Superb analysis of a great comic! The way the 'camera' *doesn't* zoom in until the very end is so clearly and wonderfully linked to the ease of reading this. Excellent video on all levels, including the superb editing - thank you!
I appreciate this channel! I love your breakdown so much. Precise, straight to the point, good camera angles, everything feels so simplified yet so informative. I easily understand your points! Imma watch more of your case studies from now on!
Ik a lot of people dismiss Miller because of his modern works and his controversial works, but his impact on Batman and Daredevil CANNOT be overlooked. Great video and a great channel. Edit: for suggestions I recommend Chip Zdarsky's Peter Parker: the spectacular spider-man #310. That story always makes me cry and it has some very good visual storytelling, I feel that would be a great topic for a video. Also the final pages of Spider-man: Blue.
Excellent points to make! Now I have to re-read the book. But also, that 12th minute was so tense, watching you point at the book with a lidless Sharpie®...
This episode was in my suggestions, and I'm a huge fan of Mazzucchelli's visual storytelling. Your name sounded familiar, and after a quick Google search, I realized that you're the reason "The Infinite Loop" was in my (very tall) pile of TBR Graphic Novels & Collected Comics. So I FastTracked it to tonight's reading, and I have to say, Fantastic character work, and Graphic design. Also, great page breakdown. Subscribed.
I'm not an avid comic book reader, but I've always loved Year One. Your breakdown of just this tiny aspect reveals why I must have responded to it years ago. After seeing Tim Burton's movie, I remember thinking I wish it was more like Year One. Batman Begins was close. But Year One is so down to earth and has the best of what prose and visual storytelling can offer. Great channel!
Did you ever think that when you were madly, desperately teaching yourself to draw comics that you would be teaching us? I love it! More case studies please! One on your own work would be terrific.
Fantastic videos. Referring my students to them! Requests: Jillian Tamaki? Eleanor Davis? Jaime Hernandez? And, if it's not too much to ask, maybe a personal "process" video that shows a collaborative process you've been part of, how you manage the transition from script to breakdowns, etc. (November)?
And this is just one page. This is one of my favorite books of all time not just because it's a good story but also how well it teaches how to make compositions if you pay enough attention.
I'm so glad I subscribed to your substack with TK...this video analysis was awesome. Thank you for sharing the subtleties of the panel with us. Much ❤️ from Toronto!
Merci beaucoup pour ces vidéos je trouve ça super intéressant d'avoir tes analyses parce qu'on apprend toujours quelque choses sur des notions de lisibilité et de rythme ! J'adore 😊
Just found your channel and I’m impressed. Awesome video! Year One is one of my favourites, and your analysis definitely made me appreciate it more. If you’re in the mood to make more late 80s Batman videos, I’d love to see your take on Brian Bolland’s art in The Killing Joke!
Great...i mean....GREAT stuff. I learnt a lot from this and David Aja analysis, i just hope you do more and more! A suggestion for artists to do this breakdowns, Eduardo Risso (100 bullets) and Mike Mignola. I think they are masters of composition but couldn't explain why (not at such a great depth anyways). Thank you!
Absolutely love this, I did similar studies of both comics and novels when I did my degree in 3D animation, it really helped in making me understand why certain Artists/Writers made the decisions that they did. A common thread I found in studying my favourite stories which were also big hits or tended to be quite popular is that they were always focused on how they made a person feel with the story they were telling. I could go on and on about that but I'm gonna hold myself back from writing the LOTR trilogy here and just say you earned yourself a subscriber. :)
This is my second time watching this within 24 hours, I shared your channel with my art buddies I hope it boosts the views, you put a lot of effort in educating and sharing the knowledge of art and story. I've been looking for this type of content for years!
I really wish there was more Mazzucchelli comics out there. I really enjoy this series. Have you seen Matt Fraction's break down of an issue of Daredevil?
