Best Utility Knife? Let’s Find Out! Milwaukee, DeWalt, Gerber, Husky, Kobalt, Klein Tools, Craftsman
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 ธ.ค. 2022
- Brands: Klein Tools, DeWalt, Milwaukee, Klein Tools, Sheffield, Kobalt, Fiskars, CAT, Irwin, Craftsman, Stanley Fatmax, Crescent, Husky, Gerber, DeWalt, Black and Decker. Utility knives tested for comfort, blade storage capacity, blade change efficiency, force to extend knife into open position, force to release handle, force to unlock knive, force to slide retractable blade, blade slop, knife lock failure load, and belt clip holding strength.
I bought all of the utility knives to ensure an unbiased review. So, thank you for supporting the channel.
➡ Thank you for supporting the channel through memberships:
/ @projectfarm
➡ Thank you very much for supporting the channel through Patreon: / projectfarm
➡ An easy way to find past videos along with products tested: bit.ly/2FCrBpk A big thanks to Jim for putting this together.
➡ Merch: project-farm.com
➡ Click here if you'd like to subscribe: / @projectfarm
➡ As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
➡ Products Tested In This Video (in no particular order):
Utility Knives:
Klein Tools Auto: amzn.to/3WmVOLz
DeWalt: amzn.to/3vgKV25
Sheffield: amzn.to/3FVLdAw
Kobalt: amzn.to/3C2BdEq
Fiskars: amzn.to/3YMX2l5
CAT: amzn.to/3Gg2ZzE
Irwin: amzn.to/3YLQrqZ
Milwaukee: amzn.to/3Wo3H3H
Craftsman: amzn.to/3C2ARh4
Crescent: amzn.to/3WHqs27
Husky: amzn.to/3WJPUUQ
Gerber: amzn.to/3VqN6Lb
DeWalt Folding: amzn.to/3hPb1pX
Black+Decker: amzn.to/3hPsFd4
Klein Tools 44131: Available at Home Depot
Stanley Fatmax: Available at Home Depot
Videography Equipment:
Sony DSC-RX10 III Cyber-shot Digital Still Camera: amzn.to/2YdXvPw
Canon 70D Camera: amzn.to/31b5Gy0
Azden Microphone: amzn.to/34d3DLE
Go Pro Bundle: amzn.to/3Ca0ZVN
This video is only for entertainment purposes. If you rely on the information portrayed in this video, you assume the responsibility for the results. Project Farm LLC - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
Surprised you've never compared home fire extinguishers. It's something most of us never test until everything is on the line, so I'd love to see a comparison of a good range of them, from the First Alert EZ Fire Spray up to a 20-30lb ABCK.
Really good idea and he’d do a great job too
This would be a good one.
Thank you for the video idea!
You'd be saving lives by making this video, and it could be quite entertaining
Fire...cool!
This is a fantastic idea. Even if I'm not concerned with branding it would be very helpful to know how mine will preform.
I carry the Milwaukee fastback with screw driver and extra blade storage everyday for landscaping. Between the 2 different screw driver heads, 1/4 inch driver, can opener, blade storage, and single hand quick opening it is perfect for my needs.
Ever since I got my Milwaukee knife I promise there isn’t another knife I’ll carry. I work on a pipe crew and it makes my life so much easier. Plus when I’m bored I sit there opening and closing it because it’s so fast and easy
@@KrewKaleb the ultimate fidget spinner with a purpose. Many purposes that is.
Great to hear! Thanks for sharing.
I have the 1st gen fastback and although it doesn’t have any extra blade storage or screw driver head it’s the best and everyday knife I use I’ve had it on my everyday since I first bought it when it first came out
I wish the 6 in 1 would've made it into the comparison, it's a relatively new model from Milwaukee and imo, superior in almost every way except for maybe those who need more than 1 spare utility blade for storage. It fully opens with gravity alone, and the ergonomics are better than ever
Loved my old Husky blade. Spot on about the stiffness in the hinge but it loosened up with use and a bit of oil to the point I could easily flick it open. Rugged and reliable, everything I needed in a compact pocket utility blade.
My only complaint was the knife was so nice it apparently grew a pair of legs. Hope whoever has it now appreciates it like I did.
The reason I swapped out my Husky for the Gerber one shown in this video is that the blade release became so loose that it would not-infrequently open itself up. It was rather good up to that point, though.
I also have a fondness for those cheap husky util knives
god yea - once you break em in, they'll be good to ya. especially them old ones
I switched to the compact miluakee. Fits perfect in my pocket, lasted a couple yrs now, still going strong. I like the button folding much much more than other styles. Excellent review!
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Would love to see how JerryRigsEverything's knife stacks up against the established brands.
+1
I have 3 of them and after this video I'm very curious!
In the nicest way, I cant watch this video without his knife is in the mix.
Would love to see it if he does another round up!
Jerryrig is awful.
Milwaukee Fastback has been my go-to EDC for years. It was my best friend working HVAC, and has kept with me ever since.
Love that knife, I got two.
I had 2. Lost one😠 great knives! Open and closes so easily. I think I may get the one that has a screwdriver and blade storage next.
The fastback also has a 5 blade storage
Do they have a model that won’t get lost? 😂 I literally buy dollar store razors because I’ve lost so many quality ones
I’ve got 6 of these( bought 3 2 packs at Home Depot) and use this for EDC also. I’m a forklift operator in a warehouse, and use it all day cutting open boxes, and shrink wrap off pallets. The more you use it, the easier it operates. Love it!!!
Love the Milwaukee fastback. They make a smaller one that fits great in your pocket, then they also have a bigger one with wirecutter that I keep in my toolbox. Great knife!
Thanks for the feedback.
