Best Knife (Ep 2)? CRKT, Gerber, Leatherman, Fallkniven, Victorinox, Kershaw, DeWalt, Milwaukee
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 พ.ค. 2022
- 15 Knife Brands: Fallkniven, Benchmade, Gerber, Victorinox, Kershaw, Cold Steel, Kizer, CRKT Fossil, Leatherman Skeletool, Milwaukee, DeWalt, COAST, Kingmax, Vulcan, Master USA. Folding Knives (pocket knives) compared for initial sharpness, blade lock release pressure, corrosion resistance, and blade tip durability. Knives were then sharpened using the same sharpening system, then compared for blade edge durability. Finally, we look at a knife that's been in use for over 65 years. I purchased all of the every day carry (EDC) knives to ensure unbiased test reviews. So, thank you for supporting the channel!
➡ Thank you for supporting the channel through memberships:
/ @projectfarm
➡ Thank you very much for supporting the channel through Patreon: / projectfarm
➡ An easy way to find past videos along with products tested: bit.ly/2FCrBpk A big thanks to Jim for putting this together.
➡ Merch: project-farm.com
➡ Click here if you'd like to subscribe: / @projectfarm
➡ As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
➡ Products Tested In This Video (in no particular order):
Fallkniven: amzn.to/37ZfMbs
Benchmade: amzn.to/39yfMj8
Gerber: amzn.to/3G8Ots0
Victorinox: amzn.to/38ItSya
Kershaw: amzn.to/3G0q2g2
Cold Steel: amzn.to/3NqT7Us
Kizer: amzn.to/3FZbSvI
CRKT Fossil: amzn.to/3wDmYlV
Leatherman Skeletool: amzn.to/3lt1GCc
Milwaukee: amzn.to/3PsQyTM
DeWalt: amzn.to/3G1W6jF
COAST: amzn.to/3wFwGEe
Kingmax: amzn.to/3PpI2VH
Vulcan: amzn.to/3NotNyp
MasterUSA: amzn.to/3LvFL8e
Wicked Edge Knife Sharpener: amzn.to/3PJAq0v
Videography Equipment:
Sony DSC-RX10 III Cyber-shot Digital Still Camera: amzn.to/2YdXvPw
Canon 70D Camera: amzn.to/31b5Gy0
Azden Microphone: amzn.to/34d3DLE
Go Pro Bundle: amzn.to/3Ca0ZVN
This video is only for entertainment purposes. If you rely on the information portrayed in this video, you assume the responsibility for the results. Project Farm LLC - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
Wow!!! 65 year old pocket knife!!
Thanks so very much to the guest veteran green beret!
That kizer looks great for an everyday carry, surprised to not see Milwaukee do better.
Thank you!
Not too surprising considering Milwaukee's bread and butter is power tools, not folding knives.
@@deletdis6173 definitely true. I'm a huge fan of their power tools but it's really hit or miss with the hand tools.
Not worth sacrificing so much quality to have an all color matching tool kit.
@@TowerDragoon
My tools are Milwaukee red, Stanley yellow, and Klein ... whatever that color scheme is.
@@ProjectFarm Something that's been on my mind for while. During comparative tests like this, you could put the previous graph bars over the new graph bars for quick reference to the number being compared. Like the first sharpness number in red graph bar, and new sharpness number in blue bar. That way the final graph would be easy to read at a glance. To show before and afters.
"master USA is made in china" i really didnt see that one coming
Thanks for watching!
... and yet we should have seen it coming. So depressing.
Biden sold out the rest of the country to China.
Master USA? More like the master of deceit!
😭🤣😂😭😂🤣
I love the answer he gave when asked for advice in selecting a carry knife: "I'm the wrong person to ask, I've only had the one."
Thanks!
Agreed
The stories that man must have
I which I could have something over a year
You could have asked him for advice about choosing a wife and he would have given a similar answer!
I found a Benchmade when hiking on a remote trail. I checked with parks service and no one had reported a missing knife so I kept it. I carry it with me every hike.👍🏻 Mr. Smith is a jewel!💜
You can send it in to them for free sharpening, etc. Will come back like new.
I’ve lost my benchmade I had on deployments to Iraq and never replaced it, I carry a cheap Stanley box cutter knife for work as a carpenter everyday, but would really like to get another benchmade, I remember shaving my arm hairs with it brand new , it was sharp as a razor blade, couldn’t believe it. Hope you hang on to your new jewel.
