Why Did Israel Build a Wall Around the West Bank?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2024
- [Note: This video was created before the horrific attack by Hamas on the people of southern Israel and the outbreak of the October 2023 war.]
The separation barrier that divides the West Bank from western Israel, often referred to as the Apartheid Wall, is the source of much debate in both Israeli and Palestinian societies. For some, it serves to protect Israeli citizens. For others, it enforces an unequal system of oppression of Palestinians. And while for many it is simply a visual reminder of the continued failure of the peace process, Israel remains a land of hope.
Chapters:
00:00 Intro
00:38 Description of separation barrier
01:06 Palestinian's personal testimony
01:30 The peace process
02:21 Opposition to the Oslo Accords
04:12 Rabin assassination
04:31 The Second Intifada
05:59 Operation Defensive Shield
06:17 Plans for a barrier wall
07:08 Did the wall make Israelis safer?
07:32 Differing viewpoints of the effectiveness of the security barrier
08:27 Is the separation barrier really a land grab?
09:08 Land gained from the 1967 War
10:23 Jewish return to Judea and Samaria
10:35 Palestinian links to the West Bank
11:41 The separation wall limits Palestinian freedom of movement
12:54 The separation wall does not prevent all terrorist attacks
13:11 Rabbi Yehuda HaKohen offers a vision of hope
Special thanks to Rabbi Yehuda HaKohen of the Vision Movement visionmag.org/author/yehuda-hakohen, visionmovement.org
Subscribe and turn on your notifications so you don’t miss future uploads!
th-cam.com/users/UNPACKED?sub_...
Recommended video-Hamas-Israel War Has Changed Everything
• Hamas-Israel War Has C...
We have merch! - shop.jewishunpacked.com/?...
Let’s connect:
Website - www.jewishunpacked.com
Instagram - / jewishunpacked
Twitter - / jewishunpacked
TikTok - / jewishunpacked
Facebook - / jewishunpacked
-----------
Image and footage credits:
Pond 5
StoryBlocks
ArtGrid
Al Jazeera
AJ+
Washington post
Justin Mcintosh
Daniel Rosehill
Wisam Hashlamoun/Flash90
Ahmad Al-Bazz/GroundTruth
AP, Oded Balilty
TRT World
Associated Press
EuroNews
Highlight Films Israel
France 24
Frontline PBS
Journeyman.tv
Hadashot 2
Ebrahim Noroozi/AP
palwatch.org
Pieter du Toit
David Silverman/Getty
Israel Defense Force
The Washington Institute
ActiveStills
Voice of America
International Court of Justice
AP Photo/Peter Dejong
SA’AR YA’ACOV/GPO
Yosef Tamir Image Collection
Wikicommons
Getty Images
CBN News
ILTV
BBC
Netflix
Haaretz
ABC News
CBS
I24
AFP
Defense Ministry
-----------
Executive Producer:
- Barry Skolnick
Co-Executive Producer:
- Shmuel Katz
-----------
Translation credits:
Portuguese: Saymon Pires, www.livrariasafra.com.br, @safralivraria
About Explainers: From ancient Jewish traditions to the modern State of Israel, we explain it all. Diving into anything and everything related to Jewish culture, history, and even religion.
Understand Jewish holidays, Israeli politics, Jewish diasporic communities, and more. Learn about Judaism in pop culture, debunking myths about Jews, and explore obscure Israeli landmarks. We’re asking questions as basic as “What is the Talmud?”, and as obscure as “How did hip-hop boost Kosher wine sales?”, and everything in between.
About Unpacked: We provide nuanced insights by unpacking all things Jewish. People are complex and complicated - yet we’re constantly being pushed to oversimplify our world. At Unpacked we know that being complex makes us more interesting. Because of this, we break the world down with nuance and insight to drive your curiosity and challenge your thinking.
#israel #peace #war
I remember bombings before the Wall. It has become a necessity. When a non Bibi government happens, Palestine can not be negotiated (there is no partner) but imposed as has been the case with many conflicts.
Neither Jew or Arab will get all they want but this is true with all conflicts. Religion is what makes conflict so explosive. This and poor Palestinian leadership saying no Jew can remain in a Palestinian state which 20% of Israel is Arab. A partner for peace can not demand double standards
NON BIBI? I love Bibi
I think the question has already been answered. Why run in a circle in the conclusion? The wall reduced suicide bombing deaths and the Palestinian leader admitted that it was an obstacle to their actions. It is there for the security
They are many elementary schoolers here, they need an answer....
He is right though - there are huge regions where there is no wall and yet the terrorist attack scale was dramatically reduced.
I think that the main reason there is less terrorist attack is thanks to the cooperation of Palestinian authority that is slowly able to stop terrorist groups and foreign intervention. In the same time more money was focused to aid Hamas in Gaza as it is more convenient to support a terror group that owns the land and controls 2 million of citizens. :(
Why do suicide operations happen?
Why does the Palestinian embarrass himself?
Are you stupid?
This is apartheid and occupation
The resistance and operations will not end no matter how hard Israel tries
The cause ends with the disappearance of its cause
Injustice and apartheid end, and Israel withdraws from the occupied Palestinian territories
Then the resistance will end
Oh my God, how can some people live with their acceptance of injustice and lying to people?
The solution is very easy, but Israel only wants to kill and steal more land
Hold the Israeli officials who committed war crimes against innocent people and children accountable, and the story ends
The story will not end with a wall
Mind Begs the Question:
If Nazis escaped
Camouflage into another Nation,Religion
Rename their Political Movement
Can't be recognized
Can be recognized by Mirroring Policies
Subhuman,Camps,Raids,Ethnic Cleansing..?
Simple, sensible answer!
Because Arafat never really wanted peace...600 millions in his Swiss Bank account wasn't enough...
When your enemy lives next to you, what would you do ????
Cannot live with 😈 belivers butchers,murders, refugees, full of wanderlust, jealousy hate greedy for beautful eomenCriminals, infidelity,rapist,
Can't live with suicide bombers,refugees, murders
Can't live with refugees 😮😅. Criminal
When the thief comes to your home, what do you do?
@@ob9807 the Thief are the Arabs who occupied the holly land
That wall is necessary until Hamas ceases to exist.
The wall around Gaza, but the wall around the Arab occupied parts of Judah and Shomron will stay up until the world stops forcing Israel to "make peace" with the genocidal invaders, and removes the Arab colonizers.
Israel is directly responsible for the creation of Hamas. Hamas was once a peaceful social organization, but decades of Israeli oppression and escalation turned it into a military organization. Go brush up on some history, it doesn't take long.
The West Bank is not controlled by Hamas.
and Hesbollah and on and on. the wall is crucial to the security of Israel
The separation wall is on the West Bank through Jerusalem, not Gaza...
I'm impressed by how balanced this video is, and to see Palestinian voices on the channel. You did a good job on this one. Keep making more.
Well , I think this is exactly why this video is more of a Hollywood-like production trying to find a happy ending rather then facing the true facts of the story.
what a joke😅
Article Seven of the Charter concludes with a quotation from a hadith:
The Day of Judgment will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say, 'O Muslim, O servant of God, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.' Only the Gharkad tree would not do that, because it is one of the trees of the Jews.
Not that balanced. He's calling Palestinians resistance as terror acts.
@SHLOMIYAN the grand mufti of Palestine before it became Israel reminds me of Benjamin natanyahu you see today
Here's another aching question that I don't see explored a lot......why do all of the surrounding Muslim states refuse to accept the Palestinians as citizens? Why is it squarely on the shoulders of Israel to make a space for them? And I'd be interested to hear from the less radical Palestinians why Muslims get to have all these states while Israel is expected to have no state at all?
