Hey everyone! So what do you think? Do you like the Legends explanation for red crystals? Forged by dark meditation and anger? Or the new canon way...of a bleeding crystal from your pain? Have a fantastic day everyone! Be mindful and as always, remember, *Qui-Gon Voice* the force WILL be with you...always
Yeah probably, but I wonder if he would still pursue the Dark Side? I imagine he would. Just think about that; cruising in second place, then when they went around a corner where nobody could see...FORCE PUSH OFF THE CLIFF!
I prefer the original Origins to the red lightsabers because I feel that the synthetic lightsaber crystals are more deeply connected to the user and to the Creator because the Creator poured everything into the crystal itself instead of having to steal a crystal from a Jedi. it also means the crystal is more personal to the Sith rather than forced upon if they steal it from a Jedi.
I prefer the reason of the Sith forging crystals through their hatred because that seems so much more powerful and dark then just bleeding the crystal, like they literally made a crystal through their own hatred, anger, and darkness giving these crystals immense power in the dark side rather than just being "Hey look a Jedi crystal! I'm gonna go paint this red because why not"
Wait a minute.....does that mean someone could "cleanse" a red crystal back to blue? Jesus if that actually becomes a thing in the last movie I am done.
And it also contradict Episode 1, Maul is the only Sith for thousand of years, if the crystal taken from the Jedi, then Maul appearance will not be shocking to the council
RevanTheFireMage I think it's more fitting in Vader's case because he was, like a kyber crystal, a jedi that was made to feel intense agony and pain(loss of padme, death of his mother, burning on mustafar) and out of those emotions he embraced it and became a powerful being. It truly is a metaphor for Skywalker's life for Siths are just jedi's who embrace pain and anger and suffering. Power is its own beauty hence the bright crimson color.
This is my opinion, bit it sounds like Disney condensed the process of how a Sith saber is made in legends. Instead of explaining the very long legends process of with meditation over a synthetic crystal, Disney instead said, "You pour your hate into a living crystal..." in order to pour hate into a crystal, a Sith will essentially have to concentrate/meditate the dark side and hate into the forging process. To me, it sounds like a simple way to explain a complicated process. I like it because it aligns a Sith saber to be a more organic extension of who wields the weapon. This is also an easier way to explain the process if they decide to touch on the subject in the future films. A new question to ponder; does this mean that a Sith crystal could be healed by a Jedi to bring it back to the light side?
Since you posted this years ago, you might already know the answer. But in case you don't, spoilers ahead for the Ahsoka book: Ahsoka uses the force to heal the Sixth Brother's sabers and what came out were white lightsabers!
I like the new explanation of red crystals! I find that taking a peace-riddled crystal and pouring in all your hate and pain and rage is a far more primal and animalistic approach than crafting one from scratch. The Dark Side is a matter of Force (not THE Force, but force of will, of power, of dominance) and if it cannot dominate it is bored and useless. The need to conquer and prove your strength to be superior is a driving motivation behind the Dark Side which fits perfectly into this new cannon of conquering crystals either from the mine itself by taking it from the corpse of its previous owner. This new cannon makes crystals living organisms in a way, but also makes them able to be enslaved - which is also befitting to the nature of the Dark Side. I think the new narrative fits the personality of the Sith Order far more completely than the old synthetic crystals.
from my understanding purple indicated that you used some sort of dark side technique to help you battle the dark side hence why windu had one he used a sith fighting style
@@rich1051414 since when and is that old cannon or new cannon also just for clarity for my self which version of cannon is it that the color your crystal takes is based on you
@@rich1051414 also I just went and looked it up and no the purple crystal was old cannon the new cannon explains that the crystals take on properties from there owners there is a novel that is cannon called master and apprentice where obi-wan explains this to some princess
i like the new canon about the red crystals. to me it demonstrates the power that sith try to embellish upon all that dominance is all that matters. to TAKE a jedi's saber and corrupt it is the ultimate slap in the face to a jedi and is the principle of sith philosophy. like palapitne said the "sith and jedi are alike in almost every way" but the basis of sith is to be the same but spit in the face of what the jedi believe. so to TAKE your saber and corrupt it is the true showing of a sith.
L J It just doesnt work. Darth Maul was the first the Sith to be known by the Jedi in thousands of years. However he had his lightsabers when he fought his first Jedi. He killed his first Jedi with his lightsabers. This isnt even old canon im talking about this is new stuff. This idea conflicts with not only the movies, but also the new canon items.
@@jeffcastor9509 It's never stated you HAVE to take a Jedi's crystal, just that you need one, and then make it bleed. Maul probably found a crystal like Jedi Younglings do, and made it bleed. Or even if he needed to kill a Jedi, their a large organization, one random Jedi disappearing isn't to much an issue, especially since Maul was trained as a Sith Assassin, key word, Assassin, aka taking down a target skill fully and stealthily.
vinnie joiner I'm not sure how that would go I mean Obi-Wan is the more level-headed one out of the two which let him figure out the weakness in Grievous's for armed attack and managed to exploit it but Anakin is a lot more aggressive though he is more powerful he is very arrogant and I don't know how he would fare against Grievous with his overwhelming attacks
You know, something has been bothering me about Darth Vader's suit. If it's so sensitive to electrical attacks, then why hasn't anybody ever used an EMP blast on him? You hit Vader with one blast from an EMP rifle or cannon and then his suit malfunctions and shuts down. Without his life support and other mechanical parts down, Vader would have died. Has this been explained in Legends or the new Canon?