They also have one just like this with blade storage in it :D
I also have multiples of the knives tested and the Fastback 2 beats them all for me. Milwaukee 48-22-1902. The 1502 is OK but not as good as the 1902 IMO. I carry the 1902 almost every day instead of my ProTech switchblade.
@@EnvirotekCleaningSystems looked up the 1902 IMO , cant find anything can u send a link?
I’m a Milwaukee Fastback 1505 guy. The utility knife and driver combo is gold for me. Carry It on me at all times.
I have the Gerber and it is real handy utility knife for daily carry, since you can clip it and forget it until you need it. I have another for heavier use, but the Milwaukee looks like one I may pick up in the future. What I love about these reviews is that we can look at the testing and decide what might work better for our own use and budget, but we also can't really go wrong with the overall top two recommendations practically every review. This is *the* best review channel on TH-cam, period.
Thanks!
Yep, I've been using the Gerber for about 3 years myself. The sleek profile is #1 in my book. Some of these are nearly the width of a full size pistol grip !! Who wants to lug that around in their pocket all day ?.. not this guy.
If you do grab a Milwaukee I suggest the 6-in-1. They make a handful of slightly different fastback knives but that one fits in the hand the best imo. It looks nearly identical to this one except it has a driver and holds one spare blade. I also have that Gerber and you're right it takes up no space and gives a lot of blade to use.
I carry the Gerber as part of my EDC and use the Milwaukee when I need a full size utility knife. I think the Milwaukee is the best utility knife I've ever owned. I love the ease of opening/closing, don't think the blade change is as difficult as the video made it out to be either, I'm quite happy with it.
I LOVE my Milwaukee Fastback! Ive also had that little Gerber and it is awesome for a small EDC gear
I believe most people consider the "belt clip" more of a "pocket clip." I certainly put them in my pocket, never on my belt. The milwaukee is my favorite because it's easy to carry, sits deep in the pocket while some stick up almost an inch or more, and easy one hand use. 👍 great video.
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Yup! This!
The clip holds it in the work pants pocket just perfect.
I always use a Milwaukee fastback
@@TheDaniel85 on top of that, it ruins your belt from repeated use, pocket is the way to go for me too
I randomly saw a review of the Milwaukee 1505 (has the screw driver back) and figured I’d give it a try for $20. It’s replaced my EDC knife.
I use the Milwaukee 6 in 1 knife for work everyday. The flip action is very quick and easy to use, and it has a built in screwdriver which is very handy, and has storage for 1 blade. It is more expensive at $20, but I don't think that's bad
You can find them for $10 on sale all the time, or in a combo pack with a standard Fastback for $20. At $10 the driver version is a no brainer for sure!
I also carry that one. I love it. It competes with a multi tool for my needs.
I use a Milwaukee with a Dewalt blade
Me too!
This
I love that little Gerber tool, had it in my back pocket for about a year now. That pocket clip is really secure for a knife that small and for how light and compact it is, it's the perfect second knife to carry so you always have a sharp point.
Thanks for sharing.
Had an older model of the Milwaukee that you use here. It doesn’t have the tab over the blade release, and I’ve loved it for over 5 years now. It’s what changed me from using regular steel knives to using utility blades in a ceramic factory. I’m happy to see they haven’t done much change since then!
Thanks for sharing.
I too have owned both the older and the new design of the milwaukee knife and I can tell you they haven't changed in quality whatsoever, only added features. Feels like the same old knife.
Great testing! Wish you had included Jerry Rig Everything's knife tho
I KNOW RIGHT!!! What a missed opportunity damnn!
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Jerry Rig knife beats all these. Full metal construction, not as mass produced with the cheapest parts possible to maximize profit, still affordable
@@_-AJ-_ well it's supposed to durable so ofc it would be made out of full metal they're some in the test feature full stainless steel construction the important part is it actually feels nice and tolerance and so on all down in the test to see how good I'll actually hold up with others I won't lie but u sound based but that's fine lol
I expected that one as well. Not that I'm interested in buying any knives. I guess you don't know about it if you don't follow the tech channels.
I love my Milwaukee one. I now carry it daily instead of my fancy collectible pocket knives.
Great feedback on the Milwaukee! Thanks
I have 1 too. It has a phillips/flat head screwdriver, a 1/4 hex head screwdriver, wire stripper and a beer bottle opener. Always comes in handy. Its slightly different than the one in video, but basically the same.
@@Straight_White_Fatherly_FigureSounds handy! Know the model number? 🤔
Milwaukee 48-22-1505… the best utility knife ever made!!! It has a real screwdriver, bottle opener, extra blade, and NO Liner Lock (to cut your finger off). The blade is secure, it is very compact, lightweight, and it feels great in your hand.
@@gus473 idk why my comment keeps getting deleted, but @Mr. Water Twister posted it
I've been using the Gerber for years, anod have several. I like how it keeps the blade from wobbling around, and is very thin and light. I replaced the screw with 4-40 torx cap-head, for easier opening.
Thanks for the feedback.
That Gerber had been with me for a decade at least. Have 3 or 4. But the original one lasted years and years. It's still doing great. One of the replacementa had an issue with the belt clip. It popped off. Can't get it to stay on but also didn't really try more than once.
I've had the previous gen version of the Milwaukee for years now & love it & I'm glad to see it's successor did well here. Mine has been very durable, to the point I've used it as a makeshift hammer, to get stubborn parts moving when I didn't have an actual hammer convient. Other tools rotate through my tool pouch but the Milwaukee is a permanent resident, along with my Leatherman Wingman & Wera Kompakt 25 screwdriver. Thanks for another great comparison test.
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
I really enjoyed this test. Way back in the 1960's, my mom did dressmaking and furniture re-covering as, well, a hobby I guess, as she worked full time. But, she made maybe 90% of her clothes as well as many outfits for friends and relatives. She used Fiskars almost exclusively, and swore by them.