@@8M0US Only for people in the USA though :(
That's a great find. Very well made knife
Wow, very lucky.
The master USA is made in China - Who else laughed out loud at that?
Me!
Not out loud but I thought that was pretty funny.
Fun fact, the "I voted!" Stickers are also made in China
@@ElectroNicko_ American flags made in china give me a good chortle.
The cameo of the former "Special Forces" Green Beret Mr. Smith with the "Case Canoe"-knife in the end was really great ! Thanks !
2nd this! A-PLUS!
Agree with these guys, Please add my Thanks for his service!
Are you quoting him or?
This could even be a possibility of a second channel. Or a few 30 minute episodes. Obviously it would depend on his willingness to be interviewed, but the ”sweet old man next door” charm was really deceiving.
Loved it his Cameo
That veteran and his knife both deserve “thank you for your service”. That knife is still in amazing shape.
Thanks!
That was a wonderful clip. Completely unexpected.
I totally enjoyed that too. Like my grandfather with his decades-old Tree brand knife. It seems like a part of the knife review was cut out, or was that just me?
Well, Case manufactures some great knives.
Utter nonsense!!!
My grandpa lived from 1937-2022 and served in the Marine Corps. He had quite a few Case knives and we would use them hunting and fishing together. I remember all of them being well worn and looking the same way as Mr. Smith's. Sharpened and used many times. Because of that, I have two Case knives I rotate, those being a yellow Stockman, as well as a yellow Trapper. Just thought I'd share. Mr. Smith reminded me of my grandpa. He was and is my hero. Thanks for the hard work on all your videos. I use them for a lot of things I buy whether it be tools, fluids and other things.
That "hero" comment actually got me kinda choked up. I'm sorry for your loss, but it's good that you were lucky to have him. ✌️
I don’t think there could be a more unbiased and thorough testing of products as demonstrated in your videos. Thank you for having the guest Green Beret, thank you for your service sir! Great channel and have been watching for years now we appreciate the effort and behind the scenes work that goes into each of the videos you produce. Thank you for everything!
You are welcome!
The guest appearance at the end was so incredibly wholesome, loved to see it. You are such an incredible content creator, thank you so much for all that you do.
Thanks and you are welcome!
As a collector of old case knives, I can tell you that the quality of them was always fantastic. Your friends Cass XX USA Canoe sure has seen a lot of service. Please thank him again for his service as well. A true gentleman hero.
Thanks, will do!
As retired military I appreciated the end of your outstanding video with the Special Forces veteran with 350(!!!) jumps under his belt and his 65 year old knife. Awesome content as usual, thank you! 👍
Thanks and you are welcome!
Tod has been practicing with the wicked edge and it shows how consistant he was getting nearly all of them to 125
Thanks!
Yeah he’s becoming a master knife sharpener! Very impressive!
Very very very underrated. Or as Todd would say "Very Impressive!"
Wicked Edge is awesome!
Really was remarkable how consistent the sharpening was.
Would be interested to see a permanent marker comparison. I put my name on my dive gear but it fades extremely fast. So maybe a good test would be to use different paint markers (alcohol, water, oil based,...) on surfaces (hard plastic, flexible plastic, cloth, metal,...) and apply different wear methods (sanding, water,...)
Thanks for the video idea.
Excellent idea! 👍
Super great idea!!
Not gonna happen.buy an engraver.
Great idea
I used this video to decide on my new EDC. My old one wouldn't hold an edge at all. I decided on the 2nd place Kizer knife (I got the Justice) and after 3 months now I am happy to say I'm happy with the purchase! Thank you again for your comparison videos!
You are welcome!
The Milwaukee knife is a flip blade.A little flip of the wrist and easily open. Love your TH-cam channel and the detail you go through to give us accurate info thanks.
Thanks so much!
Yep Robert is right. Brand new, those specific Milwaukee knives open by them selves if you just hold them down. Upside down the blade will fall out, and if you just hold it straight down the knife is supposed to open and lock on its own after pressing the button and releasing it. They are called “Fastbacks”.love those things. But get concrete in them your f$cked.
Tool brands make nice low priced knives that can take a beating.
I used to have like 5 different knives for different tasks.
@@XyzXyz-pm2rj The 11th Commandment is "Thou shalt not swim in concrete." Heed this advice, sir.
@@XyzXyz-pm2rj I used to work on cell towers, and my fastback survived a 150ft fall with chipped paint. It was the first style they made with the utility blade. Love those stupid little knives.
