Pew survey on China says global majority skeptical on China, Xi, Indians, Quad more negative
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.ค. 2024
- A Pew Research Center survey of 35 countries reveals that perceptions of China's economic influence vary widely, with people in high-income nations like the U.S., Canada, and Australia showing significant negativity-70% of respondents in 18 such countries express unfavorable views of China. In Episode xxx of #CutTheClutter, Editor-in-chief Shekhar Gupta looks at 2 international takeaways--- from the Pew Research on global opinions on China & how back in France, Macron's gamble dealt a deathblow to the Hard-Right.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
India is not a middle income country. Its a lower middle income country.
Same thought
No middle, just low income country.
U anti.ntional ...go to China now😂
Likely that PEW categorizes countries in their own way.
it is a poor country.
I wonder how India qualifies as a middle income country when its per capita GDP puts it around 120th in the world?
You wonder how they clarify they are a middle income country?
Boasting, bragging and self praising.
PPP
@@aimmethod ok
The GDP per capita of India based on purchasing power parity (PPP) was $7,112 in 2022. This places India 122nd in the world in terms of GDP per capita PPP.
I know two wrongs don't make a right, but chances are PEW's samle from India, might actually be from the middle income group.
@9:56 You can start with the usual suspects, RaGa, Chidambaram, Jairam, SoGa etc. Keep counting till you get 19%.
No these are gujraties who r doing business with china ,and also your bosses IT cell
@@neerajsinghbhar966 don't remind these guys who cast the facades for the Statue of Unity 🤡
Many people would have considered the fact that Xi's actions have benefited India because EU and USA are more friendly towards India to counter China
About a month ago, the Business Standard and Economic Times reported stating that "Govt to allow JVs with Chinese firms if Indian partner holds majority stake".
😂😂😂
19% are the Chapri's view o guess
What about pew report on india?
You deliberately dont want to discuss why the report is positive on india
India has a pretty favourable reputation abroad but when you land in India there is poor infrastructure, uncleanliness and chaos.
China does not have favourable reputation abroad but when you land in China there is awesome infrastructure, modern tech and everything runs so smoothly.
Sweety, the problem is china trying to land in other country's land. Think about it honey.
Yes China is famous for its Tofu Dreg. 😂
Additionally, Chinese people who eat worms and gutter rats should not be lecturing others on cleanliness.
Maybe that is because India does not want to take away anybody's land, while China wants a piece of everybody's land Plus almost all of everybody sea! So people know that the Indians are good and ethical, while China is parasitic! Therefore most people (unlike you) are willing to overlook India's various challenges that India is trying to overcome.
10:00 probably rahul gandhi, kanimuli, stalin, manishankars, yogendra yadavs and the communists in entirety.
About a month ago, the Business Standard and Economic Times reported stating that "Govt to allow JVs with Chinese firms if Indian partner holds majority stake".
Not sure how you get link to participate in such surveys. If the agency decides whom to contact. Then these findings are manipulated.
Since I have studied the science behind surveying, a genuine sample size from a unbiased population is necessary for a correct analysis, but researchers usually have inherent bias. But companies like Pew have a reputation to make good unbiased reports
@@vishweshhramesh2163 Indians - both BJP and INDIA supporters have an unambiguous negative view on China. Unless you contact someone who has absolutely no clue about geopolitics, Im surprised why so few Indians view China negatively
China is appreciated by many in India especially for its remarkable economic rise.
Also many who view "Democracy" to be a hurdle for India's development see the Chinese model as something that can be implemented in India@@VishalKhopkar1296
@@VishalKhopkar1296because of China's remarkable economic growth
@@VishalKhopkar1296 Agreed, the only rationale can be for the 19% looking at Xi positively might be those working/benefitting due to Chinese imports
Its no surprise that the percentage of Indians who has confidence in xi ginping is 19%. This is the percentage that's left behind after partition!
absolute 🤡 comment. I wake up everyday and thank God for not making me a brain dead sanghi.
was APJ also a part of that 19%? Azim Premji? You think Muslims will support a regime that commits genocide on Uyghurs?