Part of it is that a lot of the surrounding countries don’t really have the resources necessary to take in the entire palestinian population. The other part is that a lot of those countries believe that it’s Palestinian land, and don’t think it should be Israel’s. Not to mention many Middle Eastern countries have been politically and economically destabilized due to Western intervention and military occupation, so there’s an inherent distrust for the Western countries that Israel is allied to. It’s on the shoulders of Israel because when the British gave away land to the Zionists, they gave away land that had people living on it. The Palestinians didn’t want to leave as they have historical and familial ties to the area, and neither did the Israelis, meaning that they’d have to figure out how to share it. And the reason why there’s so many more Muslim states is because when the Ottoman Empire fell, there were still people living in the areas that used to be under Ottoman control. Those people were primarily Muslim. The Arabs initially wanted one United Arab state, but the British and French had already made secret plans to divide it into several countries. While there were still some Jewish people still in the Middle East, they were an incredibly small minority of the population prior to the kickoff of Zionism. So the British didn’t have a large number to go off of when making a deal for how much land they got, not to mention there were obvious concerns for how the Arabs already living there would react to having their land effectively given away.
Why is it upto other Islamic states to take in refugees just because they belong to the same faith? That's just ridiculous. The Palestinians have an ancient, centuries old claim over parts of the region.
Why should Palestinians be displaced and ethnically cleansed to begin with?
It’s like if I forcefully kick you out of your own house and say: “Here's another aching question that I don't see explored a lot.....why won’t your neighbor accept you as a resident in their house?”
@@kpoptrash6849 Sorry, this is not very politically correct, but it needs to be said... If the surrounding arab countries have done so poorly at having resources, being peaceful, and securing human rights, why would we want yet another country like that. At least Israel has been a productive democracy that ensures its citizens have opportunities and civil rights. That alone makes me want to side with Israel
@@kpoptrash6849 That's a lie. First off,m the surrounding Arab states threw out even more Jews than there were Arabs who left israel in 1947. Each & every family could have had the homes those Jews were forced to leave behind. Secondly, in 1956, the Arab league signed a pledge to never take in the refugees, specifically to be a thorn in Israel's side.
5:07: "Trauma can play a pretty significant role in political decisions." Unfortunately, trauma plays a massive role in these wars.
All and because some are thinking atheist against religion means wanted sovereignty by the so called jealous. Chess is a number game so is funds and wars
The court not voting on the plot as they chose, when was that? The law, not the votes are determining the reason. Yes the United nations was to meet for other circumstances. Africa came in then too with nothing about it but want. Look better in the point. In the multi ways reports say documents brought agreement not via honesty and because those living there were taken out ..they want Jews to have no land. They have natives saying how indigent they are while they get paid but not full privy.
Geez, I can't be the only one that remembers all the bus bombings and other acts of terrorism .... That wall has made a HUGE difference.
Unfortunately since the wall has decreased terrorism so much, few westerners are now aware why it was built, and think it is to maintain an apartheid.
You're not the only one - and how quickly the self-righteous wokesters marching in the West forget.
You aren’t the only one. Media has changed 20 years later. Most media reporters and anchors were in college during all the acts of terrorism.
I'm continuously trying to educate myself about the historical facts and the religious influences that constantly come as the root cause of why the peace process never gets further. Thanks for this unbiased video. One of the balanced ones out here in TH-cam.
It seems to me the parties of god are part of the problem.
Religion is definitely crazy 😧
Watch Occupation 101: voices of the silent majority.
no religious influence justifies IDF soldiers' constant harassment of palestinians
Mind Begs the Question:
If God exiles a people from a land
For their Transgressions,Evil
To reestablish State with Messiah
If reestablish State before Messiah
Following Scripture or Violating Scripture?
The wall was built as a way to stop suicide bombers at a time when buses and cafes (mostly cafes) were being bombed in what was called the "second entifadeh." The argument for it was the wall surrounding Gaza. All traffic had to go through check points that could be monitored. So the Arabs then used rockets to attack Israel (including form Judea and Samaria). Its an eyesore yes, but its made to keep people alive. People can still travel through to get to work. Its unfortunate that the Arabs did not take advantage of the opportunity of Oslo to make peace a possibility. Yes, the failure of the peace process falls on the Arabs. Israel gave up land for peace, they ignored Arab terror throughout the 1990's. It was the Arabs that opened the second entifadeh in 2000, and it was the Arab violence that killed the peace process entirely.
This is plain BS;
- Ariel Sharon and Netanyahu were both against the Oslo Accords and they worked together with Hamas to ensure it is never implemented.
-The Wall helped reduce terrorism but it was applied with other measures including creating the P.A security forces and a peace agreement between Israel and the PLO
- Why should Arabs go through walls and check-points in their own country, maybe if their country wasn't occupied Israel would have nothing to fear.
- There have been no rocket attacks from the West Bank those are just lies you concocted.
- Ariel Sharon began the Second Intifada with his visit to the Al Aqsa mosque.
The Israeli leadership and Hamas are the primary parties responsible for the failure of Oslo.
Progressively defending bantustand style apartheid walls 😘🤪
AS Hamas video shows the Gaza Wall didn't really exist, it was just a tall fence that a front end loader took apart in minutes! A double line of cheap Hesco Bastions with anti-climb mesh would have been potentially cheaper & much more effective!
Arafat did reject the Accords shortly after they were signed due to Israel's refusal to follow through on them. In the end the PA was established & money/arms flowed to them(& the PA has received protection from the Shin Bet & IDF)!
Since then the tenants of the accords with regards to land in the West Bank have been ignored by the Israeli Right Wing Governments. They may have reserved the announcements of new settlements till after one terrorist attack or another & especially big developments after big terrorists attacks but they ignored them!
He forgot to mention that because of the wall and special roads only Israelis can use, they can drive around the West Bank without having to drive thru or see Palestinian towns.
Most bypass roads the Arabs in Judea and Samaria use along with Israelis. They make the path longer but the Israelis can avoid from enter ing Palesitinian Authority controlled cities (which would risk their lives.) The separation wall was to make it harder for suicide bombers to endure Israel. The roads are open. @@MrChopsticktech
100 % the wall made life in Israel safer. We had a tremendous reduction in severe Terror attacks.
Then the point is to live in a cage forever... I think it's not right. And what you say is partially correct: because it has decreased the number of casualties in Cisjordany but had increase the feeling to be oppressed and so on. Ant this is the soil of the terror, sadly.
youre an animal. I've lost any minor hope for Israelis. I dont care about you guys at all anymore. Let it rain
Notso - the Palestinians have been bad neighbors. Arafat was offered 97% of what he demanded and turned it down.
After Gazans elected hamas knowing they had blood on their hands and wanting more. After Israel was tired of terrorist attacks, they erected the fence.
From your post, I'm guessing you've never been to Israel. The West Bank is beautiful, and you can see a lot of land. However, how Areas A and B are used or not used, where people live, and what they can do is up to the PA, not Israel.
Jordan has border fences by the West Bank, and Egypt has by Gaza. Are you including theirs as well as Israel's?
@@drdonna4915 No one wants Arabs in Gaza or West Bank. Not even Jordanians or Egyptians. Jordanians have first hand experience from importing too many palestinian refugees. Not a good result.
Penjajah iblis
I believe this question was answered on Oct. 7.
An absolute nightmare ! At any moment your life could end. Hopefully , peace will one day rise and a solution will be found. God Bless
Thanks, appreciate the balanced discussion of both Israeli and Palestinian perspectives.
Article Seven of the Charter concludes with a quotation from a hadith:
The Day of Judgment will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say, 'O Muslim, O servant of God, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.' Only the Gharkad tree would not do that, because it is one of the trees of the Jews.
@OmEvul1415 I agreed with his comment that the video was unbiased, then I read your comment about a hateful god. I’m beginning to see clearer why Final Judgement is eminent. There doesn’t seem to be no other way.
Anti terror barrier seems like a good term . Blaming a wall for an entire country’s failings is dumb . Palestine has beachfront property and decent weather why can they take advantage of this and make something of themselves as opposed to just letting terrorists rule them and live in squalor I think they need to grow a pair of balls and start weeding out the problem from within instead of blaming other people for their problems.
OMG, THIS!!!!!
Yeah, ignore the occupation displacement and genocide and just pull yourself by your bootstraps bucko, great logic.
