ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ย. 2021
- Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy - Definitive Edition (PC, PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X/S/One, Nintendo Switch) is a messy collection of the classic games. Here are the technical issues we'd like to see get fixed ASAP.
Subscribe for more: th-cam.com/users/gameranxTV?su... - เกม
![[TH] VCT Masters Shanghai Playoffs DAY 1 // 100T vs FUT | FNC vs GEN](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/erQ7pGChzxA/mqdefault.jpg)
This is a perfect example of the state of gaming today. They announce something that everyone is super hyped about and inevitably release a turd
Except this is great for me. I am having alot of fun with trilogy. I am saying from my experience playing hundreds of hours of both PS2 and OG PC version. The graphical fidelity itself is huge. Then we talk about controls, it’s really bad in OG versions, Checkpoints non existent, No navigation means I have to wonder 50 minutes in the forest to figure out where I need to go. Load times are long. Did I mention the pop ins?
Visuals are far better. Grass and foliage now looks somewhat modern, it looks nearly ancient on old version. The lighting is improved greatly, There is reflections on car. Textures on trees is a generational leap, also going the resolution is higher. Half the people making fun of DE never played the OG version.
@@ahrlj24 I do not have the same experience but I'm genuinely glad you're enjoying it. What are you playing on?
@@ahrlj24 you must have really low expectations for this game to be satisfied with it
Bro you deadass couldn’t say it any better, everything you just said is complete facts. 🤙💯💯
It's time like this it makes me happy to be a patient gamer.
It's mind-boggling why they gave the remastering duties to a mobile games developer.
That same company handled the SA port to mobile. The definitive edition is the mobile port of the games and not from the PS2 😕
Money
They made Ghostbusters the game. Really good one that is. But yeah they suck
Part of me wonders if Rockstar just pushed GSG to get the remasters done in time for the 20th anniversary and wasn’t willing to pay to bring on enough people to get it done properly in the time allowed. Rockstar gonna let GSG take all the blame for it when rockstar is the one calling the shots and cashing out.
Tell me a game developer cares more about money than their consumers without telling me they do
There are 2 more things:
1. There is no animation when the glass in a car breaks. The original version had one.
2. A car gets wider and wider when you swerve from left to right.
That second one sounds so funny
@@mricardo96 It is lol
@@mricardo96 there is no limit to how big the car can get either...
CJ: "Smoke, why aren't you moving?! We got Russians on our ass!"
Big Smoke: "I cant CJ, I'm softlocked to this bike!"
Bruh literally 1 of the missions I cant get past due to glitch.
Godly
"All you had to do was get off the damn bike, Smoke!"
@@rainbarfrex3434 lol
A
At this point, the gaming industry isn't even taking steps backwards..
They're running a full marathon in reverse.
Bit dramatic. Hundreds of games released this year completely fine and playable but as soon as a big company releases an incomplete game its "wow the gaming industry is going downhill"...
I remember when GTA 4 on the PC was full of bugs and crashed constantly... And when skyrim on the PS3 was not optimised to the point where the bigger your save file got the worse it played. Also when New Vegas released full of bugs. I also remember people saying the exact same thing as you at the time...
Same with the price of gpu's. Graphics aint getting better unless the majority has a faster computer. We could have had almost real life looking games by now with ray tracing
@GH0STST4RSCR34M there wasn't a joke...
@GH0STST4RSCR34M whoosh is used when somebody didn't understand something, primarily a joke. I understood the comment and I responded to it, as you can see above. Tell me again how I misunderstood what they were saying?
Also no I didn't like my own comment... Where are you getting that from? You just sound extremely salty that you used whoosh incorrectly lmao.
@GH0STST4RSCR34M It's not a joke though because the topic of the video is how full of issues the games are, they're agreeing to that by basically saying the industry is going to shit, there's no joke.... How exactly did I misunderstand again?
I remember Rockstar Games laughing at CD Red last year, and promising how their games only launch when they are READY.
Well that was a lie
@@darkcrow3350
Either that or R* standards are really low
Wait did they say that??? That's hilarious.
Well not defending anyone here but technically the Triology DE isnt made by Rockstar, it's made by Grove Street Games (previously War Drum)
@@Ctar99n Rockstar went ahead with the plan anyway and let that same shit ass company design this travesty of a definitive edition trilogy, they knew that company had a history of making shitty game ports. Remember the GTA SA mobile and Xbox editions that were ported over and had a lot of bugs and glitches and were generally unplayable? Yeah, that was the same company who was behind it. It was rockstars decision. They let them make this game. It’s like they gave Grove Street Games a week to flesh out this entire thing and shipped it out in a box with holes in it.
They managed to make 3 games almost 20s old feel modern for sure. Rushed and full of glitches that need to be patched. Sounds like modern video game release to me good job rockstar! 👍
No don't reward them or they think it ok to keep doing this
Another fooled fan
@@Stuart503 You realise he's saying that the definitive edition is bad right?
