss issues between the two countries. Im trying to imagine what would happen in the subcontinent if majority of people in Pakistan starts thinking the way he does. Definitely going to follow him for more of his content.
majority of the Indians are also same who give huge openings to the propaganda films which breed hate/ enmity for other religion or country. Indians kill Muslims or bash them in rallies considering them as threat to the sanatan dharam.
There’s a lot of us like him. Trust me you can come to Pakistan and the average person will think rationally as he does, however our voices aren’t heard due to the establishment and the amount of power they have.
Syed Muzammil Shah inspired me to take up the books again...I was so keen of reading books in the college life, but after marriage and having kids, and due to my job, for the last 10 years i forgot how much bibliomaniac i was.... He reminded me of that...and now i am starting my second innings with the books thanks to him..❤❤❤
Listening to this gem of a podcast from India! A rare intellectual from Pakistan! Pleasure to listen to him every time! So much to learn and be inspired from! Hope to get more pearls of wisdom from this rare voice of reason, logic, political science and philosophy!
An Indian 🇮🇳 here, previously I watched few Junaid Akram's podcast, but I never watched around 3 hours of any podcast ever. A new subscriber here for you Syed Muzammil Shah. Kudos. Loved every min of this podcast.
co - existence is only possible if u r not having a mindset of having double standards driven by a fake narrative of Religiously motivated Bigoted Superiority. Zia and his followers built this narrative based on the Two nation theory propagated by the founding father of the Muslim League Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan who was from Aligarh and whose followers r still doing their best in a clandestine organized way to weaken India internally. Hence the Indian state has realized that the only way to crush these zealots is to destroy their most precious creation and achievement i.e. Pakistan. So India post PM Modis famed Sharif wedding attendance debacle post which Pathankot and URI were countered by our Surgical strike at Balakot and other operations . The current Govt. has decided on a wholistic approach of Balkanizing Pakistan by destroying its economy by destroying its internal and external support structure of Pakistan. Hence ur current Status Quo of economic degradation and political turmoil and fissures in the Establishment GHQ in Rawalpindi and ISI in Islamabad. We r further gonna help target ur ex pats and retd, generals with their children and progeny of ur political elite in their European American Australian and Dubai based exclaves created by ur 1% elites. We r going to go after these Paki Parasites Mossad style the way the Israelis did after the Muslim Brotherhood in the 60s and 70s. All this can be done only if their assets and invesments in Pakistan crash and become valueless for raising capital in the global financial markets devaluing their companies and destroying their means to survive globally as calculated by our agencies thus destroying the Fauji faundations. Pakistan will be worse than Lebanon at the peak of its financial crisis all its gonna take is an cataclysmic event at Bin Qasim Port like the one in Lebanon and guess what it only takes a few ill intentioned Afghans or Balochis who were rubbed the wrong way by the Pakistani Army or Rangers to do the needful. Jai Hind
@@Truthseeker7890 Why should we ? Its not like they've so we deliberately have to have someone like him Indian constitution ensures every individual Indian's rights, we don't need to worry like them Be on your own
Thanks for inviting Muzammil. This is your best podcast so far. It’s time Pakistanis get out of their ‘pak studies’ bubble and get a reality check of this sinking ship called Pakistan. Truth is the only way forward.
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I, can see the fallacies and errors in his interview. See my other comments for list of errors.
@@afaqh2356 Isn't everyone biased? I am also biased against backward ideas, exploitative traditions and state propaganda for example. He never said his ideas are perfect. He even said he could contradict himself at times and I think that is okay. I also dont agree with some things he says, nothing wrong with disagreement. If you disagree with him, you can also make a video sharing what you think, everyone has youtube platform available to share their views.
@@ahsanjahangir8834 @43:00 Why is Muzammil linking US revolution to revolt against religion? As he said, it was a revolt against injustice. If religion is misused by some people, then it does not mean that religion is wrong. No religion allows tyrany. It means that religion is being applied wrongly. @44:04 In Turkey, secularism was imposed on the defeated society. And religion was effectively banned. They progressed materialy, but the spiritual void remained. This got an outlet in the shape of Urdagan. And people are reverting to religion. @45:00 Muzammil praises secularism in Turkey and Azerbaijan. Crushing religion is not secularism. They have laws against religion, like not being allowed to have Muslim names or the Turkish Cap. Is this what Muzammil wants? And this is what Muslims fear. Another example is France, where wearing a turban or scarf is banned in public. Is this secularism? @46:30 Muzammil says, we should compromise on principles because India is bigger & more powerful. So we should talk to her & ignore principles. By this he means that if Pakistan were more powerful then it should also force it's illegal views on others. Also, he says India doesn't give a damn about Pakistan. India DOES give a damn. See all the Anti Pakistan rhetoric in their media. @47:37 Muzammil says where Muslims are more than 30%, they don't want secularism. This is wrong. Only in places where Muslims are in majority, they want a society that has Islamic values. @1:02:06 Muzammil likes western philosophy because it puts an individual above society. As he says, all other philosophies put society above individual. This is so because, this is the innate psychology of humans. The Libral philosophy has come only in the last century, and is promoted by a certain segment for their own interests. Survival of humans depends on community. As per Social Contract of Rousseau and Hobbs, an individual must give away some of his liberties to enable a functioning society. How many liberties to be given away varies. Liberals want individuals to think only of themselves. There be no bounds of ethics, morality, culture or religion on an individual. This causes gradual degradation and a breakup of social structure. A breakup of Families like we see in the West. There being no emotional bonds between individuals. Such a society is without roots or culture. Aim of individual is to get maximum benefits & enjoy life while it lasts. Pure capitalism which derives from Liberalism has been shown to cause harm to society. Like in West 1% of population owns majority of the wealth. @1:02:06 If an individual is greater than the society, then he/she should not give any sacrifices, for the betterment of the society. A soldier advancing against a hail of bullets, and giving the ultimate sacrifice (his life), will be an ignorant fool. Muzammil himself says, he is prepared to give sacrifices, to promote his Liberal ideology. Why? @1:7:43 Muzammil says, the challenge of Pakistan is wrong Philosophy. This is not true. The challenge of Pakistan is Elite capture. It is they, who invoke philosophies as per their interest. As he himself said, they take decisions to ensure their hold and the nation suffers the consequences. So, if they use religion, then it does not mean religion is wrong. @1:14:39 Muzammil says we are going to default in a year. He is right, that wrong policies of successive Govts is to blame. But he should note that the PTI govt, despite of Covid & being shackled, had managed to turn around the economy. They managed 6% growth, despite there being no "War". Unfortunately, the scoundrels ganged up & managed to bring down his Govt, to protect their own interests. @1:15:19 Muzammil says plagiarism is not checked in universities. This is wrong it has being enforced in last decade or so.
@@ahsanjahangir8834 @1:17:00 Muzammil is right. The Establishment is the cause of rot of Pakistan. Also Establishment cooperated with Imran Khan to bring him to power. However, they ensured that he did not have a clear majority, so that they could control him. All the media curbs, and atrocities, that Muzammil talks about were perpetrated by the Establishment. This is clear from the worsening of these practices after removal of IK, by the Establishment. Why does Muzammil not say that the curbs and atrocities multiplied many fold after removal of IK? And why was IK removed? Because he delivered (despite being shackled) and was becoming a danger to their stranglehold on Pakistan. Only problem Muzammil has with IK is that he is right wing and hence against Liberals. @1:19:40 Junaid says that the war is over wooing the establishment & Muzammil agrees. This is false. Imran Khan has totally exposed the stranglehold of Establishment over Pakistan. Now people openly talk of reigning them in. IK cannot allow them this power even if he wanted to. Just like he cannot let go of corruption of PMLN & PPP. This is the biggest accomplishment of IK. Pakistan will never be the same again, even if IK is eliminated. The Establishment is fighting for it's survival. That is exposing them even more. @1:19:56 Muzammil says PTI wants to talk to Establishment (so is ready to surrender to them) also they wanted Faiz. This is false. IK has repeatedly said PDM has no power, so he wants to talk to Establishment. And he wants to talk about holding elections. Establishment offered IK to allow elections and thus come to power, if he was willing to forgive their crimes. This IK refused. Also IK has said he had no plans to install Faiz. Faiz was as much a part of Establishment as Bajwa or Munir. What IK opposed was, removal of Faiz, bypassing the authority of PM by COAS Bajwa.
@@ahsanjahangir8834 @1:22:37 Muzammil has rightly opposed extension of Interim setup beyond 90 days. That is what IK is demanding. He has put the Establishment in such a spot, that they are forced to subvert the constitution again. Thus exposing themself. @1:25:21 Muzammil says that democracy does not work due to Biradris/tribes. This is wrong. Actually Tribes & societies exist to protect the member's rights. This is a necessity if the legal system is weak. So we need to implement the rule of Law. Biggest enabler of Democracy is education. And if democratic values exist, then even the Biradries will select competent people. @1:25:34 Muzammil says democracy comes when family structure breaks. THIS IS THE MOST DANGEROUS THING, HE HAS SAID IN THIS INTERVIEW. As said before education is the biggest enabler of democracy. Family is the basic unit of the society, and it must never be broken. It is in the western culture, where the families are dysfunctional, children leave home at 18years and have no bond with each other. Majority of kids live in single parent family. This is the biggest flaw of Western society. And Muzammil is a proponent of implementing it. @1:36:28 Muzammil says rise of populism is due to social media. This is not correct. Populism occurs when there is disillusion with the current system. People look for alternates. Social media provides a platform that cannot be controlled by the authorities. If people are impressed by a leader, then it is simply because they hope that he will be atleast better than those being projected by the mainstream media. @1:42:52 Muzammil says Pakistan can be corrected from outside. THIS IS WRONG. The outside powers have no interest in "correcting" Pakistan. They are only interested in what benefits them. Pakistan can only be corrected by awareness & activism of it's own people.
Keep up the good work Junaid bhai. Loved todays show as all others before. Lot to learn from Muzzamil bhai for everyone not only Pakistanis. Lot of love from India.
@@onestar627 tum loog apni fikar karo gobarchaap, 720 millions indians are kiving below poverty line they dont have food shelter sanitary, take those snake worshiper indians out from poverty instead off being US puppet showing off fake progress
co - existence is only possible if u r not having a mindset of having double standards driven by a fake narrative of Religiously motivated Bigoted Superiority. Zia and his followers built this narrative based on the Two nation theory propagated by the founding father of the Muslim League Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan who was from Aligarh and whose followers r still doing their best in a clandestine organized way to weaken India internally. Hence the Indian state has realized that the only way to crush these zealots is to destroy their most precious creation and achievement i.e. Pakistan. So India post PM Modis famed Sharif wedding attendance debacle post which Pathankot and URI were countered by our Surgical strike at Balakot and other operations . The current Govt. has decided on a wholistic approach of Balkanizing Pakistan by destroying its economy by destroying its internal and external support structure of Pakistan. Hence ur current Status Quo of economic degradation and political turmoil and fissures in the Establishment GHQ in Rawalpindi and ISI in Islamabad. We r further gonna help target ur ex pats and retd, generals with their children and progeny of ur political elite in their European American Australian and Dubai based exclaves created by ur 1% elites. We r going to go after these Paki Parasites Mossad style the way the Israelis did after the Muslim Brotherhood in the 60s and 70s. All this can be done only if their assets and invesments in Pakistan crash and become valueless for raising capital in the global financial markets devaluing their companies and destroying their means to survive globally as calculated by our agencies thus destroying the Fauji faundations. Pakistan will be worse than Lebanon at the peak of its financial crisis all its gonna take is an cataclysmic event at Bin Qasim Port like the one in Lebanon and guess what it only takes a few ill intentioned Afghans or Balochis who were rubbed the wrong way by the Pakistani Army or Rangers to do the needful. Jai Hind
Are all indians intellectual Liberal ??😂 Indian doesn't mean = Educated Intellectual. Vast majority of our population is UNDER poverty and deprived from education.
It took me 4 days to watch this podcast till end as I had been doing so in small breaks between my work. But it was worth every minute. Syed Muzammil is a gem and each sentence from him was clear, precise, logical, set in a proper context, and supported by historical facts. His knowledge of philosophy and history is unmatched, and the icing on the cake (the cake being his repository of knowledge) is his communication skill. The way he imparts his knowledge and applies it to answer the question asked is superb. More power to Muzammil.
جھوٹ کے بغیر اسلام مر جاتا ہے! اسلامی نقطہ نظر کے مطابق دنیا کی ساری تخلیق ابلیس اور اللہ کی دشمنی سے وجود میں آئی ہے۔ ابلیس اللہ کی نافرمانی کرتا ہے۔ اور سب سے اہم بات یہ ہے کہ محمد بے گناہ نہیں تھے، وہ گناہوں سے بھرے ہوئے تھے۔ ورنہ خالق کا کوئی نبی زہر کھا کر نہیں مر سکتا۔ وہ اپنے بستر پر اس قدر سرسراہٹ کر رہا تھا کہ ان کے پاس آنے والا فرشتہ بھی اللہ سے ان کی صحت یابی کی دعا کرتا تھا۔ اپنا اسلامی صحیفہ پڑھیں۔ آپ ایک ایسے شخص پر کیسے یقین کر سکتے ہیں جس کی 11 بیویاں ہوں اور بے شمار جنسی غلام ہوں، 6 سال کے بچوں کی شادی ہو، اس کی بلی کو اس وقت تک انگلی اٹھائے رکھیں جب تک وہ 9 سال کی عمر میں نہ کھا لے، اس نے اپنے لے پالک بیٹے کی بیوی سے شادی کی، اس نے اپنے مذہبی عقائد کی وجہ سے بہت سارے لوگوں کو مار ڈالا۔ ان کی بیویوں اور بہنوں سے ہمبستری کی، ان جنسی غلاموں کی تجارت کی، بنو قریظہ کابلہ کے بالغ لڑکے کو قتل کر دیا جو بلوغت کو پہنچنے کے بالکل قریب تھا وہ نوعمر لڑکا تھا۔ شیطان نبی کی زبان کا مالک کیسے ہو سکتا ہے؟سورہ حج کی آیت نمبر 52 میں آپ کے نبی نے اسے قبول کیا اور یہ 52 آیت گزشتہ کے 8 سال بعد آئی۔ اسے اس کی بیوی نے اپنے خوبصورت غلاموں سے ہم بستری کرتے ہوئے رنگے ہاتھوں پکڑا اور اس طرح قرآن نازل ہوا۔ اسے بچانے کے لیے. اے خوبصورت نبی! تمہارے نبی نے اپنی کزن ام ہانی کے ساتھ رومانس کیا تھا اور تم بے وقوف مسلمان سمجھتے ہو کہ اللہ اپنے نبی کو گدھے پر بلاتا ہے، گدھا اور نبی دونوں ان کے خون کی لکیر میں سب سے آخری تھے۔ تم مسلمان سب سے زیادہ گناہ گار قوم ہو اور لعنتی انسانیت ہو۔ تم ایسے شخص کی پیروی کیسے کر سکتے ہو جیسے اپنے نبی کی پیروی کرو اور عوام کے سامنے یہ کہہ دو کہ وہ بے گناہ تھا۔ تم جھوٹے ہو! شرم کرو تم پر اور تمہارے نبی پر Mmm
واہ جناب اتنے مختلف موضوعات پر اتنی مفصل گفتگو بہت کم سننے میں آئی ہے. مزمل صاحب کی پہلی نیٹ پہ موجودگی جب سے دیکھی ان کی باتوں نے تب سے باندھ رکھا ہے. ان کی باتیں کئی کتابوں کے مطالعہ کا نچوڑ ہوتا ہے.. جو سامع کو بہت ایجوکیٹ کردیتا ہے.... آپ کا بھی شکریہ کہ اتنی اچھی گفتگو کو پیش کیا ہے.. جزاکم اللہ
میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔
I didn't know muzammil shah before this podcast and I am so thankful to Junaid bhai that you invited him in this podcast. This is the mindset we need to clean the mess we have created in our country. I hope more people watch this podcast and think again what we need to do in reality.
I wonder if Barkha Datt would be appreciated in HINDUSTAN doing exactly what this dude is doing in PAKISTAN, 🤔🤨🙄 and then I wonder why not?? Is it because this dude is cute like the ex PM Imran Khan and she is not?? Or is it simply because men in South Asia have more value no matter what and whatever professional fields.
I am from India and moved to US several decades back. Enjoy listening to Mr. Shah all the time. Credit should also go to Mr. Akram for asking very sharp questions at the right time that kept the interview in a flow. Both are very intelligent people.