I’m glad someone mentioned this. Yes, very easy to open with one hand. I love my fastback
Holy mackerel, your test “Sharpness after sharpening and then Bamboo” is honestly a thing of beauty. An extremely applicable test of edge retention and steel quality. But then you put it into percentages, and I went to subscribe yet again.
Phenomenal graphs with great data from a beautiful test, you’ve done it yet again!! Thank you for your excellent work!
Additionally, seeing Mr. Smith’s story with that knife is awesome! I frequent the city Case knives are made (Bradford, Pennsylvania) and it’s wonderful to see that a Pennsylvania knife is one of the most successful time-tested knives out there. Mr. Smith is very good at not losing things haha.
Thanks and you are welcome!
Hi, The Cheat. Reminds me of the knife fight Coach Z and Pom-Pom were allegedly in that one time. :D
Agreed, excellent
Absolutely, his work is top notch!!
Man, you are one of the best reviewers ever! Intelligence, ingenuity, resourcefulness just to name a few! The time and money you put into these reviews are incredible! I love the way you streamline the video’s because I can’t even imagine the time, money spent on products and equipment and research you must put in to make one short video! Amazing, you must put in7/24 a day. Thank you!
You are welcome!
Copy that.
And you are such a nerd, and so good at it. I love it. I can see my wife rolling her eyes.
You neighbor's 65 year old pocket knife was the hands down winner. No contest. Some of the other knives were expensive, but Mr. Smith's "Case Canoe" is priceless.
You have a very cool neighbor. It's great that you recognize that. It just reaffirms the position vibes I've always gotten from your content. 👍
Thanks!
Holy sh!t, he not only had a knife for 65 years but also went through the military and Special Forces with it, and never lost it. That's insane. 🤯
I saw someone else recommend permanent marker testing, and I would love that too. Revmark makes some pretty nice ones that hold up really well compared to Sharpies when writing on abrasive materials like stone/brick.
Thank you!
This would be great to see! I would be interested in Sharpie vs: Milwaukee (which is fairly new), Bic (which seems to hold up better), and Office Depot (which have a longer tip) permanent markers.
Dykem makes a good paint marker.
I would never have thought of this, but this is an excellent idea. Cheap markers just tend to have tips that fall apart really quick.
Agreed, anyone else rember El Marko? Stunk to high heaven, but the ink was nice and thick.
I'd say your consistent sharpening skills shine here.... seeing there's a 20 point difference from all knives.
Nice work!! I know which knives work the best and have the best durability.
Thanks!
Ditto
This isn't meant to disparage him in any way but that knife sharpener he was using is pretty dummy proof.
@@Averna222 Considering he put a V edge on a convex knife id say the test wasn't fair
that "wicked sharp" he was using is a helluva device 👍🏻
Can we just all appreciate how incredibly consistent the sharpening of the knives was?? 😄
Thanks!
Heck yea!
Yeah, but he really paid the price for that bloody expensive piece of kit.
I calculated the standard deviation to be 6.3 rounded. That is fantastic consistency!
Project Farm...straight and to the point as usual. Thank you. That's why I come to your channel when I want to know the true performance of an item without bias. Thank you for all the time and effort you put into everything you evaluate. Keep up the great work.
I have two prized possessions: a picture of my Dad in Vietnam whittling on a piece of wood, and the very same Case Trapper from that picture. Thank you Dad for handing down a solid and trusted knife to me, thank you Mr. Smith for your service, and thanks for the great product tests!
Thanks and you are welcome!
i have my grandpas trapper and that canoe reminds me of it soul knife
I’ve been a knife guy since I got my first Boy Scout knife in 1963 . I was looking forward to this review and as always you never disappoint.
Thank you very much!
KNIFE GUY
I still carry my Boy Scout knife which I got in 1968 - made by Imperial. The non-stainless steel doesn’t chip and a few light strokes will put on a keen edge. Scout type utility knives are handy because you get a good assortment of tools in a fairly slim frame.
I'm glad to see broad choices among factory knives. Thank for all you do.
I have 9 of the knives tested in this showdown, and I appreciate the work you put into this video! Yes I am a knife geek.
Nice! Thanks!
Which ones are your favorites?
As a "Knife Guy" for most of my life. And as a mildly serious collector I really enjoyed this test. Especially the last part, with the Green Beret veteran! The side to side pressure test, in most cases seemed to favor the knives that use washers as opposed to bearings on the pivot point. While I do have a few well made edc pocket knives made in China, I do favor the utility and overall strength of the Benchmade, Cold Steel, and Fallkniven. Once Again another Great Video!
