Vocal Coach Reacts to Creep - Post Modern Jukebox ft Haley Reinhart | Technique Analysis & Demo
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2025
- Hello Singderellos,
In this video, I react for the first time to the breathtaking vocal genius of Haley Reinhart singing 'Creep' with Post Modern Jukebox. In this video, I analyse her performance, explain her vocal technique and what I think made it so great.
Original video link: • Creep - Vintage Postmo...
For lessons, workshops and video submissions please check out my website www.thefairyvoicemother.com
I'm so excited to be a part of your singing journey, It's one that truly never ends.
Love you forever,
The Fairy Voice Mother x
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
...If you liked this video and would like to support me to make more in the future, I would be hella grateful for a small donation via this link www.buymeacoff... (no pressure at all of course- i'll be making videos the best I can anyway) 💜
Become a patreon if you like too! / tfvm
www.TheFairyVoiceMother.com
Insta @TheFairyVoiceMother
TikTok @TheFairyVoiceMother
Mail Ed@TheFairyVoiceMother.com
Intro and Outro graphics by Lucy Chappell
#TheFairyVoiceMother #HaleyReinhart #VocalCoachReacts #reactionvideo #postmodernjukebox
THIS WAS SO COOL 💜Also I HAVE NEW MERCH! 🧚You can check it out at www.thefairyvoicemother.com/shop
If you want to support the channel, you can "Buy Me A Coffee" ☕ www.buymeacoffee.com/TFVM
You can also join our community on Patreon: www.patreon.com/TFVM
Thank you SO MUCH for the incredible support! ✨
I was reminded of a good song for you to review when I had the thought Good Golly Ms Lalli. The song: Good Golly Ms Molly by Little Richard.
"And that, my Fairy Voice Children, is how you use every single vocal technique known to mankind perfectly and tastefully in under five minutes. Otherworldly. Beautiful. She is a gift." And *that* my Fairy Voice Mother is how you do the best summary of Haley's "Creep" I have ever heard.
And all on the one and only take. WOW!
Yes.
@@toddlower5546 Which sounds incredible, until you watch her live shows, and realize this is just a regular day in the life of Haley Reinhart.
So you know how she sings but you can't do it.
agree
That video is 7 years old, and never ages a bit. Haley recently collaborated with PMJ for a rendition of No Doubt’s, “Don’t Speak” that I think you’d love just as much!
Oh wow... I want to hear that!!
*looks over at the recommendations list*
Oh hey, there's a reaction video!
*adds video to queue. :) Thanks!
100milion Creep
80 milion All about base
33 milion Oops! I did it again
Wow y years old. She’s amazing and I really like this reaction vid the best of all the ones I’ve seen for this rendition
@@wooshbait36 uh, ok. For liking the idea of watching a video response about a song I kinda like by a singer I like and a group I dig the work of? Whatever Woosh.
JustLove your reactions Lolil LoveAngelina
Butl love all types of Music Love FRANCES fromScotland xx
I’ve probably seen 100 reactions to this performance. While everyone knows it’s amazing, very few of you explain why.
Great job. I really enjoyed it.
Fun fact: she recorded this in one take... on a day where she almost didn't come in because she was sick. Mere mortals can only dream of that kind of talent and skill.
Reminds me of the Disturbed vocalist having a cold singing sound of silence on a talk show.
I read that, yes one take, but after they had finished All About the Base.
Right ON, Haley is a paragon of verbal/vocal abilities!👍
This may be my favorite reaction of all time. I absolutely love experts demonstrating their expertise and you’ve done so here with precision, style, humor, and earnest enthusiasm. You’re the best. Please never stop.
I love you :)
Haley is from the Chicago area a bit north of where I grew up. Her parents are from Chicago proper. Years ago, before I knew anything about her, I saw videos of her performing in Chicago joints. I thought this girl will go somewhere. Happy to see her success.
Wow, you're as colourful as your set. Loved your inter-reaction. You pegged Haley to a tee.
Seven Nation Army, Don't Speak, Black Hole Sun, should be on your Haley to react list.
YES. Speaking up for Black Hole Sun, holy hell Haley kills it.
