ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 เม.ย. 2024
- In #CentralHall, senior advocate Kapil Sibal explores the question of one identity at the heart of the conversation these days, that of Muslims. With academic and Vice-Chancellor of Chanakya National Law University, Faizan Mustafa, journalist-anchor and senior editor, The Wire, Arfa Khanum Sherwani and ex-bureaucrat and VC of Jamia Millia, Najeeb Jung. What is the identity of Muslims as per the Constitution? What does it mean to be Muslim in India in 2024?
Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
I am a Sikh and will stand with Muslim brothers❤if all the minorities stay United and raise our voice against the right wing than we have a fair chance.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
You are a Khalistani... a true Sikh can't support ideology of Islaam...
ok abdul
I hope they'll also stand by you and grant you equal rights wherever they are in the majority.
Kisi aur ko jaakr chew tea yeah banao Mr Khan
I am a advaiti Hindu of Ram Krishna mission Order. Leaders like swami vivekananda, Kaji Najrul Islam, Rabindranath Tagore, BR ambedkar sahab, Bhallav bhai patel, Dr. kalam , Homio Bhava, Subhash chandra bose are my heros. Dear Indians please please please get united irrespective of religious , linguistic and ethnical diversity. Otherwise , this Facist Govt. is taking our country towards collapse and darkness and massive problems. Save democracy , Save Constitution , Save Humanity
I request my Hindu brothers to stand in support of our Muslim brothers and we need to stay United to save our country from fascist leadership.
Wish.. you and your parents had said the same thing before partition to keep the country together.
ok abdul
@@adityabanerjee7145 Sikhs are more welcome in Pakistan because our heart is big like ocean. We allow muslims to have namaz in our Gurdwaras, we have built mosques for them. We don't live with animosity and hatred which keeps us divided. It is my parents who have cultivated such positive feelings for other human beings. A Sikh would never demolish others place of worship and make a gurdwara and feel proud about it.
@@deec2564 I know who worship Ram have no manners, empty people with no heritage and legacy. BTW I am a Sikh for me Ram only lives in scriptures and he was an ordinary prince, no god!
@@publicvoice2360 you are just an off shoot of hinduism . But now badly miguided by your clergy to abuse hindus . Your holy book mentions ram and shiva thousands of times .
Salute this Courageous Fair Bold Transparent TEAM.We INDIANS respect INDIAN. Dethrone the COMMUNAL Sarkar to save IMAGE of INDIA in WORLD.
As a PM, his statement on Muslims deserve condemnation from everyone!!!
Felt overwhelmed by this discussion….Thank Mr Sibal. We should all do our part in bringing our people together. That is the right way….that is the only way.
Men and woman of this country ,this is our last chance ,I appeal to all of you please vote wisely .we need to maintain the social fabric of this beautiful country
Three outstanding people of present day India who just happen to be Muslims. They are Indians first!!!!!! I will also call them intellects, highly learned, cream of our country they are!!!
Cream? - you mean BURNOL!!
@@adityabanerjee7145 don't comment if you dont understand English. The phrase "Cream of something" refers to the best of a particular group of things or people.
@@swiz97 Incorrect, cream of something is the froth on the top that needs to be thrown away to expose the real substance underneath.
@@adityabanerjee7145 dude it's an individual's perception. If you are a negative minded person, then the entire world seems to be that way. Good luck to you.
@@adityabanerjee7145 Bangali Babu I come from your part of the world too. “cream and froth - throw away” what a load of crap.
More such program's are needed for the health of india 🎉
The professor is right.Indian Muslims are as much patriotic as Hindus.
Gadga
R@@ShubhPatel-nb9ecRSS gunda
Pakistan vote dekar hinduo, sikho, Buddhist ne banwaya hai
Then how Pakistan created
I like your discussions but population wise I don't agree. They are over populating with multiple wife's.
As the only women in th penal, will you agree your husband having multiple wife??? Tell me.
Raise your voice against Injustice Inflation Unemployment and Hate. Save Your Democracy and Constitution. Jai Hind 🇮🇳🤝
Arfa sherwani didi salam 🙏 namaste....आप मेरी नज़र बहुत बेहतरीन औरत हैं जो इसली पत्रकार हो... शुभकामनाएं... जीवन के अंत तक एक्सपोज़ करो... ❤ 🎉 GOOD LUCK ALL THE TIME...... WE ARE WITH YOU ALWAYS
Kashnir Jane bolo Kabhi😂😂😂
Only people like you will save our democracy & help to protect our beautiful country.
