Supreme Court is Afraid of Modi, Collegium System Failing, Many Judges Undeserving: Dushyant Dave
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ก.พ. 2023
- Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/support-the-int...
In a devastating critique of the judiciary, the Supreme Court and the Collegium system, the likes of which I, at least, have not heard before from any lawyer speaking in public, one of India’s most highly regarded lawyers and a former President of the Supreme Court Bar Association, has said: “We have a large number of judges who are highly questionable. They either lack the expertise or the knowledge and most of all the commitment.” Dushyant Dave adds: “The Supreme Court is afraid of taking the executive head on”. Referring specifically to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who he says is a strong Prime Minister like Indira Gandhi and doesn’t want the judiciary to question him, Mr. Dave adds “unless we have a judiciary who is willing to question day in and day out” it will be failing the country, the constitution and the concept of justice.
Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Our institution are crumbling no doubt. Hats off to Mr Dave for speaking fearlessly on this critical issue.
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
Should we, commoneople, watch helplessly the appointment of judges who are rather interested for their own future after retirement.
@Subhash Banerjee in is happening from 1947. Why cry now. The statua quo is maintained as usual. Ha ha ha
@@jotendrakumar2852 judges were never murdered in other govts as in Modi govt. If you're real Indian n really have brain, your blood must boil on this misuse of power
@@logical_analyst Logic does not work with andhbhakts, neither do they care about the country nor law and order within the country. All they care about is anti-muslim stance of the party in power.
Really democracy heart beats through such courageous and unbiased lawyers like Daveji.
Thanks to Mr.Dave for his straight forward talk, which really needs serious introspection. What he says is very true. And the standard of the Indian Judiciary is really going from bad to worse. Political interference in Judiciary is not at all advisable. Judges being posted to plump positions after their retirement is not at all a good precedence. This definetely casts serious aspersions on their judgements. This is not good for Indian democracy. What we all Indians really want is truth and righteousness to last forever. Jai Hind !
Intimidation - threat to life of the self and /or the family members is not a bearable thing to any judge unless the judge is so determined to uphold the law of the land. Every human has a breaking point,of course. At times he might feel helpless and enough is enough. Deplorable.
True. Fairness and judicial.prudence cannot come at the risk of life of some of the best indian minds
Bow to you Mr. Dave , God bless you and protect you 🙏
Dushyant Dave is a lion heart. We need more people like him in all fields in India.
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
Indeed yes. Mr Dave proved himself to be MAN OF DEMOCRACY.
@@jotendrakumar2852 dude judges getting salary from people's money. Not from Modi's or Manmohan's🤦
People with half baked knowledge will ruin the nation, just like you
@Pavin Kumar ha ha ha. Are u transferring money directly to judges account. No isn't it. U pay tax to government isn't it and government pays it to judges isn't it ha ha ha . See the logic sirji. Ha ha ha
@@jotendrakumar2852 🤣🤣🤣 this is why education is important. Even P.M is paid with the tax money i.e., P.M is a servant of people just like judges. As per constitution judges should withhold the justice and not pleasing the govt🤣🤣🤣
Moreover the media and opposition should question the govt ( questioning govt is not questioning India, questioning bjp just because they are ruling India doesn't mean questioning India) if anything goes wrong. And the court should condemn it. Not me mum.
Thanks Karan Thapar for bringing such a critical issue to light. I appreciate Dushyant Dave's candid views on the state of judiciary.
Sir, we salute you for making an appreciation remark and paying karan's honourable work. I wish we could do it too.
What r your credeñtials.how do we know u know everything.To you govts r bad,collegium r also bad,then what is good. Don't mind,but I feel you also is a corrupt and shouting bez u may not have got your booty.
Really glad to see a man like him in this country
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
@@jotendrakumar2852 Don't 'ha ha ha' about it and don't repeat yourself ad nauseam. Train your mind to be in the side of truth as put forth by Mr Dave whose worth to our country is far far more valuable than the likes of the whole BJP and their sycophants put together!
He should also say that British chamcha were the constitution makers.
@@jotendrakumar2852 ... Communal company party leaders are living the life of luxury on tax payers money and judges salary is also given from tax payers money
@Ishtiaque Ahmed all parties r communal as they do religious and caste appeasement and congress has shown the way from 1947 to 2013. So why blame one party when all parties r enjoying the benefits of communal politics.
