How To Convince Someone With Dementia They Need Help

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
  • When someone with Alzheimer’s disease, Lewy Body dementia, Vascular Dementia, Frontotemporal dementia seems to be in denial, it can be hard to get them to change. In this video I share how to actually get the person with dementia to change without causing more harm to your relationship.
    Stay updated on all our announcements and programs at www.careblazers.com
    FREE Resources:
    📕Download your FREE TV Guide on Dementia to avoid common caregiving mistakes: bit.ly/3RxKzNN
    FREE Resource:
    📺 Get Access to A FREE Dementia Caregiver Training on How to Care For a Loved One With Dementia- WITHOUT The Overwhelm, Dread, and Confusion: ➡︎ www.dementiaca...
    💻Follow me on instagram and TikTOk @Dementia_Careblazers
    💌 [LET’S CONNECT]
    Connect with other Careblazers for information and support inside my Facebook group: / dementiacareblazers
    🌟 Care Course:
    Join the Care Course and transform you caregiving journey with the most amazing and supportive community. There is a better way. Change is possible. It starts here:
    www.dementiaca...
    ______________
    Instagram: / dementia_careblazers
    TikTok: / dementia_careblazers
    ______________
    CHECK OUT MY POPULAR PLAYLISTS
    Managing Stress and Burnout: • DEMENTIA SELF-CARE AND...
    Dealing with Challenging Behaviors:
    • DIFFICULT DEMENTIA BEH...
    ______________
    OTHER VIDEOS MENTIONED IN THIS VIDEO:
    • Why your loved one doe...
    __
    In case you haven’t met me, my name is Natali Edmonds and I am a board certified geropsychologist. That means that I am a clinical psychologist who specializes in working with older adults. One day, while hiking a trail, I came up with the idea for Careblazers and I decided to see if posting videos online could provide help to the many other Careblazers in the world who don’t get to have help come directly to them in their homes. I hope that this work helps you in some way on your caregiving journey.
    #careblazer #dementia #alzheimer

ความคิดเห็น • 499

  • @gsimonin1
    @gsimonin1 ปีที่แล้ว +193

    As my dear mother in law progressed in her dementia, one day she told me she was afraid, that she didn’t know where she was. This was very unlike her. I thought about it for a moment and replied, “it’s okay mom, you are safe with us and we’re going to take care of you. “. Because we had a long term relationship, she always recognized family members. It was enough.

    • @northerngirl1637
      @northerngirl1637 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      💕💙👍

    • @edewest5036
      @edewest5036 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +13

      My husband didn't know me today 1st time ever...in a store 😭 10:21

    • @lauramanion3131
      @lauramanion3131 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +7

      @@edewest5036 Oh dear … Big hug to you ❤️

    • @Rustytoolgardener
      @Rustytoolgardener 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

      @@edewest5036 this is what scares me to death. Strength to you. ❤️

    • @ya472
      @ya472 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

      Yes, but even when you think they comprehend, they do not. Try using 4 or less word sentences. The result is the same, to acknowledge their concern.

  • @brendadickenson3547
    @brendadickenson3547 ปีที่แล้ว +42

    Just as my husband was moving our wardrobe in the middle of the night, so I asked him what was he doing this for. He told me the refrigerator was in the way and he needed to go to the bsthroom. I said well we do have 3 so come with me and used another one, so I took his hand and led him out of the master bath to our guest one and he said now why didn't I think of that! I told him maybe he was so tired. He accepted that.

    • @jeweloo8
      @jeweloo8 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      V:

  • @missnucci26
    @missnucci26 ปีที่แล้ว +17

    This is great! And this ‘method’ can be used way beyond your family member with dementia. Thank You!!

  • @donnaingle1359
    @donnaingle1359 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    This will help a lot!

  • @123jinty
    @123jinty 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Great video, so helpful, many thanks

  • @francesbernard2445
    @francesbernard2445 ปีที่แล้ว

    I had the opposite situation to cope with once after over 40 years ago being hospitalized for a post partum depression which instead was a misdiagnosis. While living with a violent man who beat me up 5 days after giving birth. However my repuation since then has never fully recoverd however I have. Just last winter a DATS driver driving me in the winter to help me cope with the potential for falls on icy streets seemed demented while maybe thinking I was the demented one when believing that I could live in my own home instead of in a walk up apartment building. For some reason she had the wrong address associated with my name. When I pointed out my house to her she drove past it. At first I though maybe she was turning to drop me off on the right side of the narrow street right in front of my house. Which was fine. Except she kept askkng me several times if other houses were mine instead without dropping off anybody else while doing so. No matter how many times I said no that's not my house she kept on doing the same thing until I finally got to point again to my onw house. Reminded me of another scene I coped with well enough almost a couple of decades earlier when the bus driver started going off route while thinking I was demented because I walked up to him behind the wheel to be pointing that out to them in a calm way while saying I take his bus number home often so I should know. Good thing there was another passenger -the only other passenger on the bus he had not seen yet- who had had enough with his arrogance too while sticking up for me on how he was going off route. Maybe my second ex husband who drove bus in this city too told him I had dementia instead of only a history of postpartum depression instead before he got diagnosed with the dementia?

  • @dannymeske3821
    @dannymeske3821 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Calm down Natali!

  • @alejandrabaez5922
    @alejandrabaez5922 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

    How do i get my mother to do her exercises,? When i ask her to do it she gets angry with me. Her mobility isnt good, she told me she needed special shoes, got them, she then says its too hot or its cold outside, got her some machines at home for to do them, but she still refuses and the doctors get upset with me as she isn't doing them, i have told them all i have done and purchased for her and she only gets angry at me and the doctor as well... what do i do?? 😢

  • @daynacjones
    @daynacjones ปีที่แล้ว

    My mother got ahold f her debit card statement and accused us of gambling at Race Track! Race Track the gas station………

  • @douglasfowkes6461
    @douglasfowkes6461 ปีที่แล้ว +53

    This is Douglas just to add to the last posting I given here I think it's important that my wife Jessica was only 52 years old and she was at least 48 when I noticed signs of dementia but all of your videos that you did all of the information you handed out was my lifeline to me be my wife's only caregiver because she was denied every service is available to her so I was on my own and you were my lifeline thank you for all your videos and get really save me to help take care of my wife thank you

  • @vzeimen
    @vzeimen ปีที่แล้ว +78

    So good! It took me so long and so much frustration to learn how to do this. I felt I had finally overcome arguing and convincing (and for the most part had) and then last week I had a big ol argument over clipping toenails. (sigh). Part of the issue with us caregivers is that we want our loved one to be more themselves and to be logical in these things that seem to be no-brainers. What helps me at each new stage is to take some time to actually mourn incrementally the losses and then see clearly the path forward. This really helps me shift my thinking and be a better caretaker for her.

    • @amyhenningsgard8618
      @amyhenningsgard8618 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Thanks for sharing!

    • @deawallace3584
      @deawallace3584 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Exactly right...mourning the loss of the actual relationship. There is nothing that can save a relationship when a Spouse is not a spouse, but has turned into a narcissistic toddler, and you are now their parent.

    • @ya472
      @ya472 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      At the same time of mourning, learn to accept this is a new person who needs your calming help.

  • @AWanderingEye
    @AWanderingEye ปีที่แล้ว +57

    Another thought about the house would be to leave, drive around the block and say "oh shoot I forgot we have to stop at this house and water the plants" then drive back and go inside. by the time inside she may recognize something of the interior so not have the thought "this is not my house".

  • @candicane1
    @candicane1 ปีที่แล้ว +47

    8 years in with my LO and they still are convinced they are completely fine. It’s beyond frustrating. Yes, I know it’s the disease, but it’s still frustrating.

    • @stevecrane8102
      @stevecrane8102 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Hopefully by now, you realize you don’t have to convince them that they are not fine, you just have to work around it.

    • @mapleext
      @mapleext 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +7

      I don’t think it’s a piece of cake to work around it. I mean you can get better at it but it’s still quite a challenge.

    • @chook1678
      @chook1678 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      It's horrible. My 62 yo husband has become physically abusive. Always been verbally horrendous. Anyone else experience this?

    • @johnhaller5851
      @johnhaller5851 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@chook1678That's when a care home would start using drugs. Hospice has many tools for that, if they are eligible for hospice.

  • @heatherjunker967
    @heatherjunker967 ปีที่แล้ว +83

    I really needed this video. Dad is in process if getting diagnosed. I have tried for ten years but my parents covered for each other and he refused to go to the doctor. Mom passed and now dad is a lot worse still months later. MRI shows problems but neurologist follow up appt isn't until a few weeks. Dad thinks he can drive and doesn't need any help. I am watching your videos and soaking up all the info I can. You are truly an angel on Earth with helping all of us care for our loved ones. Thank you.

