"you have become a far greater Jedi than I could ever hope to be." That line always did something to me, Obi-Wan was truly the biggest believer in Anakin.
This hits even harder when you remember that in the beginning Obi-Wan didn't really believe in Anakin and only trained him because of Qui-Gon and how by the end Obi-Wan truly became Anakin's biggest believer
Its like a parent or sibling watching the one you raised become a monster. Its natural to blame yourself look at anakin in ep 2 when his mother died. He felt only guilt.@@alceusrydan6237
"Obi-Wan. May the Force be with you" "Goodbye, old friend. May the Force be with you" The fact that Anakin wanted to be with his master but he has to obey on the task they have placed upon him and Obi-Wan is confident enough to leave him alone on this moment, believing that nothing could ever come between them, make their words so deep
It’s like it’s so sad how close they were Obi wan left with confidence if something like order 66 happened Anakin along side Mace would stop any threat. I hope they make some clone wars side timeline of where anakin stays good and brings peace and trains Luke as his Own with Leia even
0:24 the proud look on obi-wan's face as his apprentice attempts to show true humility. There are so so so many ways their paths could have changed in this moment. Absolutely heartbreaking
Obi Wan telling Anakin “Goodbye old friend” is a very underrated dialogue. This is the last meeting between the two as brothers. Obi Wan is saying bye to the Anakin he knew and loved so dearly in this scene forever.
Listen closely to Anakin's voice. He's making a really great effort to apologise to Obi-Wan. He's totally disagreed with Council, but with this loves and respects his Master and knows, that his behaviour made him upset. He doesn't really feel guilty about what he did, but wants Obi-Wan to know, that his intentions are clear. Prequels are so underrated...
He’s trying to repair their relationship basically. Very similar to episode 1 with Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon. I love Ewan McGregor’s performance as Obi-Wan here, you see how much he loves and cares for Anakin. And it’s contrasted perfectly with him later on being horrified and heartbroken into what he becomes. Hayden is great too. It appears that Anakin feels good about the relationship but he really doesn’t. He’s worried about what they think of him. He’s concerned about his confusion and motivation for things including to power to save people from death and upset about the fact that the council doesn’t trust him.
That's the bond student and teacher have there basically family at this point. But qui Gon jinn thought obi wan that respect for the council means nothing if they don't deserve it. After all he rebelled against them for a long time which is why they never allowed him on the council. And deep down obi wan seeing anakin doing only reminded him of his master. Which would of been a good chance to have mentioned him in this moment. And passed on Jin's words of wisdom.
"I have taught you everything I know" We can deduce from this line, that some time after this conversation, Obi-Wan learned about the high ground advantage.
Anakin knew about the high ground. Obi-Wan even reminded him of it and begged him to stop because it was practically suicide for Anakin to try to strike from below. Anakin's arrogance had completely blinded him.
Anakin already knew of the high ground advantage as he studied the way Obi Wan defeated maul, he was just arrogant and thought he could take out his master the way obi wan had defeated maul.
@@nohomers100 Why would I cite the clone wars? And them chasing after Zam in Attack of the Clones, they’re bickering like older and younger brother in that scene.
This is honestly one of the more heartbreaking scenes. 1. It's the last time Obi Wan sees Anakin before he becomes Vader. 2. Anakin actually acknowledges his arrogance. It gives a glimmer of hope that he is strong enough not to give into it and turn to the dark side. But of course that's not what happens.
The sad thing is that Anakin tried so hard to do the right thing. He went straight to Windu and turned Palps in, despite being terrified of losing Padme. If Windu hadn't tried to execute him on the spot, Anakin wouldn't have been forced to act in a moment of panic.
And Obi-Wan finally gives him the approval and validation he’s been longing for…it’s just that given what happens next, it feels like too little, too late
@@derek96720yeah honestly,if windu acted a bit more rational there,then maybe things wouldn't have gone for the worse, especially since the council already knows how emotional he is and triggering him would cause him to do very unwise things
@@darling.............. Windu was also conflicted. He certainly did not want to break the Jedi code, but he was ready to throw himself under the bus to end the greatest threat that they faced. He saw what Palps can do and how powerful he is, he also knows that outside his own personal power, he controls pretty much everything. If he had left him to go there it would have been definitely over for the Jedi and the Republic, hence also the impulsive action of Windu to try and end his life there.
@@derek96720 I used to belief so but I've gotten away from that line of thinking years ago. If you had a dictator in your grasp who was responsible for the death of billions of beings through a war he engineered just for the purpose of establishing his empire, wouldn't the right thing to do be to execute him? Both Windu and Anakin (unless he was even stupider than the films made him out to be) knew Palpatine was behind the Clone Wars. The guy in front of you has committed multiple capital crimes. One could bring up due process and such but realistically, if you *knew* the guy in front of you is a career war criminal, I think most of us would agree that it'd be justified to kill him. One could argue that Anakin was desperate to save Padme and allowed that desperation to get the better of him (something the novelization makes clear). But that has another flaw. Anakin knew Dooku was behind Padme's assassination attempts, and that Dooku was Sidious's apprentice. Further, in the novel, he knew that Padme and Palpatine were political adversaries, and that Palpatine does not take kindly to political opposition (which he made clear by equating them to "traitors"). But since these were Prequels, they couldn't exactly just nullify the original timeline so we get plot conveniences.
No matter how many times I watch, there’s a piece of me that hopes things turn out differently than they did. But, that’s obviously impossible. Hurts my soul
I think Disney would make a lot of money if they made what if scenario type shows or films. I think if they chose the right ones they’d be very successful. Like if Obi Wan turned Anakin back to the light but Sidious killed Yoda, or if Qui Gon survived just to name a couple. Sadly though the chances of that happening are next to zero.
The scene where Anakin tells Mace Windu about Palpatine being a Sith lord and then wanting to go with him, has strong symbolism.If you look closely Anakin is in half of the shadow and light when he's standing there showing the conflict of the light and dark side. Very powerful. Lucas is a genious.
"it will not be long before the council makes you a Jedi master." I kinda get the feeling that obi wan is giving Anakin a wink and a nudge like "yeah, once the war is over were gonna make you a master."
