Tchaikovsky - Piano trio - Kogan / Rostropovich / Gilels
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ค. 2024
- Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky
Piano trio op.50
I. Pezzo elegiaco 0:00
II. Tema con variazioni - Variazione Finale e coda 18:16
Leonid Kogan
Mstislav Rostropovich
Emil Gilels
Studio recording, Moscow, 2.I.1952 - เพลง
What a miraculous time we live in! To be able to hear the great performances sitting at home and be able to say "oh, I really like the way that Rubenstein, Heifitz, and Piatigorsky did this", and "how marvellously the young people from The New England Conservatory phased that", and "how deftly Argerich put that run." We owe an enormous debt to the people like incontrario motu who are the stewards of this precious legacy and share it with us. Thank you.
THE paul barton elephant piano man?
Oh, goodness no. I am A paul barton. A person of no particular distinction.
I agree, Paul. Although I’m vulnerable to losing myself on Wikipedia for hours, and Instagram, Quora, etc, at least TH-cam is discursively addicting in the most edifying ways. I have discovered Schubert and Handel jewels I never knew about.
And I can whip through the advantages of Earth’s obliquity of orbit for the evolutionary speciation of life in the Permian and compare them to the disastrous effects of precessional perturbation like nobody’s business. Before TH-cam I was a celestial lightweight.
Ditto!!!!
This is the best version of Tchaikovsky piano trio op50
The Beaux arts recording is really great too
Unvergleichlich schöne Interpretation dieses romantischen Meisterwerks mit klarem Schlag des Klaviers, seidigem Ton der Violine und tiefem Ton des Cellos. Die Tonqualität ist auch ziemlich hoch als eine Aufnahme von 1952. Die UdSSR war wirklich ein musikalisches Wunder im 20. Jahrhundert!
Kogan's playing is so enchanting! Truly magical.
Kogan's wife, Elizabeth, is Gilels' sister.
One of my very favourite pieces of chamber music. I remember first hearing it as a teenager and being completely hooked from the opening bars. Nobody writes melodies like the great Russian composers.
It seems that Russian composers have a special melodic gift.
In the case of Tchaikovsky, this feeling was supported by the experience that in his earlier incarnations he was sometimes a ballet dancer. We once performed together for a long time. There are moments when dance helps the performance and it should not be applied in a patterned way. In this case, I mean when the turn of time comes to escape for the ballet dancer and the pianist and the composing is unpredictable. Tchaikovsky has the most flexible mind of any man I have ever spoken to. I remember that he was my father once, and now I started to remember the previous time as well.
Outstanding played, the golden Gilels tone. Rostro and Kogan are great.
The Trio of the trios.
Yes.. The Music of the Musics. One of the best Om variations and combintions. Holy... What a world.. Earth is really on a great period. Of transition and evolution.. The ones who aligns with this will surely last 🎉
Incomparably beautiful performance of this Romantic masterpiece with clear touch of the piano, silky sound of the violin and deep sound of the cello. The sound quality is also fairly high as a recording of 1952. The USSR was really a musical wonder in the 20th century!
never heard of a 48min trio too
@@daniel3231995 Quite true. Only Tchaikovsky could write such a beautiful and lyrical piano trio without any element of boredom.
There were musical wonders in the USSR, and that’s despite the USSR!
Russian musicians were even better before the USSR.
@@JulienGaudfroy Really, despite the emergence of Richter, Gilels, Ashkenazy, Lazar Berman? only to mention some pianists!
Это шедевр . Трое гениальных музыкантов❤❤❤
Three gigantic artists, what a treat!
Superb rendition of these wonderful Russian musicians
A performance of timeless beauty and passion.
Чайковский- гений на все времена. Его музыка божественна
Trois géants interprètent divinement la musique d’un géant de la musique romantique
I. 00:00
II.
Theme 18:16
Var I. 19:19
Var II. 20:13
Var III. 20:48
Var IV. 21:43
Var V. 22:49
Var VI. 23:35
Var VII. 25:58
Var VIII. 27:07
Var IX. 29:35
Var X. 32:47
Var XI. 34:19
Variazione Finale e coda 36:27
Genius musicians ! My favourite violinist ! Гениальные музыканты! Мой любимый скрипач!
That lush cello opening is so romantic.
Fred MyOpinion Slava plays the opening, correctly in my not so humble opinion, all on the d-string.
великий Чайковский! Гениальные МУЗЫКАНТЫ! Спасибо.
Ah, Tchaikovsky! Endless beauty in this Piano Trio!!! And the performance, my God!!!
ПОТРЕСАЮЩЕЕ ИСПОЛНЕНИЕ!!!!!!!! СПАСИБО!
