the phantom winning was entirely my fault, and I'll regret it for the rest of my life. they should fix it tho. Maybe re-tooling it to haunt 1.18's new caves, and only attacks when it hears you.
@@spicymeatballs2thespicening I like to think the hovering inferno would be like the elder guardian y'know? miniboss type shit but I wouldn't think the elder guardian is a miniboss though
Would you choose: A) A wholesome variant of a cow mutation and a new possibly useful item to come with it, making an already beautiful biome all the more lively B) An ingame reincarnation of the russian bringer of cold and ice, Grandfather Frost, the Iceologer. Making you rethink your expedition in the icy mountains of the Overworld C) Flashy squid dReAm sAiD i ShOuLd vOtE fOr gLoWy SqUiDdy, i LiKe gLoWy SqUiDdy nOw. I vOtE fOr gLoWy SqUiDdy Flashy stupid squid wins.
Actually glow squids are very nice and it's good they won as they are very useful for signs and a few other things also them being in caves all over just adds a nice detail even tho they just die half the time. Actually NVM they suck
With how easy it would be to add Glow Squids and Mooblooms (being literally reskins of existing mobs already) it's incredibly annoying why they couldn't just add them both and still have plenty of time to implement the Iceologer.
Imagine how cool vultures would have been if they were added as passive mobs that start to circle around you if you are dying of hunger. In the event that you die, they stay where you died and serve as a death marker so you can get your stuff back so long as it hasn't despawned.
Mojang literally said that they steal items from dead players lmfao. Not that I don't want them to be in the game(they only spawn in badlands, after all. Isn't gonna be too annoying), it's just that this idea literally contradicts their entire point.
I love how almost always, youtubers ended up influencing the votes for the worst. Literally almost no real threats in the ocean and is a very barren experience and yet vote for yet another night time mob in land which sounded quite dumb. A squid that just “glows” instead of literally anything else.
@@injetavel279 comments start like that because they are being sarcastic, passive aggressive speech is important and allows people to not just be completely aggressive
@@engineergaming1669 That's not how they're being used, next time keep an eye out and you'll see that most TH-cam comments start with "I love how...", "I like how..." and "Can we appreciate how...", It's almost uncanny.
I think a big issue with the mob votes is the lack of clarity for what each mob is going to do. The phantom, at the time, sounded pretty cool. I voted for the Chillager, but when the Glow-Squid got in I had hoped that it would bring in a glowing variant for every dyable block and item. Alas, that wasn't the case. The Glow-Squid also seemed like it would have some kind of weird hypnosis effect, but I guess that was just a joke for the video? The newest mob vote was pretty clear as far as each mob's function went, it wasn't a bad vote by any means (RIP copper boi though)
Phantom did not sound cool, it was the least favorite to win. It literally just lost because they keep doing livestream voting instead of leaving the votes open for 24 hours worldwide.
@@MeteorJunk kinda sad how he choose it cuz glow squid dont bother with speedrunning, but after the vote HE got cancelled for cheating lmfao. What goes around comes around i guess
@@MeteorJunk keep in mind it wasn’t just dream, lots of other youtubers told their fans to vote for it too. People just say dream because his name was really REALLY controversial a year ago.
I’m going to be honest: the mob votes are terrible ideas. I would much rather have mojang release one good mob without community input rather than have the community pick between three crappy concepts that are never executed properly
@@NapaCat that entire mob vote was just straight up dumb... allays are just lazy af people, copper golem is a dispenser/dropper and the glare is java's F3 menu.. that vote was a joke
@@emilianoherrera389but when your building something or playing for a while you won’t necessarily want to/can be able to sleep. Also on servers unless they have a special setting the night will rarely skip. It depends on the amount of players obviously but you almost never get all the players sleeping at the same time.
It always makes me feel weird that the mob votes lasted such a short amount of time. For how big of an impact the votes had on the state of one of the biggest videogames of all time, the mob votes came and went in the blink of an eye.
It's also pretty dumb that it's only done on Twitter, meaning you can only vote if you have an account there making a large portion of the community ineligible to participate. For how big Mojang is they could easily set up a poll on their own site or even within the game.
Seventy. One. Votes. That's all that made the difference and more people might like your comment than the amount that made the difference Edit: as of right now it's over 5 times that amount
As people complain day and night about phantoms being annoying, I'm pretty sure others would have the same outcome. Yes that Blaze king thing sounds cool and all, but aren't the regular blazes annoying enough? What difference would a badass version of it make? Oh so now these blazes can snipe you with 12 shots instead of one, leaving you no means of dodging. And has a shield too so your arrows won't make enough damage. Other 2 are even worse. People already complain about guardians being hard to deal, and they're not even roaming in the ocean they only hangout in their temples. I don't think a jumpscare in middle of deep ocean would do any good for anybody (altho not gonna lie, it was a bit considerate given 1.13 was the aquatic update). And that trap thing was also a jumpscare that could rip your enchantments away. That doesn't sound cool and exciting for me, it sounds awful and annoying. So yeah between these I'd pick Phantom
@@kingp1n817 all of them sounded annoying to me, especially the Blaze King. I hate fighting blazes already. The phantom could have been really good. That description sounded really cool. Still, I don't mind the discouragement of never sleeping, but man are they just not fun to fight. That is something they can fix though.
@@Petrslav Yeah phantoms wasn't meant to be hit and fly birds. They should put up a good fight with I dunno projectiles and potion effects and stuff. Only annoyance I think that could've work out well is if phantoms didn't let you sleep. Like if they had double or triple the range of not letting you sleep. As of right now, you don't need to fight phantoms. Just wait until they're high up in the sky then sleep; the sun will do the job for ya
For as popular as "The hovering Inferno" was, I was surprised to not see it added into the Nether update. You would assume that reusing a previously "scrapped" idea would be very convenient, while also making people happy to see a mob they wanted in the first place. Anyway, I'm still holding out hope for a Moobloom. If there's ever an update to plants and foliage, it would be nice to see it added.
Honestly, all the mobs in 2017 would’ve fit perfectly in the past few updates. Mob A would’ve been perfect for Update Aquatic, The Phantom would’ve fit well in Village and Pillage, Mob D would’ve worked well in the Nether Update, and Mob C would’ve been perfect for Caves and Cliffs.
the piglins are basically the hovering inferno+. they spawn randomly in some of the biomes, are hostile (unless you have gold), and have ranged attacks. so in a way they did add the hovering inferno
Iceologer and the hovering inferno will always be in my heart. Even if I'm slaughtering thousands of glow squids and phantoms the sorrow never ends.....
@@liz4460 my dark zombie dungeon exp farm sometimes spawns glow squid which end up getting cornered and drown . recently look in my drops chest to find a lot of glowing sacks and I was like . NICE this exp farm is also spawning and killing automatically the worst mob . xD
Would of been nice but I feel like people would of hated them too, I remember when the vote was going on and people were going on and on about renewable ice or some crap. The community hates everything.
Exactly it would give the Ice spikes a actually reason to exist. They would have been a annoying thing to fight but I think it would be a really fun job to add in. You could even add in a new structure to go along with them like a Witch hut
@@dennist8290 And they could freeze you with the powdered snow effect, similar to when you are swimming across the the ocean and you get mining fatigue by a nearby monument. The effect could be cured by being in a 5-block radius of any light source.
well vultures would probably not attack players. they are scavengers, not predators. they would probably steal items, mostly meats likely, and avoid the player like the janitors they are
Some vultures vomit as a self defense mechanism (usually if they just ate and need to lose a lot of weight fast to escape). Idk if mojang would go for it though but it would be a good punishment for attacking vultures. Im thinking like -3 hearts of damage
I'm glad everyone isn't too disappointed with the alley, but I'm still disappointed that the copper golem didn't get in. It would've been the first new buildable mob since the iron golem and snow golem. Plus it just looked really cute and had a cool function. Hopefully we'll one day be able to see all the mobs that didn't make it into the vote. #justiceforcoppergolem
Tbh, I think all three mobs from the 2020 mob vote could have fit really well with Caves and Cliffs. The moobloom would have went well with the lush cave's more nature theme, the glow squid worked well as a water mob alongside the axolotl, and the iceologer would have been a great addition to the mountains alongside the goats. Man.
@@Allodoxxed Same. I desperately wanted Moobloom to win. And I’m still sad about it losing in the first round. Then I wanted Iceologer to win, because the other option is literally just a blue squid. And now that the blue squid is in the game, it’s fine, I like what it does to signs, but I’m not going to pretend that either Moobloom or Iceologer would’ve been way better.
I feel like the only problem with the iceologer is it would either make mountains to hard to climb (a long with goats, taller heights and powder snow) or fall into just a variant category ( like the husk and stray)
@@queenofmoons720 If you have difficulty climbing mountains with a chillager on it you might need to relearn minecraft... mojang never implemented a difficult mob, and according to this they might never do.
I'm my defense for voting for the phantom, it sounded way cooler in concept, they really were a letdown. When it said they would attack players who hadn't slept i imagined just going about my night farming spiders and then as you said hearing a noise, only to find a fearsome beast behind me, but really they do like no damage and aren't scary at all.
Yeah I think it would be cool if they didn’t dive bomb for 1/2 a heart with no hit box. Maybe if it were bigger and more of a mini boss it would be cool bc you’d actually fear it probably
Personally I would really like phantoms if their hitboxes were just a bit bigger. That being said, I wasn't playing the game at the time of the vote, so idk what I would've actually picked.
@@slig4656 mojang should just make all four, but their product is much higher quality than any mod I’ve ever played (I’ve played dozens, from the good to the bad). Most mods are buggy, have frame rate and lag issues, and get updated rarely. Also, the devs have to carefully consider every decision they make because if they spend a bunch of time on the glare mob, for example, and nobody likes it, it was a waste of dev resources they could’ve used on something that would make them much more money.
@@user-ni7ui1nk8p yes and no, while I agree the product they release are lot more polished and not causeing game breaking lag. How hard could it be to give an item/mob use? Besides don't forget they are still in multimillion company they have more resources then an small teamed or sometimes lone modders who can churn out game changing mods regardless of how large they can be.
@@user-ni7ui1nk8p higher quality I'm sorry, Dr. Zhark's Mo'Creatures (because of which horses were added into the game after Dr. Z himself was contracted to add them into the game by Mojang), Thaumcraft, Galacticraft, Mekanism, Thermal Expansion, EnderIO, and many more were and are much higher quality than the stuff Mojang has been creating for Minecraftsoft for some time. Few massive updates as of late have compared to mods that have been developed by the community
In my defense, I really thought glow squid would finally give us a mobile light source. They need to explain the mobs better before we vote because the idea we have for a mob will always be cooler than the one we get
Mojang will never made glow new stuff materials because in reality squids dont drop glow dyes. And Glow squids are very rare to find and can be in found in the deep ocean or in the cave underwater deep.
I personally think that the way the glow squid has been implemented is fine, adding nice ambience to deep aquifers, though I will agree that it would've been better as a mobile light source. The cow would've worked as well.
Honestly the main reason why I liked the moobloom was theming, I think having more variations of different mobs in certain biomes is a really fun idea and could add more variation and atmosphere. Also they’re just really cute
@@prosandcons-fl2cc well now you get it anyway, and also a cool looking squid that WONT harass you in the mountains and be a nuicance at every encounter.
I’d like to point out that the disenchainting feature from Mob C of 2017’s mob vote did get added in the form of the grindstone. Mojang might not add the vote-losing concepts in full, but the ideas may still be reused in some form or another. Also the campfire totally carried the Taiga by being such a good building block otherwise I don’t really believe there would be much reason to vote for the taiga otherwise. As someone who lived in Hong Kong until about a year ago, this year’s mob vote was the one where I was finally able to wake up on time to get my vote in lol. I feel you, MisterEpic
@@Dynamo33 It is not, far from it. The Hunger had enough details made known to make an actual mob with it. One that hungers for your enchantments in an unpredictable, mob like style while attacking from below making any biome it spawns in much more stressful. And as mentioned, it's function to remove enchants was added in the form of a grindstone down the line in vanilla. So that more or less confirms that function as well.