Yes .... And I would also add "all about that bass" and "Dear Prudence" by the Beatles with Morgan James as well
The new one From PMJ and Hailey is a cover of "Don't Speak" by the band No Doubt. She is absolutely, indescribably wonderful in that one.
Also, Habits. It's one of my favorites.
Haley is amazing, yes. But can we appreciate how you managed to mimic her style almost flawlessly? Stunning!
Whoever disliked this hilariously adorable woman's video can kindly see me in the streets🙏
🥺aw I appreciate you loads and loads x
@@TheFairyVoiceMother You mentioned at the end of you video that musical theater and opera singers have a harder time with these techniques. Haley's colleague at PMJ, Ms. Morgan James, does both styles (classically trained at Juilliard). She has her own great PMJ cover of "Dream On" by Aerosmith that would be an excellent one for you to analyze.
@@ernestbrown9660 Also "All about the Bass" which shows how well the 2 compliment each others gifts. th-cam.com/video/aLnZ1NQm2uk/w-d-xo.html
Here's the link for Morgan Jamess "Dream on" th-cam.com/video/Yq4KA0mUnC8/w-d-xo.html
I’ll be in Philly waiting to hash it out over booze.
@@bertpainter8385 Exactly! I would recommend that as well. With Ariana Savalas in the mix, she'd have 3 different female vocal styles to analyze at once.
Scott is just a musical genius! Though you rarely will hear him speak, let alone sing, he understands vocalists better than anyone in his generation. He deserves to be rated on the Quincy Jones, Mutt Lange, Dorsey Brothers, Duke Ellington kinda level for his arranging, producing and even playing to the vocalists he works with. Every song is a masterpiece.
Fantastic fun and tremendously informative analysis of Haley's performance ! You're the most engaging and energetic vocal coach on You Tube ! You're breakdown of all of Haley's vocal techniques were spot on and so well explained for the layman ! It's a pleasure to see you perform your vocal analysis ! Thank you so much it's so well appreciated and keep posting sweetheart ! Sending you much love from Canada !! 🤗👍🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦❤️❤️❤️❤️
hahahahaha sorry for laughing at your comment, but in spanish caca means poop (shit, actually). So i wasn't expecting so much shit at the and of such a nice comment hahaha
@@painisfeargettingout I hope I said Canada ; I didn't say caca ughhhhh ! I hope you didn't get that spelling ! My bad if you did ! So so sorry ! Lmao ! 🤗👍🤣🤣🤣
You should also check out the Charasmatic Voice analysis
@@wcurren17 I did she is a fabulous analyst too ! Thank you !
Haley was my favorite idol contestant ever , she has an amazing range . She’s able to crescendo and belt so loud without losing vocal pitch/tone, but distorts when she wants to . I highly recommend watching her idol performance of Bennie and the jets .
I keep wondering why in all the hells she did not win. Who was she up against and who won that season? Weird. She totally deserved to at least be a finalist. I mean, just LISTEN to this! In short, WITAF?
@@jamescurfman3284 Scotty McCreary won with Lauren Elaina coming in 2nd. Both kind of had ok success after American Idol. Haley should have won, but you could tell the judges really didn't want her to throughout the season. Probably because they wanted to push a generic country star that they could exploit
@@anthonysims3116 Oh, wow. That fucking figures, doesn't it? Office Politics, of course. :P
Thanks for the information. I hope Hayley is doing MUCH better these days! She SHOULD be able to do very well with her ACTUAL skills instead of politics getting in the way all the time.
@@jamescurfman3284 she’s had quite a career and stayed very relevant. She’s booked a few really good commercials . I also believe she’s toured quite a bit as well!!. I agree , she’s super talented and an amazing artist
@@anthonysims3116 At the time I was pissed she didn't win, but now I'm glad (and she probably is too) because they wouldn't have known what to do with her and she would have ended up having to make bland, overproduced pop music. With the exception of Kelly and Carrie, a lot of contestants that didn't win ended up being more successful than the winners. (Nick Fradiani who?)
Fairy voice mother. Your videos are the best. Not only can you point out EXACTLY what is going on technically and know the proper terms for them but unlike the vast majority of youtube "vocal coaches" you can ACTUALLY sing. And do polyphonic overtones, and death growl... it's insane! I think I can collectively speak for everyone when I say please post a video of you singing a song!