@@bojpuri423 Aakhir Zaahilistan Bhikaaristan ki aukaat dikha di tune. Ye intellectuals ki baatein, sumane samajhne ki kaabiliyat Bhikaaristan ke Jyaadaatar Zaahilon ke kamjor dimaag ke bas ki baat nahin hain.
@@rajeshjoshi3646India ka b koi intellectual bata do jisi sune ham godi godi hi bazar ata ha ka Pakistan ha hi intelligent Country India is cheap country
I am 81 years old... As I have seen Pakistan as a part of India, I feel very bad inside when I see people are suffering there... This is the first podcast which makes me feel that people there, are understanding things.. Keep it up..
❤❤ this is what we expect from you brother. We are the same people. Arabs are not ours but you are separated brothers.but our hearts beat the same blood. And our bodies carry the same DNA
@@ExamCracker912yes but most of ur population consider Arabs,Turks as ur ancestors which is totally wrong, u also belong to indus valley civilization like us😊
Bhai Pakistan se hu seekh lo...hamare yahan ab wohi sab ho raha hai jo unke yahan 70 saal pehle hua tha...wohi institutions ko compromise karna, wohi media par badhta state control, wohi bigotry, wohi communalism...shuru shuru mein unko bhi economic growth mili thi aaj dekh lo kya haal hai...kuch seekh lo
I am an Indian and a fan of syed Muzamil hope people of Pakistan release this mans knowledge and wisdom, hope to see in positions where he can contribute to the society
My deepest respect to Muzzamil! Your knowledge speaks for itself. It's not easy to speak facts and not offend anyone! Class. 100% eloquence in conversation. One of the best ever podcast if not the best.
Syed's knowledge is impeccable. His voice and narration is so absorbing that one can listen to him all day! Amazing! Love and respect from an Indian Aussie.
@@ShahidMehmood-ff3px I am from early 80's India, the amount of pain, Pakistan machineries instilled in us as a form of thousand cuts, when I see Syed Muzammil Shah, it saddens me, but when I see comment like yours it gives me hope 😀 Anyway jokes apart, there is a difference between *Knowledge* and *Application of gained knowledge* , try not to point shallow analogy of Chatur. Muzammil possesses both. Pause for a bit, use your gray matter and think how Chatur was depicted in the movie. Let me explain. The way it was shown, even if in a comedic way, Chatur was working, earning well and was important to his company. Competitive corporate work life is not that easy, hope you know this. No one will pay you 6 figures salary for charity. So Chatur might be shown as weirdo, but had knowledge and applicability,
Educate youth or demotivate youth? There is a big difference.. I watched his show with Syed Muzammil Hassan. And I noticed that this man is Criticizing each and everyone, everything and has no solution... Actually he is not educating he is demotivating people. He is against everything man literally everything. Against PTI and Imran khan. Against pmln Against ppp Against religion thoughts Against Men's dignity Against Media and all of media channels. Against Army, even the whole establishment. Philopher my 🏈
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views (towards Liberals) and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview. See my other comments for list of errors.
I am a professor in National University in Sweden. this is the first time I heard this man, and I am super impressed to say that he's really intelligent . thank you Junaid for introducing him to us.
@G That's why I said I am an academic, we are used to seeing regurgitation of existing theory but we look at the art of communications and how well one can articulate a structured argument backed up by theoretical evidence. Muzamil has beautifully relayed the historical facts and philosophical concepts in plain terms for the younger audience using this medium. It is impressive that he's attempting to spread a balanced thought and in doing so potentially and hopefully creating a progressive mindset. Hope this clarifies your question; but I detect a green-eyed monster more than anything else in it. Good luck with your inquiring mind.
@@iamglad1359 it was a simple question. The only thing I see is someone who's throwing names to sound philosophical...I don't kniw him....neither am I in the same space as he...why would I be green eyed...but if you can tell me what new he's staying I'll be forever grateful..
@@DWAGON1818 don't get jealous. The guy explained himself with reason why he liked Muzzamil but tumheri qk jaali hui hai because of your own bias to agey sy arguments kar rahe ho.
I really appreciate it how you both talked about the issues which balochistan and its people are facing since decades, It will help alot of people who doesn't know anything about balochistan and its issues. One of reason I watch your podcasts is that you talk about everything happening in this country, i hope someday people would understand whats its like to live as a Balochi and in Balochistan.😊
I'm an overseas Pakistani in the UAE. Me and my entire family is Punjabi so my view of Pakistan was centred around Punjab and Lahore. I met this Baloch girl in my school and I realised that Pakistan is much bigger than Punjab and really started reading up on Baloch culture, language, traditions and history. Balochistan really is a unique place and hope to explore eventually and understand the on-ground situation. If you have any resources on Balochistan to read up on, would you please tell me? Cheers from Abu Dhabi !
@@umerghaffar4686 There was a book in my father’s library written by a British lady who traveled to hinterland of Balochistan and wrote an interesting book called the Tigers of Balochistan. This book is more about culture and traditions but is very interesting. I don’t know how you can access it but Al Jazeerah did a documentary on the civil war in Balochistan.
Intellectualism is a dual-edged sword. If used purely to elevate your standing in the society, it can lead to narcissism and tunneled vision. However, if it's used with a purpose to elevate the society, it can lead to liberation. Keep searching for truth. You're a hero!
@@huzaifagujjar2762 Religion is a beautiful thing if we focus on the core teachings of the messengers. They were pure and wanted to elevate the society. Unfortunately, the masses are being controlled by power-hungry people these days in the name of religions. I wish you inner peace and wellbeing :)
Uncensored & unfiltered scathing social/political documentary! This is exactly what we need more of. Please don't let this kind of talent & truth leave our country 🙏
Syed, Being a Pakistani American it was so good to hear such a thought provoking arguments, reference, realization with the prevailing truths and taboos of the society. Pleasure to hear you. Looking forward for more from you. Good Luck.
Syed Muzzamil Shah is an outstanding intellectual and political scientist, who has devoted his life to the pursuit of knowledge and the promotion of critical thinking. He is a true champion of justice and equity, and has been an unwavering advocate for the rights of all individuals, regardless of their background or status. Through his tireless efforts, he has inspired countless others to think deeply about the world around them, and to challenge injustice wherever it may be found.
SHEIKHO KA SIYAAPA 0 seconds ago ye muzamil har problems ko west k philosophers k perspective say daikhta hai jis ka poora doctrine he ghlt hai agr sai hai to muje koi encounter kare eski analysis weak aur biased hoti hai aur recently es ne bht ghlt statment di hai jis par youth club ne react kae esko apni ghalthi aknowledge karni chaye aur pakistanio thora out of the box soucho tahqeeq k beghair har cheez ki tareefay shoro kardaite ho es se 50 gunah achi aur intellectual zuban sadguru istamaal karta hai to kia wo sai hai
SHEIKHO KA SIYAAPA 0 seconds ago ye muzamil har problems ko west k philosophers k perspective say daikhta hai jis ka poora doctrine he ghlt hai agr sai hai to muje koi encounter kare eski analysis weak aur biased hoti hai aur recently es ne bht ghlt statment di hai jis par youth club ne react kae esko apni ghalthi aknowledge karni chaye aur pakistanio thora out of the box soucho tahqeeq k beghair har cheez ki tareefay shoro kardaite ho es se 50 gunah achi aur intellectual zuban sadguru istamaal karta hai to kia wo sai hai
@@Patriotic8422 baat daleel sa Hoti ha ... Hawa main teer mat urao..! Jawab na ho pass tou Shia, Ahmdi, Qadyani, Gustakh, Liberal aur Ghaddar kehny koi bahaduri Nahi.
@@AliHaiderBaig بھائی آپنے بلکل ٹھیک فرمایا ۔ ایسے بہن چود پاکستانی ہمیشہ اسی چکر میں رہیں گے ۔جنکے اپنے باپ دادا کچھ سال پہلے غیر مسلم تھے اور آج وہ لوگ صرف خود کو پکے سچے مسلمان سمجھتے ہیں۔
Equal credit goes to Junaid Akram for opting to remain low-key with minimal intervention allowing Muzammil to speak out his heart and mind. Great flow to the interview. Thoroughly enjoyed. Thanks for this masterpiece. One for the ages!🙌
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I, can see the fallacies and errors in his interview. See my other comments for list of errors.
I didn't know I could have the patience to watch a 3-hour long debate, Muzamil's ability to delve into diverse subjects and present his views with clarity and depth is truly commendable and quite captivating. I still wonder how could he remember the exact quotes from those books. you are a blessing.
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I, can see the fallacies and errors in his interview. See my other comments for list of errors.
Syed Muzammil is the kind of influencer the newer generation needs. he’s such an inspiration. all his thoughts are his OWN. propaganda and school curriculums have nothing on this guy.
I am an Indian.. watched many Pakistani videos.. for the first time i jealous that you have personality like Syed muzamil... So much respect. He is your national treasure
Wow. This is truly a master class in the disciplines of Social Science, Anthropology and Political Science. The brilliance in analysing the empirical phenomena by Syed Muzammil sir is beyond excellence. Respect for you sir and wishing you good health forever.
پوری زندگی میں اج تک کسی صحافی نے ایمپریس نہیں کیا تھا اور مزمل بھائی نے کردیا، سوچو اگر ہماری سارے صحافی ایسے ہوتے تو کتنا اچھا ہوتا، خیر اللّٰہ مزید ترکی اور کامیابی دے مزمل بھائی، لو فرام پختون بھائی ❤
@43:00 Why is Muzammil linking US revolution to revolt against religion? As he said, it was a revolt against injustice. If religion is misused by some people, then it does not mean that religion is wrong. No religion allows tyrany. It means that religion is being applied wrongly. @44:04 In Turkey, secularism was imposed on the defeated society. And religion was effectively banned. They progressed materialy, but the spiritual void remained. This got an outlet in the shape of Urdagan. And people are reverting to religion. @45:00 Muzammil praises secularism in Turkey and Azerbaijan. Crushing religion is not secularism. They have laws against religion, like not being allowed to have Muslim names or the Turkish Cap. Is this what Muzammil wants? And this is what Muslims fear. Another example is France, where wearing a turban or scarf is banned in public. Is this secularism? @46:30 Muzammil says, we should compromise on principles because India is bigger & more powerful. So we should talk to her & ignore principles. By this he means that if Pakistan were more powerful then it should also force it's illegal views on others. Also, he says India doesn't give a damn about Pakistan. India DOES give a damn. See all the Anti Pakistan rhetoric in their media. @47:37 Muzammil says where Muslims are more than 30%, they don't want secularism. This is wrong. Only in places where Muslims are in majority, they want a society that has Islamic values. @1:02:06 Muzammil likes western philosophy because it puts an individual above society. As he says, all other philosophies put society above individual. This is so because, this is the innate psychology of humans. The Libral philosophy has come only in the last century, and is promoted by a certain segment for their own interests. Survival of humans depends on community. As per Social Contract of Rousseau and Hobbs, an individual must give away some of his liberties to enable a functioning society. How many liberties to be given away varies. Liberals want individuals to think only of themselves. There be no bounds of ethics, morality, culture or religion on an individual. This causes gradual degradation and a breakup of social structure. A breakup of Families like we see in the West. There being no emotional bonds between individuals. Such a society is without roots or culture. Aim of individual is to get maximum benefits & enjoy life while it lasts. Pure capitalism which derives from Liberalism has been shown to cause harm to society. Like in West 1% of population owns majority of the wealth. @1:02:06 If an individual is greater than the society, then he/she should not give any sacrifices, for the betterment of the society. A soldier advancing against a hail of bullets, and giving the ultimate sacrifice (his life), will be an ignorant fool. Muzammil himself says, he is prepared to give sacrifices, to promote his Liberal ideology. Why? @1:7:43 Muzammil says, the challenge of Pakistan is wrong Philosophy. This is not true. The challenge of Pakistan is Elite capture. It is they, who invoke philosophies as per their interest. As he himself said, they take decisions to ensure their hold and the nation suffers the consequences. So, if they use religion, then it does not mean religion is wrong. @1:14:39 Muzammil says we are going to default in a year. He is right, that wrong policies of successive Govts is to blame. But he should note that the PTI govt, despite of Covid & being shackled, had managed to turn around the economy. They managed 6% growth, despite there being no "War". Unfortunately, the scoundrels ganged up & managed to bring down his Govt, to protect their own interests. @1:15:19 Muzammil says plagiarism is not checked in universities. This is wrong it has being enforced in last decade or so.
@1:17:00 Muzammil is right. The Establishment is the cause of rot of Pakistan. Also Establishment cooperated with Imran Khan to bring him to power. However, they ensured that he did not have a clear majority, so that they could control him. All the media curbs, and atrocities, that Muzammil talks about were perpetrated by the Establishment. This is clear from the worsening of these practices after removal of IK, by the Establishment. Why does Muzammil not say that the curbs and atrocities multiplied many fold after removal of IK? And why was IK removed? Because he delivered (despite being shackled) and was becoming a danger to their stranglehold on Pakistan. Only problem Muzammil has with IK is that he is right wing and hence against Liberals. @1:19:40 Junaid says that the war is over wooing the establishment & Muzammil agrees. This is false. Imran Khan has totally exposed the stranglehold of Establishment over Pakistan. Now people openly talk of reigning them in. IK cannot allow them this power even if he wanted to. Just like he cannot let go of corruption of PMLN & PPP. This is the biggest accomplishment of IK. Pakistan will never be the same again, even if IK is eliminated. The Establishment is fighting for it's survival. That is exposing them even more. @1:19:56 Muzammil says PTI wants to talk to Establishment (so is ready to surrender to them) also they wanted Faiz. This is false. IK has repeatedly said PDM has no power, so he wants to talk to Establishment. And he wants to talk about holding elections. Establishment offered IK to allow elections and thus come to power, if he was willing to forgive their crimes. This IK refused. Also IK has said he had no plans to install Faiz. Faiz was as much a part of Establishment as Bajwa or Munir. What IK opposed was, removal of Faiz, bypassing the authority of PM by COAS Bajwa.
@1:22:37 Muzammil has rightly opposed extension of Interim setup beyond 90 days. That is what IK is demanding. He has put the Establishment in such a spot, that they are forced to subvert the constitution again. Thus exposing themself. @1:25:21 Muzammil says that democracy does not work due to Biradris/tribes. This is wrong. Actually Tribes & societies exist to protect the member's rights. This is a necessity if the legal system is weak. So we need to implement the rule of Law. Biggest enabler of Democracy is education. And if democratic values exist, then even the Biradries will select competent people. @1:25:34 Muzammil says democracy comes when family structure breaks. THIS IS THE MOST DANGEROUS THING, HE HAS SAID IN THIS INTERVIEW. As said before education is the biggest enabler of democracy. Family is the basic unit of the society, and it must never be broken. It is in the western culture, where the families are dysfunctional, children leave home at 18years and have no bond with each other. Majority of kids live in single parent family. This is the biggest flaw of Western society. And Muzammil is a proponent of implementing it. @1:36:28 Muzammil says rise of populism is due to social media. This is not correct. Populism occurs when there is disillusion with the current system. People look for alternates. Social media provides a platform that cannot be controlled by the authorities. If people are impressed by a leader, then it is simply because they hope that he will be atleast better than those being projected by the mainstream media. @1:42:52 Muzammil says Pakistan can be corrected from outside. THIS IS WRONG. The outside powers have no interest in "correcting" Pakistan. They are only interested in what benefits them. Pakistan can only be corrected by awareness & activism of it's own people.
@1:43:43 Muzammil thinks part of establishment is still supporting Imran Khan. Otherwise he would have been arrested & hanged like Bhutto, the most popular leader of Pakistan. THIS IS WRONG. Bhutto may have been most popular amongst the leaders, but his support base was narrow, due to his own actions. Also there was only one TV channel & no social media. The Establishment cannot control the narrative now. If Establishment had it's say, IK would have been history long ago. @1:51:38 Muzammil says there is Sui gas in Lahore but not in Sui. THIS IS WRONG. Yes Sui gas arrived late in Sui & Quetta, but it is there. @2:07:21 Muzammil says the awakening in Punjab is only in favour of a personality. This is wrong. It is more so against the Establishment. The movement will not die even if IK is removed. @2:08:42 Muzammil says one who is not a friend of Modi, is a traitor. Because Pakistan will not survive without trade with India. THIS IS WRONG. There are many more countries in the world other than India. Survival of Pakistan DOES NOT depend on trade with India. @2:09:03 Muzammil thinks Bilawal "may" be intellectually better than Mariam or Imran Khan. This is a joke. It shows how biased Muzammil is for the Left & Against the Right. This is intellectual dishonesty at it's worst. @2:47:36 Muzammil recommends books by Haqqani. It is clear that Haqqani is an opportunist, besides being a traitor. He started his career as a leader of Jamaat e Islami. Worked with dictator Zia. Then joined Leftist Benazir when she came to power. Joined Rightist Nawaz when he came to power. Then joined corrupt Zardari, when he came to power. Then joined the Indian lobby (anti Army, anti Pakistan) when ousted by the establishment of Pakistan. Then started supporting the Army when hired by Bajwa. So how does Muzammil consider his books intellectual and honest? This means Muzammil himself is dishonest.
