This song was written specifically in response to the deaths of a 12 year old and a 3 year old in a bombing in the early 90's. The emotions you were feeling were completely intentional to the songwriting, and it's a masterwork.
She would not know. Even though they are her neighbors. People this age know NO recent history. I bet she never heard of the IRA. She didn't even bat an eye when the IRA mural hit the screen. Sad.
@@nielgregory108 Not her fault, it is modern teaching ideas that have no time for this type of history. I fear for the future with what is happening in our world at the moment, and end up remembering Heinrich Heine's famous quote - "Where they burn books, so too will they in the end burn human beings."
Definitely keep the raw version. So long as you feel comfortable with it of course. Often the reason we love these songs is because they impact us on an emotional level, and whilst your musical analysis is OFF THE CHART, seeing someone else experience those emotions is very powerful.
also if you need cheering up, I've been thoroughly enjoying watching Pomplamoose creating their new work, and Félicitations! is a fab single to listen to on it's own
100% agree...it is up to you. As for my preference, I prefer to see the genuine emotional reaction as that is ultimately what music is FIRST about in my opinion. Thanks for you reaction!
As someone peripherally associated with some of the stuff going on back in the 90's, I DIRECTLY credit her, and the Cranberries, with shaming all parties to the table that finally led to peace. Never thought I'd see it, and never was I more grateful. She was a true bard, and healed her people
Please keep the raw emotions. Your technical breakdowns are brilliant, but your humanity is what brings us all here. You have charisma, and your honest reactions really brings that to the forefront. Never stop being you and always react honestly, please.
I gotta agree. Your passion and emotion when listening to music, along with your huge expertise are what make you so compelling to watch. Please, record it all, and chop it up later, if that's the way the music makes you feel. It's absolutely captivating and makes you stand out from the crowd. Love your work. Keep it up x
Absolutely right. You have a keen and sensitive spirit. You feel things very deeply and you allow us to feel them right along with you. This direct connection with your emotions is the wellspring of your creativity. Pray you never become inured to the highs and lows life is always throwing at us, for they are what make life special. And you can't truly enoy the sun without having felt the rain. Chiaroscuro...light and dark.
It's always incredible to me how a song can evoke such emotions. It's a testament to those who made it. It seems to paint a picture, like an artist evoking emotion with brush strokes. The broader issue being addressed by this song is something they felt deserves attention, and rightfully so. There was a lot of suffering involved.
In my opinion... crazy as it may seem... the reason we love music and the way it makes us feel is because everything in our physical world is about frequency. Sounds and vibrations are everything.
Your actual reaction is the best thing to show -- if a song leaves you stunned and you can't comment right away, that's a-ok, getting to see your genuine response makes the whole thing personal.
I always enjoyed how Dolores kept her Limerick accent in her singing and her use of keening. She was a very original and unique talent, who left this earth entirely too soon. This is a very emotional and powerful song, so your reaction is completely understandable and appreciated.
It was very interesting your mention of the Celtic/ Gaelic tradition of Keening. Not really well up on the subject I looked it up, where else but on Wikipedia.and it seems the song is a perfect example of the tradition thank you for bringing it up I’m now going to have to find more examples of of it in Ann attempt to learn more about it. 👍👏👏👏👏
Yes keening is beautiful. If you didn't know you may be interested, Bad Wolves did a remake that was supposed to have her in the video but she died before it was done. It's still a great video, nothing like the first but still impactful
NEVER replace genuine feels. We NEED more of that in this world. It's this very thing that draws me to your channel. Your sense of humor is right there also. Love what you do!
Bad Wolves did a cover of this. On January 15, 2018 Delores O'Riordan was supposed to sing on it with them but she passed before she could record it. They did the cover anyway with their own singer and donated all money made from the cover to her children.
I really appreciated how they made the video with some one representing her in the gold. Was one of my favorite songs when it came out and in as excited when I heard about a cover. So much respect for what they did for her children. 🙌🏼
I hate that we lost her. Been listening to them since day 1. For me... this is a thing where I'll always remember where I was when I heard it on the news.
Dear Lolli, To me you stand out amongst the various reaction channels out there, particularly because you are so empathetic. There are so many false emotions out there, specifically aimed at harvesting views and likes, it is refreshing to see some honousty. I saw your emotional reaction to Johnny Cash's version of Hurt before, and your tears made me feel free to let go of my own. Please don't ever change. This song is another one of those gems out there that is aimed at touching people deep inside. If one would not at the very least feel uncomfortable, it would not have the intended impact. I think it is fitting that you sat through it completely, unable to speak. Breaking the video up afterwards to interject the technicalities, to be fair was a little odd at times, but I am convinced it is the best option available. Sorry for the lengthy response, but I wanted to make it absolutely clear that you need not be afraid of people not liking the way this video came out. If any do, that's their loss.
Keep the emotions in. It's the main attraction for me. Concerning putting on an American accent when UK artists sing, as an American musician, growing up I was always intrigued with those UK accents, and loved the few artists who sang in their own accents, like Johnny Rotten. We LOVED hearing that "IIIIIIIII, WANT TO BEEEEEE, ANARCHEEEEEEE"!
Keep it raw. Don’t ever edit or censure yourself Lolli. When you groove I groove with you, when you laugh I laugh with you, and when you cry I cry with you. You’re the best reactor/analysis creator on TH-cam. ❤
This is honestly one of the most powerful songs I've ever heard. Her voice, the message, the circumstances, and the fact that 30 years later its still relevant creates such an important piece of musical history. The use of keening is particularly amazing. RIP Dolores. Never forget the two children who's passing spurred this songs creation, and all the children who have died since in needless wars.
Yeah and i visisted the places not realizing i did a couple of years after this song was released. And i can tell you its also the best truth i've ever heard about it.
Amazing reaction - I got all weepy along with you. I teach about this song in my university music history course - when Dolores sings "But you see, it's not me / It's not my family", I think she's addressing the extremists who carry on the violence, as they claim, in the name of the Irish people. She is essentially saying, "Don't you dare claim to be fighting for me or my family - we want none of your bloodshed." Don't ever stop showing how hard a song hits you - your reaction is so profoundly human and moving.
I think she is addressing the attitude of the middle class, who bear witness to an atrocity and fall into paralysis. This weakness is justified by the fact that you are not affected yourself.It is a call to everyone to stand up against violence and not to hide behind excuses.
As a Northern Irish person who grew up during the 80s, 90s, this one hit hard. I appreciate how you have tried to comprehend the pain and confusion, and the risk to innocence that such times can result in, and of course you can appreciate how Dolores and gang so aptly conveyed that musically and vocally in this piece. That you bring up contemporary painful events unfolding as we speak, is very apt. It brings up the question, who are the real terrorists?
In the case of the six counties of ulster under british administration. The british government in collusion with loyalist murder gangs were pretty terrifying.
As a person of NI heritage (Kesh, Fermanagh), I love your comments. I also love your beautiful country and always feel at home when I’m there. It’s almost impossible today to even fathom what it must have been like given how lovely it is there now.
@@kennethabebdroth8513 I think at the very least Dolores made most people know that it is a traditional way of expressing grief, sorrow, and sadness for the deceased.
