Play Conflict of Nations for FREE on PC or Mobile: 💥 con.onelink.me/kZW6/WYNGX01 Receive 13K GOLD & 1 month premium subscription, only available for the next 30 days!
@@remryu2 i mean why would they do that in the first landing hell they could have just belly landed that plane easily once it was already onthe ground. what a m0r0n.
Your explanation is so good that even My 7 year old cousin concluded "maybe the pilot was also flying with a fake licence but to protect the airline's dignity they hid the truth"
What makes it most interesting is the fact that more than 150 pilots of PIA were found having fake licenses in 2020 fake license scandal in Pakistan. In this shitty country where federal education minister was found having a fake degree, where pilots can buy licenses with money and where they can get hired to pilot an Airbus just by giving $2-3000 is ironic and highly despicable. The bastards living in this country are bound to be doomed, always.
this was such a hard watch like they had SO many chances to save the plane yet they ignored it all, and there was literally no communication between the captains 😭
There is a quote in Pakistan: "You are elder statesman so you are right". There is 25 year age gap between co pilot and the captain. So obviously this was bound to happen. Captain thought as if he was Captain America
@@ak09168 in situations like these, elders should not be in control at all. Their mental capacity is way lower than someone esp 25 yeas younger than them. Human cultures and superstitions have really ruined us, our politicians, leaders etc are all above the average life span 300 years ago, there's a reason why nature naturally used to eliminate us as we hit that point, just cuz medicine is advanced doesn't means its natural. Stop giving important positions to oldies wth
@@RehanMohyuddin that behaviour was also the reason for a Korean air crash in San Francisco. Cultural practices of not questioning the older person even when they are wrong is common in many asian countries. That is why the rules were updated to cockpit personnel being expected to follow cockpit rules , not culture, and start on CRM procedures. Let's hope that prevents further loss of life. So near, yet so far - such a tragedy.
@@RehanMohyuddin listen there is no wrong with respecting elders and i do agree with respecting elders. but as an elder who seen lot in your life you should know that in some cases you can be wrong and someone young then you can be right even if you worked in the same industry for more time than others. I saw many cases when elder think just because they are old they are right and youngsters who didn't see as much as life as them are always wrong one. the reason we respect elders is not because they are old because they are wise and they saw more hardships than youngsters and probably make right decision when faced hardship. again respect everyone not just elders but just because you are older than others doesnt make you are right. sometimes learn to accept that you as elder can make mistake but again i dont think they would because of ego like how can someone younger than me take back to me? only i do the taking .
I remember that day I was at work and my aunt called me, said don't worry we are saved, so I was puzzled I asked her what she was talking about she told me the plane has crashed near her house. She lives 4 blocks away from the crash site.
Accidents do happen but this was suicidal attack, both pilots were no less than human bombs, no communication, egoistic, ignoring warnings and overconfident. Poor people lost their lives
I used to work for PIA in the HQ (finance and law) the amount of curroption involved is crazy but legally i could do nothing due to the corruption within I don't care anymore PIA constantly hire pilots with no real licenses since they started and i told them this would happen one day but they laughed and threatened to kill my family and jail me for life Hell the CEO threatened to R word my loved ones and sell them as wives to their family Worst fucking shite I've ever experienced
This really triggers me that even after paying a hefty amount on ticket on a reputed flight your entire existence depends on 1 human being and if he is arrogant and careless like in this case you will lose your life without any mistake of yours and people will call it bad luck
Reputed flight? You mean Airbus or PIA? If you meant PIA then you are absolutely delulu, almost 40% of pilots have fake pilot degrees which is why the US and EU banned them, tgat doesnt sound reputable. 😂😂
Damnn you made a documentary better than any OTT platform can. Wonderful Animations, excellent reaserch!! Proud of you! Never stop making videos like this.
I don't even know how i ended up here on your channel. It just showed up randomly in my feed. But after watching one video, now i am binging the entire thing! That's how good you are!
Han subky dost us ek plane sy he arhy thy ,, or yeh b bt sahi h ky jb plane nechy arha tha tw waha ky sary shopkeeprs bhr agye or customer sb mil k uper dkhny lggye koi sweets lyrha tha koi kya krhha tha ,, Model colony k upr sy ktny planes daily nklty h lekn woh ek he plane tha jisky crashed ka sbko pta lgga ,, first officer ny left turned ly k jb Mayday ki call di tb shyd @shanzaynauman ko lggai or woh sweets lyta chor kr hell dkhny lggya ,, yeh model colony waly hi aise English likh skty h,, bs attention chye ajeeb log hai CH*****
this channel is a hidden gem and needs encouragement from the audience mostly Indians.........but our audience is busy supporting talentless youtubers in India making them undeserving money......
Pakistani pilots do not undergo rigorous training like those in other countries. Many are selected due to the political influence of their family or relatives, Believe it or not this is the reality of Pakistan Aviation Sector!
And how do you know that? Your indian news? Well sir let me remind you our pilots are amongst the best in the world ask abhinandan and yes i know we had licence issues in the past but to say every pilot is like that is a disgrace so i think instead of being toxic towards us pakistanis you should focus on research more so you dont talk BS
@@capottoman bruh what are you even saying we won recently the spaceshow where our pilots showed beautiful tricks with jets having no license doesnt mean we cant drive a car and yes we know we had incidents where unlicensed pilots flew planes but those were commercial airliners not military otherwise pakistani pilots are world class and yes you with your european license will fail to drive here in Pakistan its that chaotic here
@@Thanos-u5f PIA was one of the best airline back in time, they trained emirates airline crew and gave them a few planes, corrupt gov fucked pia, although they're not in the state of begging though, you sound like ur from India.
This is one of the most horrifying aviation stories of all time, and there are a lot of scary stories. Those poor passengers... Well done, instant sub, your sim capture is fantastic.
Arrogance, false religiosity, general tendency to mock SOPs and regulations, "respect" for seniors,....a lot of factors contributed to this tragedy. This is not an accident. It's mass murder.
Pakistani here, My mother's cousin was in that plane she died but her body was found, May allah forgive those who died in the crash and give them a place in Jannah, This flight will be remembered and it is the reason I never wanted to get on a plane. As A Pakistani I feel that the world no longer wants to visit our country because of terrorist attacks, Shootings, Poverty and That they barely trust us anymore. I hope we develop and increase your trust so that our country actually wants to be visited.