@@Stuart503 another fooled commenter lmao
Yea thats the problem.they did three games all at once.they should of did them one at a time.or took more time and attention.they just whipped them together.i bet rockstar is gonna come out with theyre own .but probly not if gta 6 aint out yet.they put this out I think cause gta 6 is still gonna take a while so they thought we needed something in the meantime.
9:14
It's not a bug, NPC sometimes will keep chasing you if you bumped into them, it happens in original version too.
No it doesn't
Yes, exactly this
It doesn't in gta 3 and vice city but happens in sa
@@sudingamerz5013 like you said,the video only shows the example on SA
I think he doesn't mean like stuck when there's a ragging driver but stuck like if every car was a tow truck
These games deserved a full remake, it has been possible to make it look like this or even better with mods for years now
Full remakes cost a lot of money. Much more money than the development studio can afford. Rockstar didn't work on these remasters. A much smaller developer did and they don't have the best reputation either.
Yeah like resident evil remastered edition
But that would have cost money.
@@skankalicious.777 we can wait for every single game ... We don't want all 3 at the same time , c'mon man Rockstar have so many Money
@@MayankGautam2004 it wasn't Rockstar who did these remasters though
They didn’t give a shit about this trilogy and honestly my heart is broken.
Tarnished their legacy
sad to say i expected it :(
Vice city is 9/10
So nagative
Rockstar basically said, “we don’t care about these story driven games. Buy our new GTA online stuff and give us money”. Rockstar indirectly said they’re finished with quality single player
Never in my life would I ever have imagined that the Switch port of a game was the least buggy of them all.
“Are people really paying $60 for incomplete games that developers plan to fix 6 months later?”
YES.
Didn’t realise a few bugs meant it’s an incomplete game. People talk like the originals never had bugs
@@daylebacchus5395 Those we’re the originals. This is a new time that releasing shit broken and fixing it later shit gotta stop.
@@daylebacchus5395 if the original had the same bugs, why not they fix it on the remaster?
@@sirkkkasir the originals are 20ish years old the bugs then we're acceptable and people grew to like it's quirks but this is a new remake rockstar is a big boy company now they have the budget to make a good remaster they hardly tried for god's sake they gave this project to a mobile game company
@@deloader yeah mate. It feel like GSG wont even touch any code in the game.
some steps back for Rockstar. The easy money grab is too obvious.
Hopefully this means they needed the money for upgrades in gta 6 after this gta 6 better be remarkable 😂
They remove the original 3 gtas from their launcher in pc and we get this buggy mess of remastered games
Rockstar is going the way of Bethesda. They're just gonna milk every penny out of something they can, for as long as possible. They've become lazy and complacent. That's why GTA Online continues to see tons of updates while the original story DLC was forgotten about.
Unfortunately, I see the single player of GTA 6 being trash with a massive focus on online.
@@bloodmoneyhistory6845 the game hasn't been released yet plus as long as there is no official or unofficial statement from rockstar or take 2 we all don't even need to bother talking about gta 6 especially since 5 is first about to come out for ps5
More like easy showing of how a-hole they are. I don't think this is a good business in anyway possible
I'm sure everyone that's working on this project won't be adding this to their resume/cv.
They prolly got their Janitor to do this trilogy remaster. :)
they gladly will, since the work to profit ration will be absolutely insane! it's like they're printing money with these games!
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Job interview:
Have you ever heard of GTA Tri-
NO I HAVE NEVER HEARD OF REMASTERED TRILOGY!!
Never said remastered, get out!
It’s a shame we can’t get a single polished game anymore, pray elden ring is as good as it looks
ON GOD BRO. If elden ring sucks, I’m fucking done gaming
I think there should be an option to turn off highlighting outline around the enemy target, which breaks immersion for me or atleast an option to turn off
Lol I get what you're saying, no disrespect but how does one immerse himself in a gta game? Ahahah
More of a reason to wait for a sale. It's crazy that they are selling a lesser quality product for full price.
Honestly I’d just say never buy it in the first place, unless some serious fundamental changes are made to it. The “definitive edition” is substantially worse than the original. I say put the old games back up on shelves.
nah with the publisher wanting a cash grab over these classics, Rockstar is not going to see my money
No sale. Gamers are too weak! Just walk away from this one dude...
They aren’t giving you the product at full price you are literally paying 20 for each game which is not full price even back than standard price 50-60
@@perezhernan32 1) The _trilogy_ is the product - you pay for the lot.
2) The state of this "definitive" edition is like a prank gone horribly wrong. If you have the originals, you may as well fire those up - you're guaranteed a better experience.
CJs neck makes him look like he is constantly doing a quagmire impersonation
Gigity
Giggity goo
A couple of things I haven't seen people mention much, if at all:
1) Vibration on the controller seems to be hit or miss. Some impacts register, some don't. And, for example, I remember on the PS2 if you rode over the train tracks on a bike in San Andreas, you get a lot of vibration. On the Definitive Edition, you feel nothing. It's just weird to me.
