Let's remember their names: Three-year-old Johnathan Ball was killed when two bombs hidden in litter bins detonated on a busy shopping street in March 1993. Tim Parry, aged 12, died five days later. There were many other victims, but this is the incident that inspired the song.
Let's remember the names of all the children killed or twisted by the wars and conflicts worldwide since this song. This comment was meant in love with all the strength of this song and video.
@@brianboye8025 He will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain anymore, for the former things have passed away.” Revelation 21:4
I am not Irish and still I am secondhand-embarrassed when a reacting youtuber has, seriously, no clue at all and keeps wasting my time with wondering aloud where "this place might be" without really caring.
"With their tanks and their bombs and their bombs and their guns..." "Bombs" is said twice because there were two bombs in Warrington and both maged to kill a child (RIP Jonathan Ball and Tim Parry)
My uncle was a plastic/reconstructive surgeon in Chester at the time. He was called in and had a police escort to speed to the hospital. He told me he was in the OR for 10 hours straight, operating on one patient after another. So tragic. RIP.
Tanks because Ireland was occupied for 800 years with millitary force. Shot innocents covered it up and refuse to make them face justice. Starved during the famine, millions died. Sent ptsd riddled ww1 soldiers to savage our population use irish children as human shields(pictures). The video is British soldiers shooting children because it happened.
Between 1969-2003 there were over 16,000 bombings. In Belfast, on 21 July 1972, 19 IRA bombs were detonated in little over an hour. Most attacks were orchestrated by the IRA, but loyalist paramilitaries from the UVF, UFF and UVF also carried out bombing campaigns. Terrorism was orchestrated by both sides and it was mostly innocent civilians that paid the price. I was born in 1993 and whilst I wasn’t around during the worst days of the Troubles, I’ve still heard the sound of bombs and gunfire. Thankfully the violence has subsided and hostilities are mostly in the past. Northern Ireland is a safe place to live in and visit. Although sadly there are still some that cling to the past. To give you an example, in 2019 a 29 year old reporter, Lyra McKee was murdered in crossfire when a New IRA gunman started shooting towards the police. She dedicated her life to speaking out about the Troubles and LGBT rights, she was researching unsolved killings during the conflict at the time she died and never finished her second book. Lyra had only just bought an engagement ring and was about to propose to her partner.
I’m from northern Ireland and this song released when I was a young teen. Dolores is using an Irish wailing sound called keening, made at wakes or at gravesides. It draws out more emotion in this song with the subject matter. Still hard to listen to this song without the tears!
I'm from the South, along the border and she spoke for a lot of us who were automatically assumed to support these acts by ira when we absolutely did not. When she sings "it's not me, not my family" she spoke for all of us. The keening is absolutely appropriate as you say, to draw out the emotions that we felt for every act like this from both sides. I am so grateful there is peace at the moment. I was a teen when this came out too and it was amazing to have Delores speak for us in such a powerful way
They actually filmed in Belfast in the heartland of the Troubles, getting permission from the British army by saying they were making a documentary about the peace-keeping efforts, so those shots of the soldiers, graffiti etc are real. The b/w of the band playing was filmed in Dublin. The vocal technique she uses is keening - a classic Irish (and Scottish) vocal lament. The song and video are haunting and when it was released it was profoundly shocking - am An Old and remember it well.
Why is it that some clown always brings up keening when it comes to her singing? She was from Limerick and her singing style is derived from traditional Irish singing styles, of which keening is not one.
As an Irishman .. I loved your thoughtful & insightful reaction .. Most in-depth I’ve watched on this iconic song .. You’re a deep empathetic young man .. keep up the great work .. Love & blessings to you & yours from across the pond 🌊.. Thankfully we’ve had a relative peace in the North over the last 20 years ..
Zombie" is a protest song by Irish alternative rock band the Cranberries, written by the band's lead singer, Dolores O'Riordan, in response to and in memory of two young victims of a bombing in Warrington, England, that occurred during the Troubles in Northern Ireland.
"it's not me it's not my family" when you grew up in this time it means alot because you hear a big bang at night that's what you thought as another persons family was taken.
Oh shit yeah that's true. I always interpretted as the apathy we develop to wars that are going on overseas that tends to be hard to shift unless it affect you and yours personally.
It still cuts me up every time. As a Scot with Irish heritage and growing up watching the troubles regularly on the news, it takes me back to my childhood. I remember going shopping in Glasgow and having to regularly leave stores with my mum aged 10 cause of bomb scares. It was much worse in Ireland as they had to check under their cars for detonators every time before driving off. Dolores' voice giving way to 'keening' the Irish funeral lament is so haunting. There is also a Scottish Gaelic version of this too, but I only know a few words of Gaelic being on the West coast.
He’s got WAY more understanding of practically every other non-Irish/British reactor I’ve seen. I’m a 49 year old American (Arkansas), certainly old enough to remember what it was like still in the 80s and 90s, and honestly I sometimes get frustrated with feeling like so many people are living under a rock concerning major global events. So many reactors have never even heard of The Troubles.
Can't help but shed a few tears when I hear this song. Wild how it evokes such deep emotion. Masterpiece is a perfect word to describe this piece of art.