I hope all the mobs that are “gone forever” will return. All the remaining mobs in the first vote were cool. The second vote was 50% good. And the third had a cool copper golem and I love copper
yeah i really wanted the King blaze and the Frostellager (im fine with the glow squid tho) and the allay is kinda bad because its hard to find pillager outposts and woodland mansions
@@444-o2w Or just big mobs in general. Maybe add like a new realm or update the end and it'll have these huge whales that slowly fly juuuuust out of reach, and they drop (if you're heartless and manage to kill one) something like pitch or something cool like an element for torches that would absorb light!
@@444-o2w Or just actually a deep ocean. Oceans are still so disappointing shallow ponds :( I once used the custom world tool (or however it was called) before it was removed to create a world from 0 to ~200 blocks just water and some rocks inbetween and it felt so chilling and mysterious. That would go so well with a whale mob, which then would have enough space to swim...
I still find it shocking that only 2,229 people were involved in the vote that got the phantom in, and by my calculations, only *71* more people voted the phantom over Mob C. *71* people led to the addition of likely the most hated mob in the most-sold game of all time.
@@chrono9503 except that those aren't "our" fault but by "our" I mean almost certainly not your fault because only a few thousand people participated in the vote so if I had to guess, you weren't a part of it (I sure wasn't, I only voted this year)
I hope one day theres just a massive update called the "Revenge of the Losers" or something, and just have all the mobs that weren't voted put into the game and be extremely aggressive, even the fricken moobloom. Maybe one day they'll put some of these in another mob vote, so they have a second chance. I hate the fact that theres some mobs just missing forever.
I feel like the phantoms can do with an AI update as well as more features that incentivize staying up for a few days, and the phantoms as a gate keeper of those features. For example what if the new frogs croaked more frequently when a thunderstorm is five days away. This prompts the player to stay up for a few days and have to deal with phantoms in order to get the benefits of a thunderstorm; like powdered snow farms, mob heads through charged creepers, brown mooshroom, and skeleton horses.
Honestly mob votes as a concept just don't mesh well, voting for 3 mobs and having the other two just wiped off feels incredibly dumb and can very easily just create unnecessary controversy, honestly I think I good idea would be to add a hostile mob that has unique attacks and then a passive mob that has a unique use. Another thing to note is that all the votes take place on twitter which is a pretty idiotic choice since it means nonminecraft players (aka trolls that will try to make fans mad) can determine the vote because of the influence of popular youtubers, having a website that only allows those with a legit minecraft account to vote, would be much better, also the votes really should last longer and shouldn't just stay up for an hour which leaves millions out.
I agree. The votes should last longer (maybe like a week ?) and have it on the Minecraft site or launcher so only those that have the game can vote. There are a handful of videos that suggest new changes to how the votes should work.
I'm not seeing how a large game company backed by the largest computer technology company in NA in charge of the most popular rated E game ever made can't just add all 3 mobs rather then making people vote for them. minecraft was the most purchased game for 3 years running, you can't tell me they don't have the money.
@@MsMoonDragoon They have money and resources but of course the employees aren't robots they still need to eat,drink and sleep and not only that they still need to test if the mob works well because Minecraft is a sandbox game and it will affect alot
@@MsMoonDragoon more people doesn’t always lead to faster development their are diminishing returns also it’s better the focus on cool stuff like the warden in my opinion
I would have thought most Dream fans would have a Minecraft account, so although an MC-account requirement is something they should do and would help with trolls who don't care about the game, it wouldn't do anything for that scenario.
When looking at the first mob vote, I see that everyone compares the current iteration of the phantom against their speculation of what the other mobs could have been. The unfortunate thing about that is there could be a definite chance that the other mobs would have not lived up to people's original expectation of them, thus making it no different than the scenario with the phantom. I would like to say, however, that I was not playing minecraft at the time of the first mob vote, so I am just simply speaking from a neutral position.
Tl;dr: We should stop voting on mobs based on how we would like them to be in game, but vote instead on how we think mojang will implement them. If mojang has promised certain things for a mob, do not expect them to implement them in the way you want them to, expect them to implement mobs and their properties in the easiest way possible. I completely agree with this, I feel like most of the time players vote for the most interesting sounding mob, phantoms were promised to live in the end, and attack players like a, well, phantom. but we ended up getting a glorified hostile bat. The glow squid was said to have musical hypnotism powers and useful drops, of course most people knew that even this was boring compared to the other options but the vote was slightly tampered, and we ended up with, a retextured squid and some cool sign fonts (a complete shock to absolutely nobody). This is the reason I think the Allay is going to fail, because almost every time we get a vote, players vote big, on mobs that have more vague properties because the more vague the properties of the mob is, the more they can assume it will work how they want it to, and not really putting much thought into how mojang will make it. The more vague the mob is, the more people will come up with their own ideas on how the mob works, the more disappointed they will be when mojang makes the mob infinitely more boring in game, because it will be easier to implement than more ambitious mob qualities. The Allay will be implemented with this same design philosophy. Mojang will disappoint, because they have only promised us that it is a mob that will pick stuff up, and drop it at a noteblock, players are going to expect more than that but that is likely all it will do. Worst of all, mobs cannot load chunks, so if you die somewhere in the world far away, you won’t be able to give the allay a copy of your gear, and expect it to find it for you, because an allay can only operate in the chunks you are in, and in terms of farms, what more use can an unreliable mob have than completely reliable blocks (hoppers), sure it may be cheaper, but it might also not be, what if the allay is only found in rare areas, and players have to travel miles to go find them, how much cheaper is that than just mining for half an hour for iron? Why trust the functionality of your farm, with a mob that might die, pick up the items from the wrong area, or wander off over the functionality of a hopper that will consistently collect from the same block? We have been given too little information on how the mob will work, which is why I think players like it (they will always vote for what they think a mob will be, rather than it’s actual named qualities, e.g. players think allays will phase through walls even though that was never promised), and also why it will fail (mojang will never make a mob that will live up to what players have hyped it up to be, preferring to implement a mob more easily with the functions promised, rather than implement functions players assume will be there, but was never promised).
Except in the phantom mob vote for example it told exactly what it would do. In future votes they told way less about them which annoys me because you don't know their potential
@@cjrbread5928 exactly. But some dont seem to realize this because a lot of people thought the allay would dupe items like really do you really think mojang would do that
Considering how the Sniffer has history (plus functionality and new possible plants), and how the community wants it mostly for the lore. I'm starting to believe they're reconsidering adding the three mobs from 2017 Mob Vote. As someone who loves lores on video games (most of the time), it'll actually be interesting and makes meeting/defeating them in battle would have more value than just *FARM.* 🧐
As useless as the copper golem is, it would've been fun to have a little robot to hangout with and be responsible for as opposed to a dog, cat, parrot, etc.
I wanted it because I though it could be used in many different build. Labratory: have golems pressing buttons to make them look like scientists. Steampunk: have golems around like they are maintaining engines. Any ancient build: have an army of oxidized golems all lined up in a grand hall. And the list goes on but everyone always said "it's just a less efficient randomizer"
@@prosandcons-fl2cc I think they should have been made able to be taught to push particular buttons, for purposes of automation. I feel like that would have been a far better mechanic than the "flying hopper minecart" allay.
@@prosandcons-fl2cc Agreed. I wanted it to populate my town, and press random buttons to look like a worker or randomise Things in town/dungeons. No need for contraptions. Also could be used story-wise. A button behind an impentrable wall. But you can unrust a golem through a small hole and he can press the button. Etc. The Allay is... I mean. we already Automate item gathering. and pick up stuff we want already.
It would be interesting to see how the Hovering inferno would effect speedruning if it were added. As blazes and nether fortresses are a very important part of speedrunning. I feel it would be kind of similar to the Piglin brute in 1.16.
@@Jodio-Joestar It would be really cool that if the Hovering inferno got in instead of the phantom, axes could be made to break it’s defenses similar to a shield.
@@Jodio-Joestar Well I'm sure people would have defiantly have come up with a way to counter the mob. But it would definitely have had some sort of impact on speedruning weather its a big impact or not.
Yeah but it has one glaring weakness: fire Res. With fire resistance you could literally just charge in and not take any damage. I personally voted for the great hunger bc it's basically a bear trap mob that could mess with your enchants which sounds rly interesting
Mob D is one of the coolest things ive ever seen. I love me a new challenge,and also a new hostile mob,so finding out that two notorious monsters (Mob D/chillager) lost to an updated bat and a re-skinned squid makes me wanna fucking puke
Personally for me, I don't want a bunch of new hostile mobs being added to the game. When I play minecraft, I don't want to have to always worry about being jump scared by something trying to kill me when I simply just want to get resources. That's why I didn't vote for them.
we need a jungle update next with jungle villages up in the trees called "hanging villages" and canoes and other cool stuff to add to the jungle. I think a Jungle update would be cool and should be included in the wild update
The game honestly needs more to do after getting diamond tools. Also the fact that building is still so limited in survival mode. We should be able to build machines or tools that let us produce and place large amounts of blocks.
@@AndreasJepsenMusic like you still have to place one block at a time. I know commands exist but imagine if those were available though an item in the game. Or if you could place blocks in some third person view, cause by the end of the game you get tired of how long it takes to build things and just go creative.
@@Distress. I get where you're coming from, but i don't think it's limited in survival, it just takes up a lot of time. For me, it's more satisfying to finally complete my survival builds after gathering all the resources and spending the time on building them. And i don't get the urge to go to creative to build my stuff. But i will agree that some command like item would sick af tbh
I never understood why they’d scrap good ideas when they could just add them later down the line, but to be fair if they did add them later down the line it would take a million years because despite being one of the biggest games ever mojang somehow takes forever to release some of the most minuscule updates ever, literally the slowest working studio I’ve ever seen.
mojang are legit bad people im convinced they spend most of their time at the office stealing a paycheck from microsoft just sipping coffee reading reddit smiling
I mean, not recently. We’ve gotten huge updates pretty frequently. The Nether Update, which still was 2 years ago but the best update yet, a WHOLE Mountains and Caves rework that’s actually GOOD and outshines most if not all mods, and the Deep Dark, which is pretty high effort, just LOOK. Sure the warden should be a boss and reward you more for killing it, but other than that, yeah. We can ignore Bees, the Color update and certain prior releases. Mojang is set for the future. Edit: I'd like to apologize.
i think the mountains winning against the savanna was worth it, even at face value, as a builder. campfires are some of the most useful detailing blocks ever and make everything look perfect if used correctly.
I certainly think that vote was good all around. All 3 were necessary, so each one should've happened. I wonder what building ideas we could've done with Termite nests, especially if there was a "Vacant Termite nest" block. Also i'm a sucker for wood types, so i wonder how the baobab wood would've looked like. Aesthetically, i can understand desert, but it is what it's supposed to be, and palm trees only make sense near water sources. Plus deserts already had their own variants of villages, wells, and the desert temple, and the Savannah seemed the most lacking.
The Inferno one would be such a cool mini boss, like one spawning in every fortress or something. That would be so cool. Giving the player even more insensitive to be careful and prepare before farming blaze rods...
@@movingchannels2203 perhaps you lack a use case? If something is not of immediate use to you, would you consider it outright bad? What makes it bad in your opinion? Nice animations on your channel btw, berry intriguing!
@@TheBinklemNetwork It mainly just floats around and looks pretty Sure it can glow up signs and item frames but it’s not that useful. That’s also adding the fact that I normally don’t see their ink sacs in areas where they die, so they fill up my inventory and it gets pretty annoying having to clear it out every 10 minutes But thanks for the compliment!
@@movingchannels2203 no problem! Ahh I guess since I'm playing with shaders in a cave the whole "making items/signs glow" I put more of a worth to those sacks than most would! Thanks for your perspectives!
I want to point out that Mojang made it seem that the glow squid would "hypnotize" players (an interesting new mechanic I may add) when they got close to it. So not only did the glow squid NOT give off actual light, its also didnt "hypnotize" players either.
@@giuliocusenza5204 that would have been cool but a little op for the game. Also there wouldn’t be much of a use in survival except for mobs but if you could freeze a warden…. Kinda op
@@YaStreamerBrownie I know, but I assumed the freezing would have been buffed by extreme shortness of the effect or by being not actual freezing, but rather slowness + some visual hypnotic effect.
