I'm a converted Scotch drinker. My wife used your videos to select my Christmas presents this year, 1792 Small Batch, and Old Forester 1920, OMG! Thanks guys!
Yeah me too - scotch guy. I got a bottle of 1910 last night and was pleasantly surprised. It's pretty good and holds up against the scotches in value for money in my opinion ($54 at the Virginia ABC store).
Very weird we're not alone in converting from Scotch. Not that it's not great but bourbon has that spark the soul is after. So much more variety & if they could finish in Ex-Bourbon barrels, there would be no contest globally🤌🏼🥃Great wife right there!
Old Forester is sentimental to me. On an overnight pass from Basic training in Fort Polk, I took a bus to Deritter, LA. I walked around the town. Found a local hamburger stand (not MacDonald or similar) Walked back to the four unit motel. Confused, I asked the landlady 'is this a dry town or something'? She replied something like 'yeah would you like a drink? She delivered an Old Forester pint bottle half full and 4 cans of Budweiser to my room at no charge. Next morning, she had friends take me to church and after church, to the country club for lunch. There is more to this testament of Southern Hospitality in the late 60s but it gets too far off the Old Forester theme.
Love Old Forester. For me it’s 1920, followed by 1910, then Signature 100. To me those are easily the best of the OF line. The rest of them I think there are better bottles from other distilleries at their price points.
Well this makes me quite curious, because I didn't much care for the 86 and 100. I'm quite interested in trying the 1920 and 1910, but the price points just don't have me itching to pull the trigger.
I agree with your lineup for sure although 20 vs 10 is a hard one. Both super good. I’m nursing a single barrel 100 store pick. It’s a flavor bomb in my mouth. I might get sad when it’s all gone haha
So, the Old Forester Statesman comes out of the movie starring Jeff Bridges, "Kingsman: The Golden Circle". Its concerns a British Secret Service entity that saves the world and revolves around a Kentucky distillery headed by Bridges. The Old Forester 1910 is the product of what happened to that distillery in 1910 - a severe fire which began with the barrels burning. In order to save the whiskey from exploding, they transferred it into as many severely charred barres as could be salvaged. The whiskey was fabulous. So this new iteration is aged in severely charred (called an alligator char) barrels, hence the notes of burnt sugar and dark caramel. It is my favorite of all those you have just reviewed.
I am sure many followers of SBL would love to hear the real story behind Old Forester 1910, and Keslyn Howard, a tour guide at Old Forester, would be the perfect person to tell.
@@wmbenson68 I’d love to! It does involve a fire, but actually a fire on our bottling line when we were in our original 1883 distillery on Main Street Louisville. It wasn’t too detrimental but we did have a lot of bourbon that never made it into a bottle. So the big question became “what are we to do with all of this free floating bourbon?” The owner at the time (the founders son) Owsley Brown decided to put that free floating bourbon back into some brand new charred oak barrels. That way he could store them away easier and also keep the integrity of their being a bourbon. When they decided to get these barrels out about 2ish years later they didn’t really care that they were one of the first people to make a double barrel bourbon, but when Owsley tried it he was like wow this tastes like a good old mature whiskey. So they brought it to market back in 1912 as their “old fine whiskey”. We actually have an original unopened bottle of the old fine whiskey on display at our distillery now. This distillery once again resides in the same building from 1883 on Main Street! This story inspired us to make todays version of 1910, however we do treat that second barrel differently these days. We will char it (a proprietary time) about 15 seconds before disintegration starts to occur on the inside of that barrel. This allows the char to have a really great affect on the product even though it’s only sitting in that second barrel about 7-9 months! We now also have 1910 experimental bottles as well, such as 117 series 1910 extra old and 1910 extra extra old!
@@keslynhoward9998 Many thanks for that clarification. I bought the 1910 the first year it was introduced (comparing it to the three others in the “Whiskey Row series) and absolutely loved it. Compared to the 1920, which many bourbonites prefer as getting “more bang for the buck (higher proof), the 1910 isn’t in it for the bang but rather the wonderful layer upon layer of extracted flavors produced but the “alligator” char, the lush and lingering mouthfeel and protracted smoothness of the finish. A sipping bourbon at its finest which continues to reveal itself with slight oxidation. My guess is the two others mentioned in your reply, the 117 series 1910 extra old and the extra extra old on not publicly available?
I have a bottle of the 1920. It is an excellent pour. Every time I sip a glass I can feel the tension easing away. There are only a few whiskeys that do this. Excellent therapy for a day of stress!
John, I live in North Nashville and totally agree with you. Bourbon prices around here have really spiked recently, and the good stuff has gotten much harder to find.
For me here in Arizona, 1920 can't be beat, then 1910 and then the 100 I recently went to Mexico and brought a big 1.75 liter of OF 100 , it was the juice everyone loved for our 3 day getaway.. Hell yeah !!! Great show as always !
Great show, as usual! Thank you for your honest and sincere approach to tasting, as well as explaining. It’s very enjoyable. I have a few ideas for future videos, if I may be so bold. 1) You mention almost every show that this or that has a ‘quintessential’ bourbon flavor. It would be great to have a show where you describe what it is that makes a bourbon ‘quintessential’ to you. For example, is there a base flavor you look for? Is it a group of basic flavors that make up a certain flavor profile? Are there nuance flavors that give it that touchstone quality? What are the nuances or flavors that contribute to the quintessential quality? What nuances ‘disqualify’ a bourbon as being quintessential? Once addressed, have a blind test of some of your favorite ‘quintessential’ bourbons. That is one idea for a show. 2) You’ve done many very interesting shows of bourbons at a certain price point and you identified this one is worth the money, or a good value at this price, and others you felt were not worth that money. What about a show of the bourbons you feel are the best value, at a number of different price points, and perhaps a blind taste of them as well? Thank you for a great show that is interesting and educational. Can’t wait for the next one!