2) I remember in Vince City you had honking car alarms. In the Definitive Edition, this doesn't seem to be a thing. I haven't had one car alarm go off yet. Again, this is a small thing, but it's still a missing game mechanic.
Here's the easiest fix: give us the old versions back.
It will be $60
If you deleted them that's on you. Thankfully I kept the OG Vice City and SA on my ps4
No checkpoints, shitty controls, horrible graphics. Leave them in the past.
@@alnobleman2884 your lucky
It’s starting to become comedic just how many games are coming out in such an unfinished state at this point
Not comedic it's just sad
@@thesilentassassin1167 And it's even sadder how people give their money before seeing reviews and videos like this one. They are the problem.
can blame the gaming community for feed the gaming industry with tons of money for early access games and pre orders... it has now set a precedent to now producing unfinished games, "we'll patch it finished over the months" business moto.
Because game has gotten way more big and complex than before. Even this was made in new engine.
@@attilaracz2626 i could not agree more. People who Pre order are just plain simpletons.
Rockstar should really hire some of the best modders to make the remakes.
Unfortunately they try to ban all of them
@@yololoyo7379 i know and thats not the right approach from rockstar
i know and THEY SHOULD. I remember that modder that fixed the gta online loading times, that is the value of modders
@@ryhanzfx1641 They have fixed so many things. They fixed the rain in definite editions with mods already while rockstar hasn't fixed anything yet
@@mr.mcdonalds8326 yeah fuck R*
Thank you so much for this review, just cancelled my pre-order. You guys saved me some money. Will now definitely wait a few months until prices hit rock bottom and we will (hopefully) be provided with some bug-fix updates.
things i would love to see:
the ability to bail out of a vehicle in GTA3.
the ability to swim for at least 10 seconds if you end up in water so you have a chance to get back to land in GTA3 and VC. 10 seconds shouldn't break the games since there's such a large distance between areas.
the ability to remap certain controls. i hate having the E-break set to R1(PS5). i find myself always hitting the X button because that's what i'm used to and it does nothing while driving.
checkpoints in the longer and more frustrating missions, especially with how often the game seem to crash while i play...
i'm sure there was more that but those are the 4 that come to mind.
Yes around 5-10 second swim before you die to a shark in vc and toxic waste in gta 3 should be fine. With unlimited swim time at a 100% completion.
I can't believe the company that made the most detailed games ever such as RDR2 and GTA 5 with so much care and love would just laze off on games that made everyone's childhood.
They didnt do it, a 3rd party did it for them
Outsourced to a company called Grove Street Games.
They did the mobile ports of SA. Etc.
@@Sirriebo tbh rockstar should still be held accountable . If not more accountable they can’t just let projects like these be treated like this. It’s not another port or etc it’s a HD Remaster it’s basically a new game . They just don’t look at it like that like they’re not doing expanded and enhanced for gta V. They have the bigger budget. They oversee the projects and allowed them to hit online stores. They didn’t even bother to play test this game. You would think after a failed mobile port Rockstar would be on their ass this go around but they’re not because Rockstar doesn’t care. If it’s not V Online Rockstar literally do not care because the people that worked on other projects there are almost completely all gone by now.and replaced with the new age developers who only know micro transactions and loot boxes .
@@dan77oyo well it's still rockstar. regardless of what they did to get this game out. it's on them. they hired that company. and they chose to release this piece of crap without even making sure the game is good to be sent out. blaming the outsourcing doesn't make sense.
The houser bros and lazlo left the company so I guess this is the proof that we've been all fearing which is that it's only downhill for the company I am hoping for the best when it comes to gta 6 but you just dont know anynore
The fact you were able to make a top 20 list shows the game has more problems than it's worth playing currently or if ever
Class action lawsuit anyone??
Top 20? I figured this was Part 1 : The first 20 problems
This could be a year long series.
Stuttering is definitely my biggest issue. Player controls and ai accuracy are a close second and third. Great list thanks for the content!
In addition to what this video points out,, These are some of the bugs and issues I have currently ran into while playing the definitive edition on ps5.
Vice city :
-San Andreas menu sounds in the pause menu
-car health is extremely weak, any vehicle you're in as a player can take way less damage than npc cars before they catch fire
-cars blow up within seconds once they are on fire
-when flying in a helicopter, the blades spin in an unnaturally slow pace
Gta San Andreas:
-weird collision when bumping into cars, it's like your body is a metal object and bumping into a car seems as if something heavy and large hit the vehicle
-bicycle tires sink into the ground when riding on alot of surfaces
-camera shifting into a weird angle slowly when the player commits grand theft auto, it's extremely annoying
-power lines running straight into walls and windows and roofs and some go literally nowhere just hanging in the air, not sure if that was in the original
-cj swims awkwardly now, it's kindve difficult to control his swimming and I'm not far into the remaster but it seems like you can't swim underwater
"We hope they fix this as soon as possible" oh you sweet, summer child... This is Rockstar we're talking about. You've got all you're gonna get.
