Amit shah, modi & co. Can't understand this kind of important discussion, because they are unqualified to understand such nuances. They are just leading the sheeps towards chaos!
Back ? After enabling the malignant BJP agenda for decades he is only unhappy at being excluded from the party core. By the way, the party core is two people now, all the rest are just yes-men and attack dogs.
Our politicians including the pm are uneducated riff raffs who do not know law or the constitution. Trying to hijack the constitution.. INDIA REQUIRES AN EDUCATED PM NOT CHAIWALLA WHO WILL DESTROY DEMOCRACY AND THE CONSTITUTION. SHAME ON THE VICE PRESIDENT PM AND LAW MINISTER. DAMAGING INDIAS IMAGE
@Prashant Tawade Tired of the same 70 year BS. If it's still the same or worse after 70 yrs, why elect this Government? It has only made matters worse. If you can't improve anything in 10 yrs, time to go.
Before killing any person, make him or her enemy, a traitor, murderer, criminal or a terrorist ; it makes it easy to kill him or her and it's absolving crime and freeing one of any guilt. In the name of religion and ones own god, anything goes.
Mind Begs the Question: Hitler falsely Demonized Jews/Minority To justify Evil Laws necessary To protect,for safety If a PM/Govt use same methods Following on footsteps of Hitler,No?
The word "Supreme" irritates Rijiju ji. Why not they rename Supreme Court as "Central Court"? That way it shall look like part of Central Government. 😂
Karan, it's been roughly 3 years since I started to listen to your interviews. I rarely comment, but I listen to you and the guest with utmost focus, but today I want to comment, to commend and appreciate the efforts you put in these interviews, your interviews are always fun and exiting yet they full of insight, courage and wisdom of unaccountable magnitude. As I have in the past years started to watch your interviews I have learned many things, my mental horizon has expanded manifold and my admiration for your journalism and your style of interviews has grown. Karan you are my grandfather's age, I am student of class 12th but I love that i can still call you karan. Just wanted to tell you, that your interviews have really helped me become more mature and aware of my surroundings. Never stop, keep going. Your interviews will not only educate the present but will serve as a template for many generations to come. A template of courageous journalism, of forthrightness and boldness and most importantly of guarding indian democracy. But karan, If you are reading this always remember you have a huge responsibility on your shoulders, a responsibility of accountability, a responsibility of being truthful, a responsibility of being fair and above all a responsibility of always getting truth to your listeners. Because for me karan thapar is not merely a name, it's a hallmark, I dont know, i may be wrong, but it's your duty karan to prove me and all your listeners right. Keep going my boy, today its modi, tomorrow it may be someone else, but karan thapar should always be the same.
Supreme Court Judge, RBI Governor, CBI Officer, Police Officer, Director of Enforcement Directorate (ED), Chief Election Commissioner, Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Owners of TV Channels etc all are scared of Modi Shah these days and are now busy saving their lives, recollecting the fate of Justice Loya for compelling Amit Shah for being produced in his court.Will the people of India also have to resort to violence like the people of Sri Lanka?
More power to you my friend.. if i may in my humble experience advice - 12th standard is when you listen and learn, keep aside any emotional impulse (for good or bad), its better if you stay indecisive at younger ages.. you will grow and then you will act and be decisive, Resolute.
@Prashant Tawade Fiddlesticks .If India had been administered by the RSS in 1947, there would have been only fake sadhus & sanyasis in power & the south & the East & the NE would not have been a part of India & today the competition would have been only with Pakistan
A very enlightened interview with a number of constructive suggestions made by Mr Shourie for strengthening the judiciary particularly against the political class and the bureaucracy. Much respect to Mr Shourie and Mr Thapar .
Our money deposited in banks is being embezzled in BJP fund through Adani's electoral bonds by waiving Adani's loan by Modi . Supreme court with support from Army should put Modi in jail because Police,CBI,ED,EC,IT are all Modi,s slaves.
Wonderful interview by Karan Tapa on the current relevant and dynamic topics: Judiciary, Executive and Legislature and their separate functions, and how in our day, the Legislature and Executive are trying to over-step, and how the Judiciary is failing to assert its rightful role. Arun shourie, as always, being open, outspoken, articulate, does not mince matters, when it comes to calling spade a spade. He hit the nail on the heads of those responsible in the judiciary as well as the banks, who practice double standards, favouring the rich and discriminating the poor. Karan's interviews, with outstanding, enlightened, and highly educated, and those with vast experience in different walks of life, have immense value for learning, not from books, but from the living legends and geniuses. The credit for this goes entirely to Karan alone. Thank you. 🙏🙏🙏
Very thought-provoking and inspiring interview. It's so wonderful to see such debates which concern our day to day living and which give us hope for a better multi-cultural India. We hold the Judiciary in the highest esteem even if there have been a few excellent judgements by Judges whose names will be enshrined in people's hearts and minds. Both Karan and Arun raised my hopes. As for sitting and retired judges, we can only pray they grow a spine so as to remain faithful to the Constitution, and speak out boldly when called upon to do, respectively.