An artifact of the Easter Sunday, 1916 rising. The sound of British artillery, and of the firing squads thereafter kept ringing in the ears of all involved. Generations of zombies on both sides infected their children with their hate for one another, and some even refused to take 'yes' for an answer once the peace was negotiated in the 1990's. Small wonder O'Riordan (RIP) got so angry.
Seen him react to UK hip hop where he goes into detail about the meaning of the lyrics. His European knowledge is better than many locals, One of the reasons he's my favourite reactor.
Excellent analysis and reaction- thanks! Yes, Delores sings with her limerick accent in all of her songs but in this song she is using a vocal technique referred to as "Keening" common in Irish folk songs and used at Irish funerals to emphasize heartbreak and grief. Please react to the 'Bad Wolves' cover of this song while this one is still fresh in your mind. Delores was scheduled to reprise her vocals and record that cover with them but passed away suddenly the day it was to be recorded. It is a stunning tribute to Delores and the proceeds of that song go to her children.
I always liked dreams too the cranberries were such apart of my life growing up if I remember dreams and linger are in the babysitters club I cried the day she died she was going to make a new album 💔 😢
The style in which this is sung in is called keening. It’s used at Ireland funerals and anywhere there is mourning. I may be wrong but I’m pretty sure!
@@maxmess1235 I'm from Ireland and have never encountered keening at any funerals or wakes. The point however is that it is not a singing style. It's just some rubbish taken from Wikipedia that people persist in putting in comments like these as if they know what they're talking about when they clearly don't.
The Catholic Church had Keening almost forgotten. The church found it pagan and wanted it stopped, the hunt to try and destroy the ancient rites was done all over the world. If they couldn’t erase it they adapted some practices into Christianity.Keening was rediscovered by some from early recordings. It’s not a common practice. Like some other cultures women might be paid to wail to accentuate the pain at a funeral
Dolores always sang with her Irish accent and also used traditional Irish singing styles like keening. You should react to Ode to my Family, Linger, Dreams, When You’re Gone. All beautiful songs.
If you like this check out the bad wolves cover of zombie. She was supposed to do vocals for the track but died before the plane got there. They donated all proceeds to her family after she passed.
I LOVE IT when Knox gets historical. This song is incredible, the story behind is powerful, and this band is amazing. HIGHLY RECOMMEND you dig into the Cranberries more, Knox. Dolores is a truly generational voice. There was no one like her, and she is much missed.
No way this is your first time hearing this!! What??!! One of my favorite songs of all time! Please react to more cranberries! "Linger" is a great next Cranberries.
Dolores was the voice of a whole generation. Incredibly talented, incredibly powerful and just gorgeous in every way. One of if not the best female rock singers in the history. If you wanna check more of the Cranberries and just get a glimpse of her capabilities, I'd recommend the song Promises, live from Paris in 1999. Incredibly energetic, sounding exact to the album version, but even better, without any hiccups or flat notes. Her vocal control was just spectacular.
It also surprises me how smart you really are with like facts and histroy and events. Like you were just pulling this off the top of your head. Something I could never fathom. But again another good break down. They show the kid with the gun and then the soldier as well. And it makes me wonder if that kid was the soldier after he grew up. It just comes across as a possible thing. But love the song and your break down!
The fact she mentioned bombs twice, is accurate, not just a lyrical repeat. Both sides had bombs. She was pointing fingers at two entities, with "their bombs" and "their bombs".
It also adds another layer to the equation when you consider that the footage for this is real. It was filmed in Belfast. Also, the image of the cross evokes sacrifice. So, if follow that line of thought and note the children around and then on the cross,the question is posed. Are we really willing to continue to sacrifice our children? How horrific is it that the answer to that question is all too often “yes”.
As an Irishman from Dublin, this song is extremely important. I respect your knowledge and understanding of history 🇮🇪🇮🇪🇺🇲🇺🇲 love your content! Go Raibh Mile Maith Agát!
Remembering this music video released and aired on TV makes me feel so old and I am only 37... This song is inspired by real events, you should definitely read the backstory, it's very sad.
When Bad Wolves covered this in 2018 they put that date in place of 1916 and they changed one of the the “bombs” to “drones” it’s sooo powerful as is this one RIP, she was supposed to be ft on the cover but she passed before they got into the studio to record her vocals
Have loved this song since the day it came out, and will never get tired of it. I loved a lot of the songs the band came out with. The Bad Wolves version is also a beautiful rendition., and contribution to The Cranberries and the lead singer, Dolores Mary Eileen O'Riordan, after her accidental drowning, due to alcohol intoxication in January 2018. May she rest in peace, and her legacy go on.
RIP Deloros O’Riordan. That sound she’s making is called keening. It’s the traditional sound of lament for the dead. She was so talented. I think she was around 19 at this time.
Holy shit dude. I"m 50 years old, I remember when this song came out, huge Cranberries fan, and I've never heard some one critique this song better than you. I've heard this song 100's of times, but never once understood it's meaning better than you. Especially the title Zombie. That breakdown was epic. Awesome insight. Keep going bro.