As a Pakistani, I feel really ashamed that our whole system is so corrupt and incompetent. It saddens me that the tragedy of PIA flight 8303 was not about the plane itself, but rather the pilots involved. Pakistan has many great minds and skilled individuals, yet our system is plagued by corruption and bribery. Those with money can easily find their way, while highly skilled individuals with fewer resources struggle to succeed. It truly breaks my heart to say that I feel ashamed to call myself a Pakistani, because these issues tarnish the reputation of my country.
@@Ankita-o3zbut real Pakistani wont change their nationality, instead of correcting the mistake of your homeland, you will abonden it in the time it needs you?how could you!We are not that different from Germans or Japanese After ww2 they rebuilded themselves and improved IF THEY CAN DO IT THEN WE CAN ALSO KEEP IN MIND A COUNTRY IS RUN BY PEOPLE NOT BY A NATION ITSELF
Maybe it's time to get rid of Democracy and Secular Liberalism and bring in Shariah law, where people who run the system are God fearing people? Yes have politicians who praye 5 times a day, and read the Quran. Maybe God fearing people will stop accepting bribes.
I just opened this video by mistake and ended up watching it whole with my eyes stuck to the screen. AMAZING JOB with animation, editing, script, voiceover and research!!
97 ppl died in this crash .. victims include 5 members from pak army , 9 children and an actress named zara abid (28)..who was returning from her uncle funeral.. very sad
It was so sad that she was returning from a funeral but then she only passed away, I'm imagining how her family must be feeling and only 2 people survived out of 97
i flew with PIA on the first day of Lahore airport opening, over 20 years ago! I remember when the oil was leaking on take off, everyone was screaming and the crew said don't worry it will stop leaking when we are in the air! It was very scary!
I am a patriotic Indian Hindustani, but I really love educated people of Pakistan. Only you all can change the future. Hope our Nation's can build good relationship in the future.
@@RehanMohyuddin Indians have no hatred for non-jihadi Pakistanis.... only pity. Despite breaking away in 1947, you've been reduced to beggars due to obsession with islam. Sometimes your country becomes a whore for US, and other times a concubine for China. And yet you can't get yourself to stop heading for your destruction. It is pathetic really.
@@RehanMohyuddin insha Allah and Jai shri Ram (don't mind I seriously don't know the meaning of that. I only know that every Muslims are not bad as Americans described to this world. They play more like Indian serials. I'm a kattar Hindustani Hindu but I surely love and respect my Muslim friends. Please let's just end up this comparison
I think you should have added a mistake counter at the bottom right corner of the screen for this video, because I lost count of the braindead decisions taken by those 2 nincompoops in the cockpit throughout the course of that flight. On a serious note, top notch production quality especially the visualization for glideslope angle. Loved the in-depth research & end to end analysis. Hope you hit 100k mark soon :-)
I am simply gobsmacked by the sheer and utter stupidity displayed by these pilots. On every moment they somehow managed to make the WORST possible choice available. and when the landing gear was finally lowered after losing both engines, I literally facepalmed so hard that my forehead is red now.
Had they somehow survived, i am guessing as a layman, with this level of negligence they probably would have recieved a death penalty, A death penalty for being negligent at work! 😳
You described the crash really well. You made it so simple that even someone who doesn’t know much about aviation could understand it easily. Great job! RIP to the ones who have lost their lives because of arrogant unqualified pilot.
Edge of the seat narration. My heart was thudding while watching this. So sad and frustrating that so many lives were lost due to incompetence of 2 individuals .
What a load of bull shit. The Prophet Muhammed Pbuh and the Sahabi would go to battle fasting. Mohammed Salah would fast while playing soccer. Bachar Houli in Australian rules used to fast while playing professional sport, same with Adam Saad for the Carlton Football Club, stop blaming Fasting because of the incompetence of the Pilot. You can see clearly that He failed a medical exam regarding his Psychological issues how He was a bully, arrogant, control freak, that didn't listen to orders and the list goes on. And ontop of that the report also suggests almost 150 Pakistan pilots have been stood down for holding either a fake Pilot license or have a dubious one, and yet you guys ignore all of that and pick on "fasting". Even if he didn't fast it wouldn't have made a difference, because he was a known offender even on days he didn't fast, did you even watch the video that clearly stated He had a "track record" of not adhering to SOP's? And that on many occasions He would enter a run way being to high from the run way, so clearly the pilot had a history even when he wasnt fasting not adhereing to standard procedures? So clearly this Pilot was a known offender and had really bad driving habits. How convenient to blame their fasting, Get out of here.
@ The hadith about the permissibility of not fasting while traveling can be found in multiple narrations. One of the well-known ones is narrated by Anas ibn Malik (رضي الله عنه): Hadith 1: Anas ibn Malik (رضي الله عنه) reported: “We used to travel with the Prophet (ﷺ), and neither the fasting person criticized the one who was not fasting, nor did the one who was not fasting criticize the fasting one.” (Sahih al-Bukhari, Hadith 1947; Sahih Muslim, Hadith 1118) Hadith 2: Another narration from Aisha (رضي الله عنها): “Hamza ibn Amr al-Aslami asked the Prophet (ﷺ), ‘O Messenger of Allah, I find myself able to fast while traveling. Should I fast?’ The Prophet (ﷺ) said: ‘It is a concession from Allah, so whoever accepts it, it is good, and whoever prefers to fast, there is no harm in it.’” (Sahih Muslim, Hadith 1121) Hadith 3: In another hadith, narrated by Jabir ibn Abdullah (رضي الله عنه): “The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) was on a journey, and he saw a crowd of people and a man who had been shaded. He (ﷺ) asked, ‘What is this?’ They said, ‘He is fasting.’ He (ﷺ) said, ‘It is not righteousness to fast while traveling.’” (Sahih al-Bukhari, Hadith 1946; Sahih Muslim, Hadith 1115) From these hadiths, we understand that fasting during travel is not obligatory and is a concession granted by Allah (ﷻ). A traveler has the option to either fast or break the fast, depending on what is easier for them. However, it is emphasized that there is no blame on either choice, and the key principle is to do what is less burdensome.
Fasting and flying, Having 'inshallah' instead of proper training, corruption. All these combined make PIA now a blacklisted Airline and also made some Pakistani reach heaven prematurely.