@@liamengram6326 The thing is, although I'm 58 years old and have known the word "keening" since childhood (and had a rough idea of the sound it referred to), I don't think it ever heard or seen anyone use it in reference to this song - or to Dolores at all - until right now. Certainly when this song first started appearing on the radio, decades ago, it was a sound we Surrey-ites had never heard before! (But then for most of us, "Irish" just meant Terry Wogan and Val Doonican and "those thick people in all the jokes"; and the letters "IRA" just meant "don't go to London unless you really have to". =:o/ )
I want to give Lolli a big hug now, Zombie was written by Dolores O'Riordan in response to and in memory of two young victims of an IRA bombing. I would rather see the genuine emotional impact of a video Lolli, don't worry about that. We lost Dolores too soon, gone to that great gig in the sky but never forgotten 🙏
Your real-honest-first-raw reactions set you apart and place you directly into the hearts of your fans. Never stray from that format, because we need confirmation of our own emotions as we listen, and to be reminded that music is meant to help us feel thoughts.
Absolutely the best and most poignant vocal analysis/review of the song Zombie ever done. She is deeply missed...RIP Dolores O'Riordan, your music stands as an everlasting tribute to your heart.
You got this one just right. Anyone who isn't at least a little teary by the scene where the kids are silently screaming isn't paying enough attention.
This song is just a masterpiece, the mourning guitar, the drums like gunshots. I'm pretty sure Dolores had a clear vision in her mind, how the song should sound, when she wrote it. When she presented the song to her bandmates she said to the drummer "can you please hit the drums real hard?" RIP "Rose of Ireland".
I'm a huge prog rock fan, so I love ridiculously complicated crap that instrumentalists can gush over, but this song actually makes me cry. It's just pure, raw emotion, and that's the best kind of music. Masterpiece, indeed.
There is no greater compliment to a musician than showing raw emotion to their performance. Never deprive yourself and your audience of what you’re feeling towards a song, Lolli
I was a teenager when I heard Zombie and The Cranberries and I instantly fell in love with Dolores. Their music helped me through dark times and now 30 years later I still get goosebumps. Daffodil Lament is such an emotional roller coaster and my absolute favorite. I 'll be happy to see your reaction :)
I, too, heard them for the first time as a teen in the 90s. I didn't like it at first, her vocals were too alien for me at the time. 10 years and a lot of folk metal later, in the early 2000's I heard this again and had the same feeling you did. I just had to understand what she was doing a little better to really grasp the whole thing. Can't wait to see this reaction
Yes there is an emotional intensity to Dolores songs and lyrics that is hugely powerful . She was a poet I think ,. Her words ,her singing , her tone is from the soul - it resonates. It invokes the same reaction as great poetry .This song is a masterpiece .one of the most powerful song and video combinations ever I think .A work of of the highest art ! RIP Dolores !
About a year or so ago this song came on the TV as I was chilling with my eight year old. By the end of it I was in floods of tears as I realised that thankfully she wont have the childhood I did. I grew up during 'The Troubles.' There were so many 'Warringtons' that it was almost easier to become anesthetised to the pain ("But you see, it's not me, It's not my family..."). But music will always find the way to challenge and ultimately break through. This song is the perfect example of that. For you to glean all the inferences you got without knowing the events that inspired it prove it. Your emotion is entirely appropriate. There is no shame in it.
Hi from Australia 🇦🇺, how are you all these years later? Mental health wise, ptsd ?? I grew up in 70s & 80s hearing about the bombings on the news and the IRA always being the bad guys…
Please, don't EVER apologize for being raw & real. It's what makes you genuine. It's what music is for. Thank you for being you. Thank you for sharing.
Coming from a part of ireland, and era, where the “troubles” never affected me… but dolores was one of our heroes that single handedly brought our country, and our north, together without inciting violence. She voiced our frustrations and anger and made an impact. When she only died 2 years ago we made sure her voice never left us, especially during the rugby World Cup. We made sure the world knew our pride and our loss of one of our saints.
@@spirishabroad - I don't agree. Metallic is cold and most Irish women's voices are not. Sinead O'Connor had a strong voice and loud at times, (for emphasis) but not metallic. You couldn't say that about Enya either.
Loli, a genuine reaction is exactly why people are drawn to your channel. This song is both a real challenge and absolutely brilliant and you have really engaged with it. If you want a song to really cheer you up, I defy you not to laugh or smile at the theme from the Muppets…
I'd say Kermit performing Rainbow Connection. But really there's a few musicals I'd love to see Lolli react to the whole thing--The Muppet Movie, Grease, Rocky Horror ....
Please keep your reactions as unedited as you can! That's what makes YOU so special! "Everyone" out there seems to be a robot, afraid of feelings... your audience appreciates you for what and how you portray your analyses! We are humans, capable of feelings. We are all flawed individuals, but showing emotions and feelings are NOT flaws! That's why we love this platform!
Flawlessly doesn't mean perfection. You're right, most people spends too much time trying to presents themseves in certain way instead of simply be themselves. It's not that easy to be honest with yourself, yet with another people though.
As my best friend's dad always used to say, "Music is meant to be felt." Keep the raw emotions and come back to give insight when you collect yourself.
I think your reaction is exactly the type that was intended when they wrote and recorded the song. Thanks so much for giving us an open and brutally honest reaction and analysis. You are loved and appreciated. ♥
I just wanted to say that as someone who often doesn't feel emotions strongly at all, sometimes its incredibly therapeutic to witness your emotions and feel what I can vicariously through your reactions. Ive watched both your johnny cash "Hurt" and "toad sings chandelier" a dozen times each. You wear your heart on your sleeve and it just means so much to me.
Perfect examples!!! Two polar opposites that were felt in the core and shared very generously ❤ After watching this I was thinking I need to go watch lolly’s reaction to toad sings chandelier 😂
I think this is a song that speaks to anyone with a heart. I grew up in the early 90s and even though I'm American, I had a special connection to Northern Ireland thanks to some students who were brought over to escape the warfare. Both of their parents had been killed by a bomb and I will never, ever forget the weary, haunted, totally shell-shocked looks on their faces the first day they joined my class. That has stuck with me for over 30 years and Zombie makes it seem like yesterday every time I hear it.
This song hits hard. It was meant to. All that emotion in her voice was as real as it gets. Her ability to channel that into such moving music was just genius.
Lovely Lolli, ALWAYS keep your raw reactions in because it shows your humanity and your empathy. Most of us who are subscribed love you BECAUSE of your empathy and humanity. NO one better at this than you my friend. Sending as many hugs as possible.
As an emotionally sensitive person , I fully understand just how hard that was for you. Thank you for being willing not to edit it out and share those raw emotions with us. ❤ major respect for that.
Thank you for sharing. I appreciated you mixing your first reaction and later analysis together. It lets us appreciate the emotional impact of the work as well as the technique. When a song can make you cry like this one does, that's a sign of an amazing artist. Still makes me cry this many years later.
I met Dolores few times, I’ve been to her funeral. She’s the most sensitive person I’ve ever met. She could understand everything I was thinking without even talk.
Yup. The video served it’s purpose. It wrecks all of us the first time. I saw it when it first aired when I was young. And it got me the same way. It was intended to invoke that response. Intended to make the world think about how the greed of the few affects the innocent.
