John Smith becomes Reichsführer｜The Man In the High Castle｜Season 4
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 พ.ย. 2019
- Connect with me: / tudor.chrs Reichmarchall John Smith and German Obergruppenführer Wilhelm Goertzmann planned a putsch against Himmler and Eichmann. As Smith was summoned to Himmler's office, where he planned to kill him, Goertzmann's men eliminate all the members of the Nazi war command, including Eichmann. Hoover was left to be knifed to death by John Smith for his betrayal.
Movieclip from:Season 4 Episode 9 - The Man In The High Castle
The Man in the High Castle is an Amazon Prime original series that portrays a post-war, dystopian world where the Allies lost World War II. Watch season 4 here:www.amazon.com/Season-4-Offic...
Disclaimer:
I upload the videos for entertainment purposes only.I do not own nor take credit for the clips uploaded here and I do not take or plan of making profit for any of the videos posted here.All credit goes to the creators/owners. - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
I’m pretty sure a lot of American presidents wanted to do that to Hoover.
True...he served under 8 presidents for 48 years...any many wanted to change him
@@ChristiansEdits Hoover created a police state inside a state and had gathered so much information about the sitting presidents that he was untouchable and the shadow president. A dictator. Americans never acknowledged this to preserve the image of being The free country, The democracy. But they were a dictatorship until Hoover left the world.
@@ReuterL very hyperbolic but still too close to the truth.
@@ReuterL He had a lot of power he shouldn't have had, and I'm sure he influenced a lot of policy positions, but he wasn't a shadow president or dictator, he had no public appeal and his power was limited by that.
@@spencernicolls8112 he dictated policies. Those policies which were interesting to him was done without any way to stop that. He was never tried for his crimes against the constitution and other crimes. Public appeal doesnt matter. A dictator doesnt need to look like Borat the Dictator to be a dictator
This should’ve been the ending and there should’ve been a season 5 to end the show properly
Yeah, then continue the rest of season 4 in season 5 and then show what happened after John Smith died
Travel to my universe, where there is a Man in High Castle Season 5 and Cersei got some elephants.
@@Mark50x John Smith should not die, he should take his daughters and travel to the other universe
Nah he should’ve died, his abandonment of his brothers proved that, i think his eldest daughter should’ve went across to the new universe as she had an appreciation for freedom. And Takeshi should have suffered a bit, sure servitude to the yakuza is bad, but this guy murdered finks sister
@@J.Artan6 Takeshi did suffer though.
If season 4 ended with this scene. It would've been probably the greatest cliffhanger in a television series. I was completely speechless when Smith opened the door to reveal that some of the men were loyal to him. I was in disbelief. I don't think I will ever be as surprised as I was with this scene again.
hell yeah. just bingewatched all 4 seasons. Liked them all. This indeed would have been a great ending
OMG, you need to watch "Dallas" and the whole "Who shot JR" cliffhanger. THAT is the greatest cliffhanger ever from a TV series. Second would probably be the series finale of "The Fugitive", which I've never seen or watched but it is legendary. This was good, and unexpected, but those TV shows were epic.
I saw this scene before watching the show. It actually got me into it. However, watching the series all the way up to this scene made it so much better and was just as shocking.
And he dies two weeks later.the reichfurher after him likely dies almost as fast after that abortive attack on the BSR.many members of the former US would've been party members and they're not going to understand why the country wasn't reunited.the end of the series left a lot out.
@@NLWilmar Perhaps, but it would also undermine the story, replacing one that shows us a trajectory of self-destruction with one that might imply the triumph of the Nazis.
"I left Hoover for you." What a great guy!
lovely coworker lmao
Indeed. Legit thoughtful of him. He gave Smith the chance to satisfactorily crush the man who tried to have his wife and children killed.
And they say Nazis aren’t human.
I kind of started to like the guy with that gesture. Kind of.
Lmaoo
“Heil Smith” just doesn’t sound right. And this is coming from a Smith.
Greg Smith Its because Smith only has 1 vowel. Saying “Heil Johnson” or “Heil Stoneman” sounds somewhat more natural
Still gave me chills :)
Heil Schmidt?
Smith-ler
season 4 was total bullshit
I feel the writters intended for this episode and scene to be the end of the season, and the show to get one more season
From what I've heard the producers of the show hoped for more seasons but amazon didn't give them another one, which is a shame. I do believe amazon has more than enough money to pay for another season.
@@sebping7205 I get the feeling they would much rather spend their money on Jack Ryan and The Boys, which to be fair has had amazing success this year.