Now, in 2022/23, I still have several pair of the Fiskars scissors she used so long ago. Still razor-sharp, and they cut like a dream. Thus, I'm biased towards Fiskars, and was very glad to see that brand win. Good to know that there's some manufacturers out there that still consider quality of product as very important.
As always, I'm very appreciative of the effort and cleverness you put into your testing. Thanks again, Todd, for all that you do for us.
fiskars is my standby brand for any type of scissor or pruners
Fiskers are big in plant pruning scissors and shears.
I've yet to buy anything from Fiskars that didn't exceed my expectations. I use their PRO-1 retractable utility knife and it is easily the most comfortable, well made utility knife I have ever had.
As a Finn it's kind of blasphemy to buy other brands. You might save a buck but it's not worth it. Also they have some years of know how :)
"Fiskars Group is a Finnish group company. The company has its roots in the village of Fiskars, where it was founded in 1649. The oldest business still operating in Finland, its global headquarters are in the Arabianranta district of Helsinki. It is one of the oldest companies in the world."
Fiskars used to be great for pruners and other yard tools but are now pretty crap - poor steel and durability. I now buy Bahco, Silky and ARS yard tools but they are pricey.
The Milwaukee knife has several available configurations. I have one with 1 blade storage and also a Philips and Flathead screwdriver, and there's also another one that has no screwdriver but does have several more blades you can store in the handle
Thanks for the feedback.
I own 3 MKE Fastback knives, the “compact”, the newest with 1-blade storage and screwdriver, and the one tested here. Love all of them. They are the only utility knives I’ve ever really liked carrying, and the wire spring “belt clip” is great for hanging the knife on your pocket. The single hand opening/closing is also extremely useful and fast. The only one I don’t own is the one with 5 blade storage in the handle, it just feels too large for a knife I’ll carry on my pocket.
I’ve owned and/or still own folding models from Cobalt and Husky, plus non-folding models from Stanley, Craftsman, and used at least a dozen other models over the years. The Fastback are the only ones that have ever really impressed me, and the reasons show in the results of Todd’s testing.
I’ve never tried the Fiskars model, probably won’t just because I’m so satisfied with the Fastback.
I also own the one with the screwdrivers. It is hands down my favorite yet and it has saved me many trips back to my tool bag just for a screwdriver. It's well worth the hefty $20 price tag!
@@agrsk8r I think it’s down to $15 now, but I could have misread the tag recently, wasn’t looking to buy another just saw it on the wall. Could have been in the wrong place.
I had the one with 5 blade storage but lost it and havent seen it available since. I now have the new one w the screwdriver, and two without the blade storage. One has the twine cutter/wire stripper and the other doesnt. The one that doesnt has a tether hole. Not a huge milwaukee fan, but definitely my favorite utility knife that ive owned. Theres a new irwin one that looks like it might be a little more comfortable in the hand by the curve it has. Still can never go wrong w the fastbacks. Only utility knife i ever had that didnt break and have had one for years
I also have a fastback pocket knife thats been pretty good to me as well. Starting to get a little dull though
Thank you so much for making these vids!!! Every time I've struggled with finding out what tool I should buy I watch your vids first! You've really helped me out a lot!! 😊
You are welcome! Glad to hear!
That Gerber is a surprisingly well built tool for the money. My favorite things about it are, super slim design (it stays out of the way while in the pocket) and easy to open and close with one hand without the "look at me" wrist snap. Now if I am cutting lots of things the Milwaukee is in my tool box and it beefy size is perfect for working with gloves on. As always thanks for another informative video.
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for the feedback.
I love my Gerber but it will only take one brand of blade, can't use "standard" razor blades because the mounting hole does not line-up. I've had mine over 10 years; maybe that's been fixed (?)
Maybe you can answer a question for me. I’ve got the previous generation Gerber, got it because it was the only one that had zero play on the blade, which I needed. The problem tho, is the pocket clip - it clips onto the knife’s handle (no screw to secure) and it constantly falls off. Do you know if this newer model still uses a clip-on clip, or is it better secured?
I use the Milwaukee, the thin profile makes it easier for me to keep clipped to my pocket vs the other well-performing knives.
This video did a really good job showing the strengths and weaknesses of each knife, and makes it easy to select one based on what is important to individual users. Well done!
Love the milwaukee.
I also carry a Milwaukee. I’m hard on the clips for some reason and on top of all the strengths shown the belt clip is easy to bend back if you screw it up. Love it!
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
Right! The milwaukee clip stays tight, and it is slim and light in your pocket.
I carry the GERBER every day. Small lightweight. It is a bit sharp on the edges. I like how it doesn't have any blade movement. So the 2nd side doesn't get dull
Me too. 🙂
Thanks for sharing!
I everyday carry one, keep it clipped in a front packet. If I need more than my Gerber I grab a stanley 99E.
The EAB also has more exposed blade edge than most knives.
I also EDC the Gerber EAB. Pocket space is a premium and it has a very small folded profile.
I have been carrying the smaller Klein knife for about 3 years now, I have worn a couple out in that time but some days it ends up being used for 6 or more hours straight. I absolutely love how comfortable and easy to use it is. My favorite part is that it's easy to spot when you leave it somewhere
Thanks for sharing.
Who sells Klein tools now?
@@Richard-yi3usLowe’s
Please include more fiskars products during your tests, when available.
I always choose fiskars above all other brands as I find they make tools to last a long time and outperform at their price point.
I can say that lenox blades are much better than fiskars. I tried to cut the stall mats with both of them. It was hard to even scratch the stall mats with fiskars blade when lenox blade cut it like butter.
I only use Fiskars shears for gardening or pruning
I love my Milwaukee fastback. As an overnight grocery stocker you can't really beat the one-handed operation with closing and opening at only a push of a button and flick of a wrist. I've had mine for over 4 years now......best $13 I ever spent to increase my productivity.