Singers like Dolores always amaze me. I don't know how you can put so much emotion into something and not sob and cry and scream... I could never hold it together enough to be a singer, I always let a guitar or bass do my speaking. And even then emotions run high and I'd loose myself in the emotion of a song. The kids silent scream always hits so hard. RIP Dolores
Same with Eric Clapton's Tears in Heaven. I could *never* do that. How Doleres and Eric can hold it together and in that way share their emotions with us is nothing short of amazing.
I love you. You're probably thinking "you don't even know me". But if people can hate for no reason, I can love. No, honesty, you are an incredibly beautiful soul. Watching you makes me believe there's still good people out there.
When claim that others hate „for no reason“, they‘re often just to the reason. I visited Ireland shortly after the Good Friday was reached. At the time my country still warned against visiting Northern Ireland, due to the - thankfully unfounded fear the agreement wouldn‘t hold. I took a wrong turn and the first thing I saw was a „police station“. The thing looked like a fortress walls at least four metres high, crowned with razor wire - using that stuff is considered a war-crime today - and surrounded by tower with machine gun emplacements (the actual guns were no longer, but the means to attach them were unmistakable) giving them a 360 degree firing arc and thus the ability to create a circle of death several hundred meters around the building. That thing was by far the most hostile and fear inducing bit of architecture I‘ve seen in my life - and I‘ve been to East Germany while it was still under communist rule. I cannot imagine growing up catholic in the shadow of one of those police stations, knowing it‘s directed against catholics and not growing to hate the put who put that constant threat of death into my neighbourhood. Which makes the fact that the good Friday agreement is still in effect one of the greatest achievements of peace of my life-time.
Jesus, your reaction broke me. I love so much that you showed your emotions on this. Music is such a wonderful way to share human experience, and seeing other people be just as affected by a song as you are is like nourishment for the soul. I like your approach to analyzing as well. Just subscribed. I’m a fan of yours already. Thank you for covering this song. The Cranberries are incredible, and seeing their music be appreciated like this makes my lil 90s heart so fkn happy.
Pls keep the raw versions, you have a very special talent, a rare gift, and an awesome heart and genuineness the world needs more of. The people here, including me, love you for who you are and the passion you have for music..❤
Don't ever apologize for being a sweet,sensitive and caring person.How wonderful it would be if there were more of us out there.I like this version of you.More please.
Nearly 30 years on and still one of the most powerful and emotional protest songs ever produced. Has remained one of my favorite pieces of music since hearing it in my teens.
When Dolores O'Riordan passed in Jan. 2018 the band stopped playing as a tribute to her. In 2019 they released there last album in her honor. She was a awesome singer and is missed.
YES!!!! Always keep the emotion! I’m not a musician, but I’m drawn to your channel because of my appreciation of your own vocal talent, your ability to analyze and break down the technical aspects of voice and performance, your humor, and especially by the way you are impacted by music and comfortable sharing that impact through your emotions. My daughter is a musician, and you have helped me see and understand how music impacts her. The first video I watched of yours was your reaction to Pentatonix “Hallelujah”. The entire video was great, but your rant about how “some people do horrible things, but some people do THIS!” is what got me hooked to your channel and earned my subscription. You do you, and keep doing you. 😊
Thank you for making me really feel that song for the first time. Like many have said, when I first heard that song in my 20s, we were drunk and dancing to it. I did not know the history. (Not something I'd learned in my U.S. high school education with its sanitation of history... Your tears gave me permission to cry, too. Incredible song.
Obviously a song about a specific incident during the "troubles" in Ireland. I love the emotion she poured into this song. It's best listen at max volume. She was just an amazing singer. She is missed. God rest her soul, may she rest in peace😢❤🇨🇦
One of the most important songs out there. Loved it since I was a child and the video reminds me of watching the news at that time. Her seething anger caused by generations of senseless violence is breathtaking.
Have loved The Cranberries for a long time, had so many great songs. The anniversary of Dolores's passing was on the 15th of January. Only 46 years old when she passed in 2018, much too young to leave us. She was in Mayfair at the time 😢😢😢 but she left us with a pretty good sized library of music and memories ❤❤❤ love your channel- and love youuu!
Don’t ever apologize for feeling emotion. I first heard this song as a teenager & I still get overcome by emotion when I listen to it. Dolores put her heart into this song & you aren’t human if you don’t feel it. ❤
I really like that you show your emotions when you analyse songs. This and your detailed explanations of different vocal and music techniques are what differentiate you from most other voice analysis/reaction youtubers.
Lolli, People like your channel because you're a authentic person who speaks from emotion and genuine passion for what you do. You should do your videos in whatever way feels right for YOU and I guarantee you that people will respond positively to it!! I don't know if it means anything to you, but I personally thought your video was very touching and still informative, even if it was less technical in the vocal analysis department... And if kindly intended words don't hit the spot for you at this time, I suggest watching another Electric Callboy video! That'll do it!
Good lord. I'm not a vocalist, or even close, but I love this song and thought it'd be interesting to hear someone talk about it. It was flat out amazing to hear you describe the choices she's making. It never crossed my mind how her breath affects the message in the lyrics. Super informative, super interesting, and worthy of a sub. You are very, very good at this. Stick with it! You're awesome.
Perfect reaction video. Love the combination of switching between your thoughts afterwards and the first time viewing. Keeping it close while also teaching a lesson. Keep it up!!!
Absolutely haunting and gut-wrenching. The image that hits me the hardest is when the angel children, a symbol of innocence and purity, begin screaming. Also, please do more videos like this. Your visceral reaction is one that I shared. I cried along with you. Don't ever edit out your feelings. They are vital to understanding the impact of songs like this, and the message they deliver.
As a musician I absolutely loved your pure reaction. Music like this without authentic emotional reaction is meaningless. I absolutely fell in love with you and your sensitivity and compassion. What a beautiful heart you have.
Watching your reaction made me experience emotions I've never had while listening to this song. Please, keep being yourself, don't suppress any of your feelings.
Never apologize for your feelings when they show because of the music. That is why most songs are written to evoke feelings. You showing your feelings and how a song effects you connects you to others that feel the same. For me a second video for analysis isn't a bad thing. This song still gets me since I first heard it you aren't alone.
This is the first "reaction channel" I've seen where the feelings are obviously real and not staged. You can only have these feelings if you immerse yourself deeply in the music, the voice, the lyrics and the corresponding video clips.
When I first heard this song, in 1994, I was 13 years old and I couldn't believe what was playing on the radio. So powerful... I almost felt like my soul was leaving me lol.
Hyper-sensitive personalities are both a curse and a blessing, and I think you proved that in this. Stay true to yourself - your insight goes beyond the academic and it's your raw emotion that brings most of us here, although I wouldn't be that presumptive, it's an instinct. You look at music in the same way that an archaeologist looks at a rock, they see beyond what's on the outside, they can see its make-up, its layers, its life (yeah OK I know, it's a rock, but come one, give me room here), the rawness that I saw here today was beautiful and sad but true. This rates as one of my favourite videos from you Lolli, that and the fact that the song was so indicative of those times, but still is so very relevant today, got me. Badly. Even with pieces like this, that are sad, still make you shine like the ray of sunshine you are and why we keep coming back for more. Please don't change for our sake. You are a beautiful, warm, funny human being and I think we like that. Stay true gorgeous.
it's hard not to have an emotional reaction to this song, partly because of the topic, but also because it is such an inspired masterpiece of music. On top of good writing, very talented musicians singing about a tragedy that is very personal and real to them. They put their all into this song, it is the embodiment of their pain and being so technically excellent and complex makes the technical analysis difficult because it flows over the mind so smoothly while attacking the emotion. They don't want you to focus on the technical side, at least not the first time
Your idea about the big crashing parts being like a bomb really informs the stark and abrupt ending in a way I never thought about before. For some people, there is no dust settling afterward, just a bang and then nothing.
