Can’t remember his name, but the Judo instructor of Bruce’s first student was asked about Bruce’s grappling and ground game, and the guy basically said he was decent at stand-up grappling, he sucked at ground game grappling, but he was too fast for most guys to be able to reliably take him down, which I thought was cool.
I gotta watch these movies now! I have only seen the first Ip Man movie...I didn't know Bruce was in the narrative! super cool. Thanks for this video, it's always fun to hear instructors break down fight scenes from movies.
@@RiveBassCovers But this movie timeline is different, IP man should be about 20 years younger than the real life, so in Ip man 1, he was about 25, and in this one, he was around 50. If you are talking about real life time line, Bruce was in Hong Kong making movies in early 70, instead of teaching martial art in san francisco.
I am so glad you pointed out the nunchuck thing. Lol. If I'm not mistaken, he was really big on the idea of having the whip stick to wrap around blocks on the half beat around this time? (Which I assume is actually supposed to be 1964 given the exhibition, so I think this is the year he would've met Dan but not yet been actively training with him.)
Hitting some one in the head, is leaving yourself wide open to attack, esp fighting someone else who has done martial arts, even some street fighter can see it coming and counter it.
Are you sure bro? Danny Chan kwok-kwan playing as Bruce Lee is a Martial Artist he is a Jeet kune do practitioner also & he played not only for that Ip man 3 & 4 movies as Bruce lee but also portrayed The Legend of Bruce Lee in 2008 television series produced by Bruce lee daughter the one & only SHANNON LEE.
@@Anton-ce1np I am 100% sure. I’ve pored over his technique in every episode and appearance as Bruce Lee. It is NEVER him when there are spin kicks involved. Even in the alley street fight, none of the kicks are particularly high, and he never spins. Danny Chan can pull off the hands, but not the legs. He was a dancer first, which made it easier for him to transition to martial arts, but yeah, I’m sure. I’m huge into the fine details of fighting mechanics.
@6:25mins - That is continuous switch step combined with turning stance on the balls of your feet: Classic Wing Chun foot work. Not that this guy knows BTW.
I wonder if this guy is an actual licenced JKD instructor? I have met them before and they are not versed in Wing Chun. I can say this as I am a Master of 4 styles of Wing Chun. Bruce Lee used the Sui Nim Tao and Chum Cui with the 4 sections of the Mook Jong he was taught and based JKD off this. And as I am aware there are only 7 actual authorised JKD instructors on the Planet i.e., authorised by Bruce Lee. So, is this gent a JKD instructor or a You Tuber that practices what he sees on videos?
There are more than 7 authorized JKD instructors. Some of bruces students teach someone who teaches someone. idk about the Channel host's lineage but mine is, Bruce Lee>Dan Inosanto>kevin seaman>Raffi Diederman>Collin Liberman> Me. Im going to assume the channel host stems from the Inosanto Lineage aswell given his affinity for Kali.
@@kidddogbites I have an affinity for Kali and Escrima, as my master trained with Dan Inosanto; Ip Chun; Ip Ching; Samuel Kwok; Sabhir Ahktar; Gary Lamb; Royce Gracie; Robert Chu; William Chung; and many others - especially in the Wing Chun World. I was personally awarded my master instructorship from Ip Chun and Samuel Kwok. This is why I put the comments on that I did as he did not know the name of the techniques that were obvious to see, but obviously difficult for this gent to define in his "expertise". He doesn't seem genuine to me. Sorry to berate him but he is uneducated in the field of Wing Chun and what Bruce Lee was taught of Wing Chun - which was not all of it BTW. Bruce Lee was only taught Sui Lim Tao, Chum Cui; and 4 sections of the Mook Jong. If this gent realise this he would know how Bruce adapted what he knew in to Wing Chun to develop intercepting fist. But, as this gent does not appreciate this he has no understanding of how interception works - as interception with the fist is a concept from Wing Chun i.e., hitting through the hit. If this gent cannot pinpoint the area you look so you can intercept then he is going to continue trying to intercept the opponents attack rather than what his interception should be intercepting - which isn't the opponent attack BTW.
I really enjoyed this i don't know much about jkd because haven't had the chance to study it so I liked how you broke down the moves from a jkd practitioner stand point
This movie is one giant Chinese propaganda tract. As a JKD rpractioner since 2005 I still can't watch this movie without a clear contentious. That being said, who doesn't love Bruce ? The casting is good but this sequence ignores all the Wing Chun he practiced. At this point in his life this fight would look much more like Wing Chun and not like the films he did later. Had he incorporated fencing footwork and savate kicks yet?