Still holding out hope for the moobloom. I really love mooshrooms and their design, so having an alternate style and more would make me happy. I also love the cute mobs, lol
@@heyolorenns at this point, I'd be grateful if ignorable shit got added. Like the things they add now not only duck, but you are being forced to interact with them.
@@tovishitomeiji5383 but indefinitely scrapping the losers makes the mob votes feel not like "this mob was added in because of you" and more like "these two perfectly good ideas are gone forever and it's your fault"
Espically due to people voting some mobs in as jokes Glow Squid does have a use, but we all know why people hate them (I don't really mind them, but i'd rather have the Moobloom or Ice-Illger)
I mean i think the new Ghost guy was pretty neat. Tho other than him? Yeah... Tho to be honest? I do like the idea of Phantoms but they are so damm tiny and annoying! They are cool in a way. I kinda wish more things whould change if you didint sleep in minecraft like mayby animals whould get replaced with Shadow animals that are hostile to you for example.
Remember that some features from mobs in the 2017 mob vote were added into the game, like the ability for mobs to hold shields from the Hovering Inferno and the ability to remove enchantments through the grindstone from the Great Hunger
So if Mob B lost, there would eventually be an insomnia mechanic in the gane that would likely give you bad effects of you negated sleep. I'd pick weak flying mob over poison for the whole game day.
@@jeuno. personally, i have almost no problems with Phantoms. I always go to sleep most nights in the overworld, and sometimes I will stay up to shoot them down for sport. I see them as easily countered fun clay shooting rather than annoyances. Also I cant live without Slow Fall Potions.
The fact that the modding community can add 100 times more interesting and diverse mobs that actually work well in the game over one year while Mojang does not even a fraction of that in a couple of years is really sad
I still think the most annyoing part about the phantom is how it spawns. Having a mob which is annyoing to be around and aweful to fight, spawn when the player does not skip the night by using the bed is genuinly bad design. The night is one of the challenges of minecraft. Players should either be punished for skipping the night too many times or rewarded for not skipping it.
@@Whodjathink if you live underground you spend copious amounts of time down there however your entire playthrough isn't underground, you still come up to do things and as soon as you do you get swarmed by phantoms
I’m still not sold on the allay, but enough people are psyched about its potential usefulness that I’m hopeful it’ll be good when it comes out. Was really hoping for the copper golem personally, another usage for copper, along with copper buttons, and a good way to add randomization to redstone.
Tbh allay doesnt really seem as useful as people make it out to be since we have hoppers/hopper minecarts. Copper golems wouldve been a fun alternative to chicken randomizers that i could see being used for fun little contraptions (although even it's uses seem kinda limited still).
@@Preetzole i mean the allay can maybe sort unstackbles, thats pretty much it, would also would've wanted the copper golem to win but some *cough* Minecraft speedrunners *cough* rigged it they even said it on twitter that they rigged it
@Xudid Dkkdddidisidi fun fact, none of them were useful in the slightest. The glare is f3, the golem is only there as decoration, the allay... you all seem blind to how flying mobs have horrendous path finding in this game, they are just gonna increase the lag of farms while doing their work slower than a minecart that's it.
Yeah but if they made the phantom sound way cooler than it actually was then the same would've likely happened with the other mobs and we would be like "phantom was so cool! Why didn't it win?"
Yeah, the other mobs sound infinitely more annoying. Trying to get blaze rods? Guy with shields and a shotgun in your way Trying to swim? Not on the tongue guy's watch, now drown Trying to _walk?_ Nuh-uh-uh, there go your items and enchantments
man i always wanted to see n still want the hovering inferno. hes so damn awesome. oh yes the glowsquid. amazing if it could add a glow to objects or make certain blocks glow it be cool. but its kinda pointless. the chilliger and the inferno should have been in the game tbh. i also rly liked the copper golem. it would have been so cool! though i dun hate the alley.
I love how he hi-lighted the number of people who voted for “do not care” on the moon shape vote as if to say “ that many people didnt care?!” But didnt say anything about it
I think Glare would've filled a niche type of useless part of the game, which in a way, would've been kind of perfect for the update. Anyway, I think mob votes are stupid. I want them all.
The devs have like infinite ideas so asking the community to pick one from the top ideas is not bad if the rest of the mobs will get added but the phantom mob vote was definitely stupid.
We could have an insane bossfight at the bottom of the ocean with the ocean terror, we could have a intense fight within the nether fortress against the king of the blazes. But we got vex v2.
the bit about living in australia and weirding out the parents is too accurate. woke up at 2:30 for the 1.19 announcement... parents were very concerned and confused
The first mob vote was actually in 2016, where Jeb asked fans wether they wanted either the alpaca or llama to be added in 1.11. The llama won, and so it was added soon after. Alpaca’s probably won’t be added any time soon, since their practically the same thing as llamas, unless they would be different somehow.
Fun fact Mob D- Hovering Inferno, which is known as Wildfire was actually in the files in MC dungeons, where you can see the way it moves and it’s textures. Even the developers mentioned it as a unfinished mob for the nether DLC
I still miss the Moobloom… and what makes it worse is that when it lost, I really wanted the Chillager to win, since it actually looked pretty cool compared to a blue squid. And it didn’t. That vote was easily my least favorite one ever.
I wish they DIDN'T kill of the 2017 mobs that lost. They were all good, at least concept-wise. Maybe they'd even all NOT flop like the Phantom once they released
The fact that TH-camrs can create all 3 of these mobs in just days shows that Mojang could make the vote determine which order the mobs get into the game at bare minimum.
Phantoms could easily be revived by making it extremely hard to capture and tame one, just sayin'. Having a mountable flying mob would be a nice second tier to elytras.
@@InternetAntagonist Maybe, but also maybe not. It depends on the implementation IMO. Should it still burn in daylight? Maybe it could have it's own armor in netherite that stops this. Should it still be capable of attacking? If not, it's just a flying mount. Should you need multiple rare items to tame it? Perhaps it has to be done in the air while using an elytra. Anyways, there are perfectly reasonable methods of making this not as OP. Certainly wouldn't be any more OP than elytras + fireworks.
@@kilospade i think phantoms should be scary non-physical mobs that give you effects instead of damage since they spawn because of insomnia. You’d need to use items like soul lanterns to scare them away or make them physical to kill and loot them. I think it could be coherent. Or maybe have a few of them spawn every night but only being able to see you when you lack sleep and have a chance to attack living hostile mobs (but maybe only in swamps or on full moon). Apart from wolves and foxes and maybe cats there s little to no interaction between usual mobs.
The problem with that is that some mobs were designed for different versions of the game. The hunger pacman thing was supposed to de-enchant, which you can now do with the grindstone. The depths one was to make the sea more interesting, but we got the update aquatic. The glare is quite useless now that only 100% dark areas can spawn mobs, but before it was an interesting idea (only java players have F3 and it's not really legit anyway).
Well still though, the hunger pac man would of been great, because you’d be forced to create an stable for your horses and stuff to keep them safe from the hunger. Also it would suck to have mending and sharpness 5 on your sword until the hunger eats these items and spits them out without the enchantments. (Assuming the hunger eats you first)
Also I still think the depths monster would be nice. Even with the drowned, I’m not scared of the oceans. I’d like to have some times where I avoid the water, because I saw “something”
I think the glow squid had a lot of potential, I thought it would drop a glowing dye that would give us the ability to craft a glowing blocks of various different colors like glass and wool.
I was sad to hear that the Wild Fire and the Iceologer lost the Mob Votes, but I am happy they are added into Minecraft Dungeons, which is the second game. I was still glad to encounter and fight them in the game.
I probably voted for that blaze boss, but after recently spending a lot of time in the nether makes me glad it did not get added as regular blazes are already a huge pain in the ass early game. I'm salty about not getting the ice-ologer
Yeah i guess that makes sense but just imagine how cool a blaze Mini boss or even a Boss whould have been? Tho yeah. Illager gang rise! Hopefully one day we will see Illusioner aswell.
@@draw2death421 the only problem is that knowing how underwhelming the phantom was in comparison to the expectations, the blaze boss probably would have been a normal OP mob or even a deception
6:24 I assumed the Phantoms would only exist to a single player at a time, so as you fought them others would see you swinging at empty air and firing arrows at literal nothing.
I still really like Mob A, it fits perfectly into the game and it's a great alternative for not adding sharks. Lets hope that one day Mojang adds them all into the game!
i dislike bedrock due to major performance issues that piss me off really hard. like whenever i press a button in the menu it takes 5 WHOLE SECONDS to load it up. and server performance sucks. but its the only minecraft version i can play with my friends.
The copper golem could’ve been used some way in red stone contraptions as a random input, and also would’ve been a good use of copper, which is useless outside of building. I can see why the allay won but I hope they add the copper golem in the future.
also to me the ally just seems like a aoe hopper. so more pointless in my eyes. its better then the glare but thats not a fair compairason since the glare needed something eles to be worth it
They need to find other uses for copper. Because copper golems are a completely pathetic attempt. There are so many other ways to make random inputs! Maybe if the copper golem could be programmed to make specific inputs at specific times, then they would be worth something... barely. But even then I vastly prefer the Allay.
@@juicebox7372 At that point you may as well just add both rather than having one rip off the functionality of the other. That would just be outright insulting to the people who wanted the Allay.
I think the reason why people are always so upset about mob/biome vote is because mojang always promises or at least shows up more then they add. I was so excited for the glow squid thinking it would mesmerize you when you were near and would act as a light source but… instead we got a re-textured squid that has a special ink sac, I find it’s the same with the recent “wild” update it was basically caves and cliffs pt3 they showed us many different concept art that of course never had any changes, I feel mojang is just promising more than what they actually end up adding:(
To be honest, Mojang has been pretty lazy for a while now, it's crazy how it can take them an entire year to make a single mob and a single biome, as someone who knows modders and has tried modding myself, I just can't explain myself how it takes them SO LONG to make such minuscule updates. Also, the web about that mob vote, specified the glowsquid wouldn't provide light, but none read that of course.
@@pestrusiariopaezmengoso2868 I feel like you don’t know what you’re talking about. The only mediocre update in years is the wild update. All the other ones immersed you in a previously shallow aspect of the game. Nether was too empty and bland? Let’s add mobs, biomes, structures, and more. Ocean had like 2 mobs? Let’s add more fish, turtles, structures, and mechanics. Caves were repetitive and boring? Let’s add biomes, better cave structure, a new ore, and much more. Villagers wanted 64 emeralds for a piece of dirt? Let’s make trading diverse and actually useful. And for the record, you’re just plain wrong. The wild update was a 6 month update.
Don't give up hope too soon. All of the losing biomes were all warm biomes. Maybe one day, deserts savannahs and badlands can all be updated in a massive "warm update" of something of the sorts.
Scrapping the other ideas still pisses me off to this day. The first vote was handled horribly and had such good ideas that fit so naturally it seems ridiculous that those simple, effective, and great ideas are being thrown away.
We will never know. But I have to say that it is pretty easy to blame it on Dream. People didn't had a gun pointing towards them when voting, they still had their free will. At the end of the day, it's a community vote. If people are not happy with the result, it's the community's fault, not Dream's (and also Mojang's for proposing such a useless mob)
Vultures would be incredibly interesting mobs, perhaps they could start out like cats where they flee if you get too close but as you get lower on health they gradually become more aggressive. First they stop flying away, then they start looking towards you, then flying after you, before finally attacking you with increasing aggression.
one comment above said the similar thing about health and starving and this is the response: How many players actually starve do death? At most you just dont have hunger but i never heard of someone actually starving to death and if they did it wouldve been in the first day of minecraft for unexperianced players who wandered there at the start (so they probably dont have any items on them) because experianced players would avoid Mesa at the start if they could even find one beacuse it very rare... *Vutures would be usseless and had no interaction with players except maybe the first day of the game but even then it would be still actually hard to find Mesa*
I liked the copper golem, as there are only two other golems. We already have water streams on ice to transport items, and item sorters are much faster and simpler. I've never used allays in survival. They're just fairies that like music and can sort through items, all of which already have solutions.
Phoenix SC did point out that Phantoms have a size value. They could definitely just make phantoms change is size more drastically for every night you don't sleep. That honestly seems already plenty interesting than what we currently have.