@@Tuturial464I honestly wonder if it was up to Obi Wan he probably would have already made Anakin a master, at the latest after the Invisible Hand and defeating Dooku
"And you have become a far greater Jedi than I could ever be." Obi-Wan truly was a great friend and brother. He knows Anakin is dealing with so many problems (too many to name) and yet Anakin has still held onto the light side, being on par with Obi-Wan. A shame that Anakin fell to the dark side.
Ive always suspected that Obi-Wan knew more about Anakin than he let on. He knew good and well there was more going on between him and Padme than "just friends".
@@DV_Dark_Jedi In the novel Obi wan directly alludes to knowing and not interfering with anakin's relationship with padme because it was the only thing that made him happy.
This is definitely one of those moments that Obi Wan replays in his head over and over like a record. I have moments I replay of people that I ended up having a falling out with, or they died. Little moments with people can hold so much meaning, and its heart breaking when they become permanently entrapped in a memory loop with no future.
I know a popular theory is the moment Obi Wan dropped Luke off he went to Mos Eisley and got plastered at the Cantina mentally processing everything moments like this, Dooku telling him the truth on Geonosis, the final conversation on Mustafar etc.
@@LegendaryCaptainobi wan by ep 4 had relequished his demons and become the wise sage. Kenobi show illustrated this by showing us his transition from emotional mess to jedi master once again.
The fact Anakin calls him Obi-Wan in the final farewell, after Obi-Wan just told him he was a greater Jedi, he finally felt like the two were equals and brothers, just as Obi-Wan says after their final confrontation.
“goodbye old friend”, without knowing it was really the last time they were going to cross paths as brothers, is one of the deepest lines in the whole star wars saga.
Anakin needed to only trust Obi-Wan's words here, and if he had, things may have been different, but his frustration towards the council and his desire to save Padme fucked everything up.
Faith in The Force obliterates fear, just like Faith in Christ casts out fear, and doubt. Anxiety is a lack of trust/faith in YAH's Will. (Force typology)
To me hayden more than anyone got treated horribly unfair, he did a great job and i couldnt imagine a better anakin, the negativity he got for his role at the time was so undeserved
Weird direction from higher ups telling him what to say and how to say it, and retards mistaking that for the actors responsibility like some of the replies in this section
This scene is what makes the scene so damned heartbraking as we know that this is the last time that Obi wan will see the true Anakin Skywalker for 20 plus years
Just because he gave himself a new name as some cheap psycho babble trick to disassociate from his crimes doesn't mean that video isn't the true anakin. Every action he ever took was the true anakin. It's in him, it is him.
@@fd8934 you two guys are retards, it was already confirmed Anakin and Vader are not the same, they are different personalities, Anakin only wanted to use the dark side to save padme, but the dark side corrupted him destroying his being and gave birth to the sith Lord sidious named Darth Vader, another thing is that sidious named him, he didn't changed his name himself, i swear the ignorant star wars fans are not even real fans
@@fd8934 I see your point but anakin became so disillusioned with his feelings he began to do things that would disgust his old self. He becomes someone else, he betrays all of his morals and friends. That was the point Lucas tried to make.
@@fd8934 perfect example being the younglings in the beginning of ROTS he would gladly lay down his life to protect the Jedi temple and the younglings. He is a leader who is deeply compassionate of his subordinates, by the end he’s the very person leading the assault on the temple and personally massacres the children.
The apprentice humbles himself before the master, and the master humbles himself before the apprentice. A scene of genuine brotherhood between these 2.
1:05 it's so sad after a brief respite provided by a friend seeing all of Anakins problems coming back to the forefront of his mind, much like waking up the day after a personal tragedy.
Anyone notice Obi-Wan going out to the sunny, light area and Anakin staying in the shadows, dark? Lucas knew what he's doing. What a brilliant underrated scene.
0:16 Did you see how Obi-Wan twitched his eyebrows like that? That's the one thing I find hilarious in movies like this: A character's eyebrow twitching.😅😂
Separating Anakin and Obi-Wan proved to be a grave mistake especially as far as the Jedi council is concerned. I don’t believe Palpatine’s influence on Anakin would’ve been as strong if he’d gone with Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan kept him focussed and on the right path.
You have a point there as we see how rapidly Anakin falls to the dark side after Obi-Wan's departure, just like when He went on a rampage and slaughtered the tusken raiders after His mother's death in Episode 2, it always seemed like Anakin was at His worst when Obi-Wan WASN'T there to keep Him in check
When obi wans face lights up as anakin apologizes... Ewan is an awesome actor. And it's interesting how obi wan said goodbye, old friend, as if they'd never meet again.
Seeing this scene in the theater when the movie came out was so heavy. You could feel that shit was gonna go down after this scene & what I love about scenes like this, especially in this movie, is how it makes you wonder what woulda happened if Anakin went with Obi-Wan. RotS has so many great situations that are so damn fun to think about happening a different way, but unlike other movies, they never eclipse the actual movie we got. I love this movie so much.
From the novel *He couldn't just stand here and let him walk away. Not now. He had to say something... He had a sinking feeling he might not get another chance.*
0:54 - Anakin is dimmed by the shadows, predicting his "heel turn" at the climax of the film 0:56 - Kenobi is within shining lights, symbolizing his longevity and commitment to the light side of the force. Foreshadowing at its finest.
Is it just me or this is similar to Vader and Luke? Also Kylo Ren represents darkness. Rey represents light. But in the 9th film, Rey is powerful than Ben. Ben is not offically a Sith. That's why he is not the main character. His maternal side is pure jedi. His mom and uncle are children of the chosen one. He got the snarky personality of Han. Rey is the granddaughter of the Emperor. that's ironic.
I always liked the friendly dynamic between Anakin and Obi-Wan. They both had such deep respect for each other. Makes what happened all the more tragic.
That scene. Knowing what their next meeting is. It's gut-wrenching, heartbreaking. And that's why it's one of the greatest! Also a great detail, one clone signaling to another in the background to give their General some space for a heart-to-heart convo with his former apprentice =3
“You didn’t kill Anakin Skywalker, I did” A part of him however small still cares and loves Obi Wan, it was a subtle way for Vader/Anakin to free Obi Wan of the guilt he carried himself with. It also deepens the context of, “Obi Wan once thought as you do” in ROTJ and “He’s more machine than man now”
@@Killzoneguy117 A presence I didnt feel since Original meaning: Obi-Wan totally and utterly beat me New meaning: Obi-Wan totally and utterly beat me And he still was a "learner/padawan" because he coulnt let go his need to win-as demonstrated in episode five with the flashbacks.