Thank you Dushyant Dave ji for speaking up. Hope we have more people in the Indian judiciary, like you, who are honest and fearless.
BRAVO DUSHYANT DAVE JI. HOPE OTHER LAWYERS AND JUDGES GET ENCOURAGED TO STAND UP BRAVELY AS YOU DO FOR JUSTICE AND LIBERTY.....
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
🤣😭🤣🫢🤣🥴🤣😭🤣
@@jotendrakumar2852 Judges do not depend on the party in power. The salaries and other court expenses becomes automatically payable ; those expenses being charged expenditure on the consolidated fund.
@BR really. Ha ha ha. Government provides their salaries and perks isn't it. They don't have a finance source of their own isn't it
@BR consolidated fund comes from government coffers isn't it. Ha ha ha . So from 1947 judges listen to party in power. Why cry now
Thanks Thapar Sahab & hats off to Adv. Dushyant Daveji. You both have condolisated my belief that there are fearless people who dare to take head on P.M., Ministers, Executive, CJI & other incompetent judges.
Kudos to you Gentlemen.
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
IT guy spotted
What an explosive and bold interview. God bless a handful of upright and honest people,because of which,we have a semblance of justice.We need more such individuals if we truly want a just and honest legal system.
What a brilliant exposition of the state of affairs in our top most court of law,and
what ails it.
Mr Chandrachur is sauve, but he is yet rise to the occasion the people demand from him.
Dave is real Indian... Keep it up Sir. You are a great source of inspiration. Standing up against the tide is appreciated.
I saw his speech couple of days ago.. It was outstanding and true.
The best interviewer and the best Supreme Court advocate , was an excellent discussion. I was very much impressed that Mr. Dushyan Dave has very well understood ,what will be the impact of him voicing his frank opinion, and still he stood what was right. Wonderful thank u both.
You could feel the frustration and sadness in voice of Mr Dave.
What an outstanding personality Mr. Dave is who has the guts to say spade an spade.
He is straight forward, honest and bold in his observations about the judiciary of today
So much is happening- thank you Mr Thapar & Mr Dave for this.
🎩's off to Dushyant Daveji for very honestly, boldly and fearlessly speaking his mind on the very sorry state of affairs. True fighter and upholder of principles of Democracy. Hope you succeed.
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
Well said sir, how many judges has heard this speach, and realize and changed for the sake of humanity and sake of our nation india, sir we need you has a judge
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
@@jotendrakumar2852 here comes the "Copy paste Man, from IT cell."
@Mike copy paste in judiciary has been happening from 1947. Why cry now
@@jotendrakumar2852 because democracy is bad to worse now going to dead atleast you should stand up and support such brave people to save our Judiciary .
Jai hind.
@@jotendrakumar2852 you are crazy 🤣. Don't know what you are talking about.
True humanity speaks through both the interviewer and the interviewee
Congratulations to Mr Dave for his candid and passionate account of the Indian judiciary. Hope more eminent judges and lawyers speak up and set the ball rolling for effecting corrective reforms within the judiciary.
Dave Sir is a bold and courageous lawyer who speaks out his heart. Hats off to you sir for highlighting the lacunas and constitutional duties underperformed by sc and collegium. Thank you Karan Sir and the wire for bringing out such a fabulous interview.
Salute the fearlessness and daring of Adv Dave in coming out so openly against the sorry state of the highest court of the country. Supreme court gas always failed the citizens of this country in the kind of political situation as we find ourselves in . This happened during emergency and is again happening in such an unabashed manner in the present political scene so much so that one can almost predict what the outcome on petitions would be when these seek relief from the excesses of the executive which are clear violations of the fundamental rights .
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
The fellow tells us that people elected Executives have to work under judges selected judiciary! This is how he thinks he is honouring our democratic Constitution. Is he telling us Alladin's story?
He should also say that British chamcha were the constitution makers.
@@jotendrakumar2852 Govt get money from people. Judges are constitutional post to prevent executive over reach. Not only Karan, everyone should be worried.
@@jotendrakumar2852there are constitutional bodies and statutory bodies. Constitutional are those that were created to be almost independent of the executive, their salaries are not voted upon, hence independent of the government in power.