The Dragon Warlock He has made it through moments during which his suit was damaged. I don't know if they are canon or not, but he, through the power of his anger and the the force, was capable to survive.
If it shuts down, he would probably compensate by using the force to move until he reactivates it. A good example of that (not saying it would work but the logic by SW standards is sound) is the Super Power Beatdown Vader vs Batman match.
Sir Soundwave the weaker people might get their lower torso ripped off. as for stronger people im sure his claws would impale your genitals and surrounding area
i conside legends and Star Wars of old Canon, as i sure as hell know Star Wars much better than Disney knows Star Wars theirs to me is not canon i don't care how much Disney tells me their shit is real it just isn't canon to Lucas idea and what Stat Wars Jedi and Sith is about.
Just a little constructive criticism: Ease up a bit on the intensity of your inflection. Also, the emperor's voice is way too deep. Other than that, keep up the good work!
"Hey, here's something to help your channel grow and improve" "Oh shut the fuck up" I'm SO glad you aren't in charge of anything. Although, with that behavior, it shouldn't be a surprise.
I liked how lightsaber crystals worked in KOTOR, that they could be found naturally in certain colors. I feel like Disneys system could be compatible with this, since there are random concentrations of the dark side in the galaxy. So it would be possible to harvest crystals from such places. I liked the concept of having to face an ordeal rather than just manipulating the crystal through meditation or direct force powers.
What if the Tusken Raiders killed Luke? Luke: "Ah... What a beatiful day on tatooine..." *yawns* *Tusken Raider comes* "UUUUGH UUUUGH!!!" Luke: "OH CRAP!!! NOT BEAUTIFUL! NOT BEAUTIF..." *Gets killed by Tusken Raider*
Love the way you read these comics and add sound effects, really brings them to life and draws you in to the story! I always look forward to your next video keep it up!
Why doesnt he just send vader to Illum to get a crystal? Be a lot easier if there are no jedi about....! The new cannon explanation, essentially getting blood from a stone, sounds like an attempt to make the sith even more unequivocally evil, which is unnecessary - the sith are about ideology as much as the jedi are, not just bogeymen in black, snarling and killing stuff.
Well their ideology is still based around hate, greed, and fear. SO it would only make sense if Vader was sent to kill a jedi for his crystal. Killing a user of the light side of the force, and using their crystal would add on even more to it's corruption. Even in this way it's still like a ritual for Darth Vader.
because the red saber is more than a weapon, in this case, it becomes a symbol of the sith's power, not only was he able to take a saber from a jedi, he was also able to corrupt it to his will. in that way, they become even more dreadfull to fight. on a second look, it also means that, the suffering of the crystal may affect the jedi he faces, since they can feel the force, it would be fair to say, that the crystal crying for help would be alot more distracting as well, of course it isnt confirmed, but maybe it happens without them noticing.
I like the factor of the pain and making it suffer because that makes it personal and not only that but you are pooring all of the hated things into it making it a reminder to what and who you are as a sith
Please continue on this comic, lightsaber connections to their wielder is one of my favorite topics in the SW universe, as is studying the hilt designs. So, please continue on this particular comic to where he gets his new saber.
well sith can force chock people to make them enable to breath but I don't see the point of pushing oxygen because either way you die not being able to breath
in one of the books thats what force choke is described as. using the force to stop the air flowing into the lungs of your target. rather than using it to constrict the airway. one of the jedi counter a force choke by using the force to move air into their lungs.
why didnt ankins saber turn red after he turned and killed the younglings, choked padme, and fought Obi wan?? He definitely had rage as the novel stated he unleashed his dragon?
Maybe because Anakin didn't want to be a Sith. He hated the Sith but he was doing what he felt was right. This is why he was crying when he did those things. He didn't really become Darth Vader completely until he got cut down and burned alive.
Star Wars Theory, I have a theory... About Star Wars. In the Last Jedi trailer, Luke says "It's time for the Jedi to end." But before that, Luke asked Rey what she saw in the force. Rey said she saw the light, the dark... And the balance. The Ashla, Boogan... And Bendu. What Luke could possibly means that the Sith and Jedi must end, and become the Je'daii. And we also know Legends material is being brought into Star Wars cannon. So what do y'all think about this theory? Seem likely, or not?
What if: Anakin gets killed in the Tusken camp. While Anakin speaks to his mother, a Tusken Raider enters the camp and attacks the Jedi killing the surprised Anakin. Now Obi-Wan would be alone in the arena and probably killed. There would be no Vader or his children. Padme would be alone on Tatooine
I feel like this one is more true to the sith, by taking another Jedis lightsaber and in a sense kidnapping the Kyber Crystal and torturing the Crystal to bend it to their will, is more what they are about instead of just making one
Wesley Cantrell I think the crystal is a reflection of ones self. You don't torture the crystal you project you're emotions and feelings onto it. Theoretically a darkjedi with a red lightsaber could be a thing.
I was actually liking it except about the Kyber crystals being alive...That's totally goes against what was said in Rouge One. Didn't he say that they where made from collapsed stars?
Probably something among these lines: He would overthrow Vader by the time the events of Ep VI took place. Without the best pilots from the galaxy at their side, the Rebels would surely perish on the battle of the 1st Death Star, Leia would naturally be on Yavin and die once Vader located the rebel base and destroyed the planet. Han would naturally continue his life as a smuggler,shrugging off the undisputed rise of the Empire.
How we he overthrow Vader? He would never have been trained by Ben/Obi-Wan, and he never would have 'unlocked' his Force powers. He would has just become a normal stormtrooper.