How tf you want gaza to use their beachfront property when it is under active blockade?
I agree ab….they have prime real estate and they trash it😂😂😂
They have much money for Rockets, Bombs, Drones and Millions for Tunnels. If they focus on Education, Creative Skills and Development of self esteem and Infrastructure, with a Population of 2million. Who's accountable for that. Hamas is Rich and the Population is Poor, how many Leaders of Hamas lives in Gaza.⌛💵🎲🚑.
Because they kept on sourgraping and grow violent on their beliefs and actions for generations. Any other excuse/s?
When you have a bloodthirsty hate filled enemy you do what you have to do.
U mine the border for one thing , thats a basic start
Since they are squatting on land they stole, in 1948, through ethnic cleansing, the smart thing would have been drive them back to Jordan. That is what should have happened in 1967.
@@deborahfreedman333 arabs stole the land you silly american
@@deborahfreedman333Israel is here to stay, they got the land from the people that defeated Palestinians, like how all landowners/ occupants got them today... they were willing to coexist but thanks to the long and continued violence, almost all Jewish people stopped seeing them as humans...
What did Israel do to make them bloodthirsty
Maybe if Palestinians had accepted a compromise the multiple times it was offered to the instead of saying everything is theirs they would not be in this situation. But it seems they do not learn.
My guy, it was Israelis who kicked the Palestinians out. No the other way around you clown.
@@orbitalpotato9940 wrong
@@Daisy-ue9vk history says im right
@@Daisy-ue9vk What, because some rando on TH-cam says so? Read some actual history for once.
They wasn't in those meetings
This is probably the most unbiased jewish channel I've ever seen
LoL
They actually liked they comment😂 was this not sarcasm?
Its true mvther fvcker...dis is the used of the barrier....all the palestinian its reslly blijd to their leader...if ur leader loves u all hamas......dey will not allowin u all to died and sacrifices ur life...wers ur leader now?enjoyin his life corrupting all the money instead to give to the people to have good life...ur leader lives like a king...with good food,house and cars...wat the bout the palestinian people wer dey r?still starving....no wrk no progress...
Lol
@@royghosn18 Just shows the amount of common sense the dude posting these has 😂
Thanks to this wall, the 7th October hamas nazi massacre was not able to happen from the west bank
The timing of this couldn’t have been better
For the propganda. 😂
11:20 mark: "Not a single Israeli [read: Jew] will be allowed to live in a Palestinian state." That, right there, is apartheid.
Zionist propaganda
You must be kidding to resume all the matter with this.
Israelis are the ones not allowing non jews in Israel
Rightwing Israeli are no better. And they are making it happen on the West Bank either by (violently) taking land or bogus "legal" means.
keep lying
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼excellent video! As a jew, I share your views. Respect and compromise should be part of their negotiations.
Shalom to all and I hope a solution will come after this storm(conflict)….🌈☀️🇮🇱 🇵🇸
You agree that you invaded them and opressed them in they're own country?
@justsaying9659 i was never their country, look at yourself at the mirror and tell yourself you actually studied history, if you had, it would've taken you days.
@@justsaying9659😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂keep crying as their was never a Palestinian state before 1948.
Who was the leader of Palestine , what demonation of money did they have , their flag is the Jordan flag , Jordan controlled Jerusalem until yom kuppor war of 1967 and Egypt controlled Gaza.
@@ColinReardon-vi7um Crying? I'm good..Your head is full of bullshit..... life ur f... life and let other live their life..
@@justsaying9659they were not invaded just read the Quran and other credible sources and you'll understand don't be so shallow all those three religions lived in peace actually it was Mohammed who massacred the Jews in their own land
Definately security barrier. Just imagine what would have happened without it. They are all complicit, no excuses. One should stand up and take responsibility sometimes.
Baby it's there Land
They have the right to fhight for iT and they will Get iT back
Dont cry about it when they do and then die in the process. You can be both a fascist and a complete Loser..@@oussamabekk1108
Name a Palestinian leader before 1920? ill wait @@oussamabekk1108
@oussamabekk1108 good luck with that.
@@rmirandauk 👆🤓
I blame the problem on extremists on both sides. People use history to justify taking others land, and people use past injustice to justify direct attack on the innocent. I think a wall can only be a temporary solution. The two people has to learn to accept each other.
Israel never took land forcefully until they acquired land as a result of a Defensive War.
Also consider that more than half of "Palestinians" are foreign Egyptians.
I blame the side that has spent 75 years building and maintaining an oppressive ethnostate.
there are nutcases and peace mongers on both sides. most people just seem to get swept up in the times.
Article Seven of the Charter concludes with a quotation from a hadith:
The Day of Judgment will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say, 'O Muslim, O servant of God, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.' Only the Gharkad tree would not do that, because it is one of the trees of the Jews.
How can you take a land from someone when it wasn't theirs to begin with?
Jews and arabs were both present on "the state of palestine" even jews were called palestines.
Just stop with the false nartive "it was our land"
It was a state, not a country.
And jews were present on the lands way before the arabs so they might as well say "they stole our land" according to your argument right?
Balanced and informative. Thank you 🫶
Thanks for making this. Very helpful for context.
Now that there are millions of Muslims in Western countries marching in the streets to support Hamas, you can call on them to go to Palestine and support the Palestinians.
When people hate walls are needed. No hate no wall.
Need to ask how the hate was created in the first place.
@@mymal2002 Yes, it was created by Mohammed, who used religion as a cover for global conquest.
All over North Africa, they speak Arabic instead of their own native languages.
@@mymal2002Muhammad hate other religions??
@@georgemetesky5519just like Jesus and Abraham before him. We should put all Christians and Jews behind bars too then?
@@TirabintaToktik-hz1lx Yes, first he copied it and then started wars against others. Read Hadith, read Qur'an.
Thanks for not picking sides....everybody suffers in this conflict. Jews and Palestinians have the right to the Land of their forefathers...I really DO hope that one day, two states can share the land and respect each other...or two nations, sharing the same country. Greetings from a Chilean, descendant of Crypto-Sephardim
There are two states its called Israel and Jordan
The first problem I have with your comment is the "jews and palestinians" as if Palestinians cannot be Jewish. This isn't a religious problem. It's an oppressive apartheid state versus indigenous people
Palestinian lol. Its ottomans. The real palestinian are greek
@@Amila-ym7nyindegenous my ass
@@Amila-ym7nythe romans empire are fighting the indigenous of judea, and its not arabs. Learn from history its indigenous are jews.
Walls in your homes are also apartheid not security!
I mean they do withdraw from Gaza in 2006 and it became a terrorist haven so there's that
According to B'tselem's calculations (2021), some 2,171 Palestinian children have been killed in the last two decades by Israeli military actions
Sshhhh don't confuse them with facts and common sense!
As if this would solve the problem. And it's not like they just withdrew and did nothing else
It doesn’t matter where your relatives are from… I can’t just go claim land in Spain because my family is from there ! 🤯
Youre right, but thats not what happened in this situation. There have been jews on that land since the beginning of recorded history. The returning jews didnt steal land. They bought land. And built up the land. Which caused arabs from other countries to relocate there, as well, seeking better living conditions. The jews have no problem living side by side woth people of different ethnicities and religions. The same cannot be said for jihadists who continupusly attacked jews. This caused a civil war. Arab leaders advised their people to get out and wait for the jews to be annihilated, and then return. Some arabs left, some didnt. The jews won the war. A democratic govt was established. The arabs refused a dual state and every other attempt at peace. One cannot make peace unless both parties are seeking peace. This is not only the effect of a civilnwar which they started, but the effect of a death cult, which is what their ideaological system is, a death cult nothing more nothing less.
