@Jinny Barebuckle One has nothing to do with the other. The way Europe treated the Jews doesn’t excuse how the Jews were treated as second class citizens in the Arab lands. Europe has reformed many of its institutions while sadly, the Arab world has basically ethnically cleansed all Jews from Arab countries and the other remaining minorities are treated very poorly to say the least.
The settlements belonged to the Turkish Ottoman Empire for five hundred years until 1918. After WW1 the British took it over. It never belonged to the Palestinians. It is the ancestral land of the Jews.
@@danielt.3152 All the neighboring Arab countries deny entry to Palestinians (despite having room and being the same nationality) because they want to leave them on Israel's hands.
The settlements belonged to the Turkish Ottoman Empire for five hundred years until 1918. After WW1 the British took it over. It never belonged to the Palestinians. It is the ancestral land of the Jews.
i like that you mentioned that the palestinians dident get a say in the things from the start since they were jsut annexed by jordan and egypt who were anti Israel from the begining
I think this is a HUGE misconception. Palestine was never independent. Neighbouring Arabs have done as much to dispossess Palestinians and don't genuinely want them to have their own state either. If Jordan wanted to, they could have easily granted Palestinian refugees citizenship and Jordan could effectively be Palestine.
One small correction. When Ben Gurion declared the state in 1948, he was very careful to not specify it's borders, recognizing that a war was about to break out. The outcome of the war would determine the borders. Your video said that Ben Gurion declared the state on the basis of the borders of the UN Partition plan which is incorrect. He did make reference to the UN Vote but in the context of the right to declare a state.
For all understanding ben gurion knew if the un would allow a jewish state the arab states would go to war the un partition plan only had a chance if the arabs would agree basicly the arabs didnt agree to the un so much for isreal not listening to the un
Ben Gurion was right. Hope Israel has learned from the Yom Kippur war. Complacency is the enemy of efficiency. Never put your guard down because it will be “never again”.
Clearly Ben-Gurion always intended to annex all of "Palestine" (aka "Eretz Israel" aka "Israel, the West Bank, Gaza and the Golan Heights"). In 1937 he said "A partial Jewish state is not an end but a beginning, The establishment of a state, even a small one, will serve as powerful leverage in our historic efforts to redeem the land in its entirety ... We will organize a sophisticated defense force, an elite army - I have no doubt our army will be one of the best in the world - and then I am sure nothing will prevent us from settling the whole land..." Israel has been using force to expand its borders since May 15th 1948.
Thank God, and God bless you guys - you have a series on settlements because I couldn't find A SINGLE WORD on settlements from Ben Shapiro! You guys even have timestamps for 10-19 minute videos! Wow!
They all have top dollar houses and solar power. USA gives them 3 million per day. We are their slaves. We complain about paying for welfare recipients... Yet these are the ones receiving the real welfare.
@@adammiddleton2503 i would like to know bow much aid money is given by the us to afganastan and egypt afganastan is 5 billion egypt 1.3 billion iraq 1.3 and many more countries happens to be in the early yrs of the state america was not very kind under Eisenhower but isreali intelligence was a little to good to turn down if America wasnt interested Russia would pay be thankful that America has good friends in israel
@the business handler yeah let's play this game.. Around 1% of the population of the USA is Muslim. Let's give them 1% of the land, maybe the state of Indiana(or maybe let them choose). How would the Americans feel about that? Now imagine we give them the entire east coast (still less than 10%)
3:19 "Syrian Held Golan Heights?" What do you mean held? You make it sound like it wasn't really theirs. When the French Mandate of Syria terminated in 1946, it became part of the newly independent Syrian Arab Republic. It wasn't a part of the British Mandate of Palestine or any partition plan of Mandate Palestine accepted by Jews.
We know that this is a contentious topic and that people will have differing opinions on the matter about who's "right" or "wrong". We encourage you to express and tell us what you think, feel, and believe. We just ask one thing of you - please do so respectfully. Be respectful of others, and their opinions. Hateful, violent, racist, sexist, and otherwise uncool comments will be REMOVED.
In the introduction at 2.58 and later on on at least three, occasions yo refer to "borders" as being the outcome of the war of Independence. They are not boarders but CEASE FIRE lines. Your reference is misleading and gives the impression that the 1948-49 lines constitute the basis for the Palestinians to lay a territorial and juristic claim the the West Bank. Jordan's claim to sovereignty over the West Bank was never recognised internationally, other than by Britain and Pakistan Gerald M. Adler
Unpacked The Jews in Israel today are not original Jews but people that converted to Judaism over a thousand years ago. They come from the Ukraine and have no ancestral connection to Israel or Jesus. Below is the geneticist findings where he concluded that only around 2% of BOTH Jews and Palestinians carried the Jewish genome. Pls look it up yourself.... Out of Khazaria-Evidence for “Jewish Genome” Lacking. Eran Elhaik, a geneticist at the Johns Hopkins School of Public Health, thinks so.
Unpacked Many Jews refuse to come to Israel because in the Torah it says the MESSIAH will bring them to Israel, this never happened. A group of people that believe that GOD promised them the land called Israel today but do not follow the Torah.
Unpacked In 1948 the Jewish population in Palestine was only 30% (look it up) pls leave link that says otherwise. The signed Balfour declaration prohibits the removal of existing citizens, it is against international law and morally wrong as well. Pls leave link that says otherwise. Jewish professor Ilan pappe Phd researched and proved that no prophet ever told the Palestinians to leave, they were violently forced to leave. If Israel followed international law and let the Palestinians return the Palestinians would outnumber the Jews and only elect other Palestinians into office.
Unpacked Aside from DNA evidence, the khazars that converted to Judaism have not fulfilled the curses that it is said through scripture. One of them ...FORGETTING WHO THEY ARE. (Every khazar claims to be Jewish)
@JM.5387 And the Mandate of Palestine with the British as administrators was not what was discussed here. The 1947 UN Partition plan was. The Mandate of Palestine was established in 1922, your point?
@@srbrant5391 Lol, yeah. 🤭 Overrated. But I too expected to find a bloodbath down here. These are some pretty daring things he's saying, for today's culture. Am pleasantly surprised I was wrong. 🙂
Actually, Israel is not much wider with Judea and Samaria in its possession, especially up north. Between the Mediterranean Sea at Netanya and the Jordan River, Israel is only 40 miles wide as a bird flies. Now that is better than the previous 9 miles wide, and the Samarian Mountains and the 3000 foot drop from the Samarian Ridge to the Jordan River at about 600 feet below Sea level in the Jordan Valley provide the defensive depth.
@@AnalystTosh Yes, the Southern tribe of Judah was all due south of Jerusalem. The Northern Kingdom of Israel was in the Hill country of the Tribes of Ephraim and Menashe with breakaway ancient Israel's capital in Samaria between the territories of Ephraim and Menashe. In between Judah south of Jerusalem and the Ephraim Hill country is the territory Benjamin north of Jerusalem, but it was part of the southern Judean kingdom. So today Benjamin is often considered part of Samaria even if it was part of the Southern Judean kingdom.
@@dovbarleib3256 got it… to be clear, all that is known as WB today was per of Kingdom of Judea or was the whole Kingdom of Judea? And what was Ramallah called in the old days?
I think it's interesting that you don't mention the proposal, that was made by all of the Arab and Muslim state members of the UN in 1947, for a democratic state that would protect rights of all citizens equally. This was just one example of an offer for peace that was turned down by Israelis.
They didn't mention it because it's zionist propaganda. Their opener to the video is along the lines that Jews wanted to return to "their land". This channel is a joke. Probably funded by Israel and American tax dollars.
the last time muslims and non-muslims were in equal abundance, 15 million people died trying to move. india-pakistan division was started by the muslim pakistanis and i don’t think the Palestinians plan on it. also israel has arab politicians and arabs can vote and hold office so its already halfway there
You seem like a reasonable and rational person, either that or a highly attuned PR expert. I appreciate this is a particularly unique perspective, but the current occupation has been called unlawful by the UN. The opposition to the policies of the Israelis government by groups Jewish people all over the world is also a pretty incriminating testament, not just based on ultra-orthodox views, but on humanitarian views. Israel can survive and prosper as part of a two state solution, with buffers of shared non secular borders in religious sites. The suggestion of anyone having a birth right to lands that are not in their possesion is nothing short of imperialism. The use of chemical weapons such as white phosphorus on the citizens of Gaza is damning, and an argument that surrounding countries who are enemies of the Israeli state having chemical weapons capabilities is not a sufficient argument, given the fact that no one has used chemical weapons against Israel, and there are multiple cases of Israel using such weapons. The occupation of Palestinian lands is exemplified by the hatred that it requires in order to use white phosphorus on civilians. Forward to a peaceful two state solution that recognises the ethnic, religious, and cultural significances of both states, where militaristic interests are not at the helm.
Well take into consideration that Jordan comprises 80% of Mandate Palestine and 80% of its population calls themselves "Palestinians" the only logical, historically sound and just thing to do is to recognize the Jordan River as the border between Israel and Palestine (Jordan). There you have it, "the two state solution."
This was a very one sided conversation used to paint the Arabs as the villians. Wish you would have talked truthfully about the Palestinian suffering and how the Israeli settlers torment these people as well. There are always two sides to every story. With ugly actions in each.
When I leave my home now, my grandsons 2000 years later are no longer entitled as "owners" of this house. Especially when they kick out and kill those whom have been living in the house for millenniums.
So if the arabs living in the West Bank are ethnically Jordans, then Jordan should have the right to decide what to do with the territory? And if so, did not they grant it independece after 1967? Or should the people that live there decide what to do with it, including those that were expelled in 1948 (but not if they where expelled from Israel)? I am confused (Sarcasm).
Jordan was created by British empire because B.E. just wanted it. B.E. stole the land from Otoman Empire. Also British created other artificial countries that never existed created many problems since that.
@@timkishelov9489 how exactly is this a reply to my comment? I wrote sarcasm at the end and clearly meant that the people that live and lived there should have the right to decide in which state they want to be, as long as it is democratically. Was it not clear enough?
@John Sm So the other ethnicities have no right to decide for themselves? And if they are all livingin the country of israel, why do they not have the citizenship? Which one do you think they have? Or are they the only people in the world without it, who just happen to live in the most contestent region on earth? How convenient.
