Kinda when Batman gets asked right before he punches a man dressed as a women saying "you would hit a lady now would you?", and Batman proceeds to say "the hammer of justice is unisex" proceeds to punch the crooks face in lol
The way the chick in front turns to look at the lady in the back as she speaks just shows the amount of effort and detail they put into this masterpiece
For being a cold-blooded murderer; Arthur was pretty progressive for a late 1800s man. He wasn’t racially nor sexually prejudiced, spiteful of foreigners, nor ignorant (illiterate). He was an insightful and curious individual with a good heart in a circumstancial life of hardship and violence.
Yeah! That's what I love about Arthur and John, they aren't hateful, they dont judge quick and are rather intelligent. They're progressive men and only kill when they need to. Hosea definitely taught them right!
Arthur hates captivity. Being shackled. He learned to love freedom from Dutch. He learned that everyone is the same from Hosea. As such, Arthur is an incredibly consistent character. Despite being in the 1800's, his hatred of shackling transcends racism and sexism. Anyone shackling someone else (emotionally, physically or societally) disgusts Arthur. He could be "progressive". But i think it's more interesting to see it as such an intense love of freedom and hatred towards those who try to stop freedom. Again, taught by Dutch. Dutch gave Arthur his mind, Hosea gifted him his heart.
Isn't it amazing how you literally love every single character in this scene? Look at any of their faces and tell me there isn't a place in your heart for every one of them? That your heart doesn't skip a beat whenever Arthur speaks. What a beautiful game.
That's literally what Republicans are like but everyone labels them as racist and sexist and whatnot because of not wanting the gender and race politics shoved in their face every second, we literally just don't care😭
@@just_delta-2589 Republicans DO care. They want to enforce their preferences on others (look at the Roe V Wade situation) You’re confusing libertarians for republicans. Libertarians support your right to do whatever as long as it doesn’t impede on them.
@godofdeath4582 no, because my ENTIRE family is republican and most of our friends are too. All I've EVER heard is that they don't give a crap what you do, just don't shove it in our faces.
@godofdeath4582 and no, liberals do not believe that. They are the most anti-rights people I've ever seen. If you're not "special" in some way, then you're complete trash to them. I got treated worse as a kid by Liberals when I believed I was a straight white boy. Now I know I'm bisexual (and republican, yes, it's possible) and I'm not treated as bad because I'm finally special and not just a straight white man.
Despite looking like a stereotypical one dimensional bad ass cowboy character, both John and Arthur are emotionally intelligent, though it is hard for them to communicate how they feel. They're both progressive men and know well enough to not judge others on superficial things like sex, race, gender, things like that. That's what I love about them, yeah, they're bad asses that can take on an entire battalion of law men, but they are people, and they love, fear, hope like us. I love them so much
Watched too many movies about cowboys lol most midwestern people were nonchalant as it was still the frontier basically, not much law and order and people were just trying to survive. Didn’t have time to get political and worry about equal rights when one day you might get cholera from a sip of water.
Arthur isn’t masculinity, he’s stoicism. This ideology was actually taught to him by Dutch, so it’s nice to know there are some things dutch holds dearly to his heart ♥️ Edit: Ah a feisty comment section, nice to know nothing changed🗿✌️
Stoicism is the most traditionally masculine trait. Be a tightly controlled, disciplined monster, a sword in the sheath which is never wielded lest necessary. Or as the Bible would put it, a bridled warhorse. Real shame that it's been underappreciated and even railed against in the name of instant gratification these past decades.
I love that Arthur and John didn't judge people on their race or sex. In fact, I absolutely LOVE that they don't freak out over anything that was unacceptable back then. Like when Arthur (or John, depending on who you do the missions as) helps Charles Chatenay escape the men that are after him and Charles kisses Arthur (or John) to keep from being seen, Arthur only tells him "Please, don't do that again." And not even in an aggressive tone. Any other man in those times would've shot Charles for doing something like that but Charles became a friend and they knew that it wasn't something that was a huge deal as society made it seem then.
They were secure in themselves and thought critically for themselves rather than allowing society to think for them. Plus, on occasion, they can be calm and reasonable people, just like kratos
Ian Fraser Kilmister, better known as Lemmy Kilmister or simply Lemmy, was an English musician. He was the founder, lead singer, bassist and primary songwriter of the rock band Motörhead, of which he was the only continuous member, and a member of Hawkwind from 1971 to 1975.