Nope. It's mostly because of
1. Leftists Communists who view China as the solely successful "Communist" Nation
2. Many who see Democracy as a hindrance to India's development appreciate the Chinese model of development
I think I guess your IQ, it's probably in double digit.
Hr jga musalman dikhte baap ki jagah..
Wow u deserve nobel prize
Don't you know who are those 19%?
Lal Topi as we say it.....
Lol salaam 😂
Pew has interviewed 45k people in 35 countries. The sample size Is very very less for this kind of analysis.
Actually not. I am sure the population is properly weighted in the sample. For a social survey this is a fairly good population…
That don't matter.
You have to look at the randomization of the sample. 45000 is a huge sample size if balanced correctly.
How is 45k out of almost 3 billion global Adult population a good sample size?
Not necessarily
Use indo pacific not Asia pacific
Its very surprising that 20% if Indians are "not concerned" about China's territorial plans, even with the highly publicised border disputes and past history.
I would really like to know who are these Indians interviewed by Pew.
Thankfully Congress is SG's favorite party or he would have drawn parallels between that parties vote share exactly matching the China-philes in India ;)
There is no concern about China's territorial plans. They have no history of colonialism.
The same who said not to donate blood to the Indian army in 62.
The same peoples leader went to China 7 times.
Nehru was selected to become PM to give Tibet to China and even won the 1957 election and 1962 also. In general, Indians are not concerned. 30% of Indians do not even get one proper meal a day and you think that they should be worried about these things. You should be worried about how you can help those poor people with a good nutritious meal with meat.
maybe they are more concerned about unemployment, paper leaks, corruption, traffic etc
That 19% is from kerala for sure 😂
Also many view China's remarkable economic growth as something which can be done in India
kerala's poulation is less than 3% of country. Atleast get ur facts right.
@@sreedharreddyabbidi5374 don't worry.... He is a product of Andhbhakt ideology
@@afrazamjad1644paki apni asli id se aa.
Cries in high hdi 😢
2:33 Appreciated Shekhar sir
sir 19 percent indians are favourable of Xi but coincidentally Congress Vote percent is also around that percentage (+- 2%)
And favourable of pakistan is close to bjps vote share 🤔 maybe it's because of nawaz Sharif's biryani
@@TeeeheeeteeheeeWe know for a fact Bjp voters are pakistan haters. But congress is literally in alliance with the communists the ideological twin of CCP in India😂
Those 19% were foreigners using VPN
French results show the same thing which happened in India election. All parties coming together to defeat a potential game changing party
That’s quite early today Shekhar - thanks for sharing your insights, always a delight that adds to one’s knowledge and understanding of all the complex developments around us.
Thank you for appreciating and supporting our journalism, Himar. Do keep watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
It doesn’t matter. That’s how Pew classified India. What’s important are the results of the survey.
So much confidence in a US company's survey data. Shame.
Why? What is the problem? Please provide then India companies survey data. You have a typical Brahmavadi attitude.
@@vinsin328 Seems like ricebag still hasn't emptied yet. Btw, the likes of the missionaries that teach you this stuff spit on you at their home place because of your skin colour. Study african conversion.
i'm glad someone made a 25 min video explaining graphs from one pew opinion study
About a month ago, the Business Standard and Economic Times reported stating that "Govt to allow JVs with Chinese firms if Indian partner holds majority stake". How many Indians know about it?
but does it effect china ,i dont think china is going to amend , then whats the point of this research , i dont understand why some media and political parties give priroty to these surveys
It is imp from a vote bank perspective and winning an election.
You can use Duplex option to print both sides.
Shekhar, you can pring 2 pages per sheet and print both sides to better utilize paper
You can call few "journalists" in The Print. and a few in The Wire, and a few from Scroll and others from JNU and publish a survey. Noice.