The guy who played Bruce Lee here is Danny Chan Kwok Kwan, well known for his resemblance to the former. He even wore Bruce Lee’s Game of Death jumpsuit in Shaolin Soccer, and played Bruce Lee in a TV series
What do you guys think of a possible WONG SHUN LEUNG FILM? Which would be connected to the Ip Man series. Hey Sifu Stahl, you should do a video on Wong Shun Leung. Thanks!
That would be cool. They did make a sequal about the student of Yuen Kay San that was defeated in the 3rd movie. It's highly fictionalized, but supposedly the character is based on Sum Nung. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master_Z:_Ip_Man_Legacy
Have you seen the Grandmaster, or the last dragon or the Bruce Lee series on Netflix, or Dragon the Bruce Lee story, an older movie called Bruce Lee the man the myth the legend
I appreciate the bit about Guru Dan and the nunchaku, but I think a little wording difference may be needed. I wouldn’t necessarily think Guru Dan was the one who exposed him to the nunchaku, just the one who trained him. Guru Dan recounted that he taught Bruce a set and Bruce practiced it obsessively overnight to perfection for filming the next day. I’m sure Bruce would’ve been exposed to the nunchaku earlier than meeting Guru Dan. However, I’m not saying he trained with them pre-Inosanto badassery, but I’m sure he’d be aware of them and a few other flails from Chinese and other Asian martial arts. Anyway, I loved this movie and appreciate your take on it, especially the technical aspects that they included. Oh and the collabs are fantastic. I particularly like how you’re warming Icy Mike up to JKD 😂
It’s a shame there isn’t enough media depictions of Dan Inosanto as there is Bruce Lee. The man’s life is filled with marital arts movie tropes: trained since a kid, a part of a prestigious military group, brought validity to an obscure martial art, and spends his elder years being a grandmaster of multiple martial arts
Actually, the Jing energy that powers the "one inch punch" is used continuously in an ON/OFF pattern. Therefore, Wing Chun Jing energy that powers the inch punch is used not in emergency situation - as is thought - but in every technique used by a Wing Chunner. Once again, not like this guy knows.
Can’t remember his name, but the Judo instructor of Bruce’s first student was asked about Bruce’s grappling and ground game, and the guy basically said he was decent at stand-up grappling, he sucked at ground game grappling, but he was too fast for most guys to be able to reliably take him down, which I thought was cool.
I gotta watch these movies now! I have only seen the first Ip Man movie...I didn't know Bruce was in the narrative! super cool. Thanks for this video, it's always fun to hear instructors break down fight scenes from movies.
Chin Na would have been in the taijiquan training. I could be wrong but that is where I learned to grapple. Love your channel keep up the good work.
Thanks much!!
this is not 50s, its mid 60s, cuz bruce was a kid in Hong Kong back in the 50s.
It’s early 70’s. Ip Man died from cancer in this movie and that happened in 1972
@@RiveBassCovers But this movie timeline is different, IP man should be about 20 years younger than the real life, so in Ip man 1, he was about 25, and in this one, he was around 50.
If you are talking about real life time line, Bruce was in Hong Kong making movies in early 70, instead of teaching martial art in san francisco.
I am so glad you pointed out the nunchuck thing. Lol. If I'm not mistaken, he was really big on the idea of having the whip stick to wrap around blocks on the half beat around this time? (Which I assume is actually supposed to be 1964 given the exhibition, so I think this is the year he would've met Dan but not yet been actively training with him.)
While the first was accurate around 50% the second was just 20%. The third part was almost complete fictional and so was the fourth part.
Thanks for your analysis. You take me back to my childhood memory :)
Do more of these please!
Would it be alright that you share more about yourself? Thanks!
Sure! To both.... 🤜💥🤛
He actually fought like Bruce Lee here if not really really really close 😊😊😊😊😊😊
Green Hornet where Bruce Lee kicked the light.
Jeet kune do 👍👍
Taekwondo kicks from Bruce lee is Great
Hitting some one in the head, is leaving yourself wide open to attack, esp fighting someone else who has done martial arts, even some street fighter can see it coming and counter it.
Ed you Fantastic
Thank you sir! I hope you are well!
@5:33mins - That was called a nailing kick BTW. Shows how much Wing Chun you have done sir.
I haven't done a lot, I'm a jkd guy
The actor playing Bruce Lee can't do the kicks all that well. It was a double doing the kicks against the 3 karate guys.
I could see that. Kicks are hard
Are you sure bro? Danny Chan kwok-kwan playing as Bruce Lee is a Martial Artist he is a Jeet kune do practitioner also & he played not only for that Ip man 3 & 4 movies as Bruce lee but also portrayed The Legend of Bruce Lee in 2008 television series produced by Bruce lee daughter the one & only SHANNON LEE.