Im a big Old Forrester fan. My two favorites is the 1897 B and B and the 1920. Very hard to beat the 1920, so smooth it is hard to believe it is a 115 proof. I have had some $100 bourbons that do not come close to the 1920.
Been searching for a new bourbon for awhile after my coach JB stopped making his slapdick agave whiskey ….well let me tell you I went out purchased 1870, 1910, 1920 Did a taste test and off your video and never having old forester I guessed each one right very first time hats off to SLB for finding me my new favorite bourbon in this order 1920, 1910, and 1887 What a great maple brown sugar note in 1920 and 1910 can’t wait to pair it with my cigars ….kudos SLB
I give the edge to 1910 over 1920. For me, that proof point is just right and I don’t think you lose any taste. Old Forester is great. I only wish I could find the other selections you profiled.
I've been an Irish whiskey guy for a long time - had a few bourbons (including Pappy 23) but never been pulled towards them. I got a bottle of 1910 this weekend and don't want to drink anything else now. Straight Cherry Cola and Oak.
I was underwhelmed by 1870 and the bottled in bond, and actually enjoyed the Statesman so it looks like we have opposite OF tastes, ha. Granted, I started with 1920 so it kind of makes sense. The 100 proof is easily one of the best value bottles. P.s. the Statesman is from the second Kingsman movie - quality movie too.
I just want thank you. I picked up a bottle of the Old Forester 1920 based on your opinion, and its amazingly good. I’ve never had any of their brands, and it’s pretty damn good. Thank you, bottoms up, and cheers. 👍
Some of the early 2000's Birthday Bourbons were excellent as well. Very nice bottle for the wife to make lamps out of as well. I like the distillers putting their product in pretty bottles so that gives the beautiful young lady and excuse to let me buy bourbon. Hats off to Blantons!
Kurt, I bought a 1920 a couple of weeks ago based on your March Madness. I thought it was ok at first taste, but trying it now, I get all the complexities you were talking about. Good stuff! Keep up the good work! :)
Early in my bourbon life (three years ago), I took a flight of the years and the 1897 was my pick. I recently purchased a bottle of 1870 and 1920 and the 1920 took the gold!! I'm going to get bottle of the 1897 in the next week or two and try a flight again! My tastes have changed dramatically in three years.
I'm quite green when it comes to OF, but the two (86 and 100) I had didn't impress me. I was happy to see the 1920 come into town recently, but at $60, I wasn't ready to roll the dice given the tasting notes of the younger brothers. There are a couple others at lower price points that I know are winners. I wanted to try that 1915 blend, but $115 (plus tax) to do so? Eh. I think I can wait.
I’m more of a scotch drinker and islay in particular but always have a bottle of the 86 in my collection. I can get it as cheap as £17 when it’s on offer and at that price it’s an amazing drink.
I’m newer to whiskey & bourbon. I had the 1870 since December, thank God I’m finally almost done with it! Not a fan! But looking forward to trying the 1920 for sure!
I tried the old forester 1920, 115 proof. It’s the highest proof I’ve had so far in my tastings and I was pleasantly surprised. The flavors has so much depth. The heat feels slightly stronger than a makers mark 101 but it’s worth it for the flavor profile.
Our intent is to eventually get through them all! Lots of fun! Btw I spoke to Harry about you (owner at bees liquor Hobart) he said if you stop by let him know that you are a supporter of the channel and he will see what he has available in the back room. Where he hides the more allocated bottles. Good luck!
I am watching this after subscribing about a week and a half ago. Still early on my bourbon journey, and I am trying different whiskey to find what I like. That being said I picked up my second bottle of the orange label 100 today. The first bottle was amazing. So far I have tried a lot of the $35 and under bourbons, tomorrow I will look for a bottle of WT Rare Breed, the 101 was outstanding.
Hey Kurt, can I take partial credit for this? If you recall, I was the first to suggest an OF tasting in the comments for the Four Roses tasting. You said, "good idea", and I'm so glad you did this! I've only had three of these seven. This was really helpful. Clearly, I need to get my hands on a bottle of either 1910 or 1920. Problem is, they are hard to find. But thanks again Kurt!
Yep. I'm an OF lover too. Love my 100 proof and 1920. I also love the rye. I've never heard good comments on the Statesman. I just finished my 1920 and will probably pick up an 1897 based on this review. Keep it up boys...
Any of those from the Whiskey Row series are just fantastic. I prefer 1910 and 1897 BiB with the single barrel bourbon close behind. They are more than worth the money.
The 100 proof Signature is one of my favorite 100 proof bourbon (WT 101, Knob Creek 9, and ET BIB are the others). Love the 1920 and the 1910. The rye is really good, too.