The Extremely Mediocre Gamer But Vader or the Emperor would eventually hear about a pilot who was able to perform such amazing feats for the Empire. As soon as one of them met Luke, they'd be able to feel how strong he was in the Force, which would lead to either Vader or Palpatine recruiting him as a secret apprentice in other to kill the other (Much like in Force Unleashed).
Why would they execute her? They know she's allied with the rebels. By torturing her and then (maybe) faking their escape, she could lead the Empire to the Rebel base, which would then end their problems.
The cannon version is darker more in character with the nature of the dark side taking a Jedi crystal and making it bleed with anger, rage and pain for a former Jedi turned sith it is a statement that you relinquish every thing the Jedi and the light side stood for once the crystal bleeds there’s no turing back.
Why not both? Take the crystal from a jedi and put it in the forge to twist and reforge it in the dark side though meditation. But If I had to choose I'd go with the method pre-Disney lore purge.
Decker Nation yea, instead of just meditating and making it "bleed red" it's basically tortured, broken apart, reconfigured, and filled with the dark side. And you could probably add a detail about how in tune with the dark side someone is or something that could make a crystal that causes something like Ren's unstable saber from cracks and such from uncontrolled hate and torment. So Maul would have the blade he has from his focus and dedication, while Ren who will slash up a room in a rage has a cracked crystal that causes the unstable blade.
I think both ideas are really good. But I like the idea of the crystals being alive, in a sense. Makes me wonder what the crystals in the Death Star felt
If I can offer advice to your Emperor voice: His voice tone sometimes falls soft-mid-range into frail-old-man-palpatine while explaining things. He's a good story teller, and like Palpatine was, he lures them into a false-sense of comfort before crushing their dreams.
Well if the Jedi have blue, green and yellow to determine their genre of a jedi then the sith should have different colors too like red, black and purple.
That IS new cannon. The Black Mandalorian blade is from Rebels and everything in the cinematic universe is still considered cannon aka Mace's lightsaber. :) ... and now the Sith/Darkside red blade AND Ahsoka's white blades.
I was against the new crystal thing & prefered the old way of changing crystals color, but now I kinda like it the way they explained now here that the Lightsabers bleed from all the pain and anger from the users, but it kinda contradicts alot of dark moments in the movies like 1. Obiwan when angered against Maul who killed Qui Gon in front of him, 2. When Anakin goes insane with rage against the Sand People, 3. When Luke snaped against Vader.
OMG THEN WHAT HAPPENED??? I gotta get these comics! Bro so many star wars channels but yours is my fav so far! I love how you do the voices and recount everything its amazing!!
Doesn't that depend on your perspective anyway. Old or new way, the dark side still stands for what it does. Generally forming our antagonists. Even If you don't think the Dark side represents an antagonist. It's still true that sith draw power from feelings such as rage. I personally like the idea that those feelings corrupt kyber crystals. Over manufactured synthetic crystals. Each to their own opinion though.
Well the most prudent detail about the old synthetic crystals was that they could short out a jedi saber. But it never happened once in any of the movies, tv shows, or video games. It was strictly a comicbook thing. So they tried to over simplify it with a lazy answer which was "Oh...... well it's a 1 in a million chance of happening..... so......uhhhh.... they wouldn't put that in the movies cause it would be unfair to the hero...... uh yeah!!!!" And the most unfortunate part is ppl actually bought it
Surprisingly, I like the new version. It teaches the Sith to harness their inner anger, rage, hatred, etc...and focus it on the crystal. The same way they would focus on cutting down an enemy with a saber
'In their own way.' This does not mean kyber is a living being. Crystals, after all, have many of the same properties of living beings in that they grow, reproduce, and in some ways respond to stimulation while consuming resources. Kyber however it seems is spiritually sensitive and I feel that Maul's meditation for days would still be a thing that is done. After all he would want his blade to be a perfect reflection of his rage and hate and so would meditate for days on end to hone it to a razor's edge that he blade would have no choice but to accept and mirror.
Does this explain Asage Ventris (however its spelled) or any one not considered full sith can have red blade? Can the crystal call someone who is force sensitve like in episode 7 since it is alive?
DAZZAKE dude you realize Disney disagreed over 200 books and acted like they never happened right? And that they don't listen to the fans suggestions ...you said we're the ones who don't deserve to breathe? You're the one who supports the eradication of 80% of Star Wars
It fits with how they interpreted the crystals in The Clone Wars. Where the crystal is sort of a mystical thing, that chooses its user. Makes sense that the sith would have to bend one to their will. I kind of like it.
I’m on the fence about how I feel about synthetic or bleeding but the bleeding the crystals thing made me feel sorry for crystals lol Great video by the way!
I don't like it. I liked the explanation that they were artificially made. It just seems like a needless and pointless change Disney made just to show you they can change anything they want and to hell with previous facts. Maybe they did this just so they can make a scene in the movies where a lightsaber changes color.
Hey first I love what your doing with the narrating comics and other novelizations. And your titles are spot on. However equally confusing as each one stands by itself even though they are sequels. I love to follow along, since they are comics and chapters, so putting like a tag or handle with episode number at the end? Then we can see what the video will cover like always, but also be able to find the chapters that we might have missed. Also you have a really good emperor Palpatine voice. And I like synthetic crystals better. I'd go for like a dark side planet filled with red crystals, but this 'bleeding' talk is silly.