Just check. 434 people liked this video those are same ppl interviewd by pew
The views in Hungary indicate Orban's own unpopularity.
In india they might have asked this question to traitor lefyists .
Thank you for correcting the map of India
It is not a rocket science to guess who 19% are
Complex game INDIE alliance played in Loksabha elections. Despite that and Anti incumbency NDA won for the third time.
Very interesting... Thanks
Thank you, my friend. I'm glad you enjoyed the episode. Do keep watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
What are sri Lanka and bangladesh concerns about China's territorial disputes, they don't even border china.
Concern doesn't mean engagement.. As per the graphs, SL, Ban, THA, SG favors china..
Bangladesh has a water dispute with China. China claims SL also as part of China.
That 19% is from kerala😂😂😂
And Tamil nadu
Sekhar sir own pew survey approval given by grand old party
Pew has Few takers
❤Displayed the correct map of India. loved the presence of mind kudos to team print..
How do you know it is correct? Tibet is not shown as part of India.
Excellent, enjoyable episode!
I'm glad you found the episode insightful. Thank you, my friend...best wishes, Shekhar
@@ThePrintIndia Thank you!
We wanted CTC on French and English elections.....and the impact on EU and global politics.....please come with an separate video
Thats a mont blanc pen isnt it?
Smart move Shekhar ji 😂😂😂😂
You don't understand the difference between a part of country and a whole country. 😂😂😂
People who are crying here about why India is being said a “Middle Income Group” don’t know that Pew considered GDP (PPP) as its the true indicator of the economy. I cant survive on 100$/month in US where in India, I can easily do that.
Ok, Shekhar couldn't understand the high rate unfavorable rating from Singapore about China's territorial disputes. Singapore is a tiny country with high Chinese ethnic people, yet they are Singaporeans not Chinese. Singapore in the past has made China clear that it's not an extension of China, and the large country should not take the ethnic dominance of Singapore as "China". Singapore's nationalistic Identity is the reason for that high rating.
Russian is Fading & Today's Left Hand of China 🇨🇳 and Modi Visit is a Counrticy Visit
The world bank says Russia has moved from "middle income" to "high income" country. Russia is the strongest economy in Europe currently inspite of all the heavy sanctions. Russia's GDP growth has been higher as well. Militarily, Russia is stronger than ever and out producing the west in ammunition. Back your statements with facts, else it is like Feku's speeches.
You can't go without gesture
19% indians having confidence are: 25% muslims and around 4% congressi or leftists from WB & Kerla
No use wasting time on such surveys. India is a poor country that doesn't put enough emphasis on education. The effects are unavoidable no matter how much one cries.
India is going to make great gains over the next century, their population demographics are far healthier than China. This is why such surveys matter.
@@12time12 population demographics are currently favourable for India yet it's losing people by the millions every year to immigration. China is becoming a high income country from a middle income country.
It is not only about education, it has also to do with Food.
@@vinsin328 Cant study if you're starving.
The graph at 9:00 clearly shows East vs West and India is with West.. Even South America is with east but not India..
This survey, conducted over five months, includes responses from 44,166 individuals across 35 countries, averaging 1,262 participants per country. Given the varying populations and landmasses of these countries, it is important to note the diversity in the sample. On average, 252 people were surveyed each month. These characteristics should be taken into account when interpreting the data.
Hi Shekhar, I can not say this applies to Xi Jinping, but it applies to China and it is very easy to explain why China's opinion is favorable with younger and liberal generation in the West. There are a lot more Chinese workers and business leaders in the big cities, and especially Bay Area. When you have lunch and socializing with Chinese on a daily basis, it is very hard to have a different perspective on the country China. In contrast, the older and middle America does not meet that many Chinese so that have a different perspective. Over time as Chinese, and South Asians, and others move to the interiors, of course perception can change for middle America too, but it is also possible it gets into negativity since you can easy rabble rouse scared majority that they at the brink of extinction. You know how it works. Anyways, hopefully it clarifies or at least provides one perspective on how the numbers can vary widely within the same country.