Old Forester standard is hands down the best bang for the buck as far as big time distilleries go. Yes, some high end stuff like the birthday bourbon and the single barrel cask strength offerings are tough to find, BUT are capable of finding when compared to overhyped Buffalo Trace stuff. Seriously, places are charging $200 for Blantons and $100 for Eagle Rare! That's all the proof you need for standard lineup avaliablity versus quality
Hi Kurt. I know you made this vid some time ago but I am just adventuring into Old Forester and went back to review. You and Kurt make such fun and informative posts. It is now my main go to for things whiskey. My pallet seems more similar to yours than Trent's preferring warm, spicy and sweet to fruity and sour notes (I grew up before Skittles-lol). I am just venturing into Old Forester and am planning to buy my first two bottles. I am definitely getting the 1920 but would like your advise on the other. For reference my favorites include Knob Creek 9 yr CS, Russel's 10 yr CS, and Jim Beam Single Barrel CS. My daily drinkers are Rebel 100, WT 101, and KB (9Yr 100). I am not so keen on Heaven Hill products ( have Larceny, ECSB, and HH BiB). I generally sip neat but occasionally , if I am drink a cocktail, it is an Old Fashion. For my second bottle do you recommend OF 100 or OF Rye 100?
Good show again today Kurt, I wish I had the time & the money to try them all and make my own decisions. That being said, there were a couple that you and Trent gave a thumbs down on so I'll take you words on those. When I'm back in the US it's only for 30 days and I stay with friends so I'd have to buy a lot of bottles and leave them behind. TSA doesn't allow open bottles in checked baggage either.
A few months ago you guys put Stateman in third place in OF blind testing, today last place. This is why picking order is so hard. Anyways great video as always!!
If my memory is correct that would have been on a live show with my brother. Got me curious so I will verify however your point is well taken. Certain days can absolutely result in different results! The statesman just wasn’t for me on this show.
Good to know the "Statesman" isn't worth the money (Here, 40 bucks more than what you're paying!) Unfortunately, the only other ones we can get here are the 86 Proof and the Rye. Of those, I'm seriously considering the Rye only. Great video as always!
I can only speak for the 100 proofs, I just can't get myself to reach up and grab the bottle (750ml) of 1897 BIB $54.99 when there is a bottle of (1L) Old Forester Signature 100 Proof for $37.99 just below it, considering they are both identical from what I can find online except for the BIB with the 1897? so, what would give one more character than the other when the mash bill is I identical? I have a 1L of the 86 proof that is quite good also. Great review 🥃Cheers!
the 1920 changed; it used to have so much going on but once they made that change it feels dull. Wife and I blinded the 4 corked bottles (not the Statesman bc we heard only bad things) and the 1920 was a distant 3rd for both of us (she liked 1897 at 1 and I def went 1910). That said Id rather just do the 100 and 86 over any of them. I avoided the 86 for years bc the low proof. After hearing/watching so many reviews on how its about the best of the bunch I picked one up. I was STUNNED. Yeah its not hot at all but the nose! Wow! Cherries Banana so much going on and its got a great pallet too! back to 1920: blinded against WT Rare Breed and it wasnt even close. Winner by KO 20 seconds into round 1 - RB. Again once they changed the label color of the 1920 the presence left with it
The only OF products I have seen on our local store is the 86, 1910, and 1920. I like all 3 of them and even though the 86 is no where near as good as the other 2 it is awesome for the price point. I hope to find the 100 proof on the shelf at some point. IMO for being 115 proof the 1920 has very little burn to it and might very well be my favorite but it is $60 here compared to $55 for the 1910. It amazes me how taste preference can vary between people. Of the 3 OF products I have tried I like all 3 which you do as well but you are a big fan of WT 101 and to be honest I think it is just OK and like the OF 86 better. I love WR double oaked but prefer the OF 1910 just a hair better but have a brother that likes the WFDO better.
What you will find with me is that I have a wide range of tastes. That’s why at times I introduce other spirits that are not just bourbon. Maybe good maybe bad but I like a lot of different varieties of spirits lol!
Kurt, great stuff as usual. I recently tried the Statesman and thought it was actually pretty good. However, I have only had the OF 1920, which was obviously really good. I really want to try the 1910 and the 100.
Unlike the norm I am glad you liked the statesman! We can’t agree all the time that’s for sure and there is nothing worse than buying a bottle of bourbon you don’t like.
I’m laughing because I really liked the old statesman too. Just picked it up and I was actually really surprised. I don’t get any of the harsh taste that you all got. I thought is was extremely easy to drink. Price though is an issue.
For me, the order would be 1897 (the current stuff just rocks), 1920 (fantastic, just not my usual proof point) and the Statesman (hoping my current bottle is an aberration). All (usually) magical, and so is their rye.
Love your shows, Always so much information. I havent done much with Old Forester, I do have a 1920, but I need to try a few more. As always Thanks for a great show
Gotta agree with Trenton, love the Old Forester line. Further agree that the Statesman is the weakest link and by far the worst value. Wondering if you think that the 1897 BIB is worth twice the price ($44 vs $22 ) of the regular OF 100 ?? Same proof, just adding perhaps a year of aging if that?? Love the 1920 and 1910 - both hitters but around here, the 1920 is about $5 or $6 more which is absolutely worth it for the proof difference. Great review 👏
Concerning Statesman: From the OF web-site - Inspired by the dynamic characters in the film, ”Kingsman: The Golden Circle,” Old Forester Statesman offers bold flavor blended to a smooth 95 proof from hand-selected casks of our famed Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky from the warmest places in the warehouse. Because true character is only revealed after a little heat, the Statesman product offers an exceptional balance of heat and spice.
Nice review! I love the 1920, but, unfortunately, has become very hard to come by in my area. It seems every time I find something l really like it soon becomes hard to get…..😑
@@slbdrinks I talked to the owner, and it’s a fairly large store, and he said they get a “ few bottles of the 1920 every once in a while…”. such that they took its shelf space away and hold it for those who ask…..🤷♂️😑
Funny that every single bottle you reviewed is $5-$10 more expensive here than the prices you quoted. I like the 1920, but is $60 here. So I don’t stock the 1920 although I do enjoy it. Bourbon has really shot up in price over the last five years or so. For me, I will stock the 100, and pick up the 1920 from time to time. I would skip the rest (just my opinion).
