Remembering this era is a gift of my generation, The music was made with so much passion and was "so us" . The kids thses days might listen to it but never hear it. those that do hear it are truly gifted..
Shut the fuck up and stop saying "kids these days will never understand X" you are embarrassing us older generations. "Kids these days" have better response to what they have than we did. As a matter of fact, behind all of these good things we remember we hide so many bad decisions, bad influences, problems and deceptions. We choose to forget them and still hold new generations accountable of the behavior of a few as if it were the norm. Don't treat liking a specific kind of music of a mean to feel better about yourself.
Back in the 70s, when you saw one of the great prog bands, you usually sat in awe during the whole concert. When Marillion performed, the audience was also a major part of the experience. On their feet, and singing along. Continued with solo Fish, and the audience excitement continued also with Hogart Marillion. This was even more awesome.
I'm 34 now and was raised on Marillion. I proud to have been around to enjoy this era. Only recently I went to see The Fishheads in Brighton, and all I can say, he still got it.
BEEN LUCKY enough tosee MARILLION,accompanied by VAN DER GRAAF, OH what a WEEK THAT was,FROM LONDON TO CARDIFF,and WE got to meet BOTH BANDS, brilliance extraordinaire,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
José Vieira Fish himself compared themselves to Genesis in their early days, similar but different. I am happy to enjoy both!! Only Genesis has to be with Gabriel, not afterwards!!
Genesis were light years ahead of them ! There’s no comparison,’ even fish giggled when his band was compared to Genesis, Genesis were true top shelf musicians and writers, no one came close ! Not Pink Floyd or Yes or ELP ! Marrillion were the best of the new wave of proggers in the 80’s along with several others I used to follow at the marquee club, Inc IQ, Pendragon, Solstice, Jadis, the Enid, and few others, Marrillion made it because EMI signed them with the aim for releasing singles in mind for the charts. I followed them all for years, until prog died a 2nd Death. I don’t see much around today of the standard of the early 80’s, it’s more prog metal or cheesy.
@@tiplady you right.but Marillon was a prog rock band.like iron maiden or scorpions was heavy metal har rock band.you hace place for everybody in one category.now you have the reference of diferent styles like genesis in prog.or led zeppelin in hard rock heavy metal muzic.so for mee ay dont like to compare.everybody ave something to give to is muzic style
All I can say is check out the end of Grendel when Marillion tries sadly to mimic Apocalypse in 9/8 from Supper's ready. The rhythmic accents, the chords underneath, the mask, are all a thinly veiled copy.
Well, i think that is because the ten years or more of difference.....behind the Supper`s was the Beatles and all the rockandroll thing......but behind Marillion was Genesis, Emerson Lake and Palmer, Yes, etc etc
I agree , Marillion with Derek Dick was really something good - but maybe the Fish swam a little to much in the drink later on and maybe thats why they parted
@botman9822 You mean the 3 words(second line) he sings a little softer than the rest?? If that`s pissed, i`m wondering what i`m now then...ow yeah..completely wasted
It's a great performance of a great song , Fish screws up the lyrics , no "edgy eggs and queing cumbers " but so what ? Performance isn't about perfection , it's about passion & how it's delivered and this delivers in massive quantities !
Very different from Genesis yet also similar in some ways. Fish is a genius and a visionary so is Peter Gabriel. Comparing and trying to make judgements of ill-mindedness about who is better is stupid. I love both bands and I am a serious progressive freak. This song features the tall thin Scotsman trashing the pretensions and failings of the English upper class in a very funny and brilliant way. For whatever this is worth and I think it's worth it's weight in gold let me say this: storm the industry, take it down, and bring back actually played, written, and sung by humans music! Computerized shitting of the pants must go out the window!
Fish could certainly put on a hell of a performance. As well as being a great singer and lyricist. The music is as tight as a ducks ass as well. Brilliantly played. An all time prog rock classic.
Fish was the first. He was a perfect for the time. Love ROTHERY either way. Marillion is different now but for the time it is perfect. Times and things change just like Marillion. I love both versions.
This was the first Marillion track I ever heard. They were my band of the 80s and saw them live many times throughout the Fish years. . I have friends who continued to follow them after Fish but I just couldn't. He was one of the great front men and had some great solo stuff. Full disclosure, I had a full belt fangirl crush on him.
Love this band, but I can't stand the decision to always keep the focus on the singer when the other members of the band are fun to watch too. Take the synth part around 5 minutes in. They give him shit for screen time and I much rather see his hands playing.
I'm actually hearing this band for the very first time right now.... ... and I'm absolutely loving it. First thing that comes to mind is a Scottish version of 70's Genesis. Suddenly, I feel less nostalgic about early Genesis. What they did in the 80's now seems to make sense. These guys obviously picked up the torch.