Hypnotized to whole podcast....Never came across someone connecting dots immaculately on all topics ,,hats off Muzammil and Junaid for brining up with this
Hello from India! I discovered Syed Muzammil a few days ago and was amazed by his ability to articulate his thoughts so well. He is well read and expresses his thoughts with such conviction. He is doing such a great job!! Celebrate this man, Pakistan.
SHEIKHO KA SIYAAPA SHEIKHO KA SIYAAPA 0 seconds ago ada waddaa political scientist tu ahahaha aur es ganje ne b daikha k bandah thora controversial huwa hai liberal feminist recently youth club ne b esko spot kiya hai ye toh log daikhaingay ganje ko har jaga paise nazar atay hai maaf karna ajj nikal gya guse mai mai idr udr es podcast ki mai bat ni kar raha overall he is very biased aur analysis ko jidr chahe kinch laite hai western philospy k through
Dont you think that believing that a country of billion people wouldn't have intellectuals is itself a sign of low intelligence or lack of common sense???? Just asking
میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview. See my other comments for list of errors.
Wonderful conversation!! Listened it in single go. Surprisingly the truth seeking is still alive in Pakistan ! Looking forward for more flowers like that ❤
Bhai sab bakchodi hai. 26 crore ke jahil mein sirf 10,000 log hai. In jaise kabutro ko koi serious nahi leta. Yeh khud jis din mauka milega bhaag jaenge Pakistan se. Aur finally sab kuch gaali dene ke baad Modi ko gaali de dete hai kyuki Qaum ka dukh nahi dekha jata hai Suaro se.
Truth seeking is very much alive. The reason it is not seen is because those who don't seek the truth get the spotlight. It's unfortunate, but it's a real phenomena that applies everywhere
co - existence is only possible if u r not having a mindset of having double standards driven by a fake narrative of Religiously motivated Bigoted Superiority. Zia and his followers built this narrative based on the Two nation theory propagated by the founding father of the Muslim League Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan who was from Aligarh and whose followers r still doing their best in a clandestine organized way to weaken India internally. Hence the Indian state has realized that the only way to crush these zealots is to destroy their most precious creation and achievement i.e. Pakistan. So India post PM Modis famed Sharif wedding attendance debacle post which Pathankot and URI were countered by our Surgical strike at Balakot and other operations . The current Govt. has decided on a wholistic approach of Balkanizing Pakistan by destroying its economy by destroying its internal and external support structure of Pakistan. Hence ur current Status Quo of economic degradation and political turmoil and fissures in the Establishment GHQ in Rawalpindi and ISI in Islamabad. We r further gonna help target ur ex pats and retd, generals with their children and progeny of ur political elite in their European American Australian and Dubai based exclaves created by ur 1% elites. We r going to go after these Paki Parasites Mossad style the way the Israelis did after the Muslim Brotherhood in the 60s and 70s. All this can be done only if their assets and invesments in Pakistan crash and become valueless for raising capital in the global financial markets devaluing their companies and destroying their means to survive globally as calculated by our agencies thus destroying the Fauji faundations. Pakistan will be worse than Lebanon at the peak of its financial crisis all its gonna take is an cataclysmic event at Bin Qasim Port like the one in Lebanon and guess what it only takes a few ill intentioned Afghans or Balochis who were rubbed the wrong way by the Pakistani Army or Rangers to do the needful. Jai Hind
co - existence is only possible if u r not having a mindset of having double standards driven by a fake narrative of Religiously motivated Bigoted Superiority. Zia and his followers built this narrative based on the Two nation theory propagated by the founding father of the Muslim League Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan who was from Aligarh and whose followers r still doing their best in a clandestine organized way to weaken India internally. Hence the Indian state has realized that the only way to crush these zealots is to destroy their most precious creation and achievement i.e. Pakistan. So India post PM Modis famed Sharif wedding attendance debacle post which Pathankot and URI were countered by our Surgical strike at Balakot and other operations . The current Govt. has decided on a wholistic approach of Balkanizing Pakistan by destroying its economy by destroying its internal and external support structure of Pakistan. Hence ur current Status Quo of economic degradation and political turmoil and fissures in the Establishment GHQ in Rawalpindi and ISI in Islamabad. We r further gonna help target ur ex pats and retd, generals with their children and progeny of ur political elite in their European American Australian and Dubai based exclaves created by ur 1% elites. We r going to go after these Paki Parasites Mossad style the way the Israelis did after the Muslim Brotherhood in the 60s and 70s. All this can be done only if their assets and invesments in Pakistan crash and become valueless for raising capital in the global financial markets devaluing their companies and destroying their means to survive globally as calculated by our agencies thus destroying the Fauji faundations. Pakistan will be worse than Lebanon at the peak of its financial crisis all its gonna take is an cataclysmic event at Bin Qasim Port like the one in Lebanon and guess what it only takes a few ill intentioned Afghans or Balochis who were rubbed the wrong way by the Pakistani Army or Rangers to do the needful. Jai Hind
I watched the complete podcast after 1 year. Best analysis,clear thoughts of Syed Muzamil. These types of podcasts can help in building a positive and critical mindset. Keep going JUNAID Akram. WELL DONE. AND IN THE LAST WE ARE PROUD OF HAVING SUCH AN INTELLECTUAL LIKE MUZAMIL. SALUTE YOU 🫡.
@@manahil558 میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔
@@kunalsamotra2072 Whatever he is. At least social media gives people a voice even if you disagree. This is true journalism. I disagree with some things that he said. But debate is important in a healthy society.
@@muzammil_pathan20 Nothing wrong in being liberal. Besides conservatives produces terrorists not liberals. I am 75% liberal and 25% conservative. I dont agree everything that comes under liberalism because some things are problematic which the speaker ignores.
@@MA-lb8dq debate with someone who is educated enough in a particular field , experienced and Ethically mature in providing practical solutions. This Librandu is just a journalist, But he think himself a Great Knowledgable person...he thinks his Research is 100% complete and Legit. He touches even those topics which he never experienced or Have basic facts learned. Better is not to listen those who are not expert and just act like a wannabe.
We don't have an analyst like Muzammil in India, the way he communicates. well read and direct to the point. Must be difficult for him communicating the way he does, with the fear of his own life. Kudos! and well done Junaid for bringing him to the podcast.
@@kunalgohil7628 citing Tharoor and Sai Deepak as analysts is precisely proving the OP's comment here. We rarely have any in India with such clear commitment to the truth.
As a Pakistani, I found Syed Muzzamil Shah's analysis of our country's politics to be spot on. It's frustrating to see how badly our leaders have mismanaged things and I'm grateful to have people like him speaking out and shedding light on the situation."and I really enjoyed listening to this podcast and learning more about Pakistani politics from Syed Muzzamil Shah's perspective. I hope that more people take the time to tune in and educate themselves on these important issues."
I am happy to see open minded people in Paksitan It is Important to ensure how World Sees us I am india, in my 40 years of life i never taught any anti Muslim things I am taught the great Akbar who united India and made great building and Culture I am proud of Ashoka who did the same thing and Then become Buddha I am blessed that jain Munni Mahavir born on my land, spread Non VOILENCE I am blessed that Sikh guru born here and ask Community to protect all I so so proud that My land has seen person like Baba shaeb Ambekar who highly educated and demolishes inequality using LAW I am proud to see sir Tata comes from Minority and has developed nation through industry Ambani Shahrukh khan Aziz Premji Sunder Pichaii a all
One of the most genuine & unbiased podcasts I’ve seen, lots of love from India 🇮🇳 hope you’re inspiring the youth of Pakistan so that they can speak up for their rights
Muzammil is a voice of reason and I love how he keeps a calm and composed tone to convey his msg. no screaming or shouting. And his use of Urdu. I see Muzammil on a video, I click to hear him. 10/10 on having him as a guest. Hes doing a great service helping educate Pakistanis about stuff - those who want to open themselves to education that is. Not everyone likes hearing the karwa sach.
After listening to the whole podcast, my opinion has changed regarding Pakistan's brief history which had never been heard in the Pakistan studies book. This podcast is one of the most brief, and informative, regarding the dissection of Pakistan's deep politics and history.
Syed Muzzamil it’s great to listen to a young enlightened man like you who can influence youth towards reading non fiction cz without reading you simply cannot expand your mind or horizons or change your mindset or converse ; it enriches not only your perspectives but you help others to view things differently as well, Junaid Akram is another treasure we have.
@@naeemabokhari2285 میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔
Awesome podcast! I am from India, never heard so much truth ever before in a discussion. Wish there are more of such intellectuals who are free from all biases and tell the truth like you guys, very good work 👍
I am amazed at this young man's extensive knowledge on various topics and his superb abilty to talk continually without once being irrelevant or at a loss for the right word or expression. His observations and his confidence besides being extremely well-read cannot be praised enough. What a gem of a scholar we have discovered through this podcast. Junaid Akram is to be congratulated for bringing forth this highly engaging and informative dialogue.
I am a follower of Syed muzzamil from his very early days from Facebook and one of the earliest subscriber on you tube. One of the very few sane minds from Pakistan 🇵🇰 . Respect from india 🇮🇳
Being a bihari where nalanda university's remains are present it's just amazing to see like literally the remains are this much interesting just imagine how great the university was 🎉
@@harrypotter-rj8ip wrong fact my son it was burnt by Muslims because they thing it was anti quran ..u must have read this fact on WhatsApp university
Holy moly! This vlog deserves an award for being the marathon of all vlogs - I had to take snack breaks to keep up! But guess what? Totally worth it! Talk about a dynamic duo - "BALD AND THE BEAUTIFUL" takes the cake. Now, I may have a few more wrinkles than you two, but hey, age is just a number, right? On a more sophisticated note, kudos for the brainy, rational discussion with a historical twist. Seriously, it's like the Avengers of intellectual conversations!
Such an impeccable podcast! ❤ He is a treasure we cant lose at any cost! Always a treat to hear him! Part where he says, The biggest oppression greater than establishment is our family system.. That struck so hard! Muzammil keep shining like a star! ❤
Wow!! What I learnt in last 3 hours through this podcast sitting here in Canada - didn’t happen in last 20 years. Super impressed with the objective analysis on such diverse topics. One of the best 3 hours of my life - Awesome job !!!
Pakistani politics offers a classic case where all the stakeholders are out on a fatalistic trail , (like that of the Norwegian lemmings that are”driven” to perform collective suicide) which can only end one way : in a massive and unprecedented cataclysm . Alternatively it could be said that all the power-wielders and power-brokers are playing a game of “Russian Roulette”. As the Euripides proverb puts it: “Those whom the gods wish to destroy , they first make mad”. May God have mercy on us…….!
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview. See my other comments for list of errors.
@1:17:00 Muzammil is right. The Establishment is the cause of rot of Pakistan. Also Establishment cooperated with Imran Khan to bring him to power. However, they ensured that he did not have a clear majority, so that they could control him. All the media curbs, and atrocities, that Muzammil talks about were perpetrated by the Establishment. This is clear from the worsening of these practices after removal of IK, by the Establishment. Why does Muzammil not say that the curbs and atrocities multiplied many fold after removal of IK? And why was IK removed? Because he delivered (despite being shackled) and was becoming a danger to their stranglehold on Pakistan. Only problem Muzammil has with IK is that he is right wing and hence against Liberals. @1:19:40 Junaid says that the war is over wooing the establishment & Muzammil agrees. This is false. Imran Khan has totally exposed the stranglehold of Establishment over Pakistan. Now people openly talk of reigning them in. IK cannot allow them this power even if he wanted to. Just like he cannot let go of corruption of PMLN & PPP. This is the biggest accomplishment of IK. Pakistan will never be the same again, even if IK is eliminated. The Establishment is fighting for it's survival. That is exposing them even more. @1:19:56 Muzammil says PTI wants to talk to Establishment (so is ready to surrender to them) also they wanted Faiz. This is false. IK has repeatedly said PDM has no power, so he wants to talk to Establishment. And he wants to talk about holding elections. Establishment offered IK to allow elections and thus come to power, if he was willing to forgive their crimes. This IK refused. Also IK has said he had no plans to install Faiz. Faiz was as much a part of Establishment as Bajwa or Munir. What IK opposed was, removal of Faiz, bypassing the authority of PM by COAS Bajwa.
@1:22:37 Muzammil has rightly opposed extension of Interim setup beyond 90 days. That is what IK is demanding. He has put the Establishment in such a spot, that they are forced to subvert the constitution again. Thus exposing themself. @1:25:21 Muzammil says that democracy does not work due to Biradris/tribes. This is wrong. Actually Tribes & societies exist to protect the member's rights. This is a necessity if the legal system is weak. So we need to implement the rule of Law. Biggest enabler of Democracy is education. And if democratic values exist, then even the Biradries will select competent people. @1:25:34 Muzammil says democracy comes when family structure breaks. THIS IS THE MOST DANGEROUS THING, HE HAS SAID IN THIS INTERVIEW. As said before education is the biggest enabler of democracy. Family is the basic unit of the society, and it must never be broken. It is in the western culture, where the families are dysfunctional, children leave home at 18years and have no bond with each other. Majority of kids live in single parent family. This is the biggest flaw of Western society. And Muzammil is a proponent of implementing it. @1:36:28 Muzammil says rise of populism is due to social media. This is not correct. Populism occurs when there is disillusion with the current system. People look for alternates. Social media provides a platform that cannot be controlled by the authorities. If people are impressed by a leader, then it is simply because they hope that he will be atleast better than those being projected by the mainstream media. @1:42:52 Muzammil says Pakistan can be corrected from outside. THIS IS WRONG. The outside powers have no interest in "correcting" Pakistan. They are only interested in what benefits them. Pakistan can only be corrected by awareness & activism of it's own people.
@1:43:43 Muzammil thinks part of establishment is still supporting Imran Khan. Otherwise he would have been arrested & hanged like Bhutto, the most popular leader of Pakistan. THIS IS WRONG. Bhutto may have been most popular amongst the leaders, but his support base was narrow, due to his own actions. Also there was only one TV channel & no social media. The Establishment cannot control the narrative now. If Establishment had it's say, IK would have been history long ago. @1:51:38 Muzammil says there is Sui gas in Lahore but not in Sui. THIS IS WRONG. Yes Sui gas arrived late in Sui & Quetta, but it is there. @2:07:21 Muzammil says the awakening in Punjab is only in favour of a personality. This is wrong. It is more so against the Establishment. The movement will not die even if IK is removed. @2:08:42 Muzammil says one who is not a friend of Modi, is a traitor. Because Pakistan will not survive without trade with India. THIS IS WRONG. There are many more countries in the world other than India. Survival of Pakistan DOES NOT depend on trade with India. @2:09:03 Muzammil thinks Bilawal "may" be intellectually better than Mariam or Imran Khan. This is a joke. It shows how biased Muzammil is for the Left & Against the Right. This is intellectual dishonesty at it's worst. @2:47:36 Muzammil recommends books by Haqqani. It is clear that Haqqani is an opportunist, besides being a traitor. He started his career as a leader of Jamaat e Islami. Worked with dictator Zia. Then joined Leftist Benazir when she came to power. Joined Rightist Nawaz when he came to power. Then joined corrupt Zardari, when he came to power. Then joined the Indian lobby (anti Army, anti Pakistan) when ousted by the establishment of Pakistan. Then started supporting the Army when hired by Bajwa. So how does Muzammil consider his books intellectual and honest? This means Muzammil himself is dishonest.
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview. See my other comments for list of errors.
Syed Mujammils argument is brilliant in many cases. But he is ideologically a liberal and opposes Islamic ideology. So dont be influenced so much by him. Leave your brain open all the time and listen to anybody.
میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔 .
Everytime i see this guy i feel jealous and bad that what is this brilliant mind doing in 🇵🇰… People of pakistan these kind of people deserves to be cherished and followed… you are on my idol’s list SYED ❤
He is good, but one doesn't have to be envious, we have a lot of talent. Just start listening to few more.... Meanwhile he never gives a straight answer, when he is asked about choices and options. Communist are really good at problem identification, but not solution oriented.
