Silver MAPLES or silver BRITANNIAS?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ก.ย. 2024
- Silver maple leaves and the silver Britannias are two of the best coins to buy and the stacking community agrees. In this video I’m going over the pros and cons of both to see who comes out on top.
Disclaimer- I am not a financial advisor, I’m just a guy passionate about gold, silver and numismatics, please do not make any purchases or sales based on my videos. What I say in this video is just my opinion.
#silver #silverstacking #coins #silvercoins #silvercoin #gold #junksilver #goldcoins
The Brittania design is my second favorite next to the libertad.
That’s saying something!
Ooof that’s a tough choice. Like them both! Let’s call it a tie!
No cheating! You have to pick 🤣
Maples for neighboring convenience&denomination
Brits for aesthetic
Smart
What’s smarter are Washington quarters compared to silver dollars
Is like 6 : 1, gain 50%face
Maple Leaf. It’s just a beautifully designed coin with great detail and a sheen that just sets it off.
That seems to be the popular choice!
Thanks for the video man! Still say maples! Both great, but with a choice, maples. 9999, radial lines, security. Just pretty
Thanks for watching brother! I’m with ya on the maples
Man I can almost feel folks cringing while you’re holding your knife close to those coins. 😊
Good video. Thanks for sharing with us.
Me:
1 - Maple
2 - Britannia
🫡
Upmost cut myself twice 🤣
So I was watching a video on UK Stacking- Britannias make a ton more sense for them to stack! Generic silver they have to pay VAT and I believe a "capital gains tax" when they go to sell them.
I recently started picking up Britannias after completing my first full Maple tube.
We do all of the above yet coins are cools bars are cool to.
Ok that makes way more sense
So yes in the uk we have VAT on silver unlike gold although on royal minted coins ( not bars ) gold and silver is capitals gains tax free which when we come to sell with hopefully profit we keeps all the money
Thank you!!!
@@robertclarkson6064 thank you for watching!
I’m trying to complete a tube of each, I’m about halfway with both. I love the simple look of the Maple, but love the intricacies of the Brit.
Great content! 🙌🏾
Thanks brother! They are both beautiful coins, maples are ahead by a little for me though
Maples always win these debates, but I'm a loyal stacker of $2 and under premium Britannias.
Maple usually win but you can’t go wrong with either
I’m in the UK, so Britannia for me as it is exempt from CGT when sold. I like the 2024 collaboration Britannia by the US and Royal Mint which features Lady Liberty and Lady Britannia.
Those are very cool coins! I have yet to pick any up
Maple leaf is my favorite. But how I buy is. I get what is on sale. Try to get my coins under 2 dollars over spot. My local store had kangaroos for 1.99 a spot. I loaded up on that. Maple leafs was 2.49 over spot couple weeks ago. I got half a tube. And 2024 Britannias was 1.99 over spot couple weeks ago on jm bullion. I belong to a coin club and they have really good silent auction and the treasury is my silver guy. He charges me 1.50 over spot. Any size bars.
$1.50 over spot is great!
If I could only choose one I’d choose the maple cause I’m Canadian and I love the mint shield. But luckily I can own both and I do!
Can’t go wrong with getting both 😉
The Spanish Toro gold coin (Spanish Mint) has a design like the Britanna where the security feature changes 3 times when you tilt it. Really cool
Changes 3 times?! Gotta look into this
@@StatesideStash youtube lol
@@jamesitsines6890 no better place lol
@@StatesideStash sent u a link 4 design changes!
Hey Mr. Stateside, I'd like to request a video on the Pressburg Mint. They are insanely intricate, and the premiums aren't too bad.
I can do that!
I just picked up one of the Britannia and Liberty coins and they are very nice.
That the collaboration coin? Very cool design!
Not sure about it’s origin, collaboration or what🤷🏻
@@rogerlester4446 yep it’s a collaboration coin done by the royal mint. Cool coins!
Great Video!
Thanks Kevin!
From across the pond.
Just to confirm another posters point Britannias are captial gains tax free, VAT is paid on it. Gold legal tender is CGT free and VAT free. So selling wise Britannia coins . The other coins l believe are treated as bullion coins so taxes apply.
I'm new to this but hope that helps?
Absolutely helps! Thank you for clarifying and watching!
Geez, I have no problem with the monarchs on the back of the Canadian or Perth Mint coins. I made sure I got both versions but Elizabeth's my gal!
Wish they would of just kept the young version of her with the crown
@@StatesideStash If you were able to get the coins made every year she was queen you would see that she ages on the coins as the years go by. Get a coin from, say, 1959 and she looks like a very young girl.
@@Farbar1955 no I understand I just wish they wouldn’t of aged her
Dropping a coin makes the video official. I only buy 2018 to present Maples.
Gonna drop a coin in every video then lol
I have both in my stack. They are both beautiful coins. You just can't beat anti milking and 4, 9's. Maple leafs are my favorites.