Once again Knox you did an amazing job and your knowledge base is so wide and I appreciate you and your attention to the facts so much. Thank you so much. Also you never messaged me back about my rapping questions. No rush or pressure as I k ow you are a busy man. Much love.
I've said this on numerous reactions to this song but this was my childhood, literally. I grew up on the Ardoyne Road in North Belfast in the 80s. Everything from the soldiers patrolling the streets to us kids playing around in derelict houses, including climbing up onto roofs and jumping around (as well as other roofs like the ones on the Wheatfield or Holy Cross girls primary schools). The murals shown in this video were ones that we passed regularly. I still remember the principle of R.B.A.I. (my secondary school that I was going to at the time) telling us the story of the Warrington Bomb as he had been in England that weekend and when travelling close to the area whilst driving up to get the ferry back to Belfast. He was extremely posh so for us a kids to hear him cursing in the assembly was a shock to all the pupils and showed just how much it had affected him.
I was a late teen in London at the height of the troubles and was involved so many times in horrific violence on the mainland. It breaks my heart to think of all the suffering on both sides off the Irish Sea and I am eternally grateful to those women of Ireland on both sides of the conflict who said enough is enough and created the right conditions for the fabulous Mo Mowland to broker the peace process. All the time whilst she had a brain tumour and was mocked for balding. I won’t ever forgive those Americans who funding the “troubles “ because they never understood and absolutely nothing was achieved. Some sort of misguided misunderstanding of a romanticised history that made Irish freedom fighter out to be hero’s.. No they were terrorists as all terrorist are they were evil.
What was the mentality then among the general population there? Did they have widespread support (active or otherwise) or did most people oppose the actions taken in their name? I’m an American who was not around during that period and only knows the basics about it.
You've analysed this better than anyone I've ever seen. Great prior knowledge of the events really helps too. I'm an English teacher in Ireland and I always get my students to react to the lyrics of this song.
Knox, I want to say thank you for your intelligent, insightful, and knowledgeable analysis of songs. You seem to be one of the few “reactors” that gets not only the meaning of the lyrics, but the emotion behind the music. I love your reactions to soad the most. Keep doing what you’re doing. One love!
Delores had the voice of an Angel, RIP i saw Bad Wolves with Five finger death punch and when bad Wolves performed their cover they said "Sing it! sing it loud enough so Delores hears us!" gave me chills
Such a big song when it came out, and I should know, I was there. It's become a real classic. Nice reaction Knox, good to see it reaching a new audience.
FINALLY someone who knows exactly what this song is about! Love this band so much and seen a lot of reactions to Zombie and half the people don't do a minute's research and are guessing about what conflict it is. Bangers!
Knox, I really appreciate your videos because I feel many people neglect lyrics. Some of these people would be considered brilliant on paper alone. It's just great to see someone appreciate it
First time viewer of the channel and this dude KNOWS his Irish history, Loved hearing your perspective of the video, pretty spot on in regards to what the video is about and in relate to.
I saw a comment on another reaction video, regarding the line "it's not me, it's not my family" that had another interpretation...both sides of any conflict, including The Troubles, generally claim to be committing their acts of violence in the name of the people they claim to be fighting for. The lyric could be interpreted as: You don't speak for me or my family, we don't condone your violence.
The song is an Irish Catholic singing about a Catholic atrocity. The video represents a British atrocity. As a British Protestant the mixing of images brings us together. That is the greatness if this song.
This really is a song that will go down in history. Not only is it about what was going on in Ireland at that time but is so relevant now too. Unfortunately I think it will always be relevant. Also there is a Ren song im not sure many people have heard with a girl called Bibi. Its called "Crutch". Holy moly not only is the song great, just like everything Ren does, but the video is absolutely beautiful too.
I really don't know what I was expecting here. I watch a lot of reaction videos. But this is the first time I've been blown away by the knowledge of the reactor. You are so impressive. Your critiques are on point. Loved this reaction. Great Job. 👍🏼 Imma watch some and subscribe. Amazing ❤❤
For metal Mondays. Bad wolves covers this song, and she was suppose to have been on it but sadly passed away before she could record. It's a amazing cover and worth a listen..
I absolutely love that you went into this reaction knowing about the troubles add to that the insightful interpretation of the lyrics and video this was one of the best reactions to this song I’ve seen❤.
I went to Ireland and Northern Ireland in 2019. While in Belfast, I did a Black Cab tour where the driver takes you around the city explaining all about The Troubles and the significant areas and what happened there. I know when I was younger, there wasn't much news about The Troubles where I was, so to hear the history of it was devastating. The driver I had, at the end of the tour he takes you to sign the Peace Wall. It's definitely an experience I would recommend
I remember being a small kid and singing this song every time it was played on the radio, and I always loved it even if I didn't know English nor understand the lyrics. When I was a teen and understood the meaning and story behind I loved it even more, but as a kid I loved Dolores' voice and the music. A beautiful yet sad song. Loved seeing you react to this one!
Amazing breakdown!! You absolutely nailed it!! I have loved this song for decades and I’m astounded by your comprehension of the subject matter!! Much respect!!
