Yep bus driver droid was there. Also there is an almost identical statue on At Attin in the background when the kids are on there way to school. It’s the same species as neel. It actually has the head too. Check it out. King no head has three fingers, short legs, and wide body. It’s got to be the same guy. A relative of Neel maybe!
I looked for that and this video showed the scene after the break 0:27 where the bus comes up from the tunnel. The statue in the background could be of Neel's race, but it's not clear. It also is in front of a building if that matters, rather than in some kind of park. Someone suggested no-head could have been Emperor Palpatine and not from the time the planet was hidden.
There is a statue there but it doesn’t look anything like the one on At Achrin. Left hand not right hand, doesn’t seem tall enough, correct about the species. All the other architecture seems to be identical, and still whims reaction to it would be strange if they had a statue of their own.
I don't think we will see the other planets. There were images and video of At Achrann released before the episode but nothing of similar clone planets. The only other locations we have seen are of the resort and scrapyard, possibly on the same planet and the treasure cavern. Given some clues from background character costumes all three may even be on the same planet.
Excellent video. I really enjoy when youtubers talk about the plot and not about their hate. Brilliant analysis. I think those planets are experiments, and everyone is the same planet with different governments.
the RX series bus driver droid was on the tram broken and slightly dismantled but it's there but else where there aren't any droids so good catch there.
On the other hand we saw only a handful of small locations on the planet so it could be there are droids, albeit broken and not functioning, here and there possibly stripped for parts to make weapons. Similarly, the reason we don’t see anyone of Neel’s species is there just happen to have been none in the few spots on the planet we saw at the moment we saw them. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, aside from humans I only recall seeing a couple of other species but that doesn’t mean they aren’t just off camera or around the next ruin. As for the presence of weapons, we’re explicitly told that the people trade with off worlders for weapons. That’s what belligerents in a war do, they buy weapons.
Good one about the droids! I watched a number of videos about episode 4, and this is the first that said it was missing droids! They have a tank that looks like it's from _The Phantom Menace_ but no battle droids that they could have bought! My next thought was that droids were running the planet (many have suggested that for At Attin since episode 1) but overthrown so it's taboo to have droids on the planet. But again, we didn't see how Jod and SM-33 were treated by the other tribe. Maybe it was as he said, he talked to them and bought the animals. Or he and SM-33 talked to them, and killed all the warriors, then took the animals? But yeah, several people are talking about them being experimental worlds. In this video it's implied the Great Work would be to provide long-term sociological data to help build better worlds. So having one without droids would be a factor. What would be some others? I think there's not enough information to say that At Achrann wasn't multi-species. They could have gone back to their own neighborhoods or other cities to protect themselves, and this area is just human-versus-human. I counted no more than 4 Neel-types in the testing center of 180 desks (not all desks and students shown). Of course since we didn't see anyone shoot or kill each other, there's the possibility they were playing at war, sounding like "Games without Frontiers" by Peter Gabriel. That would have made more sense if the adults on both sides had used kids who herd animals to scout "enemy" positions and conduct raids. But Jod's gun at the end was defective, which suggests it's show for off-worlders so they don't try to conquer them. The thing about the weapons: it's suggested the gun on the school was always there. So some think Neel will go home, go up to his school's roof and activate the gun to save the city from pirates. If there's no guns on At Attin then he can't do that. It's possible hand weapons and big guns are just locked up and not visible in day-to-day living. I wish the kids had learned conflict-resolution in school as part of being a peaceful society for 1000 years, and they could have negotiated a truce between the tribes, instead of Jod solving the problem off-screen for them.