@John Sm Almost every nation has commited itself to a two state solution (israel+palestine) there was the UN partition plan for this already in 1948 and the state of israel was to be founded from a part of the mandate of palestine (all other mandates became states afterwards), the population of palestine declared itself a state (decades ago) and no nation (including israel) is claiming all of its land (just all the parts without communities). We can discuss about the historical proof for the existence of palestine (which is evident) or you can admit you are against their democratic right to exist, because some state was there before and now wants the land but without the people.
@@valentineliasfritz115 If the Arab countries didn't start the war in 1948 the world could have another Arab country Palestine. BTW Jordan had the land before 1967 and didn't want to create Palestinian state. Until Palestinian and other Arabs stop seeking destruction of Israel they won't get their state. Israel can't commit suicide regardless of what many other countries are saying. Many Muslim and others such as Ireland, countries want Israel to disappear. It's not going to happen. Try to ask China to return Tibet (which isn't seeking annihilation of China) and see China's answer.
I lived in a settlement in Gush Etzion as a young girl. I would’nt live there now being that they’re considered illegal and ppl who live there are ultra religious. I’m basically an atheist lol
There are plenty of people who live in settlements that aren't ultra religious. The vast majority aren't Haredi, and there are entire communities of secular Jews as well.
But the whole idea of Israel is based on Jewish-Mythology, I mean it is absurd to refuse to live in a settlement because it is illegal and at the same time to move to another place Which was stolen from its owners for the same reason that the settlement was built.🙄
@@syrianatheist817 it’s not based on mythology. There’s archeological evidence that proves Jews lived in Judea and Samaria thousands of years ago, which is actually Settlement area. It’s like telling Native Americans they shouldn’t live in America. But because they’re considered illegal by the world because most of the world isn’t taught any of this and knows nothing of it, I’ll stay in my lane.
@@Rachelleluluful I studied history. Can you provide me with any archaeological evidence Proves that the "Kingdom of Judea" was in Palestine? 2- Let us say that there is evidence to prove this (I know perfectly well that, except for the Torah and Josephus, no one mentioned anything about jews in history, not even the Greek historian Herodotus, who wrote in detail about all the inhabitants of the region, including the Syrian Palestinians, as he called them. He did not write a single word about the temple, Neither about the captivity nor about the Jewish kingdoms in Palestine) but even if this were true, this does not mean that they were the only inhabitants of the area. What kind of logic is this?
@7:16 I suppose it is referring to Article 2 (4) of the United Nations Charter: "All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations." Indeed, Art. 2 (4) is not reffering to the specific nature of the war: aggressive or defensive. However, in "or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations", one may understand that, regardless of its nature, if a war is inconsistent with any os the paragraphs of Article 1 of the UN Charter, let's say, Article 1 (1) "To maintain international peace and security", such a war would not be acceptable, would it? I'm just trying to understand... why there is no peace.
Exactly, gives you a clearer picture of how things went down. I think it's obvious for any reasonable person that Js are indigenous to that land. It's a historical consensus, lol. And we all knew it, growing up - even in Islam, people learn that was the land of the Js (Children of Israel). That just leaves the political conflict to deal with...
@@dyawr it was their promised land , but they broke their promised so many times and killed god massengers and God cursed them 4 times . Then it's arabic land and it's have alot of islamic and Christians history , even Israelis they don't have a cultures there like Palestinians , they are not only stol the land also stol our food and Jordanians manasaf ,and don't have traditional dresses like Palestinians
nakba don't exist and never it was, the only thing existed in 1948 was a war between jews and arabs that was won by the jews and lost by the arabs who played victim after losing the war, losing a war is not a genocide nor so called fakestinian holocaust.
I just realized that the Arabs (Muslims) live there for centuries... And never changed the landscape... But when the Jews (Israelies) started to come back... They transformed the desert.... That means to me ... They have more right to be there.... If PLO and other 'organizations' wanted to Help ... They would accept what is given and make the most of it. I really admire Israel, I wish them well.
So you're saying because the Jewish people changed the landscape that land belongs to them so if I go to your house and cut a branch off of a tree I changed the landscape can I have your house
@@anthonymort5202 dumb analogy. A more apt analogy would be if a bunch of homeless squatters (Arabs) set up tents in an area and a man purchases the area that I owned by a large landowner, then the man has the right to evict the squatters and build up the land how he sees it.
@@anthonymort5202the land also belongs to the Jews due to extensive historical presence in the land that precedes the Arabs and the fact that Arabs and other Islamic imperialists who ruled the land were very poor caretakers of it. There's no valid reason to give a prosperous land to a people who have been shown historically to destroy it agriculturally and let it Rot. That's stupid. Eretz Yisrael shouldn't become another Arabia.
Caucasians jews are of khazars origin, King Bulan in 740ad converted to Judaism and asked his followers to do the same... Under pressure from Kzar of Russia and the Mongols spreaded to many European countries... Caspian sea used to be called khazars sea....
How ignorant!! The Jews have NO Khazar DNA, No Turkic or Turkish DNA!! There is absolutely no proof of any Khazar Conversion. There may have been one king who converted for political reasons, or none at all. The Jews show no DNA from the Khazar region. *Try reading a book! Google is free!*
@@shainazion4073 all these Jew haters have are lies on top of lies. Eretz Yisrael is fully Jewish through and through. And no amount of impotent barking from them will change it
If you’re trying to build up international support or acceptance of these illegal (per international law) settlements, then at least keep it factual. The 1967 war was NOT a defensive war, it was a war that began when the IDF took out Egypt’s and Syria’s Air Force. The rest of your arguments aren’t bad, but be honest. We can never get to peace or even security if we lie to one another.
But it is a defensive war as operation focus (which is what the air strike against the Egyptian, Jordan, and Syrian air forces was called) was a response to the acts of war committed against them. This was explained in the video. For example, Egypt remilitarized the Sinai and closed off the Tiran straight (an act of war) also in Syria, the government diverted the water flow of the rivers which supplied water to the Kineret to their own reserves (the source of 40% of Israel’s water) [also an act of war]. So feel free to debate me on this, but by definition this seems like a defensive war, no?
@@KlausBahnhof According to International Law the West Bank and Gaza are within Israels borders. I can prove that with 3 International laws, can you prove that the West Bank belongs to another entity??;
I appreciate the attempt at the history lesson, but this is oh so very one sided. The funny thing about this is: if everyone wasn’t so possessive over land then there wouldn’t be war. If the Jews accepted life outside of Jerusalem, if Arabs accepted loss of land there wouldn’t be any war. Granted I get that’s a hefty statement, but it’s true.
Nah. Accept life outside of the state? You mean jews should accept oppression from muslims surrounding countries. No free man can accept slavery and still consider himself a man.
Robustus the Jews aren’t rounding up “Palestinians” and systematically killing them, bro. Your gross false equivalence just makes you seem like an idiot. Let’s operate in the realm of reality
Settlement..... Positive word? Have someone building a house in your garden, redirecting your water, electricity supply towards his house, taking your property act, harassing you, changing the lock of your house, and see how positive you would feel
@@borisbaran from a Zionist? You are aware why your culture determines if someone is a jew based on their maternal ancestry? So I wouldn't go that route buddy.
The only difference between Tel Aviv and Ariel or Efrat is timing. Both are cases of Jews building towns in the Jewish homeland. Both are examples of decolonization.
well have you ever heard about archeology? even history can prove what he's saying, for example the Muslim conquest of the region and the subsequent presence of Arabs there
Doris Dulcey I don’t think you understand anything at all you do realize arab is like say Latino a Bolivian is a Latino but he or she has South American ancestry while a Argentine is also a Latino with European ancestry this is the same with the term Arab the Palestinians are descendants of the same people we see in biblical and historical text the only difference is a change in language and religion which happen every where especially when it’s thousands of years
David Weisberg first off Arabs are also Semites so that’s ur first step to proving ur an idiot who knows nothing about this subject second off religion language and the name of region all change over time especially when ur speaking of thousands of years of history Palestinians are the same people who were Jews u see in biblical text and the same people who later adopt Christianity and Islam as well as new languages along the way now u are right that the Romans kicked out Jews which at the time was for the most part just religion you had the people of the region who practiced multiple religions the Romans came forced people to leave Judaism or die so Jews from that region left to Europe and who ever stayed ether converted or had bad fate unfortunately a years later these Jews that fled had married into Eastern European people they still carry some dna left but they are mostly Eastern European by now jew is a religion my friend it’s only become a ethnicity because of the Jewish persecution Europe that forced them to live together and practice the culture that they’ve carried from Palestine mixed with European culture as well also there are Palestinian Jews there’s a 1000 left and millions of Christian Muslim and Druze one last thing Arabs are not monolith the real Arabs u speak of are from the Arabian peninsula Palestinians look completely different just look up Levantine people and then look up Omani people u will what I mean when I say religion and language can be adopted but genetics didn’t change in the case of Palestine
David Weisberg my friend I didn’t say Arabs were the same as the people living in what is today Palestine I said an Arab is really just a linguistic category Palestinian today are the same people u speak of people of that region before Judaism during Judaism when Christianity came Islam and Druze my point is religion language and the name of region all change the Palestinians today are the indigenous people of that land Jews from Eastern Europe as the people who stood up to the Romans didn’t convert and left to Europe they have now mixed with the population in Europe but still hold some of the same genetics as the Palestinians do please brother look up Levantine people then look up what are true genetic arab is look up Omani people are great example and also I want you to know there are Palestinian jews still 1000 left 3000 years from now maybe a new religion will come but the people for the most part stay the same I don’t want to erase Jewish identity but u have know jew was originally just religion and later because an ethnicity especially in Europe due to the insane amounts of persecution im a history major I’m not coming from a bad place I just know what’s factual and what’s not Nelson Mandela supported Palestine I will leave with that message me if want to know more about this
Would you invite these people whose charter says this to be citizens in Israel? *"Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it just as it obliterated others before it"* (The Marty, Imam Hassan al Banna, of blessed memory) *"The Day of Judgement will not come about until the Muslims fight the Jews. When the Jew will hide behind stones and trees, the stones and trees will say, "O Muslims, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him. Only the Gharkad tree, would not do that because it is one of the trees of the Jews,"* related by al-Bukhari and Muslim *"Initiatives, and so-called peaceful solutions and international conferences, are in contradiction to the principles of the Islamic Resistance Movement. Abusing any part of Palestine is abuse directed against part of religion. Nationalism of the Islamic Resistance Movement is part of its religion. Its members had been fed on that for the sake of hosting the banner of Allah over their homeland they fight. "Allah will be prominent, but most people do not know,"* *"There is no solution for the Palestinan question except through Jihad. Initiatives, proposals and international conferences are all a waste of time and gain endeavors. The Palestinan people know better than to consent to having their future, rights and fate toyed with. As in said in the honorable Hadith:* *"The people of Syria are Allah's lashing His land. He wreaks His vengeance through them against whomsoever He wishes among His slaves It is unthinkable that those who are double-faced among them should prosper over the faithful. They will certainly die out of grief and. desperation."* *"The day that enemies usurp part of Muslim land, Jihad becomes the individual duty of every Muslim. In face of the Jews' usurpation of Palestine, it is compulsory that the banner of Jihad be raised, To do this requires the diffusion of Islamic consciousness among the masses, both on the regional, Arab and Islamic levels. It is necessary to instill the spirit of Jihad in the heart of the nation so they would confront the enemies and join the ranks of the fighters,"* *"In their Nazi treatment, the Jews made no exception for women and children. Their policy of striking fear in the heart is meant for all. They attack people where their breadwiinning is concerned, extorting their money and threatening their honor. They deal with people as if they were the worst war criminals. Deportation from the Homeland is a kind of murder.* *And more! You think I want to live next door to this?*
No, this gives a 1900 year old meaning to being Jewish. For 1900 yrs the Jews were not in control of their land or their destiny for over 1900 years. They were a minority in their ancient land from the crushing of the Bar Kokhba Revolt in 135ce until 1948.
