I found that the Sky High transfers under my eyes (I'm oily) even if I'm prepped and powdered, something that the Thrive did not. It also seems to come off more as a fiber and less as a tubing. I would like to try a couple of these, but I wish there was a message on if it is cruelty-free or not. That's very important in my makeup decisions!
Those of you wondering is Sensai 38 degrees is worth it - only the curling one is. Kinda. I mean it is great, defining, comes off easily, but it does dry out pretty soon - lasts 2-3 months. I repurchased it once, but definitely don't think its worth the money unless you are ready to pay a way too much and repurchase often, but it works anyways!
Thank you so much!!! I've been wearing tubing mascaras for years now cause everything else makes me look like a panda within an hour. I'm so glad they've become so popular lately 😁
Thank you so much for making this video!!! Just a quick reminder, but DHC is a Japanese brand while Heimish is Korean. Funny how both popular cleansing brands make great mascara 😂
Thanks for sharing! I've just recently transitioned to tubing mascaras with my latest Maybelline snapscara (waterproof) purchase. It's exactly what i envisioned. After 15+ years of makeup wearing, my requirements in mascaea have changed because i want a clean removal and i want to start applying mascara to my bottom lashes.
Thanks so much! I have been a Trish McEvoy mascara girl for years, but in the last 3 years have been trying all the other options (Thrive, blinc and on and on) and none of them have come close. I did finally just find the lune + aster and am loving it! Hoping it is my new go to for the next 10 years. (and now I have even more options thanks to your reviews)
Dana!!! Thank you for testing all those! You and I both love tubing mascaras so I've bought a couple from your past videos. The Clinique has been my HG for years. The loreal one is growing on me and is easier to remove than Clinique and a little more dramatic of a look I find (in a good way). I just tried the snapscara too. Wearing it for the first time today. Looks good! We'll see how it removes... Next I'll try the Maybelline sky high one. I've never liked the blinc one. I tried the Mac one once and it was good but didn't care to repurchase. Same with kevyn aucoin. I so appreciate this review!!
You are the first one to mention Trish McEvoy Mascaras that I came across, and I've been searching for a while what others think about them. Thank you for mentioning your thoughts on their product!
This was SO helpful. I just got the Heimish one because I’m so sick of mascara transferring or being incredibly difficult to remove. So glad I found your channel! I’ll be marathoning your videos now haha
I love the L’Oréal Age Perfect mascara in the Easy to Remove waterproof (their code for tubing, I guess). I much prefer it over the double extend. I would highly recommend, but sadly, I heard they’re discontinuing it!
Thanks for the great tubing videos! Clinique has been my tubing mascara for the past two years but I recently purchased the Cali Ray at your recommendation and I’ve been impressed with it. Best volume so far of the tubing mascaras that’s I’ve tried so far.
I’m obsessed with tubing mascaras. The one I like at the moment is Clinique lash power. If any better ones please let me know. Want the false lash look but not clumpy
Very thorough evaluation, Dana! You have great lashes (and brows), so mascara is just the "icing on the cake", so to speak. Thanks for all the wear and tear on your eyes to film them all.
I have mixed before but tend to not, but that’s just me. No, there’s nothing bad about them, just be gentle when removing, but that goes for normal mascara too
Dana have you tried eyeko mascaras? I've heard that all their mascaras are tubing (or at least they used to be a couple of years ago?). I've ordered the Black Magic Cocoa Edit in brown - I'll let you know if it's actually tubing!
Thank you so much for testing all these. I've been using loreal double extend for at least 5 years now and recently stepped over to sensai 38° when it was on sale. Its so much better than the loreal one but its definitely pricy. I also tried the maybelline snapscara and got so annoyed that it wasn't tubing! I might try the waterproof version in the future haha! Sky high was a massive failure though, as wonderful the brush is, it left flakes and smudges throughout the day and did not remove in tubes. Sadly since I'm in the EU I can't try some of the brands you mentioned, I want thrive so bad!