I only learned recently dream was the reason the glow squid won. I was wanting the Iceologer so bad. The moobloom looked like it should've been for a mod.
The phantom -Has glowing eyes -Floats/flys -Is blue -Everyone hates them Glow squid -Has glowing eyes -Floats/flys -Is blue -Everyone hates them Allay -Has glowing eyes -Floats/flies -is blue -...
I think the mob voting was the beginning of the end for me. I started playing less and less once the phantom was released in favor of the better sounding mobs.
I'm really glad that the swamp got immediately updated after the mountains, as I'm sure I'm not the only one who liked the ideas of the updated swamp. However, as a mexican, I would really like to see the new cactus (called nopal) from the badlands added as well.
You’re not the only one for sure I love the swamp definitely my favorite biome and always felt like they were neglected. Especially with cool secrets like witch huts and fossils it had potential but the generation of them and the mobs in it felt like it was like everything else in minecraft fit but swamps were pulled straight from a very early version of minecraft. It would be really cool to see instead of oak wood with vines for trees, they were more twisty kind of trees with unique wood. I also think those mobs that sit underground that got voted out in the first mob vote would fit really well with the swamp
I'm seriously still angry that the Chillagers weren't added. We could've possibly, finally, had magic in Minecraft. Imagine if killing them could potentially drop a magic weapon that let you use their ice attacks. The trident is the closest thing we have to magic, but it's still primarily a melee weapon.
@@bugjams Would have be dope. The devs clearly have a vision for their game though and that's why I think it's weird to just delete the mob who didn't win. They probably wont ever give magic to the player because that would change too many things from the vanilla minecraft experience and adding really crazy things is in the end more a mod thing
minecraft dungeons imo has some of the coolest mobs to exist. (Seriously the ice illager is a great concept for vanilla. Could also argue snow zombies as well. (Also kinda wishing the illusioner gets properly added soon)
Every time I remember that we lost a giant Blaze miniboss with probably good difficulty and some nasty op drops against some birds that drops potion shit, my day gets ruined.
@@no-qy3pq blaze are already annoying enough to fight, i dont wanna get ambushed by a dozen fireballs before even finding the spawner. And dont even get me started with that item trapper bullshit
I’ve always thought they should do a mob vote with only old mobs that didn’t win, and it has always been kinda sad when a good mob doesn’t get voted for :(
So, which mob concept do you wish got added to the game? Be sure to leave a comment and subscribe!
Join the discord - discord.gg/WGc9UNM
Cool blaze boss
Heck yeah blaze boss for the win
I think you missed the alpaca/llama vote lol
Mob D is in Minecraft Dungeons.
The copper golem would be great for building :(
the phantom winning was entirely my fault, and I'll regret it for the rest of my life.
they should fix it tho. Maybe re-tooling it to haunt 1.18's new caves, and only attacks when it hears you.
They should, the concept is still very cool!
That would be phant-astic
That would be actually a great chance to get something cool out of this annoying mob we have at the moment.
so did you pull a Dream for getting the phantom in?
Good that you get what you deserve for the war crimes committed
There is a Mod called "Outvoted" that attempts to add these forgotten mobs and their abilities :D
Please send a link to the mod.
Fabric or forge?
@@thenameyoushouldknowthekin8998 it's in the description
@@reubeb8820 Cool, thanks.
I want it to be more vanilla like
I love how phantoms won the vote but were regarded as so annoying that the devs later added an option to disable them.
I HATE PHANTOMS
I HATE PHANTOMS
Literally the worst mob in the game at the cost of a brand new boss that well never see again
@@spicymeatballs2thespicening I like to think the hovering inferno would be like the elder guardian y'know? miniboss type shit
but I wouldn't think the elder guardian is a miniboss though
@@Proxy_Warning Wasnt the evil death squid in the same vote?
@@adinosaur2708 the one that harpoons you? That would have been awesome
@@spicymeatballs2thespicening Ever heard of the polar bear?
Would you choose:
A) A wholesome variant of a cow mutation and a new possibly useful item to come with it, making an already beautiful biome all the more lively
B) An ingame reincarnation of the russian bringer of cold and ice, Grandfather Frost, the Iceologer. Making you rethink your expedition in the icy mountains of the Overworld
C) Flashy squid
dReAm sAiD i ShOuLd vOtE fOr gLoWy SqUiDdy, i LiKe gLoWy SqUiDdy nOw. I vOtE fOr gLoWy SqUiDdy
Flashy stupid squid wins.
typical german thinking
What dReAm did there really made me to hate him.
Actually glow squids are very nice and it's good they won as they are very useful for signs and a few other things also them being in caves all over just adds a nice detail even tho they just die half the time. Actually NVM they suck
With how easy it would be to add Glow Squids and Mooblooms (being literally reskins of existing mobs already) it's incredibly annoying why they couldn't just add them both and still have plenty of time to implement the Iceologer.
@@fathergascoigne1457 they could just have used glowstone to make signs glow.....
Imagine how cool vultures would have been if they were added as passive mobs that start to circle around you if you are dying of hunger. In the event that you die, they stay where you died and serve as a death marker so you can get your stuff back so long as it hasn't despawned.
Ngl this kinda sounds ingenious.
That sounds pretty morbid...
Mojang literally said that they steal items from dead players lmfao. Not that I don't want them to be in the game(they only spawn in badlands, after all. Isn't gonna be too annoying), it's just that this idea literally contradicts their entire point.
They eat your stuff
i think i heard that from blockixel
I love how almost always, youtubers ended up influencing the votes for the worst. Literally almost no real threats in the ocean and is a very barren experience and yet vote for yet another night time mob in land which sounded quite dumb. A squid that just “glows” instead of literally anything else.
Do you really love how that happens? Man, I swear this term gets thrown around so much that people don't even think about its meaning.
@@injetavel279 it’s called sarcasm and has existed in the English language before any of us were born
@@engineergaming1669 It's not sarcasm, 80% of TH-cam comments start exactly like that, it has lost all meaning
@@injetavel279 comments start like that because they are being sarcastic, passive aggressive speech is important and allows people to not just be completely aggressive
@@engineergaming1669 That's not how they're being used, next time keep an eye out and you'll see that most TH-cam comments start with "I love how...", "I like how..." and "Can we appreciate how...", It's almost uncanny.
Scrapping the other mobs was a mistake, mojang should reconsider. The first vote was handled poorly anyway
the giant squid thing should've been in the Aquatic Update, the blaze thing in the Nether Update and the hungry thing for the new Wild Update
@@ChainsawMixx that’s so true
I think they didnt scrap it totally but there is a low chance theyll add them
tbh i'd love to see a "mob update" where they add a crap ton of mobs a decent portion of which would originate from the votes
@@djaydeved and update some that are already in the game
I think a big issue with the mob votes is the lack of clarity for what each mob is going to do. The phantom, at the time, sounded pretty cool. I voted for the Chillager, but when the Glow-Squid got in I had hoped that it would bring in a glowing variant for every dyable block and item. Alas, that wasn't the case.
The Glow-Squid also seemed like it would have some kind of weird hypnosis effect, but I guess that was just a joke for the video?
The newest mob vote was pretty clear as far as each mob's function went, it wasn't a bad vote by any means (RIP copper boi though)
True.
They could’ve worked with the hypnosis
Either that or just clarify it wouldn’t actually be included
or just scrap jokes like that altogether
Phantom did not sound cool, it was the least favorite to win.
It literally just lost because they keep doing livestream voting instead of leaving the votes open for 24 hours worldwide.
The big issue for the mob votes is rigging the whole thing
The copper golem could've been used for redstone😭
"JUST TO LOSE TO A GLOWING SQUID" Best line I've heard from the franchise's vote drama
Thanks Dream
@@MeteorJunk kinda sad how he choose it cuz glow squid dont bother with speedrunning, but after the vote HE got cancelled for cheating lmfao. What goes around comes around i guess
th-cam.com/video/Nw6iwoVNh_o/w-d-xo.html DREAAAAMMMM
@@zoinksscoob6523 Iceologer wouldn't bother speedrunners either. Speedrunnes NEVER go to mountains.
@@MeteorJunk keep in mind it wasn’t just dream, lots of other youtubers told their fans to vote for it too. People just say dream because his name was really REALLY controversial a year ago.
Phantoms winning over literally any of the other mobs is truly saddening
I have literally never seen one before
Even when I tried
@@Sonic-oh2ly oh they appear when u don’t sleep for 2 days
Personally I think hunger could be worse
Compared to the hidden mob that removes enchantments? Much prefer to just sleep every few days
"instead of being called extreme hills, they should have been called extreme disappointment"
best thing ive heard today
You must have a very boring life then
@@caynohh I'm shitting myself
@@caynohh could just be early in the day
@@JuanAntonioGarciaHeredia I just sharded
Sounds like something Gordon Ramsay would say
I’m going to be honest: the mob votes are terrible ideas. I would much rather have mojang release one good mob without community input rather than have the community pick between three crappy concepts that are never executed properly
Fr like bro
That's fair.
I mean, Copper Golem would have been an easy randomizer, at least.
Yeah, they failed to realize that 90% of their fanbase are TH-cam obsessed children with zero decision making skills
@@NapaCat that entire mob vote was just straight up dumb... allays are just lazy af people, copper golem is a dispenser/dropper and the glare is java's F3 menu.. that vote was a joke
The fact that a lot of servers disable phantoms says a lot about them
Yea :(
I do find them annoying.
But they should be cool.
i use vanilla tweaks to disable them and let me get membranes from bats to repair my elytra, they just suck
@@Surr3alD3sign yeah, that or I know many servers just disable phantoms and the only way to get membranes is from cats.
Literally just sleep
@@emilianoherrera389but when your building something or playing for a while you won’t necessarily want to/can be able to sleep.
Also on servers unless they have a special setting the night will rarely skip. It depends on the amount of players obviously but you almost never get all the players sleeping at the same time.
It always makes me feel weird that the mob votes lasted such a short amount of time. For how big of an impact the votes had on the state of one of the biggest videogames of all time, the mob votes came and went in the blink of an eye.
It's also pretty dumb that it's only done on Twitter, meaning you can only vote if you have an account there making a large portion of the community ineligible to participate. For how big Mojang is they could easily set up a poll on their own site or even within the game.
well probably bcs mojang saw how bad of choice makers the players are 💀
@@bibilispivilis9399 especially twitter users
it would also be good if i they made the voting time last longer so I don't have to get up at 3 AM
@@niharsheth But I saw the 2020 one on YT.
a reminder that less than 100 votes put minecraft in the darkest timeline with the phantom
Seventy. One. Votes. That's all that made the difference and more people might like your comment than the amount that made the difference
Edit: as of right now it's over 5 times that amount
Tbh, I feel like the tool eater would be pretty anoying, if not more.
As people complain day and night about phantoms being annoying, I'm pretty sure others would have the same outcome. Yes that Blaze king thing sounds cool and all, but aren't the regular blazes annoying enough? What difference would a badass version of it make? Oh so now these blazes can snipe you with 12 shots instead of one, leaving you no means of dodging. And has a shield too so your arrows won't make enough damage. Other 2 are even worse. People already complain about guardians being hard to deal, and they're not even roaming in the ocean they only hangout in their temples. I don't think a jumpscare in middle of deep ocean would do any good for anybody (altho not gonna lie, it was a bit considerate given 1.13 was the aquatic update). And that trap thing was also a jumpscare that could rip your enchantments away. That doesn't sound cool and exciting for me, it sounds awful and annoying. So yeah between these I'd pick Phantom
@@kingp1n817 all of them sounded annoying to me, especially the Blaze King. I hate fighting blazes already.
The phantom could have been really good. That description sounded really cool. Still, I don't mind the discouragement of never sleeping, but man are they just not fun to fight. That is something they can fix though.