Watched all the videos and its still focused on Israeli being the good guys and completely disregarding the Palestinian as Palestinians and marking them as Jordanians
I love that they just entirely skipped the Balfour Declaration and the influx of millions of European Jews. Let’s just pretend this isn’t obvious settler colonialism
That is the point Golda Meir said "If you call them Palestinians you give them a claim on the land" This is why he has to call them Arabs or Jordanians cause he knows the claim of a Palestinian who lives in the West bank is greater than his. Also, you can tell he is biased cause he uses the term Judea and Samaria this term is solely used by the hard-right even many in the Likud refrain from this cause it basis the Jewish claim to Israel not on history but on the Torah. The issue with this channel is that it actually omits legitimate parts of actual Jewish history in favor of using the Torah as a clutch for the land being a God-given right.
If the goal of the 48 war was to "drive the Jews out completely", why did it start in 48? Don't you think it was more political control? about the map and who gets to draw it? Especially since, as you say, Jews had been there for a long long time.
It started in '48 because that is when Israel declared itself an independent, sovereign state. Palestinians laid no claim to the land when it was under Jordanian or Egyptian control, and even in the original 1964 PLO charter, they lay no claim to it. It's only when they lost the territories in a war they started that they claim them
Can you start from how European Jews can have right to expel indigenous people and make their own state in Middle East to which they have no connection whatsoever? Why not we restore Roman Empire there? ‘Most Jews do not believe in god but believe he promised them land’ Ilan Pappe.
Lmao diaspora Jews are a indigenous to the land as the Jews who remained, bud. Also Ilan pappe is a fraud and he has been utterly demolished by Benny Morris
All israeli towns in Judea and samaria are legal. 1922 league of nations mandate cements that. The fact that Brits subsequently went about blatantly violating the core aspects of their own mandate because of their own Jew hatred and to appease Arabs doesnt change this. Some of the towns were actually re establishment of older communities that got ethnically cleansed by Jordan during the 1948 war.
@@adammiddleton2503 They also have a wall and lax abortion laws. Americans should be wary about where our tax dollars go. Republicans pretend to be proponents of the market system, yet hate free trade and love giving billions every year to Israel.
My One and Only question is: Where are the Muslims during the First and Second Temple times back then??? Why they tried to claim the Holy Temple Mount now if they were out of existence during the former two temples??? I believed they were not Muslim (Islam) before. Because they were called Philistines before - they descendants of the loser giant Goliath. Shalom Aleichem shalom
Aside Israeli Arabs, what Arabs have to do with this land? "Al Aqsa" mosque didn't exist at time of Muhammad let alone Islam. Abraham was Jew, Ishmael was Jew, Jacob was Jew, ... Islamic God is J E W I S H
The video could have been 10 seconds long. These settlements are illegal under Israeli and international law. Stop trying to justify them. You can’t move populations into occupied territory. This isn’t hard to understand.
There is no way Israel could defend themselves with a 9 mile across center of its country. The country would be divided in half. There is the Sea on one side, and an enemy population on the other.
The only real long-term solution for Israel and Palestine is for the Palestinians to have their own state in Gaza and to expand Gaza, both on the Egyptian side and Israeli side and for Israel to grant citizenship to all Arabs living in the West Bank/Judea-Samaria. If Arabs want to leave the West Bank, they should be given a grant, or stipend to afford to move to Gaza, Jordan or Egypt. Israel will NEVER give up Judea-Samaria and they never should as it's part of Israel, regardless of what the U.N. people say.
So we should just ignore international law, and believe some fairytales in the Bible or Quran ??? How a Jewish state is any different from Isis state, both are based on silly religions
The problem with giving non-Israeli Arabs in the West Bank citizenship is that many if not most of them are very anti-Israel, so it would be suicidal to do that. I think giving them a state with a portion of the West Bank connected to Jordan is really the only viable solution.
3 states: Israel, Gaza, Palestine (west bank with land swaps). Settlers whose land isn’t absorbed into Israel can continue to live as a minority in West Bank. Peace deal will require full recognition and citizenship of settlers in new Palestinian state along with continued security cooperation with both Israel and palestianian authorities. Gaza can remain the status quo and hopefully gets absorbed by Egypt. Jerusalem is a unified city and a dual capital of both Israel and West Bank. Alternative is 2 states: Gaza and Israel, but with demographic shifts eventually Israel could have a minority Jewish population. Last alternative is status quo, which depending on if you count Gazans teeters on apartheid.
The British had no right to give promises. It was not their land. They were only Administrators of the Land for the League of Nations, who issued the Mandate. The Mandate had only one mission, that was to recreate the Jewish homeland in the Area of Palestine. This was voted on unanimously by All world leaders in 1922.
the arab palestinians should be grateful everyday until the rest of their life we did not throw them to jordan or to their death as they wanted us (DEAD), be grateful for our compassion towards human life.
All of the so called "Palestinians" and Israeli "Arabs" secretly love and admire Israel, the settlements, Judaism and Jews. Everyome knows that. They are just fear of saying it out loud. This is mainly because they are Jews who forced to convert to Islam in the middle ages. I think the best way to end the conflict is a massive conversion to Judaism of the so called "Palestinians" and Israeli "Arabs" 😊❤. Their Muslimness and Arabness is doubted either way. Come back to your roots Jewish brothers! Don't affraid. Changing the name of Israel to Judea is also needed.
Absorbed all Palestinians living in Israel, give them the same rights and privileges as Israelis do so that there will be one State of Israel for all living there, with one strong Constitution and By-laws to be followed by every citizen. The UN was wronged when it partitioned Israel into two states: one for Israelis and one for Palestinians. Since Gaza residents are all Gazans, Let them have their own country as State of Gaza. Let there be peace in Israel.
NO, there are 22 Arab Muslim states, many made by the League of Nations at the same time as Israel was started. There is just one Jewish state. When the Byzantines attacked Jews or the Inquisition, there was nowhere safe to go. When rhe Arab Muslim states treated the Jews with Distain and forced them from the lands they lived in for millenia, they needed somewhere to go. Israel is the only Jewish state. In the beginning, the Jews appealed to the Arabs to stsy in their houses and to help them create a country together, the Arabs from 5 countries plus the Arab irregulars attacked the one day old country of Israel. They chose to leave, they chose to attack, not just one time but with 5 wars and 2 intafadas. The Jews won the wars, the Arabs have continually fought against them. They want to annihilate Israel and the Jews. Read the Hamas Charter, you will see, more is written on the hate and propaganda for Jews and to destroy Israel, than on how to develop or create an Arab country.
@@Wildgrifter You are misinformed Israel national law of 2018 states that Israel only recognizes Jewish self determination . And A Jew born in Brooklyn has a right to live in Jerusalem while an Arab born in Jerusalem does not have a right to live in Jerusalem while Israel extends PERMISSION to Arabs living there, by can revoke that permission at any time
@@Wyndham21044 wdym? An Israeli Arab has the same rights as an Israeli Jew… if they don’t have an Israeli citizenship, than ofc they won’t have the same rights as an ACTUAL citizen. All Israeli citizens have the same rights, from Israeli Arabs to Israelis Jews.
@@Wildgrifter so please explain how a Jew born in Brooklyn has a right to citizenship when a Arab born in Jerusalem does not have a right to live in Jerusalem? If you were correct there would not be any Palestinian refugees. And please not the answer from the Israeli in the comment above They say Arabs do not have the right to live in a Jewish state.
As my friends old Granfather said. I’m a Palestinian Jew. I fought side by side with Palestinian Muslims in the British army Palestinian brigade to fight against hate and ethnic cleansing. He left the new found Israel as he was appalled by the greed and hate from European and American Jews
No judea and samaria is a small dot on the map in the West Bank. It does not include Gaza or Jerusalem or all of West Bank. Nice try lying. Israle took all the other land in the war.
@@jsghetler Ambiguous. Either the parent comment is anti-Israel 'oh you're settling in Palestinian land you thieves?' or is pro-Israel 'oh you mean Palestinians are settling on land which is rightfully Jewish?' Since I don't know which is which, I don't know which is your stand either. Lol. 1 What is your stand? 2 What do you think the parent commenter meant?