The Supervisor is an order 66 survivor that knew of At Attin’s because he was born on At Attin and being force-sensitive was taken in by the Jedi. The Jedi are the only group capable of hiding 9 planets for the Republic. The Jedi were charged with maintaining the peace on the At-Planets, and after order 66 the Jedi stopped coming to their aid causing 8 of the planets to fall in some way. The destruction of At Attin’s coordinates was the entire purpose of SM33 and the captain. A fallen Jedi would match up N.A. Nawood’s storyline. Nawood is also an order 66 survivor that turned to piracy to survive, but due to his Jedi training he took to stealing from the pirates, smugglers and other nefarious institutions. I would expect in the next couple of episodes Whims credits will be found in Jod’s possession, and he killed the Hattan’s instead of trading the credits. Disney seems to be setting up a duel between to order 66 survivors and how the two coped differently.
His point was no droids on the planet, but there is a bus driver droid when she does that slide in the bus. My point was no active droids: they overthrew their droid masters.
I'd assume all the droids were destroyed in the cattle raiding wars between the local factions. If these guys are willing to throw kids into battle, they do the same with the droids until no more droids were left.
What if: Same planet. Just different region. The lore said the other planets were destroyed no? But this planet (that they got coordinates to) exists 🤔
i think the supervisor is Palpatine Son..Rey's Dad. and these skeleton crew acidentaly comprimise him and he runs off and hides Rey..starts "force awakens".. the supervisor though he found a good spot to hide etc..etc..
Please no time travel in Star Wars. One of the problems with a sci-fi show like Star Trek, is they get carried away: if one implausible or impossible fiction is evident, then why not anything and everything? Kind of like in _No Way Home:_ "Magic is real here?"
@@sandal_thong8631time travel, using the world between worlds, already exists in Star Wars. It is very limited though, only accessible by force users and no real control as to when you see/can interact with.
Yep bus driver droid was there. Also there is an almost identical statue on At Attin in the background when the kids are on there way to school. It’s the same species as neel. It actually has the head too. Check it out. King no head has three fingers, short legs, and wide body. It’s got to be the same guy. A relative of Neel maybe!
I looked for that and this video showed the scene after the break 0:27 where the bus comes up from the tunnel. The statue in the background could be of Neel's race, but it's not clear. It also is in front of a building if that matters, rather than in some kind of park. Someone suggested no-head could have been Emperor Palpatine and not from the time the planet was hidden.
There is a statue there but it doesn’t look anything like the one on At Achrin. Left hand not right hand, doesn’t seem tall enough, correct about the species.
All the other architecture seems to be identical, and still whims reaction to it would be strange if they had a statue of their own.
That roof turret is a huge Checkov Gun. I bet it is there on the school in At Attin.
the bus had a droid.
I don't think we will see the other planets. There were images and video of At Achrann released before the episode but nothing of similar clone planets. The only other locations we have seen are of the resort and scrapyard, possibly on the same planet and the treasure cavern. Given some clues from background character costumes all three may even be on the same planet.
What did you think of the shots in the video then?
Are they At Attin too?
In the tram my man the star tours droid is clearly visible
Great analysis buddy!
Now i need to watch ep 1 and see what exists. I wonder if the giant laser cannon is in front of the school closed under a dome.
Excellent video. I really enjoy when youtubers talk about the plot and not about their hate. Brilliant analysis. I think those planets are experiments, and everyone is the same planet with different governments.
These planets reminds me of the side colonies from gundam
the RX series bus driver droid was on the tram broken and slightly dismantled but it's there but else where there aren't any droids so good catch there.
On the other hand we saw only a handful of small locations on the planet so it could be there are droids, albeit broken and not functioning, here and there possibly stripped for parts to make weapons. Similarly, the reason we don’t see anyone of Neel’s species is there just happen to have been none in the few spots on the planet we saw at the moment we saw them. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, aside from humans I only recall seeing a couple of other species but that doesn’t mean they aren’t just off camera or around the next ruin. As for the presence of weapons, we’re explicitly told that the people trade with off worlders for weapons. That’s what belligerents in a war do, they buy weapons.
Oh I missed that, dang.