Please do not ever lose the emotion. That is so much of what i love about music, the ability to connect to a song on a visceral level. That's why songs like this stand the test of time, they have more than just a surface meaning.
One thing I look for in reaction videos is the brutal, raw, genuine, emotional reaction. it's one of the main reasons you're one of my favorite reactors. you keep being you and your followers will love it
Harrowing is the perfect word to describe this song. I’ve heard several people try to cover it and making it either too pretty or too much of an exercise in vocal gymnastics. Among the many amazing things O’Riordan is able to accomplish in the performance is infusing every note with the perfect expression of smoldering - and then explosive - outrage. It’s the musical equivalent of weeping and screaming and pounding walls in frustration. One of the real virtues of TH-cam is that it affords people (like me) with a genuine but perhaps less refined understanding of a topic to interact with people whose depth of knowledge far exceeds our own. We know how we feel when we experience a piece of music, but we may not understand the nuanced artistic choices the performer made to express her intent. What I really appreciate about your analyses is how effectively they lay those choices bare without overly dissecting the meaning of the song or reducing its impact. You have a true gift for such illuminations. Please, do not for a minute think that our desire to more deeply appreciate a piece or music or musical performance precludes you from having a genuine human experience of it. A song about 3-year-old child and a 12-year-old child dying as collateral damage in a decades-long drumbeat of hatred should be devastating; any hope we have of moving past tragedies like the Warrington bombings (or any of countless mass shootings here in the US, or what’s happening right now to blameless families in Ukraine or Palestine, and on and on) lies in having the precise reaction you had and were so generous to share with us. Please do not ever become inured to these feelings, or apologize for having the bravery to share them with us. We love you for it. Thank you for inspiring us…we look forward to more.
This is the best vocal analysis that I have ever heard!!❤❤ Your emotional response is beautiful. When I watched this video the first time, I cried my eyes out, and I'm doing it again watching you react so emotionally. I am highly emotional, and I'm a 74 year old male musician. Fairy Voice Mother, I can truly say that I love you.On top of your empathy, sensitivity, intelligence, you are hilarious. You made my day!! ❤❤😊😊❤❤
This is the most immersive experience I've had with anyone on TH-cam. I heard the the song many times before but let me tell you, I experienced everything you have while watching it along with every tear, I shed one too. I liked and subscribed. You're the only vocal coach I'm watching going forward for song analysis. Great job. I'm now going to keep watching lol
The fact that you choose to put this video up, whilst going through an emotional breakdown, is really inspiring. It leaves an honest, genuine and open review. This is the first time I believe, that I've ever left a comment on a video. I had to put it out there that I respect you a lot, and that you, Fairy Mother, you should never feel the need to apologise for your feelings or oppress them. Keep up the good work!
Funny thing is two lyrics could actually work in this song "The same old theme, since 1916" refrencing the Troubles or "The same old team since 1916" refrencing the Irish Republican Army/IRA. and the lyrics sounds like both due to the accent.
How your reaction to this song is just a proof of how Dolores was able to deliver her message. 😢 Non else have been able to sing it with such gravity it deserves.
![ลองสุ่มไอโฟน 990 โกงมั้ย? [ โกงมั้ยครับ ep.101 ] | DOM](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bfsWe0j492k/mqdefault.jpg)
This song was written specifically in response to the deaths of a 12 year old and a 3 year old in a bombing in the early 90's. The emotions you were feeling were completely intentional to the songwriting, and it's a masterwork.
This correct, at the hands of the IRA, a Irish terrorist/mafia group.
She would not know. Even though they are her neighbors. People this age know NO recent history. I bet she never heard of the IRA. She didn't even bat an eye when the IRA mural hit the screen. Sad.
@@nielgregory108 Not her fault, it is modern teaching ideas that have no time for this type of history. I fear for the future with what is happening in our world at the moment, and end up remembering Heinrich Heine's famous quote - "Where they burn books, so too will they in the end burn human beings."
@@nielgregory108didn't bat an eye? She took in a hard breath when the IRA mural popped up.
@@nielgregory108 The video she posted is about the song, not the history. Don't be too presumptuous about what she has or hasn't heard of.
Definitely keep the raw version. So long as you feel comfortable with it of course.
Often the reason we love these songs is because they impact us on an emotional level, and whilst your musical analysis is OFF THE CHART, seeing someone else experience those emotions is very powerful.
also if you need cheering up, I've been thoroughly enjoying watching Pomplamoose creating their new work, and Félicitations! is a fab single to listen to on it's own
Hear! Hear!
Completely agree.
I was already very familiar with the song when I saw that the Voice Fairy had reacted to it.
I was thrilled at the prospect.
couldnt agree more.
100% agree...it is up to you.
As for my preference, I prefer to see the genuine emotional reaction as that is ultimately what music is FIRST about in my opinion.
Thanks for you reaction!
Lolli's ability to replicate any vocal technique of any singer from any music genre is unparalleled. Unbelievable talent.
I second this comment wholeheartedly.
Absolutely correct and amazing
You nailed it. I like her raw emotions to the song, her sense of humor and editing of the video to make it even more fun. This is why I come back.
This. The techniques used in this song were varied and definitely not easy, or even common knowledge.
This is my first time her and she blew me away, mimicked her so well.
As someone peripherally associated with some of the stuff going on back in the 90's, I DIRECTLY credit her, and the Cranberries, with shaming all parties to the table that finally led to peace.
Never thought I'd see it, and never was I more grateful.
She was a true bard, and healed her people
100 percent agree bro
I‘d sure like to think so.
Yes, it's the artists who hold up the mirror for all (who will) to see, while politicians appease their base.
Give her a name, man. It's DOLORES O'RIORDAN! RIP :(
Nice to say that.
Please keep the raw emotions. Your technical breakdowns are brilliant, but your humanity is what brings us all here. You have charisma, and your honest reactions really brings that to the forefront. Never stop being you and always react honestly, please.
I gotta agree. Your passion and emotion when listening to music, along with your huge expertise are what make you so compelling to watch. Please, record it all, and chop it up later, if that's the way the music makes you feel. It's absolutely captivating and makes you stand out from the crowd.
Love your work. Keep it up x
Absolutely right. You have a keen and sensitive spirit. You feel things very deeply and you allow us to feel them right along with you. This direct connection with your emotions is the wellspring of your creativity.
Pray you never become inured to the highs and lows life is always throwing at us, for they are what make life special. And you can't truly enoy the sun without having felt the rain. Chiaroscuro...light and dark.
well put
Very well put. I mean, what's the point of a reaction video without reactions?