My feed just randomly showd me this video and since then I have watched all your videos. It's really very interesting the way you explain every detail. Appreciate your time and dedication on animation and narration. Hoping for many more such knowledge rich content regarding all aviation occurrences. Great work 👏
Its a 26 minutes documentary on TH-cam. But i felt i just came out of an IMAX Movie theater after watching a best based on true tragedy film. Hats off to the creator. You deserve masters in making documentary 👏
Even after so many regulations, the fact that aircraft crashes still happen for such reasons gives me chills down my spine. btw the way u explained this incident is just awesome i said before and i am saying again its competent with nat geo air craft crash investigation series.
Just to clear something up in case someone might be wondering; as Muslims we are allowed to abstain from fasting while traveling, during sickness etc. and it's actually recommended to not push your body to its limits if you feel like you wouldn't be able to bear the whole length of fasting. A lot of Muslims while traveling don't fast, so it baffles me how these pilots, with such an important job to do, were fasting that day!
The first psychological assessment was correct. The senior pilot's behaviour is entirely consistent with behaviour that is prevalent with those who have narcissistic personality disorder.
What a load of bull shit. The Prophet Muhammed Pbuh and the Sahabi would go to battle fasting. Mohammed Salah would fast while playing soccer. Bachar Houli in Australian rules used to fast while playing professional sport, same with Adam Saad for the Carlton Football Club, stop blaming Fasting because of the incompetence of the Pilot. You can see clearly that He failed a medical exam regarding his Psychological issues how He was a bully, arrogant, control freak, that didn't listen to orders and the list goes on. And ontop of that the report also suggests almost 150 Pakistan pilots have been stood down for holding either a fake Pilot license or have a dubious one, and yet you guys ignore all of that and pick on "fasting". Even if he didn't fast it wouldn't have made a difference, because he was a known offender even on days he didn't fast, did you even watch the video that clearly stated He had a "track record" of not adhering to SOP's? And that on many occasions He would enter a run way being to high from the run way, so clearly the pilot had a history even when he wasnt fasting not adhereing to standard procedures? So clearly this Pilot was a known offender and had really bad driving habits. How convenient to blame their fasting, Get out of here.
@@MustafaMuhammed1981nobody’s really blaming fasting but fasting do take a toll on your decision making so stop making everything about your religion people died ..many of them there’s something called science and it doesn’t lie like religion do
U have told all the possibilities of this video inch by inch.... without any lag... Awesome brother way to go more... expecing more videos from u ....❤
@@subhashishbagchi3191 Obviously he failed in three attempts of mental test. The psychiatrist failed him and still PIA declared him fit to fly the plane that's the standard of PIA.
@@RehanMohyuddin Desi people chuthiya mentality. Always reckon that money can buy calibre. People of this subcontinent should think about skill and productivity rather always being "jugadu".
Having followed this channel for a while now, the content is getting better with every video. I've seen 3 videos on PIA 8303, but this one by far is pure gold! Keep up the good work man.
Crazy to think that even after being so reckless if the Co pilot hadn’t pulled up the landing gear without mentioning it or had he realised and put it back down himself the pilot would’ve gotten away with it all. So sad and unfortunate for the passengers.
I still vividly remember that I was going back to Hyderabad with my friends from Karachi, I don't remember how much time was left for Iftar, because it was around Iftar time. Suddenly we saw a lot of police, fire brigade and ambulances near the airport, where this colony is located, and this is not ‘Model Colony’, but it is Malir Cantt. A lot of traffic and media teams had also gathered. Smoke was visible in the sky from far away. We had absolutely no idea what had happened at that time. Then one of my friends opened live news channel on his mobile phone and found out that it was an unfortunate plane crash, merely 10/20 minutes before us stopping at that colony. Few days were left in Eid. 😢
*My brother is pilot. He once told me that he was not allowed to keep his fast (fasting during month of Ramadhan) because that could affect his ability to make quick decisions during flight. Doctors who are doing surgeries are not allowed to fast aswell. As a Muslim who fasts 30 days of Ramadhan, most of the times I cannot focus on things around me. I get mad easily, i lose temper and am sleepy. I also cant make quick decisions or even wise ones. I am sure both pilots on this plane were fasting and that is why they couldn't make wise decisions. May the souls of all those who lost their lives in this crash rest in peace.*
What a load of bull shit. The Prophet Muhammed Pbuh and the Sahabi would go to battle fasting. Mohammed Salah would fast while playing soccer. Bachar Houli in Australian rules used to fast while playing professional sport, same with Adam Saad for the Carlton Football Club, stop blaming Fasting because of the incompetence of the Pilot. You can see clearly that He failed a medical exam regarding his Psychological issues how He was a bully, arrogant, control freak, that didn't listen to orders and the list goes on. And ontop of that the report also suggests almost 150 Pakistan pilots have been stood down for holding either a fake Pilot license or have a dubious one, and yet you guys ignore all of that and pick on "fasting". Even if he didn't fast it wouldn't have made a difference, because he was a known offender even on days he didn't fast, did you even watch the video that clearly stated He had a "track record" of not adhering to SOP's? And that on many occasions He would enter a run way being to high from the run way, so clearly the pilot had a history even when he wasnt fasting not adhereing to standard procedures? So clearly this Pilot was a known offender and had really bad driving habits. How convenient to blame their fasting, Get out of here.
I swear after watching this I’ve realised I can take up any profession in the world but not that of a pilot… it’s so difficult and hundreds of people’s lives are totally dependent on you. Damn!
You'd have undergone so much training and continuing education that flying will come naturally. You really earn your bread when things go wrong and you need to think on your feet to fix things!
I absolutely love these videos! Great attention to detail and amazing animations (and love the way you added your own face rather than a faceless/dummy pilot face animation). Keep up the good work!
Thank you. You made it so intriguing to watch the whole thing without getting bored. Also I learnt so much about flying a plane. It was a very sad incident. May they be accepted as shaheed. Ameen
Amazing vid, hope I'm not too late. Now I understand why you took extra time to perfect this. Still very sad that many people died just because of two peoples mistakes with so many warnings
I once flyed PIA to saudi arabia my over all rating was 9.5 it was really good but that was my first and last simce i didn’t go on there ever again since i flew emirates or flydubai after that
How come they landed without opening the landing gear and then set both engines on fire and couldn't figure out that the landing tyres were not open. They were not fasting, they were drunk for sure.
if they just stayed on the ground after the belly landing, it would've been less disastrous... but they had already lost all situational awareness before then and couldn't make such a heads-up save...