That was one that I really wanted to get but I think on Amazon it was like $60 and I just couldn’t do it. One day, if I can find it for a cheaper price! It’s so funny how different mascaras are for everyone. The sky high has never done me wrong 😅
Thanks for this video! Which one would you say is the best for holding a curl if that was the only criteria? I don’t care about volume or length or ease of use, I only care about what will get my stick straight lashes to hold a curl after I use my eyelash curler. Thanks! PS I did watch the video three times but there was so much information that I can’t quite tell out of the ones that you mentioned would be good at holding a curl which one would be the ultimate
That’s fair-there was A LOT of info and I knew I might get overwhelming. I’m assuming you use a lash curler first? If yes, I would say any of the smaller wands with a lighter formula work well for holding a curl. So like the DHC, Clinique, or MAC. I didn’t have it in this video but I’ve seen other videos where people love how the Glossier mascara holds a curl. It is quite light and natural and I think that type of formula is key for holding a curl. Heavier/wetter formulas are too much and the curl falls. Hope that helps!
@@DanaRipperton Thanks so much! I didn’t mean it as a criticism at all, I appreciate thorough reviews with lots of info and I have no problem with long videos. I was just wondering if, out of the ones that are best at holding a curl, if there was a clear winner if that were they only criteria without other attributes being a factor. I also wanted you to know that I had watched the video and wasn’t just trying to skip it and just make you spoonfeed me the info. I really appreciate the work you put into this! oh and yes I do you use an eyelash curler but my eyelashes literally point downward without one so they tend to return to that position after only about one hour.
I had never heard of tubing mascara until today when I viewed a Facebook ad for Thrive mascara. I guess I'm definitely behind the times, but maybe it's because I quit wearing mascara about ten years ago because it just wouldn't stay on my lashes and I would have terrible raccoon eyes. I guess it's because my eyes tear a LOT. And as I learned from your video, I was probably using brands that were too wet or volumizing. Anyway, I did a search on TH-cam and found your video. I think that all the mascaras you liked the least actually looked the best to me lol. I think because I prefer the definition/natural look over the voluminous look for myself, although I don't think I ever really knew that until I watched your video! I had tried so MANY mascaras and always disliked the ones that were super thick or wet or that had fat or curved applicators (I have fine lashes and I never realized there were so many differences in mascaras!). I've also never been one to be able to splurge on the better brands and usually have settled for drug store makeups since I can remember, so that doesn't help. This video explained a lot for me and I think helped me to understand what I even want in a mascara. I think I will try some of the brands that you said are drier and more defining. That, coupled with it being a tubing mascara, may finally make it possible for me to wear mascara again (and actually have eyes that look awake lol). Great video! Thanks!
Such a great video!! I subscribed after just a few seconds of the video because this is seriously comprehensive!! Super impressed by the volume of mascaras you tried.
Great video! I’m on the hunt for the perfect tubing mascara so this was so helpful🙏🤩! My dream mascara is the Thrive one but it’s not possible to buy it in Europe unfortunately. I like the No7 but would like a more spectacular one🤗. Thanks again💕!
I would say any of the ones that have a smaller wand, so the DHC, Kevyn Aucoin, Clinique, Mac. I also love the Maybelline sky high for definition. If you don’t build it up as much, you can get definition with less volume
Not sure which one to get yet but I do know I appreciated all your hard work you put into this. Think your channel will grow, especially with consistency. Thanks.
thanks for making this video!!!! it is super helpful and covers literally all the tubing mascaras i’m considering and are currently sitting in my carts 🤣 (also subscribed hehe)
Thank you Dana for your time and effort. Omg at points in your vid your eyes looked so sore. Owch. I have always used waterproof Mascaras, my favourite being Lancome, even these give me panda/raccoon eyes. I will defo investigate the tubing mascaras. Thanks to you i have a great starter list 😊 🧡
I've read that the L'Oreal Age Perfect Lash Magnifying in Waterproof is tubing and great!! I'd love to see another video with some of the new ones that have come out too!
@@DanaRippertonFinally got my hands on it. Its a brilliant mascara! Total doll eyes! - perfect balance of volume and lenght, holds and creates a curl and holds up all day. Zero smudging, even with oily products around the eye. Removes beautifully. I remember this from when it came out, but for Whatever reason, It didnt impress me then. Probably the 2 step system, and the general unhandyness of the tube. But by god Dana, so far Im sold. Thank you so much for recommending this!!
Thx for all your work on this. Can you let me know if the L’Oréal double extend needs to be waterproof to be the tubing formula? Also, do you think it would survive a workout? Thx so much.