This is a bloody great song, best thing they ever did IMO, he has a great voice. They were very brave to do the prog thing in the 80s, when it was so clearly out of fashion.
Era como ver dos shows en uno. Por un lado la banda, pero siempre estabas atento a Fish. Me recuerda a Anderson con Jethro Tull. Vocalistas que más allá de cantar, te contaban una historia. No te Ian necesidad de tirar tres octavas en cada tema.
First heard this, many years ago, on the jukebox in The Raven in Wakefield, and at first thought i'd discovered an unknown Genesis track. Been a Marillion fan ever since........
Muito show.Nunca havia escutado antes.Trabalhei com um cara nos anos 90,que falava muito deles.Hoje ouvi porque apareceu alguém falando a história da banda Fish é um gênio.Show.
Peter's bass lines are some of the most melodic aside from some of McCartney's. Pure spunk, never over the top. I love the way he pulls opens up a chord to make it interesting.
Los mejores años de mi vida con mis amigas y amigos los viví en los jardines de la plaza del Portugalete y sobretodo en los de justo al lado de la Antigua donde sigue creciendo nuestro árbol fuerte y sano aquél que nos vio morirnos de la risa cuando era uno retoño él y nosotros debajo de sus ramas quiero que descansen mis cenizas cuando de este Mundo me vaya !!! Garden Party Always !!! Salud y Vida Pa'lante !!! Cheers and Life On !!!
![[TH] FS vs BME - VCT Ascension Pacific - Lower Bracket Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wnygqsR2Fig/mqdefault.jpg)
Remembering this era is a gift of my generation, The music was made with so much passion and was "so us" . The kids thses days might listen to it but never hear it. those that do hear it are truly gifted..
I hear it
I Love prog as a boy from the 2000s
Shut the fuck up and stop saying "kids these days will never understand X" you are embarrassing us older generations. "Kids these days" have better response to what they have than we did. As a matter of fact, behind all of these good things we remember we hide so many bad decisions, bad influences, problems and deceptions. We choose to forget them and still hold new generations accountable of the behavior of a few as if it were the norm. Don't treat liking a specific kind of music of a mean to feel better about yourself.
Mądre słowa ja słyszę każda frazą dźwięku muzyka solówki gitary ponadczasowe nie znajdziesz tego we współczesnym świecie oj nie j
I totally agree with you. God bless the 80's !
Cant belive that is 83. I feel old.I am old! still listen to them almost every day with Fish on vocals. It just sticks with you!
Back in the 70s, when you saw one of the great prog bands, you usually sat in awe during the whole concert. When Marillion performed, the audience was also a major part of the experience. On their feet, and singing along. Continued with solo Fish, and the audience excitement continued also with Hogart Marillion. This was even more awesome.
70er na so alt bin ich den doch nicht 😂hat mich meine Jugend begleitet so späte 80ziger
Marillion & Fish = Quality Progressive Rock
the best band ever no one gives them the credit thy desrve
Script of a Jester's Tear: one of the best albums ever.!!!!
The best title ever without doubt .
I only discovered it a month ago and now I can’t stop listening to it
@@green2489really!
sign
No doubt
Fish was the true voice of the band.
There are two true Marillions....!
Such a great band and talented Fish.... I wish I had discovered Marillion earlier for myself.
Recital Of The Script,What a wonderfull spectacle (show)...the best i ever see.
This is almost too perfect! Awesome! So fortunate to have seen them with Fish, what a poet and showman!
I'm 34 now and was raised on Marillion. I proud to have been around to enjoy this era. Only recently I went to see The Fishheads in Brighton, and all I can say, he still got it.
I was at this gig...awesome show :) Thanks for posting the vid :)
Fischer.Z und B52 gehört auch noch zu meiner großen Familie an Musik 💓
La mejor epoca de Marillion fué con Fish!! Con su grandiosa voz,creando climas junto con los teclados y demas instrumentos...
Concordo amigo! Nunca existiu outro Fish!!!!!
Sin duda alguna 👍👍👍
Fish era Marillion was legendary!!!
Atmosphere. Period. They were great.
BEEN LUCKY enough tosee MARILLION,accompanied by VAN DER GRAAF, OH what a WEEK THAT was,FROM LONDON TO CARDIFF,and WE got to meet BOTH BANDS, brilliance extraordinaire,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Sums up my teenage years as I left school. Fabulous then & still sounds fabulous.
Montreal 1984. Fish Forever! Boo Hogarth!
Best band ever!!
I get furious when someone compare them with genesis!
Remember this: Marillion with FISH were unique...
Agree
José Vieira Fish himself compared themselves to Genesis in their early days, similar but different. I am happy to enjoy both!! Only Genesis has to be with Gabriel, not afterwards!!
