Tchaikovsky piano trio in a minor op.50
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ต.ค. 2014
- Zlata Chochieva (piano), Haik Kazazyan (violin), Nikolay Shugaev (cello) perform P. Tchaikovsky trio for piano, violin and cello in a minor, op. 50
zlatachochieva.com
nikolayshugaev.com - เพลง
![[LIVE] BABYMONSTER(베이비몬스터) - SHEESH | 두시탈출 컬투쇼](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6q-_9s6a_1g/mqdefault.jpg)
Intimate. Passionate. Dark. The bleakness of the Fifths at the end is funerial and unsurpassed. One of my favourite pieces. P .I. T. Genius. It never fails to move me and remind me of my father that played this often when I was a child. I know every note.
this violinist way better than Gidon Kremer on this same piece...what a difference..pianist brilliant....again better than many others on youtube on same piece. ..her dynamics are superb...cellist great too...thank you all three!
Yes definitely, Good observation! This is a world-class trio with prize-winning performers!
Haik Kazazyan is a famous Armenian virtuoso. He played the difficult Khachaturian Violin Concerto beautifully (also posted in TH-cam). I believe he also worked as the first violinist for Korean Symphony Orchestra.
A monumental work of art... for me, the greatest of all piano trios! And this interpretation is trully awesome: full of all kind of sound colors; rich in romantic beauty and elegance; in some sections with a delicate touch of melancolic intimacy and in others, with a powerful breathing of energy and bloody passion! The best performance that I ever heard... unique!
Ethereal.
A shattering performance. I have never heard the coda played like that, with such desolation and grief. Masterful musicians - I love you all. You're each so beautiful - works of art yourselves. Thank you for this brilliant, original and devastating op. 50.
Happy to announce that the VIDEO is again available.
We got a fake complaint from the "copyright" holder. So many scammers are around. Sad.
Peace and love to everyone!
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!
Can you help me with the timing of the variations?
1st Mvt = 0:08;
2nd Mvt = 19:11;
Var. I =
Var. II =
Var. III =
Var. IV =
Var. V =
Var. VI =
Var. VII =
Var. VIII =
Var. IX = 31:22;
Var. X =
Var. XI =
Variazione Finale = 38:22;
Coda =
Love you and love this performance!
I just listened to this again today, Tchaikovsky's 175th birthday, and what an incredible performance; you guys are amazing. There are few great performances of this work, my favorite being Zhukov; however, you are amongst the greats. Much love.
Kenneth Dower Thank you Kenneth!
@kennethdower7425 -- I'll have to find the Zhukov.....I always preferred Richter's. Cheers from Acapulco!
@@steveegallo3384km
che bello risentirlo dopo questi anni - e di esserne più entusiasti che mai!
A stunning performance! To hear it in full, as Tchaikovsky intended, is a wonderful treat. Kudos and loud Bravos! to the performers -- thank you for making this available...
I've listened to all the other big name recordings of this piece and yet this seems to be the best i can find...simply amazing...
An absolutely gorgeous performance. Close your eyes as you listen to this...
An incredibly beautiful performance. Bravo to these talented young players.
Tchaikovsky's Piano Trio is the gold standard of piano trios both melodically and playing virtuosity for all three instruments, IMO. I also notice the phrasing, balance of weight and tempo is very critical for all three performers. I have listened to this trio for 40 years at different times and by different performers and this is one of the best and most lively performances in my memory. Thank you!
Abe Shahrodi thank you very much for your comment. We’re really happy that you liked it.
@@NickShugaev I am grateful to all classical music virtuoso's who bring joy and peace to this world. For years, I could only listen to Paul Ostrovsky's recording with Moscow Conservatory Trio but now you have provided an alternate recording to enjoy this masterpiece.
Wow, one of the greatest recordings ever of this difficult work. Tears streaming down my face at the end.
Beautifully expressive, sensitive performance from artists who have clearly mastered the music. Thank you very much for this communicative performance.
A wonderful and moving performance. Zlata, Haik and Nikolay, thank you so much.
J'ai eu le bonheur de redécouvrir cette musique dans le cadre du Festival International du Domaine Forget de Charlevoix, Québec, Canada
A piece of music as beautiful and profound, powerful and vivacious as anything ever written, and played in the very same vein: a glorious performance of exquisite execution
Beautiful, expressive performance.
Certainly a trio to keep an eye on in the future. And the engineers did a fantastic job in the sound recording.
Up there with the very best versions! I dont normally like singling out any particular player in chamber music, however I feel compelled to mention Zlata Chochieva. This young woman is so brilliantly endowed both artistically and technically, her playing speaks to me in a way that few other pianists of her generation manage to achieve.
so agree re pianist...
What a wonderful performance of this great work!
Beautiful....nice timing....not delayed type like most trios....