The Cali Ray seems interesting. I think I have tried them all lol. Sky high today and got raccoon eyes 😞. Can you do a video on tubing mascara in brown
Awesome video. I use L’Oréal Double Extend and have done for years. Also made the rookie mistake of buying snapscara but not the WP version - doh! Will defo try some of the other ones you mentioned! Thank you for such a detailed video!
Thank you for this comprehensive comparison. It's so helpful. I can only wear tubing mascara. I haven't tried this many, but I've tried several that you have listed. I totally agree with you on the no 7, hourglass and em. I loved L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Million Lashes Excess Mascara but stopped purchasing due to it's cruelty free status. I really wanted to love the em one but it's my least liked other than the original blinc. I found that one way too wet, does this new formula have that same dry down time?
@@DanaRipperton the original blinc mascara. I have hooded eyes and it couldn't dry quick enough to not be everywhere! Just ordered the Kevin Aucoin. Now I've got the Trish Mcevoy, Lune +Aster and Heimish on the radar.
I was waiting for you to tell us your top 3 at the end but you didn’t :( I watched the whole video and only had to guess it would be thrive Cali ray and L’Oréal double extend do you confirm? Thank you for this video btw appreciate the effort as I only wear tubing mascaras due to ease of removal
I’m confused by your recommendation to use a cleansing balm to remove tubing mascara. I’ve been instructed to use water exclusively. I’ve never had difficulty removing any tubing tubing mascara- and I’m now concerned about the cleansing balm recommendation as I’ve told others who complain about eye irritation from cleansing balms to use tubing mascara, and eliminate the eye makeup remover/balm irritation
It’s nothing to be concerned about. I just use cleansing balms exclusively and they take off tubing and non-tubing mascaras alike. Tubing mascara doesn’t require it, it’s just what I use, especially if the mascara is tricky to get off
Can u do a all day wear test in these? I know it’s a lot, but perhaps one eye each and quick recap at the end? Unfortunately there are tunings that smear
For 22 mascaras, I’m afraid that would take over my whole life, so no. Also, what smears/flakes on me may not on you, and Vice versa. I can try to answer questions about individual mascaras though
This is a great comprehensive, tubing mascara breakdown. It's so interesting how people have such different preferences for mascara. For me I loves the em cosmetics mascara and hated the Totally Tubular one. I have a feeling I would also not like the Thrive one based on the heaviness of the formula. I will have to try the waterproof snapscara one, since I did not like the other one. Apparently before it was discontinued, L'Oreal Age Perfect's waterproof formula was also tubing, even though it wasn't advertised that way.
@Dana Ripperton the only one I didn't see on this list that other make up lovers recommended to me was the LA Girl Volumatic, about $5 at target. Molded plastic brush that has flexibility. Very voluminous outcome... false lash look. On the first try worked great, but I went back to finish my trusty Boots Stay perfect. When I went back to Volumatic, still looked great, but had some trouble removing it... almost like removing a regular waterproof mascara. It has been a perplexing one and I wanted to make sure it wasn't just me? Again, FANTASTIC video. I really enjoy hearing your thoughts about skin tints and tubing mascaras! Ty!
Thanks for much for watching! I love finding others who love skin tints and tubing mascaras! 🤗I have tried the volumatic and probz should have added it but decluttered it a while back. That said, I already have a few more I’m testing out and it’s back in the mix!
I found the loreal mascara horrible and will never purchase it again. It flakes toward the end of the day, is way too light, and runs out quickly. For just under $15 it's not worth the price in my mind.
![ทุกครั้งที่หลับตา (Lucid Dream) - AYLA's [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4i1OBAQyv58/mqdefault.jpg)
Wow. You did it, Dana. May the algorithm bless you for this work.
Awww the nicest compliment any TH-camr could receive 🤣🥰🙏🏼
I found that the Sky High transfers under my eyes (I'm oily) even if I'm prepped and powdered, something that the Thrive did not. It also seems to come off more as a fiber and less as a tubing. I would like to try a couple of these, but I wish there was a message on if it is cruelty-free or not. That's very important in my makeup decisions!
I love most maybelline mascaras,but Shy High hurts my eyes and is very difficult for me to remove.
Sky high*
Those of you wondering is Sensai 38 degrees is worth it - only the curling one is. Kinda. I mean it is great, defining, comes off easily, but it does dry out pretty soon - lasts 2-3 months. I repurchased it once, but definitely don't think its worth the money unless you are ready to pay a way too much and repurchase often, but it works anyways!