Amen
Keep the emotions. I'm 56 years old and remember when this song was released. And I still cry. Every time
It's always incredible to me how a song can evoke such emotions. It's a testament to those who made it. It seems to paint a picture, like an artist evoking emotion with brush strokes. The broader issue being addressed by this song is something they felt deserves attention, and rightfully so. There was a lot of suffering involved.
@@neil2444 This has been how I have been able to help control my bipolar to an extent. I use music therapy.
Same, and I’m 66.
In my opinion... crazy as it may seem... the reason we love music and the way it makes us feel is because everything in our physical world is about frequency. Sounds and vibrations are everything.
Your actual reaction is the best thing to show -- if a song leaves you stunned and you can't comment right away, that's a-ok, getting to see your genuine response makes the whole thing personal.
It's called keening.A Celtic lament. Love her voice.So strong and emotional. ..
Folk and classic. RIP Dolores. From Poland.
I always enjoyed how Dolores kept her Limerick accent in her singing and her use of keening. She was a very original and unique talent, who left this earth entirely too soon. This is a very emotional and powerful song, so your reaction is completely understandable and appreciated.
It was very interesting your mention of the Celtic/ Gaelic tradition of Keening. Not really well up on the subject I looked it up, where else but on Wikipedia.and it seems the song is a perfect example of the tradition thank you for bringing it up I’m now going to have to find more examples of of it in Ann attempt to learn more about it. 👍👏👏👏👏
Yes keening is beautiful. If you didn't know you may be interested, Bad Wolves did a remake that was supposed to have her in the video but she died before it was done. It's still a great video, nothing like the first but still impactful
@@PeterBeacham-pe1uf"Keening" cones from the Irish verb "caoineadh", to weep or cry
Been listening to this song for 30 years and it still breaks my heart every time 😢
I HEAR THAT! 💀💕💕💕
Same. Whenever the song comes on, I know I'm gonna be a mess.
OMG it is that long - feels so present and prescient every time makes it seem more recent. RIP D.
I avoid listening to this song in public because I can't hold back my tears.
NEVER replace genuine feels. We NEED more of that in this world. It's this very thing that draws me to your channel. Your sense of humor is right there also. Love what you do!
Bad Wolves did a cover of this. On January 15, 2018 Delores O'Riordan was supposed to sing on it with them but she passed before she could record it. They did the cover anyway with their own singer and donated all money made from the cover to her children.
They did a good job on that cover. Shame the singer turned into a mental case and 86'd his career
@Sraticjm35 Not a fan of since they changed some of the lyrics. Does not hit the same way
@@charlesdoyle3630 I understand your point but they changed it to fit modern times.
I really appreciated how they made the video with some one representing her in the gold. Was one of my favorite songs when it came out and in as excited when I heard about a cover. So much respect for what they did for her children. 🙌🏼
I hate that we lost her. Been listening to them since day 1. For me... this is a thing where I'll always remember where I was when I heard it on the news.
Dear Lolli,
To me you stand out amongst the various reaction channels out there, particularly because you are so empathetic. There are so many false emotions out there, specifically aimed at harvesting views and likes, it is refreshing to see some honousty. I saw your emotional reaction to Johnny Cash's version of Hurt before, and your tears made me feel free to let go of my own. Please don't ever change.
This song is another one of those gems out there that is aimed at touching people deep inside. If one would not at the very least feel uncomfortable, it would not have the intended impact. I think it is fitting that you sat through it completely, unable to speak. Breaking the video up afterwards to interject the technicalities, to be fair was a little odd at times, but I am convinced it is the best option available.
Sorry for the lengthy response, but I wanted to make it absolutely clear that you need not be afraid of people not liking the way this video came out. If any do, that's their loss.
Keep the emotions in. It's the main attraction for me.
Concerning putting on an American accent when UK artists sing, as an American musician, growing up I was always intrigued with those UK accents, and loved the few artists who sang in their own accents, like Johnny Rotten. We LOVED hearing that "IIIIIIIII, WANT TO BEEEEEE, ANARCHEEEEEEE"!
I'm a tough old man of Scottish Irish descent.....tears every time i witness this iconic song
This AND the Bad Wolves cover of this song, especially with the story behind it and the video...hits in the feels every time.
@@dwarvensmith80 I play the the bad wolves version because it has keys. One of my favorites to play because the crowd feels it.
As a Norwegian of Finnish descent... I cry with you.
But we're besties us 2 too countries ao I don't blame you
Count me another Scottish + Irish lad who feels the same!
Keep it raw. Don’t ever edit or censure yourself Lolli. When you groove I groove with you, when you laugh I laugh with you, and when you cry I cry with you. You’re the best reactor/analysis creator on TH-cam. ❤
This is honestly one of the most powerful songs I've ever heard. Her voice, the message, the circumstances, and the fact that 30 years later its still relevant creates such an important piece of musical history. The use of keening is particularly amazing. RIP Dolores. Never forget the two children who's passing spurred this songs creation, and all the children who have died since in needless wars.
Its not just the music, the video is also a rare masterpiece........I have yet so see anyone with human feelings no to end up in tears
Yeah and i visisted the places not realizing i did a couple of years after this song was released. And i can tell you its also the best truth i've ever heard about it.
Amen to this In Peace beautiful Dolores and beautiful Sinead O'x
Amazing reaction - I got all weepy along with you. I teach about this song in my university music history course - when Dolores sings "But you see, it's not me / It's not my family", I think she's addressing the extremists who carry on the violence, as they claim, in the name of the Irish people. She is essentially saying, "Don't you dare claim to be fighting for me or my family - we want none of your bloodshed." Don't ever stop showing how hard a song hits you - your reaction is so profoundly human and moving.
I think she is addressing the attitude of the middle class, who bear witness to an atrocity and fall into paralysis. This weakness is justified by the fact that you are not affected yourself.It is a call to everyone to stand up against violence and not to hide behind excuses.
Gotta love Art. Ooen to interpretation by each individual that experiences it. The song/lyrics mean both of your interpretations.
Spot on. As an Irishman myself, that's exactly how I interpreted that line.
you did this perfectly. Watch it straight through for the emotion, then chop it for the analysis info. perfection!
When I first heard this song in 1994, I cried too. It is very dark and it feels heavy on the heart. I cried watching it here on your channel.
As a Northern Irish person who grew up during the 80s, 90s, this one hit hard. I appreciate how you have tried to comprehend the pain and confusion, and the risk to innocence that such times can result in, and of course you can appreciate how Dolores and gang so aptly conveyed that musically and vocally in this piece. That you bring up contemporary painful events unfolding as we speak, is very apt. It brings up the question, who are the real terrorists?
free speech ("hate speech") is illegal right now in Ireland ...
who are the real terrorists? - Tommy
In the case of the six counties of ulster under british administration. The british government in collusion with loyalist murder gangs were pretty terrifying.
As a person of NI heritage (Kesh, Fermanagh), I love your comments. I also love your beautiful country and always feel at home when I’m there. It’s almost impossible today to even fathom what it must have been like given how lovely it is there now.
The governments.
The raw emotion of her keening makes this so timeless. It's a harrowing listen every time, yet so beautiful and so important of a song.