Syed muzammil is probably one of my favorite people to listen to.. The way he intertwines regional/global politics with philosophy and goes to the root of the problem is fascinating to me.. We need people like him in India... He reminds me of another of my favorite speakers Mr Christopher Hitchens.. It was an absolute pleasure to watch this podcast..
People like him in India..? We are far better without him.. !! He belongs there where he is right now.. Pakistan mein ho kar bhi kya kar liya jo india aa kar .. kar lenge ? This Blind LOVE for pakistanis is gonna cost us heavily in near future !
I mean I dont know how you judge a person and how ur thought process works but the moment he said ki "Aajkal India me narrative badalne ki koshish ki jaa rahi hai (means muslims are in danger) made me laugh so hard and it immediately showed this guy's "brilliance"! ye log toh pure Islami hai na? Inke yaha toh hindu ab rahe bhi nahi toh aaj kya hora hai inke saath? pure islami hokar bhi tootne ki kagaar pe hai. If there was really a narrative change going on (anti muslim narrative) then I suspect Muslim population wouldn't had grown further here but it isn't true These people lecture India (and idk how their points are so in sync with INC and other opposition parties) and people like u are "impressed" by their knowledge lol!
He kept me hooked for the entire three hours while I studied and listened to him simultaneously. What a personality! I only hope to be as intelligent, well-spoken, and poised as him in the future.
I recently started to follow Muzammil.. everything else I can digest but the topic which he has raised about social issues and the Child abuse specially male child is something which made me completely speechless. I could have never imagined that such things are happening in the society 😥😥 We always speak about abuses faced by female child but forget that male kids are also vulnerable to the same threat.
Muzammil is a living testament of the idea that "Readers are Leaders". Smart, articulate and a strategic deep thinker. His kind are rare. Everytime you watch his content, you will find something new to learn and improve your way of thinking.
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview. See my other comments for list of errors.
@@afaqh2356 what other comments were you asking me to find of yours for reference? All I could see were your desperate replies under different comments that are praising him. You sure you are not a hater or a jealous person if you have to copy paste the same sentences under every comment praising the guy? LMAO XD
Guys, yours debate was so engaging I went to bed 3am Sunday morning. BTW, am an Indian Australian & throughly enjoyed the way it was structured & discussed. Sharp questions & solid answers!!! More power to you both!
What a spooky world. I am British Indjan and finishing podcast by 3am British time on Sunday morning. Both are brilliant and opened up my mind to box of Pandora
co - existence is only possible if u r not having a mindset of having double standards driven by a fake narrative of Religiously motivated Bigoted Superiority. Zia and his followers built this narrative based on the Two nation theory propagated by the founding father of the Muslim League Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan who was from Aligarh and whose followers r still doing their best in a clandestine organized way to weaken India internally. Hence the Indian state has realized that the only way to crush these zealots is to destroy their most precious creation and achievement i.e. Pakistan. So India post PM Modis famed Sharif wedding attendance debacle post which Pathankot and URI were countered by our Surgical strike at Balakot and other operations . The current Govt. has decided on a wholistic approach of Balkanizing Pakistan by destroying its economy by destroying its internal and external support structure of Pakistan. Hence ur current Status Quo of economic degradation and political turmoil and fissures in the Establishment GHQ in Rawalpindi and ISI in Islamabad. We r further gonna help target ur ex pats and retd, generals with their children and progeny of ur political elite in their European American Australian and Dubai based exclaves created by ur 1% elites. We r going to go after these Paki Parasites Mossad style the way the Israelis did after the Muslim Brotherhood in the 60s and 70s. All this can be done only if their assets and invesments in Pakistan crash and become valueless for raising capital in the global financial markets devaluing their companies and destroying their means to survive globally as calculated by our agencies thus destroying the Fauji faundations. Pakistan will be worse than Lebanon at the peak of its financial crisis all its gonna take is an cataclysmic event at Bin Qasim Port like the one in Lebanon and guess what it only takes a few ill intentioned Afghans or Balochis who were rubbed the wrong way by the Pakistani Army or Rangers to do the needful. Jai Hind
Highly appreciable- this 3 hours of intellectual debate was far more educational and helpful than any schooling institute. We want & need to see such more platforms coming up ahead! Thankyou for making the ground Junaid bhai, and our own muzammil bhai! Love ♥️🙌
Bro this is the history and reality of Pakistan.. Tumhare mulk kya karte he with common people.. Military, politicians made this kind os situation of your country
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I, can see the fallacies and errors in this interview. See my other comments for list of errors.
It was an absolute pleasure, Junaid. Your listening skills were commendable. Best wishes to you and to your audience here. Cheers.
Please do more videos on your Channel, been waiting for long now.
Pls do an Podcast with an Indian political expert..and your views on Indian politics
do a podcast on revival of paksitan economy
do a podcast on revival of paksitan economy
do a podcast on revival of paksitan economy
Clear, unflinching, criticism by muzammil is what this country needs! Great job Junaid bhai and Muzammil.
Need to see your podcast with this guy too! that would be cool!
Lagta hai Mooroo ko Shehzad Ghias ko gaali dene aur ladkiyo ko harass karne se fursat mil gayi
I an watching this podcast third time honestly amazing personality!
Bandiyal jo adhi raat ko adalat khol ker patwariyon ko hakomat mein laya, aaj patwari ussi ko galiyan dey rahe hain, ye 'Suwer' patwari Faiz Issa ko bhi nahin chorrain gey hehe.
tu bhi attention lele bsdk charsi 😆
You are one of the few TH-camrs who are actually trying to do something positive in Pakistan. Keep up the good work Junaid bhai!
More power to you from Berlin, DE 🇩🇪
😢
Watch ex Muslim sahil and Adam seeker...
@@SunShine-do8iv oh Hindu,
watch Abuzar responds
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview.
See my other comments for list of errors.
@@afaqh2356yeah sure
If, Out of 15,57,000 viewers who have seen this video, at least 50% are Pakistanis, the hard work of Junaid Akram and Muzammil Shah is fulfilled. God save Pakistan.
Amen
Amin
Ameen
😊😊
I’m a 73 year old senior indian and after listening to Muzzimil can safely predict that as long as sane and knowledgeable people like you are there in Pakistan everything is not lost. Just want to add that it doesn’t mean that everything is perfect in India but at least we are moving in right direction. Wish you a great future.
Your comment is much appreciated. Best wishes
i hope you guys also stop mob lynching muslims, its our pain point
Thanks sir for the best wishes
@@bilalarshad6767 proving what Syed Muzammil Shah is saying the whole interview
@@freeieltsreadingtest yes
1st time i hv observe junaid feeling under confident infront of any person, syed muzammil. love from 🇮🇳
Seems, he is letting muzammil speak to have a good interview..
Bhot psand hai , lele uska ja
Koi gal bani? @@Pihu_rajput_45
😂😂😂@@Pihu_rajput_45
From India here. I've heard Syed Bhai in great detail in many of his videos and podcasts. I must say I'm always blown away by his clarity of thoughts and his ability to speak his mind out. A gem of Pakistan. I also believe that the majority of people in Pakistan even despise him but people like these are the ones who need to be heard. More power to you Syed.
Completely agree .. I felt same as well..
❤❤❤❤❤❤
+1
بہت ھی خوبصورت تجزہہ اور گفتگو ھے لیکن گزارش ھے کہ تھوڑا سی گفتگو ٹھہراؤ کیساتھ اور آسان الفاظ میں ھو تو ھر بندے کو سمجھنے میں آسانی ھوگی
"Cruelty stems in weakness not in strength, a strong man can never be cruel" just blown away 🔥🔥
कभी महाभारत पढ़ी नही।क्या भाई? अगर पढ़ा होता तो ये नही बोला होता,
@@Abhijit_Mishra91mtlb
@@राकेश_रेल10:42
@@Abhijit_Mishra91kuch bhi bolte ho kya? Maine Padhi hai, could you explain ?
I am an Indian and have watched podcasts of many intellectuals from India and West. But have never been astonished by the knowledge level of a person in Politics and Philosophy until I watched this podcast.
Mr. Shah is a hidden gem.
Thanks Syd Muzamil for this amazing podcast. Honestly for me Junaid Akram, Syd Muzamil and Wildlens Abrar are the youtubers who are worthy of watching from Pakistan.
Please add Faisal warraich as well
It would be great if Pakistani TH-camrs add english subtitle since they're missing a massive Indian audience who don't know Hindi/Urdu(especially from South & East India). It's great to hear history, different view points, economics, etc., which is not a shouting match!!! Hope they add Subtitles to this video as well.
I also like Irfan junejo
Faisal warraich dekho suno channel is amazing
Same for me as well. And also Uzair Yunus and Pakistan experience
I'm from India 🇮🇳. This is a very long podcast but every minute was worth it. There was so much clarity and logic behind each spoken word. I'm blown away!!! There were so many pointers to take away as learnings that we can incorporate in our personal lives (even if I keep aside Pakistan's current state & political scenario).
Love 💕 India ❤❤❤❤
ALL the Books mentioned by Syed Muzammil Shah:
- Two Treatises of Government (in the Former, The Falfe Principal and Foundation of Sir Robert Filmer)
- Leviathan - Thomas Hobbes
- The Social Contract - Jean-Jacques Rousseau
- Amusing Ourselves To Death (Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business) - Neil Postman
- The Origins of Totalitarianism - Hannah Arendt
- Madness & Civilization - A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason - Michel Foucault
- A Princely Affair The Accession And Integration Of The Princely States Of Pakistan 1947 1955 - Yaqoob Khan Bangash
- The Crowd (A Study of the Popular Mind) - Gustave Le Bon
- The Communist Manifesto and Das Kapital - Karl Marx
- Crime and Punishment - Fyodor Dostoevsky
- The Brothers Karamazov - Fyodor Dostoevsky
- Blook and Oil (MSB's Ruthless Quest for Global Power) - Bradley Hope & Justin Scheck
- The End of History and The Last Man - Francis Fukuyama
- The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the World Order - Samuel P. Huntington
- Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media - Edward S. Herman and Noam Chomsky
- Brave New World - Aldous Huxley
Syed Muzammil Shah's list of must-read books:
- Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind - Yuval Noah Harari
For understanding (introduction to) Philosophy, these three books:
- The Pleasures of Philosophy - Will Durant
- The Story of Philosophy - Will Durant
- A History of Western Philosophy - Bertrand Russell
- Beyond Good and Evil - Friedrich Nietzsche
- Thus Spoke (Spake) Zarathustra - Friedrich Nietzsche
- The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam (Encountering Traditions) - Mohammad Iqbal
For Pakistan (these three books are based on objective history)
- Magnificient Illusions - Husain Haqqani
- Reimagining Pakistan - Husain Haqqani
- Pakistan Between Mosque & Military - Husain Haqqani
- Yeh Khamoshi Kahan Tak by Lt. Gen. SHahid Aziz
- The Murder of History - K.K. Aziz
- The Nine Lives of Pakistan - Dispatches from a precarious state - Declan Walsh
Religious History:
- The Heirs of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) - Barnaby Rogerson
Partition:
- Freedom at Midnight - Larry Collins and Dominique Lapierre
Jinnah:
- Jinnah - His Success, Failures and Role in History - Ishtiaq Ahmed
- Jinnah of Pakistan - Stanley Wolpert
- My Brother - Fatima Jinnah
Military:
- Military Inc - Inside Pakistan's Military Economy - Ayesha Siddiqa
Great! You missed the two mentioned at the end:
Thus Spoke Zarathustra - Nietzsche
Beyond Good and Evil - Nietzsche
Thanks man... This is quite helpful
Thank you man. Kudos for the effort !
great compilation.
thank you so much
Books recommended by Sir Muzammil shah
1.Sapians a brief history of humankind
2.The pleasures of philosophy
3.Story of philosophy by Will Durant
4.A history of western philosophy by Bertrand Russell
5.Magnificent delusion by Hussain Haqani
6.Reimagining Pakistan
7.Pakistan between mosque and military
8.The nine lives of Pakistan by Declan Walsh
9.Heirs of prophet Muhammad
10.Jinnah his success, failures and role in history by Ishtiaq Ahmed
11.Jinnah of Pakistan by Stanley Wolpert
12.My brother by Fatima Jinnah
13.Military inside Pakistan's military economy second edition by Ayesha siddiqa
14.Beyond good and evil by Friedrich Nietzsche
15. Murder of the history
16. Freedom At Midnight
Need to be studied
I have read Sapiens and it's safe to say it's a populist book written by a populist writer. He has mixed science and fiction a lot to present his ideas.
bro ❣️
میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔
Please add the author name. And if possible the publishers also.
Here from 🇮🇳. He is one of the very few educated minds in true sense who thinks rationally and logically. Pakistan should bring forward people like him to discuss issues between the two countries. Im trying to imagine what would happen in the subcontinent if majority of people in Pakistan starts thinking the way he does. Definitely going to follow him for more of his content.
majority of the Indians are also same who give huge openings to the propaganda films which breed hate/ enmity for other religion or country. Indians kill Muslims or bash them in rallies considering them as threat to the sanatan dharam.
There’s a lot of us like him. Trust me you can come to Pakistan and the average person will think rationally as he does, however our voices aren’t heard due to the establishment and the amount of power they have.
Syed Muzammil Shah inspired me to take up the books again...I was so keen of reading books in the college life, but after marriage and having kids, and due to my job, for the last 10 years i forgot how much bibliomaniac i was.... He reminded me of that...and now i am starting my second innings with the books thanks to him..❤❤❤
Same case is here ...now i try to build interest again nd again in reading but no success
@@Ajazahm Try whichever book pique your interest. Even if it is a trash fiction. Once a habit is formed, you will move to better ones.
Same
@@ArjunKelaiya thanks for the advice … in this age of social media, its really hard to read books. Its better to start somewhere rather not starting.
@@codewithovi997 I am doing the same. Good luck. The advice is from Naval Ravikant by the way.
Listening to this gem of a podcast from India! A rare intellectual from Pakistan! Pleasure to listen to him every time! So much to learn and be inspired from! Hope to get more pearls of wisdom from this rare voice of reason, logic, political science and philosophy!
An Indian 🇮🇳 here, previously I watched few Junaid Akram's podcast, but I never watched around 3 hours of any podcast ever.
A new subscriber here for you Syed Muzammil Shah. Kudos. Loved every min of this podcast.
co - existence is only possible if u r not having a mindset of having double standards driven by a fake narrative of Religiously motivated Bigoted Superiority. Zia and his followers built this narrative based on the Two nation theory propagated by the founding father of the Muslim League Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan who was from Aligarh and whose followers r still doing their best in a clandestine organized way to weaken India internally.
Hence the Indian state has realized that the only way to crush these zealots is to destroy their most precious creation and achievement i.e. Pakistan.
So India post PM Modis famed Sharif wedding attendance debacle post which Pathankot and URI were countered by our Surgical strike at Balakot and other operations .
The current Govt. has decided on a wholistic approach of Balkanizing Pakistan by destroying its economy by destroying its internal and external support structure of Pakistan.
Hence ur current Status Quo of economic degradation and political turmoil and fissures in the Establishment GHQ in Rawalpindi and ISI in Islamabad.
We r further gonna help target ur ex pats and retd, generals with their children and progeny of ur political elite in their European American Australian and Dubai based exclaves created by ur 1% elites.
We r going to go after these Paki Parasites Mossad style the way the Israelis did after the Muslim Brotherhood in the 60s and 70s.
All this can be done only if their assets and invesments in Pakistan crash and become valueless for raising capital in the global financial markets devaluing their companies and destroying their means to survive globally as calculated by our agencies thus destroying the Fauji faundations.
Pakistan will be worse than Lebanon at the peak of its financial crisis all its gonna take is an cataclysmic event at Bin Qasim Port like the one in Lebanon and guess what it only takes a few ill intentioned Afghans or Balochis who were rubbed the wrong way by the Pakistani Army or Rangers to do the needful.
Jai Hind
Hey, Junaid and Muzammil, this was an absolute feast to our ears. Lots of Love from India. Keep up the good work.
@@Truthseeker7890We have way better wtf
@@miloblackmetalhate name a few mate..
@@Truthseeker7890
Why should we ? Its not like they've so we deliberately have to have someone like him
Indian constitution ensures every individual Indian's rights, we don't need to worry like them
Be on your own
@@hopeless.optimist He is a converted bot
@@deniedchirst who?