A wonderful achievement- many thanks for this beautiful & inspiring performance.
I am covered with shame, for I had never before heard this work. It is an astonishing, sublime achievement - sublime in its ultimate sense of beauty that overwhelms and fills you with awe... Tchaikovsky is often relegated to the second rank of composers, but this piece demonstrates his complete mastery of "western" compositional technique (a Tchaikovsky fugue? Done! at approx. 29:00) and his fusion of this technique with his inimitable personal voice - soul, I should say - unmistakably Russian.
This trio is absolutely superb - technically and musically impeccable; so much so that their playing becomes transparent - I mean that, rather than gasping at their technique and ensemble, you just marvel at the music.
When I hear young people perform the classical canon I am incredibly moved, because I fear this great body of work is gradually being forgotten. Spiegel Trio - your playing gives me hope. Without music, humanity won't survive. It's that important. Brava / Bravi !
Thank you so much for your kind words David!
Best wishes to you!
No offense, my friend, but I don't know of *anyone* who seriously would think of relegating Tchaikovsky to "the second rank" of composers. No less a luminary than Tom Service places both Tchaikovsky's First and Sixth Symphonies among the rank of the top 50 Symphonies ever written. His ballets not only changed ballet music, they transmogrified it. This piece is an example of what he was capable of achieving in chamber music...and I won't even mention that the Andante cantabile of Tchaikovsky's First String Quartet moved Tolstoy to tears. I could go on, but I think you should reconsider Tchaikovsky, and place him where he truly belongs -- among the greatest of composers who ever lived...
+Tchaikovskiana If you took my remark as meaning that "*I*" felt that he was second rank, you misread it. I don't think that at all. I adore Tchaikovsky! I said, "Tchaikovsky is often relegated [by others] to the second rank of composers, but this piece demonstrates his complete mastery of "western" compositional technique".
But some do relegate him to the second rank. Tant pis! Most of my favorite composers would probably fall into that category (Francis Poulenc, anyone?). I was saying that relegating him to the second rank was snobbish and absurd, (and I"m not totally convinced that the denigration of his works doesn't have something to do with his homosexuality).
Inasmuch as comparisons are valuable at all, and it's moot, Tchaik is of the first rank, a genius, but not a game-changer in the sense that Beethoven was, for example. But it's apples and oranges isn't it? Who cares? Every time I hear one of the ballet scores, or the 4th, 5th, or 6th symphonies or.... I'm blown away. Art isn't a boxing match. There is good music, and there is everything else.
I suppose *my* point was, if you don't believe that, then why repeat it? The snobbish love to hear their misguided opinions echoed, even if they're not true.
In any case, Tchaikovsky was indeed a game-changer and not just in the way he transmogrified the world of ballet music, changing it forever, but in his symphonic works as well.
Tom Service at The Guardian, in his series "50 Greatest Symphonies" ranked Tchaikovsky's First Symphony and well as his Sixth Symphony as being among those 50 greatest symphonies. About "Winter Daydreams, he said, "His First Symphony is one of the most important markers in the symphonic story in the 19th century, the piece in which a *new type of symphony - absolutely Tchaikovsky's own*, and Russia's too - is not just glimpsed, but claimed, staking out the territory his next five symphonies continued to explore."
About the Pathétique in that same series, Service said, "In the Sixth, [Tchaikovsky] *creates a new shape for the symphony*, in one of the most audacious and boldest compositional moves of the 19th century. That slow, lamenting finale turns the entire symphonic paradigm on its head, and changes at a stroke the possibility of what a symphony could be..."
Forgive me if I sound scolding, but having studied Tchaikovsky's life and music for many, many years, I find myself becoming weary at hearing or reading of his genius being belittled or dismissed. He simply deserves so much more...
It's great to hear such enthusiasm for Tchaikovsky. I've heard all of Tchaikovsky's music that it's possible to hear including the obscure operas. His music is much greater than commonly acknowledged. David Brown , the Tchaikovsky "scholar" did the composer a great disservice and completely fails to see the greatness in many works, including this trio. I too get tired of the same old clichés about Tchaikovsky, prejudice and snobbery are still rife in musicology. The worst thing of all for me is the way the Manfred Symphony is routinely mutilated and cut, the greatest of all programme symphonies. David Brown's limited understanding has effectively endorsed such travesties.
Love it! Great work lady and gentlemen.
Magnificent performance. Kudos.
Amazing performance - the most representative video for this piece :)
Beautiful performance of a musical gem.
Sublime music, performance to treasure.
Beautiful. Wonderful shaping of the veeery many contours of this amazing epic work. Unselfish service to higher art. Bravo!!!!!
The “Saga of the Rus People” in sound?