If your family had land there you possibly could
Not true terrorist organizations Haganah, Lehi and Irgun had been smuggling weapons into Palestine since the 20’s they had planed to establish the state of Israel and get rid of the Arabs that’s why they were ready and equipt to fight in 1948. The people that came bare feet all of a sudden were equipt. C’mon
In 1948 after Israel declared independence (end of british rule), Jordan army crossed the Jordan river into Judea & Samaria (known as the west bank by MSM) and east Jerusalem. The Jordan army killed or drove away the Jewish people. The Jordan army then destroyed Jewish property or took it over. Jordan then encouraged Jordanian settlement in the occupied land. Jewish property not destroyed became occupied by Jordanians. After the Israeli victory in 1967 and Jordanian disillusionment with their expansion effort (1988), Jordan revoked the Jordanian citizenship of "palestinians" in Judea & Samaria (known as the west bank by MSM) and east Jerusalem. For the most part "palestinians" are leftover Jordanian colonist (Gaza residents more closely tied to Egypt). The homeland of the majority of "palestinians" is Jordan.
Youre right. But Spain is an actual country. Palestine could have been, at least 7 times but refused.
Before the wall there were around 15 attempted terror attacks per day. The wall reduced the number.
That one side of the fence is successful and the other not is due to leadership. The Palestinians could have economic development but didn't want it; they would lose their power.
Sure thing buddy.
And the 11,000 attacks on Palestine by Israel?
P@lestinians have 2 favourite occupations - attacking innocent Israelis (ie terrorist attacks) and being crybabies when they receive retaliation. Are they honestly that dumb that they didn't think there'd be consequences for their barbarity?
Jup the answer to the question "it is good" depends on who you ask.
100% true. The leadership matters for the progress of the society along with education and civility!!!
It’s interesting. In Israel, there are loads of Arabs living happy lives, and yet in Palestinian areas they say not a single Jew will be allowed under their rule. It’s a very clear indicator of just where the intolerance lies. It’s all about religion. And it’s really sad tbh.
Not single j.. allowed under their rule? Common who would want to cross 700 military checkpoints in the west bank when they can easily take their home.
To anyone who says that we don't need this fence.. now you know that without a fence - 1300 dead and hundreds more injured and kidnapped 😭 I live in Israel and this fence is a matter of life and death
The fence was overcome. Understood?
@@user-vo3dn8fi9d The watchtowers with automatic submachine guns as well as the cameras along the wall were checkmated by drone drops. The wall was also torn down in almost 30 places. Even a few more sensors won't help.
Netanyahu is as corrupt as Zelensky. Both are leading their countries into the abyss.
@@user-vo3dn8fi9dyou need drop your supremacy and stop oppressing these people....how about that.
Just add minefields, it'll be nice and dandy.@@switch12345678
@@switch12345678 imagine if there was no fence. then it will be happening on a daily basis
Great video. The explanations were very understandable and clear.
Great to hear!
U need to ask the very question to people who do build fences surrounding their houses
Thank you very much for this insightful and factual video in a time of vile misinformation propaganda, you can always rely on unpacked for the facts 🇮🇱🇬🇧
🇮🇱❤️🙏
Article Seven of the Charter concludes with a quotation from a hadith:
The Day of Judgment will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say, 'O Muslim, O servant of God, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.' Only the Gharkad tree would not do that, because it is one of the trees of the Jews.
@@OmEvul1415what a hateful holy book their religion is based upon.
@@OmEvul1415this can only happen in your dreams 😂
America woke up stop genocide in Gaza
@that_semite This isn't your best video by any means. There are some glaring omissions. Such as Jews literally couldn't safely live anywhere else in the world - between expulsions, pogroms, Holocaust, literally no where to go - hence the necessity to RE-establish Israel. It doesn't mention that Jews have had a *continued* presence in Israel for thousands of years, well before the advent of Islam. It failed to mention that even inside of Israel, which colonizers had renamed Palestine, Jews weren't safe. They were regularly massacred by Christians and Muslims. It wasn't all fun and peace until 1948 after the War of Independence. You didn't mention that the Brits brought in and encouraged mass Arab immigration to British Mandate Palestine and that they can get citizenship within 2 years. They are colonizers. The Arabs don't like that it takes 2 hours to make a 30 minute trip? Oh well, tell your brothers not to knife people or blow them up. Why do you feel sorry for them? They had the ability to make it better. They have billions in aide to make it better. They choose not to. And all they had to do was live in peace. Literally that's it. You didn't mention that Jews STILL can't travel to parts of their own country and visit holy sites in Judea & Samarea. Or that Jews there are still daily targets. Or that Palestinians still make land grabs via agriculture. Or that they can't sell to Jews without being killed.
> In the early 1980s, US President Ronald Reagan decided to allow refugees of the Soviet regime to immigrate to the United States, an offer greeted with overwhelming demand. In response, the Israeli government exerted pressure to have the gates of immigration to the United States blocked by all possible means. Because the immigrants continued to insist on the United States, and not the Middle East, as their preferred destination, Israel collaborated with Romanian ruler Nicolae Ceauşescu to limit their ability to choose. In return for payoffs to Ceauşescu’s Securitate and the corrupt Communist regime in Hungary, more than one million Soviet immigrants were routed to their “national state,” a destination they had not chosen and in which they did not want to live.
It is true. Just look the Ramala massacre of 2000 and you will see why Jews have to stay far from the west bank
Can you make one about gaza's electricity and water palestinains lie about it. Israel doesn't need to support nazis
😂😂
You're brainwashed. Keep watching FOX NEWS.
Thank you for such a balanced video. I find in it a source for hope too.
Yes it is balanced Israeli propaganda. Wait no it isn’t.
Balanced that is.
An excellent and I could add necessary program. I follow Unpacked for some years we need a bit of reflection. Thanks 🙏.
The Quran actually never mentions Jerusalem once. The Arabs basically just valued it because the jews did and they were In Competition with the jews
Quran mentioned palastine and Jerusalem masjid al aqsa
not Jews, Westerners and Europeans. Sephardi are the only indigenous Jews outside of African Falasha.
@fakaaaM97 taqqiyah. I see that you are following the commandment of lying. Allah started clearly in the Qu'ran that He made the Jews inherit the holy land, and it states the Jews will return to it in the future. But of course, you lie as usual and deny the words of Allah. That's haram and you will burn in hell for it. Why do you spit on Allah's word and on the Prophet Muhammed's (blessings be upon him) face?
@@Applecider-Poetry not true. but some people like to think so
how are Ashkananzi indiginous to the Middle East? hmmmm??? @@bitiaaflalo9829
Video obviously made before October 7th
It depends on which authority you consult. I feel sorry for the Palestinians having to go through checkpoints, but I can understand why Israel has the wall and the checkpoints.
So do Jewish immigrants deserve to be killed?
Why do you feel sorry for the Falestinians? They live on stolen land, and find gainful employment from the people they stole the land from.
Agreed it literally made a difference. Besides, Palestinians do not comprehend the purpose of the Wall, and most even supports the death of Israel...
The only problem with the walls and the checkpoints is that they are built on Arab lands. If you really want to be safe you could stay within your own borders.
@@michaelotieno6524 So, should the European Khazar immigrants return to their lands in Russia, Ukraine, and Belarus, or should the Rothschild family in Britain prevent this?
as the song said, why can't we be friends?
Praying for peace in Israel and within Gaza.
I think we just found out why Israel built this wall!
I appreciate that this video is not trying to paint one side as the villain. But I think it is worth mentioning why the peace talks have broken down.
"Arafat did not negotiate in good faith; indeed, he did not negotiate at all. He just kept saying no to every offer, never making any counterproposals of his own... I killed myself to give the Palestinians a state. I had a deal they turned down that would have given them all of Gaza,” -- Bill Clinton
It is crazy when you dig a bit and learn about the whole situation... I am very concerned about future perspectives in the region, as many ppl I assume.
So much has been put out of the equation in the US-Israël relations, so much suspicion and animosity, such incapacity of working together during the crucial post Oslo treaty period...
I mean... it is a litteral geopolitic hell of a mess now more than ever, and litteraly EVERYONE in power there from every side seem to contribute to chaos rising in the region. And have been doing so for decades now.