    • @trishaplute4850
      @trishaplute4850 ปีที่แล้ว +18

      When my grandmother was not safe to drive, but insisted on it, my dad came up with a clever solution. He dismantled the car, and put a note under the hood telling anyone she recruited to fix the car what was going on. It worked, as nobody seemed to be able to fix it for her!

    • @theaweavers8576
      @theaweavers8576 ปีที่แล้ว +10

      With the car problem the keys went missing as it was the best solutuon to a really difficult situation ...

    • @carlallen3857
      @carlallen3857 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      My mom has her appointment in 3 days… 6 week wait. She thinks she is fine. Take the keys and the spare keys. I said insurance suspended until assessment is complete.

    • @heartofglass7235
      @heartofglass7235 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      diagnoses is hard when they are good at fooling others who dont know them. had to go to geriatric dr and have mri done and even then i had to tell him her brain mass was 2 standard deviations lower than normal . “ oh yeah, ok ill prescribe arricept” . not that it helped

    • @susanwhite655
      @susanwhite655 ปีที่แล้ว +27

      @@heartofglass7235 I would you give you more thumbs up if I could. On my mom's first evaluation, they asked her to spell the word "world" backwards, which she did, and they said oh, she has mild dementia. I got so upset and told them that stupid test does not show that she cannot operate a microwave, almost started a fire on the stove, already gave away her social security checks to sweepstakes instead of paying her past due bills, is eating nothing but toast day in and day out and throwing away everything else, already had the police bring her home because she got lost driving. They finally sent her to a 4-hour interview with a neuropsychologist; after 4 hours of talking, my mom was no longer able to fool, everyone could see the true condition of her brain.

  • @valerieeves4557
    @valerieeves4557 ปีที่แล้ว +37

    I appreciate what you are saying in this video but am having a hard time applying it to my situation with my mother. She should not be living alone but refuses to move or have help come in. She is an extremely negative person and sits all day at her kitchen table being angry and blaming me because her Dr. took her license away. Being alone is very bad for her mental health. I live an hour away but there is a person taking her out for groceries and cleaning ladies come to do housework. How do I get her moved without trying to convince her? I often have to back off because I get angry and particularly because I am the target of her wrath.

    • @davidhunter5062
      @davidhunter5062 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      I’m with you on “how do you apply this to the mom-can-no-longer-live-alone?” situation. The goal is to keep her safe. The only solution, since she had dementia and dad just passed away two weeks ago, is for her to not live alone and assisted living is the only real alternative. But how do you accomplish your objective by “diversion”? (The “this is not my home” situational response of “Oh, I know, we just had to stop here and check on the owners’ cat”, etc. has no equivalent to the living at home safely problem…as far as I can see.)

    • @paulbunsell3736
      @paulbunsell3736 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      I’m in the same situation. My dad has just been diagnosed with Korsakoff (alcohol induced dementia) and the doctors have stated he needs 24/7 care in an aged care facility as we don’t have anyone who can look after him around the clock. At least he’s not leaving the hospital until this is resolved, so I won’t be getting calls from the police that he’s fallen in front of a car again, or crashed a car, or been unconscious on a park bench.
      He furious and says it’s my fault I didn’t help him earlier - I live 1000 kms away in a different state and have gone up multiple times to bring him back, help him sort out his house, rescue him. I’ve also booked him into rehab 3 times prior to the diagnosis and he’s refused at the last moment to go. He’s only 68 years old. Then other times he says he’s fine, has no problem, and asks why I lied to the doctors about his behaviours.
      I’m so angry at him too, but at the same time I just want him safe. And I also want him in an environment where he can socialise with new people, where he’s living his best life. I have no idea how to solve this just yet.

    • @debby891
      @debby891 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      This sounds like my life with my mom except I care for her 24/7

    • @goodpony1971
      @goodpony1971 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +9

      i’m in the same situation over here. My dad basically killed himself and I think it was so he could get away from my mom
      with mild dementia, because who knows- she may have had dementia since she was 50 and no one knew it. She’s always been paranoid and delusional and hostile and aggressive, and then she can be a sweet and docile child like go-getter. I guess I always thought she was just a narcissistic borderline personality who was a very toxic individual and now she’s 81 and my dad‘s been dead Almost a month and she refuses to go anywhere or hire any help and even if I get a caregiver for a few hours a day that won’t be enough because she’s still driving and she loops every five minutes but then other time she has crystal clear memory and it’s scary! I’ve taken over everything and sometimes I think maybe I’ve made a horrible mistake and I doubt everything and I feel like I’m gonna get in huge trouble. And also, it’s hard for me to call her my “Lo”, because I don’t know if I even love her. She’s horrible and she abused my poor dad, unfortunately I am the closest person to her, and Im suffering terrible guilt and feelings of responsibility for her even though she has always been her own worst enemy. I don’t know how to think backwards to solve this impossible riddle. I usually just pray that she will die peacefully in her sleep and so I can say, “thank God that nightmare is finally over”. And then I just feel like a terrible person for thinking that and of course the next time she calls me she’ll be sweet and nice and say something like I’m a wonderful daughter and she loves me and she got my daughter a lot of nice Christmas presents and she misses my dad and then I flashback to her pinching him and throwing water on him and screaming at him And I get caught in this loop.

    • @itzchelleytime185
      @itzchelleytime185 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@debby891me too…..

  • @denisemerillat5407
    @denisemerillat5407 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +11

    One thing caregivers need to understand is that they are NOT deceiving their loved ones using these techniques. Ultimately, the goal is to do what is in their loved one’s best interest. Their lack of understanding is part of the disease. I really appreciate your videos!

  • @michaelzumpano7318
    @michaelzumpano7318 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +13

    For example: My mother believes the cemetery workers moved her mother’s and father’s graves. For four years we pass the cemetery every day on our rides, and for FOUR YEARS!!!! I have been struggling to get her to understand! I’ve shown her pictures that obviously show her parents are where they’ve always been. I’ve had the cemetery staff meet with her and explain the legal ramifications of such a move. OMG! Tomorrow, we are just going to start taking a route that doesn’t go by the cemetery. Jeez! I should really take an IQ test.

    • @RL-kn2dt
      @RL-kn2dt หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Thank you I needed this post. 😂

  • @antm64
    @antm64 ปีที่แล้ว +55

    As a former care provider, this is the most valuable video I have ever seen!! Everyone caring for a dementia person needs to understand and follow your advice!!

    • @drc04
      @drc04 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      I find the comments almost as helpful as the video! Join your local Alzheimer’s Support Group!

    • @Bareness
      @Bareness 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I agree!

  • @alexmorgan3435
    @alexmorgan3435 ปีที่แล้ว +39

    Thank you Dr Natalie. Your video is so timely and helpful. I have adopted this strategy in the last few months as I am so sick of arguing with my mother it goes absolutely no where and is pointless for the reasons you give for both the LO and the care giver. So now I just do, with only the necessary conversation to get her to do the things she needs to do or I need her to do for her benefit. Nothing more. Things seem to be better now although not hugely better. Often I still have to bite my lip really hard, but a quiet life is the prize. Thanks again.

    • @KactusKM
      @KactusKM 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@SamSlugg456I so understand. My mom has betrayed me and lied to me my entire life, emotional neglect where I had to care for her needs since a very young child. I was always the responsible one. She carried on trauma behaviors from her past to me, her only child. And while I was codependent for so long and didn’t know the difference, I have learned and stepped into my own self. Still dealing with cptsd however and the pull that her dementia has on trying to draw me back into codependent behaviors and give up caring for myself. This is a truly hellish situation. I have had her power of atty, health directive, etc and we have subsidized her housing and solved her real world problems since my dad died. 30 years ago. She transferred all the responsibility for her life from dad to us. I am so raw and needing to care for myself before I can care for anyone else. I thank God that my husband does not have the history with her that I do and he does the interactions while I work behind the scenes trying to be creative for her and remain safe for myself. We are pursuing independent care for her so we can just be with her at times and not try to handle all her care. She cannot live in her own anymore.

