The US 🇺🇸 rather spend the money 💵 on weapons, defense spending, aiding wars in another country than it's own citizen's welfare like health care, homelessness issues, improving infrastructures and so on.
It's because average to below income people don't matter to them. Just so long that the top 1% stay on top and continue to get richer, that's all that really matters to them. Also, in a capitalist society, there can be no rich without the working poor. It's just how things work with that kind of system unfortunately.
@@rsuriyop China has more extremely poor people living on $1500 USD/year (600 million) than the US even has people(330 million). So please explain how that works? Why is China still trying to keep "Developing nation" status with the WTO if all the people are doing so well?
I went on the Shanghai metro in 2018, and I was astounded. The network was so vast and deep down, you could take journeys of escalators going down or up, especially in an interchange station. Thousands would be on their phones because wifi was already widespread underground. Everything was so seemless and in order, and was very cheap. I’ve travelled on the Shanghai maglev and China’s high speed rail system. It is world class! It’s great to see your authentic shots of China Subway VS America Subway in your videos.I am so impressed by this. I only wish we have such modern and convenience transport system in the US. It is so dirty and dated in the US. China is allot more modern and developed than I expected! Our media in the West always tells us China is collapsing.
When China collapsed last time, I was still a 14-year-old boy. 10 years later, I am now a single mother with a daughter, and China is still on the brink of collapse
US has a car culture, public transportation within a metropolitan area by rail & buses is not prioritized leading to under-investment to the point of neglect. Hence most of the subway systems is in the state they're in right now. But the road transport network system to cater to road vehicles - freeways, highways, wide boulevards, etc. are modern, extensive & well-maintained.
@@tweedy4sgYou can see China has huge amount of cars now even in the small villages in the countryside and express way in China is also super good and convenient. China government cares more for their people
Hilarious to think that US citizens get jealous over subways lol! Most of us own 60-100 k trucks , Harleys , Boats and RVs ! Our food isn’t cooked In oil from the gutters ? We can actually go fishing because our natural lakes havnt been fished into extinction! Our air isn’t so polluted we can’t see the building across the road ! No doors on public toilets in China let alone toilet paper ! Old people spitting everywhere ! If this ever has a kid their grandparents will refer to them as wai guo ren 😂😂😂! Most of us Americans live in 3+ bedroo 2+ bath houses with big gardens and big bbqs ! Most Chinese people live in crappy little apartments that look like they are gonna fall apart after 5 years! There is a reason why 90 percent of Chinese would leave China for America or the west if they had the chance 😂😂😂 I could go on all day lol … congratulations on you flashy subways though!!
@@davidgmaloof You don't have to wait, it already happened. Ask yourself, why the US keep provoking China with sanctions, ban certain products export to China and so on. On morons can't see that is happening or pretend not to notice that. 😆
@@davidgmaloof evidence ? Then why the US impose trade sanction and ban certain products example, semi conductor chips to China, what got the US fear about ?
@@davidgmaloof You don't have to wait, the evidence was all along there till now. For example, just look at the NYC subway station worn down condition and the trains condition, those trains look like crap and once you step into the train, it smell like 💩 and very often people fight inside the train, commuters sometime get mugged by scumbags and even gun shooting happened also. Davidgmaloof, do you dare to deny that ?
Brilliant video! It took Shanghai from no metro to the world's biggest in just 15 years. I have updated my record of it as my record back in 2021 was it had only 398 stations and not 508 today. It was just 800km long but now 826km in total length.
Hello Alex, I just found your channel now and I enjoyed this subway comparison, there's no doubt China's transport system is the most advanced on earth, cleanest, safest and most efficient. Did I forget cheapest too? If you upload regular content I shall subscribe and look forward to watching more. 🇨🇳👍
You're talking about Confucius? In America nobody knows word Confucius. That word is ET for America. Actually Confucius 👍👌👏 is a FIRST that we called today Communist. Second is a Jesus Christ. If it's something to profit American would be first to know about it. Confucius lived in 575 BC. He's to advanced for American leaches Capitalist System.
You're talking about Confucius? In America nobody knows word Confucius. That word is ET for America. Actually Confucius 👍👌👏 is a FIRST that we called today Communist. Second is a Jesus Christ. If it's something to profit American would be first to know about it. Confucius lived in China 575 BC. He's toooooo advanced for American leaches Capitalist System.
🎉You're talking about Confucius? In America nobody knows word Confucius. That word is ET for America. Actually Confucius 👍👌👏 is a FIRST that we called today Communist. Second is a Jesus Christ. If it's something to profit American would be first to know about it. Confucius lived in China 575 BC. He's toooo advanced for American leaches Capitalist System.
1) All Chinese had been indirectly BRaiNWaSHed by the UK Troops to FEAR & to ReSPeCT the Collective--West for more than 100 yrs to be SLAVEs of the US--UK--German--France. 2) The ProoFs are so Obvious. Just check the Chinese Names & the Direct Translations of All these 4 white nations above. 3) The Super AMaZinG thing is 99.999% of Chinese are totally UnAware of these UK OPiuM Dealers BrainwashinG. There are still so many hidden older generations Self--HaTinG Chinese inside PRC CHN who are very much worshipping their Colonial Western Masters & 4) They are being extra willing to act as CIA Spies. ** ( these may include XI JinPinG & many inside his team BeiJing team who had been studying in USA. 😮😮😮
Considering China 's population is 4X larger than the United States, there's absolutely no excuse for its public spaces and local transits to be in such a dismal condition. Just goes to show what the government thinks of its city and its citizens.