No surprise hell is letting loose today 😔
❤
You gotta dig further then if you believe this , you gotta read what Oslo entails: it gives nothing to the Palestinians, none , 0 , in fact it just recognizes Israel and that's it. Also you gotta read about the first and the second intifada,
Your lack of what is and has been going on all over that region for as long as you have been alive tells me you may want to spend a little time looking into not just Israel, but every other country in the middle east. Hint: Start with Ottoman Empire and see where it went from there. Forever war is pretty imminent all over that section of the world sadly.
This is biased. You haven't talk about the massacre of the Palestinians who lived all throughout the whole of Palestine/Israel where 15,000 men, women and children some with grenades throw into their homes and some lined up and shot, plus the forcible removal of 750,000 Palestinians that were living in now Jewish cities. The population was 1.2M Palestinians with 600,000 Jewish given arms by the british and the power over them. It may be your Ancestral home but what was done to the Palestinians was pretty evil.
Ur the invader 😂😂😂
Sahih Muslim 1767 a
It has been narrated by 'Umar b. al-Khattib that he heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say:
I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula and will not leave any but Muslim.
وَحَدَّثَنِي زُهَيْرُ بْنُ حَرْبٍ، حَدَّثَنَا الضَّحَّاكُ بْنُ مَخْلَدٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ جُرَيْجٍ، ح وَحَدَّثَنِي مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ رَافِعٍ، - وَاللَّفْظُ لَهُ - حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ الرَّزَّاقِ، أَخْبَرَنَا ابْنُ جُرَيْجٍ، أَخْبَرَنِي أَبُو الزُّبَيْرِ، أَنَّهُ سَمِعَ جَابِرَ بْنَ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ، يَقُولُ أَخْبَرَنِي عُمَرُ بْنُ الْخَطَّابِ، أَنَّهُ سَمِعَ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم يَقُولُ " لأُخْرِجَنَّ الْيَهُودَ وَالنَّصَارَى مِنْ جَزِيرَةِ الْعَرَبِ حَتَّى لاَ أَدَعَ إِلاَّ مُسْلِمًا " .
You have no proof that any of that ever happened. 😂 Because it didn't.
@@waitandsee9345 I haven't invaded anyone, I immigrated to Australia as a child and I'm nowhere near your region nor am I a Jew or Muslim, so stop your hatred.
@@dexterplameras3249 islam invaded until andalusia 🙃
I'm indonesian and i know how islam is spread here🙃
@@waitandsee9345common don't even spread this about umar RA
It means Historians are lying.he was the one who allowed j.. to enter Jerusalem after Roman expelled them.
Because according sharia Judaism is one of the legitimate religion and it must be protected.
From what I can see it has killed zero people but saved many
And what about the Israeli soldiers? How many have they killed?
@@Link-ym3hm what do you mean the border wall has killed zero soldiers
@@Link-ym3hmask that to arab false prophet
Sahih Muslim 1767 a
It has been narrated by 'Umar b. al-Khattib that he heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say:
I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula and will not leave any but Muslim.
وَحَدَّثَنِي زُهَيْرُ بْنُ حَرْبٍ، حَدَّثَنَا الضَّحَّاكُ بْنُ مَخْلَدٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ جُرَيْجٍ، ح وَحَدَّثَنِي مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ رَافِعٍ، - وَاللَّفْظُ لَهُ - حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ الرَّزَّاقِ، أَخْبَرَنَا ابْنُ جُرَيْجٍ، أَخْبَرَنِي أَبُو الزُّبَيْرِ، أَنَّهُ سَمِعَ جَابِرَ بْنَ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ، يَقُولُ أَخْبَرَنِي عُمَرُ بْنُ الْخَطَّابِ، أَنَّهُ سَمِعَ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم يَقُولُ " لأُخْرِجَنَّ الْيَهُودَ وَالنَّصَارَى مِنْ جَزِيرَةِ الْعَرَبِ حَتَّى لاَ أَدَعَ إِلاَّ مُسْلِمًا " .
@@waitandsee9345 good luck with that one lmfao
It killed Palestinians, they can't uprise again or stand up to your bullshit treatment.
Here an sincere question for pro Palestine people. If there was no walls. Zero borders or barriers. Would this whole issue be done for? Or is there still a fight still?
But, they didn't just stop at all wall!! They are oppressing them in other ways that have zero to do with security....if it was just the wall....and they let Palestine thrive and have access basic needs, then nobody would care about the wall.
Come on man. You know the answer.
Of course there will be no fight we don’t want Zionist control we want peace like before where Muslims Christian’s and jews lived
Oh of course not. The violence will only be perpetual
I’ve thought deeply about both sides “POV” and I saw greed and total desperation, but all the ties to that land makes it way deeper than just that for them. It’s about their history and beliefs and all that.
I pray that my brothers of the world realizes that we are one people, then will we see the true meaning of living life in accordance to all our god/gods 🙏
You know Jerusalem is connected to over 3 Billion people by way of religion? I suppose the people with the bigger guns have the most powerful God. And last time I checked, God of Jews, Christians, and Muslims wasn't the God of Real Estate.
These lands are political motivated and to use religion to justify their evil actions is blasphemy in all of the Abrahamic religions
How many generations away do you reckon that will be? I know my kids snd grandkids are all for one world....I'm older but until I am gone....
Idealistic, but not realistic
@@ninamenon it could happen 10 yrs from now but also it may never happen sadly but I think this is what we should all aim for
Ps. This will be almost impossible with selfish independent government in which people really have no say in policies and actions they take
@@bitiaaflalo9829 it’s neither my friend, It’s called “hope”.
Same land…one side loved and cared for, the other side trashed garbage everywhere unloved. I remember as kids my sister and I shared a room and we divided it for a reason….she was untidy and I was tidy😂. In this case one side loves life the other celebrates death of their own and others.
Judah and Samaria belonged to the Ottoman Turks who ceded it to the League of Nations in 1920. The League handed it to the British for the purpose of establishing a Jewish State (The British Mandate for Palestine). The United Nations honored the League's authority and declared the State of Israel. Immediately, Jordan invaded it and illegally occupied it for the next 19 years until it was liberated by the Israelis in 1967. The Arabs didn't need to have a state as long as the land was controlled by Arabs. Only when the Jews had it did they start demanding a state and at the same time declaring themselves to be Palestinian. Something they had not done before. So their claims both to the land and to the Palestinian identity are bogus. Really, they are following their religion, which says that Muslims and Sharia Law should rule the world. Israel is a big wrinkle in their plans of domination. Israel just wants to exist in peace. The Arabs want to destroy Israel. who is more at fault?
The names Judea and Samaria are Hebrew not Turkish or 'Arabic.' So no, Judea and Samaria never belonged to any foreign entity other than Jews. Before the Ottoman's showed up 👉🏾 the Romans were the colonial rule in Israel. Guess what? The Romans didn't fight Arabs or Turks - they fought against Jews. You can see the history in the Arch of Titus in Rome. Get your facts right.
The UN plan called for 2 states one Jewish & one Arab . The Arab state was assigned the west bank , western galilee , Jaffa & Gaza while the Jewish sate got the central coastal strip , eastern galilee & the Negev with Jerusalem to become an international enclave run by the UN itself . Weather or not the Palestinian Arab people called them selves by what ever name they were & are a people today who have national rights in the land that most of there ancestors came from . Some are from Circassia , Algeria & Egypt . Today most Israeli Jews are of middle eastern decent being expelled from Arab states but it is only a minority that is of Palestinian Jewish decent , with only one town Pekin that has had an unbroken continuous Jewish presence from the times of old Rome . The latest terror assault against innocent Israelis is disgusting & I will never what about this issue . When the war is over & hamas has been driven from power & sent into martyrdom a new reality will need to account for the national rights of Palestinian Arabs , other wise there will be no end .
@@gracechadi"Before the Ottoman's showed up 👉🏾 the Romans were the colonial rule in Israel."
Before the Ottoman Empire it was the Mamluk Sultanate, not the Romans.
Here's a list of foreign occupiers of the Jewish Homeland, including major Jewish uprisings:
1. *Neo-Assyrian Empire (722 BCE):* Conquered the Kingdom of Israel.