  • @CadusBane
    @CadusBane 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +23

    How I wish you could help me right now! My mom has all of the signs of at least stage four vascular dementia. And I am disabled with reflex sympathetic dystrophy. I’ve told her doctor over and over again. He is also my doctor, but he can’t tell me anything.
    We a leaving a a few hours for a long car trip across two states. I have my permit back, but she won’t let me drive! Last week she ran the busiest red light in town twice. There was five car horns going off at us. Last year around Christmas we almost got T boned because she doesn’t pay attention when driving!
    She’s lost four of her upper front teeth. Because she stopped brushing her teeth. She did the same thing as you talk about in this video she accused me of replacing the lights in the bathroom last year.
    She’s got physical with me and I’ve taken pictures of it. But she won’t face it at all. Her doctor has ordered her to get an MRI and she won’t do it. Nothing I say works!!!
    If anyone reads this it’s October 12th and tomorrow is the 13th. If a person of faith and prayer. Please pray for us as we travel through WI today and tomorrow MN.
    She’s paranoid, has sudden mood swings, is very impulsive, and when she’s not all she does is sleep.
    I have done all I can do because the state of Wisconsin can’t help me till she’s diagnosed. And she won’t get the test done to get diagnosed and it’s bad. It’s so so bad. She’s hasn’t cooked since thanksgiving if 2021. I’ve lived off snack food, junk food and fast food so much my stomach is a mess. I had to finally stop eating at times. Because the stress and my own pain issues. I am sick all the time because I’m in my last stage of my own illness.
    I have God and I know he’s on my side. But being in this all alone is so tough. I had a girlfriend of nine years keep saying will figure it out. I begged her last year to move up here and help me. She freaked out and didn’t know what to do. I knew then it was over. When I ended it in June, she’d later write back out of hurt and anger I was right she never was brave enough to move.
    Does anyone know how tough it is to be with a mom that was emotionally and physically abusive till I got too big to hit. Then watch her control my dad for so many years. How she had to have the dishes and the house set up. Now it’s a little house in the north woods she won’t let anyone else enter because of the mess it is inside.
    I am awful for saying this but I can’t wait for her to get found out because I’ve tried for two years. Nothing has happened but she’s gotten so much worse.
    God bless anyone that read this I power dumped a lot. I’m scared and I’m alone and it’s really tough to be in this battle all alone. I have faith and trust that the Lord will be done.

    • @davidhaskell4837
      @davidhaskell4837 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      You are not alone, others like myself go through similar battles. Your alone in your battle but not in the war is a good way to put it. It can be rough when you love them so much. But keep going your a warrior.

    • @christineantwine277
      @christineantwine277 หลายเดือนก่อน

      i hope things have improved for you. i cant even imagine the struggles you are having. im glad you are holding to your faith but please realize the devastating things we are facing is not from Him. it is from ... well... this will explain, 1John 5:19. but there is hope because God is aware. i do not want to be preaching here so will stop. try contacting organizations that might have information where you can get help for free. the Lyons club might have information. even calling senior centers around your location might have information you can use in order to get help. my heart goes out to you.

    • @adelinamadjarova7518
      @adelinamadjarova7518 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Leave God, he might or might not help. You need a person to take care of you and your mother. Or two carers.

    • @notmeee7302
      @notmeee7302 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      There is an adult protective services in your state that you can call yourself. Call the police. Call somebody. Keep calling until you get help.

  • @miumama2007
    @miumama2007 ปีที่แล้ว +20

    Thank you. I have been doing the wrong way...showing evidence, step by step asking my loved one to think if something makes sense. Now, its a big discovery that it doesn't work at all!!!! Thank you so much for the enlightenment

  • @btpuppy2
    @btpuppy2 ปีที่แล้ว +33

    I just wonder why people with dementia seem to always make everything so difficult or even impossible? Why don’t more people just QUIETLY lose their faculties while being pleasant and non-combative? My grandmother was like this. Super easy.. but not my mother! Why is it always such a huge fight?

    • @dudanunesbleff
      @dudanunesbleff 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      I believe that it's because most people aren't really quiet or nice. They may have behaved like that, but it was a very long act, to be socially accepted.

    • @DustinKillyact
      @DustinKillyact 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      I'm thinking the person Im having this problem with was already like that all their life they drove every person involved away with insanity they wouldn't admit it then and is just worse about it now

    • @wyleddawg6130
      @wyleddawg6130 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      ​@@DustinKillyactyes I understand that too. The doctors diagnosing my mother were trying to get a baseline for my mother's aggressive behaviour and I kept saying that is her personality just hugely magnified. They thought she may have been a drinker or smoker that suddenly she had to give up and was angry about that. She wasnt. Her way or the highway.

    • @rebeccamoore4177
      @rebeccamoore4177 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

      My mother also did not fit society’s norms. It was tiring to explain so if I didn’t have to I wouldn’t.

    • @blind5211
      @blind5211 16 วันที่ผ่านมา

      there could be different reasons... one of them is, like the author of this video said, they might have no awareness that they can no longer work, or why. It might literally make no sense to them. As ridiculous as it sounds, they might not realize their condition, even after you prove it to them. It's a mental abnormality that happens with people sometimes. Of course, to them, it would look like people are trying to get them to retire for no good reason. But it could be a different reason too. Brain is a complicated thing, but the most important thing is, don't assume that they understand everything, that they control everything they're doing or saying perfectly, that they "just wanna resist and be stubborn" etc., because it could always be something else entirely, even when it looks like stubbornness. And remember, it could be really painful to lose a job, or the ability to work at all. This whole condition is obviously very painful, so just living with it can often be a reason for their bad mood

  • @TheDWZemke
    @TheDWZemke ปีที่แล้ว +26

    You are so spot on! My wife, PhD, has not been a corporate leader for over 7+ years. She believes she is 100% capable. Yet, She can not remember where the coffee cups are in a house that we have lived in for 20+ years, that we use every day. .....(Now that you understand my world). I find that, I end up negotiating things for future discussions. For example. Go to bed here tonight, and tomorrow we can discuss... going home. You know if you do "X" for me it will make my life better. Lastly, my wife will remember that she has been arguing / debating with someone for hours... but NOT remember what the discussion was about or with whom, with in 5 min of the discussion. (We live alone). To your point, logical discussion is over ruled by her feelings.

    • @SuperNewKittie
      @SuperNewKittie ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Thank you so much for posting this. I really love the idea of "discussing it later".
      My mom stopped drinking 22 years ago after many years of having a nightly glass of wine (or two) with dinner. She was prompted to quit by a sudden acute pancreatitis attack the doctors attributed to alcohol. Her dementia has been slowly progressing for 5 or 6 years but has recently become more pronounced and she and my dad picked up their nite-cap routine again. My dad mistakenly thought it would help with her anxious/ agitated behavior but it has turned into her feigning for alcohol almost from the first moment they wake up in the morning until they go to bed every night. It became really bad recently when she was sneaking his gin and guzzling it in the mornings and she was spending the entire day drunk and mean. She fell into her nightstand around 10 days ago and had to be hospitalized for two nights for a brain bleed (we were so lucky it wasn't much worse!). The drinking was a high concern to the hospital staff and we were told she had to stop. My dad had already been working on trying to end the drinking once he realized it made his life a living hell, but my mom's dementia has made her meaner than a hornet's nest, and she is very stubborn, so he would relent and go to the store to buy wine for her every day just to have a few minutes of peace in his life. Now with the injury, he has stuck to his guns and refuses to buy it for her, but she never stops asking for it. She's on a loop all day long about it, and calls me and my daughter multiple times a day to yell at us that we are in on this conspiracy with my dad to ruin her life.
      I am learning a lot from some of the dementia groups I've joined about how to talk to my mom with this condition but nothing seems to work for this alcohol thing. I am going to try the technique you've mentioned. Thanks so much.

    • @nancyevans1278
      @nancyevans1278 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      @@SuperNewKittie I feel terrible for you and for your situation! My neighbor had a very clever solution that worked for her when her husband, who had dementia, wanted to continue his evening drinking routine. She gave him a watered down 'version' with grape juice and water mixed together, which she served to her husband in a wine glass. She kept this concoction in a carafe so it would look like red wine. He enjoyed his glasses of wine every night. I hope that something like this might work for you. Good luck!

    • @bratniadusza480
      @bratniadusza480 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@SuperNewKittie there are plenty of alcohol-free alternatives, but the answer from @nancyevans1278 is also clever

  • @toadhall5041
    @toadhall5041 ปีที่แล้ว +78

    So many people object to "lying" to your loved one. Being kind is way more important. Example: telling a woman who is asking for her husband that her husband is dead is in fact cruel. Lying by saying he's at work is kind.

    • @jimmiecox2496
      @jimmiecox2496 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      That's the type of question that I will gently change the subject. It generally works.