@@Anton-ce1np I dunno. 🤷♂️ That can be typical in film, but I don't know anything about this guy
@@Anton-ce1np I am 100% sure. I’ve pored over his technique in every episode and appearance as Bruce Lee. It is NEVER him when there are spin kicks involved. Even in the alley street fight, none of the kicks are particularly high, and he never spins. Danny Chan can pull off the hands, but not the legs. He was a dancer first, which made it easier for him to transition to martial arts, but yeah, I’m sure. I’m huge into the fine details of fighting mechanics.
the green hornet!
@6:25mins - That is continuous switch step combined with turning stance on the balls of your feet: Classic Wing Chun foot work. Not that this guy knows BTW.
I do know. Way more than you think I do 😂
“We don’t know he’s-he’s dead😐…”
bruh😂
Yip never set foot in America.
Yeah lol I'm pretty sure you're right lol
Man-ure-isms lol
Lol
I wonder if this guy is an actual licenced JKD instructor? I have met them before and they are not versed in Wing Chun. I can say this as I am a Master of 4 styles of Wing Chun. Bruce Lee used the Sui Nim Tao and Chum Cui with the 4 sections of the Mook Jong he was taught and based JKD off this. And as I am aware there are only 7 actual authorised JKD instructors on the Planet i.e., authorised by Bruce Lee. So, is this gent a JKD instructor or a You Tuber that practices what he sees on videos?
I'm a JKD instructor my dude.
There are more than 7 authorized JKD instructors. Some of bruces students teach someone who teaches someone. idk about the Channel host's lineage but mine is,
Bruce Lee>Dan Inosanto>kevin seaman>Raffi Diederman>Collin Liberman> Me.
Im going to assume the channel host stems from the Inosanto Lineage aswell given his affinity for Kali.
@@kidddogbites my lineage:
Bruce Lee > Dan Inosanto > Scott Shields > Me
Bruce Lee > Dan Inosanto > Ron Balicki > Me
Bruce Lee > Dan Inosanto > Me
@@metrolinamartialarts Very cool you've had the opportunity to study directly with Dan Inosanto. Keep fighting the good fight my brother.
@@kidddogbites I have an affinity for Kali and Escrima, as my master trained with Dan Inosanto; Ip Chun; Ip Ching; Samuel Kwok; Sabhir Ahktar; Gary Lamb; Royce Gracie; Robert Chu; William Chung; and many others - especially in the Wing Chun World. I was personally awarded my master instructorship from Ip Chun and Samuel Kwok. This is why I put the comments on that I did as he did not know the name of the techniques that were obvious to see, but obviously difficult for this gent to define in his "expertise". He doesn't seem genuine to me. Sorry to berate him but he is uneducated in the field of Wing Chun and what Bruce Lee was taught of Wing Chun - which was not all of it BTW. Bruce Lee was only taught Sui Lim Tao, Chum Cui; and 4 sections of the Mook Jong. If this gent realise this he would know how Bruce adapted what he knew in to Wing Chun to develop intercepting fist. But, as this gent does not appreciate this he has no understanding of how interception works - as interception with the fist is a concept from Wing Chun i.e., hitting through the hit. If this gent cannot pinpoint the area you look so you can intercept then he is going to continue trying to intercept the opponents attack rather than what his interception should be intercepting - which isn't the opponent attack BTW.
Dude talks way to damn much
Which dude?
Bro just stop, you cant be jeet kun do instructor, you have no jeet kun do master....
Oh lord. I'm not sure what Jeet Kun Do is buddy. You don't seem to either considering you can't spell it lol
@@metrolinamartialarts cuz im Polish SO maybe, popiszemy sobie po Polsku i jeśli dasz radę to możesz być dalej taki cwany :)
@@kosimazaki8093 I'm not Polish, so I think I'll continue to write in English. もしかして日本語の方がいいかな⁉️
お前、俺のチャネルに来てバカなこと貼ってたんだけどさー 言語変わりたいって言った❔ふざけな～お前
@@metrolinamartialarts I think so American boy, 1 language and still try to lecture xD i know 4
@@kosimazaki8093 whatever buddy. So I don't have a jeet kun do master, huh?
Yip man 100% never went to America. Fun movie though.
Yeah that's what I thought
Where did you see the 4th one at how did you find out about it
If Bruce trained with Gene LeBell and those other high-ranking grapplers. I’m sure he got something good out of it.