Take note Disney - this movie is how you make a simple and interesting story that’s easy to follow: you focus the story on only the few main protagonists and not 50 other side characters. And you advance the plot through proper character development, not flashy action scenes that are there only for the sake of being there. The action scenes in this movie are 100% story driven and have an actual purpose in advancing the plot unlike any of the sequel movies.
I think the side character thing works with the mandalorian but really does not work when they bring established characters in for their own show and then fill it with loads of random new characters. As far as I am concerned Obi wan show has been pretty good but it is indeed a slippery slope.
@@BlueSkullX I've never shitted on them. I loved them. I've actually liked the prequels much more than the OT when I was a kid. So...am I not part of the fanbase?
@@BlueSkullX it's the majority. It's just that there minority is more vocal on the internet. Also, the prequels weren't hated by the fanbase, but by the media/critics. They didn't have yt and fb at the time.
Man that “goodby old friend” from obi wan must replay in obis head all the time while he was on Tatooine. It was more of a goodbye than you thought at the time, he really was saying goodbye to Aniken for the last time
@@derek96720 True, I guess that seems very yeah of course but it really is crazy at the same time. The worst is when you try to find them and rekindle later but they’ve passed at that point
Everytime I watch this scene, I get so sad, especially knowing this is the last time they see each other as friends/brothers. If Anakin had gone with Obi Wan or if someone else had gone and Obi Wan had stayed back to help Anakin, then maybe everything could have been avoided. But that's what makes ROTS so good, the tragedy and the constant "what if" scenarios that could have changed things.
This feels a lot more impactful after Clone Wars. When this came out they’re history before that was of teacher and student who barely tolerated each other. After clone wars and all the went through, the upcoming events have a much more devastating impact.
That’s one of my main problems with the prequels. We don’t actually get to see many scenes of Obi Wan and Anakin’s relationship. I feel like if we did, the scenes in Revenge of the Sith would have hit a lot harder.
@@sophieamandaleitontoomey9343 I agree...and i think that was a massive waste of the chemistry between Hayden & Ewan. We only get that tired, strict dad trying to raise a moody teenager vibe from most of their scenes together but that wasn't the reality...obi wan raised him and they did have a strong bond despite Anakin's different acts of defiance from time to time, which Obi Wan learned to tolerate and accept as a part of his personality
0:55 the imagery here is fantastic and incredible foreshadowing of what is to follow.... Obi wan standing in the light and Anakin standing in the shadows signifying his gradual descent into the dark side... the prequels were well and truly underrated in so many ways
So sad man. To see what kind of relationship they could’ve had as the years went on. 😭😭 and obi wan carries the weight that because of him or his teachings it was all his fault that anny turned in to Vader, which isn’t true. It’s just so sad cause obi wan is one of the best Jedi ever imo, in his steadfastness to his duty, he had to grow up quickly because he wasn’t much older than anakin when qui gon was killed. He is everything a Jedi should strive to be and it’s heartbreaking knowing that he unnecessarily bears the weight of what happened. It’s why he went into exile more or less to guard over luke - that maybe if he couldn’t save anakin he could save his son. And in the end he did. And he died well - knowing that what he set out to do he had finally after long years accomplished. Man, what a beautiful story arc.
It’s crazy from going from the most humble and apologetic version of Anakin to the most arrogant and pompous version when they see each other next on mustafar
Anakin admitting he's been arrogant to Obi-Wan speaks volumes. Anakin has always been self-assured and cocky, so hearing him try to be humble and admit his faults is so powerful and all the more tragic when he becomes drunk on power and slips back into the hubris that leads to his downfall.
It's really painful It is noted Obi-Wan does know Anakin has a thing with Padme and rather than get judgy he actually tries to understand him. He also vouched for Anakin trying to explain them why is not a good idea to send him to the chancellor to spy on him and despite Anakin's issues and behavior, he's still patient enough and still compliments for his achievements nonetheless. Has Obi-Wan stayed with Anakin rather than been sent to fight Grievous, maybe Darth Vader wouldn't have happened. And to make it worse, while arguably not fully canon now because of being related to Legends, the novelization actually demonstrates some moments when Anakin's friendship with Obi-Wan in the rescue mission actually let him see a nastier side of Palpatine, which could have prevented all the subsequent disgraces.
Finally, someone here who gives credit where it's due. Everyone else keeps saying Lucas is a genius, and sure he's great, but when there's dialogue like in this scene it's the actors doing the heavy lifting.
@@HighNoonTex I feel like this scene could've been a little more natural with Obi-Wan putting his hand on Anakin's shoulder and even a handshake/hug before he leaves. Would've shown they were more like friends before leaving. Cause yeah Lucas is the master of wooden dialogue lol
@@akillzonefanboy3313 i think its better that that feeling of wanting to do that is thick in the scenes atmosphere but there is a boundry between them which for obi-wan os the jedi code and for anakin his secrets. Both are reachinf out for eachother but neither one can close the gap
@@oz2362 Obi-Wan was mentored by Qui-Gon Jinn who actually was more attached and often defied tradition without straying too far from the jedi order's teachings. Obi-Wan also was willing to defy the council to teach Anakin but Yoda granted his request anyways. Also Anakin is a man who believes Jedi are encourage to love others. He would've learned that from Obi-Wan. Also Qui-Gonn does place his hand on Shmi's shoulder as a term of endearment when Anakin powers up his pod racer the night before. He's a jedi.
People might dislike the prequels due to the cgi/bandwagon and jar jar but looking back they were genuinely really good, episode 3 over episode 6 anyday
Not to mention people forget that for its day the CGI was groundbreaking, with new technologies and techniques created just for these films that were then used on other films like Jurrasic Park etc. Not to mention Jar Jar was also groundbreaking CGI as the first fully CGI character in a film. Also also, people don't look past the CG to realize the Prequels used more practical effects than the entirety of the OT.
The last time we seen them both really loving and understanding one another. As a die hard fan, I wish we could’ve seen the 2 talk things out before both of their lives went completely left
There’s something very heartwarming and heartbreaking about this scene. To feel these two things at the same time makes Anakin’s fall so much more devastating for him and Obi-Wan.