Gotta focus on The Boys. As much as I loved the acting in this show *(and think they’re criminally underrated)* compared to John Krasinski and Karl Urban, Rufus Sewell and Alexa Davalos are small potatoes.
@@jonasvestvold6470 That explains the pretty terrible ending to the last season at least
@@jonasvestvold6470 and the new series of lotr
I think, we can all agree, that this episode should be the real final episode
I agree. I think this should have been a season finale for the 4th season and they will come up with season 5 as the final season
@@hazri8758 I would instantly be in on that
in my book this is the final of the series, I don't count ep10.
No.
@@balabanasireti Why not?
"You have complete autonomy"
And then a few episodes later John is sad that he can't stop the camps. Even though his generals are so loyal they were willing to commit treason for him just a few episodes earlier.
In this episode he made massive moves, gained the power to fix everything, but he didn't use it. Instead he became passive for the rest of the series.
What episodes? There was only one last hastly rushed crappy season finale after this episode. They didn't let Smith be in his role as Reichsfuhrer long enough to do anything before killing him...
@@ReveredDead Yeah they really let this series slip...
The status quo had to be maintained. Until the US can stand against an entire Europe - he has to play the game.
@@ReveredDead Hitler doesn't like us Arizonans apparently.
@@desertdude8274 *In Steve Rogers' voice*: I understood that reference
"Heil Goertzmann" "Heil Smith"
End of the not last season
This scene was so good and then the next episode just derailed everything
Hahaha. I see what you did there.
@@migukmoonpark4312 no pun intended
I thought smith was going to turn a new leaf and liberate America. I hated the ending.
@@christo-gj1qk Honestly looked like he was going to takeover and basically reform the Reich or something
The next episode showed John Smith embraced being a Nazi. His entire attack plan was a carbon copy of the Nazis attacks. Making camps to kill the same people the Nazis did in MITHC
This was such a great finale. Too bad there's no more episodes after this one.
Not a single other episode. Not one.
Yeah. Though I have to admit, they should quit while they are ahead. This is a perfect way to end a season, or even a series! Let the viewer decide what happens after. Will Smith create his own version of the United States? Or will he enforce Nazism coast to coast?
@@haydricht6899 well, the thing is, it is HEAVILY implied that in the wake of John Smith's demise, William "Bill" Whitcroft became the defacto leader of Nazi America... but instead of furthering the regime, he used his power to reinstate the United States of America, as he was seen taking off a nazi medal after calling off an attack on the Black Communist Resistance, which means he had denounced Naziism. And who knows? Maybe after that, slowly, more of the allied powers start trickling back too, and could lead to the defeat of the central powers in this universe too. Who knows?
@@haydricht6899 He's just gonna slap the shit out of everyone while his wife pretends to not know him.
wtf does Will Smith have to do with any of this?@@haydricht6899
Why?
They divided the empire; it’s Rome all over again.
And the Eastern still survived lol
And we know how Rome ended...
We don’t know the state of the Reich. If the occupied territories of the Japanese Empire are rebelling, I could see the occupied Europeans take advantage of this chaos to rebel too.
History repeats it self !
That’s exactly what I was thinking.
You know I might be the only one here but I have to appreciate Hoover’s stoicism when being faced not only with his death but being stabbed in the stomach, that is incredibly painful. Props to him for taking it like a champ.
not sure why they didn't keep him though. He obviously was good at his job and they still needed him, not like he had anywhere else to go, and not much to gain by killing his new bosses.
@@failtolawl Will Given Context of What Real Hoover has done , He wouldnt be as Good of a person either
Ofc a Enclave soldier would say that.
@@failtolawl Smith would've been insane to keep Hoover alive.
@@failtolawl He had a reputation for betraying anyone if he stands to gain from it, not the kind of person you want around in the long run
Did Hoover seriously not learn his lesson? Never ever threaten John Smith's family if you value your life.
Draka Shrakenburg Productions ain’t that the truth
I think pretty much everyone that ever threatened his family ended up dead 😂😂😂 the only ones left were the ones who wanted him dead specifically
I guess it feels different when you don't actually get to see him push another man off a skyscraper with one hand.
They paid too much attention on the BCR. Should've delved into this coup, and what led both men to come to conclusion of taking their respective homeland on their own way.
I think this whole thing was fine the way it was because this huge twist was pretty satisfying. We think john is fucked but he once again bails himself out and becomes the king of America. Had we known this whole time then it would've had less of an impact
Marcos you really need an explanation into why they planned a coup? How about the fact it benefits them both? Jesus are you someone that needs baby details explained to them
Yup, all that BCR BS was a waste of time
@@rucajuda Fr bruh. Even being half black i dont really give two shits would rather see more development with goertzmann and smith. Would also love to see nazi britain, tokyo and more of the reich like africa would be awesome
BUT WOKENESS
This is one of the best scenes in season 4. A true masterpiece.