Absolutely fascinating. I just subscribed on the strength of your analysis. Your astute breakdown of a single page helps me appreciate the analytical reasoning and strategic placement of managing content within panels. I just started reading Darrow’s Shaolin Cowboy and his line work is incredibly detailed and intentionally gratuitous. However, from what I’ve seen thus far, he counters the graphical overload with pages that, for the most part, aren’t text heavy. Our eyes are meant to start and stop, camping on the minutest of details. Oftentimes, it feels like a treasure hunt. Elsa, (and forgive me if you’ve already addressed this), I’d like your thoughts on this type of storytelling as it appears to be a counterpoint to your analysis here.
It's brilliant how the fight panels are simultaneously Gordon's POV and a neutral POV (because he's far enough away). Never noticed that before, or understood how important it is.
Very good video. Please do more of these studies :) Also I would love to see you analyse Dragon Ball, Akira or Thorgal ( the first 28th volumes are the best, the rest is less good since they changed the writer) Thanks a lot!
Would love to see your take on Watchmen, Pax Americana by Morrison, Sex Criminals, Sandman, Transmetropolitan , Jessica Jones by Bendis, Gideon Falls by Lemire, Mister Miracle by Tom King. All of these have some interesting panel layouts and storytelling cues.
One of my all-time favorites!! I've been dissecting that book so many times I could probably put a video together. I'm a sucker for everything Mazzucchelli puts out. His City of Glass was a huge inspiration for my series November (co-created with Matt Fraction).
Quelle découverte ! Merci beaucoup pour ces explications Elsa, ça me fait aimer encore davantage certains grands dessinateurs! Des suggestions d'oeuvres/artistes à analyser, qui ne font pas du tout dans le minimalisme, mais qui conservent une clarté impressionnante (enfin selon moi): toutes les oeuvres d'Alex Ross, Killing Joke, Black Bolt (par Christian Ward), et toutes les oeuvres de Andrea Sorrentino (notamment ses runs sur Green Arrow et Old Man Logan) Petite question: as-tu prévu d'étudier d'autres formes de bd (bd franco-belge, mangas...)?
This is incredible Elsa!! Your channel will blow up shortly! That's a guarantee. I have a humble request~ Could you do a breakdown of a manga? Their paneling and structure. I've always been curious about the comparison between western comics and eastern comics. You can do a popular manga like Naruto or something more mature like Solanin and Monster.
Would love to see a study of All-Star Comics #65 Page 10 panels 4-5. Wally Wood on pencils and inks...masterful display of momentum, movement and framing/leading the eye. Well, at least I think so :)
Heya I just stumbled upon your channel 2 years too late. Such good content. I have a question, would it have been a good idea to frame the 3 panel violence from Commissioner Gordon’s POV instead of across the street? I ask this because I feel like the intention is that we are supposed to be feeling what Gordon is feeling in this scene.
⚡️ Get my new artbook here! www.bigheadlittlearms.com/shop
This is honestly the best comic instructional series right now
Superb analysis of a great comic! The way the 'camera' *doesn't* zoom in until the very end is so clearly and wonderfully linked to the ease of reading this.
Excellent video on all levels, including the superb editing - thank you!
I appreciate this channel! I love your breakdown so much. Precise, straight to the point, good camera angles, everything feels so simplified yet so informative. I easily understand your points! Imma watch more of your case studies from now on!
It's pretty interesting to see how much thought can go into a single page.
Would love to see you breakdown anything by Mignola, great video as always.
Mignola is definitely on my list! I’ve got a great oversized b&w edition, so his way of spotting blacks could be a nice angle.
TH-cam: Thank you so much for recommending me this high-quality content.
Subscribed!
Je n'ai pas lu/vu de contenu aussi instructif sur la BD depuis l'art invisible. Chapeau.
David Mazzuchelli is the master. great video.
This series is incredibly fascinating. Going to go support the Patreon right now!
Thanks for this wonderful video ♥️
I'm going to say it: YA Boi Zack brought me here. I'm so happy.