A wonderful treasure! Many thanks to the people who built the technology that made it possible. And of course, many thinks to the deceased but still brilliant musicians who left us their artistry.
Какие же гиганты жили и творили на сцене! Просто диву даешься-какое совершенство.
Это правда, исполняет как буд- то один организм
@@MsAnnaSnegina de acuerdo
This piece deserves these wonderful interpreters. Argerich, Kremer, and Kogan do justice to the sadness and pathos of Tschaikovsky's only piano trio - but what a trio! One of my favorites in the entire chamber repertory.
I would not be surprised if these three Genius had recorded the 48 minutes of music from one single take! 😍
BRAVO BRAVO BRAVO,
Quelle belle osmose des sons ! Une entente parfaite des hommes à travers l'oeuvre, les instruments et le temps qui peut bien passer : Qu'importe puisque reste la musique !
Great. The russian version of Rubinstein, Heifitz and Piatigorsky. Both of them are not only musicaly perfect, but they are also human. I love them.
Sorry, if I misunderstood you, however, both of them are not "Russian version of", either Rubinstein and Piatigorsky are originally russians. Cheers
You're right. I'm sorry but it does'nt change the miracle provide with their music.@@felixgolivkin3409
the best ever perforrmance of this great masterpiece
Perfecta interpretación de eximios músicos a la bella y mágica música de genial compositor ruso Piotr Tchaikóvsky! Muchas gracias, "incontrario motu" por compartir, es una fiesta para el alma!!!!
Что тут можно сказать,кроме слов: Гениальная Музыка! Гениальное исполнение!
А композитор вообще гений величайший!
Stellar performance of a masterpiece that has yet to receive its proper recognition. It's amazing that the old hokum about Tchaikovsky being some sort of moronic machine for beautiful tunes still persists. But I admit I'm enormously amused by those sage critics.
I believe that started with Moguchaya kuchka ( the Mighty group) of extremely nationalistic composers: Borodin, Mussorgsky, Rimsky- Korsakov, Kyui, who denounced Tchaikovsky’s music, as too pro- western, too Italian. Their friend writer Stasov, carried their verdict through the press.
Divino!
This is a rare original, unabridged version. Beautiful!
What's the label? Melodia?
@@srothbardt Да, "Мелодия"! Других не было!
Как же крупно и масштабно играли раньше.
Идеальная интонация унисов.
Из современных скрипачей так масштабно и глубоко исполняет только Виктор Третьяков!
As far as the performers were concerned, this was by far the best version of this work I have heard. I like the delightful little disjointed Mazurka, The sound recording perhaps needs some digital work though. Thanks very much for the download
Amazing artistry by legendary performers!
From all the different versions I have heard: favorite cellist _Rostropovich, favorite violinist - Heifetz, favorite pianist - Horowitz
Yes you're right
No, this one is just perfect
Heifetz met Kogan, when Kogan was just 10, and predicted his great future. Kogan was an avid admirer of Heifetz. And he became the best violinist of all times in his country and maybe in the world in XX century.
Oistrakh/Oborin/Knushevitsky is the other Russian classic version from long ago.
Гиганты!!!
DAMN
What verve, passion and beauty!
I keep on coming back. It feels good to be back home.
В юности услышала их по радио / в то время всегда звучала или классическая музыка или народная/, помню, я заливалась слезами от услышанного и до сих пор, а мне 75, слезы выступают на глазах, когда прослушиваю эту запись снова и снова.
A remarkable masterpiece.
Bravo!!!
Bella música, una de las más destacadas obras de Tchaicovsky interpretada por tres intérpretes geniales. !Y qué foto tan bella! Debo felicitar al fotógrafo que logra capturar una atmósfera única de solaz y esparcimiento en el que Rostropovich parece darle jaque mate a Kogan, ante la mirada divertida de Gilels
I listened to this because I was a fan of Gilels; but I just became addicted to Leonid Kogan's violin and went to listen to his recordings. Kogan is so good
Dude is something that the Russians just wanted to keep for themselves, pretty much like Sofronitsky in this case.
All three's playing is so EPICALLY bright, so inside of the group, no personal STARRING at all!! So beautiful in comparison to the modern "music makers"!
Скромный Эмиль Абрамович Гилельс! Все они были великими и потому дружными и понимающими музыкантами! Та эпоха уже больше не повториться, эпоха гениев!
３人の巨匠の名演奏に感動しました。３６歳のギレリス若々しい素晴らしい！！
In my opinion, the best 3 russian interpreters of the XX century
You forget greats such as Richter, Feuermann, Piatigorsky, Oistrakh, etc, etc.
Thank you, Slava!
@incontrariu motu Thank you for this amazing posting, and also all your other wonderful postings. I diligently listen to all of them. Words fail me to express how much they mean to me, so just an inadequate but heartfelt 'THANK YOU' will have to do!