You haven't mentioned the ticket price. I had been there twice. It is 7 or 8 RMB ($1) for the longest distance and 2 RMB for a short distance such as 3 stations. Can't remember exactly.
Its wrong to compare China & US Its akin to comparing an Art student (US) & Science student (China) That's why there are millions of engineers, scientists & builders from China In US there are millions of lawyers, salesmen & sweet talkers.
American politicians approved 300 millions dollars to promote anti China propaganda machine around the world instead of using the money to focus on their citizens and its infrastructures🎈
It doesn't matter what people want to improve American's public, people will always ruin it. I have seen people don't care anything brand new buildings and public metro.
It's amazing that the Chinese citizens don't damage their public properties. You don't see paintings on the walls or broken glasses at the bus stations..... They understand that if things got destroyed, they will be the one that has to pay for it or suffer. I'm learning everyday from them.
In US, if someone damages public properties, the person is not held accountable but the public. All these are taught to US kids while they were little.
I've lived in both New York City and San Francisco over the last 5 decades (yes I'm aging myself) and have had to use the subway systems in both places and both are filthy and with rats and homeless in the stations AND the mentally ill on the trains but........ truth be told when you use the systems day in and day out you really do get used to them and your mind just learns to block them all out and your only concern is for the train to show up and get you to where you're trying to get to.
Even if you block them out, can you block out the mindset that you are in a dangerous situation? Aren't you nervous? That's exhausting. A safe environment allows you to relax more and conserve energy.
@@cheneyli6332 *:* OBVIOUSLY YOU ONLY know the "heavenly clean HongKong and East Asian" metros and thus have never experienced metros in North America and WESTERN Europe..... LIKE I SAID: I've been using metros/subways in the US since the 1970s before I was even an adolescent. Using the dirty, graffitied, LOUSY service subways for pretty much all my life AND THAT IS WHAT I'VE EXISTED WITH FOR AS LONG AS I REMEMBER OVER THE DECADES WHEN USING THE METRO/SUBWAY. You HAVE to exist. You HAVE to live and that "living" means - for me at least as the vast majority of americans have never been anywhere close to a metro/subway - USING THE METRO/SUBWAY. Because my "brain" is SOOOOOOO "acclimated" to the horrible conditions of american metros, the "brain doesn't notice" as LIKE I SAID, my "brain" is OVERWHELMINGLY CONCERNED WITH THE TRAIN JUST SHOWING UP SO I CAN GET TO WHERE I'M TRYING TO GET TO.
@@archstanton5973 I can't stand it that many New Yorkers pop their dirty shoes on the subway seats. US people generally are selfish, they may keep their home clean but not the public area.
In China, the govt is doing its job and not working towards elections and voters. In US, govt talks a lot to win voters, without the need to improve the lifes of its citizens, and yet they are elected. So which systems benefits the citizens.. think about it.
@@chopsticksandtrains , you should boast that your people can sure compete with China's population as your people are far more productive in baby making than China.
Also things to note is, the 4g/5g/6g what ever cellular connection you have, coming down to the metro there is no blind spot for disconnection. That is why chinese youths like to play online games for their commuting.
Most of the trains aren't that old. It's not as bad as a lot of people are making it out to be. The system is old but is being modernized with CTBC signalling.
Japan is overstated, false, and as you can tell from your in-depth knowledge, Japan is a very hypocritical people. Serves them right for eating plum barbecue.
Don't denigrate the NYC subway station. That's the only kind of subway station where you can film Matrix. Can you imagine Neo fighting in a Chinese subway station? How much more boring that would be!
Lol, Matric & Marvel heroes, the US government have cockold its citizens. "The house of delusions is cheap to build, but drafty to live in." A E Housman.
In Nuremberg, Germany, there is also a driverless subway, even without staff at the front. So you can stand there by yourself and imagine being the driver xD But of course Nuremberg subway is a lot smaller, which is obvious if you think about that this city has only 1/30 the population of Shanghai...
Well, North American subway is a bit less developed from outside, but in many places it’s 24/7 and riding subway in the states it’s like an adventure for me, whereas in China you never expect to see something surprising
@@passby8070 you might’ve watched to many horror movies about nyc subway, yes it does look weird sometimes, but you wouldn’t feel any aggression towards you, American/Canadian people are usually way more polite and civilized than Chinese people (generally) and you are gonna feel it from the first hours after landing there, and even if you were attacked by anyone then people around you would help you out, whereas in China if you are in a sketchy situation then you are on your own
Lol, I got your drift. Riding in a US subway is like entering a dungeon. One wouldn't know when or what "unexpected," one would encounter inside, or whether one would come out of it alive.
In USA the taxpayers exists to benefit the government and the corporations. In China the government exists to the benefits of the taxpayers ways of living. That's the big difference of those two government systems.
Great Video, Good Editing and Comments! Keep up your good Work! ❤ from USA! Your work help educating the American here to know what going on in the World 🌎! I am a loyal US citizen, I wish all American know how Far we are behind the World 🌎 , especially China! We need our government to spend more money in Education, Infrastructure etc. and not Military Weapons to invade the World under their so called Democracy !!! American are digging their Heads in the Send like an Australian Ostrich in the Desert because they are so ignorant under their Fake News Propaganda Government Control Network, so that we are all Blind Folded in US by Satan = Anti Christ!!! US create thousands of Lawyers every year! They are all Career politicians work selfishly for their own political interests and for their country folks! While China spending Huge Amount of money on Education to produce millions of skillful dedicated Scientists and Engineers to build infrastructures! That's makes an Amazing difference!!! It takes a century for America to Risk Up to a Super Power while China only takes 20 to 40 years to Rise Up to be a Global Leader 20 years ahead of the Western World 🌎 NOW, if you seriously do a research on You Tube or Google about Top 20 Cities in China or China Infrastructure, Speed Rail, Mega Projects, Military Power etc . !!!