The Arabs of Palestine (who only became “Palestinians” in 1968) have a 100-year tradition of rejecting every offer made. Why would they stop now and spoil a perfect record of shooting themselves in the foot? Here’s a list: 1919: Arabs of Palestine refused to nominate representatives to the Paris Peace Conference. 1920: San Remo conference decisions, rejected by the Arabs of Palestine. 1922: League of Nations decisions, rejected by the Arabs of Palestine. 1937: Peel Commission partition proposal, rejected by the Arabs of Palestine. 1938: Woodhead partition proposal, rejected by the Arabs of Palestine. 1947: UN General Assembly partition proposal (UNGAR 181), rejected by the Arab League and the Higher Arab Committee for Palestine. 1949: Israel's outstretched hand for peace (UNGAR 194), rejected by the Arab League and the Higher Arab committee for Palestine. 1967: Israel's outstretched hand for peace (UNSCR 242), rejected by the Arab League and the PLO. 1978: Begin/Sa’adat peace proposal, rejected by the whole Arab world (besides Egypt), including the PLO. 1994: Rabin/Hussein peace agreement, rejected by the whole Arab League (except for Egypt and Jordan). 1995: Rabin's Contour-for-Peace, rejected by the Palestinian Authority. 2000: Barak/Clinton peace offer, rejected by Yasser Arafat, who then initiated the pre-planned second intifada. 2001: Barak’s offer at Taba, rejected by the Palestinian Authority. 2005: Sharon's peace gesture, withdrawal from Gaza, rejected by the Hamas takeover in 2007. 2008: Olmert/Bush peace offer, rejected by Mahmoud Abbas, head of the Palestinian Authority. 2009 to present: Netanyahu's repeated invitations to peace talks, rejected. 2014: Kerry's Contour-for-Peace, rejected by the Palestinian Authority. 2018: Trump’s “deal of the Century”, rejected in advance by Mahmoud Abbas (unelected head of the Palestinian Authority). This should just about say it all.
Why you are so fast and hurry in explaining? Perhaps you have to go somewhere or do some other work after finishing creating this video. Please free yourself and do video in calm. 💯💯💯💯💯💯
Caucasians jews all of khazars origin, other Jews belong to their countries... Ancient Israel, Judea and Samaria belong to ancestry of Palestinians... Before Islam many parts of Arabia were Jewish and Christians...
Why are you writing the same comment over again? What are saying is not true! Jews have zero Khzarian DNA. They do however have genetic ties to the Middle East.
That's because most of the world is uneducated . I don't see why people from the west will be against another fellow country with western values . Israel is the only real democracy in the middle east , a great ally to the west .
Nope..... Indians are huge supporters of Israel..... We support Israel ..... Especially Hindus .... through and through.... even Israel recognised india as it's biggest supporter...
It basically goes like this. First their is the occupation in 1967, than Israel declares that they occupy the west bank and gaza for the sake of protecting Israel because those areas are posing danger, the Palestinians begin to fight the two decades of oppression at the early eighties, which prompted the revival of all these militant groups aka hamas. Than israel decides to build settlement in the same region that they claim to be unsafe, and they segregated them completely from Arab towns and villages, than the Palestinians fought back with suicidal attacks etc, which prompted Israel to build a wall completely segregating Palestinians and towns from one another. After building all these settlements, now israel is focused on Driving Palestinians out of their lands and homes, specifically in Jerusalem, aka yakub the thief. While doing all this, militant groups like hamas are getting stronger every couple of years, with rockets now that can target every town in Israel. How did this war start? Just ask yakub the settler he’ll tell you all about it. He basically told the Palestinian struggle, so thank you yakub.
It's a delicate balance between what is an actual hate comment and what is just an annoying troll. We leave it up to our discretion, and some comments that were automatically held by TH-cam have not been allowed.
He tried to explain the settlers' views, since you literally never hear the reasons behind why many people created these settlements in the first place.
Se supone que todos nuestros videos tienen subtítulos en español. Puede acceder a ellos haciendo clic en el engranaje y luego seleccionando su idioma en el menú de subtítulos
@@UNPACKED Then I would have to see it once more, so no. You can maybe explain why the video skips that more than 500 palestinians were killed by settlers and IDF in 2023?
Jeffrey Culpepper Do not speak for us Americans with a CONSCIENCE who stand against apartheid and Israeli occupation. 🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸💕🕊
Jeffrey Culpepper NOPE. This American supports PALESTINE 🇵🇸 and the human right for a person to live on the land they were born to. NOT IN AN OPEN AIR PRISON. You support apartheid.
The Soviet Union convinced Nasser that Israel had massed troops on the border. The 1967 war was hardly defensive. Nasser was weakened due to his meddling in Yemen. The fact he had a big mouth did not help matters
Newsflash: Israel took those territories in unprovoked defensive wars. It's given many back for the sake of peace, and now gets regular rockets fired from there onto the Israeli civilian population.
I'm sure the comments section will be rational and thorough.
Hahahhaha
@Jinny Barebuckle One has nothing to do with the other. The way Europe treated the Jews doesn’t excuse how the Jews were treated as second class citizens in the Arab lands. Europe has reformed many of its institutions while sadly, the Arab world has basically ethnically cleansed all Jews from Arab countries and the other remaining minorities are treated very poorly to say the least.
😂 For sure.
The settlements belonged to the Turkish Ottoman Empire for five hundred years until 1918.
After WW1 the British took it over.
It never belonged to the Palestinians.
It is the ancestral land of the Jews.
@@HoldenNY22 nothing of course
*mentions Israel and settlement at the title at the same time*
Oh boy oh boy the comment section is where the Fifth arab-Israeli war will start
If you think about it Syria is ripe for settlement by Palestinians now it’s practically empty
@@danielt.3152 All the neighboring Arab countries deny entry to Palestinians (despite having room and being the same nationality) because they want to leave them on Israel's hands.
You mean 9th? I thought there were 8 so far. 🤔
@@Theouterrim77 I agree actually.
The settlements belonged to the Turkish Ottoman Empire for five hundred years until 1918.
After WW1 the British took it over.
It never belonged to the Palestinians.
It is the ancestral land of the Jews.
i like that you mentioned that the palestinians dident get a say in the things from the start since they were jsut annexed by jordan and egypt who were anti Israel from the begining
I think this is a HUGE misconception. Palestine was never independent. Neighbouring Arabs have done as much to dispossess Palestinians and don't genuinely want them to have their own state either. If Jordan wanted to, they could have easily granted Palestinian refugees citizenship and Jordan could effectively be Palestine.
@@dunnowy123 unless I'm mistaken, Jordan WAS the Arab state created in the first place, back when (but nobody want's to look under THAT rock).
Yep! Jordan was curved out of the British Mandate Palestine and given to the Arabs...but they came back for more @@CrystalConcentrics
@@dunnowy123 Jordan later on did give some help but turns out the palastinans wanted to take control of Jordan
@@dunnowy123 a huge misconception, fueled by Vox and similar "journalists".
One small correction. When Ben Gurion declared the state in 1948, he was very careful to not specify it's borders, recognizing that a war was about to break out. The outcome of the war would determine the borders. Your video said that Ben Gurion declared the state on the basis of the borders of the UN Partition plan which is incorrect. He did make reference to the UN Vote but in the context of the right to declare a state.
For all understanding ben gurion knew if the un would allow a jewish state the arab states would go to war the un partition plan only had a chance if the arabs would agree basicly the arabs didnt agree to the un so much for isreal not listening to the un
Ben Gurion was right. Hope Israel has learned from the Yom Kippur war. Complacency is the enemy of efficiency. Never put your guard down because it will be “never again”.
Oh, that's interesting. 🤔
normally the winner deserves everything
Clearly Ben-Gurion always intended to annex all of "Palestine" (aka "Eretz Israel" aka "Israel, the West Bank, Gaza and the Golan Heights"). In 1937 he said "A partial Jewish state is not an end but a beginning, The establishment of a state, even a small one, will serve as powerful leverage in our historic efforts to redeem the land in its entirety ... We will organize a sophisticated defense force, an elite army - I have no doubt our army will be one of the best in the world - and then I am sure nothing will prevent us from settling the whole land..." Israel has been using force to expand its borders since May 15th 1948.
Thank God, and God bless you guys - you have a series on settlements because I couldn't find A SINGLE WORD on settlements from Ben Shapiro! You guys even have timestamps for 10-19 minute videos! Wow!
Glad you like them!
@@UNPACKED
Please tell Ben Shapiro to talk about settlements. It's killing me. XD
1:17 what an inconvenience... some people already live in the land we want to take.. nevermind, we have the greatest power on our side ..
They all have top dollar houses and solar power. USA gives them 3 million per day. We are their slaves. We complain about paying for welfare recipients... Yet these are the ones receiving the real welfare.
@@adammiddleton2503 i would like to know bow much aid money is given by the us to afganastan and egypt afganastan is 5 billion egypt 1.3 billion iraq 1.3 and many more countries happens to be in the early yrs of the state america was not very kind under Eisenhower but isreali intelligence was a little to good to turn down if America wasnt interested Russia would pay be thankful that America has good friends in israel
the business handler that’s a lie. Much of the Middle East is catholic
@the business handler yeah let's play this game.. Around 1% of the population of the USA is Muslim. Let's give them 1% of the land, maybe the state of Indiana(or maybe let them choose). How would the Americans feel about that? Now imagine we give them the entire east coast (still less than 10%)
@the business handler with all my criticism to Islam and Muslims, they seem to get along just fine in Europe. Just like the Jews you know.
3:19 "Syrian Held Golan Heights?" What do you mean held? You make it sound like it wasn't really theirs. When the French Mandate of Syria terminated in 1946, it became part of the newly independent Syrian Arab Republic. It wasn't a part of the British Mandate of Palestine or any partition plan of Mandate Palestine accepted by Jews.
We know that this is a contentious topic and that people will have differing opinions on the matter about who's "right" or "wrong". We encourage you to express and tell us what you think, feel, and believe. We just ask one thing of you - please do so respectfully. Be respectful of others, and their opinions.
Hateful, violent, racist, sexist, and otherwise uncool comments will be REMOVED.
In the introduction at 2.58 and later on on at least three, occasions yo refer to "borders" as being the outcome of the war of Independence. They are not boarders but CEASE FIRE lines. Your reference is misleading and gives the impression that the 1948-49 lines constitute the basis for the Palestinians to lay a territorial and juristic claim the the West Bank.
Jordan's claim to sovereignty over the West Bank was never recognised internationally, other than by Britain and Pakistan
Gerald M. Adler
Unpacked The Jews in Israel today are not original Jews but people that converted to Judaism over a thousand years ago. They come from the Ukraine and have no ancestral connection to Israel or Jesus.
Below is the geneticist findings where he concluded that only around 2% of BOTH Jews and Palestinians carried the Jewish genome. Pls look it up yourself....
Out of Khazaria-Evidence for “Jewish Genome” Lacking. Eran Elhaik, a geneticist at the Johns Hopkins School of Public Health, thinks so.
Unpacked Many Jews refuse to come to Israel because in the Torah it says the MESSIAH will bring them to Israel, this never happened.
A group of people that believe that GOD promised them the land called Israel today but do not follow the Torah.
Unpacked In 1948 the Jewish population in Palestine was only 30% (look it up) pls leave link that says otherwise.