Thanks and you are welcome!
I second the Benchmade and Cold Steel assessment. If not for weight it might be a tossup for me between Cold Steel and Benchmade offerings. Considering weight I've been carrying a Benchmade for three or four years now. Before that I would change them out every year.
Kizer seems the clear winner to me, given the price.
@@kid5Media Made in China VS Made in the USA. Better steel costs more as well.
The Milwaukee Fastback’s button releases the blade and you’re meant to then “flick” it out. Takes a few tries to get used to but it does work well. I use the utility-blade version of the Fastback and it uses the same mechanism.
I'm not sure about that. Milwaukee also has a Fastback-branded knife, which has the fastback-style lock instead of this liner lock. This one seems way too stiff to flick open.
I love projectfarm videos but I got a little triggered when I saw him try to open the fastback. Had to take a breather and finish the video later lol
The utility blade version is my EDC at work. Some of them are still when you get them out of the box but within a day all of them open up with that one handed flicking motion super smoothly.
@@Paremo_ Some come a bit stiffer out of the box than others but it should loosen up with use to become flickable.
Thank you for the information!
How serendipitous that I watch this video so close to Veteran's Day. I hope that gentleman has a very nice day and that his knife is as sharp as his mind. Loved his reply for what to look for in an EDC knife, haha. A knife that used and worn but still sharp is a gem. Unbelievable.
Okay, this video was already EXACTLY what I want and need-- But then introducing Mr Smith!!! Brought this to a whole new level and I LOVE it. If you hadn't just earned my sub when I watched the other pocketknife round up earlier today, then you would have ABSOLUTELY earned it with Mr. Smith!
Thanks for sharing! Glad you enjoyed Mr. Smith! Thanks for watching and subscribing!
65 years?! That older gentleman was amazing to hear, I could listen to him for hours. Great comparison video.
Thanks!
I think the best one was the Case! It's used a dozen times a day for the last 65yrs! Not many can say that! He's an awesome guy and please thank him for his service!
Will do! Thanks!
You know... I realize how invaluable you and your channel is to me. I have been using your tests now for a couple years since I found you and due to your tests I have bought some amazing products I would never have known about. I want to say thank you for everything you do here. In a world of cheap crap out on the market priced so high I feel your channel is probably my (and probably others) most important TH-cam subscription. Here is a little story from a little while back...
So I was looking to buy gloves and a bunch of other stuff from Depot (Home Depot) and remember seeing a test you done but, I had forgotten the results. As I was looking over the glove rack trying to find what I thought might be the best glove for the job I was doing at the time a Depot employee came to me and asked if I needed any help. First I had to get over the shock of a Depot employee actually attempting to help a customer, as here in southern California that type of thing is a VERY rare experience. After I got over the shock of being helped in a Depot I asked the question "What do you think is the best glove here?" So he pulled out his phone and right away I recognized what was on is screen. It was the results of one of your glove tests. This dude actually took screen shots of your video to use as a tool to choose the best products for himself as well as for helping customers. Turning a long story shorter, I ended up buying some gloves and by the end of the job was the only one who didn't wear holes through the fingertips.
Hat's off to the employee of Home Depot in North San Bernardino who took the time to do that and for helping customers without them having to chase you down for 20 minutes!!!!
Wow, thanks for sharing!
I just ordered a Leatherman Skeletool after watching this video. A perfect addition to my backpack! Thank you for yet another great product testing video!
Thanks and you are welcome!
I was very surprised and impressed with how well the $40 Leatherman Skeletool performed!
Thanks for sharing.
They are junk. Don’t believe the hype.
me too, that's my choice pick right there. near the top at every test and only 40 bucks.
@@deeRay7292 Spend the extra and get a Benchmade.
I liked the skeletool also but didn't see the opening of this knife in the test. If it has spring assist, it will be my next buy.
What I like about this review is that it was quantitative mostly. I wish David c Anderson at the knife center would incorporate some of this gentleman's techniques because I find that science and numbers are far superior than qualitative discussions. This review was one of the best that I have ever seen, great job!
Thanks and you are welcome!
Not in his best interest to tell everyone that the knife industry is a rip-off
I really appreciate the edge retention test after sharpening. Cameo was a surprise and also appreciated. Thanks!
You are welcome!
