Man this got way darker and more graphic than I was expecting as your stories don't normally get this violent. It's well written, just unexpected. Very curious on how a part 2 would play out.
What if Palpatine was arrested for his murder of hego demask? Anakin, upon determining that palpatine killed Plagueis, could work through the legal system rather than the jedi
For as dark as this timeline was, I can't help but imagine that scene with Anakin and the slaughter of the Hutts with Huey Lewis and the News 'It's hip to be square' playing in the background!
Bruh, the mere fact that Anakin disobeyed him would be a problem. Lol he'd get electrocuted as a punishment, followed by a cruel second punishment because Palpatine is vindictive like that.
@@TreyTheDestroyer Palpatine's treatment of Anakin did not become bad until Anakin failed, lost most of his force potential, and got put in the suit. In this scenario, Anakin was never defeated. He was still the prodigal apprentice that Sidious always wanted, complete with all of his potential. So, I think that Palpatine would have spared Anakin the electrocution treatment and continued to play the part of the friendly mentor, even with his disobedience.
@@freethinker77 Sooo Sith Lords are not generally and unnecessarily harsh with their apprentices? 😅 That's not a thing? He intentionally made the suit painful for him... Vulnerable to force lightning... In this scenario Anakin would be capable of achieving full potential and truthfully Palpatine would never even want Anakin to reach his full potential because that means he'd be overthrown. With ease. Sidious is paranoid and will go to any length to keep his power, and that would include even killing Anakin if he had to and occasionally teaching him a lesson to remind him of his place.
What if during Padme's pregnancy that she become Force sensitive and noticing the darkness growing in Anakin and around Palpatine. After Ahsoka left the Jedi Order, Padme hired her as a covert personal agent. Anakin's too busy in the war to notice Ahsoka being with Padme as he spends most of his time in the front lines. Ahsoka did start to train Padme the basics on using the Force on her spare time.
What if Jabba the Hutt was a Sith lord? A crime lord controlling half the galaxy for hundreds of years is a pretty good candidate for secret Sith lord.
Well that was similar to the plot for the sequels by George Lucas but instead of jabba it would be maul. He would create his own secret legion of criminals to overthrow the new republic after the fall of the empire.
Part II, please! Also, please please please do What if Revan wasn't found in stasis until the first year of the clone wars? That would mean that Revan in his prime would be alive and well, and Darth Vitiate's spirit would still be dormant since Revan didn't awake his spirit at Yavin.
What if Vader learned Leia was his daughter on the Death Star just as he was about to torture her? Think about how deep that could be. Vader obsessed over Padmé and wanted to bring her back for years in both continuities. If he meets his children, do anyone really believe Vader would torture that remnant? At the risk of them dying or hating him when he would want their loyalty and them to see him as their father? I personally don't. He would be possessive but not abusive imo. It was implied multiple times in sources that Vader cut off Luke's hand by accident, aiming for the lightsaber and only catching his hand in a fit of rage. How would it be now that Vader was about to torture Padmé's daughter?
That's a good point. Vader was completely and utterly helpless in the original timeline-stuck between trying to avoid Palpatine from getting his hands on Luke and didn't want to claim his life and his mentality of loyalty. If he found out Leia was his daughter, Vader would simply have more time on his side because Palpatine wouldn't know and thus wouldn't be as pressured. I think the obvious answer is "turn her to the Dark Side", but a deeper and more complex story is Vader trying to protect Leia where he failed to Padme because Vader became more of a nuanced character throughout the years. He missed Padme and wouldn't torture her child because if she dies he would be completely without nothing.
I like that, while this what-if counts as a RotS fix-it, it's not a clean fix (although it is debatable whether your Sith paste scenarios could be called "clean" because of, well, the Sith paste). Order 66 still happens. Knightfall still happens. Anakin DOES calm down a little and I think there is still hope for him, despite everything that he had done (I don't blame him for slaughtering the Hutts. Fuck the Hutts.) - but he has yet to contact Padme or take any meaningful steps against Sidious. There are so many ways for this setup to be resolved if you decide to continue this. As much as I enjoyed the scene of Gardulla's death, I must point out that the blood wouldn't have the time be expelled from the hilt; given the temperature of a lightsaber blade, it would **immediately** vaporize. Also note: at that point of the timeline, Anakin wore a brown cloak, not a black one.