@@Petrslav Yeah phantoms wasn't meant to be hit and fly birds. They should put up a good fight with I dunno projectiles and potion effects and stuff. Only annoyance I think that could've work out well is if phantoms didn't let you sleep. Like if they had double or triple the range of not letting you sleep. As of right now, you don't need to fight phantoms. Just wait until they're high up in the sky then sleep; the sun will do the job for ya
I swear to God, when it comes to video game community votes, everybody caves in their frontal lobes and is by far the best argument against democracy
minecraft players on there way to vote for the worst fucking option ever for no reason
@@EvilMaster4002 fr like on god I hope the.next mob gets voted right
Minecraft players attacking other minecraft players cause they didn’t choose the same mob as them (politics)
@@SilvaRings minecraft mob vote is the best example against democracy
@@EvilMaster4002 it aint that deep fr
It's not all bad. If the mountains biome didn't win the vote, the Caves & Cliffs update would only be half of what it is.
very true
yep, this is like the only vote that i think all of us can be happy with lol
@@catswork theres still people swearing that this vote was dumb. Honestly those people are really clueless
That’s true
It would be called caves and _____ (depending on what won
For as popular as "The hovering Inferno" was, I was surprised to not see it added into the Nether update. You would assume that reusing a previously "scrapped" idea would be very convenient, while also making people happy to see a mob they wanted in the first place. Anyway, I'm still holding out hope for a Moobloom. If there's ever an update to plants and foliage, it would be nice to see it added.
Moobloom for the win brother. 😞
Honestly, all the mobs in 2017 would’ve fit perfectly in the past few updates.
Mob A would’ve been perfect for Update Aquatic, The Phantom would’ve fit well in Village and Pillage, Mob D would’ve worked well in the Nether Update, and Mob C would’ve been perfect for Caves and Cliffs.
hehe pisscow
the piglins are basically the hovering inferno+.
they spawn randomly in some of the biomes, are hostile (unless you have gold), and have ranged attacks.
so in a way they did add the hovering inferno
@@TheFlyfly bro.
The hovering inferno is a literal blaze king.
Piglins are glorified pigmen.
Iceologer and the hovering inferno will always be in my heart. Even if I'm slaughtering thousands of glow squids and phantoms the sorrow never ends.....
your not alone shit this glow squid will always be my number 1 prey
every time i see a glow squid, no matter if it's right beside me or far away, i will swim to it and brutally murder it.
the absolute WORST PART is that they could've done the same effect with the Glow Berry item.
they are great encounters in minecraft dungeons at least . the iceologer killed me once
@@liz4460 my dark zombie dungeon exp farm sometimes spawns glow squid which end up getting cornered and drown .
recently look in my drops chest to find a lot of glowing sacks and I was like . NICE this exp farm is also spawning and killing automatically the worst mob . xD
Instead of making the phantom a regular enemy, I think it should’ve been a boss with some more interesting attack.
I feel like the phantom should be an end city mini boss
Imagine how COOL Iceologers would have been though. They could have even lived inside ice spikes which are literally useless besides their looks
Would of been nice but I feel like people would of hated them too, I remember when the vote was going on and people were going on and on about renewable ice or some crap. The community hates everything.
Yeah but I play MC dungeons where they come from and when I saw it I got Vietnam flashbacks lol
why did u comment 764983 years ago
Exactly it would give the Ice spikes a actually reason to exist. They would have been a annoying thing to fight but I think it would be a really fun job to add in. You could even add in a new structure to go along with them like a Witch hut
@@dennist8290 And they could freeze you with the powdered snow effect, similar to when you are swimming across the the ocean and you get mining fatigue by a nearby monument. The effect could be cured by being in a 5-block radius of any light source.
The fact that phantoms and GLOWSQUID won is just unbelieveable
Speedrunning too hard. Must vote easy mob. - Minecraft community
no heheha
They dont even glow
@@Bittermintz are you stupid th-cam.com/video/ocbAfuNRQ1c/w-d-xo.html
@@Bittermintz yes they do. that's like saying an enderman's eyes don't glow
well vultures would probably not attack players. they are scavengers, not predators. they would probably steal items, mostly meats likely, and avoid the player like the janitors they are
Glad theyre not in then, i dont want the stuff i drop when i died to be robbed by vultures
@@defaultio3354 dont die then
@The Pickle Behind The Slaughter i mean vultures dont attack u even if u have meat on u, it doesnt make sense
Some vultures vomit as a self defense mechanism (usually if they just ate and need to lose a lot of weight fast to escape). Idk if mojang would go for it though but it would be a good punishment for attacking vultures. Im thinking like -3 hearts of damage
I'm glad everyone isn't too disappointed with the alley, but I'm still disappointed that the copper golem didn't get in. It would've been the first new buildable mob since the iron golem and snow golem. Plus it just looked really cute and had a cool function. Hopefully we'll one day be able to see all the mobs that didn't make it into the vote. #justiceforcoppergolem
Yeah Allay are so hard to find
Tbh, I think all three mobs from the 2020 mob vote could have fit really well with Caves and Cliffs. The moobloom would have went well with the lush cave's more nature theme, the glow squid worked well as a water mob alongside the axolotl, and the iceologer would have been a great addition to the mountains alongside the goats. Man.
If the Moobloom and Iceologer don’t make it in the game at some point I’m rioting
@@Allodoxxed Same. I desperately wanted Moobloom to win. And I’m still sad about it losing in the first round. Then I wanted Iceologer to win, because the other option is literally just a blue squid. And now that the blue squid is in the game, it’s fine, I like what it does to signs, but I’m not going to pretend that either Moobloom or Iceologer would’ve been way better.
I feel like the only problem with the iceologer is it would either make mountains to hard to climb (a long with goats, taller heights and powder snow) or fall into just a variant category ( like the husk and stray)
@@queenofmoons720 If you have difficulty climbing mountains with a chillager on it you might need to relearn minecraft...
mojang never implemented a difficult mob, and according to this they might never do.
@@havk. Facts
I'm my defense for voting for the phantom, it sounded way cooler in concept, they really were a letdown. When it said they would attack players who hadn't slept i imagined just going about my night farming spiders and then as you said hearing a noise, only to find a fearsome beast behind me, but really they do like no damage and aren't scary at all.
Ikr, they had so much potential, yet it was executed horribly. At least they look cool.
Nah, they scared the crap out of me
@@digimonlover1632 warden will
Yeah I think it would be cool if they didn’t dive bomb for 1/2 a heart with no hit box. Maybe if it were bigger and more of a mini boss it would be cool bc you’d actually fear it probably
Personally I would really like phantoms if their hitboxes were just a bit bigger. That being said, I wasn't playing the game at the time of the vote, so idk what I would've actually picked.
imagine being a multi billion dollar company and you have to make your players vote on concept art cause making 4 mobs at once is so hard
While fans are able to churn out massive, game changing mods
cause mojang turned into fucking trash once microsoft started pressuring them
@@slig4656 mojang should just make all four, but their product is much higher quality than any mod I’ve ever played (I’ve played dozens, from the good to the bad). Most mods are buggy, have frame rate and lag issues, and get updated rarely. Also, the devs have to carefully consider every decision they make because if they spend a bunch of time on the glare mob, for example, and nobody likes it, it was a waste of dev resources they could’ve used on something that would make them much more money.
@@user-ni7ui1nk8p yes and no, while I agree the product they release are lot more polished and not causeing game breaking lag. How hard could it be to give an item/mob use? Besides don't forget they are still in multimillion company they have more resources then an small teamed or sometimes lone modders who can churn out game changing mods regardless of how large they can be.
@@user-ni7ui1nk8p higher quality I'm sorry, Dr. Zhark's Mo'Creatures (because of which horses were added into the game after Dr. Z himself was contracted to add them into the game by Mojang), Thaumcraft, Galacticraft, Mekanism, Thermal Expansion, EnderIO, and many more were and are much higher quality than the stuff Mojang has been creating for Minecraftsoft for some time. Few massive updates as of late have compared to mods that have been developed by the community
In my defense, I really thought glow squid would finally give us a mobile light source. They need to explain the mobs better before we vote because the idea we have for a mob will always be cooler than the one we get
I didn't vote for it because it was a squid.
Mojang will never made glow new stuff materials because in reality squids dont drop glow dyes. And Glow squids are very rare to find and can be in found in the deep ocean or in the cave underwater deep.
@@jahlahbrine843 I find the corpses of like hundreds of them by just exploring caves, they arent that rare
You are right. I supposed the hovering inferno was a human-like cavalry.
I personally think that the way the glow squid has been implemented is fine, adding nice ambience to deep aquifers, though I will agree that it would've been better as a mobile light source. The cow would've worked as well.
Scrapping the mobs might be one of the biggest mistakes minecraft could make, and continuously make, and they know it.
"Continuously make" ....they literally already stopped scrapping mobs ever since 2018. Have you even watched the video the whole way through?? Lol.
@@Deltakryzz What do your comment even mean?
@@rejuno1991 they only completely scrapped the 2017 losers. But after that, the losers nowadays aren't.
Like the other guy said, they only scrapped the stuff from the first vote. proof of this is in the swamp content being added to the wild update
We could of had a iceoleger BUT a certain green youtuber TOTALLY didnt rig the vote
Honestly the main reason why I liked the moobloom was theming, I think having more variations of different mobs in certain biomes is a really fun idea and could add more variation and atmosphere. Also they’re just really cute
The reason I wanted the moobloom, was because there was also going to be a birch forest update to go with it
I just want cottagecore piss cow. That's it.
i wanted more cows :(
@@prosandcons-fl2cc well now you get it anyway, and also a cool looking squid that WONT harass you in the mountains and be a nuicance at every encounter.
Agreed I love flower forest and always build my base there I was so happy about moobloom
Rip :(
I’d like to point out that the disenchainting feature from Mob C of 2017’s mob vote did get added in the form of the grindstone. Mojang might not add the vote-losing concepts in full, but the ideas may still be reused in some form or another. Also the campfire totally carried the Taiga by being such a good building block otherwise I don’t really believe there would be much reason to vote for the taiga otherwise.
As someone who lived in Hong Kong until about a year ago, this year’s mob vote was the one where I was finally able to wake up on time to get my vote in lol. I feel you, MisterEpic
you don't know. it could be stupid like the phantom
@@isaacmorrey768 There are mods that add the Hunger, among others, and it's the worst thing in existence.
@@Dynamo33 It is not, far from it. The Hunger had enough details made known to make an actual mob with it. One that hungers for your enchantments in an unpredictable, mob like style while attacking from below making any biome it spawns in much more stressful.
And as mentioned, it's function to remove enchants was added in the form of a grindstone down the line in vanilla. So that more or less confirms that function as well.
I hope all the mobs that are “gone forever” will return. All the remaining mobs in the first vote were cool. The second vote was 50% good. And the third had a cool copper golem and I love copper
Moobloom is in education stuff, Icologer is in Dungeons, at least
yeah i really wanted the King blaze and the Frostellager (im fine with the glow squid tho) and the allay is kinda bad because its hard to find pillager outposts and woodland mansions
We need more options for copper.
@@erebusvonmori8050like crafting copper and iron to make bronze so you can make bronze tools/armor
Love how people complain about a Mob that can easily be avoided by sleeping ever 3rd night.
Honestly I would love to see more arctic mobs such as penguin's and orca's. And maybe even caraboo and other cold region mobs.
so badly i want a deep ocean whale. just like huge passive mob
@@444-o2w Or just big mobs in general.
Maybe add like a new realm or update the end and it'll have these huge whales that slowly fly juuuuust out of reach, and they drop (if you're heartless and manage to kill one) something like pitch or something cool like an element for torches that would absorb light!
I just want iceolloger
@@jammedyam3389 yeah mountains are cool and all but they would be so much better with iceologers on them.
@@444-o2w Or just actually a deep ocean. Oceans are still so disappointing shallow ponds :( I once used the custom world tool (or however it was called) before it was removed to create a world from 0 to ~200 blocks just water and some rocks inbetween and it felt so chilling and mysterious. That would go so well with a whale mob, which then would have enough space to swim...
I still find it shocking that only 2,229 people were involved in the vote that got the phantom in, and by my calculations, only *71* more people voted the phantom over Mob C. *71* people led to the addition of likely the most hated mob in the most-sold game of all time.
It's quite interesting how few votes that entire poll had in general
Silverfish and the Vex: are you challenging me?
@@chrono9503 except that those aren't "our" fault but by "our" I mean almost certainly not your fault because only a few thousand people participated in the vote so if I had to guess, you weren't a part of it (I sure wasn't, I only voted this year)
well, from what I remember it was voted through the minecon, not through twitter
but I might be wrong
welp it's only been about an hour and more people liked my comment than the amount of people who got the phantom in.