Nicely done tests on these folding knives. I've watched many Project Farm comparison videos and will continue to do so. I'm impressed with your ability to cover the many tests in the short amount of time. I like the fact that you follow each test with a graph/scale showing the ranking/order of how the items finished. I'd like to see a comparison of a different type of knife that we don't see much about. That is the OTF (out the front) type knife. Thank you and I look forward to watching more of your videos.
Thanks so much!
Greatest of all time video! I especially liked that you sharpened all the knives to a nearly identical sharpness, then ran the cutting test, and again tested the sharpness. Sharpness out of the box is important to some folks, but I want to know how well the blade is going to hold up after use.
Thanks!
Exactly! Out of box sharpness only tells me how it will perform on day 1. Thanks for exploring how it holds up to use and abuse.
Bro, his sharpening consistency is sick!
Mr. Smith and his knife were the best part of this video in my opnion. Pride and care for a simple personal tool that has lasted that man a lifetime. Thank you for your service sir.
Thanks!
I love watching these videos of the Knife comparisons and other products. Thank you so much for what you do.
Thanks and you are welcome!
Yet another fantastic video!
A little past veterans day, but better late than never... Thank you for your service, Todd! And give, Mr. Smith a huge thank you for his service as well.
And last but not least, thank you for including the clip with Mr. Smith and his incredible pocket knife story! That knife should be considered a national treasure, just like Mr. Smith!
350 jumps! I've dropped knives jumping off the tailgate of my truck, much less out of an airplane! Lol.
Thanks and you are welcome!
The poor showing by Dewalt and Milwaukee reveals the importance of shopping within a company's wheelhouse. Their power tools perform reliably, but they can't do everything well.
Thanks for another great test!
I especially appreciate the percentage of lost sharpness display. Very useful.
Thanks and you are welcome!
Milwaukee knives are soooooo bad. Including the utility knives. Miles behind even the cheap chinese knives.
@@-fazik-3713 my fastback utility blade is rock solid, not sure what you mean. The blades themselves?
While not having any insider knowledge I would bet the knives made by power tool companies are made by someone else. Subcontracted out.
For sure! What caught me off guard was the difference in design. Milwaukee has a very usable design and it would be great if it was higher quality, but Dewalt had a design that is...well, I have no idea what they were aiming for.
I've had the same Victorinox Swiss army knife in my pocket for the last 25 years, using it multiple times every day,......and I lost it yesterday
I'm desolate.
I enjoyed this comparison video, thanks.
Thank you!
did you check the washer and dryer? have found many of my knives in there
@@mailchrisbailey thanks mate, a good suggestion. But I'd had it in the morning, went to the supermarket, came home, reached in my pocket to use it, and it wasn't there. Double checked the car seat etc, but must've fallen out when I was getting car keys in the store car park.....
I'd kept it on a lanyard for years so I couldn't drop it overboard when sailing. Ah well.........
I watch all your videos, the bonus with your buddy at the end was awesome. Keep up the good work!
Thanks, will do!
I love how concise these videos are. No useless rambling.
Thanks!
I'm not too sure how important "initial" sharpness is. I would be more concerned about how long it stays sharp after being sharpened.
Great point! Thank you
I think it is a combination of the two. It is shocking how many people never sharpen a knife and then proceed to toss it after it goes dull.
This was going to be my point. The knives really show their quality after you remove initial sharpness. I don’t mind seeing the comparison, mind you, but it certainly wouldn’t affect a purchasing decision.
Yes. Any steel alloy can have an initial sharpness of a razor, but the ability to hold the edge and ease of sharpening can vary greatly.
Exactly what I was thinking. While getting and inadequately sharpened knife out the box is unacceptable especially for big dollar knives , it doesn't say anything about the quality of steel and heat treatment that the knife possesses.
I've watched a LOT of knife testing videos, and I must admit I enjoyed some of the creativity here. The implementation of weights and scales to try and better quantify attributes like edge retention, ease of opening, and closing were pretty crafty.
One nitpick, I did wince a little each time I heard 'Fall-keevin', jajajaja
Thanks!
Todd pronounced "Fällkniven" pretty decently...
@@omicrondec I'm just used to hearing 'fallk-neevin'.
Love your channel, your narrative is always spot on! Very impressive 😅
Thanks!
I really appreciated your special guest, thank him for his service. What a good man. Great video.
Thanks!
It’s amazing how much time you put into these test. Thank for all you do.
You are the real life Consumer Reports.
Thanks and you are welcome!