For someone that was supposed to represent the "old past" he actually was very ahead of his time, if he wasn't a gunslinger he would have suited the modern 1890's world perfectly
There are plenty of differences between men and women, and acknowledging that men and women are different doesn't mean you don't think they should be treated equally
Cringe rockstar made arthur a liberal sjw. in those times he wouldnt have cared about compton being a racist or said men = women. the latter is complete brain damage
Tilly got him cornered 🤣 Arthur gave a wise response. I love the camp girls, they're great. And then, for contrast, Micah's opinion on women in camp: "What are they good for if they won't even fuck you with a gun to their head?" 💀
Exactly when Arthur was on the verge on getting back together with Mary you could tell how concerned she was always asking him how it was going with Mary
Nah bruh dutch is a creep to Marybeth. All the lessons he gives are bullshit, he's just talking out of his ass to stay afloat. Arthur just took the lies of 1 man and turned them into truth for himself.
When he says a few worth loving and dying for a few come into my mine like Mary, maybe Sadie and, maybe Mary-beth they should've added a love interest thing for them all like maybe depending on side missions or honor it would've been cool in my opinion and ain't no damn way that they shouldn't have if sadie only trusts arthur out of anyone in the gang or if mary-beth has so much in common with arthur and literally tries impressing him by robbing a store but getting caught and then she also dances with him and mary just has some hints of interest in arthur still even though they already broke up
I love the way Arthur felt about people and society. "Most of both are awful" there's no difference, really, because both sides have their evil. It went the same with anyone that was racist, Arthur knew Mexicans, Indians, Africans and felt fine with most he knew lol
arthur morgan is the best writen character ever, if he was real he would be the best example ever of what a man should be, not the snowflakes that most modern boys(there not real men) are
I actually wish that some of the gang had an unlikeable side. They live in 1899 which was a very different time for america. I wish that they had some discriminatory views but were still likable in order to make the player have a dilemma where they're confused how they could like somebody despite their terrible ideals
I think a lot of it has to do with Dutch's shepherding the outcasts of society, and thats why most of the gang isn't all that prejudice. If Dutch wanted loyal people he needed to treat everyone equally, and that moral got passed onto everyone else in the group
@@itsmrbigsmoke862 i think Bill's more of a wild card than anything. Hes definitely unhinged and thats what i chalk it up to. To me the true group has always excluded Micah and Bill, even though Bill was running with the gang for a decent amount. Edit: and I think there was a scene where Bill was getting racist around Dutch and Dutch shut it down very quickly
He took a breath to make sure he doesn’t screw up
in my head it’s more about regret in his voice than messing up
@@mushroom_pi same
nah he was just taken a bit by surprise, its a pretty good question
That was a sigh
Bro was sweating
1899, the year of love
2022 the year of idiots toxic feminists and so much more
And lumbago
And slavery
@@ppkiller-ln6ym another pro
@@Glowstikc 😈
Arthur in front of them: 🌝
Arthur in the theatre: 🌚
LMAO💀💀💀
💀
YOU BELONG IN THE KITCHEN
No fucking way 💀💀
this is a reference to Mrs Linton but I don't get what the emojis are saying
"I didnt know I was talking to a lady"
Regular dandy and a charmer
@@rutmarotto “fetch me something to eat”
@@ddynamite excuse me?
@@amitr24242 I said fetch me something to eat!
@@ddynamite (ohohohhhahha ohhhhhhhh!!) Eat that...
Mr. Morgan the type of guy to say he’s into equality then follow it up with “because i hate everyone equally” and I love that about him
Kinda when Batman gets asked right before he punches a man dressed as a women saying "you would hit a lady now would you?", and Batman proceeds to say "the hammer of justice is unisex" proceeds to punch the crooks face in lol
I think he actually did say something like that
@@eggchomp Yea he did I dont remember exact words tho
The way the chick in front turns to look at the lady in the back as she speaks just shows the amount of effort and detail they put into this masterpiece
You don’t know their names?
The girl who’s speaking is named Karen, the black girl is tilly, and the furthest away is Mary Beth
Her name is karen, and she becomes a karen later on.
@@YSL8704 nah she’s just a bietch
@@Ghost-xo5sz yeah she is
Arthur is the most based as fuck character on the planet
Best character
Based? Nah he’s the best period!
@@bowman303 Arthur is a feminist, and so am I.
Dumbass.
@@bowman303 what
@@bowman303 you lost.