I always took the message as ‘This war is old, the people are losing the will to fight as their families are caught in the crossfire. But you still keep fighting, not seeing the harm you’re causing your own people. Not letting it rest. Like a Zombie.’
The Irish Rugby Union team is one of the very few teams that is drawn for all across Ireland, North and South. This song is sung by the crowd at all their home matches,
This song hits hard every single time. Great interpretation. I believe the violence causing silence line also indicates the silence of trauma and shell-shock from seeing and experiencing such brutality.
Actually so nice to experience this through your eyes after knowing this song most of my life. The song and the band deserve so much respect. I'm so glad you appreciated the layers of it all.
This song came out when I was in middle school and is one of the first songs to really open my mind to the world and the evils in it. It’s always kept a special place in my mind.
Bad Wolves did an amazing cover of this song as well. They were supposed to record it with Dolores but she died the night before they were to film it. Dolores does an amazing job of "keening." Such a powerful song. Really enjoyed this one Knox 💜💜
You now need to see the Badwolves cover, which was meant to feature Delores but she passed away the day before she was sceduled to sing her part in the song. It's since become a tribute, and the video is heartbreaking.
Let's remember their names: Three-year-old Johnathan Ball was killed when two bombs hidden in litter bins detonated on a busy shopping street in March 1993. Tim Parry, aged 12, died five days later. There were many other victims, but this is the incident that inspired the song.
I live in Warrington and the town truly is scarred. Still.
Let's remember the names of all the children killed or twisted by the wars and conflicts worldwide since this song. This comment was meant in love with all the strength of this song and video.
❤️
@@brianboye8025 He will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain anymore, for the former things have passed away.” Revelation 21:4
@@brianboye8025🥺🙏🏻🫶🏻
As an Northern Irish person I just want to say: I have seen so many Americans react to this song, but finally someone really gets it ❤
Haha thanks. I mean I do have a bit of a cheat code - my wife is British and I did study history (international relations) in school 🤟 Loved this song
@@KnoxHill Check out "Linger", "Ode To My Family", "When You're Gone", "Salvation", "Dreams". The Cranberries are Awesome! RIP Dolores. 🙏
@@KnoxHill Aaah, that explains some things!
I am not Irish and still I am secondhand-embarrassed when a reacting youtuber has, seriously, no clue at all and keeps wasting my time with wondering aloud where "this place might be" without really caring.
Knox Hill’s interpretations of music are excellent. He really breaks down lyrics, vocal abilities, metaphorical theories, etc.
"With their tanks and their bombs and their bombs and their guns..." "Bombs" is said twice because there were two bombs in Warrington and both maged to kill a child (RIP Jonathan Ball and Tim Parry)
My brother was a British soldier serving in Ireland, they were terrible times for everyone involved.
My uncle was a plastic/reconstructive surgeon in Chester at the time. He was called in and had a police escort to speed to the hospital. He told me he was in the OR for 10 hours straight, operating on one patient after another. So tragic. RIP.
Even after all this time, I never knew that. Thanks for posting it!
Tanks because Ireland was occupied for 800 years with millitary force. Shot innocents covered it up and refuse to make them face justice. Starved during the famine, millions died. Sent ptsd riddled ww1 soldiers to savage our population use irish children as human shields(pictures). The video is British soldiers shooting children because it happened.
Between 1969-2003 there were over 16,000 bombings. In Belfast, on 21 July 1972, 19 IRA bombs were detonated in little over an hour. Most attacks were orchestrated by the IRA, but loyalist paramilitaries from the UVF, UFF and UVF also carried out bombing campaigns. Terrorism was orchestrated by both sides and it was mostly innocent civilians that paid the price. I was born in 1993 and whilst I wasn’t around during the worst days of the Troubles, I’ve still heard the sound of bombs and gunfire. Thankfully the violence has subsided and hostilities are mostly in the past. Northern Ireland is a safe place to live in and visit. Although sadly there are still some that cling to the past. To give you an example, in 2019 a 29 year old reporter, Lyra McKee was murdered in crossfire when a New IRA gunman started shooting towards the police. She dedicated her life to speaking out about the Troubles and LGBT rights, she was researching unsolved killings during the conflict at the time she died and never finished her second book. Lyra had only just bought an engagement ring and was about to propose to her partner.
I’m from northern Ireland and this song released when I was a young teen. Dolores is using an Irish wailing sound called keening, made at wakes or at gravesides. It draws out more emotion in this song with the subject matter. Still hard to listen to this song without the tears!
I'm from the South, along the border and she spoke for a lot of us who were automatically assumed to support these acts by ira when we absolutely did not. When she sings "it's not me, not my family" she spoke for all of us. The keening is absolutely appropriate as you say, to draw out the emotions that we felt for every act like this from both sides. I am so grateful there is peace at the moment. I was a teen when this came out too and it was amazing to have Delores speak for us in such a powerful way
They actually filmed in Belfast in the heartland of the Troubles, getting permission from the British army by saying they were making a documentary about the peace-keeping efforts, so those shots of the soldiers, graffiti etc are real. The b/w of the band playing was filmed in Dublin.
The vocal technique she uses is keening - a classic Irish (and Scottish) vocal lament. The song and video are haunting and when it was released it was profoundly shocking - am An Old and remember it well.