..please don't compare him to Consumer Reports!..Consumer Reports are a sham..Project Farm is not!...
@@dyer2cycle noted.
That gentleman is a hero thank you for your service I loved his knife that old case is a great looking knife for it’s age and used that long wow thank you for sharing buddy your videos are awesome my day always gets better when you post something god bless everyone
Thank you very much! This means a lot to me!
I'm nearly his age, and haven't had a knife for more than 6 months without losing it.
Kershaw makes really good knives. I'm disappointed the tip failed but I still think I will keep carrying them. They hold an edge very well. Out of all of the pocket knives I have purchased over the years I always find myself going back to Kershaw for the one that ends up in my pocket.
Thanks for the feedback.
The thoroughness of your reviews is absolutely incredible.
Thanks!
I just bought that exact Kershaw earlier this year as my edc! As long as I don't drop it point first onto a steel plate, looks like I made a good choice!
Thank you!
Yeah, Kershaw points dont seem to last long but other than that their knifes are great.
Kershaw Dividend composite. Great knife.
EDC? Get a p365 lot less messy
@@chavira2009 you should be able to send it to them and they will replace the blade for free
The thing about the Milwaukee knife is you’re supposed to flip it out! I was also confused on why they would make a push button without them studs but you just flip it!
Great point. Thank you
All my knifes I flip even if they are spring adsisted
The millcrappie is still a POS which is surprising to me.
I came here to say the same thing. Also knives like this benchmade with the axis lock can be flipped in the exact same way.
@@jedigoof1548 in both directions too
Great video as always. Usually I'm watching these and I think "It would be good if..." Then 10 seconds later you do exactly the test I was thinking of. So good.
Thanks!
I love these knife videos! Happily support you on Patreon - you’re the best TH-camr!
Thanks! Thanks for being a Patreon!
I would love to see a comparison of window ac units. It's the perfect time for it & I think it would be a nice change of pace from your always great and thorough tests on tools and oil. Thanks for your dedication to your craft.
Thank you for the video idea!
That bonus clip at the end was awesome! I've become infatuated with collecting Case knives over the last few years or so, there is just something about a quality slipjoint pocket knife, and that guy really personifies that. What a cool little story!
Thanks!
I think Case makes a good knife. Old fashioned, but well made.
I wonder how the modern ones measure to the past? Many blades now days are made in China (which many associate with mass production/low quality) but most blades now days are some version of stainless steel, since you collect Case, how do you rate the older vs the newer? The reason I ask is I have a much older Cold Steel that was made in Japan vs a newer Cold Steel made in China could tell the blade steel quality has taken a hit over time (could also say similarly with one of my Gerbers as well).
Very nice job and cool that you found that old knife and its green beret owner. A special thanks for his service.
Been watching you for a long time now. Your comparisons have been very valuable to me over the years. I can't tell you how much I appreciate you doing these tests. They are extremely complete and accurate.
I have 2 suggestions for you.
1. Rather than having to take screen shots of each graph and then print them out to make my own comparisons based on my priorities, maybe supply a link to spreadsheets that you could supply to make it easy to download and print.
2. After each test, maybe show that product on a graph as you build the graph in order to see how much better or worse the current product you're testing is compared to the ones you already tested.
Thank you again for all your hard work and dedication. You are invaluable in my life.
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
Great video Todd! The detail and effort you put forth in every one of your videos really shows. We really sincerely appreciate everything you do. Thanks for showing an old case as well, snd honoring a US veteran. God bless!
Thanks so much!
Loved this one. I think it was a smart choice on your part to include a lot of lower end subjects as a way of testing our assumptions about them. The interview with Mr. Smith was awesome, thanks for that.
Thank you very much!
Was gifted a Benchmade years ago and never realized how nice it was until I found it recently and started using it almost daily. It really is an amazing knife.
Thanks for sharing.
This guy puts out a TON of info while also not wasting any time. THIS is how educational and experimentation videos should be!!!
Thanks!
For a lot of everyday folks or everyday knife collectors, good and inexpensive is king. I appreciate the video knife testing. It's homework for the everyday guy wanting quality at affordable pricing. As always, you create well done educational videos that stay to the point and fast paced.
Thank you!
I’d love to see a EDC type flashlight comparison. 3 brands I’d like to see are Nebo, stream light and milwaukee. Love the videos!