Maples are an excellent choice
I'd take the Bars (RCM and RM) over those 2 coins any day. The Britannias milkspot but cool design. The main reason is I do not want Monarchs on my metals... God bless America!
Just wish we could make bars 😢
You own any Perth mint coins?
@@StatesideStash No Monarchs, I gave them away for birthday presents :) Only rounds are Zombucks. Coins ASEs and Libertads and 90%.
I get not wanting monarchs on your coins but I kind of like it. Makes it feel historic. I have old coins with queen Victoria, king Edward VII, king George V, King George VI, queen Elizabeth II and now King Charles. I think that’s pretty cool.
Britannias all the way! I just wish they would develop some anti milk spotting technology like the maples.
I’m not sure why they haven’t yet. I feel like if they fixed the milk spot problem more people would buy
I really like the Libertad too
The libertad is my favorite!
I stack mostly maples, as far as coinage, but I did spring for two 10oz Britannias and they are gorgeous.
Both of the bars are stunning. Just like the coins you can’t go wrong
good video.
mostly maples
but I'd go for the Mexican now, that and US junk, Fthe5eyes countries
The libertad is BEAUTIFUL
Maple baby .9999 localally mined and sourced, the smart answer is any silver that isn't a American silver eagles.
Maples are the best to stack as of right now
Another great vid bud , as they say everyday is a school day
Thanks brother! I learn something new every day myself
I prefer the maple, but if the Brit is cheaper, then that’s my choice
Can’t go wrong either way
Neither for me. I admit the backs look great and the security features are great as well, but the fronts suck!
You don't like king charlie's turkey neck?
Totally understandable! I try and look past it but it’s difficult 🤣
@@punkhillbilly3869 haha turkey neck 🤣
"It ain't cool being no jive turkey so close to Thanksgiving." Best line from the movie Trading Places.
@@punkhillbilly3869 🤣🤣
I’ve gotten 2024 Brittanias that have massive milk spots on them, if they could fix that I would stack mostly Brit’s but I won’t buy them anymore because of that, maples are the safest way to go, even new eagles spot, I’d say about 25% of my new silver eagles have milk spots right out of the box, sucks .
I have noticed that with the new eagles as well which is unfortunate
I have several of both coins.
Same here! Great choice!
If the Britania had milk spot protection, I would choose the Britania mainly because of the overall look. I like the figure over the maple leaf and the security features of the Britania are cool. I have both.
I have both also but definitely have more maples
I’m an ASE guy but I started stacking them at $18 ea. Too pricey nowadays.
$18 would be amazing
I prefer Britannias in gold and maples in silver. 100% of my silver Britannias have milk spotted.
That’s a solid answer!
Being Canadian, it was easier to stack Maples. In fact, my first silver purchase was converting silver certificates that my parents left me into Maples. All of my sovereign mint bars are also from the RCM. Having said that, I wish I’d purchased a few of the Britannia bars just to have the variety since they have an amazing design. As for Britannia coins, I have a tube of 1oz and one 10oz coin.
Both beautiful coins but I’d have to go maples. You like the 10oz coin?
@@StatesideStash
Yeah, it’s definitely got better defined details. I’ve also got a couple of 10 oz maples. The reason I even considered the 10 oz coins was just variety. The premiums at the time weren’t much higher than bars or rounds and I had been stacking hard for 2 years so I was looking for something a little different
@@phil6926 I’ve been thinking about picking up some 10oz maples
Don’t pick just one, get them both. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
No that’s cheating!!! Pick one 🤣
Maples are so much nicer looking. But i love that the Britannias have more security features. But im choosing Maples every day. And im from the UK. Maples are one of my favs!
They are both incredible coins but agreed I’m gonna have to go with the maples
Milk spotted maples. Silver is silver. Milk spots are a security feature. At least one libertad boob coin just for laughs lol
Just like how wear is a security feature for junk silver
Maples of course. They're recognized everywhere. Though, if I lived in Europe I'm sure I'd get the Brittani.
Yeah stacking can change based on location
Definitely the maple our neighbors to the north 2nd only to the Eagles.
Agreed!
Maples. My Britannias all turned into British Milk Maids 😡
It’s a common problem 😢
@@StatesideStash RCM just released their High Relief Maple.
@@tomtharos4440 I want one!
Definitely my two favourite government minted coin designs. I love this specific topic, and I'm glad to hear your input on them. As a Canadian stacker, I obviously have a bias for the Maples. Secondarily I stack Britannia's. :) I would probably stack more stuff from the USA, but my eyes find the commonwealth coins much prettier. ;)
Maple leafs are beautiful and I do enjoy the Britannias. I only use to stack ASEs till the premiums got outrageous
@@StatesideStash totally don't blame ya. I'd stack ASEs if maples here had the same crazy premiums. :) I'd honestly like an AGE, but our silly laws would do sales tax on them I believe. Oh well.
@@HushedDeath we need to end taxes
@@StatesideStash STATESIDE FOR PRESIDENT!!! ;D
@@HushedDeath I’m running in 2028!!!!