She has!! Check out her other channel Lolli Wren.
@@tracywallis1400 Wait WHAT? brb Edit: Holy crap that was just as good as I expected! I think she could really grow her channel and business doing more covers on her channel. It would really help showcasing that she not only can talk the talk but walk the walk. So to speak.
Honestly first time I heard it I cried it was so beautiful... amazing rendition
Damn I appreciate these videos! I've listened to jazz singers since I was a teenager, and today was the first time I realised that the reason the vibrato sounds different because it's covering a wider range of frequency.
I've gone decades without learning that! Thank you so much for explaining it!
I always watch Haley reaction videos. I had never seen any of yours. And now that I've went through a big rabbit hole. I gotta say you are one of the best reactors on youtube. Not only was I entertained, but legitimately learned things. I'm old, and that doesn't happen very often. Thank You
She just dropped cover Don't Speak with PMJ......wow wow
Hands down the best analysis videos on YT, words fail me to describe the sheer tidal wave of skill and knowledge you display in these breakdowns. Wonderful stuff!
I'll love to see and hear a collab between The Fairy Voice Mother and The Charismatic Voice!!!!
So much yes and just for added spice, bring in Maggie Renee
Oh no,while the latter is ok our fairy voice mother is far far better-kinder,less egotistical in her reactions& explanations,analyses,
lessons&info. TFVM is par excellence. The bar is so much higher bc of her!
Fairy Voice Mother + Haley Reinhart = Joyousness. Even I can do that math. This woman deserves way more subscribers.
Super thumbe sup! As a vocalist and musician, you NAILED everything!! Distortion, breath, embouchure,... look most people don't' even know what that is.
I've heard this song hundreds of times and I still get goosebumps every time!
I have watched dozens of vocal coaches and others react to Haley singing Creep and your reaction is the most informative and entertaining/enjoyable I've seen. Thank you so much!
Came for pmj. Stayed for your reaction. Ended up binge watching all your reactions. I adore your responses. Can tell your adoration of the craft in all your videos. Coming from someone who couldn't carry a tune in a bucket. Keep up the great videos.
the vibrato pitch drop?! Thank you for letting us in on that little secret and so much more. So glad you are back. We missed you!
Haley is incredible!!!!
amen!!
@@TheFairyVoiceMother I absolutely love your reactions and your knowledge. Peace from Poland :)
Hailey is just unreal. I was vibing on this 5 years ago but so glad to hear it again. Wow! And I love your presentation.
Dearest Fairy Mum, you are far and away the best reactor I've had the pleasure of watching! I find myself smiling every time! Wonderful work!
your face was a picture watching that, gorgeous reaction and explanation
You will really enjoy doing "Don't Speak" (also by PMJ ft. Haley) and also, "Dream On" (with PMJ too, with Morgan James)!
ITS ABOUT TIME!
I've seen a lot of vocal coaches react to this. You're the first I left with confidence knowing they actually understood what Haley was doing, because you brought receipts and actually successfully duplicated it.
This is a spectacular reaction video and analsys of Haley Reinhart's amazing vocal control. Thanks for doing it very much.
Haley Reinhart, (pronounced "Rhineheart"), is easily the best vocalist that has ever performed with PMJ. As all her music videos have by far the most views relative to everybody else. That cover of "Creep" you just reacted to is not only the first PMJ music video to reach over 100 million views, but it also stayed on the Billboard Digital Jazz Chart for 58 straight weeks.
Some other outstanding PMJ/Haley Reinhart covers you may want to react to are "Seven Nation Army", "Oops, I Did It Again", and "Don't Speak". All of them will literally blow you and your subscribers away every bit as much as her "Creep" cover you just reacted to. As Haley is truly an amazing vocalist.
Loved this react! Haley is one of my favorite Idol contestants ever. Gotta check her out doing "Seven Nation Army", "Don't Speak" and does a great "Mad World" with PMJ and Puddles the Pity Party". Can't wait for those!
When Haley growls it gives me shivers!
I just love your entertaining reactions, and I learn things too, LOL. It is so good to laugh, especially these days. Yea, Haley (Rhineheart) is an amazing singer. I loved her on AMERICAN IDOL. She has a unique was of singing and true to her own style. Thanks for your reaction! By the the way, the green blouse really pops on the screen. Good color choice.