Yes! I swear by my Streamlight penlights, I use them more than any flashlight ever in my life to be honest, they are great for working on trucks, even in the day time I use them out of habit. Id like to see how they match up against other brands
Speaking of flashlights I’ve ruined many lately with alkaline batteries leaking. Nothing but lithium for me now.
@@ecksdog NiMH is the way to go for edc AA or AAA lights
Throw in malkoff, nitecore, Cloud defensive and modlite to that list.
"Torque Test Channel" has been doing some nice testing very similar to this channel for lights recently. Come to think of it, would be a nice crossover for these two channels to collaborate on something, they make very similar kinds of content although TTC is generally more limited in scope.
Loved this. Brilliant content as usual! I own the Victorinox in your test and am totally happy with it.
Thanks and you are welcome!
Loved the interview at the end
Thank you!
Always good to see a new video from Project Farm! Especially when the tools tested are ones you use daily
Thank you very much!
Awesome tests, as we have come to expect! Especially appreciated was the guest appearance of Mr. Smith and his beloved Case knife; what a treasure they both are. It's clear both have served honorably and deserve a great deal of respect o7
Thanks!
Excellent work as always. Cool to see Mr Smith's knife too
Love these videos. Objective evidence based content to help drive real world decision making for consumers like me. Like all of your videos, this one’s Gold!
Thanks and you are welcome!
I've had that exact style benchmade for around 3 years now. Best knife I've ever owned.
Thank you!
I've had a Mini Griptilian in my thumb pocket for years. Wonderful knife and always sharp. Every few years I send it down to Benchmade for free service and it comes back sharp as a tack. I never need to sharpen it myself since it keeps an edge so well.
The one thing I would love to see tested on these blades is corrosion resistance. I've got the Milwaukee knife, and I'm not surprised at how poorly it did in these tests. On the other hand, I lost it outside in the dirt and rain for about 2 weeks, and when I found it there was no rust on the blade.
Thanks for the video idea.
generally that question is answered by looking up the steel. some of the diving knives are made of garbage for knives Stainless, being used only being of corrosion resistance. they dont rust, but they dont hold an edge either
I also carry the Milwaukee knife and it does rust too easily except for if it gets sweat on it. I dropped it went it was new and broke a large piece of the tip off. I don't really like how heavy it is.
@@un7ucky That's why its common for dive knifes to have a serrated portion to the blade.
@@un7ucky True, but not all manufacturers actually let you know what the steel is.
Another test that's right on point, and exceptional, as always. I am always impressed at the thoroughness and professionalism of your tests. You're kind of like the TH-cam version of Underwriters Laboratory!
Thanks!
Wauw! What a great video, objective measuring, and the amount of work put into it. Much appreciated.
Glad it was helpful!
This made me rethink the parameters of what makes a good knife. Nice meeting Mr. Smith, and I love that he still has that knife. Thank you BOTH for your service.
Thanks and you are welcome!
One of Fällkniven's big selling points is the high quality steel, very pleasing to see that your tests seem to confirm this!
Plus their legendary convex grinds on most of their knives 👍.
Thank you for your service, Mr. Smith.
Great test, Project Farm! I carried Buck lockback folders for most of my career, but I started carrying a Benchmade Vector just before I retired. The Vector is a much better tool than my many Bucks, but I don't think I would've abused it to get the job done.
Thank you!
The Milwaukee is a fast back action. You press in the button with your thumb and flick it open with your wrist. Easy to do with one hand and kind is a fidget toy cause you can snap it back closed with one hand.
Great feedback. Thank you
As expected, and as usual: your testing is Top Nptch. Hands down so very objective! Certainly my "Go To" for any type of Very High Quality testing. Thank You, J
Thanks and you are welcome!
Todd!!
Please take a bow!
On top of being a VERY IMPRESSIVE tester of all consumer products, (automotive especially) you most likely sharpened all those knives within single digits of one another!! Your channel is easily the best resource on the internet... making it one of the best resources in the world, really!
You are wonderfully inventive and the super tight video editing you do is First Rate!
Thanks so much!
Kershaw has always been my favorite brand. The speedsafe is awesome and is the easiest and smoothest knife to open. I have a kershaw launch auto knife that's amazing. Insanely sharp. Even my 20$ Kershaw knives are almost as sharp as the more expensive Kershaw ones. I have probably 15 and haven't sharpened one of them and they still cut real well
Thanks for sharing.