I feel like I have a hard time choosing great bourbons as a clear winner. Different day, different moon, i like 1 better than the other lol. Both 1910 and 1920 were amazing. I thought the 1910 was better in an old fashion, but again i only compared 1 time.
you guys hit it right on the nose. for me , 1920, 1910,1870, 1897, the two entry levels and the statesman dead last. will never purchase again. norwalk ohio loves you guys.
I love the exposure they got via the Kingsmen Golden Circle and the ‘Statesmen’ but that bottle is WAY too expensive for what it is. Hell I don’t even think Kirkland would want that for their bottles (which are actually pretty decent for the price). If someone offered me the 86, 100, or Statesmen; I would walk away with the 100 anyway and be very happy.
We tried a couple of these at Brooklyn & The Butcher, a Louisville area restaurant. really liked them. I've never bought a bottle though. I have picked up the 200 proof a couple of times in the store and nearly purchased it. Usually about $20/bottle here. I'll for sure give it a try now!
My step-father passed away in 1979. When my mom passed in 2008, when I cleaned out her house and my stepdad's bar, there was a new, unopened bottle of Old Forester in the storage cabinet that had a Texas liqueur tax stamp dated 1976. Here, now in 2022, I haven't opened that bottle...yet. Should be good...
1910 is my favorite drink ever! Its hard to find in my state but I just cleaned out a liquor store near by that had three bottles. Anyone know how hard it would be to get a piece of a barrel of this stuff?? Like a tenth or something?
I'm a converted Scotch drinker. My wife used your videos to select my Christmas presents this year, 1792 Small Batch, and Old Forester 1920, OMG! Thanks guys!
Yeah me too - scotch guy. I got a bottle of 1910 last night and was pleasantly surprised. It's pretty good and holds up against the scotches in value for money in my opinion ($54 at the Virginia ABC store).
You better treat her right brother! lol
Your wife is pretty cool
Very weird we're not alone in converting from Scotch. Not that it's not great but bourbon has that spark the soul is after. So much more variety & if they could finish in Ex-Bourbon barrels, there would be no contest globally🤌🏼🥃Great wife right there!
I'll also add, if you want a remarkable experience.... mix some malty scotch with a deep bourbon. Probably the best thing I've ever tasted.
Old Forester is sentimental to me. On an overnight pass from Basic training in Fort Polk, I took a bus to Deritter, LA. I walked around the town. Found a local hamburger stand (not MacDonald or similar) Walked back to the four unit motel. Confused, I asked the landlady 'is this a dry town or something'? She replied something like 'yeah would you like a drink? She delivered an Old Forester pint bottle half full and 4 cans of Budweiser to my room at no charge. Next morning, she had friends take me to church and after church, to the country club for lunch. There is more to this testament of Southern Hospitality in the late 60s but it gets too far off the Old Forester theme.
Love Old Forester. For me it’s 1920, followed by 1910, then Signature 100. To me those are easily the best of the OF line. The rest of them I think there are better bottles from other distilleries at their price points.
Excellent lineup!
I'm right there with you!
These three are three of my fav's. Love the rye, too.
Well this makes me quite curious, because I didn't much care for the 86 and 100. I'm quite interested in trying the 1920 and 1910, but the price points just don't have me itching to pull the trigger.
I agree with your lineup for sure although 20 vs 10 is a hard one. Both super good. I’m nursing a single barrel 100 store pick. It’s a flavor bomb in my mouth. I might get sad when it’s all gone haha
So, the Old Forester Statesman comes out of the movie starring Jeff Bridges, "Kingsman: The Golden Circle". Its concerns a British Secret Service entity that saves the world and revolves around a Kentucky distillery headed by Bridges. The Old Forester 1910 is the product of what happened to that distillery in 1910 - a severe fire which began with the barrels burning. In order to save the whiskey from exploding, they transferred it into as many severely charred barres as could be salvaged. The whiskey was fabulous. So this new iteration is aged in severely charred (called an alligator char) barrels, hence the notes of burnt sugar and dark caramel. It is my favorite of all those you have just reviewed.
Thanks for the knowledge!
As an Old Forester Tour Guide, the 1910 story is a little different than that. But the statesman is spot on!
I am sure many followers of SBL would love to hear the real story behind Old Forester 1910, and Keslyn Howard, a tour guide at Old Forester, would be the perfect person to tell.
@@wmbenson68 I’d love to! It does involve a fire, but actually a fire on our bottling line when we were in our original 1883 distillery on Main Street Louisville. It wasn’t too detrimental but we did have a lot of bourbon that never made it into a bottle. So the big question became “what are we to do with all of this free floating bourbon?” The owner at the time (the founders son) Owsley Brown decided to put that free floating bourbon back into some brand new charred oak barrels. That way he could store them away easier and also keep the integrity of their being a bourbon.
When they decided to get these barrels out about 2ish years later they didn’t really care that they were one of the first people to make a double barrel bourbon, but when Owsley tried it he was like wow this tastes like a good old mature whiskey. So they brought it to market back in 1912 as their “old fine whiskey”. We actually have an original unopened bottle of the old fine whiskey on display at our distillery now. This distillery once again resides in the same building from 1883 on Main Street!