Mary-Beth: *I knew you are romantic Mr. Morgan*
Artur: *Oh, I didn't know I was talking to the lady*
He mentioned "worth"
For being a cold-blooded murderer; Arthur was pretty progressive for a late 1800s man. He wasn’t racially nor sexually prejudiced, spiteful of foreigners, nor ignorant (illiterate). He was an insightful and curious individual with a good heart in a circumstancial life of hardship and violence.
Yeah! That's what I love about Arthur and John, they aren't hateful, they dont judge quick and are rather intelligent. They're progressive men and only kill when they need to. Hosea definitely taught them right!
I think being an orphan(which they both were) would teach you a thing or two about prejudice. Dutch saved them both... Without prejudice.
It’s Dutch’s teachings probably
After your 3rd playthrough you start to notice how dedicated and taken in Arthur is by Dutch’s ideology
@@lilypaigeham they robbed and killed all their lives lol they killed bc they were gang members
That’s the thing, it doesn’t matter how “progressive” you are if you’re a cold-blooded murderer.
Arthur hates captivity. Being shackled. He learned to love freedom from Dutch. He learned that everyone is the same from Hosea.
As such, Arthur is an incredibly consistent character. Despite being in the 1800's, his hatred of shackling transcends racism and sexism.
Anyone shackling someone else (emotionally, physically or societally) disgusts Arthur.
He could be "progressive". But i think it's more interesting to see it as such an intense love of freedom and hatred towards those who try to stop freedom. Again, taught by Dutch.
Dutch gave Arthur his mind, Hosea gifted him his heart.
hmmm, so it's a hatred for exploitation.... Marxist Arthur confirmed
"Dutch gave Arthur his mind, Hosea gifted him his heart" bruh..... 😢 well said.
feel like aurther was thinking of Mary here, “a few worth living and dying for” was a good hint and i was sold when he mentions “if they’ll let you”
These games were like ballads, poetry and a classic play all in one
And then in online it’s just “well everyone’s just a bag of money to tbh”
Isn't it amazing how you literally love every single character in this scene? Look at any of their faces and tell me there isn't a place in your heart for every one of them? That your heart doesn't skip a beat whenever Arthur speaks. What a beautiful game.
arthur is the best progressive person ever, his take on everything is just “i don’t really care, do what you want”
So a social libertarian basically
That's literally what Republicans are like but everyone labels them as racist and sexist and whatnot because of not wanting the gender and race politics shoved in their face every second, we literally just don't care😭
@@just_delta-2589 Republicans DO care. They want to enforce their preferences on others (look at the Roe V Wade situation) You’re confusing libertarians for republicans. Libertarians support your right to do whatever as long as it doesn’t impede on them.
@godofdeath4582 no, because my ENTIRE family is republican and most of our friends are too. All I've EVER heard is that they don't give a crap what you do, just don't shove it in our faces.
@godofdeath4582 and no, liberals do not believe that. They are the most anti-rights people I've ever seen. If you're not "special" in some way, then you're complete trash to them. I got treated worse as a kid by Liberals when I believed I was a straight white boy. Now I know I'm bisexual (and republican, yes, it's possible) and I'm not treated as bad because I'm finally special and not just a straight white man.
Despite looking like a stereotypical one dimensional bad ass cowboy character, both John and Arthur are emotionally intelligent, though it is hard for them to communicate how they feel. They're both progressive men and know well enough to not judge others on superficial things like sex, race, gender, things like that. That's what I love about them, yeah, they're bad asses that can take on an entire battalion of law men, but they are people, and they love, fear, hope like us. I love them so much
So you mean a regular cowboy
@@HKNative217 regular, but not one-dimensional
Oh brother 🙄
Watched too many movies about cowboys lol most midwestern people were nonchalant as it was still the frontier basically, not much law and order and people were just trying to survive. Didn’t have time to get political and worry about equal rights when one day you might get cholera from a sip of water.
He was 100% thinking about Mary 😔 justice for Arthur
Arthur Morgan may be an Outlaw, but he's the most agreeable and reasonable one I've ever seen.
Anyone else dance with Mary-beth
Why wouldn't you lol
Arthur isn’t masculinity, he’s stoicism. This ideology was actually taught to him by Dutch, so it’s nice to know there are some things dutch holds dearly to his heart ♥️
Edit: Ah a feisty comment section, nice to know nothing changed🗿✌️
Dutch clearly doesn’t practise what he preaches lmao. Bro is not stoic
@@nurponurpo5886 he just went insane thats all
@@raccwacc nah before then he was still very talkative
Stoicism is the most traditionally masculine trait. Be a tightly controlled, disciplined monster, a sword in the sheath which is never wielded lest necessary. Or as the Bible would put it, a bridled warhorse.