This idea does spark another. What if Obi-Wan secretly contacted R2-D2 and has him delay Anikan just a bit so he and Padme arrive on Mustafar before? They find the separatist leadership and in an odd change of events Obi-Wan saves the separatists from Anikan. The leaders, realized they gave been utterly betrayed and turn to Obi-Wan and Padme to save them. In one fell swoop Obi-Wan is now the military leader of the CIS replacing General grievous and Padme becomes the political leader replacing Count Dooku. No Droid shut down. No end of the war. Now Sidious has a real problem. Just a thought. 😏
Lol.... Palpatine is not the type to overlook disobedience. Anakin would be electrocuted and then subjected to suffering in some cruel situation created by Palpatine because he is vindictive like that.
oh bro...just got done watching "what if anakin didnt go to mustifar" and harkened back to the separatists waiting there and you have anakin despatch come clones minute 1 i feel so foolish hell yeah dude youre SickWarsQuill
Seeing his newly recruited apprentice go rouge, Palpatine would probably count him amongst the ranks of the jedi, at least as far as order 66 is concerned. Anakin would be forced to run the gauntlet of both the republic and remaining seperatist forces along every step of his journey untill he either falls back in line under his master, or succumbs to the emporers forces. 🤔
What if Palpatine cut funding to the Jedi instead of obliterating them? You know, they have to take the bus instead of personal ships, Yoda's got a second job, they all have to share lightsabers, after helping anyone they're required to bill them or ask for a small donated to Jedis Without Borders fund, etc.
What if anakin was a girl? It seems like it might not change much, but it definitely will. 1. Annie (anakin) won't fall in love with padme 2. Since girls mature faster, she might not be as tempted by the dark side. 3. Luke and leia wouldn't exist. 4. You will be able to use Taylor Swift as her image. 5. And if she did turn to the dark side, the witches of dathomir might accept her as a witch, and then, with her extreme power, become mother skywalker. 6. Because she is a girl and therefore not as physically strong, she would be less likely to use form 5. This would lead her to use form 4, similar to qui gon jinn. This would lead to less anger. 7. Assuming that padme is a guy, annie would be the one getting pregnant if the relationship happens at all. 8. She would have a better relationship with Ahsoka, and they would be more comfortable around each other. 9. She might fall in love with obi Wan because young annie looks up to jedi. Palpatine would be able to use this to turn her to the dark side. 10. It would be interesting
What if general Grievous was defending the separatists council on mustafar (as originally planned via the meeting we see on Utapau before obiwan makes his entrance) when Vader arrived to kill them, resulting in a confrontation between the general and the new darksider over the fate of the separatist council?
What if luminara fell in love with anakin or vice versa. There’s many outcomes for this, this would affect Barriss which in turn would affect Ashoka and how that would affect anakin which would change things by the time of Rots
Anakin, what the devil is he doing on tatooine ? He's supposed to be on musitfar ? Anakin I mean Lord Vader can you hear me, it's is Emperor Palaptine.
I'd like to see Anakin beat Obi-Wan this time around. The lack of lava, Anakin slipping deeper into the dark side, and Anakin having more time to collect himself after his deed in the Jedi temple should all play in Anakin's favor.
What if Leia kept up with her training and fought Ren on Crait? What if Satele returned during The Phantom Menace and trained Anakin? What if Plo was sent to fight Grievous?
I love this. And why not have the conflict between Anakin and the Jedi be about their tolerance of slavery? They condemn it, but know they dont have the mandate or nubers to stamp it out. Anakin just wants them to try. Palpatine lies and tells him the Jedi have refused his requests to expand to the outer perimeter.
It doesn't make any sense why the great Lord Vader would allow Owen and Berue to continue their existence . They failed him and failure can't be tolerated .
RotS Vader is very different from OT Vader. At this point of the timeline, Anakin was experiencing a mental breakdown. He wasn't thinking rationally. Visiting his mother's grave helped him calm down *slightly*; I see no issue with Anakin's thought process presented here by Quill.
@@lordofpain3476 Because the Larses gave his mother a loving home before her death and Cliegg lost his legs looking for her. Vader having some sort of vendetta against the Larses doesn't make sense at all.
What if Jabba saw Anakins story from being a slave to being a hero of the clone wars and after Anakin saved jabbas son jabba would push to end slavery out of respect and would aid Anakin in the clone wars
What if Anakin chose Windu instead of Palpatine in ROTS, yet Windu used Anakin as a scapegoat for the Chancellor's death? Would this betrayal by Master Windu push Anakin to the dark side? Would the Republic believe Mace's word over the hero of the clone wars? Would this backfire on the Jedi Order or would they get away scott free?
![The Entire Clone Wars Timeline [Canon]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/peg3vTiWAj8/mqdefault.jpg)
What if Anakin and Obi Wan handed over their lightsabers to Dooku on the Invisible Hand?