2. *Neo-Babylonian Empire (586 BCE):* Captured Jerusalem in 586 BCE, leading to the Babylonian Exile.
3. *Persian Empire (Achaemenid Dynasty) (6th century BCE):* Under Cyrus the Great, allowed Jews to return to their homeland and rebuild the Temple in the 6th century BCE.
4. *Hellenistic Period (Seleucid Empire) (Late 4th century BCE) and Maccabean Revolt (2nd century BCE):* Alexander the Great's conquests led to the establishment of the Seleucid Empire. The region came under Seleucid control after his death.
The Jewish uprising against the Seleucid Empire, led by the Maccabees (Hasmonean family), resulted in the establishment of the Hasmonean dynasty in the 2nd century BCE.
5. *Roman Empire (63 BCE):* Conquered the region in 63 BCE under Pompey. Notable uprisings include the Jewish-Roman Wars, including the Great Jewish Revolt (66-73 CE) and the Bar Kokhba Revolt (132-136 CE).
6. *Byzantine Empire (4th century):* Following the division of the Roman Empire, the Eastern Roman Empire (Byzantine Empire) continued to control the region until the Islamic conquest.
7. *Rashidun Caliphate (Islamic Conquest in 7th century):* The Arab Muslims under the Rashidun Caliphate, particularly Caliph Umar ibn al-Khattab, conquered the region in the 7th century.
8. *Crusader States (11th-13th century):* During the medieval period, European Crusaders established states in the region.
9. *Ayyubid Dynasty (1187):* Salah ad-Din (Saladin) recaptured Jerusalem from the Crusaders in 1187.
10. *Mamluk Sultanate (13th-16th century):* The Mamluks, a slave soldier dynasty, ruled the region from the 13th to the 16th century.
11. *Ottoman Empire (16th century-End of World War I):* Conquered the region in the 16th century and ruled until the end of World War I.
12. *British Mandate (Post World War I):* After World War I, the League of Nations granted Britain the mandate to govern Palestine (including modern-day Israel) until 1948. The Jewish population in Palestine experienced tensions and conflicts with the British authorities. Notable events include the Arab-Jewish conflicts and Jewish paramilitary activities.
The Ottomans did not cede it, they lost it to the British in 1917.
@@Long-Ball-Larry Am still right - the Romans came before. Or did they destroy Jerusalem after the British empire 👀? I know Israel has exchanged hands so many times and has been divided so many times since it's creation. The Bible is their history and the Bible is their future. The crazy muslims is all prophecy.
“The only way evil can exist is if Good Men do Nothing” 🙏
I can appreciate Muslims consider Jerusalem a holy land, and they should be allowed to visit as they please. But they also have Mecca and Medina. That they have total control over and non Muslims cannot visit. Jerusalem was a Jewish holy land first, why should they also control that?
The americas belonged to the native american! There are so many white european countries! Why should europeans control australia and the americas
From the book "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine" by Israeli historian Ilan Pappé:
“To bring their project to fruition, the Zionist thinkers claimed the biblical territory and recreated, indeed reinvented, it as the cradle of their new nationalist movement. As they saw it, Palestine was occupied by 'strangers' and had to be repossessed. 'Strangers' here meant everyone not Jewish who had been living in Palestine since the Roman period. In fact, for many Zionists Palestine was not even an 'occupied' land when they first arrived there in 1882, but rather an 'empty' one: the native Palestinians who lived there were largely invisible to them or, if not, were part of nature's hardship and as such were to be conquered and removed. Nothing, neither rocks nor Palestinians, was to stand in the way of the national 'redemption' of the land the Zionist movement coveted.”
@@neoesm Yeah, these sorts of insane lies are why no one takes Pappe seriously as anything, much less a "historian".
Why ado we keep conflating religion with politics? The Palestinians need a state because they have been ethically cleansed and under occupation. Simple.
Zionists don’t want that because they want to force ethno-religious supremacy, hence the Apartheid.
Another in depth report. Hoping that both sides can attain lasting peace
they won't because Palestinians are going to always be treated as less than second-class citizens. Their fight for a two-state solution or freedom in Israel is a lost cause. they need to relocate to other countries that will take them in Chile in South America being the start. And I say this is someone who supports Palestinian civilians.
@@travelingjohn69 The new Jewish settlers should move back to where they came from and return the stolen land to the Palestinians. Palestinians will never forget their oppression done by the Jews. The more bombing, the more hate and more "terrorism". In fact, there will never be peace in the Middle East as long as Israel exists.
The Best simple explanation so far. Kudos bro
Its worked very well and its not even debatable
Thank you so much for this channel. I keep coming back here for much-needed sanity, not to mention all the facts to share with my anti-Israel associates.
"Prophet Joshuah conquered Jericho 3 millennia ago. Why shouldn’t Jews get to live there?"
This is the problem with the settler mindset.
In the history book. Check bible.
i personally crossed the wall illegally 4 times just to see the beach and visit jerusalem, the crossing was not that hard and if i had a bad intention i could have done bad things
the better security situation in the westbank is the result of security coordination between the palestinian authority and israel, they crushed hamas in the westbank, there are no explosives now that cant be moved because of the wall, the terrorists only exists in jenin camp and a few limited areas that are monitored 24/7 to prevent anything dangerous getting out of it
Trust the PA? really??
Yet illegal settlements are being built in the West Bank more than ever. But of course if you believe Isreal should consist of land from the Nile to the Euphrates, then i can understand you.
@@johnso2399When you win several wars which have been started by the other party, you get to decide what you keep and what you give back. According to Israeli law, those settlements are LEGAL. What the UN suggests is not binding. My grandparents were expelled from Schlesien after WWII but I'm not running around hating and butchering polish people. My family accepted that we have lost our land and built a new life. We used to have a huge beautiful farm.
The huge problem here is HATE. Parents teaching their innocent babies to hate should lose their children.
The Arab in Palestine area were mostly content with Turkish and British rule, there are many reasons that this time around they choose to resist the Zionist. I believe if Isreal were created earlier , saying 1920s, that thing would be much more claim by now. As post WW2, everyone has a false believe in freedom, especially when they see how Kosovo got they own state. They have to realise, it is all about geopolitic under a Hypocritic justice facade. Which pre war, people were much more realistic. @@elfriededrunus6402
@@elfriededrunus6402which wars were started by the other party though?
There were big holes in the fense for years, the Palestinian side even added a bus route to the biggest hole, so Palestinians could come and go to work as they pleased. Israeli security services ignored it, the idea apparently being that it would encourage peace.
They were wrong.
Yep... Can't trust terrorist-breeders.
I really appreciate that this is seemingly non-biased. I am an outsider and only know what I know about this conflict from the news and TH-cam.
It's such a shame on the memory of their ancestors that suffered so much in the previous war. Their forefathers must be so ashamed of their next generation to have become cruel and heartless people
This is one of the most balanced videos in reporting of the conflict. Keep it up!
This video is anything but balanced. He doesn't even say the word "settlement" once nor does he actually explain how the wall fits into Israel's broader strategy for the West Bank by fragmenting and displacing the Palestinian population to make way for eventual annexation.
At one point he says he'll explain annexation and land grabbing, but then goes on to say "one million Palestinians *watched* in horror and shock as Israelis streamed into land they considered theirs [while] Israelis relished the chance to finally visit the holy sites." He's describing the systemic confiscation of land and forced relocation of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians by reducing it to something that they simply watched as spectators.
This isn't balance. It's a crafty attempt to launder Israeli propaganda through language of neutrality, and judging by the comments, it's effective.
A fair summary. We can go back 75 years into the past and debate who killed whom first, or keep living in unrealistic dreams...
The facts are that over the years Israel was able to reach peace with some of its neighboring countries (Egypt, Jordan and recently others with the Abraham accords), and made multiple attempts for peace with Palestinians. Those attempts were rejected by Yasser Arafat and later by Mahmoud Abbas, and answered with increased violence from their militaristic-terrorist factions, as this video rightfully depicts.