    • @virginiatozier9957
      @virginiatozier9957 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      You can see what the dementia is doing to them. Don't be blind to what it's doing to you.
      This world is full of liars, it doesn't need another one. Find a soft was to say it.

    • @KarinCrawford
      @KarinCrawford ปีที่แล้ว +12

      Or even better, you'll see him after a while... which is true in one sense...

    • @elizabethyoung4900
      @elizabethyoung4900 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      ​@@virginiatozier9957sounds like you're advocating Reality Orientation which is no longer considered as a way to deal with things, it's deemed unkind and distressing

    • @tracybenson6364
      @tracybenson6364 ปีที่แล้ว +13

      Please be kind.
      The individual who suggested that we tell her “he’s‘. ‘at work’ was offering a solution. She does not need to be shamed. And The individual with dementia has memory loss. She still has feelings and knows you are annoyed. If we could all just be kind to EVERYONE (including ourselves) all of us could be so much better.

  • @annwatts9884
    @annwatts9884 ปีที่แล้ว +19

    Thank you, so insiteful. For the first time today she sat outside carehome saying why have you brought me here. i did it all wrong but luckily she decided to go with it and get out of car. My horror was she pushed open car door and got out without even looking for oncoming traffic , luckily nothing coming. Another Lesson learned. On the good side i have been listening to your talks and stopped confrontations and correcting with redirecting and we had a lovely afternoon.

  • @jancoleman84
    @jancoleman84 ปีที่แล้ว +82

    Learning about anosognosia from you was one of the most enlightening moments in understanding the behavior of my mother with dementia.

    • @shaynebergwever6268
      @shaynebergwever6268 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Same here, great information here

    • @KactusKM
      @KactusKM 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      My mom ALWAYS has had a lack of awareness! That is what makes this so difficult - from a borderline personality issue to dementia. The only thing has changed is her memory and her physical inabilities.

    • @MaryannAyer-t9q
      @MaryannAyer-t9q 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      What is anisognosia

    • @jancoleman84
      @jancoleman84 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@MaryannAyer-t9q here is the definition: Anosognosia is a neurological condition in which the patient is unaware of their neurological deficit or psychiatric condition. It is associated with mental illness, dementia, and structural brain lesion, as is seen in right hemisphere stroke patients.

  • @Robynn-pr4lv
    @Robynn-pr4lv ปีที่แล้ว +13

    My mother is in a nursing home. She is convinced that she doesn't need to be there & she will be able to come home & do chores & cook meals & never hallucinate & fall. The nursing home's doctor told her it is up to me when/if she can come home. So now my mom thinks that I don't love her & don't want her around.
    I know why I want to convince her she needs help. So she knows how loved & precious she is to me & does not have the stress of constantly tryingto convince me she's fune. I get that part. I just don't know what steps to take next.

  • @LK-qz7eh
    @LK-qz7eh ปีที่แล้ว +9

    Too bad there’s not a video out there that covers my problem.
    My problem is even bigger. My dad doesn’t believe he has dementia and his other kids and his friends/ business associates don’t believe he is sick. Despite medical evidence from caregivers and drs official diagnosis . So my dads other kids and friends are trying to get him out on his own because they believe he is perfectly fine. So he’s getting violent and aggressive with caregivers. Dad is now blaming my oldest sister (who he appointed power of attorney) for controlling him and taking away his independence.

    • @StrawBerry-mm1iy
      @StrawBerry-mm1iy 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Yes, sometimes they will behave extremely normal with other people and behave otherwise with us that sometimes we even think that maybe they are just acting? But it is not acting it is the sickness. Also they become extremely cunning so be aware and stay safe.

  • @pamfreeman6376
    @pamfreeman6376 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    I am dealing with both my parents having dementia. I'm responsible for most things. I have M.S. and many other things including chronic pain. I don't know what I'm going to do as they get worse. There is no $ for care.😢

    • @bcLCurtis214
      @bcLCurtis214 ปีที่แล้ว

      Check out Gabor Mate - neurologist who details how caregivers get autoimmune diseases from burnout. Save yourself.

  • @jeanneharrison8120
    @jeanneharrison8120 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Not that I don’t appreciate your advice, for I do. It’s just that you repeated the same information numerous times and the 13 minute video could have been done in 5 and maybe would get more views. Sorry, I know you are very knowledgeable and I hope you don’t think I’m attacking you personally

  • @KDJ4Jesus
    @KDJ4Jesus ปีที่แล้ว +16

    Thank you so much for posting this video!! My dad has been living with us for the past year and a half and I’ve been doing everything you stated as a “DON”T DO THIS!!” Bummer! I didn’t consider the “horse sense” you mentioned and have seen, what I now realize is depression, shown by his withdrawing to his room for long periods of time, even skipping meals. Now I know how to change this and the correct way to talk to him. Thank you again. P.S. A simple 1-2-3 point reminder printable would be excellent as well!

  • @mikewoodley8767
    @mikewoodley8767 ปีที่แล้ว +18

    Goal cantered vs problem centered 🙃 thank you !

  • @audraberreth7632
    @audraberreth7632 ปีที่แล้ว +30

    I was a CNA in the early 90’s and we were forced to use Reality Orientation. I’m so glad they’ve moved on from that, because it exacerbated their behavior. My step mother is in early stage and now you’ve helped me to understand her “denial” and “contentiousness” with my dad and give him some strategy to help. Thank you!

    • @sandraoommen
      @sandraoommen ปีที่แล้ว

      99

    • @sandraoommen
      @sandraoommen ปีที่แล้ว

      Thanks so 😊

    • @sandraoommen
      @sandraoommen ปีที่แล้ว

      I86i⁹pi😮😊

    • @elizabethyoung4900
      @elizabethyoung4900 ปีที่แล้ว

      @audraberreth7632 I used to hate being told to use RO, it's so unkind and distressing. Thank heavens they've moved on

  • @heatheranne3103
    @heatheranne3103 ปีที่แล้ว +21

    Thank you, Dr. Natali. Exactly the balm so many of us need.

  • @sandyschneider6792
    @sandyschneider6792 ปีที่แล้ว +18

    Your channel was extremely helpful! My mom has passed away. She died from “Terminal Restlessness” which was never titled or addressed and created serious problems with hospice and I in the end stages. It was very traumatic for both of us…primarily my mom. I was told to sedate her and she would sleep for 24 hours…get dehydrated, and Season’s Day care would get upset with me not bringing her in on a “regular” schedule! They had NO u derstanding if her situation.😓🙁. Perhaps you could address “terminal Restlessness” at some point because …even the ALZ help line did not address it. I learned about it 3 months after she passed and all our trauma/drama. 😵‍💫🙁

    • @yvonnerojas5737
      @yvonnerojas5737 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I wonder if that's what my husband has who continually needs to be doing something. He gets mad w me if I don't want to go out w him every day and that is still not enough! He also doesn't want to eat. I have to fight w him about that. He's lost so much weight.

    • @JennySimon206
      @JennySimon206 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      You can't force a dying body to absorb nutrients. Do not force food into someone not hungry. Their body can't assimilate it. They can't even force IV fluids when the kidneys are failing.

  • @undonemissionarts4222
    @undonemissionarts4222 ปีที่แล้ว +43

    Thank you! This has been such a challenge because things change moment to moment and sometimes I feel guilty when I choose not to be honest in order to solve problems

    • @miragaiamaia8966
      @miragaiamaia8966 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      i think about it like this: when we reach the level where we need to use magical thinking, honesty doesn't apply, and maybe some other values... i'm just starting this road...

  • @mollyvollmer608
    @mollyvollmer608 ปีที่แล้ว +27

    I only wish I could have used some of these techniques with my mother. She was a very stubborn woman. Even the nurses, as nice as they were, had an extremely difficult time with her. It was heartbreaking. I am thankful now to learn this 😊

  • @kathrynbritt3463
    @kathrynbritt3463 ปีที่แล้ว +10

    You described my aunt perfectly. Any suggestions on how to get her to memory care? There is finally an opening and I need to get her there ASAP. Not safe in her own home and starting to wander. Recently diagnosed but known for years. Please help!

