Our Taste Test of the Best Extra-Virgin Olive Oil at the Supermarket
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2024
- Tasting expert Jack Bishop challenges Julia to a tasting of supermarket extra-virgin olive oil.
Buy our winning Olive Oil: bit.ly/3WwKQ9g
Read our full review of Supermarket Extra-Virgin Olive Oil: cooks.io/2KLmANy
Watch What's Eating Dan - Olive Oil: • The Science of Olive O...
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America's Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
americastestkit...
/ americastestkitchen
/ testkitchen
/ testkitchen
/ testkitchen
I like that Julie tastes while Jack explains. That's quality viewing and not drawn out.
Yeah, it's a great format.
This whole channel is the finest instructional video content ever made. It's genius. Even if you're not into cooking, if you want to know how to make an instructional/education video for...whatever...study this channel
We did a taste test in Italy, the region of Tuscany, during the carefree travel days....How you described it, is exactly how we approached the tasting and we all had our favorite. Of course we were in the middle of Tuscany, on a warm sunny day, surrounded by olive trees, amazing company, good wine and incredible cheese, so may have influenced our entire tasting experience. Non the less, I don’t view olive oil the same anymore and have found that the Kirkland 100% Italian Extra Virgin, cold extracted olive oil from Costco is quite nice for the price.
I couple days ago I got a bottle from my friends in Umbria. The oil is green as most olives are. I wish I could take a pix and show it to you. These olives were handpicked, the entire batch was not mixed with any other olives from the region or even from the neighbor's tree, all where taken to a frantoio and cold pressed with a stone wheel! It's so good!
Why can't you ?
@@6gbarton , because TH-cam comments can't show photos, in case you haven't noticed.
Control@@Birdylockso
I've been using California Olive Ranch for a long, long time. It is consistently fresh and delicious.
it is very good, especially at that price
@@richardwallace6313 Unfortunately, it is no longer made from only CA olives. It's now a blend.
@@AbsoluteNut1 unfortunate
Same here.
@@AbsoluteNut1 No they have both available. One is a global blend and one is 100% California olives.
I appreciate these taste tests. As someone who is admittedly ignorant of sooooo many things culinary, I find the ATK suggestions a good place to start. Often after a purchase I don't agree with the top choice, but the runners-up sometimes work for me. It helps me try something new without forming my opinion based on a lower-grade sample.
@Bo Zo Right on. Same thing with Beer and Liquors.
This isnt real olive oil its american crap
@@whitealliance9540 What exactly makes it fake tho?
@@silvergarcia9897 the american manufacturing process makes it fake. They didnt press olives like they do now.... Thousands of years ago they pressed olives 1 way to make oil. Some handmade oil and middle east oil is real. But this crap is crap. Real olive oil is so good you can drink it from a shot glass... Its creamy, rich, clean aftertaste. Low earth tones. And sweet.
@@whitealliance9540 Just because the oil is extracted differently doesn't mean it's not olive oil. And let's be honest the current supply and demand wouldn't support olive oil if it was hand pressed only.
When this test was conducted, California Olive Ranch really was purely from California. I know that because I always bought it. In the ensuing months, it is now blended with oils from other countries, sorry to say, probably to keep the price steady.
UPDATE: the California version is now available in the New York City metro area, and that’s what I’ve been buying. Definitely a higher-quality product than the other mass market brands.
Yup...I smelled the difference right away...they fucked it up.
The reason they sourced olives from other countries was because of the poor olive harvest last year in California. Hopefully things will return to normal this year. As far as olive oil is concerned.
@@derfnoslein1178 I cant see them going back to more expensive olives...once they go cheaper that's it.
Oh their own locally grown California olives are less costly and usually higher quality. You have to add transportation costs to the imported stuff as well.
No they take pride in their product and have noted all the complaints. I think they will return to standards with next harvest.
They should definitely redo this test now that the main offering from California Olive Ranch is the “Destination Series” which is a blend from a number of different countries (and the 100% California olive oil is now a premium product with a pretty label so they can charge more for the same olive oil they were already selling.)
@CJ Wilemon But you're using TH-cam.
@@pf6112 lol
@CJ Wilemon I'm guessing you're from West Virginia?
Cali oil was always premium . The new blends are just cheaper since local oils more expensive .
Cali evoo was sold at Aldi until about two years ago it cost $5.99 for 500ml.