Like the Godfather.
the best turd in the toilet
What cap is??
Damn this scene depicts the analytical and persuasive mind of Jon Smith. His approach to tackle the direst of situations makes him a formidable person to reckon with. He changed the course of reality by joining forces against Himmler and plotted efficiently to not only kill him but take North America for himself. What a great diplomat. Amazing performance by Rufus.
But we must realize Rufus cut his acting chops on stuff like Shakespeare.... Stuff that would put me to sleep.... I thought it was such a sweet move, to stare into Hoover's eyes just as he twists the knife.... Revenge...
2:25 "This is getting out of hand! Now there's two of them!"
Ok, so what line is that from originally? It's driving me crazy. I can hear it in my head on a loop but cannot place it.
Seth Zwicker Star Wars Episode 1
@@Exodon2020 aha starwars Said by viceroy gunrays advisor
“What could be worse than a giant paint bubble?!” “Oh I know, TWO giant paint bubbles!”
WE SHOULD NEVER HAVE MADE THIS BARGIN!!!
Smith is such a good character that i began to side with him and hated the resistance. Wyatt is ok but Juliana is so boring
Nubwo wait we were supposed to side with the resistance? I sided with smith in like the second episode
BlakeKevin Gaming same lol and yeah, thats why the resistance won
the resistence here are complete jokes, to little motivation and BCR are complete mess, SJW took the script and made minority as a heroes but it too obvious and made the entire story are pointless beside only showing "justice" to minority. i mean its not bad showing equality but those ending make me drowned with dissapointment, from the beginning i always with smith side and hoping the ending are Smith could death by Nazi at war with interdimensional US or with japan but the reality is the last episode are the worst ever episode. 4 seasons ended with smith killed by equality shit
@@rcordh5657 I honestly thought the BCR could be a pretty cool faction but they had so little development.
Same here. For me This show ends with episode 9. I like to imagine Smith conquered NA and become great leader.
I love the fact that when you rewatch Season 4, you notice that what you might of saw as rivalry between Goertzmann and Smith was really a courting of the two. Basically "we both have enemies, let's be friends"
This show is such a masterpiece...I'm amazed to see it isn't that popular on you tube
It sucks that the final season ends like that.
@Manuel Camelo I'd report you for hate speech, but I don't want the clip to get deleted along with your stupid comment. disgusting mindset you have
Because it contains Nazis
@Manuel Camelo Alex is right, your comment is stupid.
@@Panzer_Runner lol like your mentality
I loved the show but the last season especially the last episode was so rushed it didn't make any sense in the end. While watching this scene(which is my favourite) I think the writers had plans for another season.
What if they don't?! I hope there are someone far more cunning than John Smith in the Natsoc Army.
Agreed-it was a great series until the last few minutes of the finale in particular.
the director i believe was being rushed to finished it because he got commissioned for another project, though normally I don't like this but the next project for him is for a IP that
I really love so I'm looking forward to it
Someone111ify not sure about Natsoc but I think they were clearly making this guy more cunning than Smith.
Daniyal Sulaiman Well, there’s no telling whether or not they’ll make a spin-off or a sequel series, there’s a LOT of potential available following the finale.
Yeah, I'm going, and suggest many people do the same, to pretend the show ended here. Himmler and Hoover dead, Smith in power, about to become the best leader of the American Reich could ever hope for. It's a much more satisfying ending than what we got in the so called finale.
Have you read the book? Because in the book version, it also had an open ending, aka cliffhanger.
Try Hard Actually, I'm referring to the predictable "good guys win" and John's death. That was the most disappointing thing to me.
@@thehightable5995 Suggest you read the book, because the producers tried very hard to follow in line what Philip K dick had intended for his unfinished sequel.
I feel you bro,I mean if the series ended with Episode 9 or let's say an episode 10 where John unify the US under one flag would have been a lot more satisfying
Lordo Demons Thank you for agreeing. That's exactly what I thought it would happen, but nope.
There is actual historical significance with the knife. It was given to high ranking Nazi officers and they where expected to kill someone with it who posed a threat to the state.
Very interesting information.
Thank you! :)
You made that up
@@jdools4744 not only to the state but a risk to personal honor. That knife is called the Ehrendolch (honor dagger). You can go and search that yourself
@@JunguianPhantom I know what it is retard I also know you weren't suppose to actually use it on anyone
That's so BS 😂
Tagomi's extremely early ending - Juliana not even thinking about or asking about Frank and Ed when she made it back to her world - The one year skip at the beginning of the season. But meh, I like the final season, even if it was rushed
I believe that initial intention was to make 5 seasons, so they had to speed up things x2 (which is a shame).