There are nothing to do comparison at all. China subway are easy 50 years ahead from advanced, cleanest, safety and fully organized. Look at NY subway, its stinks, dirty, so rundown and no safety at all. 😂
This is one view - One must bear in mind that China's beautiful subways are very new while most of US's system is very old. The US can't upgrade their aging system due to many reasons, the primary one is money. Most of its budget is spent on warfare than its ordinary citizens. Of course they can issue bonds or print more dollars but that'll just add up to the trillions of $$ debt .... well, you can figure it
The US Metros and trains may be ageing but is there any excuse for not keeping it all clean and spotless? Do elderly people stop taking baths and deodorants simply because they are getting old? One should stop making excuses for bad social behavior and bad attitudes towards one's own public property and have some pride enough to maintain them instead of having graffiti and foul language defaced across public walls and trains with slashed seats and smashed windows. These have nothing to do with whether something is new or old.
The United States should shift its war investment to the construction and maintenance of infrastructure, so that it will get a more beautiful subway than China.
As per China's national poverty line, 8.5 percent of people were in poverty in 2013, which decreased to 1.7 percent in 2018. On 6 March 2020, Xi Jinping, the General Secretary of the Chinese Communist Party, announced that by 2020, China will achieve all poverty alleviation in rural areas.
Some of the Asian countries have the best infrastructure. Our Governments are by the people & for the people, stay within our means, and not for policing the whole world in the name of self declared international law, that got no mandate from any authority.
Moscow subway was opened 15 of May 1935 at 07:00 am, so google to see it after those 89 years in service. And during WW2 it was also used as bomb shelter. US is getting behind in almost everything, and the uneducated US population is brain washed withsome US pipe dream that turned to nightmare long time ago.
Please god and help the good American citizens that has to sleep in tent cities that are cold and hungry. The USA is the only country in the world that does not have a real government to take care of its own citizens.
@@theasianjaywalker4455 Don’t go to Chiina! Foreigner will be put into jail if you say Taiwan passport or Taiwan president That's why foreigners are leaving Chiina NOW
@@zackk4969 Hi caveman, You see people in the trains not in the stations because trains arriving every 2-3 minutes. You see people in NY stations because they're not many trains available and trains are late.
I came back from Shanghai for the first time and it was just living in a futuristic world Amazing 🤩 …oh yeah the transport especially the train system was never late it was on average 20sec early … Sydney where I live is disgusting nothing but cancellation and replacement buses …the west have got it wrong
It was nothing more than a transportation track for transporting slave workers. It is not as full of human rights as the New York subway. For example, the New York subway can express freedom of speech with graffiti, and can jump over the ticket gates to escape the oppression of capitalism. The rats in the subway also express their love for animals.
I would suggest Alex to show us the Shanghai Subway Line #1, which is the first line and started to run around 20 year ago。 I believe it is still clean and comfortable though with age。
@@banarama4144 Moscow Metro is a museum built under a much different system than the USA system which is much more utilitarian. New York City maintains its museums. It's also not 24/7. Moscow's train stations are very impressive.
I like how you show nyc dumpster subways. Most embarrassing thing i have ever seen. You see rats, homeless, mentally ill, and crimes all over. HOw do i know, unfortunately, i live there. POS city.
I used to live and commute in Paris. My nose got used to the smell. Whenever I revisit Paris, oh boy, the bad smell of the old world, raw sewage, and other smells cause nausea. But after a few days, the body adapts and everything is fine. The scenes from NY subways are terrible! The Chinese subways look good and worthy of the investment. Chinese new airports are also world-class level. When it comes to cleaners, Singapore is still probably #1.
The NYC subway holds a special place in my heart; it’s a constant reminder of the hustle and determination needed to achieve my goals. With perseverance, I envision the day when I’ll be behind the wheel of my own car.
Don't be biased and have unfair n poor judgement on bothe countries rail. Not because NYC or America are no good on their rail systems , NYC are very old rail system and have no space for expansion not because they can't expand due to already hundred years whereas china have hugh empty land thats why they can build as long as the snake can sizzle. Don't compared juat for the sake of comparing but must looked back when America have rail china still sleeping so china now have progressed congratulations to them not beacsue they are smart rather they are building at the era of high technologies and good equipment that allowed them to produce better rail systems.
I sit around all the time thinking about how great China's subways are, so jealous. I've never been on one and never will, I'll drive, if I'm ever in a city that has one.
You show a new station in China but no, not one, new station on the NYC system. You show an R32 train in an early clip yet the R32 train was retired from service a long time ago. You did not show a new subway train like the R211. You can't really compare the systems. The NYC system is much older and is 24/7 and NYC is a way different type of environment than China. That's not to say the Chinese train isn't impressive. But showing the worst of the NYC system and not a balanced representation is doing a disservice to any real comparison.
This is a bad reason. There are many things in the world that were built early, including subways, many of which are very good. The subways in Beijing, China and some subways in Japan are very old, and they are still very good now. modern, clean, orderly and safe. What's wrong with the UK and the United States? They started so early and had so much time to develop, upgrade, and update, but they seemed to have done nothing, even the simplest task of maintaining environmental hygiene was done in a mess.
US government : We mainly serve capital not public.
China government : We mainly serve public not capital.