They didn’t wanna make a mess in front of the Chancellor I guess.
do part 2
This actually makes sense his demons is on that planet.
That sand boutta get turned to glass
GLASS THE PLANET!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Man this got way darker and more graphic than I was expecting as your stories don't normally get this violent. It's well written, just unexpected.
Very curious on how a part 2 would play out.
What if Palpatine was arrested for his murder of hego demask?
Anakin, upon determining that palpatine killed Plagueis, could work through the legal system rather than the jedi
For as dark as this timeline was, I can't help but imagine that scene with Anakin and the slaughter of the Hutts with Huey Lewis and the News 'It's hip to be square' playing in the background!
Anakin: Hey, Jabba!
Jabba: *sees lightsaber coming at him* aaargggghhh
I doubt Palps would appreciate Anakin low-key starting a war with the Hutts
Anakin’s slipping more into the dark side and there will always be more crime lords. Palpatine can improvise; he just wants Anakin’s power.
he cant start a war with the hutts if they are literally all dead.
Bruh, the mere fact that Anakin disobeyed him would be a problem. Lol he'd get electrocuted as a punishment, followed by a cruel second punishment because Palpatine is vindictive like that.
@@TreyTheDestroyer Palpatine's treatment of Anakin did not become bad until Anakin failed, lost most of his force potential, and got put in the suit. In this scenario, Anakin was never defeated. He was still the prodigal apprentice that Sidious always wanted, complete with all of his potential. So, I think that Palpatine would have spared Anakin the electrocution treatment and continued to play the part of the friendly mentor, even with his disobedience.
@@freethinker77 Sooo Sith Lords are not generally and unnecessarily harsh with their apprentices? 😅 That's not a thing? He intentionally made the suit painful for him... Vulnerable to force lightning... In this scenario Anakin would be capable of achieving full potential and truthfully Palpatine would never even want Anakin to reach his full potential because that means he'd be overthrown. With ease. Sidious is paranoid and will go to any length to keep his power, and that would include even killing Anakin if he had to and occasionally teaching him a lesson to remind him of his place.
Anakin was acting like how I play in shadow of mordor. I love it. This would be dope animated. Definitely R rated lol. Good stuff.
@@Da_Senate7T Glad you liked it, man :)
Its Skywalkin time Proceeds to butcher watto and jabba
Makes sense and the clones spare the CIS leaders.😊
This definitely needs a part 2
In this case I have to hand it to Anakin for taking his vengeance on those who enslaved him was great.
What if during Padme's pregnancy that she become Force sensitive and noticing the darkness growing in Anakin and around Palpatine. After Ahsoka left the Jedi Order, Padme hired her as a covert personal agent. Anakin's too busy in the war to notice Ahsoka being with Padme as he spends most of his time in the front lines. Ahsoka did start to train Padme the basics on using the Force on her spare time.
PART 2
PART 2
PART 2
PART 2
🎉🎉
" Go to Mustafar and...what the heck it's the other way!"
What if Jabba the Hutt was a Sith lord? A crime lord controlling half the galaxy for hundreds of years is a pretty good candidate for secret Sith lord.
Well that was similar to the plot for the sequels by George Lucas but instead of jabba it would be maul. He would create his own secret legion of criminals to overthrow the new republic after the fall of the empire.
Part II, please! Also, please please please do What if Revan wasn't found in stasis until the first year of the clone wars? That would mean that Revan in his prime would be alive and well, and Darth Vitiate's spirit would still be dormant since Revan didn't awake his spirit at Yavin.
Part 2 would be awesome!
What if Vader learned Leia was his daughter on the Death Star just as he was about to torture her?
Think about how deep that could be. Vader obsessed over Padmé and wanted to bring her back for years in both continuities. If he meets his children, do anyone really believe Vader would torture that remnant? At the risk of them dying or hating him when he would want their loyalty and them to see him as their father? I personally don't. He would be possessive but not abusive imo. It was implied multiple times in sources that Vader cut off Luke's hand by accident, aiming for the lightsaber and only catching his hand in a fit of rage. How would it be now that Vader was about to torture Padmé's daughter?
He might figure out a way to train her to take out Palpatine.
Freezing her boyfriend in carbonate tells me that he did know
@RobertJohnson-kg3pu 😂😂 I hadn't actually seen it that way.
Oh my lord that's funny.