Thank you for including “keening”. I thought that’s what it was, but I’m not very familiar with it. It’s very haunting and heartbreaking.
Why is it that some clown always brings up keening when it comes to her singing? She was from Limerick and her singing style is derived from traditional Irish singing styles, of which keening is not one.
Same J. Hits hard when you saw it in real time.
"An Old." 😂 Ditto.
As an Irishman .. I loved your thoughtful & insightful reaction .. Most in-depth I’ve watched on this iconic song .. You’re a deep empathetic young man .. keep up the great work .. Love & blessings to you & yours from across the pond 🌊.. Thankfully we’ve had a relative peace in the North over the last 20 years ..
Best analysis on this song's meaning I've ever seen - he seemed to understand the power of the song and the message.
Absolutely my thoughts as well. He totally understood everything
Bro you shouldn’t leave a clover to represent us 😭
@@medb8882 ☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️☘️.. with bells on them 😂
WOW JUST WOW!!!
❤❤❤
AWESOME KNOX
You're one of the very few reactors that I watch who even knew what the reference to 1916 is in this song. Very well done reaction.
Zombie" is a protest song by Irish alternative rock band the Cranberries, written by the band's lead singer, Dolores O'Riordan, in response to and in memory of two young victims of a bombing in Warrington, England, that occurred during the Troubles in Northern Ireland.
thank you, ChatGPT
@@joshuapeek9555 *Wikipedia
My hometown
Ÿep copied and pasted from google, i couldnt write it better so.. *shrug
@joshuapeek9555 nope, unfortunately, it was a Google, i couldnt write it better
One of the best things about Dolores was you could still hear her Limerick accent when she sang!
one of the best voices
"it's not me it's not my family" when you grew up in this time it means alot because you hear a big bang at night that's what you thought as another persons family was taken.
She said it was because the IRA was always saying they were fighting 'for the people' and she's saying 'no, not me, not for my family'.
Wow so sad 😢
Oh shit yeah that's true. I always interpretted as the apathy we develop to wars that are going on overseas that tends to be hard to shift unless it affect you and yours personally.
It still cuts me up every time. As a Scot with Irish heritage and growing up watching the troubles regularly on the news, it takes me back to my childhood. I remember going shopping in Glasgow and having to regularly leave stores with my mum aged 10 cause of bomb scares. It was much worse in Ireland as they had to check under their cars for detonators every time before driving off. Dolores' voice giving way to 'keening' the Irish funeral lament is so haunting. There is also a Scottish Gaelic version of this too, but I only know a few words of Gaelic being on the West coast.
I'm an old man from north Belfast and your knowledge of my wee country in mighty impressive, great reaction as usual 👍
He’s got WAY more understanding of practically every other non-Irish/British reactor I’ve seen. I’m a 49 year old American (Arkansas), certainly old enough to remember what it was like still in the 80s and 90s, and honestly I sometimes get frustrated with feeling like so many people are living under a rock concerning major global events. So many reactors have never even heard of The Troubles.
There's an awful lot of Irish history online I've viewed it.
To the US Ireland hardly feels like a wee country, it had an outsized cultural influence on us from all the Irish that came here.
@@Alex-dh2cx Ireland is bigger 100% but like I said I'm from Belfast Northern Ireland and we are a wee country!
When the kids are shot and their golden counterpart screams, it brings me to tears, every single time. Great reaction!
Every time
This song is just as current as the day it was released…. RIP Delores 🙏🏻
The sound and the visuals in combination = breaks my heart every time. really a masterpiece
Can't help but shed a few tears when I hear this song. Wild how it evokes such deep emotion. Masterpiece is a perfect word to describe this piece of art.
An artifact of the Easter Sunday, 1916 rising. The sound of British artillery, and of the firing squads thereafter kept ringing in the ears of all involved. Generations of zombies on both sides infected their children with their hate for one another, and some even refused to take 'yes' for an answer once the peace was negotiated in the 1990's. Small wonder O'Riordan (RIP) got so angry.
The drummer just beat the hell out of those skins in this song! It makes them sound so crisp and impactful.
Yeah he was a definite animal on those drums. Not difficult considering the power behind the song.
The drummer was actually given free reign from Dolores to play how he wanted. You can see in his face the pain and anguish.
Very fitting how they sound like gun fire at times
Delores specifically told the band to play the shit out of their instruments during recording. She wanted it to hit as hard as possible.
This song always gets me right in the feels😢 RIP Jonathan Ball, Tim Parry, Dolores O'Riordan.
Same. Its one of my favourite songs, actually, but it gives me shivers every time.
This is one of my favourite reactions to this song, because you actually seem to have some knowledge. Big hugs from Sweden.
Seen him react to UK hip hop where he goes into detail about the meaning of the lyrics. His European knowledge is better than many locals,
One of the reasons he's my favourite reactor.
Excellent analysis and reaction- thanks! Yes, Delores sings with her limerick accent in all of her songs but in this song she is using a vocal technique referred to as "Keening" common in Irish folk songs and used at Irish funerals to emphasize heartbreak and grief. Please react to the 'Bad Wolves' cover of this song while this one is still fresh in your mind. Delores was scheduled to reprise her vocals and record that cover with them but passed away suddenly the day it was to be recorded. It is a stunning tribute to Delores and the proceeds of that song go to her children.