Real shame that it's been underappreciated and even railed against in the name of instant gratification these past decades.
@@pubcle My thoughts exactly
Arthur is a fair and balance person
The scene where Arthur takes part in the suffrage movement is powerful, the man of all men standing by women in equality
Morgan is never sure of anything, he just guesses
I love how we made every interaction in this game feel real and true
Every thought of Arthur has a great deep meaning
Arthur drinking enough Respect Women juice to have enough disdain for errybody
I love that Arthur and John didn't judge people on their race or sex. In fact, I absolutely LOVE that they don't freak out over anything that was unacceptable back then. Like when Arthur (or John, depending on who you do the missions as) helps Charles Chatenay escape the men that are after him and Charles kisses Arthur (or John) to keep from being seen, Arthur only tells him "Please, don't do that again." And not even in an aggressive tone. Any other man in those times would've shot Charles for doing something like that but Charles became a friend and they knew that it wasn't something that was a huge deal as society made it seem then.
They were secure in themselves and thought critically for themselves rather than allowing society to think for them. Plus, on occasion, they can be calm and reasonable people, just like kratos
@@mack-attack-420 Exactly! But who's Kratos? Lol
Arthur says the goodest boah thangs.
LEMMY!!!
@@edwardmorrison5262 ynneL?
Ian Fraser Kilmister, better known as Lemmy Kilmister or simply Lemmy, was an English musician. He was the founder, lead singer, bassist and primary songwriter of the rock band Motörhead, of which he was the only continuous member, and a member of Hawkwind from 1971 to 1975.
I don't think he was talking about Mary Beth, I think he was talking about them, he was willing to die for them.
He's talking about Mary Linton
And they didn't even ask me about my thoughts on it....
i think you and molly were enough of an answer, van der line.
@@XeonDoesstuff will I can't exactly disagree, son
He sure did love that girl💯it's sad he never got the chance to run away with Mary....
Mary don't deserve Arthur she's a horrible women!
man when he said there were some worth dying for it was so clear he was talking about them, i’m crying btw
Rizzed up 3 girls at once
Tilly looking at Arthur like, “Say something, I dare you, I’ll go off”
Rizzster Morgan 🥶
For someone that was supposed to represent the "old past" he actually was very ahead of his time, if he wasn't a gunslinger he would have suited the modern 1890's world perfectly
That is a good man’s answer…
My man Arthur rizzing girls up before it was even a thing
Equal of respect, but theres a world of differences
"if they'll let you" hit me
After that dead eye activated and they gain alot of love and romance
Arthur reminded me so much of my grandmother
Based Arthur
Another great thing to add to Arthur’s list
There are plenty of differences between men and women, and acknowledging that men and women are different doesn't mean you don't think they should be treated equally
He misses his son and his real wife. That’s why he took that breath.
I love how they only got the "he's a romantic" out of a far deeper comment he just announced
Hands down, Arthur Morgan the best of all time ❤️
“YOU BELONG IN THE KITCHEN” - Arthur Morgan
Meanwhile Arthur: YOU BELONG IN THE KITCHEN
😂😂
He literally wouldnt say that
@@lilypaigeham he actually would in the theater of Saint Denis if you watch a specific show dunno which
Damn I just keep finding more and more shit that makes me relate to Arthur more
Cringe
rockstar made arthur a liberal sjw. in those times he wouldnt have cared about compton being a racist or said men = women. the latter is complete brain damage
@@geniuz4093 What da fuck 🤨
@@geniuz4093 why
@@geniuz4093 It’s funny, your name seems to be the opposite of what you are.
@@geniuz4093 I mean if they didn't make him a liberal they would've been canceled because you know in 1899 no black people would be in a white gang
Arthur Morgan ❤
Aurthur is a special character
Tilly got him cornered 🤣 Arthur gave a wise response. I love the camp girls, they're great.
And then, for contrast, Micah's opinion on women in camp: "What are they good for if they won't even fuck you with a gun to their head?" 💀
Micah is the worst. He's misogynistic and racist. Plus he's cruel to animals (kicking and even killing Cain)
“Okay. I’ll catch you later, then.”
😂😂 bro
You know he was thinking of ML in that last bit 😭
Homie made sure to hide his power level
Mary Beth always really liked Arthur.