I just bought a bottle of the California Olive Ranch oil based on this video. It says 100% California on the front label, a sticker on the front, on the back label, and has a number of certification seals on it, and a Dec '19 harvest date.
That's the only one I found..
It would have been interesting if you sent samples to universities to perform tests on the authenticity of the EVOs
got a troll on here after me for saying the same
THE lady in this video that is drinking all this OLIVE OIL, will be running to the bathroom WITHIN the next 15min at the less
@@gwendolynmyers4248 You may want to get both your digestive system and your caps lock key checked out.
There are labs that are certified for testing olive oils by the international olive council (ioc). These labs have very specialized equipment and have trained tasters (like myself) that determine if oils have any levels of defects.
2 years late, but according to the review they have! They sent it to the official olive oil council which said that all but 2 were disappointing and had critical flaws. They also sent them to a lab (in another tasting I believe) to test for if they were extra virgin or not (which was defined by certain amounts of aromatic compounds I believe)
Nick Stellino has a cooking show on "Create". He's Sicilian. I recall one thing he said on one of his shows, "The best olive oils have a slightly sweet taste." I remember my Sicilian grandmother. Even during WWII she had olive oil sent to her from Sicily. It was superb for her sauce, which was outstanding and great for dipping. I remember the olive oil she had wasn't oily, had a nice smooth flavor and it wasn't peppery.
I get Kirkland Signature Extra Virgin Italian Olive Oil, 2 L. We use it for all our oil needs. From dipping to frying.
Agreed. I've used it for some time (the organic version).
ME AS WELL ,,ITS REAL OLIVE OIL ,,, NOT THUG LOSER OIL
the Trader Joe's California EVOO is fantastic and only $6.49 for a tall bottle
I'm an EVOO snob, having worked in a boutique. California Olive Ranch is an extraordinary, lovely domestic oil. I've used it since it launched.
i dont care for the taste of grass. prefer oils from older trees and old school.
@@horsepastetosy2587
They have a variety of oils, all different.
Such as the Greek Koroneiki olive, some olives import a grassy quality, some peppery, others buttery, etc. The process is of utmost importance, though, and theirs is solid.
You are correct about age. One reason Cali oils are finally becoming worthwhile is that the trees are finally coming of age!
@@BantiarnaMacRaghnaill Stage of ripeness tends to give more to the flavour than age of the tree. Old trees, old vines are marketing ploys.
Early harvested fruit tends towards green (think Vinho Verde) whilst very mature fruit (think German late harvested grapes) is softer.
ycart tosy, if you don’t like grassy tasting olive oil then don’t buy Italian olive oil because that’s the prominent note from Italian olive oil.
I See a Blond Clown that doesn’t know Oil
I used to use California Olive ranch until they went to the "destination" series. Now I use Partanna from Sicily. It's non GMO and has the harvest date on the bottle.
Albert Motyka there are no GMO olive oil. When you buy that brand with the non- GMO label, you are essentially paying extra for the label.
Thanks for this update and clarification on the “Destination” series. I use this brand, and didn’t know this!
@Albert Motyka
Joining @Linda Hart in thanking you for the update. Sorry to hear California Olive has degraded their product.
Redd Green please do your research first. By default, olive oil is non-gmo as no olive varietals exist that are gmo. However, the reason some oils use the label are that enzymes are used during olive milling, and these can be gmo or non-gmo.
Furthermore, whether you (or the brands) like it or not, some retailers require non-gmo certification regardless of if it’s warranted or not, so some brands will obtain it because they need to in order to access the retailers they want.
MasterShake9000 The topic is Virgin Olive Oil, by convention the label Virgin Olive Oil requires that oil is processed from the olive drupes using mechanical processes only with no chemical treatment (where is the enzyme there?). Further, producers pay for the non-GMO label, which is not an insignificant cost, especially for small operations. These costs are passed on to the consumers. I do not dissuade anyone from buying non-GMO, it is their choice, but they should know that there is an extra cost for their choice.
California Olive Branch is now mixed with olive from different countries. It also lost its certification from COOC. Sad.
They are back to domestic now.
@@mysterymeat586 I'll check it out. Thanks
I used to buy half liter bottles of California EVOO at Aldi---unfortunately no longer sold there. I refuse to buy their other so-called olive oils bec they are too low-priced to be trusted so I've had to do without.
@@rolex84 Yea, I wrote them an email and they said they had problems with supply of domestic sources They do still carry the foreign blend "Destination" so look for "Every Day". Your very welcome.