In 2005 - Israel completely disengaged from Gaza after forcibly dismantling the Jewish settlements there...Instead of making Gaza into a sea beach paradise, its people elected Hamas, and we all know what that led to....
The truth is that the tragedy of the Palestinian people continues but it's not due to Israel, but due to the Palestinian leadership, Iran regional interests, Islamic militaristic radicals and the neighboring Arab nations that benefited for decades from the ongoing conflict by keeping the Palestinian people as victims, and by that - drawing attention from the corruption and failures in their own countries, by pointing at the "great evil - Israel".
israel did not give palestinian the land they said they were going to give after the agreement and instead made cages around them and seperated them
and to add insult to injury they are following an apartheid state judge system
every time an innocent civilian get killed by the israelis they say it's an accident and will look into it then dismiss it
but if a palestinian kills an israel they send a squad to his home and punish his whole family without looking if it was in self-defense or even an accident
the jews in israel became the very thing they hated the most they became nazi's
Spot on
it might not have been as simple as becoming a 'sea beach paradise'. Jewish settlements are supported by US dollars, which is why they usually look better. After exiting Gaza in 2006, an economic/security blockade to prevent any suspicious products was imposed on Gaza by both Egypt and Israel. I don't know the extent of this blockade but any red tape imposed on an economy means lost productivity. I'm not excusing their poor choices and mismangament of resources, but not convinced economic prosperity is possible under severe economic blockade conditions
@@johnblack6819 it is a security border just like all countries have. The only thing different is that all the millions of dollars intended for the Palestenian people has been used by Hamas to build weapons and missiles fired into Israel on a daily basis for years ever since 2006 disengagement , therefore there must be supervision as to what goes in. Up until recent events Palestenians from Gaza with work permits were allowed to enter Israel and earn a salary. Instead of building infrastructure, schools building their economy they are focused on using all international funds to annhilate Israel. If you are looking to blame someone, point your fingers at Hamas who could care less about Palestinian lives and bettering their future.
@@sandraabu3797u must been not in gaza like i do. But here there are local humanitarian valunteer report they stated horribly daily bases human atrocities doing by idf at civilan in gaza at border. They life is cheaps in that camp concentrated . And not only one stated that but many with different organization. And when big west media try cover it like few days ago. We already know decade ago.
Build what? sand castles.
Just a reminder that last time a government built a wall, it was at Berlin……
And the last time a unifying Caliphate was established, it resulted in "jenaside". See the difference?
Who started the War ? Who lost ? When do you give up land to the people who started the fight?
Considering how terrorist attacks and especially suicide bombings have reduced since its construction, and considering what we saw in Gaza, yeah, it's a security barrier.
And as much as I loath to say that, the Palestinians themselves turned it into an 'apartheid wall'.
Imagine if African-Americans decided to claim lands in Africa, if Asian-Americans returned to Asia or even Caucasian Americans returned to Europe in multiple waves of thousands to millions anywhere claiming what’s basically eminent domain with military support to gentrify any community. The sheer quantity of refugees flooding the region since the end of WW2 was the natural source of the contention, and the trend grew into the go-to easy no brainer way when all other nations would vehemently rewrite their migrant’s laws to block any new wave. Under such global restrictions, with leaders who’d follow up with more provisions to let more refugees to invade the area, guess what? Natural procreation would be the only way to legitimize their presence. It’s very important to separate religion from government mandates, and also to listen carefully to what others are saying about the living nightmare for the hosts in their own homes. She said it best "….you are stealing my house…" to which he replied if not him someone else will. This implication tells us he didn’t even challenge the choice of the word "stealing." Where on Earth can anyone claim any rights to property forgone thousands of years earlier? There’s no rationale to this.
They went back, established a country, and actually made a thriving metropolis from all that desert. Then it grew. The 'Palestinains' who are there were mainly just settlers from the British era who came to work for them from Eqypt and Jordan. No one had a 'set piece of land' anywhere in the region. As for African-Americans.... oh dear... go check out Liberia and see how slaves returned home to simply enslave the people living there. Kind of a 'thing' that happens all over the world.
@@kempkennedy3542 Liberia was an experiment, now the other idea floating around is reparation. Palestinians are the descendants of those who stayed in the region, helped flourish it and contributed to the advancement of its civilization. Their "distant cousins" evolved abroad, but WW2 turned them (back) against each other. They are kinda the same people, one with a local flair and the other, a multicultural metissage, yet the latter would identify more as civilized Europeans or Westerners. This is perhaps one of the reasons why they engage in name calling the Palestinians people anything to justify exterminating them similarly to how "Radio Mille Collines" did it.
@@l2etranger you mean the squaters from Arab countried helped flourish it and contributed to the advancement of its civilization
SO FUNNY 🤣
I wonder how black South Africans feel about Israel being called an "apartheid state". Although it's policies may well be criticized as harsh and perhaps oppressive, the indisputable fact remains that they respond (at least in large measure) to legitimate security concerns. Calling this apartheid would seem to imply that the white South African government had some legitimate reasons for its policies of separating the races and denying blacks their full civil rights.
As a black South African I don't see Israel as an Apartheid state what Palestinian people and Black South African people is completely different Apartheid was based on race not the occupation of land. 🤷🏾♀️
Israeli law has _always_ explicitly favored Jews and granted them exclusive rights while oppressing Palestinians both inside Israel and in occupied territories. This clearly meets the definition of apartheid. It's a joke for you to insist the last 75 years don't count because of "security concerns."
you realize how insane that argument is right? basically If ISREAL is right THEN SOUTH AFRICA was right???
@@thinadlamini4671to create a ethnic jewish state
Totally agree, that apartheid argument is insane.
I think the greatest achievement today would be to bring true peace..Both sides happy and thriving..Can it be done?
I can never see this ...as much as anyone would want peace.....there can never be peace between these two countries
I think you'd need the power of a quantum computer to find a solution...
Great video! As a Lebanese, I’m sympathetic towards Palestinians and have my grievances with Israel, but I love this channel and found this vid very unbiased. Great work! I wish you had more views
As a fellow human being of everyone there, this war hits me hard too.
I am Colombian and went to a jewish high school (even though) I am not jewish... I'd love to hear from other Arab countries their POVs about Israel, because all of these videos I've been watching lately certainly weren't shown when I was in school. For example, I was so confused a couple of days ago when I was googling the map of Palestine and came to find out that it is the same one as where Israel lies today....
According to the BIBLE Lebanon Syria Jordan and Egypt they do have borders with Israel but Hamas and some other Palestinian terrorists they don't believe in the ancient Israel whose kings ruled Jerusalem such as David
So what are you doing to clean up your own Palestinian refugee camps, which actually ARE camps & not cities like Gaza?
oh you are from hizbullah
One of the best documentary I have ever seen including important facts about israel and palestine conflict.
11:18 I'd very much like to get the source of this quote, as it shows how belligerent the PLO is.
Please inform the new generations that Palestine is the given name that the Roman provided to the Jude land. Consequently, the present palestinian people are Arabs and the Jude religion was there before the Muslim. This is my opinion as a Christian.
And you ignored the fact that the Jews already left Judea for Europe and America, leaving the land empty for the Muslims to came and settled. Also 'Jewish land's were almost founded in Uganda or Paraguay until Herzl stepped in and asked for it to be build in Israel, which some people calling him 'crazy' for that
@@Kuricang31take your Pallywood propaganda elsewhere. Nobody is buying the lies that you’re selling anymore.
@@Kuricang31 Wrong. Jews have always lived in the land of Israel, even if the Arabs have been killing and stealing from them since before there was a US. Yes, some Jews were transported, as slaves, to Europe, by the Romans. Those slaves' descendants were European Jews.
Not exactly, the Jewish diaspora started at around the end of the complete Roman Empire and the beginning of the Byzantine Empire which was loooooooong before America existed as a state. The Muslims didn't just 'move in' either, there was the Muslim/Arab - Byzantine wars which fought for control of the area before the region was conquered by the Ottoman empire. You make it sound like the Jews just grew tired of the land and upped and left by the own accord.