😂 read this just as it was said
"Test marker" implies that they tested these games and I refuse to believe that
it’s probably from 20 years ago they just never fixed it
#5. Cars following and "getting stuck" is something that happens in the original that I remember. Those are the aggressive drivers that follow you and then just keep bumping into your car to explode the car.
They could have disabled the New Austin sniper for Arthur in RDR 2 instead of this definitive edition remaster.
Someone hasn't played all of rd2 yet ;)
@@brownierdo5428 I have played RDR2 entirely. 2 complete play throughs. Got 100 % completion on the 2nd play through. I know we get access to New Austin as John Marston. But I hate that Arthur isn’t permitted access to New Austin despite having his own unique lines for New Austin. The denied access to the town of black water is understandable but restricting New Austin makes no sense at all. Petty minded people of rock star are control freaks.
Them removing music and not putting in any additional songs says it all about the lack of care they put into these games.
too true
The character models in this "remaster" remind me of my freshman year 3D modeling animation projects I used to churn out LOL
They remind me of Xavier Renegade Angel on adult swim
@@glowingdawn9179 this comment hit different
all the characters look like they ride the short bus!
@@glowingdawn9179 XRA at least had decent looking models
My dad told me cars made in the 80s had doors that fell off as soon as you opened them. Rockstar has been getting a lot of shit for these remasters but they nailed that one detail.
I was looking forward to playing these. I really hope Rockstar monies this better. Show us what those deep pockets can do.
Working as a QA Tester, this shows how Rockstar was more interested with easy money grab than make a flawless experience. We eat some of these bugs on breakfast, it's really easy to find and it is really easy to fix, but probably the devs where forced to waive or got no time to fix it
Grovestreet ported their awful mobile ports into Unreal Engine and then allowed A.I. to remaster the whole thing. The developers and publisher are 100% to blame for this dumpster fire. Grovetsreet should be banned from making games ever again and Rockstar should be held legally liable in my opinion. There is no excuse for this and I cangaurantee you that not one single QA tester was even consulted on this project.
Games companies > Games Corporations
@@danbooke2001 the problem is QA testers these days aren't meant to find bugs. Their feedback is generally restricted to one parameter: "can you get to the credits?" If yes, then pass. The rest can be fixed later.
Jake, we need to establish one thing: I think the reason you’re enjoying the ‘Remastered Trilogy’ is not because they’re good, it‘s because the BASE games were good. There‘s also the nostalgia factor. Think of it this way: If this was your first time playing these games, and you really didn‘t know much of the hype around them, would you have liked playing through the hot mess that these 3 games are?
Exactly, the game itself is good but the port is terrible.
A lot of people are defending this game saying "but I'm having a lot of fun" it's only because the game itself is fun. Doesn't change the fact that the port is god awful.
I never played the original games and I'm having a good time
You're looking at it from a perfectionist perspective right now but back as a kid you did not. Back in 2006 i did not care if my characters neck looked weird, heck he could have had scoliosis or could have been non-human i would not have cared i just wanted to shoot people and drive cars
@@Fortunato7 but would you have cared if the rain made it difficult to play? Or if your game crashed when you left it idle for a bit to use the bathroom? Or if the game didn't run at a consistent FPS and casued you many unfair deaths?
No game is perfect, and nobody with any working braincells expects perfection from a game, especially a remaster.
That doesn't mean that mega sized game companies shouldn't provide a solid 6/10 game on average. We expect a functioning game that respects it's own history, and cares more than, "how much money could this make off nostalgia or cool effects in HD".
Fallout 3 and 4 are great examples of a company not really giving a shit and doing what they want with no regard for the series history or fanbase, and providing a 2/10 and 1/10 respectively.
He literally said that tho
5 - the car attach is a thing from the old game too. it's happening when you collide it and then it starts following you
I honestly just got it so I can relive my childhood I’m still having fun
I love between the rain and the draw distance you have two options - see nothing or see way too much.
They need to add low cloud and shit. Just imagine seeing some clouds around chilliads peek, and some birds flying over the land. They could have done so much fancy stuff... I almost doubt that they will add those thing but I hope. Lets get back to the og then.
@@GreenSabre187 I can't believe this studio made rdr2
@@geezjoe9679 They didn't. Grove Street Games made this version.
@@mrdavis8814 ooooooh that's why ....... But again how did this garbage get out of quality control and get rockstar approved
San Andreas really deserved better, such a phenominal game.
All 3 do dummy
@@dungmaker no, san andreas. Dummy
@@dungmaker san andreas and gta 5 sold the most
@@GamesWePlay95 yeah but gta3 is the reason for all this. If 3 wasn’t as groundbreaking as it was, you don’t have Andreas or 5
@@matthewsmith8727 you name is MATTHEW 🤮 I expect you to say something like that 😆😹
Thank God you didn’t cover everything that needed to be fixed in this game!!
Each game featured in this Vid, would have Needed a Trilogy itself-
Playing the collection on the Switch and man, I fucking LOVE the gyro aiming and map/menu navigation with the touchscreen.
The character models and rain should’ve been 1 and 2, on a whole it needs a massive graphical overhaul.
