Fantastic work, that's an unusual and yet still faithful way to adapt the essence of the scene, the only thing that could be added I think is maybe more sound effects to the 2nd black page. Maybe the top row would be complete silence as the three men freeze in shock then sounds kick in, heavy breathing sounds, fiddling sounds, clicking sounds, bumping sounds, splashing sounds, even dialog balloons emerging from the darkness as the three men panic an start fiddling with their equipment in the dark, bump into each other and the walls and express their frustration and panic through maybe profanity or jumbled dialog.
As an aspiring comic book artist! You don’t have an idea of how this channel is helping me!! I resonated so much with your story! I started to draw only 2 years ago (22 yo) and I thought I was too late to the party seeing that all the people have been drawing their entire life!! Keep going!! I love this channel so much!! Saludos desde México :)
Question: Do you think these choices should be made by the writer in the comic script or should the writer leave the artist with these choices to make?
It really depends. Some writers are very visual and will include effects like that. Others aren't as much and in that case, if your creative partner trusts you, they'll allow you to mess up panel count a little to make your idea work. In the case of the 2 following spreads, if they weren't in the script it would be hard to add them and still meet the 24-page count, though.
Awesome that's really inspiring and genius. I would have added at 8:41 that this second page, should arrive on "odd" page, therefore when reader turn the first page he will be surprised by the unexpected black page. 👍🏽 I would be interested by an adaptation of scenes from "Inception" from Christopher Nolan. Especially one of the last scene, when we see the 3 dreams level with all their part of suspens in a raw. And another one is a scene from the movie "Le collier perdu de la Colombe" from Nacer Khemir when the young calligrapher is picking an eye to his master's daughter (that he secretly love) while he is in the pigeons lofts.
Loved this one!!! Just an IMHO - For lights it could be more horrifiying if every panel there'll be zoom out and : 1) click... leaves 2 lights 2) click.. leaves one light 3)click - only small countours of workers in a complete darkness standing shocked ....
I really appreciate these videos. As a wannabe comic artist they are invaluable in showing the nuances and tips 'n tricks of visual storytelling, and as a movie fan it's fascinating to see how you interpret my favourite films. Great presentation too, thanks so much!
I really love that format of video ! Have you ever thought that some old comic books like Tintin, first X-men stories or some other early comic books would be tell in a totally different way if a same scene was show in a modern comic book style ? In a way, it's a bit the situation which appears when we compare the old Tintin comic book to his animation serie of our childhood, where camera angles are totally different. If you like that idea, i would be super interested to see how a very old comic book script could be interpreted with modern codes. Thank you for your wonderfull work !! :)
very interesting choice for a Scene, the show was definitely great but also hard to watch at times. Loved the video, these 10 min layouts are so impressive Looking forward to more of these The idea of the lack of borders adding to the composition as opposed to substracting it is mindblowing wow your layout had the same tension i felt while watching the show!!
Elsa as usual every week you guys are blowing me away with these amazing videos!!! And I would like to add that this whole layout and everything you did on the page, it was so impressive and amazing!! I hope to see more of these layout videos in the future, maybe even a live one ?Keep it up guys!!!
I LOVE THIS - your explanations help so much and get me thinking in different ways about telling stories (which I love). Thanks so much for tickling the creative parts of my brain. Can't wait to see more of your videos. You're really doing some cool things with this channel.
Je crois que c'est la première fois que je trouve un chaîne traitant aussi bien la question de la BD, de la narration comme art séquentiel, précis et complexe ! Merci beaucoup, c'est passionnant ! Pourquoi pas faire une vidéo traitant de la question des dialogues ? Je pense aux séries de David Simon comme The Wire ou The Deuce qui ont un gros travail d'ambiance, mais aussi énormément de dialogues : comment traiter toutes ses informations toute en gardant une lecture dynamique et ambiante ?
Thank you very much Elsa (and your team), I really enjoy all of your content ! It's always very interesting, I already learned a lot with your previous videos !!! And I really appreciate the efforts and the work you put in your content. It shows ! :)
C'est vraiment précieux, de pouvoir découvrir un processus créatif d'adaptation ainsi. Je me demande s'il serait intéressant de tenter d'adapter une scène qui repose énormément sur le dialogue ? L'intro de The Social Network par Fincher et Sorkin par exemple, comment pourrait-on aborder cela dans le medium?