Only following islamic rules will not work, if it is prohibited to go on fasting once u r involved with public service and where proper health care is mandatory
Play Conflict of Nations for FREE on PC or Mobile:
💥 con.onelink.me/kZW6/WYNGX01
Receive 13K GOLD & 1 month premium subscription, only available for the next 30 days!
anything is possible in a place like pakistan
@gnnana96 I just tried it bro. It's working
@@_WyngXit ain't working bro
@@AbhayGNair What message are you seeing when you click on it?
@@_WyngX Item not found
Captain: "He will be surprised to what we have done"
Also captain: Suprising the entire world including himself 20 min later.
Well, the first officer surprised him by pulling the landing gear up before landing.
@@remryu2 i mean why would they do that in the first landing hell they could have just belly landed that plane easily once it was already onthe ground. what a m0r0n.
@@remryu2(shouldn’t laugh but )😂
Was the captain a f**l didn't he see the gears going down 👎👎👎@@thebook5458
@@RupeshYadav-u9gtheir al**h gave them the reward of fasting 😅😅😅
It's astonishing to see how someone can be this careless like these two pilots when there are lives of people involved.
Yeah, exactly!
Pakistanis becomes pilot with fake documents and by getting training from maksad academy of jihadi institute 😂
I am not defending them but repeat anything for a 1000 times and at some point you too will start disregarding some rules.
@@swagatrout3075 then get out, you do not get to destroy lives because of your disregard for rules
@@swagatrout3075 Some rules?! It's a complete mockery
Your explanation is so good that even My 7 year old cousin concluded "maybe the pilot was also flying with a fake licence but to protect the airline's dignity they hid the truth"
How cool's that.. I hope I've gotten a little one hooked to aviation! :)
What makes it most interesting is the fact that more than 150 pilots of PIA were found having fake licenses in 2020 fake license scandal in Pakistan. In this shitty country where federal education minister was found having a fake degree, where pilots can buy licenses with money and where they can get hired to pilot an Airbus just by giving $2-3000 is ironic and highly despicable. The bastards living in this country are bound to be doomed, always.
Nope he was a very experienced pilot as well.
@@Someone0764experienced pilot with fake degree😂
This is the corrupt egomania in that part of the world.
this was such a hard watch like they had SO many chances to save the plane yet they ignored it all, and there was literally no communication between the captains 😭
There is a quote in Pakistan: "You are elder statesman so you are right". There is 25 year age gap between co pilot and the captain. So obviously this was bound to happen. Captain thought as if he was Captain America
@@RehanMohyuddin yeah we are always taught to respect our elders which in this case made him feel as if hes in control and he can do whatever he wants
@@ak09168 in situations like these, elders should not be in control at all. Their mental capacity is way lower than someone esp 25 yeas younger than them. Human cultures and superstitions have really ruined us, our politicians, leaders etc are all above the average life span 300 years ago, there's a reason why nature naturally used to eliminate us as we hit that point, just cuz medicine is advanced doesn't means its natural. Stop giving important positions to oldies wth
@@RehanMohyuddin that behaviour was also the reason for a Korean air crash in San Francisco. Cultural practices of not questioning the older person even when they are wrong is common in many asian countries. That is why the rules were updated to cockpit personnel being expected to follow cockpit rules , not culture, and start on CRM procedures. Let's hope that prevents further loss of life.
So near, yet so far - such a tragedy.
@@RehanMohyuddin listen there is no wrong with respecting elders and i do agree with respecting elders. but as an elder who seen lot in your life you should know that in some cases you can be wrong and someone young then you can be right even if you worked in the same industry for more time than others. I saw many cases when elder think just because they are old they are right and youngsters who didn't see as much as life as them are always wrong one. the reason we respect elders is not because they are old because they are wise and they saw more hardships than youngsters and probably make right decision when faced hardship. again respect everyone not just elders but just because you are older than others doesnt make you are right. sometimes learn to accept that you as elder can make mistake but again i dont think they would because of ego like how can someone younger than me take back to me? only i do the taking .
Captain Sajjad Gul was not even eligible to drive an auto rickshaw.He made simple thing complex.
According to one PIA employee he was very rude behavior
Not Even Netflix Can Make Such A Good Documentary
Thank you so much 😊
@@adii.11😂
Real dude
That’s really true 😊
They Can
only if they hire WyngX
Not having down the landing gear while landing is like driving a car on its rims and dragging the engine on the concrete, but three times faster.
Exactly!
3 times is understatement.
When they needed tyres they kept it up and when they needed tires glide they brought landing gears down. Insane
Pak govt., And the game suggested ...
More like 30 times
I am in total shock. With 90 souls onboard. Such disrespect to ATC. Massive disregard to work ethic and regulations. This is a murder.
No, it is roohani aviation training
It's Pakistan, what do you expect
@@terrifictanishIt's South Asia. Safety standards are the lowest priority in this region.
@@Zrs3820 India is much better than other countries in terms of safety of aviation. There is no comparison
@@Zrs3820 Give me one example of an indian airline failure. Our pilots are amazing
I remember that day I was at work and my aunt called me, said don't worry we are saved, so I was puzzled I asked her what she was talking about she told me the plane has crashed near her house.
She lives 4 blocks away from the crash site.
😳That was so scary!
Accidents do happen but this was suicidal attack, both pilots were no less than human bombs, no communication, egoistic, ignoring warnings and overconfident. Poor people lost their lives
I used to work for PIA in the HQ (finance and law) the amount of curroption involved is crazy but legally i could do nothing due to the corruption within
I don't care anymore
PIA constantly hire pilots with no real licenses since they started and i told them this would happen one day but they laughed and threatened to kill my family and jail me for life
Hell the CEO threatened to R word my loved ones and sell them as wives to their family
Worst fucking shite I've ever experienced
@Unknown-to-you703 they are already bankrupt now, karma hits back.
This really triggers me that even after paying a hefty amount on ticket on a reputed flight your entire existence depends on 1 human being and if he is arrogant and careless like in this case you will lose your life without any mistake of yours and people will call it bad luck
Crazy arrogant people relying on "Inshallah" and "Insallah God permit we will make it" (refered to the Saudia crash).
I don't think anyone considers PIA to be reputed.