Yes, she usually sounded like this.
I always liked this song and "Linger".
Dolores always kept her Limerick accent. She was very good with the keaning too. Very much an Irish sound. RIP Delores always missed
Gorgeous song. I always loved these two, dreaming my dreams and no need to argue.
I always liked dreams too the cranberries were such apart of my life growing up if I remember dreams and linger are in the babysitters club I cried the day she died she was going to make a new album 💔 😢
You are the first reactor I have seen to link the children play fighting to growing up to be the soldiers actually fighting.
You are by far and away the most intelligent and informed reactionist to the UK alternative music scene from the US. Congratulations and, keep going.
The Cranberries are Irish and nothing to do with UK.
@@TheLeahygirl Did the Cranbberries not form part of the UK music scene?
The style in which this is sung in is called keening. It’s used at Ireland funerals and anywhere there is mourning. I may be wrong but I’m pretty sure!
You couldn't be more wrong. "Keening" is not a singing style. Her vocals had their roots in traditional Irish music.
@@jonnyw1391it’s “Irish wailing” done at wakes and graveside, referred to as “keening”.
@@maxmess1235 I'm from Ireland and have never encountered keening at any funerals or wakes. The point however is that it is not a singing style. It's just some rubbish taken from Wikipedia that people persist in putting in comments like these as if they know what they're talking about when they clearly don't.
The Catholic Church had Keening almost forgotten. The church found it pagan and wanted it stopped, the hunt to try and destroy the ancient rites was done all over the world. If they couldn’t erase it they adapted some practices into Christianity.Keening was rediscovered by some from early recordings. It’s not a common practice. Like some other cultures women might be paid to wail to accentuate the pain at a funeral
The amount of perspective I just witnessed is like hearing this song for the first time …
Dolores always sang with her Irish accent and also used traditional Irish singing styles like keening. You should react to Ode to my Family, Linger, Dreams, When You’re Gone. All beautiful songs.
Those are all my favorite songs ❤️
If you like this check out the bad wolves cover of zombie. She was supposed to do vocals for the track but died before the plane got there. They donated all proceeds to her family after she passed.
Yes and the video is such a beautiful tribute to her/this video.
Please do this one too!
Completely agree.
The Badwolves cover brings another layer of emotion to it. I love it
I love the Bad Wolves cover!
I LOVE IT when Knox gets historical. This song is incredible, the story behind is powerful, and this band is amazing. HIGHLY RECOMMEND you dig into the Cranberries more, Knox. Dolores is a truly generational voice. There was no one like her, and she is much missed.
No way this is your first time hearing this!! What??!! One of my favorite songs of all time! Please react to more cranberries! "Linger" is a great next Cranberries.
Dreams as well is amazing
@@FleaÉire yes! ❤️❤️❤️
Dolores was the voice of a whole generation. Incredibly talented, incredibly powerful and just gorgeous in every way. One of if not the best female rock singers in the history.
If you wanna check more of the Cranberries and just get a glimpse of her capabilities, I'd recommend the song Promises, live from Paris in 1999. Incredibly energetic, sounding exact to the album version, but even better, without any hiccups or flat notes. Her vocal control was just spectacular.
One of the best songs EVER
💯!!!
There is no doubting that statement.
Not best song ever bro not😡
It also surprises me how smart you really are with like facts and histroy and events. Like you were just pulling this off the top of your head. Something I could never fathom. But again another good break down. They show the kid with the gun and then the soldier as well. And it makes me wonder if that kid was the soldier after he grew up. It just comes across as a possible thing. But love the song and your break down!
It's absolutely crazy hearing an american know so much about Irish history, Great video as per usual! Thanks!
One of the few reactors who took the time to examine the historical context of this song. Much appreciated
The fact she mentioned bombs twice, is accurate, not just a lyrical repeat. Both sides had bombs. She was pointing fingers at two entities, with "their bombs" and "their bombs".
It also adds another layer to the equation when you consider that the footage for this is real. It was filmed in Belfast. Also, the image of the cross evokes sacrifice. So, if follow that line of thought and note the children around and then on the cross,the question is posed. Are we really willing to continue to sacrifice our children? How horrific is it that the answer to that question is all too often “yes”.
That was and is a Masterpiece😢She had such a unique Voice.....R.I.P DOLORES 😓
As an Irishman from Dublin, this song is extremely important. I respect your knowledge and understanding of history 🇮🇪🇮🇪🇺🇲🇺🇲 love your content! Go Raibh Mile Maith Agát!
Remembering this music video released and aired on TV makes me feel so old and I am only 37... This song is inspired by real events, you should definitely read the backstory, it's very sad.
30 years on and I still tear up.
I can believe it’s 30 years, feels like yesterday and I still cry
When Bad Wolves covered this in 2018 they put that date in place of 1916 and they changed one of the the “bombs” to “drones” it’s sooo powerful as is this one RIP, she was supposed to be ft on the cover but she passed before they got into the studio to record her vocals
Not only that, but Bad Wolves also signed away all profits from their cover to a trust fund for Dolores' children ❤
@@ziggythedrummer Yessss 🫶🏼
Oh I didn’t know this about the drones. That is impactful. I need to give it a listen. Also to support the kids.