Ik a lot of people dismiss Miller because of his modern works and his controversial works, but his impact on Batman and Daredevil CANNOT be overlooked. Great video and a great channel. Edit: for suggestions I recommend Chip Zdarsky's Peter Parker: the spectacular spider-man #310. That story always makes me cry and it has some very good visual storytelling, I feel that would be a great topic for a video. Also the final pages of Spider-man: Blue.
Discovered you from Richard Meyers videos... and I'm very happy he spotlighted you! Great content. I'll be back.
I love your channel.
Please analyze the full double page fight scenes from the newest run of Black Widow.
Your channel has become my new favorite. Enjoying your content a lot. Thank you! 😊
Excellent points to make! Now I have to re-read the book. But also, that 12th minute was so tense, watching you point at the book with a lidless Sharpie®...
My heart dropped at that 12 minute point!
My sharpie so close to the book seems to be a concern to a lot of you guys :) Not to worry, it came out unscathed!
Keep growing this channel please !! It's amazing content
Brilliant Breakdown! I love this! I would love to see you breakdown another great Mazzucchelli work, Asterios Polyp.
This episode was in my suggestions, and I'm a huge fan of Mazzucchelli's visual storytelling.
Your name sounded familiar, and after a quick Google search, I realized that you're the reason "The Infinite Loop" was in my (very tall) pile of TBR Graphic Novels & Collected Comics. So I FastTracked it to tonight's reading, and I have to say, Fantastic character work, and Graphic design.
Also, great page breakdown. Subscribed.
Absolutely pre-ordering that artbook. Fantastic channel.
Frank Quitely and Hugo Pratt, great video!!!
You do an awesome job explaining framing decisions! Thank you for this content!
The breakdown truly does help me appreciate comics even more. Thanks I am glad someone recommended your channel.
So glad I discovered this channel!
I'm not an avid comic book reader, but I've always loved Year One. Your breakdown of just this tiny aspect reveals why I must have responded to it years ago. After seeing Tim Burton's movie, I remember thinking I wish it was more like Year One. Batman Begins was close. But Year One is so down to earth and has the best of what prose and visual storytelling can offer. Great channel!
I’m a sucker for early Burton movies, but I see your point!
@@ElsaCharretierChannel I'm a sucker for early Burton too, like Pee Wee, Beetlejuice and Edward Scissorhands, but I never liked his Batman movies.
I think they made an animated adaptation
Did you ever think that when you were madly, desperately teaching yourself to draw comics that you would be teaching us? I love it! More case studies please! One on your own work would be terrific.
Wow, extremely insightful and well thought out. Thank you for sharing, Elsa!
Here from Hector (@Heroes Reforged). Subscribing cause THIS IS WHAT I WANTED WITHOUT EVER REALISING!!!
The red marker and the blouse make me anxious.
Naturally, I subscribed immediately.
Intelligent, insightful, and a pleasure to listen to. Thanks so much for your videos!
Your analysis is spot on Elsa. You have yourself a new subscriber.
Fantastic videos. Referring my students to them! Requests: Jillian Tamaki? Eleanor Davis? Jaime Hernandez? And, if it's not too much to ask, maybe a personal "process" video that shows a collaborative process you've been part of, how you manage the transition from script to breakdowns, etc. (November)?
And this is just one page. This is one of my favorite books of all time not just because it's a good story but also how well it teaches how to make compositions if you pay enough attention.
I'm so glad I subscribed to your substack with TK...this video analysis was awesome. Thank you for sharing the subtleties of the panel with us. Much ❤️ from Toronto!
I saw you on Near Mint and love your videos. Your tone of your voice is very easy to listen to
Merci beaucoup pour ces vidéos je trouve ça super intéressant d'avoir tes analyses parce qu'on apprend toujours quelque choses sur des notions de lisibilité et de rythme ! J'adore 😊
Excellent objective analysis. thanks!
Very interesting analysis into the creative process. Thanks for these videos.