Imagine after Anakin said "You're going to need me on this one, master", Obi Wan agreed to take him with to Utapau to confront Grievous (maybe even the 501st Legion as well). For Palpatine, the whole point was to get Anakin and Obi Wan separated.
You know what’s more sad, is that we probably won’t get another scene like this in any Star Wars feature film. These words hold so much weight, so much so that Hollywood can’t even carry them.
As usual… great music transition from the beginning of the scene to the end where the heavy undertones start foreshadowing the conflict to come…brilliant story telling
"I have taught you everything I know...except for well there is this one thing about the high gr- you know what? It isn't important...I'll see you around my friend"
In the end only Obi wan and Padme really knew he was a good person. He didn’t always do things by the book but he loved people and cared about them. If the Jedi hadn’t saw that as a problem they could’ve helped him channel that need to protect into a positive outcome.
I like how the Star Wars story (despite its flaws) is so coherant that it hits deep for everyone lol. Every video about Star Wars on YT has everyone in their feels in the comments. Great franchise.
"you have become a far greater Jedi than I could ever hope to be." That line always did something to me, Obi-Wan was truly the biggest believer in Anakin.
This hits even harder when you remember that in the beginning Obi-Wan didn't really believe in Anakin and only trained him because of Qui-Gon and how by the end Obi-Wan truly became Anakin's biggest believer
@@lilidittrich5512and then when anakin turned dark. Obi wan said that he failed Anakin, that it was his fault anakin turned to the dark side 😢
Its like a parent or sibling watching the one you raised become a monster. Its natural to blame yourself look at anakin in ep 2 when his mother died. He felt only guilt.@@alceusrydan6237
several hours later: "You have become the very thing you swore to destroy"
This scene hurts ne man lol
The last time Obi-Wan will see Anakin before the celebration on Endor
deep
BibleThump
@@fabiansmh5060 Wtf, whats deep about that? He/she was just spitting facts
@@ahabduennschitz7670 uhhh chill?
@@bullymaguire6315 Uhhh i am chill? Im just pointing out the obvious. Who hurt you?
"Obi-Wan. May the Force be with you"
"Goodbye, old friend. May the Force be with you"
The fact that Anakin wanted to be with his master but he has to obey on the task they have placed upon him and Obi-Wan is confident enough to leave him alone on this moment, believing that nothing could ever come between them, make their words so deep
Beautifully said.
It’s like it’s so sad how close they were Obi wan left with confidence if something like order 66 happened Anakin along side Mace would stop any threat. I hope they make some clone wars side timeline of where anakin stays good and brings peace and trains Luke as his Own with Leia even
@@jye_24 you are a softie and that would kill the tragedy that makes star wars so special
@@jye_24 if he stay good, how the force can be balance 🤔
@@vietcuongnguyenle8530 That's the problem, the good ending need the order 66 to happen. If not, no balance is made
0:24 the proud look on obi-wan's face as his apprentice attempts to show true humility. There are so so so many ways their paths could have changed in this moment. Absolutely heartbreaking
He remembers when he did the same with Qui Gon as a padawan
0:16 the eyebrow raise is another sign of that
Not really he was the chosen one it was meant to.happen
Yes.. many other actors would not have been as great in this moment
Lies again? CBF French
Obi Wan telling Anakin “Goodbye old friend” is a very underrated dialogue. This is the last meeting between the two as brothers. Obi Wan is saying bye to the Anakin he knew and loved so dearly in this scene forever.
I like to think they reunited and made peace as brothers in the force, as the last scene of ROTJ show them side by side.
Lies again? Do Organize Meeting
@@NazriB how many burritos did you eat?watch the turtle closely and see
Good bye anakin. Hello darth vader
@@d4c798 too bad they were already dead
Listen closely to Anakin's voice. He's making a really great effort to apologise to Obi-Wan. He's totally disagreed with Council, but with this loves and respects his Master and knows, that his behaviour made him upset. He doesn't really feel guilty about what he did, but wants Obi-Wan to know, that his intentions are clear. Prequels are so underrated...
He’s trying to repair their relationship basically. Very similar to episode 1 with Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon. I love Ewan McGregor’s performance as Obi-Wan here, you see how much he loves and cares for Anakin. And it’s contrasted perfectly with him later on being horrified and heartbroken into what he becomes. Hayden is great too. It appears that Anakin feels good about the relationship but he really doesn’t. He’s worried about what they think of him. He’s concerned about his confusion and motivation for things including to power to save people from death and upset about the fact that the council doesn’t trust him.
That's the bond student and teacher have there basically family at this point. But qui Gon jinn thought obi wan that respect for the council means nothing if they don't deserve it. After all he rebelled against them for a long time which is why they never allowed him on the council. And deep down obi wan seeing anakin doing only reminded him of his master. Which would of been a good chance to have mentioned him in this moment. And passed on Jin's words of wisdom.
Pause. Obi Wans hair changes between scenes
Original 0:29
Hair changes 0:35
Back to original 0:48
@@activatekruger446 lol
I MISSED THE PART WHERE THAT’S MY PROBLEM
"I have taught you everything I know"
We can deduce from this line, that some time after this conversation, Obi-Wan learned about the high ground advantage.
Lol. He lied to him.
No, Kenobi taught him the Maul kill move which is why Anakin/Vader tries it twice on Mustafar, we know how the 2nd attempt went.
Anakin knew about the high ground. Obi-Wan even reminded him of it and begged him to stop because it was practically suicide for Anakin to try to strike from below. Anakin's arrogance had completely blinded him.
Anakin already knew of the high ground advantage as he studied the way Obi Wan defeated maul, he was just arrogant and thought he could take out his master the way obi wan had defeated maul.
"Anakin, remember, you can use the low ground and turn on your lightsaber for a surprise attack!"
Such a genuine wholesome scene. Lucas really knows how to develop great relationships then bring them to a heartbreaking end.
Are you joking? This is the only scene of them acting as genuine friends from three movies
@@nohomers100 Wrong.
@@freebandz4332 what’s the other scene? From the movies not clone wars
@@nohomers100 Why would I cite the clone wars? And them chasing after Zam in Attack of the Clones, they’re bickering like older and younger brother in that scene.
Yes I like how he built them up as brothers over the films
"He was the best star pilot in the galaxy,a cunning warrior and A GOOD FRIEND"
yes thanks for repeating that lol
@@kellymulderino7156 yes thanks for repeating that lol
@@patrykk11 yes thanks for repeating that lol
@@ErraticFaith yes thanks for repeating that lol
@@SDKFZ259 yes thanks for repeating that lol
They separated like friend's.