    • @AWanderingEye
      @AWanderingEye ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Here's a thought I came up with: is there something about her home she has wanted fixed over the years? Maybe a rouse would be to say "please stay at this hotel while we redo your paint/carpet, etc. Don't worry about how we're paying for it, we've got that covered. Just go and enjoy yourself at the hotel while we get this done." Get memory care staff onboard using "hotel" instead of memory care ward. Many memory care facilities have things like a cafe, beauty salon, theatre so are like a kind of mall. Hoping that you can make her transition as pain free as possible!
      When we had to take my dad to nursing home because my mom had broken femur and needed to be in nursing care herself, the staff met him at the car and walked with him inside so none of us know how it went down. He had alz. and my mom was the primary care giver. During his stay he had access to phone and would have them call our numbers asking to be picked up, but we each had to just say we couldn't pick him up. We would visit and leaving was the most difficult time, got to say, is there anything I should bring you the next time I come? just to get out the door. Many tears on our parts but it also meant he got anti anxiety meds and likely was more relaxed and less concerned about day to day life than he was when living with my mom. she wasn't an esp good caregiver in general so house was filled with arguments. he didn't get anti anxiety meds until he as in memory care as they didn't abide with meds for his condition. it would have helped both of my parents immensely but the flat out refused.

  • @HellaBella
    @HellaBella ปีที่แล้ว +13

    Great way to approach a difficult situation. My grandma has started going to the grocery store every day and buying stuff to the point of stuffing her fridge beyond capacity. Now it is filled with out of date/moldy food. I am so overwhelmed at the prospect of cleaning up over there. I don’t want to upset her or make her think she’s not good enough but we can’t continue to let her live in such a gross environment. She watches the same movie every single day and gets up and does the same routine for the most part. Right now she’s able to live alone but I don’t think she will be able to for much longer. She has delusions that her abusive ex husband has moved in next door and she also told us she’s been getting mail from his new wife, but then told us the mail is thrown away when we ask to see it. It’s crazy how this stuff progresses. She was okay last year and now she is a completely different person.

    • @debby891
      @debby891 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Sounds like exactly what I’m going through with my mom and she gets so paranoid about everything

  • @marysusa6985
    @marysusa6985 ปีที่แล้ว +34

    OMG, this is soooo helpful. Just like all your videos, but I really needed to hear this today. Thank you so very much for your generosity in sharing your knowledge with us.

    • @DementiaCareblazers
      @DementiaCareblazers  ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Glad it was helpful!

    • @jillorcutt6830
      @jillorcutt6830 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      I need a creative explanation to get my older sister to allow the aides at her facility to wash her hair. About 6 weeks ago, she said "NO" when it was time to wash her hair. The aide spoke to her supervisor and was told "We cannot for e her to get her hair washed." I live 4 hours away and when I was there about 2 weeks ago, she told me her hair had just been washed the day before I arrived! Any suggestions will be so appreciated.

  • @douglasfowkes6461
    @douglasfowkes6461 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Hi my name is Douglas my wife is Jessica I'd love to view comments throughout the last couple years on some of your things but you've had the best videos my wife she's passed away from dementia but I couldn't have done it as your caregiver without watching your videos I've been on board for probably four years now I think she had a rapid decline here at the end but because it's just been me and my wife we've had no help because I don't protect the services traumatize your victimize your neglected her with her sisters who cannot take care of her so thank you thank you for all your videos excellent stuff on everything thank you I don't know where to post this or how to get a direct email this is like the newest video I've seen so I'm not very tech savvy but thank you thank you thank you for all that you done because it helped me beyond anything else, thank you Douglas

  • @suzannemonet
    @suzannemonet ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I was just searching for ways to help mom understand that she’ll need 24 hour care now. She just told me that she can take care of herself for the 1000th time…so I suggested she try driving herself home and pick up her prescriptions on her way!! (I was extremely frustrated and being a royal b***ch suggesting such a thing) I so hate myself some days for the way I respond to her denial that she needs help. She forgets immediately that I’m being ridiculous. But I feel terrible and beat myself up for days. I found a fabulous retirement home that she would love if she’d give it a chance but I can’t reason with her about it. Having said all that, what could I say to accomplish my goal of moving her into this lovely place and have 24 hour care?

    • @KarinCrawford
      @KarinCrawford ปีที่แล้ว

      What does she value and love the most? Tie the move to it. For my mother in law, she's looking forward to someone else cooking for her.
      Or on another direction, find an activity, music presentation or show she'll enjoy and ask them to allow you both to come. Tell her you're taking her somewhere special for a meal and a concert (class, etc)
      Or ask the staff there to invite her to a special event so it's not you suggesting it??

    • @johnhaller5851
      @johnhaller5851 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Or tell her your house has termites and she has to stay somewhere nice while they fumigate because the hotel room you got is only for one person. Or that you are remodeling, and can't be in the house. Or that you are taking a trip and want to be sure someone can keep an eye on her while you are gone so you don't worry.

  • @marionwest3661
    @marionwest3661 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    If you don’t want conflict with a dementia patient, where possible, go along with what they say. Don’t argue. Also, swiftly change the subject if things are getting difficult. Remember, they do not think logically.

  • @emilykrahn3185
    @emilykrahn3185 ปีที่แล้ว +18

    Thank you so much, I was doing this all wrong. I kept thinking, if I just explain this very slowly and carefully, the logic, they'll finally get it, but now I see they don't get it and can't get it, and I have to focus on what am I trying to accomplish, what is the goal. And just get that done. They may not need to understand, because they probably are incapable of understanding. Thank you.

  • @shaynebergwever6268
    @shaynebergwever6268 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Great video, "They will never understand their limitations". It's more important we are aware of our loved ones condition, we can take necessary measures to keep them safe. Great advice, lost Dad to Alzheimer's and it looks like mum has a dementia. I thought it was denial, but after watching this, I'm understanding what's happening.

  • @angelinalanzillotti2773
    @angelinalanzillotti2773 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    This is exactly where we are with our Loved one.
    This video is so helpful and help so hard, aka think outside the box.

  • @sandrafigueroa3429
    @sandrafigueroa3429 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    Thank you dr. Natalie . I’ve been watching your videos for the past two years when my husband got diagnosed with Louis body dementia Parkinson’s. I I’m trying to understand for when he gets worst he is ok now with a few things that he sees but he still understand what’s going on .😔🙏🏼

  • @tonyavalvo1956
    @tonyavalvo1956 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    This is so helpful thank you!! Do we use this same technique with moments of rage during sundowners? Or is the response to them a little different?

  • @AWanderingEye
    @AWanderingEye ปีที่แล้ว +3

    WARNING: Rant/Essay Ahead.
    Loss of independence. isn't that our greatest fear as adults, the permanent loss of independence? think of yourself, do you have a plan for how you'll accept that? each family has its own values and history. my family has no issue with a 92 year old woman driving her country roads. other families look askance at that situation. that woman drives during daylight and wears a safety pendant but yes, it will take cops 20 mins to find her if something goes down. she is selfish person who is putting herself and likely others in danger every single time. she thinks if she passes the test she is good to go. she limits her driving to about 2 days per week and is very conscientious keeping up the gas tank. Keeps car well maintained. Has caregivers drive her car to dr appts., errands, etc.
    so far she hasn't been diagnosed with any neurological condition but those creep up on a person don't they?
    have a plan in place for yourself. look at your values and reevaluate if they are still your values and if you are living according to them esp when there is a deviation. but at 92 reasoning is pretty much a loss cause imho, so a practical solution is going to have to happen...sadly the car is in her name only, it is a well maintained newer car with all the safety features.
    a difficult conversation: where are you going when you are out driving? I'd be glad to go there and get that for you. it just so happens i am going to that very place want to come with me? I love to go on the country roads why not ride along with me? I'd love for you to see your friends but get there in one piece, let me drop you off and pick you up when you're done. I'll be your on call personal limo service. (these have helped reduce her driving but it takes all family members participation. she recently drove 3 hours round trip for family thanksgiving dinner attended by 4 adults with drivers licenses who could have figured out how to pickup/drop off among themselves. except they didn't.)
    America is a driving country. the oldest among us now are some of the first drivers in their families. All their adult lives, they have been working hard to drive, buy new cars, get roads paved and maintained, paying their taxes, driving cross country on vacations, using their vehicles to help children move, gifting their old vehicles, treating their cars with loving care. Driving equals independence. Or does it? Can we think of other ways to have independence without personally driving a vehicle? Every adult who is independent today has potential for needing to address this issue. Address it before it becomes an "issue" and share your decision with your family --- that is another way of being independent. Having a plan in place for how you will stop driving a car permanently. And act accordingly. Be mature. Be proactive. Give your loved ones future peace of mind.

  • @tracybenson6364
    @tracybenson6364 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Please remember the person with dementia has memory loss. She still has feelings and knows you are annoyed. If we could all just be kind to EVERYONE (including ourselves) all of us could be so much better.

