The World Is Safer Without the JCPOA || Debate #2
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ต.ค. 2024
- The Trump administration's decision to pull the United States out of the JCPOA, colloquially called the Iran nuclear deal, has received mixed reviews. Some say Iran wasn’t really complying with the terms and that the deal gave too much away from the outset with the easing of sanctions. Others disagree, saying the multilateral agreement was the global community’s best shot at curbing Iran’s nuclear ambitions. Which side is right? Is the world safer without the JCPOA?
Michael Doran - Senior Fellow, Hudson Institute & Fmr. Sr. Director, National Security Council
Reuel Marc Gerecht - Senior Fellow, The Foundation for Defense of Democracies & Fmr. CIA Case Officer
Bernard Haykel - Professor of Near Eastern Studies, Princeton University
Brett McGurk - Fmr. Special Presidential Envoy for the Global Coalition to Defeat ISIS
Barbara Slavin - Director, The Future of Iran Initiative, The Atlantic Council
Seems like they shipped this panel straight from tel Aviv.
Lol true
Israel with 300 nukes yet iran a treat. Total nonsense some this guys are total right wing double standard
hamidu barrie this why they keep all way eyes open on Saudi Arabia and letting Iran spreading chaos without single small slap
America, I am glad these guys are your thinkers, and I am an Iranian...
Your exit from mideast will be a lot sooner than I thought.
Very clever point. . . as an Iranian why get angry that these guys don't make any sense!
Loraine Jones exactly that’s why poverty is widespread in Iran
@@hamadalmehrizi6078
You can live in your universe.
More % of Iranians own their home outright than in USA.
And that is a fact.
kamran kam I agree with you that’s why there are many Iranians that live all over the world.
@@hamadalmehrizi6078
There are many Arabs and many Italians and many Irish a d many Spanish and many Indians and many Chinese live all over, and your point is???
Why "Double Standard" when it comes to Iran????
I'm not a Iranian!!!
Burloakonario that’s true. it should be bombed and disarmed as they did with Irak first hour. then establish democracy on occidental model.
because iran is biggest terrorist nation funder
Is this program made inside Israel!?
Iran is paying a price because it strives to be independent and not a u.s client state like Saudi Arabia.
I would like to see a debate on whether the U.S. should re-sign the nuclear forces INF Treaty with Russia. As it is now it is an arms race because Russia does not want to feel vulnerable but at the same time the U.S. was handcuffed from defending itself from other countries that could be a threat. The other video I would like to see is define in detail the New Start treaty and how it is effective or not. Does it replace the INF Treaty or is it a shadow without definitive lines
This video and the expert opinions have not aged well. Nearly 2.5 years down the road, everyone looks quite wrong and their predictions just completely off the mark.
It is logical for Iran and Saudi Arabia to have nuclear weapons once Israel can boast a hundred nuclear heads as a threat to other nations in the area.
Because of the consequences of No deal we had a deal. JCPOA was not call a grand bargain..live with it..Iran is a nuclear capable country
Saudi Arabia may not depend on America in the coming days, especially after the end of the Trump era because it does not support the views of Saudi Arabia on Iran and its regime, and there are more than one country wishes to have an ally Russia and many others and if Saudi Arabia changes alliances will change all Arab countries as well ...
Thanks lots for sharing. ❤️
Irán has not invaded any country while it was invaded by Iraq.
Money that us payed was iranian money before revelation
NO
A better tittle for this show is square root of intelligence. these people are war hawks and all European partners cannot also be stupid for being in the deal.
God bless you Barbara, the most truth speaking mind on this panel
It's funny they keep saying the US gave Iran money whose money
Barbara Slavin really embarassed herself here. I could've done a better job arguing her position
Safer this is total lies smh
I want to answer this question your expert and you said trump told Saudi stop funding Islam out side suadi Arabia or traditional Muslim how they can survive around muslim world?
Im not and advocate of Iran or Saudi Arabia. But please Iran has a civilization dating back to 7000 years. Compared to Saudi which is 70 years. The country should not be named Saudi Arabia after a family name (Saud)
Abdulaziz Alshareef you ignorant fool learn about Saudi and the Arabian peninsula history which is much older than many civilizations combined... it’s as old as religion itself!
iran before 1979 = good
iran after 1979 = bad
khominei is terrorist
Sa is one of the oldest civilization in history of huminty.
hhhhh176 wow you morons really don’t know history do you? Were there people in Saudi Arabia 8000 years ago? Probably. Was there a civilisation back then? NO!. The oldest civilisations, were Mesopotamia (Iraq/Iran 10000BC), ancient Egypt, Norte Chico ( South America), Mayan (South America),Indus civilisation, (Afghanistan/Pakistan), and Jiahu (China).
Just because someone has a suit and talks fancy doesn't mean they know what the hell they're talking about!
Very weak SHALLOW debate, disappointed at IQ squared.
What 'yes' sayers argue is absurd. . .
A. Middle East is a very unsafe region with countries spending astronomical amounts of money on military.
B. Israel and Pakistan both have nuclear ballistic missiles.
C. Iraq invaded IRAN and the result was 8 years of bloody war with a MILLION ppl DEAD on the Iranian side.
D. It is crystal clear US wants to topple down Iranian Gov, just look at their military bases, look at what their officials have been openly saying, look at Libya, Yemen, Syria, Egypt etc.
E. US is already and has been for a long time waging economic warfare against Iran with all sorts of crippling sanctions.
F. Under these very sanctions imposed on Iran by the US, Iranians can't buy any military equipment!
Now given all these points the 'Yes' sayers are saying that GPoA wasnt good cause it didn't stop Iran's proxies, and Iran's ballistic missiles program!!!!!!!!!!! HOW F'in absurd. . . you would look more truthful if just come out honestly and say we want Iran's gov. changed through any means possible. . . have a lil bit of honesty!
And the whole ballistic missile program is Absurd again . . . Anyone with a bit of TECHNICAL knowledge about military equipments would know that Iran's missile program (is one of a kind in the world) is focused on use of ballistic as PRECISION WEAPONS to make up for Iran's weak airforce!
We're living in the age of communication and technology yet people are so misinformed that it's funny.
Cuneyt Özdemirden Gelenler toplanma noktası👍
6:30 min Excuse me. you did not do your homework. It does not provide a full inspection as their military sites cannot be inspected!
11:37 min Excuse me. Slavin. You lost the argument and you shut it out with a closing illogical sentence.
hahahaha LMAO. . . what sort of powerful sovereign country would let foreigners inspect "WHERE EVER THEY WANT" !!!!
Do u have any ideas how absurd you sound!
If that's what you expect fine. . . .wait for Iran to give that permission :D
That's why the JPCOA is a JOKE!
Debate!!! 😂😂😂😂😂
How many Jews on that panel
O