If you lose the public you will lose your capital. If you serve the public they will earn you capital.
Spoken like a true spy.
@@IronKnee963spies speak truth
@@IronKnee963 The spy who speaks true.
@@MarkMiller304中国在公路及铁路，地铁上不但不赚钱，还是亏损的，这是给人民的福利，激励人民勤劳致富，不做懒虫，勇于出去发展😂😂
The US 🇺🇸 rather spend the money 💵 on weapons, defense spending, aiding wars in another country than it's own citizen's welfare like health care, homelessness issues, improving infrastructures and so on.
Homeless.
th-cam.com/users/shortsipXquJ0i-B4?si=HPksUJxVEiKy-tbK
It's because average to below income people don't matter to them. Just so long that the top 1% stay on top and continue to get richer, that's all that really matters to them. Also, in a capitalist society, there can be no rich without the working poor. It's just how things work with that kind of system unfortunately.
@@rsuriyop China has more extremely poor people living on $1500 USD/year (600 million) than the US even has people(330 million). So please explain how that works? Why is China still trying to keep "Developing nation" status with the WTO if all the people are doing so well?
U r fake news !
@@rsuriyop
Yep, you're right. Especially those weapon manufacturers (military industrial complex) in the US, they are getting richer and richer.
Love China’s subway station they all clean and safe without any homeless or trash.
Agree
th-cam.com/video/UpJshh_qdXw/w-d-xo.html&si=d2_usVL91QwV0kwy
The streets are just as safe, even at night!
I've never seen a homeless person in China.
Not really. China had move poverty.
I went on the Shanghai metro in 2018, and I was astounded. The network was so vast and deep down, you could take journeys of escalators going down or up, especially in an interchange station. Thousands would be on their phones because wifi was already widespread underground. Everything was so seemless and in order, and was very cheap. I’ve travelled on the Shanghai maglev and China’s high speed rail system. It is world class! It’s great to see your authentic shots of China Subway VS America Subway in your videos.I am so impressed by this. I only wish we have such modern and convenience transport system in the US. It is so dirty and dated in the US. China is allot more modern and developed than I expected! Our media in the West always tells us China is collapsing.
When China collapsed last time, I was still a 14-year-old boy. 10 years later, I am now a single mother with a daughter, and China is still on the brink of collapse
Western media is the media of its capitalist and so their interest.
US has a car culture, public transportation within a metropolitan area by rail & buses is not prioritized leading to under-investment to the point of neglect. Hence most of the subway systems is in the state they're in right now. But the road transport network system to cater to road vehicles - freeways, highways, wide boulevards, etc. are modern, extensive & well-maintained.
@@tweedy4sg - "well-maintained"? Try to drive on New York City streets and many other big cities.
@@tweedy4sgYou can see China has huge amount of cars now even in the small villages in the countryside and express way in China is also super good and convenient. China government cares more for their people
It’s worth getting the subway just to see the fantastic stations!!
Not only 🇺🇸 the US is jealous about China's subway but they are also angry, envy and shock. 😆 🤣
@@moeza114 Evidence? I'll wait.
Hilarious to think that US citizens get jealous over subways lol! Most of us own 60-100 k trucks , Harleys , Boats and RVs ! Our food isn’t cooked In oil from the gutters ? We can actually go fishing because our natural lakes havnt been fished into extinction! Our air isn’t so polluted we can’t see the building across the road ! No doors on public toilets in China let alone toilet paper ! Old people spitting everywhere ! If this ever has a kid their grandparents will refer to them as wai guo ren 😂😂😂! Most of us Americans live in 3+ bedroo 2+ bath houses with big gardens and big bbqs ! Most Chinese people live in crappy little apartments that look like they are gonna fall apart after 5 years!
There is a reason why 90 percent of Chinese would leave China for America or the west if they had the chance 😂😂😂
I could go on all day lol … congratulations on you flashy subways though!!
@@davidgmaloof
You don't have to wait, it already happened.
Ask yourself, why the US keep provoking China with sanctions, ban certain products export to China and so on. On morons can't see that is happening or pretend not to notice that. 😆
@@davidgmaloof
evidence ?
Then why the US impose trade sanction and ban certain products example, semi conductor chips to China, what got the US fear about ?
@@davidgmaloof
You don't have to wait, the evidence was all along there till now. For example, just look at the NYC subway station worn down condition and the trains condition, those trains look like crap and once you step into the train, it smell like 💩 and very often people fight inside the train, commuters sometime get mugged by scumbags and even gun shooting happened also. Davidgmaloof, do you dare to deny that ?
Brilliant video! It took Shanghai from no metro to the world's biggest in just 15 years. I have updated my record of it as my record back in 2021 was it had only 398 stations and not 508 today. It was just 800km long but now 826km in total length.
I love China!! ❤❤❤
I couldn't agree more. Long live China!
二位不要演了。
为什么要演？我也爱中国哦
China is now more beautyful than usa
Don't go to the china!
Hello Alex, I just found your channel now and I enjoyed this subway comparison, there's no doubt China's transport system is the most advanced on earth, cleanest, safest and most efficient. Did I forget cheapest too? If you upload regular content I shall subscribe and look forward to watching more. 🇨🇳👍
Welcome aboard!
@@MrAlexCage thank you 👍
China has the best infrastructure
Outside top 50. 1 million Tibetan children had to leave home for boarding school because of such appalling infrastructure.
@@JohnSmith-sm7ezbefore 1950? You are correct
@@JohnSmith-sm7ez
Tibetan live a better life than a million homeless in your country.