This story inspired us to make todays version of 1910, however we do treat that second barrel differently these days. We will char it (a proprietary time) about 15 seconds before disintegration starts to occur on the inside of that barrel. This allows the char to have a really great affect on the product even though it’s only sitting in that second barrel about 7-9 months!
We now also have 1910 experimental bottles as well, such as 117 series 1910 extra old and 1910 extra extra old!
@@keslynhoward9998 Many thanks for that clarification. I bought the 1910 the first year it was introduced (comparing it to the three others in the “Whiskey Row series) and absolutely loved it. Compared to the 1920, which many bourbonites prefer as getting “more bang for the buck (higher proof), the 1910 isn’t in it for the bang but rather the wonderful layer upon layer of extracted flavors produced but the “alligator” char, the lush and lingering mouthfeel and protracted smoothness of the finish. A sipping bourbon at its finest which continues to reveal itself with slight oxidation. My guess is the two others mentioned in your reply, the 117 series 1910 extra old and the extra extra old on not publicly available?
I have a bottle of the 1920. It is an excellent pour. Every time I sip a glass I can feel the tension easing away. There are only a few whiskeys that do this. Excellent therapy for a day of stress!
Well said sir!
Old forester in my book has to be one of the best line ups there are. I’ve only had three of them so far. You can’t go wrong.
Fantastic distillery with options for everyone!
Josh, I agree completely!
Only had 3 but you know it's the best? Huh 🤔
Around Nashville, it seems most liquor stores raised prices about $5 on most bourbons. Even lower ends are up at least $2.
Another spot we visit often because of his great selection averages 5-8.00 more on most bottles.
John, I live in North Nashville and totally agree with you. Bourbon prices around here have really spiked recently, and the good stuff has gotten much harder to find.
A lot of that is due to difficulty sourcing bottles, as well as inflation
For me here in Arizona, 1920 can't be beat, then 1910 and then the 100 I recently went to Mexico and brought a big 1.75 liter of OF 100 ,
it was the juice everyone loved for our 3 day getaway.. Hell yeah !!!
Great show as always !
1920 is a staple at my bar. Doesn't come in hot but has all the flavors you could ask for at a price I appreciate. Keep up the great videos!
Great show, as usual! Thank you for your honest and sincere approach to tasting, as well as explaining. It’s very enjoyable.
I have a few ideas for future videos, if I may be so bold.
1) You mention almost every show that this or that has a ‘quintessential’ bourbon flavor. It would be great to have a show where you describe what it is that makes a bourbon ‘quintessential’ to you. For example, is there a base flavor you look for? Is it a group of basic flavors that make up a certain flavor profile? Are there nuance flavors that give it that touchstone quality? What are the nuances or flavors that contribute to the quintessential quality? What nuances ‘disqualify’ a bourbon as being quintessential?
Once addressed, have a blind test of some of your favorite ‘quintessential’ bourbons.
That is one idea for a show.
2) You’ve done many very interesting shows of bourbons at a certain price point and you identified this one is worth the money, or a good value at this price, and others you felt were not worth that money.
What about a show of the bourbons you feel are the best value, at a number of different price points, and perhaps a blind taste of them as well?
Thank you for a great show that is interesting and educational. Can’t wait for the next one!
All great ideas! I appreciate the recommendation!
Im a big Old Forrester fan. My two favorites is the 1897 B and B and the 1920. Very hard to beat the 1920, so smooth it is hard to believe it is a 115 proof. I have had some $100 bourbons that do not come close to the 1920.
Been searching for a new bourbon for awhile after my coach JB stopped making his slapdick agave whiskey ….well let me tell you I went out purchased 1870, 1910, 1920 Did a taste test and off your video and never having old forester I guessed each one right very first time hats off to SLB for finding me my new favorite bourbon in this order 1920, 1910, and 1887 What a great maple brown sugar note in 1920 and 1910 can’t wait to pair it with my cigars ….kudos SLB
I give the edge to 1910 over 1920. For me, that proof point is just right and I don’t think you lose any taste. Old Forester is great. I only wish I could find the other selections you profiled.
I've been an Irish whiskey guy for a long time - had a few bourbons (including Pappy 23) but never been pulled towards them. I got a bottle of 1910 this weekend and don't want to drink anything else now. Straight Cherry Cola and Oak.
I have had a hard time finding a bourbon I really like coming from scotch, but 1910 is probably my favorite bourbon so far.
Scotch to bourbon I think would be harder than bourbon to scotch. Glad you found 1910!
Even though I’m a more barrel proof guy, I prefer 1910 to 1920. To me, it has more flavor.
I keep a bottle of 100 & 1920 in my bar, the 100 is part of my “ daily screw top” collection
Yes!!
Early Times is the other member of my "daily screw top" collection
I love Old Forester expressions and my top 4 are the same as yours Trenton. Great bourbon!!
Such a great lineup!
I was underwhelmed by 1870 and the bottled in bond, and actually enjoyed the Statesman so it looks like we have opposite OF tastes, ha. Granted, I started with 1920 so it kind of makes sense. The 100 proof is easily one of the best value bottles.
P.s. the Statesman is from the second Kingsman movie - quality movie too.
I'm with you. In order for me is probably - 1920, Statesman, 100 proof, 1870, 1910, 86 proof, BiB.
That’s great you like the statesman!
Just purchased the 1920. Can't wait!