They reunited like enemies.
A strong friendship and they are like brother's.
They separated in death
They united in the Force
Naruto/ sasuke
You don't need those apostrophes
@@jacobroa6912 Sasuke is a jerk face.
@@taraungoogle8482 chills
This is honestly one of the more heartbreaking scenes.
1. It's the last time Obi Wan sees Anakin before he becomes Vader.
2. Anakin actually acknowledges his arrogance. It gives a glimmer of hope that he is strong enough not to give into it and turn to the dark side. But of course that's not what happens.
The sad thing is that Anakin tried so hard to do the right thing. He went straight to Windu and turned Palps in, despite being terrified of losing Padme. If Windu hadn't tried to execute him on the spot, Anakin wouldn't have been forced to act in a moment of panic.
And Obi-Wan finally gives him the approval and validation he’s been longing for…it’s just that given what happens next, it feels like too little, too late
@@derek96720yeah honestly,if windu acted a bit more rational there,then maybe things wouldn't have gone for the worse, especially since the council already knows how emotional he is and triggering him would cause him to do very unwise things
@@darling.............. Windu was also conflicted. He certainly did not want to break the Jedi code, but he was ready to throw himself under the bus to end the greatest threat that they faced. He saw what Palps can do and how powerful he is, he also knows that outside his own personal power, he controls pretty much everything. If he had left him to go there it would have been definitely over for the Jedi and the Republic, hence also the impulsive action of Windu to try and end his life there.
@@derek96720 I used to belief so but I've gotten away from that line of thinking years ago. If you had a dictator in your grasp who was responsible for the death of billions of beings through a war he engineered just for the purpose of establishing his empire, wouldn't the right thing to do be to execute him? Both Windu and Anakin (unless he was even stupider than the films made him out to be) knew Palpatine was behind the Clone Wars. The guy in front of you has committed multiple capital crimes. One could bring up due process and such but realistically, if you *knew* the guy in front of you is a career war criminal, I think most of us would agree that it'd be justified to kill him.
One could argue that Anakin was desperate to save Padme and allowed that desperation to get the better of him (something the novelization makes clear). But that has another flaw. Anakin knew Dooku was behind Padme's assassination attempts, and that Dooku was Sidious's apprentice. Further, in the novel, he knew that Padme and Palpatine were political adversaries, and that Palpatine does not take kindly to political opposition (which he made clear by equating them to "traitors").
But since these were Prequels, they couldn't exactly just nullify the original timeline so we get plot conveniences.
No matter how many times I watch, there’s a piece of me that hopes things turn out differently than they did. But, that’s obviously impossible. Hurts my soul
Right there with ya 😔
Saddest movie ever
Well hey look on the brightside, Hayden and Ewan are really great friends in real life :)
Dude I knowwwwww. Every fucking time I rewatch RoTS I desperately want things to be different.
I think Disney would make a lot of money if they made what if scenario type shows or films. I think if they chose the right ones they’d be very successful. Like if Obi Wan turned Anakin back to the light but Sidious killed Yoda, or if Qui Gon survived just to name a couple. Sadly though the chances of that happening are next to zero.
The scene where Anakin tells Mace Windu about Palpatine being a Sith lord and then wanting to go with him, has strong symbolism.If you look closely Anakin is in half of the shadow and light when he's standing there showing the conflict of the light and dark side. Very powerful. Lucas is a genious.
It's also in this scene. Obi Wan and Anakin go on two separate paths, Anakin is in shadow when he walks away, while Obi Wan is in sunlight
@@therealx1ras453 Yeah i notice that as well on the second time watching the movie very symbolic.
Lucas haters would say it was on accident 🤣
They are dumb
They can't redo these movies
Yes
Goodbye... Darth
😔😢
OBI WAN!!
OBI WAAAAAN!
@@Paragus_No.1Handsome_Saiyan *darth vader breath
Kenobi…
"it will not be long before the council makes you a Jedi master." I kinda get the feeling that obi wan is giving Anakin a wink and a nudge like "yeah, once the war is over were gonna make you a master."
But it was too late because on how the jedi played themselves with their dogmatic thinking
@@Tuturial464I honestly wonder if it was up to Obi Wan he probably would have already made Anakin a master, at the latest after the Invisible Hand and defeating Dooku
“Goodbye, Old friend”........ that ages well so fast!
Goodbye... Darth
OBI WANNNNNNNNNNN🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬@@miguelgomez6891
"And you have become a far greater Jedi than I could ever be." Obi-Wan truly was a great friend and brother.
He knows Anakin is dealing with so many problems (too many to name) and yet Anakin has still held onto the light side, being on par with Obi-Wan.
A shame that Anakin fell to the dark side.
Ive always suspected that Obi-Wan knew more about Anakin than he let on. He knew good and well there was more going on between him and Padme than "just friends".
@@DV_Dark_Jedi In the novel Obi wan directly alludes to knowing and not interfering with anakin's relationship with padme because it was the only thing that made him happy.
he did not fall, the jedi push him into the dark side.
@@CVargas202 no he definitely fell, personal responsibility is a thing lol.
@@kleatise52 as if he had a choice... lol
What a friendly and respectful gentleman. I would say he will go on and help a lot of people including his master.
Help them to die
Indeed he will. He will help children as well and give them hope.
@@atulvikram5279 He will also help slaugther some younglins what great guy
@@crow_g1639 Slaughter? That's a big word old friend. He helps them escape the harsh reality known as life :)
@@atulvikram5279 not just the children...but the men and women too
0:15 Obi-Wan raises his eyebrows when Anakin says he's been arrogant!
This is definitely one of those moments that Obi Wan replays in his head over and over like a record. I have moments I replay of people that I ended up having a falling out with, or they died. Little moments with people can hold so much meaning, and its heart breaking when they become permanently entrapped in a memory loop with no future.
I know a popular theory is the moment Obi Wan dropped Luke off he went to Mos Eisley and got plastered at the Cantina mentally processing everything moments like this, Dooku telling him the truth on Geonosis, the final conversation on Mustafar etc.
@@LegendaryCaptainobi wan by ep 4 had relequished his demons and become the wise sage. Kenobi show illustrated this by showing us his transition from emotional mess to jedi master once again.