@@jennifermorris6848 Yes! It’s such a powerful video and I’m going to watch it daily now that I was reminded of the proceeds going to her kids❣️
I was a teenager when this came out in the 90s. I was no head banger but this song gave me chills then and it still does today. Timeless classic.
Have loved this song since the day it came out, and will never get tired of it. I loved a lot of the songs the band came out with. The Bad Wolves version is also a beautiful rendition., and contribution to The Cranberries and the lead singer, Dolores Mary Eileen O'Riordan, after her accidental drowning, due to alcohol intoxication in January 2018. May she rest in peace, and her legacy go on.
Alittle side note this woman’s voice was so strong she could sing with no microphone
RIP Deloros O’Riordan. That sound she’s making is called keening. It’s the traditional sound of lament for the dead. She was so talented. I think she was around 19 at this time.
Holy shit dude. I"m 50 years old, I remember when this song came out, huge Cranberries fan, and I've never heard some one critique this song better than you. I've heard this song 100's of times, but never once understood it's meaning better than you. Especially the title Zombie. That breakdown was epic. Awesome insight. Keep going bro.
Once again Knox you did an amazing job and your knowledge base is so wide and I appreciate you and your attention to the facts so much. Thank you so much. Also you never messaged me back about my rapping questions. No rush or pressure as I k ow you are a busy man. Much love.
WOW ...im so glad you are reactiong to this song ...one of my fav groups from the 90s
RIP .....DELORES X
Dolores
Another song by The Cranberries that is about a senseless war is War Child. My mom always cries when we listen to that one.
As an irish man, it's nice to see someone understand what this song really stands for before you've even listened you got it love it ❤
An eternal masterpiece. Just out of words honeslty.. Great breakdown and reaction as always!
I've said this on numerous reactions to this song but this was my childhood, literally.
I grew up on the Ardoyne Road in North Belfast in the 80s. Everything from the soldiers patrolling the streets to us kids playing around in derelict houses, including climbing up onto roofs and jumping around (as well as other roofs like the ones on the Wheatfield or Holy Cross girls primary schools).
The murals shown in this video were ones that we passed regularly.
I still remember the principle of R.B.A.I. (my secondary school that I was going to at the time) telling us the story of the Warrington Bomb as he had been in England that weekend and when travelling close to the area whilst driving up to get the ferry back to Belfast. He was extremely posh so for us a kids to hear him cursing in the assembly was a shock to all the pupils and showed just how much it had affected him.
I was a late teen in London at the height of the troubles and was involved so many times in horrific violence on the mainland. It breaks my heart to think of all the suffering on both sides off the Irish Sea and I am eternally grateful to those women of Ireland on both sides of the conflict who said enough is enough and created the right conditions for the fabulous Mo Mowland to broker the peace process. All the time whilst she had a brain tumour and was mocked for balding.
I won’t ever forgive those Americans who funding the “troubles “ because they never understood and absolutely nothing was achieved. Some sort of misguided misunderstanding of a romanticised history that made Irish freedom fighter out to be hero’s..
No they were terrorists as all terrorist are they were evil.
What was the mentality then among the general population there? Did they have widespread support (active or otherwise) or did most people oppose the actions taken in their name?
I’m an American who was not around during that period and only knows the basics about it.
Thank you for doing Zombie!
You've analysed this better than anyone I've ever seen. Great prior knowledge of the events really helps too. I'm an English teacher in Ireland and I always get my students to react to the lyrics of this song.
Fun fact: Eminem have sampled this song in the Revivals Album 🙏🏻🔥
In your head
Crazy how he took à song about war and with the same lyrics of the hook he made it into à song about a parent mental state
@@vimantheroninboy 🔥👍🏻👍🏻
My favourite Eminem song
@@Haydyn4304 Bro???? It’s your tastes but:
Not afraid
Lose Yourself
The ringer
The Real Slim Shady
When I’m Gone
Killshot etc….
Knox, I want to say thank you for your intelligent, insightful, and knowledgeable analysis of songs. You seem to be one of the few “reactors” that gets not only the meaning of the lyrics, but the emotion behind the music. I love your reactions to soad the most. Keep doing what you’re doing. One love!
Love your ability to breakdown whatever you sink your hands into! You are truly gifted! RIP Johnathan and Tim 🕊️
Delores had the voice of an Angel, RIP
i saw Bad Wolves with Five finger death punch and when bad Wolves performed their cover they said "Sing it! sing it loud enough so Delores hears us!"
gave me chills
She's name is Spanish and is Dolores
This song will always resonate with me. It's hard to find one like this nowadays!!!💜
Shes a real Irish legend and this song is the most popular song ever hear! Hope you had a great paddies day! 💪❤️🇮🇪
Such a big song when it came out, and I should know, I was there. It's become a real classic. Nice reaction Knox, good to see it reaching a new audience.