I've heard somewhere (not sure where) that at one time in the story each person's lightsaber became the color that matched their personality/alignment/whatever I kind of like that explanation
I kind of like a mixture of the two ways a sith gets their red crystal - through the shattered remains of the kyber crystals, the sith meditates and forges them together with the power of the force and their rage, twisting the crystal until it bleeds red.
Hey everyone! So what do you think? Do you like the Legends explanation for red crystals? Forged by dark meditation and anger? Or the new canon way...of a bleeding crystal from your pain?
Have a fantastic day everyone! Be mindful and as always, remember, *Qui-Gon Voice* the force WILL be with you...always
Star Wars Theory hey man, I prefer the legends version, tbh but I don't really mind too too much
Star Wars Theory to be honest I like them both. I see why Disney went the route they did, but am of legends view and ideas.
Star Wars Theory Make :How Darth Vader stole the Lightsaber
i liked the legends explanation. Support from finland!
Star Wars Theory Love your vids !!!
Hey, I've got a good one for you: "What if Palpatine ended up getting into professional racing like he wanted, instead of politics?"
Sith Thunder He would still cheat
Yeah probably, but I wonder if he would still pursue the Dark Side? I imagine he would. Just think about that; cruising in second place, then when they went around a corner where nobody could see...FORCE PUSH OFF THE CLIFF!
Sith Thunder
HAHAHAHAHAH SCREW YOU ALL I WIN YOU GUYS
-PALPATINE
Kevin TCP either way, as long as he was careful no one would realize what was going on except for those trained in the use of the force.
He would be called Sheev "The Fast and Sidious" Palpatine instead of "The Senate"
I prefer the original Origins to the red lightsabers because I feel that the synthetic lightsaber crystals are more deeply connected to the user and to the Creator because the Creator poured everything into the crystal itself instead of having to steal a crystal from a Jedi. it also means the crystal is more personal to the Sith rather than forced upon if they steal it from a Jedi.
I prefer the reason of the Sith forging crystals through their hatred because that seems so much more powerful and dark then just bleeding the crystal, like they literally made a crystal through their own hatred, anger, and darkness giving these crystals immense power in the dark side rather than just being "Hey look a Jedi crystal! I'm gonna go paint this red because why not"
Wait a minute.....does that mean someone could "cleanse" a red crystal back to blue?
Jesus if that actually becomes a thing in the last movie I am done.
Jericho Strayker Dunno about Blue but Ahsoka healed an inquisitor's red and it turned white.
MissVasques Shit
And it also contradict Episode 1, Maul is the only Sith for thousand of years, if the crystal taken from the Jedi, then Maul appearance will not be shocking to the council
RevanTheFireMage I think it's more fitting in Vader's case because he was, like a kyber crystal, a jedi that was made to feel intense agony and pain(loss of padme, death of his mother, burning on mustafar) and out of those emotions he embraced it and became a powerful being. It truly is a metaphor for Skywalker's life for Siths are just jedi's who embrace pain and anger and suffering. Power is its own beauty hence the bright crimson color.
This is my opinion, bit it sounds like Disney condensed the process of how a Sith saber is made in legends. Instead of explaining the very long legends process of with meditation over a synthetic crystal, Disney instead said, "You pour your hate into a living crystal..." in order to pour hate into a crystal, a Sith will essentially have to concentrate/meditate the dark side and hate into the forging process. To me, it sounds like a simple way to explain a complicated process. I like it because it aligns a Sith saber to be a more organic extension of who wields the weapon. This is also an easier way to explain the process if they decide to touch on the subject in the future films. A new question to ponder; does this mean that a Sith crystal could be healed by a Jedi to bring it back to the light side?
Since you posted this years ago, you might already know the answer. But in case you don't, spoilers ahead for the Ahsoka book:
Ahsoka uses the force to heal the Sixth Brother's sabers and what came out were white lightsabers!
When all the issues of this series come out. You should combine them into an ultimate movie.
Please cover Anakin vs Sandman
I reckon Anakin really hates Metallica
Obi-Wan Kenobi Stop it master
Obi-Wan Kenobi You're a bold one
I like the new explanation of red crystals! I find that taking a peace-riddled crystal and pouring in all your hate and pain and rage is a far more primal and animalistic approach than crafting one from scratch. The Dark Side is a matter of Force (not THE Force, but force of will, of power, of dominance) and if it cannot dominate it is bored and useless. The need to conquer and prove your strength to be superior is a driving motivation behind the Dark Side which fits perfectly into this new cannon of conquering crystals either from the mine itself by taking it from the corpse of its previous owner.
This new cannon makes crystals living organisms in a way, but also makes them able to be enslaved - which is also befitting to the nature of the Dark Side. I think the new narrative fits the personality of the Sith Order far more completely than the old synthetic crystals.
So Samuel L Jackson poured all of his mothafuckas into the kyber crystal? He is the only one with a purple color
Cannon was added for purple kyber crystals. Purple kyber crystals are found on the planet Hurikane.
from my understanding purple indicated that you used some sort of dark side technique to help you battle the dark side hence why windu had one he used a sith fighting style
@@lieroushenry3959 No, it means they are using a purple kyber crystal from Hurikane...
@@rich1051414 since when and is that old cannon or new cannon also just for clarity for my self which version of cannon is it that the color your crystal takes is based on you
@@rich1051414 also I just went and looked it up and no the purple crystal was old cannon the new cannon explains that the crystals take on properties from there owners there is a novel that is cannon called master and apprentice where obi-wan explains this to some princess
i like the new canon about the red crystals. to me it demonstrates the power that sith try to embellish upon all that dominance is all that matters. to TAKE a jedi's saber and corrupt it is the ultimate slap in the face to a jedi and is the principle of sith philosophy. like palapitne said the "sith and jedi are alike in almost every way" but the basis of sith is to be the same but spit in the face of what the jedi believe. so to TAKE your saber and corrupt it is the true showing of a sith.