Tchaikovsky can write a totally formless movement (first) where the themes just keep coming one after another. One theme leads seamlessly into the other so logically so full of feeling. There is no development of motifs. After finishing the series of themes he just repeats the whole series saying to the listener--- I've created something so beautiful I want you to hear it again relatively unchanged.
Exactly.
Perfectly explained! I wish I studied music theory with you...
Tchaikovsky's way of creating music was always very sentimental, very natural. He created beautiful melodies, and wasnt as worried as other composers with the form and the technique. This makes many of his works unusual, and i also believe its the reason so much of his music sounds so romantic, in the purest sense of the word.
It's a classical sonata form, what do you mean by formless?
beautifully written
Beautiful,rare with gigantens ♫♪♥
This reminds me of Mahler's piano quartet in A minor, perhaps Mahler took inspiration from Tchaikovsky. Beautiful playing, I think Kogan and Gilels are certainly under rated Virtuoso's.
Under rated? Are you serious? They are so highly regarded musicians. The best of the best! Virtuosity is secondary for them, if you know what I mean!
Gilels, underrated? By whom? The greatest Russian of the C20th along with Richter and Sofronitsky And Kogan was a very great virtuoso by any standard
Mahler’s piano quartet was written 6 years before this work, but he was probably influenced by Tchaikovsky in his Pathetique symphony to end his ninth with an adagio.
Underrated? I think not.
You’re absolutely right! Virtuosity…or technical prowess…is just a means to an end-which is the creation of music.
Awesome trio!
Bellísimo este trío y esta maravillosa versión!
Glorious !!
I also have the original Melodiya recording, brought to me from the USSR by my uncle in 1959.
Wow, what a heritage!
Comment ne pas aimer ces deux merveilleux artistes Si la perfection existait ces artistes en seraient les modèles
Ou que vous fassiez Maestros bravo . BRAVISSIMO.
Extraordinário!
♥️♥️♥️♥️
Perfect phrasing. Stunning!
Thanks for uploading!
Braaaaaviiiiiiiiiiii!!! ❤❤❤
Poor Emil left out of that chess game, having to sit in the corner like a punished schoolboy...
The only “poor” about Gilels was, perhaps, his bank account. But with such sumptuous wealth as his playing, who cares about a bank account?
Superb !
Wonderful!
-- Une version de référence pour cet immense chef-d’œuvre de Tchaïkovsky. --
Thank you for posting this performance which I hadn't heard since the old Monarch LP from early 50s - one of the first chances to hear Rostropovich's playing in the west.
Соскучилась! Люблю!
И до новой встречи.
8.12.2020.
Beautiful ! Thanks for sharing :)
Люди - Монстры другой эпохи!!! Супер!!!
Для сравнения послушайте это трио в исполнении иностранцев! Вы поймете, что эти гиганты были еще до корней волос русскими! Такое глубокое и драматичное исполнение возможно только музыкантами российской школы.
@@irinaermolova2232 Да, Гилельс, Коган и Ростропович. Таки да. Очень русские. К слову, а что в них русского-то?
@@ean1245 Конечно, курносо-тупорылый, ты прав. А ещё они в сортир сугубо русский, очковый, во дворе не бегали. Куда им до твоей русскости, мудак!
@@markdenemark7298 I apologise, good sir, however what I meant by this is that those geniuses are not russians. That was a compliment. These are Jewish people, and they shall be recognised as Jewish and not russians.
@@ean1245 1. Rostropovich was not Jewish. 2. All of them were Russians CULTURALY - that what Irina means...
ANNA MARTÍ🐾🐾. TRÉS GRÁNS
MÚSÍCS INTERPRETÁN LA
MÚSICA 🎶 🎵 DEL GRÁN .
CUMPUSITÓ PEDRÓ ILÍCH .
TCHAIKOSVKY TOTA LA SEVA
MÚSICA 🎶 🎵 ÉS GRÁNDIOSA.
Í MARAVALLOSAAAAAA NÉS TÍC
ENAMURADA🙏🙏💖💖❤❤
🦋🌺🦋👏👏👏👏👏🌾🌾🥀🥀
Love this performance! Not too fast and good sound quality. I can hear many more details than in the recording I owned before.
chapeau TCHAIKOVSKY
Interesting portrait.
오..감사해요^^♡♡♡♡!