🫂 it's an awful feeling. And you can't change anything about it. Just stuck in that same memory loop. It hurts alot 💔
The fact Anakin calls him Obi-Wan in the final farewell, after Obi-Wan just told him he was a greater Jedi, he finally felt like the two were equals and brothers, just as Obi-Wan says after their final confrontation.
I swear everybody in the cast was at their physical peak in ROTS…just beautiful. I wish they had hugged goodbye.
Anakin and Obi-Wan never hugged and it's something that always bothers me.
i like how at the end it seems like anakin can almost sense it’s the last time they’re going to see each other as master and apprentice
he wasnt his apprentice anymore at this point
Well, there is a risk that Grievous kills him...
That's probably just the fact that his only true support system was leaving him showing in his face
Yeah he seems evil at this point
In the novelization it actually touches on that point and why Anakin wanted to go with Obi-Wan
“goodbye old friend”, without knowing it was really the last time they were going to cross paths as brothers, is one of the deepest lines in the whole star wars saga.
Anakin needed to only trust Obi-Wan's words here, and if he had, things may have been different, but his frustration towards the council and his desire to save Padme fucked everything up.
Thanks to palpatine telling him he can save his loved ones
Faith in The Force obliterates fear, just like Faith in Christ casts out fear, and doubt. Anxiety is a lack of trust/faith in YAH's Will. (Force typology)
Ewan and Hayden are such good actors, I don't know why people hate on them so much.
Hayden? haha.. hHAHAHAAH
No one hates on ewan
Literally no one hates on Ewan
To me hayden more than anyone got treated horribly unfair, he did a great job and i couldnt imagine a better anakin, the negativity he got for his role at the time was so undeserved
Weird direction from higher ups telling him what to say and how to say it, and retards mistaking that for the actors responsibility like some of the replies in this section
This scene is what makes the scene so damned heartbraking as we know that this is the last time that Obi wan will see the true Anakin Skywalker for 20 plus years
Just because he gave himself a new name as some cheap psycho babble trick to disassociate from his crimes doesn't mean that video isn't the true anakin.
Every action he ever took was the true anakin. It's in him, it is him.
@@fd8934 thank you lol they act like somebody stole his body he does everything himself
@@fd8934 you two guys are retards, it was already confirmed Anakin and Vader are not the same, they are different personalities, Anakin only wanted to use the dark side to save padme, but the dark side corrupted him destroying his being and gave birth to the sith Lord sidious named Darth Vader, another thing is that sidious named him, he didn't changed his name himself, i swear the ignorant star wars fans are not even real fans
@@fd8934 I see your point but anakin became so disillusioned with his feelings he began to do things that would disgust his old self. He becomes someone else, he betrays all of his morals and friends. That was the point Lucas tried to make.
@@fd8934 perfect example being the younglings in the beginning of ROTS he would gladly lay down his life to protect the Jedi temple and the younglings. He is a leader who is deeply compassionate of his subordinates, by the end he’s the very person leading the assault on the temple and personally massacres the children.
Seeing Anakin in the shade and Obi Wan in the light when saying goodbye brings this scene together so well
The apprentice humbles himself before the master, and the master humbles himself before the apprentice. A scene of genuine brotherhood between these 2.
1:05 it's so sad after a brief respite provided by a friend seeing all of Anakins problems coming back to the forefront of his mind, much like waking up the day after a personal tragedy.
Anyone notice Obi-Wan going out to the sunny, light area and Anakin staying in the shadows, dark? Lucas knew what he's doing. What a brilliant underrated scene.
“Goodbye, old friend.”
Obi-Wan is standing in the sunlight, Anakin is standing in the darkness.
0:16 Did you see how Obi-Wan twitched his eyebrows like that? That's the one thing I find hilarious in movies like this: A character's eyebrow twitching.😅😂
It's been almost 20 years and it still hurts
I love how right as they say good bye Obi wan is in the light and anakin remains in the dark surrounded by clones. Brilliant foreshadowing.
Separating Anakin and Obi-Wan proved to be a grave mistake especially as far as the Jedi council is concerned. I don’t believe Palpatine’s influence on Anakin would’ve been as strong if he’d gone with Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan kept him focussed and on the right path.
You have a point there as we see how rapidly Anakin falls to the dark side after Obi-Wan's departure, just like when He went on a rampage and slaughtered the tusken raiders after His mother's death in Episode 2, it always seemed like Anakin was at His worst when Obi-Wan WASN'T there to keep Him in check
"Obi-wan *SHOULD'VE* let anakin come with him. It *WOULD'VE* prevented *ALOT OF SHIT."*
A lot of sith? Perhaps
This hits so much different after episode 6 of kenobi. Now obi wan says sorry to Anakin.
Damn it does lol.
😭
@tusken gaming maybe you just have a narrow mind.
Fuc that trash ass show
@🅱️ebel Then you have no emotions...
When obi wans face lights up as anakin apologizes... Ewan is an awesome actor.
And it's interesting how obi wan said goodbye, old friend, as if they'd never meet again.
Seeing this scene in the theater when the movie came out was so heavy. You could feel that shit was gonna go down after this scene & what I love about scenes like this, especially in this movie, is how it makes you wonder what woulda happened if Anakin went with Obi-Wan. RotS has so many great situations that are so damn fun to think about happening a different way, but unlike other movies, they never eclipse the actual movie we got. I love this movie so much.
"I've just been so frustrated with the council."
I wonder if Obi-Wan couldn't help but remember his chats with Qui-Gon here.
From the novel
*He couldn't just stand here and let him walk away. Not now. He had to say something... He had a sinking feeling he might not get another chance.*
Im not crying i just a good bye old friend in my eyes
0:54 - Anakin is dimmed by the shadows, predicting his "heel turn" at the climax of the film
0:56 - Kenobi is within shining lights, symbolizing his longevity and commitment to the light side of the force.
Foreshadowing at its finest.
Is it just me or this is similar to Vader and Luke? Also Kylo Ren represents darkness. Rey represents light. But in the 9th film, Rey is powerful than Ben. Ben is not offically a Sith. That's why he is not the main character. His maternal side is pure jedi. His mom and uncle are children of the chosen one. He got the snarky personality of Han. Rey is the granddaughter of the Emperor. that's ironic.