@Prashant Tawade undoubtedly the current regime has superseded other previous dispensations with regard to travesty of justice, it does however gives a fillip to examine theirs too! Records of sorts have been broken, unprecedented!
he was the union minister in a.b.vajpayee's govt. which came to power after demolishing the babri mosque & faciliating riots all over the route of advani's rath yatra, bjp in 90s, then also was a hindutva party, worshiping savarkar, godse, spreading rss, vhp, bajrang dal all over india, training young people with arms & brainwashing them with communal hatred against muslims & christians, so just because he's speaking liberally now doesn't make him any better these people are the political fathers & gurus of modi, shah, yogi etc. Also, they were in the party, which made modi the cm of gujrat & later the pm candidate even after 2002 gujrat riots.
Great figures like Karan Thapar sb and Arun Shourie sb are also the strong pillars of the Nation. Thank you both the Sirs for speaks out boldly in such a way that raise the dying hopes in the public.
A really insightful interview and debate to understand the present condition of India. And our country need such cabinet minister like Arun Shourie who can tell without any fear. It was one of the most important and insightful interview I ever seen. Thank you Karan Thapar for such an interview.
So bold n academically powerful content. Two objectives n daring minds enlightening the nation. Thank you sincerely for doing it so well. God bless you both n protect you from all harm.
Aim of supreme court is to be to go all out fearlessly, objectively, not being calculative and adjusting for semi-visible settlements. Call spade a spade. Even if your life is at risk.
Was so missing Arun Shourie; its marvellous to hear and see him again, rationally placing his erudite, sensible, democratic views on the table to remind us that the Judiciary is supposed to safeguard our constitution. Thank you Karan Thapar and The Wire
CJI mila hua hai, pehle jhooth mooth ka ladenge fir compromise kar ke supreme court ko bech denge , fir CJI ko retirement ke baad governor ya ambassador bana denge
Sir Arun Shourie is brilliant as usual Thorough, impeccable, highly knowledgeable gentleman.What a BRAIN. Thoroughly thought provoking. Sincerely hope all our learned Judges,ex judges, the bar council take a leaf out of this great interview and see that Justice Is Served.
What a treat to hear Mr Thapar n Mr Shourie. Request wire to continue such meaningful discussions and involve Mr Shourie more since he’s known for his honesty n intellect
Grave warning to the present day rulers of our country as also so many valid points to note for corrective steps by them. Better late than never. Thanks to the channel for the amazing video and the contents of the interview 🙌
Am blessed to see two great gentlemen of all time having a brilliant discussion on points so important and backed by a specific roadmap laid out by Mr Shourie. One of the finest moments of my life indeed. Many thanks to Mr Karan Thapar and Mr Arun shourie . Please accept my humble Regards to both.
What an interview, amazing discussion with high quality questions, answers, body language. A perfect discussion no matter what type of questions are... Beautiful.. good place to learn many things... I love every interview on Karan.... Thanks
The present govt. has a message: "Toe our line, and you'll be rewarded; refuse to do so, and you'll be singled out for punishment." The country has not only seen Sadhasivams and Gogois but also Loya! The whole country saw through the Babar Masjit injustice. Now it is shown how the govt rewards those who gave such an unjust verdict!
I really appreciate you sir. I have been seeing your all programs for 15 years.. I completely inspired the way you posing questions. Sir I appeal you to do interview with Siddaramaiah who is stalwarts of the one Indian politician when election is approaching..
A very interesting interview that should please and at the same time should disturb the mind of the Nation. The Country should really support the honest journalism in the interest of the country.
Very means interviews between karan thapar ji and Arun sherie ji Once again we feel karan thapar ji is master of subject, he does lot of studies,which makes him most successful. Congratulations to karan thapar ji again.
All News Papers in India should publish this interview in their editorial page. Also all News channels in India (except govt sponso red) must include this interview in their prime time discussion.
Arun Shouri is a senior BJP-RSS leader and yet his handicapped son was brutally abused by BJP-RSS trolls for his remarks against BJP-RSS misgovernance. Prayers with him for speaking the truth.
By giving various prestigious positions to the retired Supreme court justices, BJP government proved its point; anyone can be bought, manipulated and destroyed of reputation, reverence and dignity.