I own both, but since 2018 the maples don't milkspot
Exactly!
ASE 'S for the best security, but Germania Mint is the best looking , just kidding on the ASE 'S
Ok when I first read “best security” my jaw dropped 🤣
I’m picking maples but want to get a tube of the Brittannia’s just bc 🤷♂️
Do it!
I prefer the reverse on the Britannia but with their milkspotting issues and the fact both have monarchs on them, I would probably pass on both unless I could get them for a really good price. Three of my ancestors didn't fight in 1775 for me to buy rounds with kings and queens on them.
Fair enough!
Maple Leaf .
Same!
Great info, thank you
Thanks for watching man!
I’ll take the MintShield RCM 4 9’s over the RM 3 9’s but both are very good
Like you said, both are solid choices
Britannias, especially the alternative designs
Like on the bars?
@@StatesideStash look at the different designs from 1998-2011, the Britannia changes many times. The maple, not so much.
@@rasbobbo I have several with the snake privy on the side
@@StatesideStash the first one I bought was a 2022, I think. Looked like all the other Brits in design so I figured it was the standard like the eagle, maple, Noah’ ark, etc. Then I found a ‘99 with Britannia driving a chariot. Research had to be done. Another thing is they were .958 until 2012 - Britannia silver.
Love this video. Now this is what I call silver porn. 🤣
I definitely grab more Maples due to the lower price, but I still equally love the Britannias despite the milk spotting.
They are both awesome! The milk spotting on the Britannia just puts the maple a little ahead for me
Weird i just ordered one of each. Maple is 100x better. My brit came with terrible milkspots was actually a bit pissed about it when it arrived and the place just brushed it off like it was normal.
This has been the common trend I’ve been hearing from people is how bad the milk spots are
two beautiful coins
Yes they are!
Maples all the way
Right there with ya!
cool bars
Thank you!
Britannias milk spot BADLY! And then it looks so ugly
Milkspotting looks aweful 😢
I like them both, but being Canadian I’d have to go with the Maple. The monarchy situation isn’t the best, but you can’t have it all sometimes.
Well said and like I pointed out I have to look past it and look at it for being silver
@@StatesideStash another thing about being Canadian, is that we’ve had Queeny on our coins for my entire life. I guess I’m kind of desensitized to the old girl.
@@Randy-MacDonald haha yeah you probably don’t even think of it now 🤣
Not to many people like him:-/ I know I don’t!! Who knows what happen to Diana. :-/
I’ve never forget seeing my mom cry when the news broke she died
Gold..
Gold maple or gold Britannia?
I buy both!
Can’t go wrong there!
I'm going to stick with ASEs because 'Merica. But if I had to choose, it would be the Maple Leaf. "That other guy on YT." 2 is 1?
Yeah 🤣 him and his damn cool knifes!
You like the type 1 or type 2 eagle most?
@@StatesideStash I'm on the fence. I just started stacking in January, so all I have is 2024, i.e. type 2's. I like the type 1's but it's purely a matter of price for me.
@@bhoward9378 ah I Gotchya!
Maple 🍁 💯
Agreed!
My stack is heavy with both. also plenty of kangaroos. All with the king and queen.
Can’t go wrong with anything Perth mint
the face of the monarch is the obverse not the reverse...granted...should maybe be considered the reverse
I know I’ve said it 1,000 times and still screwed it up 🤣
I get a bit confused with the Eastern Caribbean Central Bank coin produced by Scottsdale Mint. They have the queen's face on them. Are numismatic or semi numismatic or just generic rounds? I have all 3, maples, Britannia, and the island coins.
Are you talking about the Barbados coins?
Canada wins I think.
I think the RCM just is over all better
The king or queen are on the front (obverse), not the back (reverse).
I know I always say the wrong thing when I’m talking in videos 🤣 thanks man
3:57 - The Britannias are 999, not 4x9s... the Maples and the Australian coins are actually 9999.
You are absolutely correct. Thank you for catching that
The gold is 9999 so it was stupid of me to assume the silver was too
No king Charles for me, only queen Elizabeth 👑 I like both.
I can’t stand Charles 🤣
Great informative video!!!
Loved to see the current comparison between two of my favourite coins!🫡
Would love to hear what you think about Philharmonics?🤔
They’re the only other silver coins I collect, love the European look, and how they’re isn’t the face of a leader on either side, I also like how it’s unique without having ridges on the end.
You’re not gonna like my opinion on the philharmonic 😬 I do like the unique part that it has no reeded edge though
Fair enough, they’re definitely not for everyone.👍
@@alphageekspeaks9248 that’s the beauty of silver though! We all get to stack what we enjoy!
i have 1 tube of brits and am working on a 2nd tube of maples , have 6 tubes of ase
That’s a solid stack!
@@StatesideStash i have over 700 oz
@@iamwhoiam105 you’re well past what most own. Congratulations!
@@StatesideStash working towards 1000 and 5 ounces of gold
@@iamwhoiam105 that’s a great gold! Bars or mostly coins?