Reputed flight? You mean Airbus or PIA? If you meant PIA then you are absolutely delulu, almost 40% of pilots have fake pilot degrees which is why the US and EU banned them, tgat doesnt sound reputable. 😂😂
reputed flight my ass
@@mrsubramanian-hy9xb ye bhi theek hai
The way you demonstrate the ideas and the situations, it's totally insane!!! Rooting for you.🎀
Thank you so much bro. I appreciate your support! :)
eto tara kisher, ki bishoysuchi eder sheta ki janen
Ikr
Damnn you made a documentary better than any OTT platform can. Wonderful Animations, excellent reaserch!! Proud of you! Never stop making videos like this.
Thanks so much for the encouragement! :)
I don't even know how i ended up here on your channel. It just showed up randomly in my feed. But after watching one video, now i am binging the entire thing! That's how good you are!
It crashed 2 streets away from my home, and 1 of my best friends was on that plane, coming back after two years. Alas, what a loss.
I saw the plane go down with my eyes when i was out w my father gatteing sweets and we even got close to see the plane if was just hell
My best friend also died
Han subky dost us ek plane sy he arhy thy ,, or yeh b bt sahi h ky jb plane nechy arha tha tw waha ky sary shopkeeprs bhr agye or customer sb mil k uper dkhny lggye koi sweets lyrha tha koi kya krhha tha ,, Model colony k upr sy ktny planes daily nklty h lekn woh ek he plane tha jisky crashed ka sbko pta lgga ,, first officer ny left turned ly k jb Mayday ki call di tb shyd @shanzaynauman ko lggai or woh sweets lyta chor kr hell dkhny lggya ,, yeh model colony waly hi aise English likh skty h,, bs attention chye ajeeb log hai CH*****
@@shanzaynauman4234what's the name of your friend dude!!
this channel is a hidden gem and needs encouragement from the audience mostly Indians.........but our audience is busy supporting talentless youtubers in India making them undeserving money......
Thank you so much, Suvit! :)
@@_WyngX Hindi is needed for masses !!
@@Santosh_ChoubeyHe has an Hindi Channel too
@@_WyngXyou should make content in every language like mr beast he has different language in the same video and channel
@@Thanos-u5f That feature isn't enabled yet for all channels, unfortunately. :(
Pakistani pilots do not undergo rigorous training like those in other countries. Many are selected due to the political influence of their family or relatives, Believe it or not this is the reality of Pakistan Aviation Sector!
And how do you know that? Your indian news? Well sir let me remind you our pilots are amongst the best in the world ask abhinandan and yes i know we had licence issues in the past but to say every pilot is like that is a disgrace so i think instead of being toxic towards us pakistanis you should focus on research more so you dont talk BS
@@TheKayaniPakistani Pilots are Not as Good as other Countries☠️
@@capottoman bruh what are you even saying we won recently the spaceshow where our pilots showed beautiful tricks with jets having no license doesnt mean we cant drive a car and yes we know we had incidents where unlicensed pilots flew planes but those were commercial airliners not military otherwise pakistani pilots are world class and yes you with your european license will fail to drive here in Pakistan its that chaotic here
@@TheKayani nigga your PIA is banned from European Airspace.
@@TheKayani lol, pakistan is the super power
AS A PILOT, FLYING THIS BEAUTIFUL AIRCRAFT IT WAS BOILING MY BLOOD… HOW CAN ANY PILOT FLY LIKE THIS. THIS IS SUCIDAL 😡😡😡😡😡
I totally agree.. So many chances to live, but none taken!
I know. If I was a Pilot I would be pissed as well.
you flew this?
@@Aadilabdul. yes I fly Airbus 320
@@moizshaikh5145 have you flew this plane 8303
Pakistani auto drivers who know English applied for Pilot jobs and they got the jobs and the rest is History.
They are beggars when they fly planes that could be a begged plane from other country so what could we expect
@@Thanos-u5f PIA was one of the best airline back in time, they trained emirates airline crew and gave them a few planes, corrupt gov fucked pia, although they're not in the state of begging though, you sound like ur from India.
@@Javaxmlx your whole country is running on others begged money 😂😂
Your allah is not helping you
@@Thanos-u5f Same goes for India, highest poverty rate, no food, no toilets, no hygiene, I'm glad I live in Pakistan cus I have everything here!
@@Javaxmlx India doesn't keep begging money wherever Indian pm go
Like yours shahbaz Sharif goes 😒😒
This is one of the most horrifying aviation stories of all time, and there are a lot of scary stories. Those poor passengers...
Well done, instant sub, your sim capture is fantastic.
Thank you so much! :) Welcome to the channel! :)
I woke up from a nap groggy and i thought this is a mentour pilot video, that's how good this is!
Thanks a lot mate! :)
@@_WyngX No problem matey :)
mentour also covered this flight :) both videos are masterpieces
Exactly 💯
Arrogance, false religiosity, general tendency to mock SOPs and regulations, "respect" for seniors,....a lot of factors contributed to this tragedy. This is not an accident. It's mass murder.
well said
Pakistani here, My mother's cousin was in that plane she died but her body was found, May allah forgive those who died in the crash and give them a place in Jannah, This flight will be remembered and it is the reason I never wanted to get on a plane. As A Pakistani I feel that the world no longer wants to visit our country because of terrorist attacks, Shootings, Poverty and That they barely trust us anymore. I hope we develop and increase your trust so that our country actually wants to be visited.
allah isnt real but god is soo
Jesus is not Allah is
@@Jake_Wilson-t5tlet people believe what they want eventually they'll all follow what is right
We will see.insha Allah. Allahu aalam@@Unknown-to-you703
May Allah have mercy on her and everyone else that lost their lives that day Ameen
As a Pakistani, I feel really ashamed that our whole system is so corrupt and incompetent. It saddens me that the tragedy of PIA flight 8303 was not about the plane itself, but rather the pilots involved. Pakistan has many great minds and skilled individuals, yet our system is plagued by corruption and bribery. Those with money can easily find their way, while highly skilled individuals with fewer resources struggle to succeed. It truly breaks my heart to say that I feel ashamed to call myself a Pakistani, because these issues tarnish the reputation of my country.
@@Ankita-o3zbut real Pakistani wont change their nationality, instead of correcting the mistake of your homeland, you will abonden it in the time it needs you?how could you!We are not that different from Germans or Japanese
After ww2 they rebuilded themselves and improved
IF THEY CAN DO IT THEN WE CAN ALSO
KEEP IN MIND
A COUNTRY IS RUN BY PEOPLE NOT BY A NATION ITSELF
Maybe it's time to get rid of Democracy and Secular Liberalism and bring in Shariah law, where people who run the system are God fearing people?