L J It just doesnt work. Darth Maul was the first the Sith to be known by the Jedi in thousands of years. However he had his lightsabers when he fought his first Jedi. He killed his first Jedi with his lightsabers. This isnt even old canon im talking about this is new stuff. This idea conflicts with not only the movies, but also the new canon items.
@@jeffcastor9509 It's never stated you HAVE to take a Jedi's crystal, just that you need one, and then make it bleed. Maul probably found a crystal like Jedi Younglings do, and made it bleed.
Or even if he needed to kill a Jedi, their a large organization, one random Jedi disappearing isn't to much an issue, especially since Maul was trained as a Sith Assassin, key word, Assassin, aka taking down a target skill fully and stealthily.
What if anakin fought general grievous and not obi wan? Think that would be interesting
Jabraulter Braulter could do like both sides if he lost what sidious would do and if he won if the story line would continue the same or change
Anakin would have died and Obi-Wan in his despair would have become Darth Hello There.
lmfao
MarEXksz no, Darth high ground!
vinnie joiner I'm not sure how that would go I mean Obi-Wan is the more level-headed one out of the two which let him figure out the weakness in Grievous's for armed attack and managed to exploit it but Anakin is a lot more aggressive though he is more powerful he is very arrogant and I don't know how he would fare against Grievous with his overwhelming attacks
What if Star Wars Theory was a character in Star Wars?
Maybe I am.
:)
Star Wars Theory Jedi or Sith?
What if Star Wars theory never found Star Wars? Maybe he could do this in a draw my life thing for 1 million subscribers.
Kira Granett he would be the high ground
Why not Grey? ;)
I am loving these videos. how do you not have more subscribers. have a great day or night man
This video was great to today. I really liked it. Keep up the great work.
You know, something has been bothering me about Darth Vader's suit. If it's so sensitive to electrical attacks, then why hasn't anybody ever used an EMP blast on him? You hit Vader with one blast from an EMP rifle or cannon and then his suit malfunctions and shuts down. Without his life support and other mechanical parts down, Vader would have died. Has this been explained in Legends or the new Canon?
The Dragon Warlock He has made it through moments during which his suit was damaged. I don't know if they are canon or not, but he, through the power of his anger and the the force, was capable to survive.
Maybe it has some kind of protection against emp attacks? Interesting question, far as I know there's not been any explanation
Energy Shields, maybe?
Or maybe just the good ol' Deus Ex Machina: "He used the Force."
Hy- chan I think it's the latter... but it's true that the Force is the biggest plot armour there ever was
If it shuts down, he would probably compensate by using the force to move until he reactivates it. A good example of that (not saying it would work but the logic by SW standards is sound) is the Super Power Beatdown Vader vs Batman match.
"Makes me feel young, good food does"
Nate's Film Tutorials Told you, have I, of young days?
+Logan Chandlers
Yes, yes. Owners of the dancefloor, we where!
...
...
...
Accept it, you must. For ever and ever!
Tuning3434 Ben? Steve Ben Obi Wan Larry Kenobi? Where have you been?
Tuning3434 wait a second! Far2 was there too?!
+reveladorreal
Just give in, midychlorify!
...
...
Ladies locker rooms, Duke, ladies locker rooms!
What if general grievous kicked everyone in the balls
Sir Soundwave they would explode
Sir Soundwave the weaker people might get their lower torso ripped off. as for stronger people im sure his claws would impale your genitals and surrounding area
SMG gaming true true but the he'd have to clean up the mess
Anakin would be rendered infertile, padame wouldn't get knocked up, and there'd be no Luke or Leah.
Christopher Woodbury Leia*
I like the new way cause it's brutal as fuck
Edgy for no reason, is what it is.
As brutal as the Sith.
I like the Legends explanation for red crystals better because it takes more dedication.
As always, wonderful video Star Wars Theory!
i conside legends and Star Wars of old Canon, as i sure as hell know Star Wars much better than Disney knows Star Wars theirs to me is not canon i don't care how much Disney tells me their shit is real it just isn't canon to Lucas idea and what Stat Wars Jedi and Sith is about.
Just a little constructive criticism: Ease up a bit on the intensity of your inflection. Also, the emperor's voice is way too deep. Other than that, keep up the good work!
His emperor voice isn't much deeper than RotS Palpatine right after being "deformed" though...
Lee Thomas Oh shut the fuck up
Raptor Jesus damn son he's just offering some criticism
"Hey, here's something to help your channel grow and improve"
"Oh shut the fuck up"
I'm SO glad you aren't in charge of anything. Although, with that behavior, it shouldn't be a surprise.
Do one on black sabers!
What if Obi-Wan DID NOT say "hello there "🤣🤣😂
what is Hello there said "Obi-Wan"
He would become,"Darth Hello There"
anthony ward mindfuck
I liked how lightsaber crystals worked in KOTOR, that they could be found naturally in certain colors. I feel like Disneys system could be compatible with this, since there are random concentrations of the dark side in the galaxy. So it would be possible to harvest crystals from such places. I liked the concept of having to face an ordeal rather than just manipulating the crystal through meditation or direct force powers.
Wow, I just realized that your outro really fits the topic of this video. Amazing!
