Nightwish - Ghost Love Score with Tarja!!! (LIVE TWITCH REACTION!)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ก.ค. 2024
- ❤️ PATREON: / halflifesistah
☕️ SAY THANKS: www.buymeacoffee.com/halflife...
😎 TIP: streamelements.com/halflifesi...
👉 OFFICIAL MERCH STORE: www.halflifesistah.com ™️
Let’s Connect!
*** Twitch: / halflifesistah
*** Twitter: / _halflifesistah
*** Facebook: / halflifesistah
*** Instagram: / halflifesistah
Business Inquiries: Email: Halflifesistah@gmail.com
Mail:
HalfLifeSistah
P. O. Box 278354
Miramar, Florida 33027
#halflifesistah #tarya #nightwish - เพลง
![Nightwish - Ghost Love Score [ Wacken Live ] ( REACTION )](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Sdkr3LkuShc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Nightwish - Ghost Love Score [ Wacken Live ] ( REACTION )](/img/tr.png)
![[EP.01] ดูฟรีตอนแรก LOL: Last One Laughing Thailand Thailand หัวเราะทีหลังปังกว่า | Prime Thailand](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t4KunBRKn3s/mqdefault.jpg)
![fellow fellow - Proud [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9uZF7BlUQPE/mqdefault.jpg)
Great Reaction! JMHO, but Tarja doesn't give you the goosebumps that Floors version does. Just a heads up concerning TGSoE. The song is about life as we scientifically know it. Starting out with the those first fireworks that represent the Big Bang forming the ever expanding and changing Universe in which we dwell. Followed by the formation of our galaxy, the Milky Way. Then the formation of our own Solar System. Then our own planet Earth, with it being in the Goldilocks zone. Being neither to hot or to cold. Thus allowing life to evolve over billions of years. Then finally the evolution of man, to become the dominate species. Then the likely demise of our own species. As nothing last forever.
The last spoken word part, after the last of the music has been played. Speaks of historical long long odds against you ever having been born. Before the advent of modern medicine. Only 3 in 5 children born made it to age five. With only 1 of the remaining 3 would reaching adulthood and have children of their own. Again with only 1 in 5 reaching the age of having children of their own. Thus you being here in the DNA form that you are in. Thus each one of us Is a such a extreme rare being made of stardust!
I think that Tarja's voice has a way of just melting into the instruments and engulfing everything without overshadowing it? Her voice is like, the grandest of the grand. Almost like she can't even be a human entity. It's Godly.
Then Floor's voice has a way of making the same song have sort of an audio illusion of having deeper fluctuations and climaxes, more struggle back and forth tug and pull through the song. She is a vocal WARRIOR.
Have to disagree. For me this is the correct version and that Floor version sounds like a "forced show off" and her voice just doesn't do it for me. Never understood this floormania and probably never will, but we all have different tastes. Haven't really listened Nightwish since Tarja left, but at least I can still listen to these old recordings sometimes..
I love both for their variety. I'd love a Floor studio version of this with the floorgasm, and whacken vocal charm, minusing the crowd.
Only one I can't stand is Annette, I mean, man she sucked so bad live, unless it was her own songs.
@@Ruhtinas84See I like Floor's arrangement and style choices in how she sings it. I do prefer Tarja's rendition, but I agree.
I don't understand the full Floor obsession. She has technique and she is versatile but I guess I just don't care for the actual sound of her voice. It doesn't have qualities that pull me in regardless of what it can do.
For me, Floor just has a softer tone in her range; both in studio and live...
Tarja some times feels somewhat monotone and emotionless in her live renditions.
Tarja is The Siren from Tuomas mythology.
This was Tarja's last concert with Nightwish and if you watched the entirety of the End of an Era, you can feel how emotionally charged it was.
How so? She didn't know this is going to be her last song with the band.