That's a good point. Vader was completely and utterly helpless in the original timeline-stuck between trying to avoid Palpatine from getting his hands on Luke and didn't want to claim his life and his mentality of loyalty. If he found out Leia was his daughter, Vader would simply have more time on his side because Palpatine wouldn't know and thus wouldn't be as pressured. I think the obvious answer is "turn her to the Dark Side", but a deeper and more complex story is Vader trying to protect Leia where he failed to Padme because Vader became more of a nuanced character throughout the years. He missed Padme and wouldn't torture her child because if she dies he would be completely without nothing.
Definitely needs a part 2
This should have a part 2
got to say love the open ending, i do hope for a part 2
I like that, while this what-if counts as a RotS fix-it, it's not a clean fix (although it is debatable whether your Sith paste scenarios could be called "clean" because of, well, the Sith paste). Order 66 still happens. Knightfall still happens. Anakin DOES calm down a little and I think there is still hope for him, despite everything that he had done (I don't blame him for slaughtering the Hutts. Fuck the Hutts.) - but he has yet to contact Padme or take any meaningful steps against Sidious.
There are so many ways for this setup to be resolved if you decide to continue this.
As much as I enjoyed the scene of Gardulla's death, I must point out that the blood wouldn't have the time be expelled from the hilt; given the temperature of a lightsaber blade, it would **immediately** vaporize.
Also note: at that point of the timeline, Anakin wore a brown cloak, not a black one.
This idea does spark another.
What if Obi-Wan secretly contacted R2-D2 and has him delay Anikan just a bit so he and Padme arrive on Mustafar before?
They find the separatist leadership and in an odd change of events Obi-Wan saves the separatists from Anikan.
The leaders, realized they gave been utterly betrayed and turn to Obi-Wan and Padme to save them.
In one fell swoop Obi-Wan is now the military leader of the CIS replacing General grievous and Padme becomes the political leader replacing Count Dooku.
No Droid shut down.
No end of the war.
Now Sidious has a real problem.
Just a thought.
😏
Please make a sequel
Lol.... Palpatine is not the type to overlook disobedience. Anakin would be electrocuted and then subjected to suffering in some cruel situation created by Palpatine because he is vindictive like that.
Bro was playing a dungeon simulator 😂
Imagine if palpatine thought of this and sent the separatist leaders there to get Anakin all in on the dark side?
i give anakins vengence a chefs kiss
"remember the bunta eve, bish??"
oh bro...just got done watching "what if anakin didnt go to mustifar" and harkened back to the separatists waiting there and you have anakin despatch come clones minute 1 i feel so foolish hell yeah dude youre SickWarsQuill
Seeing his newly recruited apprentice go rouge, Palpatine would probably count him amongst the ranks of the jedi, at least as far as order 66 is concerned.
Anakin would be forced to run the gauntlet of both the republic and remaining seperatist forces along every step of his journey untill he either falls back in line under his master, or succumbs to the emporers forces. 🤔
What if Palpatine cut funding to the Jedi instead of obliterating them? You know, they have to take the bus instead of personal ships, Yoda's got a second job, they all have to share lightsabers, after helping anyone they're required to bill them or ask for a small donated to Jedis Without Borders fund, etc.
We need a part 2!
What if Obi-wan and Padme arrested and interrogated the separatist leaders and got all the evidence to reveal Palpatine's treachery?
Kudos man. These are really well written! Please keep it up!
A bad time to be a hutt
What about the droid snack on the Cookies?
Master Jogurt:
''Go i will, good Relations with the cookies, i have''.
Chancellor paperplane: command order 66, im hungry for windys
Master Windshield: You are at this table, but we do not grant you a platter.
Apple(in) Strawberry: ''what?
How can you do? this is Outrageus, it's unfair!''
What if anakin was a girl? It seems like it might not change much, but it definitely will.
1. Annie (anakin) won't fall in love with padme
2. Since girls mature faster, she might not be as tempted by the dark side.
3. Luke and leia wouldn't exist.
4. You will be able to use Taylor Swift as her image.
5. And if she did turn to the dark side, the witches of dathomir might accept her as a witch, and then, with her extreme power, become mother skywalker.
6. Because she is a girl and therefore not as physically strong, she would be less likely to use form 5. This would lead her to use form 4, similar to qui gon jinn. This would lead to less anger.
7. Assuming that padme is a guy, annie would be the one getting pregnant if the relationship happens at all.
8. She would have a better relationship with Ahsoka, and they would be more comfortable around each other.
9. She might fall in love with obi Wan because young annie looks up to jedi. Palpatine would be able to use this to turn her to the dark side.
10. It would be interesting
What if yoda and mace were the only jedi masters and extremly posessiv of this title
Feels like the story is only half over by the end.