The signed Balfour declaration prohibits the removal of existing citizens, it is against international law and morally wrong as well. Pls leave link that says otherwise.
Jewish professor Ilan pappe Phd researched and proved that no prophet ever told the Palestinians to leave, they were violently forced to leave. If Israel followed international law and let the Palestinians return the Palestinians would outnumber the Jews and only elect other Palestinians into office.
Unpacked Aside from DNA evidence, the khazars that converted to Judaism have not fulfilled the curses that it is said through scripture. One of them ...FORGETTING WHO THEY ARE. (Every khazar claims to be Jewish)
So far, completely accurate as far as I can see.
@ Unpacked. - In 1947, the Land was not assigned to the Jews, it was recommended to be partitioned. It was not binding, it was only a suggestion.
The British Mandate was a mandate from the League of Nations to establish a Jewish state.
@JM.5387 And the Mandate of Palestine with the British as administrators was not what was discussed here. The 1947 UN Partition plan was. The Mandate of Palestine was established in 1922, your point?
Great job 🎉
This comment section is going to get _carcinogenic._
Thank god I made it before the Arabs got here
😂 I think it stayed pretty quiet. Maybe bc the channel doesn't have so much traction with the average 'woke mob'.
@@dyawr Funny how I hear more people complaining about SJWs than actual SJWs.
@@srbrant5391 Lol, yeah. 🤭 Overrated. But I too expected to find a bloodbath down here. These are some pretty daring things he's saying, for today's culture.
Am pleasantly surprised I was wrong. 🙂
@@jays5926 Yeah, it's a nice and safe racist circle-jerk for you.
Actually, Israel is not much wider with Judea and Samaria in its possession, especially up north. Between the Mediterranean Sea at Netanya and the Jordan River, Israel is only 40 miles wide as a bird flies.
Now that is better than the previous 9 miles wide, and the Samarian Mountains and the 3000 foot drop from the Samarian Ridge to the Jordan River at about 600 feet below Sea level in the Jordan Valley provide the defensive depth.
West Bank is Judea and Samaria?
@@AnalystTosh Yes, the Southern tribe of Judah was all due south of Jerusalem. The Northern Kingdom of Israel was in the Hill country of the Tribes of Ephraim and Menashe with breakaway ancient Israel's capital in Samaria between the territories of Ephraim and Menashe. In between Judah south of Jerusalem and the Ephraim Hill country is the territory Benjamin north of Jerusalem, but it was part of the southern Judean kingdom. So today Benjamin is often considered part of Samaria even if it was part of the Southern Judean kingdom.
@@dovbarleib3256 got it… to be clear, all that is known as WB today was per of Kingdom of Judea or was the whole Kingdom of Judea? And what was Ramallah called in the old
days?
All of you did an excellent job for this first episode explaining that mess. Well done looking forward to the next one.
They could have settled anywhere in Europe but noooo. They'd rather slaughter a million Arabs holy war style and make us pay for it.
@@relhage100 ))j
It's all zionist propaganda
I am amazed this guy is as objective as he is! It's refreshing!
I think it's interesting that you don't mention the proposal, that was made by all of the Arab and Muslim state members of the UN in 1947, for a democratic state that would protect rights of all citizens equally. This was just one example of an offer for peace that was turned down by Israelis.
Can you share more about that proposal and what happened to it, as well as other offers for peace that Israel turned down?
They didn't mention it because it's zionist propaganda. Their opener to the video is along the lines that Jews wanted to return to "their land". This channel is a joke. Probably funded by Israel and American tax dollars.
I'm waiting for the link to that proposal... and other proposals from the Arabs
Can you give source of that proposal ?
the last time muslims and non-muslims were in equal abundance, 15 million people died trying to move. india-pakistan division was started by the muslim pakistanis and i don’t think the Palestinians plan on it. also israel has arab politicians and arabs can vote and hold office so its already halfway there
great vid. thanks
Settlers make bases in enemy territory, cutting their lines of communication and obstructing everything. They are doing their job excellently.
dont cry when they get what they are looking for.
It's not enemy territory, it's liberated Jewish territory.
@@גרשוןפרלמן The only Jewish territory is in hell with the devil himself
Because if the settler won't do it, then another settler will do it.
Why are you mentally sick in the head? Are an offspring of your cousins?
@@גרשוןפרלמן then who are you fighting?
You seem like a reasonable and rational person, either that or a highly attuned PR expert. I appreciate this is a particularly unique perspective, but the current occupation has been called unlawful by the UN. The opposition to the policies of the Israelis government by groups Jewish people all over the world is also a pretty incriminating testament, not just based on ultra-orthodox views, but on humanitarian views. Israel can survive and prosper as part of a two state solution, with buffers of shared non secular borders in religious sites. The suggestion of anyone having a birth right to lands that are not in their possesion is nothing short of imperialism. The use of chemical weapons such as white phosphorus on the citizens of Gaza is damning, and an argument that surrounding countries who are enemies of the Israeli state having chemical weapons capabilities is not a sufficient argument, given the fact that no one has used chemical weapons against Israel, and there are multiple cases of Israel using such weapons. The occupation of Palestinian lands is exemplified by the hatred that it requires in order to use white phosphorus on civilians. Forward to a peaceful two state solution that recognises the ethnic, religious, and cultural significances of both states, where militaristic interests are not at the helm.
Well take into consideration that Jordan comprises 80% of Mandate Palestine and 80% of its population calls themselves "Palestinians" the only logical, historically sound and just thing to do is to recognize the Jordan River as the border between Israel and Palestine (Jordan). There you have it, "the two state solution."
This was a very one sided conversation used to paint the Arabs as the villians. Wish you would have talked truthfully about the Palestinian suffering and how the Israeli settlers torment these people as well. There are always two sides to every story. With ugly actions in each.
This is the first in the series of five videos, we recommend you watch all of them - we present the other side as well.
pleasantly drifting Oh for god sake. No one is INNOCENT in this CONFLICT. Get off of your superfluous, imaginary moral high ground
The arabs refuse to aknowledge Israel, and in turn they suffer. All is well.
It's honestly not hard to "paint" the Arabs as the villains in this story.
When you ally with the Nazis to try to exterminate the Jews, you come out looking like the villain. It is what it is.
Good video, as always. Tel Hai!
When I leave my home now, my grandsons 2000 years later are no longer entitled as "owners" of this house. Especially when they kick out and kill those whom have been living in the house for millenniums.
nvm English is a weird language and same for them they were always at owned land
@Alan Hughes uk
@Alan Hughes true but plastine was supposed to be Jewish Arab state the Arabs were against it
God has spoken, Who is man?the land is for Israel forever.
Except when we left our home unwillingly we still kept a connection to the home and when some of my grandchildren continued living in that house since
What happened to the Sinai peninsula that they conquered...is it still there's today?
Nope.
Stupid Begin brought it back to treacherous Egypt after the peace agreements in 1979. I hate him for that and many other reasons.
No, but that's because we gave it back, we never lost land
It's the one time that "land for peace" actually worked.
This was rated G we wanted rated R
Land won from aggressors in a defensive war becomes property of the defenders in any sane person's mind.
Sanity is sadly deficient here.
Not after ww2 and this happens after btw
Crazy logic you have here.
@@drtak4512 Really? So victors give the land they’ve taken back after they’ve won? Talk about crazy logic 🤡
So if the arabs living in the West Bank are ethnically Jordans, then Jordan should have the right to decide what to do with the territory? And if so, did not they grant it independece after 1967?
Or should the people that live there decide what to do with it, including those that were expelled in 1948 (but not if they where expelled from Israel)?
I am confused (Sarcasm).
Jordan was created by British empire because B.E. just wanted it. B.E. stole the land from Otoman Empire. Also British created other artificial countries that never existed created many problems since that.
@@timkishelov9489 how exactly is this a reply to my comment? I wrote sarcasm at the end and clearly meant that the people that live and lived there should have the right to decide in which state they want to be, as long as it is democratically. Was it not clear enough?
@John Sm So the other ethnicities have no right to decide for themselves? And if they are all livingin the country of israel, why do they not have the citizenship? Which one do you think they have? Or are they the only people in the world without it, who just happen to live in the most contestent region on earth? How convenient.
@John Sm Almost every nation has commited itself to a two state solution (israel+palestine) there was the UN partition plan for this already in 1948 and the state of israel was to be founded from a part of the mandate of palestine (all other mandates became states afterwards), the population of palestine declared itself a state (decades ago) and no nation (including israel) is claiming all of its land (just all the parts without communities).
We can discuss about the historical proof for the existence of palestine (which is evident) or you can admit you are against their democratic right to exist, because some state was there before and now wants the land but without the people.
@@valentineliasfritz115 If the Arab countries didn't start the war in 1948 the world could have another Arab country Palestine. BTW Jordan had the land before 1967 and didn't want to create Palestinian state. Until Palestinian and other Arabs stop seeking destruction of Israel they won't get their state. Israel can't commit suicide regardless of what many other countries are saying. Many Muslim and others such as Ireland, countries want Israel to disappear. It's not going to happen. Try to ask China to return Tibet (which isn't seeking annihilation of China) and see China's answer.
What are we going to do when the Mongols want their empire back?
Learn monggolian language
Let's Mongolian take back their ancestors land and built legal settlement
But the Mongols already have their own country
Give back the land back to Mongolia empire..
They would need to fight back for it just as we (Israelis) did in 1948 I guess
I lived in a settlement in Gush Etzion as a young girl. I would’nt live there now being that they’re considered illegal and ppl who live there are ultra religious. I’m basically an atheist lol
There are plenty of people who live in settlements that aren't ultra religious. The vast majority aren't Haredi, and there are entire communities of secular Jews as well.
But the whole idea of Israel is based on Jewish-Mythology, I mean it is absurd to refuse to live in a settlement because it is illegal and at the same time to move to another place Which was stolen from its owners for the same reason that the settlement was built.🙄
@@UNPACKED Certainly secular ;) They do not believe in ''God'' but they believe that he gave them the land and then vanish
@@syrianatheist817 it’s not based on mythology. There’s archeological evidence that proves Jews lived in Judea and Samaria thousands of years ago, which is actually Settlement area. It’s like telling Native Americans they shouldn’t live in America. But because they’re considered illegal by the world because most of the world isn’t taught any of this and knows nothing of it, I’ll stay in my lane.
@@Rachelleluluful I studied history. Can you provide me with any archaeological evidence Proves that the "Kingdom of Judea" was in Palestine?