LLOLI YOU ARE PHENOMENAL. YOUR EXPERT ANALYSIS IS SPOT ON. YOU ARE SUCH A BREATH OF FRESH AIR IN YOUR BREAKDOWN OF HALEY'S VOCAL TECHNIQUES. YOU ARE A SIGHT FOR SORE EYES AND A BEAUTIFUL SOUND FOR SORE EARS.
not only a cute little fairy but a hyper knowledgeable coach.....i learn so much.....i'm a bass so.....Voiceplay "i can't help falling in love"...Geoff Castalucci.."."...multiple Geoffs "Blackbird"
Really enjoyed your reaction and breakdown of this song. Thanks a bunch.
Everytime I think I've heard enough reactions to this song I always enjoy another one. Can never go wrong reacting to Scott Bradley PMJ. The most interesting vocal talent is drawn to these time traveling covers. Haley is standout for bringing such a distinct toolbox of vocal techniques but not even alone in that.
Love How much you geek out on these reactions, so much love and it shows. Thanks for the content even if bit "late"
You should do Haley and Puddles Pity Party doing Mad World
1:31 first shiver
aaaaand 3:40 is about when the gay panic started to fully set in and I knew I was going to LOVE this reaction! 😅 (I don't know what your orientation was before Haley, but no one stays completely straight by the time she gets to the first chorus!)
This was a FABULOUS breakdown of her style, and all I can say is I wish you were my vocal coach. 🥰 You have just the kind of technical physiological focus my ASD brain loves!
Hands down the most enjoyable and informative reactionalysis I’ve seen on this song, thank you!
I was a fan of Haley Reinhart on her season, but I haven’t kept up with her much since a couple years after the show was over. But I do remember learning that she was a singer long before she got on that competition. She had been singing jazz for years prior to that, so yes she does know how to scat! 😊
What's more incredible than these amazing artists who have perfected their styles, is you who can replicate these incredible sounds in demonstration. I love your work.
Yup! Haley! What a set of pipes! And..., she whistles too! See her, (PMJ) "Don't Speak" cover. Real class!
Gotta say one of the best breakdowns I've heard, loved it. Haley herself is as you say..a gift.
This is a great performance, showcasing a wide variety of techniques that were reproduced perfectly. Kudos, Lolli! Haley was pretty good, too. I just stumbled upon the most emotional jazz vocal I've heard in many a year. The audience sat, and in one case stood, mesmerized as Shoshana Bean bared her very soul on stage live at The Theatre At Ace Hotel, singing Make It Rain. It's a tour de force. Can I get a witness, guys?
I second you strongly.
What great knowledge about singing, and so Young, get!
Stellar, hugely informative, and entertaining analysis - and to use your word, otherworldly performance. Nothing but enjoyment, appreciation, and awe here. Nicely done.
I love Haley Reinhart, i mean for me, for my taste, she's one of the best vocalist of this era : )
I follow her work with PMJ since many years, saw a lot of vocal coach react to her version of creep, but i never heard a vocal coach with a voice like yours, really Haley is awesome but you are really amazing too!
The amount of information I've learned of singing from this video is incredible in itself! I've watched many reaction videos of singing, and never walked away with anything meaningful like I have here. Thank you so much for this!
I love that Haley Reinhart version, and the fact that you could emulate all her phrases just goes to show that, you, are pretty special! excellent!
I have no idea why I watch all the reaction videos of this song, but I do! Lol
I've watched a few of her live performances of this and a lot of what she does is clearly improvised. She is riffing a lot.
I am late to your review of this wonderful artist. Your facial expressions tell it all. I do appreciate your technical analysis and examples. Nicely done.
Damn!! I'm in! Loved your incredibly nerdy reaction. It is clear that you feel music in a more complete way than a lot of people and watching you enjoying it, is contagious. Plus you knowledge is something to enjoy by itself. Thank you!!
The demonstrations of concepts are helpful and entertaining in their own right. Personality is gold. Subbed.