Perfect commentary on fight between Executives & Judiciary. Glad that Mr. Shourie is giving very balanced and meaningful views. Being highly educated and as ex cabinet minister we can take his opinion on the face value.
A very good Interview, no doubt. I watch this program often. But, this interview could have been a lot better if Mr Arun Shourie Ji was allowed more space and a chance to speak. We love to listen to Mr Shourie Ji's point of view, interesting anecdotes, sharing of his own experience, and precious words of wisdom! What I felt today was that Mr Thapar was saying a lot more than a great Interviewer should, using long sentences, interrupting often, and perhaps seeking approval/endorsement of his statements from Arun Shourie Ji! No offence meant at all. I have great admiration, regard, and respect for both these learned gentlemen!
None of the instructions or their individuals are showing their spine these days against the govt. Should we presume that they are all either sold or threatened?
The preamble of the Constitution starts with 'We the People' not with 'We the Collegium' Constituent Assemble did not mention anything about the fictitious basic structure which is an invention on the Supreme Court. The power to amend lies with the People through their elected representatives in Parliament.
Happy to see Arun Shourie ji. When we were doing journalism, he was our role model. He was then heading The Indian Express, and made sleep less nights to Congress party and Indira Gandhi, with his investigative articles.
Karan another excellent interview and I fully agree with you and Arun. Having said that, I would also like to point out that, if today the Judiciary is feeling slighted, it could be a result of the weakness of self preservation of a few, who may have leaned in favour of the govt. Pre retirement judgments for post retirement benefits. Otherwise, such comments on judiciary could not have been made with such ease and nonchalance.
One of the best interviews I have ever heard in the re e t past. They discussed all matters beautify. Now it is for the judges court to save the judiciary and shut the mouth of law minister and other politicians to stop their bluff.
what an insight discussion. Going through the discourse of the interview, it has shown us the right direction to find the epicenter of the new normal term "India's Democracy at risk". Keep up the good work Sir. My highest respect to you. Love you from Manipur, a land of pro Modi's style of governance @totalitarian, majoritarian and autocratic way of governing, and where giving critical comments on the state governance via social medias ,such as facebook, means getting yourself a direct ticket to JAIL.
So right Mr Shourie that judges themselves are falling for post retirement 'rewari' undermining credibility of judiciary. It's always a pleasure to listen to Mr Shourie. Thank you Karan for getting him again on your show.
This is such a great idea. This is our dream as janta of India. It will be a happy dream come true in a country where a lot of common people understand justice is not to be expected. What a wonder it would be if…If judiciary can grow a pair and speak up for our constitution. If it could demonstrate activism in such dark times. If judiciary can stop its own degeneration that has been happening for years might have sped up in recent years. I hope justice system stands for our nation’s democracy, equality, fairness and independence and people can finally see that this country was founded upon rational thinking and not unfair, emotionally hightened speeches. Also, judiciary finds a way to speed up the justice trials and the process between charges and submission of forged evidences. Mind you, Judiciary in India didn’t have a great image among comon folks in India before current government crisis. For example a normal divorce case takes years and costs a victim so much money to ensure a fair settlement. People in this country had ultimate frustration with police and law system which was exploited during the campaign of the current government. The hunger for faster judgements is what fuelled this swift judgment era, even if it’s wrong. People see active intervention happening in the name of justice. Unfortunately, the deep rooted lack of reforming the judiciary at the same speed or scale as the country’s population or corruption is what has led to these war times for the judiciary. And it is indeed a war. If our judiciary still doesn’t wake up and speak up, show non discriminatory attitude and active resistance against internal corruption, it will be a landslide of everything we hold dear in this nation. I hope all judges and everyone associated with this profession speaks up. You can’t just be intelligent and be silent at the face of totalitarianism, when people are misled, misinformed, being brainwashed and subjugated. Your silence might ascertains non interference of opinion in the society in other times. Times when the public is fully prepared to be a citizen again instead of a “praja”.
Thanks to the Wire and Arun Shourie for the super interview. Arun shourie is a rare intellectual and one of the main stalwarts of the EX PM Vajpayeeji Team. Vajpayeeji and his team had the interests of the country on the whole in what ever circumstances in utter constrast tothe present day Regime. In the present day the value and sense of Patriotism is completely lost and the rich get richer while the down trodden get a raw deal. And the reason for all this is nothing but money, in fact it is quid pro quo policy system being run now in the country. Thats the reason why all the Ex BJP great stalwarts like Arun Shourie, Yashwant Sindha, Joshi, Jaswant Singh, who are all greats in their own way, had been shown the door and kept outof politics by the present day Regime. This is the democracy of the land in the present day. The need of the hour is a great leader who has the interest of the country foremost. First of all what has to be done is ban the use of EVM machines, and the Chief Election Commission should be controlled by the supreme Court. Jai Hind !