Genesis were light years ahead of them ! There’s no comparison,’ even fish giggled when his band was compared to Genesis, Genesis were true top shelf musicians and writers, no one came close ! Not Pink Floyd or Yes or ELP ! Marrillion were the best of the new wave of proggers in the 80’s along with several others I used to follow at the marquee club, Inc IQ, Pendragon, Solstice, Jadis, the Enid, and few others, Marrillion made it because EMI signed them with the aim for releasing singles in mind for the charts. I followed them all for years, until prog died a 2nd Death. I don’t see much around today of the standard of the early 80’s, it’s more prog metal or cheesy.
I would choose Genesis over Marillion but A script for a Jesters Tear just might be my favorite album of all time it rarely gets old.
@@tiplady you right.but Marillon was a prog rock band.like iron maiden or scorpions was heavy metal har rock band.you hace place for everybody in one category.now you have the reference of diferent styles like genesis in prog.or led zeppelin in hard rock heavy metal muzic.so for mee ay dont like to compare.everybody ave something to give to is muzic style
listening this song is still great...!!! ,
Thank God they say
I'm punting, I'm beagling, I'm wining, reclining, I'm rucking, I'm f**king
So welcome, it's a party, YEAH 🐺🐺🐺
Pure genius!
Genialne wykonanie , chyba najwyższą forma fisha
I was there...!
Mick Pointer!!
Просто превосходно!
"Rugger is the tops! A game for men"
Garden party held today, invites call the guests to play
Seit ich das 1.Mal die Script fort a Jesters Tear hört war im Bann von Marillion seit 1985
amazing perfomence,real art
Happy Christmas, still up, Garden Party...what else could you need?
Fantastic!!!
This is the single-best version of GP
"Garden Party" live is even better.
Marillion is one of the best Rock bands ever, the other one is SAGA...
All I can say is check out the end of Grendel when Marillion tries sadly to mimic Apocalypse in 9/8 from Supper's ready. The rhythmic accents, the chords underneath, the mask, are all a thinly veiled copy.
Garden party held today!!!!!
eternal forever
Well, i think that is because the ten years or more of difference.....behind the Supper`s was the Beatles and all the rockandroll thing......but behind Marillion was Genesis, Emerson Lake and Palmer, Yes, etc etc
I agree , Marillion with Derek Dick was really something good - but maybe the Fish swam a little to much in the drink later on and maybe thats why they parted
Hahahaha excellent.
Not sure what your saying, but TAK!! Bardzo.
What is this live?
Top class front man = FISH
flash, flash!! Flash!!!
@botman9822
You mean the 3 words(second line) he sings a little softer than the rest??
If that`s pissed, i`m wondering what i`m now then...ow yeah..completely wasted
Olho de Horus e brinco de peixe.
This is what genesis would be if peter don't Left behind Genesis and move on alone
Damburgery-you have to understand that Fish was continuing the legacy of Genesis throughout the 80's due to Phil taking them down the pop $hitter.
It's a great performance of a great song , Fish screws up the lyrics , no "edgy eggs and queing cumbers " but so what ? Performance isn't about perfection , it's about passion & how it's delivered and this delivers in massive quantities !
Marillion = Fish
zgadzam się w pełnej rozciągłości, że marillion bez fish'a to nie to samo.
@DrummerGrrrl
Well, I personally look past the make up, as it is has to be taken in the context of that era, and hear some great songwriting.
no genesis were in the beginning,there good but not as good as genesis
Very different from Genesis yet also similar in some ways. Fish is a genius and a visionary so is Peter Gabriel. Comparing and trying to make judgements of ill-mindedness about who is better is stupid. I love both bands and I am a serious progressive freak. This song features the tall thin Scotsman trashing the pretensions and failings of the English upper class in a very funny and brilliant way. For whatever this is worth and I think it's worth it's weight in gold let me say this: storm the industry, take it down, and bring back actually played, written, and sung by humans music! Computerized shitting of the pants must go out the window!
sorry pal ... this is a carbon copy project, sound and visual. At least they write their own material ...
dont forget fugazi, boss album well better than misplaced
Marillion were never the same after Fish left. A beautiful poet.
Totally true, they never were as good
You're abosolutaly right man...
Totalmente de acuerdo. Hubo un antes y un después. Saludos desde Argentina 🇦🇷
And brilliant front man
You don't know H...but there is none comparable to Fish in these days....
The whole Script for a Jesters Tear album is just pure magic.
Fish`s voice makes me shake.
One of the top ten masterpieces of Prog Rock of all times...!
Blain face
Blain face
Even one of the firts five ones.
They were brilliant live and I really miss them.
This is a vintage song from a long lost era, thanks for the upload,
Fish could certainly put on a hell of a performance. As well as being a great singer and lyricist. The music is as tight as a ducks ass as well. Brilliantly played. An all time prog rock classic.