@@MultiJejje but tou van feel It on Thuomas
@@leoncozy94 I think Tuomas is as excited and emotional _always_ when I watch their live songs. It isn't just this. He is reacting always like this because he loves music and in his every music piece has some message. Some of them are super personal.
@@MultiJejje ... right..she was just glowing proud to finally finish out the tour, working in her ill state barely staying ahead of the sweats....while the boys were all happy grinning and getting drunk onstage...what really struck me was Emppu, who was her closest friend among them, smiling and hugging her as they left the stage, in GLS, and then stabbed her in the back with the rest
@@lastword9475 what I her her on a talk I don’t think Emppu her friend really knew until towards Tarja’s last day’s and myself he had a positive vote for Tarja to stay in the band is how I took it from a talk show.
To me Night-wish Band made a mistake by voting Tarja out of the band a big mistake, Tarja was hurt but she said she needed to be.home with her family cause she had two kids to raise.
Tarja had a special voice that Floor didn’t have for Night wish but no one can replace Tarja’s beautiful voice.
The Tarja era really was something else. A magical, mystical dream in a blanket of joy and wonder.
Floor have an incredible voice range but still Tarja is the masterpiece of their album when Tarja era.
No one's talking about the album. We are discussing this song which Tarja did no justice for. She sounded terrible.
@@Dirtnap1986 New fan detected 🤣
@@bangbray4224 not sure about that. I was listening to nightwish for years when Tarja was in it, then when Anette came to band i stoped, and don't get me wrong here, two of them (Tarja and Floor) are queens of nightwish, but to be honest, Floor is better, no matter how much i love tarja voice, i still listen to her music, but Floor is killing it, she sang this song perfectly without back vocals, and on this video Tarja had mistakes, and had a lot of back vocals to support her. For me two of them are great, but as someone said, Tarja dont give me goosebumps.
Tarja's version arouses so much more emotion in me. It's the best version of all. For me, it's just the voice that makes it so much better.
Tarja's version is the OG. i'llgive you that, but there is one thing missing... Floorgasms!!
@@anakincubawalker538 Floor who?
I prefer Tarja, but I love Floor's version too. Not sure why one would have to choose between two awesome voice when you can literally have both
Tarja's voice is like there's no emotion high note but flat feeling... Also her voice now is so weak and broken and I'm really sorry for saying this... Floors voice is like "emotions talking"
@@vasilis428You have it all wrong. Tarja has gotten better, even past her age, her stroke and many other issues she's had.
Floor is badass singing Valkyre and Tarja is majestic Nordic goddess :)
I love Tarja ♥️
Great reaction!! 😢 I love Tarja too ❤♥
No more words, Mr. Judge, TARJA TURUNEN !!!!
I love both Tarja and Floor. It should be remembered that at the recording of this version, Tarja had flu so wasn't at her best.
Excuses always come out.
Le1fur but she did wonderful it’s a profesional singer
@@patgrt83 there is petty, and then there's what you just did.
Dave Ghrol from foo fighter break a facking leg on secound song on concert, and with pain and a guy holding his leg he finish the concert of 3 hours. Flu is an excuse.
@@patgrt83 What excuses. Even sick and Floor sounds like Dutch Beyonce.
Love both of them obviously, but I just have a soft spot for Tarja, because she’s the first singer I‘ve heard with Nightwish and I absolutely love her voice, because it’s so unique and beautiful!❤️
When i first heard Floor do this song, i was impressed with her rock and roll vocals, BUT, after hearing TARJA do this song, i am BLOWN AWAY WITH THE SOUND OF HER ENCHANTED AND MYSTICAL VOICE!!!!!!! WOW!!!!! She takes you away to another magical realm with castles and fairy tales!!!! So BEAUTIFUL to have Nightwish combined with the Magical Voice of QUEEN TARJA's ENCHANTING MAGICAL AND MYSTICAL VOICE!!!😊👍👍👍
Tarja's era of Nightwish was like a beautiful dream inside a bubble or me. Once she left, the bubble burst. For me, nobody can ever replace or surpass her as vocalist for Nightwish.