What if the Tusken Raiders killed Luke?
Luke: "Ah... What a beatiful day on tatooine..." *yawns*
*Tusken Raider comes*
"UUUUGH UUUUGH!!!"
Luke: "OH CRAP!!! NOT BEAUTIFUL! NOT BEAUTIF..."
*Gets killed by Tusken Raider*
The Force obi wan: AW FUCK
Vader would feel more pain after he found out Luke was his son.
But pain fuels the dark side...
DON"T REMIND ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Darth Vader ever heard of Darth Sion? He used his pain to keep himself from dying, earning the title "Lord of Pain." Take hints from that buddy
The Force That is s great idea! Dude do it!
I like the Legends explanation more. Great video, though. Keep up the good work!
I like this. Can you do a video on the rest of the comic? Maybe like: The new Canon way of how Vader got his Lightsaber
Pretty excellent voiceovers I must say, especially for Sidious. He has always been my favorite Star Wars character.
Love the way you read these comics and add sound effects, really brings them to life and draws you in to the story! I always look forward to your next video keep it up!
The new canon shows you that you truly have a hateful person in your presence, no doubt. But it doesn't for sure mean they are a Sith.
Anyone else notice how Vader and Palpatine are like father and son?
Why doesnt he just send vader to Illum to get a crystal? Be a lot easier if there are no jedi about....! The new cannon explanation, essentially getting blood from a stone, sounds like an attempt to make the sith even more unequivocally evil, which is unnecessary - the sith are about ideology as much as the jedi are, not just bogeymen in black, snarling and killing stuff.
The Jedi and Sith are religions; philosophies.
Well their ideology is still based around hate, greed, and fear. SO it would only make sense if Vader was sent to kill a jedi for his crystal. Killing a user of the light side of the force, and using their crystal would add on even more to it's corruption. Even in this way it's still like a ritual for Darth Vader.
because the red saber is more than a weapon, in this case, it becomes a symbol of the sith's power, not only was he able to take a saber from a jedi, he was also able to corrupt it to his will. in that way, they become even more dreadfull to fight.
on a second look, it also means that, the suffering of the crystal may affect the jedi he faces, since they can feel the force, it would be fair to say, that the crystal crying for help would be alot more distracting as well, of course it isnt confirmed, but maybe it happens without them noticing.
It's literally getting blood from a stone, but korriban had a few natural red crystals if I remember
I like the factor of the pain and making it suffer because that makes it personal and not only that but you are pooring all of the hated things into it making it a reminder to what and who you are as a sith
Dude i only want to say your voice acting is always amazing the best is always from the emperor keep up the good work man
I Like the original way the lightsaber of a sith was made
That's actually a pretty cool explanation. Maybe even cooler than the original one.
Nice vid.
I like both explanations.
Would be amazing if the synthetic crystals were added back in
to the canon later on, but keep the bleeding crystals too.
Please continue on this comic, lightsaber connections to their wielder is one of my favorite topics in the SW universe, as is studying the hilt designs. So, please continue on this particular comic to where he gets his new saber.
Can force users push oxygen away from people, so they would die??
well sith can force chock people to make them enable to breath but I don't see the point of pushing oxygen because either way you die not being able to breath
in one of the books thats what force choke is described as. using the force to stop the air flowing into the lungs of your target. rather than using it to constrict the airway. one of the jedi counter a force choke by using the force to move air into their lungs.
why didnt ankins saber turn red after he turned and killed the younglings, choked padme, and fought Obi wan?? He definitely had rage as the novel stated he unleashed his dragon?
Because it would only be logical for it remain blue. Episode 3 hadn't been done by Disney. thankfully.
Michael Manczko actually the lightsaber was going to turn red during the fight with obi wan but they scrapped it. idk why.
Decker Nation lucas probably realized how stupid that would have been.
Maybe because Anakin didn't want to be a Sith. He hated the Sith but he was doing what he felt was right. This is why he was crying when he did those things. He didn't really become Darth Vader completely until he got cut down and burned alive.
If you read and listened to the Canon explanation you would know why....
Star Wars Theory, I have a theory... About Star Wars. In the Last Jedi trailer, Luke says "It's time for the Jedi to end." But before that, Luke asked Rey what she saw in the force. Rey said she saw the light, the dark... And the balance. The Ashla, Boogan... And Bendu. What Luke could possibly means that the Sith and Jedi must end, and become the Je'daii. And we also know Legends material is being brought into Star Wars cannon. So what do y'all think about this theory? Seem likely, or not?
For those who don't know.
Ashla = Light
Boogan = Dark
Bendu = Balance
Btw, I loved the video. It's interesting how the Star Wars Universe can change from Legends to cannon.
Kodey - so the First Jedi worship the Moose God.
The bendu is what represents balance... So I guess they do
Romeo Javier 😃
have you done a vid how darth obtained his kyber crystal in this new canon comic or did the issues just end there?
Those voices you do are awesome!!
Ray is wicket the ewok's kid
No, if Rey was an Ewoke she would at least cute and fluffy.
i love you, MTFBWY
What if: Anakin gets killed in the Tusken camp.
While Anakin speaks to his mother, a Tusken Raider enters the camp and attacks the Jedi killing the surprised Anakin.
Now Obi-Wan would be alone in the arena and probably killed.
There would be no Vader or his children.