  • @aprilpremiere
    @aprilpremiere ปีที่แล้ว +10

    This is your best composed video I have seen yet. The repeated emphasis on the main point the pragmatic steps to solution, concise yet repetitive for emphasis. bravo Natalie, you are ready to lead a Master class. Similar to Cesar Milan, the goal is to teach the caregiver how to approach the pet/ patient. It's the caregivers mindset/ perspective that needs the adjustment.

    • @meditationpraise
      @meditationpraise ปีที่แล้ว

      Thank you so much he's a great help with my whole family

  • @janstanley538
    @janstanley538 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    I have listened to many of your videos for a few years now but this is definitely the most helpful one for me. Thank you so much!

  • @keariewashburn4680
    @keariewashburn4680 ปีที่แล้ว +14

    I'm so burned out that it is really hard to get creative now. I'm a retired nurse and my aunt needs to go to a long term care facility for 24 hour care. She sustained 3rd degree burns. She has been alcoholic most of her life. I termed it as finding her a new apartment to go to. She does not remember her actual house at all. Of course the deed and finances need to be put in for medicaid. She had me as POA but the revoked. So, we have to wait for court to appoint guardian/conservator. She is still at the hospital that is an hour and half away. Now her general disposition is coming out of " I can do my own affairs" and " I don't agree with these things" also asking me how much have I got accomplished, and what am I doing. I'm thinking her real mean side is getting ready to explode. I am sick from this. She isn't the only one in my family really. I think I'm having a breakdown and I can't make the system go fast enough and it's so damned complicated.

    • @KarinCrawford
      @KarinCrawford ปีที่แล้ว

      So sorry you're experiencing this! How challenging!

    • @b.bernal6151
      @b.bernal6151 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I know how difficult it is. I’m having a similar situation with my uncle, but I learned a lot dealing with my mom who passed away a few months ago and trying not to commit the same mistakes. I felt I was having a breakdown too when I brought her to live with me and had to place my mom in ALF where she passed away within a month. It always helps if you have someone to talk to.

  • @moparmissile
    @moparmissile ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Thank you so much. Like an Angel you have appeared on my youtube feed in our time of need. We are facing all the things you have outlined and will try to implement them with our mother. Thanks again ❤

  • @user-oq5ds5gx5v
    @user-oq5ds5gx5v ปีที่แล้ว +2

    How do you get your dad's clothes in the washer without him freaking out? 😳

  • @theaweavers8576
    @theaweavers8576 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Unfortunately they will never understand or remember what u want them to so u have to be imaginative to get to your goal xxxx

  • @boulgom2008
    @boulgom2008 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Thank you for your videos, they are so helpful. My mother has had dementia for a number of years and most certainly has anosognosia. I have tried the techniques mentioned here over the last few years - essentially it is to solve the immediate problem at hand in the most efficient way possible. But we still face plenty of issues which I have no idea how to solve, for e.g. we cannot get her to exercise. She was also starting to avoid having a shower and I suspected it might have been because she was afraid she might slip. So I bought a shower chair and put it in the shower for her. She was happy about it for the first few days but then removed it after a week. How do we get her to exercise if she doesn't even want to walk?

    • @KarinCrawford
      @KarinCrawford ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Oh wow, how challenging. Re exercise, did she like to dance when she was younger? If so, how about creating a Playlist of tunes from her teens and 20s and play it and invite her to dance? Or 'dance' while sitting down, moving arms, etc?

    • @sarahstrong7174
      @sarahstrong7174 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Are there any sessions for people with dementia locally that might include dance or gentle ball games, kicking balloons etc? Could you get together with other carers & create such sessions? Can you invite her to a 'dance party' with other family members? If you put on a chair dance video & start following it might she join in? Might she help you decorate/write a card for someone & then walk to the postbox with you? Maybe she has another interest that would help, such as watching birds, looking at flowers, seeing children playing, seeing plants at a garden centre, walking around a store to consider buying something new for the house, seeing a place with links to historical events?

    • @johnhaller5851
      @johnhaller5851 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      There can be multiple problems. Your sense of balance gets worse normally as you age. With dementia, it gets worse faster. A fear of falling and not just slipping could be part of it. My mom is 94, and a shower just about wears her out. She barely walks, and was couch surfing when she did walk. Before I put her in a care home, I was hiring a former CNA who helped her with a bath. My mom needed reminding what to do in a bath, she could wash herself with prompting, but need help drying off so she wouldn't get cold, and help with dressing and undressing. If you mother has Medicare, she might be eligible for hospice, where they will give her a bath or sponge bath twice a week. Your mother might be having concurrent heart problems which makes it difficult for her to exercise. My mom gets winded walking to the bathroom.

  • @nancywright4730
    @nancywright4730 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +10

    I recently purchased a digital clock for my LO.
    I just said” I came across this while thrift store shopping with my daughter”
    “ I thought it was pretty cool, tells you month , day, date, time and whether it’s morning afternoon or evening”
    She’s thinking, I wait patiently.
    “ I thought maybe we could just put it here I on top of the fridge.”
    She said oh I don’t really need that. I have my calendar here.
    I didn’t say anything, we proceeded to have a muffin and coffee.
    About 30-45 later.
    Oh did you get me this nice picture?! Looks it tells me everything I need to know! Isn’t that nice.
    She proceeded to call me and ask me everyday if I had bought it for her.
    She Loves it!

  • @lindasanchez1250
    @lindasanchez1250 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I understand all you just said and I have been practicing it with my mom already but nothing I say or do will get her to take a bath. I have tried a lot of creative ways and NOTHING works. I am at the point of asking her nicely one more time and if she says she will take one tomorrow, I'm going to let her see me bang my head against the wall.

    • @jomarielopez2229
      @jomarielopez2229 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Me too!

    • @lindasanchez1250
      @lindasanchez1250 ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@@jomarielopez2229 what can we do?😢

    • @kimmclean9933
      @kimmclean9933 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      My Aunt will not take a shower. She says she only takes baths. At her care home she can only take a shower. It is so frustrating.

  • @dnice3473
    @dnice3473 ปีที่แล้ว +13

    Mannnn u just helped me so much and it just clicked… I’ve been watching so many videos.. and I see these stories and blogs where families get together.. and they figure it all out.. that’s the best case scenario…
    Well my dad dosent realize what’s going on… and it’s not some Brady bunch story…. But what am I trying to do by trying to get my dad he is having problems?!?
    I just have to weather thru this storm.. he dosent need to understand and admit that he is having problems… he is having problems… period..
    But I have so many family members that are not here.. so they think I’m making thing up, so it makes me seem like a liar… but oh well… I know what’s going on…
    I love my dad so much and I’m going to weather this storm because I love him to the world and back and I don’t need anyone else, that’s not here to understand.. and I don’t need to prove it.. I don’t need anyones elses aproval..
    When my dad denies his hallucinations, and his delusions… my family members that know nothing about dementia, ask him if he is hallucinations, and he denies it, it’s ok… I don’t need him to confirm it.. maybe he doesn’t know, or maybe he dosent just dosent understand…
    But I love my dad and I know what’s going on…
    I used to try to get him to admit it.. but oh well, he dosent have too… I’m here for him and I have his back…
    It just clicked that I don’t have to get him or anyone else to understand..
    My dad told me he sees giants walking down the street and he talks to our dead aunt,,, I was so spooked and scared, I told my brother….. my brother asked and my dad told him he dosent know what I’m talking about…
    So I’ve been trying to get my dad to admit it and I’ve been trying to prove it… I have to let it go! I know what’s going on and nobody else is here and I know everything else that’s been going on…
    I just need to be here for my dad! This whole situation is so scary,,, on top of it all, I’m a single dad trying to raise a toddler by myself and help my dad…
    But there is no point in trying to prove it and get my dad to admit what’s going on

    • @susanwhite655
      @susanwhite655 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      Your enlightenment is beautiful DNice34. And you bring up an additional situation that alot of us are facing too. They are talking about renaming our generation to "sandwiches", feeding our children with one hand and feeding our parents with the other, and caregivers are stuck inbetween. I want to encourage you to hang in there. It's a long, steady road.

    • @nancyrandall1762
      @nancyrandall1762 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      You are a brave person! I too am scared sometimes; you should feel proud of yourself for taking care of your dad and if no one else believes you, that is their fault. Someday they will and when they feel guilty I wouldn't even say it's OK. I have a brother who won't help and now that i am taking care of our brother, he has cut me off. His loss. Bless you!