Tarja's and Floor's versions are different arrangements. In End of an Era Tarja sings the loud choir version, here she sings the same quiet choir versions as Floor: 2004 Montreal th-cam.com/video/ox4pOeBYFfI/w-d-xo.html and here 2004 Romania th-cam.com/video/HNfmCF457Fs/w-d-xo.html In the quiet choir version the vocalist's voice is heard much better than in the loud one.
And in End of an Era she unfortunately had the second half of GLS her voice spent (she was in flu).
And that while it was written for Tarja...
@@JHX1
🤣🤣🤣🤣 You dunse! Her voice literally melded into the chorus in the back, not to mention they layered her voice in certain parts where she needed the help. For Floor's live performance all you heard was Floor. The chorus and the instrunents didn't drown her out at all.
@@Aurinkohirvi Are you trying to say if those things you mentioned were tweaked as they were for Floor then Tarja's performance would have been better? I think not!!
Nah floor is just a better fit for this.
@@DynamiteProd They are different versions. Here's is Tarja singing quiet choir version GLS: 2004 Montreal th-cam.com/video/ox4pOeBYFfI/w-d-xo.html and here 2004 Romania th-cam.com/video/HNfmCF457Fs/w-d-xo.html
HalfLIfeSistah I really like your reactions, and I suggest you to see a video of Tarja with her own band performing Stargazers for exemple (there's an amazing performance in Buenos Aires)... Even if it is a fan video it shows how Tarja interacts much more with her crowd in smaller audiences... I've seen both Floor and Tarja Live in concert, and I really like them both and their work with Nightwish, and Floor added her own thing to the older nightwish songs, which was wise from her, and she shines a lot in GLS, no doubt! With songs that are harder or in higher keys, nightwish decided to lower down the keys while performing them with Floor, so she seems to be more comfortable with those songs now (for exemple "sleeping sun" or "she is my sin" or "Stargazers" are performed in lower keys now)... However, if you want to feel the vibe that you get with Oceanborn album, you get it much more if you go to a Tarja concert and listen to Stargazers. It all depends on what period of Nightwish sound you prefer, and I think its Amazing to have a band which already produced so much variety of sound in those different Eras. I really love Nightwish's first four albuns in particular (those are the ones I listen the most), but I also have the more recent ones (I have almost all their studio material actually :D )... So here I leave a link for a Tarja concert, and even if its not the best quality of recording, I think you will get that vibe of Oceanborn Era mixed with Tarja's chemistry with the crowd... I hope you enjoy it! All the Best for you! th-cam.com/video/U7F7EihAYqg/w-d-xo.html
Yes, Tarja Turunen is definitely operatic, since she is classically trained. I love this performance and many others with Nightwish. Anette was interesting and Floor seems to have great chemistry with the band, but Tarja was freaking magic to me. The mix between her voice and the music, and her duets with Marko are great. I love, love her with Nightwish. Oh, those were the days...
Tarja and Floor are very good singers, I love them both ... the difference is noticeable, but we must also take into account the years of difference between one version and the other. thanks for this reaction. My regards from Argentina
Also keep in mind that at this point Tarja was with them for 9 years, was her last show even (since she got the letter right after this show).
And that the performance at Wacken with Floor, that at that time she was singing with the band for just over 6 months cause she filled in for Annet from october 2012 during the Imaginarium tour (what was the show at Wacken part of) and that she wasn't even a member of the band yet (she was asked at the end of the tour). And before she filled in for Annet, she had just 48 hours to learn their songs and they had to reherse during the tour to get used to each other.
@@kerimmejdoub1381 It's true, this woman is really at a superlative level because of her ability and control of her vocal cords. Very impressive.