One of the best live performances by anyone ever !! WOW. This song is actually better live.
Marillion-Fish's
Toujours magnifique du groupe, des sons et de leurs paroles.
Genesis has Phill Collins and Peter Gabriel, Marillion just having "Fish" is enough.... Still listening at 2021... 👍👍👍👍👍
Weltschmerz
Having Steve Rothery helps too...lol
2024 still at it.
Wow aye. I love Phil and fish.
Grande fish! grande Marillion una de la mejores bandas de rock sinfónico de los 80´!!
Fish was the first. He was a perfect for the time. Love ROTHERY either way. Marillion is different now but for the time it is perfect. Times and things change just like Marillion. I love both versions.
This was the first Marillion track I ever heard. They were my band of the 80s and saw them live many times throughout the Fish years. . I have friends who continued to follow them after Fish but I just couldn't. He was one of the great front men and had some great solo stuff. Full disclosure, I had a full belt fangirl crush on him.
the most underrated band in progressive rock
Que pedazo de artista...yo me medico con un poco de Marillion y un poco de Pink Floyd y estoy saludable.
Love this band, but I can't stand the decision to always keep the focus on the singer when the other members of the band are fun to watch too. Take the synth part around 5 minutes in. They give him shit for screen time and I much rather see his hands playing.
Only Fish could completely mystify his audience with such finger gestures but still entertain them.
Disfruto cada momento con esto marilion genios del mejor sonido😊
songs like that dont happen today anymore
just great
happen is the right word
Simply flawless. Spectacular performance!
Creative genius!
Fish al día de hoy , la esencia de MARILLION
I'm actually hearing this band for the very first time right now....
... and I'm absolutely loving it.
First thing that comes to mind is a Scottish version of 70's Genesis.
Suddenly, I feel less nostalgic about early Genesis.
What they did in the 80's now seems to make sense.
These guys obviously picked up the torch.
This is a bloody great song, best thing they ever did IMO, he has a great voice. They were very brave to do the prog thing in the 80s, when it was so clearly out of fashion.
Milton Keynes heatwave , one of the best live performers ever experienced! Legend is fish's marillion !
Era como ver dos shows en uno. Por un lado la banda, pero siempre estabas atento a Fish. Me recuerda a Anderson con Jethro Tull.
Vocalistas que más allá de cantar, te contaban una historia. No te Ian necesidad de tirar tres octavas en cada tema.
Thats an unreal performance buy Fish a real Genius great voice and underated 5***********
Still one of the best gigs I've ever been to - Marillion at the Cornish Colosseum!
Damn lots of elements from Grobschnitt (German progressive Krautrock band from the 70s) in this song ;-)
First heard this, many years ago, on the jukebox in The Raven in Wakefield, and at first thought i'd discovered an unknown Genesis track. Been a Marillion fan ever since........
Muito show.Nunca havia escutado antes.Trabalhei com um cara nos anos 90,que falava muito deles.Hoje ouvi porque apareceu alguém falando a história da banda Fish é um gênio.Show.
This is sooo precious ! Thank You for sharing ! Cheers from Montreal Québec Canada !
This music saved my life in difficult time of adolescence
I would part with one of my bollocks to jump back in a time machine to see this gig!!
LMAO
Fish = Gênio
Fish is still performing. I saw him last week. he was brilliant.
Long gone era … No bands these days with the same quality of music and lyrics. But it will live forever in our hearts and minds … and YT ;)
No fish no marrilion simple
That sip of Guinness before passing it to the audience is legendary. My father was always telling me that was cola, but now I know it wasn't!
Fish was a true Romantic Poet Warrior ⭐️
Peter's bass lines are some of the most melodic aside from some of McCartney's.
Pure spunk, never over the top. I love the way he pulls opens up a chord to make it interesting.
It is really fuckin outstanding after all this time, thanks Derek.
Marillion has definitly life without being the shadow of Genesis.
MARILLION DEREK JESTEŚ DRUGI PO BOGU!!#kocham Cię💃👍💖💖💕👏✋ POZDRAWIAM💟.
Pete Trewavas on his Rickenbacker 4000. 👌
Simply incredible, these guys are masters at their craft! Love Marillion!
Los mejores años de mi vida con mis amigas y amigos los viví en los jardines de la plaza del Portugalete y sobretodo en los de justo al lado de la Antigua donde sigue creciendo nuestro árbol fuerte y sano aquél que nos vio morirnos de la risa cuando era uno retoño él y nosotros debajo de sus ramas quiero que descansen mis cenizas cuando de este Mundo me vaya !!! Garden Party Always !!! Salud y Vida Pa'lante !!! Cheers and Life On !!!