Ditto, it's such a good knife. There's a more expensive one that has room for 5 blades in the handle.
My local grocery store gives people the cheapest utility knives and I saw one guy struggling and gave him one of the Fastbacks I had and he was so happy
The push button ruins the other lock styles for you. It's super nice.
Thanks for sharing.
@@Greatwhitesloth It makes it super handy if you're holding something in your one hand and need to cut something
I’m sure this has already been said, if so, please forgive the redundancy… but y’all… get on your feet and put your hands together for this man! He is out there crushing it every week and still drops us a video even on holiday weekends. These tests are not only extremely expensive, but require an enormous amount of time! Camera set up, lighting, rolling while testing, retakes, downloading, editing/post production, then uploading to us each and EVERY week. This is precious precious time that Todd could be spending with his family.
Todd, we appreciate your dedication and loyalty to us and the channel.
My list of resolutions this year include being more mindful and showing true appreciation of not only this channel, but other channels of good content. Wishing many blessings of health and prosperity to each and every one of you!
Thanks again Todd!
Thanks and you are appreciated very much for your encouragement!
Very well said, sir. For us this was twenty minutes but this took Todd hours upon hours of planning and executing. And the knives were tested to destruction, just so we can have even more valuable information when choosing which one to get. Todd, thank you once again for your dedication and effort. We truly appreciate everything you do.
Thank you so much, Todd! Appreciate it so much you got to test a request I had. Exactly the information I was looking for! You're the best.
You are welcome!
I've had one of those Milwaukee knives as my work knife for just shy of 20 years, now. Earlier version, of course. It's been an absolute workhorse, still fully functional and in great mechanical shape all these years later. GREAT piece of gear.
Thanks for the feedback.
I wore through a number of Milwaukees and switched exclusively to Fiskars a few years ago and carry one with me at all times when working. No regrets, best knife I've ever come across in every way. I concur however that the Milwaukee is a strong #2, far and away better than anything else besides the Fiskars. Other knives I use regularly but store in a toolbox are all from OLFA - retractable snap-blade variety.
@@espressomaticit's a 15 dollar tool it's going to wear out, same as the fiskars lol, although it seems to be the best option here
Have been using the Gerber as a pocketknife for over a year. No issues. Slim and easy to carry.
Thanks for the feedback.
I've carried out an extensive (also expensive?) search over the last year while trying to find the perfect utility knife. The milwaukee and the fiskars were my favourites, so I am glad to see that bears out in proper testing. Thanks for the work you do Todd.
check out coast's knives. especially if u like little ones
I've said this before but the thoroughness of the tests in your videos is amazing.
Thank you!
I have about 4 of these knives. My favorite by far is all the Milwaukee ones. Easy to open and close, comfortable to hold. For cutting tougher things I like the dewalt folder with retractable blade.
Thanks for sharing!
I have one that's about a decade old now and if I clean it up, it still looks brand new. Couldn't recommend it more. Just don't bother with their overpriced blades, the generic 50 pack for $6.99 on Amazon are just as good. They're disposable items after all.
All seem to not last long least if looked after well always get cement, sand, dirt ect in them
I have the version of the Milwaukee with the flip-out screwdriver and single blade storage inside the handle. With a little use, the blade gets so easy to open you can just press the button and it falls into place. Great when you're balancing boxes with your other hand.
Thanks for sharing.
My Milwaukee utility knife is a bit older than the one you tested, but uses the same mechanism and performs flawlessly. Feels very solid in the had and easy to open. One caution is that it is also very easy to close when the lock is released, best keep your fingers out of the way.
Thanks for sharing.
It's the only knife allowed in canada you can close with one hand easily with a glove on cause they don't have the stupid security lock, I waited a couple years to be able to purchase it lmfao
I'm in Canada and I have an older Milwaukee as well. Very comfortable handle.
I've had 2 of the older ones. Have absolutely abused them, and they've done outstandingly. Love the wire belt clip. A lot of people don't like the older ones because they were so long, but I actually prefer them....the extra handle has been used as a hammer on a few occasions😂
I started working and tried all types of knives. My coworker swore by the Stanley 99e. I eventually switched to the 99e and it will be my forever favorite. A few wraps of ice and water shield around the body to fatten it up in your hand and it’s perfect. Those foldable and complex action knives never work nicely in a tool belt knife slot.
Great video as usual.
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Happy New Year to you Project Farmer! I really appreciated this review a relatively tool that nearly of us use and take it for granted relying on brand allegiance or price for our selection. Thank you for your advice and for taking the time (and risk) of rating then against one another. Peace be with you, Ciao, L (Riverside & Starshine Farms, Inc.)
Thanks and you are welcome! Happy New Year!
I've used the same small Milwaukee Fastback for 3+ years now almost every day and I'm not surprised the larger version did so well! Once the lock wears in it is super easy to open. I never put it on my belt because its so hard to use so I put in in my left pocket. The larger Milwaukee does hold extra blades in the black part in inside the handle unless they have changed it's design!
Thanks for the feedback.
I have been using the Milwaukee Fast Back utility knives for almost a decade (I use mine multiple times a day as I a residential/commercial repair and remodeling contractor). I have broken a few of them, called Milwaukee and they have sent me new ones at no cost to me. They are strong, crazy easy to deploy & the Fast Back I carry today holds 5 extra blades which is incredibly convenient!
Agreed. There are none of these others that were tested, that I would choose over the Milwaukee.
I just bought a 2 pack that gave a free pack of 50 blades on black Friday sale for $19.99. As a builder we use a ton of Milwaukee tools.
They’re also fun to flip open!
@@joeyfh Agreed. Not only fun, but super convenient.