It is quite Educative and Enlightened Interview.The DUO is the most revered and the ones who hold their ground.As the things stand the Secretary Law is the one who signs for Minister and Minister cannot be held responsible as the Rules of Buisness stands today. It requires to be clarified???
Amit shah, modi & co. Can't understand this kind of important discussion, because they are unqualified to understand such nuances.
They are just leading the sheeps towards chaos!
They did not pass 2nd class both fail
they are doing it knowingly. they perfectly understand.
They know that we won't know, but the problem is eventually everyone will know but then they hope that it'll be too late by then.
The problem is that the sheep are in multitudes.
They are like bird of the same feather.
Very glad that Shourieji is back !!!! Being a political insider his insights are accurate & based on facts. Always good to hear him .
Back ? After enabling the malignant BJP agenda for decades he is only unhappy at being excluded from the party core. By the way, the party core is two people now, all the rest are just yes-men and attack dogs.
Mind Begs the Question:
If under a PM/Govt
Judges removed,murdered
If Judgement not Favorable
Judiciary - Independent,Compromised?
Great to see him back
This man should not be in gujju team which has dumb ministers . Good to hear him.
Our politicians including the pm are uneducated riff raffs who do not know law or the constitution. Trying to hijack the constitution.. INDIA REQUIRES AN EDUCATED PM NOT CHAIWALLA WHO WILL DESTROY DEMOCRACY AND THE CONSTITUTION. SHAME ON THE VICE PRESIDENT PM AND LAW MINISTER. DAMAGING INDIAS IMAGE
"De-humanise the person and then can do anything...." ...wow very strong remark
Absolutely the psychological truth.
@Prashant Tawade Tired of the same 70 year BS. If it's still the same or worse after 70 yrs, why elect this Government? It has only made matters worse. If you can't improve anything in 10 yrs, time to go.
Before killing any person, make him or her enemy, a traitor, murderer, criminal or a terrorist ; it makes it easy to kill him or her and it's absolving crime and freeing one of any guilt. In the name of religion and ones own god, anything goes.
@@rigeshyogi Bhai wo Modi ka kutta Hai, INC par to bhokega hi
Mind Begs the Question:
Hitler falsely Demonized Jews/Minority
To justify Evil Laws necessary
To protect,for safety
If a PM/Govt use same methods
Following on footsteps of Hitler,No?
The word "Supreme" irritates Rijiju ji.
Why not they rename Supreme Court as "Central Court"? That way it shall look like part of Central Government. 😂
Then he will become a supremo
Mind Begs the Question:
If under a PM/Govt
Judges removed,murdered
If Judgement not Favorable
Judiciary - Independent,Compromised?
Well said 😊
They may change "central government" to "super supreme government" soon 😂😂
@@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings well said
Karan, it's been roughly 3 years since I started to listen to your interviews. I rarely comment, but I listen to you and the guest with utmost focus, but today I want to comment, to commend and appreciate the efforts you put in these interviews, your interviews are always fun and exiting yet they full of insight, courage and wisdom of unaccountable magnitude. As I have in the past years started to watch your interviews I have learned many things, my mental horizon has expanded manifold and my admiration for your journalism and your style of interviews has grown. Karan you are my grandfather's age, I am student of class 12th but I love that i can still call you karan. Just wanted to tell you, that your interviews have really helped me become more mature and aware of my surroundings. Never stop, keep going. Your interviews will not only educate the present but will serve as a template for many generations to come. A template of courageous journalism, of forthrightness and boldness and most importantly of guarding indian democracy. But karan, If you are reading this always remember you have a huge responsibility on your shoulders, a responsibility of accountability, a responsibility of being truthful, a responsibility of being fair and above all a responsibility of always getting truth to your listeners. Because for me karan thapar is not merely a name, it's a hallmark, I dont know, i may be wrong, but it's your duty karan to prove me and all your listeners right. Keep going my boy, today its modi, tomorrow it may be someone else, but karan thapar should always be the same.
Supreme Court Judge, RBI Governor, CBI Officer, Police Officer, Director of Enforcement Directorate (ED), Chief Election Commissioner, Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Owners of TV Channels etc all are scared of Modi Shah these days and are now busy saving their lives, recollecting the fate of Justice Loya for compelling Amit Shah for being produced in his court.Will the people of India also have to resort to violence like the people of Sri Lanka?