2- Let us say that there is evidence to prove this (I know perfectly well that, except for the Torah and Josephus, no one mentioned anything about jews in history, not even the Greek historian Herodotus, who wrote in detail about all the inhabitants of the region, including the Syrian Palestinians, as he called them. He did not write a single word about the temple, Neither about the captivity nor about the Jewish kingdoms in Palestine) but even if this were true, this does not mean that they were the only inhabitants of the area. What kind of logic is this?
FINALLY, WE GET TO HEAR THE R-E-A-L TRUTH ABOUT IT ALL.
THANK YOU!!
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 keep sleeping and don't even bother answering 🙄
yeah your truth
@7:16 I suppose it is referring to Article 2 (4) of the United Nations Charter: "All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations."
Indeed, Art. 2 (4) is not reffering to the specific nature of the war: aggressive or defensive. However, in "or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations", one may understand that, regardless of its nature, if a war is inconsistent with any os the paragraphs of Article 1 of the UN Charter, let's say, Article 1 (1) "To maintain international peace and security", such a war would not be acceptable, would it? I'm just trying to understand... why there is no peace.
Motti Hud was the Israeli pilot that led the air strike on Egypt, and eventually, president of El Al Airlines. An unsung Israeli hero.
You can't delete the history man
Propoganda of isra'hell. No sane person would buy your logic. "2000 years a go" seriously ?
You can't make one up either.
Ask neutri karta ( Palestinian jews in Palestine)
Exactly, gives you a clearer picture of how things went down. I think it's obvious for any reasonable person that Js are indigenous to that land. It's a historical consensus, lol. And we all knew it, growing up - even in Islam, people learn that was the land of the Js (Children of Israel).
That just leaves the political conflict to deal with...
@@dyawr it was their promised land , but they broke their promised so many times and killed god massengers and God cursed them 4 times . Then it's arabic land and it's have alot of islamic and Christians history , even Israelis they don't have a cultures there like Palestinians , they are not only stol the land also stol our food and Jordanians manasaf ,and don't have traditional dresses like Palestinians
Convenient he didn't mention the Nakba 🤔
That’s not the topic of this video. But you can learn about the Nakba here: th-cam.com/video/jB6IhmHYzWs/w-d-xo.htmlsi=DoEZy4k_GVUSQWeQ
It took place during the time period covered by this video. Might be perceived as a convenient oversight.
It’s not the topic of this video - but you really can learn all about it in our videos about the Nakba
nakba don't exist and never it was, the only thing existed in 1948 was a war between jews and arabs that was won by the jews and lost by the arabs who played victim after losing the war, losing a war is not a genocide nor so called fakestinian holocaust.
Israel was in league with France and Britain to take the Suez Canal
I just realized that the Arabs (Muslims) live there for centuries... And never changed the landscape... But when the Jews (Israelies) started to come back... They transformed the desert....
That means to me ... They have more right to be there....
If PLO and other 'organizations' wanted to Help ... They would accept what is given and make the most of it.
I really admire Israel, I wish them well.
That’s stupid
So you're saying because the Jewish people changed the landscape that land belongs to them so if I go to your house and cut a branch off of a tree I changed the landscape can I have your house
@@anthonymort5202 dumb analogy.
A more apt analogy would be if a bunch of homeless squatters (Arabs) set up tents in an area and a man purchases the area that I owned by a large landowner, then the man has the right to evict the squatters and build up the land how he sees it.
@@anthonymort5202the land also belongs to the Jews due to extensive historical presence in the land that precedes the Arabs and the fact that Arabs and other Islamic imperialists who ruled the land were very poor caretakers of it. There's no valid reason to give a prosperous land to a people who have been shown historically to destroy it agriculturally and let it Rot. That's stupid. Eretz Yisrael shouldn't become another Arabia.
@@ajvorob9117 so if I show up to somebody's house and say hey I lived here at one time I can have their house
Caucasians jews are of khazars origin, King Bulan in 740ad converted to Judaism and asked his followers to do the same...
Under pressure from Kzar of Russia and the Mongols spreaded to many European countries...
Caspian sea used to be called khazars sea....
How ignorant!! The Jews have NO Khazar DNA, No Turkic or Turkish DNA!! There is absolutely no proof of any Khazar Conversion. There may have been one king who converted for political reasons, or none at all. The Jews show no DNA from the Khazar region. *Try reading a book! Google is free!*
@@shainazion4073 all these Jew haters have are lies on top of lies. Eretz Yisrael is fully Jewish through and through. And no amount of impotent barking from them will change it
If you’re trying to build up international support or acceptance of these illegal (per international law) settlements, then at least keep it factual. The 1967 war was NOT a defensive war, it was a war that began when the IDF took out Egypt’s and Syria’s Air Force.
The rest of your arguments aren’t bad, but be honest. We can never get to peace or even security if we lie to one another.
But it is a defensive war as operation focus (which is what the air strike against the Egyptian, Jordan, and Syrian air forces was called) was a response to the acts of war committed against them. This was explained in the video. For example, Egypt remilitarized the Sinai and closed off the Tiran straight (an act of war) also in Syria, the government diverted the water flow of the rivers which supplied water to the Kineret to their own reserves (the source of 40% of Israel’s water) [also an act of war]. So feel free to debate me on this, but by definition this seems like a defensive war, no?
They are not illegal in any way!! Stop believing nonsense. Research things yourself.
💯
@@shainazion4073 According to international law, every settlement built outside of Israel's internationally recognised borders is illegal. Fact.
@@KlausBahnhof According to International Law the West Bank and Gaza are within Israels borders. I can prove that with 3 International laws, can you prove that the West Bank belongs to another entity??;
I appreciate the attempt at the history lesson, but this is oh so very one sided.
The funny thing about this is: if everyone wasn’t so possessive over land then there wouldn’t be war. If the Jews accepted life outside of Jerusalem, if Arabs accepted loss of land there wouldn’t be any war. Granted I get that’s a hefty statement, but it’s true.
Nah. Accept life outside of the state? You mean jews should accept oppression from muslims surrounding countries. No free man can accept slavery and still consider himself a man.
If you think Jews are going to give up the holy land you're infantile
Sooooo it’s not ok when germans kill jews and take their homes but it’s just fine when jews kill palestinians and take their homes....
Probably the most neutral comment in the whole channel, though it isn't saying much. Well done though.
Robustus the Jews aren’t rounding up “Palestinians” and systematically killing them, bro. Your gross false equivalence just makes you seem like an idiot. Let’s operate in the realm of reality
Settlement..... Positive word? Have someone building a house in your garden, redirecting your water, electricity supply towards his house, taking your property act, harassing you, changing the lock of your house, and see how positive you would feel
i comment on every ad I get so hi
Summed up with one word: Lebensraum.
Summed up in two words: Deine Mudda
@@borisbaran someone's butthurt!
@@BaltimoresBerzerker That would be... YOUR MOTHER!
@@borisbaran from a Zionist? You are aware why your culture determines if someone is a jew based on their maternal ancestry? So I wouldn't go that route buddy.
There are many western people living in the West Bank
The only difference between Tel Aviv and Ariel or Efrat is timing. Both are cases of Jews building towns in the Jewish homeland. Both are examples of decolonization.
At least you must Prove what you said between 0:40 - 1:00 because I think it is a deceit.
Anas Hyousef That’s what Zionists do best! Other than creating genocide and an apartheid system.
well have you ever heard about archeology? even history can prove what he's saying, for example the Muslim conquest of the region and the subsequent presence of Arabs there
Doris Dulcey I don’t think you understand anything at all you do realize arab is like say Latino a Bolivian is a Latino but he or she has South American ancestry while a Argentine is also a Latino with European ancestry this is the same with the term Arab the Palestinians are descendants of the same people we see in biblical and historical text the only difference is a change in language and religion which happen every where especially when it’s thousands of years
David Weisberg first off Arabs are also Semites so that’s ur first step to proving ur an idiot who knows nothing about this subject second off religion language and the name of region all change over time especially when ur speaking of thousands of years of history Palestinians are the same people who were Jews u see in biblical text and the same people who later adopt Christianity and Islam as well as new languages along the way now u are right that the Romans kicked out Jews which at the time was for the most part just religion you had the people of the region who practiced multiple religions the Romans came forced people to leave Judaism or die so Jews from that region left to Europe and who ever stayed ether converted or had bad fate unfortunately a years later these Jews that fled had married into Eastern European people they still carry some dna left but they are mostly Eastern European by now jew is a religion my friend it’s only become a ethnicity because of the Jewish persecution Europe that forced them to live together and practice the culture that they’ve carried from Palestine mixed with European culture as well also there are Palestinian Jews there’s a 1000 left and millions of Christian Muslim and Druze one last thing Arabs are not monolith the real Arabs u speak of are from the Arabian peninsula Palestinians look completely different just look up Levantine people and then look up Omani people u will what I mean when I say religion and language can be adopted but genetics didn’t change in the case of Palestine
David Weisberg my friend I didn’t say Arabs were the same as the people living in what is today Palestine I said an Arab is really just a linguistic category Palestinian today are the same people u speak of people of that region before Judaism during Judaism when Christianity came Islam and Druze my point is religion language and the name of region all change the Palestinians today are the indigenous people of that land Jews from Eastern Europe as the people who stood up to the Romans didn’t convert and left to Europe they have now mixed with the population in Europe but still hold some of the same genetics as the Palestinians do please brother look up Levantine people then look up what are true genetic arab is look up Omani people are great example and also I want you to know there are Palestinian jews still 1000 left 3000 years from now maybe a new religion will come but the people for the most part stay the same I don’t want to erase Jewish identity but u have know jew was originally just religion and later because an ethnicity especially in Europe due to the insane amounts of persecution im a history major I’m not coming from a bad place I just know what’s factual and what’s not Nelson Mandela supported Palestine I will leave with that message me if want to know more about this
Give everyone citizenship from the river to the sea. They are all humans deserving dignity.
Would you invite these people whose charter says this to be citizens in Israel?