@ you good we all look over things it’s okay but you are right there aren’t any droids like at Attin does
Good one about the droids! I watched a number of videos about episode 4, and this is the first that said it was missing droids! They have a tank that looks like it's from _The Phantom Menace_ but no battle droids that they could have bought! My next thought was that droids were running the planet (many have suggested that for At Attin since episode 1) but overthrown so it's taboo to have droids on the planet. But again, we didn't see how Jod and SM-33 were treated by the other tribe. Maybe it was as he said, he talked to them and bought the animals. Or he and SM-33 talked to them, and killed all the warriors, then took the animals?
But yeah, several people are talking about them being experimental worlds. In this video it's implied the Great Work would be to provide long-term sociological data to help build better worlds. So having one without droids would be a factor. What would be some others? I think there's not enough information to say that At Achrann wasn't multi-species. They could have gone back to their own neighborhoods or other cities to protect themselves, and this area is just human-versus-human. I counted no more than 4 Neel-types in the testing center of 180 desks (not all desks and students shown).
Of course since we didn't see anyone shoot or kill each other, there's the possibility they were playing at war, sounding like "Games without Frontiers" by Peter Gabriel. That would have made more sense if the adults on both sides had used kids who herd animals to scout "enemy" positions and conduct raids. But Jod's gun at the end was defective, which suggests it's show for off-worlders so they don't try to conquer them.
The thing about the weapons: it's suggested the gun on the school was always there. So some think Neel will go home, go up to his school's roof and activate the gun to save the city from pirates. If there's no guns on At Attin then he can't do that. It's possible hand weapons and big guns are just locked up and not visible in day-to-day living.
I wish the kids had learned conflict-resolution in school as part of being a peaceful society for 1000 years, and they could have negotiated a truce between the tribes, instead of Jod solving the problem off-screen for them.
Correction: there's a bus driver droid after the Troik kid does the slide in the bus. So sorry about your theory of no droids.
The Supervisor is an order 66 survivor that knew of At Attin’s because he was born on At Attin and being force-sensitive was taken in by the Jedi.
The Jedi are the only group capable of hiding 9 planets for the Republic. The Jedi were charged with maintaining the peace on the At-Planets, and after order 66 the Jedi stopped coming to their aid causing 8 of the planets to fall in some way. The destruction of At Attin’s coordinates was the entire purpose of SM33 and the captain. A fallen Jedi would match up N.A. Nawood’s storyline.
Nawood is also an order 66 survivor that turned to piracy to survive, but due to his Jedi training he took to stealing from the pirates, smugglers and other nefarious institutions.
I would expect in the next couple of episodes Whims credits will be found in Jod’s possession, and he killed the Hattan’s instead of trading the credits. Disney seems to be setting up a duel between to order 66 survivors and how the two coped differently.
Pretty sure i saw a bus driver droid on At-Acrin
His point was no droids on the planet, but there is a bus driver droid when she does that slide in the bus. My point was no active droids: they overthrew their droid masters.
I'd assume all the droids were destroyed in the cattle raiding wars between the local factions. If these guys are willing to throw kids into battle, they do the same with the droids until no more droids were left.
I'd hope they used the droids for battle before children.
What if:
Same planet. Just different region. The lore said the other planets were destroyed no? But this planet (that they got coordinates to) exists 🤔
When things get bad, the droids pick up and relocate to a new area with a new barrier
Like LOST and their research stations on the island to study different things
i think the supervisor is Palpatine Son..Rey's Dad. and these skeleton crew acidentaly comprimise him and he runs off and hides Rey..starts "force awakens".. the supervisor though he found a good spot to hide etc..etc..
Please no.
Feels more like time travel or parallel universe. Seems more likely than clone planet if you ask me
Please no time travel in Star Wars. One of the problems with a sci-fi show like Star Trek, is they get carried away: if one implausible or impossible fiction is evident, then why not anything and everything? Kind of like in _No Way Home:_ "Magic is real here?"
@@sandal_thong8631time travel, using the world between worlds, already exists in Star Wars. It is very limited though, only accessible by force users and no real control as to when you see/can interact with.