Orlinski for his rich masculine voice colour. Unique in countertenors. His straight tone, economical vibrato make him stand out of many, many singers who have the tendency to overuse it to the point that it sounds like a bad mannerism. However, all out of the 3 are great singers and it is always a matter of personal taste.
The three are superb singers and each interpretation is great in its own right. Stutzmann and Jaroussky are two ends of the spectrum: Stutzmann has a very rich, full and rounded voice; Jaroussky has a very light and crystalline voice. Orlinsky is somewhat in the middle with the lightness of a countertenor but with a more masculine voice, fuller than Jaroussky's. The latter is very easy and pleasing to hear, particularly if you are not used to this kind of singing. Then there are the artistic choices: Stutzmann and Orlinski use little ornamentation and rely on the colour of their voice to add nuance to their singing, Stuzmann in particular. Jaroussky, by contrast, uses a lot of ornamentations: vibrato, breath, dynamic range, etc; it is technically superb. All choices are valid and based on different schools and traditions. Which one is best, well it is a matter of taste.
1.- Orliński una voz especialmente particular con mucho colorido. 2.- Stutzmann una contralto fuera de serie. 3.- Jaroussky la perfección en la interpretación, pero demasiado "soprano" para mi gusto. Un gusto tenerlo de vuelta !!! Desde Buenos Aires - Argentina.
Une voix et un talent qui font rager tant d'aigris coincés. Bravo Jakub, force à ta tes talents, tu nous aides à vivre ds la beauté, ce qui nous manquait cruellement. merci pour l'ouverture des coeurs, ENFIN🎶🙏💜💛💙
Сойти с ума... Гениальные звуки вокала.... Ничего нет прекрасней настоящей красоты... Божественной музыки..... Бог.... Живёт........ В творчестве.... ГЕНИЕВ..... Поздравляю всех с красотой, парящей..... С небес....
У Philippe Jariussky, такий ніжний, ласкавий і легкий голосочок. Люблю його слухати. Якуб Орлінський теж дуже професійно, чудово заспівав. Чудове сопрано у Nathalie Srutzmann. Глибоке контральто. Всі троє чудові співаки. ❤❤❤
Impossible to decide. They are all beautiful and skilled performances. But if I absolutely had to pick one: Stutzmann's interpretation is my personal favourite.
Easy. Orlinski is on the top of the countertenor game right now and for the past 5 years. Everyone wants him. Best in the world (yes even better than Dimash)
Interesting challenge. Thank you!. I would have to say that Jarrousky's version has the best orchestra (orchestration) and his note variations and voice depth (color) are best while Stutzmann does the best performance in this particular "aria"/song/piece. She sings it with more "gusto"/confidence/strength.
Die pointiertheit des Orchesters, die Aufnahmequalität und Jarousskys glasklare Stimme (die in anderen Zusammenhängen an Wärme missen lässt) entscheiden hier die Sache für sich.
Филипп живёт музыкой и образ ом,не говоря уже о безупречном исполнении.Сердце плачет и радуется. Штуц Ман тоже не оставляет равнодушным Очень интересно.Высочайший профессионализм и музыкальность.
Mir gefiel dieses mal Ph.Jarousski am besten. Ich empfinde seine Stimme bei diesem Lied am reinsten, klar und zart. Merkwürdigerweise empfand ich die Stimme von N.Stutzmann als sehr "männlich ".
Die Stimmung von Stutzmann ist voll weil die ganze stimlippen vibrieren. Die Männlichkeit kommt von der Schausspielerei . Die Countertenöre haben mehr Spannung . Ein drittel der Stimmlippen verengt ist um die Tonhöhe zu erzeugen. meiner Meinung nach Orlinski klingt mehr männlich als Jarousski . Ausserdem sind alle super!
Orlinsky he is the most I like but stutzmann has surprised me in positive because fémina voices I don’t really like them. All are brilliant and different and this is what it’s great , because he music can be played in many different scopes
Orlinski for his rich masculine voice colour. Unique in countertenors. His straight tone, economical vibrato make him stand out of many, many singers who have the tendency to overuse it to the point that it sounds like a bad mannerism. However, all out of the 3 are great singers and it is always a matter of personal taste.