Great video. I'm a mechanic by trade and a minimalist at heart. The Gerber has been serving me well for the past three years as my EDC. The compact profile is its most valuable feature in my opinion. I don't even feel it clasped to my pocket. And it's a great value at only $11. If I lose it.. no big deal.
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
Would love to see a cartridge style oil filter test video for us who have more modern cars. Not sure how they could be tested but I never doubt the creativity and devotion of this channel. Thank you for all you do!!
You are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
love that you even went to the length of testing belt clips. it's a small detail but as far as workflow is concerned, it matters a lot when you can expect to slide it on and off your belt throughout a day. great video as always.
Thanks for sharing!
At the same time, those look more like pocket clips than belt clips. If the clip is on the right side, you'd have to clip it to the left side of your belt, or clip it backwards.
Meanwhile a pocket clip on the right side will go in your right pocket.
Didn't expect to see Mado here on a PF video!!! I just bought a favorite doujin album of mine on eBay...
Edit: the album is "yume nikki tame no waltz machigelita" for anyone curious! You can find it on Nyaa
@@hitemlow92 agreed! I generally put mine in the pocket, not on the belt
Also, the clip's ability to grab easily is likely user-adjustable with some pliers. Yes, a smooth-working clip is nice, but it is also perhaps readily fixed to meet user needs.
I have the Milwaukee and it works great, blade changes are easy and I generally keep in it my front pocket so no issues with the belt hook. Great video as always, good info and no BS!
Thanks and you are welcome!
The Sheffield style blade-retention is my favorite because there's no wobble or accidental release like happen on other styles. I use the aluminum body version, but it's definitely worth taking a few minutes to adjust the tension on the leading bolt so the knife opens more easily and carefully bending the tab on the blade retention to lock securely. No rubber on the handle makes knives slip into/out of your pocket more easily too, especially with jeans that might fit a little tight.
Thanks for the feedback.
I really enjoyed this review. I use a utility knife every day and over the years have tried many different brands. The Milwaukee is my personal favourite. My version has internal storage for 5 blades.
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
I went with that Milwaukee Fastback, but with the additional 5 blade storage. I've worn it in to the point where it's gravity open and close. It's one of those no regrets purchases.
Thanks for sharing.
Would have been really cool to see the JerryRig knife in this lineup, I've been using one for a while and it's been good to me so far.
First thing I looked for. 😞
Sorry I didn't include it. However I listed it for round 2 testing.
@@ProjectFarm Great!
@@ProjectFarm Yay!
@@ProjectFarm fantastic news, really curious to see how it compares in your gauntlet
I carried Husky for about 5 years because they were cheap, so I could keep extras all over the place. I had my eye on the fiskars for a year or two, but when I finally tried it out, I never went back. The only category it scored poorly in, the belt clip ease, is actually more functional as a pocket clip, though I can't recall if it's marketed that way, but explains why the holding strength was so high as well. I've carried one every single day for around 5 years now and the ease of entirely one handed operation is second to none. I need this feature quite often and it always delights me that I can open, use, close and put away in just a few seconds and flicks of the wrist. Incredibly satisfying. I will say the joint needs to stay relatively clean and free of grit or grime for that flip ease to remain smooth enough to rely on every time, but imo it's more of a precision edc tool to be taken care of than one I'd rely on in the grime in that way. Might go with another brand in the case that I needed one to hold up to greasy, grimey, muddy conditions.
Of note as well are Fiskars carbon coated blades. I'm not sure if you've tested utility blades yet, but they do last very well compared to average. The pricing definitely reflects this though. They're very interesting on cut characteristics. The coating seems to slightly increase the angle of the blade edge and somewhat affect the drag, both positively and negatively, depending on the task and especially with deeper cuts. Similar to comparing a German Chef's knife and a Japanese made. The 15-20° German blade has slightly more drag, but is more durable, while the 9-12° Japanese blade has very little drag and is more brittle. Of course they balance this with slightly softer steel on the German blade to make frequent honing fairly easy and slightly harder steel on the Japanese so it holds it's edge well.
I'd love to see a utility blade comparison in the future if you haven't done one already. At this point, it's quite likely I'll come across it soon if you have already. This is currently my favorite channel and I've been through dozens of your videos in the past few months. Incredibly creative and intelligently straight forward testing methods as well as extremely well organized and cut together videos and evaluation style you have.
Thanks for all that you do for those of us obsessed with spending our hard earned money wisely!
You are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
I love watching these videos. Just head to head on basic wear and tear on products before making a purchase it heavenly! Thank you!
Thanks and you are welcome!
Definitely needs a part two with the utility knife from Jerry Rig Everything.
No he don't
@@MariuszChr Milwaukee all day
For some reason posting the model number gets my comment deleted. Censortube 😓
@@Straight_White_Fatherly_Figure Agree, but JRE knife looks like Husky with custom look, so... If somebody wants JRE just get Husky and dremel something on it lol.
@@MariuszChr the CAT in this video is pretty much the same
I bought the fiskars pro on a whim and it turned into my favorite utility knife ever. I'm so glad that purchase was justified by your testing as well. It's just so buttery smooth to open and close, super comfortable, and perfectly sized. I was shocked it won the vertical breaking weight test, I really thought one of the lock backs would've done better than such an easy to open and close utility knife.
Just like you I was surfing on Amazon and got the fiskars pro cause I liked the way it looked😂 it is the best most comfortable knife I ever bought and thinking of getting another just in case they’re not available later
The Stanley Classic #99 has been my go to utility knife for decades. I bought my first one in the late 1960s and was hooked. Cheap, sturdy and reliable. I also have the Husky knife and really like it. Good video!