Holy shit this is awesome! Now this is the type of content I’ve been looking for
It's amazing how much thought, preparation and planning go into designing a page. Very helpful study.
Great work.
Can't believe how much thought goes into even white space! Keep up the great work and these videos Elsa!
This channel is in a league of it's own. Every video I'm blown away.
Please pleaaaaase more content like this, as an inspiring graphic novel maker this information is invaluable! Subscribed.
I really liked this format. Keep it up!
It would be so cool to see you do a breakdown of anything by Bill Sienkiewicz. Love this channel.
Just found your channel! Awesome and thank you!
A breakdown of a Chris Ware or Jason page from you would be amazing. Wonderful insights of one of my favourite comics, thank you!
Major Chris Ware fan over here. So, yes, definitely!
This is such great content, thank you for putting these video out there!!!
Why does this channel not have ALL the followers?
Sometimes youtube recommendations get it right. Amazing content!
Awesome work!! I love how you break down the panels! This is my favorite TH-cam channel
Another nice and good breakdown, thank you for sharing your thoughts and perspective. =)
It's crazy how much writing is like this. She's brilliant. Subbing on Patreon.
Just found your channel and I’m impressed. Awesome video! Year One is one of my favourites, and your analysis definitely made me appreciate it more.
If you’re in the mood to make more late 80s Batman videos, I’d love to see your take on Brian Bolland’s art in The Killing Joke!
There are definitely lots to say on the Killing Joke!
Loved this case study and break down, very insightful. Page awareness, a masterwork shared here!
Great evaluation of a fantastic artist. This channel has definitely become a highlight of my week. Thank you for the amazing content.
Great
Analysis
Thank you, It was very interesting.
Great...i mean....GREAT stuff. I learnt a lot from this and David Aja analysis, i just hope you do more and more! A suggestion for artists to do this breakdowns, Eduardo Risso (100 bullets) and Mike Mignola. I think they are masters of composition but couldn't explain why (not at such a great depth anyways). Thank you!
I’m a BIG fan of both, and I have definitely planned to cover both their work!
Thanks for these videos Elsa, I really learn a lot! I appreciate all the effort BTS and the final outcome
Absolutely love this, I did similar studies of both comics and novels when I did my degree in 3D animation, it really helped in making me understand why certain Artists/Writers made the decisions that they did. A common thread I found in studying my favourite stories which were also big hits or tended to be quite popular is that they were always focused on how they made a person feel with the story they were telling.
I could go on and on about that but I'm gonna hold myself back from writing the LOTR trilogy here and just say you earned yourself a subscriber. :)
So happy to see this in my sub box
This is amazing. I'm learning so much. Thank you, Elsa.
This is my second time watching this within 24 hours, I shared your channel with my art buddies I hope it boosts the views, you put a lot of effort in educating and sharing the knowledge of art and story. I've been looking for this type of content for years!
Loving your content, thank you!
This is a great channel!!
Bah trop bien! C'était vraiment cool! Merci!
such a great breakdown! I would really be interested in seeing a study on Pretty Deadly or Witch Hat Atelier.
best youtube content, just amazing!
Welp, I was just reminded to subscribe to this channel!
I really wish there was more Mazzucchelli comics out there. I really enjoy this series. Have you seen Matt Fraction's break down of an issue of Daredevil?
Absolutely fascinating. I just subscribed on the strength of your analysis. Your astute breakdown of a single page helps me appreciate the analytical reasoning and strategic placement of managing content within panels. I just started reading Darrow’s Shaolin Cowboy and his line work is incredibly detailed and intentionally gratuitous. However, from what I’ve seen thus far, he counters the graphical overload with pages that, for the most part, aren’t text heavy. Our eyes are meant to start and stop, camping on the minutest of details. Oftentimes, it feels like a treasure hunt. Elsa, (and forgive me if you’ve already addressed this), I’d like your thoughts on this type of storytelling as it appears to be a counterpoint to your analysis here.