I just want thank you. I picked up a bottle of the Old Forester 1920 based on your opinion, and its amazingly good. I’ve never had any of their brands, and it’s pretty damn good. Thank you, bottoms up, and cheers. 👍
Some of the early 2000's Birthday Bourbons were excellent as well. Very nice bottle for the wife to make lamps out of as well. I like the distillers putting their product in pretty bottles so that gives the beautiful young lady and excuse to let me buy bourbon. Hats off to Blantons!
I scored a ‘22 birthday a couple months ago. Not one of the best but still delicious!
Kurt, I bought a 1920 a couple of weeks ago based on your March Madness. I thought it was ok at first taste, but trying it now, I get all the complexities you were talking about. Good stuff! Keep up the good work! :)
Glad you like it! Some of those higher proof bourbon need some time after popping the cork for the first time.
For me it's 1920, 1897, 1910, 100. Statesman, 1870, 86. Great exploration of a solid product line!
Thank you! Good lineup on your part!
Early in my bourbon life (three years ago), I took a flight of the years and the 1897 was my pick. I recently purchased a bottle of 1870 and 1920 and the 1920 took the gold!! I'm going to get bottle of the 1897 in the next week or two and try a flight again! My tastes have changed dramatically in three years.
That 1920 goes crazy!! Had a friend that had the barrel proof bottle but that’s gone now. Super good.
Just bought another 1920 the other day.
I'm quite green when it comes to OF, but the two (86 and 100) I had didn't impress me. I was happy to see the 1920 come into town recently, but at $60, I wasn't ready to roll the dice given the tasting notes of the younger brothers. There are a couple others at lower price points that I know are winners. I wanted to try that 1915 blend, but $115 (plus tax) to do so? Eh. I think I can wait.
Man what a great review! Our palettes always line up Kurt for the most part. I haven't had the Statesman yet probably won't waste the money.
Some on these comments disagree but just wasn’t for me.
I’m more of a scotch drinker and islay in particular but always have a bottle of the 86 in my collection. I can get it as cheap as £17 when it’s on offer and at that price it’s an amazing drink.
Kurt these are great see the lineups and how they rank. Just bought the 1920 the other day can’t wait to try it.
I’m newer to whiskey & bourbon. I had the 1870 since December, thank God I’m finally almost done with it! Not a fan! But looking forward to trying the 1920 for sure!
I'll be picking up a backup to my backup of 1920 soon. That's one that you definitely need backups of.
Love a backup of a great bottle!
I mean, come on man! You guys are great, love your chemistry and appreciate the education as I start my bourbon journey. Cheers!
1910 just didn't do it for me, but the 1920 is one of my all time favorites. We also love the Signature 100.
Both excellent picks!
I tried the old forester 1920, 115 proof. It’s the highest proof I’ve had so far in my tastings and I was pleasantly surprised. The flavors has so much depth. The heat feels slightly stronger than a makers mark 101 but it’s worth it for the flavor profile.
Really enjoy the dist. Reviews, great review!, New riff & wilderness trail would be interesting for kraft distillery
Our intent is to eventually get through them all! Lots of fun!
Btw I spoke to Harry about you (owner at bees liquor Hobart) he said if you stop by let him know that you are a supporter of the channel and he will see what he has available in the back room. Where he hides the more allocated bottles. Good luck!
@@slbdrinks thank you! Really appreciate it 😁
I just picked up a bottle of the single barrel barrel proof and excited to give it a try. Hoping you'll do a video that includes it.
Hope you love it!
I am watching this after subscribing about a week and a half ago. Still early on my bourbon journey, and I am trying different whiskey to find what I like. That being said I picked up my second bottle of the orange label 100 today. The first bottle was amazing. So far I have tried a lot of the $35 and under bourbons, tomorrow I will look for a bottle of WT Rare Breed, the 101 was outstanding.
New to all this stuff.. However a bottle of the OF 86 followed me home from the liquor store today. I get a strong caramel flavor with some citrus.
Nice!
Hey Kurt, can I take partial credit for this? If you recall, I was the first to suggest an OF tasting in the comments for the Four Roses tasting. You said, "good idea", and I'm so glad you did this! I've only had three of these seven. This was really helpful. Clearly, I need to get my hands on a bottle of either 1910 or 1920. Problem is, they are hard to find. But thanks again Kurt!
Yep. I'm an OF lover too. Love my 100 proof and 1920. I also love the rye. I've never heard good comments on the Statesman. I just finished my 1920 and will probably pick up an 1897 based on this review. Keep it up boys...
Any of those from the Whiskey Row series are just fantastic. I prefer 1910 and 1897 BiB with the single barrel bourbon close behind. They are more than worth the money.
Indeed! 1897 was the surprise for me! Don’t blame Trent at all for placing it 2nd!
The OF Whiskey Row series is just fantastic. Add in OF 100 and y’all can be in bourbon heaven.
No doubt lol!
The 100 proof Signature is one of my favorite 100 proof bourbon (WT 101, Knob Creek 9, and ET BIB are the others). Love the 1920 and the 1910. The rye is really good, too.
Old Forester standard is hands down the best bang for the buck as far as big time distilleries go. Yes, some high end stuff like the birthday bourbon and the single barrel cask strength offerings are tough to find, BUT are capable of finding when compared to overhyped Buffalo Trace stuff. Seriously, places are charging $200 for Blantons and $100 for Eagle Rare! That's all the proof you need for standard lineup avaliablity versus quality
Hi Kurt. I know you made this vid some time ago but I am just adventuring into Old Forester and went back to review. You and Kurt make such fun and informative posts. It is now my main go to for things whiskey. My pallet seems more similar to yours than Trent's preferring warm, spicy and sweet to fruity and sour notes (I grew up before Skittles-lol). I am just venturing into Old Forester and am planning to buy my first two bottles. I am definitely getting the 1920 but would like your advise on the other.