According to the World Economic Forum, the US infrastructure ranks second in the world, behind only Singapore. China ranks #36.
Oh, and here's the link if you're allowed to click it. www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_TheGlobalCompetitivenessReport2019.pdf
Russian metro stations is also clean and beautiful
莫斯科地铁站非常漂亮且具有艺术气息，简直就是地下宫殿
俄罗斯本就是深具艺术气质得文明大国
You talking about Moscow ! What is communist decorated is very nice but many old trains and not that clean
@@EA00000Zionist
我是中国人，很奇怪你们会以新旧来衡量事物，在我们看来物品可以旧，但是收拾的干净整洁，那依然是很棒的
as a Chinese. I'm shocked why foreigners are surprised at there is no graffiti on the wall.
No graffiti on the wall because Chinese people are more civilized and have better education than American people…
Coz we don't have clean walls.
@@MrAlexCage但你们有自由😂
@@danningsun7556在美国没在中国自由的。
@@danningsun7556in amerikka people have freedom to be homeless. In China people have freedom to live in a clean environment with basic hygiene.
chinese mindset is 22nd century more advance ny other country cleanliness is mind blowing 😮😮
To Confucius. “In a country well governed, poverty is something to be ashamed of.
In a country badly governed, wealth is something to be ashamed of.”
You're talking about Confucius? In America nobody knows word Confucius. That word is ET for America. Actually Confucius 👍👌👏 is a FIRST that we called today Communist. Second is a Jesus Christ. If it's something to profit American would be first to know about it. Confucius lived in 575 BC. He's to advanced for American leaches Capitalist System.
You're talking about Confucius? In America nobody knows word Confucius. That word is ET for America. Actually Confucius 👍👌👏 is a FIRST that we called today Communist. Second is a Jesus Christ. If it's something to profit American would be first to know about it. Confucius lived in China 575 BC. He's toooooo advanced for American leaches Capitalist System.
🎉You're talking about Confucius? In America nobody knows word Confucius. That word is ET for America. Actually Confucius 👍👌👏 is a FIRST that we called today Communist. Second is a Jesus Christ. If it's something to profit American would be first to know about it. Confucius lived in China 575 BC. He's toooo advanced for American leaches Capitalist System.
Wow.. The 2nd quote clearly says about my country (India). 😢
China calls America in Mandarin ... Beautiful Country !
It means ....America is A Beautiful Country .
Now ,
I see China is A Beautiful Country .
It's meant to be phonetic, not literal.
@@natn41r
Now China calls USA 尾国 "tail nation". 😂
FYI USA has been unofficially referred to as an" Ugly Country" on Chinese social media and almost all Chinese bloggers now.
I think they should use 霉國. Directly translated as a rotten country.
1) All Chinese had been indirectly BRaiNWaSHed by the UK Troops to FEAR & to ReSPeCT the Collective--West for more than 100 yrs to be SLAVEs of the US--UK--German--France.
2) The ProoFs are so Obvious.
Just check the Chinese Names & the Direct Translations of All these 4 white nations above.
3) The Super AMaZinG thing is 99.999% of Chinese are totally UnAware of these UK OPiuM Dealers BrainwashinG.
There are still so many hidden older generations Self--HaTinG Chinese inside PRC CHN who are very much worshipping their Colonial Western Masters &
4) They are being extra willing to act as CIA Spies. ** ( these may include XI JinPinG & many inside his team BeiJing team who had been studying in USA.
😮😮😮
Considering China 's population is 4X larger than the United States, there's absolutely no excuse for its public spaces and local transits to be in such a dismal condition. Just goes to show what the government thinks of its city and its citizens.
You haven't mentioned the ticket price. I had been there twice. It is 7 or 8 RMB ($1) for the longest distance and 2 RMB for a short distance such as 3 stations. Can't remember exactly.
This is why it's not making money.
3 yuan is the basic price but anyway it will just cost you less than one dollar in the most circumstances and 2 dollars to anywhere in the underground
@@PunditKING In Europe it's the same. Public services are *NOT* meant to make money. In the US, even healthcare is a money-making industry!!! 😲
@@BlackHoleSpain this is not a public service. It a train line where you pay for its use.
Amazing CHINA we LOVE you ❤
Its wrong to compare China & US
Its akin to comparing an Art student (US) & Science student (China)
That's why there are millions of engineers, scientists & builders from China
In US there are millions of lawyers, salesmen & sweet talkers.
美国这么有钱，为什么不翻新一下他们的地铁？
American politicians approved 300 millions dollars to promote anti China propaganda machine around the world instead of using the money to focus on their citizens and its infrastructures🎈
都换成枪炮弹药去把别的国家打成稀巴烂了
China is so great , why were they such a disgrace to humanity for so long.
资本家有钱而已。地铁是重投资，收益却只能在其他方面综合体现的，所以不是公有制国家，靠私营资本很难健康运营。
翻新地铁不能使资本家获利
Jualous is right , we are F..
It doesn't matter what people want to improve American's public, people will always ruin it.
I have seen people don't care anything brand new buildings and public metro.
It's amazing that the Chinese citizens don't damage their public properties. You don't see paintings on the walls or broken glasses at the bus stations.....
They understand that if things got destroyed, they will be the one that has to pay for it or suffer.
I'm learning everyday from them.
说的太对了。。。因为我们从小就是这样教导的！Well said... Because we have been taught this way since childhood!
In US, if someone damages public properties, the person is not held accountable but the public. All these are taught to US kids while they were little.
