No worries. Chimpsky will live, eternally, through his recorded lectures and through his many articles, and through his books. I am a lover of both Chimpsky and Chomsky. I have studied both primates. Chomsky is smarter than Chimpsky. But, Chimpsky is far smarter than Chomsky at the game of Tic-Tac-Toe. The reflexes and eye coordination of the chimp are far superior to any guy, like Chomsky, from Philly.
A meeting between two giants in the world of language and linguistics, accompanied by a brilliant Moroccan with a Moroccan tongue from which English words flow, and a wide knowledge of the world of linguistics. Thanks from Algeria
I've watched hours of Krashen's many wonderful lectures and discussions on TH-cam. This is perhaps his most concise and eloquent one. Absolutely delightful. Here's my theory: it must be a wonderful feeling to have such a giving hero to show off for. Thanks Dr. Krashen, your passion alone is inspiration!
Prof. Krashen's introduction to linguistics and way of tempting people to read are significant and, an important introduction to the importance of reading in itself.
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
Prof. Noam chomsky. I familiar with your writing when I was in college and I toke language but it is the first time I know your picture... thanks for your sharing sir...
7:00 *hablemos "Let's do x" requires the present subjunctive tense of the verb, even though most spanish speakers will understand non native speakers when they use present indicative.
It's great watching this webinar featuring these two linguistics giants. It would be nice if you could organise more in the nearest future, Dr Belmekki.
@@fabiengerard8142 Excellent point. And, no, as far as a future for the Human Species is concerned, so long as Satellite Cognative Entrainment is concerned, if it continues, I hold out no hope for the future of the Human species. I know that we are at a point of Diminishing Returns. We, as a species, are headed straight toward Terminal Velocity. I was just "saying" if there is a future for the Human Species it will be, in a significant way, because people listened closely to Prof. Dr. Chomsky's Rationalist Theories. His truth offer's hope.
Quite honored that I had the opportunity to come across this webinar as it was one of my ultimate goals to attend one of prof. Chomsky’s lectures and this webinar kind of granted me a wish 😭❤️ Thank you so much Dr.Nabil
This was great. I learned a lot of things and brought me some realizations. I thank you for providing a very informative, smart-witted, and historical webinar.😍🤩
I'm very happy to see this historical meeting online again. Thank you Dr. Nabil Belmekki. I hope the certificates are on their way. Thanks again. Mr. Reda BOUKLI HACENE Assistant Professor in Linguistics
Oh my happy to see both Professor Krashen and Professor Chomsky, two institutions of language, linguistics,grammar and many more we are studying now about Second Language Acquisition ...my salute to both of you Sirs
It’s been really quite fun to have conversations with chat GPT, and to use it to tell me stories about any subject that I want in any language that I want, and at any reading level. It’s entertaining and fantastically helpful! And free!
Many thanks to the organizer of this interesting meeting and my thanks also go to our esteemed guests for devoting their time and efforts to enlighten our brains much appreciated.
Had lunch with Professor Chomsky @ Henry Ford College in early 90s. He couldn't have been kinder, willing to discuss linguistic innateness with me for over an hour. I then ran home and got my copy of ATS, which he autographed after his public lecture. What a thrill.
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
Hi this side Ejaj Ahamad. I am a student of education department from Jamia Millia Islamia New Delhi, India I would like to friendship with you☺️. I want to conversation to you on effective education of students.
Excellent meeting ! I truly feel lucky to have watched this live, the quality and quantity of informations is astonishing. it is simply Sublime to have those 2 gaints speaking.
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
@@Amirhossein8844 it is still a great events for us teachers of English in Morocco. The organizer Nabil is a Moroccan teacher and he is free to choose whatever words from the dictionary to give a title or the like to a meeting or another.... English words are nobody's property Greetings & respect
Greetings Dr. Nabil: What books in Arabic would you suggest to a new student of Arabic? I have reached the level that enables me to understand bout 50 percent the news that I watch on TH-cam. I spent money on grammar books but I soon realized that they were not for me. I am a native Persian speaker. Thanks for this great video.
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
We are currently studying the theories of Mr. Noam Chomsky, I can't believe he still alive! From Philippines!
No worries. Chimpsky will live, eternally, through his recorded lectures and through his many articles, and through his books. I am a lover of both Chimpsky and Chomsky. I have studied both primates. Chomsky is smarter than Chimpsky. But, Chimpsky is far smarter than Chomsky at the game of Tic-Tac-Toe. The reflexes and eye coordination of the chimp are far superior to any guy, like Chomsky, from Philly.
@@YuChiGongG so what are you saying in your cutsie form
Chomsky is eternal
Remember.
España gave you chocolate.
The US gave you AIDS.
same with me... it is like unbelievable when we are familiar with his writing but for the first time knowing noam chomsky
A meeting between two giants in the world of language and linguistics, accompanied by a brilliant Moroccan with a Moroccan tongue from which English words flow, and a wide knowledge of the world of linguistics. Thanks from Algeria
Hi can you please explain something
Crazy: Chomsky will be leaving an hour into an over 2-hour talk, but have him sit in silence for the first 40 minutes.