Only the destination series comes from other parts of the world. I only buy the 100% California. Says so on the front label.
I've used this brand for years now. Excellent quality and taste
At the end they unveiled the names of three brands of oil.
When writing a comment it's useful to remember that we can only read what you write, we can't read your mind.
@@youdoitillwatch lol
@@youdoitillwatch if you watched this video until the end then you'd know which one is voted "Best Pick". . No mind reading needed, just the ability to pay attention for four minutes and thirty seconds. Sorry I couldn't be there to hold your hand and walk you through this.
@@edmundblackaddercoc8522 sorry, can't help lazy fucks...
@@youdoitillwatch not my fucking problem. If you don't have the ability to watch a four minute and 30 second video to see the results maybe your Mommy can help you next time
How do I get a job as a guy in the background pretending to chop onions?
LOL!!!
Jim Crovatt LOL...right on!
Ohhh you must not be from the 50s
U r right!
Jim Crovatt There is a PhD program in onion chopping performative arts at Trump University.
I'm using a lot of olive oil grown and bottled here in southern Mexico. I get it at the local organic market and love the taste. I use it in place of butter and drink it during the day from tablespoons.
lol, who told you to drink oil?
I really like Pompeiian olive oil on veggies and salads. It smells and tastes a little fruity, like raspberries. But I use avocado oil for most cooking because it has a higher smoke point.
I've been using the California Olive Ranch olive oil for years and even though Ina Garten recommends something else (LOL) (much more expensive and hard to find) this is definitely my go to for everything. I'm happy to see the experts agree! Love your videos and watching you on Create TV.
I would have liked to have heard more about a larger number of Olive oils. They didn't even mention that some oils are not 100 percent olive oil. I heard that awhile back. You'd have thought they would have addressed that.
His tip on looking for country of origin can help avoid this issue. Even better look for varieties or singular varieties on the bottle. Common varieties in Spain for example are Hojiblanca, arbequina, cornicabra and picual. Just like you would look for a wine that had merlot grapes;) Always look for extra virgin olive oil. Good luck!
That omission jumped out at me also, since it's been fairly widely reported that even high-end products at pricey, allegedly health-conscious stores have been found to be adulterated with poor-quality oils. There's even an outfit (olive oil hunters?) that sells subscribers quarterly shipments at about $40/bottle after screening producers in person. Taste guidelines provided in this video may be useful, but there are serious health benefits to using good olive oil....
If Partanna was included in this test, it would win every time. These tests are never fair.
By sheer coincidence, California Olive Ranch is what I buy. I found it at my local Wegmans, liked the taste, and have been using it ever since.
California olive oil manufacturers are trying to replicate the success the state's wineries had versus the European brands. It is good.
Richard Dalin I would rather go local so I agree with you
Read your label. That CA oil is a blend. Exactly what they warned against!
I've always been told it depends on what you're using it for. Cooking vs Drizzling. I've been taught that for cooking you're better off with a cheaper oil.
From a money standpoint, a cheaper oil makes sense, but from a culinary standpoint there's no reason to not always use good EVOO. I like having fewer bottles with fresher oils in my cupboards. See: th-cam.com/video/l_aFHrzSBrM/w-d-xo.html
I bought some California Olive Ranch a couple years ago after seeing it highly rated on several sites, I was not disappointed. It turned out I had never tasted good olive oil before, as I had been buying a very cheap brand for years. First off I noticed it smelled fruity I thought, and just tasted good. I keep running out as I now use it on so many things.
Granted California Olive Ranch is good👍 But Carapelli is better😋
@@DangerousParent I'd like to try it but i haven't seen it in the store here, also i noticed prices have sky rocketed, and California Olive Ranch is the most i will pay.
@@MaxStax1 "Skyrocketing prices," yep👍 The only grocers here selling Carapelli are Kroger's, it's a-dollar more and worth every penny: one of my guilty pleasures😋I buy the California brand when too angry about jacked up prices to spare the extra dollar😉Fortunately I'd stocked up "On sale" before inflation hit🥲
In the past year, I have switched to the California oil based on ATK's recommendation and like it very much but, I would have liked to see my previous favorite, Colavita, included in this taste test.
Colavita Premium Selection Extra Virgin Olive Oil came in 6th of the 11 oils tested, and got a "Recommended" rating. They wrote, " 'Mild, buttery, neutral, not superdistinctive, but perfectly fine,' this 'gently peppery' oil was described as 'middle of the road,' 'smooth,' and 'subtle,' whether it was on beans or dressing a salad."