I always liked the friendly dynamic between Anakin and Obi-Wan. They both had such deep respect for each other. Makes what happened all the more tragic.
Sad to see this bromance end the way it did.
That scene. Knowing what their next meeting is. It's gut-wrenching, heartbreaking. And that's why it's one of the greatest!
Also a great detail, one clone signaling to another in the background to give their General some space for a heart-to-heart convo with his former apprentice =3
When he said « the fight is done» « we lost » 😭😭😭😭😭
Pretty sure thats commander cody
"I have taught you everything I know" that's when sith try to kill their masters
Lucas is a subtle man, nice line
The most underappriciated scene in all of Star Wars
“You didn’t kill Anakin Skywalker, I did” A part of him however small still cares and loves Obi Wan, it was a subtle way for Vader/Anakin to free Obi Wan of the guilt he carried himself with. It also deepens the context of, “Obi Wan once thought as you do” in ROTJ and “He’s more machine than man now”
Completely agree.
I was worried about how having a rematch would affect the OT. But honestly, it really does enhance it.
Never thought of it that deeply, very nice insight
@@Killzoneguy117 A presence I didnt feel since
Original meaning: Obi-Wan totally and utterly beat me
New meaning: Obi-Wan totally and utterly beat me
And he still was a "learner/padawan" because he coulnt let go his need to win-as demonstrated in episode five with the flashbacks.
Don't bring that fanfic here. Nothing Disney made is Canon
@@yuki-tan you can either keep crying and stay sad in the past or move forward and find the good in what’s being made. no one cares about your opinion
This scene is so sad 😭. Obi Wan giving his reassurance to Anakin but you can see Anakin is still troubled
Take note Disney - this movie is how you make a simple and interesting story that’s easy to follow: you focus the story on only the few main protagonists and not 50 other side characters. And you advance the plot through proper character development, not flashy action scenes that are there only for the sake of being there. The action scenes in this movie are 100% story driven and have an actual purpose in advancing the plot unlike any of the sequel movies.
Yeah let's just pretend that the entire prequel trilogy didn't get absolutely shitted on by this fanbase just because the sequels exist.
I think the side character thing works with the mandalorian but really does not work when they bring established characters in for their own show and then fill it with loads of random new characters. As far as I am concerned Obi wan show has been pretty good but it is indeed a slippery slope.
@@BlueSkullX I've never shitted on them. I loved them. I've actually liked the prequels much more than the OT when I was a kid.
So...am I not part of the fanbase?
@@muchanadziko6378 The small minority of good the fanbase has. I'm also in the small minority. Now it's just filled with whiny adults.
@@BlueSkullX it's the majority. It's just that there minority is more vocal on the internet.
Also, the prequels weren't hated by the fanbase, but by the media/critics.
They didn't have yt and fb at the time.
This movie is just amazing ❤️😭
'goodbye old friend' *sobs*
I love how the lighting foreshadows in this scene. Brilliant.
Man that “goodby old friend” from obi wan must replay in obis head all the time while he was on Tatooine. It was more of a goodbye than you thought at the time, he really was saying goodbye to Aniken for the last time
Sooner or later we all say goodbye to someone we care about, not realizing in the moment it's the last time we'll ever do so.
@@derek96720 True, I guess that seems very yeah of course but it really is crazy at the same time. The worst is when you try to find them and rekindle later but they’ve passed at that point
This scene hits home after the season finale for Kenobi 😔.
"I'm sorry Anakin, for all of it."
@@MuditVerma stop I’m crying 🥺
The foreshadowing in having such ominous music as they say goodbye, Anakin's change of expression as his smile fades
“And you have become a far greater Jedi than I could ever hope to be”
-Obi Wan to Anakin
Everytime I watch this scene, I get so sad, especially knowing this is the last time they see each other as friends/brothers. If Anakin had gone with Obi Wan or if someone else had gone and Obi Wan had stayed back to help Anakin, then maybe everything could have been avoided.
But that's what makes ROTS so good, the tragedy and the constant "what if" scenarios that could have changed things.
Yup. Anakin only trust Obi Wan
Then no Vader
This is such a wholesome and yet sad moment.
This feels a lot more impactful after Clone Wars. When this came out they’re history before that was of teacher and student who barely tolerated each other. After clone wars and all the went through, the upcoming events have a much more devastating impact.
Facts!! After u watched Clone Wars this scene will crush you..
That’s one of my main problems with the prequels.
We don’t actually get to see many scenes of Obi Wan and Anakin’s relationship. I feel like if we did, the scenes in Revenge of the Sith would have hit a lot harder.
@@sophieamandaleitontoomey9343 I agree...and i think that was a massive waste of the chemistry between Hayden & Ewan. We only get that tired, strict dad trying to raise a moody teenager vibe from most of their scenes together but that wasn't the reality...obi wan raised him and they did have a strong bond despite Anakin's different acts of defiance from time to time, which Obi Wan learned to tolerate and accept as a part of his personality
0:55 the imagery here is fantastic and incredible foreshadowing of what is to follow.... Obi wan standing in the light and Anakin standing in the shadows signifying his gradual descent into the dark side... the prequels were well and truly underrated in so many ways
So sad man. To see what kind of relationship they could’ve had as the years went on. 😭😭 and obi wan carries the weight that because of him or his teachings it was all his fault that anny turned in to Vader, which isn’t true. It’s just so sad cause obi wan is one of the best Jedi ever imo, in his steadfastness to his duty, he had to grow up quickly because he wasn’t much older than anakin when qui gon was killed. He is everything a Jedi should strive to be and it’s heartbreaking knowing that he unnecessarily bears the weight of what happened. It’s why he went into exile more or less to guard over luke - that maybe if he couldn’t save anakin he could save his son. And in the end he did. And he died well - knowing that what he set out to do he had finally after long years accomplished. Man, what a beautiful story arc.
It’s heartbreaking to see Anakin try and hold onto Obi Wan, almost like he realizes that everything is about to change.
It’s crazy from going from the most humble and apologetic version of Anakin to the most arrogant and pompous version when they see each other next on mustafar
We could say, this version of Anakin died along the way, when I say died, I meant heavily suppressed by the Darth Vader aspect of him.
I cried cause this was the last smile obi had with anakin
"You should've killed me when you had the chance."