    • @dnice3473
      @dnice3473 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@susanwhite655 thank you so much

    • @dnice3473
      @dnice3473 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@nancyrandall1762 yep, it’s already a lot for you and me. It is scary to see our loved ones suffer from this horrible disease, and we suffer with them, then not to have the support from our other relatives is absolutely sickening.
      My dad is progressing so fast, I’m not sure how long this has been going on and I just didn’t notice it. It really tears me to pieces seeing him in this state, and to him I smile and act like everything is normal and I didn’t notice him being confused and not knowing what’s going on, or confused and not know how to tie his shoe, etc….
      I am trying to the best of my ability not to have hate in my heart towards my brother and the others that I told, and they don’t believe me. I just wanted to let them know so they wouldn’t wonder why I didn’t tell them, and I also needed someone to talk to about the scary stuff going on.
      Your brother will definitely regret it. I’m sorry you are having to go thru this without him having your back

    • @johnhaller5851
      @johnhaller5851 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Maybe you could record him talking, and that might make it easier to convince the relatives. Still, have the relatives watch this video so they know that it's not helpful talking to Dad, who doesn't remember what happened yesterday. I found with my mom that just watching television can greatly confuse my mom, who can't tell the difference between where she is with what's on TV. We watched a video about someone taking a train journey. On the way to bed, she asked if this train has a bathroom, so she obviously thought she was on a train. One time, she asked me if Aunt Kate knew i was getting packages at her house, so she must have thought we were visiting her long-dead aunt, and didn't belive that i owned this house.

  • @4everyoung24
    @4everyoung24 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    This makes sense! Lightbulbs just went on!
    What about them having access to computers and social media? It’s one of my mother’s major sources of interaction. I keep an eye on her private messages but there have been people who are trying to scam her.
    I think the whole thing is difficult because it’s a parent and you feel like you’re treating them like a child. It’s frustrating but also so, so sad because they used to be so smart and active.

  • @theaweavers8576
    @theaweavers8576 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    What wonderfull solutions you suggest. We did direct debits to help the bank.... also when we went shopping for clothes that i wanted mums opinion on plus she could try on something while there...

  • @seekerofgrace2058
    @seekerofgrace2058 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    What if every day he thinks /is ahocked & saddened that his adult son is dead ( he died 15 yrs ago) . What would i say? That his son is onvacation?

  • @susanmeredith4957
    @susanmeredith4957 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    I learned after awhile arguing doesn’t help. It was hard to do, and in the beginning it felt like I was just letting her go. I tried so hard to keep her in the real world but it didn’t work. You can’t. And once I learned this fact our relationship got easier. You’re so right.
    They can no longer be in our world, and we have to enter theirs. Instead of saying no, that’s not your son in the restaurant, I’d just say, he’s very handsome and go along with it. Etc.

  • @dr.scanlan6112
    @dr.scanlan6112 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Please please please get to the point . The vids are much (!) appreciated..but soon we'll be dust.

  • @kelliewitwer9205
    @kelliewitwer9205 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    My mother in law constantly says we are stealing her money. Even though she writes them out with my help and gets all her bank statements. But everyday we get told she don’t get mail she don’t see her bank statements. Ugh I don’t know what to do.

  • @donnayork7540
    @donnayork7540 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    You sweet people, there are some medications that help to calm down patients, of course it has to be under doctors care. With my dad we had husky nephews & a policeman friend to help get him into the nursing home.

  • @m.d.5335
    @m.d.5335 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I have found ALL of your videos extremely helpful and comforting to know I have a resource and that I am not alone But this one was perhaps the most helpful videos , for my current situation, I’ve watched so far. Thank you!!!

  • @christianemichelberger8245
    @christianemichelberger8245 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    This is genius. My sister is becoming demented and we are having exactly this problem.

  • @ainsliejones3764
    @ainsliejones3764 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    You have no idea how helpful this was. I can be more creative without feeling I’m living or cheating on my wife, thank you

  • @lifeisstillrad9296
    @lifeisstillrad9296 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Honestly, o feel like this is awesome advice for both dealing with my strong headed spirited 5 year old as well as my 68yr old father in law with the dementia issues

  • @cindynielson4231
    @cindynielson4231 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    What I'm getting from you is to try to make them feel helpful and needed. Great ideas.

  • @melanieadiseshan9027
    @melanieadiseshan9027 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Thank you SO much for your wonderful communications! I found you via IG when I was in the US last year and brought you home to Sydney, Australia. I wish you were here permanently too. My spouse has vascular (from a R Lacunar Infarct in 2014) and fronto-temporal (from 2 punctate strokes in 2019) dementia. I've struggled alone for 8 of the past 10 years. Thanks to you and Montessori Care, I'm managing a little better now, but am just exhausted trying to out-think the nuances of this disease. Appreciate you xo

  • @diane4071
    @diane4071 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I needed this video, caregiving to hubby who denies he has dementia. Just the other night, he thought someone was knocking on the door, he goes downstairs in his underwear to see who is out there. Of course there was no one there.

  • @JayRevay
    @JayRevay 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    This video was so triggering for me. No matter how creative I get in trying to help my mother she always circumvent my efforts. Just a simple example. She has a belief that she needs to unplug everything in her house every evening. Unfortunately, when she does this, she no longer has a telephone because of the way that it set up. It also affects her television, because she unplugs the cable I have done everything under the sun to prevent her from being able to unplug things and she just finds a workaround because she is so determined to unplug them and that’s just a small example but it is how she is with everything this video made me feel like I should be able to fix everything and that is just not possible

  • @hesterdeyzel8934
    @hesterdeyzel8934 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    So good. For a long time I thought that by helping my husband to stay part of decision making will prolong progression of dementia. It really does take a toll.

  • @oreoandoz7723
    @oreoandoz7723 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    This was like a light bulb going off! Thank you so much. Subscribed! Can you do a video on what to do about pets with dementia parents? I don't want to rip the pets away, and try to rehome them, very traumatic for both parent and pets - but she can no longer adequately care for them. I'm not close enough to go in every day and feed the dog, let the dog out, feed the cats, check that they're all ok. Thank you!

  • @reenimelgoza6450
    @reenimelgoza6450 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    This video was my light bulb moment. Eye opening! Now to act, not react. Thank you!

  • @TheFluffyPeacock
    @TheFluffyPeacock ปีที่แล้ว +11

    I think you need your person to understand and accept for you. At least that's how it is in my case. All the talking and reasoning in the world can't make my mother understand that this is her home, so now I just tell her it's my home and she seems fine with that most days unless she's having a day where she doesn't remember I am her daughter. It's very tough. I sure do appreciate these videos as well as hearing about other people's problems and how they are dealing with them!

    • @KAVIANSTREET
      @KAVIANSTREET ปีที่แล้ว +2

      That is what I was going to say. We don’t want to admit that our mother can’t understand anymore. It makes the disease and the situation more real.

    • @susanwhite655
      @susanwhite655 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@KAVIANSTREET Yes, you reminded me of our motto we rehearsed and put on the wall when my mom moved in. Each day is a new day, a little better than tomorrow and a little worse than yesterday. We had to do that for our own mental health - face the truth of the situation. Caregiving to dementia and Alzheimer's is not an uphill battle but a downhill one.

    • @KAVIANSTREET
      @KAVIANSTREET ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@susanwhite655 I like that. That’s true.

  • @amtrue_
    @amtrue_ ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Oh my goodness! I can solve for this! I will solve for this! Thank you Dr. Natali

  • @hughesjill53
    @hughesjill53 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    An excellent video, some very good advice and will come in handy for future use. We haven’t had a diagnosis yet, appt is Nov 2023!!!! Very busy hospital

  • @amberbrittany7546
    @amberbrittany7546 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Your videos have been helping me. I was so confused living with my exes old widowed dad it didn’t seem
    Like he really had dementia but now it all makes sense & it’s progressing. Nobody talks about how to handle this ! Ty !

  • @deeperstillll2151
    @deeperstillll2151 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    My mother’s dementia angers me. I am not equipped, nor do I want to be equipped, as her care giver. Being a care giver means that I am the one who has to change and honestly, I cannot make the changes needed. I am a very Black & White person, lying is not part of who I am. I will not lie or use deception or manipulation to care for a person who refuses to be helped and only gets angry when you try. Caring for her is very stressful and causes me such anxiety that I try to stay away.

    • @baileymadison9019
      @baileymadison9019 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      I’m a care giver to and you need to look at it with the perspective that you want to cause the least harm possible. The reason lying is seen as bad is that it causes harm 90% of the time. This is the other 10%. She needs a constant and she does not have the brain cells to understand what is going on. She is scared out of her mind losing herself.