Wouldn't surprise me if a majority of people don't know what keening is
@@kennethabebdroth8513 I think at the very least Dolores made most people know that it is a traditional way of expressing grief, sorrow, and sadness for the deceased.
@@liamengram6326 The thing is, although I'm 58 years old and have known the word "keening" since childhood (and had a rough idea of the sound it referred to), I don't think it ever heard or seen anyone use it in reference to this song - or to Dolores at all - until right now.
Certainly when this song first started appearing on the radio, decades ago, it was a sound we Surrey-ites had never heard before! (But then for most of us, "Irish" just meant Terry Wogan and Val Doonican and "those thick people in all the jokes"; and the letters "IRA" just meant "don't go to London unless you really have to". =:o/ )
This song is a true masterpiece.Doloras was a one of a kind talent.RIP
I want to give Lolli a big hug now, Zombie was written by Dolores O'Riordan in response to and in memory of two young victims of an IRA bombing. I would rather see the genuine emotional impact of a video Lolli, don't worry about that. We lost Dolores too soon, gone to that great gig in the sky but never forgotten 🙏
+1 to the hug
@@MalakianM2S+ 2
Okay, hug que starts here.
RIP Dolores , your voice is eternal 💐
Thank you @TheFairyVoiceMother
From a Turkish fan
Your real-honest-first-raw reactions set you apart and place you directly into the hearts of your fans. Never stray from that format, because we need confirmation of our own emotions as we listen, and to be reminded that music is meant to help us feel thoughts.
Absolutely the best and most poignant vocal analysis/review of the song Zombie ever done. She is deeply missed...RIP Dolores O'Riordan, your music stands as an everlasting tribute to your heart.
You got this one just right. Anyone who isn't at least a little teary by the scene where the kids are silently screaming isn't paying enough attention.
It's crazy how beautiful and powerful this song is, that even after decades it still hits like a truck, and chills to the bone.
This song is just a masterpiece, the mourning guitar, the drums like gunshots. I'm pretty sure Dolores had a clear vision in her mind, how the song should sound, when she wrote it. When she presented the song to her bandmates she said to the drummer "can you please hit the drums real hard?" RIP "Rose of Ireland".
I'm a huge prog rock fan, so I love ridiculously complicated crap that instrumentalists can gush over, but this song actually makes me cry. It's just pure, raw emotion, and that's the best kind of music.
Masterpiece, indeed.
There is no greater compliment to a musician than showing raw emotion to their performance. Never deprive yourself and your audience of what you’re feeling towards a song, Lolli
I was a teenager when I heard Zombie and The Cranberries and I instantly fell in love with Dolores. Their music helped me through dark times and now 30 years later I still get goosebumps. Daffodil Lament is such an emotional roller coaster and my absolute favorite. I 'll be happy to see your reaction :)
I, too, heard them for the first time as a teen in the 90s. I didn't like it at first, her vocals were too alien for me at the time. 10 years and a lot of folk metal later, in the early 2000's I heard this again and had the same feeling you did. I just had to understand what she was doing a little better to really grasp the whole thing. Can't wait to see this reaction
Whole album is great, title song is my fav. I like also "Electric Blue".
Yes there is an emotional intensity to Dolores songs and lyrics that is hugely powerful . She was a poet I think ,. Her words ,her singing , her tone is from the soul - it resonates. It invokes the same reaction as great poetry .This song is a masterpiece .one of the most powerful song and video combinations ever I think .A work of of the highest art ! RIP Dolores !
No Need to Argue is one of my favourites
@@EponaDreams-AmbientDreamscapes Me too ! There is an absolutely amazing version of the song No need to Argue on here on TH-cam
The emotional response is the reason I subscribed. Please never lose that.
Her keening gives me absolute chills every single time I hear this.
About a year or so ago this song came on the TV as I was chilling with my eight year old. By the end of it I was in floods of tears as I realised that thankfully she wont have the childhood I did.
I grew up during 'The Troubles.' There were so many 'Warringtons' that it was almost easier to become anesthetised to the pain ("But you see, it's not me, It's not my family..."). But music will always find the way to challenge and ultimately break through. This song is the perfect example of that.
For you to glean all the inferences you got without knowing the events that inspired it prove it.
Your emotion is entirely appropriate. There is no shame in it.
Hi from Australia 🇦🇺, how are you all these years later? Mental health wise, ptsd ?? I grew up in 70s & 80s hearing about the bombings on the news and the IRA always being the bad guys…
Fuck England
This ginormous amount of reactions confirms that we love Lolli as she is. Don't ever change, Mum, and don't apologize for being you.
Please, don't EVER apologize for being raw & real. It's what makes you genuine. It's what music is for. Thank you for being you. Thank you for sharing.
Dolores had an incredible voice. Rest in peace.
Coming from a part of ireland, and era, where the “troubles” never affected me… but dolores was one of our heroes that single handedly brought our country, and our north, together without inciting violence. She voiced our frustrations and anger and made an impact. When she only died 2 years ago we made sure her voice never left us, especially during the rugby World Cup. We made sure the world knew our pride and our loss of one of our saints.
There’s just something about Irish singers, their voices just seem to cut right through you with an angelic beauty
Aw thanks
Dolores Mary Eileen O'Riordan had a fantastic and unique voice which you can hear on the song linger, a great loss to music.
I love Irish music!
There’s always a metallic feel to women voices in Ireland.
@@spirishabroad - I don't agree. Metallic is cold and most Irish women's voices are not. Sinead O'Connor had a strong voice and loud at times, (for emphasis) but not metallic. You couldn't say that about Enya either.
Authenticity is the pinnacle of reaction channels. The more true to your honest reactions you are, the better.
Loli, a genuine reaction is exactly why people are drawn to your channel. This song is both a real challenge and absolutely brilliant and you have really engaged with it. If you want a song to really cheer you up, I defy you not to laugh or smile at the theme from the Muppets…
Mah Na Mah Na...
I'd say Kermit performing Rainbow Connection. But really there's a few musicals I'd love to see Lolli react to the whole thing--The Muppet Movie, Grease, Rocky Horror ....
Please keep your reactions as unedited as you can! That's what makes YOU so special! "Everyone" out there seems to be a robot, afraid of feelings... your audience appreciates you for what and how you portray your analyses! We are humans, capable of feelings. We are all flawed individuals, but showing emotions and feelings are NOT flaws! That's why we love this platform!
Flawlessly doesn't mean perfection. You're right, most people spends too much time trying to presents themseves in certain way instead of simply be themselves. It's not that easy to be honest with yourself, yet with another people though.
As my best friend's dad always used to say, "Music is meant to be felt."
Keep the raw emotions and come back to give insight when you collect yourself.
If you are not tearing up by the end of this song you were not paying attention.
I think your reaction is exactly the type that was intended when they wrote and recorded the song. Thanks so much for giving us an open and brutally honest reaction and analysis. You are loved and appreciated. ♥
Always keep the raw version. Don't be embarrassed by your emotion it's why I like your reactions so much. Your a lovely person😊
I just wanted to say that as someone who often doesn't feel emotions strongly at all, sometimes its incredibly therapeutic to witness your emotions and feel what I can vicariously through your reactions. Ive watched both your johnny cash "Hurt" and "toad sings chandelier" a dozen times each. You wear your heart on your sleeve and it just means so much to me.