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
I have the sheffield version made for Craftsman from quite a few years ago... Looks good, positive connection excellent feel in the hand once you make sure the lever is down as you noted... I also got a Kobalt here a few years ago and really like how that works. It is simple and one handed and that came in handy down on my hands and knees, getting old silicone off of a shower surround here a couple of weeks ago... I give the nod to Kobalt there for sure... I have the Sheffield/Craftsman one on my tool belt as it has a nice clamp built in that HOLDS IT in place and I use it seldom... Also Sheffield/Craftsman had a small version that came with it that is perfect for the car/truck... Finding the little blades isn't easy though... For occasional use with a good blade already in one, the Sheffield is nice if only for looks and feel in the hand, but for WORK changing out blades a lot, the Kobalt is quite nice...
I've the one badged Craftsman too, 'n came with a dandy stiff nylon pouch..free with some wrenches I bought. ha, I use the pouch for my SAK Huntsman knife.
I have that Milwaukee, I keep in my breast pocket at work, the utility knife aspect for what I do is several magnitudes better than normal blades for most instances, its get paired with a Leatherman surge, a pen light, a micro slotted screwdriver and a pen that has a built in ruler. So my pockets are pretty busy, the slim form factor of the Milwaukee fits perfectly with my other stuff. Of all of these blades it's by far the best for me.
That all being said a closing lock on these things is almost entirely necessary, I had a young apprentice a few years ago open his arm from almost his wrist to his almost his elbow because his knife opened in his pants pocket and was sticking out just enough to catch his arm, and because the blade is like a scalpel he hard even felt it enter his skin until was too late, all he did was pick something up off the ground. 😬
Over the years, you have continued to remain in a class all your own. Many have tried, but NONE come close to your style. Looking forward more of your thoughtful content!!
Thanks so much!
I have a gen 1 Milwaukee Fastback, it's so nice. Definitely worth the $10 I spent. I used blades coated in titanium nitride and they last for ages, it's a great combo.
Thanks for sharing.
I got the fiskars, and it has one feature I really like. Just about every other pocket knife I've ever owned had the belt clip either riveted on or attached with a really really small hex key. This one is attached with small Phillips head screws. Within two days of owning it I got the belt clip caught on something and bent it outward. So I was able to just unscrew it, and then squeeze it back into shape with a pair of pliers. Every other knife I've ever owned I had to break it off because it was sticking out so far.
Thanks for the feedback.
You always find creative ways to test things👍
Thank you! I typically wake up at around 3 AM with ideas. lol
@@ProjectFarm sounds like me sometimes
He’s the master. That’s for sure.
@@ProjectFarm Best utility knife of all time is the WORKPRO. I use it everyday making military cables, box cutting, and more.
Part Number is B08X6X8132.
Nice to see Fiskars tested! I always find that their tools (and cutlery) has a really good grip design, and fits naturally into the hand.
Thank you for the feedback!
I love your content your reviews are thorough and it's obvious that each test takes hours of prep. All I wanna say is thank you
Could u pls add survival and outdoor items to your list i.e. best outdoor carry bag, axe, binoculars, fire starters, safety and defense gear etc
I think these will be very cool and open for more great content
FYI I've been following your channel quite some time already 😀
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
I LOVE my Milwaukee Fastback! Ive also had that little Gerber and it is awesome for a small EDC gear
Thanks for the feedback.
I recently bought a 3d printer and got a set of diamond files from Husky for finishing up the rough edges on my prints. I don't think you've ever tested metal files and if there are any better brands out there I'd definitely be interested in seeing your results!
Edit: Happy New Year!
I'm an amateur luthier in my spare time and id also appreciate a file video, maybe even rasps too
A test and review of files and rasps is an excellent idea. Both the usual ridged tooth type and the ones that are diamond impregnated.
@@coolerthanyou9548, Do you watch Ted Woodford's TH-cam channel on guitar repair? I highly recommend it. He typically gives a short history lesson on the brand and model of guitar being repaired, and he has a wonderfully dry sense of humor. His wood working skills are top notch.
Thanks for the suggestion.
@@goodun2974 i haven't heard of him, but i will definitely check him out, i love repair videos
I own that Milwaukee (but the version with extra blade storage in the handle) and it’s the best utility knife I’ve ever owned. Highly recommended and not surprised it finished 2nd.
Thanks for sharing.
Just wanted to say thanks for your thorough objective as you can be reviews. I've been wanting a high quality utility knife and good thing I remembered to search on TH-cam. Back during the holidays, I also got the Shark Vertex Pro Powered Lift-Away Cordless Vacuum with the help of your other review video.
You are welcome!
What a fantastic comparison! Tough too. I am very happy with the results. I got a Fiskars and I love it. So comfortable. I have the Milwaukee on the way. I have the older small Gerber too, which is also nice. It's very compact, with a nice clip, and it holds the blade very securely. Thank you very much for this informative and entertaining video! :D
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for the feedback.
I really like my Milwaukee fastbacks. I have both the old and new designs. It was nice to see they tested so well. I'm going to check out the Fiskars next and see how I like that one.
Your gonna wish you got it sooner. I've tried every design of knife. Nothing even close to the fiskars.
Thanks for the feedback.
Been using the Milwaukee as a mechanic daily for ever, but just ordered the fiskars for comparison
@@azwrenchmaster5334 you will notice that the Fiskars has a tad bit extra rubber on the handle that after about a week of use will begin to curl inward just enough to grab the blade shank. All you need to do is trim it slightly with a sharp razor blade and it will be like new again and never be an issue after that.
@@beerbeforebreakfast thanks for that. Rubber on a work tool doesn't ever seem to be a great idea.
Miwaukee. Open with an easy flick. Closes with a flick. Looks nice. Feels nice. Holds extra blades. Doesn't lose blades
Great feedback. Thanks!
Pretty much my summary on this knife too..
I debated spending that much on a utility knife, but it is worth it.