Since this comment off yours was almost an year ago, I hope you must have already learnt all this by now. So moot point. But if you haven't, I would request you to pick up the constitution or atleast a school grade civics book. You will be able to understand the interview better. :)
Dave sahab is only real lawyer who deserves to be a supreme judge. Whenever I listen him it reconfirm my view that our judiciary should be like that. I don't know what extent one could do these once be a judge but still his views are really required to be listened and followed
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
Everybody is too busy looting the national wealth, sorry no time to think over moral or ethical issues.
@@jotendrakumar2852 No boss lot of good judges were there always there who didn't succumb to the government pressure. But the thing is more dangerous that what Dave sahab is telling that nowadays those types of judges are not selected either by the collagium or if selected but not actually appointed by the government by using some unfair tactics. And why the current judiciary is not taking this seriously and not taking any real action which power they actually having.
He should also say that British chamcha were the constitution makers.
Greatest of respect to Mr.Dave... Brave of him to stand up in these trying times. ✨
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now. Trying times from 1947. Nothing changed
Thank you, Mr. Karan Thapar, for bringing such a bold and contemporary program, which is truly an eye-opener for many to safeguard democracy and our holy constitution. Thank you Sir Dushyant Dave for sharing such an innocently courageous statement which is the hard reality of our judiciary system. we are proud of you .
Karan I thank you for being such a great interviewer, asking the right questions, keeping the interview on track and interpreting the answers with such clarity and comprehension
Rightly said Mr.Dave. only way this can be avoided is by a law that the judges should not be appointed to any government post for atleast five years unless some enquiry need to be made under retired judge .
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
Hat's off to D.Daveji, Prashant Bhusan ji & few courageous for fighting for the innocents, against wrong doings by the government machinery, especially the minorities..
The common man has lost faith in law's and Courts upto HC level,but now even the SC has lost the people's confidence,for its non actions since the last Seven to Eight years,in various matters.
SC has become Suspicious Court.❓
Mr Dave is an exceptionally brave person. It's always a pleasure listening him.
The Supreme Court, the Bar, the collegium and his peers must take his words without any fear or prejudice, to save the judiciary, our democracy and this beautiful country.
We are always with neutral and intellectual media.
Things can still be set right, if people speak up, and take a stand. We need many more Dushyant Daves in the Law community, too.
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
@@jotendrakumar2852 Government as a representative of the State is traditionally separated into 3 parts, ie the legislature, the executive and the judiciary, and all of them are to discharge their constitutional obligations! Perhaps, you don't know that the salaries of the justices from higher judiciary are charged on the consolidated fund of India, beyond the power of the executive (govt as you meant)! Ask those who know or Google it and help restore the confidence of Aam Aadmi in the institutions of the country!
@@jotendrakumar2852 ... The top leader is touring the world on tax payers money
@Ishtiaque Ahmed But he has contributed to starting business relationships with Saudi UAE and they have given him their nations top awards isn't it and doing business opportunities with India. Same with Europe USA Japan Singapore Malaysia Indonesia Mongolia isn't it.
All politicians travel with tax payers money from 1947. So Modi ia doing the same. No surprise as it ia okay with political parties leaders in India and other nations.
When u become PM, u will also get benefit to travel with tax payers money. This is a perk u get. So just avail the perk benefits. Cool
TRUE That ...BUT; With a largely impoverished peoples of 1.30 BILLION - That will never ever happen. Give That Absolute Number of "largely impoverished people" : ROTI, KAPPADA, MAKAAN & The CIRCUS and One is Free to get on with a " larger agenda" 🙂. I guess, we will have to 'Enjoy The Ride' and HOPE that everything will pan out well.
It's time for action by cbi, ed against Dushyant? Fully agree with the views, tbanks Karan Thapar, Dushyant Dave and The Wire
Thank you Mr. Thapar, for an excellent interview with a man of extraordinaire skills (Mr. Dave) in judicial system, having courageous anti-tide stand and vocal about the shortcomings of present system.
I was fortunate to have been an intern at Mr. Dave's chamber and can say with my hand on heart that he is one of the most genuine lawyers who deeply cares for the underprivileged and the unrepresented population of the country. Thank you for your courageous interview and hats of to Karan and The Wire.
Can you please provide mail of Mr. Dave Sir's office, where we can apply for imternship?
A lawyer with a difference, TO BE GREATLY ADMIRED
A big salute to Ad.Dave for his courage to stand with truth,....Jai Hind
Great interview, thanks Karen for the extraordinary piece of journalism in these very testing times.
Was a treat to listen to the legal stalwart
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
Thank you very much Mr Thapar. And about Mr Dave no words of praise is enough..
