**NEWS FLASH** This is one of the most difficult pieces in all of chamber music. Truly, Tchaikovsky wrote a "Symphony for 3 Instruments"!! (And, Zhao's playing is worth the entire trip!)
This team climb this mountain of a piece making music all the way. They are terrific with Argerich on great form and the strings a revelation. Dora Schwarzberg nearly steals the show, wonderful.
This is a great combination of course, how could it not be with Argerich involved!. I have to say though I prefer the Spiegel Trio with the outstanding Zlata Chochieva, those players give a beautifully integrated account of this challenging masterpiece.
Coincido con el comentario de M. Foster y hago notar que el desempeño de Schuartzberg es impresionante por su apasionada habilidad como artista que comparte con la notable solvencia de M. Argerich para articular el fraseo de los otros integrantes sin imponerse por encima de ellas. Es una pieza de difícil ejecución que tal vez necesitaría una batuta experta para desarrollarla sin perder intensidad... aunque es mi opinión de aficionado ya un poco sordo por mi avanzada edad. Agradezco escuchar esta versión de nuevo en video de muy buena calidad.
What an outstanding performance. I am listening on Plantronics headphones and the balance is superb at all times. The sensitivity to Tchaikovsky's style is remarkable. It is rivaled only by Van Cliburn and Kiril Kondrashin. Shame on all detractors.
I always have a broken record experience with the 1st couple of minutes of the 1st movement DIVINE... The Golub Kaplan Carr recording is also well worth the listening
Комментарий аматора. Несомненно скрипачка здесь центральная фигура. Она здесь хозяйничает. Как бы жарит котлеты но со смаком. Успевает стряхнуть пыль со скрипки и улыбнутся товарке. Поначалу относишся к ней недоверчиво, но она демонстрирует такой вулкан эмоций, удивлдению и восхищению нет предела
Просто Дора Шварцберг здесь единственная дама с предками российского происхождения, видно, что ей очень близка эта музыка и она ей безмерно наслаждается. Дора Шварцберг - профессор Венской Консерватории (а это немало!), а не просто скрипачка😊
Beautifully performed, but it's just a pity that a huge omission (vi-de - more than 100 bars) was made in the finale: the whole development section of this extended sonata allegro. However, this vi-de was allowed by the author.
Don't feed the Trollovskis, especially when they are stupid enough to comment about a moment of slightly bad intonation in almost 50 minutes of beautiful music-making.
+Vladimir Trollovski How about at 14:35? That was more noticeable to me. I personally could never get a note that well on a Violin. Probably because I don't play one. The Piano does make a few apparent mistakes, but I'm not familiar with the composer or the song. I guess if we wanted perfection we would have robots playing it for us. There would be no mistakes nor any pulse. It's hard to critisise absolutely, one needs another reference performance.
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D1 | Summer | ถ้าไม่พร้อมลุย ได้ไปคุยกับรากมะม่วง](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XlkKtVvBxac/mqdefault.jpg)
**NEWS FLASH**
This is one of the most difficult pieces in all of chamber music. Truly, Tchaikovsky wrote a "Symphony for 3 Instruments"!! (And, Zhao's playing is worth the entire trip!)
Schwarzberg´s passion, but also her tradition, this wonderful tradition. LOVE
What a performance! I adore Schwarzberg's tone and passion. They are all great!
Schwarzberg is phenomenal ....
One of the great piano trios and there is great balance among the instrumentalists here.
You think so? I think Schwarzberg plays herself in the 1st position...
I was only going to click this video to sample the performance and now I'm having trouble stopping the video. This work is just so powerful.
L'interprétation de Madame Argerich est parfaite, -- comme toujours depuis si longtemps...
This team climb this mountain of a piece making music all the way. They are terrific with Argerich on great form and the strings a revelation. Dora Schwarzberg nearly steals the show, wonderful.
Semplicemente sublimi!
Dear, dear Dora... Wooow ❤🎻🎶
They hold unchallenged positions as interpreters of Tchaikovsky
Their wonderful performance is unrivaled, indescribable and outclassing
divinely inspired playing.....
36:00 - Zum Weinen schön! Beautiful to cry
LO MEJOR DE ESTE GENIO COMPOSITOR,EXCELENTE INTREPETACION YMAGISTRAL SONIDO,LA MUSICA ME LLEVA A LA NOSTALGIA Y POESIA.