Yes have politicians who praye 5 times a day, and read the Quran. Maybe God fearing people will stop accepting bribes.
I just opened this video by mistake and ended up watching it whole with my eyes stuck to the screen. AMAZING JOB with animation, editing, script, voiceover and research!!
97 ppl died in this crash .. victims include 5 members from pak army , 9 children and an actress named zara abid (28)..who was returning from her uncle funeral.. very sad
It was so sad that she was returning from a funeral but then she only passed away, I'm imagining how her family must be feeling and only 2 people survived out of 97
i flew with PIA on the first day of Lahore airport opening, over 20 years ago! I remember when the oil was leaking on take off, everyone was screaming and the crew said don't worry it will stop leaking when we are in the air! It was very scary!
I had lost a family-friend on this flight, he was seated next to a survivor, his loss was quite unfortunate
U kidding yeah?
that's sad
@@pasangezrod4052 why would they be kidding?!
I am a patriotic Indian Hindustani, but I really love educated people of Pakistan. Only you all can change the future. Hope our Nation's can build good relationship in the future.
Nice to see positive comment from an Indian.
@@RehanMohyuddin Indians have no hatred for non-jihadi Pakistanis.... only pity. Despite breaking away in 1947, you've been reduced to beggars due to obsession with islam. Sometimes your country becomes a whore for US, and other times a concubine for China. And yet you can't get yourself to stop heading for your destruction. It is pathetic really.
Neighbors are just brothers from another mothers.
Very educated comment to be honest I think cricket spoils our relationships 😅
@@RehanMohyuddin insha Allah and Jai shri Ram (don't mind I seriously don't know the meaning of that. I only know that every Muslims are not bad as Americans described to this world. They play more like Indian serials. I'm a kattar Hindustani Hindu but I surely love and respect my Muslim friends. Please let's just end up this comparison
You are an absolute legend. I wasn’t really a fan of aviation but your documentaries have changed that. Best of luck for your future! ❤
Thanks a ton!
I think you should have added a mistake counter at the bottom right corner of the screen for this video, because I lost count of the braindead decisions taken by those 2 nincompoops in the cockpit throughout the course of that flight.
On a serious note, top notch production quality especially the visualization for glideslope angle. Loved the in-depth research & end to end analysis. Hope you hit 100k mark soon :-)
Thank you so much! :)
I am simply gobsmacked by the sheer and utter stupidity displayed by these pilots.
On every moment they somehow managed to make the WORST possible choice available.
and when the landing gear was finally lowered after losing both engines, I literally facepalmed so hard that my forehead is red now.
Had they somehow survived, i am guessing as a layman, with this level of negligence they probably would have recieved a death penalty, A death penalty for being negligent at work! 😳
You described the crash really well. You made it so simple that even someone who doesn’t know much about aviation could understand it easily. Great job!
RIP to the ones who have lost their lives because of arrogant unqualified pilot.
Edge of the seat narration. My heart was thudding while watching this. So sad and frustrating that so many lives were lost due to incompetence of 2 individuals .
In Islam you’re exempted from fasting if you’re traveling but they ignored it too
What a load of bull shit. The Prophet Muhammed Pbuh and the Sahabi would go to battle fasting.
Mohammed Salah would fast while playing soccer.
Bachar Houli in Australian rules used to fast while playing professional sport, same with Adam Saad for the Carlton Football Club, stop blaming Fasting because of the incompetence of the Pilot. You can see clearly that He failed a medical exam regarding his Psychological issues how He was a bully, arrogant, control freak, that didn't listen to orders and the list goes on. And ontop of that the report also suggests almost 150 Pakistan pilots have been stood down for holding either a fake Pilot license or have a dubious one, and yet you guys ignore all of that and pick on "fasting".
Even if he didn't fast it wouldn't have made a difference, because he was a known offender even on days he didn't fast, did you even watch the video that clearly stated He had a "track record" of not adhering to SOP's? And that on many occasions He would enter a run way being to high from the run way, so clearly the pilot had a history even when he wasnt fasting not adhereing to standard procedures? So clearly this Pilot was a known offender and had really bad driving habits.
How convenient to blame their fasting, Get out of here.
@ The hadith about the permissibility of not fasting while traveling can be found in multiple narrations. One of the well-known ones is narrated by Anas ibn Malik (رضي الله عنه):
Hadith 1:
Anas ibn Malik (رضي الله عنه) reported:
“We used to travel with the Prophet (ﷺ), and neither the fasting person criticized the one who was not fasting, nor did the one who was not fasting criticize the fasting one.”
(Sahih al-Bukhari, Hadith 1947; Sahih Muslim, Hadith 1118)
Hadith 2:
Another narration from Aisha (رضي الله عنها):
“Hamza ibn Amr al-Aslami asked the Prophet (ﷺ), ‘O Messenger of Allah, I find myself able to fast while traveling. Should I fast?’ The Prophet (ﷺ) said: ‘It is a concession from Allah, so whoever accepts it, it is good, and whoever prefers to fast, there is no harm in it.’”
(Sahih Muslim, Hadith 1121)
Hadith 3:
In another hadith, narrated by Jabir ibn Abdullah (رضي الله عنه):
“The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) was on a journey, and he saw a crowd of people and a man who had been shaded. He (ﷺ) asked, ‘What is this?’ They said, ‘He is fasting.’ He (ﷺ) said, ‘It is not righteousness to fast while traveling.’”
(Sahih al-Bukhari, Hadith 1946; Sahih Muslim, Hadith 1115)
From these hadiths, we understand that fasting during travel is not obligatory and is a concession granted by Allah (ﷻ). A traveler has the option to either fast or break the fast, depending on what is easier for them. However, it is emphasized that there is no blame on either choice, and the key principle is to do what is less burdensome.
Fasting and flying, Having 'inshallah' instead of proper training, corruption. All these combined make PIA now a blacklisted Airline and also made some Pakistani reach heaven prematurely.
no sthu
@@OfficialMMVon cry all you want but accept the truth.
@@rakchong no u cry and stop lying lil bro
@@OfficialMMVon what's the lie here kid?
@@rakchong what you said you dumb kid
My feed just randomly showd me this video and since then I have watched all your videos. It's really very interesting the way you explain every detail. Appreciate your time and dedication on animation and narration. Hoping for many more such knowledge rich content regarding all aviation occurrences. Great work 👏
Thank you so much! :)
Mann how does this channel only has 167k subscribers??