Thanks for inviting Muzammil. This is your best podcast so far. It’s time Pakistanis get out of their ‘pak studies’ bubble and get a reality check of this sinking ship called Pakistan. Truth is the only way forward.
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I, can see the fallacies and errors in his interview.
See my other comments for list of errors.
@@afaqh2356 Isn't everyone biased? I am also biased against backward ideas, exploitative traditions and state propaganda for example. He never said his ideas are perfect. He even said he could contradict himself at times and I think that is okay. I also dont agree with some things he says, nothing wrong with disagreement.
If you disagree with him, you can also make a video sharing what you think, everyone has youtube platform available to share their views.
@@ahsanjahangir8834 @43:00 Why is Muzammil linking US revolution to revolt against religion? As he said, it was a revolt against injustice. If religion is misused by some people, then it does not mean that religion is wrong. No religion allows tyrany. It means that religion is being applied wrongly.
@44:04 In Turkey, secularism was imposed on the defeated society. And religion was effectively banned. They progressed materialy, but the spiritual void remained. This got an outlet in the shape of Urdagan. And people are reverting to religion.
@45:00 Muzammil praises secularism in Turkey and Azerbaijan. Crushing religion is not secularism. They have laws against religion, like not being allowed to have Muslim names or the Turkish Cap. Is this what Muzammil wants? And this is what Muslims fear.
Another example is France, where wearing a turban or scarf is banned in public. Is this secularism?
@46:30 Muzammil says, we should compromise on principles because India is bigger & more powerful. So we should talk to her & ignore principles. By this he means that if Pakistan were more powerful then it should also force it's illegal views on others. Also, he says India doesn't give a damn about Pakistan. India DOES give a damn. See all the Anti Pakistan rhetoric in their media.
@47:37 Muzammil says where Muslims are more than 30%, they don't want secularism. This is wrong. Only in places where Muslims are in majority, they want a society that has Islamic values.
@1:02:06 Muzammil likes western philosophy because it puts an individual above society. As he says, all other philosophies put society above individual. This is so because, this is the innate psychology of humans. The Libral philosophy has come only in the last century, and is promoted by a certain segment for their own interests. Survival of humans depends on community. As per Social Contract of Rousseau and Hobbs, an individual must give away some of his liberties to enable a functioning society. How many liberties to be given away varies. Liberals want individuals to think only of themselves. There be no bounds of ethics, morality, culture or religion on an individual. This causes gradual degradation and a breakup of social structure. A breakup of Families like we see in the West. There being no emotional bonds between individuals. Such a society is without roots or culture. Aim of individual is to get maximum benefits & enjoy life while it lasts. Pure capitalism which derives from Liberalism has been shown to cause harm to society. Like in West 1% of population owns majority of the wealth.
@1:02:06 If an individual is greater than the society, then he/she should not give any sacrifices, for the betterment of the society. A soldier advancing against a hail of bullets, and giving the ultimate sacrifice (his life), will be an ignorant fool.
Muzammil himself says, he is prepared to give sacrifices, to promote his Liberal ideology. Why?
@1:7:43 Muzammil says, the challenge of Pakistan is wrong Philosophy. This is not true. The challenge of Pakistan is Elite capture. It is they, who invoke philosophies as per their interest. As he himself said, they take decisions to ensure their hold and the nation suffers the consequences. So, if they use religion, then it does not mean religion is wrong.
@1:14:39 Muzammil says we are going to default in a year. He is right, that wrong policies of successive Govts is to blame. But he should note that the PTI govt, despite of Covid & being shackled, had managed to turn around the economy. They managed 6% growth, despite there being no "War". Unfortunately, the scoundrels ganged up & managed to bring down his Govt, to protect their own interests.
@1:15:19 Muzammil says plagiarism is not checked in universities. This is wrong it has being enforced in last decade or so.
@@ahsanjahangir8834 @1:17:00 Muzammil is right. The Establishment is the cause of rot of Pakistan. Also Establishment cooperated with Imran Khan to bring him to power. However, they ensured that he did not have a clear majority, so that they could control him. All the media curbs, and atrocities, that Muzammil talks about were perpetrated by the Establishment. This is clear from the worsening of these practices after removal of IK, by the Establishment. Why does Muzammil not say that the curbs and atrocities multiplied many fold after removal of IK?
And why was IK removed? Because he delivered (despite being shackled) and was becoming a danger to their stranglehold on Pakistan. Only problem Muzammil has with IK is that he is right wing and hence against Liberals.
@1:19:40 Junaid says that the war is over wooing the establishment & Muzammil agrees. This is false. Imran Khan has totally exposed the stranglehold of Establishment over Pakistan. Now people openly talk of reigning them in. IK cannot allow them this power even if he wanted to. Just like he cannot let go of corruption of PMLN & PPP. This is the biggest accomplishment of IK. Pakistan will never be the same again, even if IK is eliminated.
The Establishment is fighting for it's survival. That is exposing them even more.
@1:19:56 Muzammil says PTI wants to talk to Establishment (so is ready to surrender to them) also they wanted Faiz. This is false. IK has repeatedly said PDM has no power, so he wants to talk to Establishment. And he wants to talk about holding elections. Establishment offered IK to allow elections and thus come to power, if he was willing to forgive their crimes. This IK refused. Also IK has said he had no plans to install Faiz. Faiz was as much a part of Establishment as Bajwa or Munir. What IK opposed was, removal of Faiz, bypassing the authority of PM by COAS Bajwa.
@@ahsanjahangir8834 @1:22:37 Muzammil has rightly opposed extension of Interim setup beyond 90 days. That is what IK is demanding. He has put the Establishment in such a spot, that they are forced to subvert the constitution again. Thus exposing themself.
@1:25:21 Muzammil says that democracy does not work due to Biradris/tribes. This is wrong. Actually Tribes & societies exist to protect the member's rights. This is a necessity if the legal system is weak. So we need to implement the rule of Law. Biggest enabler of Democracy is education. And if democratic values exist, then even the Biradries will select competent people.
@1:25:34 Muzammil says democracy comes when family structure breaks. THIS IS THE MOST DANGEROUS THING, HE HAS SAID IN THIS INTERVIEW. As said before education is the biggest enabler of democracy. Family is the basic unit of the society, and it must never be broken. It is in the western culture, where the families are dysfunctional, children leave home at 18years and have no bond with each other. Majority of kids live in single parent family. This is the biggest flaw of Western society. And Muzammil is a proponent of implementing it.
@1:36:28 Muzammil says rise of populism is due to social media. This is not correct. Populism occurs when there is disillusion with the current system. People look for alternates. Social media provides a platform that cannot be controlled by the authorities.
If people are impressed by a leader, then it is simply because they hope that he will be atleast better than those being projected by the mainstream media.
@1:42:52 Muzammil says Pakistan can be corrected from outside. THIS IS WRONG. The outside powers have no interest in "correcting" Pakistan. They are only interested in what benefits them. Pakistan can only be corrected by awareness & activism of it's own people.
Storehouse of knowledge ... Incredible IQ. Don't have words to praise Muzammil. Wish his countrymen listen to him. ❤❤❤
Really Muzammil is storehouse of knowledge good go ahead
This man is so very clear with his thought process. Every nation needs youth of his caliber and thinking. Kudos to you Syed Muzammil.
I am From India 🇮🇳 and the clarity of thought displayed is amazing by Syed Muzammil. One of the best podcasts I have seen in a while.
110lqa1l
Ql
0qpall😉1la❤😉qq
Now pakistan will wake soon... respect from Pakistan
The man is a facts digger of our current society. Hatsoff to his views. Marvelous interview.
Only educated People can understand this person,,,,,,,
I'm Indian but I Like this Man very much,,,,
Keep up the good work Junaid bhai. Loved todays show as all others before. Lot to learn from Muzzamil bhai for everyone not only Pakistanis. Lot of love from India.
سید مُزمل شاہ ایک شیعہ مُلحد ہے جس نے قُرآن اور احادیث کا مذاق اُڑایا، اسکی لفاظی اور چرب زبانی سے اپنے ایمان کو بچائیں 🙏
@@Patriotic8422 tumlog ki yahi mentality rahi too aise hii backward rahoge
@@onestar627 correct bro 😂
@@onestar627 tum loog apni fikar karo gobarchaap, 720 millions indians are kiving below poverty line they dont have food shelter sanitary, take those snake worshiper indians out from poverty instead off being US puppet showing off fake progress
I’m from India 🇮🇳 and I must admit i was blown away by this intellectual, knowledge is everything.
co - existence is only possible if u r not having a mindset of having double standards driven by a fake narrative of Religiously motivated Bigoted Superiority. Zia and his followers built this narrative based on the Two nation theory propagated by the founding father of the Muslim League Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan who was from Aligarh and whose followers r still doing their best in a clandestine organized way to weaken India internally.
Hence the Indian state has realized that the only way to crush these zealots is to destroy their most precious creation and achievement i.e. Pakistan.
So India post PM Modis famed Sharif wedding attendance debacle post which Pathankot and URI were countered by our Surgical strike at Balakot and other operations .
The current Govt. has decided on a wholistic approach of Balkanizing Pakistan by destroying its economy by destroying its internal and external support structure of Pakistan.
Hence ur current Status Quo of economic degradation and political turmoil and fissures in the Establishment GHQ in Rawalpindi and ISI in Islamabad.
We r further gonna help target ur ex pats and retd, generals with their children and progeny of ur political elite in their European American Australian and Dubai based exclaves created by ur 1% elites.
We r going to go after these Paki Parasites Mossad style the way the Israelis did after the Muslim Brotherhood in the 60s and 70s.
All this can be done only if their assets and invesments in Pakistan crash and become valueless for raising capital in the global financial markets devaluing their companies and destroying their means to survive globally as calculated by our agencies thus destroying the Fauji faundations.
Pakistan will be worse than Lebanon at the peak of its financial crisis all its gonna take is an cataclysmic event at Bin Qasim Port like the one in Lebanon and guess what it only takes a few ill intentioned Afghans or Balochis who were rubbed the wrong way by the Pakistani Army or Rangers to do the needful.
Jai Hind
Haha, we do not need intellectual here. Only semi educated and corrupt people succeed.
Are all indians intellectual Liberal ??😂
Indian doesn't mean = Educated Intellectual.
Vast majority of our population is UNDER poverty and deprived from education.
koi bhi pakistani sach bolta hai to aisa hi feel hota hai lekin indian intellectual hona bahot tuff hai
@@A.S.Bhullar3602exactly
It took me 4 days to watch this podcast till end as I had been doing so in small breaks between my work. But it was worth every minute. Syed Muzammil is a gem and each sentence from him was clear, precise, logical, set in a proper context, and supported by historical facts. His knowledge of philosophy and history is unmatched, and the icing on the cake (the cake being his repository of knowledge) is his communication skill. The way he imparts his knowledge and applies it to answer the question asked is superb. More power to Muzammil.
U should also listen Shakil Chaudhary
Same here
Yes this podcast was like a book which you want to finish soon as possible
جھوٹ کے بغیر اسلام مر جاتا ہے! اسلامی نقطہ نظر کے مطابق دنیا کی ساری تخلیق ابلیس اور اللہ کی دشمنی سے وجود میں آئی ہے۔ ابلیس اللہ کی نافرمانی کرتا ہے۔
اور سب سے اہم بات یہ ہے کہ محمد بے گناہ نہیں تھے، وہ گناہوں سے بھرے ہوئے تھے۔ ورنہ خالق کا کوئی نبی زہر کھا کر نہیں مر سکتا۔ وہ اپنے بستر پر اس قدر سرسراہٹ کر رہا تھا کہ ان کے پاس آنے والا فرشتہ بھی اللہ سے ان کی صحت یابی کی دعا کرتا تھا۔ اپنا اسلامی صحیفہ پڑھیں۔
آپ ایک ایسے شخص پر کیسے یقین کر سکتے ہیں جس کی 11 بیویاں ہوں اور بے شمار جنسی غلام ہوں، 6 سال کے بچوں کی شادی ہو، اس کی بلی کو اس وقت تک انگلی اٹھائے رکھیں جب تک وہ 9 سال کی عمر میں نہ کھا لے، اس نے اپنے لے پالک بیٹے کی بیوی سے شادی کی، اس نے اپنے مذہبی عقائد کی وجہ سے بہت سارے لوگوں کو مار ڈالا۔ ان کی بیویوں اور بہنوں سے ہمبستری کی، ان جنسی غلاموں کی تجارت کی، بنو قریظہ کابلہ کے بالغ لڑکے کو قتل کر دیا جو بلوغت کو پہنچنے کے بالکل قریب تھا وہ نوعمر لڑکا تھا۔
شیطان نبی کی زبان کا مالک کیسے ہو سکتا ہے؟سورہ حج کی آیت نمبر 52 میں آپ کے نبی نے اسے قبول کیا اور یہ 52 آیت گزشتہ کے 8 سال بعد آئی۔ اسے اس کی بیوی نے اپنے خوبصورت غلاموں سے ہم بستری کرتے ہوئے رنگے ہاتھوں پکڑا اور اس طرح قرآن نازل ہوا۔ اسے بچانے کے لیے. اے خوبصورت نبی! تمہارے نبی نے اپنی کزن ام ہانی کے ساتھ رومانس کیا تھا اور تم بے وقوف مسلمان سمجھتے ہو کہ اللہ اپنے نبی کو گدھے پر بلاتا ہے، گدھا اور نبی دونوں ان کے خون کی لکیر میں سب سے آخری تھے۔ تم مسلمان سب سے زیادہ گناہ گار قوم ہو اور لعنتی انسانیت ہو۔
تم ایسے شخص کی پیروی کیسے کر سکتے ہو جیسے اپنے نبی کی پیروی کرو اور عوام کے سامنے یہ کہہ دو کہ وہ بے گناہ تھا۔ تم جھوٹے ہو!
شرم کرو تم پر اور تمہارے نبی پر
Mmm
Some British prisons are Islamised you won't believe it.
واہ جناب اتنے مختلف موضوعات پر اتنی مفصل گفتگو بہت کم سننے میں آئی ہے. مزمل صاحب کی پہلی نیٹ پہ موجودگی جب سے دیکھی ان کی باتوں نے تب سے باندھ رکھا ہے. ان کی باتیں کئی کتابوں کے مطالعہ کا نچوڑ ہوتا ہے.. جو سامع کو بہت ایجوکیٹ کردیتا ہے.... آپ کا بھی شکریہ کہ اتنی اچھی گفتگو کو پیش کیا ہے.. جزاکم اللہ
The best interview of Syed Muzammil till date . Lots of credit to Junaid because he is such an awesome interviewer.
سید مُزمل شاہ ایک شیعہ مُلحد ہے جس نے قُرآن اور احادیث کا مذاق اُڑایا، اسکی لفاظی اور چرب زبانی سے اپنے ایمان کو بچائیں 🙏
@@Patriotic8422 hahahaha
@@Patriotic8422 single mum with multiple fathers is the recipe of liberals..
@@Patriotic8422 you are right dear...
میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔
I didn't know muzammil shah before this podcast and I am so thankful to Junaid bhai that you invited him in this podcast. This is the mindset we need to clean the mess we have created in our country. I hope more people watch this podcast and think again what we need to do in reality.
He is a psudo intellectual.
Two very amazing gents! With rare and sane arguments and opinions!! Keep up the great work Junaid and Muzammil!!
Good wishes from Japan 🇯🇵
Thanks so much
Thanks Junaid bhai.. an intelligent person asks the right questions 🙏🏼 some of these topics are equally relevant to Indians as well.
Thank you, Vinnu :)
This guy is a gem - hats off to his intelligence and bravery.
absolutely agree with you
yup
Rule 1 - Never ever believe any Muslim.
Rule 2 - Always follow the Rule number 1
History has proven.
They are down that's why some of them speak soft otherwise these so called intellectuals will invoke religious atrocities.
I wonder if Barkha Datt would be appreciated in HINDUSTAN doing exactly what this dude is doing in PAKISTAN, 🤔🤨🙄 and then I wonder why not?? Is it because this dude is cute like the ex PM Imran Khan and she is not?? Or is it simply because men in South Asia have more value no matter what and whatever professional fields.
I am from India and moved to US several decades back. Enjoy listening to Mr. Shah all the time. Credit should also go to Mr. Akram for asking very sharp questions at the right time that kept the interview in a flow. Both are very intelligent people.