Jerry
Not à rated oil
@@eugenesedita Yes it was. It got a "Recommended" rating.
Most people I know use the Kirkland olive oil at Costco. I am surprised they were not one of the ones even tested.
I wish you would have sampled Costco's brand, Kirkland.
I agree, they’re constantly sleeping on the Costco brand and they do a very good job of sourcing their Kirkland brand. I’ve always gotten excellent evoo there. The last time I purchased oil there they didn’t have the Kirkland brand but they had one called Tasso which was also excellent.
Kirkland is in a clear plastic container. They said it should be in a coloured bottle.
@@theresekehler8282 No it’s not I have a bottle in my pantry right now it’s a dark green bottle
Check out the UC Davis olive oil lab. They rate Kirkland Organic at the top. They don't like many of the most common olive oils.
they may well have. These were the top 3
Can you do a video re: tips & tricks to identify/avoid counterfeit foods? such as honey, olive oil, fish etc. Thanks.
I have been buying the California brand in the green bottle for years, because of the cost. Glad to find that it is also the favored one.
The Trader Joe's extra virgin is just as cheap and is better.
Agree, I love the CA Olive ranch brand. Not everyone has a Trader Joe's close by, they are only in large metro areas.
CORanch has went to an international blend in 2019z.
Watching this a year later, the California Olive Ranch one has been discontinued due to "the state [CA] could not produce enough olives to meet demand" so they get the same style oil from Portugal, Chile, and Argentina and mix that oil with what little they can get from California for a replacement I'm not sure it's Product name from California Olive Ranch, I had Bertolli the 3rd in this segment but now I think they consider it #2 due to some recent quality improvements. This always happens with all products, Beard shavers, Microwaves & washing machines, they make one good run then once people hear about it they switch to lower cost versions and coast on the one good run.
I just bought 2 bottles from Walmart "Robust" and "Butter" from california olive branch. Best I ever had. (4th time I bought this brand and I live in Ca.)If you shop hard enough you can get the str8 up CA oil and not their destination blend. Bertolli is over processed.
@@goinbananers Thanks I'll look for it! I was not sure of the names of what product was what. I was quoting from the America's test Kitchen web site on this subject.
I thought I was alone in seeing this activity. It is grievous in the food industry, where they may produce a good product and either have a poor marketing strategy or switch production practices. With the current pandemic, the stores are void of most products, and certainly, boutique brands are history.
Maybe they had yo switch due to the fires last year?
@@kevinabel4267 LOL. that was pine trees and underbrush, not Olive trees.
I see people upset about CA Olive's Destination series. They new oils are clearly labeled on the front of the bottles with the countries names. If you don't want a mixed oil buy the one the test kitchen recommends it's 100% from CA. No one is trying to pull the wool over your eyes. It's very clear which ones of their oils is from a variety of countries.
My preference has always been Spanish olive oil. But in pinch Italian or Californian. We have an excellent variety of competent brands.
Yes, the best olive oil does come from Spain.
Which brands do you recommend?
Team Spain
I definitely appreciate the to the point approach of these reviews but the thumbnail showed various brands that I would have liked to hear information/opinions about as the top three may not be to everyone’s liking or available.
If you subscribe to the Web site (as I have done for more than a decade) you can see the full tests, including the ranked order of all products tested.
I'm pretty sure they did purity tests on extra virgin olive oils and Whole Foods and Trader Joe's were both near the top along with Kirkland brand, all of them at relatively low cost.
The Trader Joes extra virgin is the closest thing I have found to what I can get in the Mediterranean countries. That California brand they touted is meh.....Also they criticized oils coming from different countries. Well, Spain produces inexpensive oil, so other countries such as Italy will buy from Spain and bottle it in their own countries. That doesn't mean the quality of the oil is not good, so that guy is wrong about that. Also some oils are really underrated. For example, olive oil from Tunisia which is cheap and flavorful.
@@jaime8318 I don't think he said oil from other countries is bad, rather one bottle made from olives from many countries. But if the oil is from other countries you lose freshness because of time getting here.
@@Britgirl58 got it. Anyway, try the Trader Joe (Trader Giotto) brand. There was another oil I found that was good too, but was expensive. Can't remember the brand.
Should it not be Trader Giuseppe?
Anyway, yeah, I've had good results with Trader J's and Costco housebrand. California also good. I've also read these oils are not "adulterated" / mixed with other oils.