These "19%" is Congress voter which is around the same percentage.
6:22 it's Indo-Pacific not Asia Pecific
In eyes of media and intelligentsia,
The Left doesn't matter how violent ad radical they are , called Left. While Right is always branded as far-Right and Fascist irrespective of their way of working.
Aaj kya ho Gaya? Itni jaldi??!!😂
In India low negative rating may be due to the way they asked questions.
If anyone asks indians, are you concerned about China, they will say NO to show that tgey are daring.
Thats why may be this rating.
If you ask someone in india do you hate China, they will say a big YES.
We all know who those 19 percent are 😂
fake nationalists? businessmen of religion? hmmm 🤔
Cap wearers?
Of course the pedophile follower
Sanghis
Pedo follower of course 😅
india should be 100 % concerned
Scepticism against Xi is good but still India needs to balance its relationship with china as well. Especially economic relationship. We need diversified investment from everywhere. America is increasing its pressure on India day by day using different tactics and west will stick together with USA stance apart from France maybe. Pakistan will act as a puppet to US through its military. Hopefully we are able to somehow restore ties with China, over dependence on US will have its own problems.
*Scepticism against Xi is good but still India needs to balance its relationship with china as well*
Not until the Chinese retreat from the borders. Else it will legitimize their position.
Well said.
Chinese bots
@@Jun_kid Which border?
@@vinsin328 You won't get it . . . let it go bro, it's above your geography knowledge.
I must give credit to SG for simplying for us why Macron called a surprise parliamentary ellection. The way SG presented it was much better than than how many of the bigger News channels like the Economist or the Bloomberg presented iit.
I wonder if the French hard right voter will not feel cheated upon by this move and work hard in the next parliamentary and presedential elections to ensure that all right wing voters band up so as to ensure a victory for the right.
I think this year pew done there survey from Kerala and TN people set😂
I am in the 19% sir.
SG, what is the conversion rate of Yuan?
1 reminbi ie Yuan = 11.50 INR 😂
@@SlimJim3082 And yet, China is in doldrums? 🤣
@@Crowka274 howTF would I know? I'm not from China 🤣🤣🤣🤣🫵🏼🫵🏼🫵🏼🫵🏼
Of course, you aren't, I thought you are an economist. 😉🤙
@@Crowka274China has been collapsing for the past 30 years, if you listen to international news 😂
These international surveys are questionable. All it takes one bad actor to manipulate the outcomes for whatever reason.
As par Indian Xi is not issue😅..server may be taken by chinise on Indian behalf 😅😅
Rahulji can only help China with Dhruvji media channels to revive their brand
But import from China under your papa modi grows many fold ,also your papa hand over land to china ,,jhula bhi jhula tha
Do we really need China?
@@neerajsinghbhar966aksai chin just saying 😂😂😂😂 uneducated spokesperson .
About a month ago, the Business Standard and Economic Times reported stating that "Govt to allow JVs with Chinese firms if Indian partner holds majority stake".
can you pls talkabout Modi NATO visit , how was it taken ,how did world take russia visit.
Want to meet these people in India who thinks China is good for us...
LOL, Pew survey. Now we know how valid it's results are. If you tell us that the survey doing agency is US and EU based we all know what their findings will be.
It's the best global survey company, do you have any alternative? No ofc
Bus bakwas Pele jao. Survey ma s bhi nahi Pata, but criticism Pele jao
Do you have alternative survey data? Typical Brahmavadi attitude.
SEKHAR SIR , ALWAYS REMEMBER BEING OLD BEING SEXY;MORE YOU WILL BE OLD MORE YOU WILL LOOK SEXY.
You are not being objective: only the high income countries (the West) are negative about China. The middle and low income countries are positive mostly about China.
Whst about similar study on india and Modi?