Thank you so much!!! I've been wearing tubing mascaras for years now cause everything else makes me look like a panda within an hour. I'm so glad they've become so popular lately 😁
I absolutely love Loungeface mascara. It’s a fantastic tubing mascara that gives length, volume and curl hold. Definitely recommend that one.
I’ll check it out!
Thank you so much for making this video!!!
Just a quick reminder, but DHC is a Japanese brand while Heimish is Korean. Funny how both popular cleansing brands make great mascara 😂
Thanks! I didn’t mean to mix them up! But yes-funny indeed. And I love all of them
This is the most thorough and comprehensive review of tubing mascaras I’ve seen. Subscribed! TYSM!!!
🥹🥰thank you!!!
Thanks for sharing! I've just recently transitioned to tubing mascaras with my latest Maybelline snapscara (waterproof) purchase. It's exactly what i envisioned. After 15+ years of makeup wearing, my requirements in mascaea have changed because i want a clean removal and i want to start applying mascara to my bottom lashes.
Thanks so much! I have been a Trish McEvoy mascara girl for years, but in the last 3 years have been trying all the other options (Thrive, blinc and on and on) and none of them have come close. I did finally just find the lune + aster and am loving it! Hoping it is my new go to for the next 10 years. (and now I have even more options thanks to your reviews)
Trish was my gateway mascara 😂 I loooove the Lune + Aster and it’s lasted a long time too without drying out. 🩷
Dana!!! Thank you for testing all those! You and I both love tubing mascaras so I've bought a couple from your past videos. The Clinique has been my HG for years. The loreal one is growing on me and is easier to remove than Clinique and a little more dramatic of a look I find (in a good way). I just tried the snapscara too. Wearing it for the first time today. Looks good! We'll see how it removes... Next I'll try the Maybelline sky high one. I've never liked the blinc one. I tried the Mac one once and it was good but didn't care to repurchase. Same with kevyn aucoin. I so appreciate this review!!
Fellow tubing mascara lovers are my people 🥰🥰🥰 the Clinique is great too!
@@DanaRipperton I also love: skin tints, sunscreen and no makeup makeup so you're pretty much my ideal channel :)
Ahhhhh truly my people 🥳🥰that literally made my day 😍
You are the first one to mention Trish McEvoy Mascaras that I came across, and I've been searching for a while what others think about them. Thank you for mentioning your thoughts on their product!
It was my holy grail mascara for many years
This was SO helpful. I just got the Heimish one because I’m so sick of mascara transferring or being incredibly difficult to remove. So glad I found your channel! I’ll be marathoning your videos now haha
Awww yay!!! Glad you’re here and I LOVE the Heimish one so much! 💗
I love the L’Oréal Age Perfect mascara in the Easy to Remove waterproof (their code for tubing, I guess). I much prefer it over the double extend. I would highly recommend, but sadly, I heard they’re discontinuing it!
Thanks for the great tubing videos! Clinique has been my tubing mascara for the past two years but I recently purchased the Cali Ray at your recommendation and I’ve been impressed with it. Best volume so far of the tubing mascaras that’s I’ve tried so far.
I wore the Cali Ray to the beach today! It’s a solid choice! Thanks so much for watching 😘🤗
I’m obsessed with tubing mascaras. The one I like at the moment is Clinique lash power. If any better ones please let me know.
Want the false lash look but not clumpy
Very thorough evaluation, Dana! You have great lashes (and brows), so mascara is just the "icing on the cake", so to speak. Thanks for all the wear and tear on your eyes to film them all.
Have you ever mixed them? Use a lengthening one AND a volumising one ?
Also do you know if they are bad for your lashes ?
I have mixed before but tend to not, but that’s just me. No, there’s nothing bad about them, just be gentle when removing, but that goes for normal mascara too
Dana have you tried eyeko mascaras? I've heard that all their mascaras are tubing (or at least they used to be a couple of years ago?). I've ordered the Black Magic Cocoa Edit in brown - I'll let you know if it's actually tubing!