Aguante Argentina viejaaa... que vuelva Nightwish, y tengo que ver a Tarja en alguna oportunidad. :D
Habla en español wachin
Somos miles los argentinos nightwishteros (the ocean souls) disfrutando de estas obras maestras
I ADORE that chorus. You can really hear it here. Goosebump inducing!
Indeed the background chorus is much, much louder in Tarja's song than Floor's. And there is more of it.
finally the real nightwish
Yeah, I know how you feel... this is one of my favorite songs ever... whether sung by Tarja or Floor, it doesn't matter... it still gives me goosebumps!
TARJA ES LA REINA , UNICA E INIGUALABLE
I love watching your reaction to nightwish. You are musically empathic. You pick up the emotions that Tuomas put into the lyrics and music.
Thank you, love. I'm still so new to all of this. I'm having so much fun!🤗💖
Ghost Love Score is definitely owned by Floor now, but Sleeping Sun and Nemo will forever be Tarja's.
No, Ghost Love Score is Tarja's too.
Please react to "underneath", the studio version. It's one of the most beautiful ballads I've ever heard. It's from Tarja Turunen's solo career. Thank you very much!
l like nightwish for tarja , without her , they was not exist now
Speak for yourself. You Tarja fanatics are nothing but losers. Nightwish has moved on and is still going strong.
@@Dirtnap1986 This is a Tarja video you dumb bitch.
I will forever miss Tarja. Nightwish is never the same without her.
They would never have continued if they didn't let Tarja go.
She has great solo work. Tuomas's work lives on, with a vocalist that expresses and loves the music so much more deeply than Tarja ever did.
Never the same, so much better now.. Floor is flawless.
@@BrunoDAlvim-fv5zg there is no such thing as flawless when it comes to singing.
Unless we're talking about a lost Valkyrie from Valhalla. LoL. Dont get me wrong, Tarja kicks ass in songs like phantom of the opera, Floor’s voice is just more.. dinamic, variable I guess. That spices things up.
I just wish they could have had a good relationship between them to continue with NW from her era a while longer, which is my favorite phase. I appreciate Anette era but it was not really NW for me, even though she did great on the albums and everything was polished to perfection. The new stuff with floor is meh but she did breathe new life to some already amazing classic and perfectly executed tarja era songs so I give her that. If Tarja and NW would reconcile for 1 show it would be so awesome for the OG NW fans that loved them waaaay back when.
I'll be the weird one and say it. I grow up with Nightwish with Tarja, this is the NW i knew first and fell for since '97 (dat awkward time whan Toumas was the male singer) , every time I watch End of an Era and From Wishes to Eternity
, I feel those goosebumps you have with Floor, but always with Tarja. Annette was ok, I really liked Bye Bye beautiful and Amaranth but just that. Floor is magnificent, I like her, but for me, will be always Tarja. Anyway, regardless of the singer, the master of all of this, is Toumas, what a great composer. Singers and musicians can come and go, but he will always take NW to the top.
I think I'm just getting old :x
All the singers are great in their own right and respective styles but I'm with you, Tarja brings that magic and mysterious quality for me more than any other rendition. Anette did a great job and had the perfect fit for Imaginareum if not for early nw material, and now Floor is doing her contemporary rocker thing that the masses love and manages to make early AND Anette era NW songs work with her style, even tho Tarja and Anette had them already perfected in their style. That's Floors greatest strength is that she can make it work to appeal to the average listener whereas the other ladies were more niche singers whose styles and voice types are more of an acquired taste for many people. I think Floor is just easier for the average listener because she's a hybrid pop/rock style thus appeals to casual listeners that either like contemporary or like rock but don't appreciate Tarja classical/operatic approach or Anettes bright spritely sound.
@@ScheisseTyranna I like how you try to make Floor sound generic "appeals to the masses" "appeal to the average listener " while trying to make Tarja and Anette sound one of a kind. "more niche singers" "acquired taste". When Tarja sounds like any other opera singer and Anette sounds like your typical 80's rocker. Please!!