@@drsunilkumardar1959 Why forget an ex-minister called Pandya
More power to you my friend.. if i may in my humble experience advice - 12th standard is when you listen and learn, keep aside any emotional impulse (for good or bad), its better if you stay indecisive at younger ages.. you will grow and then you will act and be decisive, Resolute.
Very thoughtful citizen.... Good maturity....
@Prashant Tawade Fiddlesticks .If India had been administered by the RSS in 1947, there would have been only fake sadhus & sanyasis in power & the south & the East & the NE would not have been a part of India & today the competition would have been only with Pakistan
A very enlightened interview with a number of constructive suggestions made by Mr
Shourie for strengthening the judiciary particularly against the political class and the bureaucracy. Much respect to Mr Shourie and Mr Thapar .
Panfish them minetrey
They crafty rubbin Baja ratad
Our money deposited in banks is being embezzled in BJP fund through Adani's electoral bonds by waiving Adani's loan by Modi . Supreme court with support from Army should put Modi in jail because Police,CBI,ED,EC,IT are all Modi,s slaves.
मैं एक पत्रकार हूं यह हमारा नया न्यूज़ प्लेटफार्म है आप सब के सहयोग की आवश्यकता है हम सत्य के साथ हैं ..🙏🙏👆❤
💯💯💯💯
Best debate
This Is One Of The Masterpiece...... As Usual Great Interview By Karan Thapar
मैं एक पत्रकार हूं यह हमारा नया न्यूज़ प्लेटफार्म है आप सब के सहयोग की आवश्यकता है हम सत्य के साथ हैं ..🙏🙏👆❤
💯💯💯
Kudos to you Shouri ji !! Democracy's watchdog forever.
In the judiciary's and nation's interest to heed his advice.
Please read world of fatwa written by arun shouri
Wonderful interview by Karan Tapa on the current relevant and dynamic topics: Judiciary, Executive and Legislature and their separate functions, and how in our day, the Legislature and Executive are trying to over-step, and how the Judiciary is failing to assert its rightful role.
Arun shourie, as always, being open, outspoken, articulate, does not mince matters, when it comes to calling spade a spade. He hit the nail on the heads of those responsible in the judiciary as well as the banks, who practice double standards, favouring the rich and discriminating the poor.
Karan's interviews, with outstanding, enlightened, and highly educated, and those with vast experience in different walks of life, have immense value for learning, not from books, but from the living legends and geniuses. The credit for this goes entirely to Karan alone.
Thank you. 🙏🙏🙏
Sir,
We want you to be more active in present time.
It’s good listening to you.
Karan Thapar is setting new standards to his programmes with his guest speakers. We are glad we are getting quality programmes. Please do continue.
Thank you to Arun Shourie ji and Karan Thapar ji
A great and perfectly timed interview. Thanks alot to both of you.
Very thought-provoking and inspiring interview. It's so wonderful to see such debates which concern our day to day living and which give us hope for a better multi-cultural India. We hold the Judiciary in the highest esteem even if there have been a few excellent judgements by Judges whose names will be enshrined in people's hearts and minds. Both Karan and Arun raised my hopes. As for sitting and retired judges, we can only pray they grow a spine so as to remain faithful to the Constitution, and speak out boldly when called upon to do, respectively.
Gratefully thank to honorific journalist and seasoned writer prior law minister for their trustworthy informations.
Listening Karan's show is always a fruitful act of gaining new perspective. May it be continued for many more years.
I agree 100%with Arun Shouri ji's comments.
Arun Shouriji it is a pleasure seeing & listening to you. 🙏
Good to see Arun Shourie back !
Happy to see Arun Shourie back
Present government donot require like this type of . fellows, want only bhakta .
Wanted to listen to Arun Shourie from very long, special thanks to the wire for bringing this interview to us.
Thank you very much! That’s a magnificent interview 👏🏽👏🏽
What judges can do ? fear has been instilled in their spines!
If fear is a cardinal point, then we would not have the benefit of freedom. Fearless people brought our freedom.
If they are frightened to deliver the right judgement. They should quit.
@@samsemirza3300 Rightly said
Mind Begs the Question:
If under a PM/Govt
Judges removed,murdered
If Judgement not Favorable
Judiciary - Independent,Compromised?
@Prashant Tawade undoubtedly the current regime has superseded other previous dispensations with regard to travesty of justice, it does however gives a fillip to examine theirs too!
Records of sorts have been broken, unprecedented!