You right you opinion with missing parts Palestinian land has always been there with Jews and Arabs Palestinian living there toghether
But since you don’t read happen to missed that after the second templo was destroy by the Romans many Jews left some remain , then after Second World War Jews from Europe with not conéction tho the land ( only biblical) came to Palestinian land and start to take the land for them and as the Palestinian they were kick of from their homes and condemn to live in ghettos like those that came from Germany or Poland . And treat them like animals . So those European Jews forgot how their people suffer in Nazi Germany but impose the same treatment to those people in Palestine . And THAT IS NOT RIGHT !
people like you keep the bloodshed coming because you want to acknowledge one people right to freedom and what about the others ? That what you messiah teach you ?
Peace and justice for all without religion or background .. we all creatures of hashem , not one have the monopoly or owner ship on him
This will be ongoing situation. Deep down it's hatred, although looking closely they are like first cousins. So many similarities.
Lets say, some 400 Years ago my Grandfather decided to become a Jew... does that mean my Ancestors from 3000 Years ago were Jews and i have right to live in Israel and claim that its my "ancestors" land... well guess what im pretty sure a lot of Israelis today who moved to Israel did that.
Your grandfather? No. Not unless he married a Jewish woman & your family had been Jews for 400 years. Nice try, though.
Good point tho❤❤
Israel has the right to decide which people can emigrate to there.
In an interview with the Dutch newspaper "Dagblad de Verdieping Trouw", March 31, 1977, PLO executive committee member Zahir Muhsein stated: "The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people.”
Walid Shoebat, a former Fatah activist claims that everyone he met in Palestine "knew to trace the roots of their families to the country from which their great-grandfathers came." He stated: "We knew full well that our origin was not Canaanite, despite what they tried to teach us," he said. "My grandfather would often remind us that our village, Beit Sahour, near Bethlehem, was empty when his father arrived there with six other families. Today, there are over 30,000 residents in the village."
We need this wall on our southern US border
We need more fortification, not less.
What I want to know is how secure are those electric fences?
Could they protect us from a Hamas-style invasion? I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure a few bowl dowers could just drive right through them.
It can't prevent even illegal workers, they just cut it in hundred places in a night
If your question is, could you do a Hamas style attack on America? The answer is no, the continent is just too big and the major cities tend to be far from the border in theory you possibility could may be attack a San Diego but logistics say that’s impossible as it’s one of the few locations That has an Air Force base , a navel base and a army base all basically in the same location. You could try El Paso but that’s basically regarded as a death sentence being the 3rd or 4th largest and most equipped army base in the world. Also you could possibly try the north but environmentally the Canadian US border wants to kill you. The death rate on illegal crossing is higher at the northern border than the south just because of the weather, wildlife and terrain.
Also Americans, not the American armed forces , the civilians have more guns than most modern militaries.
I didn´t know they killed Rabin because he wanted peace, That means there are extremists in both sides. The problem is that Israel has an army, so Palestinians are not going to win this, and when you realize that you are not going to win, you need to negotiate a good deal. The US stole half of Mexico. Did we commit suicide bombs to resist the invasion? Not at all. We fought until the end, and accepted defeat. Now the South West is mostly Mexican again, but we want to be both Mexican and American. We like this country; there is less corruption and more rule of law. It´s a win-win for everyone. The US needed our labor, and we needed better wages. Now we are part of this country, respect its laws, share its values, we have fought in all its wars, and receive more decorations than any other ethnicity in proportion to our numbers.
Duh.... there's been extremists on both sides!! The Israeli government and soldiers act as supremacists. Have you heard their language....they literally say they're special....and not equal to Palestinians....watch more videos! You will see them sound consistently smug, arrogant...flat out racist. The United Nations already said this was an illegal occupation!
Not only Israel closed it's border but also Egypt because of Hamas
Gaza not west bank
@@safwanzidan6427 Jordan closed it's border in the West Bank
The wall reduced terrorist attacks from about 200 *per year* for 5 years (including dozens of bus bombings) to zero
There was no other way - dozens of Israeli court cases described agonising considerations of exactly where it should go and how to balance the security needs whilst maximising the rights of the Palestinian population
Props to you for providing a subdued narrative - hopefully this means more people will watch this video and try to digest it. At the same time, anyone with a moderate grasp of the history of this region knows you're being generous to the Arab side in your language, and can see why a wall is a bare minimum. In the vox pops at the end, where the Arabs are complaining about the wall - they only need to ask themselves what prompted the need for a wall in the first place. How about condemning their fellow Arabs' savage actions and killing sprees over the past 80+ years. That would be a start.
Fair enough but at this point in time Israel is under no legal obligation to return the West Bank or any part of the land to Palestinians. But in 2000 they did offer almost all of the West Bank back to them. Of course there were some highly prized land they wanted to keep. But still, beggars can't be choosers. They've lost every war. I have no problem with the idea of a Palestinian state and while I'm sure some of them would be OK living in peace with Jewish neighbors, so many times in history, enough of them were not willing to allow this to happen. I don't understand why some people here in the West, who ridicule and castigate you, if you are intolerant towards others, are OK with the fact that many Palestinians have zero tolerance for a Jewish state.
When Turkish prime minister Mesut Yılmaz visited Israel, after he had a meeting with Yitzhak rabin, he had also dinner with natenyahu. Throughout dinner, natenyahu complained about Yitzhak rabin and Yaser Arafat and he said that he could not negotiate with Yaser Arafat, but Hamas was ready to negotiate with natenyahu. Then, Yitzhak rabin was assassinated and everything was ruined. In my opinion, natenyahu turned Israel- palestine conflict into his election campaigne and let Hamas strengthen deliberately
Based on that important little film clip Bibi Netanyahu has blood on his hands..💯✔️
Bullshit
..."it fought another war.." should clarify why - Who provoked the conflict?
Does this question even has be has to be asked. I mean do people forget what happened October 7, 2023?
But the question still remains can they just come and take over someone who has been living in those houses for 3 or 4 generations?
Where is the sense in that?
If in one time did stay there and moved out because of the command from God, they can't return and steal it from the people staying there
They never moved out. Not once. They were invaded/kicked out/exiled by foreign empires. Assyrians, Babylonians, Romans, other Arab nations. They even have a word for it: The diaspora. Jews were always trying to come back and taking every chance they could to resettle and build their temples in peace. Then they would get attacked and their a temples and their identity would be destroyed. That's why enemies called the land "Palestine", which is a kick in the face to Israelis because it comes from Philistine, who were the Israelis enemies. Even with all of this, there have always been Jews in that land. There's never been a day when Jews haven't been there in some capacity.
you are obsessed the "steal." who stole? and don't tell me Israel.
You forgot to inform people that Israel been taking more and more land from the Palestinians for over 50 years. No wonder they are pissed.
Which lands has Israel taken over since 1974?
And did Israel take over Palestine? th-cam.com/video/0BasXaiHiiI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=LteOy7fWbPdU8PwM
@@UNPACKEDYou also forgot the part we're netwnYahoo wasn't involved in rabin's assassination
You can learn more about that here: th-cam.com/video/TDHYHuGFnao/w-d-xo.html
The only way to move forward is to stop looking back at the past and to look ahead then walk. They can only do this with forgiveness and the love of Jesus in their hearts. Otherwise, there will always be war and hatred among these people.
2 month later dosent seem to be a bad thing to have a wall with neighbors like this
So the way I see this, Palesntinians don't want Jews near their holy land, those places have proofs of the connection of jews to the holy land like monuments and temples etc.? Isn't that wrong to start with?
It's weird how walls work over there. But here in America the TV says walls don't work. We've been building them for thousands of years for no reason because they don't work.
Walls alone don't work. People can simply go over, through or under. That's why Israel invests a lot in electronic surveillance and guards too.
I hope it would no more war is this world in the future
MAYBE WHEN ALIANS COME AGAINST THIS WORLD
I kept wondering when you posted this. It was October 11. One today would include a section of how oct 7th was needed more. Or proves it was a complete failure
Thanks!