It was the best thing I have experienced in my whole life! Prof. Krashen's response to my question 2:07:00
You need to add this to your resume. That's something unique!
I've watched hours of Krashen's many wonderful lectures and discussions on TH-cam. This is perhaps his most concise and eloquent one. Absolutely delightful. Here's my theory: it must be a wonderful feeling to have such a giving hero to show off for. Thanks Dr. Krashen, your passion alone is inspiration!
Prof. Krashen's introduction to linguistics and way of tempting people to read are significant and, an important introduction to the importance of reading in itself.
Indeed! A meeting of the Century!
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
Thank you, so much!
🙏❤️🙏
Currently studying the linguistics theory of Prof. Chomsky. Glad to see him for the first time..
Two giants of the language, this video must be watched by all the students and teachers who are studying linguistics, from Venezuela.
It's absolutely a meeting of the century. Thank you so much🙏
Thank you for this wonderful opportunity. I am from the Philippines.
Prof. Noam chomsky. I familiar with your writing when I was in college and I toke language but it is the first time I know your picture... thanks for your sharing sir...
I am happy, a lot of Filipinos are listening/learning to these two guys, especially Noam(who I admire and look up to). Have a good day everyone!
7:00 *hablemos
"Let's do x" requires the present subjunctive tense of the verb, even though most spanish speakers will understand non native speakers when they use present indicative.
Maslow and Chomsky was two of my favorite people in education course
Knowledge has no end . Thank you Mr. Nabil for such a precious meeting it is really historical
My pleasure
thank you so so much for that webinar! Dziękuję! Greetings from Poland :)
It's great watching this webinar featuring these two linguistics giants. It would be nice if you could organise more in the nearest future, Dr Belmekki.
I can't believe such meeting has happened actually!! Waww!! This must be marked in history!!
We will always be studying Prof. Dr. Noam Chomskey. For hundreds of years to come. Yes. He is THAT phenomenal.
´...for hundreds years to come.’
Well, you seem to be EXTREMELY optimistic about the future of ‘civilization’ as well as of the human species itself!
@@fabiengerard8142 Excellent point. And, no, as far as a future for the Human Species is concerned, so long as Satellite Cognative Entrainment is concerned, if it continues, I hold out no hope for the future of the Human species. I know that we are at a point of Diminishing Returns. We, as a species, are headed straight toward Terminal Velocity. I was just "saying" if there is a future for the Human Species it will be, in a significant way, because people listened closely to Prof. Dr. Chomsky's Rationalist Theories. His truth offer's hope.
Thanks so much. I truly enjoyed this.
what a meeting!!! so proud to attend it ❤️❤️❤️
This is a very delightful conversation. I enjoyed listening. Thank you. Greetings from Turkey!
Congratulations, dear Nabil on such a great webinar! Thank you very much for this opportunity.
Quite honored that I had the opportunity to come across this webinar as it was one of my ultimate goals to attend one of prof. Chomsky’s lectures and this webinar kind of granted me a wish 😭❤️
Thank you so much Dr.Nabil
what a gift to humanity!
Great webinar with really helpful ideas and tips from the best!
This was great. I learned a lot of things and brought me some realizations. I thank you for providing a very informative, smart-witted, and historical webinar.😍🤩
Amazing webinar! I can`t thank you enough! All the best from Argentina!
Wooowww.... Really adore both of you Prof. Chomsky and Krashen... used to read your books about The theory of acquiring language n so on...
It's true, I've been reading a lot in English lately and I feel my English has been improving too.
a really interesting exposition from two great gurus, thank you so much Mr Nabil belmekki we are proud of you!
Amazing opportunity!!! thanks a lot from Chile Mr Nabil for this big work.
This is an incredibly valuable video! Thank you!
Thank you Mr. Nabil for such a precious meeting it is really historical
It's been a fruitful academic meeting. Thank you Mr Nabil Belmekki
Absolutely fantastic.. thank you for arranging this and thanks for professors Chomsky and Krashen for such an interesting and enriching discussion.
Well, it has been a pleasure to hold a meeting with a great man like Mr. Noam, especially you are moroccan ...I wish ya better luck ,sir.
I'm very happy to see this historical meeting online again. Thank you Dr. Nabil Belmekki. I hope the certificates are on their way. Thanks again.
Mr. Reda BOUKLI HACENE
Assistant Professor in Linguistics
Oh my happy to see both Professor Krashen and Professor Chomsky, two institutions of language, linguistics,grammar and many more we are studying now about Second Language Acquisition ...my salute to both of you Sirs
Such a great webinar ! I'm from Malaysia !
Unforgettable experience, thank you for this webinar it was extremely wonderful.
جزاك الله خير د نبيل
So interesting.Thank a lot professor Nabil.
It’s been really quite fun to have conversations with chat GPT, and to use it to tell me stories about any subject that I want in any language that I want, and at any reading level. It’s entertaining and fantastically helpful! And free!
Best 2 hours of this week!