I like my Kershaws.. but I broke the tip off one also 😄 sent to Kershaw and they returned it with a very sharp replacement blade
Bench made knives are better
Kershaw knives are very good in their price range. I have a Kershaw cryo, Skyline, leek, crown, and a few I'm forgetting. These are all older models, for a reason. I have broken the tips off of 2 Kershaws, and have not purchased a new one for almost 7 years.
I'm still on my original benchmade, no problems, ultra reliable, holds an edge, lightweight. It has been my EDC for 4 years consecutive. If i ever need another knife, it will be a benchmade.
I have carried $20 Kershaw's for years I have never broken a blade tip and I use mine many times a day, I rarely ever have to sharpen either. The opening test was the only one I had an issue with, as you can't show opening force using the wrong opening method for a knife. The correct way to open a knife with a flipper is with the flipper, and Kershaw's are effortless.
I think I speak for everyone when saying, thank you so much for putting so much time and care and work into your videos
You are so welcome!
I have owned Kershaw for decades and will never have another knife. Your assessment of the tip is quite accurate as several of my Kershaw's are sans tip, but after fixing that, they remain some of the most sturdy and sharp knives I have ever possessed.
Thanks for sharing.
After 7 months TH-cam algorithm suggested this for me, and I’m glad it did it. Great guest at the end!
Awesome! Thank you!
The zinger: Project Farm left the farm to visit a retired green beret about his 60+ year-old Case knife.
He's a great neighbor and great person! Thank you
Very informative as always!
I found a battered milwaukee between my barn boards, sharpened it up and it's always been in my backpack since. On the note of one handed opening, it opens very nicely with just a small flick of the wrist, even my younger siblings could work it that way. The steel is soft though, I have to sharpen it more often than my other knives but it just feels so comfortable in the hand so i keep it around. After 4-5 years of use and sharpening the blade has gotten a lot smaller, didn't even notice it before i saw a new one here haha, must have taken close to 7-8mm off the blade in that time.
Thank you for your work!
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
Yeah, you are supposed to flick the Fastback knives. I had a Milwaukee Fastback 2 utility knife years ago and I loved that thing. The clips on them are great as well in my experience.
I couldn't believe how horrible the steel is on the Milwaukee knife. I was thinking about buying one until I saw this. I would take a free one though.
Love bless that Service Man, thank you for your service! Amazing that his knife lasted that long! Going to order the Benchmade 556-S30V (smaller than the 551) for EDC, Thank you!
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
Blade Geometry is one of the most important factors in edge retention. I believe you should first sharpen all the knives to the same angle, and then perform the bamboo test and recheck sharpness. This way a blade that was sharpened at 15 degrees wont seem to "dull" much more than a blade sharpened at 25 degrees out of box. Could influence the numbers quite a bit.
Thanks for the constructive feedback.
The griptilian has been my carry for a year. And I love that knife. I'm glad it did well. They also have a lifetime sharpening which is awesome.
Thanks for sharing.
Yes!! I love these knife tests! Keep up the great work!
Thank you and hope you enjoy the video!
I loved this video. Your thorough testing is so great! How about a similar video which reviews kitchen cutlery knives?
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Great video as always! Would love to see more tests on modern Case knives!
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
As always a fantastic made video and incredibly informative. Exactly what people want to see👍
Also if you read this, I'm a mechanic and I would love too see you do a show down on the best brand of sockets. Specifically chrome sockets and witch ones are best at not chipping or rounding bolts, etc... 😊
Great video idea! Thank you for the positive feedback too
Love the reviews! One suggestion for reviewing - Multitools. The ones like the Leatherman Skeletool CX, the Wingman, offerings from Gerber etc. DeWalt are also doing a multitool at a much cheaper price point. Knowing what you're getting for the money and if the more expensive ones offer better value/longevity would be super interesting.
He did one on 10/10/21. There's a link to a spreadsheet of his tests in the description
th-cam.com/video/Q9E2PjjdCAM/w-d-xo.html
When I was active duty I always received a new multi tool every time I got to a new unit, always either a Gerber or a Leatherman. As such I accumulated quite a collection over the 27 years I was in, and the major factor of which one I carried came down to two things, first the Gerber always had the better pliers (square jaw) v. the pointed nose pliers of the Leatherman. And second, the Gerber you could sling out the pliers with a flip of the wrist v. the Leatherman, which had to be opened in the old skool fashion. Having said that, the one I carried for all those years was the Leatherman, because the Gerber would pinch the crap outta your palm on a regular basis due to the handle design, and it hurt a LOT, whereas the Leatherman would not.