We feel and believe that because of people like Dushyant Dave there is HOPE. Otherwise the country is going to dogs.
God bless you and protect you, Sir. We appreciate your heart felt reasons for going public fearlessly. You have done a great justice giving this interview to Karan Thappe.🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍
Astonishing interview and mindblowing too which reveals the bitter truth of our judiciary system and makes me thinking about our future generations
Mr. Dave and Mr. Bhusan are few luminaries in the jurisprudence that gives us hope in this system. They are not only wise but extremely brave and passionate of the rule of law that makes India a great country to live.
Wish our collegium with take the right clues to meet its commitments and aspirations.
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
Thank you profoundly Mr. Dave for your courage and integrity. Wish the Supreme Court had the same.
Makes me Wonder if there are No
Honest People left in the System.
Are We Incapable of Producing
Honest People as a Society ? 😭
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
Yes, of course
Colleguim looks like close knit group where post will be hankipankied among themselves...lol...so called hon judiciary..or mockery...
Very courageous journalist and lawyer. India needs such courageous people very much.
Crystal clear… what an interview 👌. This is called real journalism.
Dave ji, we are really honoured to hear your not only sharp but realistic views and critics on the judiciary and legislatures. Our country needs more people like you to speak up against unlawful things and situations. You are really brave sir, we salute you.
Thank you Dushyant Dave for your candid speech.
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
Thank you Karan and Mr Dave for bringing out the real issues of judiciary. Hats off to you both. I loved
Dushyant Dave, sanjay hegde, Prashant Bhushan are gems of Indian law fraternity.
We have a very few honest true objective journalists left in the country. You are one of them Sir. 👍👍
Professional ethics more important than anything in discharging our duties .Life is one beginning and one ending between these two our life is .
Even a clip I have seen , admitting Ex. Supreme Court Judge and now a MLC in Rajyasabha Mr. Ranjan Gogai, saying Corruption in Courts is very well there and its way of accepted life now a days. Now what to say further.
Never liked the poison dwarf Gogol after his interview with Sreenivasan Jain. Your comment suggests his conscience is as challenging as his physical appearance
Dushyant Dave a Braveheart,
We respect you for your honesty & for speaking the truth ,
Wish the judiciary has many more like him & protect Democracy in today's India
Bravo Mr Dave.
You are a legend.
Please continue with the good work.
We have seen how Justice Muralidhar was transferred immediately when he sought information from police about the case he was handling.
Thanks Karan tapar for bringing this issue . Thanks Mr. Dave for speaking the truth. 👍
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
We always love and respect Dushyant Dave sir for his sincerity, honesty and loyalty towards justice ⚖️ and nation. BRAVO sir, wish you were the CJI.
One of the great interview. Thank you.
We are still fortunate enough to have lawyers activist like Dushyant Dave, Prashant Bhushan who are fearlessly spearheading the campaign against the high handedness of govt and shortcomings of Supreme Court.
Was surprised by the comments of Justice Chandra hand and his lack of urgency in the hijab ban. Thought he would rise above this deference to the BJP. So much for a Harvard education and all the Indians swear by "Education". Just because someone is a doctor or CEO does not make them honest and god people
Sure Mr. Dave, your fearless stance will definitely contribute to make a better country, better judiciary and better rule of law. Proud of you sir ! 🔥💖
Thank you, Mr. Karan Thapar for an exceptional interview 👌💖
Coming generation will remember you Mr Dave for speaking out the truth . Bravo.👍
May God bless Mr Dave. Only such honest lawyers can safeguard Judiciary and Domoracy .
Kudos for sharing thoughts with the most coveted legal perspective and personalty ... What a pleasure to listen to the most civilized discussions with no noises...
To my mind He is the only one who is very sharp not only in the field of law but also very critical of what happened in our beloved country.
It's difficult for most to be so courageous and sacrificing as Mr Dave. However, all of us should have some 'Daveness' in some measure.
Salute you Mr D. Dave. God bless you for your boldness. We need people like you desperately. We need people like you to speak fearlessly and honestly. Thank you sir. My best wishes go with you.
I am highly impressed by the views of Adv. Dave. It is time for genuine people in positions of power to be on the side of justice .
Now the situation is worse. BJP wanted RSS ideologists as SC judges.