❤ ‼️THANKS, KAPIL SIBAL ‼️SIR ‼️WE APPRECIATE YOUR CONTRIBUTION TOWARDS OUR SOCIETY AND COUNTRY, SIR PLEASE SAVE OUR INDIAN CONSTITUTION AND DEMOCRACY, THANKS 🙏🙋♂️✌️🌹✔️
SABKASATH SABKAVIKAS ger achi niti aur Achi niyat ho to Hum bhi Aap ke sat
🔴🟢 ‼️ THIS TIME ONE VOTE IN THE NAME OF ‼️ " INDIAN CONSTITUTION AND "‼ " DEMOCRACY "‼ 🙏 ✔
➡️‼️ To protect and preserve our Indian Constitution and Democracy is the first duty of every Indian citizen as it has been achieved after great difficulties and lakhs of sacrifices and shedding of much blood. This is our mother -❓ Otherwise we all will never be able to forgive ourselves❓ Because this is our inheritance Please do not take it lightly, please consider it, if our soul is still alive❓ = Thank you.
Very well n rightly spoken 💯🌹💯🇮🇳
Very correct.Need to stand against fascism.
Poor kashmiri pandits . Their dead souls must be still echoing in their native valleys 🙏
Arafa is right in expressing her view
The wire channel is one of the best channei
Whatever Modiji says and does to the contrary, minorities always were, are and will remain the citizens of India . Thank you sir for all you have done and are doing to uphold the constitution and democracy.
Yes that true... But minority ke countary ke liye koi responsibility nhi hoti... One minority khalistan ko support krti... One only muslim ki bat krti..... Countary stand krti unke liye kuch ya nhi..... Or apko ya any ko issue hai..... Ucc same law for every person... 1950 se consitution mai hai..... Usse issue kisko hai... Or jo aaj tak apply nhi hua... Pls read it first
WE ARE ALL INDIAN CITIZENS
WE ARE ALL EQUAL
NO MATTER FROM WHICH RELIGION, CASTE, CREED AND GENDER.
💯🇮🇳💯👍🌹
But special community needs Haz Subsidy, Madrasa Education, Wakf Bord in the name of secularism !!!!!
@@krishanuadityapandey4414
What about Vedic Schools? Seem to have forgotten to include the list.
@@lourdumary5915 No Vedic School runs with public money.
Stop spreading bullshit propaganda.
@@lourdumary5915 No Vedic School is running with public money.
Stop spreading your majhabi propaganda.
An excellent Discussion with highly educated speakers. Thank you Kapil Ji and The Wire.
Manohar Soulay
Bangalore
Modi ji today talking about Muslim, tomorrow Christian Sikh Jain Dravidian SC ST Dalits, tribals Buddhists, Adivasi, OBC and Finally Rajput then Brahmins rule the nation the name of Manuscript, the Election Commissioner writting poem he may get Bharat Ratna award like Narasimha Rao and Advaniji.
One by one all will be victim.
Kerala Christians to vote for Anil Anthony.
Hindus including Shia, Ahmedia and Boris and Pasmandas are only completely Hindus
Iam a proud Hindu,iam a proud British
Rishi sunak
Sonia Congress agenda break Bharat
North Bharat
South Bharat
I love all Indians. We grew up in an India where religion never came up. Come on all, we have to defeat BJP hate politics and make India great again❤
Good discussion Arfaji 🎉🎉
जब सड़के और civil society शांत होजाती है तो राजनीति आवारा होजाती है
Citizens QUIT BJP LEADERSHIP! SAVE DEMOCRACY OF THE GREAT NATION!
Go raise your voice against the Khalistanis......
You guys love Manmohan despite corruption, terrorism, etc.
@@rahuljadhav5599 No one can fix such bigoted political devotees like this guy. Arguing with them is also a waste.
@@1008apocalypse1008 BJP/Modi ji put a red carpet for those financial criminals and corrupted people and Washed in their washing machines... BJP has no right to talk about corruption or terrorism...
@@1008apocalypse1008 modi is the only t e r r o r I st in india
very happy to listen all the four of you .we got good knowledge of constitution ;;; fundamental rights of common citizens
No vote for bjp
Wait for June 4. Majority of vote is for BJP
The only remeady.
Wait for June 4
Vote INDIA
@@AftabKhan-lg8uc Why ???