Nevertheless, one of the coolest TV series of recent years.
The Tagomi death to me felt like something you’d do if an actor died IRL, it was so out of place.. I wonder what’s the reason behind that because they could’ve at least have him there for one scene if not for some drama or cost cutting
Tagomi didn't die, his true master Shao Khan ordered him to prepare an invasion of the Nebenwelten.
They wantes one more season but didnt get it. There was supposed to be the whole case with the BCR and yakuza. Had to squeeze it down.
Tagomi was the best character of the fucking show and they killed him off screen. I overall liked Season 4 but that still puts a bitter taste in my mouth.
" You were a failed chicken farmer. "
Because Hoover ate all the chickens.
😂
Nah, the Hound eats all the f&#$king chickens in the room.
@@knight7se7en No, because Himmler was a chicken farmer before Nazis seized power in 1933.
Maciej Jarczyk: Not a Game Of Thrones fan, huh?
@@maciejjarczyk5244 r/woosh
Guys I'm so glad that I was able to share one of the best moments of this show with you, the Man in the High Castle community and I honestly belive that each one of us felt fulfilled to see how our favorite character,John Smith, finally reaching the top of the hierarchy after all this struggle.
Moving words my dude,same we want to thank you for posting those unforgetabale moments.You did a great job editing all those videos and providing us a great quality.Keep the good work up! :D
Heil Smith!!!!
errrr, sure!
Heil GotchManz
1:36 John Smith is a believer of both back and front stabs. He's an equal opportunity stabber.
This is the ending, there’s no more episodes after this
Yea this is a perfect ending
The end of this season was such a shame. A real disappointment for an otherwise very good season. It really felt rushed towards the end.
And here’s the thing... Smith was kinda the show's main character. Season 1 he was the antagonist. Season 2 and 3 he had become an antihero and by season 4 Juliana's arc had been so far relegated to the side, that Smith and Helen were constantly centre stage with the Japanese plot being the next most interesting. The show went out of its way to make clear that John was never a die-hard Nazi. Every deed and decision he’d ever made he’d done for his family. The tragedy of his character was supposed to be that he could only go upwards onto ever more shaky ground, or come crashing down with his wife and kids' fates in the balance.
To all of a sudden take a 180 with his character feels so cheap and forced to me. Why is he going full steam ahead with plans for Holocaust.3.0 when he and his family are safe? Because he “didn’t know how” to stop it? Really!? But his mate, Bill, could turn the planes around with a single order and publicly throw away his badge? Not to mention that’s terribly unrealistic for a nation where significant portion of the population are extremely indoctrinated and at least half the top military staff in the American Reich are still die-hard Nazis.
This needed another fucking season. We should’ve had John lose his sanity over Thomas and kidnap him. It would’ve made for great storytelling. If the writers wanted to drum up the “Absolute power corrupts absolutely” trope, they could’ve... but not in half a bloody episode! Way to butcher 4 seasons worth of character development in 30 fucking minutes.
:(
Indeed perhaps there is another alternate version after the scene maybe he takes His family what’s left of them to the other place in this becomes another ground moment diversion
As I said...they messed with John's arc in the end.
Authoritarian states also hold their rulers captive , if they ease up on repression they will be killed in a coup or an uprising. They don't have the power to change course on whim.
Bill DeBerger Exactly. Making Bill's actions even more nonsensical.
I mean, the power corrupts absolutely trope with John has been going on for the entire show arguably with John. And at the start of the season, alt-john talks about how he hated himself in the military and what it made him, it strongly implied that John having so much power leads to horrible and grave things.
"You have complete autonomy"... this is where the portal opened and a universe of endings were possible. Sadly, the writers chose the wrong one.
I know it's based on the novel and all, but I think this show would have been a lot better solely as an alternate history without the alternate universe.
Agreed. Leave the films as mere propaganda and take out the nazi science bs
@@userseveneleven It just feels like a missed opportunity, I would have liked to see the state of the entire world, not just New York, San Francisco, Denver and Berlin. But unfortunately the studios are still trying to recreate Lost.
yeah agree truly
Yes, and it's not even close to the novel, if I remember correctly.
@@generalripper7528 correct, I haven’t watched the show but from this little scenes I have seen a couple things.
One: the black communist rebellion
Two: The Eastern United States. The American Reich was never talked about.
Three: In the book Canada is the last free nation.