@@jaime8318 Which brand is the Tunisia brand. I love the taste of Greek oil.
I did a similar test of 7 different olive oils; California, Tuscany, Spain, Morocco, Greece, Sicily and Lebanon. Certainly was not a benchmark because within each of these countries there are many olive producers. It was a blind test and remarkably the Sicilian oil from Trader Joes was the only one that stood out. I use it exclusively now. Also the best bargain of the group.
I used to get the California oil because it was all California olives. Recently i noticed a bottle with multi sourced olives. I was shocked and disappointed
Yep, they seem to have switched to being multi-sourced. I used California for years and still occasionally do, but looking for another option now.
They still sell the "California only" oil. Check out the smaller bottles of California Olive Ranch on the grocery store shelf because sometimes it's there. My grocery store has it here in northern Maine where variety can be kinda limited.
Yes, I noticed that too! I was disappointed when I noticed that.
Yep, we noticed this about 2 months back all of our 100% California California Olive Ranch oil was being replaced with "Destination Series" nonsense. Trying to charge the same or more for pooling multiple sources as if that's a benefit to the consumer? From their website it appears they still have the 100% California variety. So either grocery stores are making the switch, or California Olive Ranch is pushing out lower quality purposefully. I verified online at all of our local vendors, Safeway, Whole Foods, QFC, and Fred Meyer. They've all made the switch to the Destination Series. Seems too coordinated to not be coming from California Olive Ranch themselves.
What?? Aww man .. why are the consumers always getting screwed 😒
I've used Filippo Berio for years, and it is absolutely wonderful
Me too🫒
Her reaction when he "aspirates" the oil was my exact reaction.
If you come to Italy this is how we taste the oils!
Me too!
I've tried many and tend to gravitate to Cento. The EV has a nice, snappy olive taste and their regular olive oil I find great for general cooking. Priced right as well.
I've been using the Cento for some time now, really like it. I got it cause it was on sale, but, I remembered, it is one of the sponsors of Lidia's kitchen on PBS.
If it’s not dark rich green in color, it’s not truly extra virgin olive oil. Most of the best quality EVOO is not found is grocery stores.
That's not even true. In all foods - be it rum, whiskey, olive oil, etc. always ignore the color, because coloring something is the easiest thing to do. The producers often throw leaves and grass into the press to add that "vibrant, green color". That's why they use blue cups. Quality olive oil can be really deeply green when unripe olives are used, but also golden yellow when the olives were ripe.
Daniel Ryslink You clearly don’t know good quality olive oil. My aunt and uncle make it off their own olive trees for personal use. I know what I’m talking about. You clearly don’t.
Kirkland’s (Costco house brand) extra-virgin olive oil is highly rated. Wonderful taste, affordable.
Yes is true, I can believe Kirkland is one the best olive oil.
i started looking at that brand a few years ago because of ATK recommendation. but i have never seen a bottle that was harvested less than a year before i was purchasing it.
As I think you note on your website, that California Olive Ranch Everyday olive oil - which has been my go to basic olive oil for years - was replaced earlier this year by their new "Destinations Series." Now their everyday olive oil is sourced from multiple countries. I wish this video had discusses _that_ oil, not the old, unfortunately discontinued California-grown Everyday.
Good to know!! Thanks for posting that information.
My understanding is that California Ranch is no longer single county sourced, not that I have noticed a difference in quality.
Yes, most grocery stores now carry a blended offering from them (at the same price).
4 different sources: Argentina, Chile, Portugal and California...I’m reading the bottle label at this very moment.
@@KK-lo8ki that's disappointing.
@@TheIntJuggler Welcome to global warming. Harder to plant now.
I disagree with Jack that multiple sources is a bad sign; it depends on *why* there are multiple sources, and what those sources are. Using olives from different locations can allow for using the best from each location when it's available, and not using a particular location when the quality falls.
I’ve used the California Oil since they’re last test. Very good, not all that expensive either.
I would like a video on true avocados oils.
Absolutely. I love Olive oil but I absolutely love Avocado oil much more and it's an oil that's truly good for the heart.
Avocado oil has a very high smoke point. Great for high temp frying but the taste takes getting used to.
Filippo Berio per Grandparents (restaurant owners) .....from way back, love my food heritage....
Sadly the Everyday series of oils have been replaced with the Destination series, which comes from different countries.