What if Anakin lost his legs and arms with his duel on Geonosis with Count Dooku?
Leaves him limbless
What if general Grievous was defending the separatists council on mustafar (as originally planned via the meeting we see on Utapau before obiwan makes his entrance) when Vader arrived to kill them, resulting in a confrontation between the general and the new darksider over the fate of the separatist council?
I didn't know Jabba spoke in a basic language. and it was a little Stat Wars dark.
What if Padme shot on the battle of Geinosis? I mean Dooku shot her, but not killed her.
What if luminara fell in love with anakin or vice versa.
There’s many outcomes for this, this would affect Barriss which in turn would affect Ashoka and how that would affect anakin which would change things by the time of Rots
Maybe Luminara would be more open to improvisation and more lax on Barriss
Anakin, what the devil is he doing on tatooine ? He's supposed to be on musitfar ? Anakin I mean Lord Vader can you hear me, it's is Emperor Palaptine.
Put off main story to do side quests.
What if Anakin had a vision where he sees someone choking padme (he can't see the face) then the vision of padme dying
This needs a part 2
You’re just going to end it like that? Nah man, come on, part 2!
Watto was actually pretty good morally for a slave owner
There is no such thing as a good slave owner.
There really needs to be a part 2 of this as stopping on a cliffhanger sucks.
Damn Jabba got the Leonard Starkweather treatment.
This will need another part to it
Oh no,
you don't say ETA,
you say E, T, A, and then Actis.
Yah, once I heard that,
I just had to stop right there.
What if han died when he was put into carbonite
What if luke skywalker was captured when he went to rescue han leia and chewie
Heh I got an idea.....What if Obi Wan got caught in Barriss explosion within that hanger and he died?
When is part 2 dropping
So he saber whipped her 😂😂😂
What if Luke used yellow eyes while killed Jabba,The Hutt,and yours henchman for save Leia and Han Solo?
What if anakin was knocked out on the invisible hand instead of obi-wan ?
Bro when will you complete the story of anakin and ahsoka escaping mount tantiss
What if Dooku killed Anakin and Obi Wan on the Invisible Hand.
Part 2?
I'd like to see Anakin beat Obi-Wan this time around. The lack of lava, Anakin slipping deeper into the dark side, and Anakin having more time to collect himself after his deed in the Jedi temple should all play in Anakin's favor.
What if Leia kept up with her training and fought Ren on Crait? What if Satele returned during The Phantom Menace and trained Anakin? What if Plo was sent to fight Grievous?
I love this. And why not have the conflict between Anakin and the Jedi be about their tolerance of slavery? They condemn it, but know they dont have the mandate or nubers to stamp it out. Anakin just wants them to try. Palpatine lies and tells him the Jedi have refused his requests to expand to the outer perimeter.
What if Anakin and padme were addicted to death sticks and spice in attack of the clones
What if ahsoka becomes a night sister back during her childhood?
I want to see a part 2
It doesn't make any sense why the great Lord Vader would allow Owen and Berue to continue their existence .
They failed him and failure can't be tolerated .
RotS Vader is very different from OT Vader. At this point of the timeline, Anakin was experiencing a mental breakdown. He wasn't thinking rationally. Visiting his mother's grave helped him calm down *slightly*; I see no issue with Anakin's thought process presented here by Quill.
@@lordofpain3476 Because the Larses gave his mother a loving home before her death and Cliegg lost his legs looking for her. Vader having some sort of vendetta against the Larses doesn't make sense at all.
Part 2 please
Part 2, please
So you’re saying there’s a chance he could turn back to the light?
What if Jabba saw Anakins story from being a slave to being a hero of the clone wars and after Anakin saved jabbas son jabba would push to end slavery out of respect and would aid Anakin in the clone wars
What if Kelleran beq along with ahsoka tano raised luke and leia skywalker the skywalker twins.
What if Anakin chose Windu instead of Palpatine in ROTS, yet Windu used Anakin as a scapegoat for the Chancellor's death? Would this betrayal by Master Windu push Anakin to the dark side?
Would the Republic believe Mace's word over the hero of the clone wars? Would this backfire on the Jedi Order or would they get away scott free?
what if tarkin was force sensitve?
His family (on Eriadu) was kinda heavy of tradition and all that apparently. So can’t say for sure :/ I doubt they would have surrendered him.
@@starwarsquillit’s a good thing the Jedi don’t take children by force.
Oh right..
@@nobbyfirefly57 I don't think Tarkins dad is gonna turn into a demon monster lol.
Hello there
part 2?
we need a part 2!