I have tried them but never loved them 🤷🏻♀️
Thank you so much for testing all these. I've been using loreal double extend for at least 5 years now and recently stepped over to sensai 38° when it was on sale. Its so much better than the loreal one but its definitely pricy. I also tried the maybelline snapscara and got so annoyed that it wasn't tubing! I might try the waterproof version in the future haha! Sky high was a massive failure though, as wonderful the brush is, it left flakes and smudges throughout the day and did not remove in tubes. Sadly since I'm in the EU I can't try some of the brands you mentioned, I want thrive so bad!
That was one that I really wanted to get but I think on Amazon it was like $60 and I just couldn’t do it. One day, if I can find it for a cheaper price! It’s so funny how different mascaras are for everyone. The sky high has never done me wrong 😅
Thanks for this video! Which one would you say is the best for holding a curl if that was the only criteria? I don’t care about volume or length or ease of use, I only care about what will get my stick straight lashes to hold a curl after I use my eyelash curler. Thanks! PS I did watch the video three times but there was so much information that I can’t quite tell out of the ones that you mentioned would be good at holding a curl which one would be the ultimate
That’s fair-there was A LOT of info and I knew I might get overwhelming. I’m assuming you use a lash curler first? If yes, I would say any of the smaller wands with a lighter formula work well for holding a curl. So like the DHC, Clinique, or MAC. I didn’t have it in this video but I’ve seen other videos where people love how the Glossier mascara holds a curl. It is quite light and natural and I think that type of formula is key for holding a curl. Heavier/wetter formulas are too much and the curl falls. Hope that helps!
@@DanaRipperton Thanks so much! I didn’t mean it as a criticism at all, I appreciate thorough reviews with lots of info and I have no problem with long videos. I was just wondering if, out of the ones that are best at holding a curl, if there was a clear winner if that were they only criteria without other attributes being a factor. I also wanted you to know that I had watched the video and wasn’t just trying to skip it and just make you spoonfeed me the info. I really appreciate the work you put into this! oh and yes I do you use an eyelash curler but my eyelashes literally point downward without one so they tend to return to that position after only about one hour.
I had never heard of tubing mascara until today when I viewed a Facebook ad for Thrive mascara. I guess I'm definitely behind the times, but maybe it's because I quit wearing mascara about ten years ago because it just wouldn't stay on my lashes and I would have terrible raccoon eyes. I guess it's because my eyes tear a LOT. And as I learned from your video, I was probably using brands that were too wet or volumizing.
Anyway, I did a search on TH-cam and found your video. I think that all the mascaras you liked the least actually looked the best to me lol. I think because I prefer the definition/natural look over the voluminous look for myself, although I don't think I ever really knew that until I watched your video!
I had tried so MANY mascaras and always disliked the ones that were super thick or wet or that had fat or curved applicators (I have fine lashes and I never realized there were so many differences in mascaras!). I've also never been one to be able to splurge on the better brands and usually have settled for drug store makeups since I can remember, so that doesn't help.
This video explained a lot for me and I think helped me to understand what I even want in a mascara. I think I will try some of the brands that you said are drier and more defining. That, coupled with it being a tubing mascara, may finally make it possible for me to wear mascara again (and actually have eyes that look awake lol).
Great video! Thanks!
Love to hear this!!! ❤️❤️❤️
Such a great video!! I subscribed after just a few seconds of the video because this is seriously comprehensive!! Super impressed by the volume of mascaras you tried.
Awww thank you🥰😘
Great video! I’m on the hunt for the perfect tubing mascara so this was so helpful🙏🤩! My dream mascara is the Thrive one but it’s not possible to buy it in Europe unfortunately. I like the No7 but would like a more spectacular one🤗. Thanks again💕!
I wish Thrive would ship internationally but hopefully some of these that are available on Amazon will ship to you. ❤️😘
Have you tried the ELF Lash Xtndr? Supposedly ELFs version to dupe the thrive
wow this was so helpful, new subscriber! which would you say is the most defining and separating?
I would say any of the ones that have a smaller wand, so the DHC, Kevyn Aucoin, Clinique, Mac. I also love the Maybelline sky high for definition. If you don’t build it up as much, you can get definition with less volume
Subscribing immediately just for the amount of work that went into this!
🥹🥹🥹welcome!
I just bought the Heimish mascara, I can't wait to try it ! 🥰 thank you so much for this video, very helpful !
I use a primer before thrive. Try it using the Maybelline primer you already have. That’s what I use
Ohhh good idea! I’ll try it out!