*"Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it just as it obliterated others before it"* (The Marty, Imam Hassan al Banna, of blessed memory)
*"The Day of Judgement will not come about until the Muslims fight the Jews. When the Jew will hide behind stones and trees, the stones and trees will say, "O Muslims, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him. Only the Gharkad tree, would not do that because it is one of the trees of the Jews,"*
related by al-Bukhari and Muslim
*"Initiatives, and so-called peaceful solutions and international conferences, are in contradiction to the principles of the Islamic Resistance Movement. Abusing any part of Palestine is abuse directed against part of religion. Nationalism of the Islamic Resistance Movement is part of its religion. Its members had been fed on that for the sake of hosting the banner of Allah over their homeland they fight. "Allah will be prominent, but most people do not know,"*
*"There is no solution for the Palestinan question except through Jihad. Initiatives, proposals and international conferences are all a waste of time and gain endeavors. The Palestinan people know better than to consent to having their future, rights and fate toyed with. As in said in the honorable Hadith:*
*"The people of Syria are Allah's lashing His land. He wreaks His vengeance through them against whomsoever He wishes among His slaves It is unthinkable that those who are double-faced among them should prosper over the faithful. They will certainly die out of grief and. desperation."*
*"The day that enemies usurp part of Muslim land, Jihad becomes the individual duty of every Muslim. In face of the Jews' usurpation of Palestine, it is compulsory that the banner of Jihad be raised, To do this requires the diffusion of Islamic consciousness among the masses, both on the regional, Arab and Islamic levels. It is necessary to instill the spirit of Jihad in the heart of the nation so they would confront the enemies and join the ranks of the fighters,"*
*"In their Nazi treatment, the Jews made no exception for women and children. Their policy of striking fear in the heart is meant for all. They attack people where their breadwiinning is concerned, extorting their money and threatening their honor. They deal with people as if they were the worst war criminals. Deportation from the Homeland is a kind of murder.*
*And more! You think I want to live next door to this?*
Israel liberated the land, so build more settlements!
What will they do with the millions of Palestinians in Judea and Samaria?
@@amitkenan3878 Either kick em out or give them citizenship.
This gives a new meaning to being jewish
No, this gives a 1900 year old meaning to being Jewish. For 1900 yrs the Jews were not in control of their land or their destiny for over 1900 years. They were a minority in their ancient land from the crushing of the Bar Kokhba Revolt in 135ce until 1948.
@@dovbarleib3256 jews are a minority because there arent alot of them. that doesnt mean you go form an ethnostate lol
Watched all the videos and its still focused on Israeli being the good guys and completely disregarding the Palestinian as Palestinians and marking them as Jordanians
There is no Palestinians as a nation nowadays.
I love that they just entirely skipped the Balfour Declaration and the influx of millions of European Jews. Let’s just pretend this isn’t obvious settler colonialism
That is the point Golda Meir said "If you call them Palestinians you give them a claim on the land" This is why he has to call them Arabs or Jordanians cause he knows the claim of a Palestinian who lives in the West bank is greater than his. Also, you can tell he is biased cause he uses the term Judea and Samaria this term is solely used by the hard-right even many in the Likud refrain from this cause it basis the Jewish claim to Israel not on history but on the Torah. The issue with this channel is that it actually omits legitimate parts of actual Jewish history in favor of using the Torah as a clutch for the land being a God-given right.
@@hannahr5037
There was no Jordnian nation in the past, no Libyan nation in the past, therefore Jordan and Libya don't deserve to exist
Freedom for Palestine
"palestine" don't exist and never it was, israel has been always israel even from 3000 years ago.
It's all business
If the goal of the 48 war was to "drive the Jews out completely", why did it start in 48? Don't you think it was more political control? about the map and who gets to draw it? Especially since, as you say, Jews had been there for a long long time.
It started in '48 because that is when Israel declared itself an independent, sovereign state. Palestinians laid no claim to the land when it was under Jordanian or Egyptian control, and even in the original 1964 PLO charter, they lay no claim to it. It's only when they lost the territories in a war they started that they claim them
Peace to Eli Cohen !
Can you start from how European Jews can have right to expel indigenous people and make their own state in Middle East to which they have no connection whatsoever? Why not we restore Roman Empire there? ‘Most Jews do not believe in god but believe he promised them land’ Ilan Pappe.
Lmao diaspora Jews are a indigenous to the land as the Jews who remained, bud.
Also Ilan pappe is a fraud and he has been utterly demolished by Benny Morris
Roman Empire, much like the Islamic empires, was an imperialist force. Judea is the homeland of Jews. End of story.
All israeli towns in Judea and samaria are legal.
1922 league of nations mandate cements that. The fact that Brits subsequently went about blatantly violating the core aspects of their own mandate because of their own Jew hatred and to appease Arabs doesnt change this.
Some of the towns were actually re establishment of older communities that got ethnically cleansed by Jordan during the 1948 war.
Who is this channel backed by which billionaire
@@adammiddleton2503 slaves? Ok. Go back to wearing you tin hat
@@adammiddleton2503 They also have a wall and lax abortion laws. Americans should be wary about where our tax dollars go. Republicans pretend to be proponents of the market system, yet hate free trade and love giving billions every year to Israel.
@@dogestranding5047 democrats support Israel as well, every politician on the west is controlled by Israel.
@@SealofApprovalTWU That's cute
My One and Only question is: Where are the Muslims during the First and Second Temple times back then??? Why they tried to claim the Holy Temple Mount now if they were out of existence during the former two temples??? I believed they were not Muslim (Islam) before. Because they were called Philistines before - they descendants of the loser giant Goliath. Shalom Aleichem shalom
Are you serious? I've heard some Israelis actually talk about how they own the land because of events millennia ago. Are you joking?
Because Muslim believe the last fake prophet that was pedo guy and a bloody killer.
Nobody:
Jew: sometimes called judea/sumaria
Because that's the original name
Aside Israeli Arabs, what Arabs have to do with this land? "Al Aqsa" mosque didn't exist at time of Muhammad let alone Islam. Abraham was Jew, Ishmael was Jew, Jacob was Jew, ...
Islamic God is J E W I S H
I like the video, I would like it to speak more slowly as I am not that fluent in english
Usa los subtitulos de español
You can slow down the speed of the video
If i dont steal it someone else gonna steal it.
Beautiful
You are the best💕
The video could have been 10 seconds long. These settlements are illegal under Israeli and international law. Stop trying to justify them. You can’t move populations into occupied territory. This isn’t hard to understand.
1967 should be kept. It would be crucial to Israel's defence. The Sinnai is crucial. They should just keep Sinnai
There is no way Israel could defend themselves with a 9 mile across center of its country. The country would be divided in half. There is the Sea on one side, and an enemy population on the other.
@@shainazion4073 1 state.solution....and Israel should be the only state
@@ericgregorious7047 Halavi!
And how they break international law?
Kyler Which side, you’ll have to be more specific
@Vitaliy Markov ocuppide from whom?
Jordan?
The only real long-term solution for Israel and Palestine is for the Palestinians to have their own state in Gaza and to expand Gaza, both on the Egyptian side and Israeli side and for Israel to grant citizenship to all Arabs living in the West Bank/Judea-Samaria. If Arabs want to leave the West Bank, they should be given a grant, or stipend to afford to move to Gaza, Jordan or Egypt. Israel will NEVER give up Judea-Samaria and they never should as it's part of Israel, regardless of what the U.N. people say.
So we should just ignore international law, and believe some fairytales in the Bible or Quran ???
How a Jewish state is any different from Isis state, both are based on silly religions
The problem with giving non-Israeli Arabs in the West Bank citizenship is that many if not most of them are very anti-Israel, so it would be suicidal to do that. I think giving them a state with a portion of the West Bank connected to Jordan is really the only viable solution.
3 states: Israel, Gaza, Palestine (west bank with land swaps). Settlers whose land isn’t absorbed into Israel can continue to live as a minority in West Bank. Peace deal will require full recognition and citizenship of settlers in new Palestinian state along with continued security cooperation with both Israel and palestianian authorities. Gaza can remain the status quo and hopefully gets absorbed by Egypt. Jerusalem is a unified city and a dual capital of both Israel and West Bank.
Alternative is 2 states: Gaza and Israel, but with demographic shifts eventually Israel could have a minority Jewish population.
Last alternative is status quo, which depending on if you count Gazans teeters on apartheid.
Well that ignores the promise that the British made through TE Lawrence to the Arabs of the creation of an Arab state
The British had no right to give promises. It was not their land. They were only Administrators of the Land for the League of Nations, who issued the Mandate. The Mandate had only one mission, that was to recreate the Jewish homeland in the Area of Palestine. This was voted on unanimously by All world leaders in 1922.
FREE PALESTINE
Witch one?
Grow up
Don't attack Israel unprovoked next time.
the arab palestinians should be grateful everyday until the rest of their life we did not throw them to jordan or to their death as they wanted us (DEAD), be grateful for our compassion towards human life.
Jews should be grateful the Arabs allowed them any safe haven in the first place. They should have just taken Martin Luther’s policy.
@ObiJohnKenobi67 Arabs didn't have any legal authority or right to bar Jews from returning back to their homeland
All of the so called "Palestinians" and Israeli "Arabs" secretly love and admire Israel, the settlements, Judaism and Jews. Everyome knows that. They are just fear of saying it out loud. This is mainly because they are Jews who forced to convert to Islam in the middle ages. I think the best way to end the conflict is a massive conversion to Judaism of the so called "Palestinians" and Israeli "Arabs" 😊❤. Their Muslimness and Arabness is doubted either way. Come back to your roots Jewish brothers! Don't affraid.
Changing the name of Israel to Judea is also needed.
They were not forced that long ago. Watch the video, on Misinai Tzvi's You Tube channel, *"Palestinians of Jewish Origin higher resolution"*
🔥
I love Israel
Absorbed all Palestinians living in Israel, give them the same rights and privileges as Israelis do so that there will be one State of Israel for all living there, with one strong Constitution and By-laws to be followed by every citizen. The UN was wronged when it partitioned Israel into two states: one for Israelis and one for Palestinians. Since Gaza residents are all Gazans, Let them have their own country as State of Gaza. Let there be peace in Israel.
NO, there are 22 Arab Muslim states, many made by the League of Nations at the same time as Israel was started. There is just one Jewish state. When the Byzantines attacked Jews or the Inquisition, there was nowhere safe to go. When rhe Arab Muslim states treated the Jews with Distain and forced them from the lands they lived in for millenia, they needed somewhere to go. Israel is the only Jewish state.
In the beginning, the Jews appealed to the Arabs to stsy in their houses and to help them create a country together, the Arabs from 5 countries plus the Arab irregulars attacked the one day old country of Israel.
They chose to leave, they chose to attack, not just one time but with 5 wars and 2 intafadas. The Jews won the wars, the Arabs have continually fought against them. They want to annihilate Israel and the Jews. Read the Hamas Charter, you will see, more is written on the hate and propaganda for Jews and to destroy Israel, than on how to develop or create an Arab country.