@@ScheisseTyranna I'm sorry but Anette does not have I niche voice. She has a generic swedish pop voice, and she shouldn't be singing outside her house. I get some people prefer Tarja over Floor and vice versa, but Anette doesn't even belong in that conversation. Every Nightwish song she sang she made sound so generic that it's not even funny in a tragic way.
This was when Nightwish was TRULY NIGHTWISH, and magical at it's VERY BEST!!!
love your reactions Sistah. keep going!! regards from Spain
In background, it's Taria's voice.
I really love Taria's version, this is the right one, it's simply amazing.
So... If you think that Floor sing higher, maybe, because Floor may sing that what she want, Tarja had must sing the way that Tuomas wanted, she no had a freedom in Nightwish... You may listen some her solo performances, some classical/operatic from her symphonic concerts, or rock/metal like her version of "Supremacy" by Muse, live from Woodstock 2016, it's amazing performance.
Just compare Floors Phantom of the Opera with Tarjas if we're talking high notes 👀 Tarja made that song her bitch even when she was sick w flu!
Tuomas had her locked down with no freedom? Yeah okay. They built the band around that broads voice for crying out loud!! Stop making excuses. Tarja can sing in her own right and this song might have been written for her voice but she did it no justice with her operatic style. Not to mention her timing.....completely off.
@@ScheisseTyranna
And there are plenty of other singers who are operaticlly trained who can hit those high notes just as well 🤷♀️. Stop trying to make Tarja sound one of a kind because she's not!
Dirtnap1986 Please, listen Nightwish songs from album "Angel Fall First" and from "Once", how Tarja's voice has changed, has been less operatic with years. Please also listen Tarja's classical/operatic performances and then you will see what she can, and in non-operatic singing how low voice she has. She told this that in Nightwish she had no freedom.
@@tamashii6670
I don't believe her one bit. If Tuomas was relentless in sticking with this operatic style then why did he have a singer like Anette or even Floor? If anything Tuomas locked himself in when he decided to change the original direction of the band to fit Tarja's voice. Tarja is opera period. Years of training in one specific style is hard to break.
THE BEST: TARJA TURUNEN!
CHILLS ME, SO MUCH EMOTION IN THE VOICE OF THIS GREAT TALENTED WOMAN! 🔝🔝🔝❤️❤️❤️👏👏👏👏👏
What an end of an era..for me THIS IS THE BEST VERSION...
Haha wow :) cool reaction to music I enjoy. You connect to music so passionately !
hey guys, could you react to some of the works of André Matos? He was a brazilian musician, he was a singer, composer, maestro and pianist. He unfortunately passed away 10 days ago and it was a shock for all of his fans world-wide and even people that just knew his bands by name... He played on bands such as Viper(1985-1991), the most famous one Angra(1991-2000), Shaman(2000-2006), then his solo career, besides another projects like Virgo, Symfonia and a project with the guys from an american prog metal band called Sieges Even. He was just 47 years old... He really loved his country and was proud to show the world what we're capable of musically, even with all the music degradation across the globe, he was persistent, yet with his death the media didn't care at all, at max a channel made a homage of 3 minutes, but nothing more than that... The politicians even less, it's pretty sad and if you could react to one or some of his work would be awesome and it would mean the world for his fans such as myself. My request is this Make Believe from Angra live or Shaman - Fairy Tale live, I'd send you the album version but I'd like you to see André Matos and how his perfomance was. People might have another requests, I would put all the requests from him here aswell but I know you do a video per reaction, so these are good ones in my opinion
They should definetely do!
Tarja the best !
She was ill during this gig which makes it even more impressive!