Not sure which one to get yet but I do know I appreciated all your hard work you put into this. Think your channel will grow, especially with consistency. Thanks.
😘😘
thanks for making this video!!!! it is super helpful and covers literally all the tubing mascaras i’m considering and are currently sitting in my carts 🤣 (also subscribed hehe)
Whooo!!! So glad it helped and welcome 🤗❤️
What would you say is the most volumizing tubing mascara??
Ohhh boy, that is a tough one. For me, the Blinc UltraVolume, Thrive, L’Oreal Double Extend, Heimish, and sometimes caliray.
Thank you Dana for your time and effort. Omg at points in your vid your eyes looked so sore. Owch. I have always used waterproof Mascaras, my favourite being Lancome, even these give me panda/raccoon eyes. I will defo investigate the tubing mascaras. Thanks to you i have a great starter list 😊 🧡
Hahaha I did it for science 😂glad you found it helpful
I bought the L’Oreal Double Extend based on your recommendation. I absolutely love love love it. Thank you so much!
Whooo!!!! It’s such a staple and solid mascara. I’m never without it amongst my MANY mascaras ❤️🤗
L'Oreal Double Extension was my favorite mascara more than 15 years, but now it's discontinued. I can't find it anywhere. 😭😭😭
The Thrive always flakes for me....not sure why
I've read that the L'Oreal Age Perfect Lash Magnifying in Waterproof is tubing and great!! I'd love to see another video with some of the new ones that have come out too!
Oops, I just saw that you have a video on this already! I'm about to go watch it!
@@kalaniblake8699 hahah no prob! I have a few news ones that I’m making a video on now too. I try to stay current 🤗❤️😘
Fantastic video!! Thank you for sharing!❤
Does the double extension wash off with warm water?
Absolutely! It’s the OG of drugstore tubing mascaras!
@@DanaRipperton 😆 thx!
@@DanaRippertonFinally got my hands on it. Its a brilliant mascara! Total doll eyes! - perfect balance of volume and lenght, holds and creates a curl and holds up all day. Zero smudging, even with oily products around the eye. Removes beautifully. I remember this from when it came out, but for Whatever reason, It didnt impress me then. Probably the 2 step system, and the general unhandyness of the tube. But by god Dana, so far Im sold. Thank you so much for recommending this!!
@@Firkant2 yay!!!! So happy to hear that! The two step process is a little annoying but also might be why it’s so great.
Thank you for this video! I'm currently using the Blinc, and will try the Caliray next.
Nice video, great format. Btw DHC is a Japanese brand (not Korean).
Thanks! And yes, I was corrected about that a number of times 😁
Thx for all your work on this. Can you let me know if the L’Oréal double extend needs to be waterproof to be the tubing formula? Also, do you think it would survive a workout? Thx so much.
Nope, it’s just the regular version that is tubing 💕it survives many of my workouts, but everyone is different but it’s a long-running fave of mine
Great video!
The Cali Ray seems interesting. I think I have tried them all lol. Sky high today and got raccoon eyes 😞. Can you do a video on tubing mascara in brown
I think it would be a pretty short video, there are only 2 maybe 3. Thrive, Snapscara waterproof and maybe the Hard Candy
Great review! Thank you! Taste just came out with a new tubing mascara. Would love to hear your thoughts on it
Thank you! I saw they did and I’m planning on reviewing it as soon as I can get my hands on it
Which do you think would be most cry proof?
Oooff hard to say but the Blinc one is pretty moisture-proof, same with Cali Ray for me
Awesome video. I use L’Oréal Double Extend and have done for years. Also made the rookie mistake of buying snapscara but not the WP version - doh! Will defo try some of the other ones you mentioned! Thank you for such a detailed video!
Happ to help!! 💕💕
I watched the end a few times, but I didn't see a Top 5/Bottom 5 as mentioned in the intro. Did I somehow derp and miss it?
I think I forgot 😩 but it’s in order of my favorites
Which ones, if any, curl your lashes?
No mascara will curl your lashes, only a lash curler 🤗
Thank you for this comprehensive comparison. It's so helpful. I can only wear tubing mascara. I haven't tried this many, but I've tried several that you have listed. I totally agree with you on the no 7, hourglass and em. I loved L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Million Lashes Excess Mascara but stopped purchasing due to it's cruelty free status. I really wanted to love the em one but it's my least liked other than the original blinc. I found that one way too wet, does this new formula have that same dry down time?