Subbed a couple of days ago and this is one interesting channel.
ready for 9grid panel analysing 👌🏻👌🏻
Fantastic, as always!
It's so interesting and so well explained ! Thanks for that and for your work in general. A très vite, j'espère ! :)
This is fantastic!
Excelente video y excelente análisis. Sigue así que muchos apreciamos la calidad de tu apreciación. Saludos desde Perú!
Great video! I would love to see one case study of Akira!
What an excellent channel
Just brilliant again!
It's brilliant how the fight panels are simultaneously Gordon's POV and a neutral POV (because he's far enough away). Never noticed that before, or understood how important it is.
The only POV that could be Gordon's is the second one.
Great stuff. Thank you for this. Would love to see you analyze David Aja.
I did! Our first Case Study was on an hawkyere panel! You should be able to find it on my page.
@@ElsaCharretierChannel Oof. I feel like a donkey. I am fixing my mistake and currently watching that video
Great video as always, I love it. I have suggestions, maybe analyze anything by Leo Romero, Chris Samnee and James Harren
Vraiment un format incroyable, merci Elsa !
Very good video. Please do more of these studies :)
Also I would love to see you analyse Dragon Ball, Akira or Thorgal ( the first 28th volumes are the best, the rest is less good since they changed the writer)
Thanks a lot!
WAAOO SUBSCRIBED SOO FAST I LOVED THIS
Would love to see your take on Watchmen, Pax Americana by Morrison, Sex Criminals, Sandman, Transmetropolitan , Jessica Jones by Bendis, Gideon Falls by Lemire, Mister Miracle by Tom King.
All of these have some interesting panel layouts and storytelling cues.
Vagabond might be the best panel layout i've ever seen in a comic.
You should do one of these for Asterios Polyp, a comic I barely hear anybody talk about anymore
One of my all-time favorites!! I've been dissecting that book so many times I could probably put a video together. I'm a sucker for everything Mazzucchelli puts out. His City of Glass was a huge inspiration for my series November (co-created with Matt Fraction).
@@ElsaCharretierChannel I love that comic and was my gateway into Paul Auster's books!
@@sobreiro Which I also need to get into! Any suggestion?
@@ElsaCharretierChannel I started with The New York Trilogy itself! I also liked Mr. Vertigo, The Book of Illusions
asters polyp is one of my all time favorite books! it's vastly overlooked.
Quelle découverte ! Merci beaucoup pour ces explications Elsa, ça me fait aimer encore davantage certains grands dessinateurs! Des suggestions d'oeuvres/artistes à analyser, qui ne font pas du tout dans le minimalisme, mais qui conservent une clarté impressionnante (enfin selon moi): toutes les oeuvres d'Alex Ross, Killing Joke, Black Bolt (par Christian Ward), et toutes les oeuvres de Andrea Sorrentino (notamment ses runs sur Green Arrow et Old Man Logan)
Petite question: as-tu prévu d'étudier d'autres formes de bd (bd franco-belge, mangas...)?
Superbe vidéo !
Ok when's the next video I can't wait. This helps alot.
This is incredible Elsa!! Your channel will blow up shortly! That's a guarantee.
I have a humble request~ Could you do a breakdown of a manga? Their paneling and structure. I've always been curious about the comparison between western comics and eastern comics. You can do a popular manga like Naruto or something more mature like Solanin and Monster.
I would love to get your opinion on Geof Darrows work on Hard Boiled! Great video!
You know exactly what I need
Would love to see a study of All-Star Comics #65 Page 10 panels 4-5. Wally Wood on pencils and inks...masterful display of momentum, movement and framing/leading the eye. Well, at least I think so :)
Heya I just stumbled upon your channel 2 years too late. Such good content. I have a question, would it have been a good idea to frame the 3 panel violence from Commissioner Gordon’s POV instead of across the street? I ask this because I feel like the intention is that we are supposed to be feeling what Gordon is feeling in this scene.
I would enjoy your take on Elektra Lives Again .