I hope one day theres just a massive update called the "Revenge of the Losers" or something, and just have all the mobs that weren't voted put into the game and be extremely aggressive, even the fricken moobloom.
Maybe one day they'll put some of these in another mob vote, so they have a second chance. I hate the fact that theres some mobs just missing forever.
Moobloom is a secret boss fight that appears whenever glow squid enter a flower forest
@@Ssure2 LMAOOOOOOOOOOOO
Imagine if the moobloom would aggro and summon an army of bees to fight you.
you must give the moobloom blood to keep it from turning the whole forest into flames
@@PoProstuBoniacz Who doesn't?
With the glow squid, they should of added a new potion which makes you light up and glow by using its drop.
Terraria shine potion lol
Nah people shouldn’t have voted for it they had a chance for a cool water mob and chose phantoms 😂
I feel like the phantoms can do with an AI update as well as more features that incentivize staying up for a few days, and the phantoms as a gate keeper of those features. For example what if the new frogs croaked more frequently when a thunderstorm is five days away. This prompts the player to stay up for a few days and have to deal with phantoms in order to get the benefits of a thunderstorm; like powdered snow farms, mob heads through charged creepers, brown mooshroom, and skeleton horses.
this is actually a very good idea, you should post it at minecraftsuggestions subreddit
@@raandomplayer8589 I agree
Honestly mob votes as a concept just don't mesh well, voting for 3 mobs and having the other two just wiped off feels incredibly dumb and can very easily just create unnecessary controversy, honestly I think I good idea would be to add a hostile mob that has unique attacks and then a passive mob that has a unique use. Another thing to note is that all the votes take place on twitter which is a pretty idiotic choice since it means nonminecraft players (aka trolls that will try to make fans mad) can determine the vote because of the influence of popular youtubers, having a website that only allows those with a legit minecraft account to vote, would be much better, also the votes really should last longer and shouldn't just stay up for an hour which leaves millions out.
I agree. The votes should last longer (maybe like a week ?) and have it on the Minecraft site or launcher so only those that have the game can vote.
There are a handful of videos that suggest new changes to how the votes should work.
I'm not seeing how a large game company backed by the largest computer technology company in NA in charge of the most popular rated E game ever made can't just add all 3 mobs rather then making people vote for them. minecraft was the most purchased game for 3 years running, you can't tell me they don't have the money.
@@MsMoonDragoon They have money and resources but of course the employees aren't robots they still need to eat,drink and sleep and not only that they still need to test if the mob works well because Minecraft is a sandbox game and it will affect alot
@@MsMoonDragoon more people doesn’t always lead to faster development their are diminishing returns also it’s better the focus on cool stuff like the warden in my opinion
I would have thought most Dream fans would have a Minecraft account, so although an MC-account requirement is something they should do and would help with trolls who don't care about the game, it wouldn't do anything for that scenario.
When looking at the first mob vote, I see that everyone compares the current iteration of the phantom against their speculation of what the other mobs could have been. The unfortunate thing about that is there could be a definite chance that the other mobs would have not lived up to people's original expectation of them, thus making it no different than the scenario with the phantom. I would like to say, however, that I was not playing minecraft at the time of the first mob vote, so I am just simply speaking from a neutral position.
Tl;dr: We should stop voting on mobs based on how we would like them to be in game, but vote instead on how we think mojang will implement them. If mojang has promised certain things for a mob, do not expect them to implement them in the way you want them to, expect them to implement mobs and their properties in the easiest way possible.
I completely agree with this, I feel like most of the time players vote for the most interesting sounding mob, phantoms were promised to live in the end, and attack players like a, well, phantom. but we ended up getting a glorified hostile bat. The glow squid was said to have musical hypnotism powers and useful drops, of course most people knew that even this was boring compared to the other options but the vote was slightly tampered, and we ended up with, a retextured squid and some cool sign fonts (a complete shock to absolutely nobody). This is the reason I think the Allay is going to fail, because almost every time we get a vote, players vote big, on mobs that have more vague properties because the more vague the properties of the mob is, the more they can assume it will work how they want it to, and not really putting much thought into how mojang will make it. The more vague the mob is, the more people will come up with their own ideas on how the mob works, the more disappointed they will be when mojang makes the mob infinitely more boring in game, because it will be easier to implement than more ambitious mob qualities. The Allay will be implemented with this same design philosophy. Mojang will disappoint, because they have only promised us that it is a mob that will pick stuff up, and drop it at a noteblock, players are going to expect more than that but that is likely all it will do. Worst of all, mobs cannot load chunks, so if you die somewhere in the world far away, you won’t be able to give the allay a copy of your gear, and expect it to find it for you, because an allay can only operate in the chunks you are in, and in terms of farms, what more use can an unreliable mob have than completely reliable blocks (hoppers), sure it may be cheaper, but it might also not be, what if the allay is only found in rare areas, and players have to travel miles to go find them, how much cheaper is that than just mining for half an hour for iron? Why trust the functionality of your farm, with a mob that might die, pick up the items from the wrong area, or wander off over the functionality of a hopper that will consistently collect from the same block? We have been given too little information on how the mob will work, which is why I think players like it (they will always vote for what they think a mob will be, rather than it’s actual named qualities, e.g. players think allays will phase through walls even though that was never promised), and also why it will fail (mojang will never make a mob that will live up to what players have hyped it up to be, preferring to implement a mob more easily with the functions promised, rather than implement functions players assume will be there, but was never promised).
REAL TL;DR: democracy is broken.
but atleast they didnt fly
Except in the phantom mob vote for example it told exactly what it would do. In future votes they told way less about them which annoys me because you don't know their potential
@@cjrbread5928 exactly. But some dont seem to realize this because a lot of people thought the allay would dupe items like really do you really think mojang would do that
Considering how the Sniffer has history (plus functionality and new possible plants), and how the community wants it mostly for the lore. I'm starting to believe they're reconsidering adding the three mobs from 2017 Mob Vote. As someone who loves lores on video games (most of the time), it'll actually be interesting and makes meeting/defeating them in battle would have more value than just *FARM.* 🧐
jeb said gone forever
As useless as the copper golem is, it would've been fun to have a little robot to hangout with and be responsible for as opposed to a dog, cat, parrot, etc.
I wanted it because I though it could be used in many different build. Labratory: have golems pressing buttons to make them look like scientists.
Steampunk: have golems around like they are maintaining engines.
Any ancient build: have an army of oxidized golems all lined up in a grand hall.
And the list goes on but everyone always said "it's just a less efficient randomizer"
@@prosandcons-fl2cc yeah that would be really good for story maps and builds, maybe they'll add it eventually
@@prosandcons-fl2cc I think they should have been made able to be taught to push particular buttons, for purposes of automation. I feel like that would have been a far better mechanic than the "flying hopper minecart" allay.
@@prosandcons-fl2cc Agreed. I wanted it to populate my town, and press random buttons to look like a worker or randomise Things in town/dungeons. No need for contraptions. Also could be used story-wise. A button behind an impentrable wall. But you can unrust a golem through a small hole and he can press the button. Etc.
The Allay is... I mean. we already Automate item gathering. and pick up stuff we want already.
@@facelesshalo5174 agreed once more
It would be interesting to see how the Hovering inferno would effect speedruning if it were added. As blazes and nether fortresses are a very important part of speedrunning. I feel it would be kind of similar to the Piglin brute in 1.16.
good point
Nah people would have learned about this mob and then it wouldn't have been a problem on speedruning since people would knew how to counter this mob
@@Jodio-Joestar It would be really cool that if the Hovering inferno got in instead of the phantom, axes could be made to break it’s defenses similar to a shield.
Dream was voted againts, because they will ruin speedruns.
@@Jodio-Joestar Well I'm sure people would have defiantly have come up with a way to counter the mob. But it would definitely have had some sort of impact on speedruning weather its a big impact or not.
I feel like the Hovering Inferno would have been the best mob to vote for
Looking back now, it WAS the best mob to vote for
100%
I’m gonna be honest that sounds like a nightmare to deal with
Literally the phantom is so bad
Yeah but it has one glaring weakness: fire Res. With fire resistance you could literally just charge in and not take any damage. I personally voted for the great hunger bc it's basically a bear trap mob that could mess with your enchants which sounds rly interesting
Mob D is one of the coolest things ive ever seen. I love me a new challenge,and also a new hostile mob,so finding out that two notorious monsters (Mob D/chillager) lost to an updated bat and a re-skinned squid makes me wanna fucking puke
Personally for me, I don't want a bunch of new hostile mobs being added to the game. When I play minecraft, I don't want to have to always worry about being jump scared by something trying to kill me when I simply just want to get resources. That's why I didn't vote for them.
@@thriilers1017 then play peaceful, pussy
@@thriilers1017 but...minecraft is literally a survival game. if you dont want enemies and fighting, thats what creative mode is for.
@@thriilers1017 there is a peaceful mode...
@@koolhoven6342 I don’t want peaceful mode, I just don’t wanna be fighting mobs in every place I go.
we need a jungle update next with jungle villages up in the trees called "hanging villages" and canoes and other cool stuff to add to the jungle. I think a Jungle update would be cool and should be included in the wild update
Yessssss. This I love the jungle biome. It’d definitely be cool if they updated it.
The game honestly needs more to do after getting diamond tools. Also the fact that building is still so limited in survival mode. We should be able to build machines or tools that let us produce and place large amounts of blocks.
@@Distress. There is netherite plus how is building limited in survival? Genuinely curious about what you think.
@@AndreasJepsenMusic like you still have to place one block at a time. I know commands exist but imagine if those were available though an item in the game. Or if you could place blocks in some third person view, cause by the end of the game you get tired of how long it takes to build things and just go creative.
@@Distress. I get where you're coming from, but i don't think it's limited in survival, it just takes up a lot of time. For me, it's more satisfying to finally complete my survival builds after gathering all the resources and spending the time on building them. And i don't get the urge to go to creative to build my stuff. But i will agree that some command like item would sick af tbh
I never understood why they’d scrap good ideas when they could just add them later down the line, but to be fair if they did add them later down the line it would take a million years because despite being one of the biggest games ever mojang somehow takes forever to release some of the most minuscule updates ever, literally the slowest working studio I’ve ever seen.
I blame microsoft for that, for no reason at all hehehe
mojang are legit bad people im convinced they spend most of their time at the office stealing a paycheck from microsoft just sipping coffee reading reddit smiling
@@poorlymadeproduction So sad that such could be the case yet there's people suffering their asses off to find a decent job at the same time.
Probably what pisses me off the most. Other studios would kill for the funding that microsoft offers, yet mojang pisses it away and does nothing.
I mean, not recently. We’ve gotten huge updates pretty frequently. The Nether Update, which still was 2 years ago but the best update yet, a WHOLE Mountains and Caves rework that’s actually GOOD and outshines most if not all mods, and the Deep Dark, which is pretty high effort, just LOOK. Sure the warden should be a boss and reward you more for killing it, but other than that, yeah. We can ignore Bees, the Color update and certain prior releases. Mojang is set for the future.
Edit: I'd like to apologize.
i think the mountains winning against the savanna was worth it, even at face value, as a builder. campfires are some of the most useful detailing blocks ever and make everything look perfect if used correctly.
you mean taiga winning over savanna
Campfire has been quite the various aesthetic to me, I'm glad they added that to the game.
I certainly think that vote was good all around. All 3 were necessary, so each one should've happened. I wonder what building ideas we could've done with Termite nests, especially if there was a "Vacant Termite nest" block. Also i'm a sucker for wood types, so i wonder how the baobab wood would've looked like.
Aesthetically, i can understand desert, but it is what it's supposed to be, and palm trees only make sense near water sources. Plus deserts already had their own variants of villages, wells, and the desert temple, and the Savannah seemed the most lacking.
To me it doesn’t really matter as long as we get them all in the end. I personally would have picked the taiga if I voted.
The Inferno one would be such a cool mini boss, like one spawning in every fortress or something. That would be so cool. Giving the player even more insensitive to be careful and prepare before farming blaze rods...