Atlas is organic, dated, harvested at a single farm, and from Morocco - it is loaded with polyphenols - it is by far the best. Test Kitchen has the Alas bottle on the table in the background but do not mention it,. You can buy it from Amazon. Also is by far the most expensive ($31 a 750ml. bottle). California is a good brand, real olive oil but is not as tasty and lower in Phenols. We use California or Kirkland oil for cooking and routine stuff, and Atlas for food where raw taste and Phenols matter. Atlas has a much higher Phenol content in several other quantitative reviews. However, Cosco Kirkland also quite high and is lower cost.
California Olive Ranch is now made with a blend from three countries. I just knew it was happening the second they rose in popularity.
What is your source?
Doestheuniversehaveanedge? The bottle
They do make a few products, their original is 100% California olives.
Doestheuniversehaveanedge? Correct. They raised the prices on domestic products, and they aren’t stocked at most regular grocery stores. They even make the robust variety from imported stock. I should say I still buy their Everyday variety pretty much exclusively. I don’t have a way to compare the quality of the new blend vs the old single varietal.
I’d like to hear from an expert what they think of the change.
I was using an olive oil and then I purchased California Olive ranch several years ago and The taste difference was transformingly amazing!
Am surprised that an olive oil from Spain wasn't at the top in this test. When I travelled throughout Spain a few years ago it was olive groves as far as you could see all over the country.
I was always told that olive oil from Spain is better because there is something in the soil in Spain that is lacking in Italy.
We use only spain imported olive oils in Puerto Rico it simply complements our style of dishes better.
I'm so glad they did this taste test. I am so overwhelmed with the choices. Thanks 😊
Be aware that this test is from 2017, and things do change with time. The winner in this test, for example, has been discontinued and replaced with a multi-source equivalent. ATK plans to do a new test in a few months. (In the interim, they tested the new California Olive Ranch "Everyday" oil, and still recommend it.)
Need an updated test using Kirkland and Amazon Fresh’s Olive Oils 👌🏽
Berio bought in the gold n yellow tin can, after opening it never lasted more than six months. Stays fresh as it is packed air tight.
To each his own. I like Colivito - I also like many Greek imported oils.
Could you please make a video on balsamic vinegar taste testing?
The two I most like (at reasonable prices) are Colavita and California Olive Ranch. In that order.
Lucini has been my every day favorite for over 20 years and Badia a Coltibuono when I want to splurge a little.
Is the Badia a Coltibuono really that good? Where do you buy it? Thanks!
@@AirrowRocket I usually get it from Central Market, however, if you don't have one of those in your area, it's available on Amazon.
Thanks.
Betis and Goya, both from Spain, are the top sellers in Puerto Rico for generations.
The 3L rectangular metal cans are best for imported olive oils. Its a better value and they arent exposed to light.(my 2 favorite are from Greece and Spain) Check the expiry dates though. Best domestic olive oil comes from Cali (UC-Davis)
Moroccan Olive Oil is my go to. Never had a bad batch
Where can you buy that?
My olive oil is from Turkey and as they say here, it tastes like olives. Since the US doesn't have standards for oil like Italy, Spain or anybody else they dump their diluted oil here. They sell it by the gallon $20 in cans.
I just learned to always store my olive oil in a dark cabinet instead of on the countertop.
Great Job but I live on the east coast and would have liked to see a couple more options!
I shop by price, and I cook with olive oil. So Pompeian is my favorite. I keep a little bit of small batch, locally sold oil around for my home made vinaigrette, but that’s not the work horse.:)
My favorite is Colavita, although I have yet to try California Olive Ranch. That will be my next bottle.
Colavita makes a very nice balsamic vinegar, too.
Colavita is my favorite too
I use Cobram Estates olive oils.
I now use California Olive Ranch oils exclusively and I love them. At first it was all pure Calif. olives, then they came out with a blend, Destination, Argentina, Chile, Portugal & Calif. olives. But they offer a half dozen oils that are purely from Calif. olives, Arboquina, Arbosana, Robust, Everyday. They also sell an Olive/Avocado mix oil but it is with the mix of olives.
Madre Sicilia and Al Koura are my go-to’s. I keep the Sicilian for Sicilian specialties and the Lebanese one for general application. Of course both are huge containers but in my home we go through a couple liters per month.
Looking at your name I can see why but I would never use that much olive oil in even couple of months I use more avocado oil van EVOO
Take an honest test yourselves by purchasing several small bottles, recommended or not, with your favorite "dried"bread and mild cheeses. Only YOUR own tastebuds will know. Pax
Couldn't agree more. I found that some nameless brand olive oil that I got from a strip-mall Mediterranean market tasted much better than California Olive Ranch, which was my original go-to.