For reference my favorites include Knob Creek 9 yr CS, Russel's 10 yr CS, and Jim Beam Single Barrel CS. My daily drinkers are Rebel 100, WT 101, and KB (9Yr 100). I am not so keen on Heaven Hill products ( have Larceny, ECSB, and HH BiB). I generally sip neat but occasionally , if I am drink a cocktail, it is an Old Fashion. For my second bottle do you recommend OF 100 or OF Rye 100?
Try the OF rye. It’s low rye content so somewhat drinks like bourbon and makes a great old fashioned!
Just bringing out an 1870, 1920 and a full proof here. Pricey though but looking at a 1920 in any case.
A bit delayed but just saw on the website the local government store had 6 1920 bottles, quick trip and they now have 4.
Just picked up a second bottle 1897, really enjoyed the 1st bottle.
Yes, very much so. 1910 and 1920 are hard to beat
Picked up the 1920 at Costco yesterday for $43.99, on sale!! And, that's in California!
Like the OF line. My fav is the 1910
Great choice!
I love old forester 86, not bland and not too sweet brings a nice balance of flavors even at the low end of the market
Good show again today Kurt, I wish I had the time & the money to try them all and make my own decisions. That being said, there were a couple that you and Trent gave a thumbs down on so I'll take you words on those.
When I'm back in the US it's only for 30 days and I stay with friends so I'd have to buy a lot of bottles and leave them behind. TSA doesn't allow open bottles in checked baggage either.
A few months ago you guys put Stateman in third place in OF blind testing, today last place. This is why picking order is so hard. Anyways great video as always!!
If my memory is correct that would have been on a live show with my brother. Got me curious so I will verify however your point is well taken. Certain days can absolutely result in different results! The statesman just wasn’t for me on this show.
@@slbdrinks exactly! I double check to see if my memory was correct and yes Stateman was 3. See you guys on the live stream friday have a great day
Great! Should be a lot of fun!
Thank you guys soon much for this review. I was thinking of getting this. And now I don't think I do😆 i will stick with the old forester 1910 , 1920
Grabbed a old forester single store pick last night , excited
Yalls videos are so wholesome. Always enjoy watching. Feels like I'm sitting in a warm lit basement feeling nice
Good to know the "Statesman" isn't worth the money (Here, 40 bucks more than what you're paying!) Unfortunately, the only other ones we can get here are the 86 Proof and the Rye. Of those, I'm seriously considering the Rye only. Great video as always!
The rye is the best of the two by far imo. Enjoy!
1910 is the only one I've tried so far and it's delicious.
I can only speak for the 100 proofs, I just can't get myself to reach up and grab the bottle (750ml) of 1897 BIB $54.99 when there is a bottle of (1L) Old Forester Signature 100 Proof for $37.99 just below it, considering they are both identical from what I can find online except for the BIB with the 1897? so, what would give one more character than the other when the mash bill is I identical? I have a 1L of the 86 proof that is quite good also. Great review 🥃Cheers!
the 1920 changed; it used to have so much going on but once they made that change it feels dull. Wife and I blinded the 4 corked bottles (not the Statesman bc we heard only bad things) and the 1920 was a distant 3rd for both of us (she liked 1897 at 1 and I def went 1910). That said Id rather just do the 100 and 86 over any of them. I avoided the 86 for years bc the low proof. After hearing/watching so many reviews on how its about the best of the bunch I picked one up. I was STUNNED. Yeah its not hot at all but the nose! Wow! Cherries Banana so much going on and its got a great pallet too!
back to 1920: blinded against WT Rare Breed and it wasnt even close. Winner by KO 20 seconds into round 1 - RB. Again once they changed the label color of the 1920 the presence left with it
Just bought a oldforster 1920 today about 55.00 in Pennsylvania
I read an article on the best Booz for the buck and Old Forester was there.
I’m convinced. I gotta get a bottle of 1920
Hope you love it!
The only OF products I have seen on our local store is the 86, 1910, and 1920. I like all 3 of them and even though the 86 is no where near as good as the other 2 it is awesome for the price point. I hope to find the 100 proof on the shelf at some point. IMO for being 115 proof the 1920 has very little burn to it and might very well be my favorite but it is $60 here compared to $55 for the 1910.
It amazes me how taste preference can vary between people. Of the 3 OF products I have tried I like all 3 which you do as well but you are a big fan of WT 101 and to be honest I think it is just OK and like the OF 86 better. I love WR double oaked but prefer the OF 1910 just a hair better but have a brother that likes the WFDO better.
What you will find with me is that I have a wide range of tastes. That’s why at times I introduce other spirits that are not just bourbon. Maybe good maybe bad but I like a lot of different varieties of spirits lol!
@@slbdrinks It is one of the reasons I like your videos even though it often makes me spend more money.
That 1910 ruined me! Tried it once and now it's my go to! Sooooo good.
Kurt, great stuff as usual. I recently tried the Statesman and thought it was actually pretty good. However, I have only had the OF 1920, which was obviously really good. I really want to try the 1910 and the 100.
Unlike the norm I am glad you liked the statesman! We can’t agree all the time that’s for sure and there is nothing worse than buying a bottle of bourbon you don’t like.
@@slbdrinks no kidding. This stuff is too expensive to get one you end up not liking:)
I’m laughing because I really liked the old statesman too. Just picked it up and I was actually really surprised. I don’t get any of the harsh taste that you all got. I thought is was extremely easy to drink. Price though is an issue.