It's just cleared 100 million views. Usual informative reaction reaching parts other reactors don't. She can scat, yodel, whistle and do a very good impression of a trumpet (see Steamroller Blues). I particularly enjoy hearing her in a duet (Dear Prudence with Morgan James) (Mad World with Puddles Pity Party) or most jazzy improv songs with Casey Abrams ( also off of American Idol...a musical genius in his own right).
After hearing you sing "Lilac Wine" I think this would be perfect for you to cover . I listen to "Lilac Wine every day I Love It x
My favourite cover of all time. Love seeing your reaction to it
Great reaction! Don't be afraid to say it; Haley simply provides one of the greatest performances by an artist in history.
I was browsing through voice coaches reaction videos so they'd tell me why I shouldn't be obsessed with this performance or at least reassure me that it's fine. And I find this gem. TFVM not only HAS editing but has A LOT of it AND does it well. A love it, I rewatched it, I love it. It shames other reaction videos, just burns them.
TFVM, I love you, I'd merry you. Love your teeth, green eyes, humor, energy and unlike many other voice coaches you can sing.
Thank you, you deserve more love on YT. Sorry for my english.
Haley's natural husky tone is evident as a voice actor in "F is for Family" where she plays Billy Murphy a young boy character.
You bring so much energy and have really great combination of reaction/knowledge and quirkiness, please do more reactions.
I love her...she is a gift for real!
Never change, gorgeous Fairy Voice Mother of ours! Watching you get the crush we all have on Haley was one of my favorite things this week, haha. I'm so glad I happened to find you through my fun habit of finding people reacting to Jinjer - Pisces! You're one of my favorite youtubers, and you always are fun to listen to and manage to explain things without talking down. All the love from Texas!
the lovely fairy voice mother is the definition of a "voical nerd" xD I dont know any other youtube channel that goes so deep into the analysis of the singing technique.. loving it.. always a big fan of this channel :D and its growing steady.. keep it up :D
Thank you for putting another video out so soon! I don’t know if you realize how many poser voice teachers are out there. Thanks for being the real deal.
Interesting. Do more of Haley. Stay well.
I've watched this reaction many times. I revel in your excitement and enthusiasm every time. Thank you so much! ❤️
I think I loved your facial reactions as much as the technical explanations of what she was doing. A passionate enjoyment of a passionate performance.
They hadn't even planned to record this. They used a day off while on tour to record some other songs. This version was originally done for another singer but Haley had fallen in love with it and done a great job with it on stage the night before so Scott asked her if she wanted to record it. She was hesitant because her voice was a bit tired from the tour but agreed to do a single take. And that take was all it took!
Scott Bradlee's official comment
th-cam.com/video/MskKSH1Kf4U/w-d-xo.html
i absolutely love how you talk so much with you hands. TBH it really sells it that you know what you talking about bc like i can feel it every time your hands go crazy.
Love love love your reactions and how your body responds...wow!
I love your enthusiastic gleeful reaction !!
The best thing about this performance is it’s a one take and done by Haley ! She had been performing / recording all day and wasn’t sure her voice was up to it, so gave I just one try !! This one ....amazing!!
I love the evolution of your presentation style since you've had this channel. I'm almost getting Beakman's World vibes watching you explain the anatomy of mechanics of Haley's technique. I absolutely love it and keep it up.
watching again.... WHEN I watch you here, it makes me smile and cry at same time to see your affectations and also the humor along with amazement. Joy. It is same with your Angelina Jordan reaction and your first Dimash and one other of his... SADLY THOUGH, I await many more ANGELINA JORDAN reactions from age 6, 7, 8 , 9 , 10, and on till now at age 16 next week!!!!!! Say Happy Birthday Angelina (Jan 10th)
Haley has been my favorite singer since American Idol 10 years ago and has been quite successful since. The best voice on the planet. Not only her vocal skills but knowing how to arrange it her way and don't forget her incredible stage presence! She grew up with music as her parents have been musicians performing in Chicago for years. Haley has a jazz background and loves 60's music. Her latest release is No Doubt's "Don't Speak" in a return with PMJ after a 6 year absence. Haley has many great originals as well. I loved your reaction to Angelina Jordan's Bohemian Rhapsody and have it saved. Angelina and Haley are two of the most professional and underrated artists and should be up there with the best. LOVED, LOVED,LOVED this reaction and analysis and btw, you, FVM should be at the top of the reaction world!! This was so much FUN! Thank you!