When the Sheffield was originally marketed I purchased a dozen or so and gave my employees and subs one each for Christmas. I never had a problem opening with one hand but I had initially oiled and polished the mechanisms to make the action very smooth. I still have the one I kept for myself, must be around 20 years or so by now and still works like the first day I used it. I do however use a Stanly fat-max (non folding) for most serious use on jobs such as drywall which is also over 20 odd years in constant use
Thanks for sharing.
love the milwaukee utility knife - bought a two pack and gave one to my dad, I loved mine so much when I saw one with the screwdriver built in I knew I had to get it. plus I have a STACK of those spare blades
Thanks for the feedback.
Great review. The only thing you missed was, belt clip strength. Over the years I've noticed some of the belt clips bend and the knife can slip out of my pocket. I now use the Milwaukee and so far the clip hasn't let me down.
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Knives that have a removable belt clip can be taken off and bent back into shape. The ones that aren't removable unfortunately can't be fixed.
Or the screws fall out
@@orisisseibert3507 the Milwaukee does have a screw holding the belt clip in place but they must have really cranked it down at the factory. I literally own a dozen of these knives because they discontinued the FastBack II that everybody loved, so I cleared out an eBay clearance seller in case I ever broke mine. Milwaukee got so much push-back from their customers that they had to bring the FastBack II back--the FastBack III had a shorter handle and guys with big hands had to shift their grip to open and close the knife. It was not ideal, and often it felt dangerous to use. Small-handed people seem to like it though. :)
Yep, would have been a great category. 👍
I have an older husky folding utility knife with an axis-style lock, as opposed to the typical spine lock that they now feature. Love it and would be lost without it. Makes for excellent one-handed deployment and closing
Great feedback! Thank you
When you say “We’re gonna Test That”, I smile and it makes my day better. Not sure why but it’s my favorite part. 😊
Thanks so much!
I've had the Sheffield Branded knife here in the UK for nearly 18years now! Its branded as Bluepoint here but is otherwise idetical. Loosens up nicely and has a good weight to it which i find much nicer to work woth than other knifes!
Thanks for the feedback.
Great comparison video once again Todd! I look forward to your videos every Sunday and it's truly a pleasure. Happy New Year! The Milwaukee Fastback you have is the 1501 but the 1502 can store 5 blades in a swing-out magnetic arm. I've had it for a couple of years and came in a two-pack with a Fastback 1500 for just $20 total, but the 1502 can be bought at Home Depot for $15 by itself. I use at least one of them every single day and they seem perfect to me, but because of your video maybe I will try a Fiskars knife if I ever lose or break my Milwaukee knives. Thank you for all of your dedication!
Thanks and you are welcome! Happy New Year! Thanks for sharing.
Absolutely love the Milwaukee's opening capability. I've been pairing it with the Irwin blades you tested some time ago and together they make a great combo.
Thanks for sharing.
I always hate commenting because I know you read and respond to every one!
But I also love telling you how awesome you and your testing are! Idk how you think of these tests. Amazing brother! You’re a god send to all us tool nerds! 👍
Thank you very much! I appreciate your support.
I really like my Milwaukee. I'm glad to see it did very well in your tests! Bought a 2-pack of them a few years ago for $14.
Thanks for sharing.
For my EDC I choose the Husky, 3 for $14.98 so it doesn't hurt if it grows legs, really slim and compact, no issues with blade flying out, it's great for quick cuts, durable when I drop it, it doesn't leave my waistband. But for comfort and longer use periods such as cutting through caulking on base boards or crown molding I use the Dewalt non-folding utility knife.
Thanks for sharing!
That's why the multiple tests are worth watching
@@flhusa1 yeah, I'm thinking of getting a Milwaukee now, I like that it's full sized and folds, plus the sweet belt clip.
Yeah, I'm 100% with you there. I've got the Husky 3-pack and they're good for general use. However, changing the blade is unintuitive to me, even though I've used them for years. It takes me a few seconds to remember how to open the mechanism. Plus, I'm a lefty, so not being able to change the thumb bar for opening the blade, nor the belt to the other side, makes things a bit more painful to use (my EDC is Benchmade because of their great Axis lock - it works great for both hands!).
But for comfort, I much prefer a regular sliding utility knife. Stanley, DeWalt, whatever... So I use that when I'm having to cut hard or for a long time.
@@ThePainkiller3666 I use the Milwaukee with the extra blade storage, it flips open and close so easily, also the ergonomics are really good in the hand
I‘m always interested in your constructions to test different products. Your work is very impressive, helps a lot of people and i always learn a lot. Thanks so much!
My pleasure!
Those are worth watching videos by them themselves
Love the humor you put into your scripts
Keep up the fantastic work! I thoroughly enjoyed watching you torture these poor tools
Thanks so much, will do!
I use the Milwaukee fastback knife every day. It looks exactly like that one and can store 5 blades. Love the thorough testing and attention to detail! Thank you for what you do!
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
Fantastic work comparing these - really valid testing and great reporting. Thanks.
My pleasure!
Great video. I use the non folding DeWalt every day. I agree that it is very comfortable. Holds up great too, I once dropped mine 2 stories. Still works great.
Thanks!
I have that black and decker knife at work, but then with the Stanley name.
I did some slight tweaking on it and now it really easily flicks open. I've been using it (lightly) on a daily basis just opening boxes and it's been perfect for me personally. So far it easily lasted 2+ years and I imagine it will last several years more.
Thanks for sharing.
Never knew these are available, so used to just buy the 2.00 harbor freight box cutters, So many neat engineering work, Thanks again,
I ended up buying the Fiskars out of necessity because I bought some panels that wouldn't fit in my car unless I cut them down. I will never go back to box cutters again. That thing is amazing and cuts through cardboard like butter. The blades dull with use quickly, but given how insanely sharp they are it's understandable. Definitely recommend picking up the 50 pack of replacement blades if you get that one. You won't want to go with cheaper blades when you see the difference in performance.