Glad you liked it!
I suggested this to yall a while back, I am glad you made this video. Thank you very much.
For me, the order would be 1897 (the current stuff just rocks), 1920 (fantastic, just not my usual proof point) and the Statesman (hoping my current bottle is an aberration). All (usually) magical, and so is their rye.
Old Forester makes excellent whiskey!
Love your shows, Always so much information. I havent done much with Old Forester, I do have a 1920, but I need to try a few more. As always Thanks for a great show
Just tried old forester for the first time got the 100 bottle cheap and a decent pour for the price
Glad I am not the only one that was disappointed with the Statesman
Really love your videos. Just starting out with purchasing different whiskey and your videos are very helpful. Thank you.
Gotta agree with Trenton, love the Old Forester line.
Further agree that the Statesman is the weakest link and by far the worst value. Wondering if you think that the 1897 BIB is worth twice the price ($44 vs $22 ) of the regular OF 100 ?? Same proof, just adding perhaps a year of aging if that??
Love the 1920 and 1910 - both hitters but around here, the 1920 is about $5 or $6 more which is absolutely worth it for the proof difference.
Great review 👏
Great video, I can't wait to try the 1920 again. The 100 is fantastic.
So really brand new at this bourbon chasing, but spot on with that 1920. It's sooooooooo good, that I have to be careful with it.
I really love your reviews. Comparing all kinds of whiskey from one brand.
All okay to various degrees, but for two. 1910 and 1920 are among the very best I’ve ever had, and easily available.
Really like and agree pretty much with your choices. I do have an O.F. Single Barrel Store Pick. Mmmmm 🥃 Cheers
Wow good for you! Soooo good!
Concerning Statesman: From the OF web-site - Inspired by the dynamic characters in the film, ”Kingsman: The Golden Circle,” Old Forester Statesman offers bold flavor blended to a smooth 95 proof from hand-selected casks of our famed Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky from the warmest places in the warehouse. Because true character is only revealed after a little heat, the Statesman product offers an exceptional balance of heat and spice.
Nice review! I love the 1920, but, unfortunately, has become very hard to come by in my area. It seems every time I find something l really like it soon becomes hard to get…..😑
That’s horrible! I truly don’t understand that. I can find 1920 in every store in the county. Sorry
@@slbdrinks I talked to the owner, and it’s a fairly large store, and he said they get a “ few bottles of the 1920 every once in a while…”. such that they took its shelf space away and hold it for those who ask…..🤷♂️😑
Get on his call list! 😎🤠👍🇺🇸
@@thelegionoftools Trust me, I’m on everyone’s call list….
Thankfully, supply has improved last several months. I stock up!
Funny that every single bottle you reviewed is $5-$10 more expensive here than the prices you quoted. I like the 1920, but is $60 here. So I don’t stock the 1920 although I do enjoy it. Bourbon has really shot up in price over the last five years or so. For me, I will stock the 100, and pick up the 1920 from time to time. I would skip the rest (just my opinion).
Hey your opinion is the only one that counts! Just 20 min away we have another great store with good bottles but they are 5-8.00 more as well.
That was awesome...
I cannot fine old forester in Cambodia and I want that 1920 for my collection...that BinB would be a cracker too!
Appreciate this video. It helps me figure out the order I want to try these! 😊
Great time- thanks!!
if it is available and msrp.. sure.. if it is alloctated(Birthday Bourbon) or secondary market.. F-It. Great Video.
Can’t blame you.
I feel like I have a hard time choosing great bourbons as a clear winner. Different day, different moon, i like 1 better than the other lol. Both 1910 and 1920 were amazing. I thought the 1910 was better in an old fashion, but again i only compared 1 time.
Yes!
Funny i tried them all too and think the Statesman was the best.
We all have different palates. Enjoy!
I love the Whiskey Row series
you guys hit it right on the nose. for me , 1920, 1910,1870, 1897, the two entry levels and the statesman dead last. will never purchase again. norwalk ohio loves you guys.
I love the exposure they got via the Kingsmen Golden Circle and the ‘Statesmen’ but that bottle is WAY too expensive for what it is. Hell I don’t even think Kirkland would want that for their bottles (which are actually pretty decent for the price). If someone offered me the 86, 100, or Statesmen; I would walk away with the 100 anyway and be very happy.
You could be a old forester salesman. Not sure if I should try the 100 or the rye first
We tried a couple of these at Brooklyn & The Butcher, a Louisville area restaurant. really liked them. I've never bought a bottle though. I have picked up the 200 proof a couple of times in the store and nearly purchased it. Usually about $20/bottle here. I'll for sure give it a try now!
I wonder how the old BF Early Times bonded or Coopers Craft would rank in this BF grouping?
My step-father passed away in 1979. When my mom passed in 2008, when I cleaned out her house and my stepdad's bar, there was a new, unopened bottle of Old Forester in the storage cabinet that had a Texas liqueur tax stamp dated 1976. Here, now in 2022, I haven't opened that bottle...yet. Should be good...
1910 is my favorite drink ever! Its hard to find in my state but I just cleaned out a liquor store near by that had three bottles. Anyone know how hard it would be to get a piece of a barrel of this stuff?? Like a tenth or something?
What do you guys think of Town Branch Kentucky bourbon?
I know you meant the best, but Memorial Day in addition to fallen Soldiers, honors fallen Sailors, Airmen, and Marines.
I can’t agree with you more! I have the utmost respect for our service men and women past and present.
1920 for the WIN 🏆