They do have the same rights… just like every other Israeli citizen
@@Wildgrifter
You are misinformed
Israel national law of 2018 states that Israel only recognizes Jewish self determination .
And
A Jew born in Brooklyn has a right to live in Jerusalem while an Arab born in Jerusalem does not have a right to live in Jerusalem while Israel extends PERMISSION to Arabs living there, by can revoke that permission at any time
@@Wyndham21044 wdym? An Israeli Arab has the same rights as an Israeli Jew… if they don’t have an Israeli citizenship, than ofc they won’t have the same rights as an ACTUAL citizen. All Israeli citizens have the same rights, from Israeli Arabs to Israelis Jews.
@@Wildgrifter so please explain how a Jew born in Brooklyn has a right to citizenship when a Arab born in Jerusalem does not have a right to live in Jerusalem?
If you were correct there would not be any Palestinian refugees.
And please not the answer from the Israeli in the comment above
They say Arabs do not have the right to live in a Jewish state.
I love how this video is totally unbiased and doesn’t at all present a one-sided narrative 😂🤣😅
As my friends old Granfather said. I’m a Palestinian Jew. I fought side by side with Palestinian Muslims in the British army Palestinian brigade to fight against hate and ethnic cleansing. He left the new found Israel as he was appalled by the greed and hate from European and American Jews
Judea-Samaria Is Israeli land going back to thousands of years, including Gaza, the West Bank, Golan, East Jerusalem, and above all, the Temple Mount.
No judea and samaria is a small dot on the map in the West Bank. It does not include Gaza or Jerusalem or all of West Bank. Nice try lying. Israle took all the other land in the war.
Did you mean Palestine?
No they didn’t.
@@jsghetler
Ambiguous. Either the parent comment is anti-Israel 'oh you're settling in Palestinian land you thieves?' or is pro-Israel 'oh you mean Palestinians are settling on land which is rightfully Jewish?'
Since I don't know which is which, I don't know which is your stand either. Lol.
1
What is your stand?
2
What do you think the parent commenter meant?
The land is called Israel. Palestine is Jordan and Jordan is Palestine
No mention of the Transfer Agreement? 🤔
The Arabs of Palestine (who only became “Palestinians” in 1968) have a 100-year tradition of rejecting every offer made. Why would they stop now and spoil a perfect record of shooting themselves in the foot?
Here’s a list:
1919: Arabs of Palestine refused to nominate representatives to the Paris Peace Conference.
1920: San Remo conference decisions, rejected by the Arabs of Palestine.
1922: League of Nations decisions, rejected by the Arabs of Palestine.
1937: Peel Commission partition proposal, rejected by the Arabs of Palestine.
1938: Woodhead partition proposal, rejected by the Arabs of Palestine.
1947: UN General Assembly partition proposal (UNGAR 181), rejected by the Arab League and the Higher Arab Committee for Palestine.
1949: Israel's outstretched hand for peace (UNGAR 194), rejected by the Arab League and the Higher Arab committee for Palestine.
1967: Israel's outstretched hand for peace (UNSCR 242), rejected by the Arab League and the PLO.
1978: Begin/Sa’adat peace proposal, rejected by the whole Arab world (besides Egypt), including the PLO.
1994: Rabin/Hussein peace agreement, rejected by the whole Arab League (except for Egypt and Jordan).
1995: Rabin's Contour-for-Peace, rejected by the Palestinian Authority.
2000: Barak/Clinton peace offer, rejected by Yasser Arafat, who then initiated the pre-planned second intifada.
2001: Barak’s offer at Taba, rejected by the Palestinian Authority.
2005: Sharon's peace gesture, withdrawal from Gaza, rejected by the Hamas takeover in 2007.
2008: Olmert/Bush peace offer, rejected by Mahmoud Abbas, head of the Palestinian Authority.
2009 to present: Netanyahu's repeated invitations to peace talks, rejected.
2014: Kerry's Contour-for-Peace, rejected by the Palestinian Authority.
2018: Trump’s “deal of the Century”, rejected in advance by Mahmoud Abbas (unelected head of the Palestinian Authority).
This should just about say it all.
So... are you saying that the Palestinian Authority are unwilling to negotiate peace with the Israelis?
@@kgosimagano8966 yes that is what he is saying.
do they pay you hasbara clowns by the word or do you just copy and paste what they tell you?
@@SidewaysBurnouts We get paid in humus!
@@shainazion4073 not the organs of missing kids?
Why you are so fast and hurry in explaining?
Perhaps you have to go somewhere or do some other work after finishing creating this video.
Please free yourself and do video in calm. 💯💯💯💯💯💯
Danny ayalon has done the best videos of clarifying israeli issues. I give this video a 5 on 10 at best. Not impressed.
Caucasians jews all of khazars origin, other Jews belong to their countries...
Ancient Israel, Judea and Samaria belong to ancestry of Palestinians...
Before Islam many parts of Arabia were Jewish and Christians...
Why are you writing the same comment over again? What are saying is not true! Jews have zero Khzarian DNA. They do however have genetic ties to the Middle East.
ashkenazi jews have no dna ties with khazarians, the ones who actually does we're the turkish people because khazars are turkics.
My favourite part about Israel is that to this day: Its only fanbase - itself.
Which is pretty sad, as they've got a very rational argument.
That's because most of the world is uneducated .
I don't see why people from the west will be against another fellow country with western values .
Israel is the only real democracy in the middle east , a great ally to the west .
Nope..... Indians are huge supporters of Israel..... We support Israel ..... Especially Hindus .... through and through.... even Israel recognised india as it's biggest supporter...
@avipinhasov302 An apartheid state cannot be a democracy, it's one or the other.
כל הסרטונים בערוץ הזה ישראל
It basically goes like this. First their is the occupation in 1967, than Israel declares that they occupy the west bank and gaza for the sake of protecting Israel because those areas are posing danger, the Palestinians begin to fight the two decades of oppression at the early eighties, which prompted the revival of all these militant groups aka hamas. Than israel decides to build settlement in the same region that they claim to be unsafe, and they segregated them completely from Arab towns and villages, than the Palestinians fought back with suicidal attacks etc, which prompted Israel to build a wall completely segregating Palestinians and towns from one another. After building all these settlements, now israel is focused on Driving Palestinians out of their lands and homes, specifically in Jerusalem, aka yakub the thief. While doing all this, militant groups like hamas are getting stronger every couple of years, with rockets now that can target every town in Israel.
How did this war start?
Just ask yakub the settler he’ll tell you all about it. He basically told the Palestinian struggle, so thank you yakub.
You said that hateful comments would be removed. I see a lot of this in the comments below and you should act on your declaration.
It's a delicate balance between what is an actual hate comment and what is just an annoying troll. We leave it up to our discretion, and some comments that were automatically held by TH-cam have not been allowed.
mirskym More censorship please!!!!!
Screw yourself.
Criticism isn't hateful commenting.
this guy is really trying to justify the illegal settlements?
He tried to explain the settlers' views, since you literally never hear the reasons behind why many people created these settlements in the first place.
I hate this channel. They just seem like a Fox News extension.
@@BeeboHamido most of liberal and republicans are Zionist
Subtitulos en español?. Soy de Argentina
Se supone que todos nuestros videos tienen subtítulos en español. Puede acceder a ellos haciendo clic en el engranaje y luego seleccionando su idioma en el menú de subtítulos
@@UNPACKED Es el único video que me da la opción única de subtítulos en ingles.
No lo puedo ver.
Gracias por responder
Deberían hacer un canal en español
It isn't your land... Ashkenazi Jews are not related to the Jews from thousands of years ago
Don’t tell me you’re a believer in this conspiracy theory: th-cam.com/video/cw0G9COpeMY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=jnap_UBIv_GnftJw
@@UNPACKED David Grün
Benjamin Mileikowsky
So you are a believer in conspiracy theories - got it!
DNA testing of the ashkenazi jews proves that they are related from ancient jews that lived from 2000 years ago before their exile to europe.
The claim that an imaginary god has promised you this land is laughable
Nice ad 😏
There are no Israeli settlements because Jerusalem is Jewish and Jewish forever🇮🇱🇮🇱
So many lies, so much bragging. Plain propaganda and no shame.
Can you share any lies? We’re unpacking a complex story, and you might not like all perspectives, but that doesn’t make it a lie
@@UNPACKED Then I would have to see it once more, so no. You can maybe explain why the video skips that more than 500 palestinians were killed by settlers and IDF in 2023?
First can you tell me how many of the Palestinians killed in 2023 were terrorists/militants?
@@UNPACKED You tell me. A 13 years old trowing a stone, is he a terrorist?
Actually yes - would you prefer attempted murderer?
First
Who israel?,country?,lol.
@Adnan Rasheed lol.
@Adnan Rasheed
You forgot greedy too.
Your mom.
@@BOG0690 Every Countries is Greedy silly.
@Adnan Rasheed oh you’re talking about Palestine!
Video failed to talk about the nabka, the Palestinian refugees 1948
I love and support Israel ❤️! 🇮🇱🇺🇲🇮🇱🇺🇲🇮🇱🇺🇲!!!
🖕🏻
Jeffrey Culpepper Do not speak for us Americans with a CONSCIENCE who stand against apartheid and Israeli occupation. 🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸🇵🇸🇺🇸💕🕊
Jeffrey Culpepper NOPE. This American supports PALESTINE 🇵🇸 and the human right for a person to live on the land they were born to. NOT IN AN OPEN AIR PRISON. You support apartheid.
So I’m the only one here who supports a two state solution 😅
💕 🇺🇸 🤝 🇮🇱 💕
Title: What are Israeli settlements?
The Israeli Government: T A R G E T
P R A C T I C E
The Soviet Union convinced Nasser that Israel had massed troops on the border. The 1967 war was hardly defensive. Nasser was weakened due to his meddling in Yemen. The fact he had a big mouth did not help matters
The war was 100% defensive, the Egyptian closing the straits of Tiran to Israel was an act of war.
Shame on you for excusing unlawful settlements of Palestinian land!
Palestine isn’t even a country that you can steal land from
Grow up
Newsflash: Israel took those territories in unprovoked defensive wars. It's given many back for the sake of peace, and now gets regular rockets fired from there onto the Israeli civilian population.
How long will you continue lying?
Straight propaganda.
find a more convincing argument than just two words.