Perfect examples!!! Two polar opposites that were felt in the core and shared very generously ❤
After watching this I was thinking I need to go watch lolly’s reaction to toad sings chandelier 😂
Another one she loses it is Yebba - My Mind
I think this is a song that speaks to anyone with a heart. I grew up in the early 90s and even though I'm American, I had a special connection to Northern Ireland thanks to some students who were brought over to escape the warfare. Both of their parents had been killed by a bomb and I will never, ever forget the weary, haunted, totally shell-shocked looks on their faces the first day they joined my class. That has stuck with me for over 30 years and Zombie makes it seem like yesterday every time I hear it.
This song hits hard. It was meant to. All that emotion in her voice was as real as it gets. Her ability to channel that into such moving music was just genius.
Lovely Lolli, ALWAYS keep your raw reactions in because it shows your humanity and your empathy. Most of us who are subscribed love you BECAUSE of your empathy and humanity. NO one better at this than you my friend. Sending as many hugs as possible.
I love it when you edit your videos like this. We get an honest reaction and an in depth analysis. It's quite brilliant really.
As an emotionally sensitive person , I fully understand just how hard that was for you. Thank you for being willing not to edit it out and share those raw emotions with us. ❤ major respect for that.
Thank you for sharing. I appreciated you mixing your first reaction and later analysis together. It lets us appreciate the emotional impact of the work as well as the technique. When a song can make you cry like this one does, that's a sign of an amazing artist. Still makes me cry this many years later.
I met Dolores few times, I’ve been to her funeral.
She’s the most sensitive person I’ve ever met. She could understand everything I was thinking without even talk.
She was a sweetheart. May she rest in peace and rise in glory.
Thanks for making me 😭 you are such a bright light in any room. Have a wonderful day Lolli
Yup. The video served it’s purpose. It wrecks all of us the first time. I saw it when it first aired when I was young. And it got me the same way. It was intended to invoke that response. Intended to make the world think about how the greed of the few affects the innocent.
I think the song has gotten only more powerful in the years since and, sadly, more relevant and universal.
Singers like Dolores always amaze me. I don't know how you can put so much emotion into something and not sob and cry and scream... I could never hold it together enough to be a singer, I always let a guitar or bass do my speaking. And even then emotions run high and I'd loose myself in the emotion of a song.
The kids silent scream always hits so hard.
RIP Dolores
Same with Eric Clapton's Tears in Heaven. I could *never* do that. How Doleres and Eric can hold it together and in that way share their emotions with us is nothing short of amazing.
I love you.
You're probably thinking "you don't even know me". But if people can hate for no reason, I can love.
No, honesty, you are an incredibly beautiful soul. Watching you makes me believe there's still good people out there.
"But if people can hate for no reason, I can love" Beautifully put
@@HororKodStudio I second that. I think I will take that as a motto to live by.
Here here
When claim that others hate „for no reason“, they‘re often just to the reason. I visited Ireland shortly after the Good Friday was reached. At the time my country still warned against visiting Northern Ireland, due to the - thankfully unfounded fear the agreement wouldn‘t hold. I took a wrong turn and the first thing I saw was a „police station“. The thing looked like a fortress walls at least four metres high, crowned with razor wire - using that stuff is considered a war-crime today - and surrounded by tower with machine gun emplacements (the actual guns were no longer, but the means to attach them were unmistakable) giving them a 360 degree firing arc and thus the ability to create a circle of death several hundred meters around the building. That thing was by far the most hostile and fear inducing bit of architecture I‘ve seen in my life - and I‘ve been to East Germany while it was still under communist rule. I cannot imagine growing up catholic in the shadow of one of those police stations, knowing it‘s directed against catholics and not growing to hate the put who put that constant threat of death into my neighbourhood. Which makes the fact that the good Friday agreement is still in effect one of the greatest achievements of peace of my life-time.
I so understand what you mean, well put. Thanks!!
Jesus, your reaction broke me. I love so much that you showed your emotions on this. Music is such a wonderful way to share human experience, and seeing other people be just as affected by a song as you are is like nourishment for the soul.
I like your approach to analyzing as well. Just subscribed. I’m a fan of yours already. Thank you for covering this song. The Cranberries are incredible, and seeing their music be appreciated like this makes my lil 90s heart so fkn happy.
Me too . I love the Cranberries . A very different and special band . Dolores was amazing .
Pls keep the raw versions, you have a very special talent, a rare gift, and an awesome heart and genuineness the world needs more of. The people here, including me, love you for who you are and the passion you have for music..❤
Don't ever apologize for being a sweet,sensitive and caring person.How wonderful it would be if there were more of us out there.I like this version of you.More please.
I can only agree Girl... and cry along with You....
I Miss Delores.....
Crying right along w us, yes!
Nearly 30 years on and still one of the most powerful and emotional protest songs ever produced. Has remained one of my favorite pieces of music since hearing it in my teens.
When Dolores O'Riordan passed in Jan. 2018 the band stopped playing as a tribute to her. In 2019 they released there last album in her honor. She was a awesome singer and is missed.
Linkin park should of do it
YES!!!! Always keep the emotion! I’m not a musician, but I’m drawn to your channel because of my appreciation of your own vocal talent, your ability to analyze and break down the technical aspects of voice and performance, your humor, and especially by the way you are impacted by music and comfortable sharing that impact through your emotions. My daughter is a musician, and you have helped me see and understand how music impacts her. The first video I watched of yours was your reaction to Pentatonix “Hallelujah”. The entire video was great, but your rant about how “some people do horrible things, but some people do THIS!” is what got me hooked to your channel and earned my subscription. You do you, and keep doing you. 😊
Makes you hurt from start to finish. Delores was special, and we where blessed with her music. It makes us a better people than without her.
Thank you for making me really feel that song for the first time. Like many have said, when I first heard that song in my 20s, we were drunk and dancing to it. I did not know the history. (Not something I'd learned in my U.S. high school education with its sanitation of history... Your tears gave me permission to cry, too. Incredible song.
Obviously a song about a specific incident during the "troubles" in Ireland. I love the emotion she poured into this song. It's best listen at max volume. She was just an amazing singer. She is missed. God rest her soul, may she rest in peace😢❤🇨🇦
One of the most important songs out there. Loved it since I was a child and the video reminds me of watching the news at that time. Her seething anger caused by generations of senseless violence is breathtaking.
💔 This old man loves your reactions. I find them healing.
They are still fighting in your head. That one line takes me back to situations I'd rather bury deep inside. I have very dark places in my soul.
Have loved The Cranberries for a long time, had so many great songs. The anniversary of Dolores's passing was on the 15th of January. Only 46 years old when she passed in 2018, much too young to leave us. She was in Mayfair at the time 😢😢😢 but she left us with a pretty good sized library of music and memories ❤❤❤ love your channel- and love youuu!
Don’t ever apologize for feeling emotion. I first heard this song as a teenager & I still get overcome by emotion when I listen to it. Dolores put her heart into this song & you aren’t human if you don’t feel it. ❤
I really like that you show your emotions when you analyse songs. This and your detailed explanations of different vocal and music techniques are what differentiate you from most other voice analysis/reaction youtubers.
Always brings tears and goosebumps. Rest in Peace Dolores. You are missed.