I think your layout for the first page is excellent! However, I'm not so sure about the 2nd page following being empty (black) panels. If you had an Editor, they might want a different solution. Plus, you are taking up a lot of page space; it's a bit self-indulgent. BTW: Your overall presentation here is very well done, and *_I want your Cintiq!_* ;)
the artistic part is really interesting but the scientific part is not really on point, for exemple the part at 2:15 is reaaaaaally wrong, it's a bad misconception, chernobyl could never have wiped out europe or anything like that, there wasn't enough radioactive "fuel" in the core to do it. powerful and dangerous radioactive elements have a short half-life and most were solid blocks so not really volatile enough to affect far enough countries. the radioactive clouds would have been way worse than they were but not enough to wipe out europe
⚡️ Get my new artbook here! www.bigheadlittlearms.com/shop
I really hope the 10 minute Layouts become a constant on this channel. They are not just fun but I feel I learn the most watching these :)
They are! We plan to do a new one once a month or so.
@@ElsaCharretierChannel That's a great news ! :)
That trick with the flashlights and then the black page with only the click sound, what an awesome sequence.
I loved this video and how you adapted this short scene. After this and your Resevoir Dogs vid, I would love for this to be a regular series.
Fantastic work, that's an unusual and yet still faithful way to adapt the essence of the scene, the only thing that could be added I think is maybe more sound effects to the 2nd black page.
Maybe the top row would be complete silence as the three men freeze in shock then sounds kick in, heavy breathing sounds, fiddling sounds, clicking sounds, bumping sounds, splashing sounds, even dialog balloons emerging from the darkness as the three men panic an start fiddling with their equipment in the dark, bump into each other and the walls and express their frustration and panic through maybe profanity or jumbled dialog.
Imagine a dialogue heavy scene from the first season of True Detective. I would love to see that!
The quality and information in your videos are fantastic! Very engaging. Plus you're an amazing storyteller and artist.
I somehow always forget how good you are and then you blow me away again. Every time. Great video, as always
I think this page will work really well with a webtoon format. The vertical schrolling is great for the suspense and tension
As an aspiring comic book artist! You don’t have an idea of how this channel is helping me!! I resonated so much with your story! I started to draw only 2 years ago (22 yo) and I thought I was too late to the party seeing that all the people have been drawing their entire life!! Keep going!! I love this channel so much!! Saludos desde México :)
The Stalker poster there really made me want a Tarkovsky episode of this 💚
Man, now I'd just pay the lord's Ransom for you to adapt Chernobyl in its entirety!
This is an incredible idea for an exercise!! What a creative challenge!
Question: Do you think these choices should be made by the writer in the comic script or should the writer leave the artist with these choices to make?
It really depends. Some writers are very visual and will include effects like that. Others aren't as much and in that case, if your creative partner trusts you, they'll allow you to mess up panel count a little to make your idea work. In the case of the 2 following spreads, if they weren't in the script it would be hard to add them and still meet the 24-page count, though.
Awesome that's really inspiring and genius.
I would have added at 8:41 that this second page, should arrive on "odd" page, therefore when reader turn the first page he will be surprised by the unexpected black page. 👍🏽
I would be interested by an adaptation of scenes from "Inception" from Christopher Nolan. Especially one of the last scene, when we see the 3 dreams level with all their part of suspens in a raw.
And another one is a scene from the movie "Le collier perdu de la Colombe" from Nacer Khemir when the young calligrapher is picking an eye to his master's daughter (that he secretly love) while he is in the pigeons lofts.
Yes, definitely an odd page, thanks for adding that detail.
Loved this one!!! Just an IMHO - For lights it could be more horrifiying if every panel there'll be zoom out and : 1) click... leaves 2 lights 2) click.. leaves one light 3)click - only small countours of workers in a complete darkness standing shocked ....
I really appreciate these videos. As a wannabe comic artist they are invaluable in showing the nuances and tips 'n tricks of visual storytelling, and as a movie fan it's fascinating to see how you interpret my favourite films. Great presentation too, thanks so much!
Not only is the way you handle the subject matter great,your editing of the video itself n projection of you page made it better
That's a really cool masterclass
I really love that format of video !
Have you ever thought that some old comic books like Tintin, first X-men stories or some other early comic books would be tell in a totally different way if a same scene was show in a modern comic book style ?