Free Khalistan and Nagaland from india 🐷🇮🇳🐷
@@bojpuri423 aa muh me lele
@@bojpuri423 Aakhir Zaahilistan Bhikaaristan ki aukaat dikha di tune. Ye intellectuals ki baatein, sumane samajhne ki kaabiliyat Bhikaaristan ke Jyaadaatar Zaahilon ke kamjor dimaag ke bas ki baat nahin hain.
@@bhupeshkumar2537seta ka muh ma da do
@@rajeshjoshi3646India ka b koi intellectual bata do jisi sune ham godi godi hi bazar ata ha ka Pakistan ha hi intelligent
Country India is cheap country
I am 81 years old... As I have seen Pakistan as a part of India, I feel very bad inside when I see people are suffering there... This is the first podcast which makes me feel that people there, are understanding things.. Keep it up..
Like South Korea considering N. Korea as part of one country.............strange
❤❤ this is what we expect from you brother. We are the same people. Arabs are not ours but you are separated brothers.but our hearts beat the same blood. And our bodies carry the same DNA
@@ExamCracker912yes but most of ur population consider Arabs,Turks as ur ancestors which is totally wrong, u also belong to indus valley civilization like us😊
Bhai Pakistan se hu seekh lo...hamare yahan ab wohi sab ho raha hai jo unke yahan 70 saal pehle hua tha...wohi institutions ko compromise karna, wohi media par badhta state control, wohi bigotry, wohi communalism...shuru shuru mein unko bhi economic growth mili thi aaj dekh lo kya haal hai...kuch seekh lo
@@princer2893 they are germs I m not among them
I am an Indian and a fan of syed Muzamil hope people of Pakistan release this mans knowledge and wisdom, hope to see in positions where he can contribute to the society
My deepest respect to Muzzamil! Your knowledge speaks for itself. It's not easy to speak facts and not offend anyone! Class. 100% eloquence in conversation. One of the best ever podcast if not the best.
Syed's knowledge is impeccable. His voice and narration is so absorbing that one can listen to him all day! Amazing! Love and respect from an Indian Aussie.
He is more like Chatur from 3 idiots , he narrate books n quotes word by word. All bookish lines
@@ShahidMehmood-ff3px I am from early 80's India, the amount of pain, Pakistan machineries instilled in us as a form of thousand cuts, when I see Syed Muzammil Shah, it saddens me, but when I see comment like yours it gives me hope 😀
Anyway jokes apart, there is a difference between *Knowledge* and *Application of gained knowledge* , try not to point shallow analogy of Chatur. Muzammil possesses both.
Pause for a bit, use your gray matter and think how Chatur was depicted in the movie. Let me explain. The way it was shown, even if in a comedic way, Chatur was working, earning well and was important to his company. Competitive corporate work life is not that easy, hope you know this. No one will pay you 6 figures salary for charity. So Chatur might be shown as weirdo, but had knowledge and applicability,
@@ShahidMehmood-ff3px can you elaborate further. why is he bookish?
What an intellect Muzamil is.
Never knew about him before.
Need more people like him to educate youth.
th-cam.com/video/13fesnhNJak/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=WajahatS.Khan
Educate youth or demotivate youth?
There is a big difference..
I watched his show with Syed Muzammil Hassan. And I noticed that this man is Criticizing each and everyone, everything and has no solution... Actually he is not educating he is demotivating people.
He is against everything man literally everything.
Against PTI and Imran khan.
Against pmln
Against ppp
Against religion thoughts
Against Men's dignity
Against Media and all of media channels.
Against Army, even the whole establishment.
Philopher my 🏈
Follow him on his channel that goes by his name.
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views (towards Liberals) and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview.
See my other comments for list of errors.
The rational way Syed Muzammil uses to dissect things is phenomenal.
I am a professor in National University in Sweden. this is the first time I heard this man, and I am super impressed to say that he's really intelligent . thank you Junaid for introducing him to us.
Has he said anyhing new? Anything that hasn't been said by someone else or written else where? What are you impressed by?
@G That's why I said I am an academic, we are used to seeing regurgitation of existing theory but we look at the art of communications and how well one can articulate a structured argument backed up by theoretical evidence. Muzamil has beautifully relayed the historical facts and philosophical concepts in plain terms for the younger audience using this medium. It is impressive that he's attempting to spread a balanced thought and in doing so potentially and hopefully creating a progressive mindset. Hope this clarifies your question; but I detect a green-eyed monster more than anything else in it. Good luck with your inquiring mind.
@@iamglad1359 it was a simple question. The only thing I see is someone who's throwing names to sound philosophical...I don't kniw him....neither am I in the same space as he...why would I be green eyed...but if you can tell me what new he's staying I'll be forever grateful..
@@DWAGON1818 don't get jealous. The guy explained himself with reason why he liked Muzzamil but tumheri qk jaali hui hai because of your own bias to agey sy arguments kar rahe ho.
@@fatimaasif3622 jealous of what? Can you please explain. What does Muxamil have that I want?
Please also tell what he is contributing
I really appreciate it how you both talked about the issues which balochistan and its people are facing since decades, It will help alot of people who doesn't know anything about balochistan and its issues. One of reason I watch your podcasts is that you talk about everything happening in this country, i hope someday people would understand whats its like to live as a Balochi and in Balochistan.😊
I'm an overseas Pakistani in the UAE. Me and my entire family is Punjabi so my view of Pakistan was centred around Punjab and Lahore. I met this Baloch girl in my school and I realised that Pakistan is much bigger than Punjab and really started reading up on Baloch culture, language, traditions and history. Balochistan really is a unique place and hope to explore eventually and understand the on-ground situation. If you have any resources on Balochistan to read up on, would you please tell me? Cheers from Abu Dhabi !
@@umerghaffar4686
There was a book in my father’s library written by a British lady who traveled to hinterland of Balochistan and wrote an interesting book called the Tigers of Balochistan. This book is more about culture and traditions but is very interesting. I don’t know how you can access it but Al Jazeerah did a documentary on the civil war in Balochistan.
Intellectualism is a dual-edged sword. If used purely to elevate your standing in the society, it can lead to narcissism and tunneled vision. However, if it's used with a purpose to elevate the society, it can lead to liberation. Keep searching for truth. You're a hero!
Bro your comment made my struggle much less with my religion
@@huzaifagujjar2762 Religion is a beautiful thing if we focus on the core teachings of the messengers. They were pure and wanted to elevate the society. Unfortunately, the masses are being controlled by power-hungry people these days in the name of religions. I wish you inner peace and wellbeing :)
@@RaWhoPodcast exactly brother i struggled bit now I came to decision that the people are corrupt religion came to lift the people up
Uncensored & unfiltered scathing social/political documentary! This is exactly what we need more of. Please don't let this kind of talent & truth leave our country 🙏
Syed, Being a Pakistani American it was so good to hear such a thought provoking arguments, reference, realization with the prevailing truths and taboos of the society. Pleasure to hear you.
Looking forward for more from you. Good Luck.
Search "Ex-muslims in India" on TH-cam
U r n American....!Why the hell America allowing people from terror sponsoring state of Pakistan....
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351you should search ex Hindus. Trust me there’s a lot of them and you should focus on that
Syed Muzzamil Shah is an outstanding intellectual and political scientist, who has devoted his life to the pursuit of knowledge and the promotion of critical thinking. He is a true champion of justice and equity, and has been an unwavering advocate for the rights of all individuals, regardless of their background or status. Through his tireless efforts, he has inspired countless others to think deeply about the world around them, and to challenge injustice wherever it may be found.
Critical thinking 😂😂😂😂 pseudo liberal
@@muzammil_pathan20 elaborate your counter points instead of throwing random terms around
@@muzammil_pathan20 pseudo ka matlab bata youthiye
SHEIKHO KA SIYAAPA
0 seconds ago
ye muzamil har problems ko west k philosophers k perspective say daikhta hai jis ka poora doctrine he ghlt hai agr sai hai to muje koi encounter kare eski analysis weak aur biased hoti hai aur recently es ne bht ghlt statment di hai jis par youth club ne react kae esko apni ghalthi aknowledge karni chaye aur pakistanio thora out of the box soucho tahqeeq k beghair har cheez ki tareefay shoro kardaite ho es se 50 gunah achi aur intellectual zuban sadguru istamaal karta hai to kia wo sai hai
SHEIKHO KA SIYAAPA
0 seconds ago
ye muzamil har problems ko west k philosophers k perspective say daikhta hai jis ka poora doctrine he ghlt hai agr sai hai to muje koi encounter kare eski analysis weak aur biased hoti hai aur recently es ne bht ghlt statment di hai jis par youth club ne react kae esko apni ghalthi aknowledge karni chaye aur pakistanio thora out of the box soucho tahqeeq k beghair har cheez ki tareefay shoro kardaite ho es se 50 gunah achi aur intellectual zuban sadguru istamaal karta hai to kia wo sai hai
People like Syed Muzammil give me hope for the future of our country. There are still some rational people left!
سید مُزمل شاہ ایک شیعہ مُلحد ہے جس نے قُرآن اور احادیث کا مذاق اُڑایا، اسکی لفاظی اور چرب زبانی سے اپنے ایمان کو بچائیں 🙏۔
@@Patriotic8422 bus tere jaiso ke hi wajah se aaj pakistan mai aata lene ke liye log mar rhe hai. 😂😂
@@Patriotic8422 baat daleel sa Hoti ha ... Hawa main teer mat urao..!
Jawab na ho pass tou Shia, Ahmdi, Qadyani, Gustakh, Liberal aur Ghaddar kehny koi bahaduri Nahi.
@@AliHaiderBaig بھائی آپنے بلکل ٹھیک فرمایا ۔
ایسے بہن چود پاکستانی ہمیشہ اسی چکر میں رہیں گے ۔جنکے اپنے باپ دادا کچھ سال پہلے غیر مسلم تھے اور آج وہ لوگ صرف خود کو پکے سچے مسلمان سمجھتے ہیں۔
Trud
Pakistan needs more youngsters like him.
Muzammil❤
He's not youngster.
Equal credit goes to Junaid Akram for opting to remain low-key with minimal intervention allowing Muzammil to speak out his heart and mind. Great flow to the interview. Thoroughly enjoyed. Thanks for this masterpiece. One for the ages!🙌
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I, can see the fallacies and errors in his interview.
See my other comments for list of errors.
Wow... What a fantastic podcast.. Juned bhai we need more like you and Muzammil for peace n prosperity in our region..
Thank you
I didn't know I could have the patience to watch a 3-hour long debate, Muzamil's ability to delve into diverse subjects and present his views with clarity and depth is truly commendable and quite captivating. I still wonder how could he remember the exact quotes from those books. you are a blessing.
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I, can see the fallacies and errors in his interview.
See my other comments for list of errors.
Syed Muzammil is the kind of influencer the newer generation needs. he’s such an inspiration. all his thoughts are his OWN. propaganda and school curriculums have nothing on this guy.
I am an Indian.. watched many Pakistani videos.. for the first time i jealous that you have personality like Syed muzamil... So much respect. He is your national treasure
❤
Saeen twha ja lakh lakh qurb
Abe we have dime a dozen people like him in Bharat. What the hell are you getting jealous of Pakistan over him for?
He is anchor news person of Bol News Channel which famous for abusing India day and night
I agree
Syed Muzammil's courage and intelligence is unparalleled. I am from India and have started watching his videos recently.
Watch ex Muslim sahil and Adam seeker...
Wow. This is truly a master class in the disciplines of Social Science, Anthropology and Political Science. The brilliance in analysing the empirical phenomena by Syed Muzammil sir is beyond excellence. Respect for you sir and wishing you good health forever.
پوری زندگی میں اج تک کسی صحافی نے ایمپریس نہیں کیا تھا اور مزمل بھائی نے کردیا، سوچو اگر ہماری سارے صحافی ایسے ہوتے تو کتنا اچھا ہوتا، خیر اللّٰہ مزید ترکی اور کامیابی دے مزمل بھائی، لو فرام پختون بھائی ❤
I can listen to Syed muzammil speak facts nonstop for hours and still won't get tired of listening him. He is a gem .
Insulin ki tarah dekhtay ho kuch din chaska rahye ga phir chor do gye.
@Almas Tech immature and stupid thinking learn to respect out of you border.
@@muhammadhussain5854 burnt paki
@Almas Tech ya we take intellectuals that's why we are 5th largest economy and u are what ohh ya bhikari
@Alpha Astro that has nothing to do with secularism
'clarity of thought is power nowadays ' What a brilliant sentence. It always on the back of my mind what you intelligently put in one sentence.
@43:00 Why is Muzammil linking US revolution to revolt against religion? As he said, it was a revolt against injustice. If religion is misused by some people, then it does not mean that religion is wrong. No religion allows tyrany. It means that religion is being applied wrongly.
@44:04 In Turkey, secularism was imposed on the defeated society. And religion was effectively banned. They progressed materialy, but the spiritual void remained. This got an outlet in the shape of Urdagan. And people are reverting to religion.
@45:00 Muzammil praises secularism in Turkey and Azerbaijan. Crushing religion is not secularism. They have laws against religion, like not being allowed to have Muslim names or the Turkish Cap. Is this what Muzammil wants? And this is what Muslims fear.
Another example is France, where wearing a turban or scarf is banned in public. Is this secularism?
@46:30 Muzammil says, we should compromise on principles because India is bigger & more powerful. So we should talk to her & ignore principles. By this he means that if Pakistan were more powerful then it should also force it's illegal views on others. Also, he says India doesn't give a damn about Pakistan. India DOES give a damn. See all the Anti Pakistan rhetoric in their media.
@47:37 Muzammil says where Muslims are more than 30%, they don't want secularism. This is wrong. Only in places where Muslims are in majority, they want a society that has Islamic values.
@1:02:06 Muzammil likes western philosophy because it puts an individual above society. As he says, all other philosophies put society above individual. This is so because, this is the innate psychology of humans. The Libral philosophy has come only in the last century, and is promoted by a certain segment for their own interests. Survival of humans depends on community. As per Social Contract of Rousseau and Hobbs, an individual must give away some of his liberties to enable a functioning society. How many liberties to be given away varies. Liberals want individuals to think only of themselves. There be no bounds of ethics, morality, culture or religion on an individual. This causes gradual degradation and a breakup of social structure. A breakup of Families like we see in the West. There being no emotional bonds between individuals. Such a society is without roots or culture. Aim of individual is to get maximum benefits & enjoy life while it lasts. Pure capitalism which derives from Liberalism has been shown to cause harm to society. Like in West 1% of population owns majority of the wealth.
@1:02:06 If an individual is greater than the society, then he/she should not give any sacrifices, for the betterment of the society. A soldier advancing against a hail of bullets, and giving the ultimate sacrifice (his life), will be an ignorant fool.
Muzammil himself says, he is prepared to give sacrifices, to promote his Liberal ideology. Why?
@1:7:43 Muzammil says, the challenge of Pakistan is wrong Philosophy. This is not true. The challenge of Pakistan is Elite capture. It is they, who invoke philosophies as per their interest. As he himself said, they take decisions to ensure their hold and the nation suffers the consequences. So, if they use religion, then it does not mean religion is wrong.
@1:14:39 Muzammil says we are going to default in a year. He is right, that wrong policies of successive Govts is to blame. But he should note that the PTI govt, despite of Covid & being shackled, had managed to turn around the economy. They managed 6% growth, despite there being no "War". Unfortunately, the scoundrels ganged up & managed to bring down his Govt, to protect their own interests.
@1:15:19 Muzammil says plagiarism is not checked in universities. This is wrong it has being enforced in last decade or so.
@1:17:00 Muzammil is right. The Establishment is the cause of rot of Pakistan. Also Establishment cooperated with Imran Khan to bring him to power. However, they ensured that he did not have a clear majority, so that they could control him. All the media curbs, and atrocities, that Muzammil talks about were perpetrated by the Establishment. This is clear from the worsening of these practices after removal of IK, by the Establishment. Why does Muzammil not say that the curbs and atrocities multiplied many fold after removal of IK?
And why was IK removed? Because he delivered (despite being shackled) and was becoming a danger to their stranglehold on Pakistan. Only problem Muzammil has with IK is that he is right wing and hence against Liberals.
@1:19:40 Junaid says that the war is over wooing the establishment & Muzammil agrees. This is false. Imran Khan has totally exposed the stranglehold of Establishment over Pakistan. Now people openly talk of reigning them in. IK cannot allow them this power even if he wanted to. Just like he cannot let go of corruption of PMLN & PPP. This is the biggest accomplishment of IK. Pakistan will never be the same again, even if IK is eliminated.
The Establishment is fighting for it's survival. That is exposing them even more.