  • @rohanawolf2089
    @rohanawolf2089 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Fantastic! This can ease so much resistance and bad feelings. Thank you so much!

  • @sarahjohns-goodman6098
    @sarahjohns-goodman6098 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Id tell my patient " lets go Visit"!

  • @e.j.grandmaison8563
    @e.j.grandmaison8563 21 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    I used to teach preschoolers (2-4 year olds) . We were using the redirection technique to get them on the right path. This sounds a lot like it. Because you really can't reason with a 3 year old. So, this is useful. Thank you!

  • @soilmanted
    @soilmanted ปีที่แล้ว +1

    So you _cannot_ convince the person they need help. You get them help without convincing them they need help.

  • @dudewhathappenedtomycountr9099
    @dudewhathappenedtomycountr9099 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    We need them to Comply, not Understand.

  • @TitianTopsyTurvy
    @TitianTopsyTurvy ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Thank you so much, I had no clue this was what was happening with my Mum. ❤

  • @tinamaddison5688
    @tinamaddison5688 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I have one big question that is causing great anguish and upset lately. Mum with dementia fell and cut her leg. The wound is healing very slowly. It has been a month now, but the wound stings and is very annoying, so whatever is put on the wound, mum takes it off. We have been to the dr every week and they clean it and re dress it only when we get home mum takes it all off and from then on multiple plasters, creams etc go on and off this wound to the point where I cannot cope with it so leave her to it. How do you keep a dressing on? I have no idea and no one I speak to has either. 😢

    • @tinamaddison5688
      @tinamaddison5688 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Mum has gone to the hospital now, and they are dressing it!

  • @ryecatcher1670
    @ryecatcher1670 ปีที่แล้ว +13

    The path of least resistance, is the most effective route
    .

    • @MelissaR784
      @MelissaR784 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Occam's Razor theory.

    • @milels6917
      @milels6917 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@MelissaR784 can you explain .?The path of least resistance is just walk out leaving them to do as they want but if you love someone you can’t

    • @MelissaR784
      @MelissaR784 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@milels6917 Getting your loved one to do what's best for them and using the Occum's Razor theory of taking the path of least resistance, is the most effective route to reach your goal. Cuts down on the frustration in both the caregiver and the person with dementia.
      Was just putting the name to the action.

  • @Babywilltravel
    @Babywilltravel ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Any ideas on what to say to my Mom with severe dimensia who is calling everyone she knows trying to get a ride to "work" (ie rehearsals at symphony). How to convince her not to actually go. Maybe that she needs to stay home to take care of her cat? My siblings say she just needs to go and fail ... so she learns she can't do it any longer. I think they are hoping that the other musicians will send her home so they don't have to break her heart by telling her she can't physically and mentally do it any more. I'm trying to find a less formal group she can go play with so it won't be so many hours and it won't matter if she can't but she doesn't want that. Plus she needs a walker to get around and her instrument is the huge standup bass. How will she carry the bass and stool and walker? I'm worried she will fall or drop her bass (which she adores) or collapse from exhaustion or ... any number of things. It's more complicated than this even. She says she's practicing but her caregivers confirm she isn't. I've had my husband come play music with her at home but she wants the full orchestra and the stage and audience.

  • @susanmarinello4034
    @susanmarinello4034 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I know you are trying to help but I have a suggestion. A lot of people trying to deal with this issue are spouses with the dementia. I am
    79 years old and believe a lot are elderly themselves. You talk so fast that it’s very difficult to absorb at breakneck speed. You cannot truly analyze anything you are saying. Too much info crammed into to much super fast talking. It’s a shame because I know you are trying to help and information on dementia is needed so badly for us caretakers. I am a person with a sharp mind and cognitive difficulties but you are trying to squeeze to much info into to short a time. Just a thought. I know not everyone that is listening is in their 40’s,50’s dealing with parents. Lots of us seniors out here. Thank you

    • @susanmarinello4034
      @susanmarinello4034 ปีที่แล้ว

      Sorry for the mistyped and spelling. I meant to say I have No cognitive issues. Also I meant to say spouses of the people who have dementia. Also I am 79 years old and believe a lot of the caretakers are seniors. Lots of to’s I/O too’s. My fingers are typing too fast, I also need to slow down!!

    • @fuzzy3562
      @fuzzy3562 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Susan, did you know there is a great way to slow down you tube videos? If you click on the little cog at the top right of your screen, a dialogue box will open up, and if you scroll to the bottom choice you can change the “playback speed” to slow down ( or speed up) any video. If it helps, you could also click on the CC square next to the cog, and that will give you subtitles, if it helps. I use both these tips for watching foreign language videos and find them very useful in language learning , I hope it will help with Dr Natalie’s videos for you, as they are so informative, it would be a shame to miss any of her tips. Good luck! ❤

    • @susanmarinello4034
      @susanmarinello4034 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Dear Fuzzy, thank you so much I was totally unaware of that feature. It made a big difference. I don’t need cc just needed it slowed down so I didn’t miss the important info. I know that feature is also available on audible. Thank you for your kindness, it is appreciated. Susan 😊

  • @pc4764
    @pc4764 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I totally understand this strategy and I've been trying to get my sister to adopt it with her husband. She's mostly there. But its driving. It's out of the question. Not happening but he is relentless. She completely got rid of the car years ago. What really needs to happen is for her, not him. He's driving her insane with it. It's been 10 years of this. Every single day, all day long, over and over and over again. It's endless. Anyone have a strategy for that?

    • @AWanderingEye
      @AWanderingEye ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Sadly this was my parents situation too. They were resistant to try any medications beyond ones for obvious physical conditions. He didn't even want pain meds for his chronic and debilitating arthritis. But the asking things repeatedly is a symptom of anxiety (of course Alz means one forgets the answer so the question is asked again, but the initial need to ask is driven by anxiety).
      Try getting a psych to offer anti-anxiety meds. My dad when he went into nursing home (which was basically a locked ward so a real shock coming from their home which he could walk freely) eventually was offered meds and it likely made his adjustment to his new life a little easier to take (while he was still aware of it).
      I know folks often don't like to think psych meds are the best route but had he had these while living with my mom both of their lives would have been a lot easier. As it was she was hell to live with and he was miserable. He was at the mercy of her and his condition. Unfortunately he got to be the guinea pig. Now I have an abundance of 20/20 hindsight and nowhere to use it except YT...hope you can glean something useful from our experience.

    • @pc4764
      @pc4764 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@AWanderingEye Thank you. This is really helpful. My concern is focused on my sister because I have no input with him, though I do have great affection for him. My sister just brought him back home from a care home. The home was sold and the care was deteriorating. Now he's physically unable to hurt her. She's gotten tremendous relief by hiring an agency to support his care. She was going to manage a team of non-agency employees. Too much of a burden for her. The carer told her yesterday, the only thing he wants to talk about is the driver's license. Alz affects everyone in the patient's orbit. I got a little insight into Alz from working as a support for an Alz patient after my dad died. I needed something to use up the energy so I could come down from it. I learned a lot from doing that for a while. Nice to find this group.

    • @KarinCrawford
      @KarinCrawford ปีที่แล้ว

      Thinking of the driver's license, could he get the travel ID that's not a license and have something in his wallet? The explanation? It's a new form of id. Not sure if that would work...

  • @JamesMiller-wg7mf
    @JamesMiller-wg7mf 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Lying to a loved seemed so wrong to my wife and me. With my mother-in -law, we realized that it was morally ok to fabricate reasons (lie) to get her to go back into the home, etc. this was a huge stress for us at first, but trying to reason and explain did nothing to help the situation.

  • @maryellentrella1030
    @maryellentrella1030 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I wish I had this info when someone in my family had the same diagnosis!

  • @elizabethsawyer4951
    @elizabethsawyer4951 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Deep thinking and sometimes I can't come up with a thing

  • @partyof7712
    @partyof7712 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I’m so done with her gossiping.
    Is that normal

  • @azguardian
    @azguardian ปีที่แล้ว +2

    4:33 This is great advice for anyone assisting a loved one with dementia! It can be hard for a legal guardian to practically help their family member even after gaining legal authority. Creative thinking and redirection is key!

  • @jakemelinko
    @jakemelinko 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I had to lock up everything cause my dad won't stop going through everything over and over looking for food in my home where he lives but it just makes him crazy not being able to. Watching the camera of him walking back and forth looking in everything is sad.

    • @cmv07
      @cmv07 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      my mom does the same