In a way, it's a bit the situation which appears when we compare the old Tintin comic book to his animation serie of our childhood, where camera angles are totally different.
If you like that idea, i would be super interested to see how a very old comic book script could be interpreted with modern codes. Thank you for your wonderfull work !! :)
Great solution, very informative presentation. (Plus, the projection effect is cool - going to steal that :)
very interesting choice for a Scene, the show was definitely great but also hard to watch at times.
Loved the video, these 10 min layouts are so impressive
Looking forward to more of these
The idea of the lack of borders adding to the composition as opposed to substracting it is mindblowing
wow your layout had the same tension i felt while watching the show!!
love these movie scene to comic panels videos. very cool and highly educational. hope you do these every week.
Elsa as usual every week you guys are blowing me away with these amazing videos!!! And I would like to add that this whole layout and everything you did on the page, it was so impressive and amazing!! I hope to see more of these layout videos in the future, maybe even a live one ?Keep it up guys!!!
Look forward to seeing your channel grow. It will definitely will due to the fantastic content and production quality.
Love it. This channel continues to impress. Keep up the great work.
An interesting take on a complex problem. Thanks for the continued quality content. 🥰
My goodness, this video, your creativity - just genius! Thank you for sharing - the insight here is unbelievable!!
Dude, can you imagine a 10 Minute Panel based on Genndy Tartakovsky's PRIMAL?!
Brilliant as always. Well done Elsa.
Beautiful, thank you for this
Excellent breakdown of your process. Thanks for sharing this!!
Excelente!!!!!!! Gracias!!!!
Great video. that was a lot of fun :)
I LOVE THIS - your explanations help so much and get me thinking in different ways about telling stories (which I love).
Thanks so much for tickling the creative parts of my brain. Can't wait to see more of your videos. You're really doing some cool things with this channel.
Je crois que c'est la première fois que je trouve un chaîne traitant aussi bien la question de la BD, de la narration comme art séquentiel, précis et complexe ! Merci beaucoup, c'est passionnant ! Pourquoi pas faire une vidéo traitant de la question des dialogues ? Je pense aux séries de David Simon comme The Wire ou The Deuce qui ont un gros travail d'ambiance, mais aussi énormément de dialogues : comment traiter toutes ses informations toute en gardant une lecture dynamique et ambiante ?
Spectacular as usual!
This is so good. Would love more of this series of adaptations!
Your thoughtful approach to breaking the scene down was fascinating and extremely helpful! Thank you for creating such lovely and educational videos
Magnifique travaille passionnant a suivre et hyper instructif
Great layouts, great editing, and great information! I love this series
C'est tout simplement brillant. Epoustouflé par le contenu, tout autant que la mise en scène et le rythme de la vidéo.
Bravo !
So good!
You're a genius
Thank you very much Elsa (and your team), I really enjoy all of your content ! It's always very interesting, I already learned a lot with your previous videos !!! And I really appreciate the efforts and the work you put in your content. It shows ! :)
great analysis!
Great Stuff!
AMONG US when the lights turn off
Wow!
You’re a pro
C'est vraiment précieux, de pouvoir découvrir un processus créatif d'adaptation ainsi. Je me demande s'il serait intéressant de tenter d'adapter une scène qui repose énormément sur le dialogue ? L'intro de The Social Network par Fincher et Sorkin par exemple, comment pourrait-on aborder cela dans le medium?
I think your layout for the first page is excellent! However, I'm not so sure about the 2nd page following being empty (black) panels. If you had an Editor, they might want a different solution. Plus, you are taking up a lot of page space; it's a bit self-indulgent. BTW: Your overall presentation here is very well done, and *_I want your Cintiq!_* ;)
wow!!
I'm realing loving your Chanel, chers from brazil.
Очень интересно. Нужно выучить язык, чтобы понимать без субтитров
the artistic part is really interesting but the scientific part is not really on point, for exemple the part at 2:15 is reaaaaaally wrong, it's a bad misconception, chernobyl could never have wiped out europe or anything like that, there wasn't enough radioactive "fuel" in the core to do it. powerful and dangerous radioactive elements have a short half-life and most were solid blocks so not really volatile enough to affect far enough countries. the radioactive clouds would have been way worse than they were but not enough to wipe out europe