They are polite
I've lived in both New York City and San Francisco over the last 5 decades (yes I'm aging myself) and have had to use the subway systems in both places and both are filthy and with rats and homeless in the stations AND the mentally ill on the trains but........ truth be told when you use the systems day in and day out you really do get used to them and your mind just learns to block them all out and your only concern is for the train to show up and get you to where you're trying to get to.
Even if you block them out, can you block out the mindset that you are in a dangerous situation? Aren't you nervous? That's exhausting. A safe environment allows you to relax more and conserve energy.
@@cheneyli6332 *:* OBVIOUSLY YOU ONLY know the "heavenly clean HongKong and East Asian" metros and thus have never experienced metros in North America and WESTERN Europe.....
LIKE I SAID: I've been using metros/subways in the US since the 1970s before I was even an adolescent. Using the dirty, graffitied, LOUSY service subways for pretty much all my life AND THAT IS WHAT I'VE EXISTED WITH FOR AS LONG AS I REMEMBER OVER THE DECADES WHEN USING THE METRO/SUBWAY.
You HAVE to exist. You HAVE to live and that "living" means - for me at least as the vast majority of americans have never been anywhere close to a metro/subway - USING THE METRO/SUBWAY.
Because my "brain" is SOOOOOOO "acclimated" to the horrible conditions of american metros, the "brain doesn't notice" as LIKE I SAID, my "brain" is OVERWHELMINGLY CONCERNED WITH THE TRAIN JUST SHOWING UP SO I CAN GET TO WHERE I'M TRYING TO GET TO.
@@archstanton5973went a little excited there eh?
@@archstanton5973 I can't stand it that many New Yorkers pop their dirty shoes on the subway seats. US people generally are selfish, they may keep their home clean but not the public area.
❤🇨🇳❤️
Is the maintenance that NYC can’t do, renovation of a station will take 5 years . Just face it the MTA sucks
As Chinese, we take going out without fear at any time for granted.😊
In China, the govt is doing its job and not working towards elections and voters. In US, govt talks a lot to win voters, without the need to improve the lifes of its citizens, and yet they are elected. So which systems benefits the citizens.. think about it.
Should be "The world cannot compete with China's subway. America and Engdia jealous"
Well, we sure can compete with China's stock market though (which currently sits at 10 year negative levels)...
@@chopsticksandtrains , you should boast that your people can sure compete with China's population as your people are far more productive in baby making than China.
America and India are third world countries 😂😂😂
Bruh India is out of the question lmfao
Only USA and china
Also things to note is, the 4g/5g/6g what ever cellular connection you have, coming down to the metro there is no blind spot for disconnection.
That is why chinese youths like to play online games for their commuting.
Almost no Internet in NYC underground.
@@hyc1266 Even Madrid, Spain has 5G repeaters all along their 300 subway stations and 300 km of tunnels!
America's subway is 10x times the price of China's subway - and you get to experience some scary ride
You have the freedom to film in a subway station.
In the UK, filming are not permitted.
Maybe they want to hide something.
metro in China is truly amazing, I can safely say its the best by a country mile...
I live in NY, NYC subway system is so old, piss spots, homeless people, chewing gum spots, lacking of bathrooms are all common.
那不是很正常的事情 以昂撒和犹太人组成的垄断阶级指望他们给底层修建好的福利根本不可能 她只要保护好世家利益
Most of the trains aren't that old. It's not as bad as a lot of people are making it out to be. The system is old but is being modernized with CTBC signalling.
World most clean city China ❤
And JAPAN ❤❤
Japan is overstated, false, and as you can tell from your in-depth knowledge, Japan is a very hypocritical people. Serves them right for eating plum barbecue.
Most Asian countries are clean
China , korea , Japan , Singapore etc
Heck even north Korea is clean af
我来自中国很想和你做朋友
East Asia 🎉
America was, what it was till few years ago. But China has reigned over that for the last few yesrs already.
Don't denigrate the NYC subway station. That's the only kind of subway station where you can film Matrix. Can you imagine Neo fighting in a Chinese subway station? How much more boring that would be!
Lol, Matric & Marvel heroes, the US government have cockold its citizens.
"The house of delusions is cheap to build, but drafty to live in."
A E Housman.
👍👍👍
This is why East Asian Transports more developed than Western Transportation. Japan, South Korea, Singapore, China ETC
In Nuremberg, Germany, there is also a driverless subway, even without staff at the front. So you can stand there by yourself and imagine being the driver xD
But of course Nuremberg subway is a lot smaller, which is obvious if you think about that this city has only 1/30 the population of Shanghai...
Well, North American subway is a bit less developed from outside, but in many places it’s 24/7 and riding subway in the states it’s like an adventure for me, whereas in China you never expect to see something surprising
Yeah and I am not the adventurous type, I rather not see anything surprising in a subway
if you like to live your life on the edge and look for adrenaline yeah... I just like to travel in a clean, peaceful and safe environment.
@@passby8070 you might’ve watched to many horror movies about nyc subway, yes it does look weird sometimes, but you wouldn’t feel any aggression towards you, American/Canadian people are usually way more polite and civilized than Chinese people (generally) and you are gonna feel it from the first hours after landing there, and even if you were attacked by anyone then people around you would help you out, whereas in China if you are in a sketchy situation then you are on your own
Lol, I got your drift.
Riding in a US subway is like entering a dungeon. One wouldn't know when or what "unexpected," one would encounter inside, or whether one would come out of it alive.
@@TheFriend2u you can be sure that you will come out alive and safe, let’s be honest about that
In USA the taxpayers exists to benefit the government and the corporations.
In China the government exists to the benefits of the taxpayers ways of living.