Death Vader/Anakin is probably the best story ark ever put to the big screen
Somewhat heart-wrenching knowing where it all ends up
Anakin admitting he's been arrogant to Obi-Wan speaks volumes. Anakin has always been self-assured and cocky, so hearing him try to be humble and admit his faults is so powerful and all the more tragic when he becomes drunk on power and slips back into the hubris that leads to his downfall.
It's really painful It is noted Obi-Wan does know Anakin has a thing with Padme and rather than get judgy he actually tries to understand him. He also vouched for Anakin trying to explain them why is not a good idea to send him to the chancellor to spy on him and despite Anakin's issues and behavior, he's still patient enough and still compliments for his achievements nonetheless.
Has Obi-Wan stayed with Anakin rather than been sent to fight Grievous, maybe Darth Vader wouldn't have happened.
And to make it worse, while arguably not fully canon now because of being related to Legends, the novelization actually demonstrates some moments when Anakin's friendship with Obi-Wan in the rescue mission actually let him see a nastier side of Palpatine, which could have prevented all the subsequent disgraces.
The amount of charm the Obi-Wan and Anakin scenes have with Lucas's wooden writing is a testament to what two actor really meshing can do.
Finally, someone here who gives credit where it's due. Everyone else keeps saying Lucas is a genius, and sure he's great, but when there's dialogue like in this scene it's the actors doing the heavy lifting.
@@HighNoonTex I feel like this scene could've been a little more natural with Obi-Wan putting his hand on Anakin's shoulder and even a handshake/hug before he leaves. Would've shown they were more like friends before leaving. Cause yeah Lucas is the master of wooden dialogue lol
@@akillzonefanboy3313 not very jedi, the jedi are supposed to be quite detatched
@@akillzonefanboy3313 i think its better that that feeling of wanting to do that is thick in the scenes atmosphere but there is a boundry between them which for obi-wan os the jedi code and for anakin his secrets. Both are reachinf out for eachother but neither one can close the gap
@@oz2362 Obi-Wan was mentored by Qui-Gon Jinn who actually was more attached and often defied tradition without straying too far from the jedi order's teachings. Obi-Wan also was willing to defy the council to teach Anakin but Yoda granted his request anyways. Also Anakin is a man who believes Jedi are encourage to love others. He would've learned that from Obi-Wan. Also Qui-Gonn does place his hand on Shmi's shoulder as a term of endearment when Anakin powers up his pod racer the night before. He's a jedi.
“Goodbye old friend….”
:(
Goodbye... Darth
People might dislike the prequels due to the cgi/bandwagon and jar jar but looking back they were genuinely really good, episode 3 over episode 6 anyday
Not to mention people forget that for its day the CGI was groundbreaking, with new technologies and techniques created just for these films that were then used on other films like Jurrasic Park etc. Not to mention Jar Jar was also groundbreaking CGI as the first fully CGI character in a film.
Also also, people don't look past the CG to realize the Prequels used more practical effects than the entirety of the OT.
Ep3 for the ani vs obi fight alone honestly
I like it more than the sequels.
Jesus, grow up and say that again.
I loved them as a child... but as an adult I think they were as bad as they were good.
Although this movie is remarkably the "darkest " star wars movie, this scene is one of the more loving scenes in the saga
The last time we seen them both really loving and understanding one another. As a die hard fan, I wish we could’ve seen the 2 talk things out before both of their lives went completely left
There’s something very heartwarming and heartbreaking about this scene. To feel these two things at the same time makes Anakin’s fall so much more devastating for him and Obi-Wan.
"Good bye old friend" so ironic, man that hits hard later on...
They bid farewell to each other with a lot of respect and unspoken love.
So sad to know that they never met again.
Imagine after Anakin said "You're going to need me on this one, master", Obi Wan agreed to take him with to Utapau to confront Grievous (maybe even the 501st Legion as well). For Palpatine, the whole point was to get Anakin and Obi Wan separated.
"Goodbye old friend"
Let that sink in.
Obi Wan is very modest. That's what a true Jedi is. It's not about arrogance.
You know what’s more sad, is that we probably won’t get another scene like this in any Star Wars feature film. These words hold so much weight, so much so that Hollywood can’t even carry them.
Before Disney, before the dark times...
Goodbye James Earl Jones, may the force be with you.
Sad this was the last time they met as brothers as friends and the next time was as enemies… the dark side clouded everything
As usual… great music transition from the beginning of the scene to the end where the heavy undertones start foreshadowing the conflict to come…brilliant story telling
so much pain... so much agony... so peace, justice and security to his new empire
His new empire?
@@vergil9180 don't make me kill you
Don't make him kill you.
@@nightwalker5455 my allegiance is to the republic!, to democracy!
Master I have been arrogant and I'm sorry. Literally 10 minutes later. I have bought peace and security to my new empire
It’s like he’s apologising for what he’s about to do. Still love this scene
"But be patient Anakin" Ewan McGregor delivers that line with perfect fatherhood. So heartbreaking.
The contrast between this Anakin and the clone wars is startling sometimes.
"I have taught you everything I know...except for well there is this one thing about the high gr- you know what? It isn't important...I'll see you around my friend"
Before they started burning each other
Kelso: BUUUUUUURN
In the end only Obi wan and Padme really knew he was a good person. He didn’t always do things by the book but he loved people and cared about them. If the Jedi hadn’t saw that as a problem they could’ve helped him channel that need to protect into a positive outcome.
"Anakin should've went with obi-wan..."
Obi-wan couldn't have even a blink of guess that he was about to cripple Anakin forever.
I like how the Star Wars story (despite its flaws) is so coherant that it hits deep for everyone lol. Every video about Star Wars on YT has everyone in their feels in the comments. Great franchise.
Too bad the Disney projects didn't continue that coherent design lol
@@bigdoubleu117 Right? They didn't even know who Rey was until the last minute. What a hot mess.
I'm calling it now the obi wan series will have Obi-Wan saying hello old friend to Anakin in the afterlife
Why would they have a flash forward like that? The show takes place when Luke is 10.
I love obiwan, man. He’s like the father we all want.
That was Qui Gonn tbh
@@meisterlukey Qui Gon was more of a grandfather, I feel.
That Anakin guy, he's going places.
You keep your eye on that guy, cause he gonna be making some moves.
Aparrently he didn’t teach him everything he knows because he didn’t teach him about high ground
he probs did, anakin was just cocky lol