I'm just saying, I would've rather had the Moobloom or "piss cow" over the glow squid. If the iceologer still got voted out at the end
Glowsquid ain't bad, but it is far from the star of the show
@@TheBinklemNetwork
Let’s be honest here
It’s bad
@@movingchannels2203 perhaps you lack a use case? If something is not of immediate use to you, would you consider it outright bad?
What makes it bad in your opinion?
Nice animations on your channel btw, berry intriguing!
@@TheBinklemNetwork
It mainly just floats around and looks pretty
Sure it can glow up signs and item frames but it’s not that useful.
That’s also adding the fact that I normally don’t see their ink sacs in areas where they die, so they fill up my inventory and it gets pretty annoying having to clear it out every 10 minutes
But thanks for the compliment!
@@movingchannels2203 no problem! Ahh I guess since I'm playing with shaders in a cave the whole "making items/signs glow" I put more of a worth to those sacks than most would! Thanks for your perspectives!
I want to point out that Mojang made it seem that the glow squid would "hypnotize" players (an interesting new mechanic I may add) when they got close to it. So not only did the glow squid NOT give off actual light, its also didnt "hypnotize" players either.
I thought the glow ink sac could have been a new potion ingredient for a paralisis - hypnosis effect or something else
@@giuliocusenza5204 that would have been cool but a little op for the game. Also there wouldn’t be much of a use in survival except for mobs but if you could freeze a warden…. Kinda op
@@YaStreamerBrownie how do you hypnotize someting with no eyes?
@@YaStreamerBrownie I know, but I assumed the freezing would have been buffed by extreme shortness of the effect or by being not actual freezing, but rather slowness + some visual hypnotic effect.
@@giuliocusenza5204 ah ok yeah that makes a bit of sense.
I think mob votes are more of a curse then a blessing. My main point being that it just ends up in the end dividing the community
So it was a curse and became a blessing? How?
@@viporal7898 I think they meant 'than'
@@J4cquieLantern there's no way he's that stupid
@@viporal7898 not everyone is perfect in English
@@J4cquieLantern when did I say anyone had to be perfect? Reread my comment--no where in it does it say that.
Still holding out hope for the moobloom. I really love mooshrooms and their design, so having an alternate style and more would make me happy. I also love the cute mobs, lol
ah yes, lets have mojang add even more fucking useless cute mobs that 70% of regular players will ignore and forget they totally exist
@@heyolorenns yep.
@@heyolorenns at this point, I'd be grateful if ignorable shit got added. Like the things they add now not only duck, but you are being forced to interact with them.
@@an2thea514 it took mojang 2 years to add a brush. them adding anything at this point is a blessing lmao
Mob vote is just sad ;(
Minecraft should do the mob vote like the biome vote. Adding the mobs later and not scrapping them :(
Agreed
Except for the ones that everybody hates, and we don't want added to the game ever.
It's probably to add the stakes so that people would make even more conscious decisions, though often we'd regret choices we make
@@tovishitomeiji5383 but indefinitely scrapping the losers makes the mob votes feel not like "this mob was added in because of you" and more like "these two perfectly good ideas are gone forever and it's your fault"
I agree entirely. it's a huge waste of potential to get rid of them forever.
i love how with nearly every vote we've had, we happened to choose the least interesting selections there were
no
Espically due to people voting some mobs in as jokes
Glow Squid does have a use, but we all know why people hate them (I don't really mind them, but i'd rather have the Moobloom or Ice-Illger)
@@CinnaMae420 true, i can see a lot of people complaining if the copper golem won instead of allay
I mean i think the new Ghost guy was pretty neat. Tho other than him? Yeah...
Tho to be honest? I do like the idea of Phantoms but they are so damm tiny and annoying! They are cool in a way. I kinda wish more things whould change if you didint sleep in minecraft like mayby animals whould get replaced with Shadow animals that are hostile to you for example.
@@quinnholloway5400 glow squid has no damn use! i don't want another mob I'm going to forgot in 4 months!
Remember that some features from mobs in the 2017 mob vote were added into the game, like the ability for mobs to hold shields from the Hovering Inferno and the ability to remove enchantments through the grindstone from the Great Hunger
And magma blocks in the ocean as Barnacles
I still really wanted burrow boy though, still wondering what it would’ve been called
So if Mob B lost, there would eventually be an insomnia mechanic in the gane that would likely give you bad effects of you negated sleep. I'd pick weak flying mob over poison for the whole game day.
@@Master_Brutus You probably won't get poison but might lose your hunger a lot faster, although you might as well just sleep or play on peaceful
@@jeuno. personally, i have almost no problems with Phantoms. I always go to sleep most nights in the overworld, and sometimes I will stay up to shoot them down for sport. I see them as easily countered fun clay shooting rather than annoyances. Also I cant live without Slow Fall Potions.
The fact that the modding community can add 100 times more interesting and diverse mobs that actually work well in the game over one year while Mojang does not even a fraction of that in a couple of years is really sad
I still think the most annyoing part about the phantom is how it spawns. Having a mob which is annyoing to be around and aweful to fight, spawn when the player does not skip the night by using the bed is genuinly bad design. The night is one of the challenges of minecraft. Players should either be punished for skipping the night too many times or rewarded for not skipping it.
Yes but if you punish people for sleeping too much you alienate portions of the community as well. Many player types need to be taken into account.
if you cant sleep every 3 nights i genuenly feel bad for you, you get 3 whole nights, and even so just disable spawnphantoms in the game rules.
@@afewofmycommentsarecringy.8646 what if you live underground and literally just can't tell when it's night time
@@niox1920 then phantoms aren't an issue for you? I fail to see the problem there
@@Whodjathink if you live underground you spend copious amounts of time down there however your entire playthrough isn't underground, you still come up to do things and as soon as you do you get swarmed by phantoms
I’m still not sold on the allay, but enough people are psyched about its potential usefulness that I’m hopeful it’ll be good when it comes out. Was really hoping for the copper golem personally, another usage for copper, along with copper buttons, and a good way to add randomization to redstone.
Tbh allay doesnt really seem as useful as people make it out to be since we have hoppers/hopper minecarts. Copper golems wouldve been a fun alternative to chicken randomizers that i could see being used for fun little contraptions (although even it's uses seem kinda limited still).
@@Preetzole i mean the allay can maybe sort unstackbles, thats pretty much it, would also would've wanted the copper golem to win but some *cough* Minecraft speedrunners *cough* rigged it they even said it on twitter that they rigged it
Copper golem would make for a neat decoration for temples build if nothing else
@Xudid Dkkdddidisidi fun fact, none of them were useful in the slightest. The glare is f3, the golem is only there as decoration, the allay... you all seem blind to how flying mobs have horrendous path finding in this game, they are just gonna increase the lag of farms while doing their work slower than a minecart that's it.
The was only useful for the redstone community, the Allay has more uses for the majority of the entire community
Yeah but if they made the phantom sound way cooler than it actually was then the same would've likely happened with the other mobs and we would be like "phantom was so cool! Why didn't it win?"
No
Yeah, the other mobs sound infinitely more annoying.
Trying to get blaze rods? Guy with shields and a shotgun in your way
Trying to swim? Not on the tongue guy's watch, now drown
Trying to _walk?_ Nuh-uh-uh, there go your items and enchantments
@@QuokkaWaka We have learned to vote for the more boring mobs because it's More likely to payoff then the others
@@maxalmgren-storm9442 A very compelling argument.
@@QuokkaWaka but that is more interesting than a bat that does damage
man i always wanted to see n still want the hovering inferno.
hes so damn awesome.
oh yes the glowsquid. amazing if it could add a glow to objects or make certain blocks glow it be cool. but its kinda pointless.
the chilliger and the inferno should have been in the game tbh.
i also rly liked the copper golem. it would have been so cool! though i dun hate the alley.
exacly
the glow squid would be less hated if it has chance to drop like glow dust that makes blocks slightly glow
At least inferno is in dungeons in the form of wildfire
I love how he hi-lighted the number of people who voted for “do not care” on the moon shape vote as if to say “ that many people didnt care?!” But didnt say anything about it
They did say something about it. They said they didn't care, hence the result.
@@m.c.filmmakers626
As in the guy in the video, not the voters
i liked the round moon and sun
I think Glare would've filled a niche type of useless part of the game, which in a way, would've been kind of perfect for the update.
Anyway, I think mob votes are stupid. I want them all.
F3
The devs have like infinite ideas so asking the community to pick one from the top ideas is not bad if the rest of the mobs will get added but the phantom mob vote was definitely stupid.
I think the Glare would be perfect for Bedrock players not playing on pc but instead a console of some sort.
@@Alphaj0r BEDROCK
We could have an insane bossfight at the bottom of the ocean with the ocean terror, we could have a intense fight within the nether fortress against the king of the blazes. But we got vex v2.
the bit about living in australia and weirding out the parents is too accurate. woke up at 2:30 for the 1.19 announcement... parents were very concerned and confused
same, but my parent did not know... :)
Ahh, you woke up 7 years from now. Happens to me all the time
The first mob vote was actually in 2016, where Jeb asked fans wether they wanted either the alpaca or llama to be added in 1.11. The llama won, and so it was added soon after. Alpaca’s probably won’t be added any time soon, since their practically the same thing as llamas, unless they would be different somehow.
Fun fact Mob D- Hovering Inferno, which is known as Wildfire was actually in the files in MC dungeons, where you can see the way it moves and it’s textures. Even the developers mentioned it as a unfinished mob for the nether DLC
Uh-huh sorry but I forgot to ask
@@virtuoso513 Uh-huh sorry but you forgot what sonic said
"If your profile picture is from an anime, your opinion doesn't count!"
Also
*i asked*
Oh nice
Wild update = Wildfire
We chawe a chance a add.
@@virtuoso513 imagine being in a public space and not caring what other people say.
I still miss the Moobloom… and what makes it worse is that when it lost, I really wanted the Chillager to win, since it actually looked pretty cool compared to a blue squid. And it didn’t. That vote was easily my least favorite one ever.
thanks to dream and his fanbase, they ruined mob vote 2020.
Now that's funny, because it's not blue.
Thanks DREAM
We blame the green mask man who thinks they're a musician.
Pisscow lol
I wish they DIDN'T kill of the 2017 mobs that lost. They were all good, at least concept-wise. Maybe they'd even all NOT flop like the Phantom once they released
The fact that TH-camrs can create all 3 of these mobs in just days shows that Mojang could make the vote determine which order the mobs get into the game at bare minimum.
Phantoms could easily be revived by making it extremely hard to capture and tame one, just sayin'. Having a mountable flying mob would be a nice second tier to elytras.
Especially early game
that sounds OP
@@InternetAntagonist Maybe, but also maybe not. It depends on the implementation IMO.
Should it still burn in daylight? Maybe it could have it's own armor in netherite that stops this.
Should it still be capable of attacking? If not, it's just a flying mount.
Should you need multiple rare items to tame it? Perhaps it has to be done in the air while using an elytra.
Anyways, there are perfectly reasonable methods of making this not as OP. Certainly wouldn't be any more OP than elytras + fireworks.
@@kilospade i think phantoms should be scary non-physical mobs that give you effects instead of damage since they spawn because of insomnia.
You’d need to use items like soul lanterns to scare them away or make them physical to kill and loot them.
I think it could be coherent.
Or maybe have a few of them spawn every night but only being able to see you when you lack sleep and have a chance to attack living hostile mobs (but maybe only in swamps or on full moon). Apart from wolves and foxes and maybe cats there s little to no interaction between usual mobs.
@@reedy_9619 Sounds pretty neat actually. Would be interesting if your idea had some sort of new hallucination effect.
It would be cool if they took all the un-used mobs and put them into one poll every time they did an update, instead of new mobs.
Agreed, so I could spam vote the "Hovering inferno" blazes and withers are too boring, I mean the blaze looks cool but their getting pretty old
The problem with that is that some mobs were designed for different versions of the game. The hunger pacman thing was supposed to de-enchant, which you can now do with the grindstone. The depths one was to make the sea more interesting, but we got the update aquatic. The glare is quite useless now that only 100% dark areas can spawn mobs, but before it was an interesting idea (only java players have F3 and it's not really legit anyway).
Well still though, the hunger pac man would of been great, because you’d be forced to create an stable for your horses and stuff to keep them safe from the hunger. Also it would suck to have mending and sharpness 5 on your sword until the hunger eats these items and spits them out without the enchantments.