The part of the map near Catalina’s place where you do the robbery missions, the road that adjoins the small town to the main city has missing edges to the roads where you can see through the map.
A LOT of buildings seem to have this too. In San Andreas most safe houses have clear white lines where the floor and walls join up
Not even. Frame rate needs to be absolutely number one with pop in being a close second. What's the point of fixing anything else if the game engine isn't even running properly? Fix the core issues and than work on cosmetics.
@@CommaderRockwell Very true. The simple fact that ps2 games can run smoothly on mondern day consoles make zero sense. But for me, the waypoints NEED to be fixed right away too. They dont work when you're on foot or during missions, and on missions is when you NEED a waypoint most of all. Smh
@@CommaderRockwell Game mechanics are still tied to FPS.........
@@KoolKeithProductions og san andreas didnt have gps either. The waypoint is not an issue lol
Don't worry guys rockstar games is just going to release The Ultra GTA Trilogy: Definitive Edition Improve Remastered and maybe Seamless character-switching
Ps5 edition
concerning the ai accuracy: i remember in a speedrun i watched for one of the games done quick events, the runner purposely entered and exited vehicles to manipulate the aim of the ai... so that doesn´t sound like a new bug but rather something that got carried over from the earlier versions
Jizzy's alt. escape scene if you destroy his pimpmobile before entering in "Ice Cold Killer". Instead now it gets stuck in a fail state saying you destroyed the phone and you have to restart the mission. Also invisible objects popping up blocking people in places. Worst I've seen was in "Yay Ka Boom Boom". Also in the "Pier 69" mission, while chasing Rider, I've seen what was basically a man cannon from Halo and CJ rocketed from the railing to the island by the boats and died.
undoubtedly the bug that puts rockstar in the worst light is how your save can corrupt if you drink too much soda from the vending machines (at least on switch), vsauce joel found this out recently on his stream of San Andreas
Wtf how is that a thing. sounds like an overflow error in the count off the top of my head. How many did he drink? Total idiots at Rockstar now a days i swear. I wish the Hausers were back.
How much is too much?
definitely seems like an integer overflow, to put it simply: either they didn’t program a limit to how many cans of soda you can have for the engine to remain stable, or the switch has an issue with the programming of the game and with that specific line of code when it comes to drinking copious amounts of soda.
@@Despon i didn't even think about it being the Switch but honestly that could be it too. It makes me so sad to see the games industry in this state.
@@glowingdawn9179 Rockstar had nothing to do with this remaster,it was made by Grove Street Games.
10:44 man, not even that high up and you can see San Fierro and the bridge in the distance. Really does make the map look like a little toy map…I can’t believe they somehow made the visual appeal of the game worse by improving draw distance 😅
I can't believe that rockstar highlighted the draw distance as a selling point.😆😆
In the original game the desert is more realistic with sand in the air everywhere and not being to see far. Now wtf?? U can see the whole frickin thing
@@Lee-bt2cy It looks like a sarcastic response to the people who have been complaining the low draw distance for years.
You need smog, smoke, fog, simply some particles in the air. This really does look like a toy map.
@Zeru exactly. Like GTA V where there is distant fog and mist. Overall, poor effort remaster (trash), worst cash grab and a disappointment.
CJ: "How am I supposed to cross this river, there's no bridge!"
Big Smoke: "You just gotta have a little faith, like in the book."
CJ: "What fuckin' book?"
Number 4 is indeed the center of the map, in the og version in the markers place used to be an electric pole, the only one in the area, so it made it into a kind of Easter egg thingy, but in the new one it's just a marker, which is an odd decision
These are 20 year old games but given to a team who cared about these games. This remaster could have been great. Modders have shown this to be true.
Some guy in his leisure fixing a singular graphical glitch is a bit different from translating an entire 3 games of code to run on new hardware. Even in the mod community, it takes weeks or months or years to develop an in-depth massive mod.
@@thedarkemissary like the forgotten city in skyrim
@@thedarkemissary except nothing they did hear is massive. There’s 0 added content. It’s all textures and reskins. Like the video mentioned, they didn’t redo any animations. But you’re right, rockstar is an Indie company who doesn’t have nearly as much resources as some average Joe. If only they had more time from the launch of gta 5 till now to come up with better ideas. Oh well
@@thedarkemissary It's literally ported from the mobile versions and reskinned?
@@FecalMatador To be fair, Rockstar didn't touch the DE at all. They outsourced it to smaller studio called GSG which has only done the mobile port. That itself was a bad decision
With the $ Rockstar has we should’ve got a FULLY remastered version of each game…new engine, new gameplay mechanics etc
@Agent 39 budget doesn't mean you can do anything ffs. Translating a 20 year old game into a much more advanced engine would is really hard and would be like making the games from scratch. Then it would be a remake and not a remaster
how about new location , new protaganist how about you do it you have written a computer game before right nope its bloody hard even noughts and crosses
@Agent 39 ok you sound about 9 years old, take your anger out on someone else...