@common sense more common sense Clearly more than your uncultured and racist self.
No talk about the enormous problem of substitution, or fake olive oil? I have a soy allergy. The last bottle of California Olive Ranch I bought was contaminated with large amounts of soybean oil. The reason some of the oils taste like vegetable oil? They ARE vegetable oil.
Best consistent olive oils for the western Canadian market are coming out of California. They seem to have a more honest approach to olive oils.
I've recently done some research on TH-cam concerning olive oils. I found that many brands are fake or adulterated. I found the California Ranch brand and it is a wonderful tasting pure evoo.
California Olive Ranch. That certainly is one of the best. Buy the smallest size bottles.
Have you tried the "Destination series?" They added three more sources, going against the one source rule. So im very concerned.
We buy beautiful olive oil,from a winery in the Okanagan in BC. Totally worth the extra price
Why can I only find the California "Destination Series" in stores now? I started buying this brand because it was U.S. produced and single-source, but now they're sourcing their olives from three different South American countries.
Because the stores only stock what will sell to their customers . If you cannot sell the premium Cal produced oil , sell the imported blend . It is not the producer , it is the customer that demands cheap goods .
It may be more difficult to find California Olive Ranch olive oil at reasonable prices on the East Coast.
Costco used to carry it. Lately I have seen their own Kirkland branded 100% California EVOO there. It is only about $8.00/1L bottle (one of my Costco's it is $7.97; another $8.99)
I've had olive oil in Florence, Sienna, and Cortona (all in Tuscany) and it was a revelation. Until then, I thought I had tasted OL. No. I never had. What they have over there is another thing entirely and soooo much better. Wish we could get it here (maybe, once this plague is over, we can).
We tried a lot of Extra Virgin olive oils, both domestic and imported over the years looking for a good one. Only a year or so ago we decided the best EVO we had tried was the same as your winner, California Olive Ranch. Excellent.
I've used a lot of Olive Oils in Italian Cooking and Bertolli is my favorite brand...
I used to buy BERTOLLI, I found out its one of the fake olive oil in the market. I switch to COBRAM quiet expensive but the taste is amazing.
I never really thought about the quality of the oil until I came across some some videos suggesting that a couple of table spoons of extra virgin olive oil taken daily has several health benefits. Thank you for the tutorial. A new subscriber here.
Haven't watched yet but my vote is definitely for California Olive Ranch! It's what I always use and recommend.
I have used California Ranch because it is high quality and domestic.
Saw all those bottles thought their would be a lot more in the testing!
All the brands pictured were tested, they just pull a few notable ones for the segment for the purpose of discussion.
My mom always used Goya and I never had any complaints always loved it and I received a bottle from Trader Joe's for Christmas and I love that one too
When it comes to Extra Virgin Olive Oil, I honestly don't know what to buy. I think it may have been on a 60 minutes program a year or two back, but they reported that over 70% of what is sold as extra virgin olive oil in the United States actually isn't. A certain percentage of it may be extra virgin, but it is cut with cheaper oils and sold at premium prices. What I would like to see is for you guys to do an extensive testing and tasting of highest quality extra virgin olive oil you can find within the United States, and then pick your favorite five of those friends. I'm glad you gave a couple of different options here, but I have heard that Spain also produces excellent quality extra virgin olive oils That are worth considering. The best I can do right now is a little Italian Market near where I live dead cells can olive oil that actually tastes quite good and the price is on the reasonable side. I will definitely try the California Olive Ranch brand and see how I like it. I prefer my olive oil with some serious flavor and a good peppery
Happy Blind Dad
The US won’t adhere to any European / international standards.
As in everything else the almighty USA is the odd man out. A country of thieves and charlatans.
Happy Blind Dad
They have one like that. Check the website for the choices and explanation.
@@eugenesedita you know, I really don't appreciate you taking and opportunity to run down my country. Keep it about extra virgin olive oil. And leave your hatred for the United States out of it. I can acknowledge that my country has faults without running it down like you did.
Greece is noted for their olive oil. Was it included in the testing.
Gaea has greek olive oil they're really good too
They said it was 10 best-selling brands in US...I love Greek olive oil as well, i'm sure it would've fared well.
I lived in Greece above Patras. They have very good Olive oil. Lived there for a little over a year, a wonderful place !!!