My loves! 😀
The Greatest Show oin Earth will be exited and presented to you all very very soon! 😘💖✊🏾🤘🏾
In an interview with Floor she did state that this was her favorite song.
i remember i get the DVD of End of an Era, and was so magical, that was around 2006, i was young, (ahhh youth) and i was in love with nightwish (even now), this song is so magical, tarja is so magical, (love floor too), nightwish was undertismated for many many years, but it´s nice ppl know them now too, keep listen tarja,, she is solist, marko too, tuomas has a band called "auri" is so good, so f....g good, i recommend all you that if like nightwish listem to them too, thanks for you react! bye all
i just love tarja... and i love your reactions sistah :)
That emotion and soul Tarja delievers in this song is just beyond amazing, goosebumps for sure. The other singers in Nightwish can't give me that feeling even if Floor is outstanding too
se siente bien , ver a alguien que ama la musica
love to see you getting so emotional, yes that's one touching music 😎👍
This song was 100% Tarja's song and Floor just can not ever achieve those levels. People must and people do get it. NOTHING can beat a beautiful female soprano with metal music. Floor is just a voice within soooooo many other similar voices. Tarja is not in that pool, Tarja is in higher class. You know it, you all. Don't fight it. Tarja's song and Tarja 4ever.
100%
Found you looking at Night wish music...your flipping amazing lol. I think we would be BFFs 💖
best version ever!
I love to see your reaction!!! Please do videos for Tarja's new solo songs "Dead Promises" and "Railroads"...love
you should react to her singing kuolema tekee taiteilijan next :D
Tarja is symphonic rock, and floor is rock
What a voice that woman has bloody hell!
she is epic, an old soul
Girl I love your reaction you are amazing
You said the "D" word, Sistah: DETAIL! Nightwish is so full of them.
I absolutely love to watch your reactions and especially Nightwish reactions. Have you yet seen any videos from Tarot, Marco's band?
This version is totally different than Floor's. The key is changed to adapt to Floor's vocals and even Floor changed the style. Tarja sang it as it was meant to sound originally. Floor is a great singer she can't make justice to the best nightwish albums IMO (angels fall first, oceanborn and wishmaster).
Agreed. Floor's a great singer, but her voice just isn't dark enough.
i love your reaction
Tarja the best!!!
Please react to "underneath", the studio version. This is one of the most beautiful Tarja Turunen's songs. It's from her solo career. I never saw anyone reacting to this. It is really a beautiful song, with a beautiful message. It's poetry. And we need poetry to warm our hearts in this quarantine.
Both singers have their own unique and beautiful styles. Floor, for me, has a way of bringing a new dimension of emotion and stage presence. Nothing against Tarja, not ever. She, too, is incredible in her own way.
I initially couldn’t get into Nightwish years ago cause Tarja’s style was too intense for me (I was into rock and metal, but not necessarily that style yet). Since my personal taste in music has changed over the years, with me really diving headfirst into Symphonic (type) Metal in 2008/9 with Leaves’ Eyes and Epica as my first official experience with it...I’ve come to respect and appreciate it more. Tarja and Nightwish really helped pave a path for them, so I’m grateful for them. I found Leaves’ Eyes through Cradle Of Filth (Nymphetamine Fix feat. Liv Kristine).
this song was not meant to be sang aggressively..if it was, Tarja would step it up profoundly, as she did in end of all hope and 10th man down
Great reaction! I think you are right on point with your analysis !