Four: The Portal to OTL
It appears as though Goertzmann and Smith did more in their military training than simply spend "Years at the military academy just to learn how to hold a knife and fork."
This scene was unreal, wish this season had ended here and one last season:(
No.
@@balabanasireti shut up
Same. The fact that John dies in the next ep ruined it for me. He was the only good character. Waaaay better than Juliana
@@arthurmorgan3823 Agreed. Juliana was just a whore who screwed so many people, ruined peoples lives, got people killed and used people to achieve her own goals. Smith had his family, Frank had Ed and Childan. All she did this entire show was use people and by season 3 I hated her greatly.
@@arthurmorgan3823 I believe saying he was the ONLY good character is a bit too much. Kido was FANTASTIC, so was Tagomi and maybe Frank
I really liked SS major general Kreutzmann, he was really fun to watch I wish they had more of him. Damn I missed this show, it’s too bad they ended it like they did but that’s what has been happening a lot lately with really good shows
This whole scene keeps making me think of the "Night of the Long Knives" event.
that's exactly what i said after Eichmann i think mentioned knives
Seeing this comment made me happy. This is what came to my mind.
That's exactly what's being mirrored here
He really fit the role perfectly. John Smith is just a badass. The uniform looks cool af too
The piano riff from Verrater that comes back as they're dividing the Reich makes this scene. Talk about an amazing musical motif
Rufus Sewell is an amazing actor. He was able to portray the character Smith as a complex, conflicted man you could never quite figure out. I think this made the series and Smith was the main character as far as I was concerned. The resistance and Julianna were boring side trips compared to the conflict in Smith's soul. They should have carried this through for the final season or ended it with this episode.
Fantastic scene. Thoughts on the ending: it's not so much the ending I have a problem with, as how there wasn't a chance for everything that happened between this scene and the last one in episode 10 to be fleshed out. It certainly feels like there was a considerable time gap that would have made a fantastic season 5, with so much content to play with (e.g. Kido with the Yakuza, BCR establishing an independent nation, better understanding inter-dimensional travel, John potentially returning to our world). Sad that a fifth season wasn't ordered.
Amazon was going to cancel the show, so they had to craw two season's worth of content into one, which is why it felt so rushed near the end. Good ideas and a fascinating plotline, but it kinda fell flat due to the time constraints. Still, loved the show overall
Hoover never learned the childhood lesson of not being a tattle tail.
"Hippity hoppity, the Reich is now our property"
Lv.1 Crook
Lv.30 Reichführer
That's how High Castle works
0:09
Right guy: "Heil."
Left guy: "That way."
I literally skipped every Juliana cranes scene in this season only to watch this man . It's such a shame what they did to him. For me he is the protagonist, the one who carried this show.
When you and your mate kill everyone so now you're bored and waiting for other players to spawn.
What a delicious scene! He looked him in the eye, it was the very last thing Hoover saw!
Man that was a productive meeting, Goertzmann really has a way with words!
Episode 9 ending was a million times better than a season finale.
Loved this show but I was very upset that Rommel never appeared nor they never looked into another fascinating aspect. In OTL the reason that Operation Valkyrie was able to go into action by the Anti-Nazi movement inside Germany was the disaster at the front. In this timeline those officers, largely Wehrmacht and Kriegsmarine, would have to keep their hatred of the Nazi’s hidden for decades. The show could’ve established an underground cabal of the Anti-Nazi movement teaming up with the Resistance.
I feel this scene could’ve ended even better during the genuine meeting if Rommel had been present, retired as he is, because Himmler wanted his input. Instead the Desert Fox launches his own Anti-Nazi coup in coordination with the Resistance, would that not make an even more brilliant cliff-hanger ending. Just a fade out from Smith’s face his expression set in stone cold shock
Well, if you're name-dropping Rommel, I'm forced to name-drop Michael Wittmann. Although, most of Wittmann's military accomplishments were near the end of the war historically, which this alternative universe never touched on, right?
Rommel is mentioned early in the season as the first reichsmarshall of of north america accepting pattons surrender. i think the only nod to him in this universe sadly
Rommel wasn’t anti-Nazi. He was very close to Hitler and there was no evidence he was actually involved in the July 20 Plot.
this entire season is a joke, had nothing to do with the story for the previous 3 seasons.
Just no, Secret Germany would be nice but no name dropping Rommel. He liked Hitler. Also the Valkyrie planners were not good people, they were still nazis and believed in the nazi philosophy. They just wanted to end Hitler and the war in the west so they could focus on the Soviet Union and the Slavs/Jews
They left so many plot holes in the final episode.