Padme would be alone on Tatooine
LukaZ _ al heil teh tuskin rader
i don't understand why ppl gives this a thumbs down?... Thanks bro keep going on this
I really love your videos man. Keep up the good work
I feel like this one is more true to the sith, by taking another Jedis lightsaber and in a sense kidnapping the Kyber Crystal and torturing the Crystal to bend it to their will, is more what they are about instead of just making one
Wesley Cantrell I think the crystal is a reflection of ones self. You don't torture the crystal you project you're emotions and feelings onto it. Theoretically a darkjedi with a red lightsaber could be a thing.
"The light saber is an extension of yourself, young padawan."
What if the Jedi had found and trained Palpatine
...Hey wait a minute, this is all a pun on squeezing "blood from a stone."
I see what you did there Disney.
Yeah I don’t think so
fantastic video as usual bud always glad to see your putting up awesome content i really enjoy thank you
Hey Theory! Can you put this in the comic playlist? It seems to be missing after the first two. :)
yup
I have always preferred the old Sith and old Star Wars.
I like the new way because sith sabers in canon are built in a way any jedi would never use. That makes it special.
What if Obiwan went to capture Fives instead of Anakin?
Doughboyz Then he may have survived.
Thats actually a great idea
Yeah, I'm wondering how everything would turn out. Woulda been better since Anakin's mind was already clouded, so his judgment was incorrect.
could I know the music that plays on all your videos?? i love them all
the Palpatine voice is getting pretty good man! I can only recommend maybe getting a little bit higher pitched
I was actually liking it except about the Kyber crystals being alive...That's totally goes against what was said in Rouge One. Didn't he say that they where made from collapsed stars?
"Alive in their own way"
Alive doesn't mean conscious or even sapient.
In Rogue One it was said that "The strongest stars have hearts of Kyber", that does not necessarily mean it can only be forged inside of a star.
The crystal is a deadly laser
What if Luke joined the imperial academy?
Probably something among these lines:
He would overthrow Vader by the time the events of Ep VI took place.
Without the best pilots from the galaxy at their side, the Rebels would surely perish on the battle of the 1st Death Star, Leia would naturally be on Yavin and die once Vader located the rebel base and destroyed the planet.
Han would naturally continue his life as a smuggler,shrugging off the undisputed rise of the Empire.
How we he overthrow Vader? He would never have been trained by Ben/Obi-Wan, and he never would have 'unlocked' his Force powers. He would has just become a normal stormtrooper.
The Extremely Mediocre Gamer
But Vader or the Emperor would eventually hear about a pilot who was able to perform such amazing feats for the Empire. As soon as one of them met Luke, they'd be able to feel how strong he was in the Force, which would lead to either Vader or Palpatine recruiting him as a secret apprentice in other to kill the other (Much like in Force Unleashed).
Actually Leia would be executed on the Death Star and the empire would not be able to locate the rebel base on Yavin IV.
Why would they execute her? They know she's allied with the rebels. By torturing her and then (maybe) faking their escape, she could lead the Empire to the Rebel base, which would then end their problems.
I love the voices, you should do audio work for Disney
The cannon version is darker more in character with the nature of the dark side taking a Jedi crystal and making it bleed with anger, rage and pain for a former Jedi turned sith it is a statement that you relinquish every thing the Jedi and the light side stood for once the crystal bleeds there’s no turing back.
"DO IT"
Why not both? Take the crystal from a jedi and put it in the forge to twist and reforge it in the dark side though meditation. But If I had to choose I'd go with the method pre-Disney lore purge.
Pieshka Coltic that is a good idea in my opinion. it's pretty much a geneticly modified crystal.
Decker Nation yea, instead of just meditating and making it "bleed red" it's basically tortured, broken apart, reconfigured, and filled with the dark side. And you could probably add a detail about how in tune with the dark side someone is or something that could make a crystal that causes something like Ren's unstable saber from cracks and such from uncontrolled hate and torment. So Maul would have the blade he has from his focus and dedication, while Ren who will slash up a room in a rage has a cracked crystal that causes the unstable blade.
what if ahsoka fell in love with anakin
Elite Trooper 51 I like this, but I think she did love him but more like a brother or a father, rather than a lover.
Caution_CrAzY Friendzoned
Then some battle droids join in
Preston Garvey don't you have some settlements that need some help?
Can people pls stop doing this? I'd sooner join the Sith than see that fanfic. Star Wars Theory pls don't do it
I think both ideas are really good. But I like the idea of the crystals being alive, in a sense. Makes me wonder what the crystals in the Death Star felt
If I can offer advice to your Emperor voice: His voice tone sometimes falls soft-mid-range into frail-old-man-palpatine while explaining things. He's a good story teller, and like Palpatine was, he lures them into a false-sense of comfort before crushing their dreams.
Well if the Jedi have blue, green and yellow to determine their genre of a jedi then the sith should have different colors too like red, black and purple.
Black is Madalorian and Purple is for practitioners of Vapad.
YEah I know that. But we're in a new canon now
That IS new cannon. The Black Mandalorian blade is from Rebels and everything in the cinematic universe is still considered cannon aka Mace's lightsaber. :) ... and now the Sith/Darkside red blade AND Ahsoka's white blades.
Big Blue Black could be an Advance Version of Red, stolen from Multiple times.
But some jedi lightsabers are red.....
Redeye Gaming exactly
Old legends is far superior
Redeye Gaming Because there afony and hate for the darkside was strong. They were darkjedi after all.