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
@@WeGetWildTV This test was about the folding-knife style of utility blade, not fixed blade handles or razor blades themselves.
HF got a box of folding knives for 2$?
@@derpherpp have you bought a BOX?
I use the gerber eab , just because it's very small and easy to carry.
Great feedback! Thank you
I have that one to and I love it. We aren't really suppose to have knives at my job, but they just makes things easier and that one, being so slim and small, really comes in handy. It's not bulging in my pocket and I sometimes forget that it's even there.
I've used the Craftsman for years until I switched to the Milwaukee Fastback 2. It was like going from walking to driving a car (incredible difference). And with the Fastback 2's bit holder, it's almost everything you could ask for in an EDC knife, too.
Thanks for sharing.
I carry the Milwaukee daily. Just love the easy opening and comfortability for everyday use. Big bonus is that you can get two for the price of one on Black Friday from Home Depot, they’ve done it two years in a row now that I’ve notice atleast
Thanks for sharing.
I have an older Sheffield 12113 that is well over 20 years old, I still use it daily. It has been dropped on concrete from 30 ft, ran over, dropped in a river and so many things, and is still with me. It is stiff to start out with but after a short time of constant use, it did become easier to open, one hand. I do not like plastic slides, buttons, and how many are set up for blade replacement or holding them in place. The difficulty in changing the blade on the Sheffield is exactly what I look for as I do not want the blade to fall out, or anything else that could cause personal injury. I also hate line locks because they are weak. I have seen where the blade became unlocked when in use due to their weakness. I do wish that it had a place for extra blades, but all in all, it has lasted, been through a lot, and is still working. I am going to build a belt case for it that will hold it and a small blade box that I will probably make out of brass and mahogany seeing as I have much of both on hand. I use regular blades as well as hooked blades and switch between the two often.
Thanks for sharing!
love my sheffield
Just glad the knife is not with you in the river. ;) lol
@@larrybe2900 Well I was for long enough to get the knife back LOL
Same, never had to replace my Sheffield due to wear. When I gave one to a co worker I kept my original. It did eventually grow legs but still on my second for about 7 years of daily use now.
Early last year I grabbed 3 Irwins from a hardware store Clearance section and they were all push buttons with round wire belt clips. I don't know what prompted them to go to go with liner locks but I'm glad I did
Thanks for sharing!
I have a Kobalt, mostly because it was the only one I could find when my old Husky broke. For me, some of the main things I look for in a pocket utility knife are the "rideability" in my pocket. Wider knives are uncomfortable and cause bruising to my hip if I bump into something with it clipped in my front pocket. I also like a narrow blade holder like my old Husky, which is useful when making multiple deep passes on material, but that often comes with a compromise with the ability to retain the blade when pulling through thick material. The design of the clip is important. Not enough taper on the clip makes it hard to clip in place as you showed, but too much clip sticking out has caused me to scratch my truck when I brushed up against it and the clip caught the paint. The bigger clip also causes the knife to come out sometimes. I've had mine clip itself to my seatbelt and remove itself. I'll be checking out the Millwaukee if I can find one locally.
Thanks for sharing.
Excellent test!
I have a few Milwaukee variations and a couple Craftsmen that are designed like the Sheffield. I like them both, but the Milwaukee are definitely great designs and perform well.
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
I’ve been using the Milwaukee pocket version for drywall for a couple years now. Love it. No issues.
Impressive!
@@ProjectFarm kinda wanna try that fiskars tho
I have owned several different utility knives and several similar to those on the list. The Gerber is by far my favorite. I like the screw to secure the blade as there is no wobble. The Gerber is also small and pocket friendly.
Thanks for sharing.
Excellent comparison! I was shopping for a new utility knife and had selected the Fiskars. I stumbled across your review and you confirmed my choice. Thanks!
I've used regular Stanley for 40 years always worked pretty good.
I worked in construction & roofing for over 20 years as a side hustle.
For roofing I recommend the bowtie style knife with wing nut slide adjustment.
Thanks for sharing.
I love watching your videos. I would like to see you test metal files since their quality is usually not adequate.... and battery powered backpack sprayers might be fun
That would be perfect right around February ish
I think he may have already tested files.
Thanks! Thanks for the video idea.
The Milwaukee fastback was the first utility knife I ever bought way back when I first got my very first paycheck (granted, that was only 4 years ago), but still. I bought it because I liked the fastback feature and I've had two of them... not because the first one broke but because someone stole it. Also in my experience the blade replacement button being covered by that little nub has never been a problem.
Anyway, like I said, I've been using the fastback for a little over four years now, and it is the only utility blade I will ever buy
Great video, as always Todd
i have on the original bulky looking one with out blade storage. only thing about them is the thread for the pocket clips doesnt seem deep enough ive seen a bunch of them with loose clips.
The older ones didn't have that guard.. mines the first version and still haven't broken it..... yet
Makes me feel really old... first pay check with taxes withheld was when I was 13 working cattle auctions. back in 1978😵💫
Thanks for sharing.
Awesome video as always, in my line of work, I make hundreds of cuts a day with my utility knife. The company provides the blades and they're the break-away kind so a showdown with 1 inch break away blades would be cool.
Video showdown idea. Best flashlights or best headlamps would be awesome!
Thank you for the video idea!
Excellent, intricate, thorough tests! This was great for starting out 2023.
Thank you, Todd.
Thanks and you are welcome!
The impact test is very useful 👍
I happened to drop them from the ladder and it's not nice to see it explode on the ground
Lol....
Thanks! Glad the impact test was useful!
@@ProjectFarm actually all the tests that I could see in his videos are interesting precisely because they are NOT laboratory but real life (regardless of the price/quality-performance ratio). Thank you for all the passion you show. Happy New Year 🙂