09:00- The -/+ve rating of Jin Ping/CCP is based on each (adversary) nation's threat perception. The majority of Indians are not worried- out of confidence in their own Armed Forces.
~20% nay- sayers (and assorted blacklegs & useful idiots) are par for any democracy. The Modi govt. is unabashedly nationalist and has done a far better job in modernising the entire defense sector than was achieved in the previous 40 years. Give credit where it is due🎉. Jai Hind!
Pew pew. HH haaaaa
From the India results, it appears that PEW outsourced the job of conducting this survey, here, to the Congress party & the Left!
Awwww.....reminds me of people who blame pitches, weather conditions et at when the results do go according to plan.
Twice you have posed questions who these 19% people are in India who are positive about Xi pin I and you know it but it will be politically incorrect to name it
Mr. Gupta, it is interesting that the approval rates for China and Congress party in India are almost the same.
The Congress took China Communist Party subscription for Rajiv Gandhi Foundation. Rahul Gandhi meets the Chinese clandestinely during the Galwan skirmishes.
Will you look at these secular and socialists in the eye???
About a month ago, the Business Standard and Economic Times reported stating that "Govt to allow JVs with Chinese firms if Indian partner holds majority stake".
@@manjulashanmugasundaram706 Is that not different from allowing Chinese companies uninterrupted access to India in a manner that destroys Indian companies.
China is not an enemy country. Indian politicians should work for Indian interests and not foreign vested interests
@@NarendraKv Even Chinese electronic goods are suspect. Chinese apps too. Chinese JV is open invitation to Chinese spying
Allowing Chinese JV is open invitation to Chinese spies @@NarendraKv
Why can't they show correct map of India? Can and should they be taken seriously. My foot.
okay, but it is as per the Indian government only. You can always file a case with evidence.
Under BJP Constitution is safe and India is Democratic.
Wow
Left winning in France is not a important story for Shekhar (pro-right pro capitalist)😂..
actually Shekhar will happily ignore anything which he detests
Really? The Left won? What was the vote share of the 3 parties. Ah, the useful idiot of the Left. I wish they would all just go to Venezuela. The staggering success of socialism
First?
Whatever may be , atlast people want money and something to eat
I wonder if this report is reflective of bad state of reporting and journalism in india. Average indian does not have access to reliable news or information. Very reflective of govts education policies, govts priorities and journalistz and their freedom state in india.
Kabhi khud bhee karlo research indians , confidence nahin hai..kab tak angrezo par bharosa ..aak thoo journalism
No space for har har modi in this episode
Kam se kam koi desh hai is duniya me jo Jihad free hai.
Koi desh aisa hai jo demographics changes se free hai. Please don't confuse with demographics changes and demographic decline.
Mujhe isliye China se koi khash problem nahi hai. Koi to Khushi se ji raha hai.😊
Basically a survey paid by propagandist to measure how successful the propaganda has been.
Use less analysis.
Hahaha Hahaha
sahib id se aa mulle
If I say who are those 19% percent, Vivad ho jayega. /s
Fake guy agent 007 love u china
To get birdsview and paradoxical, narrative based public view, need to check on investments, import, export, even with all factors reflect public view vs political and investors view as have democracy but we invest in autocratic regimes, look east but work with west, history teaches
This is west sponsored
Aabki Baar 400 paar😂😂😂😂.....Thank whatever we not gone to same extr 8:06 eme like China....And geting same nazi tags..
Biased.Period!
I can do it to get the opposite conclusion easily. It's called anglo saxon propoganda.
India’s Left - Liberal - Pseudo Civil activists Atheoislamists NGOs would have definitely voted for XI and PEW would have skewed the survey which is statistically possible
About a month ago, the Business Standard and Economic Times reported stating that "Govt to allow JVs with Chinese firms if Indian partner holds majority stake".
global south is all positive on China in Pew poll.
Concern about China's territorial dispute is normal. Concern doesn't mean negative. Everyone hope that China won't go the way of US by using sanctions or military actions in their disputes and China hasn't yet