Such as? No everything unexplained is a plot hole, but I'd be curious what bothered you most.
@@LostieTrekieTechie probably the end where a bunch of people came out of that portal
More like big ones. The number of plot holes is no that huge.
if it is not the last season then those can hopefully be explained in the next one but since this is the last..... this ending sucks
@@LostieTrekieTechie ... are you serious?
John Smith look at Hoover just says --- "I've been waiting to do this... "ALL FU%^KING DAY'...."
Well Goertzmann was more useful and strategic than Harry Strickland was
I thought I saw him before...
Was I the only one that was shocked when watching this?
Eu também !
Easily the best moment of the entire season I loved every second of this. Also goes to show the writers definitely have favorites seeing as how John is the best developed character in the show. It helps Rufus Sewell was also the best actor in this thing.
I could not fucking believe my eyes. I was laughing hysterically. What an amazing plot twist, and I never even remotely saw it coming!
They had so much opportunity to dive further into this storyline of Smith ruling America under his terms. I was legitimately surprised when the next episode was queued after this scene. Helen deserved to get an opportunity to see the portal, Childan to see his wife after making deal with the Yakuza, and the resistance getting more time to build an actual militia. I hope the writers fix this by adding one more season, especially when the ending made zero sense
This show was a nonsense shit show from the start. The ending was rushed
@@Excalibur01 stfu
Seeing Hover in any reality stabbed is deeply satisfying
H M 😄😄 Savage
1 problem: Rudolf Hess and Keitel still live in this universe!
As an aside, you gotta love the overhead light and 'big board' homage to Kubrick
This final episode was one of the most mind-blowing cliffhanger I've ever seen!!
Give Hoover this much he didn't beg or show fear in the end, didn't even cry out in pain. By Viking law, that means he can enter Valhalla.
"Gentlemen, you can't fight in here, this is the War Room!"
I love that one of the troops that salutes John Smith was placing a lamp neatly back onto a table when John Smith first enters the room.
In this episode, its like watching history repeat itself; this is something that happened with the Roman Empire when it was divided into 2 sections, with the West and the East.
If the series had ended here. What do you think would have happened down the line?
@@Spartain14 Just like in our history, the Western Roman Empire collapsed not long after the final divide. I think with how it was looking in America, I think it would have happened the same. Europe is in this case the Eastern Roman Empire and it would survive unlike America, though it will try to reclaim America like the Eatsern Roman Empire did though succeeding only partially before loosing the territory again. I personally think the Nazis in Europe would last much longer than in America but I also think it would collapse too at a later date since America, Japan or even internal political issues like we saw in America could lead to its downfall.
Alexander Anderson Yes but unlike the Roman Empire, in this universe Nazis have accomplished a much more consistent infrastructure, system and economic structure, their army is in good shape and they have no real powerful enemies. This Empire would maybe have collapsed as well, but in a much longer time spam.
@@DavidGonzalez-ff6yk let's not get too picky with the details as it is only just alternative history. However, the Roman Empire, especially the Eastern Empires weakness was internal struggle. I think that internal struggle and political turmoil would most likely cause the collapse of the Third Reich.
@@DavidGonzalez-ff6yk having no more powerful enemies can be a huge threat to any empire that is based on military conquest. Sooner or later, officers get bored and they start trying to leverage their influence on political conflicts. It's what happened in the final days of the Roman Empire, generals started using the command of legions as a political crowbar
I love how Amazon will not openly state that this show was cancelled, yet after 3 solid well thought out seasons, suddenly you get the mess that is season 4 and then it's over.....
There was not a single moment in this series that Smith was not working some kind of angle. A truly devious and devilish man and great series character.
The whole premise of the Axis powers winning ww2 is brilliant. The ultimate what if scifi story. Kudos to Phillip K Dick for imagining this, and to the markers of this TV Series to stay true to his vision. And how about that eerily haunting version of Edelweiss as the theme song.
First time watching this tv show in 2021 and binge watched all four seasons within a few weeks and wow I’ve never thought I’d feel so much empathy towards a nazi, John smith was amazing father and only wanted the best for his family. To see to sides to every coin makes a person question there own decisions in life for what could have been
One of the best scenes of the whole show in my opinion
Too bad they ruined the rest of it
@@Excalibur01 Sadly :(
@@TWWIW Dedicated fanfiction is better than this crap
I loved this scene. It was scary in many ways the power dynamic shifts. But in a single stroke it was functionally two autonomous entities within the same Empire.
2 power brokers after a flawless bloodletting. Mr. Dick probably enjoyed this bit of cinematography!