I really enjoyed this i don't know much about jkd because haven't had the chance to study it so I liked how you broke down the moves from a jkd practitioner stand point
This movie took place in 1972, because at the end Ip Man passed away from cancer. Bruce Lee actually passed away 7 months after Ip Man did
This movie is one giant Chinese propaganda tract. As a JKD rpractioner since 2005 I still can't watch this movie without a clear contentious. That being said, who doesn't love Bruce ? The casting is good but this sequence ignores all the Wing Chun he practiced. At this point in his life this fight would look much more like Wing Chun and not like the films he did later. Had he incorporated fencing footwork and savate kicks yet?
no he wouldn't actually. Ip man 4 was when ip man had cancer and was close to dying. Bruce lee died shortly after ip man so do the math genius
@@naeemislam1105 I don't know... Wikipedia and IMDB say that the movie is set in 1964...
This movie is not historically accurate at all lol but it's a great movie.
Fictional Yip Man can fight 10 karate black belt at once, why are you questioning weather he can fight Mike Tyson?
The guy who played Bruce Lee here is Danny Chan Kwok Kwan, well known for his resemblance to the former. He even wore Bruce Lee’s Game of Death jumpsuit in Shaolin Soccer, and played Bruce Lee in a TV series
That light was in his eyes and that door was closed, Bruce kicked the light on Marlow and in Way of the Dragon
Wow very good react bro!!!
13:04 my favourite Bruce Lee kick the way of the dragon.🔥🔥🔥
Asians were targeted for violence in the '60s - but probably not by dudes wearing karate gis. Unless it was Count Dante...
What do you guys think of a possible WONG SHUN LEUNG FILM? Which would be connected to the Ip Man series. Hey Sifu Stahl, you should do a video on Wong Shun Leung. Thanks!
That would be cool. They did make a sequal about the student of Yuen Kay San that was defeated in the 3rd movie. It's highly fictionalized, but supposedly the character is based on Sum Nung. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master_Z:_Ip_Man_Legacy
The light kick was first in Marlowe, starring James Garner and then in Way (Return) of the Dragon.
In this movie.. why is there a hanging light there in the alley, and what's it hanging from?
@@des6853 In both movies it is in an office space. th-cam.com/video/wdTGFG0Y4Ao/w-d-xo.html
@@ronrodriguez8971 no, i'm saying in Ip Man 4 it's hanging outside.. but it is out of place.
In ‘Marlowe’ Bruce played Winslow Wong where he kicked the light in James Garner’s office and in ‘Way of the Dragon’ he did the same thing.
Really glad to see your videos! Thank you!
Thank you!!
Have you seen the Grandmaster, or the last dragon or the Bruce Lee series on Netflix, or Dragon the Bruce Lee story, an older movie called Bruce Lee the man the myth the legend
I've seen Grandmaster and hated it. So long and nothing happened. I haven't seen the Bruce Lee series. But I have seen Dragon! Good fun movie.
Osu!
Ed, please react to The Raid 2 final fight scene. I would love to hear the perspective of a JKD instructor in a silat based fight scene.
I'll take a look at it!!
Nobody cares about your silat.
The actor who did Bruce Lee is Kung Fu Hustle I think
Shaolin Soccer
T'es un gamin 😃😃😃👍👍👍
🤜💥🤛
JkD is not a system or style da.
Ok
I appreciate the bit about Guru Dan and the nunchaku, but I think a little wording difference may be needed. I wouldn’t necessarily think Guru Dan was the one who exposed him to the nunchaku, just the one who trained him. Guru Dan recounted that he taught Bruce a set and Bruce practiced it obsessively overnight to perfection for filming the next day. I’m sure Bruce would’ve been exposed to the nunchaku earlier than meeting Guru Dan. However, I’m not saying he trained with them pre-Inosanto badassery, but I’m sure he’d be aware of them and a few other flails from Chinese and other Asian martial arts. Anyway, I loved this movie and appreciate your take on it, especially the technical aspects that they included. Oh and the collabs are fantastic. I particularly like how you’re warming Icy Mike up to JKD 😂
And cooling him off at the same time 🤣
@@metrolinamartialarts PFFHAH! I didn’t even realize I said that 😂
It’s a shame there isn’t enough media depictions of Dan Inosanto as there is Bruce Lee. The man’s life is filled with marital arts movie tropes: trained since a kid, a part of a prestigious military group, brought validity to an obscure martial art, and spends his elder years being a grandmaster of multiple martial arts
lol, interception is not countering with a technique. You intercept the opponents core movements, not their technique lol.
K
Actually, the Jing energy that powers the "one inch punch" is used continuously in an ON/OFF pattern. Therefore, Wing Chun Jing energy that powers the inch punch is used not in emergency situation - as is thought - but in every technique used by a Wing Chunner. Once again, not like this guy knows.
You must know it all 😅🤣
@@metrolinamartialarts Looks like someone protests to much.
@@garytyme9384 too*
@@metrolinamartialarts there's the immaturity I expect from a faker.
the fuck does this mean lmao