Balance- A+; Interpretation- A+; Musicianship - A+; Recording - A+; Camerawork - C-. C'mon guys, it is a PIANO trio! Set up your camera so we can see Zlata's beautiful technique! No point in close ups of Haik's handsome face while she is carrying the melody... Still, only a quibble in light of this GORGEOUS gift. Thank you X infinity!!!
+Peter Pfister I totally agree! as you see from my comment a couple of months ago, I feel this is one of the very best versions. There is a wonderful dialogue achieved between the players, and Zlata is simply a fantastic pianist. Like you I feel the camera could have focused her somewhat more given the involved and challenging writing of the piano part. Now I'm cherry picking!.
Although at 4:31 the camera was still on the pianist when I particularly wanted to see the violinist...judging by his ravishing melody I'm sure his body language was most eloquent...but thankfully this was remedied in the corresponding moment in the recap ;) :)
Amazing playing... the dialogue between the cello and violin is so well played... the piano brings another high quality touch!!! Bravo!!
Warmest regards to you all!!
I wonder if you would ever consider doing tchaikovsky/ goedicke version of the seasons for a piano trio? Imho, the trio version brings out the colours of each month perhaps better than the piano...
Great!
Beautiful......BRAVI from Acapulco!
Wow!
Ephraim Raphael van IJzerlooij thank you very much!
hermosa musica gracias nikolay
@DanielRivera-ps8ry -- BRAVI TUTTI desde Acapulco!
Very nice. Thank you!
I only own one recording of this Trio on CD. It's the Roge, Lodeon, Amoyal recording on Apex. Nothing wrong with it...it's nice...but I still end up coming back to this TH-cam video for a greater experience. I absolutely love this performance.
Great, just great.
Супер!
never knew Tchaikovsky wrote chamber music - a great discovery - the quality of the work and performance speak for themselves...
Great performance !
Magnífica interpretación. Conozco todas las grabaciones existentes de esta obra y ésta interpretación, junto con la de Rosamunde (2005), son las mejores que he escuchado. La interpretación de ustedes es superior a la mítica Gilels, Kogan, Rostropovich (1952). Felicidades y un saludo desde México.
Gerardo Tavera Gracias Gerardo! Thank you for your kind words. Greetings from Switzerland!
@@NickShugaev -- ......and from Acapulco!
I like it so much.bravo.😊
magnifique
Très belle performance
!! MUY BELLO !!!
Wondeful! Please, when and where was the peformance?
good trio
Which variation starts at 31:30? Is this IX andante felible ma non tanto?
Tchaikovskiana, yes there is value in David Brown's work. I like the biography part of The Man and his Music. It demonstrates what a good person Tchaikovsky was, how kind and empathetic and its scuppers the old myth of Tchaikovsky the wild Cossack full of self pity and no discipline; there never was a more exacting craftsman constantly sculpting ideas into perfect shapes. Yet I wonder how he could miss the qualities of such great works as Iolanta, which he calls "insipid", a opera just as great and original as the 6th symphony is in its field.
Tchaikovsky was enormously intelligent, but a shy man; a kind man; warm, and generous to a fault -- and beyond disciplined. In addition to his music, he wrote thousands of letters and read widely, from novels to philosophy, in many different languages, I might add. As for Iolanta, indeed Brown missed the boat on that, as Roland John Wiley has pointed out, that opera (his last) showed Tchaikovsky heading in some new musical directions which were never to be realized due to his untimely death. The world lost him much too early.
Argerich;Kremer and Maisky =the top!
Can anyone help me with the tming of the vriations?
1st Mvt = 0:08;
2nd Mvt = 19:11;
Var. I =
Var. II =
Var. III =
Var. IV =
Var. V =
Var. VI =
Var. VII =
Var. VIII =
Var. IX = 31:22;
Var. X =
Var. XI =
Variazione Finale e Coda = 38:22;
I'm searching for them as well :/
Ok so I found an album on spotify "Tchaikovsky/Rachmaninov: Piano Trios"
And the second movement is fragmented for each variations, so there's all timecodes.
1. - 0:08
2. - 19:12 - Tema con variazione
Var. I. - 20:17 -
Var. II. - 21:15 - Più mosso
Var. III. - 21:53 - Allegro moderato
Var. IV. - 22:52 - L'istesso tempo
Var. V. - 24:03 - L'istesso tempo
Var. VI. - 24:34 - Tempo di valse
Var. VII. - 27:21 - Allegro Moderato
Var. VIII. - 28:39 - Fuga. Allegro moderato
Var. IX. - 31:23 - Andante fieble, ma non tanto
Var. X. - 34:26 - Tempo di Mazurka
Var. XI. - 36:09 - Moderato
3. 24:23
Last thing, I found the tempo very slow :/
Can I buy a CD or DVD of this performance?
not even close to the level of the richter or rostropovich , doesn't give the feeling
Amazing performance - the most representative video for this piece :)