@@oldgoat8861 nice! as close as I get is the local farmer's market...but the vendors aren't there right now :(
elainemarietta Hellas (Greece) has my favorite olive oils. I had the great pleasure to have wonderful olive groves all around me when I lived and worked in Paleakastro, Crete for several years. Many vineyards too, and up in the lush cooler mountains they grew a lot of avocados. Hellas has a great abundance of wonderful delicious and ancient foods and my favorites are Cretan: pulses (beans), grains, fresh & dried fruit, lots of vegetables, excellent cheeses and yogurt , rustic bread, seafoods, moderate amounts of meats, field gathered herbs and greens (wild greens with little snails on them is well liked... But you just *cannot* live without olives/olive oil and wine!
Since i was a kid in the Caribbean, we always used Figaro olive oil from Spain. Best olive oil that I've ever had. Very hard to find. Costco brand (Kirkland) is pretty.
Agree with you
Finding out about olive oil is good
Julia’s reaction to Jack aspirating--PRICELESS!
Much easier to use a finger or a spoon to taste it.
I liked the California oil better. I was buying an olive oil in a black bottle with its own pour spout. I happened to be running out of money and bought the California one. Glad I didn’t wait until I had more money.
Hello. I just went to my Supermarket today and found the recommended California Olive Ranch extra virgin olive oil but it was labeled Destination Series and the label says that it came from four different countries (California, Argentina, Chile and Portugal). There were 4 different varieties including the everyday version). Can you clarify why this information on different from that of the video (the country of origin)?
Thanks
Pretty sure California isn't a country!
Craig Spiegel California used to be single sourced but maybe due to costs changed to destination series which I no longer buy and am still looking for an affordable single sourced brand. Going carnivore I cook more with butter but will use olive oil cold for flavor
Craig Spiegel
Yes, that’s just another choice. Clearly stated and dated too.
Demand forced them to come out with their blend, Destination. But they still sell several varieties of their purely Calif. oils, Everyday, Arboquina, Arbosana, Robust and 1 or 2 more. Go to their website or to Walmart on-line and order it. You can get single bottles or 6 packs. This seems to be one of the few that can be trusted without it costing an arm & a leg. We know now to always look at the label.
Pompaian oil is a blend from different countries read the label .
I get the Kirkland at Costco or the Italian store OR imported from Italy
For someone who doesnt really like olive oil, i get del lalio or something its good without too much flavor
Hi from Portugal,love your channel, and we have an amazing olive oil brands in our country
We not only have amazing olive oil brands in Portugal (including mine) we also have some of the worlds most amazing wines. I do not produce wine, I buy it.
Portuguese olive oil is my favorite. Hard to find where I am. Thanks for Amazon.
The "new" version of this EVOO called "Destination" says on my bottle "grown in California, Argentina, Chile, Portugal". Blended and bottled in California.
I consume Novello Italian Reserve extra virgin olive oil , sold at Trader Joe's. In my opinion THE BEST...
I'm still using Colavita from a prior taste test & I still like it.
A couple of years ago now I read a story about olive oil cartels & how they were mixing & adding to cheaper oils & passing them off as pure. The article said that in the supermarket the only 2 brands not involved in this cartel were Californian & Pompeian. I’ve only used these two since although I prefer the Californian in salads or a drizzle...either good for cooking lower temperature foods. Although the claim is that olive oil can cook up to 350, I only use it for lower temps.
"Our top-ranked supermarket extra-virgin olive oil, California Olive Ranch Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil, has been discontinued and replaced with an imported blend called California Olive Ranch Destination Series Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil. We compared the new and old products in a blind tasting and still recommend the new oil. However, we plan to conduct a new tasting of supermarket extra-virgin olive oil in the coming months."
They still sell the pure California in several different varieties. I don't think the Destination is the same as the Everyday, which I think is purely Californian. They also have Arboquina, Arbosana, & Robust which are straight Calif. olives. I chatted with the Director of Mkt. at length and she said the reason they went to the Destination for the masses was because of the sheer amount of oil they were selling and had to supplement it to keep up with demand. She seemed to go to great lengths telling me about the olives they get from Argentina, Chile & Portugal and it all makes sense. She sent me some nice coupons and now I'm back to straight Calif. olive oils. I was able to get one of each of their products.
I use Aldi's Carlini EVOO $5, nice buttery smoothness, gentle faint olive taste. I also have that California Olive Ranch. It's pretty darn good @ $10.