Exactly when Arthur was on the verge on getting back together with Mary you could tell how concerned she was always asking him how it was going with Mary
What a mind of an 1800s person
Classic Arthur Morgan W
Foreshadowing is pretty good
Sean and Karen are real romantic
Same with Kieran and Marybeth
Don't even get me started on Bill and Marion
@@emmahatcher9979 also Kieran and Bill 💀💀
Anyone else probably would’ve fucked up their answer but he managed to come up with the best one possible 😔
I like how Mary Beth is secretly crushing on Arthur. But she never accepts it.
You got to Remember that Dutch is the same as Arthur in this scene because Arthur looked up to and wanted to be like Dutch.
Nah bruh dutch is a creep to Marybeth. All the lessons he gives are bullshit, he's just talking out of his ass to stay afloat. Arthur just took the lies of 1 man and turned them into truth for himself.
Ima about to use this as a response to this question because its actually true
There goes Mary Beth having a crush on Arthur
Me: I feel like the 3 of y'all are dead weight.
This is my favorite thing Arthur has said in the game it’s up there with be a goddamn man
B B B BASED, he man something sound logical & romantic at the same time.
When he says a few worth loving and dying for a few come into my mine like Mary, maybe Sadie and, maybe Mary-beth they should've added a love interest thing for them all like maybe depending on side missions or honor it would've been cool in my opinion and ain't no damn way that they shouldn't have if sadie only trusts arthur out of anyone in the gang or if mary-beth has so much in common with arthur and literally tries impressing him by robbing a store but getting caught and then she also dances with him and mary just has some hints of interest in arthur still even though they already broke up
Weird Tilly called him Mr. Arthur she usually just says Arthur
Goated quote
I love the way Arthur felt about people and society. "Most of both are awful" there's no difference, really, because both sides have their evil.
It went the same with anyone that was racist, Arthur knew Mexicans, Indians, Africans and felt fine with most he knew lol
Arthur is smarter than most men of this century
he is. Most people think with their dicks and are slaves of ideologies like alpha/beta male
you're not wrongg, gigachad culture is toxic lol
@@FemboyKaiSaku its both toxic and not, my femboy
@@YaToGamiKuro yes yes i agree a lot of gigachads are awesome
@@FemboyKaiSaku kinda cringe but not exactly toxic twink
Song is Freak by Surf Curse slowed down
Fastest Rizz in the West
The only woman I’ll die for in red dead is said Adler😎
Life is too short for hate honestly, I am too lazy to deal with it 😂
Also Arthur: so how much you worth anyway
You can tell modern ideas in these games when the characters aren't realistic truth to how they really were back in the day
Arthur was just a good guy, in some ways 😅
I don’t care if Auther thinks women are equip I still like him😤
The rizzly bear
Arthur is pretty based for 1899
arthur morgan is the best writen character ever, if he was real he would be the best example ever of what a man should be, not the snowflakes that most modern boys(there not real men) are
Chad Arthur
Dutch! They are asking me about gender roles!
the three best characters imo in games are kratos doom slayer and mah boah Arthur
Mr Linton smh 😢👋
Yes there is a difference and its designed that way
he's obviously not talking about physical differences
Word of the day:
*depression*
They all wanted him let's be real
Based Aurthur
I actually wish that some of the gang had an unlikeable side. They live in 1899 which was a very different time for america. I wish that they had some discriminatory views but were still likable in order to make the player have a dilemma where they're confused how they could like somebody despite their terrible ideals
I think a lot of it has to do with Dutch's shepherding the outcasts of society, and thats why most of the gang isn't all that prejudice. If Dutch wanted loyal people he needed to treat everyone equally, and that moral got passed onto everyone else in the group
@@haarisbutt2075 I thought that too but bill and micah often show prejudice views on the other members in camp which made me stumped
@@itsmrbigsmoke862 i think Bill's more of a wild card than anything. Hes definitely unhinged and thats what i chalk it up to. To me the true group has always excluded Micah and Bill, even though Bill was running with the gang for a decent amount.
Edit: and I think there was a scene where Bill was getting racist around Dutch and Dutch shut it down very quickly
the gang consists of indians, blacks, females, males, irish, white, gay, straight.. of course they wont be discriminative for the most part.
Arthur Morgan, progressive ally
Brother Can you download a clip about All Mission Polish guy? Keep going 🙏
Most based response ive ever heard
Bro was not trying to get cancel in 1899
Women are worth everything but threat got to earn it