Only because providing you sufficient opportunity to create a few more Pakistan !!!!!!
Very intellectual ,informative debate sir.Thanks
Excellent , Keep it up , Kapil ji
Good discussion on this important issue. We need to spread this idea of India to General public. We have to convey the message that We are Indian first after that hindu, Muslim,sikh, jain etc
Excellent conversation @ thanks a lot Kapil Sibbal sir.
Wish many more such talks on other issues related with minorities
Vote for India ❤
Vote for unity ❤
A good debate. All panelist are speaking honestly. Thanks to all.
Thank you arfa ji for your hard working service. waheguru ji bless you. 🙏🙏🌹🌹🙏🙏
Soul soothing conversation between intellectuals about a sensitive issue affecting India of today. May their tribe ever increase towards influence on our Indian society , leading to the intended acceptance of Diversity, Equality, & Inclusiveness.
Sibbleji i appriciate your programme and topics.
Very relevant discussion, hope these are not the last days of moden secular liberal India
respected sir entire south indian people never fight between muslims and other religions we are living happly all as one
99.5 % correct..... But some political group wanted ly created polarisation
Appreciate to all the Participants of this program and shows the real picture of Our Country India 🇮🇳. Also discussed the to progress what we should concentrate on as a whole Nation. Thanks once again to the Honourable Big Team🎉.
Pl do this program in Hindi so it should be reach to every Hindi speaking citizen.
Yes pls discussion hindhi language ❤
Why are only Muslim panelists called for discussion as a minority? Muslims are around 20% in india, and they should not be treated as minority anymore. What is about Sikhs, jains, Parasi, adivasis, and others who are far less than Muslims in india?
Wherever the Muslims population is around 50% or more, then they do not allow freedom to other communities, including puja. Why do you not discuss the elimination and brutality of kashmiri Brahman by the Muslims?
what about temple in Abhu Dhabi, Oman, Iran...In these country population is over 50 percent muslims.
Get lost sanghi subhuman Indoctrinated by Shaka poisoning .
Hindus Muslims ekta jindabad
❤❤❤correct ❤❤
As Kashmir, '89-90 !!!!!!
Respect 🙏 ❤
Jao Kashmir ka Haal Dekho.....Tabhi Journalist nahi Gaye....
@@krishanuadityapandey4414 what about maithi and kukis in manipur2023-2024✔️
Kabil sibal is probably the only lawyer with a spine to call a spade a spade. He has been waging a relentless battle both within the sanctum sanctum of the court & outside of it in defense of our constitution. He is a shining star among the spineless & meek heaeted lawyers. Kudos.
Hindu Muslim Unity survive forever'
I think still the main problem in India is not communalism. Still the main problem is casteism. Communalism is required by ruling class to maintain caste hierarchy.
that's an interesting/thought-provoking way to look at it
4
Is communalism required to maintain caste hierarchy? or
Is communalism resorted go by politicians too polarise people based on religion to gain vote?
U caught the crux...Indian people are not communal .politician make them communal
Very enlightening! Am glad this is in Hindi so accessible to all Indians! Thank you.🙏✍🤳👌
FAIZAN MUSTAFA IS MOST SECULAR, LOVE INDIA TO THE CORE OF HIS HEART, MORE PATRIOTIC THAN ANY FANATIC HINDU
We are deeply ashamed to see this ECI, for their inaction and chaplusi
😢
RIP.
Arfa ji you spoke excellently as always 🙏 ❤
Arfa is a high standard and class one prorfic journalist who deserve award for her fight for truth
very informative discussion...
Yes hindus of Pakistan can not do this
Besides the very vital relevant topics you discuss Mr. Sibal, I love the settings where you hold these . So elegant and classy.. gives an insight to your personality. A man of class, substance and irrefutably high integrity.
Thankyou for this very great forum .
SARI DUNIYA KA PALANHAR MANNIY KAPIL SIBAL SIR KI TANDURASTI KE SATH LAMBI UMAR DARAJ KARE OR HAR WAQT, HAR JAGAH, HAR HALAT ME HIFAZAT FARMAYE. JAIHIND JAIBHARAT BHARATMATAKIJAY SATSARIAKAL MERA BHARAT DESH MAHAN.