Hoover is just standing there thinking how fast this all stopped going according to plan.
lmao "that escalated quickly"
The long knife used by smith. The symbolism to the "Night of the Long Knives".
Goertzmann: Our deal stands?
Smith: I am altering the deal, PRAY I don't alter it any further...
That's REALLY good cinematography. Smith is struggling while Hoover just stands there motionless, taking his killing. The supposed victor portraying weakness.
It would be perfect if the show ended in this scene.
I know it's like the main part of the show, but I dont think this show would suffer much if the fantastical portal/universes just weren't apart of the plot. If it was literally just an alternate world plain and simple and John was more of a conflicted protagonist.
One of the best scenes in the entire series. I am as surprised as you guys are at how Smith and his loyal agents took control. Smith certainly earned my respect.
#HailSmith
One of my favorite scenes of all time.
I really wished Amazon had dumped a little more money into the show for a 5th season. This episode just hyped everything up to the max and the last episode just kinda screwed things up. If this had been the ending to Season 4 and then Season 5 came along to wrap things up it would've been fantastic.
John's story being revealed about how he only joined the Reich to save his family and slowly climb the ranks to ensure their safety while never being a true Nazi was great. It would've been so much more satisfying if he had been the one to get rid of the Nazi ideals and return America to it's former glory after taking power. Bill mentions the nuclear Arsenal that America had access to so if America went to war against Berlin in a fight for the restoration of America, then that would've made an amazing Season 5.
Instead, he goes full steam ahead for another round of the Holocaust which feels totally backwards from the development of his entire character. Maybe he could go to war with the west and take control of the neutral zone and the west coast and THEN restore America or he could just forget those entirely and restore what he already has control over. Just going Hitler 2.0 wasn't great storytelling. I guess the actual ending to the show wasn't awful, but it could've been so much better.
Basically, if I could have it my way it would be:
1) End Season 4 with the coup
2) Season 5 is about John rejecting Nazi ideals and restoring America back to itself again
3) Either John captures the Neutral Zone and the West Coast or just crushes the BCR and friends and forgets about them
4) When John starts to restore America, Berlin gets angry and war happens
5) Ending determines whether John succeeds or fails in the end
Sorry for the long essay I just love this show so much LOL
This show really needed 2 more seasons and would have been amazing.
You could see the ideas they wanted to flesh out more but couldn't
Imagine if john abandoned the nazi symbol and reestablished the southern confederacy now going against the bcr or new afrika in the west, and the show ends with fall of japanese empire totally.
If any of this happened in real life I guarantee that the ending of this series would be entirely different. The Japanese got nuked twice and still wanted to continue fighting the war. Really don’t think a couple of minor terrorist attacks would be enough convince the Japanese government to evacuate the pacific states. The Nazis on the other hand were ruthless with indefinite hunger for victory. WW2 they literally fought until the last man was standing. If they were a arms reach away from taking over an entire continent a leadership assassination wouldn’t do anything. Next person in line would step up and take the job. Realistically speaking it would be a divided empire like Rome. More than likely that’s how the story would’ve ended.
Japan was tied down with a war in china. The pacific states provided resources but should have a been a tributary state with a puppet govt not directly under Japans thumb. Japan in OTL had no interest in a occupation of the US they wanted to force the US to the peace table so they could get control of oil supplies.
Japan in real life wouldn't be able to occupy all that territory. Also in history there has been many instances where assassinations and purges worked pretty well just look at Rome. Also Nazi America separating from the German Nazi Reich would make sense since Nazi America is a nuclear armed power of its own reclaiming it would mean nuclear war.
Yeah, but in real life Germany wouldn’t bother trying invade or control America. The suspense of disbelief is already stretched out way too far.
No empire lasts forever, ever.
Japan is more ruthless in governing than Nazi German
That is why The west did not depict japan as Evil state While Asia Make Hitler Role Model As Idol or inspiration..Hitler and German Army is Really Populer in Asia
This show really took me into its world in the beginning. It was so cool to see an alternative world. It was like learning something new in each episode since you really ARE new to this world as a watcher of the series. Things are different.
In the beginning the characters were really interesting. Learning about Joe, John - than stories like Wegeners, where he tried to become a traitor.
The thing is, in the beginning each and every story and the plot twists behind them were believeble and made sense. Where in the end it was just like "yeah... oh and John finessed them all btw, they are all dead".
Seasons 1-3 were so cool. Even stories like the romance between Joe and Nicole Dörmer. It really gave you an inside of what living in this world was like, not because it was massively relevant to the story, but that was what made that show for me.