Does congress ideology loot is better congress appointed k r Narayan and he insisted many worthless like balakrishnsn as judge and muscles of conscience started rusting
@@lappasiramasamy2440 if the Congress has done something wrong , does not provide right to wrong for BJP
@ Lappasi Ramasamy
Looting/wrongdoing by ideologues of any party - Congress in the past is not a justification for the wrongdoing by BJP during its term in political power in the country.
Citizens taking sides, about the wrongdoings by political parties, is worse, because in the process the interests of the people, who by their votes, bring these rogues into power, and they instead of giving good governance, go on betraying the interests of people by their party ideological agendas.
I hope Mr Thapar will have interview with Mr Dushyant Dave ji on topic " post retirement jobs affect the pre retirement judgements" . Thanks wire and team. Special thanks to Mr Dave ji for expressing his concern about weaker section.
The last words put in so beautifully. More power to him.
Respect for you sir for being so blunt, we need more people like you
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
This is the Best interview. The WIRE is always neutral headed by Karan Thapar
Thank you, Mr Dave, for openness and critical 🙏🏻
Mr. Dave is very passionate today and I am so moved by the stance he has taken clearly knowing the consequences. I always watch his discussion is several channels and his sincerity is unquestionable.
High praise for Mr. Dave for his fearless views under current circumstances. He has raised a very valid point that MLAs who are taken in plane and lodged somewhere else the court should not allow those MLAs to take part in floor test
Salute Dushyant Dave ji and Karan Thapar ji🌹🙏
Dave Sir, your sacrifice for a better tomorrow will be rewarded, if not in the near future, but definitely when the history of India will be written. Thank you for speaking on behalf of the thousands in this country
Salute to both of you Sir,
No words can thank you...... Dave Sir you are an inspiration to the truth lovings,
That's the spirit , such a honest person you are.
May God keep you both Always Healthy , Happy & long life
Salute to karan and dave sir.
We the Indians are always with the truth sir and you and people like you will always inspire generations to come...keep up the difficult work that you do sir and may The God help you all to be victorious in this life and the other
I love watching these interviews because of how precise, on point the talks are unlike the interviews that are held on tv channels with big public figures that just take us round and round without any context.
Adv. Dushyant Dave is an emancipated and enlightened legal luminary who serves the nation and the humanity at large.
It's indeed a very tragic situation. We heard and saw the rise of our amazing country, but we are now watching its downfall since 2014, only god should help to reverse this tragic situation.
Independent judiciary, rule of the law and strong democracy are the pillars on which the edifice of a thriving nation is built.
Frightening future: Judiciary has fallen 😮
Salute Adv Dave for his honesty and outspokenness. The truth will free any God fearing person.
Excellent interview. Thanks to Mr Karan Thapar and Mr Dushyant Dua
The eye's of the country remain shut but the voice of concern expressed boldly by Mr Dave ought to shake the conscience of the judiciary for they themselves are no less responsible for the present situation.
More respect to Dave sir, God is with you , God is TRUTH.
Dushyant Dave sir is becoming bolder by the day
He is right wherein he points out that the institutions need men of steel
It was indeed an eye opening interview. At the end of it one feels a sense of despair, where are we headed as a nation?
Ha ha ha. Judges get salary from government ie., party in power and r loyal to party in power from 1947. Why is Karan opposition crying now.
Best interview and hope it changes the hearts of the people and lead the country in the right direction
Loved the love both of has for the nation, every second of hearing worth a lot of pain for any Indian i think Bravo sir and sir
Salute to this soldier. One of the few left to defend the constitution and democracy. 🙏🙏
Justice has gone blind literally 😢
Bravo Mr. Dushyant Dave, Thanks Mr. Karan for the interview.
He has always been outspoken, we need a lot more honest and encourages judges, who, will stand up and uphold our constitution... Save our democracy.
Karan, I have seen a few of your interviews a couple of decades ago on a news channel. Your interviews were very forthright and very bold, bringIng out the facts so clearly which benefited and influenced public opinion. I heard your interview with the bold and forthright hero- advocate Mr. Dave. It was very informative and shows our judiciary in the right light. I always knew the state of affairs in the SC. But this interview brought all the details. Thank you very much. We need tens and tens of Karans and Daves to encourage our judiciary to act with an iron hand, more so with conviction and a strong conscience to fearlessly deliver justice to the POOR.
LET YOUR TRIBE GROW. 🏹🏹🏹
Mr. Dave is a gem of a man!
My regards 👍