The three are superb singers and each interpretation is great in its own right. Stutzmann and Jaroussky are two ends of the spectrum: Stutzmann has a very rich, full and rounded voice; Jaroussky has a very light and crystalline voice. Orlinsky is somewhat in the middle with the lightness of a countertenor but with a more masculine voice, fuller than Jaroussky's. The latter is very easy and pleasing to hear, particularly if you are not used to this kind of singing. Then there are the artistic choices: Stutzmann and Orlinski use little ornamentation and rely on the colour of their voice to add nuance to their singing, Stuzmann in particular. Jaroussky, by contrast, uses a lot of ornamentations: vibrato, breath, dynamic range, etc; it is technically superb. All choices are valid and based on different schools and traditions. Which one is best, well it is a matter of taste.
Jakub Józef Orlinski ❤
Jakub definitely! 👏👏👏🥰
We're so lucky to have three sublime voices! Happy to listen to all of them.
1.- Orliński una voz especialmente particular con mucho colorido.
2.- Stutzmann una contralto fuera de serie.
3.- Jaroussky la perfección en la interpretación, pero demasiado "soprano" para mi gusto.
Un gusto tenerlo de vuelta !!!
Desde Buenos Aires - Argentina.
Of course Jakub Józef Orliński ! His voice is amazing. I have heard an angel singing. Thank you Jakub.
Une voix et un talent qui font rager tant d'aigris coincés.
Bravo Jakub, force à ta tes talents, tu nous aides à vivre ds la beauté, ce qui nous manquait cruellement.
merci pour l'ouverture des coeurs, ENFIN🎶🙏💜💛💙
Jakub Józef Orliński
I had no interest in opera until I heard Orlinski sing Sento in seno. Now I can’t get enough Baroque music. So for me…
Orlinsky
Orliński,my man
All beautiful - but Orlinski most superb! 🙏❤️
Kocham barwę głosu JJO... jest wyjątkowa. Kocham techniczne Mistrzostwo JJO... ❤ Uwielbiam SWOBODĘ z jaką JJO śpiewa najtrudniejsze "kawałki"...
Сойти с ума... Гениальные звуки вокала.... Ничего нет прекрасней настоящей красоты... Божественной музыки..... Бог.... Живёт........ В творчестве.... ГЕНИЕВ..... Поздравляю всех с красотой, парящей..... С небес....
У Philippe Jariussky, такий ніжний, ласкавий і легкий голосочок. Люблю його слухати.
Якуб Орлінський теж дуже професійно, чудово заспівав.
Чудове сопрано у Nathalie Srutzmann. Глибоке контральто.
Всі троє чудові співаки. ❤❤❤
Philippe Jaroussky
Orliński
Three magnificent voices. My favourite one Is Orlinski's
JJO always! He is the angel that sings for me!👼🏼🎶
Wunderbar - habe die schönen Stimmen vermisst und möchte für diesmal gar keine Hierarchie aufstellen :)
I can't decide, they are all te best in their own way. They all have an amazingly beautiful voice!
wow, tough call, but will have to go with (1.) Jaroussky (2.) (tie) Orliński + Stutzman. Beautiful music - Thank you!
THANKS❤
Though different, I loved each one of the singers. Smiled while imagine Vivadi listening to the aria...
I prefer Orliński because I heard this aria live and it was extraordinary vocally and acting.
Can't make a decision, all 3 voices are stunning, we are so lucky to have such amazing talented singers like Natalie, Philippe and Jakub Josef.
Stutzmann, for the changes of color
Philippe Jaroussky ♥️
Молодцы оба!
Какие красивые голоса!
I just love this video. They are all beautiful voices.
I like all three of them
Jakub Józef Orliński in all the way!
Ici Jaroussky, sans doute.
Очень красиво!
PHILIPPE Yes! 🙂
Jaroussky - this expression of ferlings, superb! Then, Stutzmann.
Jakub
I love countertenor voice, but here Nathalie wins
Sans aucune hésitation, c'est Stutzmann; couleur, volume, profondeur, timbre, tessiture, TOUT.
Orlinski, sempre o melhor, inigualável, perfeito ❤
Both countertenors are different but superb! They have a purity that cannot be achieved by a female!
Constriction
Orlinski
Orlinski rifa por siempre, vatos locos!! Y viva 🇲🇽🤘🏽👨🏽🦲
Given that this a song of sadness, Jaroussky probably captures it best. They’re all wonderful though.
Молодец! Талантливый!
Дай Бог счастья!