@1:19:56 Muzammil says PTI wants to talk to Establishment (so is ready to surrender to them) also they wanted Faiz. This is false. IK has repeatedly said PDM has no power, so he wants to talk to Establishment. And he wants to talk about holding elections. Establishment offered IK to allow elections and thus come to power, if he was willing to forgive their crimes. This IK refused. Also IK has said he had no plans to install Faiz. Faiz was as much a part of Establishment as Bajwa or Munir. What IK opposed was, removal of Faiz, bypassing the authority of PM by COAS Bajwa.
@1:22:37 Muzammil has rightly opposed extension of Interim setup beyond 90 days. That is what IK is demanding. He has put the Establishment in such a spot, that they are forced to subvert the constitution again. Thus exposing themself.
@1:25:21 Muzammil says that democracy does not work due to Biradris/tribes. This is wrong. Actually Tribes & societies exist to protect the member's rights. This is a necessity if the legal system is weak. So we need to implement the rule of Law. Biggest enabler of Democracy is education. And if democratic values exist, then even the Biradries will select competent people.
@1:25:34 Muzammil says democracy comes when family structure breaks. THIS IS THE MOST DANGEROUS THING, HE HAS SAID IN THIS INTERVIEW. As said before education is the biggest enabler of democracy. Family is the basic unit of the society, and it must never be broken. It is in the western culture, where the families are dysfunctional, children leave home at 18years and have no bond with each other. Majority of kids live in single parent family. This is the biggest flaw of Western society. And Muzammil is a proponent of implementing it.
@1:36:28 Muzammil says rise of populism is due to social media. This is not correct. Populism occurs when there is disillusion with the current system. People look for alternates. Social media provides a platform that cannot be controlled by the authorities.
If people are impressed by a leader, then it is simply because they hope that he will be atleast better than those being projected by the mainstream media.
@1:42:52 Muzammil says Pakistan can be corrected from outside. THIS IS WRONG. The outside powers have no interest in "correcting" Pakistan. They are only interested in what benefits them. Pakistan can only be corrected by awareness & activism of it's own people.
@1:43:43 Muzammil thinks part of establishment is still supporting Imran Khan. Otherwise he would have been arrested & hanged like Bhutto, the most popular leader of Pakistan. THIS IS WRONG. Bhutto may have been most popular amongst the leaders, but his support base was narrow, due to his own actions. Also there was only one TV channel & no social media. The Establishment cannot control the narrative now. If Establishment had it's say, IK would have been history long ago.
@1:51:38 Muzammil says there is Sui gas in Lahore but not in Sui. THIS IS WRONG. Yes Sui gas arrived late in Sui & Quetta, but it is there.
@2:07:21 Muzammil says the awakening in Punjab is only in favour of a personality. This is wrong. It is more so against the Establishment. The movement will not die even if IK is removed.
@2:08:42 Muzammil says one who is not a friend of Modi, is a traitor. Because Pakistan will not survive without trade with India. THIS IS WRONG. There are many more countries in the world other than India. Survival of Pakistan DOES NOT depend on trade with India.
@2:09:03 Muzammil thinks Bilawal "may" be intellectually better than Mariam or Imran Khan. This is a joke. It shows how biased Muzammil is for the Left & Against the Right. This is intellectual dishonesty at it's worst.
@2:47:36 Muzammil recommends books by Haqqani. It is clear that Haqqani is an opportunist, besides being a traitor. He started his career as a leader of Jamaat e Islami.
Worked with dictator Zia.
Then joined Leftist Benazir when she came to power.
Joined Rightist Nawaz when he came to power.
Then joined corrupt Zardari, when he came to power.
Then joined the Indian lobby (anti Army, anti Pakistan) when ousted by the establishment of Pakistan.
Then started supporting the Army when hired by Bajwa.
So how does Muzammil consider his books intellectual and honest? This means Muzammil himself is dishonest.
Hypnotized to whole podcast....Never came across someone connecting dots immaculately on all topics ,,hats off Muzammil and Junaid for brining up with this
Hello from India! I discovered Syed Muzammil a few days ago and was amazed by his ability to articulate his thoughts so well. He is well read and expresses his thoughts with such conviction. He is doing such a great job!! Celebrate this man, Pakistan.
Finally the wait is over, two of my favourite TH-camrs under one roof discussing Pakistani politics, dream comes true ❤
SHEIKHO KA SIYAAPA
SHEIKHO KA SIYAAPA
0 seconds ago
ada waddaa political scientist tu ahahaha aur es ganje ne b daikha k bandah thora controversial huwa hai liberal feminist recently youth club ne b esko spot kiya hai ye toh log daikhaingay ganje ko har jaga paise nazar atay hai maaf karna ajj nikal gya guse mai mai idr udr es podcast ki mai bat ni kar raha overall he is very biased aur analysis ko jidr chahe kinch laite hai western philospy k through
orgasm hua lagta aapko😅😅
@@sheikhokasiyaapa2752 sahi baat hei ertugul season 4
@@sheikhokasiyaapa2752 Thek hai bhai koi masla nahi hai ap jau aur sunno Youth Club ko
This is what I exactly think about Pakistan's history and politics and policy
I couldn't believe such intellectual person still living in Pakistan. God bless him lighthouse for South Asia
Dont you think that believing that a country of billion people wouldn't have intellectuals is itself a sign of low intelligence or lack of common sense???? Just asking
Country of billion ???
Free Khalistan and Nagaland from india 🐷🇮🇳🐷
@@bojpuri423okay hai, aapka comment mai indian goverment ke saath share kar dunga, aapka comment dekh kar woh alag kar denge.
@@bojpuri423chutiya spotted😂😂jake atta ki line me lag lowde yaha ky kr rha hai
Real gem of Pakistan Syed Muzammil ❤❤ a guy who made Pakistanis “think”. Absolute genius!!
Do you know of anyone who has given up their extremist mindset and adopted critical thinking as a mantra after listening to Muzammil?
سید مُزمل شاہ ایک شیعہ مُلحد ہے جس نے قُرآن اور احادیث کا مذاق اُڑایا، اسکی لفاظی اور چرب زبانی سے اپنے ایمان کو بچائیں 🙏
@@ibratnak yes, myself.
@@Patriotic8422 abe tu apne imaan ki fikr kr le chu**. Bc khud mutthal hotay hai bss doosray k believes p sawal uthanay hai….apni fikr kr le bhai tu..
@@musab315 please elaborate your before and after states.
I'm speechless.....!!! And thank you so much Muzammil.. and thanks you Junaid you gifted us a great conversation!!!
Protect Syed Muzammil Shah at all costs! What a gem this young lad is, Amazing podcast!
hahahahahahahaahahahhaa
میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview.
See my other comments for list of errors.
Wonderful conversation!! Listened it in single go. Surprisingly the truth seeking is still alive in Pakistan ! Looking forward for more flowers like that ❤
😮😮
Bhai sab bakchodi hai. 26 crore ke jahil mein sirf 10,000 log hai. In jaise kabutro ko koi serious nahi leta. Yeh khud jis din mauka milega bhaag jaenge Pakistan se. Aur finally sab kuch gaali dene ke baad Modi ko gaali de dete hai kyuki Qaum ka dukh nahi dekha jata hai Suaro se.
Truth seeking is very much alive. The reason it is not seen is because those who don't seek the truth get the spotlight. It's unfortunate, but it's a real phenomena that applies everywhere
co - existence is only possible if u r not having a mindset of having double standards driven by a fake narrative of Religiously motivated Bigoted Superiority. Zia and his followers built this narrative based on the Two nation theory propagated by the founding father of the Muslim League Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan who was from Aligarh and whose followers r still doing their best in a clandestine organized way to weaken India internally.
Hence the Indian state has realized that the only way to crush these zealots is to destroy their most precious creation and achievement i.e. Pakistan.
So India post PM Modis famed Sharif wedding attendance debacle post which Pathankot and URI were countered by our Surgical strike at Balakot and other operations .
The current Govt. has decided on a wholistic approach of Balkanizing Pakistan by destroying its economy by destroying its internal and external support structure of Pakistan.
Hence ur current Status Quo of economic degradation and political turmoil and fissures in the Establishment GHQ in Rawalpindi and ISI in Islamabad.
We r further gonna help target ur ex pats and retd, generals with their children and progeny of ur political elite in their European American Australian and Dubai based exclaves created by ur 1% elites.
We r going to go after these Paki Parasites Mossad style the way the Israelis did after the Muslim Brotherhood in the 60s and 70s.
All this can be done only if their assets and invesments in Pakistan crash and become valueless for raising capital in the global financial markets devaluing their companies and destroying their means to survive globally as calculated by our agencies thus destroying the Fauji faundations.
Pakistan will be worse than Lebanon at the peak of its financial crisis all its gonna take is an cataclysmic event at Bin Qasim Port like the one in Lebanon and guess what it only takes a few ill intentioned Afghans or Balochis who were rubbed the wrong way by the Pakistani Army or Rangers to do the needful.
Jai Hind
Wtfff mannn.. this man likes speak to facts without any fear and insecurity… impressed with his knowledge and will definitely gonna read his book
co - existence is only possible if u r not having a mindset of having double standards driven by a fake narrative of Religiously motivated Bigoted Superiority. Zia and his followers built this narrative based on the Two nation theory propagated by the founding father of the Muslim League Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan who was from Aligarh and whose followers r still doing their best in a clandestine organized way to weaken India internally.
Hence the Indian state has realized that the only way to crush these zealots is to destroy their most precious creation and achievement i.e. Pakistan.
So India post PM Modis famed Sharif wedding attendance debacle post which Pathankot and URI were countered by our Surgical strike at Balakot and other operations .
The current Govt. has decided on a wholistic approach of Balkanizing Pakistan by destroying its economy by destroying its internal and external support structure of Pakistan.
Hence ur current Status Quo of economic degradation and political turmoil and fissures in the Establishment GHQ in Rawalpindi and ISI in Islamabad.
We r further gonna help target ur ex pats and retd, generals with their children and progeny of ur political elite in their European American Australian and Dubai based exclaves created by ur 1% elites.
We r going to go after these Paki Parasites Mossad style the way the Israelis did after the Muslim Brotherhood in the 60s and 70s.
All this can be done only if their assets and invesments in Pakistan crash and become valueless for raising capital in the global financial markets devaluing their companies and destroying their means to survive globally as calculated by our agencies thus destroying the Fauji faundations.
Pakistan will be worse than Lebanon at the peak of its financial crisis all its gonna take is an cataclysmic event at Bin Qasim Port like the one in Lebanon and guess what it only takes a few ill intentioned Afghans or Balochis who were rubbed the wrong way by the Pakistani Army or Rangers to do the needful.
Jai Hind
I watched the complete podcast after 1 year. Best analysis,clear thoughts of Syed Muzamil. These types of podcasts can help in building a positive and critical mindset. Keep going JUNAID Akram. WELL DONE. AND IN THE LAST WE ARE PROUD OF HAVING SUCH AN INTELLECTUAL LIKE MUZAMIL. SALUTE YOU 🫡.
Wonderful 3hrs spent listening to an intellectual like Syed Muzammil. We need more thinkers like you in Pakistan!
سید مُزمل شاہ ایک شیعہ مُلحد ہے جس نے قُرآن اور احادیث کا مذاق اُڑایا، اسکی لفاظی اور چرب زبانی سے اپنے ایمان کو بچائیں 🙏۔
@@Patriotic8422 😶😶Bruhh!
🙏🙏
I'm pretty sure you wouldn't have watched this full podcast and are spamming everywhere! Have some intellectual mindset!
@@manahil558
میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔
Social Media is the future of true journalism.
Future of pseudo liberal yes
True journalist nhi hai anti Imran khan ka hai aur secular liberal ke thakdar h 😂
@@kunalsamotra2072 Whatever he is. At least social media gives people a voice even if you disagree. This is true journalism. I disagree with some things that he said. But debate is important in a healthy society.
@@muzammil_pathan20 Nothing wrong in being liberal. Besides conservatives produces terrorists not liberals. I am 75% liberal and 25% conservative. I dont agree everything that comes under liberalism because some things are problematic which the speaker ignores.
@@MA-lb8dq debate with someone who is educated enough in a particular field , experienced and Ethically mature in providing practical solutions.
This Librandu is just a journalist, But he think himself a Great Knowledgable person...he thinks his Research is 100% complete and Legit.
He touches even those topics which he never experienced or Have basic facts learned.
Better is not to listen those who are not expert and just act like a wannabe.
We don't have an analyst like Muzammil in India, the way he communicates. well read and direct to the point. Must be difficult for him communicating the way he does, with the fear of his own life. Kudos! and well done Junaid for bringing him to the podcast.
Why not. Of course there are quite a few analysts in India who communicate well and know their job.
@@vinuthabhat3674well I think he has never seen an IAS officer talk or someone like Sashi tharoor and Dr Jay Sai Deepak
Dhruv Rathee, Mohak Mangal, Tilak Devashar, there are plenty. You just have to listen to them.
@@strawmanfallacy8666
Those are not intellectuals...you can name Shashi tharoor...Dr. Jai Sai Deepak...
@@kunalgohil7628 citing Tharoor and Sai Deepak as analysts is precisely proving the OP's comment here. We rarely have any in India with such clear commitment to the truth.
A real delight to listen to Syed Muzammil Shah again and again.
As a Pakistani, I found Syed Muzzamil Shah's analysis of our country's politics to be spot on. It's frustrating to see how badly our leaders have mismanaged things and I'm grateful to have people like him speaking out and shedding light on the situation."and I really enjoyed listening to this podcast and learning more about Pakistani politics from Syed Muzzamil Shah's perspective. I hope that more people take the time to tune in and educate themselves on these important issues."
I agree as a Pakistani too
I am happy to see open minded people in Paksitan
It is Important to ensure how World Sees us
I am india, in my 40 years of life i never taught any anti Muslim things
I am taught the great Akbar who united India and made great building and Culture
I am proud of Ashoka who did the same thing and Then become Buddha
I am blessed that jain Munni Mahavir born on my land, spread Non VOILENCE
I am blessed that Sikh guru born here and ask Community to protect all
I so so proud that My land has seen person like Baba shaeb Ambekar who highly educated and demolishes inequality using LAW
I am proud to see sir Tata comes from Minority and has developed nation through industry
Ambani
Shahrukh khan
Aziz Premji
Sunder Pichaii a all
Muzzamil might be speaking the hash truth, but this won't help. he's just criticising everyone but gives no solution to fix the problem.
@@azazpervez4588 What even is the solution though? This might sound harsh, but the country is pretty much beyond repairs.
@@azazpervez4588 The moment you accept your own mistakes you are on the path of improvement.
One of the most genuine & unbiased podcasts I’ve seen, lots of love from India 🇮🇳 hope you’re inspiring the youth of Pakistan so that they can speak up for their rights
Muzammil is a voice of reason and I love how he keeps a calm and composed tone to convey his msg. no screaming or shouting. And his use of Urdu. I see Muzammil on a video, I click to hear him. 10/10 on having him as a guest. Hes doing a great service helping educate Pakistanis about stuff - those who want to open themselves to education that is. Not everyone likes hearing the karwa sach.
سید مُزمل شاہ ایک شیعہ مُلحد ہے جس نے قُرآن اور احادیث کا مذاق اُڑایا، اسکی لفاظی اور چرب زبانی سے اپنے ایمان کو بچائیں 🙏
@@Patriotic8422 get help!
@@Patriotic8422 jnl
Kuch bhi keh lay...banday ki batay dil ko choobti hain...he seems right
@@Patriotic8422 wo yahan koi muzhub ki tabligh to kr nhi raha jo aap apna ye comment hr jaga chipkai ja rahe ho
After listening to the whole podcast, my opinion has changed regarding Pakistan's brief history which had never been heard in the Pakistan studies book. This podcast is one of the most brief, and informative, regarding the dissection of Pakistan's deep politics and history.
After living in UAE for 3 years now i can surely say islam is only in danger in Pakistan because it's being used for personal gains..
Research and find religion which teaches kindness and compassion to all humans.
@@RajKumar-md9df Islam
Same
Syed Muzzamil it’s great to listen to a young enlightened man like you who can influence youth towards reading non fiction cz without reading you simply cannot expand your mind or horizons or change your mindset or converse ; it enriches not only your perspectives but you help others to view things differently as well, Junaid Akram is another treasure we have.