Epicness of seeing those huge Nazi-monuments in Berlin like the Volkshalle and than of course the replacement of the statue of liberty. Those were great scenes. This show really had something utterly unique to it. Seeing further Nazi-technology like the plains or the VTOL ships. The cinematic shots that it had were awesome.
And than season 4 came. Season 3 was getting kinda meh with them writing Tagomi out of the story but it was still good, nothing to complain about that much, but than that damn fourth season came...
Lets keep it short; wokeness killed this series.
BCR appearing, wearing not only plot-armour but rather sitting in a plot-deathstar.
BCR: "Dude lets plant some bombs to give them a hard time"
Japanese empire: "Nah, fuck america ... we fought the biggest war of all time to make it here and culturized half of the US but nah, lets get out of here"
On the other side of the story - the portal bunker was unconquerable as Himmler stated but apparently some para-military resistance warriors are able to storm it all in like half an hour.
This is the most disappointing end of a series that Ive ever watched. Game of Thrones was rushed and I was not satisfied at all but THIS ... I wasnt even disappointed, I was just sad.
We knew that it would come since the only thing that season 4 was lacking was the lgbtq-resistance-rainbow army riding down to Berlin on unicorns but come on. What a great show it was in the beginning and how much potential it had before things turned sideways somewhere in season 3.
For me, they couldve left out the whole parallel-universe sci-fi stuff. I just liked the scenario of the axis having won WW2 and seeing the outcome of it all. Things like Joes father designing that damm that was supposed to be built across the mediterranean sea. I was looking forward to see Africa and Europe as 3. Reich versions. Like I said in the first few sentences - viewing things that arent from our world. But they killed that idea quickly and the show went to shit. I dont know man, such waste. *mic drop*
Your comment honestly speaks for pretty much how I felt about his whole series when I watched it a few months ago. This series was one of my favorite tv shows ever when I watch the first two seasons. I genuinely believe that if Amazon gave the series 1 or 2 more seasons and Frank Spotnitz didn’t leave the show, this series would have been legendary.
This is the real ending to The Man in the High Castle.
The cinematography in this scene is brilliant.
"Blut und Ehre" - What do you want to lose first..?
This show, right up through this scene, made you realize empathize with Smith, a fucking Nazi. That's not a small feat. After season one, where he is the antagonist, he becomes the main character in the second season (which was by far the best) and you really begin to sympathize with his willingness to do anything to keep his family safe. And season three and four make it clear that although he has lost himself in the Nazi order, that he was clearly never a devoted Nazi.
I'm not sure Smith needed a "redemption arc" and (for obvious reasons) I can see why the writers would have hesitated to give him one, but he deserved a more concrete end of his story than 'Sorry wife, I just don't know how to stop the mass murder of millions of people' even after he has succeeded in making his family untouchable and his word is essentially law. And this came only a handful of episodes after he was in tears talking to the Alt version of his Jewish friend in the Alt-verse, apologizing for letting him die. How could that Smith return to his universe and instantly start planning to build more death camps? Obviously the show was fucked up by Amazon 'lite-cancelling' the show, and just telling the team to wrap it up, but it ruined 4 seasons of character development of Smith. Hell, I feel like if they at least told them 4 was the last season from the get-go, they could have written Smith to start to appear MORE fanatically Nazi than we ever thought, showing the audience that he was too far gone. Like, how do you include the season with his Jewish friend and expect us to believe he then wants to murder a few million more Jews? Shouldn't he have, like, spat in the guys face if he "doesn't know how to stop?" But it honestly feels like they had filmed 90% of the season and then some bureaucrat popped his head in the door and said "Uh, guys, the shows cancelled, so... like, can you shoot a few more scenes and just wrap it up?"
And I won't even get into the last scene with the portal. Unintelligible nonsense. So disappointing.
This was the ending in season 4 for me. Such a cool and great scene that would be ideal for a season ending or even series ending.
I loved this scene. The last one I liked. I wish it ended like this. After everything that John Smith survived such an unsatisfactory ending for his character.
This show is absolutely a masterpiece.
Que buena escena. Cuando la ví me puso la piel de gallina!!!
Great scene for sure, put the element of surprise into the show like hell.
Nevertheless, I am the only one wondering why only 5 guards stationed front of Himmler room?
How Smith was able to put his own men into Berlin's most securely guarded building?
The soundtrack is amazing
Aw, what an absolute mate, sharing the Riech with one of the lads
Best scene of the whole fcking series!
In all respects Hoover worked diligently for his bosses and did a job quite well. I would have hired Hoover considering he would have nowhere else to go. Sun Tzu tactic in a sense.
Love this scene, John Smith is the best character of the serie.
The Season 4 recaps actually make me want to watch the show.