A beautiful voice taken from us far too soon. R.I.P. Dolores O'Riordan
Gone but never forgotten
Rest in Peace Dolores and the two wee Angels Jonathan and Tim...never forgotten
FINALLY someone who knows exactly what this song is about! Love this band so much and seen a lot of reactions to Zombie and half the people don't do a minute's research and are guessing about what conflict it is. Bangers!
May Dolores be in a very beautiful blessing place. I'm Irish descent☘️☘️
Knox, I really appreciate your videos because I feel many people neglect lyrics. Some of these people would be considered brilliant on paper alone. It's just great to see someone appreciate it
A reviewer with constructive and critical thinking. Well played my man!
First time viewer of the channel and this dude KNOWS his Irish history, Loved hearing your perspective of the video, pretty spot on in regards to what the video is about and in relate to.
I saw a comment on another reaction video, regarding the line "it's not me, it's not my family" that had another interpretation...both sides of any conflict, including The Troubles, generally claim to be committing their acts of violence in the name of the people they claim to be fighting for. The lyric could be interpreted as: You don't speak for me or my family, we don't condone your violence.
I love your breakdown of this. Prior knowledge of the situation + your thoughts are very much appreciated.
One of my favorite songs yesss
Same here
The song is an Irish Catholic singing about a Catholic atrocity. The video represents a British atrocity.
As a British Protestant the mixing of images brings us together.
That is the greatness if this song.
This really is a song that will go down in history. Not only is it about what was going on in Ireland at that time but is so relevant now too. Unfortunately I think it will always be relevant.
Also there is a Ren song im not sure many people have heard with a girl called Bibi. Its called "Crutch". Holy moly not only is the song great, just like everything Ren does, but the video is absolutely beautiful too.
A rare thing - an intelligent, thoughtful reaction. This song gets me every single time.
One of the best voices ever, now gone.
I really don't know what I was expecting here. I watch a lot of reaction videos. But this is the first time I've been blown away by the knowledge of the reactor. You are so impressive. Your critiques are on point. Loved this reaction. Great Job. 👍🏼 Imma watch some and subscribe. Amazing ❤❤
For metal Mondays. Bad wolves covers this song, and she was suppose to have been on it but sadly passed away before she could record. It's a amazing cover and worth a listen..
I absolutely love that you went into this reaction knowing about the troubles add to that the insightful interpretation of the lyrics and video this was one of the best reactions to this song I’ve seen❤.
I have goose bumps every time I hear (or every time I listen to) that song. Haunting indeed.
I went to Ireland and Northern Ireland in 2019. While in Belfast, I did a Black Cab tour where the driver takes you around the city explaining all about The Troubles and the significant areas and what happened there. I know when I was younger, there wasn't much news about The Troubles where I was, so to hear the history of it was devastating. The driver I had, at the end of the tour he takes you to sign the Peace Wall. It's definitely an experience I would recommend
What she’s doing with her voice is keening (the yelp type sounds) which is often used at Irish funerals. It’s very much a lament and a protest song
No it isn't
I remember being a small kid and singing this song every time it was played on the radio, and I always loved it even if I didn't know English nor understand the lyrics. When I was a teen and understood the meaning and story behind I loved it even more, but as a kid I loved Dolores' voice and the music. A beautiful yet sad song. Loved seeing you react to this one!
RIP Jonathan Ball and Tim Parry
Amazing breakdown!! You absolutely nailed it!! I have loved this song for decades and I’m astounded by your comprehension of the subject matter!! Much respect!!
Ridiculously good reaction😢❤
I always took the message as ‘This war is old, the people are losing the will to fight as their families are caught in the crossfire. But you still keep fighting, not seeing the harm you’re causing your own people. Not letting it rest. Like a Zombie.’
The Irish Rugby Union team is one of the very few teams that is drawn for all across Ireland, North and South.
This song is sung by the crowd at all their home matches,
This song hits hard every single time. Great interpretation. I believe the violence causing silence line also indicates the silence of trauma and shell-shock from seeing and experiencing such brutality.
That's a powerful song ❤️❤️
It’s so refreshing to see someone actually do research before critiquing a video and not just blindly reacting. Job well done 👍
React to bad wolves cover of this
Actually so nice to experience this through your eyes after knowing this song most of my life. The song and the band deserve so much respect. I'm so glad you appreciated the layers of it all.
Great bro! Now do a breakdown of the sampled eminem song of "zombie" called "in your head"🔥
Such a legendary and iconic track.
Will hopefully be forever cherished and remembered.
RIP Dolores
This song came out when I was in middle school and is one of the first songs to really open my mind to the world and the evils in it. It’s always kept a special place in my mind.
*The Cranberries (Linger)*
*#RIP** Dolores*
Bad Wolves did an amazing cover of this song as well. They were supposed to record it with Dolores but she died the night before they were to film it. Dolores does an amazing job of "keening." Such a powerful song. Really enjoyed this one Knox 💜💜
You now need to see the Badwolves cover, which was meant to feature Delores but she passed away the day before she was sceduled to sing her part in the song. It's since become a tribute, and the video is heartbreaking.
You're the most-knowledgeable reactor on TH-cam. Every subject, you're on it!