Impossible to decide. They are all beautiful and skilled performances. But if I absolutely had to pick one: Stutzmann's interpretation is my personal favourite.
Great to see you back! Where have you been?
All three are sublime!
Orliński for me.
Easy. Orlinski is on the top of the countertenor game right now and for the past 5 years. Everyone wants him. Best in the world (yes even better than Dimash)
@@rykehuss3435 I agree whith you! I like Scholl too. From Argentine
Tempo Is a bit troppo allegro in Jakubs version.All 3 Amazing,love them
Interesting challenge. Thank you!. I would have to say that Jarrousky's version has the best orchestra (orchestration) and his note variations and voice depth (color) are best while Stutzmann does the best performance in this particular "aria"/song/piece. She sings it with more "gusto"/confidence/strength.
Супер..... Не сплю... Музыку.... Слушаю...... Брависсимо............
Даже не спите?!
ORLINSKI
Orlinsky again!
Qué maravilla de voces!!! Preciosas las tres...
Stuzmann hands down rich and dark ,the right voice timber for this aria ❤
J. J. Orliński perfecta
Die pointiertheit des Orchesters, die Aufnahmequalität und Jarousskys glasklare Stimme (die in anderen Zusammenhängen an Wärme missen lässt) entscheiden hier die Sache für sich.
Филипп живёт музыкой и образ ом,не говоря уже о безупречном исполнении.Сердце плачет и радуется. Штуц Ман тоже не оставляет равнодушным Очень интересно.Высочайший профессионализм и музыкальность.
Orlinski e Stutzmann a pari merito.
Wonderful music!
🌺Chef-D'œuvre🌺Masterpiece🌺CapolaVoro🌺Meisterwerk🌺Obra Maestra🌺Шедевр🌺
🌺Arcydzieło
🌺 VIVALDI 🌺
WINS
🌺
Jaroussky
all 3 were great but Orlinski Stuzmann then Jaroussky was the best I think Thank you
I love them all and this is one Comparison I play over and over.
Mir gefiel dieses mal Ph.Jarousski am besten. Ich empfinde seine Stimme bei diesem Lied am reinsten, klar und zart. Merkwürdigerweise empfand ich die Stimme von N.Stutzmann als sehr "männlich ".
Die Stimmung von Stutzmann ist voll weil die ganze stimlippen vibrieren. Die Männlichkeit kommt von der Schausspielerei . Die Countertenöre haben mehr Spannung . Ein drittel der Stimmlippen verengt ist um die Tonhöhe zu erzeugen. meiner Meinung nach Orlinski klingt mehr männlich als Jarousski . Ausserdem sind alle super!
Очень понравилось ваше красивое пение!
All 3 excellent.
Натали бесподобна! Парни тоже классно исполняют. Ноту Натальи такая приятная бархатистость и сочность звучания одновременно ❤ до мурашек!
Welcome back!
Nathalie, Jakub, Philippe
All the best !
Каждый по своему интересен. Натали в конце интересно заканчивает. Но все равно, конечно Jakub Orlinski 👍
Nathalie Stutzmann 🤩
O, J, S. ❤👏👏👏👏
La Stutzmann su questo brano è la migliore anche se le variazioni di Orlinski sono le più belle
Orlinsky he is the most I like but stutzmann has surprised me in positive because fémina voices I don’t really like them. All are brilliant and different and this is what it’s great , because he music can be played in many different scopes
Orliński wunderbar
Inconditionnelle de Jacob orlinki,puis Philippe jaroussky .
Natalie, Philippe
JAKUB !!!!!!!
São os 3 fantásticos, porém eu aprecio vozes menos agudas e por isso voto em Orlinski e Stuzmann
Orliński , Stuzmann , Jaroussky .
Orliński & Jaroussky
Nathalie Stutzmann .. para mi la mejor interpretación.
JJO~!
Nathalie Stutzmann is the best
2:45
JACUB
Jarousski, Orlinski, Stutzman
Stutzman has the most rounded sound. Orlinski's singing is more nuanced.
Silke Gäng + Accademia Bizantina + Ottavio Dantone
Jstouddky....good!
PJ... jest... WSPANIAŁY... ❤
Stutzmann❤❤
nathalie
Jaroussky y Orlinski
nathalie, though she sounds like a couter tenor herself...
Jaroussky, Orliński, Stuzmann.😊
Orlinski❤
Nathalie