Excellent interview thank you Mr Kapil
This must be one of the rare times when an 'open' debate on such a sensitive yet important issue was held. We need more such sane discussions (as opposed to uncivil shouting matches) to let people know the truth of the situation (again without being partisan) and then allow solutions to rise from such interactions. It is no doubt a very complex issue but we wont solve it by brushing it under the carpet; in fact we will allow zealots to use the divide to spread more hatred.
I think my face is my greatest power but my face has become my greatest vulnerability just because of your identity. This is very logical statement which is highly considerable.
Dear Kapil Sibal.. Please tell us what ordinary people can do when our prime minister is taking the country through a dangerous path?
Go out and vote. But think before voting.
Thank you Kapil sibal. It's high time these things required to be discussed on public. The people of India need to re think what is happening with minorities. Protection of minorities and their rights need to be felt and implemented as law. Writing in constitution is like having a dog which can't bite
We love & very much respect Kapil Sibbalsab, you are true, honest and sympathy of minorities, May Allahpak gives you good health so you can serve our nation for long long time
Najeeb jung sir ji. 🙏💐
Jinnah vote dekhar Pakistan kisne banwaya tha? Muslim apna hissa le chuke hai...aab humlogo ko jajiya jaisa strict tax lagana chahiye illegally India mai rahne ke liye..
Bilkul.
24:29 Oh, Omar Khalid could've been one. But he has been in jail for years now. Just look at how even Kanhaiya had to move to Congress.
An eye opener interview to the Leaders and the Public of Indians. 👍
Wonderful Speech is given by every one of our interviewer.🙏
A really engaging conversation and so pleased that it was delivered in a mixture English and Hindi/Urdu. Please can we have more of this type of informed, rational and well tempered discussions
में हिन्दु हूं ।लेकिन धर्म निरपेक्ष हूं ।आप के programme lgbhg dekhti hu
Thoda hate preacher Gujarati Modi ko bhi dekhaa do zra ayeena, himself got 6 brothers but blames Muslims for more children
मैंने अपने आस पास देखा है ।जिनकी हिन्दु में 5-6 बेटियां हो जाती हैं ।बेटे करने के चक्कर में लाइन लागते है ।
कई मुस्लिम पढे लिखे हैं 2 बच्चे करते हैं
Thanks
Very good conversation.
दोस्तों, कृपया वोट ज़रूर करें। 🙏🙏
समाज में प्रेम और एकता के लिए वोट करें।
हम भारतीय मिलकर उन नेताओं को हरा सकते हैं जो नफरत फैला रहे हैं और धर्म के आधार पर समाज को बांट रहे हैं।
हम सभी जानते हैं कि नफरत की राजनीति हमारी अगली पीढ़ी के भविष्य को खत्म कर रही है। किसी भी राजनेता के बच्चे या अमीर लोगों के बच्चे सांप्रदायिक दंगों में नहीं मारे जाते, केवल हमारे सामान्य लोग / परिवार ही प्रभावित होते हैं।
जाइए और नफरत के खिलाफ वोट दीजिए। 🙏🙏
Kindly give English subtitles when the conversation is in Hindi for pan Indian understanding
We are always with neutral and intellectual media.❤😂🎉
I am ex faculty of Sir Chutu Ram Institute. I had served Institute with sincerity, loyalty and love to teach not only my students but any students who seeks my help and guidance. I always care students irrespective of their gender, cast, creed, region and religion. It's heart breaking that our PM hates as no one such person can ever had done in the country.
Madam u r educated u must know nehru liaqat pact.. hindus of Pakistan r suffering much more
@@ramraghuwanshi2562 bhai es baat ko samjhn, apka ek padosi bahut kharab h apni family ko marta Peet ta h. To kya aap bhe apni family ko petne lg jaoge.
Dear sir, This is the first time that our intellectual minds are sitting together and asking the right questions from the Government which is misleading the country and we want you to talk about the solutions as well as high lighting the problems. Your panel presented by very intelligent minds discussing the future of Indian Muslims so please let’s bring out from this mess of Hindu Muslim hate speeches and we all must work for the betterment of our great country.
We hope that your next episode ‘Dil Se’ will be more interesting.
With best Regards to Honorable Kabil Sibbal sahab and the members of the Panel.
It was indeed a great discussion amongst four beautiful and loving persons.
Such an amazing conversation sir...👏 Need more talk like this
The Congress party ruled for 65 years and is now accusing the BJP for Muslim backwardness. Hypocrisies. Education is a state matter, and the majority of Indian states have never been dominated by BJP.