Brilliant! Thank you!
It was a great meeting indeed.Happy to see our model.
Many thanks to the organizer of this interesting meeting and my thanks also go to our esteemed guests for devoting their time and efforts to enlighten our brains much appreciated.
Merci beaucoup c'est trés interessant... Merci pour les grands professeurs savants et merci aussi pour les organisateurs ... Gratitude à vous tous !!!
Congratulations for organising team.. It's great pleasure
wow! a rare chance to see them together.
Had lunch with Professor Chomsky @ Henry Ford College in early 90s. He couldn't have been kinder, willing to discuss linguistic innateness with me for over an hour. I then ran home and got my copy of ATS, which he autographed after his public lecture. What a thrill.
Wonderful! The video is finally restored.
شكرا أستاذ نبيل على مجهوداتك لعقد هذه اللقاءات العلمية الماتعة و المفيدة
My hair in the back stood up hearing morocco hosting these international Linguistic pioneers.
Great two professors that waiting for this day that you discuss on going issues. From Philippines
Thank you for this Webinar - I am from the Philippines .
Thank you sir Belmekki for making this happen..
Antonette Ramos
I would’ve enjoyed this live definately will watch it! What an honor and pleasure to see you both! Thank you so much for this webinar! 🥰
definitely
Legends 🥰
It was a pleasure to attend such a Webinar. Thank u 🙏🏻
OMG meeting with chomsky 😍😍😍.right now i am studying his subject TGG ..😁thanks for an amazing information that he has given us ..
Thank you and God bless!
Thanks for inviting me Uncle Stephen! 🥰
استمتعنا به مرة أخرى..رؤية متقدمة وانجاز يحسب لكم ..لطالما انتظرناه
Watching since DR Congo, Kinshasa 🇨🇩
Currently doing study about language, thank you so much sir!
شكرا جزيلا استاذ على هذه المحاضرة التاريخية القيمة جدا جدا
Amazing, thanks for making this happen
It is amazing watching two giant scholars in Linguistics. Prof. Chomsky and Prof. Krashen. I highly elated.
Onisabi, Abdullah Shehu
Nigeria
محتوى عظيم بارك اله فيك.
"هي فعلا "لقاءات مع الكبار
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
Je suis bien fier du professeur Nabil et de ce qu'il propose
❤️
Thank you Nabil for thos wonderful opportunity 😍
Can see and hear perfectly. Thanks
Thank you so much for that reach full meeting
خالص الود والتقدير، تستحق يا عزيزي كل ثناء واحترام، موفق ومنصور دائما... أخوك د. سويدي تمكليت، باحث في اللسانيات
Thanks a lot teacher Nabil Belmekki
A meeting of the century, indeed!
Thanks teacher for efforts I hope you good job god willing 👏👏👏👏👍👍👍🥰
Thank you so much for sharing those peoples' participation
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
Thanks for that wonderful webinaar . I am from Pakistan
thank you! this is great
Thanks a lot Mr Nabil for this big work.
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
لقاء رائع وشائق ..وجزيل الشكر للمنظمين والعالمين الفاضلين ..وتظل القراءة علي راس القائمة ...اقرأ
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
حفظك الله دكتورنا العزيز
Great content. Not to be missed. I notice the huge increase in the advertising rate as well.
Hello, Dr, Nabil How are you doing? This meeting is very interesting and memorable for World history. I'm live watching in TH-cam.
شكرا جزيلاً لك
Excellent . Thanks for sharing this video.,,
شكرا د بلمكي.
Indeed.... So amazing, I am from Pakistan.... Noam Chomsky ✌❤❤
✌🇵🇰🇵🇰
Very interesting and fascinating ideas and points.Thanks
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
Thank you Professor Krashen and Prof Chomsky
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
Really thankful from Egypt!
Hi this side Ejaj Ahamad.
I am a student of education department from Jamia Millia Islamia New Delhi, India
I would like to friendship with you☺️.
I want to conversation to you on effective education of students.
Excellent meeting ! I truly feel lucky to have watched this live, the quality and quantity of informations is astonishing. it is simply Sublime to have those 2 gaints speaking.
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html
@@Amirhossein8844 it is still a great events for us teachers of English in Morocco. The organizer Nabil is a Moroccan teacher and he is free to choose whatever words from the dictionary to give a title or the like to a meeting or another....
English words are nobody's property
Greetings & respect
Greetings Dr. Nabil: What books in Arabic would you suggest to a new student of Arabic? I have reached the level that enables me to understand bout 50 percent the news that I watch on TH-cam. I spent money on grammar books but I soon realized that they were not for me. I am a native Persian speaker. Thanks for this great video.
This was wonderful, so interesting. What a privilege. Thank you!
Amazing...
Wonderful. Thank you for this webinar 🤓
A great webinar for sure, but the organizers should adhere to the code of academic conduct regarding copyright! The expression "The Event of the Century" was first used for a webinar hosting these two great professors in 2020 by IZ language school in Zanjan, Iran. th-cam.com/video/CbVrWCR8O88/w-d-xo.html