Arun Shourie ji.. you're my favourite. May God bless you and your family with a very long life
he was the union minister in a.b.vajpayee's govt. which came to power after demolishing the babri mosque & faciliating riots all over the route of advani's rath yatra, bjp in 90s, then also was a hindutva party, worshiping savarkar, godse, spreading rss, vhp, bajrang dal all over india, training young people with arms & brainwashing them with communal hatred against muslims & christians, so just because he's speaking liberally now doesn't make him any better these people are the political fathers & gurus of modi, shah, yogi etc. Also, they were in the party, which made modi the cm of gujrat & later the pm candidate even after 2002 gujrat riots.
Great figures like Karan Thapar sb and Arun Shourie sb are also the strong pillars of the Nation. Thank you both the Sirs for speaks out boldly in such a way that raise the dying hopes in the public.
A really insightful interview and debate to understand the present condition of India. And our country need such cabinet minister like Arun Shourie who can tell without any fear. It was one of the most important and insightful interview I ever seen. Thank you Karan Thapar for such an interview.
So bold n academically powerful content. Two objectives n daring minds enlightening the nation. Thank you sincerely for doing it so well. God bless you both n protect you from all harm.
Ameen 🤲
@Prashant Tawade for 70 years, judges were not subservient to the government of the day like they are today.
Exactly same thoughts/ feeling here... God protect them 🙏🏼
Aim of supreme court is to be to go all out fearlessly, objectively, not being calculative and adjusting for semi-visible settlements. Call spade a spade. Even if your life is at risk.
Was so missing Arun Shourie; its marvellous to hear and see him again, rationally placing his erudite, sensible, democratic views on the table to remind us that the Judiciary is supposed to safeguard our constitution. Thank you Karan Thapar and The Wire
Terrific interview! God bless and protect you both! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
HOPE THE PRESENT CJI WATCHED THIS VIDEO : IT IS NOT ONLY INDIA BUT THE WORLD WHO HAS HIGH EXPECTATIONS FROM HIM !
Absolutely Sir..we all hope the present CJI is listening to these discussions.!!
CJI mila hua hai, pehle jhooth mooth ka ladenge fir compromise kar ke supreme court ko bech denge , fir CJI ko retirement ke baad governor ya ambassador bana denge
The greatest intellectual in India Today !....always a pleasure to hear your Views Mr. Shourie !!
Hg
As usual a nice interview taken by Senior journalist karan Thapar.
Both my favorites. We need you guys for long. ✌️
Sir Arun Shourie is brilliant as usual Thorough, impeccable, highly knowledgeable gentleman.What a BRAIN. Thoroughly thought provoking. Sincerely hope all our learned Judges,ex judges, the bar council take a leaf out of this great interview and see that Justice Is Served.
The very same man only brought modi in 2014 do u know,
He took 4 yrs to understand him aftér
What a treat to hear Mr Thapar n Mr Shourie. Request wire to continue such meaningful discussions and involve Mr Shourie more since he’s known for his honesty n intellect
Karan Thapar, Ravish Kumar, Ajit Anjum, SATYA TV, WIRE(ARSHA KAHNUM) Abhishar Sharma are the Pillars of TRUE JOURNALISM.
Where are PPBajpaye Nabin kumer,srinivasan Jain . These
are also should be included
In the list of Best jurnalists
.
Abdul toh bolega hi yahi 😂😂😂
Jab tak 25% nahi hote yahi karna hai good strategy abdul
Awesome interview, judges should be requested to avoid post retirement jobs
Grave warning to the present day rulers of our country as also so many valid points to note for corrective steps by them. Better late than never. Thanks to the channel for the amazing video and the contents of the interview 🙌
Am blessed to see two great gentlemen of all time having a brilliant discussion on points so important and backed by a specific roadmap laid out by Mr Shourie.
One of the finest moments of my life indeed.
Many thanks to Mr Karan Thapar and Mr Arun shourie .
Please accept my humble Regards to both.
What an interview, amazing discussion with high quality questions, answers, body language. A perfect discussion no matter what type of questions are... Beautiful.. good place to learn many things... I love every interview on Karan.... Thanks
Very wonderful interview.. Thanks karan thapar,,,,arun shourie.. Thanks the wire team 💐
The rot is deep. We now need to fight it at the highest level, judiciary.
The present govt. has a message: "Toe our line, and you'll be rewarded; refuse to do so, and you'll be singled out for punishment." The country has not only seen Sadhasivams and Gogois but also Loya! The whole country saw through the Babar Masjit injustice. Now it is shown how the govt rewards those who gave such an unjust verdict!
Absolutely right. You just spoke my mind
I am blessed to see you Shaurie saahab today.. Thanks for giving this interview to the man who is, again, a mind blowing person...
Thank you, Arun Shourie and Karan Thapar, for another illuminating and insightful discussion.