سید مُزمل شاہ ایک شیعہ مُلحد ہے جس نے قُرآن اور احادیث کا مذاق اُڑایا، اسکی لفاظی اور چرب زبانی سے اپنے ایمان کو بچائیں 🙏۔
@@Patriotic8422 khuda k leay har cheez ko negativity ki taraf na lay jaen 🙏
@@naeemabokhari2285
میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔
Awesome podcast! I am from India, never heard so much truth ever before in a discussion. Wish there are more of such intellectuals who are free from all biases and tell the truth like you guys, very good work 👍
Free Khalistan from india
I am amazed at this young man's extensive knowledge on various topics and his superb abilty to talk continually without once being irrelevant or at a loss for the right word or expression. His observations and his confidence besides being extremely well-read cannot be praised enough. What a gem of a scholar we have discovered through this podcast. Junaid Akram is to be congratulated for bringing forth this highly engaging and informative dialogue.
I am a follower of Syed muzzamil from his very early days from Facebook and one of the earliest subscriber on you tube. One of the very few sane minds from Pakistan 🇵🇰 . Respect from india 🇮🇳
Being a bihari where nalanda university's remains are present it's just amazing to see like literally the remains are this much interesting just imagine how great the university was 🎉
Such a loss to India!!
@@harrypotter-rj8ip wrong fact my son it was burnt by Muslims because they thing it was anti quran ..u must have read this fact on WhatsApp university
سید مُزمل شاہ ایک شیعہ مُلحد ہے جس نے قُرآن اور احادیث کا مذاق اُڑایا، اسکی لفاظی اور چرب زبانی سے اپنے ایمان کو بچائیں 🙏
@@Patriotic8422 ye bat English me likh Leta jhaantu
@@Patriotic8422 bhakkkk
You guys need to do another podcast, this one was hands down the best discussion of the decade.
Holy moly! This vlog deserves an award for being the marathon of all vlogs - I had to take snack breaks to keep up! But guess what? Totally worth it! Talk about a dynamic duo - "BALD AND THE BEAUTIFUL" takes the cake. Now, I may have a few more wrinkles than you two, but hey, age is just a number, right? On a more sophisticated note, kudos for the brainy, rational discussion with a historical twist. Seriously, it's like the Avengers of intellectual conversations!
Such an impeccable podcast! ❤ He is a treasure we cant lose at any cost! Always a treat to hear him!
Part where he says, The biggest oppression greater than establishment is our family system.. That struck so hard!
Muzammil keep shining like a star! ❤
سید مُزمل شاہ ایک شیعہ مُلحد ہے جس نے قُرآن اور احادیث کا مذاق اُڑایا، اسکی لفاظی اور چرب زبانی سے اپنے ایمان کو بچائیں 🙏۔
Wow!! My two most favorite Pakistani TH-camrs together!!! This is going to be Gold!!
Fantastic podcast. Almost 3 hours and still never wanted it to end. Gained so much out of it
We always enjoy Muzammil Shah's interview. He is one who talks with facts. He is a courageous journalist. Lets pray for his welbeing. Keep it up.
Wow!! What I learnt in last 3 hours through this podcast sitting here in Canada - didn’t happen in last 20 years. Super impressed with the objective analysis on such diverse topics. One of the best 3 hours of my life - Awesome job !!!
Pakistani politics offers a classic case where all the stakeholders are out on a fatalistic trail , (like that of the Norwegian lemmings that are”driven” to perform collective suicide) which can only end one way : in a massive and unprecedented cataclysm . Alternatively it could be said that all the power-wielders and power-brokers are playing a game of “Russian Roulette”. As the Euripides proverb puts it: “Those whom the gods wish to destroy , they first make mad”. May God have mercy on us…….!
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview.
See my other comments for list of errors.
@1:17:00 Muzammil is right. The Establishment is the cause of rot of Pakistan. Also Establishment cooperated with Imran Khan to bring him to power. However, they ensured that he did not have a clear majority, so that they could control him. All the media curbs, and atrocities, that Muzammil talks about were perpetrated by the Establishment. This is clear from the worsening of these practices after removal of IK, by the Establishment. Why does Muzammil not say that the curbs and atrocities multiplied many fold after removal of IK?
And why was IK removed? Because he delivered (despite being shackled) and was becoming a danger to their stranglehold on Pakistan. Only problem Muzammil has with IK is that he is right wing and hence against Liberals.
@1:19:40 Junaid says that the war is over wooing the establishment & Muzammil agrees. This is false. Imran Khan has totally exposed the stranglehold of Establishment over Pakistan. Now people openly talk of reigning them in. IK cannot allow them this power even if he wanted to. Just like he cannot let go of corruption of PMLN & PPP. This is the biggest accomplishment of IK. Pakistan will never be the same again, even if IK is eliminated.
The Establishment is fighting for it's survival. That is exposing them even more.
@1:19:56 Muzammil says PTI wants to talk to Establishment (so is ready to surrender to them) also they wanted Faiz. This is false. IK has repeatedly said PDM has no power, so he wants to talk to Establishment. And he wants to talk about holding elections. Establishment offered IK to allow elections and thus come to power, if he was willing to forgive their crimes. This IK refused. Also IK has said he had no plans to install Faiz. Faiz was as much a part of Establishment as Bajwa or Munir. What IK opposed was, removal of Faiz, bypassing the authority of PM by COAS Bajwa.
@1:22:37 Muzammil has rightly opposed extension of Interim setup beyond 90 days. That is what IK is demanding. He has put the Establishment in such a spot, that they are forced to subvert the constitution again. Thus exposing themself.
@1:25:21 Muzammil says that democracy does not work due to Biradris/tribes. This is wrong. Actually Tribes & societies exist to protect the member's rights. This is a necessity if the legal system is weak. So we need to implement the rule of Law. Biggest enabler of Democracy is education. And if democratic values exist, then even the Biradries will select competent people.
@1:25:34 Muzammil says democracy comes when family structure breaks. THIS IS THE MOST DANGEROUS THING, HE HAS SAID IN THIS INTERVIEW. As said before education is the biggest enabler of democracy. Family is the basic unit of the society, and it must never be broken. It is in the western culture, where the families are dysfunctional, children leave home at 18years and have no bond with each other. Majority of kids live in single parent family. This is the biggest flaw of Western society. And Muzammil is a proponent of implementing it.
@1:36:28 Muzammil says rise of populism is due to social media. This is not correct. Populism occurs when there is disillusion with the current system. People look for alternates. Social media provides a platform that cannot be controlled by the authorities.
If people are impressed by a leader, then it is simply because they hope that he will be atleast better than those being projected by the mainstream media.
@1:42:52 Muzammil says Pakistan can be corrected from outside. THIS IS WRONG. The outside powers have no interest in "correcting" Pakistan. They are only interested in what benefits them. Pakistan can only be corrected by awareness & activism of it's own people.
@1:43:43 Muzammil thinks part of establishment is still supporting Imran Khan. Otherwise he would have been arrested & hanged like Bhutto, the most popular leader of Pakistan. THIS IS WRONG. Bhutto may have been most popular amongst the leaders, but his support base was narrow, due to his own actions. Also there was only one TV channel & no social media. The Establishment cannot control the narrative now. If Establishment had it's say, IK would have been history long ago.
@1:51:38 Muzammil says there is Sui gas in Lahore but not in Sui. THIS IS WRONG. Yes Sui gas arrived late in Sui & Quetta, but it is there.
@2:07:21 Muzammil says the awakening in Punjab is only in favour of a personality. This is wrong. It is more so against the Establishment. The movement will not die even if IK is removed.
@2:08:42 Muzammil says one who is not a friend of Modi, is a traitor. Because Pakistan will not survive without trade with India. THIS IS WRONG. There are many more countries in the world other than India. Survival of Pakistan DOES NOT depend on trade with India.
@2:09:03 Muzammil thinks Bilawal "may" be intellectually better than Mariam or Imran Khan. This is a joke. It shows how biased Muzammil is for the Left & Against the Right. This is intellectual dishonesty at it's worst.
@2:47:36 Muzammil recommends books by Haqqani. It is clear that Haqqani is an opportunist, besides being a traitor. He started his career as a leader of Jamaat e Islami.
Worked with dictator Zia.
Then joined Leftist Benazir when she came to power.
Joined Rightist Nawaz when he came to power.
Then joined corrupt Zardari, when he came to power.
Then joined the Indian lobby (anti Army, anti Pakistan) when ousted by the establishment of Pakistan.
Then started supporting the Army when hired by Bajwa.
So how does Muzammil consider his books intellectual and honest? This means Muzammil himself is dishonest.
We need more people like Muzammil in our society. Thank you Junaid for inviting such a gem.
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview.
See my other comments for list of errors.
@@afaqh2356please tell me about the errors
@@asteriod8364 I did but they dont like criticism. They deleted my post.
Syed Mujammils argument is brilliant in many cases. But he is ideologically a liberal and opposes Islamic ideology. So dont be influenced so much by him. Leave your brain open all the time and listen to anybody.
@@RAVU514 🤣🤣 They are superchat ji of like 'vola vala' you
Listening to Muzammil is therapy
Love u bro❤❤❤
میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، مُجھے گالیاں دینے کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں، مزمل کو شیعہ ملحد اس لئیے کہا کہ وہ ایک کٹر شیعہ ہے جو مُلحد کا لبادہ اُوڑھا ہوا ہے۔ ارتغرل سمیت یہ زیادہ تر مُسلم حُکمرانوں کو کافر کہتا ہے، اسکے سامنے جو کوئی صدارتی اسلامی نظام یا خُلفاء راشدین کے نظام کی بات کرتا ہے یہ باریکی سے اُسکے خلاف زہر اُگلتا ہے۔ میرے معصوم پاکستانیو، کیا آپ اتنے ہلکے ہو کہ چرب زبانی لفآظی سے دس بارہ کتابوں کا حوالہ دینے والوں کی پوجا شروع کردوگے؟ کیا آپ وہ کتابیں نہیں پڑھو گے جو بغیر سیاق و سباق کے یہ شیعہ ملحد اپنے آئیڈیاز کو جوڑ کر آپکی ذہن سازی کرنے کی کوشش کررہا ہے؟ خُدارا اس دور فتن میں فتنوں کی پہچان کرکے خود کو بچائیں۔ میں نے اسکی بُہت وڈیوز اور تقریریں دیکھی سُنی ہیں یہ ایک کنفویز قسم کا مُلحد ہے، خود اسی وڈیو میں دیکھیں کہتا ہے میں کسی سیاستدان کا نہیں کہتا آپ خود دیکھیں، آخر میں بلاول زرداری کو بہترین سیاستدان اور حُسین حقانی کو انقلابی بنارہا ہے۔ کیا آپکو نہیں پتہ کہ بلاول زرداری پیپلزپارٹی پاکستان کو لادین اور سیکولر بنانے کے لئیے امریکہ کی خوشامد میں لگی رہتی ہے؟ کیا آپکو حُسین حقانی کے کارناموں کا نہیں معلوم جو اسلام اور پاکستان کی اساس کے خلاف امریکہ میں کام کررہا ہے؟ کیا آپ نہیں دیکھتے کہ اسکی باتوں سے سب سے زیادہ بھارتی اور غیر مُسلم خوش ہوتے ہیں؟ آگے آپکی مرضی 😔 .
Everytime i see this guy i feel jealous and bad that what is this brilliant mind doing in 🇵🇰… People of pakistan these kind of people deserves to be cherished and followed… you are on my idol’s list SYED ❤
He is good, but one doesn't have to be envious, we have a lot of talent. Just start listening to few more....
Meanwhile he never gives a straight answer, when he is asked about choices and options. Communist are really good at problem identification, but not solution oriented.
Syed muzammil is probably one of my favorite people to listen to.. The way he intertwines regional/global politics with philosophy and goes to the root of the problem is fascinating to me.. We need people like him in India... He reminds me of another of my favorite speakers Mr Christopher Hitchens.. It was an absolute pleasure to watch this podcast..
People like him in India..? We are far better without him.. !! He belongs there where he is right now..
Pakistan mein ho kar bhi kya kar liya jo india aa kar .. kar lenge ?
This Blind LOVE for pakistanis is gonna cost us heavily in near future !
@@bhaktikulkarni2005 on point 👍
I mean I dont know how you judge a person and how ur thought process works but the moment he said ki "Aajkal India me narrative badalne ki koshish ki jaa rahi hai (means muslims are in danger) made me laugh so hard and it immediately showed this guy's "brilliance"! ye log toh pure Islami hai na? Inke yaha toh hindu ab rahe bhi nahi toh aaj kya hora hai inke saath? pure islami hokar bhi tootne ki kagaar pe hai. If there was really a narrative change going on (anti muslim narrative) then I suspect Muslim population wouldn't had grown further here but it isn't true These people lecture India (and idk how their points are so in sync with INC and other opposition parties) and people like u are "impressed" by their knowledge lol!
@A143 True that, India has many of this kind...but Pakistan has only handful....or may be even less...
He kept me hooked for the entire three hours while I studied and listened to him simultaneously. What a personality! I only hope to be as intelligent, well-spoken, and poised as him in the future.
He is so underrated, im so happy.. he will get recognition now.
I recently started to follow Muzammil.. everything else I can digest but the topic which he has raised about social issues and the Child abuse specially male child is something which made me completely speechless. I could have never imagined that such things are happening in the society 😥😥
We always speak about abuses faced by female child but forget that male kids are also vulnerable to the same threat.
Muzammil is a living testament of the idea that "Readers are Leaders". Smart, articulate and a strategic deep thinker. His kind are rare. Everytime you watch his content, you will find something new to learn and improve your way of thinking.
What new thing has Muzammil brought? Anything that hasn't been said or written before by someone else?
@@DWAGON1818 his concept about communism and capitalism for Pakistanis was very unique,
@@legendaryhound5261 how exactly. Does he want both? That can't happen. What is the concept.
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I can see the fallacies and errors in his interview.
See my other comments for list of errors.
@@afaqh2356 what other comments were you asking me to find of yours for reference? All I could see were your desperate replies under different comments that are praising him. You sure you are not a hater or a jealous person if you have to copy paste the same sentences under every comment praising the guy? LMAO XD
Guys, yours debate was so engaging I went to bed 3am Sunday morning. BTW, am an Indian Australian & throughly enjoyed the way it was structured & discussed. Sharp questions & solid answers!!! More power to you both!
What a spooky world. I am British Indjan and finishing podcast by 3am British time on Sunday morning. Both are brilliant and opened up my mind to box of Pandora
co - existence is only possible if u r not having a mindset of having double standards driven by a fake narrative of Religiously motivated Bigoted Superiority. Zia and his followers built this narrative based on the Two nation theory propagated by the founding father of the Muslim League Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan who was from Aligarh and whose followers r still doing their best in a clandestine organized way to weaken India internally.
Hence the Indian state has realized that the only way to crush these zealots is to destroy their most precious creation and achievement i.e. Pakistan.
So India post PM Modis famed Sharif wedding attendance debacle post which Pathankot and URI were countered by our Surgical strike at Balakot and other operations .
The current Govt. has decided on a wholistic approach of Balkanizing Pakistan by destroying its economy by destroying its internal and external support structure of Pakistan.
Hence ur current Status Quo of economic degradation and political turmoil and fissures in the Establishment GHQ in Rawalpindi and ISI in Islamabad.
We r further gonna help target ur ex pats and retd, generals with their children and progeny of ur political elite in their European American Australian and Dubai based exclaves created by ur 1% elites.
We r going to go after these Paki Parasites Mossad style the way the Israelis did after the Muslim Brotherhood in the 60s and 70s.
All this can be done only if their assets and invesments in Pakistan crash and become valueless for raising capital in the global financial markets devaluing their companies and destroying their means to survive globally as calculated by our agencies thus destroying the Fauji faundations.
Pakistan will be worse than Lebanon at the peak of its financial crisis all its gonna take is an cataclysmic event at Bin Qasim Port like the one in Lebanon and guess what it only takes a few ill intentioned Afghans or Balochis who were rubbed the wrong way by the Pakistani Army or Rangers to do the needful.
Jai Hind
Best man ever! Amazing Pakistani talent. So proud of this young man.
Highly appreciable- this 3 hours of intellectual debate was far more educational and helpful than any schooling institute. We want & need to see such more platforms coming up ahead! Thankyou for making the ground Junaid bhai, and our own muzammil bhai! Love ♥️🙌
Bro this is the history and reality of Pakistan.. Tumhare mulk kya karte he with common people.. Military, politicians made this kind os situation of your country
I think Muzammil has some knowledge but is a psudo intelectual. He is highly biased in his views and has said many wrong things. I am not a Philosopher, or intelectual, but even I, can see the fallacies and errors in this interview.
See my other comments for list of errors.