Looking forward to see your´s (and your hubbys) reaction to "Greatest show on earth". :)
I dislike Comparisons..But sometimes They're Unavoidable. Tarja has a lovely voice BUT FLOOR took this song and made it EPIC.❤️🔥
Yea I love Tarja and Floor, but here's the thing... before floor came around to nightwish, this performance gave everyone chills because it just ends on such a magical level... but whats a bit unfair (yet amazing) is that floor took what this song already was and DID bring it to the next level, because as Floor has mentioned, she wants to make the songs her own too (and I understand that because as a professional vocalist, I'm sure she's not trying to mimic the tonality and inflections of every note as tarja's, so I get that)... But as we all know, the studio version was constructed in the very same manner as it was performed here at the End of an Era Concert, so no one would ever expect Tarja to belt out "TIME TO NEVER HOLD OUR LOVVVEEE" or give you that last Floorgasm bit at the end... and yet the weird part about it is that this performance now feels like its "missing" Something because Floor did in fact do an amazing job in doing her own interpretation. I'm sure people have also accustomed themselves to how Floor starts off the chorus just a tad bit sooner than Tarja when singing "...mmmmyyyyyyy Fallllll" ... so yea, I just want to say that I LOVE both versions, but also point out how a bit unfair it is for tarja.... and who knowwss if after some time Tarja would have made her own little spins on this song (considering it was still a fresh track since it was the last album she recorded with them), butttt that's speculations! Great reaction nonetheless! Love it!
As a professional singer, what other differences you notice in Floor's and Tarja's versions arrangements?
Tarja didn't need to oversing to make that song a classic 😆 Floor brought a cool element to it but people get waaaay too caught up in that end flourish, Tarja was definitely singing everything just the way Tuomas wanted it and could have blown floors end note out of the water if she had the chance, just like she blew floors choked, sour phantom rendition out of the water with that beautiful sustained high note she did in End of an Era.
Tarja is a classically trained Full Lyric Soprano singing this song bel canto...she does not belt.
Tarja and floor are just amazing, tarja has more clasical tone to her voice
this song was made for someone like tarja
Floor's version does not give up toward the end like Tarja did. Floor keeps belting and hits the high belt that Tarja leaves off. And, Half Life Sista, listen to Floor sing Phantom of the Opera with Henk Poort on "Beste Zangers".
You said it!
This song was for Tarja, but she never could take it to a level Floor have done.
Yeah it was rearranged for Floor.
I Love You and your reaction too!!!
I saw your Floor reaction. Was hoping you watched Tarja too. Thanks.
Tarja’s is the one that made Nightwish sound beautiful.
As a Nightwish fan since they released Century Child, I was completely lost for words when I listened to this song for the first time (and I still am). If I am not mistaken, this was the first song they released with Floor singing. I am also a long-time Floor's fanboy, since when she was leading After Forever. And I was super excited when I first knew she was touring with Nightwish after Anette's departure from the band. I think in that video they wanted to highlight Floor as the new singer. In the original version, I feel Tarja is part of the song just like the rest of the band, and I think this is awesome. Of course, our experience with this song is completely different, because you heard Floor's version before. When I heard Floor's for the first time, it gave me goosebumps, I was blown away, and my only reaction was: "wow, what did they do to this song? (in the most positive way as possible)". But when I go back to Tarja's (specially in this concert), it just breaks my heart, mostly because it was her last concert with Nightwish and this is still my favorite song from them up to this day.
Summing up: Floor's version blows me every time I listen to it;. Tarja's version just make me feel like a heartbroken child who can't stop crying. Love them both and I am so grateful from both of my favorite symhonic metal singers have perfomed this.
Thank you, Sistah, for reacting to this version as well. I was super happy when I looked for a Tarja's reaction of this song and your channel was the first one in my search. Love you channel, keep it up!
Do disturbed "the sound of silence" 93 milliion views on connan show live. IT'S AMAZING!!
TARJA!! 100%!
Nightwish became a mainstream metal band after "The End Of an Era" . Just my humble opinion.
After dark passion play*
It could be mainstream and good, but in this case, is not, nightwish is just another pop band without passion, now days
Fernando Del Real
You really are stupid lmao
Can't wait to see your reaction to TGSOE
Floor is talented but Tarja.. God she's out of this world!!!!
Floor is out of this galaxy
@@LeN0Re18 Then why are you here?
I just compare the two live version from DVD releases ... for me Floor's version is way better. And Floor's final on this song is absolutely insane.