Thank you for getting Mr. Shouri on your program again. 🙏
Thanks!
Great to see Arun Shourie after a very long time.
Very enlightening interview to understand what's going on between Judiciary and government.
Mind Begs the Question:
If under a PM/Govt
Judges removed,murdered
If Judgement not Favorable
Judiciary - Independent,Compromised?
Karan you have a wonderful guest for opinion.Arun Shourie gave some beautiful insights 👍👍
Kudos to Karan Thapar and Arun Shourie for their fearless journalism! Keep the good work going #Wire 💯💯💯
Great interview. Judges should show courage at this historic miment
I really appreciate you sir. I have been seeing your all programs for 15 years.. I completely inspired the way you posing questions.
Sir I appeal you to do interview with Siddaramaiah who is stalwarts of the one Indian politician when election is approaching..
Thanks
A very interesting interview that should please and at the same time should disturb the mind of the Nation. The Country should really support the honest journalism in the interest of the country.
Very means interviews between karan thapar ji and Arun sherie ji
Once again we feel karan thapar ji is master of subject, he does lot of studies,which makes him most successful. Congratulations to karan thapar ji again.
All News Papers in India should publish this interview in their editorial page. Also all News channels in India (except govt sponso
red) must include this interview in their prime time discussion.
Unfortunately, almost all the media are part of Godi Media ecosystem.
Nice 👍
Arun Shouri is a senior BJP-RSS leader and yet his handicapped son was brutally abused by BJP-RSS trolls for his remarks against BJP-RSS misgovernance. Prayers with him for speaking the truth.
Judgements in public intetest cannot be delivered sitting in ivory towers.Judges have to come down to the ground level to do it.
Honest judiciary keep all institutions within their limits and people accountable
So nice to see Arun Shourie Back. What a Grace Karan Thapar brings as an Interviewer . He's the best.
Congratulations to both Karan Thapar and Arun Shourie. 🙏
After Nazeer has been rewarded for his favoring judgements i don't believe anything is Supreme about the court.
Wow what a discussion, thank you Wire, ... thank you so much Sirs 👍🏼🇮🇳🌹
good to see him in This role. - more focused towards the country - than a party. - good to see that 👍
By giving various prestigious positions to the retired Supreme court justices, BJP government proved its point; anyone can be bought, manipulated and destroyed of reputation, reverence and dignity.
A great and eye-opening interview I hope the judiciary stand up and take action
Perfect commentary on fight between Executives & Judiciary. Glad that Mr. Shourie is giving very balanced and meaningful views. Being highly educated and as ex cabinet minister we can take his opinion on the face value.
A very informative and eye opening interview very very thank you sir and the print team , you are doing great job
A very good Interview, no doubt. I watch this program often. But, this interview could have been a lot better if Mr Arun Shourie Ji was allowed more space and a chance to speak. We love to listen to Mr Shourie Ji's point of view, interesting anecdotes, sharing of his own experience, and precious words of wisdom! What I felt today was that Mr Thapar was saying a lot more than a great Interviewer should, using long sentences, interrupting often, and perhaps seeking approval/endorsement of his statements from Arun Shourie Ji! No offence meant at all. I have great admiration, regard, and respect for both these learned gentlemen!
Absolutely wonderful to listen Mr Arun. And thank you Karan sir.
Wow. This one is a super interview. Thanks Karan and Wire. DYC has to find time to listen this one. Please point him. :)
He who has an ear, let him hear.
None of the instructions or their individuals are showing their spine these days against the govt. Should we presume that they are all either sold or threatened?
The preamble of the Constitution starts with 'We the People' not with 'We the Collegium'
Constituent Assemble did not mention anything about the fictitious basic structure which is an invention on the Supreme Court. The power to amend lies with the People through their elected representatives in Parliament.
Happy to see Arun Shourie ji. When we were doing journalism, he was our role model. He was then heading The Indian Express, and made sleep less nights to Congress party and Indira Gandhi, with his investigative articles.
Karan another excellent interview and I fully agree with you and Arun. Having said that, I would also like to point out that, if today the Judiciary is feeling slighted, it could be a result of the weakness of self preservation of a few, who may have leaned in favour of the govt. Pre retirement judgments for post retirement benefits. Otherwise, such comments on judiciary could not have been made with such ease and nonchalance.
One of the best interviews I have ever heard in the re e t past. They discussed all matters beautify. Now it is for the judges court to save the judiciary and shut the mouth of law minister and other politicians to stop their bluff.
GREAT Program. Please keep this information coming.