Half life is a PC game, far easier to work with than a console's architecture.
My point was, translating games from the PS2 onto the new gen would take much more time than you think, just because they have money doesn't mean it's easier to do. I assume R* considered doing it themselves but chose to focus on GTA 6 probably. After all, gta 6 is going to make them more money in its first week than gta 5 has made in the past 5 years.
"it's easy just time consuming" just shows you know absolutely nothing about game development.
I fail to see where I defended them... I'm responding to you saying that it would be easy to make the trilogy with the gta 4 engine when it wouldn't be... regardless of budget.
@@Towey8 I 100% agree with you, but considering the legacy these games have, they deserved the absolute best treatment, the GTA series made Rockstar after all
@@Towey8 you …..you do know original games are on pc too right? How about you remastered the game based on pc version, including some effects from ps2 , fixed minor bugs remains then released? That’s exactly what modders did! And this de is half remastered half remake, not totally remastered ( graphics is remake with unreal 4 instead bring old engine), sound, voice….. are from original! If modders can do it! Rockstar can do it better! Your excuse is unacceptable for a company like this!not to mention the studio behind this mess thing up once in 10 years anniversary remastered!
despite all the bugs and issues in the game, im still having a blast playing it
People are making this sound horrible in the comments, is it really that bad or are they nitpicking?
good thing I bought the PS2 version of San Andreas on PS4 a while ago and then 3 and Vice City PS2 versions on PS4 the week they were going, I played San Andreas since I was 10, played Vice City once when I was a toddler and yes I did the exact same stuff I did in the game as a toddler to relive nostalgia, and I had never played 3 but the icon for it is my favourite so far and would love to try it, I wanted to wait on the remakes and turns out I had the right idea to wait on the remakes and get the original versions instead
Can you add me on ps4?
@@LL-tk3pn why?
With number 15, I’m glad someone mentioned the enemy having insane accuracy. Just on some parts I’ve died many times because I’d get crowded with enemies holding an SMG and they’d erase me instantly with their aim
It's not a big deal, just need proper cover and a lot of ammo 😁
I actually like that , gives the game a challenge then it used to be ,play smarter
@@drechillin2154 I’d agree. However there isn’t a cover system in this game. If you crouch behind an object. Chances are, they’ll be able to still shoot you with their amazing aim
seems like gta online problem to me
just git gud
I'd like to see the 2 player feature brought back more than anything else.
Same, was really excited to play SA with my brother again but Grove Street Games and Rockstar really did the bare minimum
@@sharmgidly3497 wowww didnt even know this
I didn't even know it had 2 player
no they removed it in de
I hope they have the common sense to bring it back I've seen lots of complaints. I played this for 1000s of hours 2 player with my brother and my best friend. I just don't get why they would use the mobile port and have an outside company make it. It's terrible.
I always felt like GTA 5 should have been a total rebuild of San Andreas but just better in all aspects, would be cool to see the golden gate in GTA 5 and all the other left out areas
I think there are mods for that
Thanks guys, I was considering buying it, and then I saw this video today. Gonna wait until things get fixed a bit before I buy it :P
one of my favorite things to do in original San Andreas was to get the nrg racing bike and run the Los Santos spill ways at full speed. I could make it across town faster than the game could load stuff in. It would just be CJ the bike, and that weird grey/blue void till I hit something and the game could catch back up.
There are more weird things that would make a good part 2. I noticed that if you are in a police car with the siren on and hold the horn button other police cars around you will play the same variation of the siren, like you are controlling them. Other thing that really bothers me A LOT is the amount of places with invisible objects that you can collide with. I noticed that quite a lot in the hills next to Las Colinas in San Andreas and it makes driving there nearly impossible. Finally, the biggest "screw you" were the special animations for fat and buff CJ that were simply not there.
There is an invisible tree in San Fierro that I hit like 20 times
In one mission in san fierro where you have to place a car inside a building to detonate the bomb inside it, theres invisible things you can get stuck on and makes it extremely difficult to get through even outside the building
@@muneebrehman6288 I've witnessed that also. I've pulled drive-bys on crowds of people, including cops, and got no reaction. I've gone on a tear with a Rhino with zero police attention.
Has anyone had the "magnetic" car thing happen yet? I've seen it once so far. I was ATTEMPTING to do ambulance missions when a random car just stuck itself to the back.
@@muneebrehman6288 I've been playing 3 for a while today (off of work). I keep going up to the spot in Portland where you fall through the map near the tunnel. I've been farming money from that because the game counts it like a jump when you respawn!
The draw distance is like Morrowinds fog, it looks ugly because you want to see farther, but when you do you realize how small everything is, and it loses it's magic.
Tbh I like that the nps have a good aim it makes the missions harder and so that you don't finisher the game as fast
CJ doing the quagmire when he shoots. Gigitigigiti!
That make me laugh, Then I could hear the voice.
Also reminds me of the confused black girl meme
Litterally visualised and heard quagmire when I read that
that needs to be a sound mod.