I think it's a masterpiece, you feel the pain when she sings, the music and her voice is perfect.
Lolli, People like your channel because you're a authentic person who speaks from emotion and genuine passion for what you do. You should do your videos in whatever way feels right for YOU and I guarantee you that people will respond positively to it!! I don't know if it means anything to you, but I personally thought your video was very touching and still informative, even if it was less technical in the vocal analysis department...
And if kindly intended words don't hit the spot for you at this time, I suggest watching another Electric Callboy video! That'll do it!
Good lord. I'm not a vocalist, or even close, but I love this song and thought it'd be interesting to hear someone talk about it. It was flat out amazing to hear you describe the choices she's making. It never crossed my mind how her breath affects the message in the lyrics. Super informative, super interesting, and worthy of a sub. You are very, very good at this. Stick with it! You're awesome.
Perfect reaction video. Love the combination of switching between your thoughts afterwards and the first time viewing. Keeping it close while also teaching a lesson. Keep it up!!!
Absolutely haunting and gut-wrenching. The image that hits me the hardest is when the angel children, a symbol of innocence and purity, begin screaming. Also, please do more videos like this. Your visceral reaction is one that I shared. I cried along with you. Don't ever edit out your feelings. They are vital to understanding the impact of songs like this, and the message they deliver.
I'm more reminded of the Holy Innocents - symbolised by those children.
As a musician I absolutely loved your pure reaction. Music like this without authentic emotional reaction is meaningless. I absolutely fell in love with you and your sensitivity and compassion. What a beautiful heart you have.
Her use of Keening was done to perfection!! As keening is used at funerals and is a mournful wailing sound!
Watching your reaction made me experience emotions I've never had while listening to this song. Please, keep being yourself, don't suppress any of your feelings.
Never apologize for your feelings when they show because of the music. That is why most songs are written to evoke feelings. You showing your feelings and how a song effects you connects you to others that feel the same. For me a second video for analysis isn't a bad thing. This song still gets me since I first heard it you aren't alone.
This is the first "reaction channel" I've seen where the feelings are obviously real and not staged. You can only have these feelings if you immerse yourself deeply in the music, the voice, the lyrics and the corresponding video clips.
When I first heard this song, in 1994, I was 13 years old and I couldn't believe what was playing on the radio. So powerful... I almost felt like my soul was leaving me lol.
Hyper-sensitive personalities are both a curse and a blessing, and I think you proved that in this. Stay true to yourself - your insight goes beyond the academic and it's your raw emotion that brings most of us here, although I wouldn't be that presumptive, it's an instinct. You look at music in the same way that an archaeologist looks at a rock, they see beyond what's on the outside, they can see its make-up, its layers, its life (yeah OK I know, it's a rock, but come one, give me room here), the rawness that I saw here today was beautiful and sad but true. This rates as one of my favourite videos from you Lolli, that and the fact that the song was so indicative of those times, but still is so very relevant today, got me. Badly. Even with pieces like this, that are sad, still make you shine like the ray of sunshine you are and why we keep coming back for more. Please don't change for our sake. You are a beautiful, warm, funny human being and I think we like that. Stay true gorgeous.
it's hard not to have an emotional reaction to this song, partly because of the topic, but also because it is such an inspired masterpiece of music. On top of good writing, very talented musicians singing about a tragedy that is very personal and real to them. They put their all into this song, it is the embodiment of their pain and being so technically excellent and complex makes the technical analysis difficult because it flows over the mind so smoothly while attacking the emotion. They don't want you to focus on the technical side, at least not the first time
Your idea about the big crashing parts being like a bomb really informs the stark and abrupt ending in a way I never thought about before. For some people, there is no dust settling afterward, just a bang and then nothing.
Please do not ever lose the emotion. That is so much of what i love about music, the ability to connect to a song on a visceral level. That's why songs like this stand the test of time, they have more than just a surface meaning.
One thing I look for in reaction videos is the brutal, raw, genuine, emotional reaction. it's one of the main reasons you're one of my favorite reactors. you keep being you and your followers will love it
I was once asked to describe this song in one word, all I could come up with is gutpunch.
Harrowing is the perfect word to describe this song. I’ve heard several people try to cover it and making it either too pretty or too much of an exercise in vocal gymnastics. Among the many amazing things O’Riordan is able to accomplish in the performance is infusing every note with the perfect expression of smoldering - and then explosive - outrage. It’s the musical equivalent of weeping and screaming and pounding walls in frustration.
One of the real virtues of TH-cam is that it affords people (like me) with a genuine but perhaps less refined understanding of a topic to interact with people whose depth of knowledge far exceeds our own. We know how we feel when we experience a piece of music, but we may not understand the nuanced artistic choices the performer made to express her intent. What I really appreciate about your analyses is how effectively they lay those choices bare without overly dissecting the meaning of the song or reducing its impact. You have a true gift for such illuminations.
Please, do not for a minute think that our desire to more deeply appreciate a piece or music or musical performance precludes you from having a genuine human experience of it. A song about 3-year-old child and a 12-year-old child dying as collateral damage in a decades-long drumbeat of hatred should be devastating; any hope we have of moving past tragedies like the Warrington bombings (or any of countless mass shootings here in the US, or what’s happening right now to blameless families in Ukraine or Palestine, and on and on) lies in having the precise reaction you had and were so generous to share with us. Please do not ever become inured to these feelings, or apologize for having the bravery to share them with us. We love you for it.
Thank you for inspiring us…we look forward to more.
This is the best vocal analysis that I have ever heard!!❤❤ Your emotional response is beautiful. When I watched this video the first time, I cried my eyes out, and I'm doing it again watching you react so emotionally. I am highly emotional, and I'm a 74 year old male musician. Fairy Voice Mother, I can truly say that I love you.On top of your empathy, sensitivity, intelligence, you are hilarious. You made my day!! ❤❤😊😊❤❤
This is the most immersive experience I've had with anyone on TH-cam.
I heard the the song many times before but let me tell you, I experienced everything you have while watching it along with every tear, I shed one too.
I liked and subscribed. You're the only vocal coach I'm watching going forward for song analysis.
Great job. I'm now going to keep watching lol
Song makes me cry every time I hear it.
Because it’s that bad? Me
Too….. me too.
@@scjohnk the internet is now infested with disruptors like you. It's a shame and only slowing down any kind of progress.
@@scjohnk the internet is now infested with disruptors like you. It's a shame and only slowing down any kind of progress.
@@scjohnkyou must have a dreadful taste in music
The fact that you choose to put this video up, whilst going through an emotional breakdown, is really inspiring.
It leaves an honest, genuine and open review.
This is the first time I believe, that I've ever left a comment on a video.
I had to put it out there that I respect you a lot, and that you, Fairy Mother, you should never feel the need to apologise for your feelings or oppress them.
Keep up the good work!
Your tears come from a place that is deeper than emotions. I'm crying with you. ❤
Funny thing is two lyrics could actually work in this song "The same old theme, since 1916" refrencing the Troubles or "The same old team since 1916" refrencing the Irish Republican Army/IRA. and the lyrics sounds like both due to the accent.
How your reaction to this song is just a proof of how Dolores was able to deliver her message. 😢 Non else have been able to sing it with such gravity it deserves.