Lot of thanks 🙏 to Honourable Karan Thapar & Honourable Arun Shauri
Excellent interview! Great discussion and nicely dissects the govt vs judiciary do’s and don’t . Congratulations 🍾
Excellent Discussion. Judges should be free of any type of pressure.
It's so mind-blowing so enlightening 🙏
Very good suggestion by Mr. Arun Shourie regarding monitoring and honouring it's judgements
After a long time to see Mr. Arun Shauri his honesty and views expressed about the constitution.
You are making the profession of journalism an exalted one. Congratulations Karanji Advocate MCM Jamal
Very impactful discussion.
Arun Shourie is candid . Thanks for superb program
One among your most insightful Interviews Karan!
what an insight discussion. Going through the discourse of the interview, it has shown us the right direction to find the epicenter of the new normal term "India's Democracy at risk". Keep up the good work Sir. My highest respect to you. Love you from Manipur, a land of pro Modi's style of governance @totalitarian, majoritarian and autocratic way of governing, and where giving critical comments on the state governance via social medias ,such as facebook, means getting yourself a direct ticket to JAIL.
Thanks Mr Arun Shourie and thanks Mr Karan Thapar
I'm sure Modi government couldn't have afforded this man who's full of wisdom unlike its other cabinet ministers
Excellent interview, Mr Shourie and Mr Thapar
> I am so happy to see Mr Arun well and fit
Both the men are great intellectuals and it was an opportunity to see the interview.👍👍
So right Mr Shourie that judges themselves are falling for post retirement 'rewari' undermining credibility of judiciary. It's always a pleasure to listen to Mr Shourie. Thank you Karan for getting him again on your show.
Brilliant discussion by both legend at the Era of Godi Media... Save our Democracy & people of India 🇮🇳 Keep it up, Karan Saheb..
This is such a great idea. This is our dream as janta of India. It will be a happy dream come true in a country where a lot of common people understand justice is not to be expected. What a wonder it would be if…If judiciary can grow a pair and speak up for our constitution. If it could demonstrate activism in such dark times. If judiciary can stop its own degeneration that has been happening for years might have sped up in recent years. I hope justice system stands for our nation’s democracy, equality, fairness and independence and people can finally see that this country was founded upon rational thinking and not unfair, emotionally hightened speeches. Also, judiciary finds a way to speed up the justice trials and the process between charges and submission of forged evidences. Mind you, Judiciary in India didn’t have a great image among comon folks in India before current government crisis. For example a normal divorce case takes years and costs a victim so much money to ensure a fair settlement. People in this country had ultimate frustration with police and law system which was exploited during the campaign of the current government.
The hunger for faster judgements is what fuelled this swift judgment era, even if it’s wrong. People see active intervention happening in the name of justice. Unfortunately, the deep rooted lack of reforming the judiciary at the same speed or scale as the country’s population or corruption is what has led to these war times for the judiciary. And it is indeed a war. If our judiciary still doesn’t wake up and speak up, show non discriminatory attitude and active resistance against internal corruption, it will be a landslide of everything we hold dear in this nation. I hope all judges and everyone associated with this profession speaks up. You can’t just be intelligent and be silent at the face of totalitarianism, when people are misled, misinformed, being brainwashed and subjugated. Your silence might ascertains non interference of opinion in the society in other times. Times when the public is fully prepared to be a citizen again instead of a “praja”.
Thanks to the Wire and Arun Shourie for the super interview. Arun shourie is a rare intellectual and one of the main stalwarts of the EX PM Vajpayeeji Team. Vajpayeeji and his team had the interests of the country on the whole in what ever circumstances in utter constrast tothe present day Regime. In the present day the value and sense of Patriotism is completely lost and the rich get richer while the down trodden get a raw deal. And the reason for all this is nothing but money, in fact it is quid pro quo policy system being run now in the country. Thats the reason why all the Ex BJP great stalwarts like Arun Shourie, Yashwant Sindha, Joshi, Jaswant Singh, who are all greats in their own way, had been shown the door and kept outof politics by the present day Regime. This is the democracy of the land in the present day. The need of the hour is a great leader who has the interest of the country foremost. First of all what has to be done is ban the use of EVM machines, and the Chief Election Commission should be controlled by the supreme Court. Jai Hind !
Excellent interview.. Thanks
Excellent analysis of the subject to the bare truth of happening .
Way to put out your suggestion to the Judiciary.
It is quite Educative and Enlightened Interview.The DUO is the most revered and the ones who hold their ground.As the things stand the Secretary Law is the one who signs for Minister and Minister cannot be held responsible as the Rules of Buisness stands today. It requires to be clarified???
Very lively debate on the conduct of judges in the high up court. Thank you