I was so looking forward to these games…. Here’s hoping a patch actually rolls out to patch some of these things up and I’ll finally pick it up.
Why?
A patch won't fix this thing.
@@smilemore3181 exactly.
Why support any company that is so anti-consumer based?
Just play the originals, those thiefs do not deserve a fucking penny for putting out horse shit for 60 bucks
Research the studio that worked on it and you will loose all hope
No patches can fix this. Its a port of the mobile versions. Literally the least amount of work possible
I knew I wasn't going crazy during the shoot out sections in San Andreas. I actually completed the ambulance mission early so that I could get max health right away and I was still barely scraping by.
9:27
Wow that bug is rare?? I actually experienced that bug the first few minutes playing SA definitive edition. I was just driving around grave street and I hit a NPC car, while I thought it was one of those road rage NPCs, yet no matter how many times I tried to shake him off it felt like he glued to my car even when I drove faster. After some time he stopped and drove away??
I've definitely had a few experiences with the npc's having crackshot aiming. especially in Vice City.
On the Copland mission the minute I leave the mall I basically get sniped
It's not 20 things, it's 1 millions THINGS!
Number 5 did happen in the original San Andreas as well, seemed to start happening sometimes after you crashed into a NPC car, maybe a crude way of chasing you down??
I Actually love the release. I'm enjoying playing these games and I haven't found any of these issues nearly as noticable as everyone else in the world apparently.
Thanks for being part of the problem by rewarding shitty developers for this type of bullshit
The fact they show no gameplay b4 the release and people still bought it 😂
@@mikeuk666 people were calling that heap of garage the game of the year before it was even released lmao
I did and I'm happy with it but it does need to fix some things for everyone. Fuck the rain lol
people are gullible asf 😂😂
@@mikeuk666 Didn't they show like 50 minutes of gameplay in 2018 E3? What they didn't show was gameplay on last-gen consoles.
This is becoming the oldest trick in the game publishers book, yet people keep falling for it over and over again so they keep doing it.
Less than 1% of all the issues with this trilogy will be fixed.
yup u know why because thats the game or do u want gta 5 lol
I thought they took the games back until 7th december?
@@DavidVenters bruh most of these are issues that didn't even exist in the original versions. All we are asking is for the remasters to at least not be worse than the originals lmao. By "improving" one thing they created 5 more issues along with the "improvement" and didn't bother to fix them
@@NephiylusBaphson bruh you sound like you didnt play the original just the hd remake bruh i played 8 bit games loaded by tape bruh ive done c++ programming bruh and one change can throw out a whole program bruh
@@DavidVenters Damn that's crazy. I don't care if you can code yourself to Jupiter, these remasters are still a pathetic cash grab lol
The issue #5 is actually an AI behavior from original. The angry drivers would follow you like this at high speeds with perfect accuracy. lol
its crazy thinking back to first playing gta san andres when it came out and how large that world seemed lol
Car A.I is that when the player is in a car the enemies get more accurate, the reason being that if you are on foot or on a bike/motorcycle they want the enemies to hit you less because you are a small target so their accuracy is set to a smaller percentage, on the other hand if you are in a car it is easy to hit a car so their accuracy goes up so they hit the car more, but if you are on a mission when you get out of the car the accuracy doesn't reset so you get Swiss cheeseed, that is the way it use to working making it critical that speed runners used motorcycle or maybe even bikes on specific missions where a lot of enemies had guns
Still not fixed? Modders fixed it years ago xD
@@phleepy_bird6418 thats fair, moders fix a lot but I mostly watch speedruns which are only allowed to use the base version of the game, and I think silent patch
9:15 cars getting stuck might be actually a feature, on the original game when you hit some people's vehicle they would follow you violently and try to crash you back continuesly
Yup,it's weird how he didn't know that,those things happen all the time you just need to crash your car into another npc's car,it's been a thing since the game launched in 2004.
They would hit you in the og one this is just following you around without actually hitting you.
@@arundas8870 they would also follow you like this in the same fashion. He didn't stop the car, if he maybe stopped or went even slower he would've probably get hit
8:05 the actual fix for this is not turning off HDR. Leave HDR on, go into the settings of the game, set the contrast to 0 and brightness to the max. This will fix this issue.
Also #5 happens in the OG PC port of game. It is not a new "bug" and rather an intended feature
Basically everything in SA alone
The rain is like a damn filter
There's so many bugs
It's just
*EUGHH*
@Captain Slapo *And*
You want me to name more?
I very much can
With all of the mods- I can’t imagine they couldn’t contact someone and give them a percentage of sales. Would work out for everyone
Mods are the only thing I have hope for. Give it a few years and modders will make mods for everything this "remaster" actually needed.
Hello Nicole 😍
Mods are also well known to cause glitches and game crashes.
@@dozhadeville444 How down bad do you have to be to hit on women on TH-cam ?
Companies prefer just getting them for free or making the players pid for a work they didn't do.