Although a world-class vocalist, I disagree that Haley has been quite successful since her debut on American Idol. To the contrary her career has remained very stagnant and it is because she runs her own career, unlike virtually all successful music artists in the world today. Her problem is she is not a trained professional business manager. In fact, she has no clue what she is doing. Had Haley had a professional business manager running her career for her since her days on American Idol, Haley Reinhart would be a worldwide mega star today.
@@theblackdog2399 It depends on your definition of success. I get the feeling Haley is quite comfortable doing her style of music and wants control of her own music and not be dictated to by a corporate conglomerate. She performs what she wants and when she wants. She has a huge fan base and has earned a few million. I would call that success. I do agree that had she gone the way you expressed she would be a mega star.......but would she be happy? Success to many is happiness.
As always great reaction. Your joy listening to music is infectious THANK YOU
All your brilliance aside and all of the analytic knowledge greatly appreciated, what struck me the most is how much you seem to genuinely enjoy that song. Often times i feel the deeper the knowledge, the more it seems to dull many peoples capability to enjoy... art, music, beauty. - i don't know how to put it otherwise, somewhat like a physician looking at a body. While still capable to appreciate it, not able to shiver, love and adore anymore. You seem to still have a deep well full of that particular ability!
i LOVE HOW YOU NAILED HER STYLE!💘
i've been binging on The Fairy Voice Mother this morning. If I don't get a hold of myself and change channels the men in white coats are going to come and drag me away
There are A LOT of reactors on youtube but you and your channel are absolutely unique. I feel like I need a sedative every time I watch you---you're contagious' ____and maybe even a little dangerous‼ ❤🩹
Tnx!!! Watched every one of her creep reactions (dozens and dozens) and enjoyed this as much as any of them. I know nothing about music other than listening to what I like. U obviously an expert and nice to hear how much u liked what she did. Tnx subscribed!
That was the most entertaining reaction video ive ever seen. The editing and effects were awesome! That is my favourite Haley/PMJ cover.
Haley is superb in pretty much every way, as you’ve accurately described and you FVM are an absolute delight to watch! Nicely done!
Brilliant. I learn so much from you and love hearing your voice as part of your analysis of the vocalist!
The fact that you can replicate what she is doing is so so impressive and really speaks to your technical knowledge.
I just love how excited you look as you reacts to this! Shows hoe much you love music!
You should totally check some of her American Idol performances, maybe react to them. You've Really Got a Hold on Me, I Who Have Nothing, Bennie and the Jets and a lot of her performances are amazing!
i love how you can both demonstrate all of this so even I can understand how it works and still be really natural and entertaining reacting to it. Love your videos!
Had to subscribe as I've not heard a better analysis and description of Haley Reinhart's stylings.
Most beautiful singer in the world today.
KNEW you would love this!! This and ""Dream on feat. Morgan James" are my two fav PMJ covers..I think you'll LOVE that as well!
P.S. You're the BEST!
Yes! This is what I came here to recommend. Haley’s Creep and Morgan’s Dream On are my two favorite PMJ covers, by far… actually, I prefer both of them to the originals. They are truly awesome.
@@HanleyMan i know it will sound sacriligious to say that, but i wholeheartedly agree. I definitely like the originals, but the flip and also the style of the music of the covers is more of my personal preference
I swear Morgan James can teleport air from another dimension, because how in the hell does that much breath come out of such a petite woman?
Loved your reaction, and analyzes, thank you! :)
What a fun reaction. I learned a lot and you were a pleasure to watch. Thank you for taking us along with you. 😉
Absolutely transcendent performance…
I’ve heard it more than a dozen times, and it still brings me to tears:
-the vocal technique
-the lyrics hitting close to home
-the stylistic choice of black-and-white
If there were some kind of digital legacy recordings compilation that could outlast the human race (beyond the Library of Congress, like perhaps an underground bunker or something), this should be among them.
I love this! I saw this a while ago and forgot about it for a second. I love the original but I just love her voice so much
Yeah, I've decided you're definitely my favorite vocal coach reactor. The Breakdown of her technique and skillset was awesome