Amo este trio elegíaco que expressa tanta beleza deste morto que inspirou ao grande Tchaikovsky uma obra -prima de câmara. Excepcionais intérpretes. ❤😢
録音時間1952年，比我年紀都長幾歲，音效太棒了，三位演奏者都是前蘇联共和國籍的知名演奏家，髙岡-小提琴，羅斯波維奇-大提琴，吉爾利斯-鋼琴(這位是否是前蘇联需再查証)，他們的演奏默契也是-流的，水凖佷高，六十多年前的演奏錄音，拜現代科技之賜，音效表現，臨塲感，音樂性都極佳，愛樂者之福，我透過Logitech蓝芽啦叭播放，有如全音域啦叭，音質頗佳(信價比頗好)，提供愛樂者参考，請多指教！ 壢愚山人謹識，梅姬颱風剛離台湾，祝大家平安喜樂。
same
Allen壢愚山
Allen壢愚山人 주
응원하겠습니다!
Emil's like: come on guys, we don't have all day
Pjotr Iljics Csajkovszkij:a-moll Zongoratrió Op.50
1.Pezzo elegiaco (Moderato assai - Allegro giusto) 00:00
2.Tema con variazioni:Andante con moto - Variazione Finálé e coda: Allegro risoluto e con fuoco - Andante con moto - Lugubre (L'istesso tempo) 18:16
Leonyid Kogan-hegedű
Msztyiszlav Rosztropovics-gordonka
Emil Gilelsz-zongora
赞！太美了！科冈（Kogan）大师！
Разговор по душам скрипки и виолончели в медленном эпизоде меня растрогал до слёз.Я очень горжусь нашей Россией.
Yes!
Zeer mooi ! !
beauty
Habrá otras versiones pero después de escuchar ésta no siento el menor interés. El mas poderoso del mundo no podría hoy lograr un trío de este nivel.
Vaya, lo malo es que ya nadie toca así. Ya no hay ni la remota posibilidad de escuchar esto en directo, aproximaciones como ésta te transportan cuando las escuchas en directo pero cuando escuchas las grabaciones de unos y otros no hay color.
Les micros de l'URSS..... heureusement que les musiciens sont géniaux !
Kogan e Rostropovitch jogam xadrez. Nas horas vagas, tocam Tchaikovskii, magníficamente... Com Gilels...
Appropriately sad and heartbroken, and this seems to be in better sound than the recording I have (big box set of their trios). Is this remastered?
Thanks for the upload.
Walter, you are back
9:48 ...❤🎶
Rostropovich: checkmate! *smug face*
Chess was so live then! Schostakovich and Prokofiev were big chess players and David Oistrakh had the 1st category in it! 😰
The sudden intrusion of the Romanze from the Gladfly at the end of this recording (by way of a TH-cam advert) was most upsetting!
Why haven't you downloaded AdBlock (free) or AdBlock Plus ($1.99 per month) You will never see an ad again.
@@autodidact2499 I have ad block disabled on TH-cam so that I'm not depriving creators of ad revenue... However I regret that when I try to listen to classical music recordings and find they are monetized when the uploaded is not the copyright holder.
This is a very nice performance of a difficult piano trio. The lyrically beautiful first movement (Pezzo elegiaco) is somewhat capricious and in sonata form. The awe-inspiring climactic sequence starts at 5:34 and reaching climax at 6:54, but shortly later, you are comforted by a heavenly melody at 7:23; a Tchaikovsky trademark which has been somewhat weakened here. For the best performance of this work, I suggest the recording by Moscow Conservatory Trio with Paul Ostrovsky.
I personally find that this performance is difficult to equal let alone surpass. Still I'd be curious to hear the Ostrovsky performance you mention. Is it available on TH-cam?
@@AngeloVillaniPianist No it is not available on TH-cam.
Nice!!!???
“Nice” is not a nice word.
Glorious interpretation is the least one can say.
@@affonsosantos5729 I totally agree!
@@abe_48 Also I don't understand when you say at ..7'23 .."heavenly melody which been somewhat weakened here"
Please explain.
❤🙏👏👏👏
🙏🙏🙏
gut gut
I somewhat get Robert Schumann's at 36:28.
Когда я слушаю Ростроповича, я горжусь что я русский.
довольно примитивно с вашей стороны
@@punkpoetry череп не давит, изысканный вы наш?
N SS национализм в 21-ом веке есть примитив, ничего не поделаешь
@@punkpoetry причём тут национализм????? Вам тоже никто не мешает смотреть на Буденного и Сталина и гордиться не менее пышными усами. В чём примитив? Один позитив. Лучше по-любому, чем уныло осуждать других в ютюбе) В данном конкретном случае комментатора воодушевляет общность культурных корней с выдающимися композитором и музыкантами. Что в этом плохого? Он, может, пошёл на подъёме и сонату на тему "Камаринской" за пару часов написал, причём тут национализм???
N SS желаю вам этого позитива как можно больше. Фразу насчёт усов Сталина и какого-то Буденного не скажу что разобрал, ну и бог с ним