Ezekiel Powell Not all of them... master Gallia had a red one but the order said she shouldn't use it.
a red saber stay red even if now is used by a jedi(but a jedi can purify it)
I actually liked the legends way better
I was against the new crystal thing & prefered the old way of changing crystals color, but now I kinda like it the way they explained now here that the Lightsabers bleed from all the pain and anger from the users, but it kinda contradicts alot of dark moments in the movies like 1. Obiwan when angered against Maul who killed Qui Gon in front of him, 2. When Anakin goes insane with rage against the Sand People, 3. When Luke snaped against Vader.
Best channel, ever
Obi-wan Kenobi hello there
Another happy channel
Obi-wan Kenobi it's over obi wan I have satines vagina🙊
yeah its great its just so hard to watch vids in order it would be cool if he made playlist
Yes, from a certain point of view
OMG THEN WHAT HAPPENED??? I gotta get these comics!
Bro so many star wars channels but yours is my fav so far! I love how you do the voices and recount everything its amazing!!
What if fives shot fox first?
Star Commander nice
The old way is way better.
They don't make the sith seem like just mindless antagonists and one sided characters, but the new one do
Doesn't that depend on your perspective anyway. Old or new way, the dark side still stands for what it does. Generally forming our antagonists.
Even If you don't think the Dark side represents an antagonist. It's still true that sith draw power from feelings such as rage.
I personally like the idea that those feelings corrupt kyber crystals. Over manufactured synthetic crystals.
Each to their own opinion though.
Well the most prudent detail about the old synthetic crystals was that they could short out a jedi saber. But it never happened once in any of the movies, tv shows, or video games. It was strictly a comicbook thing. So they tried to over simplify it with a lazy answer which was "Oh...... well it's a 1 in a million chance of happening..... so......uhhhh.... they wouldn't put that in the movies cause it would be unfair to the hero...... uh yeah!!!!" And the most unfortunate part is ppl actually bought it
I'm the SENATE
I am*
littleg8r I AM*
Surprisingly, I like the new version. It teaches the Sith to harness their inner anger, rage, hatred, etc...and focus it on the crystal. The same way they would focus on cutting down an enemy with a saber
I like the new canon reason, it seems so much more emotional and difficult for a sith to achieve it
*BECAUSE RED IS FASTER!!!!!!*
Legends>cannon!
Orkan You said it brother or sister don't want to piss off Disney and assume your gender.
You will be unhappy to hear this but im a Strait. White. Male.
Orkan "No...no its not true...THAT'S IMPOSSIBLE!!!! "
legends over canon when it comes to lightsabers or just in general?
+Nabil Iman in general
hello there I'm first
'In their own way.' This does not mean kyber is a living being. Crystals, after all, have many of the same properties of living beings in that they grow, reproduce, and in some ways respond to stimulation while consuming resources. Kyber however it seems is spiritually sensitive and I feel that Maul's meditation for days would still be a thing that is done. After all he would want his blade to be a perfect reflection of his rage and hate and so would meditate for days on end to hone it to a razor's edge that he blade would have no choice but to accept and mirror.
Does this explain Asage Ventris (however its spelled) or any one not considered full sith can have red blade? Can the crystal call someone who is force sensitve like in episode 7 since it is alive?
what if count dooku was actually anakin
Legends is superior, I reject disneys "new cannon".
Fuck anything disney added or changed the way is was before was better
Seth Benson Shut up.
DAZZAKE nah he's right, you shut up.
DAZZAKE dude you realize Disney disagreed over 200 books and acted like they never happened right? And that they don't listen to the fans suggestions ...you said we're the ones who don't deserve to breathe? You're the one who supports the eradication of 80% of Star Wars
Blah blah blah, cry more why don't you? Bunch of fucking cry babies, I swear.
DAZZAKE please you ignorant fuck look at the comments between all of us and then tell me who's the cry baby
It fits with how they interpreted the crystals in The Clone Wars. Where the crystal is sort of a mystical thing, that chooses its user. Makes sense that the sith would have to bend one to their will. I kind of like it.
they are are not wands.
I’m on the fence about how I feel about synthetic or bleeding but the bleeding the crystals thing made me feel sorry for crystals lol Great video by the way!
I don't like it. I liked the explanation that they were artificially made. It just seems like a needless and pointless change Disney made just to show you they can change anything they want and to hell with previous facts. Maybe they did this just so they can make a scene in the movies where a lightsaber changes color.
Jordan Little yeah maybe ren's lightsaber changes from broken red to beautiful green
you should do complete readings for the canon comics...you make the story come alive
yo fam what background music do u use? i like the epic feel
my question is now about ashoka white crystals she purify the crystals from the sixth brother... so she heal the wound inflicted to the crystal?
What's the BGM at 2:15? Been looking for it.
Interesting :D. I really love the voice actor for palpatine. it gives chills men :D
Hey first I love what your doing with the narrating comics and other novelizations. And your titles are spot on. However equally confusing as each one stands by itself even though they are sequels. I love to follow along, since they are comics and chapters, so putting like a tag or handle with episode number at the end? Then we can see what the video will cover like always, but also be able to find the chapters that we might have missed.
Also you have a really good emperor Palpatine voice.
And I like synthetic crystals better. I'd go for like a dark side planet filled with red crystals, but this 'bleeding' talk is silly.
I've heard somewhere (not sure where) that at one time in the story each person's lightsaber became the color that matched their personality/alignment/whatever I kind of like that explanation
I like the idea of forging your red cristels. To me it means you've created something that can become much stronger and more in quantity as well.
I kind of like a mixture of the two ways a sith gets their red crystal - through the shattered remains of the kyber crystals, the sith meditates and forges them together with the power of the force and their rage, twisting the crystal until it bleeds red.