That's the big difference of those two government systems.
Great Video, Good Editing and Comments! Keep up your good Work! ❤ from USA!
Your work help educating the American here to know what going on in the World 🌎!
I am a loyal US citizen, I wish all American know how Far we are behind the World 🌎 , especially China!
We need our government to spend more money in Education, Infrastructure etc. and not Military Weapons to invade the World under their so called Democracy !!!
American are digging their Heads in the Send like an Australian Ostrich in the Desert because they are so ignorant under their Fake News Propaganda Government Control Network, so that we are all Blind Folded in US by Satan = Anti Christ!!!
US create thousands of Lawyers every year! They are all Career politicians work selfishly for their own political interests and for their country folks! While China spending Huge Amount of money on Education to produce millions of skillful dedicated Scientists and Engineers to build infrastructures!
That's makes an Amazing difference!!!
It takes a century for America to Risk Up to a Super Power while China only takes 20 to 40 years to Rise Up to be a Global Leader 20 years ahead of the Western World 🌎 NOW, if you seriously do a research on You Tube or Google about Top 20 Cities in China or China Infrastructure, Speed Rail, Mega Projects, Military Power etc . !!!
Thanks. ✌️
Cant American democracy build trains stations ?
There are nothing to do comparison at all. China subway are easy 50 years ahead from advanced, cleanest, safety and fully organized. Look at NY subway, its stinks, dirty, so rundown and no safety at all. 😂
That is a film studio, not a metro station.
I been to both country and definitely know how to differentiate. I’m not from China.
You should see the new turnstiles they installed to prevent fare beaters. They’re even easier to defeat than the old ones.
This is one view - One must bear in mind that China's beautiful subways are very new while most of US's system is very old. The US can't upgrade their aging system due to many reasons, the primary one is money. Most of its budget is spent on warfare than its ordinary citizens. Of course they can issue bonds or print more dollars but that'll just add up to the trillions of $$ debt .... well, you can figure it
The US Metros and trains may be ageing but is there any excuse for not keeping it all clean and spotless? Do elderly people stop taking baths and deodorants simply because they are getting old? One should stop making excuses for bad social behavior and bad attitudes towards one's own public property and have some pride enough to maintain them instead of having graffiti and foul language defaced across public walls and trains with slashed seats and smashed windows. These have nothing to do with whether something is new or old.
The United States should shift its war investment to the construction and maintenance of infrastructure, so that it will get a more beautiful subway than China.
Show everyone Your Chinese passport in Your next video
Just came back from Shanghai and used a lot Shanghai metro for transportation. What you said is all true. 👍👍👍
US gov: I would have banned China metro if I could.
.....US Gov - Now you make us look incompetent and bad 😢
BBCNN :
How much do ccp pay you ?
Are you ccp ?
Have you ever been ccp ?
Do you have a passport of ccp?
Do you ... whatever ccp ?
😂😂😂
Does ccp subscribe to your TikTok channel?😁
tiktok CEO😂
Eekkkk yesss 😬
I am surprised. Guangzhou metro is convenient but packed with people.
Which is better, no people or packed with people?
'shooting occurred as the train was traveling between the 59th Street and 36th Street stations. 2022 New York City Subway attack.' - CNN News 2023
As per China's national poverty line, 8.5 percent of people were in poverty in 2013, which decreased to 1.7 percent in 2018. On 6 March 2020, Xi Jinping, the General Secretary of the Chinese Communist Party, announced that by 2020, China will achieve all poverty alleviation in rural areas.
And to think Kamala Harris went full scale cackling over buses with USB ports to charge phones. 😂😂😂
Thise floors behind you are pretty dang shiny.
The US govt was busy with the construction of democracy, no time to consider the subway.
The US gov't is busy with the construction of democracy in OTHER countries but US.
Some of the Asian countries have the best infrastructure. Our Governments are by the people & for the people, stay within our means, and not for policing the whole world in the name of self declared international law, that got no mandate from any authority.
American subway system looks like shit hole.
New York Subway was built in the 70's and you really can't make that type of comparison. Its like comparing a Tesla to a 1970s american K car.
The conditions of the subway shouldn’t be an excuse just because it was built in the 70s. Where is the pride ?
北京第一条地铁在1970年开通还是保持得很好
Bullshit, heard of upgrade? Use your trillions wisely and not on forever wars and weapons.
Moscow subway was opened 15 of May 1935 at 07:00 am, so google to see it after those 89 years in service. And during WW2 it was also used as bomb shelter. US is getting behind in almost everything, and the uneducated US population is brain washed withsome US pipe dream that turned to nightmare long time ago.
Moscow subways are very old too
Did you compare the cost of the 2 systems?
US: I’m bored, let’s go invade someone.
China: I’m bored. Let’s build a railway.
US: I’m broke. Let’s invade someone.
China: I’m broke. Let’s build a smaller railway.
Please god and help the good American citizens that has to sleep in tent cities that are cold and hungry. The USA is the only country in the world that does not have a real government to take care of its own citizens.
USA is by far not the only country...
The most unacceptable thing of the American subway, is the price, far more expensive than that of China.
Chiina is dooomed
Nobody is in the station!
@@theasianjaywalker4455 Don’t go to Chiina!
Foreigner will be put into jail if you say
Taiwan passport or Taiwan president
That's why foreigners are leaving Chiina NOW
@@theasianjaywalker4455swollow your pull now please
50time, you live in what, 60s'?@@theasianjaywalker4455
@@zackk4969
Hi caveman,
You see people in the trains not in the stations because trains arriving every 2-3 minutes.