The one thing that's consistent across remasters is very counter intuitive but it speaks to the nature of creativity. Those pre HD consoles had serious technical and graphical limitations, those limitations and inadequacies forced the developers to create a unique sense of style. Now that those limitations don't exist, the new developers can create the same glossy looking game and disregard the style the original team developed that suited the narrative of the game. Master Chief collection did the same thing with Halo 1, the doesn't feel the way it should
I was lookin forward to playing this trilogy but i guess ill have to wait for some patches and fixes for this game to be enjoyable like its original minus the old bugs. Hmmm.
This is R* giving the contract for this remaster to the lowest bidder.
I'm pretty well convinced, especially considering the history of the developer, that they started from the mobile versions of the games instead of the originals. Which if I just wanted an upscaled android port I would plug my phone into my TV.
Well actually in san andreas mobile you cant lock on and free aim at the same time. So I'd still rather have this.
Some of the old glitches like things randomly popping in, low quality buildings and invisible bridges just give nostalgia. I don't want all the glitches to be fixed just the game breaking one like the rain.
I encountered a game breaking clipping bug on yay yay kaboom. Invisible barriers blocked the warehouse route to the car drop off point. Luckily the main locked door was glitched so I managed to reverse back out of the warehouse, drive round and enter it.
There is only one thing they need to fix: EVERYTHING
I've enjoyed the gta trilogy but I've had every single 1 of these issues. My biggest issue is Lock On aim. When AIMING you should be able to WALK backwards not turn around in circles while still aiming. Because the enemies have such good accuracy it makes it harder to enjoy even FREE AIM.
Finally someone having same problem as me, aim is cancer
So irritating!!!
That was always there, wasn't it?
@@maggiethegamer1271 yeah, you need to get better at aiming, when you reach the max level with a weapon it allows you to move more freely (I hope I'm remembering correctly)
@@pietrocavicchioli6128 it's only limited to SMG and rifle such as AK or M4. weapons like pistol, sawn-off shotgun and micro smg still do that when you move backward
I haven’t run into these issues except for the invisible bridge which pissed me off because I actually fell through it💀 another bug is if you climb behind the clucking bell counter, you’ll get stuck back there. I’m satisfied graphics wise because there’s only so much you can do to a remaster without making it a new game. But they should have charged 40$ for this trilogy
"All you have to do, is remaster the damn game CJ!"
I hate the argument "it's a remaster, not a remake what did you expect". With the name "definitive edition" you'd expect Rockstar made an effort on these, but instead they hired another studio to make them.
Mobile port of the 10 year anniversaries, done by same shite team
Things they should of improved on : co-op, gun sound effects, CJ's anatomy, fog, original aesthetics.
An they should of fix the ai to help more
Wtf is should of?
9:16 its actually gta sa feature called angry drivers,when you touch a car it will start following you,especially taxi
Haven't gotten to play them yet. From the first videos of it though the rain has always bugged me. Not just in how it falls, but especially the way it looks hitting the ground. It's like they took a 5x5 ft area and just copy/paste it to create the entire rainfall. You can easily see the pattern in it and it looks terrible.
The hdr thing is wild, I thought my TV was just being stupid even tho I had the brightness maxed haha
how did you even get HDR enabled? they only open in SDR for me on PS5
@@jorm1652 go to your PS5 settings --> screen and video, and set HDR to "always on"
You should stop saying "this is not a full remake" and start saying THIS SHOULD HAVE BEEN A...
yeah... that's definitely easier said then done... that's truly rebuilding the game... that's not what they wanted to do, they just wanted a easy cash grab and to shut down modders
this isnt a remake, its a remaster and a disastrous one at that.
@@SankofaNYC instead shut down the modders, they should hired them. Adding swimming feature to GTA III and Vice City isn't much work. If modders could do it personally, why multibillion company couldn't do the same.
@@Mikael2492 I agree, they should have and honestly... I have no idea how modders consistently manage to fix bugs and add polish to games that big developers miss... it's impressive and I have no idea why the developers drop the ball often
@@SankofaNYC Nice U turn of opinion buddy, see what peer pressure does?
No. 5 in my experience, it happens when you somehow touch (not even crash with, just touch) another car. The driver goes on some kind of road rage following you around like a shadow. When it happens, if you stop and get out of the car, the other driver will start backing up and trying to run you down like in a blood rage.
It's not a bug it's a feature
@@abodymody7641 it works fine on my PC 😆
Well, I learned the intro mission IS more difficult than it originally was. My first play of it had me pinned between the Ballas car and a building and they gunned me down QUICK, no matter how fast I cycled. I played the original SA Port (the Rockstar issue one in the Launcher) and it wasn't NEARLY that difficult. The AI logic just went UP for that mission. and yeah the ped gang members are INSANELY good shots now. I never was, so that's a challenge for me. I've been wanting to replay the game and this was a good excuse but yeesh there are a few logic issues that shouldn't have been addressed and others that really should be..
That said, I didn't have an issue with staying with the damn train this time. Had all the enemies finished off before we got into the outskirts headed North into Palomino. I did notice that many of the cutscene characters never changed, even if the models have LOL