🙌🔥
Its a 26 minutes documentary on TH-cam. But i felt i just came out of an IMAX Movie theater after watching a best based on true tragedy film. Hats off to the creator. You deserve masters in making documentary 👏
Thanks bro! :)
Your story telling, visuals and sound make this one of my favourite channels.
Thank you so much! :)
Even after so many regulations, the fact that aircraft crashes still happen for such reasons gives me chills down my spine. btw the way u explained this incident is just awesome i said before and i am saying again its competent with nat geo air craft crash investigation series.
Thank you so much Kartik! :)
@@_WyngX 😊
I cant describe this content in words, but its crazy and the best youtuber on these stories. Thanks for making these for us man really appriciate it.
Glad you enjoy it! Thanks for the encouragement! :)
@12:11 dhamal movie moment -
P1- wo red button dikh raha hai
P2- Ha dabaa diya
P1- nahi dabana tha
lmaooooo
Just to clear something up in case someone might be wondering; as Muslims we are allowed to abstain from fasting while traveling, during sickness etc. and it's actually recommended to not push your body to its limits if you feel like you wouldn't be able to bear the whole length of fasting. A lot of Muslims while traveling don't fast, so it baffles me how these pilots, with such an important job to do, were fasting that day!
The first psychological assessment was correct. The senior pilot's behaviour is entirely consistent with behaviour that is prevalent with those who have narcissistic personality disorder.
What a load of bull shit. The Prophet Muhammed Pbuh and the Sahabi would go to battle fasting.
Mohammed Salah would fast while playing soccer.
Bachar Houli in Australian rules used to fast while playing professional sport, same with Adam Saad for the Carlton Football Club, stop blaming Fasting because of the incompetence of the Pilot. You can see clearly that He failed a medical exam regarding his Psychological issues how He was a bully, arrogant, control freak, that didn't listen to orders and the list goes on. And ontop of that the report also suggests almost 150 Pakistan pilots have been stood down for holding either a fake Pilot license or have a dubious one, and yet you guys ignore all of that and pick on "fasting".
Even if he didn't fast it wouldn't have made a difference, because he was a known offender even on days he didn't fast, did you even watch the video that clearly stated He had a "track record" of not adhering to SOP's? And that on many occasions He would enter a run way being to high from the run way, so clearly the pilot had a history even when he wasnt fasting not adhereing to standard procedures? So clearly this Pilot was a known offender and had really bad driving habits.
How convenient to blame their fasting, Get out of here.
@@MustafaMuhammed1981nobody’s really blaming fasting but fasting do take a toll on your decision making so stop making everything about your religion people died ..many of them there’s something called science and it doesn’t lie like religion do
Your quality is unmatched, amazing job man!
Thanks a ton! :)
Love the masterpiece. great story, graphics and details. Waiting for the next one!
Thank you very much!
7400 ft... Landing gears are down... Flap 1.... I mean... Are these guys high on Jet fuel???? Seriously?? 😂😂😂
From day 1 his family began blaming the airline for out of maintenance aircraft. Consequently, he airline delivered his body home in a cargo van.
U have told all the possibilities of this video inch by inch.... without any lag...
Awesome brother way to go more... expecing more videos from u ....❤
Wow i commented on previous video to make a documentary about karachi plane crash and it's here ❤
You ask. I deliver 😍
@@_WyngX You cook well mate :)
9l.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
😢 26:26 26:26 26:26
5:18 In Islam if you are travelling you don't have to fast.
According to Dr Zakir Naik, even if you travel , as per Quran you have to do mandatory fasting... And no body knows quran better than Zakir.
@@durgeshsingh5220no, wrong assumption
@@durgeshsingh5220Dr zakir naik isn't a scholar
ATC karachi tried to save the plane( Pakistan 8303 DISREGARD turn left at 180) , but pilots of PIA disobeyed the order on ATC
Stop flying with PIA they will automatically upgrade their air crafts and change their pilots.
@@RehanMohyuddinthe main pilot was very egoistic and arrogant.
@@subhashishbagchi3191 Obviously he failed in three attempts of mental test. The psychiatrist failed him and still PIA declared him fit to fly the plane that's the standard of PIA.
@@RehanMohyuddin Desi people chuthiya mentality. Always reckon that money can buy calibre. People of this subcontinent should think about skill and productivity rather always being "jugadu".
chilling how even ATC could see what a ridiculous thing was being attempted. How can a pilot not heed such a clear direction is shocking.
Having followed this channel for a while now, the content is getting better with every video. I've seen 3 videos on PIA 8303, but this one by far is pure gold! Keep up the good work man.
Much appreciated! 😌
Thank you...loved your narrative and the visuals. Best Wishes.❤
Bro single handedly destroying multi million documentaries with flight simulator … hats off man
Thanks bro :)
i remember this sad tragedy, It happened when i was in pakistan, i was so shocked tbh
Such intricate details! You are an amazing speaker sir! Looking forward to many more videos.
Thumba thanks Katyayini avare
Crazy to think that even after being so reckless if the Co pilot hadn’t pulled up the landing gear without mentioning it or had he realised and put it back down himself the pilot would’ve gotten away with it all. So sad and unfortunate for the passengers.
I still vividly remember that I was going back to Hyderabad with my friends from Karachi, I don't remember how much time was left for Iftar, because it was around Iftar time. Suddenly we saw a lot of police, fire brigade and ambulances near the airport, where this colony is located, and this is not ‘Model Colony’, but it is Malir Cantt. A lot of traffic and media teams had also gathered. Smoke was visible in the sky from far away. We had absolutely no idea what had happened at that time. Then one of my friends opened live news channel on his mobile phone and found out that it was an unfortunate plane crash, merely 10/20 minutes before us stopping at that colony. Few days were left in Eid. 😢
The quality and detail in these videos are amazing man! You deserve atleast a million subscribers 👏🏽
Thank you so much 😀
Wake up babe, Wyngx just dropped another Video!!
hhahaha! Cheers bro.. Tell me how you liked the video! :)
@@_WyngX More than her! 😉
lol
@@The_Indominus_1 Wyngx's videos are better than girlfriends lol
@@The_Indominus_1 lol :)
@@USAISHEREBRINGTHEOIL lol hope u never get one than
*My brother is pilot. He once told me that he was not allowed to keep his fast (fasting during month of Ramadhan) because that could affect his ability to make quick decisions during flight. Doctors who are doing surgeries are not allowed to fast aswell. As a Muslim who fasts 30 days of Ramadhan, most of the times I cannot focus on things around me. I get mad easily, i lose temper and am sleepy. I also cant make quick decisions or even wise ones. I am sure both pilots on this plane were fasting and that is why they couldn't make wise decisions. May the souls of all those who lost their lives in this crash rest in peace.*
Muslims are exempted from fasting while traveling but they ignored it too
Non fasting rules were put in place after and because of this accident
What a load of bull shit. The Prophet Muhammed Pbuh and the Sahabi would go to battle fasting.