You see people in NY stations because they're not many trains available and trains are late.
I came back from Shanghai for the first time and it was just living in a futuristic world Amazing 🤩 …oh yeah the transport especially the train system was never late it was on average 20sec early … Sydney where I live is disgusting nothing but cancellation and replacement buses …the west have got it wrong
Your English easily understand, I like your video
Glad to hear that
It was nothing more than a transportation track for transporting slave workers. It is not as full of human rights as the New York subway. For example, the New York subway can express freedom of speech with graffiti, and can jump over the ticket gates to escape the oppression of capitalism. The rats in the subway also express their love for animals.
There's hardly any graffiti on NYC subways or stations anymore and hasn't been for a long time.
Its unfair to compare subway with US. Let compare weapons...LOL.
I would suggest Alex to show us the Shanghai Subway Line #1, which is the first line and started to run around 20 year ago。
I believe it is still clean and comfortable though with age。
Gotcha! I will soon!
@@MrAlexCageGood! I’m looking forward to seeing it
And how old is the NYC system?
@@benjaminsmith2287Moscow metro was built in the 30s and very clean and very well maintained
@@banarama4144 Moscow Metro is a museum built under a much different system than the USA system which is much more utilitarian. New York City maintains its museums. It's also not 24/7. Moscow's train stations are very impressive.
Even I want to move to China.
I like how you show nyc dumpster subways. Most embarrassing thing i have ever seen. You see rats, homeless, mentally ill, and crimes all over. HOw do i know, unfortunately, i live there. POS city.
I used to live and commute in Paris. My nose got used to the smell. Whenever I revisit Paris, oh boy, the bad smell of the old world, raw sewage, and other smells cause nausea. But after a few days, the body adapts and everything is fine. The scenes from NY subways are terrible! The Chinese subways look good and worthy of the investment. Chinese new airports are also world-class level. When it comes to cleaners, Singapore is still probably #1.
事实上在中国，我们也认为新加坡会更干净一些。中国与新加坡干净的方式不太相同，中国靠大量的清洁工作以及少部分特定的罚款，新加坡从根源解决问题，他们有大量的高额罚款。这是一种面向结果的取舍，我不会说哪个更好，只要适合并达成目标就好了。
The NYC subway holds a special place in my heart; it’s a constant reminder of the hustle and determination needed to achieve my goals. With perseverance, I envision the day when I’ll be behind the wheel of my own car.
How do people from my country(🇮🇳) literally compare bangalore and Ahmedabad metro to this😂
Correction:
Americans are not "jealous" of any subway system. Americans drive cars. No subway can come anywhere close to what a car can do.
Don't be biased and have unfair n poor judgement on bothe countries rail. Not because NYC or America are no good on their rail systems , NYC are very old rail system and have no space for expansion not because they can't expand due to already hundred years whereas china have hugh empty land thats why they can build as long as the snake can sizzle. Don't compared juat for the sake of comparing but must looked back when America have rail china still sleeping so china now have progressed congratulations to them not beacsue they are smart rather they are building at the era of high technologies and good equipment that allowed them to produce better rail systems.
Another useless video of foreign visitors making comparisons, already annoying, show something different
What do you expect? It's expensive being The Master of the Universe.
Imagine resident evil playing in a chinese subway station... boring! Get inspired America is the way to go.
I sit around all the time thinking about how great China's subways are, so jealous. I've never been on one and never will, I'll drive, if I'm ever in a city that has one.
Need to redefine a few things at this point: 1) What is Third World; 2) What progress means; 3) What an authoritarian regime is;
I collect the vouchers and coupons from the internet, so I take subway always for free.
NY city subway are much more better than China 🤣🤣🤣
Now the comparison 😂😂😂 sorry there is none, China wins hands down 🎉🎉
How brave you are to take the subway in US! Its stinky and gross!
California and texas are building high speed train too
No a single person in the station? What's happening? There should be a ton of people, did they film it at middle of night?
Charity Biggins in home wake up USA and UK no more money going to who ?
there is no poverty in China ~ just like Kerala
the subway belong to gov means all chinese people not the company so dont need ad in it
👍👍🇨🇳👏👏✌️✌️
Endia moody said endia train are worlds best , endia .
You show a new station in China but no, not one, new station on the NYC system. You show an R32 train in an early clip yet the R32 train was retired from service a long time ago. You did not show a new subway train like the R211.
You can't really compare the systems. The NYC system is much older and is 24/7 and NYC is a way different type of environment than China. That's not to say the Chinese train isn't impressive. But showing the worst of the NYC system and not a balanced representation is doing a disservice to any real comparison.
This is a bad reason. There are many things in the world that were built early, including subways, many of which are very good. The subways in Beijing, China and some subways in Japan are very old, and they are still very good now. modern, clean, orderly and safe. What's wrong with the UK and the United States? They started so early and had so much time to develop, upgrade, and update, but they seemed to have done nothing, even the simplest task of maintaining environmental hygiene was done in a mess.
Oh man come and see india trains and metros u will be amazed ..
06:17 just in case that someone'bag or hair got caught by the doors, so he can open the door manually.
Gotcha! Thanks
Это вы ещё Московское метро не видели
莫斯科地铁非常具有设计感且艺术气息浓厚宛如地下宫殿，值得我们学习
@@hailianjia 学习个JB
Mr alex!Shameful on u USA
US not jealous of tofu choo choo😂
If we didn't believe what you showed in the video in China, we would say you 😂had a fake background.
😂
Why it so empty?
Shanghai suppose to be economic powerhouse of China?
Chinese new year time.