(Assuming the hunger eats you first)
Also I still think the depths monster would be nice.
Even with the drowned, I’m not scared of the oceans. I’d like to have some times where I avoid the water, because I saw “something”
They should have just added them all, why the fuck they only choose to add one is so fucking lazy and irredeemable.
I think the glow squid had a lot of potential, I thought it would drop a glowing dye that would give us the ability to craft a glowing blocks of various different colors like glass and wool.
your idea is actually the best ive read so far
I feel Rick rolled
maybe but to say it would be more interesting then the mountain biomes first native hostel mob would be scratching it
Yeah I wanted to dye leather armor to glow or at least have the glow squid actually glow
@@NyctopenYTmaybe
I was sad to hear that the Wild Fire and the Iceologer lost the Mob Votes, but I am happy they are added into Minecraft Dungeons, which is the second game. I was still glad to encounter and fight them in the game.
Fun Fact: a statue of The Hovering Inferno can be found in Minecraft Dungeons' Nether Fortress level.
I probably voted for that blaze boss, but after recently spending a lot of time in the nether makes me glad it did not get added as regular blazes are already a huge pain in the ass early game. I'm salty about not getting the ice-ologer
Yeah i guess that makes sense but just imagine how cool a blaze Mini boss or even a Boss whould have been? Tho yeah. Illager gang rise! Hopefully one day we will see Illusioner aswell.
@@draw2death421 the only problem is that knowing how underwhelming the phantom was in comparison to the expectations, the blaze boss probably would have been a normal OP mob or even a deception
because the nether is not early game
"After climbing the new mountains I'm glad there isnt a mob that spawns in the daytime to knock me off to my death"
@@Levixne No water bucket, hay, slime block, cobweb, honey block or other stuff that saves you from falling? 💀
“Instead of being called Extreme Hills, they should have been called extreme disappointments.”
Best part of video omg
Scrolled down the comments to find this quote
As an asian I can confirm this is what my parents said
6:24 I assumed the Phantoms would only exist to a single player at a time, so as you fought them others would see you swinging at empty air and firing arrows at literal nothing.
I still really like Mob A, it fits perfectly into the game and it's a great alternative for not adding sharks. Lets hope that one day Mojang adds them all into the game!
Add into bedrock only its amazing 🤣
"The glare is a cute version of f3"
You have triggered tens of millions of Bedrock Players
Mobile go brrrrrrrrrrrr, seriously though mojang should get on that
One of the reason I dislike playing on bedrock is the lack of f3 and other dev tools
i dislike bedrock due to major performance issues that piss me off really hard. like whenever i press a button in the menu it takes 5 WHOLE SECONDS to load it up. and server performance sucks. but its the only minecraft version i can play with my friends.
Mobs will only spawn in complete darkness come 1.18, we have eyes
Cries in bedrock
The copper golem could’ve been used some way in red stone contraptions as a random input, and also would’ve been a good use of copper, which is useless outside of building. I can see why the allay won but I hope they add the copper golem in the future.
🤝
also to me the ally just seems like a aoe hopper. so more pointless in my eyes. its better then the glare but thats not a fair compairason since the glare needed something eles to be worth it
They need to find other uses for copper. Because copper golems are a completely pathetic attempt. There are so many other ways to make random inputs!
Maybe if the copper golem could be programmed to make specific inputs at specific times, then they would be worth something... barely. But even then I vastly prefer the Allay.
Why not just give the copper golem the Allay abilities?
It would make sense (and when I say abilities I mean holding items and such)
@@juicebox7372
At that point you may as well just add both rather than having one rip off the functionality of the other. That would just be outright insulting to the people who wanted the Allay.
That squid in the beginning would be really cool to have in caves instead of glow squids
I think the reason why people are always so upset about mob/biome vote is because mojang always promises or at least shows up more then they add. I was so excited for the glow squid thinking it would mesmerize you when you were near and would act as a light source but… instead we got a re-textured squid that has a special ink sac, I find it’s the same with the recent “wild” update it was basically caves and cliffs pt3 they showed us many different concept art that of course never had any changes, I feel mojang is just promising more than what they actually end up adding:(
To be honest, Mojang has been pretty lazy for a while now, it's crazy how it can take them an entire year to make a single mob and a single biome, as someone who knows modders and has tried modding myself, I just can't explain myself how it takes them SO LONG to make such minuscule updates. Also, the web about that mob vote, specified the glowsquid wouldn't provide light, but none read that of course.
@@pestrusiariopaezmengoso2868 They do that to keep hype... If u do this every other week the entire hype would be dead
U are a dumbass... Mesmerize you? So just look pretty? We got texture packs for that wanker.
@@pestrusiariopaezmengoso2868 I feel like you don’t know what you’re talking about. The only mediocre update in years is the wild update. All the other ones immersed you in a previously shallow aspect of the game. Nether was too empty and bland? Let’s add mobs, biomes, structures, and more. Ocean had like 2 mobs? Let’s add more fish, turtles, structures, and mechanics. Caves were repetitive and boring? Let’s add biomes, better cave structure, a new ore, and much more. Villagers wanted 64 emeralds for a piece of dirt? Let’s make trading diverse and actually useful. And for the record, you’re just plain wrong. The wild update was a 6 month update.
It's really weird that they didn't give glow squids a light source. It's literally in the name - a GLOW squid.
No joke, one of my favorite biomes is the dessert. I'm a bit sad for finding out it won't be updated until 10 more years
Don't give up hope too soon. All of the losing biomes were all warm biomes. Maybe one day, deserts savannahs and badlands can all be updated in a massive "warm update" of something of the sorts.
@@lazykirby57 the "Heatstroke Update"
@@YataTheFifteenth lmao
Its pretty sad desert didnt got a update. it would be such a awesome thing palm trees in a beach
Scrapping the other ideas still pisses me off to this day. The first vote was handled horribly and had such good ideas that fit so naturally it seems ridiculous that those simple, effective, and great ideas are being thrown away.
The vote is rigged. They choose mob that easy to implement.
@@hellatze what lol why would mob votes even be a thing if they were too lazy to add a mob
@@cursedfl4mes645 for marketing
@@hellatze
Dude everyone on the planet knows what Minecraft is already. They don’t need to market anything
@@i-kneel-for-no-man3814 you have no idea what marketing is.
Literally there's no reason they can't just implement all the mobs in snapshots and just axe ones people don't like
Still think if the vote before last was legit, Iceologer would've won.
of course. If not for Dream.
I'd hope so
Ikr
@@TheMisterEpic i think iceologer would have won if they named it the chillager instead.
We will never know.
But I have to say that it is pretty easy to blame it on Dream. People didn't had a gun pointing towards them when voting, they still had their free will.
At the end of the day, it's a community vote. If people are not happy with the result, it's the community's fault, not Dream's (and also Mojang's for proposing such a useless mob)
All Minecraft mobs that were voted in have these characteristics:
-Blue
-Has glowing eyes
-Floating/Flying
What about the goat
@@mous_1020 goat can't fly but it can make other mobs do
@@mous_1020 you could argue the goat or fox but they were mainly for a biome vote not specifically focused around the mobs.
The phantom has green eyes
@@thewatcher8733 but they do kinda glow
Vultures would be incredibly interesting mobs, perhaps they could start out like cats where they flee if you get too close but as you get lower on health they gradually become more aggressive. First they stop flying away, then they start looking towards you, then flying after you, before finally attacking you with increasing aggression.
Vultures eat the dead, they don't actively kill things, they wait
one comment above said the similar thing about health and starving and this is the response:
How many players actually starve do death? At most you just dont have hunger but i never heard of someone actually starving to death and if they did it wouldve been in the first day of minecraft for unexperianced players who wandered there at the start (so they probably dont have any items on them) because experianced players would avoid Mesa at the start if they could even find one beacuse it very rare...
*Vutures would be usseless and had no interaction with players except maybe the first day of the game but even then it would be still actually hard to find Mesa*
I liked the copper golem, as there are only two other golems. We already have water streams on ice to transport items, and item sorters are much faster and simpler. I've never used allays in survival. They're just fairies that like music and can sort through items, all of which already have solutions.
Phoenix SC did point out that Phantoms have a size value. They could definitely just make phantoms change is size more drastically for every night you don't sleep. That honestly seems already plenty interesting than what we currently have.
I have actually played a plugin/mod that does that, it is awful and makes phantoms 100x more annoying
They should just remove phantoms lol. They are annoying overall, and especially for skyblock players
@@alihene2225 how would we get phantom membrane?
@@alihene2225 L
I only learned recently dream was the reason the glow squid won. I was wanting the Iceologer so bad. The moobloom looked like it should've been for a mod.
The phantom
-Has glowing eyes
-Floats/flys
-Is blue
-Everyone hates them
Glow squid
-Has glowing eyes
-Floats/flys
-Is blue
-Everyone hates them
Allay
-Has glowing eyes
-Floats/flies
-is blue
-...
I think the mob voting was the beginning of the end for me. I started playing less and less once the phantom was released in favor of the better sounding mobs.
I'm really glad that the swamp got immediately updated after the mountains, as I'm sure I'm not the only one who liked the ideas of the updated swamp. However, as a mexican, I would really like to see the new cactus (called nopal) from the badlands added as well.
You’re not the only one for sure I love the swamp definitely my favorite biome and always felt like they were neglected. Especially with cool secrets like witch huts and fossils it had potential but the generation of them and the mobs in it felt like it was like everything else in minecraft fit but swamps were pulled straight from a very early version of minecraft. It would be really cool to see instead of oak wood with vines for trees, they were more twisty kind of trees with unique wood. I also think those mobs that sit underground that got voted out in the first mob vote would fit really well with the swamp
Not a massive fan of this way of implementing new features to be honest. I'd have them all be added one by one
I'm seriously still angry that the Chillagers weren't added. We could've possibly, finally, had magic in Minecraft. Imagine if killing them could potentially drop a magic weapon that let you use their ice attacks.
The trident is the closest thing we have to magic, but it's still primarily a melee weapon.
@@bugjams Would have be dope. The devs clearly have a vision for their game though and that's why I think it's weird to just delete the mob who didn't win. They probably wont ever give magic to the player because that would change too many things from the vanilla minecraft experience and adding really crazy things is in the end more a mod thing
They are, outside of the phantom vote, just very spaced out. The swamp is getting updated soon for example
@@bugjams Me dream haha squid glow
@@trashcan3266 ok dreamer
I think Minecraft dungeons is definitely a great way to give the outvoted mobs some new light. It’s not perfect, but it’s something
minecraft dungeons imo has some of the coolest mobs to exist. (Seriously the ice illager is a great concept for vanilla. Could also argue snow zombies as well. (Also kinda wishing the illusioner gets properly added soon)
They should have just added them all, why the fuck they only choose to add one is so fucking lazy and irredeemable.
"Minecraft dungeons is definitely the perfect way to give the outvoted mobs some new light."
Next sentence:
"It’s not perfect, but..."
bruh
@@peterjohnson11655 lmfao I know I know, it’s changed now
@@slendermonkey7 lloll
The problem is
The Rule of cute
no one cares what the mobs do aslong as "Their cute"
Mobs who lost the mob vote: *gone forever*
Mods: let's us introduce ourselves
Wow you're so clever, nobody has ever said that before I'm certain.
@@spets234 why you acting like a spongiform encephalopathy
@@spets234 Mald
Melo
That just makes it worse, knowing the community had to add them themselves.
Every time I remember that we lost a giant Blaze miniboss with probably good difficulty and some nasty op drops against some birds that drops potion shit, my day gets ruined.
this is just a reminder that eveysingle little bits of action you did through out your whole entire life has consequences
@@no-qy3pq blaze are already annoying enough to fight, i dont wanna get ambushed by a dozen fireballs before even finding the spawner. And dont even get me started with that item trapper bullshit
@@Tinaphromad lmao if youre bad at videogames just do literally anything else, and also shields exist
I’ve always thought they should do a mob vote with only old mobs that didn’t win, and it has always been kinda sad when a good mob doesn’t get voted for :(
yeah, and add the mob that won into the survival gameplay, and the lost mobs into unused mobs in creative
Theyre not gone forever, they will be added in the future
@@anormalperson9552 no, only the biomes