Mohammed Salah would fast while playing soccer.
Bachar Houli in Australian rules used to fast while playing professional sport, same with Adam Saad for the Carlton Football Club, stop blaming Fasting because of the incompetence of the Pilot. You can see clearly that He failed a medical exam regarding his Psychological issues how He was a bully, arrogant, control freak, that didn't listen to orders and the list goes on. And ontop of that the report also suggests almost 150 Pakistan pilots have been stood down for holding either a fake Pilot license or have a dubious one, and yet you guys ignore all of that and pick on "fasting".
Even if he didn't fast it wouldn't have made a difference, because he was a known offender even on days he didn't fast, did you even watch the video that clearly stated He had a "track record" of not adhering to SOP's? And that on many occasions He would enter a run way being to high from the run way, so clearly the pilot had a history even when he wasnt fasting not adhereing to standard procedures? So clearly this Pilot was a known offender and had really bad driving habits.
How convenient to blame their fasting, Get out of here.
@MustafaMuhammed1981 but the Sahabis were on ground and not flying 40000 feet above handling lives of 100s of people. Use common sense brother
Massive well done, everything so technically sophisticated yet explained simply enough.
Thank you.
Thank you so much! :)
Your explanation skills are so on point that even me,who is so bad at calculations understood everything. Well done👍🏻
Glad to hear that! 🥺
Bro will go Viral soon enough you are underrated as hell
Keep continuing! We need more content
Appreciate that. Thank you so much for the encouragement 😍
MH370 MYSTERY? 🥺@@_WyngX
New here! Thanks for these videos, Wyngx! Really love watching them. My favorite so far is about Air India 101. Thanks again and good job indeed!
Gracias, Mattias! :)
I swear after watching this I’ve realised I can take up any profession in the world but not that of a pilot… it’s so difficult and hundreds of people’s lives are totally dependent on you. Damn!
If you are trained pilot don't worry but if you are blind as these two were then obviously this profession isn't suitable for you.
You'd have undergone so much training and continuing education that flying will come naturally. You really earn your bread when things go wrong and you need to think on your feet to fix things!
I'm really glad to see coverage of accidents and incidents in Asia, a lot of channels don't cover flights in these regions
Thank you so much 😀
I absolutely love these videos! Great attention to detail and amazing animations (and love the way you added your own face rather than a faceless/dummy pilot face animation). Keep up the good work!
Thank you Shreya! :)
thankyou for using the correct map of kashmir ... love from india
I’m Indian 😂
@@_WyngXlove from Bharat then 👍
@_WyngX love you bro!!!
i have never seen a better quality than this your amazing
keep the good work🥵😮💨🙃
Thank you so much Vineet 😀
Thank you. You made it so intriguing to watch the whole thing without getting bored. Also I learnt so much about flying a plane. It was a very sad incident. May they be accepted as shaheed. Ameen
Thank you so much! :)
Loved this documentary great story telling.... Very nice..!!
Wow another masterpiece🔥🙌🏻
Was so eagerly waiting for this. Great work Wyngx!!
Thank you 🙌 Glad you liked it! :)
Amazing vid, hope I'm not too late. Now I understand why you took extra time to perfect this. Still very sad that many people died just because of two peoples mistakes with so many warnings
Thank you so much Deepthi! :)
Felt bad for those who lost their lives.
Sad tragedy.
Good presentation 👍
The way you explain the whole situation is crazy you explain better then ZedTV
Why people fear of airplane crash is just like this reason. You cant do anything if the person flying you is turned out to be like this captain.
Never fly PIA, if you want to live.
I once flyed PIA to saudi arabia my over all rating was 9.5 it was really good but that was my first and last simce i didn’t go on there ever again since i flew emirates or flydubai after that
You post in one month but for that quality.. it was worth the wait.❤
Thank you so much! :)
Very good documentary bhaiya!! Thanks for using the actual map of Pakistan. ❤️❤️❤️
Thanks Bhai! :)
On the flight where junaid jumshaid died, the pilot was my mamu who is a pilot too best friend and he was very sad when he heard about the news
How come they landed without opening the landing gear and then set both engines on fire and couldn't figure out that the landing tyres were not open.
They were not fasting, they were drunk for sure.
You literally have only made a few videos and im already in love with ur vids, keep it up
Thank you so much! :)
Dude this video was amazing! Thank you for producing netflix level documentaries for us!
Glad you enjoyed it! And thanks for the encouraging words 😍
Amazing how a content creator can make such an amazing documentary with a flight simulator and other gear. Keep going!
Thanks a ton! :)
Brother this is the best documentary i've ever watched.
Thank you so much! :)
No Netflix Documentary can compede this video, You Are Awesome Wyngx!
Thank you so much bro! :)
😊
if they just stayed on the ground after the belly landing, it would've been less disastrous... but they had already lost all situational awareness before then and couldn't make such a heads-up save...
Not as easy as you say. Runwaya is not infinite, Plane was probably moving at very high speed, Not capable of landing.
Not Even Mayday Air Crash Made A Video This Detailed In This Time
Thanks Dawud! :)
This is Insane. Finally someone made a channel of my fav videos
Thank you so much :)
Your way of detailing every aspect including the flight controls is awesome. Love from TN 😍
Nandri thalai! :)
That’s just the problem with Pakistan. People are careless and gives our country a bad name. I am honestly ashamed of this. 😢
LOL when your pilot says my gods willing we will lund safely😂
I am from pakistan, and i suggest do not travel with PIA IN LIFE
Well done mate! I felt as if I was watching a documentary on Netflix. Great work 💥
They could have made it if the landing gear was down, no other points you mentioned in the video matter that much.
Atc also did not Warned them that landing gear is down
Only following islamic rules will not work, if it is prohibited to go on fasting once u r involved with public service and where proper health care is mandatory