These are a few titles the present pm has got from various agencies:-
India Today: Hero of Hatred & Master Divider
Times: India's Divider in Chief
New Statesman: India's Worst Nightmare
We need more learned persons like you, & I am proud of you as a citizen of India.
I think this episode should be recorded in other local languages in order to reach to the common people.
Muslim community will do well to back Arfa Khanum Sherwani as their leader. She is articulate intellectual with a passion for upliftment of her people.
Dear Sibbal ji, kudos to you for this series, the issues you debate on this series and the basic issues you debate are fantastic. After 2013, I am re-exploring you. Either I misunderstood you then or you are a new person now, but hat's off to your concept of our nation and constitution..
Muslim want all india to be secular but they should remain communal ,secondly they will vote against BJP no-matter what .
Its this zeal that brought the down fall and none of these highlighted this point.
Exactly.👍
56 ya Chapan Inch ki Chati Wala Shrimati Indira Gandhi Aur Shri Manmohan Singh ke Phere ke Niche ki Dool ke bi Layak ya Barobari Nahi Hai.
I am very happy to see the change of tone and tenor of previous Delhi LG during this discussion, it seems like his swan song is over now and has come out of dark whole of polity.
Very happy to see Faizan Mustafa Sir. After a very long time
Very introspective discussion, thanks Kapil ji for this . We as a nation are definitely going through crisis of nationalism and what we as Indian stand for . The diversity fabric has been torn apart completely. Muslims have already been marginalized. The so called secular Hindu leaders too are shying away from raising issues of minorities specially Muslims and using them only as vote bank . Muslims are an integral part of India and Arfa Khannum ji mentioned if one part of the body is impaired or weakened how can the entire body be strong or developed. Yes we need Muslim intellectual leaders and they are in making its a matter of time we will for sure see a change in the demographic fabric in the coming years as this awareness and discussion is now happening in almost majority of Muslim families groups and gatherings . The communal forces are working against us but it will have a very short shelve life is my opinion and belief 🙏
Is it written in constitution that minority means Muslim only? In fact it. Is majority considering some region like Kashmir,and some 30 _ 40 districts.These people are creating unnecessary fear especially Sibbal and Afrfa Khanum.
Excellent question.
THANK you Kapil sir for wonderful discussion
We are a democracy Mr. Sibal. A person can belong to any religion to lead people of any religion. Thank goodness Faizan Mustafa answered sensibly.
Simbol sir ji. 🙏💐
Very True Exelent words sir
Ekta mai takat hai sub ek hona chahiye sir Democracy Secularism zinda bad.
Free phalastines Gaza
Insha Allah, 🤲
Highly intectual debate by these stelwarts from different fields.
What a conversation 🙏🙏🙏
Thank you Kapil saab !!!
We Stand with Muslims 👍
Correct explanation by Kapil Shibal Sir.
Saffron blinds, a hateful sway,
Drowning India's vibrant display.
But hope remains, a vibrant choir,
Raising voices, setting hearts on fire.
Yeh bade bade Tilak Lagann wale aur bade bade daadi wale are the two sides of the same coin, both spread lies and hatred
Thank you so much y'll for amazing open statements and more often we need likewise of conversation. Thanks again guys
I like the fact that WIRE always has eminently educated people on their panels in stead of only uneducated netas.keep it up.
"INDIA IS A CIVILIZATIONAL STATE WITH ITS OWN NATIVE, INDIGENOUS VALUES, CULTURES AND TRADITIONS WHICH MUST BE PROTECTED AND RESPECTED"
I have a problem with those who disagree with this factual narrative and tend to project India only as some modern-day creation like the U.S. and Canada, and also those who weaponize this narrative to target others. I have a problem with both these categories of people. India was, is and will forever remain a civilization which remained tolerant and accepting throughout its history. Yes, its openness led to it being backstabbed and invaded for centuries, but it won't happen anymore. India's indigenous values should be protected and respected. But I firmly oppose politicization of this fact by self-proclaimed nationalist entities and the targetting of those subscribing to non-Indian beliefs by these entities.
Absolutely right
Patriotism is not a propriety of only one relious group but belongs to all
इस चर्चा में
South India से भी एक प्रतिभागी हो तो अच्छा होता था
Prof.Shakeela Khanam Dean and Director UGC-DEB Affairs and Campus Development BRAOU Jubilee Hills Hyderabad Telangana
Infiltrators are infiltrators, citizens are citizens.The two can never meet.
Exactly.👍