Ik voel me door deze prachtige uitvoering van de muziek van Tjaikovsky totaal gelukkig!! Dank daarvoor!
BRAVO !!!!!
Beautiful!
A very fine and sensitive performance by Miss Zhao. Thank you for posting.
This is a great combination of course, how could it not be with Argerich involved!. I have to say though I prefer the Spiegel Trio with the outstanding Zlata Chochieva, those players give a beautifully integrated account of this challenging masterpiece.
Maravilhoso ❤️
Eu estava lá !
The best ever.
Wunderbar!
Спасибо!
Que preciosidad !
Una obra maestra y grandes intérpretes
Truly first class performance of an astonishing work. Thank you!
+Francisco Sunderland HI, you´re not the only one. Yesterday I was hearing this work with my portable player and just think the same.
+JDPBILI at 11.20 too.... :-)
Coincido con el comentario de M. Foster y hago notar que el desempeño de Schuartzberg es impresionante por su apasionada habilidad como artista que comparte con la notable solvencia de M. Argerich para articular el fraseo de los otros integrantes sin imponerse por encima de ellas. Es una pieza de difícil ejecución que tal vez necesitaría una batuta experta para desarrollarla sin perder intensidad... aunque es mi opinión de aficionado ya un poco sordo por mi avanzada edad. Agradezco escuchar esta versión de nuevo en video de muy buena calidad.
What an outstanding performance. I am listening on Plantronics headphones and the balance is superb at all times. The sensitivity to Tchaikovsky's style is remarkable. It is rivaled only by Van Cliburn and Kiril Kondrashin. Shame on all detractors.
Muito bom mesmo !
einfach "nur" schön! erinnert stark an das violinkonzert.
Nur besser:)!
언제나 들어도 늘 감동.
seungjin yang jb
I don't know why but this music makes me remember the movie "the labyrinth of the faust", of Guilherme Del Toro... I can't be the only one, for sure
S eu estivesse lá, nem conseguiria bater palma, com o estado que fiquei aqui.
I always have a broken record experience with the 1st couple of minutes of the 1st movement DIVINE... The Golub Kaplan Carr recording is also well worth the listening
Dora schawaaarzberg, che brava.....
이 환상의 하모니 숭고함 마져.
아르헤리치!!!!
小提琴真的拉出了悲淒如訴的感覺
Am i the only who hears resemblance with Schindler's list at 2:10..?
Tchaikovsky like as Brahms in th pieces!
Комментарий аматора. Несомненно скрипачка здесь центральная фигура. Она здесь хозяйничает. Как бы жарит котлеты но со смаком. Успевает стряхнуть пыль со скрипки и улыбнутся товарке. Поначалу относишся к ней недоверчиво, но она демонстрирует такой вулкан эмоций, удивлдению и восхищению нет предела
Просто Дора Шварцберг здесь единственная дама с предками российского происхождения, видно, что ей очень близка эта музыка и она ей безмерно наслаждается. Дора Шварцберг - профессор Венской Консерватории (а это немало!), а не просто скрипачка😊
This is awsome. However, listen to Argerich-Kremer-Maisky, and..., unless you have ear problems...
Beautifully performed, but it's just a pity that a huge omission (vi-de - more than 100 bars) was made in the finale: the whole development section of this extended sonata allegro. However, this vi-de was allowed by the author.
what is the commenting language? Russian?
Italian
Señora Argerich es fantástica, pero en esta pieza hay momentos en que el piano tapa a los otros dos instrumentos
Oh my god the Schwarzberg is so flat at 4:30! Such dross
Don't feed the Trollovskis, especially when they are stupid enough to comment about a moment of slightly bad intonation in almost 50 minutes of beautiful music-making.
+Vladimir Trollovski She actually isn´t :)
+Vladimir Trollovski How about at 14:35? That was more noticeable to me. I personally could never get a note that well on a Violin. Probably because I don't play one. The Piano does make a few apparent mistakes, but I'm not familiar with the composer or the song. I guess if we wanted perfection we would have robots playing it for us. There would be no mistakes nor any pulse. It's hard to critisise absolutely, one needs another reference performance.
JO B: She is! From 4:25 on she is flat.
I'd rather take the Kardashian sisters, but thank you very much.....
Of course... because you're a fucking ignorant TOOL.