Fellow tubing mascara lover💗🙌🏼which one are you referring to with the dry down?
@@DanaRipperton the original blinc mascara. I have hooded eyes and it couldn't dry quick enough to not be everywhere! Just ordered the Kevin Aucoin. Now I've got the Trish Mcevoy, Lune +Aster and Heimish on the radar.
I was waiting for you to tell us your top 3 at the end but you didn’t :( I watched the whole video and only had to guess it would be thrive Cali ray and L’Oréal double extend do you confirm? Thank you for this video btw appreciate the effort as I only wear tubing mascaras due to ease of removal
Hahaha whoops my bad. I pretty much went in order of my faves though🤗very hard to rank. Heimish is also up at the top
About to watch this. Does anyone recommend any brown tubing mascaras?
Thrive has a brown, so does Clinique
I’m confused by your recommendation to use a cleansing balm to remove tubing mascara. I’ve been instructed to use water exclusively. I’ve never had difficulty removing any tubing tubing mascara- and I’m now concerned about the cleansing balm recommendation as I’ve told others who complain about eye irritation from cleansing balms to use tubing mascara, and eliminate the eye makeup remover/balm irritation
It’s nothing to be concerned about. I just use cleansing balms exclusively and they take off tubing and non-tubing mascaras alike. Tubing mascara doesn’t require it, it’s just what I use, especially if the mascara is tricky to get off
Amazing work! Thank you!
🥹🤗💕
Can u do a all day wear test in these? I know it’s a lot, but perhaps one eye each and quick recap at the end? Unfortunately there are tunings that smear
For 22 mascaras, I’m afraid that would take over my whole life, so no. Also, what smears/flakes on me may not on you, and Vice versa. I can try to answer questions about individual mascaras though
This is a great comprehensive, tubing mascara breakdown. It's so interesting how people have such different preferences for mascara. For me I loves the em cosmetics mascara and hated the Totally Tubular one. I have a feeling I would also not like the Thrive one based on the heaviness of the formula. I will have to try the waterproof snapscara one, since I did not like the other one. Apparently before it was discontinued, L'Oreal Age Perfect's waterproof formula was also tubing, even though it wasn't advertised that way.
Thanks! I think you can still find the L’Oreal one in some stores and online 🤗
Excellent video!!!
Thank you Dana! This is such a nice video!! Appreciate the time stamps and your efforts.
@Dana Ripperton the only one I didn't see on this list that other make up lovers recommended to me was the LA Girl Volumatic, about $5 at target. Molded plastic brush that has flexibility. Very voluminous outcome... false lash look. On the first try worked great, but I went back to finish my trusty Boots Stay perfect. When I went back to Volumatic, still looked great, but had some trouble removing it... almost like removing a regular waterproof mascara. It has been a perplexing one and I wanted to make sure it wasn't just me?
Again, FANTASTIC video. I really enjoy hearing your thoughts about skin tints and tubing mascaras! Ty!
Thanks for much for watching! I love finding others who love skin tints and tubing mascaras! 🤗I have tried the volumatic and probz should have added it but decluttered it a while back. That said, I already have a few more I’m testing out and it’s back in the mix!
Thank you so much for this! Super helpfull.
Thank you so much! Very helpful.
❤️❤️❤️
Good job Dana! 🤩 Thanks for sharing ❤️
Thanks so much for watching 🤗
Thanks for your thorough research on all things tubing mascara! Could you please review the “Wow Combo My Amazing Lashes”?
I’ll look into it! Thanks for watching 🥰🤗
Which is you all time fave ?
Such a hard question to answer. Any in the top category but I honestly use them all for different purposes
fantastic video, thanks so much!
Thanks for watching! ❤️🤗
Thank you for doing this video
Excellent vid thank you - just subscribed England x
Welcome 🤗🩷
love your videos😍
Thank you! 🥰😘❤️
Bravo!!!!
Have a nice weekend.
Hej från Sweden
😘❤️❤️
Tarte: Tartelette is 🥇
😬😬
I found the loreal mascara horrible and will never purchase it again. It flakes toward the end of the day, is way too light, and runs out quickly. For just under $15 it's not worth the price in my mind.
Terrible
Cool story, bro