Don't really know Nightwish and Tarja, but what I think is that Tarja can do Opera, but Floor can do Opera, rock song, metal, and so more things with her voice
All hail THE REAL TRUE AND ENCHANTING QUEEN of Nightwish!!! TARJA the mysteriously mythical voice of from another beautiful enchanting realm!!!😌👍
I'd cry when Tarja Is gone
I am one of those ppl who loves Taria's version of these song
And that's totally fine!!😀❤
Tarja's version is infinitely better.
No, no. They did good changes to Floor's version. Absolutely.
@@Aurinkohirvi They had to, or else the chorus would be so loud Floor's voice would have been drowned out.
I've since learned they had these two versions of background chorus (loud and silent & partly missing) already in Tarja's era. The loud one is used both in the audio album and End of an Era. But for example Romania and Montreal gigs use the same silent as Floor had.
You definitely need to see "Rammstein" by Rammstein from "Live Aus Berlin 1998" - that's was really awesome performance. :) \m/
Gracias por tu video, 👍
This is the original (close to album) version and so awesome with feeling and amazing harmony (also in the end with backing). I just wonder that after this concert all changed (audience thinks that all is right in 6:07 for instance). The whole concert peaks when the glitter comes down...that is the higest moment they did. Sadly because the continuous dress change in this concert (maybe six or seven times) Tarja had to "run" away so quickly from the stage so often.
Tarja in the original version is the best version. It was written for her voice
Floor is a really good singer but Tarja is just a thousand times better
Tarja is originally from an operatic background. Nightwish, even though is still great, will never be the same without her :(
Get over it. Nightwish is no longer stagnant and locked down by just one style of singing. All of you loving Tarja's operatic style is the same one's that wouldn't even make it through an opera show without falling asleep.
@@Dirtnap1986 Throw another temper tantrum pussy.
@Ariel Wainzinger Floor would not have a career if not for Tarja trailblazing.
So you two (declared atheists) are gonna do "The Greatest Show On Earth", right? 😋
Recording it, tomorrow!🙃💖✊🏾🤘🏾
Tarja is the best!!!
Always has been!
STACCATO FROM THE END THIS EPIC
Guys, you absolutely have to react to Painkiller. It's just the perfect metal song. It needs to be done! (love your channel, by the way)
The emotion is real!!!
Please, do a react of a André Matos song! He was a great brazilian singer, pianist and maestro, but sadly passed away recently. He was and always will be one of the best singers of the world. I bet he will make you cry. 😂
I love them both. Floor gave me chills but Tarja was my intro to Nightwish back in 2004.
Two very different eras of my life. Floor is a perfect fit for Nightwish. Tarja was super classical and I know the song was written for Tarja’s voice but you gotta admit that Floor really brought that song to a whole new level
The first Nightwish song I heard, if only a snippet from before hearing it all, was Over the Hills and Far Away but, Ghost Love Score, live at Wacken 2013 was THE SONG that got me hooked and, deservedly so...after my jaw hit the floor partly due to hearing my first Floorgasm, lol.
Lawrence Walston same here bro!!!!!
For more than 10 years I listened to Ghost love score with Tarja. GLS is my favorite song. When I listened to Floor's version I've erased all! I listen to only Floor's version. The way Floor sing, perform, live the song is Absolutely amazing. Ghost love score is written for Floor!
So you listened it so many times, did you notice the different arrangements in the songs?
Смотришь на нее и сам ревешь ) Андрюша 33 годика
Also, just letting you know that all of the offshoot bands that are associated with this one are also really good and they are: Marco Hietala: Northern Kings and Tarot, and Emppu Vuorinen: Brother Firetribe.
Shaman - Fairy Tale Live version
Live não mano, gravadinho tudo redondinho e completo é melhor, não?!
You should react to the spirits carries on of dream theater!
Yeah, Sistah, I can completely understand your feelings. I love all of them, all the 3 singers, but this particular song was made for Floor. She gives it more energy.